CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY
ASIA
The date shows when this volume was taken.
comprise
**■' - . Aval ouri
looks not in use
^ruction or re-
search are limited to
all borrowers.
Volumes of periodi-
cals and of pamphlets
comprise so many sub-
ithat they are held
ibrary as much
issible. For spe-
;hd purposes they are
!™’ii out for a
i limited
time.
Graduates and sen-
iors are allowed five
volumes for two weeks.
Other students may
have two vols. from the
circulating library for
two weeks.
Books not needed
during recess periods
should be returned to
the library, or arrange-
ments made for their
return during borrow -
er’s absenefe, if wanted.
Books needed by
more than one person
are held on the reserve
Books of special
value and gift books,
when the giver wishes
it, are not allowed to
circulate.
CORNELL
W7^
4"> 2.
T8
/.<//
/s
\
%
JOURNAL /'
OF THE
ASIATIC SOCIETY OF BENGAL.
VOL. XLI.
PART I. (History, Literature, &c. )
(Nos. I to IV. — 1872 ; with sixteen plates.)
EDITED BY
J HE jiONORARY ^SECRETARIES.
CALCUTTA :
f^INTED BY p. p. pEWTS, pAFTIST _/VIlSSION ^RESS.
1872.
T
I\ % V 4 I
4
>
CONTENTS
V
OF THE
JOURNAL, ASIATIC SOCIETY OF BENGAL, FOR 1872.
Part I.
No. I.
Page
List of Words of the Nicobar Language as spoken at Camorta, Nan-
cowry, Trinkutt, and Katschal. — By E. H. Man, Assistant
Superintendent in charge op the Nicobaes. — Communicated
bt the Government op India,
More Buddhist Remains in Orisa.- — By J. Beames, C. S., M. R.
A. S., &c., Balasoro,
Notes on a Visit to the Tribes inhabiting the Hills south of Sibsagar,
A'sam (with five plates). — By S. E. Peal, Sibsagar,
Note on Ghargaon, As&m (with one plate). — By J. M. Foster,
F. R. G. S., Ndzirah, Asam,
Translations of seleoted portions of Boole I. of Chand Bardai’s Epic. —
By John Beames, B. C. S., M. R. A. S., &e.,
Koch Bihar, Koch Hdjo, and A'sam, in the lGth and 17th centuries,
according to the Akbarnamah, the Padishahnamah, and the
Fathiyah i ’Ibriyah. — By H. Bdochmann, M. A., Calcutta
Madrasah,
Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions, No. II. (with one plate). —
By H. Bdochmann, M. A., Calcutta Madrasah,
1
7
9
32
42
49
102
No. II.
The Legend of Baghesar, a deified spirit held in great reverence by
the Kusru, Sun, Markam, Netia, and Sarsun clans of the Gond
Tribe. — By Capt. W. L. Samuells, Assistant Commissioner,
Manbhdm
Essays in aid of a Comparative Grammar of the Gaurian Languages.
— By Rev. A. F. Rudoip Hoeende, D. Ph., Professor of Sanskrit,
Jay Narayan’s College, Benares,
iv
Contents.
Pane
174
Beef in Ancient India. — By Babii Ra'jendeaxaTa Mitba,
The Conquest of South India in the Twelfth century by Parakrama
Bahu, the groat King of Ceylon. — By T. W. Rhys Dayids, Esq.,
District Judge, Anuradhapura, Ceylon, 197
Note on an Arakanese Coin.— By Captain G. E. Fryer, Officiating
Deputy Commissioner of Sandoway, (with three wood-cuts) 201
List of the Books contained in Chand’s poem, the Prithiraja Raso. —
By John Beames, Esq., B. C. S., M. R. A. S., Balasore, 204
No. III.
The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. — By A. M. Beoadley, Esq., C. S.,
(with nine plates), 209
I. Bilidr in Patna, 209
II. Anoionfc Magadha, 211
III. Buddhist Remains, 221
IV. Kusagarapura and Rtijagriha, 230
V. Prom Tiladaka (Tilldfali) Monastery to Kalyanpur, ... 250
VI. The Indra Saila Peak, 261
VII. The Monasteries of Ghosrawan and Titrawan, 266
VIII. Pawapuri and Bihar [The Isolated Rook], 283
IX. Rajagriha in the Mahawanso, 298
X. Nalanda [Bargaon] 299
XI. Conclusion, 306
No. IY.
The Tirthas of Vrinda-vana and Gokula. — By F. S. Growse, Esq.,
M. A. Oxon., B. C. S., 313
On a now King of Bengal, and notes on the Husaini Dynasty and
their conquest of Chatgaon (Chittagong.) — By H. Beochmann,
Esq., M. A., Calcutta Madrasah, 331
A Picnic in Ancient India. — By Babu Ra'jendeala'ia Mitea, 340
Index,.. 355
LIST OF PLATES
nr
JOURNAL, ASIATIC SOCIETY OF BENGAL, 1872.
Paet I.
PL I (p. 110). Inscription on the tomb of ’Alauddin Shah at Badaon.
PL II (pp. 17, 24). Naga Houses and Jobolca Mount.
PL III (p. 20). ’Ak,’ or tattoo, of the Banparas. — Joboka Chang.
Pl. IV (p. 19). A Naga Skull house, and NagS Utensils.
Pl. V. A Naga with his dliao climbing a tree.
Pl. VI (p. 19). Naga woman with the dliao.
PL VII (p. 40). The Rajah’s Palace at GhargSon (As 5m).
Pl. VIII. Map of Bihar, shelving the routes of Fah-Hiyan and Hwen
Thsang, and the principal sites of Buddhistic Ruins.
Pl. IX (p. 222). Restored elevation of the great Nalanda Temple.
Pl. X. Pillar and Capital from the Vestibule of the Nalanda Temple
(p. 223), and sketch of a Stupa found at Titrawan (p. 282).
Pl. XI. Ground plan of the Buddhist Temple on Mount Baibhar (p. 241).
Pl. XII. Plan of the Tillafah ruins (p. 250).
Pl. XIII. Pillars from the Sangin Masjid at Tillarah.
Pl. XIV. The Ghosrawan Inscription (p. 208).
Pl. XIV. Sketch plan of Ghosrawan (p. 266).
Pl. XVI. Sketch plan of Titrawan (p. 266).
Two Woodcuts of Arakanese Coins (p. 201).
One Woodcut of the legends on do. (p. 202).
ERRATA
m
JOURNAL, ASIATIC SOCIETY, BENGAL, FOR 1872.
Pabt I.
Page 55, 1. 19 .for QariLqylp&g (?) tribe read Qaraqalpik tribe, and add as a
foot note — “The Qaraqalpalts swore allegiance to Russia in 1732.”
Perofski’s Narrative of the Khiva Expedition in 1839.
73, 1. 9 .forjfdjM rea d
,1. 14/or read tji y>-.
79, foot note, /or Dalai (Jalal ?) read Dalai (Dinyal).
106, 1. 7 for oL>f /Aj read
1. 14 for Zafarabad read Muzaffarabad.
107, 1. 4, for read
j 1. 7, for Mu’Sn read Na9r.
175, line 23, for it is read is it.
178, „ 42, for read
179, „ 14, for were read was.
180, „ 16, for Rudra read of Rudra.
182, „ 7, for If read It.
187, „ 28, for vertebra read vertebrae.
193, „ 25, for As'valayanas read Asvalayana’s.
216, „ 15, for Kalandavanonvana read Kalandavanouvana.
220, „ 13, from below, for cette ville read cette ville aux Bralimanes.
252, „ 15, et passim, for Sangi read Sangin.
263, „ 9, for Giriyak read Giryak.
JOURNAL
OF TIIE
ASIATIC SOCIETY.
— * —
Part I. -HISTORY, LITERATURE, &e.
No. I.— 1872.
List of Words of the JVicobar Language as spoken at Camorta, Nancowry,
Trinhutt, and Eatschal.—By E. H. Max, Assistant Superintendent
Of CHARGE OP THE NlCOBARS. — COMMUNICATED BY THE GOVERNMENT
op India.
A.
Absent (nothing), Hadart.
Ache, Tehiali.
After, Latdolc.
Air, Ilainh.
Alive, Ye-enn.
All, Aumtome.
Always, Dul.
Ambergris, Kampe.
Angry, Mubungcore.
Another, Deeoh.
Answer, Oopschap.
Arm, Chee-koal.
Ask (to), Atot.
Axe, Enloin.
B.
Baby, Kunyoon.
Back, Oke.
Bad, Had-lapoa, or Menkain-yoslieh.
1
Bamboo, Hadwah.
Basket, Hintai.
Bathe (to), Lawn.
Beat (to punish), Oodee.
Beard, Enhoing.
Before, Hadek.
Begin (to), Hoolatai.
Belly, Weeung.
Below, Deg.
Betel-nut, Heeya.
Betel-leaf, Dai Heeya.
Betel- tree, Telieea Heeya.
Big, Kadoo.
Bird, Sheetchua.
Bird’s nest (edible), Heekai.
Birds (ordinary), Hong-Kang.
Biscuit, or bread, Puang.
Bite (to), Opkah.
Black, Ool.
2
[No. 1,
List of Words of the Nicobar Language.
Blind, Pukeean.
Blood, Wah.
Blue, Tchoongoa.
Boat (Euporean), Haifoor.
Body, Oke Enha.
Bone, Ong-aing.
Boot, Denapla or Shapata.
Bow and Arrow, Shenna-Foing.
Boy (male child), Lit.
Bracelet, Hutlaw.
Brass, Kalahee.
Brave, Yock-ehaka.
Breast, To-akh.
Breeches, Kunha.
Broken, Dakgna.
Brother, Tchao.
Brother (half), Tama Oosheh.
Brother (own), Tchao Enlooya.
Bullet, Plooroo.
Buy (to),Hullao.
C.
Calf (of leg), Kunmoana.
Calm (no wind), Nyam.
Cane, Nat.
Cannon, Hen-wow.
Canoe, Dooey.
Can (to be able), Doh.
Cat, Cochin.
Chair, Iiutteardeh.
Cheat (to), Hai yoo nang.
Cheek, Tapooah.
Chest, Undaiyah.
Chief, Oomai-muttai.
Child, Kenh-yoon.
Child (own), Koo-un.
Chin, Shummah.
Clean, Koten.
Cloth, Loih.
Cloth (strip of), Lanoa.
Cloud, Kullahaya.
Coat, Kunlioin.
Cocoanut, green, Gnee naw.
Cocoanut, ripe, Gnoat.
Cocoanut tree, Wee-ow.
Cock (fowl), Kamoy-koin.
Cold, Ivaay.
Come (to), Kaiteri.
Copy (to), Hoomyee.
Coral, Shai-yonn.
Comer, Ongkaiung.
Cover, Oke.
Count (Imperative) Haro.
Crying, Tcheem.
Coward, Pumma-hoin.
Custom, Tatoicha.
Cyclone, Hoorasheh,
D.
Dance (to), Katoaka.
Danger (fear), Poohah.
Darkness, Toey-chool,
Daughter, Kooun Engkana,
Day, Haing.
Dead, Kapa.
Deep, Ool.
Devil, Eewee.
Dhoty, Loili Sharong.
Difficult, Gnia-nayun.
Dirt, Yuch.
Dirty, Oomeh.
Dishonest (untrustworthy) , Chit-
tong-natau.
Distant, Hoee.
Divide (to) , Hundowa.
Doctor, Munloenna,
Dog, Am.
Dollar, Para.
Drink (to), Top.
E,
Ear, Nang.
Earring, Eetchai.
Earth, Doo.
East, Fool.
East wind, Hainh-fool.
Easy, Too-yayun.
1872.]
3
List of Words of the Nicohar Language.
Eat (to), Okenok.
Ebb Tide, Tchoh.
Edible Bird’s nest, Heekai.
Egg, Hooya.
Elbow, Deg-ong Kaiung.
Enough, Layah.
European (man), Bajo taten hamatt.
Eye, Owl-mat.
Eyebrow, Oke-mat.
Eyelash, Kut-fight.
P.
Pace, Gnoitchaka.
Farewell, Yu-tchuh.
Father, Tchia Engkoin.
Far, Hoee.
Fear, Poohah.
Feast, Yukura.
Feather, Pooyawl.
Fight, Pamon.
Finger, Kaneetai.
Finish (to), Laird.
Fire, Heoch.
Fish, Ka.
Flesh, Enh-ha.
Fly, Yooch.
Flute, Hunhell.
Forehead, Lai.
Forget (to), Painatau.
Fowl, Kamoy.
Foot, (upper part), Okelah.
Foot sole, Awl-lah.
Friend, or, my friend, Kaiyol.
Flood Tide, Hayow.
G.
Give, Hanh huttar, or, Horn koo am.
Girl, Hooleeyen.
Go (to), Tchuh.
Gold, Emloum.
Good, Lapoa.
Grandfather, Tcho-um.
Grass (jungle), Opyooap.
Grass Lalang, Shenfo.
Grass, ordinary, Shen.
Great, Kadoo.
Green, Tchoongoa.
Guano, Aingala-ah.
Gun, Hunndell.
Gunpowder, Taroo.
H.
Hair (short), Yoo-ock.
Hair (long), Hunkoiya.
Hand, Koal.
Handkerchief, Langsheh.
Handsome, Yahnaisnchka.
Happy, Yah-natau.
Hat, Sliapeo.
Hate (to), Ha-natau.
Hatchet, Enloin.
Have (to), Ought.
Head, Koee.
Headache, Tchiak-koee.
Hear, Yang or Katool.
Heart, Enka-hato.
Heaven (sky), Kullaliaya.
Heavy, Langung.
Hen, Kainoy Engkana.
Here, Eeta.
Hill, Kohinjuan.
Hog, Nod.
Hot, Ke-owyun.
House, Gnee.
Hungry, Oingna.
Husband, Koin.
Hut, Kunsherpa.
I.
Imitate (to copy), Hoomyee.
Impossible, Oolahad Sheh.
Inside, Awl.
Invitation, Kala-kala younde.
Iron, Karao.
Island, Poolgna.
J.
Jar, ICoodun.
Jungle, Oltchua.
4
List of Words of the Nicobar Language.
[No. 1,
Jacket, Kunhoin.
K.
Key, Tunwahn.
Kill (to), Thaw Kooee.
Knee, Kokanoang.
Knife, Innoyet.
Knife, (Toddy), Innoyet Tua.
L.
Lad, Huh.
Land, Oal Mattai.
Large, Kadoo.
Laugh, ItA
Lead, Tchoomper.
Leaf, Dai.
Leg, Lah.
Lemon, Carroy.
Lie (to lie down), Laan.
Lie (to tell lies), Mattai.
Life, Aim.
Light (to light the fire), Haiyooing.
Light (not heavy), Had lang ung.
Lightning, Maig.
Like (similar to), Hangnesheh.
Lime, Shooka.
Lips, Manoing.
Little, Ompetmsheh.
Long, Kialeg.
Love, Shaiyong-yuntaw.
Listen (Imp.) Katool.
M.
Man, Paiyooh.
Man (old), Pomoy-sheh.
Man (young), Maiyerkh, or, Ilub.
Measure, Tah.
Medicine, Danoon.
Moon, Kahair.
Monkey, Dooen.
More, Paitery.
Morning, Ha kee.
Mother, Tchia Engkana.
Mosquito, Menh hoya.
Mouth, Awl_fuang.
Much, Odo liutchee.
Musket, Hundell.
Murder, Fliaw-kooee.
Muscle, E-hay.
N.
Nail (finger), Kaischua.
Nail (iron), Hun em.
Name, Layung.
Navel, Fori.
Near (not far) Me-enh-houh.
Neck, Onglongna.
Needle, Tcha room.
Never, Kit ma.
Nest, Hongkang.
No, Wat or watchion.
North, Kappa.
Nose, Moanh.
Nothing, Hadart.
O.
Oar, Kan noot.
Obey (to), Yu yung.
Often, Dul.
Oil, Gfnai.
Old (animate) ,Boomooashee Oomioha.
Old (inanimate), Lat shee.
Open, Foigna.
P.
Paddle, Pow-wha.
Pan (cooking), Chattee.
Pandanus, (tree), Larohm.
Paper, Lehpery.
Parrot, Kattoch.
Perhaps, Yonghuddeh.
Pig, Nod.
Pigeon, Moongmoo.
Pineapple, Shoodoo.
Pipe, Tanop.
Plant (to), Opeep.
Plantain, Hehpoo.
Plenty, Yolor Ooroohud sheh.
Poor, Pooap.
Present, Tunnier sheh.
List of Words of the Nicobar Language.
1872.]
Pretty, Yahnai shehka.
Q.
Question, Humma.
Quill-pen, Anet-lay-bery.
E.
Eain, Ahmee.
Eat, Koomate.
Eattan, Pantang.
Eow, Hooyow.
Eed, Ak.
Eice, Arosh.
Eich, Chumwoahun.
Eipe, Eeshiun.
Eing (finger), Kunlongtai.
Eiver (stream), Whaieda.
Eoad, Kaiee.
Eope, Naat.
Eoof, Oke.
Eow, Kan not.
Eudder, Hunlaidedla.
Eun, Deeunna Hundial.
S.
Sand, Pee-yet.
Sea, Komaleh.
See (to), Hadduk.
Ship, Tjiong.
Shirt, Kunhoin.
Short, Mitatu, or, Meh-enh-Shehkoee.
Shot, Kutchung-kutchung.
Shoot, Hadeel.
Shoes, Shapata.
Shoulder, Koee-oonga.
Show (Imp.) Hychung.
Shut, Kurrup.
Sick, Tchiak.
Sing, Eekaisher.
Sit, Eepoohenhde.
Sister, Tchao.
Sister, (half), Tama-oo-sheh.
Sister (own), Tchao Enlooya.
Skin, Oke.
Sky, Kulahaya.
Slander (to), Kaiyawnasheepaiyoo.
Sleep, Eeteoah.
Small, Ompaislieh.
Smell, Eckait.
Smoke, Fosh.
Snake (Boa), Toolan.
Snake (ordinary), Paik.
Sometimes, Kaiyai or Hang-hang.
Son, Koo nr Engltoin.
Speak, Olyola.
Spear, Sha nenh.
Steamer, Tjiong-heoeh.
South, Lakhna.
Star, Shok maleicha.
Strong, Koang or Mong egg.
Stone, Mungeh.
Stockings, Hunho-ulla.
Stand, Omshierma.
Stomach-ache, Tchaik Weeung.
Stupid (not clever), Hadokai.
Sugar, Shoonk.
Sugarcane, Mao.
Summer (N. E. Monsoon), Koeekapa.
Sun, Haing.
T.
Table, Menh sheh.
Tool, Deg.
Take, Okair.
Tell, Tchong Koee.
Teeth, Kanap.
There, Matareo.
Thief, Kaloh or Kahalacher.
Thigh, Poolaw.
Throat, Kolulla.
Thunder, Koodei (or Koomtoogna).
Tipsy, Hoo-yoy.
Tobacco, Oomhoi.
To-day, Len-heng.
Toe, Kanechlah.
To-morrow, Haing Hakee.
Tongue, Kalleetah.
Torch, Pal.
[No. 1
List of Words of the Nicobar Language.
6
Tortoise-shell, Kap.
Turtle, Kap oltchua.
Tree, Tcheea.
Turban, Langsheh.
U.
Ugly, Oomeh had sheka.
Uncle, Hoey tchia.
Unhappy, Kit yah natau.
V.
Valley, Awl-hok.
Village, Awl-mattai.
Voyage, (long), Yohatayha.
Voyage, (short), Yock dooan.
W.
Walk, Ongshongha.
Want, Yok.
Warm, Kee-ow-yan.
Warrior, Hoo-Ekka.
Wash (to make clean), Atchek.
Water (fresh), Dak.
Water, Ivomaleh.
Weak, Had-ko-ang.
Weapon (Europe), Hundell.
Weapon (Nicobar), Paiyooha.
Weep, Tcheem.
Weigh (to), Kunlah.
West, Shoo-hong.
White, Tenhya.
When, Kalie.
Wife, Kan.
Wind, Hainh.
Wing, Danoyen.
Winter (S. W. Monsoon), Lakhna-
shoohong.
Woman, Englcdna.
Wood, Ooneeha.
Work, Winnair shi sheh.
White, At-ait.
Y.
Yam, Kopaeh.
Yawn, Hing-ap.
Yellow, Laaom.
Yes, Aonka.
Yesterday, Mundee.
Young, Iluh.
Numeeals.
1, Hayang.
2, Anh.
3, Loeh.
4, Eooan.
5, Tanai.
6, Tafooel.
7, Eeshat.
8, Enfuan.
9, Hayang hutta.
10, Shorn.
11, Shorn hayang.
12, Shorn anh.
20, Hayang momtchierma.
30, Hayang momtchierma doktai.
40, Anh momtchierma.
50, Anh momtchierma doktai.
100, Tanai momtchierma.
Time.
6 a. m. (sunrise), Hakee.
9 a. m., Alhakee.
Forenoon, Kokin dowha.
Noon, Kumheng.
lp.m., Tchin foitua.
3 p. m., Tchin foitua, ainhsheh.
5 p. m., Ladeya.
Sunset, Pooyoieh.
Dusk, Hammok gnok.
Midnight, Yuang hatam.
1 a. m., Hanh-hooaka.
3 a. m., Pooyeh.
5 a. m., Tehungneeall.
Day, Haing.
Night, Hatam.
To-day, Len heng.
To-morrow, Haing-hakee.
Peesohal Peonouns.
I or we, Chier.
You, Menh.
1872.]
He, she, it, An, or, Poonan.
They, Oomtohm.
Who, Ychee.
Possessive Pkonoiihs.
This, Xeena.
That, Anaay.
Your, Tehiang menh.
Yours, Efoe or Efoye hayoo.
My, Tehiang ehier.
Sentences.
Come here, Kaiteri.
I will come, Yudook poonchier.
He will come, Yudook poonan.
Why are you afraid ? Choounpahar
menh?
Where is your village ? Choon mattai
menh ?
Go there, Yu chu, or, ehu.
Bring me some fish, Okai kah paite-
sheh.
Light a fire, Haiyoon heoeh.
I don’t know, Kit-akah.
I know, Akah.
Take away, Kai tery.
Who is he ? Tehee ka an ?
7
Get up, Koongha.
He lives at — , Kutool poonan na.
Be quick, La La.
Give me back (return), Yu Ooshoor
hutta.
Don’t come, Wat if edook.
Call that man, Eeorta paiyooh.
I am glad, Yonutto kaun chier.
I am sorry, Gniat nato kaun chier.
If it rains, I will not come, Yon
ahmee kit to.
Have you ever been to — ? Makun
menh ?
I have never been to — , Chier Kitma.
Where are you going to ? Yu chun
menh ?
I am going on board the ship, Yu to-
altjiong chier.
I want to go, Kai-yeng.
I will remain here, Yu katog kyaeeta.
Have you any shells ? Tchian kun
menhta pooker ?
How much do you want ? Kah
indokna sheh yok menh ?
This is too much, Ooroohad shehka.
Sit down, Eepoonhenhde.
More Buddhist ’Remains in Orissa.
More Buddhist Remains in Orissa. — By J. Beames, C. S., Balasore.
In continuation of the note on the Buddhist remains at Kopari recently
contributed by me, I wish to record the existence of some more structures
m other parts of Orissa, whose exact similarity to those at Kopari affords
a confirmation of the theories suggested by that place.
On my way back from Katak, where I had been to attend the Durbar,
which was not held owing to the melancholy incident which has spread such
a gloom over all India, I pitched my tents at the village of Chhatia
sixteen miles north of the town of Katak. In the evening as I was taking
a stroll along a village road, west of the encampment, I came to a flat surface
of laterite closely resembling that at Kopari. At the foot of a small hill
8
More Buddhist Remains in Orissa.
[No. 1,
was a square platform, about 40 feet square, of hewn laterite stones, from
which rose twelve pillars, octagonal and with rounded capitals, but much
worn by the action of the elements, and covered with grey lichen. To the
west of this was a rude square building composed of the same stones,
roughly put together without mortar. This had evidently been constructed
from the stones of the older structure, as there were pieces of mouldings,
capitals of pillars and sculptured stones, some upside down, and all evidently
out of place. Inside, smeared with Vermillion and turmeric, were numerous
portions of statues, heads, arms, a mutilated trunk or two, few of which
bore any resemblance to the traditional figures of Hindu mythology.
The images unfortunately are so smeared with Vermillion and oil, that it
is difficult to make out all the details. There seems to be a serpent’s hood
over the head of one, but it is too much worn to admit of any certainty.
The next day the camp was at Dhartnsala on the Brahmani river,
31 miles north of Katak. One mile to the west of the road, at the foot
of a little hill, on a small promontory jutting out into the river, stands a
temple of Siva, under the name of Golcarnes 'wara Mahadeva, or as the
peasants call it, Gok’ns’r Maliadeb. This is one of the usual Siva temples of
the melon or ninepin shape, so common in Orissa. It faces the east, and in
front of it is a square platform of laterite stones, surrounded by pillars exactly
similar in design to the Kopari ones ; they are twelve in number, three at
each comer of the platform thus : —
The Mahadeb temple has been built of stones taken from some pari of
this ancient structure, though the fact is concealed by its being entirely
covered with a smooth coating of plaster. The Hindu statues of late date
surrounding this temple are of remarkable beauty and fineness. The principal
figure is called by the people Saraswati, and represents a smiling woman with
four arms holding a conch and lotus, with many female attendants with
laughing faces grouped round the principal which is not in relief, but has
the stone cut away at the back of the figure.
This image was found in the river some years ago, and the others were
found in the jungle close by, or as the attendant Brahman states, suddenly
appeared out of the rock, and ordered themselves to be worshipped !
1872.]
9
Notes on a Visit to the Tribes inhabiting the Sills south of Sibsdgar,
Asam. — By S. E. Peal, Esq.
The various Hill tribes bordering on the valley of Asam, both on the
north-east and south, present so many points of interest and seem to be so
little known, that I take the opportunity of putting these few notes together
of a short trip into the hills to the south of Sfbsagar district, Mauza’ Oboe-
pur, hoping they may be of some use or interest.
Our ignorance of these various tribes, their many languages, customs, and
internal arrangements, seems to be only equalled by their complete ignorance
of us, our power and resources. The principle of clanship is here 'carried to
the extreme ; not only are there numerous well marked tribes inhabiting con-
siderable tracts, as the Butias, the Abors, Singphus, Nagas, but these
again are cut up into small, and usually isolated, communities, who, among
the Nagas at least, are constantly at war with each other. Their isolation is
often so complete, that their resources lie wholly within their limited area.
There seems good reason to suppose that the present state of things has
existed for a considerable period. Not only are the languages spoken by
contiguous tribes often mutually unintelligible, but the still better evidence
of strongly marked physical variation holds good. And to these inferences
of a long period must be added the tangible fact, that at their villages, or
‘ changs’, and not elsewhere in the hills, there are numerous Jack trees,
many of them very large, and not less than 400 years old, I should say,
as the Jack is a slow growing wood.
I had often wished to visit some of these ‘ changs’, but had not the
opportunity till this occasion ; and though the season was rather advanced,
I determined to go, as the Rajah of the Banparas had invited me for
the third or fourth time. My nearest neighbour consented to accompany
me, and arrangements were made to start on the 30th May, at day-break.
Before daylight our people were astir, caught the elephants, and tied our
baggage. At 6 A. M., we started. Our party consisted of two native
muharrirs, a barqandaz, and six Leklas, an interpreter, or Sokeal, joining
us afterwards.
It was a beautiful morning, a fresh breeze blowing across Bhagmorial
Potar as we passed through it, though we lost it on entering the jungle
at foot of the hills beyond. The path, so-called, we found clearer than
was to be expected ; fallen trees and such like obstructions were singularly
few. Game was looked for in vain, although it was evidently a good
shooting ground ; and tracks of buffaloe, pig, and deer, were plentiful. This
luck indeed pursued us the whole way, though it must have been exceptional.
We soon reached the Ladia Ghur, an old road, leading from Kukila Mukh
2 b
10
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the JYaffd Hilts.
via Nazira to Jaipur, and here so covered by jungle and bamboo as to be
wholly impassable. It is usually considered the boundary line between us
and the so-called Naga territory.
The land then descends a few feet, and the river Tiolc was seen
ahead at a very picturesque little bend, making a capital foreground, as it
splashed over the boulders and ran among the snags, the hills behind rising
clear and blue. The swash of the water was quite a pleasant sound to us,
so long accustomed to these muddy streams. After crossing it, the road
lay through a fine piece of high land, and soon after entered and went along
the bed of a small stream. We here dismounted ; for the bed of the stream
afforded a good path, as there was but little water, and consisted of sand
and pebbles. Blocks of petrified wood lay about in profusion, and so
good that the first piece I took up, I had mistaken for real wood.
Quartz pebbles were plentiful, but the rock on all sides was sandstone.
In some places the traffic had worn down the rock into a narrow passage,
where only one at a time could pass, and also into holes and steps, very
well for Nagas to grip with their bare feet, but slippery and unaccommodating
to thick-soled boots. To this narrow gorge succeeded an open tract close to
the foot of the first hill, part of which had been cultivated by Nagas a few years
ago, and had now relapsed into rank grass, as U'lu, Borata and Hamoru, with
a few trees here and there, and would in another few years be forest again. We
halted here to let the elephants come up : the path in several places, having
been obstructed by bamboo, had to be cleared a little for them. After
another steep ascent, we reached the head of the pass, or lowest point in this
first range, which here runs parallel with the valley.
The range of view extended from Jaipur in the east round by the hills
on the ‘ North bank,’ (or continuation of the Himalayas) which were
beautifully distinct, and then as far west as Cherydo and Nazira. Both
the hills we were on, and those bounding the north, presented a strong
contrast to the plain we had just left. The latter seemed as flat as it
was possible to be, literally a sea of jungle forest, an enormous dead level.
The smallness of the area under cultivation surprised us more than
any thing : it did not look one per cent. The Potars I could easily recognize,
Burasiilf, Nagahat, Bhagmorial, Borhoh, Tyrai, Tinikuria, Rohona Potar,
none were missed ; yet they were but little green streaks, hardly noticed in
the general view. With binoculars I could make them all out, even my
bungalow houses. The amount of waste land is enormous. The Brahma-
putra was not visible, though to be seen at times they say ; we searched also
in vain for Sibsagar ; the distance perhaps was too great, though it must have
been within our horizon line.
While we were enjoying the prospect, the chief brother of the Rajah
made his appearance with some of his people, and seemed quite delighted,
11
1872.] S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nagd Hills.
talking away as if we understood every word of his Naga, and rattling his
heads and bits of metal as he walked about. We soon afterwards
proceeded over some undulating ground, and then took to the bed of another
stream, also rocky, narrow, dark, and slippery ; the rocks still being sand-
stone, with a dip to the south of 70 0 to 80°, in fact almost vertical, the
strike running nearly east and west like the range itself. At a more open
part of the road, we came to a large pit, about 12' X 8' X 12' deep, right
in the path, and made to catch wild elephants. The bottom literally
bristled with large bamboo spears, 5 or 6 feet long, firmly fixed in the
earth, and carefully sharpened — certain death to any elephant falling in.
The pit was nearly hidden by overhanging grass and creepers and
was dug at a spot where the path on either side was difficult, and the
edges were undermined. After seeing our elephants pass this safely, we
went on the road now descending, and still over rock, usually very slippery,
and winding about abruptly, when after a second steep descent, we heard the
rush of water below and caught glimpses of the hills beyond. The stream was
soon reached. It is a tributary of the Tiok, called the Sissa, running here
to the east. It was now a small stream, but the rounded boulders on the
flanks bore witness to its being at times a formidable obstacle. Having
our doubts about the elephants being able to reach this point, we sat down
at a little ‘ Dhubi’, or water hole, under the shade of a Bor tree. The pool
turned out to be full of fish, so plentiful in fact that on throwing in a
small bit of gravel the whole bottom seemed to rise from all sides. Most
of them were small ; there were however a few large ones near the bottom.
The only way the Nagds take them is by hand or poison ; but we saw
a lot of Naganis carefully turning the stones over, and occasionally catching
a little one.
A Sowdong and a Ilundekai both of whom I knew well, were here waiting
for our arrival. A 1 Sowdong’ is a sort of travelling deputy to the Rajah ; and
a ‘ Hundekai’ is a resident deputy, and is of a higher grade. The highest next
to the Rajah and his family is a ‘ Khunsai,’ and there is one to each village.
We consulted them as to the best route, and they at first advised us to go along
the bed of the stream ; but as it was so full of huge rocks and holes, that ne
elephant could pass, we had to decide on the ordinary mountain path via
Longhong, the shortest way, but by far the steepest. The elephants at
last made their appearance ; how they managed to get down places, where
we had to scramble on all fours was a mystery to us — at times they seemed
immediately over us.
We crossed some deep clefts over which there were rude bridges. The
steepness of the ascent, especially under the hot sun, soon began to tell on us,
and the elephants seemed so distressed, though we were not half way up, that
we called a halt, and held a council, the first result being to unload the ele-
12
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nagd Hills.
plants and send them back to the Sissa, as we saw that we could not rely on
Naga estimates of distance or difficulty.
The Rfijah’s brother and the Hundokai of Longliong now had a long
and noisy palaver, as to who should, would, or could, furnish the men to
carry the few things left by the elephants. Their real power over internal
affairs seems small : the men of Longliong treated the Royal brother as
little better than their equal, and almost came to a row. Row enough there
always is when they argue any matter however small ; it seems their custom
to speak loud and look excited over nothing. The Longliong Hundekai
at last agreed to get the three or four men required, as his ‘ chang’ was near,
and we hastened their discussion by saying that if men did not soon come,
we should follow our elephants.
The Rajah’s brother now started off for Banpara to report that we
would not reach it that night, and get some huts built half way between
Longhong and Banpara where we could sleep.
This second hill is also of sandstone, running into a finer kind, and then
into a laminated clay, with a dip to the south of about 70° or 80°, and often
vertical and several times inverted. At the surface it seemed to form a rich
loam, and almost the whole hill was under rice, though seemingly a bad crop.
The road still followed the crest of the ridge, as is usual, and we soon
came to the region of bamboo, which is found close to the changs ; and where
it branched off’ leading to Banpara, we found the Longhong KMnsai seated
in state on some leaves, his spear stuck in the ground beside him. At some
20 feet on each side were other officials, also in state on loaves and with their
spears. The Khunsai I knew well, and had a talk with him. I found, he had
a bad foot, tied up in very dirty linen, and told him to wash both and keep a
water-poultice on. The only extra-decoration they indulged in was a topi
with a long feather in the crown. We wore passing on to see Longhong,
when the old fellow hailed us, and gave us his formal permission to
proceed. This we had omitted to wait for, but it seems to be considered by
them necessary.
A Longhong went with us, while the rest awaited our return to this
point. We now saw for the first time how they weed the ‘ dlian,’ commencing at
the bottom of the slopes and working upwards, in parties of ten to twenty.
The dlian stalks seem far apart, and they use a bamboo loop to scrape up the
earth, removing the weeds with the left hand and throwing them in little heaps.
Each house or family seems to have its dlian marked out by sticks, stones,
or weed heaps, and neighbours combine to work in batches. The rate
at which they get over the ground was astonishing, the work being well done.
The dlian was not in ear, and this was their second weeding. I was told, it
was enough for this year.
The land had last year, I believe, been redeemed from young forest and
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nagd Hills.
13
1872.]
was almost destitute of trees and stumps. The labour they are put to
for a scanty crop is almost incredible. They seldom cultivate the same piece
of land for more than two years in succession, as grass comes up rapidly the
second year, and they have no way of eradicating it, the only implement
used in cultivation being the dhdo. After the second year, they let the land
go into jungle and make fresh clearances for their dlian. The hills are thus
in all stages of jungle and forest, now all grass, as Borata, Ulu, and Ilamoru ;
or ground deserted for three years, all in small tree jungle (for the trees kill the
grass in that time) ; on other patches again larger trees may be seen, five and
six years old, or eight and ten, and no grass at all. In about ten years all the
available rice-growing land has had a turn, and they can clear the young forest
again. They thus require far more land than the ryots in the plains, especially
if the smallness of the crop yielded is taken into account.
We soon reached Longhong passing through fine groves of Lottu and
Wattu bamboo, and came upon the fortifications of which I had heard so
often. The first attempt almost made us laugh. There were a few sticks
of ekra and bamboo stuck in like a common fence, on the off-side of a
ditch about 0 feet wide by 6 feet deep, over which there was a small bridge.
A little further on we passed some small raised ehangs, on which we saw
bodies tied up in Tocoopalm leaves, and roofed in. We heard it was the way
in which they disposed of their dead. All customs relating to this subject
are worth noting, so we examined them with some interest.
We next came to a kind of palisade, with a long narrow passage
between bamboo walls, three feet apart, not very strong, but enough to check
a rush. It was the most formidable point of defence, as it was commanded
by a large rock in front, on which a house had been built to give extra cover,
and had a precipice on the left, the right also being steep. There
seemed to be no one on duty, which was contrary to what I had heard
and expected. On entering the chang, we could see very few houses at a time,
the ground being very uneven, and the paths steep and tortuous, eminently
calculated for defence, and such as give the spear its fullest advantage,
when opposed to firearms.
The houses were all thatched with Tocoopalm leaves and not grass,
as in the plains, the centre posts also all projected through the roof line for
some 5 or 6 feet, and were bound with leaves, presenting a very singular
appearance. They were built without any arrangement, no doubt many times
over on the same sites, the level being eked out by a platform raised on posts,
which people use to sit on, or dance, or hold open ah- meetings.
But by far the most striking feature was the number and size of the
Jack trees, many of them evidently very old. We were told that the fruit,
of which there seemed a large crop, was religiously respected. Each house
.has certain trees. The timber used in building was also usually Jack, and as
14
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nag A Hills. [No. 1,
it is one of the most durable timbers, the Jack trees serve two purposes. The
hill summits around are destitute of them, unless whore there is a village.
There seem in fact no villages without Jacks and no Jacks without a village.
We have therefore here a valuable means of reviewing their past history to
some extent, as Jack, Artocarpus integrifolius, is a slow-growing wood,
closely allied to the Sam, Cliama, or Artocarpus chaplasha Roxb., so celebrated
for building and other purposes, and which I suspect is the ‘ Satin-wood’ of
our English timber-dealers.
Water supply seemed a great difficulty. We often saw little troughs
placed to catch drippings from the rock, but containing little else than
mud. There are no tanks, I hear, and as most of the ‘ changs’ are built
on the hill tops, where springs are not likely to be numerous, it seems a
serious difficulty, enhanced too by the strata being all on-edge and sand-
stone. At this village, the water is obtained in a deep cleft facing the north
and some 300 yards down ; but even this occasionally fails.
We were taken to the highest point in the village from whence we had a
fine view of the surrounding changs. To the east, nearest to Longhong and the
plains, lay the Huru Mutons’ chang on its peak, which is wooded to the top.
With the binoculars the houses could be clearly seen in detail, they seemed
the same as in Longhong. The Huru Mutons are the deadly enemies of the
Banpara tribe, though so close. Next to the south lie the Kiilun Mutons, also
on a hill, and next to them again the Bor Mutons, on a conical hill with the
village on the apex. More to the south and in the extreme distance was the
chang of the Neyowlung Nagas, or, as they are called, Abors ; and due south
was U'nugaou, one of the four Banpara villages. Several small ranges ran
behind these, all inhabited by Abors, up to tho foot of the Deoparbat due east.
This mountain is uninhabited, and called ‘ Deoparbat’ from an idea that it
is haunted by a Deo, or devil. Hollow noises are said to be heard on
the summit, where a lake is believed to exist. It is wooded to the
top, and the western face is rather precipitous ; hero and there large
masses of rock stand out clear of the forest and so light as to look like
quartz. From behind Urntgiion a large hill rises, shutting in the view ;
on it are the so-called Abors, who can never get into the plains, though
in sight, as the border tribes would “ cut” them, as it is called. In the fore-
ground of this hill lay a series of small hills, all Banpara territory, and on one
of them we were shewn the village of that name where the Rajah resides.
Nearly due south-west, Joboka rises, and is as conspicuous here as from the
plains, having a gradual slope on its southern face, and a very steep one to the
north. It is the hill of the Joboka tribe, with whom the Banparas are con-
stantly at war, with varying success. As wo were viewing the changs around, a
good many women, boys, and girls came to stare at us, a compliment we
often involuntarily returned.
S. E. Peal — Visit to- tTie Niiga Hills.
15
1872.]
The sun was now getting low, and we returned to the place where we had
left the Khiinsai seated in state. He called several of the groups of weeders
up to see us. They at first seemed afraid to come, most of them being women
and girls, a few stunted and old, and some strapping wenches, who could do
more climbing in a day than I in a week. We then took the path down
the hill and among the dhan, that led to Banpara, many weeding parties on
the road stopping to stare and jabber at us. They certainly seemed to work
hard, though it was nearly dark, and long past the time to leave off work in
the plains.
We now reached the point where the huts had been built on the Sissa
River, and just as it got dark, our men with the loads came in at the same
time.
The temporary huts were rude in the extreme, consisting only of a few
sticks stuck in the ground and others laid across. Some wild plantain leaves
formed our so-called roof. The stream rushing among the stones gave us a
pleasant reminiscence of home, and soon sent us to sleep.
About an horn* after, we were all roused up by a loud thunder-clap,
and found by the incessant lightning that a storm was coming up. We there-
fore hastily rigged walls to the chang we slept on, a waterproof sheet making
a good roof ; our guns were stowed under our heads and our sundries under
the chang. The rain came down in torrents, but we were so tired that we
fell asleep, and did not find till morning that we had been saturated. Some
Nagas came diming the storm down from Banpara, hound for Longhong ; how
they managed to find their way in the dark puzzled us. We also heard bears
not far off.
On the 31st we were up early, and had our breakfast. The royal
brother now made his appearance, several Khunsais and Hundekais
came too, to escort us, and all who could muster up the remains of
a coat, wore the same in our honour. On starting, we adopted the Naga
custom of using a staff, as they do their ‘ jatties’, or spears, to assist
us in getting over the rough ground, and found we got on far easier by
its help.
The path, at first very steep and up a ferny cleft, soon became more
level, and passed round the shoulders and along the ridges of a series of small
hills, tolerably level in the main, and at a sufficient height to give us a good
view of our surroundings. A part ot the road had just been cleared for us,
or the jungle and grass had been thrown aside, for which we were much
obliged to them as the grass was literally dripping with dew. As in Asffin,
the morning dew here is like a shower, and on pausing for a moment, it
sounded quite loud falling from the trees and jungle.
At about half way to Banpara, we came to a kind of abbatis, at a point
that could he easily defended, i. e., a narrow ridge with a precipice on each
1G
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Naga Hills.
side, and not more than four or five yards across. The obstruction was com-
manded by a rise in the ground beyond, on which there was good cover, while
there was none on the near side. The fortification could not be seen, even from
a distance, and was no doubt the best point of defence on the route. There
was, however, another point further on where the road for a short distance
was cut on the face of a precipice, and only a few inches wide. Here a
few determined men could hold any number in check for some time, the preci-
pice being so steep, that I plucked a leaf off a tree top that was fully eighty
feet high. We soon after came to the region of Dollu and Wattu bamboos, of
which there were immense numbers, and here saw cattle tracks, both cows and
buffaloes, and were told they came by the same route as we did, which wo
could hardly credit.
They here asked our permission to fire a salute, no doubt to warn the
Rajah’s people of our proximity. We soon after reached the first point in the
village finding it a counterpart of Longhong, extremely irregular and broken
up, the houses all thatched with Tocoo leaves, and the centre posts project-
ing. The Jack trees were both large and numerous ; we also saw a Naga
‘ bik’, or poison, tree, the leaves of which are used to intoxicate fish, an
endogen and not unlike an aloe on a long stem. They at once conducted
us to the Rajah’s house, the largest by far in the ohang, and also the highest.
It was a repetition of all the other houses. We had to climb up a notched tree
stem to reach tho bamboo chang floor, and found ourselves at once in the
Royal presence.
The Rajah seemed a shrewd man, about 40 to 45 years old, tall and of
course tattooed. He was seated on a sort of huge stool about 8 feet by 4
or 5, over which there was a coloured rug of either Indian or English
manufacture, certainly not Naga. We were pointed out to a similar sort
of bench opposite, at about 8 or 10 feet distance, where wo sat down,
glad to get a rest after our toil, and to look around us a little.
The heir-apparent sat on a smaller throne, to the Rajah’s right and at
some 15 or 20 feet, a strapping fine young fellow. He had an heir-
apparent-manner about him which was to some extent very telling, and was de-
corated a la Naga ; for with exception of a black cloth flung round him while
he sat, he had but a bead and cowrie costume, and was tattooed also of
course. The Royal brothers of the Rfijah were all en suite, and sat about Roy-
alty on little three-legged stools, tho whole of them with faces of such
intense gravity shaded off' by a futile attempt at indifference, that they
looked supremely ludicrous. Of the brothers we fo und there were six ;
we had only heard of two. On the outskirts of this upper ten, sat
and stood the sons and nephews, &c., some of them very smart young fellows,
and decorated in the most fantastic style, and very few tattooed. In the
distance sat the outsiders, and not a few. Most of the Khunsais,
Hundekais, and Sowdongs, who could do so, camo to see us.
17
1872.] S. E. Peal — Visit to the Naga Hills.
We were now treated to unlimited discourse, several speaking at once,
sometimes in Asamese which we could understand, and often in Naga which
we could not — chiefly as to how the Rajah had heard of us, and wished to
look on us as “ brothers”, that I had been some three or four years so near and
had never visited him before. The Raj ah spoke of the difficulty which his people
often had in getting grain, and that they then relied to a great extent on
several villages in the plains. We in fact heard that in the Rajah s house
alone was there any considerable quantity of grain from last year s crop.
Some little stress was laid on our passing “ their Duars,” and we could plainly
see that they had but vague ideas regarding their position. We were in-
vited to behold the power and grandeur of the Rajah of Banpara, whose
sway extended over several mountains and four villages, i. e., Banpara,
Longhong, Und, and Nokrong, while neighbouring Royalty often was con-
fined to one, and whose warriors were literally countless, at least by Naga
numerals.
We were then asked to perform a few miracles, in a general way, with
which we immediately complied, firing our revolvers into a large tree stem
close by. My friend led ofl' steadily, and when I began he reloaded
and kept it up and put five more from my revolving carbine. This was a good
beginning, and there was a great deal of wind expended over it in ‘ wah-
wahing it was considered awful. He then drew fire from heaven, or rather the
sun, through a lens of the binoculars. And no amount of persuasion would
induce a Naga to hold his hand under the focus. Matches were enquired
after, and seemed to yield endless jabbering, when struck. I happened to
strike one on my waistbelt having nothing hard enough near, and I after-
wards heard that they thought I lit it by simply touching my skin, and that
my deota must be a “ knowing devil.” A magnet attracting or repelling a
needle, even from underneath the paper it lay on, was ‘ dawai,’ medicine,
and seemed to astonish less than I had expected.
_ An inspection of the house was then suggested, and it seems the correct
thing to sit in audience for a time at one end and then walk through to the
other, letting off a few polite ejaculations en route.
The house must have been 200 feet by 50 at least, though perhaps in
the centre not over 30 feet high, from the floor. Like most of them, it was
built two-tliirds on the rock, and one-third continued out level by a chang,
where the ground fell considerably, and supported on posts. This last is
the audience end, and had in this case no gable wall, the roofing being semi-
circular, so as to keep out wet. For the first 50 or 60 feet where the floor rested
on posts, it was like a huge barn inside, and had no partitions, the large Jack
posts shewing well in three rows, one down the centre, and one each side at
about 15 feet. Some of the Marolis, or horizontal beams, (wall plates of the
builder) were enormous, fully a foot or a foot and a half thick at the but end,
3
c
[No. 1,
18 S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nagd Hills.
and some 50 to 60 feet long. How they were ever raised to their places, let
alone up such a hill, was a mystery to us, though we were told that men lifted
them on their shoulders. On the right hand wall were hung hones and
skulls of pig, deer, mitton, buffalo, &c. About 50 or 60 lower jaws of the
boar, made a fine display, all hung in a row, some huge tusks among them —
evidently all hung as trophies of “ feasting.”
The central portion of the house through which we next passed, appeared
to have a series of cattle pens on each side of a central passage, the floor
being rock, it was dark as pitch, and by no means fresh. From the
tittering and whispering we heard as we passed or stumbled through, we
concluded it was the realms of bliss, and after a hundred feet of it, we
came out into another large room or hall, dedicated to dhan husking and
pounding, the huge ural, cut out of a solid tree, being placed lengthwise and
having places for about forty people to pound at once ; the floor was also
covered with husks. Here also we saw a small bamboo quad, for refractory
youths.
On returning to the audience end, we were told that the Rajah was
ready to receive his presents, “ as most of the Khunsais and Hundekais had
gone.” So we made our men produce what we had brought, having been
previously told by our own people, that we must expect them to be dissatisfied,
but not to mind it. We had a large purple cloth with broad silver lace
for the Rajah, a scarlet shirt, clasp knives, a red blanket, and Rs. 20 in cash.
The others came in for similar things of less value, but which were reduced
by their being six brothers instead of two as we had expected.
No end of palaver followed, and as we had been warned, they wanted
more. The Rajah, it seems, had set his heart on a gun. This we assured him
was very strictly prohibited, and that we of course dare not give one, and
this I had often told them, but no attention was paid to our remark, the way
they urged it shewed how little they understand us. One of the oldest
Sowdongs who has seen three Rajahs, a man I knew well and who understands
mo better than most Nagas do, got up and made a long speech in Asamese,
reiterating all the arguments, and eventually proposing seriously, that I
should write direct to the * Maharaiu’, and explain clearly, that it was for the
Rajah of Banpara, and she would at once acceed to the proposition. This
was hailed by all as a coup de grace for us, and the general buzz as he sat
down clearly proved he had brought down the House. To this we had to
answer, that if guns were granted to one Rajah, all would claim them, and some
were, as he knew, very insignificant, so that we knew no exception would be
allowed. A revolver was next tried for, but we said that they were very
complicated, often going off when least expected, and killing those dearest,
as well as nearest. I was then offered a slave, if I would yield the gun
question, and 1 understood, a slave for life ; but this we had to shake our
heads over, and look serious.
1872.]
19
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nag a Hills.
The palaver continuing we retired to where a part of the hall had been
partitioned off for us by mat walls, under cover of a remark we heard that
if there was much talk, a Sahib’s head ached. We now enjoyed a little peace,
a biscuit, and a cigar, in more privacy. A deputation soon after came in to
urge the gun case, but we ordered them out, in a mixed dialect, saying that
Sahibs were not in the habit of paying taxes this way, and if they only want-
ed our presents, we should return at once. This had the desired effect. A
procession now came up the house, headed by a Khunsai and the Rajah’s
brother, the former beating a little gong, which was laid before us as the
present from his Royal Highness, together with a couple of young goats ; but
we had been so worried, that we told our people privately, if possible, to
forget them when coming away.
A visit to the houses of the chief brothers was next suggested, and we
started off on a tour. They were all much alike, though smaller than the first :
an audience end, open and with trophies of the chase and poison, then a
series of the cattle pens as before mentioned, on each side of a dark passage,
and a room at the other end for dhan-husking with its ural. The floor
in all rose as we went on, the first portion being a cliang raised on
posts, and matted. We saw here some Abor women or girls, wives of the
owners, one of whom, we were told, had cost five buffaloes, and was the daughter
of an Abor Rajah. They seemed far more sprightly and intelligent and
good looking than Naganls, and could, we thought, understand us far
better too ; whether they were exceptional cases, I cannot say. They wore
the hair in a long queue, tied up with beads and wire, and in many
cases it was long, not cropped at all, as is common among RTfigSnis.
Costume as usual was at a discount, and as is often said “ a pocket handkerchief
would make four suits yet with all this, I doubt if we could beat
them in either real modesty or morals, and this applies to Naganls
too.
The Morrang (dead house) , or place where the skulls taken in their wars
are put, was next visited. It also contained the great drum cut out of a tree
stem and hollowed like a boat. I had reason to think that they might have
scruples to take us in, and as I had often tried to get a skull, I did not shew
my interest in it outwardly. Roughly estimated, there were about 350 skulls.
About half of them hung up by a string through a hole in the crown and in
the open gable end, the other half lying hi a heap on the ground. No lower
jaws to be seen, nor hands and feet, as I had expected. The latter are always
cut off with the head when a man is killed, and confer another kind of ‘ ak’
or decoration. None seemed fractured by a dh&o, and a large number were
of young people, or children, being small and smooth.
We were conscious of being face to face with the great cause of this
tribal isolation, constant warfare, evidently a custom of great antiquity.
20
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Ndgd Hills.
As long as social position depends on tattooing as here, and can only he got
by bringing hi the head of an enemy, so long shall we have these wars
and consequent isolation of clans. The man who brings in a head is no
longer called a boy or woman, and can assist in councils of state, so call-
ed. And he seldom goes out on a raid again, I hear. The head he brings,
is handed to the Rajah, who confers the ‘ ak,’ or right of decoration by
tattoo, at which there is great feasting, and pigs, cows, or even buffaloes are
killed, and no end of ‘ moad,’ or fermented rice water, is drunk. Those who
are not tattooed, when old enough, make a party and lie in wait for stragglers*
men, women, or children, anybody in fact with a head on him ; and as cover is
plentiful, they can get on the enemy’s land and lie in ambush along side his
paths ; never breaking cover unless certain of success and getting clear off
All those who get heads, get the ak on the face ; those who get hands and
feet, get marks accordingly ; for the former on the arms, for the latter on the
legs. No two tribes, however, have the marks alike, and some even do not
tattoo the face.
The worst of this kind of warfare is that women and children are as
often killed as men, and without any compunction. I had a smart little fellow
here at work for a long time, named 1 Allee,’ (four) and once asked him how
he got his ak. He said he went out and lay in wait a long tune near a
spring, and at last a woman came for water, and he crept up behind her, and
chopped her on the head, and then cut it off, and got off himself as quickly
and quietly as he could. It was utterly incomprehensible to him how such
a thing could be unmanly, I found it waste of time and breath trying to
convince him.
Besides the skulls, the Morrang also contains the big drum which is
nothing more than a “ dug-out.” It is beaten by short heavy sticks, and can
be heard a groat distance. The drum from the Muton Chang can be heard
here, at least six or seven miles in a direct line. Some are made of a hollow
tree with the inside gradually burned out , and open at the ends, some 20 feet
long by 3 to 4 in diameter.
From here we went back to the Rajah’s house, and heard an alarm of
fire, which, from the general excitement, seems to be rather dreaded. On the
chang we had a good wash, water being poured out of bamboos. It is here
also rather scarce, and I dare say they considered it woeful waste to use it
for such a purpose.
Our dinner was now ready, and as it was getting dusk, we went into our
apartment, not, however to dine in private, as we had hoped. Our mat wall
contained too many loopholes, to be resisted by feminine curiosity, and an
audience of thirty or forty had to be submitted to, whose exclamations at every
new phase in our proceedings-gave us proof of our being among many people
who had never before seen a white face. I have no doubt that the modus
1872.]
21
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Naga Hills.
operancli was to them mysterious in the extreme ; our candles, tumblers,
knives, forks, and spoons, were as good as news in a foreign tongue.
It being now dark, we made preparations to let off a couple of rockets,
which I had brought, as a final exhibition. A good site was selected where
they could fly over an uninhabited, precipice, and yet he seen by the whole
village. A bamboo tube guide was soon placed and the fuse lit, after placing
the Elijah’s party where it could be well seen. The fuse, however, went out and
had to be re-lit, when the rocket flew off beautifully, just in the direction I had
wished. A gun had been fired to warn the pykes to be on the look out, and
we heard a hum of exclamations at once. After about five minutes, I fired the
other and it flew, if anything, higher than the first, and burst well, the stars
coming out well too, a piece of the case kept burning just long enough to let
them see their value. It was evident, they were in mortal dread, as they
told us that they were all very sleepy. I afterwards heard that the rockets
were looked on as two devils, which I do not wonder at. As a “ peace-
offering” they were very valuable, I have no doubt. Our audience had to be
turned away at last, as they shewed signs of staying by us all night, and we
went to sleep. We were disturbed about two or three hours after, by a torch
being thrust in, and found we were being ‘ interviewed’ by some fresh arrivals
from another chang. To this we responded in Anglo-Saxon and Asamese
adjectives, and had them bundled out, and got peace at last.
On the 1st June, we were awoke by the old Sowdong calling out to us that
if we slept after the sun was up, we should be ill, which must bo a Naga
proverb. The view to the east, as the sun rose behind Deoparbat, was magni-
ficent. Tbo bottom of the valleys filled with white mist, the mountain
shadows crossing in great blue bars, an isolated peak rising here and there clear
like an island wooded to the top. We were ready to start, and were advised
to start soon, as the sun would be hot. We bade adieu to the Eajah in
pantomime fashion, to which he responded, and then went away, each provided
with a staff that saved us many a slip.
The walk did us good, and we got to the Sissa at 8 o’clock, a distance
of about five or six miles, and sat down for a short time, to see if our men
would come up. I went a little way up stream to a picturesque bend where
the water rushed on each side over large boulders in the bed, making a great
noise. The cliff on the other side was a sheer precipice of sandstone strongly
laminated, dip to south 85° to 90°. Here we watched some girls gathering
stones about the size of oranges used in preparing rice.
Finding our men did not soon come up, we started on through the Erra
back towards the Longhong path, the sun being fearfully hot, and several
times we had to rest, there being no shelter. On gaining the Longhong road,
we sat down and found the Naganis close at our heels though carrying heavy
loads. We here remarked for the first time the peculiar noise like a whistle or
22
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the JSfar/d Hills.
note on a flute, clear and plain and seeming to come from the chest, made
by Naganls when carrying loads and distressed. The men told us that they
always did so, when fatigued and out of breath. Subsequently we heard the
same noise or note, and found it was made by an old Naganl, who carried a
maund of rice and seemed half dead, though a muscular old lady.
Wo now selected a hut among the dhan in which to rest and enjoy the
view till our men came up. It certainly was a magnificent view, and I could
see a white speck on the horizon towards Sibsagar that may have been
the Rongghar or Ghargaon.
We were highly amused at the Huluks, or long-armed apes. They
hallooed, the chorus being led off by one giving two distinct whistles ; he
then stopped and the chorus rose to a climax and fell off again ; after a pause
the two distinct whistles were repeated, and the chorus at once broke out
again. In no instance did they ever begin without the “ que.” Subse-
quently I found that I could start them by using a railway whistle, which
I use to attract deer on moonlight nights. I do not know, by the way, if
the fact is known, that on hearing loud whistling (during October and
November, at least) deer will charge. I once shot a large Samhre doe, as
large as a pony, skin 9 feet from the nose to tip of tail ; on my whist-
ling loud, it charged out of the jungle into the open and, on repeating the
whistle, charged straight at us, when I knocked it over at twenty yards. Eight
men could hardly carry it in. The fact is well known here, but I do not
know if naturalists are aware of it.
While resting in the hut and admiring the view, some NagSs and
Naganfs came up en route to see the elephants. We therefore accompanied
them and soon got to the Sissa where the elephants were located and found
all ready to start. Many people had come to stare at the tame elephants, and to
fish. We were admiring the surroundings, and watched the women catching
fish by hand, when a man came to say that our muharrir had had some difficulty
in getting our loads carried down, and that after starting one man had
run away, though close to the chang, and he had to return and get another.
Our loads were thus so delayed, that we determined to push on home, where
we arrived about 5 P. M., earlier than wc had expected, as the distance must
be 20 to 21 miles ; but we wore not so fatigued after all.
The muharrir came in after dark, very much disgusted at the trick
they had served him. The influence of the Rajah seems less than might he
expected and the liberty of the subject at its maximum.
We could not help speculating, during our trip, on the effect of
introducing some good seeds, as the potatoe, which would no doubt grow here
luxuriantly. From internal evidence, the population seems to have been
stationary for a long period, perhaps centuries. The checks are all positive,
too, such as constant warfare and the want of food, inducing disease,
1872.]
23
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nag a Hills.
&c.# The trouble, time, and labour expended in raising their crop of hill rice,
or their Koni dhanf, if sunk in potatoes or wheat, would yield them four or
six fold, and enough to supply the plains with the former, as in the Kliassia
Hills. Whether it is politic to render them wholly independent while they
have such vague ideas regarding their relationship to us, I cannot say. A
peace policy till we get a railway, would seem the best for us planters>
unless extraordinary vigour was shewn. A glance at the map, and a knowledge
of what they have done, would show at once that they could nearly annihilate
tea south of the Brahmaputra, by a system of night raids, for which they
are famous. The present almost deserted state of this portion of the Sib-
sagar district, between the Dik’ho and Diling and south of the Dhodur All,
is a standing proof of what they did forty years ago, “ committing such
devastation,” according to Robinson, “ as to force the ryots to remove from
the neighbourhood, and stop all communication by the roads.” And there
are men living who remember this tract as a vast village, or a series of villages.
The destruction was done by Nagas, Burmese, and Singphus.
Not only during our trip, but both before and after, the question of
our present mutual relationship pressed on our notice. It is not a bad habit,
especially in a country like this, which we have recently invaded, to get the
“ oldest inhabitant” in any locality, and enquire. Thus we here heard
among others, that there never was, in the old days, a fixed boundary
to the province here, and not only did the Nagas give regular tribute in
kind to the Asamese Rajalis, but the so-called Abors as well. There were
both Naga and Abor ‘ Sokeals,’ or Official Interpreters, and the Abor
tribes had access to the plains through certain routes, now closed to them.
I see also, by referring to Robinson’s Asam, p. 384, that the Nagas about
here are reported to have paid allegiance to the Rajahs of Asam, and
again so at bottom of p. 386. As far as I can see, the tribes about here
now forget this, and consider themselves de facto free, and any attempt
on our part to remind them of their former allegiance by active measures,
such as taxation or surveys, would lead to serious complications and to a
* Wo did not see the places where they cultivate their kachchus, and garden
produce, called “ Erra j” hut I have since scon some clearances of this kind, at the
Naga village near Borhat on the Desang and Dhodar All. The land was carefully
enclosed by a fence made of the boughs of the trees felled inside the clearance, not
piled carelessly, but built up so as to be wholly impassable and impervious to pigs.
Inside, I found kachchus, chillies, yams, and also mint, cotton, and plants which
I did not know. The ground was carefully weeded, and paths led though it, and
small « tongis,’ or huts on posts, were erected here and there to servo for watching
at night.
I found many opium-eaters at this village, even among the lads. They are
Mohongias.
t Koni, dhan, and sowl.
24
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Naga Hills.
combined action on their part. What we have most to fear is their incredible
ignorance : hemmed in and stationary themselves, they cannot comprehend
our having other troops than what they see at Dibrogarh, and laugh to scorn
any idea of our being able to cope with them. Like an enraged child with
a knife, they may inflict some severe cuts before the knife is taken from
them.
The question of population of course occupied our attention, and is one
difficult of solution. This tribe consists of four villages, and the mean of
several Asamese and Naga estimates of the number of houses was as
follows :
Banpara, .
Longhong,
Uhii,
Nokrong, .
300 houses.
200
350
50
Or a total for the tribe of 900 houses.
I am inclined, however, to think it far above the truth, and that 600
houses is nearer the mark, and that the able-bodied men are about 1,000 to
1,200, or two to a house.
The Joboka Niigas have five villages, i. e. Joboka, Kamlung, Bor U'tii,
Ham U'td, and Longting, and an Asamese estimate gives the following
numbers : —
Joboka, 500
Kamlung, 400
Bor. U’td, 400
Hdru ITtd, 300
Longting, 200
Total 1800 houses.
This also, I think, is over-estimated, and 1000 to 1,200 will be nearer
the truth. This would give, say 2,000 able-bodied men.
The Miltons have four villages, i. e., Bor Muton, Huru Mutons, Kulun
Mutons, and Naugaon, (I may add that it was called ‘new village’ at least
sixty years ago). Whether these are really separate tribes or simply different
villages of one, I cannot say. A Rajah is at each, but they never go to war
with one another, but fight on the contrary together, I believe, against any
enemy. Their ak also is the same.
Of the Bor Duarias, Pan! Duarias, and Namsangias, I cannot give
an estimate, but 1 think that they have not less than 1000 to 2000 houses,
each tribe.
23
1872.] S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nag a Hills.
Some of the Abor tribes again are very small and consist of but one
village, and that a small one ; as the village and tribe of Banhsang (Bamboo-
chang). AVitb a powerful telescope, which I had for a short time here, I could
make out changs on many peaks, far in the distance to the south, of
whom neither the Asamese nor the Nagas had any knowledge whatever, and no
name hut Abor, and I regretted not having a good telescope with me when
on my trip, as we could have seen changs away in several directions, not to be
seen from the plains.
Between the Pesang on the east and the Dik’ho, there are as many as 8
or 10 tribes having a frontage to AsSm. From Desang to Lufl'ry alone, only
35 miles, there are six tribes, i. e., Bor Dudrias, Miltons, Banparas, Jobokas,
Sanglors, and Lakmas, and this gives but six miles average frontage. They
do not extend far into the hills, so that each may safely be said to occupy
about 40 or 50 square miles. In some cases a tribe is more extensively
placed ; but again in others, as Sinyong, the entire tribe consists of but one
village. I know of no cases where one tribe has conquered, and become
possessed of the lands of another ; hence the status quo seems of long continu-
ance. The oldest ‘ Nog, ions,’ or new villages, are not less seemingly than
40 or 50 years.
As a consequence of the above noted custom of head-cutting, and its
isolating influence, few Ndgas reach the plains, but those living on the
border. We thus see a community of some hundreds perched on a hill, and
depending almost exclusively on their own resources, constantly fighting
others similarly isolated, on all sides, yet thoroughly able to maintain them-
selves. Perhaps in no other part of the world can so complete a tribal
isolation be seen, and subdivision carried to such an extreme. The available
land, too, seems all taken up. To every 40 or 50 square miles there are
about four villages, of perhaps one hundred families each ; yet from the
nature of the case, as before stated, not more than an eighth or tenth of the
land available can be cultivated at one time, and the population would seem
to have reached its maximum.
I am aware that in some places there are hills and ranges said to he
uninhabited, but I know of no such places here, except the peaks and ridges
of the highest hills, 5,000 feet high, or more. All the other hills, as far as
the telescope can penetrate, shew signs of recent or previous cultivation.
But not even the names of the tribes are known, let alone the villages. In-
deed, I have lately detected large villages where all Nagas insisted that there
were none.
The raids and isolated murders for which this large tract of country
is so celebrated, have one feature in common, viz., surprise. Cover is
so universal, and favourable to the attack, that advantage is invariably taken
of it until the last moment. As a rule, when a whole tribe is at war, the
4 n
20
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Ndga Hills.
cause is a general one. One Rajah or tribe has been grossly insulted by
another. In such cases a chang may be surprised and burnt by a com-
bination of several villages. In other cases a single village of one tribe
is at war with another village of a different tribe, without involving the
other villages in hostilities. Bor Muton may be at war with Unu, and not
involve Kiiluns or Longhong. Or again what is a common form, the young
and untattooed men of three or four villages of say two distinct tribes may
combine and, headed by a few older men, quietly traverse the jungles to a
more distant tribe and village and, suddenly attack the people in their
cultivation, the object being simply heads.
Returning to the Banparas, I may say that with regal’d to weapons,
they use, like most Nagas, the ‘ jattie,’ or spear, and the ‘ dhao.’ They also
use the cross-bow.# I see that Robinson lays great stress on their not
having hows and arrows ; he considers its total disuse a very singular
circumstance, and draws rather weighty conclusions from it. It is not,
I hear, of recent date. In the use of the jattee they seem clumsy and
bad shots ; I have tried batches of several tribes at a mark for prizes,
but found them unable to reach 80 yards. Nor could they touch a sack of
straw for half an hour at 60 yards (whore I volunteered to go and be shot at),
but at 40 yards one did succeed.
Captain Norton says in his book on * Projectiles,’ that he could once
throw a spear 170 yards, and saw the wife of an Australian chief throw one
120 yards ; hence the Nagas do not seem very formidable on this score. They
use their jatties for close work, usually from ambush, and never attack in
the open.
The dh&o is used as a hatchet or mace, and held by both hands. One
blow is usually enough, if fairly given in a fight, as they can cut with tre-
mendous force. The jungle is so thick and common, that their warfare is
wholly by ambush and surprise, and this gives the dhao great advantages.
The bow is chiefly used for game and pigs.
They have a shield, or ‘ plior,’ made of buffalo or boar skin, and often
ornamented by goat’s hair dyed scarlet, or by cowries. It figures in their war
dances, but I suspect is not much used elsewhere, unless in a premeditated
onslaught.
Like most savages, the Naga seems to aim at making himself look as
hideous as possible, and their decorations at times of festivity have solely
that object. Their head gear seems generally to have some bunches of hair
fastened to long light stems so as to jerk about while moving. It is the hair
of the man or woman who has been killed, and in all cases, I think, is human
hair, if not of an enemy. But there seems no one particular head gear which
* ‘ Hap’ in Naga.
1872.] S. E. Peal — Visit to the Ndga Hills. 27
all adopt ; on the contrary, there is infinite variety ; any one who can dress or
look more hideous than his neighbour, is at perfect liberty to do so.
The chiefs often wear a long dark blue coat like a dressing-gown not tied,
that contrasts strongly with their usually nude condition. Asamese cloths
are also bought, and worn by the Nagas who can afford the luxury,
during the cold season, but those who cannot, wear the little scrap
commonly seen at all times and about the size of foolscap. Women
wear an equally scanty morsel, which in some tribes, I hear, is even dis-
pensed with. Pewter, or red cane, bracelets or armlets are considered
of far greater value and moment. As far as we could see, the women wear no
head gear at all, and about hall' have the hair cropped short.
The bunches of hair and feathers on the topis are all usually mounted on
thin slips of buffalo horn, exactly like whale hones.
Of trade there is little or none. With the exception of the salt mines
or springs eastward, and some pan and kachchus brought in exchange for
rice, there is no such thing as trade. The tribes are too poor to be able
to trade, and the constant state of warfare renders commerce impossible. On
concluding a peace, some dhaos and Abor cloths change hands, or a mitton ;
but as a rule the border tribes act as a most effectual barrier to all attempts
at commercial transactions with those beyond.
It may he worth noting that the border tribes have now lost the art
of weaving or very nearly so, as the little scraps of cloth they require, are pro-
cured in Asam ; while the Abors are able to weave very pretty, though coarse,
pieces of party coloured cloth, as they cannot trade with Asam.
If it were possible to open broad, neutral avenues among these hills, to
allow the remoter hill tribes a chance of getting into the plains, it would
benefit all parties and injure none, and the Abors* would thus be our native
allies. I may here mention that, even in the rains, five hours’ dry weather after
a week’s rain leaves communications as they were before the rain. The water
runs off as it falls, while in Asam we should have a month’s ‘ boka,’ or mud.
Both physically and linguistically, there is a good deal of difference in
the tribes bordering each other. The Naga vocabulary compiled by Mr.
Bronson at Jaipur in 1840, is of no use here, but sixteen miles west, though
some words are known ; but the numerals are different, and they here only
count to ten.
* I have carefully enquired both among Asamese and Nagas regarding tho
Abors, whether they have a wish to visit the plains, and all without exception say,
they are extremely anxious to do so. This of course is to be expected, as some of
their most valuable articles, as iron, comes from Asam, though in small quantities and
in shape of dhaos. Asam to them is like a goal, always is sight, but never to be
reached. They live in sight of the plains, at not more than a day’s journey.
They are born, live, and die, longing to cross a narrow strip of land, but cannot.
28
[No. 1,
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Naga Ilills.
When once with a number of Banparas on the road, a large party of
Nagas passed, and as neither party spoke, I asked who they were. I was
pointed out their hill, and on asking why they did not speak, they said they
would not understand one another. This I thought a good opportunity
to try them, and told them to call them'in Naga and ask who they were. On
being called to, they all turned round, and stopped, but said nothing ; I
then made them call again; but to no purpose, the other party simply jabbered
together in twos and threes, and on calling them a third time as to where they
were going, they shouted out a lot of Naga which my fellows could not make
out. Both parties passed on, unable to exchange a word, though living
within a few miles of each other. A few words did pass, but they were As-
amese. I asked how they knew the men, and they said “by their ak,” or
tattoo marks. There is more lingual variation among the remote tribes, I
believe, than those bordering As&m, as the latter frequently meet in the plains
on a peaceful footing, while the Abors are shut out from all intercourse.
The physique also varies with the tribe. I can as a rule tell a Joboka
man from a Banpara, and those from a Muton, or Namsangia, and Asamese.
Those who are familiar with the tribes can easily do so, without seeing the ak to
guide them, simply judging by their general physique and colour. Of course
there are exceptional cases, such as small stunted men, or others unusually tall
or well made.
Practically, the extraordinary confusion of tongues opposes a serious
obstacle to the explorer, and the sooner we set to work to reduce the confusion
by inducing opposite causes, the better for us and our successors, and for them
and their successors. Tattooing as a decoration, or prize for committing
murder, is at the bottom of it all, I fancy, and is so deeply rooted, that it
may take a long time to eradicate by peaceful means.
Their religion seems confined to the fear of a legion of deotas or devils,
and has no system, and their devils are of course on a par with their limited
ideas. Whatever they do not understand, is the work of a ‘ deota.’*
Every tree, rock, or path, has its ‘ deo,’ especially lor trees, and water-
falls. If a man is mad, a deo possesses him, who is propitiated by offerings
of dhan, spirits, or other eatables. Deos in fact are omnipresent, and are
supposed to do little else than distress human beings. The only remedy
is presents and counter witchcraft. They seem to have no idea of a Supreme
Being, the idea is certainly not ‘ innate’ here. There are no regular priests,
though they have ‘ deorfs,’ men whose office it is to bury or attend to the
dead. Two or more such men are in each village. They tie up the corpse
* I was once asked by a Naga to point out which of two men had robbed him of
three Rupees, and to use, for the purpose, a small horse-shoe magnet I had. Ho was
under the impression that it was capable of pointing out moral delinquencies.
29
1872.] S. E. Peal — Visit to the Naga Hills.
in tocoo leaves, and put it on the ‘ riik tuas,’ where it is left till sufficiently
decayed when the skull is put in the Morrang.
Appendix I.
Numerals used by the lianparas and neighbouring tribes.
It is worth noting that the Banpara numerals all begin with a, except
the first.
Specimen op a Naga Vocabulary.
* The Mohongias, or Bor and Pam Duarias, 8 miles east,
t The Narnsangias are at Jaipur, 16 miles east.
[No. L
30 S. E. Peal — Visit to the Nag a Mills.
1872.]
S. E. Peal — Visit to the Mgd Kills.
31
Appendix II.
The Asamese Koni Pih, or Poison Perry.
The seeds of this shrub or tree are used by the Asamese to kill and
intoxicate fish in the rivers. They usually select the deep pools, after
the floods have subsided, and stake both the outlet and inlet, so as to prevent
the fish from escaping.
It seems that both the leaf and the bark are capable of poisoning, if used
in any quantity ; but they are not used, because the seed (husk and all) is far
more active. Some say the husks alone are to be used.
Fresh seeds are not selected, but rather old and half rotten ones, and I
hear that if they have lain on the ground, they are still better. The custom is
to collect them some days before the poison is required, and steep them m water-
When soft they are pounded up, seed, husk and all, with some water, care being
taken to protect the face and especially the eyes. When thoroughly reduced
to a pulp, the mass is allowed to stand a day or two, and is then ready to be
thrown into the stream a little above the place selected to catch the fish.
About 5fts. of seed will poison a large ‘ dhubi,’ and of course affect the
stream a long way down. I hear that it is injurious to human beings, and
stories were told me of people killed by it, but I doubt the fact. It seems
universally agreed that if the seeds are kept for a long time in a pot, moistened
and allowed to rot ('? ferment), the poison is far more active, than if only
kept a few days.
‘ Nagd Pih,' another poison used to intoxicate and MU fish.
The tree known by this name grows to a large size, often 2, 3 and 4 feet
in girth, and 50 to 80 feet high. Unlike the Koni Bill, the seeds must be
used when rather unripe, or at least not old ; but all parts of the tree seem
to yield the active principle, though the seeds contain most for a given
weight. The poison is also most virulent if used immediately ; and for
this reason, I suppose, it is the juice itself that is poisonous, and not any
product of fermentation, as seems the case in the first poison. A larger
quantity is also required to produce the same result. It is prepared much
the same way as Koni Bih, that is, pounded up with water and macerated.
The outside of the husk is covered with fine hair or down. The seed
case when cut through, rapidly clanges from a light yellowish white to
a dark greenish black in about a minute or less.
There are also other kinds of poison called ‘ Lota Bih’ and ‘ Deo Bih,’
the latter not known to the Asamese, I believe, and ‘ Bor Bih,’ which is
brought down by the Misfimis,
32
J. M. Foster — Note on Gharg'ion, Asam.
[No. 1,
Note on Ghargaon , Asam. — By J. M. Foster, F. R. G. S., Nazeerah,
Assam.
Ghargaon, for many years the capital of the Ahom kings of Asam,
is so little known, or cared for even by those acquainted with its existence,
that it has been thought worth while to place a record of its appearance at
the present date in the hands of those likely to appreciate such, as in all
probability a few years more will see the place a heap of undistinguishable
ruins, or worse still, converted into materials for building purposes, dime,
neglect, the heavy rains of the country, and frequent earthquakes, have
much injured this once noble pile of masonry ; but strange to say, the hand
of man has done hut little damage so far, a few attempts to find hidden
treasure by digging being the only mischief visible : the scarcity of inhabi-
tants, the respect and awe with which it is regarded, may have served to
protect it so far ; hut it is much to be regretted that so interesting a speci-
men of architecture should have been allowed to fall into such a state, that
the abovementioned causes, and that curse of ancient Indian masonry, the
Pipal tree, must inevitably complete its utter ruin before many years pass
over.
The following extracts from “ A Descriptive Account of Asam, by
William Robinson, 1841” give a slight sketch of the founder and the his-
tory of the place.
P. 318. “ Of the state of the district antecedent to the conquest of the
Ahoms we know nothing. It was in all probability filled by an abundant
Hindu population, from whom the bulk of the present inhabitants have de-
scended. The Ahoms were for many generations confined to the tract east
of the Dehing. As their power increased, their conquests extended beyond that
river, on the left bank of which thoy founded their first capital Huluguri-
nugur. About half-way between Jaipur and Dehing Mukh, extensive re-
mains of the fortifications of the Nugur are still to be seen.’
“ On the further advance of their arms, the Ahoms removed the seat of
government to Ghergaon on the banks of the Dikko, which continued to be
the principal residence of the princes till the prosperity of the Ahom dynasty
began to fade. The royal palace at Ghergaon was surrounded by a brick
wall about two miles in circumference, but the whole town and its suburbs
appear to have extended over many square miles of country. The ruins of
gateways built chiefly of masonry are still to be seen within the fortified
circumvallations which surround the town. It may be observed that one of
the gateways is composed of stone, the blocks bearing marks of iron clamp-
ings, which evidently shows that they once belonged to far more ancient
33
1872.] J. M. Foster — Note on Qliargaon , Asam'.
edifices. From this evidence alone, were there no other, it might safely be
presumed that, long antecedent to the conquests of the Alioms, the countiy
had boon possessed by a race of inhabitants far advanced in some of the arts
civilized life.”
Ghargaon was for certain reasons subsequently abandoned, and Rang-
piir, situated lower down the river and on its left bank, was fixed upon as
the capital. In the troubled reign of Gorinat’h (1780 to 95), llangpur was
abandoned for Jorhat, but even here, the Rajah was not safe, and he fled
for refuge to Gauluitl. On Gorinat’h’s restoration, Jorhat again became
the seat of government, and continued so until the conquest of the country
hy the British troops (1826).
P. 163. “ On the death of Sarga Naraiyan, A. D. 1539, Chucltenmung
succeeded to the throne, (he is said to have instigated the assassination of the
preceding Raja Chuhummung or Dihinaja Raja, or Sarga Naraiyan). He
is said to have built the town and fort of Gargaun, or Ghergong. He reigned
thirteen years and was succeeded hy his son Chuckampha. Aothing le-
markable is recorded of him except that he enjoyed the throne for lift} -nine
years in comparative peace and comfort.”
P. 165. “ In 1654, Chutumla succeeded his father Churumpha who
was deposed and put in prison for imbecility. Soon after his accession, he
adopted the Hindu faith and assmned the name Jaiyadhajia Singh. At the
latter end of his reign, in 1601, the valley was invaded by Mir Jumla, the
Subadar of Bengal, who sent up his stores and provisions in boats, but
crossing the Bhramaputra at Rangamati, marched his army by land. The
march "was tedious and on its progress the army was greatly annoyed by
the Assamese. This added to the fatigue of dragging the boats, greatly
affected the troops. The Subadar at length reached the capital Ghergaon,
which, after a severe conflict, he succeeded in taking, and the Raja was obliged
to tako refuge in the mountains. The rains of 1662 set in with great vio-
lence, and the Raja issued from his place of concealment in the mountains
and cut off the provisions of the Moguls. A pestilence also broke out in
the camp which carried off many, whether they returned or remained they
were equally exposed to death : in this miserable state they passed the rains,
but no sooner was the country dry, than, according to the Musalman his-
torians, they took courage and bravely repelled the enemy. The Raja is
said to have solicited peace, which Mir Jumla was happy to grant, for he
was himself attacked hy disease and his troops were mutinous. The same
accounts state that the Assamese were obliged to give 20,000 tolahs of gold,
100,000 of silver, and 40 elephants ; and the Raja gave up his daughter to be
married to one of the Muhammadan princes, and agreed to pay an annual
tribute. The native annals on the contrary inform us that Mir Jumla’s
army was entirely defeated, and he was obliged to give up the whole of the
34
[No. 1,
J. M. Foster — Note on Ghargaon, Asam.
zillah Kamrup to the Assamese, which was from that time placed under
the management of a great Assamese officer, the Barphukan, and formed a
government equal to about a third of the whole kingdom. Jaiyadhajia
Singh died in 1GG3.
“ He was succeeded by Chupungmung who was assassinated in 1672. The
latter was succeeded by his younger brother Sucklumpha who was secretly
poisoned two years after at the instigation of the Bar Baruwa, who assumed a
great degree of authority, although he had installed Sulung, the young prince of
Samaguriya. The Queen objecting to the Bar Baruwa’s usurpation, laid a
plot for destroying him which he discovered, and despatched the king with
his own hands, whilst his myrmidons assassinated the Queen and members of
the Council. The young king reigned but one month and fifteen days.
The Bar Baruwa next raised Teenkungiya to the throne ; but the officers of
Gowhatty with a body of troops proceeded to the metropolis, secured the
Bar Baruwa, beheaded him and strangled the new Baja after a reign of
twenty days. Chujinpha was then placed on the throne, who committed
suicide in 1677. In 1G99, Chuclcungpha founded the city and fort of Bung-
pur (Sibsagor), and caused the extensive tank to be made which still
bears his name. In 1770, the Moamariahs captured Ghergaon, but it was
recaptured five months later by the adherents of Luckmi Singh, who died in
1780. The Moamariahs, in 1784, after some tremendous battles again cap-
tured the place, and the king, Chuhitpungpha escaped to Gowhatti : after
many changes of various kinds, the British Government sent a detachment
to aid them in 1792, under Captain Welsh, who successfully put down the
Moamariah insurrection.” The Burmese invasion, a matter of modern his-
tory, was finally suppressed by the British troops at Bungpur in 1825 ;
since that date, the authority of the Assam Bajas has been at an end.”
Another version, by a contemporary, of the invasion of Assam is to be
found in an old work entitled, ‘ Particular Events, or the most Consider-
able Passages after the War of Five Years or thereabout, in the Empire of the
Great Mogul,’ Tom. II. By Mons. F. Bernier, London, 1G71.’
P. 110. “ Aurengzebe too well knowing that a great Captain cannot
be long at rest, and that, if he be not employed in a Forreign War, he will at
length raise a Domestick one ; proposed to him to make War upon that rich
and potent Baja of Aeliatn, whose Territories are on the North of Dake,
upon the Gulf of Bengala. The Emir, who in all appearance had already
designed the same thing of himself, and who believed, that the Conquest of
this Country would make way for his Immortal Honour, and he an occasion
oi carrying his Arms as far as China, declared himself ready for this Enter-
prize. He embarked at Dake with a puissant Army, upon a Biver which
comes from those parts ; upon which having gone about a hundred leagues
North Eastward, he arrived at a Castle called Azo [Hajo], which the Bajah of
35
1872.] J. M. Foster — Note on Qhargnon, Asam.
Acham had usurped from the Kingdom of Bengala, and possessed for many
years. He attacked this place, and took it by force in less than fifteen
daies ; thence marching overland towards Chamdara, which is the Inlet into
the Country of that Raja, he entered into it after 26 daies’ journey, still
Northward : There a Battel was fought, in which the Raja of Acham was
worsted, and obliged to retreat to Guerguon, the Metropolis of his King-
dom, four miles distant from Chamdara. The Emir pursued him so close,
that he gave him no time to fortifie himself in Guerguon ; For he arrived
in sight of that Town in five daies, which constrained the Raja, seeing the
Emir’s Army, to fly towards the Mountains of the Kingdom of Lassa, and
to abandon Guerguon, which was pillaged as had been Chamdara. They
found there vast riches, it being a great, very fair and Merchant-like Town,
and where the women are extraordinarily beautiful. Meantime, the season
of the Rains came in sooner than usually : and they being excessive in those
parts, and overflowing all the Country, except such Villages as stand on
raised ground, the Emir was much embarrassed. For the Raja made his
people of the Mountains come down from all parts thereabout, and to carry
away all the provisions of the Field, whereby the Emir’s Army (as rich as
t’was) before the end of the rains, fell into great streights, without being
able to go forward or backward. It could not advance by reason of the
Mountains very difficult to pass, aud continually pester’d with great Rains :
nor retreat, because of the late Rains and deep ways ; the Raja having also
caused the way to be digged up as far as Chamdara : So that the Emir was
forced to remain in that wretched condition during the whole time of the
Rain ; after which when he found his Army distasted, tired out, and half
starved, he was necessitated to give over the design he had of advancing, and
to return the same way he was come. But this retreat was made with so
much pains, and so great inconveniences, by reason of the dirt, the want of
victuals, and the pursuit of the Raja falling on the Rear, that every body
(but he) that had not known how to remedy the disorder of such a March,
nor had the patience to be sometimes five or six hours at one passage to
make the Souldicry get over it without confusion, would have utterly
perished, himself, army, and all ; yet he notwithstanding all these difficulties,
made a shift to come back with great honour and vast riches. He designed
to return thither again the next year, and to pursue his undertaking, sup-
posing that Azo which he# had fortified, and wdiere he left a strong garrison,
would be able to hold out the rest of the year against the Raja. But he no
sooner arrived there, but dysentery began to rage in his army. Neither had
he himself a body of steel more than the rest ; he fell sick and died, whereby
fortune ended the just apprehensions of Aurengzebe. I say the just appre-
hensions, for there was none of those that knew this great man, and the
state of affairs of Industan, who did not say : “ ’Tis this day that Aureng-
zebe is king of Bengala.”
36
[No. 1,
J. M. Poster — Note on Ghargaon, Asam.
In a work styled ‘ Tales of Shipwrecks and Adventures at Sea., London,
2nd Edit., 1852,’ at page 705, under the heading, “ Loss of the ‘ Ter Schelling,’
including the various calamities of the crew, during an unfortunate voyage
to Bengal in 1661,” we find the following record of the progress of the
Emir’s army in Assam as related by some Dutch sailors who went to
Ghargaon. The ‘ Ter Schelling’ left Batavia for Bengal on the 3rd Septem-
ber, 1661, in company with two other vessels. On the 18th October,
they sighted the coast of Bengal, parted company, got caught in a heavy
storm, and struck several times on the sandbanks in the Sunderban£ They
were' finally wrecked, and the crew suffered great privations on the desert
islands. Ultimately, eight of the crew (Charles Dohbcl and seven others) left
the islands in a boat, and travelled for many days, until picked .up by some of
the natives who took them to a village after plundering them of all money, &c.
The ‘ Governor’ treated them kindly and forwarded them to Bolwa [Bhaluah].
The narrative will be best continued in the original text. ‘ The night follow-
ing they arrived at Assam [?], a poor despicable place that afforded nothing.
Here they sent hack the three barques and hired another as far as Bolwa.
At two leagues’ distance from this village, their guides set them on shore,
and made them walk the rest of the way. Whilst these guides went to the
governor to give notice of their arrival, our adventurers bought milk and rice,
which they dressed in a pot that was sent them by Moors, that spoke the
Portuguese language. It was nearly ready when their guides returned, and
told them they must come immediately to the prince, who sent for them.
This news displeased them, for their appetites were very keen ; however they
took the pot, and carried it by turns to the prince’s palace gate ; where they
eat what was in it before they entered. They were at length brought to
their lodging, and, by the prince’s order, served with an exoellent kind of
meat called brensie [harisah, ?], which is only seen here at great men’s tables.
This was such a nourishing food, that in three or four days they recovered
their full strength. In a day or two after, the prince sent them word that
they might go where they pleased, the barques being ready. This being
then’ desire they parted an horn* after, and happily arrived at Decka. The
factory received them very kindly, to whom our adventurers imparted their
whole story.
“ The governor now caused a barque to be ready to transport them to
Ongueli [Hugli], where the Dutch have also a considerable factory. But an
hour before the appointed time of their departure, the governorreceived a letter
from the Great Mogul’s general, in which he enjoined him to send them to
him. This order they were obliged to obey, though contrary to their in-
clinations ; for this general threatened, in case of refusal, to seize upon all the
Dutch in his master’s kingdom, and make them slaves. They travelled thirty
days together, sometimes by land, and sometimes by sea, passing by se-
1871.]
37
J. M. Foster — Note on Gfiargaon, Asdm.
veral cities made desolate ; the inhabitants of the country being wont, in
time of war, to leave their houses, in order to follow the army wherever it
marched.
“ On the thirty- fifth day they went on hoard one of the vessels belong-
ing to’Xiibah [the Nawab], where they found four Englishmen, some few Por-
tuguese, and two of their own party. From thence they went and cast anchor
near the city of Renguemati. In a short time they landed and were entertain-
ed in the army of the Great Mogul. The general, whom they saluted in his tent,
seemed glad to see them, and immediately ordered a large cup of arrack,
that they might drink his health. The cup was so closed that it was a dif-
ficult matter for them to open it ; and therefore the general ordered it on
purpose, to divert himself with their embarrassments. Every one endeavoured
to open it, but to no purpose ; at last one of the party finding it was made
of wood, made a hole in it with the point of his knife, and being brim-full
the arrack sprung out abundantly. By this means they all drank of it ; and
it being a very strong liquor, they were soon intoxicated.
“ The next morning tho General sent them three hundred rupees, and
assigned them certain vessels called gom’opcs[vLr« gTiraV], one of which carried
fourteen guns, and about fifty or sixty men. Each gourope was attended with
four kosses JcosaK], which are boats with cars, to row great vessels. There
were also several great flat-bottomed boats which carried no masts, but were
well furnished with guns. The greatest part of the officers were Portuguese.
There were several other vessels laden only with provisions and ammuni-
tion. As soon as they wore ordered to march, cur adventurers sought the
vessel which was assigned to them ; but, in the great multitude of people,
two of them unfortunately went astray, and were eight days without
knowing where to betake themselves. After a long march, these two
wanderers entered Kosbia [Koch Bihar], a country lying between Bengal
and Azo [Hajo],
“ The Great Mogul’s general was at war with the king of Azo, and at
this time subdued him. Our two adventurers expected a share of the plunder,
but were disappointed. This was exceedingly mortifying to them ; their
wages, which were no more than ten crowns a month, being insufficient to
maintain them, on account of the then dearness of provisions. The reason
that they had no more was, because they served in the army by constraint,
whereas those who served voluntarily had twenty-five crowns each per
month.
“ Immediately after the overthrow of the king of Azo, the general has-
tened to attack the countries belonging to the king of Assam ; and lest the
floods, which every six months overflowed the greatest part of the kingdom,
should frustrate his designs, he advanced with great expedition, and arrived
before that time at the place he intended.
38
J. M. Foster — Note on Ghargion, Asam.
[No. 1,
“ In the mean time our two adventurers, and the English who belonged
to the army, having observed all the signs of an approaching tempest, care-
fully repaired their vessels. These precautions, however, were unavailing ; the
vessel in which were our two adventurers, not having been properly ballasted,
was overturned by the currents, and four Dutchmen and twenty-four Moors
perished. Both our heroes, after swimming sevei'al hours towards land, had
the good fortune to be assisted by an English vessel, which took them on board.
The next morning they thanked their benefactors and went to the army,
where they sought an occasion of admittance to the general. As soon as he
heard of the loss of the vessel, he fell into a violent passion, and commanded
them to withdraw and choose what other vessel they had a mind to.
“ In two days after, their admiral sot sail in search of the enemy, atten-
ded by the whole fleet. Although the wind was little favourable to them,
the vessel which our adventurers entered, followed on the course, and three
or four hours afterwards dashed against a rock, wlvich struck off their helm.
Not long after, they discovered the enemy’s fleet, consisting of six hundred
sail. As soon as the enemy perceived them, they advanced, and a smart en-
counter ensued. They took three hundred of the enemy’s vessels, the least
of which carried seventy men ; and of this whole number there did not escape
above fifty. The three hundred vessels that escaped, unhappily east anchor
at about a quarter of a league’s distance from the general, who advanced up
the country with all possible expedition. Having brought near three hund-
red pieces of cannon, he planted them against them, and sunk the greatest
part of them ; the rest passed over to the other side of the river, and were
pursued by the general’s vessels with success.
“ After this pursuit, their admiral cast anchor before the city of Lokwa,
situated about six leagues from Gueragon. They were obliged to stay here
about three months in consequence of the flood : as soon as the waters were
sufficiently fallen, they quitted their post. Having been fifteen months in
the Great Mogul’s army, by the mediation of their consul, our adventurers
at length obtained their discharge, and prepared for their departure. In
fifteen days they came to Decka, and thence took shipping for Ongueli.
Having sailed about one hundred and twenty leagues along the river, they
made some stay at Cazimabahar [Qazimbazar, near Murshidabad], a place
famous for silks. From thence they returned to Ongueli, where each betook
himself to different employs, and it was not till 1673, that the last of our
adventurers was enabled to return to his native country.”
The palace of the Rajahs in Ghargaon is situated nearly in the centre of
a large enclosed space about a mile from the Dik’ho river, and nine miles
east of Sibsagar (Bangpur). The surrounding ‘bund’ is -some fifteen feet
broad on the top, and about eight feet high, but considerably more on the
outer face where an enormous ditch exists all around, some forty feet wide and
1872.]
J. M. Foster — Note on Ghargaon, Asam.
89
of various depths, made probably to provide materials for the wall as well
as assist in the defence of the place. The core of the bund is said to be brick,
and is covered with earth, now overgrown with forest trees. Here is also
another bund, (query, an outer line of defence) some four or five miles outside
Ghargaon proper. There are numerous traditions respecting the enclosed land ;
one that none but the better families were allowed to reside within it ; another
story tells us that the bund was planted with dense hedges of bamboos (hence
its name Bansgayh), and this enormous tract of country was used as a preserve
for wild elephants ; another that it was the private property of the Rajah,
and that no one could exercise judicial powers within it but the Rajah him-
self ; whilst some think, it is merely a coincidence, and this bund was simply a
road (as it is in many parts at the present date) that may have been construct-
ed before or about the time Ghargaon was adopted the capital. The Romans
have • the reputation of being the masters in the art of road-making, but their
efforts seem small when compared with the network of enormous bunds inter-
secting this country in all directions, and made absolutely from mud alone, no
other materials being procurable. The same neglect which has allowed the
historic monuments of this country to fall into ruins, is very perceptible to
any one who has the misfortune of being obliged to travel over these once
magnificent roads during the wet season.
Reference is made to Chamdara in the account of Mir JumlalTs advance,
by Mons. F. Bernier : this place will be seen marked about five miles from
Ghargaon on the road to Sibsagar, where the road cuts through the
Bansgarh, and is still known by its ancient name. The gateway there,
with an innnensc amount of fine carved stonework, has been utilized for build-
ing purposes by the Public Works Department. The road from Ghargaon to
this spot is very different to the ‘ Rajah’ roads, and seems never to have been
properly repaired since dug up to annoy the enemy’s troops in 1G62. The city
of Lokwa (Lukwah) mentioned in the sailor’s narrative, is some sixteen
miles from Ghargaon, on the Rajgarh : not a brick is to be seen there now,
the place is at present a tea garden ; a portion of Mir Jumlah’s fleet must
have gone up the Desang upon which Lukwah is situated, and probably a
portion of the forces marched down the Rajgarh to invest Ghargaon on the
east, whilst another portion of the fleet and army went of the Dik’ho, land-
ing about where Rangpur (Sibsagar) now stands, to attack on the west ;
for it seems highly improbable that the whole of the forces could have gone
up the Desang to attack Lukwah, when the Dik’ho route to Ghargaon was
nearer, more practicable for both fleet and army, and had water communica-
tion to within gunshot of Ghargaon itself, whilst Lukwah was at least sixteen
miles distant.
The stone gateway mentioned by Robinson, the guard houses, and other
brick buildings in the enclosed space at Ghargaon have all disappeared since
40
J. M. Foster — Note on Ghmydon, Asdm.
[No. 1,
1866 ; the bund is overgrown with forest ; the ditch in many places filled
with rank vegetation, and the enclosure itself a mass of dense jungle. The
palace, as before mentioned, is rapidly crumbling away ; in 1869, the north-
west front consisting of two verandahs fell in, the balustrades in many places
are gone, huge cracks gape in every direction, the rain finds its way from top
to bottom of the building, and although the plans shew that it is of the most
massive construction, it is hardly safe for a visitor to mount to the summit.
Some twenty years since, it was temporarily occupied by some tea planters
who are said to have made slight repairs ; they are also credited with having
found a sword having a silver hilt, and an ivory and gold sheath, besides
other valuables.
The so-called palace itself may be described as a quadrangular pile of
brickwork consisting of three stories above ground, and two subterranean
ones. The surface of the soil being very soft and liable to inundations 'from
the Dik’ho, an immense mass of boulders was placed there, upon which the
palace was erected, some ten feet above the level of the surrounding country.
These boulders were probably procured from Santok Mukli, about twelve
miles from Ghargaon, up the river Dik’ho, that being the nearest place where
they can be found. The subterranean chambers have been visited of late
years, but presented nothing of interest, and at the present date are hardly
accessible from fallen brickwork, &c. The building has cupolas at the angles
and a terminal one at the summit in the centre ; the openings on to the
verandahs are generally arched, frequently cusped : all the decorations are
in stucco, and although cut or carved bricks have been found in the imme-
diate vicinity, not one is visible in 'or on the palace itself. This is singular,
as cut bricks seem to constitute the chief ornaments of the old Asamese
buildings in this district. The walls and piers are very massive, and the
openings generally small. The general design seems more ornate than useful,
and it is apparently as much a temple as a dwelling or palace. The bricks,
or rather tiles, of which it is entirely composed (not a particle of wood or
stone being perceptible) are extremely hard and frequently hear a polish, and
are seldom of the same thickness and superficial measure, a fair specimen
8" x 10" x If". In one verandah the ornamented stucco has fallen off in
places disclosing an under layer of the same material having the same
pattern but on a slightly smaller scale. The plans and photographs will
give a far more correct idea of the peculiarities of the building than any
written description can supply. The buildings near the palace were stand-
ing some three years since, and consisted of a large square room, said to have
been a room for holding nautclies in, and a long arched passage-like building
of which it is impossible to conjecture the use. Remains of brickwork some
three hundred yards from the palace lead to the conclusion that there might
have been a brick wall surrounding it at that distance, but the dense jungle
1872.] J. M. Foster — Notes on Ghargaon, Asain. 41
renders it impossible to follow it up. There were several largo tanks also
within the enclosure, of which but one remains in good order. The remains
of a bund surrounding what might have been a fruit garden has also been
noticed.
A very curious tradition respecting the builder of the palace is current
amongst the natives. A Bangalf architect named Q-onsam was invited
by the Rajah Chuckcnmung to construct this palace. Wishing to obtain
for his Rajah in Bengal all particulars as to the strength and population of
the country, he suggested that in making the bricks they should bo mixed with
the white of eggs to render them harder. On Chuckcnmung enquiring where
such a vast number of eggs could be obtained, he intimated that if every one
in Asam gave two eggs each, he would probably have sufficient for his pur-
pose. The order was accordingly given, the eggs provided, and secretly coun-
ted by the builder. Unfortunately for him, the Rajah was quite alive to the
stratagem, and when the building was completed, dismissed bim and his
assistants with great praise and riches. They were escorted across the river
to be conveyed to Dik'ho Mukb by road (the Bor Alii) ; but immediately
they got as far as Nazi rah, they were attacked, made prisoners and beheaded
on the spot, and the treasure returned to the Rajah.
The importance of this place during the seventeenth and eighteenth
centuries can bo judged from the immense number of ruined temples, vast
tanks, enormous maidans, and the once magnificent roads and river bunds ;
it is now but sparsely populated, and the greater part of the country is one
enormous jungle. The district is well worthy of a visit by some competent
antiquarian, to rescue from oblivion archaeological treasures that are now
rapidly perishing from neglect and wilful destruction, and would amply
repay the tune and labour spent upon a thorough investigation of its many
art treasures and historical monuments.
G
42
J. Beames — Translations from Ghand Bardai's Epic. [No. 1,
Translations of selected portions of Boole I. of Ghand Bardai's Epic. — By
John Beames, B. C. S., M. E. A. S., etc.
After the severe strictures passed on my translation of the 19th hook by
Mr. Growse, (which, however, ho subsequently retracted) I think it necessary
again to point out that in a poem constructed like this, absolute accuracy of
translation is impossible. The lines generally consist of a string of crude
forms of nouns without any inflectional terminations, or signs of case. In
languages destitute of such grammatical formations, the order of words in a
sentence often supplies the requisite clue to the meaning. This is not the
case with Ghand. His words, if taken in the order in which they stand,
often yield no meaning at all. In some cases turn the words as we may, it
is not easy to make out any clear sense. The verbs when they occur do
certainly exhibit some signs of tense ; thus we have the singular masculine of
the preterite in -yaw, the feminine in - i , the plural masculine in -e, the plural
feminine in -in ; but more frequently all tenses and persons are rudely ex-
pressed by the indefinite participle in -i, as Icari, delclii, which serves alike for
past, present, and future time.
There are two other difficulties. Archaic words which neither occur in
the modem languages, nor can be traced to any known Sanskrit root ; and
the insertion of arbitrary letters to eke out the rhythm, such as la, su, ha,
which have no meaning whatever.
When to all this is added the extreme difficulty of dividing the words,
I think I am not asking too much from critics, if I request that they will
confine themselves to politely stating that they think I am mistaken ; in-
stead of at once taxing me with ignorance of a language which I have studied
for fourteen years, and whose difficulty I appreciate as much as any one can.
I have recently leamt from a missionary at Ajmir that even the pro-
fessional hards of that place admit their inability to understand more than
the general drift of Chand’s poems.
The secret of this loose careless archaic patois will only be discovered,
when our researches into the vast and ancient language of which it repre •
sents one phase have been established on a firm footing. To that end some
few of us are devoting our spare time. The following efforts at a render-
ing are perhaps premature, but even so they may yield some fruit of assist-
ance to the greater task, and may even prove in some sort a guide to those
who in time to come may approach the subject with a better apparatus
criticus than we possess at present. The Latin and Greek scholars of the
fifteenth century knew very little compared with those of the present day ;
yet the world is not without some debt to Erasmus and Eeuchlin, or even to
43
1872.] J. Beames — Translations from Chand Bardai's Epic.
their learned predecessors. Put me and my contemporaries as low as you
will in the scale of scholarship, yet it must be admitted that we are making
a beginning, upon which the better furnished scholars of the future will
perhaps be not ashamed to build.
1st Selection. — The OPENnra of the poem. Stanzas 1 — 13.
First, Satak metre. Om ! —
1. First reverently bowing, bowing, the poet adores the feet of the
Gurus.
(Taking) refuge at the feet of the highest, the afforder of support,1 the
husband of the opulent Lachhi ;
(Who) stands the lord of vice and of virtue, consuming the wicked, the
lord of heaven, blessing with success ;
(Who is as) sandalwood to the life of living beings moving on the earth,
lord of all, bestower of blessings.
2. Vathua metre.
First the very auspicious root is to be celebrated.2
Irrigated with the water of the truth of tradition,
Religion, (like) a fair tree with one trunk sprung up
With thrice six branches rejoicing the three worlds,
„ Leaves (of various) colours, leaves (like) mouths, there were*
Colour of flowers, and weight of fruit (it had)
Speech unfailing, princely,
Rejoicing with fragrance the sight and touch
A’san tree of hope to the parrot (-like) poet.
3. Kavit.
First having indeed proclaimed a blessing
Having honored4 the sacred writings, (whose) beginning (is) the Veda,
(Whose) three-fold branches, in (all) four directions
(Are) possessed of colour, and leaves (like) letters
Religion having sprouted (out through) the bark
Flowered fair in (all) four directions
Its fruit, (virtuous) deeds,8 springing out
Immortal, dwelling amidst mortals
(Firm as) counsel of kings, (or as) the earth, the wind shakes it not
Giving to life the flavour of nectar,
The Kali (yuga) affixes no stain to it
Containing truth, wisdom, and (perpetual) freshness.
4. Kavit.
Taking possession of the earth (like) a garden plot
Irrigating it with the fullness of the Yeda, as with water
Placing in it good seed6
Upsprung the shoot of knowledge
44 J. Beames— Translations from CTiand Bardai's Epic. [No. 1,
Combining branches of three qualities
With leaves of many names, red as earth
It flowered with good deeds, and good thoughts
Complete deliverance, union of substances
The twice-bom of pure mind have experienced the flavour of perfect
wisdom
A banian tree of delight, spreading abroad virtues,
The branches of (this) excellent tree in the three worlds
Unconquered, victorious, diffusing virtues.
5. Bhujanga prayata metre.
First be the well adorned Bhujangi7 taken
Whose name this one, is spoken in many ways
Second, betaken the god, the lord of life
Who placed the universe by powerful spells on Seshnag.
In the four Vedas by the Brahmans the glory of Hari is spoken,
Of whose virtue, this unvirtuous world is witness.
Third, the Bharati Vyasa spake the Bharath,
Who boro witness to the more than human charioteer.3
Fourth Suka deva at the feet of Parikliit
Who extolled all the kings of the race of Kura
Fifth * * 8
Who placed a six-fold necklace on the neck of King Nala.
Sixth Kalidasa, fair of speech, fair of wit
Whose speech is that of a poet, a master-poet fair-speaking,
Who made the pure fragrance of the mouth of Kali,
Who firmly bound the dyke of three-fold enjoyment.
Seventh, Banda mali’s charming poem
The wave of whose wit is as the stream of Ganga.
Jayadcva eighth, poet, king of poets
Who only made the song of Govinda ;
Take all these poets as thy spiritual guide, Poet Chand,
Whose body is as a sacrifice inspired by Devi.
The poets who have uttered praises and excellent speech,
Of them Poet Chand has spoken highly.
G. Duha.
The speech in verse of Chand, excellent.
Hearing him utter, his wife (says)
Purifier of the body, O poet,
Uttering excellent speech.
7. Kavit.
Saith the wife to her husband.
Purifier of offspring, great poet,
45
1872.] l J. Beames — Translations from CUiand Ilardai's 'Epic.
Uttering spells and charms,
Like an oblation offered to Devi,
Hero of spells, very terrible,
Giving pleasure to kings by thy poetry ;
The childish sports, one by one,
Of the gods having extolled in thy poems,
Having uttered unchecked speech,
From which to me (comes) wisdom,
That word which is the visible form of Brahrn,
Why should not the best of poets speak it P
8. Kavit, Chand’s speech.
To his wife (saith) the bal’d
Chand, muttering soft and low,
That true word of Brahrn,
Purifier of (all) others itself pure,
That word which has no form,
Stroke, letter, or colour,
Unshaken, unfathomable, boundless,
Purifier of all things in the three worlds,
That word of Brahma, let me expound
The glory of the Gurus, pleasing to Saraswati,
If in the arrangement of my phrases I should succeed,
It will be pleasing to thee, O lotus-faced one !
9. Kavit, Chand’s wife’s speech.
Thou art the poet, the excellent bard,
Gazing on the heavens with unclouded intellect,10
Skilful in the arrangement of metres
Having made the song of the Peacock-youth
The wave of thy wit is like Ganga,
Uttering speech immortal, soft
Good men hearing it are rejoiced,
(It) subdues like a spell of might.
The incarnation King Prithiraj the lord,
Who maintained the happiness of his kingdom,
Hero, chief of heroes, and all his paladins,
Of them speak a good word.13
10. Kavit, Chand’s speech.
To her of the elephant-gait, Chand
Singing a pleasant rhyme (said),
Ravisher of the soul, tendril of enjoyment,
Possessing the fragrance of the ocean of the gods,
(Thou) of the glancing eye, in the flower of thy youth,
J. Beames — Translations from Chand Tardai s Epic.
[No. 1,
46
Beloved of my soul, giver of bliss,
Wife, free from all evil qualities,13
(Thou) who hast obtained the fruit of the worship of Gauri.
As many poems as there have been from first to last
Consider how endless a string (there is) of them,
The description of this matter (is in) many books,
Thus having taken in the best counsel.14
11. Paddhari metre.
First reverencing my first of gods
Who uttered the imperishable word Om !
Who made the Formed out of the Formless,
The will of his mind blossomed and bore fruit,
The sheen of the three qualities, inhabiting the three worlds,
Shining on gods in heaven, men on earth, serpents (in hell).
Then in the form of Brahma leaving the Brahma-egg,15
The lord, the essence of truth said the four Yedas,
The creator uttered them, unwritten,
Without qualities, having neither form nor line,
He who made the heaven, earth, and hell,
Yama, Brahma, Indra, the Rishis, and guardians of the worlds,
Winds, fire, clouds, ether,
Rivers, ocean, earth, mountains, and their inhabitants,
He created eighty-four lakhs of living beings
I cannot come to an end of the description of them.
He made a tendril of eighteen colours,
Of various kinds, subject to all qualities,
No one can resist his commands,
Placing the order on his head (one) bears grief in the body.
Day by day the sun-god when night turns to dawn16
Rises ; this comes to pass by force of the lord’s command.
The moon every night obedient to order
Rises in the sky, being without division,
The guardians of the regions remain patiently pressed down by the
earth,
Their joints do not ache though they remain firmly pressed.
He appoints to the wind its measure and the place of its going,
It neither exceeds nor falls short, makes joy to the body.
Indra’s heaven, clouds, and sky (obey his) order,
He makes the rain to rain joyfully.
Firm and immoveable remains the earth (like) the glory of the lord,
It cannot shake or move for an instant in distress.
The wave rising touches the sky,
47
1872.] J. Beames — Translations from Cliand Bardai's Epic.
On the brink of the ocean there remains no trace of it ;
Having obtained its limit, not one (wave) passes it,
It advances only so far as the lord’s command (allows).
His order no one can refute,
Neither in the past, nor in the future, nor in the present.
The Yeda describes Brahma as illimitable,
Filling the water and land he remains in every material object.
Then spake Vyasa eighteen Puranas.
Arranging the incarnations in various order
He describes with clear intellect every god,
He searched out all of them, he did not confound their character.
Then Valmiki, the incarnation of Ram,
Related in a book of a hundred krores (of lines) essence of truth.
# # # #18
The mighty bear, the story of the friendly monkey
Again five poems live poets made,
Placed a light in the breasts of ignorant men,
In a few words wisdom is shown,
I might make a boast, then you would laugh.
12. Dulm. Hearing the poem of Poet Chand,
Delighted in her mind, his wife (says),
Thou art the poet, the charming poet,
Laughing being prevented.
13. Kavit. Quoth the intelligent wife.
Thou who hast spells on thy tongue — ocean of spells
Excelling in the description of witness
Like the shining moon
Thou bestower of heavenly blessings,
Grant a gift to me, 0 poet !
The eighteen Puranas
Their names and quantity all ;
Thou telling the tale joy (will be) to me,
Past and future existences will be purified,
The darkness of ignorance is destroyed by hearing this,
The filth of (spiritual) blindness is removed from the heart.
Whereupon Chand in a long Kavit recites the names of the Puranas
and number of lines contained in each.
It is not worth translating.
48 J. Beames — Translations from Cliand Bardai's Epic. [No. 1.
Notes to l.s/ Selection.
1. Or “ supporting the earth,” if trrC'rf be meant for VOift, which is
quite possible.
2. This line is extra-metral, and is probably meant as a note.
3. A conjectural rendering, which does not satisfy me. I can propose
no better.
4. I read Another reading is ijqapsj, which seems to have arisen
from an omission of the vowel by the copyist.
5.
6. This strange line I read as if for =l’t5T QW 'jTWI
7. I do not know what the allusion is here.
8. These words are probably a corruption, 'acRTT*! ^nT«J being for
more than earthly, from 'g'cr, over, and Tjfkpft, earth, and
charioteer. It is an allusion to Krishna’s acting as charioteer to Arjuna in
the great war.
9. I cannot understand this line.
10. Of the many senses of *n«(r, the one here given is the only one that
will yield any meaning.
11. This seems to be an allusion to the Sanskrit poem called Kumara
Sambhava, or the “Birth of the Wargod” Kartikeya, whose emblem is the
peacock. Chand may have written a paraphrase of that work, as he seems
to have been well acquainted with Sanskrit literature.
12. is still the common Panjibi for “ a word.” Many of these
Panjabi words occur in Chand, which is natural, as he was a native of Labor.
13. Literally, wife without the quality i. e., unqualified by) — of
heavy, bad qualities.
14. I do not pretend to understand what the poet means by these
four lines, which I have translated as literally as I could.
15. I read SHOT'S ^TtT (for but there is another reading
^3qifV, which is not intelligible. ^3 and vT are often written for one another in
the MSS.
16. rsifsr WTT, literally 1 dawn of night,’ which would convey a dif-
ferent meaning to our minds.
17. having no Kalas, or the 16 digits into which the moon is
divided.
18. This line is not intelligible, it contains some allusion to Sita’s
rape, but the meaning is not clear.
(To be continued .)
1872.]
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and Asam.
49
Koch Bihar, Koch Hdjo, and Asam, in the 16 th and Vltli centuries, ac-
cording to the Akbarn&mah, the Pddishdhnamah, and the Kathiyah i
’ lbriyah . — By H. Blochmamt, M. A., Calcutta Madrasah.
The beginning of Anrangzih’s reign is marked by two expeditions which
led to a temporary occupation of territories beyond the frontiers of
Eastern Bengal. Not only had the gradual retreat of Prince Shuja’ from
Akbamagar (Rdjmahall) to Dhaka and Chatganw (Chittagong) given rise to
the maintenance of a large army, consisting chiefly of troops recruited by the
officers themselves, which might conveniently be employed to settle several
frontier disputes of long standing, to in vade Rukhang (Aracan) and recoverthe
children of the lost prince, but Aurangzib found it also absolutely necessary
to give employment to generals on whose military experience, the result of
the wars of succession, he looked with unconcealed distrust. Dadd Khan’s
expedition to Palamau, of which the particulars were given in last year’s
Journal, occupied the Bihar corps; and Mir Jumkh Mu’azzam Khan, the
‘ Tar i wafadar,' or faithful friend of the throne, received orders to use
his army and extend the imperial dominions in the north along the Brahma-
putra, and in the south along the eastern shores of the Bay of Bengal. In
the expedition to A'sam, which is related below, the furthest point to which
the Mughuls advanced, is marked by the intersection of 95° Long., and 27°
Lat., i. e., the district north of Sibsagar and Nazir ah (the old Ghargaon) in
Upper Asam ; and in the expedition to Aracan, which was undertaken after
Mir Jumlah’s death, the most southern point is Raimi, or Rambu, between
21° and 22° Lat., half way between Chatganw and Akyab. Beyond these
two points the Muhammadans did not advance. We have no particulars
of any expedition led by the old kings of Bengal against Aracan ; A'sam
was invaded about 1500 by Husain Shdh of Bengal, the scanty narrative of
the expedition forming an interesting page in the description given by the
Persian historian of Mir Jumlah’s invasion.
The south-eastern frontier of Bengal up to the time of Aurangzib was
the Phani (Fenny) River, Bhaluah and Nawak’hali being the most easterly
‘ th&nabs’ of Sirkar Sunnargaon. The A'in i Akbari, indeed, includes
Sirkar Chdtgfinw in Bengal ; but there is no evidence that the Mughuls ever
obtained a footing east of the Phani River before tbe annexation of Chatganw
under Aurangzib. The frontier then passed along the western portions of
Tiparah as far as Silhat and Liitu, went then westwards along the southern
skirts of the Khasiah, Garo, and the Karibari Hills, Hatsilah* on the left
* Kennel spells the name Hautchella, and places it opposite to Chilmari on the
right bank of the river. I cannot find the name on modern maps. Latu is spelt
Ladu in the Am.
50 H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and Asam. [No. 1,
bank of the Brahmaputra being looked upon as a frontier town, and then
along the Brahmaputra as far as the Parganah Bhetarhand, at the
confluence of the Sankos and the Brahmaputra rivers. From Bhetarhand
the frontier passed westward to PStg&nw and the northern portions of Sirkar
Purniah. The Morang, Koch Bihar, and the districts at the angle of the
Brahmaputra lay beyond the empire.
The countries bordering on the Mughul empire in the N. E. of Bengal
were Koch Bihar and Koch Hajo. The latter is called by old English
travellers ‘ the kingdom of Azo.’ The position of Koch Bihar is sufficiently
known; even in the reign of Jahangir it did not extend eastward as far as
the Brahmaputra. Koch Hajo almost coincides with the modern district of
Gwalpfira, Lower Asam, extending from above Hatsilah in the Karibari
Hills and Parganah, on the left side of the Brahmaputra, along the bend of
the river to Gwalpdra. On the right side, it commenced north of the Par-
ganah of Bhetarhand and contained the districts along the angle of the river
as far as Parganah K’liontliag'hat inclusively, with the towns of Dhobrf and
Rangamiti. On the east Koch Hajo bordered on Kamrup, or that part of
Asam which lies between Gwalpara, and Gauhatti to both sides of the
Brahmaputra.
The comparatively recent time of the advance of the Muhammadans in
these districts explains the paucity of Muhammadan names of towns in Koch
Hajo. The maps give a Parganah ‘ Mukrumpore,’ bordering on Bhetar-
band, which, no doubt, is a corruption of Mukarrampur, so called after Mu-
karram Khun, the conqueror of Hajo in the reign of Jahangir. The par-
ganah Golah ’Alamganj with Rangimiti as chief town, where the Imperial
Faujdar had his head quarters, reminds us of ’Alamgir ; and on the left side
of the Brahmaputra, north of Karibari, lies the Parganah Aurangabad, which
also reminds us of Aurangzib. But these few Muhammadan names refer all
to localities in the immediate vicinity of the old frontier of Bengal. From
the absence of Muhammadan names we may conclude that the invasions of
Koch Bihir and Asam by several Bengal kings as Husain Shah and Su-
laiman i Kararani, in the beginning and the middle of the 16th century,
led to no permanent results.
Kamrup also, for a short time under Shahjahan, was included in the
Dihli empire, and had imperial Faujdlirs whose head quarters were Gauhatti.
As in other parts of Bengal, the Muhammadans established settlements of
Paiks, who are defined as a sort of militia, armed with spears and shields.
But the Governors of Bengal soon found that they could not trust them
as a border defence ; for in the Hajo and Asamesc wars they generally took
the side of the Asam Rajahs.
I now proceed to collect the notes given in the works of Muhammadan
Historians on Koch Bihdr, Koch Hdjo, and Asam. The notes are chiefly
taken from the Akbarndmuh, the Tuzu/c i Jah&ngiri , the Bd dish a It n dm ah ,
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
51
1872.]
the ’ Alamgirnamali, and the Fathiyah i ’ Ibriyah . The first four works are
sufficiently known ; but the last mentioned work requires a few introductory
remarks.
The Fathiyah i ’Ibriyah is also called Tarikh Fath i A sham, or
History of the Conquest of A'sam. It was written by Ibn Muhammad Wali, or
Shihabuddin Talish, between the 4th Muharram and the 20th Shawwal, 1073,
A. H., or between the 9th August, 1062, and 13th May, 1063, A. D.
We know very little about the author. He was in the service of Mir Muham-
mad Sa’id of Ardistan, better known to European historians under the name
of Mir Jumlah, lvlnin Khanan and Governor of Bengal in the beginning of
Aurangzib’s reign, and accompanied the general, apparently in the position
of a clerk, on his expedition to A'sam in 1662, and returned with him to
Bengal. His brother Muhammad Sa’id, too, held an inferior office during the
expedition. In the preface the author states that the reports which the
imperial Wdqi’ahnawises used to send to Court, were often in the opinion of
Mir Jumlah defective and incorrect ; hence the object of the author is to
give a detailed and faithful account of the whole expedition to As&m up to
the death of Mir Jumlah, with which the book closes. The office of Waqi’ah-
nawis, or writer of events, had been introduced by Akbar :* his duty was
to report to Court whatever happened in the district to which he was ap-
pointed. Before the time of the Mughuls also the office existed, though
reports were not so systematically forwarded, as from the time of Akbar. In
the TdriJch i Firuzshahi, for instance, we find the word bar id, an Arabic
corruption of the Latin veredus, used instead of ‘ Waqi’ahnawis.’ Dr.
Fryer, who was in India from 1672 to 1681, in his most interesting ‘ New
Account of East India and Persia’ (London, 1698), calls these officers
‘ Public Notaries,’ or ‘ Public Intelligencers,’ and has the following remark
{loc. cit., p. 140). — “This cheat [he means the practice of false musters]
is practised all over the Realm, notwithstanding here are Puhlick Notaries
placed immediately by the Mogul, to give Notice of all Transactions ; which
they are sure to represent in favour of the Governors where they reside, being
Fee’d by them, as well as paid by the Emperor ; so that if a Defeat happen,
it is extenuated ; if a Victory, it is magnified to the height : Those in this
Office are called Focanoveces.”
On comparing the account of Shihabuddin with the shorter account
of Mir Jumlali’s expedition in the ’ A! lamgirnd rnah, which contains a his-
tory of the first ten years of Aurangzib’s reign and was issued with the
Emperor’s permission, we find a remarkable coincidence in language and
phraseology. Whole sentences, in fact occur word for word in both books ;
and we are led to conclude that the author of the ’Alamgirnamali either
used Shihabuddin’s account, or both had access to the official reports which
were sent to the Emperor. I shall notice this circumstance below.
* Vide A'm translation, p. 258.
52
H. Bloclimann — Koch, Bihdr and Asam.
[No. 1,
In point of style, ShiMbuddin’s work is elegant and simple. The Per-
sian is flowing and pure, and the total absence of Indian isti'mdl, or Indo-
Persian constructions, shews that the author was a native of Persia.
The book* consists of a short preface, an introduction (mugaddimah)
and two parts (maqdlah). The introduction treats of the causes which led
to the invasion of Koch Bihar and Asam. The first part relates the con-
quest of Koch Bihar and the general condition of the country. The second
part narrates the invasion of Asam by Mir Jumlah ; the occupation of the
country, which lasted for fourteen months, from the 23rd Jumada I, 1072 to
the 26th Bajab, 1073 ; the peace which was concluded ; and the return of
the general to Khizrpur near Dhaka, where he died shortly after, on the 2nd
Ramazan, 1073. The second part is divided into 17 chapters, of which the
sixth is particularly interesting as containing a description of Asam and the
Asamese in 1662 and occasional notices of the Aboriginal tribes in Eastern
and Southern Asam.
Koch Biha'r and Koch Ha'jo (Lower A'sa'm).
The following extracts are taken from the Alcbarn&mah (Lucknow
Edition, III, p. 207). “ To the events of this time [beginning of the 23rd
years, of Akbar’s reign, A. H. 986, or A. D., 1578] belongs the arrival of the
pesh/cash from Bengal and Koch Bihar. Rajah Balgosain, who is the
Zamhidar of Koch, submitted again, and sent valuable presents from Bengal
with fifty-four elephants.”
This was after the total defeat of Daiid, king of Bengal, by Khan
Jahdn. Ain translation, p. 330.
The following passage from the same work (III, 762) refers to the end
of the 41st year of Akbar’s reign, or the middle of 1005 A. H. [A. D.
1596, end],
“ About tins time Lachmi Narain submitted. He is the ruler of Koch,
and has 4000 horse, and 200,000 foot, 700 elephants, and 1000 ships. His
country is 200 Jeon long, and from 100 to 40 /cos broad, extending in the
east to the Brahmaputra, in the north to Tibbat, in the south to G’hora-
g’hat, and in the west to Tirhut.
“ About five hundredf years ago, a woman prayed in a Mahadeo temple
for a son. Her prayer was granted, and she called the son Bisa. He be-
came the ruler of Koch Bihar. One of his descendants, or grandsons
* The Asiatic Society of Bengal has a MS. of the work. No. 425 of the Persian
Catalogue. It was also printed at Calcutta, in the old Madrasah, Baithak-khanah,
1st Bajab, 1265, by Masihuddin Khan, a Munshf of the Foreign Department. The
book is out of print.
+ The Lucknow Edition has fifteen. Although I quote the Lucknow Edition of the
Akbarnainah, I translate from MSS., for the text of the Lucknow Edition is worse
than the worst possible MS. For Bisd the MSS. have B{bd, Biyd, or Bisbd.
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and Asam.
53
1872.]
(nabirali) , was Bal Gosain, a wise ruler. He wrote a letter in praise of tlie
Emperor and sent it with presents to Court. As he lived the life of an
ascetic, he did not marry, and when he was fifty years old, he appointed
Pat Kunwar, his brother’s son, successor. But the Rajah’s eldest brother,
Sliukl Gosain desired a marriage, and in order not to offend him, Bal Gosain
assented, and had a son Lachmi Narain. When he died and Laclimi Nani in
became Rajah, Pat Ivunwar rebelled. Being hard pressed by the opponent,
Each mi made his submission to the Emperor, and requested Man Singh, tho
Governor of Bengal, to introduce him at Court. A meeting was arranged ;
Man Singh set out from Salhnnagar* and the Rajah travelled forty Jcos
to meet him at Anandapur. The meeting took place on 13th Dai. After
many festivities, the Rajah wished to take Man Singh to his capital ; but
Man Singh was for some reason unwilling and politely took leave of the
Rajah. The latter soon after gave him his daughter in marriage.
“ As the Koch Bihar Rajahs had not personally paid their respects at the
Court of the kings of Bengal, Sulaiman i Kararani had invaded Koch Bihar,
hut without result.”
From the Tuzwk i Jahdngiri (p. 147) we see that, in. the end of 1024,
ninety elephants were paraded before Jahangir, which Qasim Khan, the
Governor of Bengal, had taken from Orisa, the Mugs, and Koch Bihar.
“ In the beginning of 1027, or A. D. 1618, Lachmi Narain paid his re-
spects personally at Court in Gujrat, and presented a nazar of 500 muliurs”
(Joe. cit., p. 220).
The following more detailed account is taken from the Bddishahndmah
(II, pp. 64 ff).
Bengal in the north is hounded by two kingdoms, one of which is called
Koch Hajo and the other Koch Bihar. Koch Bihar lies far away from the
Brahmaputra ; Koch Hajo lies on the banks of that river.
In the beginning of Jahangir’s reign, Koch Hajo was ruled over by
Parichliat, and Koch Bihar by Lachmi Narain, who was the brother of
Parichhat’s grandfather. Now in the 8th year of the reign of that Em-
peror, when Shaikh ’Alauddin Fathpf.ri Islam Khan had been made gover-
nor of Bengal, Parichliat was complained against by hag hunat h, zamindar
of the Parganah Sosang.t whose family Parichliat had imprisoned. Rag'll li-
nat h’s complaints were found to he correct ; and as I arichhat had not
behaved so submissively as Lachmi Narain of Koch Bihar, Shaikh ’Alauddin
determined to annex Koch Hajo, and ordered Mukarram Khanf quickly to
invade Hajo with 6000 horse, 10,000 to 12,000 foot, and 500 ships§. The
* Salima agar is the name of the fort of Sherpur Murchah (Mymensingh).
f Sosang lies east of the Brahmaputra, between the Kanban and the Garo Hills.
J Ain translation, p. 493.
54
H. Bloclimann — Koch Bihar and Asdm.
[No. 1,
vanguard was commanded by Kamal Khan who quickly yet cautiously
marched to Hatsilah, which belongs to the Parganah Karibari and is the
beginning of Koch Hajo, fortifying at every stage his encampment with
bamboo palisades according to the system of warfare followed in these parts
of the country. He then advanced on Port Dhobri, which lies on the [right]
bank of the Brahmaputra and was garrisoned with 500 horse and 10000
foot of Pariohhat’s troops, and besieged it. After a bombardment of one
month, he took the fort, killing a large number of the enemies. Parichhat
now sent a vakil from Khelah, where his residence was, to the commander,
sued for peace, and offered 100 elephants, 100 Tangbans (ponies), and 20
mans of lignum aloes. He also promised to release Itag’hunat’h’s family.
Mukarram Khan and Kamal informed the Governor of Bengal of the pro-
posals, and before the answer came back, Parichhat had carried out the terms
and sent the animals, &c. But the governor demanded the surrender both
of the country and of Pariclihat’s person. Hostilities were therefore re-
sumed ; but the army stayed in Port Dhobri till the end of the rains. A
sudden attack which Parichhat made on Dhobri with 20 elephants, 400
horse, and 10000 foot, was with some difficulty repulsed, and the enemy with-
drew in disorder towards Khelah. The imperialists now left Dhobri and
encountered Parichhat’s fleet in the Gujadhar river. In the engagement
which ensued, the hostile ships were driven back, and Parichhat was forced
to retreat to Khelah. But even there he did not stay long, as ho had heard
that Lachmi Narain had joined the imperialists and was about to attack
him from the flank. He therefore left for Budhnagar, which lies on the
Banas river,* followed by the imperialists who had passed over Khelah arid
reached the Banas. Unable to hold himself any longer, he now surrendered
himself to the mercy of the Mughuls, and was taken, together with his ele-
phants and riches, to Mukarram Khan. Baldeo, however, Parichhat’s
brother, fled to the Sargdeo of Asam, whoso friend he was.
In this way Koch Ha jo was annexed to the empire. Mukarram Khan,
with the sanction of ’Alauddin Islam Khan, appointed his brother ’Abdus-
salsim Patlipiiri to command the garrison which was to be left at Khelah,
and returned with Parichhat as prisoner towards Dhaka. Immediately
before his arrival, ’Alauddin had died, and as no successor had yet been ap-
pointed, Hosliang, ’Alauddin’s son, and Mukarram sent a report to court.
Jahangir ordered Parichhat to be sent to him. Soon after, Shaikh Qasim,
’Alauddin’s brother, who had been in charge of district Munger, was ap-
pointed governor of Bengal with the title of Muhtashim Khan. Upon
entering on his office, he appointed Mukarram Khan governor of Hajo.
Mukarram obeyed and remained in Hajo for a year, when, vexed at the
* The Banas flows into the Brahmaputra, right bank, opposite to Gwalpara.
The Padishahnamah spells wrongly and
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
1872.]
annoyances lie had to suffer at the hands of Qasim, who certainly possessed
little tact, if any, he left his post and proceeded over G’horag’hat to Court.
Qasim therefore sent Sayyid Hakim, an imperial officer, and Sayyid Aba
Baler with 10 to 12000 horse and foot and 400 large ships to Hajo, and
ordered them to invade Asam. They waited in Hajo for the end of the
rains, marched three or four stages into Asam, when they were totally de-
stroyed by tire Asame.se in a night attack. As this disaster was caused by
the shortsightedness of Qasim Khan, he was deposed from his office as
governor of Bengal.
( Page 68.) Asam borders on Hajo. As the Asamese exclude foreigners,
the only information regarding the country that we possess, is derived from
prisoners or some of those doggish Asamese who come, to Hajo as traders. It
is a large country, producing elephants and lignum aloes, which is called agar
in Hindiistan, and also gold of inferior purity, which sells at half price. It
borders on Khata (Chinese Tartary). The present king [A. H. 1047, or 1637,
A. D.] is called Sarg Deo, and is an infidel who keeps one thousand elephants
and one hundred thousand foot. The inhabitants shave the head, and clip
off heard and whiskers. They eat every land and water animal. In looks
they resemble the Qaraqylp&q (?) tribe. They are very black and loath-
some to far and near. The chiefs travel on elephants or country ponies ; hut
the army consists only of foot soldiers. The fleet is large and well fitted
out. The soldiers use bows and arrows and matchlocks, but do not come up
m courage to our soldiers, though they are very brave in naval engagements.
On the march they quickly and dexterously fortify their encampments
with mud walls and bamboo palisades, and surround the whole with a ditch.
It was mentioned above that Baldeo had fled to the king of Asam,
whom he now persuaded to invade Hajo, offering his assistance under the
condition that he was to be appointed governor of the province. The Asam
Rajah agreed and sent Baldeo with an army towards Hajo. Profiting by
the unsettledness arising from the removal of one governor and the arrival of
another, Baldeo took Durang, which was owned by several zamindars of
that district and lies about 10 kos from Hajo, on the south of the Brahma-
putra, and continued his aggressions by force and persuasion, so that he soon
saw himself at the head of 10 to 12000 men, both Asamese and Bangalis.
The frontier t’hanah of the Asamese, therefore, which under the rale of
Parichhat had been far off, was now much pushed forward.
At the time of Khan Zaman, who acted as Governor of Bengal for his
father Mahabat Khan, Baldeo continued his raids unopposed, and took away
Parganahs Lulu* and Bhaomanti, causing not only much distress in
those districts themselves, but inflicting also severe losses on the empire,
* Duar Luki is separated from Gwalpara byParganah Habrag’hat, and lies E. E.S.
°f Gwalpara.
56
H. Bloehmann — Koch Bihar and A’sdm.
[No. 1
because he afforded protection to the people when the tax-gatherers came
amongst them, and indirectly influenced the zamiudars of other imperial
districts to delay the customary payments.
During the governorship of Qasim Khan several chiefs had been sent
to these districts with 10 to 12000 soldiers armed with shields and swords.
Such soldiers are called pdiks, and had before been in Hajo, and lived on the
lands which the Bengal governors had given them as jagirs, being engaged
either in cultivation or keeping up Ic'hedahs (enclosures for catching wild
elephants). But as these men had been remiss in forwarding elephants,
Qasim Khan called the chiefs to Dhaka and imprisoned them for some time,
after which he let them off on payment of a fine of 30,000 Rupees. The
result was that Santosh Lashkar and Jairam Lashkar, who were the chiefs
of the Paiks, fled to the Sargdeo Rajah of Asam, who provided for them,
and thus attached them to his party. Again, when Islam Khan was ap-
pointed to Bengal, Satrjit, the wicked Thanahdar of Pandu, made common
cause with Baldeo, and instigated him to profit by the change of gover-
nors and push forward. Baldeo thereupon collected an army of Asamese
and Kochis, left Durang, and attacked ’Abdussalam, who was in charge of
Koch Hajo and had been ordered to look after the k’hedahs. ’Abdussalam
reported matters to Islam Khan and asked for reinforcements.
Islam Khan, therefore, in the 9th year of Shahjahan’s reign (1st Jumada
II., 1045 to 1st Jumada II., 1016, or A. D. 1636), sent ’Abdussalam’s bro-
ther, Shaikh Muhiuddin, together with Muhammad £alih Kamlni, Mirza Mu-
hammad Bukhari and other imperial Mumyibdirs, as also Sayyid Zainul’abi-
din, one of his own soldiers of merit, with 1000 horse, 1000 matchlockmen, part-
ly imperial and partly belonging to his own contingent, and 10 ghrahs and
nearly 200 kosahs and jalbahs* all well provided and fitted out, to ’Abdus-
salam’s assistance. An officer was at the same time ordered to hasten to G’ho-
rag’hat.and there collect boats, to convey the army and the baggage. The rainy
season delayed matters, and when the forces reached G’horag’hat, the horses
and the heavy baggage were left behind till the end of the rains, whilst the
men proceeded in small boats upwards. Muhammad f alih, whose kosahs
were swift going, had a start of two days and arrived first in Hajo. At this
time Satrjit, the traitor, sent a message to ’Abdussalam, stating that he had
heard from spies that the Asamese intended to make a night attack on his
thanah. ’Abdussalam, therefore, ordered Muhammad palih to accompany
Satrjit and protect his thanah. After a short march, night overtook them,
and Satrjit asked Muhammad f'alih to remain where they were, whilst he
would go and get information about the thanah. But as next morning
Satrjit had not returned, Qalih broke up, and met Satrjit half-way with
his ships, who gave out that the Asamese had attacked and taken his
thanah with superior forces, and he had fled to save at least the ships.
* Kinds of ships ; vide below.
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A’sam.
57
1872.]
They remained for one day and one night at the place of meeting, and hear-
ing of Zainid'abidin’s arrival, returned to Hajo. It was now resolved that
’Abdussalam should not leave Hajo ; his brother Muluuddm and Fazil Beg,
an officer of Islam Khan, who commanded 300 horse and the same number
of matchlockmen of the Khan’s contingent, were to garrison the thanahs in
the neighbourhood of Hajo, whilst Zain ul’abidin should push the ships as far
as Srig’hat, where Asam begins, and try to keep the enemy at bay. Zain ul-
abidin, therefore, and Muhammad palili, with imperial troops and soldiers
belonging to Islam Khan’s contingent, and manyZamindars and ships, marched
forward, and met the enemy, who had advanced two kos beyond Panda.
The Asamese at once left the two fortified camps which they had erected, and
attacked the Imperialists. After a severe fight, they were dislodged and lost
five guns. Zain ul’abidin destroyed their camps, and then marched quickly on
to Srig’hat, where the Asamese had assembled in force. Fighting was at once
renewed, and in one of the engagements a Phulcan, i. e., an Asamese chief
and commander of ten or twelve thousand men, was killed. Five large
ships, which they call bachhdru, and several kosahs, i. e., ships that have
one mast,* were taken. On the following day also, the Asamese lost in an
engagement 300 men, 12 bachhdns, and 40 kosahs.
Islam Khan had in the meantime collected further reinforcements, and
intended to take personally the command of the expedition. But on account
of the great distance of Hajo from Jaliangimagar, where his presence was re-
quired, he had to give up his plan, and therefore sent his own brother Mir Zain
nddin, Allah Yar Khan, Muhammad Beg Abakash, ’Abdul Wahhab, Mir
Qasim Samnani, Amirah Sasan, Sayyid Muhammad Bukhari and others, with
1500 horse, 4000 matchlockmen and bowmen of his own contingent to
Hajo. Muhammad Zaman of Tahran, who was Faujdar and Tuyuldar of
Si I hat, was also ordered to join the detachment. As the Paiks had, in the
meantime, joined the Asamese, which deprived the Hajo and Srig’hat corps
of regular supplies, Islam Khan shipped large stores of grain and had them
conveyed by twenty-five war-kosahs belonging to Ma’fum Zamindar,f who
also took with him ammunition, weapons, and money. Khwajah Sher,
Faujdar of G’horag’hat and lately appointed to the Faujdari of Khelah, was
ordered to join with his detachment Mir Husaini, a servant of the governor,
who with 200 horse and 300 foot had gone to Koch Bihar to collect the
peslikash, and then to move to Dhobri. There they were to be joined by
* Yakchobah, pr. having one pole or beam, one-masted (?). On page 37, the
term kosah was applied to snch ships as are used to row war-ships.
The term ghrdb is looked upon by the author of the Padishahnamah
(Ij p. 431) as a Bengali term.
t Ma’<jum Zarmndar had also served in command of ships at the conquest of
Hugh, in the beginning of 1042, A. H.
58
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar aud Asam.
[No. 1,
Basbati zamindar of Patka and other districts (a relation of
Parichhat, "who exerted himself in behalf of the Imperialists) .after which they
should operate together with the Hajo army.
Before the provisions came up, ’Abdussalam had hastened to Srig’hat,
in order to induce Sayyid Zain ul’abidin who was stationed there, to come
with him to Hajo ; for the river had receded for two or three kos from Fort
Hajo, and mutual succour was rendered impossible. The Sayyid at first
refused to come ; but at the urgent request of ’Abdussalam he at last agreed,
put the ships in charge of Muhammad falili Kambu, Satrjit, and Majlis
Bayazfd, ruler of Sirkar Fathabad near Dhaka, and left several behind. No
sooner had he left than the enemy with nearly 500 ships attacked at night
the imperial fleet. The scoundrel Satrjit, who had been the cause of the
attack, took the first opportunity to retire with his ships, and several others
followed him from fear ; nor would he return, when palih sent his sons
to him to induce him to do his duty. The imperialists were defeated : palih
was killed, Bayazid was made prisoner, and the fleet fell into the hands of
the enemies. Satrjit, moreover, on his flight, fell in with a number of ships
which brought provisions to the army, and persuaded them to return.
Baldeo, thereupon, with his Asamese and Kochi troops, left Srig’hat
and Piindu, and marched towards Hajo, which he besieged, successfully
cutting off all supplies. ’Abdussalam, Shaikh Muhiuddin, and Sayyid Zain
td’abidin were thus forced to have recourse to sallies, during which they
destroyed some of his stockades. From want of provisions, the delay of
reinforcements, and the superior number of the enemies, ’Abdussalam accepted
an offer of peace, and went with his brother to the hostile camp. He was,
however, immediately imprisoned and sent to Asam. Sayyid Zain ul’abidin
with the rest of the men tried bravely to force his way through the enemies ;
but they were all cut up.
The corps commanded by Mir Zain uddin ’Ali, Allah Yar, and Muham-
mad Zaman Tahranl had, in the mean time, left the banks of the
Brahm4putra, and attacked Chandr Narain, son of Parichhat. Chandr
Narain had at first lived in Parganah Solmari, which belongs to the
Dak’hinkol, the district south of the Brahmaputra, on the right* banks
of the river. But as most parts of the Dak’hinkol had been given
to Satrjit as tuyul, the latter had sent Gopinat’h, his brother’s son,
as thanahdar and collector to Parganah Karibari. The inhabitants
of the Parganah, in consequence of Gopinfith’s oppressions, had called
Chandr Narain ; and Gopinat’h, unable to resist him, had withdrawn.
Chandr Narain had in a short time collected an army of 6 or 7000 Asamese
* Wo would say tie left bank. The Persians do not look as we do to the mouth
of a river in speaking of the right and left banks, but they look to the source, or
l&ldr&yah (AJjyiltj), ». e., against the current.
H. Bloehmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
59
1872.]
and Kocliis, and established himself at Mauza’ Matlali,# which belongs to
Karibari, where he erected a fortified camp near the Brahmaputra, at a place
full of jungle. The imperialists, on the 10th Sha’ban of the 10th year [1046,
A. H.], came from the Uttarkol, the left [right] bank of the Brahmaputra,
and arrived in rapid marches opposite to Karibari. They crossed the river, and
resolved next day to attack Chandr Narain. But the latter used the respite
thus afforded him, fled from Karibari, and retreated to Parganah Solmari,
where he had stayed before. The imperialists, next day, received the sub-
mission of the chiefs of Karibari, both of paiks and ryots, levelled the forti-
fications erected by Chandr Narain, and cut down the jungle round about the
stockades. Jaliil, a relation of the zamindar Ma’<;um, was left here with 400
matchlockmen and paiks as garrison.
The imperialists now returned across the Brahmaputra, and entered
Parganah Mardangi, which belongs to the Dak’hinkol. The chief of the
district had also the name of Pariehhat, and was father-in-law to Chandr
Narain. By promises and threats they succeeded in getting him to come to
the camp. About the same time the zamindar of Solmari also, who from
fear of Chandr Narain had fled to K'hoiff'hag'hat, joined the imperialists.
They then marched to Dhobri, where they.fell in with the traitor Satrjit and
the convoy ships which he had managed to detain. As they had heard ol
Satrjit’s treachery, and orders had in the meantime arrived from Islam Khan
to seize him, they secured him and sent him on the Dhaka.
This Satrjit was the son of Mukindra, zamindar of Bosnah, which lies
three stages from Dhaka ‘ on this side.’ Shaikh ’Alauddin, when Governor
[under Jahangir] of Bengal, had sent him along with the army which then
invaded Hajo ; and as he distinguished himself in the war, he had, after the
conquest of the country and the return of the army, been appointed Thanah-
dar of Pandu and Gauhatti, where, chiefly through his numerous dependants,
he had obtained the friendship of the Asamese, and had also, by his influence
as zamindar of Bosnah, become quite intimate with the chiefs of Koch. The
governors of Bengal who succeeded Shaikh ’Alauddin, had often called him ;
but he made for ever excuses and neither paid his respects, nor did he send
the customary peslilcash. When, however, Islam Klran was made governor,
he found that subterfuges availed nothing, and calling his son, who was in
Jahanglrnagar, to take his place, he paid his respects to the governor, and
was ordered to join the corps under Shaikh Muhiuddin. But he was a
traitor, and kept on friendly terms with the A'sam Elijah and Baldeo, Pari-
chhat’s brother, and not only furnished them with information, but induced
many zamindars to rebel. He now met with his deserts, and was imprisoned
m Jahanglrnagar and executed.
* if this be no mistake for ufc, Hatsilah. The initial htS in MSS. si
Written like a and the sin is a mere horizontal stroke.
CO H. Bloch mann — Koch Bihar and A’sdm. [No. 1,
The unhappy fate of ’Abdussalam emboldened the Asamese and Kochis
to advance with 12000 foot, 50 war-sloops, and many kosahs to Jogig’hopah,
which is a long hill situated opposite to the confluence of the Banas and
Brahmaputra [near Gwalpara], where, protected by dense jungle, they hoped
to check the imperialists. They had erected a strong fort, and had made
another opposite to it at a place called Hirahpiir, on the other side of the
Brahmaputra. Jogig’hopah was garrisoned with 3000 foot ; the other por-
tion of the army was located at Hirahpiir, whilst the fleet anchored between
the two forts. The imperialists now left Dhobri, and came to the Khanpiir
River, which flows from K’hont’hag’hat into the Brahmaputra, and crossedit.
Basbati, who with the zamindars and the footmen was employed to cut down
the jungle and prepare a road for the army, here reported that the enemies were
in sight, and Zain uddin ’Ali and Allah Yar gave him 3000 matchlockmen,
and told him to drive away the enemy. At the first attack, the Asamese
ran away and were pursued for six Icon. Next day, the imperialists came to
Jogig’hopah. After several fights, the enemies again withdrew, and the im-
perialists crossed the Banas. It was at this time that Chandr Narain perish-
ed, and received the reward for his disloyalty. As he had been the cause of
the defection of the Dak’hinkol, Muhammad Zaman was immediately sent
there with 1000 horse and 4000 foot, to clear the country : if the zamindars
submitted, they were to be sent to the army to serve ; if not, they were to
be killed. This Muhammad Zanrin did in a short time, and the Dak’hinkol
being clear of the enemy, he returned with his corps to head quarters. The
whole army then marched to ChandankoU On thoir way, they received a
letter from U'tam Narain, son of Sardabar, zamindar of Budhnagar, in
which it was said that Baldeo had arrived with 3000 Kochis and Asamese in
Budhnagar, and that the zamindar, unable to oppose him, had crossed the
Banas and gone to K’hont’hag’hat, from where he wished to join the im-
perial camp. Muhammad Zaman with a strong detachment was ordered to
march against Baldeo, accompanied by U'tam Narain, who had just come
and was thoroughly acquainted with the country. The principal part of the
army remained at Chandankot. Muhammad Zaman now crossed the Pomari
River, took a stockade which the enemy bad erected on its banks, and march-
ed upon Budhnagar. Baldeo, in the meantime, had deserted the strong
encampment he had thrown up at Budhnagar, and had withdrawn to Choth-
ri, a zamindari which also belongs to Sardabar, where he erected several
forts in the jungle at the foot of the hills. The imperialists, therefore, turned
towards the jungles, and halted at Bishnpur, an elevated spot near to Baldeo’s
encampment, in order to wait for the end of the rains and to get their war-
material into order. Baldeo boldly advanced from Chot’hri, having received
from Srig’hat and Panda reinforcements which increased his army to 40,000
men, and threw up fortifications at the Kalapani River, which is l.j kos dis-
1872.] H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'silm. 61
tant from Bishnpur, whilst he himself with the greater part of his army
remained encamped at the distance of about a hos, protected By rising ground,
a river difficult to cross, and dense jungle. He made several night attacks,
and by throwing up palisades in front of the imperialists succeeded in
reducing them to great straits. After some time, the Sarg Deo, who was
at Pandu, in consequence of a letter received from Baldeo, sent his son-in-law
to him with nearly 20,000 Asamese, who were ordered to march on Chan-
dankot.
As the rains had in the meantime decreased, the army of Islam left its
encampment at Chandankot, and marched on to Bishnpur. Baldeo determined
to do something before both hostile corps should effect a junction ; and on
the night between Friday and Saturday, 20th Jumada II., of the 11th year
of the present reign [». e. 20th Jumada II., 1W7, or 31st October, 1637], he
ordered some of his men on this side of the Kalfpani to attack the imperialists
at night. The result was that they carried two stockades which had not
been quite finished. Next morning, Muhammad Zaman took at once the
offensive, and leaving a party behind to protect his stoekadefe, he attacked
the works of the enemies. The first were immediately taken by storm, and
the imperialists in pursuing the Asamese entered with them into the second
line of their defences, and killed a good number. Even here the enemies
gave way, and the victors had arrived at their third line of fortifications.
Before noon, 15 stockades were taken, and more than 4000 Asamese killed.
Several chiefs also, who held commands of about 5 to 6000 were killed, and
three of them were brought in prisoners. Many guns, matchlocks, and other
weapons fell into the hands of the victors. All stockades on this side of the
river were burnt down. The defeated enemies fell back on Baldeo, and the
imperialists thought it best to march as soon. as possible on Bishnpur.
On the 12th Rajah [21st November, 1637], the whole army was divided
into three corps, and marched against Baldeo, whose position they attacked
from three points. The enemies soon fled on all sides. A very large num-
ber was killed. The son-in-law of the Asam Rajah was taken captive, and
was afterwards, together*' with all other captives, executed. Up to the end
of the day, every Asamese found in the jungles was killed. The shattered
remnants of the enemies withdrew to 8 rig hat and Pandu, where the Eajah
was with the heavy baggage and the fleet. Baldeo escaped to Durang.
After this victory, the imperial forces marched against Pandu and
Srig’hat, and arrived on the 24th Rajab [3rd December, 1637] near Akyali
Pahari juii, ?), The commander next morning sent three detachments
up the hill to take the outworks ( sarkob ) ; Muhammad Beg Abakash, Mir
Muhammad Qasim Samnani, Sayyid Muhammad Bukhari, and other impe-
rial commanders, attacked the works at the foot of the hill, whilst the com-
mander himself with Allah Yar and Muhammad Zaman followed in the rear.
62 H. Bloclnnann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm. [No. 1,
The enemies commenced immediately a cannonade, which did, however, no
damage whatever. The outworks on the top of the hill were taken. The
imperial fleet at the same time engaged the hostile ships, and scattered them.
Many Asamese were killed. Srig’hat was now attacked. Allah Yar and
Muhammad Zaman came up, surrounded the forts, and drove away the
enemies. The sailors, in the meantime, directed all glirdhs and kosahs to-
wards Pandu, and engaged the enemies who guarded Pandu on the other
side of the river. Here also the flight soon became general, and Ma’9um
zamindar did much damage with his ships among the enemies, many of whom
threw themselves from their ships and met with their death in the waves.
Nearly 500 war-sloops and 300 guns fell into the hands of the victors, and
in a short time no enemy was to be seen.
The whole of Koch Hajo was thus cleared of the Asamese, and was
again, as before, annexed to the empire.
The conquest was completed by the taking of Fort Kajli, which lies on
the Brahmaputra. Tho fort is surrounded on three sides by hills, through
which a large river [the Iiulang liiver] breaks that flows into the Brahmapu-
tra. As it is the place where Asam proper commences, it was held by
several Asamese chiefs. A detachment was sent to Durang to hunt down
Baldeo, and the fleet was ordered to sail to Kajli. The hostile garrison fled
also here ; the imperialists crossed the river, and took possession of the fort.
A garrison of 1000 horse, 3000 matchlockmen, 2000 paiks, and several
zamindars, were ordered to guard the place.
Baldeo, in course of time, was reduced to great straits. He fled to
Singri, an Asamese town between the hills and the Brahmaputra, and soon
after perished miserably with his two sons.
During the next three months the whole district was pacified ; the
zamindars made their submission, and the country received a financial
settlement. Gawahatti, which had formerly been an important town, became
head quarters, and the commanders remained here during the rainy season.
His Majesty [Shahjahan], in recognition of the services of the army
promoted Islam Khan, who had been a commander of 5000, 5000 horse,
3000 duaspah silmspah troopers, to a command of 5000, 5000 horse, 4000
duaspah sihaspahs ; Allah Yar Khan received an increase of 500, 200 horse,
and was now a commander of 3000, 2000 horse ; Muhammad Zaman was
made a commander of 2000, 1800 horse ; and Mir Zainuddin ’All, a com-
mander of 1000, 200 horse, with the title of Sayddat Klidn. Itahman Yar
and ’Abdul Wahhab also were promoted.
Mir Nurullah of Harat was appointed Thanahdar of Koch Hajo, with a
command of 3000, 2500 horse. ( Bddishahndmah , II., 94).
1872.] H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm. 63
Having completed the extracts from the Bddhhdlmdma.li, I now pro-
ceed to the Fathiyah i 'lbriyah. I do not intend to give a translation of
the whole hook, hut shall in general content myself with a detailed analysis,
and a comparison with the ' Alamgvrndmah. Of the more interesting chapters
and passages, however, the analysis will ho found to approach a translation.
The subjugation of Koch Hajo and Kamrup by the imperialists in 1637
appears to have been thorough. At least we have no information of new
troubles having broken out till A. H. 1068, or A. D. 1658, when Shahjahan
fell sick, and the wars of succession followed. In that year, the Faujdar of
Kamrup and Hajo was MirLutfullah of Shiraz. The government of Bengal
had for several years been in the hands of Prince Shuja’, who had now col-
lected the whole Bengal corps to oppose his brothers. From the frontier-
districts, especially, the imperial detachments appear to have been entirely
withdrawn ; for no sooner had the emperor’s sickness become known than
Bliim Narain, Rajah of Koch Bihar, made raids into Gr’horag’hat, carry-
ing off a great numher of imperial subjects, men and women. He also sent
his vazir Bhawanat’h* with an army into Kamrup. Jaidhaj Singh also,
Rajah of Asam, thought circumstances favorable, and unwilling to allow
the Kochis to recover territories which they formerly had held, he marched
with a large army, accompanied by a numerous fleet, into Kamrup. Mir Lutf-
ullah, seeing himself thus attacked from two sides, and having no troops to
check the invaders, took his ships, and withdrew to Dhaka. The Kochis
again, unable to oppose the Asatnese, retreated, and the whole province was
at the mercy of the Asam Rajah, who even annexed part of the Parganah
Karibari, Hatsilah being as formerly their most advanced thSnah.
For three years nearly did the Asamese remain in undisturbed possession
of the newly annexed territory, when after the flight of Prince Shuja’ to
Arakan, in Ramazan of Aurangzib’s third year, [*’. e. Ramazan, 1070, or
June, 1659], KhanKhanan Mir Jumlah, governor of Bengal, occupied
Jaliangirnagar. It was immediately after this event, says the author of the
' Alamgirndmah, (p. 680) that Jaidhaj Singh sent a vakil to Mir Jumlah,
stating that he had taken possession of the imperial lands for no other reasons
but to keep out the Kochis ; he was now prepared to hand them again over
to any officer whom the governor might send to him. The statement found
favor ; Mir Jumlah rewarded the vakil with a lchal at, and Rashid Khan,
Sayyid Xaciruddin Khan, Sayyid Salar Khan, A'ghar Khan, and others, were
ordered to receive back the imperial lands. Bhim Narain also sent at this
time a vakil, in order to ask the governor’s pardon for his want of loyalty
and open rebellion ; but Mir Jumlah would listen to no excuse, imprisoned
* So the Fathiyah i ’lbriyah. The ’Alamgimamah has, perhaps correctly, Blio-
lanat’h. For Bhim Narain, MSS. have also Pem Narain.
61
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
[No. 1,
the vakil, and ordered Rajah Suhhan Singh Bundelah* with an imperial
corps and Mirza Beg, one of his own officers, with 1000 horse, to occupy
Koch Bihar.
As soon as the Asamese heard of the approach of Rashid Khan, they
withdrew from Karihari and the neighbouring places, and returned at last
beyond the Bands river [opposite Gwalp&ra], Rashid Khan thought their
sudden retreat to be a snare, and refused to advance beyond four stages from
Jahangirnagar ; but on receiving further supplies under Sayyid Yusuf, who
during Shuja’s government had been Faujdar of Karihari, he occupied that
Parganab, and soon after took possession of Rangamati. Here he remained,
and reported to the governor that the Asamese were making extensive
preparations to recover the lost territory.
Suhhan Singh in the meantime advanced to Yak Duar ; but seeing
that Rashid Khan did not press forward, he, too, remained where he was,
especially as the rains had set in, and sent discouraging reports to the go-
vernor. By ‘ Du;ir’ a fortified gateway is meant, built of mortar and bricks,
which stands upon a broad dl, or raised road,f mostly overgrown with trees,
and surrounded by deep and broad ditches and jungle, where the treacherous
inhabitants of these districts use to hide.
The governor saw that matters could no longer be left in the hands of
his officers, and on obtaining the necessary orders from court, he prepared
himself to invade Koch Bihar and A'sam.
The Conquest of Koch Bihar in 1661.
On the 18th Rabi’ I., 1072 [1st November, 1661, A. D.], the fourth year
of Aurangzib’s reign, the Nawab [Mir Jumlah] started from Jahangirnagar,
leaving Ihtisham Khan in Khizrpiir to protect the capital. MukhliQ Khan
garrisoned Akbarnagar (Rajmahall), and all financial matters were left to Bha-
* The Bibl. Indioa Edition of the ’Alamgirn&mah must he used with care, as the
proper nanios are mostly all wrong. Thus on p. 679, should be p,
680, JLr5" should be ; p. 681 and in the whole narrative, ,_£wI;e** should be
Aghar Khan is also doubtful, the correct spoiling being perhaps
Ighyr Khan. On p. 690, for and read the same forms
with b ; p. 692, read for • p. 693, — >7 for ; P- 694 o
for ; p. 696 yi\ G for^i • Do., for ; p. 700, jodb for
* <xili j p. 703, for j Do., for^A,X*3. ’ p. 713jlii &.x„, for
jliLi for pp. 720, 721, for • p. 722, aljj for
j p. 727, lilf for ^ Ills’, These are only mistakes in proper nouns,
f Abulfazl thinks that the raised roads, or dls, in Bengal, have given rise to the
name of the country, Bmga-al,
H. Blochmann — Koch Biliar and Asa.ni.
65
1872.]
goti Das, the Diwan, and to Khwajah Bhagwant Das ; Mir Ghazi was ap-
pointed Bakhshi and Waqi’ahnawis, and Muhammad Muqim commanded
the fleet. The Nawab first marched to Baritalah the harem and
the heavy baggage having been sent via G’horag’hat. Now three roads lead
to Koch Bihar, two from his Majesty’s empire, and a third vid Morang
('-&)>■*). Of the former two, the first is known as the Yak Duar ; and if the
Duar be forced, there would be no further obstacles, and the army might
proceed to the town of Koch Bihar. The second is known as the K’hont’ha-
g’ha( roadf. It passes near Rangamati, and is a narrow road intersected
by many nalahs. To both sides of the dl, or embankment, there is dense
jungle up to the town of Koch Bihar. But there was still another road,
along an dl much lower than the others, and surrounded by dense bamboo
shrubs ; and as the Rajah thought the road impracticable for an army, he
had not guarded it. For this reason the Nawab determined to go by this
road, and ordered the fleet to anchor in the nalah which flows from Sirkar
G’horag’hat into the Brahmaputra.
On the last day of Rabi’ II. [12th December, 1661], Rajah Sublian
Singh joined the Nawab.
On the 1st Jumada I. [13th December, 1661], the Nawab arrived at
the foot of the dl. A few enemies were there, but they dispersed on his
approach. On the next day, the army went along the dl, the Nawab himself
being continually on horseback. The march was difficult, and the elephants
and the footmen had continually to cut a road through the jungle. At a
place three stages from Koch Bihar it was reported that the Rajah had fled
to Bhutant (Bhootan). The army also crossed here a river, which was said
to be bottomless.
On the 6th Jumada I., the army stood before Koch Bihar, and on the
next day [19th December, 1661], the Nawab entered the town. The azdn,
or call to prayer, was chanted by fadr Mir Muhammad p.tlih in the
Rajah’s palace.
The kingdom of Koch Bihar extends from Parganah Bhetarband,
“ which belongB to his Majesty's empire,” to PatganwJ near the frontier of
* “ The frontier of the empire.” ’Alamglmdmah. Baritalah lies near Chilmari,
near the right bank of the Brahmaputra, opposite to Hatsilah in Parganah Karibnri.
t The Bibl. Indica Edition of the ’ Ahmgtmdmah has O’hordg'hat, but gives the
correct reading in a footnote.
t The printed edition has Pdpgdon, the MS. Pdtgdon. Patgaon in the north of the
Rangpur District appears to be meant.
The ’ Alwingimamah ( p. 691) has the following—
“ The length of Koob Bihar is 65 statute (jartb{) kos, and the breadth 50. # * *
Whatever of the country lies within the band, is called ‘ Bhetarband.’ One large and
two small rivers enter the ‘ band;’ and these, together with such rivers as come from
9 i
66 H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A’sdm. [No. 1,
the kingdom of Morang. It is 52 statute kos long. The breadth from the
Parganah of Tsijhat, which belongs to the empire, to Pusakarpur
near K’hont’hag’hat, is 50 kos. The mountains of Bhutant, which are
inhabited by the Bhutiahs, produce T&ngan horses, Bhiitiah cloth, Pari,* and
musk. Koch Bihar is well-known for its excellent water, mildness of the
climate, its fresh vegetation and flowers. Oranges are plentiful, as also other
fruits and vegetables. If properly administrated, the country might yield a
revenue of 8 lacs of rupees. The inhabitants, since ancient times, are the
Meeh and Koch tribes. The Eajah belongs to the Mech. He coins gold
muhurs and Naruin rupees. The zamxndars of India esteem the Koch Bih.ir
Bajahs, and believe that they trace their descent from Bajahs who reigned
there before the arrival of the Muhammadans in India.
Bhim Nar. in was a noble, mighty king, powerful, and fond of company.
He never took his lip from the edge of the bowl, nor his hand from the
flagon ; he was continually surrounded by singing women, and was so addicted
to the pleasures of the harem, that he did not look after his kingdom. His
palace is regal, has a ghusulkhdnah,\ a darshan, private rooms, aecommoda-
other sides, flow into the Sankos. Outside the ' band’ are 5 chaklahs, containing 75
parganahs ; and within the ‘ band’ there are 12 parganahs. The revenue of the
kingdom is nearly 10 laos of Rupees.
* The printed edition has pari, the MS. sari. The ’ A'lamgtmdmah
says (p. 690) that ‘ pari’ is a kind of thick cloth with long threads ( purzddr , like coarse
plush), woven on strings, and is used for carpets. “Another woollen stuff is called
phut.” The last is very likely a mistake for the bhiitiah cloth mentioned in the
text.
f The word ghusuVthanah, as is well known, means now-a-day a bath-room, or a
closet, or both. At the Dihli court it had a particular meaning, as will be seen from
the following extracts. The Balmr i ’Ajarn says — “ It is said that Sher Shah, when
emperor of Dihli, appointed a room in the Palace where he nsed to sit after his bath,
in order to have his carls dried. (This, by the way, is the only historical statement
which ascribes curls [gesudn] to Sher Shah.) When Akbar came to the throne, he
called that room Diwdn i lchdg. Khan Arzu says that he had heard that the grandees
in old times used to sit on coming to pay their respects ; but when Akbar came to the
throne, he disapproved of it. He could not, however, do away with the oustom, and built
a house where he took his bath, but put on that account no carpets on the ground, so
that when the Amirs came in, they had to stand. And from his time, the grandees
in presenting reports, &e., have been accustomed to stand. Now the room was called
ghusvMlianah, and though the bath was in course of time abolished, the name
remained."
From the Pddishdhndmah (II, p 220) we see that Shahjahira wished to change
the name from ghusulkhanah to daulatlchdnah i khdg; but the old name remained.
Bernier (Calcutta edition I, p 300) calls the ‘ gosel-kanay’ an evening reception room.
Dwrshan, as the name implies, is the place where the king shews himself to tho
people, a general audience hall.
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and Asdm.
67
1872.]
tions for the harem, for servants, baths and fountains, and a garden. In the
town there are flowerbeds in the streets, and trees to both sides of them.
The people use the sword, firelock, and arrows, as weapons. The arrows
are generally poisoned ; thoir mere touch is fatal. Some of the inhabitants
are enchanters ; they read formulas upon water, and give it the wounded to
drink, who then recover. The men and the women are rarely good looking.
As the people, a day before the army arrived, had fled, the Nawab
strictly forbade plundering ; and a few soldiers, having gone marauding and
brought home a cow, or a goat, or a few plantains, were marched through the
camp and the town with an arrow stuck through then- noses, and the stolen
things suspended from their necks. This encouraged the inhabitants, and
they returned to their homes.
The son of the Rajah* about this time fled from his father, and waited
on the Nawab, and became a Muhammadan.
Isfandiar Beg, son of the late Ilah Yar Khan, was ordered to Morang to
capture Bhawanfit’h, the Rajah’s vazir. Farhad Khan also was sent there
hy another route. Riza Quli Beg Abalcash, a companion of Isfandiar,
captured the vazir and brought him in fettered, as also his wife and child.
According to orders, the Yak Duar was levelled with the ground, and by
cutting down the trees for about a hundred yards, an open space was made.
106 guns, 145 zamburaks, 11 ramcbangis, 123 matchlocks, and much material
and baggage, were seized. The artillery stores were forwarded to Jahangir-
nagar. Of the other things Muhammad ’Abid, the Barrack Master, took
charge. A party was then sent to Kanthalbari at the foot of the Bhutant
Hills, where the Rajah concealed himself ; but the Rajah withdrew to the
summit of the mountains. Only an elephant, several horses, and cow car-
nages, and a Bhutiah, were brought back. The Bhutiah begged hard for his
life, and promised to take a letter to the Rajah of Bhiitant, whose name is
Dharm rajah, and who is over one hundred and twenty years old. He is an
ascetic, eats only plantains, drinks only milk, and indulges in no pleasures what-
ever. He is famous for his justice, and rales over a large people. The prisoner
also told us that a river runs through his kingdom, not very broad, but very
* The ’ Alamgirndmah calls him Bishn Naniin, and says that Bhim Narain from
distrust had always kept him under surveillance (p. G88).
Tor MccTi , the Bibl. Indica edition of that work has Mash e< The inhabi-
tants of Koch Bihar belong to two tribes, the Mech and the Bihar tribes. The former
live within the ‘ band,’ the Bihiirs without it. In fact the name Kooh Bihdr has a
reference to this tribo ; even A'sam is sometimes called ‘ Koch A’sam.’ The people
are very ngly, both men and women ; they look like Qalmaqs, and have a steel blue
complexion. Some are fair. Among the Meches white people are found. This tribe
furnishes agriculturists and soldiers” (pp. 692, 693).
The king in the ’ Alamgirnamah also is described as an effeminate voluptuary,
who left every- thing in the hands of his vazir ‘ Bholnnath.’
G8
H Blochmann — Koch Bihar ancl A’sam.
[No. 1.
rapid and deep ; and a chain passes over the water, the ends of which are
fastened to opposite rocks. Above this chain there is another, the distance
between the two being the height of a man. People cross the river by walk-
ing along the lower chain and supporting themselves by seizing the upper
one ; even horses and burdens are made to cross the river on the chain. I can-
not vouch for the truth of the Bhiitiah’s story. The man looked very
fair, was strongly built, and had long, light brownish hair, hanging over the
shoulders. His only dress was a white cloth which covered his private
parts. Their language is related to that of the Kochis. The Nawab now
sent the man with a letter to the Dharmrajah, asking him to seize and send
Bhim Narain to him, or at least drive him from his hills. The man brought
at last an answer, in which the Dharmrajah excused himself by saying that
he had not called Bhim Narain ; but as he had come unasked, he could not
well drive away a guest.
The Nawab had no time to lose, overlooked the impertinence, and
prepared himself to invade Asam.
Koch Kiliar was thus annexed. The name of the town was changed
to ’ Almngirnagar. Isfantliar Beg received from his Majesty the title of
Khan, and was to officiate as Faujdar of the country till the arrival of ’Askar
Khan, who had been appointed to that office. Isfandiar remained in Koch
Bihar with 400 horse of his own contingent, and 1000 Imperial matchlock-
men ; Qazi Samiii Shuja’i* was madeDiwan ; Mir ’Abdurrazzaq and Khwajah
Kishwar I)tis Man9abdar were made Amins.
The Nawab after a stay of sixteen days started for As&m.
The Conquest of A'sa'm.
The Nawab left Koch Bihar on the 23d Jumada I., [4th January, 16G2],f
and marched over K’hont’haghat into A'sam. Everywhere there were dense
jungles. When he arrived at Kangamati, Rashid Khan joined him. The
zamindars of the district, who believed the conquest impossible, could not be
trusted, and the Nawab had for carriage and guides solely to depend on his
own exertions. Dilir Khan was appointed harawal (vanguard) ; and he and
Mir Murtaz.i, the Daroghah of the Artillery park, had to look after the
roads. In consequence of the jungles and the numerous nalahs, which
* I. e. Qazi Samu, who had been in the service of Prince Shuja’. The Bibl. Indica
Edition of KhafC Khan calls him Qazi Timur, evidently on the authority of bad MSS.
Besides, Khafi Khan is an untrustworthy historian.
The “rebellious” princes of the Dihli house recoivo nick names at the hands of
the historians. Dara Shikoh, i. e. ‘ one who has the dignity of Darius,’ is called
Dara he Shikoh, the undignified Dara ; Prince Shuja’, i. e., ‘ the brave,’ is always called
‘ Nashuja’, * the recreant.’ Shahryar, Jahangir’s son, who proclaimed himself at
IAhor, was nicknamed ‘ Nashudani, or ‘ good-for-nothing.’
f The ’ Alamgtmdmah (p. C94) says that the reached the Brahmaputra on the 28th.
1872.] H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm. GO
however were mostly shallow, the daily progress was not more than 2
or 2J kos. The fatigues which the men had to undergo defy all descrip-
tion. The grass and the reeds especially were annoying to men and animals-
At last, on the 9th Junnida II., [20tli January, 1662], they reached and
took possession of Fort Jogig’hopah* [opposite Gwalpara], which belongs
to Kanmlp. Tho enemies had fled without striking a blow. ’Ataullah, a
servant of the Nawab, was left here as Thanahdar. It is a high and large
fort on the Brahmaputra. Near it the enemies had for a short distance
dug many holes in the ground for the horses to fall into, and pointed pieces
of bamboo (called in their language phdnjis) had been stuck in the
holes. Behind the holes, for about half a shot’s distance, on even ground,
they had made a ditch, and behind this ditch another one three yards
deep near the fort. The latter ditch was also full of pointed bamboos.
This is the way how the Asamese fortify all their positions. They make
their forts, like the Indian peasants, of mud. The Brahmaputra is south
of the fort ; and on the east a large river, called the Banas, flows past the
mountain and joins the Brahmaputra. To the north, the fort is guarded
hy a ditch, several mountains, and dense jungle. The writer nearly lost
one his horses that had put its foot into one of the holes.
A bridge of boats was made over the Banas. At the time of crossing,
the guns of a boat fell into the river ; so also a gun belonging to the
Naw&b, which shot ser balls The latter was after several
days’ labour recovered.
Na$iruddin Khan, Yadgar Khan, and other Amirs crossed the Bralmri-
putra, and marched along the other bank opposite to the army, whilst
’Ataullah, one of the Nawab’s men, was left behind as commander of
Jogig’hopah.
On the 24th Jumada II. [4th February, 1662], the neighbourhood of
Gawaliatti was reached. Rashid Khan was sent off, to prevent the enemies
from escaping to the north. But before he could reach, they had fled, and
left the fort empty.
On the 25th Jumada II., the army reached Fort Srig’hat. The exits
and entrances had all been closed with large logs of wood driven into the
ground. Some the elephants pulled out, some Haji Muhammad Baqir of Isfa-
han, a servant of the Nawab, renowned for his strength. The Nawab entered
and inspected the place, and then moved to Gawahatti, which lies a kos further
°n. Fort Pandu also, which lies on the other side of the river opposite to
Srig’hat, was taken without fight. Yadgar Khan Uzbak killed, however, a
* The 'Ala mil (mama h (p. 696) says that Jogig’hopah means ‘ Hermit’s Cave,’ and
was so called from a Hindu Ascetic who had lived there. On the other side
of the river was a mountain called Panch llat an, also fortified. An island on the river
had also been fortifiod with palisades.
70
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A’sdm.
[No. 1,
large number of tlie retreating enemies. The garrison also of Fort Kajli,
which lies 7 kos farther from Fort Pandu, had deserted the stronghold.
Some zamburaks, matchlocks, and a quantity of gimpowder, were captured.
Fort Srig’hat is bigger and higher than Fort Jogig’hopah. Fort Pandu
is about equal to Fort Srig’hat ; Fort Kajli is not less important. Idol-
temples devoted to Gaumuk’hiadebi and Lunachamari and Isma’il Jogi,
are upon the mountain near Fort Pandu. From the foot of the mountain
to the top there is a stone staircase of more than 950 and less than 1000
steps. Fort Kajli lies near the very same ‘ Kajliban,’ which is mentioned
in Hindu books. It is a place full of elephants.
At this time Makardhaj,* Rajah of Durang, who is subject to the Rajah
of A'sara, came and paid his respects to the Nawab, presented an elephant,
received a khal'at, was promised protection, and was ordered to travel
with the army.
Muhammad Bog, a dependent of the Nawab, was made Faujdar of
Gawahatti, and Hasan Beg Zanganah, also a servant of the Nawab, was made
Thanahdar of Kajli.
II.
After Rashid Khan had occupied Rangamati, before the Nawab had
left Khizrpur, the zamindars of A'sam had sent an ambassador to Rashid
Khan with insolent letters. Rashid sent the man to the Nawab, who
told him in plain terms that if the Rajah of A'sam would restore those
lands which he had occupied and would send his daughter with a decent
peshkash and also the guns and other things which he had earned off
from Kamrup, and make a treaty and give his oath that he would in
future desist from annoying the imperialists, the Nawab would give up the
expedition. Indeed the Nawab would have liked such an arrangement, and
would have contented himself with the cession of Kamrup and a mode-
rate peskash, as he wished, after the rains were over, to invade Arakan ;
for his . Majesty had ordered him to send the children and the wives of
Prince Shuja’ to court. But the Nawab resolved to spttle in this year the
affairs of Koch Bihar and A'sam, and to go next year to Arakan. The
ambassador to whom he had given the aboVe answer, did not return ; and
after having waited some time at Gawahatti, on the 27th Jumada II., the
Nawab set out, and entered A'sam Proper. Asamese warfare depends upon
tricks and night attacks ; hence all guards were ordered to do chauki armed
and with their horses saddled.
The march was directed to Ghargaon, the capital of the Rajah, which lies
on the other side of the Brahmaputra. First it was necessary to take Fort
* The Bibl. Indica Edition of the ’ A'lamgirndmah (p. 703) lias Malirox>anj.
1872.]
H. Bio ohm arm — Koch Bihar and Asdin.
71
Chamdhurah. At the place Bartinah* which lies halfway between
Gawahatti and Chamdhurah, the whole army crossed in two days the Brahma-
putra on boats, on the 6th Rajah [15th February, 1662]. A messenger, who
had accompanied the former Asamese ambassador, came here into camp with
an evasive answer. The Rajah of Ddmuriah one of the subjects of
the Rajah of A'sarn, sent his brother’s son with an elephant to attend on the
Rajah, begging the Nawab to excuse his absence as he was sick. His rela-
tion went with the camp.
At this time Mirza Beg, the Bakhshl of the Nawab, was killed. He
was stabbed by one of his soldiers ; but though mortally wounded, he
inflicted two sword-cuts on the man. Mirza Beg died during the night,
and the murderer was killed by Mirza Beg’s relations.
At one of the stages, a tremendous storm took place, during which many
ships were upset ; large pieces of hail also fell, and many horses threw
themselves into the river. The Asamese, thinkhig that Fort Chamdhurah
would be, as it had been in former expeditions, the farthest point of the advance
of the imperialists, had strengthened the fortifications of Simlahgar, which
lies on the other side of the river, opposite to Chamdhurah. On the 11th
Rajab [20th February, 1662], the army encamped at the foot of Simlahgar,
so near the fort that a zambiirak ball from the fort passed over the Nawab’s
tent. Some of the Nawab’s men wished to take the fort by climbing up ;
hut as this would have cost much human life, they were ordered not to do
so, and a siege was commenced.
Simlahgar is very strong and high. The inhabitants are as numerous
as ants and locusts. Two sides of the fort have walls with battlements, and
guns are placed without break upon them. The guns are all manned. At
the foot of the walls are a ditch and the customary holes with the phdnjis.
On the south side, the fort ends in a hill extending for four kos. The
* AaaRj. MS. . The ’Alamgirnamali does not give the name.
The name ‘ Bartinah’ is doubtful, and our modern maps do not help us to identify
the place where Mir Jumlah crossed for the left bank of the Brahmaputra. Chamdhu-
rah lies opposite to Tezpur, the maps giving a Mahail Cliamdhoree and a place of the
same name. A Chamdhoreegaon I find marked on an island of the Brahmaputra, east
of Tezpur, half way between Tezpur and the Kamaldiya Temple.
Simlahgar (for which the Bibl.'Indica Edition of Khafi Khan gives BMmgar) is
not on our maps ; but it cannot lie far from Tezpur, as it is said to lie opposite to
Chamdhurah. After the conquest of Simlahgar, the Nawab inspects the fort, and
encamps on the same day at Kulyabar, which lies on the loft hank of the Bx-ahmaputra,
S. E. of Tezpur.
The identification of these names is a difficult matter, as it would appear that
the numerous branches of the Brahmaputra are often shifting, Mr. Foster (vide pp.
35’ 3y) identifies Bernier’s Cbamdara with a place of the same name five miles from
Ghargaon. This may be correct ; bnt if so, it is another Cbamdara, because the
Chamdurah opposite to Simlahgar lies, as will he seen below, seven days’ marches
west of Lak’hugar, the western point of Majnli Island.
72 H. Bloehmann — Koch Bihar and Asdm. [No. 1,
northern wall is near the Brahmaputra, about 3 Jcos distant from it. A
nalah extends from the south of the fort, touching the southern bastion and
from there flows westward. The army encamped on the banks of this nalah.
Mahmud Beg distinguished himself by his alertness. Dilir Khan and
Mir Murtaza were in advance, and threw up trenches within gun-shot
distance from the fort. The big guns were sent to them ; but as the walls
of the fort were too wide, the guns made little impression on them. The
commanders, however, carried their covered ways ( sibah ) close up to the wall,
continually exposed to the fire of the enemies. In one night, a sally on
the covered trenches was with difficulty repulsed.
III.
The Conquest of Simlahgar.
The attacking column moved forward in the night of the 15th Bajab,
commanded by Dilir Khan. Adam Khan tells the author that Dilir’s elephant
received twenty-five wounds. Farhad Khan and Aghar Khan were wounded.
Dilir enters the fort, and Mir Murtaza opens the gate. The enemies fly.
Mahmud Beg pursues them. A good number of Musalman men and women
were found, whom the enemies had forced to remain with them.
The fall of Simlahgar broke the spirit of the hostile garrison of
Chamdhurah. They fled.
The Nawab entered Simlahgar on the 16th Bajab [26th February,
1662], and was astonished to see the strength of the fortifications. He
then encamped at Kulvabar Much war material was taken. No
marauding whatever was allowed ; in fact during the whole expedition, which
lasted one year, the punishments inflicted on marauders were most severe.
Sayyid Nayiruddin Khan was made Faujdar of Kulyabar ; and Sayyid
Mirza, Sayyid Nisar,* and Bdjah Kislin Singh garrisoned Chamdhurah.
IV.
Victorious progress of the fleet. Arrival at Lalc'hugar.
The Nawab left Kulyabar on the 20th Bajab [2nd March, 1662]. On
account of the hills along the banks of the Brahmaputra, the army had to
march at some distance from the river, and was thus separated from the
ships. It happened that Ibn Husain for some important reason was away
from the fleet with the army, when suddenly, after evening prayer, on the
21st Bajab, 7 or 800 hostile ships attacked the fleet, which had just anchored.
Munawwar Khan Zamindar and ’Ali Beg did their best till more ships came
up. The cannonade lasted the whole night, and was heard by the army.
The Nawab sent Muhammad Mumin Beg (a servant of Yakalitaz Khan)
* The Bibl. Indica Edition of the ’A'laingtrndrnah (p. 713) has ‘ Sayyid Tatar.’
1872.]
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A’sdm.
73
to assist the fleet. He arrived at the first watch of the morning at a nalah
near the river and the fleet, and told his trumpeters to blow. This decided
the fate of the engagement. 300 or 400 ships, with a gun on each, were
seized. The author was with the fleet.
The next day the army again approached the river.
The conquest of Simlahgar and the defeat of their fleet disheartened the
Asamese. They withdrew to the hills, and trusted to surprises and night-
attacks.
The Nawsib then reached Solahgar where several Amirs
came with letters from the Rajah — Amirs are called in Asamese Phuhans
( ) — , and asked for peace. But it soon became evident that their
object was to cause delay or a decrease in vigilance, in which hope they
were disappointed.
On the 27th Rajah [9th March, 1662], the Nawab reached Lak’hugar.
Here eleven elephants of the Rajah were seized. A Brahman, an inhabitant
of Dewalgaon and spiritual guide of the Rajah, came to the camp ; so
did Yalnoli Phukan, who brought a pdnddn, a gold vessel, and two silver
jars, 100 gold muhurs, and a submissive letter from the Rajah. But the
letter was not deemed sincere, and a reply was sent that the Nawab would
soon he in Ghargaon, where alone he would treat with the Rajah.
Lak’hugar* lies at the confluence of the Hihing River with the Brahma-
putra. The Dihing comes from the mountains north of Ghargaon, and he
who goes to Ghargaon travels along the southern hanks of the Dihing.
Between the Dihing and the Brahmaputra is a tract which stretches
to the mountains of Namrup, and is well cultivated.
Ghargaon itself lies on the Dik’ho Nalali, which 8 Jcos from the town
joins the Dihing. It is very shallow, and the fleet was ordered to
remain stationed at Lak’hugar, in charge of Ibn Husain Darogah, Jamal
Khan, ’All Beg, Munawwar Khan, &c. The fleet consisted of 323 ships, viz.,
Carried forward 280
159 kosahs palils (cL^Kj ) 1
48 jalbahs (Axl^.) bhars (g4l) I
10 ghrabs (vt/*) balams ( 2
7 parindahs («^J) khatgiris 10
4 bajrahs (XysJ) mahallgiris ... 5
50 patilahs (aLJL>) palwarahs and
2 salbs (wJU) other small ships 24
280 Total 323
On the 28th of this month, the sun entered Aries.
* Lak'hugar lies on the confluence of the Dihing and the Brahmaputra. The
Dihing River, on Lieut. Wilcox’s Survey map, published in Vol. XVI of the Asiatic
10
K
71
H. Blochmann - Zuif/f BiMr and A’sam.
[No. 1,
V.
The Conquest of Ghargaon.
On the 1st Sha’bin, 1072 [12th March, 1602], the Nawab left Lak'hu-
gar, crossed the nalali, and encamped at the Naosal, or arsenal, of the
Rajah. Next day, they came to Dewalgaon, where the spiritual guide of
the Rajah lives, crossed a nalah, the water of which reached up to the saddles
of the horses, and encamped on the banks. An idol temple and a line garden,
near the Billing River, are the sights of Dewalgaon. There were plenty of
orange trees, full of very large and unusually juicy oranges. They were sold
in the camp at ten for a pice. ’All Elza Beg was made Thanahdar of
Dewalgaon.
Several Muhammadans of the place informed the Nawab that the Rajah
kept a large number of Musalmans imprisoned, and had fled with his
valuables to Namrup.
On the 4th Sha’ban [15th March], the Nawab set out, and encamped at
the village of Gajpur. Farhad Khan and Mir Sayyid Muhammad Diwan
i tan, and other Amirs, were ordered to march quickly to Ghargaon, and seize
upon the elephants and other property, which the Nawab had heard were
still there. Anwar Beg, a servant of the Nawab, was made Thanahdar of
Gajpur. Four elephants were here also seized.
On the 5th Sha’ban, [16th March] the Nawab encamped at Taramhani
which is the name of the confluence of the Dik’ho and the Billing,
and made Nurullah, one of his servants, Thanahdar of Taramhani. He col-
lected here much cattle. Muhammad Muqim was ordered to seize on Nam-
dlng,# a place between Taramhani and Ghargaon and a nalah, which comes
from the hill and passes it.
Researches, forms with the Bnri or Lohit Branch the Majoli Island. Mr. Peat informs
me that the Lohit is the old bed of tho Brahmaputra ; the Dik’ho and the Disang fell
into the Dihing, and the Majoli Island was joined to Muttok by an isthmus. On
modern maps the name of Dihing is not used ; the Lohit is looked upon as a branch,
and the former Dihing branch is now called Brahmaputra. On no map have I found
Lak’hugar, which circumstance may be due to tho shifting of the stream. But if it lay at
the confluence of the modern Lohit and Brahmaputra, it can scarcely be identical with
the Lockwa mentioned on p. 38 j for the distance of tho point of confluence from
Ghargaon is more than a geographical degree. Nor can I find the place Solahgar,
‘ which lies between Kulyabar and Lak’hugar.’
* Dewalgaon lies two miles N. E of the point where tho Ladkiitgaj-h crosses the
Sioni A1 (or Alii, which seems to be the word now-a-days used in A'sam). Gajpur lies
two miles from Jorhat,. At Gajpur the Nawab was on the Sioni A1 ; ho then turned off
to the Bor Al, on which Taramhani must have been. Mr. Foster suggests to alter the
Taramhani of the MSS. to Ta/rah-hdnt which means ‘a feeding-ground.’ The
letters he and mtm are constantly confused in MSS., and Mr. B’oster’s conjecture does
the reading of the MSS. no violence. It is also significant that at Tarahani the Nawab
1872.] H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A's'.m. 75
At every station the road was intersected by nalahs ; in fact they are so
numerous, that I cannot mention each singly.
On the l(5th Sha’ban, [17th March, 1662] the Nawab entered Ghargaon.
He crossed the Dik’ho, and went eastward, and occupied the Kajah’s
palace.
The next day many guns were recovered from the tanks into which the
Rajah had thrown them before his flight ; 82 elephants, and nearly three
lacs of rupees in gold and silver, were also found. The number of guns which
were captured, from the starting of the expedition till the return, was 675,
among them a large iron gun ) the halls of which weighed
3 mans; 1343 zamburaks ; 1200 ramehangis ; and 6570 matchlocks; 340
mans of powder ; 1960 boxes with powder, in each box about 2 or 2 1 mans of
powder ; 7828 shields ; a large quantity of saltpetre, iron, sulphur, and lead ;
1000 and odd ships, many of which accommodated 80, 70, and 60 sailors.
Unfortunately 123 bachhari ships, like which no other existed in the dock-
yards at Ghargaon, were burned, some Asamese having set fire to
the chhappars under which they were kept. About 173 store houses for
rice were discovered, over which matchlockmen were placed as guards, each
of the houses containing from ten to one thousand mans of rice. These stores
proved very useful.
VI.
On A'sam and its Inhabitants.*
A'sam is a wild and inaccessible country, cultivated only along the
Brahmaputra, which flows through it from east to west. From Gawahatti
to Sadiah (<*j the distance is about 200 kos. The breadth from the hills,
inhabited by the Miris, Michmis [Mishmis], Duflahs, and Landahs,t up to the
“ collects cattle,” and Mr. Foster tells me that according to the legends the Bor
M was expressly constructed to bring the Rajah’s milk from the feeding grounds to
Ghargaon.
The Nawfib then marches along the Bor Al, a magnificent road, to Mmdilng,
for which the ‘A'lamijtmdmah (p 719) has ‘ Lamdang, and the Fathiyah, ‘Ramdiing.
The Kamdang Rivor flows into the Dik’ho, N. N. W. of Ghargaon. lho distance of
Namdang from the Bansgark of Ghargaon is about ten miles. At the place where
the Bor Al entors the Bansgarh, there is still a ruined fortified gateway, called the
Singh Duar,’ from which the Dik’ho is about four miles distant.
* The greater part of this chapter is given in the ’Alamgirnamah, from which it
was translated into English by Mr. H. Yansittart in the Asiatic Researches, Yol. II,
P. 171. But as his proper names are mostly wrong, I give here a full translation of
the chapter as given in the more complete Fathiyah i ’ Ibriyah .
t All MSS. havo clearly landali. If the word is correct, it would refor to a tribe
Of Aborigines not mentioned in our Ethnological works. Col. Dalton, to whom I
76
H. Blochmann — Koch TZih&r and Asam.
[No. 1,
district of the N%a tribes, is about a journey of seven or eight days. Its south-
ern mountains reach the Kb asiali (Aj-aA), Kachhar, and the Gonaser Hills*
lengthways, and in the breadth, the Naga Hills. Its northern mountains
reach the high ridges of Kamrup lengthways, and in the breadth the hills
occupied by the Duflahs and the Landalis.
The northern banks of the Brahmaputra form the Uttarkol ; the
southern, the Dak’hinkol. The Uttarkol extends from Gawahatti to the
country of the Mills and Michinls ; and the Dak hinkol from the kingdom
of Nakirani to Sadiah. The hill tribes pay no tribute to the
Rajah of Asam, but regard him with awe, and submit to some of his
orders. But the Duflahs do not obey him, and often make raids into the
Rajah’s territory.
The distance between Kulyabar aad Ghargaon is well cultivated ; every-
where are houses, gardens, and orchards. Along the sides of the road there
submitted this passago, says in a letter — “ I cannot mate out the word ‘ Lnndah
but from the relative position of the word with the names ol the other tribes of the
North bank, I think, the author must mean the A'kas or Ankas ; and if yon read the
passage thus “ The breadth of Asam from the hills inhabited by the (1) Mishmis, (2)
Mins, (3) Duflahs, (4) Ankas, to the Naga Hills, &c.," yon have the tribes in their proper
geographical order. Tom- author includes only Upper and Central Asam in his de-
scription of what he calls Asam, excluding Kamrup. This explains what might other-
wise appear obscure when he says (in the following sentence) — “The northern
mountains (i e. those in which the Mishmis, Miris, &o., dwell) extend to the high
ridges of Kamrup.”
Regarding the Miris, Mishmis, and Duflahs (Dophlas) the reader will find the
fullest information in Col. Dalton’s “ Ethnology of Bengal.”
* The text has Kashmir ; the MS. of the Asiatic Society has^xiS" Kasidr,
mjdSAS Kmashir. The ’A'lamjrrndmah boldy substitutes Srinagar (i. e., Kashmir),
which Vansittart also gives. But this is absurd. I havo conjecturally translated
Oonaser Hills, i. e. Qunasher, following the MS. of the Asiatic Society. A part
of what we now call the Garo Hills is evidently meant ; and I find that Rennell, — but
no modern map — calls the southern portion of the Garo Hills Oonaser (Map ix, of the
Bengal Atlas). The order of his hills from the east is Kachhar Hills, Jaintiah Hills,
Gonaser Hills, Karim Hills, Kuribari Hills. His Giro Hills are north of the Gonaser Hills.
The word Naga is spelt with a nasal n, ‘ Nanga hence ATansittart s Nanac. For his
Zemlah, lUh we havo to read Daflahs — a shifting of the dot.
f Col. Dalton says : — “ The author again excludes Kamrup from A'sam, and com-
mences the Uttarkol from Gawahatti. The modern Gawahatti is on tho south bank;
but the ancient city, called Pragjoitishpur, oocupied a vast area on both banks.
Nakirani I cannot make out ; it may, however, refer to Deshrani, a large parganah
of Kamrup, close to the modern Gawahatti.”
Col. Dalton’s identification is confirmed by the author’s wish to exclude Kamrup
from Asam; hence the Dak’hinkol must commence with the Deshrani parganah. The
name again occurs below in the articles of peace (p. ‘J J) .
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
1872.]
are high bamboo-shrubs. There are many wild and cultivated flowers, and
behind the bamboos, as far as the hills, there are fields and gardens. So it
is also along the road from Lak’hugar to Gliargaon. There is a high and
wide dl, or raised road, up to Ghargaon.
The fields and the gardens are made so oven in this country, that the
eye up to the far horizon rejoices to see neither depression nor elevation. On
the whole, the Uttarkol is better cultivated ; hut as the Dak’hinkol is better
fortified by nature and less easy to cross, the Rajahs of Asam have
generally lived in this part. The climate of all parts near the Brahma-
putra is healthy for natives and strangers ; but the districts remote from
the river are deadly to strangers, though they may be healthy enough for the
natives of the place. The rains often last for eight months ; even the cold
season is not tree from rain.
In the cold season, fluxes and fevers attack the natives and spare
strangers ; in the hot season, strangers suffer more than natives, especially from
bilious complaints. But the natives of A'sarn are free from several disgusting
diseases, as leprosy, white leprosy, elephantiasis, abscesses, swellings of the neck
and the testicles, which last complaint is so common in Bengal, and from
other diseases. The air and the water in the hills are fatal to natives and
strangers. The fruits and flowers of Bengal are found in A'sam ; but there
are many that are neither to be had in Bengal, nor in other parts of India.
Cocoanut and Nun are rare; but filfil (pepper) , sadaj (spikenard),*
and different kinds of lemons are common. The mangoes are plentiful, but
full of worms ; sweet ones without strings are rare. The pine apples are
large and taste well ; the black, red, and white sugarcane is sweet, but so
hard as to break one’s teeth ; ginger is large and delicate, and not stringy
either, Paniulahs, a kind of amlah, are very fine, and many prefer them to
plums.
The staple food of the country is rice ; but the superior kinds are rare.
Wheat, barley, vetches, are not sown, though the ground is suitable for their
cultivation. In fact, everything grows well. Salt is very dear. At the foot
of the hills, salt is, indeed, found, but it has a bitter, biting taste. Some of the
natives dry the kelah plant in the sun, bum it, and collect the ashes in a
white sheet, which they fix on four poles. They then pour gradually water
on the ashes, and catch whatever percolates in a vessel below the sheet.
Ihe liquid is saltpetre-like and very bitter ; but they use it as salt. Ducks
and fowls are very large. Then- fighting cocks are very plucky, and rarely
run away. If a weak cock fight with a strong one and get its head broken
and its brain scattered about, or be dying, it will never take its eyes from
* Vansittart says that sadaj is the same as tezpat, Lauras cassia, laurel leaf. Sir
W Jones has an article on the Asamese spikenard in the Asiatic Researches, Vol. II,
405.
78
H. Blochmann — Koch Biluir and Asam.
[No. 1
the opponent or show its back. Elephants are large and numerous in a
wild state in the hills. Gazelles, stags, nilgaos, and wild goats, are rare.
In Ghargaon there were several cage-like enclosures, secured with strong
and high poles. It is said that some elephant drivers of the Rajah rub a
certain kind of grass over the body of a female elephant, and let her go
among wild elephants when they rut. As soon as they smell the scent
of the grass, they will run after her, and will even follow her to the
enclosure to which the driver leads her, when they are caught. The Nawab
tried in vain to get hold of one of the drivers.
Gold is found in the Brahmaputra ; about ten thousand people are
employed in the washings. Each man makes in the average a tolali of gold
per annum, and hands it to the Rajah. But the gold is not fine, and sells
for 9 or 8 rupees per tolali.
Cowries are in use ; and rupees and muhurs, coined by the Rajah, are
current. Copper is not current. In the hills of the Miris and Michmis
who live in Eastern Asam, in Uttarkol, about eleven days’ journey from Ghar-
gaon, musk deer and wild elephants are found. Silver, copper, and tin
also are obtained in their hills. The way these people live, resembles the way
of the Asamese. Their women are generally better looking than the women
in Asam. They dread matchlocks, and say, “ A matchlock is a thing that
makes a great noise, and does not stir from its place, whilst a child issues
from its womb that kills a man.” The musk deer is also found in the
mountains of Asam. The musk bags are larger than large [gram] grains,
and have a fine colour and perfume. Lignum aloes, which is chiefly found
in the mountains of Namrup, Sadiah, and Lak’hugar, is heavy, coloured, and
has a strong scent.
If Asam were administrated like other parts of the empire, it is quite
possible that the land-tax and the revenue from wild elephants and other
imposts might amoimt to 45 lacs of Rupees.* It is not customary to levy
taxes from tho inhabitants ; but of every three people in each house one is
taken for the service of the Rajah. If a man is lazy in what he is told to
do, capital punishment is immediately inflicted ; hence the absolute sway
of the Rajah,
No Indian king in former times ever conquered Asam. Even tho
intercourse of foreigners and the Asamese was very limited. They allow no
stranger to enter their territories, and prevent their own people from leaving
the country. Once a year, at the order of the Rajah, a party of Asameso
used to visit the neighbourhood of Gawahatti and the boundary of the
* Last year’s revenue of tho whole Asam Division, which contains tho districts of
Durang, Kamrup, Lak’himpur, Naugaon, and Sibsagar, in addition to the Naga,
Khasiab, and Jaintiah Hills, amounted to nearly 21 lacs (Rs. 20,93,374).
1872.]
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihxr ancl Asam.
79
country, bringing gold, musk, lignum aloes, filfil, sadaj, and silk. These
articles they gave in exchange for salt, saltpetre, sulphur, and other tilings,
which the people of Gnwahattl used to furnish. But all armies that
entered Asam perished, and no caravan ever got safe out of it. If an
army invaded the country, it was exposed to continual night attacks ; or
the people withdrew to the hills, and waited for the beginning of the rains,
when the soldiers were sure to die or could easily be cut off.
Thus Husain Shah, one of the kings of Bengal, invaded Asam with
24000 foot and horse and numerous ships. The Rajah withdrew to the
hills. Husain Shah, therefore, took possession of the country, left his son
there with a strong detachment, and returned to Bengal. As soon as the
rains set in, the Rajah came down from the hills and, assisted by his own
people, who had of course submitted to Husain’s son, killed the prince,
starved the army, and managed to capture or kill the whole of them. It is
said that the people who are now called Moslems in Asam, are the descendants
of the captives of Husain’s army.*
It is from the misfortunes which have invariably befallen those who
entered Asam, that the people of India have come to look upon the Asamese
as sorcerers, and use the word 1 Asam’ in such formulas as dispel witchcraft.
The Asam Rajahs have always been insolent and proud of their power
and the number of their men.
The present Rajah, Jaidliaj Singh, is called Sargi Rajah, because sarg in
Hindi means ‘ heaven.’ The fellow believes that one of his ancestors
commanded the heavenly host, and descended from heaven on a golden ladder ;
and as he found the country beautiful, he remained there instead of returning
to heaven. The present Rajah is much prouder than his ancestors : for a
slight fault he will destroy a whole family, or on suspicion throw people into
fetters. His wife only gives birth to daughters, and has no son ; hence the
* Vide Prinsep’s list of tho Asam Rajahs, p. 273, of Thomas’s Edition of Prinsep’s
Useful Tables. His list is based upon the Asam Buranji, or Asam Chronicle, by Huliram
Dhaikiyal Phukan, of Gawahatti. Another Asam Buranji, or history of the kings of
Asam, was compiled by Sri Radhanath Bar Bamwa and Knsinath Tumuli Phukan,
(printed by tho American Baptist Mission Press, Sibsngar, Asam 1844, 8vo , 102 pp.).
Husain's invasion is generally referred to A. X). 1408, and his son s name is said
to have been Dalai (Jalal, ?) Gliazi.
Tho ’ Alamgtmdmah and the Asam Histories speak of an invasion of Asam by
Muhammad Shah (A. D., 1337). The former work says (p. 731)—“ Muhammad Shah,
son of Tughluq Shah, sent 100,000 horse well equipped to Asam ; but the whole army
perished in that land of witchcraft, and not a trace was left of the army. He sent a
second army to avenge the former disaster ; but when they came to Bengal, they
would not go farther, and the plan had to be given up.”
Tims it would seem that Muhammad Tughluq intended to invade China via
Asam. Vide Dowson, Elliot’s History, Vol. Ill, pp. 241, 242.
so
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'tam.
[No. 1,
word ‘ succession’ has a had name in Asam, especially as there is no male
relation in the whole family. He professes to be a Hindu ; but as he
believes himself to be one of the great emanations of the deity, he worships
no idols. The inhabitants profess no religion whatever. They eat whatever
they get, and from whomsoever it be, following the bent of their uncivilized
minds. They will accept food from Muhammadans and other people ; they
will eat every kind of flesh except human, whether of dead or killed animals.
They taboo butter, so much so that they refuse food, if it only smells of
butter.
The language of the Asamese differs entirely from the dialects spoken
in Eastern Bengal.
The males are strongly built. They are quarrelsome, fond of shedding
blood, fearless in affrays, merciless, mean, and treacherous ; in lies and
deceit they stand unrivalled beneath the sun. Their women have mild
features, but are very black ; their hair is long, and their skin soft and
smooth ; their hands and feet are delicate. From a distance the people
look well ; but they are ill-favoured as far as proportion of limbs is
concerned. Hence if you look at them near, you will call them rather ugly.
Neither the women of the Rajah, nor those of common people, veil themselves ;
they go about in the bazars without head-coverings. Few men have less
than two wives ; most have four or five. The several wives of a man will
carry on sales and barter among each other.
In paying respect, the Asamese bend the knees ; and when the subjects
go to the king or the phukans, they bend their knees, sit dozdnu, and fix
their eyes on the ground. They shave the head and beard and whiskers ;
and if a man only departs a little from this custom, they call him Bengalized
and kill him.
Asses, camels, horses, are as rare in Asam as pheenixes ; but like asses
they will admire a donkey and pay a high price for it. If they see a camel,
they get quite excited in their admiration. They are afraid of horses. If
they catch one, they cut through the sinews of the feet ; and if a horseman
attack a hundred armed Asamese, they will throw down their arms, and
run away ; but if one of them should meet ten Muhammadans on foot, he
will fearlessly attack them and even be victorious.
To sell an elephant is looked upon as a heinous crime. The Rajah and
the Phiikans travel in xinghetsans, and chiefs and rich people in dulls, made in a
most ridiculous way. They use a kind of chair instead of howdahs. Turbans,
long coats, trowsers, shoes, and sleeping on chdrpdis, are quite unusual. They
use a coarse cloth for the head, one for the waist, and a sheet for the
the shoulders. Some of the richer people wear a kind of half coat, which
resembles our Yt^qubkhani jacket. Those who can afford it, sleep on a
wooden dais.
1872.] H. Bloehmarm — Koch Bihdr and Asam. 81
They eat pan in large quantities with unripe supdri, unshelled. They
weave excellent flowered silk, velvet, tatbands, and other silks. Boxes, trays,
stools, chairs, are cleverly and neatly made of one piece of wood. I saw
several stools belonging to the Rajah, two cubits broad ; even the feet were
cut out of the same piece, and not merely joined to it.
Their war-sloops resemble the Bengali kosahs. They call them
bacharis. The difference is only this that at the poop and the stern,
the kosah has two planks (£U, pr. branches) ; but the poop (sar) and
the keel (uj) of the bacharis are made of one flattened plank. They
are slower than kosahs. The shipping traffic may be estimated from
remarks taken from the reports of the Waqi'ahnawis of Gawahatti lor Rama-
zan last. He says that, up to the present time, no less than 32,000 boats,
bacharis and kosahs, have arrived here. The number of ships engaged for the
army, and those belonging to the Asamese which accompanied the army on
its return, must certainly have been larger ; and it is probable that more than
one half belonged to Asamese. The ships are built of chambal wood (
MS. J-Aa.) ; and a ship built of such wood, no matter how full it is, will
never, on sinking, remain at the bottom of the water. This fact was examined
by many, and by me, too. Their matchlocks and bavhaluldr guns are well
oast, and the people show much expertness in the manufacture. Them powder
is of several kinds ; for the best kind they import the components from his
Majesty’s country.
With the exception of the gates of Ghargaon and some idol temples,
houses in Asam are not built of bricks or stones and mortar. Rich and poor
build then' houses of wood or bamboo or grass.
The ancient inhabitants of this country belong to two nations, the
Asamese and the Kulita (UH).* The latter, in all things, are superior to
the former, except where fatigues are to be undergone, and in warlike expedi-
* “ The Kolitas are the only pure descendants of the Aryans who first colonized
Asam. They were dominant there for many centuries, and had evidently arrived
at a high state of civilization when the inroads of the Mongolians commenced. There
was a Hindu Pal dynasty in the upper portion of the valley with their head quarters
at Sadiah, who succumbed to a Chutia or Kachari invasion, probably about the same
time that the Kamrap Hindu dynasty was subverted by the Koch. Afterwards the
Shans conquered the valley from Sadiah to Kiimrup, and on the retreat of the Muham-
madans invaded and took possession of Kiimrup. These Shans after their first
successes called themselves the ‘ Ahom,’ or ‘ the non-equalled people,’ and henco
the name of Asam.” Vide Col. Dalton’s Ethnology of Bengal, Group II, Sect. I.
The interchange of s and h is very common in Asamese ; several other examples
will be found below. It is curious that the same interchange of h and s should be
found in Asam, the farthest east, and in Sindh, the farthest west ; for it is Sindh, country
and river, which, in its pronunciation hind, induced the Greeks to call the whole country
India.
L
11
82
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
[No. 1
tions, in which the former are better. Six or'seven thousand Asamese guard
the environs of the palace and the harem of the Rajah. The guards are called
jauddngs ( ),* * * § and are the trusted and devoted servants and
executioners of the Rajali. The arms used by the people are matchlocks,
ramehangis, guns, arrows with ironpoints and without them, half swords,
long lances, bamboo bows, and TaJchsh arrows. At the time of war, all
trades people and well-to-do peasants, and farmers, with or without armour,
have to serve, whether they will or not.f Like jackals, they will commence
a tremendous howl, and will like foxes think that the noise frightens the
lions of the bush. A small number of their fighting men may indeed
checkmate thousands ; they are the agal Asamese ; but their number does not
exceed 20,000. J They are given to night attacks, for which they especially
believe the night of Tuesday to be auspicious. But the common people will
run away, with or without fighting, and only think of throwing away their
armours.
They bury their dead with the head towards the East and the feet
towards the West. The chiefs erect funeral vaults (<x*Ao) for their dead, kill
the women and servants of the deceased, and put necessaries, <ftc., for several
years, viz. elephants, gold and silver vessels, carpets, clothes, and food, into
the vaults. They fix the head of the corpse rigidly with poles, and put a lamp
with plenty of oil and a mash’alcM [torchbearer] alive into the vault, to look
after the lamp. Ten such vaults were opened by order of the Nawab, and
property worth about 90,000 Rupees was recovered. § In one vault in which
the wife of a Rajah about 80 years ago had been buried, a golden pdnddn
was found, and the pan in it was still fresh. This fact was related by
Payandah Bog, Assistant Waqi’ahnawis, and by Shah Beg, at an evening
* Tulgo Sowdangs.
t Vide Robinson’s Descriptive Account of Asam, p. 200. Robinson’s work is a very
valuable book. The author died in Asam of fever, and lies buried in Mr. Foster’s
compound in Nazirah, Upper Asam.
I “ What the Persian Historian says of the physical superiority of the Asamese
over the Kolitds was, no doubt, quite true at the time; for the Asamese were then a
hardy, meat-eating, beer-drinking, fighting race, and the Kolitas were offeminate
subjected Hindus.” From a letter by Col. Dalton. Regarding the Kolitas, vide Col.
Dalton’s Ethnology of Bengal, last group.
§ “ The account of the burial of Ahom magnates is confirmed by more recent
disclosures of desecrated graves. About twenty years ago, several mounds, known to
be the graves of Ahom kings, were opened and were found to contain not only tho
remains of the kings, but of slaves, male and female, and of animals that had been
immolated to serve their masters in Hades ; also gold and silver vessels, food, rai-
ment, arms, &c., were not wanting.” From a letter by Col. Dalton.
An account of the opening of some of these tombs will be found in the Journal of
this Society, Vol. xvii, Pt. I., p. 473,
83
1872.] H. Blochmann — Koch TSihar and A'sam.
party given by the Nawab ; and Basrni Beg, who received the pand.in, told
me the same.
The Muslims whom we met in A'sam, ar.e Asamese in their habits, and
Muhammadans but in name. In fact they liked the Asamese better than
us. A few Musalman strangers that had settled there, kept up prayers and
fasts ; but they were forbidden to chant the azan and read the word of God
in public.
The town of Ghargaon has four gates built of stone and mortar, the
distance of each of which from the palace of the Rajah is three /cos. A
high and wide al, veiy sti'ong, has been made for the traffic >
and round about the town, instead of fortifications, there are circular bushes
of bamboos, about two /cos in diameter. But the town is not like other towns,
the huts of the inhabitants being within the bamboo bushes near the A’l.
Each man has his garden or field before his house, so that one side of the
field touches the Al, and the other the house. Near the Rajah’s palace, to
both sides of the Dik’lio River, are large houses. The bazar road is narrow,
and is only occupied by ym«-sellers. Eatables are not sold as in our markets ;
but each man keeps in his house stores for a year, and no one either sells or
buys. The town looks large, being a cluster of several villages. Round
about the palace, an Al has been thrown up, the top of which is fortified by a
bamboo palisade instead of by walls, and along the sides of it a ditch runs, the
depth of which exceeds a man’s height. It is always full of water. The
circumference is 1 /cos, 14 j arils. Inside are high and spacious chhappars.
The Diwankhanah of the Rajah, which is called so/ang, is one hundred
and twenty cubits in length and thirty wide inside. It has sixty-six
pillars, each about four cubits in circumference. The pillars, though so
large, are quite smooth, so that at the first glance you take them to be
planed Now though the Asamese understand planing, yet you
cannot believe that they did smoothen the pillars in this way. The orna-
ments and curiosities with which the whole woodwork of the house is filled,
defies all description: nowhere in the whole inhabited world, will you
find a house equal to it in strength, ornamentation, and pictures. The
sides of this palace are embellished by extraordinary wooden trellice work.
Inside there are large brass mirrors highly polished, and if the sun shines
°n one of them, the eyes of the by-standers arc perfectly dazzled. Twelve
thousand workmen arc said to have erected the building in the course of
one year. At one end of the hall, rings are fastened on four pillars op-
posite to each other, each pillar having nine rings. When the Rajah takes
his seat in the hall, they put a dais in the middle of these four pillars, and
nine canopies of various stuffs are fastened above it to the rings. The Rajah
then sits on the dais below the canopies. The naqqurac/ns (drummers)
strike the drum and the eland. The latter instrument is round and
84 H. Blochmann — Koch Bihdr and A'sdm. [No. 1,
flat, and made of ruin metal, and is struck like a gong. The instrument
is used when the audience commences, or when the Rajah issues forth, or
the Phukans ride out, or leave for an appointment. Mulla Darwish i
Harawi [a poet who accompanied the expedition] says that these ddnds
must be the very identical metal plates* that are mentioned in the
Shahnamah ; but God knows best. There are other houses in Ghargaon,
beautifully adorned, strong, very long and spacious, full of fine mats, which
really must be seen. But alas, unless this kingdom be annexed to his
Majesty’s dominions, not even an infidel could see all these fine things
without falling into the misfortunes into which we fell. Beyond the en-
closure of this hall there is another house, the dwelling-house of the Rajah.
It is a fine and beautiful house. The Phukans have erected dwellings in its
neighbourhood. Each Phukan is a son-in-law of the Rajah, and has a
beautiful garden and a tank. Indeed, it is a pleasant place. As the soil of
the country is very damp, the people do not live on the ground floor, but
on the maehdn, which is the name for a raised floor.
VII.
Advance of the army to Mat'hurapur. Krcction of Thandhs.
The Rajah had first intended to fly to the Naga Hills, but from fear of
our army, the Nagas would not afford him an asylum.
The Nagas live in the southern mountains of A'sam, have a light brown
complexion, are well built, but treacherous. In number they equal the
helpers of Yagog and Magog, and resemble in hardiness and physical
strength the ’Adis [an ancient Arabian tribe]. They go about naked like
beasts, and do not mind to copulate with them women in the streets and
the bazars, before the people and the chiefs. The women only . cover their
breasts, f as they say that it would be absurd to cover those limbs which
every one might have seen from their birth ; but this was not the case with
the breasts, which since then had formed and should, therefore, be covered.
Some of their chiefs came to see the Nawab. They wore dark hip-clothes
0-£d) , ornamented with cowries, and round about their heads they wore a belt
of boar’s tusks, allowing their black hair to hang down over the neck. The
chief weapon of these people is the short mace
* Vide Ain translation, p. 562, note 1.
t “ I have seen Nagas to the south of Sibsagar who answer to the description
of that people by the Persian historian. Both sexes go quite naked. The women I
did not see ; but I recollect having heard that when seen by strangers, they folded their
arms across their breasts, and wore regardless of what else was exposed.” From a
letter by Col. Dalton.
The illustrations to Col. Dalton’s ‘ Ethnology of Bengal’ and the specimens of
.Naga dress in our museum, show that the boar’s tusks mentioned below are a very
common ornament for caps. They also protect the head.
1872.]
H. Bloclimann — Koch Bihdr and A’sdm.
85
The Rajah had, therefore, fled with the Phiikans to NSmriip.* * * § This
Narnrup may he called a part of hell. It lies in the hollow of three high
ridges, and its climate is worse than that of the well of Babel. The Asamese
say, “ if a bird Hies over it, bats will yield their lives, and if steel enters the
ground, it turns to wax.” The Rajahs used to banish to Namriip those whom
their sword had spared.
There is only one road in the countryt along which a horse can pass,
and this road lends to Batam north of Ghargaon. The beginning
of this road leads for half a /cos through a jungle so dense that you can
scarcely ‘ think’ yourself through it. Afterwards comes a pass extending
for five or six /cos full of stones and mud, two high mountains being on
either side. There some of the rebellious people of the southern mountains
under the Bargosain [principal noble] had established themselves, whilst
the Phiikans with a great number of men had encamped on an ‘ island’ be-
tween the Brahmaputra and the Billing River.
About this time it rained for three days and nights, and living in tents
was impossible. The intention of the Nawab was to spend the rainy season
m Lak hugar ; hut the Muta9addis reported that there would he no time to
transport the conquered material, and secondly, tho wild elephants could not
well he brought to move properly. In any case, it was clear that it would
he impossible to reach Lak’iigar before the commencement of the rains.
It was, therefore, resolved to move to Mat’hurapur, which lies 8.1 /cos
beyond Ghargaon at the foot of a mountain, towards the south-east.
A party was left behind in Ghargaon. The author also stayed behind for
reasons which are not explained. A great number of guns were sent on to
Jahangimagar. The Nawab had also rupees and pice struck with the
name of his Majesty on them. Mir M urta/.a in Ghargaon was to take charge
of all such stores as were to he kept and sent on to Jahangimagar ; Miyanah
Khan was sent to Mauza’ Salhati,§ which lies at the foot of the hills, south
of Ghargaon, and was held by the Bargosain and other accursed people ;
Ghazf Khan was sent as thanahdar to Mauza’ T)eopani,|| between Ghargaon
and Salhati ; and Jalal Khan of Baryabad was to guard the Billing River.
* Namriip is the most eastern part of Airim and scarcely known. Vansittart in
his translation confounds it with Kamrup (Western A'sam), which he substitutes for
it. His Dhonec is the * Dihing.’ His Nanec are the Nagas.
t This seems to refer to the Ladhisigarh road, which now forms the boundary
between the British and Independent Territories.
t The name is doubtful. The MSS. have every possible diacritical mark for the
word, Niyam, Nipiim, Batam, Banam, Biyam, Panam, Patam, &c.
§ Bor Salhati the ’Alamgirnamah has, perhaps correctly, Saipan/.
II So tho ’Alamgirnamah (p. 735). The Fathiyah i ’Ibriyah has Veotani. But
Deopani is evidently the oorrcct name. It still exists, and lies due south of Sibsagar,
at the foot of the hills, and S. S. W. of Ghargaon. It is now a tea garden in possession
86 H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A’sam. [No. 1,-
On the 20th Sha’ban, the Nawab moved to Mat’hurapur, and A'dam Khan
marched eight kos farther towards Parganah Abhipfir.* He had repeatedly
to fight with the Asamese. The enemies also made night-attacks on Jalal
Khan from the other side of the Hilling. But they were every time repelled,
and Jalal Khan and his Baryabadi men became objects of terror for the
Asamese. Miyanah Khan’s position at Salliati protected the inhabitants of
that district. On the whole, the Dak’hinkol was in the hands of the Imperial-
ists, and the inhabitants were satisfied with their condition. The people of
Uttarkol also thought of submitting, but fate decreed otherwise.
VIII.
The rains set in.
At the beginning of the rains, the Asamese made a night attack upon
’All Rizii, the Thanahdar at Bewalgaon, who was enforced by a detachment,
which the Nawab sent him under Yadgar Khan Uzbak.
A flotilla with provisions sent by Ibn i Husain under the command of
Muhammad Murad from Lak’hugar, arrived safely at Ghargaon [up the
Dik’ho].
On the 1st Shawwal, an attack was made upon Anwar Beg, Thanahdar
of Gajpur. He and his men were killed. Gajpur thus fell into the hands of
the Asamese, who now made trenches on the other side of the Hilling as far
as Lak’hugar, in order to cut off the supplies of the army. Sarand&z Khan
Uzbak was at once sent off by the Nawab to recover Gajpur. Ho reached
Mauza’ Tik,+ beyond which he could not pass without ships on account of
the mud in the nalahs. The Nawab ordered Muhammad Murad to go with
several ships to his assistance. But the two commanders could not agree,
and on the 14th Shawwal, Sarandaz Khan went back to Tik, and Muhammad
Murad pushed forward. He was suddenly attacked at night by the Asamese ;
his men were in the greatest confusion, and his whole fleet was captured and
the sailors were killed. Only a few Afghans escaped to bring the tale of the
disaster to Bewalgaon. The Hilling River in the meantime rose, and the
Asamese attacked the Baryabadis at Salliati, whilst the water that rushed
of tlie * Assam Company.’ TVTr. Foster tells me tliat according to a native tradition, five
Asamese once went up to the hills to make a puja and curse a deity, when a little
stream suddenly rose and engulfed them. The littlo stream was called Deopani.
* On the maps Obeypore, S. E. of Ghargaon. The name is very frequent in the
whole district south of Sibsagar.
When Aurangzib received the Nawab’ s official reports, he made him a commander
of 7000, 7000 horse, 5000 dimspah sihaspah troopers, and added to his jagir certain
mahalls the revenue of which was 1 kror dams, or 2$ lacs rupees. ’ A'lwmgtrndmah,
p. 741.
f Evidently the Tiok River, 3 miles above Gajpur. The ’ A'lamgfmdmah (Bibl.
Indica Edition, p. 779) has for
1872.] H. Blochmann — Koch Bihdr and Asam. 87
down the mountain caused the men great inconvenience. Nay, the enemies
were even hold enough to shew themselves near Ghargaon, and it required
every care on the part of Mir Murtaza to prevent mischief.
Gh&zi Khan, the TMnahdar of Deopani, who had 20 horse and 50 foot,
was attacked by 10 or 12,000 Asamese, under the son of the Bargosain’s bro-
ther. Their leader was at the time of the attack far in advance of his men,
and encountered Ibrahim Khan, one of Ghazi Khan’s men, gave his horse a
swordcut over the head, and brought Ibrahim down. But jumping up quick-
ly, Ibrahim ran against the leader, threw him on the ground, and finished him
with his dagger. The Asamese saw their leader fall, and without coming to
his assistance, retreated and watched for a better opportunity.
At this time, the population of Ghargdon, Mat’hurapur, and Adam
Khan’s thanahs commenced to leave their houses at night.
A rumour was also current that Bhim Narain of Koch Bihar had returned
and driven away the Imperialists. The rumour proved in the end to be true.
The officer in charge of Koch Bihar, after the Nawdb had left, commenced the
jam' hand), (financial settlement) of the country ; but the people did not under-
stand the now way of assessing them, and dispersed in rebellion ; and when the
Rajah returned to the foot of the hills, they gathered round him, and attacked
and killed Muhammad Qalih, the Officer who, at Kanthalbari, tried to
intercept the Rajah. They then cut off the supplies of Isfandiar Khan.
The Rajah wrote to him that he should not unnecessarily court danger, and
would do better to retreat ; and Isfandiar profiting by his advice, retreated
to G’horag’hat. ’Askar Khan soon followed him.
The Nawab strengthened Ghazi Khan’s thanali by a detachment under
Abul Hasan, Mirza Beg’s JchaM (maternal uncle) ; for the Asamese had
thrown up trenches opposite the tlianah, and were continually on the alert.
Another detachment under Sayyid Salar was sent to Ghargaon.
IX.
Farh&d Khan marches towards Lak'hugar, and returns safely.
The Nawab, on hearing the result of Muhammad Murad’s expedition,
despatched Farhad Khan and Qarawal Khan with a strong detachment
towards Lak’hugar, to keep the roads clear for the supplies. They were also
to assist Sarandaz Khan in getting to Gajpur, and send reinforcements to the
thanahs under Mir Nurullah and Muhammad Muqim.
On the 18th Shawwal, [27th May, 1662] Farhad Khan, in spite of a
dreadful storm, reached Ghargaon, crossed the same night the Dik’ho, took
UP Abul Hasan, who was on his way from Deopani to head quarters, and
reached with great trouble Mauza’ Tik, which lies between Taramhani and
Gajpur, Sarandaz Klian joined the corps. The Asamese made their ap-
88 H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm. [No. 1,
pearance in tlieir trenches, and their ships under a renowned Phukan com-
menced to tire.
Fighting continued for several days. The Rajputs of Rajah Subli&n
Singh distinguished themselves. Forty-one ships captured. Farhad arrived
at the tlnmah of Muhammad Muqim, from whom he heard that the inhabitants
of the district had been away for some days, but had just come back with
many wounded. Farhad Khan therefore sent Muhammad Mumin Beg into
the villages, as it was clear that they had been fighting against him. All
males were killed and the women were carried off.
On the 2nd Zf Qa’dah, [9th June, 1662] Farhad Khan returns to the
Nawab. The captured women were let off.
X.
The roads entirely closed. The Thanahs are drawn in.
With the progress of the rains the thanahs had to he drawn in. At the
Nawab’s order, Adam Khan was to leave Abhipur and join head quarters.
The other thanahs were to join the corps at Ghargaon, whilst Sarandaz
Khan and Miyanah Khan were to guard the other banks of the Dik’ho.
Jalal Khan, Ghfiz'i Khan, and Muhammad Muqim, should occupy this side of
Dik’ho, and he under Mir Murtaza’s orders.
This is done with difficulty. Sarandaz Khan and Miyanah Khan
occupy a piece of land surrounded on three sides hy the Dik’ho Nalah,* and
shut up the fourth side by a strong wall. The whole country is now
re-occupied by the Asamese, only Mat’hurapur and Ghargaon being in the
hands of the Imperialists. If a man dared to leave the camp, lie was certain
to be shot by the Asamese. A similar case never happened before in the
history of Dibit. Hero were 12,000 horse and numerous infantry locked in
for six months, prevented hy the rains from continuing operations, and yet
scarcely attacked by the enemies that surrounded them. Nor did during
this time provisions arrive. “ The Amirs turned their eyes longingly to Dihli,
and the soldiers yearned for their wives and children.”
The Asamese were under orders of the Phukan Bijdili, an Asamese
Brahman, whose father had risen from a storekeeper to he a noble. The
Rajah himself had come from Namrup and taken up his abode in Solagori
( ),t which in former times had been the capital of the Asamese
Rajahs. It lies four stages from Mat’hurapur and Ghargaon. The Rajah had
called up the whole population and placed them at Bijdili’s disposal. This
commander’s head quarters were at the Dillx (^A) River, which issues from
* Evidently the modern Nazirah. Mr. Foster tells me that traces of the wall
which closed the fourth side still exist.
t Solagori lies north of Ghargaon on the Disang. It is often called Hulagori,
according to the interchange of s and h, above alluded to.
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and Asam.
8!)
1872.]
the hills, passes Mat’hurapur, and flows into the Dihing. It is a dangerous
river in the rains, though at other times it is scarcely knee-deep. He had
thrown up trenches, and had* built a strong wall three Icon long, one end of the
wall extending to a mountain, and the other to the place where the Dilli
joins the Dihing. He had also cut every where the banks of the river,
and made them so steep, that no man, much less a horse, could get up.
He had several times at night attacked Dili)- Klian, but was repulsed.
Rajah Subhan Singh drives away the Charang Rajah who threatened
Ghargaon. The (Jharangs are an Asamese tribe living in the southern
mountains, and their zamindar holds from the Rajah of Asam the title of
Rajah.
The author says that it is impossible to relate the minor affairs which
almost daily oocurred.
Once Phukan Bijdili sent an ambassador to the Nawab, and asked for
cessation of the hostilities. Khwajah Bhor Mall took the Nawiib’s answer,
which was that he agreed to stop hostilities on receiving five hundred elephants
that had still their first teeth; thirty lacs oftolahsof goldand silver as peshkash ;
a daughter of the Rajah for the harem of his Majesty ; a yearly tribute of fifty
elephants with their first teeth ; and lastly, a promise to cede that portion
of Asam over which the Imperialists had passed. Tho Rajah was to keep
Narnrup and the whole of the mountainous districts to himself.
Bhor Mall went, and was received with great honor by the Phukan, with
whom he remained for half a night alone. The Phiikan approved of the
articles, and said that should the Rajah not accept them, ho would himself
come and join the Xawab.
Bhor’ Mall returned after two days. But in the meantime the epidemic
had broken out, and the Nawab moved to Ghargaon ; and as the Asamese
looked upon this movement as a sign of weakness, Bijdili did not come, as
he had promised.
XI.
Condition of the army at Ghargaon.
The Asamese in their continual attacks upon Ghargaon had succeeded in
burning down several houses of the Rajah and the Phukans outside the
enclosure. On the 7th Zi Qa’dah [14th June, 1662], Farhad Khan, Sayyid
Salar, and Qarawal Khun had arrived, and Mir Murtaz* prepared to protect
the town more efficiently. The north-western part of the town being
principally subject to attacks, a bamboo fort was erected, of which one end
reached as far as the Dik’ho and the other to the northern corner of the
palisade of the palace. Many of the inhabitants also, who suffered in the
attacks, were transferred by Mir Murtaza inside the enclosure, notably so
the inhabitants of Mauza'Chachni wll° were transferred from beyond
90
H. Bloehmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
[No. 1,
the ditch to the north side of the enclosure of the Rajah’s palace. In one
night attack, the Asamese entered the bamboo fort, and occupied half of
Gliargdon. The confusion was extreme, as Mb’ "Murtaza could not find out
where the enemies chiefly were, when an Asamese set fire to the large
chhappars of the Rajah’s palace, and the dark night became clear as day.
Account of how they were repulsed. Farhad Khdn wounded in the hand.
Further immediate fortifications. The night attacks continue without
interruption. The Dili! Nalah and the Dandka* Nalah, which flows into the
Diliing about one Icos north-east of Ghargdon, wore especially attacked by
the Asamese. The Dandka Nalah had a bridge which allowed communi-
cations to go on between Gliargdon and Mat’hurapur. One night the
Asamese broke it up ; but it was immediately rebuilt and guarded day and
night. Several store-houses were burnt by the enemies.
Detailed description of a general night attack on Ghargaon on the 5th
Zi Hajjah [12th July, 1GG2], Bepulsed with great difficulties.
The enemies cross the Dilli, and throw up a trench on the Kakujan
Nalah, which flows between the Dilli and the Dandka.
Renewed night attack on the 8th Zil Hajjah [15th July]. Farhdd
Khan’s wounds did not allow him any longer to remain in command, and
he repeatedly asked the Nawab to relieve him. Rashid Khan arrived on
the 11th with reinforcements. Farhad went next day to Mat’hurapur. Daily
attacks. On the 16th [23rd July], Rashid Khan succeeds in taking the
trenches on the Kakujan Nalah, and 170 prisoners are taken whom the author
takes the next day to the Nawab, who sent them back. The chiefs among
them were fettered and the others impaled on the Dandka Nalah.
XII.
Affairs in Lalchugar. Condition of the fleet.
When Anwar Beg, the Thnnahdar of Gajpiir, had been killed, Ibn i
Husain despatched a flotilla under ’Ali Beg to take Gajpiir and destroy the
fort which the Asamese had erected. ’Ali Beg went, but as he was not
immediately successful, he encamped the night outside the fort, his
ships anchoring at Bansbdrf, which lies between Dewalgaon and Gaj-
pur. A few ships were taken from the enemies, among them several of
Muhammad Murad’s ships. Yddgar Khan moves from Dewalgaon, and
joins Ibn i Husain at Lak’hilgar, who fortifies his camp. Repeated attacks
on Solaligar on the part of the Imperialists. Demonstration of the people
in favour of the invaders.
On the /th Muharram, 1073 [12th August, 1662], Sayyid Najiruddin
Khan died. Several attacks repulsed. The Bargosafn brought in. Yddgar
* The Bibl. Ind, Edit, of the ’ Alain firnamah has 1 Dandkdlah Nfilah.
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sdm.
91
1872.]
Kh&n again occupies Dewalgaon. A report of his success was sent to the
Nawab, who received it in the beginning of pafar [September, 1662] at
Ghargaon.
XIII.
Epidemic at Ghargaon and Mat'lmrdpur. Return of the Nawab.
Mat’hurapur lies high and was properly speaking an excellent place for
an encampment. But it was soon found that the air of the surrounding
jungles and the water from the mountain itself were unhealthy. The
mountain is called 1 Jur Parbat,’ which in Asamese means 1 fever moun-
tain.’ The men soon suffered from severe fever, and the casualties became
numerous. Thus in the beginning of the war, Dilir Khan’s detachment con-
sisted of nearly 1500 horse ; but at the end of the rains and his expedition to
Namriip, he only mustered between 4 and 500. Of the people also an unusual
number died, and Bhor Mall had heard from Phukan Bijdili that the present
year was exceptionally unfavourable to all. Food, though it was not scarce,
was limited to a few things, and some articles were only to be had at fabulous
prices. Thus butter sold at 14 Rupees per ser ; mash, 1 Tt. ; opium tolali,
1 goldmuhur ; 1 chillum of tobacco, 3 Its. ; dalmung, 10 Its. per ser ; salt,
30 Its. per 8er rJ']]0 only thing the army had was sh&li. Many horses died.
It was altogether an extraordinary year, and famine even raged in
Jahangirnagar.
The Nawab, therefore, found it necessary to leave Mat'hurapur, and
marched on the 12th Muliarram, 1073, [17th August, 1662] to Ghargaon.
One fourth of the stores of shall, for want of conveyance, had to he left
behind. Many wounded and sick people were also left in Mat’huraphr, and
it has never become known what their fate was, when the Asamese occupied
the place. Several guns also stuck in the mud,* the cows that pulled them
having no strength from want of food. At night, the Nawab stayed at a
house belonging to the Rajah, one kos from Ghargaon, and Dilir Khan who
commanded the rear, was ordered to look after the guns, as the Nawab had
resolved to wait where he was till all the guns had been brought up. The
rain was fearful. Dilir Khan told the Nawab that he would look after
everything, and on the 13th Muharram, the Nawab entered Ghargaon.
Immediate attacks of the Asamese followed. In Ghargaon also coarse red
* Mr. Foster writes from Nazirah — There are numerous large iron gnns in the
neighbourhood. One seven miles from here is 18' 6" long, 6i" bore, and has 4 trun-
nions. There are three 14' guns within a quarter mile of my bungalow. They will
he lost in the River Dik’ho next wet season, being only some 15 feet from the bank
which is rapidly cutting away. I think they must have been left by the Mughul army,
when it retreated in 1663.
92 H. Blochmann — Koch, Bihar and A’sdm. [No. 1,
rice, without salt, and limes were the only things that could he had, and fever
and dysentery soon raged as had as in Mat’hurapur. Muhammad Mumin of
Tabriz, the Waqi’ahnawis, died.
A bridge which the Imperialists had made over the Dik’lio, was torn
away by the current, but was at last built again.
XIV.
A change for the letter.
The rains ceased about the middle of f afar [end of September, 1662],
Makrdhaj, Bajah of Durang, had died in Mat’hurapur, and his mother
who held the reigns of the government during his absence, favoured the
Imperialists, and placed men at the disposal of the Faujdar of Gawahatti.
Communications now became easier. On the 21st Babi’ I. [21th October,
1662], the first supplies arrived by land, and on the 28tli, the ships with
the provisions landed at Ghargaon.
The Asamese gradually withdrew, and the Bajah went to Solagorl,
and then back to Namrup. Bijdili and Karkumba, the two principal
Phukans, were intrenched on the Dill! Biver, and Bijdili sent again an
ambassador expressing his willingness to conclude peace, should the Imperia-
lists withdraw from the country. But his offers were not listened to.
About this time orders came from court in which Ihtisham Khan was
appointed Governor of A'sam and Bashld Khfin Faujdar of Kamrup. The
latter refused on account of the unhealthiness of the climate, and Ihtisham
Khan also begged to be excused.
On the 8th Babl’ II. [10th November, 1662], Abul Hasan was ordered
to take back the provision ships to Taramhtai, and then to take the
entrenchments of Bijdili in the rear. QarawalKhan was to accompany him.
XV.
The Nawab takes the offensive. Pursuit of the Bajah.
Abul Hasan succeeds in destroying some entrenchments held by the
Asamese, and set out for Bijdili’s trenches, whilst the Nawab, too, marches
towards the Dihing to support him. But Bijdili withdrew. The Nawab
reaches the Dihing. Has a fainting fit. Badll Phdkan pays his respects
with his three brothers. The defection of the Phukans alarmed the Bajah,
and as he had been dissatisfied with Bijdili’s operations, he killed him and
his whole family, males and females. Numerous letters also arrived from
the Bajah and the Phukans, but the Nawab paid no attention to them.
Badli Pliukan submits a plan how to hunt down the Bajah, and with
the Nawab’s permission collects between three and four thousand fighting
men, and is appointed fiibahdar of the country between Ghargaon and
Narurup.
1872.] H. Bloclnnann — Koch Bihar and A’sam. 93
Numerous requests to conclude peace arrive from the Rajah, hut the
Nawab pays no attention to them. An unwelcome news also reaches the
camp, that in consequence of the famine in Bengal no rice had been sent, and
Ibn i Husain had put his sailors on short rations. The Nawab sent off 12000
maunds of shah to Rak’liugar.
At Badli Phukan’s advice, the Nawab, on the 1st Jumada I. [1st
December, 1662], sent a detachment under Darwfsh Beg to Solagori, where
several Phukans and a number of elephants were reported to be. Badli
Phukan aeompanies Darwish, and they reach Solagori on the 6th. The
Nawab himself crosses the Dihing on the 7th [7th December], On the 9th,
he has an attack of fever and severe pain in the chest. Hakim Karima of
Oilan attends him. But though sick, he determined to follow the Rajah to
Namrup. But many of his officers and the men showed signs of dissatis-
faction, and it was reported to the Nawab that large numbers would march
away, if he ffjq uot retum, as the men would not pass another rainy season
in A'sam, much less in Namrup. The Nawab got so annoyed, that his illness
became worse ; but on the 14th [14th December], he broke up, and marched
one stage further on to Batam.* On account of his sickness he travelled by
palki. Batam belongs to A'sam, and the zamindar holds the title of Rajah.
It lies on the outskirt of the Namrup jungles.
The Rajah in the meantime renews his applications for peace, and asks
Dilir Khan to intercede on his behalf with the Nawab.
XVI.
Conclusion of Peace. Beturn of the Army to Bengal.
Illness forced the Nawab to listen to the proposals of peace. Bhor Mall
was again employed to confer with the Phukans, and the following conditions
were agreed upon —
1. The Rajahs of A'sam and Batam should each send one of their
daughters to the imperial harem.
2. Each should pay 20,000 tolahs of gold, and 120,000 tolahs of silver.
3. Fifteen elephants to be sent to the Emperor ; fifteen to the Nawab,
and five to Dilir Khan.
4. Within the next twelve months 3 lacs tolahs of silver and 90
elephants to be sent as tribute to Bengal, in three four-monthly instalments.
5. Twenty elephants to be furnished annually.
6. The sons of Budh Gosain, Karkas-ha, Bar Gosain, Prahatar, the
four principal Phukans of the Rajah, to remain as hostages with the Nawab,
till the fulfilment of the conditions in para. 4.
* Or Patam. I have not identified this place; in fact there are no maps
available. Vide p. 85, third note.
91
H. Blochmann — Koch Tiihur and A'sdm. [No. 1,
7. The following districts to be ceded to his Majesty the Emperor —
A. In the Uttarkol.
(a.) Sirkar Durang, bounded by Oawahatti on one side, and by the All
Burari,* which passes Fort Chamdhurah, on the other side.
K. In the Dale hinkol.
(a.) The district of Nakirani (<_s> |
(h.) The Naga Hills.
(c.) 1 Sol tal!
(«?.) Dumuriah
8. All inhabitants of Kamrup kept as prisoners by the Rajah in the
hills and in Namrup to be restored ; so also the family of Badli Phulian.
The districts of the Dak’hinkol that were ceded, have at no previous
time formed part of his Majesty’s empire. Nakirani [Deshrani] lies near
the Garo Hills. The Garos are a wild tribe excessively fond of dog’s flesh. J
If a dog sees a Garo, it will instinctively howl and rim away. Their hills
are also near Kalahari, which belongs to the empire.
Dumuriah extends as far as the Kulang Eiver, which flows at the foot of
Fort Kajli. Hence as the Ali Burari forms the boundary between the empire
and A'sam in the Uttarkol, so does the Kulang form the boundary in the
Dak’hinkol.
Durang is a country full of wild elephants and k’hedalis for catching
them. Once Jaidhaj captured no less than one hundred and twenty elephants.
In the territory of the Rajah of Dumuriah elephants were formerly found.
It borders on Kachhar, from which the elephants used to come into Du-
muriah ; but the Kachhar Rajah having put a stop to the migrations of
the elephants, no k’hedahs are now-a-days found in the Dumuriah.
The above conditions of peace were accepted, and the treaty was mutually
signed. After some delay caused by an attempt at cheating in the hostages,
the Rajah sent, on the 5th Jumada II., [4th January, 1963] his daughter, the
gold and silver, ten elephants, and the hostages to the Nawab, and promised to
send. thirty elephants more to Lak’hugar. The gold and silver was put into the
treasury, the hostages were given to Dilir Khan to take charge of, and the
* Called on the map Bhor-alli, or Bhoreli. It flows near Tezpur and the Kamakhya
Temple, Central A'aam.
f Vide p. 76, last note. It seems to be the same as Deshrani, because Deshrani,
Desh Dumuriah, and Desh Beltalah are mentioned together. They belong to Thanah
Gawahatti, and lie south of it. Vide also Kobinson’s Asam, p. 289,
By “ Naga Hills” the Mildr and Bengmah Naga hills appear to be meant.
$ Most of tho wild Asameso tribes eat dogs, The custom is to hang up the dog
and force large quantities of boiled rice down its throat. When it is swollen up, it
is suspended over a fire and slowly roastod. The rice is said to be ” delicious.”
1872.]
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A'sam, ,
95
Rajah’s daughter was provided a place in the Nawab’s harem. On the 9th
Jumada II., eleven elephants were brought in.
The order to return to Bengal was given on the 10th Jumada II., [9th
January, 1663], to the intense joy of all. The Nawab had still to travel in
palld ; he did not march over Ghargaon, hut went straight to Taramhani,
where the prisoners, whom the Rajah had detained in Namrup, and Badli
Phukan’s family arrived.
XVII.
Arrival at La’hhugar. Distress during the retreat. March over Baritalah
to Khizrpur. Death of the Nawab.
On the 26th Jumada II., [25th January, 1663] the Nawab left
Dewalgaon for Lak’hugar. His health daily improved. Mir Murtaza
brought all stores from Ghargaon, and twenty-five elephants arrived which the
Rajah had sent. Many people, males and females, followed the army, happy
to find thus a means of leaving A’sam.
The Nawab had resolved to go to Gawahatti, settle financial mat-
ters, and then to march against Koch Bihar. lie, therefore, embarked with
the hostages at Lak’hugar, sending the principal part of the army via
the Dak’hinkol to Baritalah where they should cross the Brahmaputra.
On the 1st Rajab [29th January], he left Lak’hugar, inspected on his road
portions of Dumuriah, now annexed, and passed in palld over the Kajli plain,
where never before an army had passed. On the first and the second days,
he travelled eight kos daily ; on the third, fourteen ; on the fourth, twelve.
He then passed the Kulang river and then Port Kajli. During these four
days, the men lived on water and the animals on grass. At Kajli, the Nawab
rested a few days. The mother and the son of Malcr Dhaj, Rajah of Durang,
who had lately died, waited on the Nawab. The Rajah of Dumuriah was also
expected. But his brother’s son only came, and, soon after, the Rajah’s
mother.
Here the Nawab had a relapse, which ended in asthma, and the hasty
way in which he proceeded from remedy to remedy, made him only
worse.
In the evening of 11th, [7th February, 1663] the same day on which
the mother of the Rajah of Dumuriah had come, tremendous lightning
and thunder frightened the army, and immediately afterwards, a strong
earthquake was felt which shook all, whether they were sitting or standing,
reclining or sleeping. The shocks continued for half an hour.
On the 13th [9th February], the Nawab left Kajli, and arrived at Pandu,
which lies opposite to Gawahatti. Muhammad Beg, Faujdar of Gawahatti
reported the capture of eighty-four Durang elephants in the k’hedahs.
The Nawab recommended to him the mother and the son of the late
96 H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and Asam. [No. 1,
Rajah of Durang, and the mother of the Rajah of Diimuriah, and dismissed
them to their homes. Badli Phukan was to have a Parganah in Bengal,
with a revenue of 3000 Rs. On the 14th, Dilir Khan arrived from Lak’hugar,
bringing eight more elephants with him.
Rashid Khan, who had formerly declined the office of Faujdar of
Karnriip, received from his Majesty a reprimand. He now accepted the
office, and was appointed to it by the Nawab. Muhammad Beg, the former
Faujdar of Gawahattl, who was a servant of the Nawab, was appointed
Tlianahdar of Kajli, under Rashid Khan.
The Nawab, though very ill, settled several financial matters of great
importance, and left Gawahatti on the 26tli Rajab [22nd February, 1663].
On the last of the month, he reached Baritalah, where the Koch Bihar
detachment joined him. Here the Nawab’s condition got much worse, the
fainting fits came on oftener, and Hakim Zahira Ardistani was sent for from
Hugli, and Mlrza Muhammad from Akbamagar.
Description of the diagnosis of each doctor. The men commonly
believed that the sickness was the result of witchcraft practised by the Rajah
of Asam. The doctors recommended the Nawab to go to Khizrpur. On
the 26th Sha'ban, he appoints ’Askar Khan to renew operations against
Koch Bihar.
The Nawab died on board the barge on Wednesday, the 2nd Ramazan,
1073 [30th March, 1663], half an hour before sunset, two kos above Khizrpur.*
The i Arikh of his death is 0r 1 occupant of paradise,’ A. H.
1073. Dilir Khan and Ihtisham Khan buried the body the next day at
Khizrpur, in a vault which the Nawab had given orders to build after leaving
for Asam. According to his last wish, his body was to be taken to Najaf,
and buried in holy ground. News of his death was at once sent to court
and to his son Muhammad Amin Khan.
* Neither Rennel’s Map of the ‘ Environs of Dacca’ in 1778 (Map xii, of the
Bengal Atlas), nor the Survey Maps help us to identify Khizrpur, and 1 addressed Dr.
James Wise, of Dhaka, who is so well known for his researches in the local history of
the District, regarding the geographical position of the place. Ho kindly sent mo
the following reply —
« Narainganj, eight miles S. E. of Dacca, is in a parganah called Khizrpur. It is
bounded by tho Dacca river, the Burha Ganga. This situation corresponds with that
of the historical Khizrpur, which was on the banks of the Ganges. A tomb, said to
be that of one of Shaistak KhSn’a daughters, is called by the Muhammadans of the
present day the ‘ Khizrpur Maqbarah.’ It is strange that the tomb of such a groat
man as Mir Jumlah should not exist.”
The Maasir ul Vma rd does not record whether the body was taken to Najaf
{ Mashhad, in Khurasan). It is said that many towns in Talinganah contain buil-
dings erected by tho Nawab, and in Haidarabad there is a tank, a villa, and a
palace, still bearing his name.
1872.]
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihdr and As&m.
97
Events after 1663.
With the death of the Nawab the Fathigah i 'Tbriyah ends. The news
of his death reached Aurangzib at Labor, and, according to Bernier, (vide
above p. 35) was a source of joy for the emperor. The ' Alomgirndmah
says that he was sorry, because Mir Jumlah had been an old servant.
Whether the “ ceded” districts of Central A'sam were ever taken
actual possession of by the Imperialists, is a matter of doubt. The
Asam Buranji, or Asam Chronicle, according to Robinson (loc. cit., p. 166),
gives a very different version, and says “ that Mir Jumlah’s army was
entirely defeated, and he was obliged, to give up the whole of zillah Kamrup
to the Asamese, which was from that time placed under the management of
a great Asamese officer, the Bar Phukan, and formed a government equal to
about a third part of the whole kingdom. Jaidhaj Singh died A. D. 1663.”
Prom the following extract from the ’ Alamglrnamah it would certainly
appear that Gawahatti was the actual frontier of the Mughul empire and
Asam, when Mir Jumlah returned to Bengal, and that the cession of
Durang as far as Tezpur was nominal ; but on the other side it is quite
clear that Mir Jumlah’s retreat was not an absolute defeat. The pay-
ments of the money are certainly nowhere recorded by Muhammadan
historians ; but a part of the elephants did come, and a daughter of the king
of Asam was subsequently married to an Imperial Prince.
Gawahatti then was the actual frontier at Mir Jumlah’s retreat, and
remained so for four years, till the beginning of 1078 A. H., or the very end
of A. D. 1667. The re-conquest by the Asamese is the last event recorded
in the ' Alamgirndmah (Bibl. Ind. Edit., p. 1068) as follows —
“ At tills time [llajab, 1078, or December, 1667], reports were received
by his Majesty from Bengal that the Asamese with a numerous army and a
large fleet had attacked Gawahatti, which is the frontier of Bengal. The
Thanahdar, Sayyid Firuz Khan, could not in time receive assistance. He
and most of his men bravely defended themselves, and sacrificed their lives on
the path of loyalty ('ubudiyat). His Majesty resolved to punish the Asamese,
and appointed Rajah Ram Singh to the command of an imperial corps, which
was to be strengthened by troops of the Bengal army. Ri^ah Ram Singh,
on the 21st Rajah 1078, A. H., [27th December, 1667] received as klial'at a
horse with a gilded saddle and a dagger with a belt adorned with pearls, and
was sent to A'sam. Na<;iri Khan,* Kisari Singh Bhurtialpt Rag’hunath
Singh of Mirthah, Bairam Deo Sisaudiah, and other Manjabdars, with 1500
Ahadis and 500 artillery, accompanied him.”
* The Madsvr i ’ AlarngM (Ed. Bibl. Indica, p. 65) has Nuqrat Khan.
t The Maasir i ’ AlamgM has Kirat Singh Bhurtiah, which is clearly the correct
reading.
13
N
98
H. Blochmann — Koch Bilidr and Asiim.
[No. 1,
For the subsequent events we have only the Maasir i ’ Alamgiri to refer
to, whose scanty notes are nevertheless of great value. I translate from
the edition of this work in the Bibliotheca Indica.
Page 73. “ On the first of Zi Hajjah, 1078 [2nd May, 1G68], Eahmat
Banu, the daughter of the king of Asam was married to Prince Muhammad
A’zam. Dowry, 180,000 Rupees.”
It is not said whether this is the same girl that was taken by Mir
Jumlah to Bengal. Her name implies that she had been converted to Islam.
It was only Akbar and Jahangir that did not convert their Hindu prin-
cesses.
Page 97. “ Rajah Rdm Singh, who was a commander of 4000, 4000
duaspah sihaspah troopers, was promoted to a command of 5000, and his son*
* This Kishn Singh is called grandson (naltrah) of Ram Singh on p. 172 of the
Marfsirr. It should he son. Ram Singh was the son of Jai Singh I, of Arnbar (Jaipur),
with whose assistance Aurangzib had como to the throno. He died at Burkanpur on tho
28th Muharram 1076, or 10th J uly, 1667. The ’A'lamgfrndinah (p. 1051) and the Madsir
i Alamtjin (p. t»2) state that he died a natural death, and that his son Ram Singh was
immediately made Rajah. Colonel Brooke ( Political History of Jcypore, p. 14) says, though
he does not mention his authority, that Jai Singh was killed by his son Kirat Singh,
whom Aurangzib had promised tho succession, and that the Emperor had engaged
his services, because he thought Jai Singh too powerful a subject. “Tho fooling of
the countiy, however, was too strong against the parricide, to allow such a succession
to be carried out, and Kirat Singh was obliged to content himself with Kamah, now
in the Bhurtpore territory, and which his descendants enjoy to this day ; but the par.
ricidal act of their ancestor has for ever excluded them from any chance of sncceeding
to the Jeypore throne.” Kirat Singh certainly was at Burk&npur, when Jai Singh died.
He had in nearly every war served under his father, as, for instance, in the Mew
disturbances, after which ho received Kamah Pahuid, and Koh-Mujahid, and was
appointed Faujdar of Mewat. Shahjahdn, two years before being disposed, had made
him a commander of 1000, and nftor the wars with Siwa, Aurangzib gave him a
command of 2500. After the death of his father, he was made a commander of 3000,
a promotion which docs not look like a reward for the great crime imputed to him.
Kirat continued to serve in the Dak’hiu, and died in the beginning of 1081 (1673, A. D.).
Jai Singh -was succeeded by his first-born son, Ram Singh. He had risen under
Shahjahan to tho rank of commander of 3000. In the battle of Samogar, he was with
Dard Shikoh, but joined soon aftorwards, like his father, the party of Aurungzib. He
served under Muftnmmad Sultan, in tho pursuit of Shnja’, and took a part in the capture
of Sulaiman Shikoh at Srinagar. Subsequently, he served under his father against
Siwa; and when the Bhonsla and his son Samba presented themselves at Court,
Aurangzib warned Ram Singh to have a sharp eye on them, and not to let them
escape. But they fled (beginning of 1077), and Ram Singh fell into temporary disgrace,
and lost his rank. The fact that Jai Singh died soon afterwards may be construed
mto a suspicion against Kirat Singh. But Ram Singh was immediately restored,
received the title of.Rajah, and a mamjab of 4000. In the same year (1078), he was
ordered to Gawahatti in Asam. Ram Singh remained in Asam till tho middle of 1086
(1675), his long stay being evidently a punishment. Ho died soon after. His son
, H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and Asam.
99
1872.]
Kishn Singh received a present of a sarpesh studded with jewels.” End of
1080 A. H., or beginning of A. D. 1G70.
Page 154. “On the 22nd Rabi’ II., 1087, [21th June, 1676] Rajah
Bam Singh returned from Asam, and paid his respects at court.”
Page 178. “ On the 29th Muharram, 1090, [1st March, 1679] Shahrukh,
a servant of Prince Muhammad A’zam brought a report to court which
contained the account of the conquest of Gawahatti by his Majesty’s troops.
The messenger received a reward of Rs. 1000 ; and a necklace of 91 pearls,
valued at 2 lacs of Rupees, and a tassel ( turrah ) studded with jewels, of a
value of 25,000 Rupees, were sent to the Prince as presents.”
Page 234. Rashid Khan reported that, according to orders, the Amirul-
Umara had been charged with 52 lacs of Rupees on account of expenses
incurred in Gawahatti. The officer referred to had written to say that the
whole expenditure amounted to 7 lacs of Rupees * * # Hence this sum
was ordered to he charged.”
Page 387. Prince Muhammad ’Azim [’Azim ushshan, son of Bahadur
Shah] was appointed pubahdSr of Bengal and Faujdar of Koch Bihar.” End
of 1108, A. H., or middle of 1697, A. D.
This closes my collection of notes on Koch Bihar and Asam from
Muhammadan historians of the 16th and 17th centuries. I have only
occasionally referred to Khdfi Khan (Ed. Bibl. Indiea, II, pp. 130 IF.).
He has used the ’Alamgirnamah, in his slovenly way, without the
slightest exactness even in his meagre geographical and chronological
details. To give an example. He makes the Koch Bihfir Rajah flee to an
old zamindar of the country, near whose castle there is a river, over which
two chains pass. The chains are fastened to pegs and stems of trees on the
opposite banks, and people use the chains as a bridge. Comparing this with
the account on p. 68, we see that Khali has a wonderful power of combina-
tion, whilst the castle is altogether fictitious. He gives Koch Bihar five
chaklahs or eighty-nine parganahs, and fixes the revenue at 10 lacs of Naraini
rupees. The kaseru root ( Cyperus tuberosus, Wild) is mentioned as the best
lemedy for wounds caused by poisoned arrows. He speaks of the breaking of
idols in Koch Bihar, and makes the Nawab build mosques iu Simlaligar and
Ghargaon, and remit one year’s taxes. The circulation of Kara ini rupees in
Asam was forbidden, because the Nawab corned money with Aurangzib’s
name on it. A great deal of silver and gold is found with the assistance of
expert treasure-finders, and ten or twelve golden keys and a map of Asam
are sent to court. He traces the epidemic to bad water ; “ for the rain
Kunwar Kishn Singh died when young, of a wound he had received. He had served
for some time in Kabul. Yido my essay, entitled ‘ A Chapter from Muhammadan
History,’ Calcutta Review, 1870.
100
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihar and A’sdm.
[No. 1,
falls on many poisonous trees, and when such water runs into rivers or tanks,
it renders them poisonous. Again, the wind blows the flowers of poisonous
trees into the rivers, and thus makes the water unwholesome. Thus between
Khandesh and Surat, four stages from the latter, there is a river called
Sapin, the water of which at the end of the rains is quite poisonous.”*
Robinson (Xsam, p. 156) has some notes on Baldeo, or Balit Narain, as
he calls him, and places his death in A. D. 1634. This is certainly too early
as his defeat by the Mughuls ( vide above p. 62) took place in 1637. He
does not mention Baldeo’s son, Chandr Narain, but a grandson of the same
name, who in 1671 was succeeded by Surja Narain. He then says that
about 1682 the territory of Surja Narain [Durang and Kamrup] “ were
invaded by Munjur Khan, a general of the emperor of Dihli, when he
himself was taken prisoner, and conveyed to the presence of the emperor.
Some time after, effecting his escape, ho returned to his own dominions ; but
from a sense of shame, is said to have refused resuming tho reins of govern-
ment.” His brother Indra Narain lost portions of his kingdom to the Ahom
kings, and only retained Durang.
I do not know who this “ Munjur Khan” can be. The spelling
suggests Manzur Khan a doubtful name, or Mamjur Ivkan
((iilAjj^uxj). The year 1682 refers to A. H. 1094 ; but I can find nothing
regarding this invasion in Muhammadan historians.
APPENDIX.
Col. J. C. Haughton, C. S. I., Koch Bihar, kindly sent me the follow-
ing extract from Biswessar’s History of A'sam, which may advantageously
be compared with the extracts from the Akbarnamah, on pp. 52, 53, 56.
“ Rajah Nara Narain, t having no male issue, determined to appoint his
nephew Rag’hudeb successor. When old, however, he had a son, and
Rag’hudeb became hopeless. The latter therefore, quitted one day the pa-
lace under tho pretext of going a hunting ; but the Rajah, in order to con-
sole him, allotted to him a portion of the raj.%
“ Nara Narain died after a reign of fifty -six years, and was succeeded by
his son Lachmi Narain.
* The text of Khfifi Khan’s history in the Bibl. Indica Edition is very untrust-
worthy as regards proper nouns. On p. 138, of vol. II., read Qazi Samui, for Qdzi
Timur; p. 142, Oawdha((l for Korthf ; p. 144, Stmldligarh for Bhimgar ; p. 161, Gagpur
for Kaohhp&r ; p. 163, Subhdm Singh, for Sagan Singh.
f The 1 Balgosain’ of the Akbarnamah. Rag’liudeb is tho ‘ Pat Kunwar.’
t This seems to have caused tho division of Koch Bihar and Koch Iliijo. Lachnu
was thus the first KSjah of Koch Bihar only.
1872.]
H. Blochmann — Koch Bihdr and A'sam.
101
“ Eag’hudeb laving obtained a portion of bis uncle's kingdom, founded
the town of Ghclabijaya in Kamrup, and erected a temple at Hajo in 1583.
He died in 1593, and was succeeded by Paricbbat Narain, who made war on
his uncle Laclimi Narain. Parichhat went to Delhi, and died at Patna on
his way home from A'grab in 1G0G.* Subsequently, the Muhammadan ruler
invaded the kingdom to realize the promised tribute. The Mantri succeed-
ed in obtaining the office of Qaniingo.
“ Ah this time the kingdom was divided into four sirkars. Baht Narain,
brother of Parichhat, got the Sirkar, east of Dikrai and west of the river
Manah. Parichhat’ s son, Bijat Narain, only got the land between the Manah
and Sankos. The descendants of Bijat Narain are known as the Rajahs of
Bijni.”
The following extract from the family history of the Rajahs of Bijni, I
also owe to Col. Haughton’s kindness.
“ Maharajah Biswa Singh had two sons. The elder, Nara Narain Blnip
leigned over that portion of the kingdom which lies between Karatuja and
Bihar. The younger, Shukladhaj Bliup ruled over the country from Biliar
o Dikrai. For his impetuosity at time of war, he was called Chilah Eai,
Hmg Kite.’ His son was Eag’hudeb Narain. The latter had three sons ;
one was king of Durang, another ruler over Beltalah, and the eldest, Pari-
o at Narain was Rajah of Bijni. Parichhat waged war with Laclimi Narain ;
but sorry for having attacked his nearest relation, he turned hermit. He
went also to Dilili with his Diwan, astonished the emperor by his extra-
ordinary talents, received a Jchal'at, and was sent back to his country
with a royal guard. But ho died at Rajmahall on his way home. The
Hiwan went back to Dilili, and was made Qanungo of Koch Bihar. Pari-
chhat left a son Chandr Narain, who enjoyed his father’s raj, but did nothing
remarkable.” [Vide pp, 58 to GO, and Robinson, p. 155.]
* This date is too early.
102 H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. [No. 1,
Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions, No. II. — Iiy H. Blochmatot,
M. A., Calcutta Madrasah.
Since the publication, in last year’s Journal, of several Arabic and Per-
sian Inscriptions forwarded to the Society during 1871, a few others have been
received from Messrs. Wilson, C. S., Badaon ; E. Yesey Westmacott, C. S.,
Dinajpur ; and Dr. J. Wise, Dhaka. As these inscriptions are of great inter-
est, I have placed them together, and added a few notes and extracts from
the letters which accompanied the rubbings.
They refer to
Dinajpur, (Gangarampur) .
Dhaka.
DhamrSi, N. of Dhaka.
Badaon,
and A’lapur, East of Badaon.
Gangara'mpu'r, Di'na jpu'r.
The following four inscriptions were received from Mr. Westmacott
C. S., Dinajpur. They are by no means new, having been mentioned by
Buchanan in his ‘ Historical Description of Dinajpur’ (p. 51), and partly by Mr.
Thomas in his * Chronicles of the Pathan Kings’ (p. 149) ; but they are here
for the first time given with the text and correct translations. Buchanan
says that the chief place in Division Gangarampur is Damdamah, the old
Dev Kct.* “ It received its present appellation (which signifies a place of
war) from its having been a military station during the early Muhammadan
government, as it probably was then on the frontier. * * * The chief officer,
under the title of Wazir, seems to have resided on the banks of a very noble
tank, which is named Dahal Dig’hi, and has evidently been formed by the Mu-
hammadans : its water being about 4000 feet from east to west, and 1000 from
north to south * * * On many different parts, especially towards the north
east comer, are heaps of bricks, probably the ruins of the houses that were oc-
cupied by the Muhammadan officers. On the centre of the north side is the
Dargah of a saint, named Mulla ’Atauddm, contiguous to which is a small
mosque. Both are very ruinous, but a canopy is still suspended over the
tomb, which is much frequented as a place of worship, and the faqir has an
endowment of 200 big’hahs (about 100 acres) of land.”
Buchanan then mentions five inscriptions belonging to the tomb and
the mosque.
* Mentioned several times in the Tdbaqat i Naqirt and in Dowson’s edition of Elliot’s
Historians, II, pp. 313, 314, tf.
103
1872.] H. Tiloelimann — Kot.es on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions.
First. — One over the gate of the mosque, “ by Wazir Shair Musaur of
“ Mozofurabad, commander of the troops of Firuzabad, in the reign of
“ Hoseyn Shah, Sultan of Hostina, son of Mozofur Shah, A. H. 718.” His
date and names are wrong ; vide p. 100, inscription III.
Secondly. — One under the former, stating that the Gumbuz [vault] of
the tomb had been erected “ by Sekandar Shah, son of Majahud Shah, son
°f Ay as Shah, A. H. 7G5.” These readings will he found corrected below ;
vide inscription II, p. 101.
Thirdly. — One in the wing of the mosque, mentioning “ Futeh Shah,
son of Mahmud Shah, A. H. 845.” I have not seen this inscription ; but
the year is wrong. Mr. Westmacott says that the wall on which the inscrip-
tion was, has fallen down.
F ourthly. — An inscription stating that “ a part of the mosque, called
Hamada [P] was built in the reign of Ky Kaos Shah, by order of Sakandar
8ani, or the 2nd, A. H. 872.” This is the famous Kai Kaus inscription,
No. I, below.
Fifthly. — An inscription “ over the door of an apartment used as a kit-
chen by faqirs, to the right of the mosque, on which Makhdum Mulla and
uzaffar Shah are mentioned. The date is no longer visible.” Vide p. 107>
No. IV.
I shall now give the text and translation of the inscriptions from the
rubbings which Mr. Westmacott forwarded to the Society.
I. The Gangaranipur Kai Kaus Inscription.
* . .. - - . * S5
Vr5 '-y-* ^..cA j $.{.1.0 $.i! A A &U|
• , „ ^ ^ | Jji
w* ■ * ^
This mosque was built during the reign of the king of kings, Rukn uddunya
w a d d i n, the shadow of God on earth, Kai Kaus Shah, son of Mahmud, son of the
ultan, the right hand of the Khalifah of God, the helper of the Commander of the Faith-
ful—n
-may God perpetuate his rule and kingdom ! — at the order of the Lord of the age, by
^hihabulhaqq wad din, a second Alexander, the Ulugh i A’zam Humayun,
afar Khan Bahrain I' t gin — may God perpetuate his rule and kingdom and
104 H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. [No. 1,
may God prolong his life!— under the supervision (batwuliyat)* of Salah Jiwand of
Multan. On tho 1st Muhnrram, 697, A. H. [19th October, 1297].
As mentioned above, this inscription is quoted by Mr. Thomas in his
‘ Chronicles of the Pathan Kings,’ p. 140, where a “ rough” translation by
Col. Nassau Lees is givon. The ‘ translation’ leaves out the name of the
builder, and wrongly puts his titles in apposition to the words Khusrawe
mm An. The absence of a facsimile has led Mr. Thomas to state that Kai
Kaus confessed allegiance to ’Alauddin of Dihli, who is the Sikandar ussani
par excellence ; but the grammatical construction of the sentence, and the
idiom, shew that the words ‘ Sikandar ussani, Ulugh i A’zam 1 lumayun, and
Zafar Khan’, are merely titles of Bahrain Ttgin. He must have been a
Malik of high rank, as the titles are high ; but my Tribeni inscriptions
(Journal, 1870) and Mr. Broadley’s Bihar inscriptions, (about to be publish-
ed in this volume) give Maliks not only similar titles, but also the phrase
‘ May God perpetuate his rule and kingdom,’ and even Julus names, if I may
say so. ‘ Shihab ul Haq waddin’, therefore, is merely tho julus name of Malik
Zafar Khan, and shews, moreover, that the ‘ Sikandar ussani,’ cannot be
’Alauddin, whose full julus name, with the Tcunyah , was ’Alauddin Abulmu-
zaffar Muhammad Shah.
Observe also that when names and titles are given, the titles are gen-
erally put first and then the name, and the idiom requires that the word
htimdyun he taken to TJluyh i A’zam, not to Zafar Khan.
It gin is Turkish and means ‘ proprietor.’ It also occurs as name ; e. g.,
in the list of the grandees of Balban’s Court ( Tarikh Barani, p. 24, last
line).
The Arabic style of the inscription is bad, as in all Bengal inscriptions.
The words are gpgptly doubtful, the rubbing merely giving
I am not satisfied with my reading of the name of the
supervisor ; ‘ Jiwand’ is unusual ; but ‘ Jiwan,’ without the final d, is very
common.
II. The Inscription on the Dargah of the Mauldna ’ Ata .
Buchanan calls him ’Atauddin, which is perhaps a mistake for ’Ataullah.
The inscription is half poetry, half verse.
L'tj k slA. jUb t.S j, j
Ijlci — 5. 1 — ^ joAj # jib-s* U yi i s IjV^i
» -j * /
'' , c A'' ' f p', l ** ..iA » j
* The same phrase occurs in the Arabic inscription on the wall of a Jain Temple
near Ajmir, of A. H. 666; vide Journal for 1848, p. 653.
1872.] H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. 105
as/ j ju. i Q SLajj j) i “ -j.] tS fSjj A>.1£
■gfc I ^ gO
AjJjSI i . -la) <Lojj UjjJI *U.w U_>j
ui UJ kP ^ .
^ jl <Ai 1 ^ ci <*.ii| *Uac Ua.c USy« ^Jdll ^ gj&S] j ^srl^l j»*
^ »
^tuva^S) } JtW) Li^cb uJ^yi J «X4*J) t •**»[<£ (StC) J-Oi'l U
tJJ] J.U jflacSl ^UJI JjUI ^UaUl ^UxJl ^ _, jlUJ)
(jUaLJI sLA^jIjJI j yl&jjjXw iAfels*^lyj| ^*.=^11 £Ai*J (^ay*a.i"6^|
.M >J
* <siL« aUI oJa-
M # y
tSXXH/JJ
*
" U) sdJ X tJ
<xii! &. — A.1JI
\iJ JJ
$ JJO <_)..&£ # 2lAa*X*«j ^.JAw _} gi
[Poetry, motre short flixsqj], In this dome, which was founded by ’Ata — may
the building be a house for both worlds ! — angels sing on account of its erection till
the day of judgment, “ Banaind fimqaleam sab’ an shidddd.”*
[Prose.] Through the grace of the maker of the wonderful seven palaces, “ who
has created the seven heavens one above the other”— his names be pTaised ! — tho
building of this lofty dome was completed. It is a copy of the dais of tho vault of
glory. And “ we have adorned the heaven of tho world with lights” in the blessed
shrine of the pole of saints, the unequalled among enquirers, the lamp of truth, and
law, and faith, Maulana ’At a — may God Almighty bestow His grace upon him in
both worlds ! [The building was completed] by order of the Lord of the age and the
period, the causer of justice and liberality, tho guardian of countries, the pastor of
the people, the just, wise, and great king, the shadow of God on earth, distin-
guished by the grace of the Merciful, Abul Mujahid Sikandar Shah, son of
■Ilyas Shah, the king, may God perpetuate his kingdom !
[Poetry, metre Khofi'f}. The king of the world, Sikandar Shah, for whom people
string pearls in prayer, and chant, ‘ May God illuminate his worth,’ and say, ‘ May God
Perpetuate his kingdom.’
Dated, A. H. 765 [A. D., 1363], Done by the slave of tho throne, Ghias, the
golden-handed.
The inscription measures about 5 feet by 3^ foot. The characters are
beautifully drawn. Ghias, the ‘ golden-handed’ ( zarrindast ) was evidently the
Court Katib of Sikandar Shah ; his title reminds us of the zarrtn-qulams and
Mishkin qalams of later times. Even in point of style, the inscription is one
* A metrical passage from the Qoran, LXXVTII, 12, “ We have built over you
seven (heavens), firm ones.”
14
o
106 H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. [No. 1,
of the best among Bengal inscriptions of the 8th century of the Hijrah, that
I have seen. The text spells baMshah, instead of pddislid h ; if this he not
accidental, we would have here a proof shewing that the Indian pronuncia-
tion of this word is of old standing.
III. PuJcn Khan's Mosque.
uS • / .
^sl»r«J) J'—J xjUJ) J )J,A
** /
* “ r
l-X)cVi} c ■■ A y jy {f1*1** *
^ • f • ^
* jlA-oJI • X I, . ^ I yjthJLu dJ) j
X- X / / **
•i/6 «|'j \) jl JjL' «jlj )j ^jjiS'CjSK lSj.& rikc
11 j jmkC ^.J. <. j itXjM e tl -f I jXn.’C ^x.jj i s j
This mosque and tlie minaret were built by the Khan i ’A z i m EuknKhan,
[son of] ’A laud din of Sarhat, cup-bearer out of the palace, Yazlr of the town
known asZafarab&d, Commander-in-chief, High Kotwiil of the town known as
Ffruzabad, Mun^if of the Diwan of books in the town mentioned, during the reign
of ’A 14 ud dunya waddin Abul Muzaffar Husain Sh4h, the king, a
descendant of the prophet, in front of the door of the Shaikh of Shaikhs, Shaikh
’A t a. Ho who keeps up and ronows this pious grant, will be renewed by God, and
will find favor with the Shaikh. A. H., 918 [A. D., 1512].
Rukn Khan united many offices in his person ; hut the titles are not quite
clear. I am not quite sure whether I have correctly translated the words
Shardbdar i ghcdr-mahalli. One of General Cunningham’s Husain Shahi
inscriptions from Sunnargaon gives a similar title, ‘jdmaddr i gliair-mahallV ,
* keeper of the wardrobe outside the palace.’
Rukn is called * Sarhati,’ perhaps from Sarhat in Birhhum. In my paper
on the Tribeni Inscriptions (Journal, 1870, p. 284), tho same man
evidently is mentioned ; hut he is there called “ Rukn Khan, son of ’Alauddin
of Sirhat,” and we have no doubt to put here an Izafat after lyhk which is
used in Persian, when is omitted. We are also enabled to fix the date of the
Tribeni inscription, which (Joe. cit., p. 285) I referred, as I now see errone-
ously, to the end of the 7th century of the Hijrah.
Firuziibad appears to be the same as Panduah, the ‘ Purroa’ of our maps,
near Maid ah. I am more doubtful about Zafarabad, unless it refers to the
same as is mentioned by Badaoni, I, p. 246.
1872.] H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. 107
IV. Muzqffar Shah's Inscription.
) jr<A.ol) ^ *j,S>
>jj UJ f a*
slyL* Xhsrl Jaa. _J (s/c) Ua- US^.o
(P *» •** <JJ
* * # L ^3 &A.v.laiAu ^ &£L<o AiflcjX^. j
This mosqne was built in the time {fi ’alid, ?) of the renowned saint, Maul ana
-A t a — may God give him affluence and may He make paradise his dwelling place ! —
during the reign (jl ’ alid ) of Shamsuddnnya waddfn Abul Mu ’in Muzaf-
far Shah, the king, may God perpetuate his rnlo and kingdom! In the year
(not legible).*
The first 'alid is unintelligible to me, as ’Ata lived before Sikandar
Shah. The inscription, though the year is unclear, is of some value, as it
gives the full name of Muzaffar Shah.
Dha'ka'.
The following inscriptions were received from Dr. James Wise, of Dhaka,
together with copious notes.
The Inscription on Khwdjah Jahdn's Mosque.
Dr. Wise says —
“ The mosque from which this inscription is taken is a very insignificant
building in a Mahallah of Dhaka, called * Churlliattah.’ The building looks
°ld, and Curious to say, the three doors of entrance are not arched, but
square. They are little over five feet in height ; hence it is probable that
the ground outside has been raised. Its history is unknown. The only
name by which it is known, is the 1 Masjid of Bhola Klum,’ a former Khadim.
The slab has evidently been removed from some older mosque and city to
Dhaka. It is a curious thing that General Cunningham and I found no
inscription at Sunuargaon earlier than A. H. 888.”
I have not been able to decipher the whole inscription, a few wox-ds be-
fore the date being illegible.
) levs*.) ,mi i^c si j
jj] jJ) j j«C| ,j
f ^ OJ ‘
i > „ -.V*A J I JilixA*
gj I Ul
vP * * j d’UJI pjJ J^ll JJI * * * * ^*^1 o^SI xL*.
* Tlie date was already at Buchanan’s time illegible. It looks as if it was ‘Eajab,
902.’
108 II. Bloclimann — Notes on Arabic and 'Persian Inscriptions. [No. 1,
I) all j txL &1J| ^U>
God says, • Surely the mosques belong to God. Worship no one elso besides God
[Qoran, LXXII, 18],
This entrance was firmly erected* during the days of the reign of the Khalifah of
God, Naijiruddunya waddin Abnl MuzaffarMahmddShah, the king,
by the Khan whose title is KhwajahJaha n — may the Merciful proteot him from all
misfortunes on earth, * * * to the day of resurrection ! Dated, 20th Sha’ban, 863, [13th
June, 1459, A. D.] of the era of the Prophet,— may God bless him and all his family !
This inscription is, I believe, the first of Mahmud Shah that has been
published. It is, therefore, of particular value. The year 803 is remark-
able, and it looks as if during the long reign of Nafir Shah, or Husain Shah I.,
as he ought to be called, Mahmud Shah had reigned as opposition king.
Mahmud’s reign must have been of precarious tenure, as he was opposed by
his son Barbak Shah, whom my Tribend inscriptions mention as reigning
king in 860.
Dr. Wise’s inscription give Mahmud’s full name NAgiruddm Abut Mw-
zaffar Mahmud Shah. This may explain the fact that Bengal Histories call
Barbak Shah ‘ the son of Na^ir Shah’ ; for confusions of names and julus
names are common in Bengal History ; vide Journal, 1870, p. 296.
It may be that the Khan Khwajah Jahan mentioned in this inscription,
is the same as the Klnin Jahan, whose tomb is at Bagerh.lt. f A description
of his tomb was given by Balm Gaur Das Baisak, in the Journal of this
Society, for 1807, pp. 130, 131. On p. 135, loc. cit., the Babu gives the
inscriptions J attached to the tomb, from which it appears that Khan Jahan
died in the end of Zil Hajjali, 863 [end of October, 1459, A. D.] — the same
year, which is mentioned in the above inscription. The Bagherhat inscrip-
tions mention, unfortunately, no king.
* The writor uses as a transitive verb, for which construction there seems
to be no authority.
t Babu Gaur Das Baisak derives the name of Bagerhat from the Persian
^b, and explains Bdjher~hd( by * garden fair.’ I cannot say whether this is correct ;
Muhammadans pronounce Bdqvr-hdt, from some Muhammadan of the name
of Bdqyr.
$ The Arabic inscription (A.) given by the Babu contains several misprints.
His inscription E. is a curious specimen in point of metre, as it is eight times
although the Bajaz i musamman i salim ( vide my Prosody of the Persian, p. 34) is
not used in Persian.
1872.] H. Bloehmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. 109
Dha'inra'i, North of Dha'ka'.
Two Inscriptions of the reigns of Jalaluddin Path Shah and Ilusain Shah.
■ Dr. Wise says —
“ Dhamrai is situated about twenty miles north of Dhaka, at the junc-
tion of Kaklajani and Bunsi rivers. It was one of the places where the Af-
ghans were settled after the defeats in Orisa and Lower Bengal, towards the
end of Akbar’s reign. There were two other places still further north on the
Bunsi, where they were granted free lands. One, Ganakp-ArS, stands on the
left hank of the river. There are no descendants of the Pat’hans there now,
nor are there old Masjids or ruins. The third settlement was Ghosi in
pergunnah ’Atiah, zil’ah Maimansingh. It is about ten miles due north of
Dhamrai.
“ Dhamrai is a scattered village, each portion being placed on a mound,
generally of red laterite. One of its Mahallahs is still called ‘ Pat’hantalah,’
and a few of the residents still claim to he of Afghan blood ; hut the pecu-
liar physiognomy of that race is not to he found now-a-days. There are no
°ld Masjids in Dhamrai. One did exist till lately ; hut it became ruinous,
and the proprietors have dug up the foundations and sold the bricks. The
only buildings of interest are the tombs of five brothers, all pirs, or saints.
The most striking one is that of Mir Sayyid ’Ali in Pat’hantalah. It is
eight feet high, and is surrounded by a high wall. On the west side of the
tomb is an inscription in fine preservation, which hears the name of Sultan
Husain Shah (vide below). The tombs of the other Pirs are of no interest.
The other inscription was found by me in a private house in Pat’hantalah.
It belongs to Path Shah’s reign. Both inscriptions are evidently plundered
from Sunn&rgaon or some other city. There is no inscription in Mu’az-
zampur.”
I.
r^i j MJU Mil Mi) JIS
„ tA» yj
W-f *1 All) Ml ks"'* 3 sd c all) Jtf
Ci^^l 4 MIL iC/jJ] 0,Upl 3 A(.*J| ^IkLw &W|
^jJ) 3 Dial) (J3U. ^jUaLMI ^ ^i*!***!)
J Mllal* J Mix 0 Mil alA ^jUaLJI j yjUalv-
w
2 ^ XgJLuaJ) ^ J
i| y j^lUJ Ml | itiL.1 i £l*Jl C-lU jjJI
.4
I) UL.jl*j 3 3 sAm J_jS)
110 H. Blochmann — JVotes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. [No. 1,
God Almighty says, 1 Surely he who believes in God and a future life, will build
mosques for God’ [Qorfrn, IX, 18]. The prophet — may God’s blessing rest on him !
— says, 1 He who builds a mosque for God, will have a house built for him by God in
Paradiso.’
This mosque was built in the fimo of the king of the ago and tho period, who is
aided by the aid of the Meroiful, the helper of Islam and the Muslims, the king, son
of the king, .T al al u d duny a waddin Abul Muzaffar Fath Shah, the
king, son of Mahmud Shah, tho king, — May God perpetuate his rule and kingdom, and
elevate his power and dignity 1
The builder of this mosque which is blessed to Islam and the Muslims, is Zahir-
ulmillat waddin, Malikul Mu Ik Ale bund Shor, the admiral — Ma.y God Al-
mighty give him a dwelling in Paradise 1 Dated 10th Jnmada I., 887 [27th June
1482, A D.]
II.
St* ** t JU »>
aJ aJJI aU JL J Axle aU| ^1-e ^aa'I JUi
ijj ^ UJ ' . . , UJ f
^ ,<*JI |»kx.Jl j-thsr I Iiilb Assr'l t (.lx* Ixxj
ji' . # OJ JJ wM . UJ
w*J
I) aAmu»J } aXm Aitkin, _j A <l-v All) jdk.
The Prophet — may God’s blessing rest on him 1 — says, ‘ He who builds a mosque
for God, will have a house like it built for him by God in Paradise.’ This Jami’ Masjid
was built by the great and respected king ’A lair ddunya waddin Abul Muza f-
far Husain Shah, the king, son of Sayyid Ashraf, a descendant of Husain, — may
God perpetuate his rule and his kingdom 1 Dated, A. H. 922 [A. D , 1516].
Bada'on.
The first inscription forwarded by Mr. Wilson belongs to the tomb of
tbe Emperor ’Aliuddln or ’A'lam Shah, who, soon after A. II. 851, ceded
the empire to Buhhil Lodi, and withdrew to Badaon, where ho lived in retire-
ment, and died in A. H. 883. The stone measures about 5 feet by 21 feet, and
is the most extraordinary inscription that has come under my notice. The let-
ters are nearly all without diacritical marks, and are so unusual, that the whole
looks like a puzzle ( vide PI. I.) With the assistance of several Maulawis of
Calcutta and Badaon, I have deciphered the greater portion of it, and can
thus give the general purport of the inscription, leaving the complete and
grammatical restoration of the text to others.
I.
First line ^Ikl J| i.^.j.(.x/e -Ix-c (?)
W s
UaJLc ^jjJ) Uij,Jhli£
1872.] H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. Ill
Second line UaKj ujISs dlkLJ| SU tUs^yiAJl f^Al ^kCl! j *
• f
L &.k:2 I j
Third line \ 4.JI 3 \J-y^> ^(Lu»,» * # # i.Ay £.xS
SJJ
( S ) AxlUj] ^ ^XU$ jyilSs* £sbj/G ( ^ )
3 v__?JL< 3
77 tU jj
-hourth line ^,-Lq ufy*l ^tjljT
(pi / , I ^ v*) $
• 1 cJ,U sJ {.xx* \2j\ Ua.| ^.o ^JL> j dulc aU|
iri^ ^^.la^A/O ^CysQ 'kSj$tS/< ^ L ** . 1 >
Fifth line yj j-xfj J>\ jfAAj ^ Jyf^ I ^UxL*
’ y~*~* ( ^ ) Xm—B-fj * L ^ ( S ) i s i ix j &.xjfxj
jj.A.L« aJEJ! jAc j! aio
^ line J’(q-) lM ( S ) ^4 ( ? ) ^
,,« * . « • **■* **•
(j! ^lc &.<J] UiU &%*** U j^*j *Jju ^KjJ &U)
* l*i*£ £i**w
SzV7<? ^jilklw l£^<«1U l-2-U'«>!y£i'<’ £-iyo ^yiw)
The purport evidently is, that certain waste lands of Mauza’ Pindoll, in
Tappah Jhonali (or Jhoniah), perganah Salbahan, were cultivated. A Hadis
of the prophet is then mentioned, according to which he who reclaims lands
becomes the owner of them. These lands appear to have been set aside for
the maintenance of the tombs of Sultan 'Alauddin ’Alam Shah, son of Sul-
tan Muhammad Shah, and his wife. Such as resume waqf lands are threa-
tened with divine punishment, according to a passage in the Qoran [II, 177],
At the side of the inscription are the words, ‘ Malik Salamat Sultani,
Mutawalli of the above place.’
Mr. Wilson says in a letter. — “ There is a village called ‘ Pindol,’ and
another called ‘ Nagar Jhonah” in perganah Kot Salbahan of this district
L ‘button] ; but there is no sub-division known as ‘ Tappah Jhonah.’
There is nothing particular about the tomb of ’Alauddin. It is a large
square, massive, structure of brick, covered with a vaulted roof, and with the
1 Milams of some minarets on the top. In the inside there are two graves
112 H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. [No. 1,
side by side, also a smaller one in the corner, but with no inscription of any
kind on them. The tomb is in a very dilapidated condition, and the same
may be said of the remains of other smaller buildings near it. Close to the
tomb is an old masonry well, which is in working order, and is used for irri-
gating the adjacent lands.”
The tomb, according to Maulavi Muhammad Karim, Deputy Collector
of the district, lies in Miran Sara, a Mahallali of Badaon. The emperor is
said to have founded A’laptir (j_>J ),* which lies seven /cos East of Badaon.
He had three sons, Ahsan, ’Abbas, Haidar. ’Abbas had no issue. Alisan
founded Sayyidpurah, outside Port Badaon, to the south. The place does
no longer exist, nor are there any descendants of his. Sayy id Haidar founded
Sarai Miran. His descendants exist to the present day, but they are all
poor agriculturists.
II.
Mr. Wilson’s second inscription is taken from the gateway of the Jami’
Masjid at Badaon. His reading is as follows : —
j IjJjJ!
^ 53 jj
^ aIJ I !
]1 Aphj j SXmj
Enter it in peace ! The great Sultan, the owner of the necks of nations, Shams-
ud dunya waddin, the helper of Islam and the Moslems, themostjust of rulers
and kings, Abul Muzaffar Tlitmish, [Altamsh] the king, who assists the
Commander of the Faithful,— may God perpetuate his kingdom ! In the blessed month
of Ramazan, 628 [November, 1230, A. D.]
A’la'pu'r.
From the Masjid in A ’la pur, east of Badaon —
III.
w_iuaxxj) t gj
UJ
1! \
Qiq, son of (?), Dadbak [highest judicial officer] in the district of Badaon. In
the middle of Rabi’ I„ 707, [September, 1307, A. D.]
The inscription seems to be incomplete.
* So spelt by the Deputy Collector, notj^jlls ’Alapur.
1872.] H. Blochmann — Notes on Arabic and Persian Inscriptions. 113
IV.
From inside a mosque at A’lapur —
\JJ w >JJ *** I ww ^
jbib y\ * *U\
I) - -‘Mf j^xi l^jt*"b"J) J_5" j c_ai|
In the name of God, the merciful and the clement ! This mosque was built during
the reign of Abu Zafar Muhxuddin Muhammad Aurangzib Bahadur,
’A'lamgir Padishah, when Dindar Khan Kliweshagi was Jagirdar. A H. 1071,
[A. D„ 1660.].
This Dindar Khan* belongs to a well known Afghan family, called the
Khweshagis, or ‘ relatives,’ who settled at Qasur ( )y~>, or )}-^*) in the Bari
Duab. He is twice mentioned in the Maasir i 'A'lamgm (pp. 213, 340).
The Maasir ul TTrnara gives interesting biographical details of Nazar Baha-
dur Kliweshagi and Husain Khan Kliweshagi.
In the Proceedings for March of this year, I gave two other inscriptions
received from Mr. Wilson. Maulavi Muhammad Karim suggests two altera-
tions in the first inscription (Joe. cit., p. 48). For the unusual J'-iaU-, he
reads J^K^, a 1 well-tank,’ which compound appears to me to he as curious
as my old reading. The date he reads 898, instead of 798. The rubbing, it
would appear, gives hi rad, instead of haft ad, which I chose, and the
Maulavi says that in Persian stands for has head, not for 0.-011*, In
giving the text of the inscription, I mentioned that it was, in point of grammar
and sense, the worst that I had seen ; and if the writer did use higad, he used a
form which no Persian knows, nor any dictionary records. Besides, there
was no occasion for an artificial Head, as hashgad suits the metre as well.
But the Maulavi gives a better reason for adopting 898, when he
maintains that the second verse is an allusion to Sikandar Lodi, in whose
reign a Khan Jahan [Lodi] lived. This Khan Jahan is mentioned in Badaoni
and Firishtah. For the three asterisks in the first line, he reads ft line
AhA ‘ Jagirdar of the District of Badaon,’ which I believe to be correct,
although the form muqati’ should, according to usage, he muqti’ . However
the author of the inscription knew as little of grammar as of poetry.
* He is not to be confounded with the Dindar Khan i Bukhari, who served under
Jahangir and Shahjahan. He was Faujdar of the Miyan Duab, and died in A. H.
1045. Maasir ul Umard.
In the julus name of Aurangzib we find, in MSS. and inscriptions, both Abul
Muzaffar and Abu zafar. .
lo
1*
JOURNAL
OF THE
ASIATIC SOCIETY.
— • —
Part I. -HISTORY, LITERATURE, Sec.
No. II.— 1872.
The Legend of Bdghesar, a deified spirit held in great reverence hg the
Kusrii, Surl, Markam, Netia , and Sarsun clans of the Oond Tribe. —
By Capt. W. L. Sam mams, Assistant Commissioner, Manbhum.
Once upon a time, in a family of the Gond tribe, there were five brothers,
named respectively Kusrii, Siiri, Markam, Netia, and Sarsun.
On the first occasion on which Kiisru’s wife was pregnant, she brought
forth a male child ; but on the second occasion she gave birth to a tiger’s
whelp. This young cub was treated by its parents with as much affection
and regard as their first-born ; and the superior nursing it received, had such
a powerful effect on its growth and constitution, that in a few months it grew
up to be the finest child of its age and kind that ever was known. From
childhood he was the constant companion of Kusrii, never forsaking his
side for a moment ; and so great was the filial attachment he bore towards
his unnatural parent, that, to this day it is said in praise of him, he was
never known to have injured Kusrii in any way. To the Gond mind no
doubt this was a most remarkable trait of character ; for what is the ex-
perience of their lives from day to day, but that of the strong lording
it over the weak.
Kusrii, whose occupation was husbandly, had taken to tilling jungle
lands near his village, and during such time as there were crops in the
ground, he used to spend the greater portion of it in watching them. But
at one time it so happened that for some days past he had been less vigilant
than usual, and the nilgai and sambar, making the best of the opportunity,
well-nigh ruined the crop and Kt'isrd’s prospects. However, it was better to
save what remained than lose all, thought Kusrii philosophically ; so he
116
[No. 2,
W. L. Samuells — Gond Legend of Bdghesar.
hutted himself' close by the field, and night and day watched without ceas-
ing. Weary days and nights were those for Kusru, and little wonder was
it that— t- s , '
* One beautiful night
When the stars shone bright’
Kusru’s head went nid-nid-nodding, and his eyes, s^re and weary from
watching, dropped tho curtains and went to sleep. But whilst he slept, the
young cub watching, saw a trespasser approach. So placing his paw gently
on K (isrus shoulder, he roused, him from sleep, and by signs and gestures
drew his attention to a noble looking sambar, who was making himself «at
home amongst "the young and tender urid plants.
Kfisru, however, instead of being quickened to . action by the sight, fell
into a desponding state ; and tearing his liah and bemoaning his ill-fortune,
sunk to the ground and cried aloud, ‘ Oh, that mine enemy might be swal-
lowed up !’ The young cub, moved by this despairing and touching appeal,
instantly crouched and sprang upon the deer, which it killed and tore to pieces ;
making emphatically no bones about the matter. And so from day to day,
till the crop was gathered, the young cub watched and slew, and thus saved
Kusru’s field from further injury.
For this great act of deliverance, Kiisrfi began to love the young cub as
he never before had loved him, with a love in fact that was little short of
idolatry. But Ivusru had at length to experience the bitter truism that
‘ all flesh is but as dust for, alas, a day came—1 the long, long, weary day’
of Kusru’s existence — when the young tiger departed this life and gave up
the ghost. In other words he died and became a bhut !
Kusru was inconsolable, and his wife by no means improved matters
by presenting him at such a time with an addition to the family in the shape
of a daughter. If she had only kept up the tiger progeny, she might possi-
bly have helped thereby to fill up that aching void which was gnawing at
Kusru’s gizzard. He ate not — he slept not ; and how life was sustained
during the following space of ten or twelve years, we are not informed.
Tradition, not to be burdened with such trifles, hurries us on to the period
when Kiisrii’s daughter had matured into a plump and buxom lass, and veiled
and decked as a bride in turmeric-stained garments, looking as fine as a carrot
fresh-scraped, we find her seated with a bridegroom at her side under a leafy
marriage-bower, which has been erected for the occasion within her father’s
court-yard. Kinsmen and acquaintances from far and near have come in
holiday attire to offer their congratulations and enjoy the fun, and are to be
seen crowding round the manva, or bower, with joyful faces and sparkling eyes.
Even Kusru, forgetful of his old sorrows, is determined to make merry
yith the rest, and is to be seen urging the drummers and pipers to increased
117
1872.] W. L. Samuells — Qond Legend of Baghesar.
exertion, as if in all conscience they were not making enough din and 'noise
already. But the time and occasion perhaps require it.
The ceremony is at a close, and the nuptial knot has been tied. , Three
hours have passed in tedious rites and ceremonies. The happy couple with
the hride’s-maids and -best man have all been kissed and marked with the
sacred symbols times out of number, first by one relation and then by an-
other. The bride and bridegroom with ;their garments knotted together
have, with mincing Steps, slowly and wearily crept seven times round the
ihcmnra, or branch, which foyms the central support to the bower. The rice
given in dowry has be§in measured out to the samp, mystical number of seven
times. Everything, in short, has been done that _ ought to have been done,
and the wedded couple are now about to retire within the house, whilst the
spectators withdraw to the green outside to dance, sing, and make merry.
But the attention of every one present is suddenly arrested by fiendish
yells and roars. i •
“ What is it ? Who is it ?” is the anxious enquiry of every one as the
words pass from mouth to mouth with wind-like rapidity. With quivering
accents and bated breath the answer comes speedily back, that one of the
company has become (demoniacally) possessed with a demon. A thrill of
mingled terroy and dismay ran through the 'whole party at the sudden news
of so untoward an event, for
“ When the sun sets, who doth ‘hot look for night P”
1 i »f %r
The most civilized community on earth could'not fail, on a similarly joyful
occasion of then’ own, to be overcome with, at least,, a sense of gloom, if one
of their number on the spot went suddenly mad or hysterical. But amongst
a people naturally superstitious, aud that to a degree almost incredible, the
circumstance before alluded to had a wider and deeper significance than any-
thing we can possibly imagine.
Falling into the midst of the company, the individual possessed is dash-
mg his body about on the ground ; up and down ; right and left ; driving
the lookers on from post to pillar, and from pillar to post ; and, by his wild
and fiendish actions, striking consternation and terror into the hearts of
all ; for a visitation of this sort had never on such an occasion been known
before. , ,
Kusru’s spirits went down with a run, and looking as grave as a judge,
he implored the Baiga, or village priest- and necromancer, to divine whose
spirit this was, and for what purpose it had pome.
Forthwith the Baiga, with an -air of authority worthy of an exorcist, in-
terrogates the spirit, saying —
118
W. L. Samuells — Gond Legend of Bnghesar.
[No. 2,
Speak ! speak ! thou fearful guest !
Whose spirit haunts thy breast ?*
Why thus as one possessed
Come ye to daunt me ?
Amidst a breathless silence, the demoniac giving the wretched Kusru a
piercing look of recognition, informs him and his terror-stricken guests in
a voice peculiar to gnomes, bogies, goblins, and such like fry,
I was a tiger bold !
My deeds, though manifold,
No Gond hath yet extolled,
For this I sought thee.
Kusru is thunder-struck, and the company in dumb show betoken
bewilderment, whilst the restless and impatient spirit roars, ‘ Worship me
with offerings and sacrifices.’
A fowl was immediately fetched for the purpose of being offered up
in the orthodox fashion ; but the spirit evinced such unmistakeable signs of
dissatisfaction at the very sight of this familiar bird, that a kid was instantly
brought to be sacrificed in its stead. As soon as the demoniac espied that
animal, he sprang at it after the fashion of a tiger, and, seizing it between
his teeth, gnawed and tore it to death.
Krisru’s joy at this sight was unspeakable ; for there was a something
in the killing way in which the demoniac went to work that revealed to him
beyond a doubt, that the spirit present was of a truth no other than that
of his favourite tiger-son. So he brought out a pot of the last home-brew,
and some of the finest and purest ghi which his store contained wherewith
to treat his welcome guest.
Three loaf-cupfuls of the former were poured down the demoniac’s throat
and a handful of ghi forced into his mouth, whereupon the spirit being
satisfied went out of the man, and took its departure for the shades below,
leaving Kusru dilated with joy, but the company en masse in grave doubt
as to the light in which this apparently unwarrantable intrusion ought to be
regarded.
But they soon received the assurance of Kusru and the Baiga that this
little novelty which had so alarmed every one at the first was the happiest
omen possible. So from that day forth, the spirit of Kusni’s tiger-son was
deified and worshipped under the name of Baghesar by the five Gond clans
descended from, and respectively named after, the brothers Kusru, Suri, Mar-
ram, Netia, and Sarsun.
* “ Speak ! speak ! thou fearful guest !
“ Who with thy hollow breast, &c.”
Longfellow’s Skeleton in Armour.
W. L. Samuells — Gond Legend of Baghesar.
119
1872.]
The substance of the above was told me by a Gond of the Tviisru
clan, at the marriage of whose daughter I was present ; and it was then
that I witnessed the pranks of the demon Baghesar from which I was led
to make enquiry as to his antecedents.
It is only at the marriages of members of the five clans, who are named
in the heading to this paper, that Baghesar manifests his presence in the
manner narrated in the story. With them he is held hi reverence as a
deified spirit ; hut with other Gonds, Baghesar is simply one of the many
spirits to whom propitiatory offerings are yearly made. According to the
latter he has no such origin as that ascribed to him by the five clans before-
mentioned, but is simply regarded as 1 the concentrated essence of spirits’,
which have issued from those Gonds who have met their deaths by tigers ;
for, according to local belief, the spirits of all Gonds thus killed, are said
to unite and form the one great spirit Baghesar ; and it is simply with a
view to saving their flocks and herds, and their own lives also, from the
ravages of tigers that the inhabitants of every Gond village yearly make
offerings to propitiate this demon. And to this extent I find the same
spirit is known and propitiated by the people of these wild parts generally.
At the marriage ceremony which I witnessed, Baghesar entered into and
possessed two men. One was the puj dr ( or priest, and the other a looker
on. The puj dr i is always told off specially for this duty, in ease none of
the company should happen to get involuntarily possessed. A woman, on
the occasion referred to, was also taken worse, but got quickly bundled out
of the way from motives of public decency.
The manner in which the two men seized the kid between their teeth
and by that means killed it, was a sight which could only be equalled in a
zoological garden or menagerie on feeding days.
But this exhibition of fiend-like butchery is only allowed to be partially
witnessed, for, as soon as the kid has been fairly pinned, the members of the
family who are standing by, throw blankets or cloths over the demoniacs,
as they say it is a sight not fit for all eyes to behold ; a point which no
civilized being would be likely to dispute with them.
The demoniacs I saw, were permitted to exercise their teeth on the
kid’s carcase some time after it had sounded its last gurgling note : and this
indulgence, judging from the motions of the covering cloths, was entered
into with an amount of zest and gusto that was positively brutal ; and from
an orange-sucking sound that was occasionally audible, a horrid suspicion
crossed my mind that they had even gone to the extent of blood-sucking,
though of this I could not be positive.
The bride’s father at length dragged out the mangled and lifeless body
of the kid and put it aside ; and the men emerging from their covering
disported themselves like electrified frogs d la Ghamasan, another gentleman
120 A. F. Rudolf Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
of tlie infernal regions whose acquaintance I made in these parts, and who
throws those whom he possesses into a state suggestive of one attacked
simultaneously with hysterics, epilepsy, ague, and colic, a fearful combination,
it is true, and to fully realise which, tha reader must make a trip to Chang-
Bhokar, which, geographically speaking, is one of the Chutia-Nagpur Tribu-
tary States, but which psychologically, I think, must be one of the outlying
provinces of Pandemonium.
The bride’s father having treated each of the demoniacs to three cupfuls
of liquor and a mouthful of ghi, Baghesar’s spirit vanished, leaving both
the men considerably blown and exhausted.
During the whole of this scene not a soul spoke, and the general impres-
sion seemed to be, that it was too solemn a matter to be sneered or laughed
at. Still no marriage ceremony is complete without it, and, according to
Gond ideas, fortune smiles on the wedded couple when Baghesar appears.
If the bride’s parents are poor and have not the means to afford a kid,
a pig is given instead. This I should think can’t be quite so pleasant for
the demoniacB, but the fun no doubt would he considerably enhanced to
those lookers-on who, like myself, had nothing to fear from Baghesar, and
could therefore with impunity smile at his pranks.
Of the extraordinary nature of the scene in general, no description could
ever supply a perfectly accurate conception ; but, as an illustration of the
superstitious belief and worship of one of the most interesting of the
aboriginal tribes of India, it is nevertheless worthy of record. -
Essays in aid of a Comparative Grammar of the Gaurian Languages. — Eg
Rev. A. F. Rudolf Hoeenle, D. Eh., Professor of Sanskrit, Jag
Ndrayan's College, Benares.
I .-—Introductory.
It may be convenient to have a collective name for all North-Indian
languages derived from the Sanskrit. As Dravidian is now, after the example
set by Dr. Caldwell in his Comparative Grammar of the Dravidian langu-
ages, the name generally received to designate the non-Sanskritic languages
of South India, and as Gaurian ( ) is the term commonly, used by San-
skrit writers as the correlative to Dravidian ( ^Tfs.^3" ), it appears to be the
simplest plan to appropriate the term Gaurian for the Sanskritic languages
of North India.*
The following languages must be accounted Gaurian : viz., the Oriya,
the Bangali, the Hindi, the Naipali, the Marathi, the Gujarati, the Sindhi,
* If X am not much mistaken, I have already seon tho word Gaurian employed by
some writers in this wise, so that its use by me is not a novelty.
I*
Note to p. 119.
Bdghesar means ‘ the Tiger-God,’ from lag'll, a tiger, and eshivar,
1 God.’ Compare also Herklots’s ‘ Manners and Customs of the Mussul-
mans of India,’ p. 220, — “ After the demoniac is well filled with the devil,
he sometimes screeching takes a kakra (large wick), continues lighting and
extinguishing it by putting the lighted end into his mouth ; some, biting
the neck of a fowl, suck its blood.”
**u
►A*
Jf*
* l&f ~
*«»*'
*
*•
*
*&•
121
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on tlie Gaurian Languages.
the Panjabi (or Gurmuklii), and the Kashmiri. They are divided into two
groups by somo striking' grammatical peculiarities, of which I may here
niention two, which will more immediately concern us in the following essays.
One is the possession of an eighth case of agent (over and above the common
seven Sanskrit cases) , formed by the post-position sr (or sf ; in the Naipali, ^j) ;
a correlate of which is the absence of an organic past tense of the verb. The
other is the adjective character 'of the genitive post-positions, which agree
with the noun which they qualify, in gender, number, and case. These
peculiarities are possessed by all Gaurian languages* except the Oriya and
Bangali, which two latter, therefore, form a group by themselves ; the
remainder making up the other group.
The Hindi is the most extensively spoken of all the Gaurian languages.
Its area consists of nearly 40,000 square miles, and extends from the River
Gandak in the east to the Satlaj in the west, and from the Himalaya in the
north to the Vindhya Mountains in the south. But a distinction must bo
made between the high Hindi and the low Hindi, the mutual relation of
which shows many striking resemblances to that between the high and low
German. I take here the terms high and low in their ordinary sense, mean-
ing by high the cultivated, the language of literature, and by low, the vulgar
Bpoken dialects. The high Hindi is used almost exclusively for literature
over the whole area, and is understood everywhere ; though it is perhaps no-
where spoken in its purity by the people : at all events, it is spoken only by
the higher and educated classes. The high Hindi does not differ from the
Urdu in its grammar ; and in its vocabulary only so far, that it substitutes
for all foreign (i. e., Persian or Arabic) words, others transferred to it directly
from the Sanskrit. It arose gradually by the substitution of Sanskrit words
partly for foreign words, partly for such Prakrit words as had become, in the
course of time, obsolete or vulgar ; and the cause of this substitution was
partly the revival of Hindil patriotism, partly the impetus given to Hindi
literature through the introduction by the English of vernacular education
and Christian missions. It is, therefore, a comparatively modem language.
In fact, its formation and growth is still going on, as ipiy one who takes an
interest in such matters may verify by personal observation.
While the high Hindi is uniform and spread over the whole area of the
Hindi, the low Hindi consists of many dialects differing more or less among
themselves and confined to different provinces. But they may be divided
into two great classes, of which the Braj Bhasha and the (so-called) Ganwari,
respectively, are typical. The former class occupies the western, the latter
the eastern half of the Hindi area. Roughly speaking, the boundary line
tna.y be drawn at 80° Long. To the western class belong, besides the typi-
cal Braj Bhasha spoken in the A'gra and Mathura Districts, the Dialects of
122 Iloemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
Gwitliar, Alwar, Jaipiir, the Marwari dialect, &c. To the eastern class be-
long, beside the typical Ganwari spoken in the Benares Division, the Bais-
wari* dialect of Audh, the Maithili dialect of Tirhut, and others. The
differences between these two classes are so great as to constitute them al-
most two different languages ; for the Ganwari and its class of dialects
participate in most of the characteristics of the Bang&li class of the Gaurian
languages, while the Braj Bhasha class of dialects share those of the other
Gaurian languages. The Ganwari, as its name which means * rustic’ or ‘ vul-
gar’ confined to villages) indicates, has never received any literary
cultivation, and is confined to the low and uneducated part of the population.
Throughout the whole area of the latter, a more or less pure high Hindi is
spoken and written by the higher and the educated classes. Hence here the
area of the Hindi class of the Gaurian languages and that of the Bangali
class overlap each other, the Ganwari forming a sort of transition language
between the two. The Braj Bhasha on the other hand has begun from early
times to receive some literary cultivation. Most Hindi poets within the last
400 years ( e . g., Kabir, Bihari Lai, Sur Das, Tulsi Das, &c.) have employed
it principally in their poems. Hence it has become the mother of the Urdu
and high Hindi. The latter derive by far the greatest part of then- gram-
mar and vocabulary from it. In fact, it is distinguished from the high Hindi
chiefly by a greater roughness and a greater abundance of its grammatical
forms. Grammars of the Braj Bhasha have been written hi modern times,
e. g., by Ballantyne, and in the Hindi and Hindustani Selections ; and per-
haps the best known prose work written hi it is the i?i janiti, a translation of
the Sanskrit HUopadeshd.
Two opposite opinions are held by different scholars regarding the na-
ture of the Gaurian languages. While some Orientalists consider them to
be, with trifling exceptions in the vocabulary, wholly Sanskritic, others
admit large un-Sanskritic additions, both in the grammar and in the vocabu-
lary. According to Dr. Caldwell, t e. g., “the grammatical structure of
the spoken idioms of Northern India was from the first, and always continued
to be, in the main Scythian ; and the change which took place when Sanskrit
acquired the predominance as the Aryans gradually extended their conquests
and their colonies, was rather a change of vocabulary than of grammar ; a
* The derivation of Baiswdra is uncertain. According to some Pandits, it is con-
nected with the word IpUTSfY which is said to be the name of a Kshattriya tribe
living in Audh, who gave to their country the name of the Baiswara countiy, and to
their dialect the name of the Baiswari dialect. According to others, it is a modifica-
tion of «[ ry y rid The meaning of the name would then be : the dialect confined to
the Yaisyas, or rustics ; and it would be almost identical with the meaning of the
name Ganwari, which is a modification of HHrerCt, e., confined to villages.
f Comparative Grammar, p. 38.
123
1872.] Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
change not so much in arrangement and vital spirit as in the materiel of the
language. Seeing that the northern vernaculars possess with the words of
the. Sanskrit a grammatical structure which in the main appears to he Scy-
thian, it seems more correct to represent these languages as having a Scy-
thian basis with a large and overwhelming Sanskrit addition, than as having
a Sanskrit basis with a small admixture of a Scythian element.” If this
theory should be true, the Gauriari languages could no more be accounted
Sanskritic or Indo-European, any more than the El'S vidian languages. For
languages must be classified according to their grammatical structure.*
Otherwise, English (Johnsonian English at all events) would have to be
counted among the Romance, and Urdu among the Semitic languages. But
the whole question is hardly yet ripe for adjudication. The Gaurian langua-
ges have as yet had very little attention paid to them as regards their nature
and origin. Moreover in such an investigation a serious difficulty is met
with at the outset in the extreme want and inaccessibility of the Gaurian
literature dating from the time when the Gaurian languages took then- origin
(about 800 to 1200, A. D.). As up to this time the Aryan population of
North India, who had imigrated many centuries before, had used exclusively
Sanskritic languages (Sanskrit, Pali, Prakrit), it would be a most remarkable
phenomenon, if they, a Culturvolk, had now exchanged their native grammar
for that of the uncultured and despised aboriginal population ; supposing
that the language of the latter was really a non-Aryan one, and that it had
really survived the long Aryan occupation ; both suppositions by no means
established as yet. It has happened more than once that a conquering nation
(especially, if inferior in culture), while retaining more or less its native
vocabulary, adopted the grammar of the conquered people (as the Normans
in England, the Arabs and Turks in North India, the Pranks in Gaul),
under the condition that this process commenced from the very first beginning
of the conquest. But that the conquerors, after having resided for Centuries
hi the country and retained their native language (both in grammar and
vocabulary, trifling instances in the latter excepted) entirely unmixed with
the aboriginal languages, should abandon their own grammar in favour of
that of the conquered, requires strong proofs to be credited, especially as it
is by no means certain whether the aboriginal languages at all survived at so
late a date ; for, according to the evidence aflorded by the Prakrit of the
playg, Prakrit was spoken by the low class population, which was composed,
uo doubt, principally of the subjugated aboriginal people, who, therefore,
either spoke a Sanskritic language from the first or adopted the vulgar
dialect of the language of their conquerors.
* Compare Max Muller’s remarks in Lectures on tke Science of Language, lect.
> pp. 86-90 (Gth Ed.).
16 *
II.,
124
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
[No. 2,
If by a more thorough investigation of the Gaurian languages it can
be shown, that they are entirely Sanskritie, this will, on account of the
many undoubted resemblances between the Gaurian and Dravidian languages
(cf. Dr. Caldwell’s Comparative Grammar, pp. 34 to 39), materially affect our
view of the classification of the latter. However, this problem awaits yet a
thorough scientific enquiry. And the following essays are offered as a slight
contribution towards its solution. For the inflexional post-positions of the
Gaurian languages are, above other points, considered to be evidences of the
Dravidian* or Seythianf character of their grammatical structure.
Essay II. — On the Post-Positions of the Genitive.
The present essay will be devoted to the elucidation of the nature and
origin of the post-positions of the genitive. They are the following : —
In the High Hindi, ... qrr, ft, % ;
Braj Bhasha, - - - - *RT, ft, f ;
Alwar Dialect,
Ganwari,
Maithili,
Naipali,
Marathi,
Gujarati,
Panjabi,
Sindhi,
Bangali,
Onya,
S5k -v
- ^ ;
-
- ^\T, ^rr ;
- ^T, 'ft, % %, "ST, ft ;
- ^T, ft, *rt, Hi;
- fl> ft, f ;
- %T, ft, f, 3IT ;
- ^ or TC ;
-
The only attempt at an explanation of the origin of these post-positions
that I remember to have met with, is one made by Bopp in his Comparative
Grammar, para. 340, note. J
He compares the Hindi genitives formed by means of the post-positions
«ffT, etc., with the Sanskrit genitive plural HginKH of hihh I, and of
thou, etc. These words are possessive pronomina (our and your) formed by
the affix Others also have referred to this Sanskrit affix or ft *4, which
expresses relation or possession, as an explanation of the Hindi post-positions.
But there are serious objections to this theory.
* By Dr. Stevenson, in tire Jonrnal of the Bombay Asiatic Society.
t Cf. Dr. Caldwell’B Comparative Grammar, p. 39. He seems, however, inclined to
admit a Sanskritie origin of the genitive post-positions, cf. p. 246.
X He says : Es verdient bemerkt zu werden, dass im Hindostanischen die Formen,
die man in beideu zalrlen alier deolinations-faehigen woerter ais genitive aufstellt,
sich als unverkennbare possessiva herausstellen, dadurch dass sie sich nach dem
Geschlechte des folgonden Substantives richten. Die pronomina erster und zweiter
person haben im masc, rft, im fern, rt, als possessiv suffix, die iibrigen woerter im
masc. k&, im Fern, ki j ka aber stimmt zum skr. suffix ka von asmaka, yusnraka,
mamaka, tftvaka.
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Oaurian Languages. 125
The form of the word to which the post-positions are added, is not
always the pure hase, as the addition of the Sanskrit affix would require, but
already inflected (e. //., ilT% hi of a horse, is not the simple base of the
word ifFfr, but an infleeted form of it). Again, it is most unlikely that
elements like the affixes 3f, cjtol, etc., which occur in Sanskrit only as integral
parts of a word, but never by themselves as independent words, should have,
in a comparatively modem language, separated themselves from the body of
the word and assumed independent life (as post-positions) similar to that of
prepositions. It would be a phenomenon contrary to those that have been
observed in all other cases of (what Max Muller calls) dialectic regeneration.
It is clear also that by this theory the other post-positions (as H, *j, %)
cannot be explained. But there can be no doubt that, whatever the true
explanation be, it must be the same for all post-positions. For these reasons
among others, any theory which traces the post-positions to Sanskrit affixes
cannot be the true one. Their explanation must be sought for in a different
direction.
In the first place, it may be remarked that the term “ post-position” is
misleading. It gives the idea as if the words, to which it is applied, belonged
to that class of words which includes the prepositions, conjunctions, etc., i. e.,
elements of language which are incapable of either derivation or inflexion.
Now most of the so-called post-positions of the genitive are capable of both.
They have clearly a nominal or more accurately an adjective character. For
the Hindi ^rr, #7, agree with the noun which they qualify, in case,
number, and gender, exactly as for instance, ^ good. If
the qualified noun is a masculine singular nominative, then «RT is used ; if a
feminine singular or plural, then cRl ; if a masculine plural nominative, then
% ; if a masculine in any oblique case, then The same is the case with the
Panjabi 27, the Braj Bhaslia 3RT, %, etc. In the Sindhi, 5H and oil
are used like 3fT and in High Hindi ; 5TT is used, if the qualified noun is
in the masculine plural nominative, and si is used, if it is a masculine in any
oblique case singular or plural. With this agrees the use of the post-
positions ir, eft, of the Alwar and Jaipur dialect.
After these explanations the following scheme of the agreement* of the
* This agreement is not altogether perfect ; bnt neither is the agreement of
the real adjective with its substantive more so; e. g., in Hindi, qyj and % ought to
have a different form in the plural ; probably these plural forms are irregularly adopted
from the singular ; but then g°0<h has also both in the singular and plural
. Originally, the agreement was much more perfect. This is clearly proved by the
Marathi, where “ sometimes, in poetry, the adjective takes a case-form corresponding
to that of the noun it qualifies ; thus :
HTW «T HT5PJ ”
Student’s Manual of Marathi Grammar, p. 39.
12G
Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
Gaurian genitive post-positions with the noun qualified by them will be easily
understood —
Singular.
Plural.
Direct case. Oblique cases. Direct case. Oblique cases.
-A —
The adjective character of these so-called post-positions indicates that
we must look for a nominal source of them in Sanskrit.
It is a well-known observation that in poetry and in the vulgar dialects,
old grammatical forms are often preserved which have been altogether lost
in the cultivated dialects. These archaic forms do the same service to the
student of language as fossil remains do to the student of geology. They
discover to us language in its earliest state from which it has developed into
its present form.t
In the Ganwari dialect, sometimes, there is found in the genitive the
post-position 'STT, or diT, instead of It is there confined to the pronominal
declension ; e. g., T?J diT, of him, is in Gunwari V^pc, or Vdi ; rxj % is Vdif , or
df ; KJf diT, of them, is or H5? ^ ^ # is V’^drx:, or f ; again,
* The forms as in use among tbo Mardthis and Gujaratis settled in Benares and
Gaya (and probably anywhere in the Hindi country) differ slightly from those given
above. In Marathi the form of the direct case plural of the neuter is f , instead of
and in the Gujarati, the form of the oblique cases singular in all three genders is alike
sj- instead of sff, f , qj-, These differences are evidently merely assimilations to the
Hindi.
f “ In every country it is in the poetry and in the speech of the peasantry that
the ancient condition oflangnage is best studied.” Dr. Caldwell, Comp. Gram., p. 31.
127
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Oawrian Languages.
fan =st ST, whose house, is in Ganwari #urr sit, or ufa sit ; fan nr sit n in
whose house, is %uiT sit, &o. The same post-position niT is frequently^ met
with in the Ilamayana of Tulsi Das (about 1650, A. D.). But there it is
not confined to pronouns, but also used in connexion with nouns, e. g.,
^fa srrfa utu II i. e.
High Hindi : '©faUT Ufl 'STTffT niT 35TV II
Lanka kand
Besides spT, Tulsi Das uses sometimes another form which is still more
archaic, viz. ^T, or ^Tl, %-G, %T. They are used exactly as urr, nft, as #t
(%TT) corresponds to the Ganwari sr , so UiT to the Ganwari UiT ; e. g., UfTT
occurs in tide following verse :
far TTTS nu -Jr©5© %TT i. e.
High Hindi : fac # ©U ST^nf ^T-
Lanka kand.
(Here possibly srtt might be used as a Nom. PL, like U\T in the Alwar
and Jaipur dialect, and an in Sindhi).
Again, tut «rrfr Jin Tuufa%r ii i.
High Hindi, TU! TJ't T’SRT m © TT« UTT II
Again, occurs in the following verses :
Lanka kand.
Again %T occurs in the following verses :
U5©! unnTT© nn nr© ii i. e.
High Hindi : © ©fin utTnr © n<fa n©vr ©nr % n
Bala kand.
Or : f. faffa ©5t©*IT II
High Hindi : n fa ©fa © ^siqi^T % II
* Lanka kand.
An example 6f cRT occurs in the following verse :
nr $nfa %t <gn nrq© ii i e.
High Hindi : n© ^ntn ^it i?[3T nrnur © ii
Lanka kand.
128 Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
A contemporary of Tulsi Das was Sura Das (about 1650, A. D.). The
following instances of the use by him of the same words (§x;T or §TT, §71,
tT) are taken from his poems called the Sura Sagar —
sir 7TTT f'Trrr ftpair §7T li «. C.
High Hindi : §07 §o’ fwrg; f^^r, ^ ftnair «piw n
Saravali 12.
Or : *p:t%t xs %v.t ii i. e.
High Hindi : xtttbt ii
Saravali.
Or : fHTTFTT xrr^rtff %tl il
High Hindi : usm ^7 fa* §17 srm §T ^ §1 n
Nitya Kirtan, 49.
Considerably older than both Tulsi Das and Sura Das is Kabir. He
lived about 1500, A. D. His Behlitahs offer many instances of the use of
§7T, §7l, §7, as signs of the genitive. A few of them are the following :
^4i7 TiTU § N77 l
«n Jin §t\ ftp^r ^77 " i. e.
High Hindi : ^vjr §rv %r xixttt |
5TT JT7 §1 f «P7T ^rrJir II
Or : %7 vr ^ ^vrii 1*^77 ii i. e.
High Hindi : xgwi % ^iTwr xi % ®i§ f§U7iT ^f7rJr n
Still further back we come to Ohand Bardai, who lived about 1200,
A. D. An instance of the same use of §7 occurs in the following verse
taken from his great epic the Priihirdj r&yasa.
^r7 j[5T ^ -TfsPnsr §7T ii
Book XIX, 41 *
If we now turn to the Prakrit, we find sometimes an adjective noun
or §vqr, inserted between the genitive and the noun qualified by it.
In such eases, the insertion appears to be perfectly 'pleonastic, that is, the
sense is complete, even if the word J|rf7*ff, or §7^i, bo altogether omitted.
Whenever §7^f is thus inserted, it agrees with the qualified noun in case,
number, and gender, i. e., is treated as an adjective ; e. g.,
* Unfortunately I have been unable to obtain a copy of Chand’s epic, and, there-
fore, must content myself with giving this single example, which by a happy accident
occurs in one of the notes appended by Mi*. Boames to his translation of the 19th
Book, printed in the J ournal of tho Asiatic Society of Bengal, Part 1, No. Ill, of 1869.
As I have not the contoxt, I cannot speak with certainty j but my suggestion as to the
nature of §^f might perhaps be a solution of the difficulty which Mr. Beames felt in
the meaning of tho verse. It might explain the verse, without taking ^yj as a verb and
altering it into which is an objoctionable emendation ; for there is (as Mr. Beames
himself admits) no verb in Hindi ; and the words “ to overthrow ” in such a con-
nection aro an anglicism.
1872.]
129
Hocrnlc — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
rpjfq qjum #fxqi 5ITf^ ^ II
Skr. sm q(fq qfTWq: 3lifff *T WCfa ll
High Hindi : ^qqt snffT **T qiTm % ll
Mrichchhakati, Act VI.
Or : Wf? *rqqt>/q<?<" qrr%rri<r wtit qi'HdtqfPer n
Skr. wqiqfr^bq qrqfirfqiSffT *rm qjDqmq n
High Hindi : at «ra qrr #raiT 5jr?rT ^ n
Ditto, Act 1.
Or : qtff qvqf qq qq'?’" n i. e.
Skr. qua q»nT ll
High Hindi : f%<? q>T ^ qq^W n
Ditto, Act YI.
Or : qr^rqr qqqrqi^qi fspjpjnw qqftro ll i. e.
Skr. *?<Yu q^qqfTts^ ^iwT^jT^r ufq^g n or
High Hindi : iiv qujqrq'jqqi u tr^r *iiii!q ^ q%si qryqr n
Ditto, Act VIII.
Or : orf?; *m ifw qqfqifw, nr f^T5 ^rq qjsq*? it i. c.
Skr. •qfq ^qqTf^qiT, frq;T f<reg- ?rrq<T ii or
High Hindi : qf<?; ^ «nft f m aqy snq wt n
* Ditto, Act X.
In the two last examples, the common interchange of q and <3 has taken
place.
It may he noted in the foregoing examples, (1) that in none of them
%r^r (or has a predicative sense. Were we to translate it by “ made
or wrought,” it would turn the sentence into nonsense. It is every where
perfectly superfluous, the sense being complete without it ; (2) that is
used pleonastically, namely, that although inserted only in connection with a
genitive, it is not yet used by itself to determine the genitive, but always em-
ployed over and above the ordinary genitive, hence forming a sort of double
or pleonastic genitive ; (3) that is used in connection with pronouns.
Compare in this respect the use of qrq in Ganwari with pronouns only. There
are, however, instances in which qrqqf is also used in connexion with nouns j
e- 9;
Skr.
High Hindi :
qm ^si^iT^r qfssw srviiT ii i e.
qq *a<sj qu^TUi: 11 or
«tt wqw ^ qiT 11
Ditto, Act IV.
Or : qw qq^w qr^t% 11 i. c.
Skr. qqw qq'S'ri 11 or
High Hindi : m Jrrft t qil 11
130 Hoernle — 'Essays on the Eaurian Languages. [No. 2,
In these examples, sfiOR still forms a pleonastic genitive. But some
places occur where the original genitive termination is altogether dropped,
and instead is joined to the crude base, with which it forms a compound,
and thus determines by itself the genitive ease, e. „
qcFspr ^siir u i. e.
Skr. u-sjrfi ^rrs?: II or
High Hindi : W vx 11 *
Ditto, Act IV:
Or : 15% H >-/e-
Skr. TT5l^rav»H£lT*rei ,*nr HJT: ^iwfa ii or
High Hindi : TTsrrawdwuw dir u fwNl 7? sn^ft ^t^'jit ii
° In these examples evidently, forms no more a pleonastic genitive,
but itself determines the genitive case of the word with which it is com-
pounded, in the place of the real original case affix. It has clearly not only
lost its predicative meaning, but has become altogether a determinative ele-
ment, or a sort of affix.
But what was originally the meaning of this word and how did it
come to lapse into the condition of a mere affix ? In order to answer this
question, we must go back to the Sanskrit. In one place occurs
instead of viz. : —
rf^ jpi || i. e.
Skr. ri? 11 or
High Hindi : vx JTTft ^ fa ^ W WTT V ll
The Sanskrit equivalent of qfa*ra is aWT* The noun tlssfa means
< nature,’ that which distinguishes one from another. Hence, MSfa may mean,
natural, peculiar, or own ; for what is peculiar to one, that is one’s own.
The word therefore means own, and was originally inserted after the
genitive to emphasize the possessive sense of the genitive. But in course of
time, this original object of the insertion of ifa*r<«r was lost sight of, and it
was used simply to express the genitive itself. In fact, it may be shown
that the genitive in many other languages arose by some such process.f As
* LitoraUy it is ’S^irPf I bat it is a vory common practico in Prakrit, of which
numberless instances aro found in the plays, to add the affix to Sanskrit words
without any effect upon tho sense of the latter (of. Pr. Prak. iv, 25, Com.).
f A good illustration of the process is mentioned by Max Muller in his Lectures
on the Science of Languages. In Lect. II, page 79, he quotes the following remarks from
an American paper about the Negro-English. “As to Oases, I do not know that I ever
heard a regular possessive, but they have begun to develope one of their own, which is
a vory curious illustration of the way inflectional forms have probably grown up in
other languages. If they wiBh to make the faot of possession at all emphatic or dis-
tinct, they use the whole word “ own.” Thus they will say “ Mosey houso. But if
asked whose house that is, the answer is “ Mosey own.” “ Co’ Molsy y own was the
131
1872.] Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian ^Languages.
^r?irf is the original of P#qtqi, so W<T is the original of qrqf (or qrsrqi) ;
and 3irr has the same meaning as garf (or qqqiqf), just as qrr means
the same as. qqrx doer, and qfTX in the phrases T"Slfi ^TPCfl, [qnxm, &c.,
(cf. Siddlianta Ivaumudi to Pan. 3, 4, 27, Yol. II, page 4G8) the same as
qqnr “ manner.”
But to return to the phonetic changes which ^xqi underwent, it is
well known rule in Prakrit, that non-initial single mute consonants ar
elided (cf. Prakrit a I’rakasa II, 2.). Accordingly q<T becomes a
form which occurs in several of the examples already quoted. When two
vowels meet in consequence of such an elision of a consonant, they are
often contracted* in Prakrit already (cf. Pr. Prak. IV. 1.), hut still
more in its descendant, the Gaurian. Hence i&rir becomes in the Gaurian
%tt, and this again changes into #XT. Thus the Sanskrit hraqb, horse, is
in Prakrit inf7.iT, in the Gaurian hpff (Alwari and Sindhi), or hif T (High
Hindi). On the change of the final to ^iT, as well as the change of the
feminine termination qjT to T in see some remarks below and in Essay IV.
From #vt (or %TT), q»T, may be derived immediately the modern
forms ?TT (or qu), qrl, qi, by another step of phonetic decay. The elision of
a medial X, though not noted in the Sutras of Vararuchi, occurs occasion-
ally in the later Prakrit ; e, g., qx, for qfx, in
qrqWTT i| i. e.
Sanskrit, ^qifqiqqfcxqifqqqTfW i
^TflflTSnfXiqi^T^Tfs)' n
Karp ura Mapjari Sattaka, verse 2.
But in the Gaurian the elision of a medial single X is not without
example. For instance, the conjunction q, but, clearly stands for the San-
skrit qxn, which occurs in Hindi also, and more commonly as qx. Simi-
larly, the Ganwdri sign of the genitive qi has arisen from the other
Ganwari and poetic form qrx. Another Hindi word qiX (qrf<) which, how-
ever, has a different origin and stands for the Prakrit qifxq (Sanskrit qr^i),
also becomes not uncommonly qi, especially in the older poets like Kabir,
e-a-, ^ ^ ^
qs%T vrq qw qi 5nqt q’qq- q> flTrit ii or
High Hindi, qr%r qjfqtuq qiq qifx arrq' q«q qifx fli?' h
There is no great difficulty, therefore, in deriving qrr, qil, qi, from qjvq,
%Xt ; qiX, still another derivation is possible which I shall presently give, and
odd reply made by a little girl to the question, whose child she was carrying. Co’ is
little j y euphonic.” — I think also, it can he shown that the affix by means of which
many Sanskrit genitives are formed, is nothing else but a possessive pronominal base,
equivalent to the common possessive pronominal base XI, meaning “own.”
17 it
132
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
which is not open to this difficulty. Before, however, proceeding to the con-
sideration of it, I will dispose of another genitive post-position which, there
appears little doubt, is really derived from ^tt and thus medially from the
Prakrit viz. the Bangdli genitive post-position XX, and the Bangali
and Oriya C
In Bangali, all adjectives which are derived through the Prakrit appear
in the crude base (that is without the Prakrit endings sit [masculine] or VjT or
^ [feminine] and anuswara [neuter]), and hence are alike in all genders and
cases, e. g., WIT siPST^, little boy, and irz Trf%*RT, little girl (cf. Shama Churn
Sircar’s Bangali Grammar, page 75, 2nd edition). Hence the Prakrit or
contracted ifiKT, would in Bangali become ffiC Now this form tfir occurs now
and then in Tulsi Das, who, in his Ramayan, has laid all the principal Gaurian
languages, and Bangali among them, under contribution. An instance of a
verse containing it, has been already quoted. I have above referred to the
Prakrit rule of eliding a medial single mute consonant. The term medial
includes also the initial consonant of a word which forms the last part of a
compound (cf. Pr. Prak. II, 2 ) ; e. g., Sanscrit becomes in Prakrit
^3PC*JT ; Sanskrit finiavTC becomes in Pr krit finpiiTTT. in Gaurian ;
Sanskrit becomes Prakrit ^jjVjTXT, Gaurian ^K. I have also
shown that, though in Prakrit i9 generally used pleonastically, so that
its concomitant word is also in the genitive case, yet in some instances it is
made to form a compound with its concomitant word which thou drops
its genitive inflexion. This latter usage seems to have become exclusively
established in the Bangali, and in using in composition with the word in
the genitive case, the initial of the former is elided regularly. Thus we
arrive at VC Take for instance the genitive of T? wire a child ; it would be vrwnvr
this would change to and this to or (by contraction
of the two adjoining vowels) ^wrrkr, which is the present genitive in Bangali.
By analogy, the other Bangali genitive post-position T, which it shares with
the Oriya, is probably a curtailment of the genitive sign <fiT, still occurring
in Tulsi Das and in the Ganwari.
It has been already noticed that the Sanskrit equivalent for the Prakrit
is VuT. But -gfcT assumes various forms in Prakrit. Perhaps the most
common, though not the most regular, form of it is (where the change
of v? to c takes place by Pr. Prak. I, 28, and that of <T to ^ by Pr. Prak.
II, 7), e. g.,
c fkc n=Sanskrit ^ % 3kHT ll
Or : vmvrsr n= Sanskrit c'reprn fwvfrT li
Or : vd fcp-J wrf< n=Sanskrit xx fk ii
Next comes the form efc, foimed regularly according to Pr. Prak. I, 27, and
II, 7, e. g.,
n= Sanskrit ii
1872.]
133
Hoernlo — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
Or : m ng u=Sanskrit SHTH n
The most regular form, though not so frequent, is with change of
^ to ^ by Pr. Prak. I, 28, and elision of 7f by Pr. Prak. II, 2., in both of
which sutras it is given among the examples. Another not unfrequent form
is (Pr. Prak. XI, 15), in which the rf of ®?T under the influence of
^3 has changed to 'S', a change not uncommon in Prakrit, as in ’q-f^vr ir, for
Vfrr^TJ, (Pr. Prak. II, 8, 2S.), for for fjpo HHHT,
(Mrichchh. Act II page 62). Examples of are —
gri n=Sanskrit arn n
efrir n = Sanskrit nreiniJ 3PT: u etc.
Another very rare foim is where the ^ may he a substitution
either for the ^ of (by Pr. Prak. II, 23, as for
for cfiWm:, Eatnawali, Act I, page 21), or for the ^ of (by analogy of Pi’.
Prak. II, 12, as for efi^yap) ; it occurs, e. g., in gr§fVr^1 ||=Sanskrit giffT
||. From the form probably spi-ang the form which occurs
only in the augmented shape by the not uncommon substitution of
an v for the first 'Uj (cf Pr. Prak. 1, 5, as ifSH for maiT, knit for ifc*H
for &c.). The most extraordinary transformation of sh, however, is the
rare one 3;^ which occurs, e. y.,in^j'%j|^jjM=Sanskrit Jiv?-- wp (Mrichchh.
Act II, page 63). From either cir^orqr^by the easy change of the linguals oi-sr
into y (cf. Pr. Prak. II, 30), arose a further form ; xuxless it be considered
itself the original of qr^r, which is equally possible ; or nrv might also be derived
direct from cf. Pr. Prak. II, 13, 14. The same relation as assist to ^r,
bears to ^ ; and as qra; is to so is to The form <*ra: (as
an indeclinable adjective like those in Han gall) has been used, as already
shown, in the vulgar and poetical Hindi, to express the genitive. And from
it, as also explained already, probably the Bangali and Oriya genitive sign T
is derived, by the elision of the consonant ^ and loss of the vowel "31 through
the contraction of the meeting vowels consequent upon that elision ; e. g.,
Jjn; = ijr?T3j< = iff K.*
The other forms or or are, I think, the originals of the dif-
ferent modern Hindi post-positions jrt or 4iT or and their feminine a#l and
inflected ■%. As the Prakrit aRrafiT becomes (by elision of ^i) ^<iiT, and this
again in the Gaurian (by contraction of the meeting vowels) afiyT or a^rr, so
the Prakrit apa^T becomes and this in the Gaurian apl or crt or aR|. As
regards this final ’sgr of ^rr which corresponds to tlxo masculine ending ajp of
all adjectives which have come into the Hindi through the Prakrit, it is every-
* Perhaps the possessive in Hindi HTT, rPCT, f?F?TC, xfTnTf, &c., should
be explained by means of this element ("C for ^T), the curtailment of (or ^iTT), thus
9^rPT Sanskrit auflri arp — Prakrit 3^ J for the commonly received deriva-
tion of these pronouns from the Sanskrit possessiva &c., is not
without difficulties.
134
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
where the substitute of the Prakrit masculine nominative ending 38T. Adject-
ive bases in ^ end in Sanskrit in the nominative singular masculine in ^i,
feminine "3TT or K\ plural ^T*. These terminations change in the Prakrit in
%T, ^6(T or x;, and ^T- In the Alwari dialect, as well as in the Sitidhi and
Naip&li, these terminations are preserved unchanged. The genitive post-
positions in Alwari and Naipali are, nominative singular masculine sfiT, nomi-
native plural masculine ^TT, feminine ; in Sindhi resp. srr, oU, srl ; similarly,
in all three languages, is a horse, rirei horses, mare, &c. The
Brajbhasha changes generally the Prakrit v*T into »-T, and has therefore efiT,
instead of ^T; similarly for Prakrit (Sanskrit e|frsirr:). The
High Hindi finally changes the harsher diphthongs % or into the more
agreeable vowel ^T, and hence has cfTT, for or or ^>^T-
Prom (or T or «rt) the feminine 3ft was formed, according to the univer-
sal rule of the Hindi of forming the feminine in x;, instead of the Sanskrit
or Prakrit ^T. The origin of the feminine 3d and the inflected form % will be
explained afterwards (see Essay I V).
The form f%g; perhaps has even a better claim than the form to be
considered the original of 3fT, '3t, 3f. It is true that so far as I have search-
ed the Prakrit dialogues of Sanskrit dramas, I have not discovered an in-
stance of either 3\ 3J or f3i <T being used in that pleonastic manner in which
■^iXT^T is employed. While 3*T^T is frequently used in a determinative sense
(as affix of the genitive), I have never found or f3f^T so used, but always
in a predicative sense (as a proper participle past passive). But besides
the direct proofs to be adduced hereafter (showing that 1%% is the original
of ^t), the following reasons will show that not much importance can be
attached to the circumstance. In the first place, that no instance of f%%
or 3<^t as genitive affix is found, is merely matter of accident. For alto-
gether the use of a Prakrit form of the Sanskrit participle ®<T in this deter-
minative sense, is confined to one play, the Mrichchhakati ; and even there it
occurs only about fourteen times (in the form 3ST3;) . This use of was evi-
dently slang. But while other plays also introduce low and vulgar people, they
do it only on rare occasions and even then put a more or less refined language
into their mouth ; on the other hand, the Mrichchhakati introduces low people
very extensively, and allows them to express themselves freely in their native
vulgar jargon. This explains also the occurrence, in the Mrichchhakati, of
other grammatical forms besides 3iT3f, which are found in no other play. We
may safely conclude that since the use of a Prakrit form of tfirT to determine
the genitive is confined to one play and even there, on account of its vul-
garity, is only exceptionally introduced, the manner of its use there must not
be taken as a measure of its use in general among the people. Among them,
^T3T was employed, no doubt, much more frequently, and very probably
other loans of sKrr (as &c.,) also, which were too vulgar to he admit-
135
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Qaurian Languages.
ted at all into any play. There is nothing surprising in the fact that, among
only about fourteen instances of grW, the form fag or gig should never oc-
cur, seeing that the latter was probably the more vulgar expression of the two.
And here 1 may call attention to the oft-observed fact that what had been once
vulgar or slang phrases, or grammatical forms, during the classical period of a
language, generally becomes the material out of which the language after its
decay reconstructs itself. This law is well illustrated by the Romance lan-
guages. “ The sources of Italian are not to he found in the classical Literature
of Rome, hut in the popular dialects of Italy. Hindustani is not the
daughter of Sanskrit, as we find it in the Vedas, or in the later literature of
the Brahmans ; it is a branch of the living speech of India, springing from
the same stem from which Sanskrit sprang, when it first assumed its literary
independence.”* (2.) Moreover, there is direct proof that fagi and ggT were
used in a determinative sense. In Sanskrit, sfifi', the locative singular of
«SrT, is sometimes employed to express the dative. Even there it has nearly
lost its originally predicative meaning, and has come to he regarded almost
like a mere case-affix. But in the Prakrit and Gaurian, s5<i as well as other
similar Sanskrit words, e. g., ^ (Marathi gfat), ggvfa (Bangali grri, Hindi
gfa) , have become mere case — signs of the dative. N ow is rendered in the
Prakrit promiscuously by gfagf (or fagfa), or by fgrg, or by gig. Examples
of gggi are the following —
gif rg fa gig rfa srmrTfo ii i. e.
Skr. % gfa ggj sfa tw 3>vj sngrfg n or
High Hindi : g gfa fa gg gr fag ( gigi g ) gg *fig V ll
Or : grigrcg fg g II i- e.
Skr. ggfai ■gigrg: sgsfa g sngrfg n or
High Hindi : g uwt fa giTg fag ( gjTgT g ) gg *r' 3fTgg\ # I
Mrichchhakati.
Or : ire giw fa II *’• e-
Skr. uu gggw gfa n or
High Hindi : gg Jifat fag g fag % ll
Or : yg trggrgtggigfagig Tugg fa u *• e-
Skr. vg vfa u or
High Hindi : gg rift vrsn % gr^T gtarg gr fag g n
Ditto, Act. VI. page, 186.
Examples of fag are —
grgj fag g;g gjrggT ll i- e.
* Max Muller, Lectures ou the Science of Language, Lect. II., page 67. The
greater part of that lecture (pp, 60 to 80) is devoted to this sirhject of what M. M.
calls “ dialectio regeneration.”
13G
[No. 2,
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
Skr. w ii or
High Hindi : fare % fasfa? *i i? II
Batnavali, Act II, page 57.
Or : sffar g*i fajfanr^^w^Tns^fai^ *iwimre il i. e.
Skr. ssgiTrr ^j?rg?fa*iTW 3fh... . ll or
High Hindi : «pt‘ g; % fa# ... v^imiii ^r<f\ y «
Venisamhara, Act II. page. 35.
An example of qrg is the following —
tit? n^-vrr^li urufa^fa; ll i. e.
Skr. tit? n^nrfjmji: g# ■ssimi’TPu?#! ^TT^r^j^r n or
High Hindi : nnr ^wnt # fa?# wttt ^Prr % il
Mrichchhakati, Act X. page 323.
It is more than probable then, that if fa#, or was used beside
to express the dative, fa#T orTj#T was also employed beside to express
the genitive. And I think it not impossible, that a more careful and ex-
tensive examination of Prakrit and the earliest Gaurian literature, might bring
to light instances of the use of fa#T or as affixes of the genitive.
But to proceed with the consideration of fa#T. By the usual elision of
the medial mute consonant, the form farin' would arise. This is, indeed, the
usual form in which the participle ssn appears in the earlier Hindi poets
(especially Sura Das), where it is written fa#T, with a slight accommodation
to the pronunciation to avoid the hiatus. Generally, however, in such cases the
vowel X before in is changed to the corresponding semivowel g; e. g., Sanskrit
= Prakrit rf?% = Hindi T!W ; Sanskrit nffajrp = Prakrit =
Hindi <r#b &c., and in the Brajbliasha r^r, qrtjr, etc. Accordingly, fafiSiT
would become #r, and in the Braj Bhasha 4#. The reason why it is changed
to farin' (or faftjT) is simply euphonism, an initial double consonant being
difficult to pronounce. But when in other words (t#T, the double
consonant would be medial and hence divisible between the two enclosing
syllables, it is not avoided ; and for the same reason the word fa#T itself, when
it is compounded with a prefix, is spelt #3T in the Naipali ; e. g., 5J«I V3
= Hindi 5R -siTf^ fapmjTT ( = S. fapWT:). This is but the ap-
plication of a well known Sanskrit Sandhi rule, according to which, e. g., fat
+ = fv^faf j jj + ^jfar = JJ^frT, but faflft + = fat#, WPT + % =
WI^t: (cf. Siddh. Kaum. to Pan. G, 4, 77, G4, 82, page 118.) Now when far#
is used to express the genitive, it is no more an independent word, but has
sunk down to the position of an affix, and forms a compound with its
concomitant word. Hence, cpj would have a medial position and, therefore,
would not be avoided. Hence fafifT, when used as a sort of genitive affix,
would be contracted into efm (or tRT).
Lastly #r would, for reasons of euphony, be contracted into %T (or 3>T or
cfTT) ; just as the harsher forms Trfjf or or T, &e., of the Braj
137
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
Bhasha are contracted in the High Hindi into the more euphonious KTT,
&c.. The following scheme will make the similarity still more manifest to the
eye—
Sanskrit. Prakrit. Br. Bhasha. Hindi.
(3rfWK:), (^f-)f«qrr: = far-)f%^T = fa-)1^rT = (^r-)w = (3T-)TT
(TB?Tr:), (T-)f%<T: = = (T-)fW = = (T-)^T
(mftrTi), (*TT-)fT7r:= (FT-)fc^T = (*T-)fC%T = (w-)m = (TJT-)TT
faftlrr:), (tjf-)fjlrr: = (~T-)faT37= (wr-)TOT= (^TT-)JTT
(®?r:), (— )f%rj: = (— )f^r= (— (— )^T = (— )3tt
A still more exact parrallel, than by these examples, is afforded by the
Hindi 'sjt (feminine '«ft, plural if), the past tense of the auxiliary verb %T*TT, to
be. For the original of «tt is Bgpr:, the Sanskrit past participle of the verb
^TT, to stand. The initiator is dropped, as usual in Prakrit; likewise the
medial rf ; thus we arrive at ; and this may change either to f’sjifT, which
would he exactly parallel to the Braj Bhasha f^rnT, or to 'Ojr, which would
he exactly parallel to the form %r. assumed by me as the immediate original
°f (3iT). Now both and 'in occur in the Naipali, and are there the
simultaneous equivalents of the Hindi WT ; e g.,
WT farijT I i e.
High Hindi : wra i St. Luke i, 5.
Again : T fafv W TWcttu i i. c.
High Hindi : Sj ir^f frfa « vi | St. Luke i, 6.
Again : T fwuT i i. e.
High Hindi : il 33 3V i i St. Luke i, 7.
In the case of v;t. therefore, we can still follow its descent, step by step,
from the Sanskrit f^cTh through fvj<T, fees,!, f*T3T, iff, to WT ; while in the
case of <st unfortmvately some of the links have been lost. But that %, or
3*T, is really a direct descendant of the Sanskrit s57p, just as WT of is
even more remarkably proved by the Naipali ; for in one ease it actually
makes use of %r (feminine 3ft, plural 3TT) as a substitute of ®<r:. The Nai-
pali, namely, possesses two forms of the past participle passive ; one is the
ordinary form, which it shares with all other Gaurian languages ; the other is
a very peculiar pleonastic form, which I believe only one other Gaurian lan-
guage, viz., the Marathi, possesses. The difference between those two forms
appears to be this, that the participle takes tho common form, whenever it is
used actively to denote the past tense active, and the pleonastic form when-
ever it is used passively as a participial adjective. The pleonastic form is
made by superadding the past participle sSU!, contracted to ifir, to the common
form of the past participle passive, and of the two participles, thus compound-
ed, the latter cannot be inflected, whereas the former (i. c., ipT) takes the in-
flexions, and agrees with the qualified noun in gender, number, and case,
138 Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
(i. e., masculine %r. feminine plural and oblique HIT) ; e. g., the past parti-
ciple passive of to write, used to form the perfect tense active, is
(i. e., Sans. fiHfrifG) ; but with the proper passive sense, it is HiT (i. e.
Sanskrit f^rfisTFr: or Hindi 1%HIT SNT or HHT), thus “the Gospel written
by Luke” is ^ r TJHHWTNTT (i e. Sanskrit SINN eRfr: TJH-
HHTNFO or Hindi ! QH«rHTr) ; but “ Luke wrote a Gospel”
is ^i^jr sjhhHTNIN (i. e., Sanskrit ^r%sr %f«slcr: TIHHHTHKb or Hindi
fls,
NtHT Vf f^figx uqviHHr^n:)- A few other examples are : HTTP? Nthtt
VNT HiT ITT H^HNK HT3 Y<T HHTN1 HTT TNHT *• e., High Hindi %?; VfJiy STTWH
Hf% 5V if h« Hi"? TH «sf r hnt Nr (Lit. Sanskrit HTOTfa srJT^N? HraTj HT%-
<TfH HHr HTHNTHHlHDT ^7f: nmrfHH: Urf: f^jTrs) St. Luke i, 20, 27.
Again, <3 HTfHH f*fff rrrs^Ti H HT eft fvjr. i. e., High Hindi HN vhj
HNN % NTH ntj^tT hn! JpTt vft (or Sanskrit NT HoTT S<TT St.
Luke i, 27. Again, ht ftsfil W *- e., High Hindi Vfpr fsivrn ^TT
NHT % (or Sanskrit Ndi gffi-TsfHl) St. Luke i, 14. Again, ^ NlHir HNJT Hit
%T NT irsf Hf-HHI nht i. e., High Hindi hh H(H> 'fft war NrTlHT
SNr. In this last example, the participle %f and the genitive affix qrr
are side by side.*
Whichever be thought the more probable derivation of HTT, either from
'fT'T or f'fT'p — and this can only be decided after a more thorough examina-
tion of the earliest Gaurian literature — I hope, I have succeeded in proving
so much beyond doubt, that the Sanskrit participle eid is in one form or the
other the original of the genitive post-positions.
There remains briefly to consider the post-positions in the other Gau-
rian languages. In the case of most of them my remarks are not meant to be
* A very similar, thougli not quite so parallel case is that of vjj, a past participle
of NT*TT, to he, which still occurs in the Ganwari, and is also met with now and then in
Tulsi Das. It stands for the High Hindi aTN (Sanski’it W«T- ), and the Low Hindi WHT,
or HHT- It occurs, for instance, in the following verse of Tulsi Das,
NH HTf# HT HVfH NHHWIT II i. e.
High Hindi : HHf SHT Hv TNT N NHHTH II
Sundar kand.
HT is, a curtailment of the Low Hindi VRT or HHT, which are both probably de-
rived from a Prakrit (for Sanskrit Wjfi) . Prom Hfq^f, by the elision of
would come VltHHT, Vli)T, WHT, and from the same, by the elision of both ^ and H, would
come «?;NT = N*TT = HUT. Another parallel case, I believe, wo have in the syllable
31T (femhnno Hi, plural H), which forms the Hindi future tense ; e. g., tHAI, he will be
For it stands probably for HHT, the Hindi past participle of NTHT, to go ; and JTHT itself
is connectedjvith the Sanskrit Hrfb and Prakrit HHT or (with insertion of an eupho-
nious *0 HHT- Compare also HI in the Low Hindi phrase HT 5JTHT, to bo found,
for HINT 5JT«TT, and HIT, the Low Hindi for Hffi, what ?
139
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
more than suggestions of their probable origin, founded partly on the fact of
the common origin of all Gaurian languages, partly on Prakrit analogies.
In the Marathi genitive post-positions ^T, a simple transforma-
tion of the guttural of <rr, yft, ^ into a palatal has taken place. For
the rest they must be derived from the Sanskrit a<T in the same manner as
'fiT, ^1, %. There is only one other instance known to me in Marathi of such
a change of gutturals and palatals : it is that of the Sanskrit fyr rl?C barba-
rian into the Maharashtri which is the subject of a special rule in
the Prakrits Prakasa (II. 33.) But the change is physiologically very easy
(cf. Max Muller, Science of Languages Lect. Ill, page, 155 vol. 2nd), and by
no means uncommonin the Aryan languages in general (cl. Bopp, Comp. Gram.
§ 14 page 25).*
The origin of the Panjabi, Sindhi and Gujarati post-positions I explain
alike, in a manner similar to that in which I have explained the Bangali
and Oriya post-positions y and yy ; viz. that they have originated from a
Prakrit form of tRH by the elision of the initial consonant 3fT and contraction
(by Sandh i) of the two adjoining vowels.
The original of the Panjabi post-positions yr, y), y is the form yiyT or
fyriy ; probably the latter. t Take for instance the genitive of horse.
It may be assumed to have been originally i|l% fyryT. % Here the original
* I had written tlie above remarks when I received a copy of the Student’s
Manual of Marathi Grammar. In the appendix on the grammatical forms which occur
in old Marathi poetry, a few forms are given which confirm my thooiy in a remarkable
way. The old form of the masculine and the neuter ^ is there (page 138) stated
to be reap. and Now represents a Prakrit form and is the
very form which, a few pages back, I postulated as tho immediate original of tlie
Hindi 3TT (taking yi and ^ to be interchangeable letters) and about which I expressed
a hope that a more thorough examination of the oldest Gaurian literature might bring
to light traces of it. I, there, derived *RT (or thus : Sanskrit fSH:, Prakrit
= fyr% (or f%%) = either (or f^T) or *1 (or (or ^T). The
derivation of ^T( in the same grammar page 132) from the Sanskrit genitive affix
W is untenable. 1 stly, because even if *8 could be the original of V, it certainly
could not bo so of tho older from fW 2 ndly. The Sanskrit * is unchangeable,
while is capable of forming case, number, and gender. 3rdly. Against the Sans-
krit derivative affix as well as against the inflexional affix HI all those objections
lie which I have pointed out with reference to the derivation of the Hindi ^1 from the
Sanskrit affix or w)v.
t The Panjabi dictionary of tho Lodiana Mission gives a form Ty^iT, a preposition
or genitive particle. If this can bo trusted, it would seem to indicate that the initial ^
of the Panjabi post-positions is a modification of the original ^ of f%yT See on this
interchange of the guttural and dental class, Bopp’s Comparative Grammar, § 401.
$ I must reserve the explanation of the inflected from UP? for another paper.
18 F
140 Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
meaning of was no more felt ; it had become like a mere affix and
had assumed an enclitic position, forming one word with Hence, as in
compound words, the (now medial) consonant 31 was elided, and the two ad-
joining vowels 5+1 contracted (by dropping c) ; thus we have iff'
— hlir Finally as in High Hindi the harsh diphthong % was changed to
the more agreeable vowel ; thus iri% gT. The process here assumed is
well illustrated by the origin of the interrogative pronoun who. In
Prakrit the interrogative pronoun *fiT ( = Sanskrit qr:) has almost invariably
appended to it, the enclitic thus #7 here the consonant^ is
always elided ; thus 'SW ; in the Gaurian again the two adjoining vowels
^ are contracted (by dropping 'S ), thus ^vr*T-*
The Sindhi post-positions 3H, 5j), 5J, aiT may have originated from the
form f+frilT (= farijT = %^t), by exactly the same process as explained above
in the case of 37 ; thus f^rer = =» %1% hb Finally the ini-
tial semivowel U of hi would change, according to a general rule of the
Prakrit (P. P. II, 31) and Gaurian, into the palatal consonant 5?; thus
ifT-t
The Gujar&ti post-positions (vf), sf, etc.) I am inclined to derive from
an obsolete Prakrit form of sfirl\ via. fsfiieT or fiuiT in the same way as the
Panjabi 37 from or the Sindhi an from f3SUT. That such a Prakrit
form must have once existed, is clearly proved by the Hindi. In poetry, an
old Hindi form 3Tr37 or qftvrT often occurs equivalent to made or done.
Two other old Hindi past participial forms, exactly analogous to them, also
occur in poetry, vie. Cl5?! or g+vTT given (= Sanskrit 3t1:) and or ^friTT.
taken (= Sanskrit Now the derivation of 3^Hl is well assured
Here I will only say that I consider the termination ^ to be a modification of the
Sanskrit genitive termination ^i*SJ (of bases in XI), which in Prakrit becomes (or
SJjThf or ^1N) or if The enrtailment of 'i3fi3T or 3! into must be supposed to
have taken place contemporaneously with the modification of the Prakrit termination
or^TN or hi into the Gaurian 'I (Hindi, Panjabi, Sindhi) or ^iT (Mar. Gujar.).
* A Prakrit lingual ^ generally changes into the dental *T in Hindi. In the
Alwar dialect the pronoun is still #T53*T ; in the Ganwarf and in Hindi poetry (e. g. of
Chand Bardai) it is compare in Marathi "^7 fourth for the Prakrit It
may be noticed also that ths vowels T and ^ which are elided, are preceded by their
own corresponding diphthongs X and ^1T.
+ The Sindhi post-positions admit, however, also of a different explanation. Their
initial Straight bo merely a softening of the initial which we have in the Marathi.
As a somewhat parallel case we may compare the Nipali Hi (they are), to which corre-
sponds in the Low Hindi of Alwar If and in High Hindi (i. e. Sanskrit Hprl).
$ Of these pairs those containing the are later and occur generally in Tulsi
141
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Qaurian Languages.
According to the Prakrit Prakasa VIII, 62, the participal past passive of the
root to give is in Prakrit (for Sanskrit ^vf) and from by a regu-
lar process of phonetic modification, which I shall explain later on, the form
originated. By analogy it follows that the other two forms «fri«rr
and ^ftvrT must also be derived from original Prakrit forms fqfnj and (of
the roots a and « ). It is true that neither far«J nor f^nir are supported by
any of Vararuehi’s Sutras, nor by the Prakrit of the plays founded upon those
Sutras. But as the process of phonetic change was certainly not stop-
ped by Vararuchi’s Sutras, the phase of Prakrit exhibited in his Sutras can-
not be taken as a measure of what Prakrit may have been at a much later
period. There is not the least difficulty, therefore, in assuming that the
Prakrit of later times and perhaps among the vulgar, contained many forms
which have not found admittance in Vararuchi’s Sutras or in dramatic Pra-
krit. Among those later or more vulgar forms fqrcT and must have
heen.f Their existence is necessary to account for the existence of the
Das. The others. without V are the more original onos and occur for example in Kabir
Chand ; e. g.,
>5fT ^irsi*5 |
5T5T 5S15T S*JJT ifipfl II *. e.
High Hindi : mi V(T^S( TVVT |
HI TJI-irT -if f^UT II
Tulsi Das Ramayan, Ajudhya Kami.
Again : 57Tfv qTtT % *JtpTT ^TT I
IlST fV ~Pf=TT II i. e.
High Hindi : 3T^T 3iT% IJtPTT f^T I
^^rfT ^ ^T% %T f^TUT II
Kabir, Rekhtas.
Again : JT5T 3ipr I
Wt ^ II i. e.
High Hindi : 3TT -til fa»=qT I
^rai ^ q^r ii
Pr. R&j Ray., I, 1 1 .
Again : '-FIV ill ?jfif a^f 1
VIPS J2W qiVT 11 i. e.
High Hindi : 35JT HiKST fqf *JT1 «q faVT I
fllff %I V*I BsTST II
Pr. Eaj II tv., 1, 18.
* The dontal «T for original qt according to general Hindi usage.
t In P. P. vm, 13, it is stated the root IF or IF r may change
he does for (= Sanskrit q>Tlf<T). Prom tffqr a past, part,
®ay be derived and it is not improbable, that giW might ohange into by the
analogy 0f just as e. y.q^q man changes into qf^V ; of. P, P, I, 33.
into sp1?; e. g.
passive ~qi,Tf
112
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
forms eftsn and sft^rr which certainly do exist. From an original Prakrit
fw then, through the intermediate modification ^t*TT, I think the Gujarati
genitive post-positions «ir, &c., may be derived.
Having thus explained the derivation of the various Gaurian post-posi-
tions of the genitive, I now proceed to state another important evidence in
support of my theory. I have shown that the word was used in two
different ways in Prakrit to express the genitive, viz., 1st, as a mere affix, in
which case it was compounded with the word which was to he put into the
genitive ease ; 2nd, as a pleonastic insertion, in which case the word which
was to he put into the genitive case, retained its organic genitive inflexion.
Now I have tried to prove that the Bangali post-positions VX and and the
Oriya post-position K are derived from the Prakrit employed in the for-
mer manner. On the other hand the Hindi post-position ^ s:t (%<fb ) are
derived from the same Prakrit employed in the second manner and the
Hindi post position qrr (qft, %) as well as the post-positions of all Gaurian
languages of the Hindi class (i. e. Naipali, Marathi, Gujarati, Sindhi, Panjabi,
hut exclusive of Bangali and Oriya) are derived from the Prakrit form
(fcffVT respectively), also employed in the second manner. This accounts why
the initial was lost iu Bangali and Oriya, while it was retained in Hindi,
Naipali and Mari. (hi. It is true was dropped (if my derivation be true)
in the Panjabi, Sindhi and Gujarati ; but this is accounted for by the cir-
cumstance that though the wordsfV^l and f^mr remained independent words,
yet being only pleonastic, they became enclitic, and hence liable to phonetic
corruption in the initial letters by contact with the principle word, on which
they leant. However the main point to which I wished to call attention is
this, that if my theory of explanation of the genitive post-positions of the
Hindi class of the Gaurian languages is true, it may be expected that traces of
their being •& pleonastic insertion, and of the existence of an organic genitive
of the inflected word will have remained. A few such traces, I think, I can
prove to exist, and considering the extent to which phonetic decay has gone
in the modern languages of India, I think they are sufficiently distinct and
remarkable.
In Hindi poetry, such combinations as wf? srtt, ^t, rrtfl? (all
= or or sftVj (— ssr) &c., are not uncommon ; e. g.,
stw -vjjl serif HTMT II i. e.
High Hindi: % fa* % ^iir WtWT 'u*?! aiMt n
Sura Das, Stirs agar, Ragvilasa.
Or : «irhf ?rrr? #t ii i. e.
High Hindi : « % <sif n
Ibidem, 162.
1872.] Hoernl e— Essays on the Gauricm Languages. 143
Or : % vfTj -z\€\ §ttt ^'vr u i. e.
High Hindi : fire # s? f?re % sv ntt ii
Kabir’s Rekhtas.
Now these forms Tip? or <Ttl%! or ^T[f%, or snf?, oTf%, wt%>
&c., are nothing hut phonetic corruptions of the Sanskrit genitives ?r^J,
V<g, &c. No doubt when standing by themselves they are commonly used
to express the dative case and even any other case (ablative, instrumental,
locative) ; but that is owing to the fact (i) that the dative case has disap-
peared altogether from the Prakrit and the Gaurian, and has been substituted
by the genitive and (ii) that in poetry all case-signs (or post-positions) are
generally omitted. But instances are not wanting where those forms are
used even by themselves in the sense of the genitive ; e. g.,
gnf% w;t»s % l «• e.
High Hindi : fsre ^ ^ ^ ^ $ 11
Rajniti, page 3.
Or : vi qqm aH*TT t
J
II *'• e.
High Hindi : re ^1 sired ^ I
xsx# 'sj« 4rV W I'
Tulsi Das Ramayan, Sundarkand.
2 In the High Hindi the interrogative pronoun %r*r forms its genitive
the relative sir forms fare^T, the demonstrative forms fire^r,
forms <3fl«*r. re forms rrerr. These forms fare. f®PT, fare, T*T have
never been explained. The fact, however, is that they are by themselves al-
ready full genitives so that fare^TT. fare &o., are in reality double ov pleo-
nastic genitives. In Prakrit there are two forms of the base of these pronouns,
one ending in ^f, the other in X (viz. qfr and fair, 31 and faff, 7T and far of which all
T bases, with the solitary exception of fare what have been lost in Sanskrit).
The bases far, fsj, fir, are in the Prakrit, as we know it now, restricted ge-
nerally to the feminine ; but that originally it was not so, is proved by the
fact that in the masculine the forms fafffnT, fsreT, farntr of the instrumental
case occur as alternatives besides are, nit. Now the genitive of the
masculine bases fair, faff, far is fW faPS(feminine far^T, fan^r, fap^T ;
for the Sanskrit fffrej, faf^J farei ; feminine etc. by the common rule
of the Prakrit of assimilating dissimilar compound consonants, cf. P. P. Ill,
2.) In the modern dialects there is a general rule, that where the Sanskrit has
two dissimilar consonants adjoining and the Prakrit turns these into two
144 Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
similar consonants, the Gaurian elides one of the latter and lengthens the
preceding vowel.* The following examples will illustrate this rule :
is all from Prakrit and Sanskrit The genitive fanjf,
&c., are also exceptional and become in Hindi , f%3, ffRI, &c. It follows,
therefore, that the forms fanofTT etc. are pleonastic genitives. Rendered in
Prakrit they would be fqr<^T (or #•%?), etc., with which may be
compared the genitive #T3i quoted above on page 23.
3. In most Gaurian languages the termination of the noun in inflexion,
i. e. when followed by post-positions, undergoes some change, generally into
y or ^T; e. g., Hindi iu^gr genitive 31% 3ii; Marathi genitive %T3T. These
inflexional forms, I believe, to be simply modifications of the old organic geni-
tives of the Sanskrit. I must content myself, however, here with this simple
statement, and reserve the substantiation of it to a future paper on the in-
flexional bases of nouns.
Essay III.
On the Inflexional Ease of Nouns.
In the former essay I promised a paper on the inflexional base of Gau-
rian nouns. The present essay will be devoted to this subject, the dis-
cussion of which, it seems best to insert here, as it offers an important con-
firmation of the theory set forth in the former essay, and a foundation for
the treatment of the other inflexional post-positions in the subsequent essays.
In most Gaurian languages, there are classes of nouns which exhibit a
different form when placed in connexion with post-positions (i. e. in all
oblique cases) from that which they have when they stand by themselves
(i. e. in the nominative case). The former form I shall call the oblique
form ; it is identical with what is often called the inflexional base. The
* Traces of this law aro seen already in Prakrit, e. g., Sanskrit becomes in
Prakrit w or .see P. P. VI, 5 ; or Sanskrit , Prakrit or : Sanskrit
Prakrit WYt or ; Sanskrit Tift, Prakrit Yr%t or Y!‘<1 or Ylf i see
P. P. Ill, 58.
f Also true, from Prakrit and Sanskrit YT3I; bat in Naipali regularly
3T3.
145
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
form of the noun in the nominative case I shall distinguish as the direct
form.
In the present essay these forms of the noun in the plural will be
altogether set aside, as in some Gaurian languages they are of a nature,
altogether different from that of these forms of the noun in the singular. For
the present I must assume this ; the proof will he given afterwards in another
essay. But it will greatly simplify the enquiry to confine our attention for
the present to the singular.
In the Hindi only one class of nouns possesses an oblique form in
the singular ; viz., all masculine nouns the direct form of which ends in
such an "ajr, as is a modification of the Prakrit nominative sing, masculine
termination %. The oblique form differs from the direct form in chang-
ing the termination to X ; e. g., nominative ur®T horse, genitive
«fT[ ; u«TT large, 3\T &c. The above definition implies that all those
nouns have passed info the Hindi from the Prakrit and, therefore, excludes all
such nouns ending in as have been transferred to the Hindi direct from
the Sanskrit or Arabic ; e.g., TT5TT king, firm father, mrm God, WT priest,
God, &c. All other nouns, whether masculine or feminine, have no oblique
form differing from the direct form ; e. g., nominative, fum father, genitive
fum «TTT ; sr^r water, genitive ; m^rf gardener, genitive m
devotee, gen. daughter, genitive uft 3fr ; m«T (fern.) word, gen.
mw ^TT, &c.
The Panjabi agrees with the Hindi in every particular ; e.g., nominative
boy, gen. ; but ^rirnr soul, gen. ^nwr ^1 ; man, gen. ;
herdsman, gen. father, gen. ^ ; mni crow, gen.
m ; calamity, gen. *H?TT ; *rri mother, gen. TTP3 m ; ft daughter, gen.
tfj m- To the masc. nouns in must be counted also those termmating in
agj ; e. y.,Wta)f shopkeeper, gen. mm ^T. (See Panjabi Grammar of the
American Mission in Lodiana).
The Sindlii follows the Hindi and Panjabi with this qualification, that
it retains the Prakrit termination 'iff, and that, therefore, to the Hindi
and Panjabi class of nouns in m correspond in Sindlii the nouns ending in
%. The oblique form changes the tenninations m of the direct form into
V , as Hindi and Panjabi ; e. g., nominative i(T^r horse, gen. oTT ; but
man, gen. ; 5Tn?T woman, gen. STT^T 51 t; word, gen. Jl.r? mT ;
Uufl mare, gem urfl mr ; m^f t bread, gen. TTl^fl sir & c. (See W . H. Wathen’s
Sindlii Grammar).
The Naipali and Gujarati again agree with the Sindhi, with this excep-
tion that they change the termination Vjf of the direct form into of the
oblique form instead of if. Similarly the Gujarati neuter nouns in ^
change their final in the oblique form into mj ; e. g.,
116
[No. 2,
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
Naipali ; nominative word, gen. fiVT gsT ;
but
VT5TT king
^rsfnvr son
trfs course
lord
^3TT *»TT
*IWIPT SfiT
vte 357
w
(Examples from St. Luke’s Gospel.)
gen. -SJVT »TT
but
(See Grammar of Shapurji Edalji.)
It is manifest that all these Gaurian languages allow an oblique form
only to such nouns as have passed directly or immediately from the Prakrit
into the Gaurian, which form part, as it were, of the original stock of voca-
bles with which the Gaurian started on its way of development, when it
first began to become a distinct language beside Prakrit. These nouns
(viz. those which admit of an oblique form) I shall always in future dis-
tinguish briefly as the Pralcritic elements of the Gaurian.
Besides these Pralcritic elements of the Gaurian, there is another class
of nouns in the above-mentioned languages (viz. Hindi, Panjabi, Sindh i,
Gujarati, Naipali, which I shall in future call for brevity’s sake the Hindi-
class Gaurian), the naturo of which is unmistakable to any one acquainted
with the phonetic peculiarities of Prakrit and Sanskrit. They are purely
Sanskrit. As the Prakrit tolerates no compound consonant in the begin-
ning, nor a dissimilar compound consonant in the middle of a word ; further
as it generally either changes a medial surd mute consonant to the corre-
sponding sonant one, or elides it altogether ; and as it generally changes
an aspirate mute consonant to the simple aspirate it follows, that, 1, every
Gaurian word containing a compound consonant in the beginning or a dis-
similar compound consonant in the middle must be Sanslcritic (barring of
course all foreign words) ; 2. Most Gaurian words containing a medial
surd mute or aspirate are Sanslcritic, e. //., wrath is in Hindi both JfiTt) and
147
1872.] Iloenile — Essays otl the Oaufian Languages.
5 but the latter is Prakritie, whereas the former is purely Sanskritic ;
again or 3TT>q work are Sanskritic, but ^TTW or 3fT3f are Prakritie ; again
written is Sanskritic, but f%*gT or is Prakritie, &c. &c*
All such nouns I shall call the Sanskritic elements of the Gaurian. It
needs no proof to show that this Sanskritic element is the most modern
part of the Gaupan ; modern, that is, not absolutely, but relatively to the
other elements ; for the presence of some of the Sanskritic element dates
from some centuries. But a very slight examination of the Hindi liter-
ature will show that this Sanskritic element is least present in its oldest
specimens, and that it increases in proportion as the date of the literature
approaches our own times. In the High Hindi it preponderates very large-
ly, and, as I have already remarked in the introductory essay, its intro-
duction is still progressing.
Now what happens when we see a Sanskrit word naturalised, as it
were, in the Gaurian (High Hindi) ? It is simply taken in the form
of the Sanskrit nominative sing. In this form it remains stereotyped in the
Gaurian and serves as the Gaupan Inflexional base for all cases, the nomin-
ative, as well as the oblique ones ; e. g., wise is in Hindi fsHTW, gen.
3TT. This inflexional base is nothing but the nominative sing, of the
Sanskrit word (or rather base) Again soul is in Hindi 'sjriJTr (with
gen. ^T(Str 3>r) which is merely the Sanskrit nominative sing, of the base
The same word occurs in Hindi also in the Prakritie form '3?PT (for Prakr.
in the sense of an honorific term of address. It follows from this as
the distinctive principle of the (Hindi-class) Gaurian, f that they have 1,
lost the power of forming organic inflexions of a noun (as the Sanskrit and
Prakrit do.) 2. That they leave their inflexional bases unchanged and
indicate their inflexion by post-positions, and 3, that they use as their bases
the nouns in the nominative singular belonging to a former and now
fossil state of the language {viz., to Sanskrit or, as we shall presently see, to
Prakrit) ; having thus become unconscious of the already inflected nature
of its nouns.
It has been now shown that the Prakritie element of the (Hindi-class)
Gaurian contains all those norms which admit of an oblique form , and
* These are only a few of the more broad and general criteria. There are others
also; e. g., in the High Hindi (not in the low Hindi of Alwar) every lingual nr of the
Prakrit (which, as is well known, not only retains all Sanskrit lingual tn but changes
even every single, dental «T of the Sanskrit into the lingual p ) is changed into a dental
•f oven in those cases whore the Prakrit represented the original Sanskrit nr Hence
every Hindi word containing a lingual nr must be Sanskritic ; e. g., to do is
Prakritie, but to do and Bfrprp cau3° are Sanskritic; ear is Prakritie, but
ear Sanskritic, &c.
t I. e.t of the Gauj*ian after its fall development as a distinct and separate lan-
guage ; leaving out of account, therefore, the Prakritie element, which represents a
state of the Gaurian, when it was not yet distinct from Prakrit.
19
a
148 Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
that all Sanskritic elements (of the Gaurian) belong to that class of nouns
which admit of no ohlique form, a class which is much more extensive than
the other. But Sanslcritic elements do not account for the whole of the nouns
belonging to that class. There are many nouns in this class which 1., ex-
hibit all the phonetic peculiarities (enumerated above) of the Prakrit ; which
2., have the form of the nominative sing, of the Prakrit ; and which 3., pre-
serve this form unchanged in all cases (i. e., do not admit of an oblique
form), indicating their inflexion by post-positions ; e. g., elephant is in Hindi
it is identical with the Prakrit nominative singular (= Sanskrit
nominative singular of the base vrmvf ), and is in Hindi the ( inflexion-
al) base of which the nominative is the gen. TIrit 357, &c. From
this we conclude, 1., that all these nouns have been transferred to the
Gaurian not from the Sanskrit, but from the Prakrit ; but 2., that they were
so transferred not before the distinctive principles of the Gaurian had fully
established themselves, i. e., after the Gaurian had finally and entirely-
replaced the Prakrit as a separate and distinct language. These nouns,
therefore, have an altogether different nature from those nouns which con-
stitute the Prdkritic elements of the Gaurian. The latter are the earliest
elements of the Gaurian which were transferred to it from the Prakrit at that
early time when the principles of the Gaurian were not yet formed, but
only in process of formation ; when as yet the Gaurian was only a much
decayed dialect of the Prakrit. Hence the Prakritic elements have a mixed
character, half Prakrit, half Gaurian ; Prakrit they are in showing traces of
organic inflexion, vie., in the oblique form (as differing from the direct form
of the nominative) ; Gaurian, in preserving their oblique form unchanged in
all oblique cases alike, indicating the difference of the various oblique cases
by post-positions. On the other hand the other Prakrit nouns entered the
Gaurian when its principles were fully formed ; and, therefore, becoming sub-
ject to the force of those principles, they were fully assimilated by the Gaurian.
I shall therefore in future denominate all such nouns as the proper Gaurian
elements of the Gaurian, to distinguish them from the Prakritic elements
on the one hand, and from the Sanskritic elements on the other hand.*
Thus we have seen that the whole of the Gaurian nouns are divided
into three classes. z. The Prdkritic element containing all nouns, which
admit an oblique form. 2. The proper Gaurian element containing one part
* By tlie term te Gaurian element” only, I shall designate both the proper
Ga/urian and the Sanskritic elements together. For all Gaupian nouns may be divided
thus : —
1. Prdkritic nouns, i. e.f admitting an oblique form.
2. Gaurian nouns, i. e ., not admitting an oblique form,
a. Gaurian proper.
b. Sanslcritic.
1872.] Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. 149
of the nouns which do not admit an oblique form. 3. The Sanskritic
element containing the remaining part of the nouns which do not admit an
oblique form. And from what has been explained above, it follows further
that these three elements or classes represent three, in the main, successive
stages in the development or periods in the history of the Gaurian lan-
guages. The PrdJcritic element exhibits the Gaurian in its earliest stage
(probably before 800 A. D.) Next comes the proper Gaurian element
which shows the Gaurian in its middle stage (extending probably from
about 800 to 1300 A. D.) Lastly comes the Sanskritic element showing
the Gaurian in its modern form (beginning probably with about 1300
A. D.)
I may remark here en passant, that the nouns (now post-positions) %T
(Naipali), (Hindi) ; (Panjabi), 5TT (Sindhi), «rr (Gujarati), since they
exhibit the phonetic peculiarities of the Prakrit (for they stand for the
Prakrit [fai^T or 3iT37 or rather for] or and the. Sanskrit
[sRri: or) as explained in Essay II), and since they admit of an
oblique form (i. e., ^TI, if, 'ft), belong to the Prakritic element of the
Gaurian and hence to the earliest period of its history ; to that tune of its
history, in fact, when it was yet merely a modification of Prakrit. The
Gaurian was not established as a separate and distinct language until after
these nouns had assumed fully the nature of mere inflexional post-positions.
This fact it is important to bear in mind, when we come afterwards to the ex-
planation of the nature of the oblique form of nouns ; and also because, as
it will be observed, it tends to confirm the theory of the origin of the geni-
tive post-positions, given in Essay II.
Another point I may also dispose of here, before I pass on to the
examination of the oblique form in the remaining Gaurian languages,
(Marathi, Bangdli, Uriya). It has been stated that it is a principle of the
Hindi-class Gaurian languages that they assume as their inflexional bases
the nouns of their parent languages (Prakrit and Sanskrit) in the form of
the nominative singular and preserve this form throughout in all cases.
Here two phonetic laws come into play which have the curious effect of
making the terminations of many Sanskritie and proper Gaurian nouns,
which would otherwise have been widely different, identical ; so that looking
simply at the termination, it would be impossible in some cases to judge,
to which class of elements such nouns belong. These two phonetic laws
are ; first, the well known law, that final short vowels in Gaurian are
quiescent or not pronounced, so that a word, though ending in reality in a
short vowel, virtually terminates in a consonant and is treated accordingly.
In most Gaurian grammars such nouns and those ending really in conso-
nants are considered alike as constituting the consonatal declension and are
subject to identical rules of inflexion. Eor clearness of distinction jn these
ISO Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
essays, all Gaupan words really ending in consonants will have the Viba'ma
(furru) appended to them while those which end only virtually in conso-
nants (but really in short vowels) will be written without it ; e. g., q\T*T ear
is pronounced kan not kiina, and treated exactly like wise (pro-
nounced budhiman, not budhimana). This explains also how it happened
that some words which really end in ^ or 'a come to be written as if ending
in vj. The truth is, that they are not really written with a final % but
their final X or not being pronounced, was also not written.* The tran-
scription of the word assimilated itself to the pronunciation ; e.g., 'YTJT fire
seems at first sight by the analogy of ^TT*T, &c., to bo really aga though
pronounced only ag ; hut this is only in appearance, in truth stands for
^Tf*I (Prakrit Sanskrit vjfjp), but as final Y was not pronounced, it
was also suppressed in writing. So again the modern High Hindi hav-
ing done stands for the older Low Hindi qifY (Prakrit q\fY3(, Sanskrit
STSfr), which lias dropped its final ?, hi accommodation to the pronunciation.
In poetry, indeed, ^Rl, qrv and other nouns of the same nature are commonly
treated as if termmating in 'Sj (i. e., aga, kara, not as ag, lcar,) but this is
merely because according to the native grammatical system, the vowel “?(
is supposed to he inherent in every consonant.
The second law is this, that a final diphthong or long vowel of the Pra-
krit is reduced by the Gaurian to its inherent simple vowel. The inherent
simple vowel of is of Y and x it is X, of ill and ^ it is In Prakrit
all masculine bases in ^ terminate in the nominative singular in % or q (cf.
Pr. Prak. V. 1, XI, 10) ; all masculine and feminine bases in X and ^
terminate in the nominative singular in Y and ^ (cf. Pr. Prak. V, 18) ;
all masculine and feminine bases in q|T, Y and ^ terminate in the
nominative singular in ^Ti, Y and <3? respectively. I have shown above that
the Gaurian adopts its nouns from the Prakrit in the form of the nomina-
tive singular of the Prakrit. Now in adopting them in this manner, the
Gaurian reduces their (Prakrit) terminations ^JT, % X, regularly to
their inherent simple vowels "W, X and 'S.f E. //., Sanskrit ^Tfli = Prakrit
* Traces of this phenomenon occur already in Prakrit ; comp. Pr. Prak. 2JI,
10., according to which sutra instead of uij qftjrj (for Skr. qq q-qq:) may be said
and written <rftj qf^fg »s well as vq qf%qr.
t Traces of this law arc not unfrequent already in Prakrit. For the reduction
of % to ,3 comp, Pr. Prak. XX, ii. (e. g., VIY^ for smiling), Y, 19— 20,
(e. S'.,niqnrS for nrqtT'qi garlands). For the reduction of u to ^ comp. Pr. Prak. Y,
22. (e. 3-,qiYY for by a river), XI, 10, ii. ( e . S-, qf^rfrj for qf%q) a man), VI, 6. (e.g.,
^iY ^or °f whom). The reduction of a final ^gp x, "3! occurs only, when they
are the final of the first part of a compound ; see Pr. Prak. IY. i. (e. g., f°r
the bank of the Jumna; VIT.) fYI f°r VYVI^i the river-stream ;
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. 151
3tTT becomes in Gaurian srirr* This is the Proper Gaurian form beside
which the Gaurian possesses the word also in the Sanshritic form utvit. The
earliest Gaurian form of ^Irf is ^t(, which is as nearly as possible like the
Prakrit utit. It occurs e. g., in Chand’s Prithiraja Rayasa (III. 64) ;
z(ti fnf? «r irr, i. «rr?r »nPf ^ ii Again
Sanskrit = Prakrit becomes in Gaurian *^35. a form which
occurs very commonly in Hindi poetry ; similarly poetical Hindi has
gain for Prakrit ~r%T = Sanskrit ; or order, command for Prakrit
== Sanskrit ^T^w: ; e. //., in Tulsi Das’s Ramayan.
sitP? 1
^ vl ^
*3T cRToT rlV RTiW-T II i. e.
H. H. fare R>r nvrhRvr id 1
*rr csi*i 11
Ayodhya Kand.
Beside these a great many other such nouns in ^ are met with in
poetical Hindi ; in fact, I have no doubt, every noun, that now in Hindi
prose ends in ^.f What is, thus, a form confined in Hindi to the old and
poetic language, appears in Sindhi to he preserved in the common modem
language. Dr, Trumpp says : “ The old Prakrit ending in o has in Sindhi
been split up into two great classes, one of which has corrupted the Prakrit
(final) o into u, the other has preserved it unchanged.” He adds : “ It
is noteworthy that many words which in Sindhi end in o, in Hindi end in
a, while on the other hand the short final u in Sindhi has in Hindi been
thrown away or become quiescent.” (Of. Journ. Germ. As. Society, vol.
XVI, p. 131). Also in the common modern Naipali an important instance of
that form has been preserved. The nominative plural is there formed by
adding to the noun. Now is nothing else but a modification of the
Prakrit %Tt, Sanskrit ifc: multitude. Though this form has disappeared from
for T having a woman’s faoe), but comp. Pr. Prak. VI, 6 (e. g , for
of what). Note that in Prakrit all these forms are optional, but not in Gaurian. X
may add a few examples from the Mrichchhakatika : —
3VI isuwv ^rf twl 1 e.
Slcr. vpnfg fffir w 11
Again | - Sanskrit fsiv: e (Tiff II
* A few other instances are in Hindi 7312, bed, for Prakrit 7§f~r; Sanskrit 7gipT ;
flute, for Prakrit ^tuif, Sanskrit sjpsjf ; ttflol, shame, for Prakrit Sanskrit
; 5f|U, tongue, for Prakrit (or SftWT ), Sanskrit shade, for
Prakrit -t? T (see Pr. Prak. II, 18.), Sanskrit at mi-
t These archaic forms are very common in poetry, only it should be noted that as
they generally occur at the end of a line, they are usually lengthened to for metre’s
sake.
1872.] Hoernle — JEssays on the Gaurian Languages. 153
Ganwari and in poetical and old Hindi, the original forms still commonly
occur, e. g.,
sr? WlfJT I
?rq -UTK ^nfjt II i. e.
H. H. 5r?t srm htji qr i
rr^t % ^tjt ii
Lanka Kand.
Or srsiffr ^TfJI Wlf^Nrl II i- e.
H. H. STtsral ^TJI II
Prithiraj Rayasa, 1. 18.
Again faff WrT HTft II i. e.
H. H. u* ft ^i’n Pfrni % wet ii
Ayodhya Kand.
Again ^THT jpv’nsrqe" WKW II *'• e.
^Tq >4UT;i5T8^ tTH #T »TT*t II
Ayodhya Kand.
Again fqrrf% wilST ^nft II i. e.
H. H. fqrTT €r ^<OTT ^oa|T ^HiW] ^Tlft II
Lanka Kand.
But also ftf?j nq spfiqr ^'qrr || i. e.
H. H. fq<ri qrr h?i vh qit tlqnr % n
Ayodliya Kand.
In Marathi, where ^TJT and similar words are mutilated in the same
Way (see below), the original r appears again in the oblique eases ; e. g.,
the gen. is ^TJll ’qT. just as nom. qfe. gen. qrit "qT.
An interesting question here arises : why is it that the Prakrit termin-
ation has not always become ^ in Gaurian, hut has remained unchanged
(or become WT as in Hindi, Panjabi and Marathi) in many instances ? e. g.,
while the Braj BhasM forms the Pres. Partic. %T3 being (= Prakrit %m)
the High Hindi has qr<TT, or while the Prakrit becomes in old Hindi
the Prakrit UT^yT, horse, becomes in modern Hindi ii^q (also in
Panjabi, Marathi, or f?T%T in Sindhi, Gujarati). If my previous remarks be
remembered and also that %7J, U*i3, etc., admit of no oblique form , while
%T<TT, iu%T, etc., do admit of one (viz. 3i%, etc.), it will be seen that the
forms %Trj. qws, etc., belong to the proper Gaurian element, while qirTT, qlfT,
etc., belong to the Priihritic element. This, however, is not yet an answer
to the question. The question still remains why did some Prakrit words
ending in qjy not submit to the Gaurian principles, but retained their
In modem Hindi the form (Rao) is limited to being a certain title of
nobility less than Raja, exactly as it is also the case with the form (mentioned
above in the text) , a perfectly parallel formation to
154 Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
Prakritic complexion ? The answer to this question, I believe, to he this :
In Prakrit any nominal ^ase in vj may have two forms as regards the
termination: 1., a general form which it has also in Sanskrit; and 2., a
particular form, peculiarly Priikrit, made by the addition of the affix
efr (gee Pr. Prak. IV. 25) ; e. g., bee is ( general form) or
particular form) ; done is faff (general) or (part.) ; true is
(gen.) or (part.), etc. The consonant qt is generally elided ; hence
The nominative sing, of these cases would be respec-
tively : MHTTorWT^T (for ; f%%orf%^% (for fqnr^r) ; W%T or
(for wi, etc. Now Prakrit nouns may of course pass into the
Gaurian in both or either of these forms. But according as they did so
in their general or in, their particular form, their fate was different. If they
passed into the Gaurian in their particular, peculiarly Prakrit form, they
retained their Prd/critic complexion, and these nouns constitute the Prd-
lcritic element of the Hindi-class Gaurian. On the other hand, if they
passed into the Gaurian in the general form, they readily submitted to the
action of the pure Gaurian phonetic and grammatical principles (that is,
the law to change to and the law of not admitting an obliqtCe form),
and thus these nouns constitute the proper Gaurian element of the Hindi-
class Gaurian. This may bo illustrated again by the present participle ;
“ being” in Prakrit is ^rwir or in both forms it passed into the
Gaurian ; hut the form was contracted to (for %rwir ) and
remained unchanged or modified to ^IrTf (in High Hindi) ; while the form
was changed to (for %rwi). It is easy enough to understand that
the Gaurian termination % (or ^IT) being a contraction of the Prakrit
termination *fi)T could not he reduced to % while the simple termination
% could be so reduced. The same fact, viz. that the Gaurian % is a
contraction of the Prakrit may perhaps explain its curious Braj
Bhasha form tiT ; for the diphthong ( = ^ + + ^) is more strictly an
equivalent of ( i . e., or ^ + *3) than the simple ^T. Farther
proofs of this theory I must defer for the present. I shall have occasion
again to refer to it in the course of this essay.*
» Another theory has been proposed lately by Mr. Beames (Indian Antiquary,
Part V., 1872) which explains the phenomenon by the different accent of the words ;
oxytones retaining the Prakrit termination (or ^l) > and barytones reducing
it to -g- (or ^j) This theory is quite insufficient for the purpose. Mr. Beames him-
self admits that “ it cannot bo said that every oxytono substantive in Sanskrit
gives rise to a noun in 1 or o in modern languages. On the contrary the exemp-
tions to the rule are as numerous as the illustrations of it." This admission, surely,
is fatal to the theory. But though in the case of tioo different oxytone words
it may be possible to show cause, why in the one instance the accent had its legiti-
mate influence, hut not in the other, this is manifestly inadmissible, when it is one
1872.]
155
Hoernle — Essays on tlie Gaurian Languages.
But to return to our enquiry, we have now seen that if a Prakrit
noun having the general form of its base, passed into the Gaurian, it sub-
mitted to the laws of the Gaurian. Hence e. g., the nominative singular
of the Prakrit HH'if would become the inflexional base in the Gaurian
not admitting an oblique form, but remaining unchanged in all cases ; thus
nominative genitive instrumental etc. But the form
of the Gaurian inflexional base is, then, modified to which now
is the unchangeable inflexional base of all cases ; lastly, is modified
to h#? which still remains the unchangeable inflexional base in modern
Hindi. But this process of phonetic corruption has obtained in all modern
Gaurian languages almost without exception, and has reduced all unchangeable
inflexional bases, which originally ended in WT, to the form of the crude
( general ) base in Only in Marathi a few isolated instances of the
original unchangeable inflexional base in remains; e. g., ^7% gain (=
nominative singular Prakrit wr%T = Sanskrit has nominative tjTT^T,
gen. *n%r ^T, dat. wTlxpsiT, etc. In the present poetical and old Hindi it oc-
curs only as ^its, and from the modem High Hindi it has disappeared alto-
gether and has been substituted by the Sanskritio ^rrw. Some other in-
stances in Marathi of the base in are WTTT surprise, *r%T sensation of
burning, 3T[%T moaning, Hl^T bees’ nest.
Confining our attention to the modern Hindi and the example we
find that the modem Hindi possesses also another form of this same word ;
viz., which is also tho unchangeable inflexional base of all cases in
the singular ; thus : nominative #?, gen. ^rr, instr. if, etc.
The difference between them is this, that Jjir? has come into the Hindi
from the Prakrit, and belongs to the Proper Gaurian element, whereas
and the same word which now exhibits tho Prakrit termination sg j (or ^jj), now the
Gaurian reduced termination ^ (or ^j), Now, in Hindi at all events with which
I am more particularly acquainted, every so-called tadbhava adjective may be used
with both forms of the termination i (though no doubt one is more common than the
other) 5 e. g., true is as well as (fern, ^t) ; great is as well as q-gq
(fem. ; y°u may say ^ jj-gyr % as well as JRiV ^ he is a very
vulgar man ; yon may also say ^ ST<T but not NxT ^Tff ^ ; again
it is more idiomatic to say ^ 't t}ian Nx? ^Trf If it be said
that it depends upon circumstances whethor the accent of the some word should
influence the termination or not, then clearly it is not the accent but that ulterior
cause which determines the form of the termination. I think there can bo no doubt
that the roal cause of the difference in the termination is the absence or presence of
the pleonastic affix This accounts most easily and naturally for all tho facts of tho
case. This is no more a mere hypothesis ; though for tho present I must content
myself with stating tho fact ; the proofs, which I hope to bring forward in another
place, amount nearly to demonstration.
156 Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
lias come into it from the Sanskrit directly and belongs to its Sanshri-
tie element, or, as I have explained in the introductory essay, is the
high Hindi substitute for the low Hindi wvry, which is considered to be
vulgar. But what it is important to observe is this, that and
are identical as regards their termination. This is a curious result of the
action of phonetic laws, by which the Proper Gaurian elements, after a
run of centuries through constantly changing forms, return to their original
Sam&ritic form. In the case of and the appearance of the whole
word is so alike, that perhaps it may have sometimes escaped observation
that there is at all a double form of the word of so widely different origin.
But the identity may even go further than this, so that in the case of not
a few words it may be now impossible to determine, whether they are
contributions of the Prakrit or the Sanskrit. The cause of the identity of
termination on the part of the Sanskritic elements of the Gaurian is the
inability of the latter to tolerate a visarga,* and its want of a neuter
gender. All Sanskrit nouns when incorporated into the Gaurian, pass
into it in the form of the nominative singular according to the Gaurian
principle. Thus father is fq<TT, brother is '‘ST'fn, mother is WrTT ; they are
the nominatives singular of the Sanskrit bases fqs, HiS. wa. The proper
Gaurian forms of these words are HH3 or Hr®, wg which are still
in use in the Panjabi, Marathi and poetical Hindi. Now the nominative
singular masculine of Sanskrit bases in % 7, and ^3 ends in a visarga.
Hence the Gaurian which is unable to tolerate a final visarga, elides it, and
therefore practically adopts Sanskrit masculine norms in raj. x. <3 in their
crude base. Sanskrit neuter bases in ?; and ^3 have no inflexional termination
in the nominative singular, and their adoption by the Gaurian makes,
therefore, no difference in their case ; but Sanskrit neuter nouns in v; end
in the nominative singular in fl . The Gaurian languages which do not
possess a neuter gender, f when adopting such Sanskrit neuter nouns, simply
* E. g. Sanskrit becomes in Hindi Sanskrit becomes in
Hindi ^•fiqryyt. Sometimes instead of the usual suppression of the visarga, it is
turned into ^ but only in Low Hindi.
+ This is Btrictly true only as regards Sanskritic nenter nouns. But as regards
Prdkritic neuter nouns most Gaurian languages possess them (another evidence by the
way that these Prdkritic nouns are the oldest element of the Gaurian) ; e. g., the Marathi,
the Gujarati, the old and poetical Hindi (in Chand Bardai) aud present low Hindi
Braj and Alwari dialects. The modern High Hindi, on the other hand, has lost tho
neuter gender throughout. Thus the Sanskrit neuter, part. fut. pass, qfyrij fjvj,
which has passed through the intermediate stage of the Prakrit into the Gaurian
languages is in Marathi Braj sjfrvt, Alwari qsTSf (all neuter) ; while in
the High Hindi it is which latter, by dropping the anuswara of tho Braj,
has beoomo a masculine noun.
157
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
out off the final *i and thus turn them into masculine nouns ;e.g., u 3 forest
becomes «P3, just as rrw: becomes KTP.
We will now pass on to the Marathi. The Marathi differs from the
Hindi class Gaurian languages in having preserved a much larger proportion
of the Prahritic element. It predominates in it very largely over the proper
Gaurian element ; so that of all the Gaurian languages the Marathi is the
most purely Prakritic tongue.
In Marathi by far the greater majority of nouns admits of an oblique
form and therefore, according to the canon previously laid down, belongs
to the Prdkritio element of the language. To the proper Gaurian element,
not admitting an oblique form, only the following nouns belong.*
(1) . All proper nouns and nouns of respect ending in (lnasc. and
fern.), e. g.. TTUT Hama, gen. 77flT =gT, etc. ; but TtTrfT mother
father-in-law, gen. fTrtrt'T ''IT. ^
(2) . All nouns in it, u, %, ; as habit, gen. ^nmi; ftr^ tripod,
gen. fww '37 ; btu%I woman, gen. *37; UT mark on a die, gen. UP3T.
(3) . All masculine nouns in 'S (exc. trrw, ^ rtpP
•IT3F, gur-g-, n, vit'S, wrn?. fw wffT; UPS,); e //., red chalk,
^ (N G\ C\ x ^
gen. jiu UT ; but traveller, gen. 313UTT UP
(4) . All feminine nouns in ^ and 'S (exc. iflt and other monosyllabic
nouns in y, and the following in us, viz. 3TTU>, UP3. Tfra,
h~T, 3P5T, sim, 3P|, TO ^0 ; e. g., JTTUt carriage, gen. Jipft UT ;
chalk ig^^T; but mother-in-law, gen. UTU§ rtT or U13i Ui ; woman
f^UT. _ _
(5) . The following neuter nouns in rt ; viz. . ’UTUU, 'SSlrt,
Us(T~f, mz, * t a?' ■ ari^, Ti3rt^. Ulsi, e. g.,
Ula', 'gen. 'W'UG but* TT? pony, gen. «TET UT, and 7TTU ship, gen. <TTOT UT.
^ ,\f ] those nouns that constitute the proper Gaurian element of Marathi,
are subject to those Gaurian laws which have been already explained ;
namely, they have been taken over from the Prakrit in the form of the
nom. sing, of that language ; and having entered the Gaurian (Marathi)
in that form, they retain it unchanged as their inflexional base of the direct
as well as the oblique cases ; e. g., tTw! elephant, in Prakrit nom. sing, —
Sanskrit uuff (nom. sing, of T>f»?r»r ) has nom. gen. Tpdf'37 instr. vpft u
dat. <gr, etc. Again <3T"iT gain, in Prakrit wtrirT, in Sanskrit 317U :
(nom. sing, of 13 [Hi lias nom. <3T%T, gen. UTT +
* See the Student’s Manual of Marathi Grammar, pp. 28, 29, and the Grammar
of Marathi by Dadoba Pandurang Esq., pp 72, 73.
t All such nouns in ^7 are in reality anomalous ; as according to the ordinary pho-
netic laws of the Gaurian, the final Prakrit % should be reduced to U7 (i. e. first to vgr,
then to *|J)4 Accordingly we find that the nouns in % are only a very few isolated
cases.
158
Hoe rule — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
[No. 2,
But (as in the Hindi class Gaurian languages) that form of the noun
(i, e. the nora. sing, of the Prakrit) undergoes in its passage from the
Prakrit to the Gaufian various phonetic modifications in its termination.
The following are typical examples TTTiT. nom. sing. Prakrit of rre (=
Sanskrit ^tr?: ), changes in the Gaurian its final diphthong to the more
agreeable long vowel ^T, thus ri"*n which, then, remains the unchangeable
inflexional base of all cases. Compare in Hindi uilfr for Prakrit iirfr or
qpg'ijp etc. Again the Marathi frR stands for the Prakrit nom. sing,
(for Sanskrit 5 the medial g is elided, leaving frpit which form
occurs in Marathi as an alternative of ; finally changes to fan
which being now a modification altogether peculiar to the Gaurian (Marathi)
remains an unchangeable inflexional base. The word fanT; illustrates also
another case. It is a feminine noun, which in the sense of tripod does not
occur in Sanskrit, but in Bangdll it is The affix Ti is the peculiar
Gaurian formative of the feminine, and feminine nouns thus formed are
therefore subject to the Gaurian law (of not admitting an oblique form ) ;
e. g., rrfat, carriage, gen. Jifat dat. Jifat ^TT ; fan^, gen. faq?; ^T, dat.
^tt, etc. As the feminine termination x, so also the fern, and masc.
termination is a peculiar Gaurian modification and hence unchangeable
in inflexion ; as in chalk for Prakrit (or »afanrr) = Sanskrit
jsifEc(fT (or perhaps rather for a Prakrit wnTT;? Jfa chalk for Sanskrit hfanfr ;
irs? bamboo for Sanskrit nffinrr and Prakrit nfal, and so foi’th.
So far then (as regards the proper Gaurian element) we have seen, the
Marathi is at one with the Hindi-class Gaurian languages. But they differ in
the treatment of their Sanskritic element. In the Hindi-class Gaurian lan-
guages we have seen the rule is, to treat the Sanskritic element according to
the law of the proper Gaurian of keeping the inflexional base unchanged
in all cases. On the contrary in Marathi the rule is, to distribute all Sans-
kritic and foreign words among the various declensions according to their
final vowels. And thus it happens that while some of them are treated
according to the proper Gaurian law of not admitting an oblique form ;
others come under the law of the Prakritic elements and admit an oblique
form ; e. g., all Marathi nouns in niT (masc. and fern.) are Prakritic ; except
nouns expressing titles or names, which are Gaurian proper. Their analogy
is exactly followed by Sanskritic and, wo may add, foreign words. For
while such Sanskritic nouns as aiJTT, ^TTnfT, THT, etc. (all names), and ?WT,
*e!T^T (Arabic titles), by the analogy of 3’T'^T, 3TT3fT, etc., remain unchang-
ed, thus gen. JtJTf ^r, etc., ■gwT ^7, etc. ; on the other hand, all other Sanskritic
nouns, as fq*TT, >3T<TT, 'HT7TT, nfMT, etc. (all masculine), by the analogy
of the Prakritic words ^pi^TT, etc., form an oblique form , thus gen.
fTrSfT ^T, nnnUT ^T, just like ^T, ; or the Sanskritic nouns
WTWT, fanjT, WrTT. etc. (all feminine), by the analogy of the Prakritic
159
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
nouns unit, Wwrr, etc., form an oblique form, gen. wru ^T, etc., just as
gTfl m, *?i#| 'erT. (In the Hindi-class Gaurian , it must be remembered,
all these nouns are unchangeable ; thus Hindi gen. fb<TT 3>r, ^m?r 'fiT, vitit
^>T, fu^Pfrr, etc.). Again the Sanskritic nouns *n#f, HTHt, etc. (nom.
sing, of etc.) form the gen. sing. KTWr^T, ^TUJT m, gTUJT
^T, by the analogy of the Prdkrittc words etc., which form
gen. wn^jj rfT TlTrHr m Here, however, an option is possible, for the
proper Gaurian noun vfTf), gen. mdT m, also affords an analogy. According-
ly we find that some Sanskritic words have chosen to follow the analogy of
and such like Gaurian words and, according to the Gaurian law, do not
admit an oblique form. Such are the Samkritic nouns ^rt, «RT), ^t, ^wiT,
etc., and the foreign nouns mspi), qfT^t, etc. Here a great deal
of arbitrariness seems to prevail as to the analogy which should be
followed. As regards the nouns in X and ^ (whether masc., fern, or neuter),
they appear to be all Sanslcritic; at least if Dadoba’s grammar represents
the case fairly ; for none of the instances given by him (pp. 7G, 78, 79, 86,
87, 89, 94, 95,) need bo a word derived from the Prakrit ; they are such as
^f%, ^ftr, (masc.), wf%, ajfs, VW, mg (fem.) ; Uifr,
(neuter). It should be remembered that according to the Gaurian law
explained formerly, the final visarga of the Sanskrit nom. sing, is dropped
in the Gaurian ; hence the nouns just mentioned are modifications of the
Sanskrit nom. sing. «tfP'*:,'3if%:,'3lf5rb etc., etc. Now all these Sanslcritic nouns
are treated by the law of the Prukritic elements and admit an oblique form
in long x or It is not very difficult to see the analogy which they follow.
There are in Marathi a good number of feminine nouns in "W which belong
to the Prakritic element and form an oblique form in long X. The reason of
this is simply this, that they are really feminine nouns in short X, which X,
however, according to the Gaurian law explained before, becomes quiescent
and, being also suppressed in writing, is thus apparently changed to *
In an older state of Marathi, no doubt, the original final ? was both written
and spoken (similarly as it has been proved already in the case of Hindi) ;
e. g., fire in Marathi is ^rrfl (which is th o proper Gaurian form of the word,
beside which the Sanskritic form is also used) ; in reality it is
standing for the Prakrit which (by the Gaurian law of shortening
* This law applies strictly only to words derived from Prakrit. In words derived
from Sanskrit the final x (or ^) is often pronounced and, as a rule, always written.
This explains the fact, why all Marathi nouns in ^ (or \3) appear to be Sanslcritic.
Exceptionally, however, the final x may dropped in Sanskritic words ; e. g., 3f rf 3fTrT,
^<T occurs besides 3|ffr, StlffT, (of* Dadobas Grammar, p. 94), and the truth
of the theory stated in the text is confirmed by these nouns, which all form tlioir
■ oblique form in long as gen. Jifft m, Ml-
[No. 2,
160 Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
final long vowels) becomes in Gaurian Marathi and finally ^TJI.
Other such feminine nouns are ftift (for Sanskrit ftrfyjs, Prakrit fVnft) ; it®
(perhaps Skr. (for Skr. ^f®i, Pr. Wt); (for Skr.tp^ft, Pr.
%Pf) ; -u-Nf (for Skr. waift, Pr. q^ft) ; (perhaps for Skr. tj'llf)1 ; iw (for
Skr. Pr. irrl, cf. Pr. Prak. I, G). They form their gen. ^TtPl ^7, fhrft
^T, it®) ^T, ^r, ^T, etc., etc. And following the analogy of these
nouns the Smskritic nouns in S' form their oblique form also in y; ; thus gen.
^T. ^T, Wt ^T. With the Sanslcritic nouns in ^ it is a similar
case, there is a small number of nouns (masc. and fern.) in long '3; which
belong to the Prd /critic element and form their oblique form in long 'S.
Their oblique form is not identical with their direct form, however it may
seem from the form ; on the contrary the termination 'at of the oblique form
is analogous to the termination y; of the oblique form of nouns in y ; while
the termination 'Si of the direct form is the Prakrit substitute for the
Sanskrit final tg: . All such Marathi nouns in 'S; namely, are derived from
bases in '3\ which in Sanskrit form their norm sing, in '3- which in Prakrit
changes to 'at, and is retained anomalously in the Gaurian (instead of being
reduced to r® and then made quiescent). Examples of such nouns are 71 y
mount Meru, etc. The gen. of fly: (or regularly fly) is fl^yT, just as ^TJI
(or ^nfii) forms gen. yjTflt yi. Now following the analogy of these nouns in
'at (or as it ought to bo according to the strict Gaurian law y) the Sans/critic
nouns in y make their oblique form in long 'S ; thus has gen. ;
r^Trj has gen. yffjyr, etc. — Beside that class of feminine nouns in y which
form their oblique form in y, there is another class of feminine nouns in W
which form their oblique form in y ; e. g., 3ff)fl tongue, gen. sftflyT. The final
y of this class is the Sanskrit and Prakrit final yi shortened to y according
to the Gaurian law ; thus 5t)*T stands for the Sanskrit fsjyr, Prakrit sflyr or
gjjflT (cf. Pr. Prak. I. 17.) Now in consequence of the native grammatical
fiction, that the vowel y is inherent in all consonants all foreign feminine
nouns which really end in a consonant, are supposed to end in y ; and hence
it comes to pass that they are treated according to the analogy of the
Prdkritic feminine nouns in y. But as the latter admit a two-fold oblique
form either in y or in y, the foreign feminine nouns also form their
oblique form, some in y, others in V. There seems some rule to obtain
whether they should form the oblique form in y or in y. But I find a
great difference among Marathi grammarians as to that rule; e. g., according
to the Manual all foreign fern, nouns in <T, y, »f make their oblique form
in x. but all abstract nouns formed by the Arabic formative 7T, as rnytH,
<ry)fl, <TKt*3, <TTyflfl, etc., form their oblique form in y. On the
other hand in Dadob&’s Grammar some of the abstract nouns with initial
<T are said to form their oblique form in y, as crytfl ; others as mylfli
rn'Tly) even in yt, as if they were mascul. nouns (according to the ana-
101
1872.] Hoemle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
logy of tho Prakritic masc. nouns in % which will be explained present-
ly). Again while the Manual declines, e. //., stotK chain, beloved
in the gen. rsisftv: ^T, w€li ; Dadoba makes the gen. tariff ^y,
^r, etc. — There remains still to consider the case of the & 'anskritic
nouns in =!j (masc. and neuter). Their final is the resultant of the drop-
ping, according to the Gaurian law, of the visarga and anuswara of the nom.
sing, of the nouns in Sanskrit ; e. //., the Marathi (Sansfcritic) nouns
are modifications of the Sanskrit nom. sing. 3«f. All (non-
Sanskritic) Marathi nouns in belong to the Prakritic element, making
an oblique form in ^ST, and their analogy is followed by the Sanslcritic
nouns in ^ and also by such foreign nouns as really end in a consonant,
but, according to the native grammatical fiction, are supposed to end in
; e. g., as the Prakritic sin? heat (for Skr. ’EfTflh Prakrit sPiiT) ; milk
(for Skr. -^rar, Pr. -^ir ) have in the gen. UnKl^f. ^sfT^T; so the Satiskri-
tic God, etc., have and the foreign nouns fitjy fault, etc., have
gen.
Here the same interesting question arises which I have had occasion
to touch upon when treating of the proper Gaurian nouns in in the
Iiindi-class Gaurian languages. The problem there was to explain the
reason, why, while all Prakrit nouns (having a base in ^f) end in the
nom. sing, in %, in the Hindi-class Gaurian languages some of them
modify % to and retain their Prakritic character in admitting an
oblique form (in V or ^3t), and others modify *5T to ^ and assume the
proper Gaurian nature of not admitting an oblique form. A very similar
phenomenon is exhibited by the Marathi. Here we have 1., Prakritic
nouns in % as ^ milk, nrw heat, vra wing, vflsr sleep, bell,
lip, etc. Their final vf has no doubt arisen by the same process as the
final w of such words in Hindi (as explained above) ; viz., the original
Prakrit termination T changed to '3, and this uJ afterwards become
quiescent and thus, being omitted in writing, was substituted by
These nouns form their oblique form in vjt. thus gen. =JTHT ^T,
•ftwr ^T, etc. 2., Prakritic nouns in *5;T as iffST horse, ’gpirsTT good (in
fact all adjectives in ^JT) which form their oblique form in ^T, thus gen.
SPfir ^t, ’qr, etc. The final in this class of nouns has arisen, as in
the Hindi-class Gaurian, by substituting the more agreeable long vowel
for the harsher Prakrit diphthong In old Marathi and in the pronouns
ilT, 5jT, etc., the original Prakrit diphthong % is still preserved (see Manual
p. 47, rule 84, note).* The difference between these two classes is to be
* According to tho Manual, p. 29, nouns in TttpyT and qui] do not change
in the oblique cases. But this is wrong according to Dadoba’s gr ammar, where p.
74, rule 207, the nouns in quiT are declined exactly as all other nouns in viz., making
an oblique form in thus an,I P- 266, where from the examples of
1G2 Hoemle — Essays on the Qaurian Languages. [No. 2,
explained by the same principle by which the similar difference in the Hindi-
class Gaurian was explained ; viz., that it is caused by a difference in their
resp. derivative bases. The nouns in ^ with an oblique form in ^t, namely,
are derived from the general base of the word in W, but the nouns in ^jT
with the oblique form in from the particular (Prakrit) base formed by
the affix eff (or more accurately as will be shown hereafter, ; e. g., VPFf
is derived from the general base (Sanskrit vil), but hr^rr from the
particular Prakrit base i)Tr?3F (== as = «fFT^r) or Sanskrit
The full discussion and proof of this important principle I must defer till I
come to the explanation of the nature of the oblique form of the inflexional
base of nouns with which it is closely connected. Here I will only note
that a parallel phenomenon is exhibited by the neuter nouns, some of which
terminate in ^5, others in *3? or V or ^ . Of these the former correspond to
the maseul. nouns in ^ ; as the final fT of the latter is a modification of
the Prakrit % and Sanskrit ^f:, so the final "VJ of the former (the neuter) is
a modification of the Prakrit (neuter) termination ^ and Sanskrit ;
again both the masc. and the neuter nouns in ^ make equally their oblique
form in "=5r. On the other hand the neuter nouns in if, gj, correspond to the
maseul. nouns in and form like the latter their oblique form in *jt or ^t,
and are also, like the latter, derived from the particular base in srr or rather
T*fi (perhaps 'a^F ) ; e. g., flnff pearl. = Prakrit wfwFT ( = for Sanskrit
Tlifi p ) 5 TTO branch of a river = Prakrit (or xfp|a|f, see Pr. Prak.
Ill, 36. = Sanskrit ; W tear = Prakrit vksdi (cf. Pr. Prak. IV.
15. for Sanskrit p ^f), etc., etc.
We now proceed to the investigation of the inflexional base in Bangali
and Uriya. These differ from the other Gaurian languages in not possessing
an oblique form at all. Nevertheless it is probable, that these languages are
not altogether destitute of a Priikritic element. In Bangali there are two
post-positions for forming the gen. case ; viz. Vt and Of these vv must
be the original one, for we can imagine vv; having been, in the cours'e of
nouns in ijr^f it appears, that they likewise are declined like ordinary nouns in
5E|f. As regards nouns in HTf^T Dadoba’a statement is confirmed by the Manual itself;
or on p. 63, rule 112. it is said that all part. adj. in as those ending in fj-y)
■'ffT^FT, are declined like ordinary ndjoctives in i. e., making an oblique form in qp.
If nevertheless the first statement of the Manual should be correct, the anomaly
is to be explained thus ; the oblique form of these nouns is not identical witli the
direct form (that is to say these nouns do not belong to the proper Qaurian element)
but with the oblique form in ^p of nouns in m . Their case is a similar one to that
of some nouns in q, which has been already explained. Their anomaly consists in
this, that their direct form which originally ended in ^ p was not modified to sg as
demanded by Gaurian law, but only to
103
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Oaurian Languages.
time, phonetically curtailed' into T, but not X having been expanded to v:r.
Hence the use of X will indicate a later inflexional formation ; and accord-
ingly we find that all those real Bangal! (». e., not Sanskrit ic ) nouns, to
which the gen. sign. K is added beloug to the proper Oaurian element. The
principles distinguishing the Gaurian element, as explained already are, that
the Gaurian adopts the nouns of its parent language (Prakrit or Sanskrit)
in that form which they have there in the nom. ease ; and the nouns thus-
adopted in their old nom. case, become anew the base; to which the inflexional
signs of the Gaurian declension are added. This base I call the inflexional
hase in opposition to the crude base which is the base to which the inflexional
signs (or affixes) pf the Sanskrit or Prakrit are added, and which is that
which the noun exhibits before any inflexional sign at all is added ; e. g.,
horse is the crude base to which in Sanskrit or Prakrit, the inflexional signs
(or affixes) arc added. The affix of the nom. sing, in Sanskrit is the visarga
O', e., ^), in Prakrit % ; hence tho nom. sing, of in Sanskrit is
; in Prakrit (or ifi-fifi). In this form ilT^T the noun is
adopted by the Gaurian ; and this form or (by tho modification
already explained) UT^l becomes in the Gaurian, the base to which the
inflexional signs (or post-positions) are added. Hence in .Bangui! the nom.
sing, of the inflexional base ilPsT is irrfT (the nom. not being distinguished
by any sign, i. e., being identical with the Prakrit nominative) ; the gen.
sing, to -(- ^ or hr?TT, etc. Similarly elephant (being the Prakrit
nom. sing. TWt, Sanskrit of the crude base ) has in the nom.
sing. gen. sing. ^Tvjt -+■ T or Again «TT lac has in the gen.
sing. 3tt -f- ^ or srK.
The case of those Bangui! nouns which add the sign ift in the gen.
sing, is probably a different one. It has been shown already in the llnd
essay that is a curtailment of and that was added not only
in the pleonastic way to tho genitive of the noun, hut also often com-
pounded with the noun itself to signify the gen. case oi the latter, and
since only in composition (excepting the isolated case oi the enclitic
particle qvrr ) an initial single consonant is dropped, it is the most
natural way to account for the origin of if’C to suppose that all the
nouns to which it is added, are in the form of the crude base with which
(i. e., with the initial elided) is compounded. Now all nouns
(or rather their crude bases) with which is compounded, end in “3? ;
and coming into Sandhi with the diphthong ^ ol was dropped; e.g.,
tiger is (Prakrit crude base for the Sanskrit crude hase ), and
its gen. in Prakrit might be expressed by UT'd%r^T ; tliis in Bangui! would
change to or '315 - UK or ^TTO, just as, e. g., =
vffllT shoemaker. It will be noticed that this way of adding or com-
pounding w-r with the crude base of tho noun is not according to the
21 i
[No. 2,
164 Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
principles of Gaurian, which adds the case-sign only to an inflexional
base (or rather inflected base, viz., the Prakrit nom. sing.) ; hut strictly
according to the principles of Prakrit. Hence those nouns in Bangali
which add yy constitute the Prdkritic element of Bangali in opposition
to its Gaurian element which adds simply y. We may assume, that
at the time of the formation of the Gaurian principles of declension,
yy, (i. e., the modified form of yry) had become finally established as
the gen.-sign., and its real nature was forgotten. The Gaurian then
added yy as an enclitic part of speech to its inflexional base to signify
the genitive ; e. g., (irrfT or) ir?T (iuflex. base) -f yy (enclitic gen. particle) ;
and in contact with the inflexional base which always ended in a vowel, the
enclitic yy lost its initial y, according to a regular tendency of such enclitic
words ; e. g., the Sanskrit now is in Prakrit regularly only ,
again yvry in Pr. is vjyr, in the Gaurian only vf for yr (as in Hindi ari^r
for 5fTT = y?s y»rx ). Hence ■iiPfr + yy becomes hi^fr + y or argiy.
There still remains a class of Bangali nouns which require an expla-
nation, as they seem to contravene the ordinary rule of the gen. forma-
tion; viz. the Bangali adjectives in as small, 'yy large, good,
etc. They add not yy as might be expected, but y ; e. g., WT«y, not wrSy.
If we compare these Bangali adjectives with those nouns, that add yy,
two facts become at once apparent which distinguish them one from the other,
and which stand in the relation of cause and effect to each other. Those
t vo facts are ; 1, those nouns which add yy (having dropped their final y?
in Sandhi with yy) end in a consonant and are pronounced accordingly ;
thus yiy tiger is read vagh and not vagha (or vagho). On the other
hand those adjectives which add y, have retained and are pronounced with
a final yj, thus WT® small is road chhota (or chhotd), but not clihot.
The other fact which is the cause and explanation of the first one is this,
(2), that those Bangali nouns which add yy occur in an identical form
in the Hindi-class Gaurian and in Marathi; while those which add y
correspond to nouns in y|f or yjT in the Hindi-class Gaurian and in Mara-
thi ; e. g., yin tiger is yra in Hindi, Naipili, Panjabi, Siudhi, Gujarati and
Marathi ; but iie small is WT^T or ilig ; W good is wyn or wyu, yy great
is or <h%t, etc. in those languages. Now, as has been already shown, all
such nouns ending in yjr or % and admitting an obligue form (in y[T or y
in the Hindi-class Gaurian and yT in Marathi) belong to the Prdkritic
element of the Gaurian and are formed from the 'particular Prakrit base in
yr. Hence it follows that those Bangali nouns whose final yf is pronounced,
are formed from the particular Prakrit base in yf ; while those whose final
^ is not pronounced are formed from the general base ; and the final yj of
the former is pronounced for the very reason because it is the remnant of
the original ending yjyr. Take for instance the Bangdli adjective noun
1G5
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
small, in Hindi it is and stands, therefore for an original Prakrit wreXT
or WPMt. The equivalent for the latter in Hang.il i would be i~rzx (or xrxx
i- e. the crude base) and the gen. of it XT^X t ft or WTXX + XX or (elid-
ing the final X in Sandhi with VX) XIXXT or XT«vy; and now the initial
T of the enclitic yy after the final X inherent in WTX is elided just as U1XT -f-
X instead of XXT + V, hence we have XTXX chhotar (or cliliotor). There
is one exceptional gen form in Bang&li, which proves and illustrates well the
process by which xtxx and such genitives wTere formed. I refer to the gen.
of the pronominal adjectives VX or XX or XX so many, XX as many, XX how
many, which have a double form (see Beng. grammar of Samaehum Sircar
P- 85), either V4V, XWX, XXX, *JHX, XdV 1 or VXXX, ’XXXX, XXXV, XXXX,
XH^r. From the way Samachurn spells the latter forms {viz., appending a
virama to y?(, XX. etc , and thus making them terminate with a consonant),
it would appear that he considers the whole of XX to be the sign of the
gen., and the base to be only vx, XX. XX, XX, XX. If this be correct the
form %y confirms my theory that the gen. - sign XX or X is but a curtailment
of an original XX (the remnant of the Prakrit xrX). But I am inclined to
think that the pronunciation of fXXX XHXX, etc. as et-kcr, at-ker, etc., instead
of etaker, ataker, etc., is only a vulgar corruption, and that the words XXXX
XXXX, etc. ought really to be divided into VXX 4- XX. XXX + IX, XXX +
Xr, jjrTEfr 4 yy, XToX + XX, so that the base is really XXX, Xnx, etc., and
the gen. sign XX My reason is this : the corresponding forms in Hindi are
?XXT or TXT so many.fsfXXT or fxXT as many, fxXWT orfxXT how many, with
the oblique forms resp. TXX or TX, fxxx or fxx, fxxx or fxx. These words,
having a,. direct form in XT and an oblique form, in x, belong, according to
the ordinary principles of Hindi, to the Pr&kritic element and are derived
form the particular Prakrit base in X. They presuppose, therefore, a Prakrit
original yxx or yfxx, fxxx or fsrfxx, fxxx or fxfxx. As a matter of
fact, these forms or, at least, forms almost identical (see Pr. Pralc. IV,
25.) occur in Prakrit ; viz., either xfxx, xfxx, xfxx, xfxx, (for xfxx,
Xfxx, xfRX, Xfxx), or VXX XTX. X^X (in which T stands for
X and x for X, see Pr. Prakrit II, 4, xf%iT for Sanskrit Wifxx: ; hence ==
Vtjx, XXX, XXX, XXX). Here, on the one hand, the Prakrit X lias been
reduced in Hindi to X (thus xfxx or xfxx for xfxx or xfflX) ;_on the
other hand, in Bangali, it has been reduced to X (thus XXX for XXX or
XXX), and besides the double consonant X is reduced to one X.* Thus we
* Theso Bangali forms yj,yr, XXX, XXX, throw light on the origin of another
Gaurian form ; via., that of the Hindi participle present in x' or 47 (as =^^rx or
XXXT going). The Sanskrit affixes ■yjx , XX. XX become in Prakrit regularly
XX, XX, XX ; of. Pr. Prak. IV, 25. VII. 10 ; thus Skr. ^HXX rich is Pr. XHXX,
Skr. tfg ff reading is Pr. xr^vfl. Similarly Skr. fqr«(X, XXX, XTXX ollght t0 be iu
16G
Hoernle — Essays on the Oaurian Languages. [No. 2,
have instead of the Prakrit yfd’SJ irffm, irri^i, qrfro, in Bangali Vrr^r,
*T«=r^f . Tjrp*. Now in Hindi yrTT, farm, fsiTiT belong to the Prakritic
element; hence naturally their corresponding forms in Bangali yci^r*
iTfPW. will belong to the Prakrit io element of the Bangali. But
the Prakritic element of Bangali is distinguished by compounding the
gen. sign, vt; (*. c., ^ry) with the crude base (as explained above). Hence
yrT^r, qrrT'ff being the crude base, their gen. is formed + yy>
etc. = ) v.rT%T, Nrphy, didiy. Next the syllable Eff or is reduced to
^ (or in other words the consonant dr of y<T^y, etc., is elided, thus mak-
ing Tdty, yjrfyy, dTHTT) and now a final ^ and initial y meeting, the
latter (being the initial of the enclitic yy) is elided ; thus we have y<ry,
^?ry 'fi’rfy ; exactly as irpiy, wyy, etc. are formed.
Lastly as regards the Sanslcritic and foreign elements in Bangali,
they are treated on the same principle as in Marathi ; that is, according to
their final letter, they are treated either by the laws of the Gaurion or by
Prakrit fqrsjsfl, yyfWl, NHtWI ; "in reality they are ^pff ( - qf), yvi ( - 30 STtT
( _e(r) . that is, the double consonant wi has changed to This is an extremely
rare change in Prakrit ; but its probability, as shown hero, is beyond doubt. Lastly
%rt3T, etc, changes in Bangali to ERa^t, etc. ; that is, the double is reduced to the
simple iff. Now this explains the origin of the Hindi pres. part, j e. g., The
corresponding part, in Sanskrit is this becomes in Prakrit this may
change to and finally to N. B. the Hindi form ^fcTT, ollique form
presupposes a particular Prakrit base next next ^rfr^i).
Usually a compound consonant of which one of the constituents is a nasal, can snffer
no phonetic modification j hence the combination sj) as a rule', remains unchanged.
There are, however, a few very isolated cases of a change of wi to in the pres,
part. ; e. g.,
HTWifRTf^rST pfwyfrsn 11 «■
Sanskrit yUJbTyy II
Mrichchhakati, 1st act.
The Prakrit commonly uses the Parasmaipada terminations for those of tho
fenanepada ; hence represents a Sanskrit UTgwfj. Now as the termination
through tho modified form Tj-fl is the original of the termination of the
Hindi, Gujarati, Marathi pros, part., so through tho modified form it is the original
of the termination of the Naipali, Panjabi and Sindhi pres. part. The Hindi forms
TrTHT, fsTTTWT, farfpdT ; correspond to the Sindhi UTpy ^fjy, ^r|y. The affixes
«ft ^ aro probably modem additions and correspond to the affix in the Gujarati
forms ERZ%r how many, etc.
* Compare with these their equivalents in Marathi fdddiT, fsiridiT,
which exhibit a closer agreement even than the Hindi.
167
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
those of the PrdJcritio elements. Whenever, namely, the final of the noun is
^ or a consonant (which has an ^ inherent), it takes VX ; in every other
cases it takes ’C ; e. a., flvrnj man has sen. Tf*fnjX ; afviwvr wise has gen.
1 J ^ ^ i vi ■”* ~
; hut xxtTT God has gen. ^«?<TTX ; xffm earth has gen. ;
•TK) woman ha§ gen. XTXlx ; tfjq beast has gen. rnjX> etc.
In conclusion it may he well to recapitulate briefly the main results
of the foregoing enquiry :
1. Th Gaurian languages consist of three parts ; a., the Pralcritic ;
b., the Gaurian; c., the Sanslcritic. Of these, speaking generally, the
Pralcritic is the oldest, then comes the Gaurian Proper, then the Sanslcritic.
2. The PrdJcritio element consists of all those nouns which have
come into the Gaurian from the Prakrit, and which have preserved traces
of the old organic inflexion of the Prakrit declension ; vis., the Prakrit
nominative and genitive. The former (i. e., the nom.) constitutes the
inflexional base of the nominative or the 'direct form of the inflexional
base in the Gaurian declension. The latter (i. e., the gen.) constitutes
the inflexional base of the remaining cases (which among themselves are
distinguished by post-positions) or the oblique form. The distinguishing
feature of the nouns of this class (vis., of the Pralcritic element) is their
possession of an oblique form, different from the direct form.
Note. — Bangali and Uriya are exceptional in so far as the oblique
form of their Prdlcritic nouns is not the organic genitive, but probably
the crude base of the Prakrit declension, and the apparent identity of the
. oblique form and the direct form of such nouns is the accidental result of
phonetic modification of the direct form. I admit, however, another view
is possible which would allow to the Bangali and Uriya no Pralcritic element
at all but onlyj proper Gaurian.
3. The proper Gaurian element consists of all those nouns which
have been contributed also by the Prakrit, but which have not preserved
any traces of the organic declension of the Prakrit. They have been trans-
ferred from the Prakrit into the Gaurian in the form of the Prakrit nom.
sing., and this form constitutes their unchangeable inflexional base for all
eases of the Gaurian declension, (which distinguishes the various cases
among themselves by the various post-positions). The distinguishing feature
of the nouns of this class therefore is their non-possession of an oblique
form different from the direct form.
4. The Sanslcritic element consists of all those nouns which have
come into the Gaurian language direct from the Sanskrit (not through
the medium of Prakrit) and which like the proper Gaurian element admit
of no oblique form ; their unchangeable inflexional base being the form of
the nom. sing, of the noun in Sanskrit.
1GS Iloernle — Unsays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
5. The relation, accordingly, of these three different elements, one to
another, is this ; the Prdkritic and the proper Gaurian parts agree in both
receiving their nouns from the Prakrit, but differ in the former (Prdkritic)
admitting an oblique form, while the latter does not. The proper Gaurian
and the Sanskritic parts agree in both not possessing an oblique form ; but
they differ in the former deriving its nouns from the Prakrit, while the
latter receives them directly from the Sanskrit. The Prdkritic and Sans-
kritic parts differ in every respect.
G. The great characteristic of the Gaurian languages in their full
development, i. e., after having finally separated themselves from the Prakrit
as distinct languages by themselves, is that they do not admit an oblique
form, but use the nom. sing, of their parent languages (Sanskrit and Prakrit)
as their inflexional base for the formation of all cases, in other words that
they do not form an organic declension. Hence the proper Gaurian and
the Sanskritic nouns only are really Gaurian. The Prdkritic nouns are
transitional forms partaking of the character of both the Prakrit and the
Gaurian.
7. Hence it follows that those Gaurian languages are most really
Gaurian which contain the largest proportion of Gaurian elements (i e.,
Gaurian Proper and Sanskritic) and least of the Prdkritic element. In
this respect the Gaurian languages differ chnsiderably among themselves.
They may be divided into three classes : the first class contains only the
Marathi ; it possesses least of the Gaurian element, and therefore is the
most Prdkritic of all the Gaurian languages, and represents most accurately
the transitional stage between Prakrit and Gaurian. The second class *
coirtains all the remaining Gaurian languages, except Bangali and Uriya ;
viz., Hindi, Naipall, Panjabi, Sindhi, Gujarati, (i. e., the Hindi-class Gaurian
languages), they are almost entirely pure Gaurian. The third class contains
Bangali and Uriya. They also are almost entirely Gaurian ; if not perhaps
altogether. The difference between the second and third class consists not
so much in the relative amount of the Prdkritic element which they contain,
as in the nature of the Prakritic element as explained in No. 2, note.
8. All Gaurian nouns which have been received from the Prakrit, are
derived either from the general base of the word (common to both Sanskrit
and Prakrit) or from a particular base in (peculiar to Prakrit). The
final sound of the direct form of the inflexional base of nouns of the latter
kind is not liable to phonetic corruption (except the change of % to
or ^T), while that of the former kind is.
9. The final sound of the direct form of the Gaurian inflexional base
(with the exceptions mentioned in No. 8) is subject to considerable phonetic
corruptions. As regards those inflexional bases which are Prakrit nom. sing.,
two stages of phonetic corruption may be distinguished ; a., a Prakrit final
1(59
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
diphthong or long vowel is reduced to its constituent short vowel, i. e.,
to v or to ?; ; ^iT or <3! to ^ ; b., a final Gaurian short vowel is made
quiescent, so that all such inflexional bases appear in pronunciation and,
generally, also in writing to end in a consonant or (since ^ is considered
inherent in a consonant) in As regards those inflexional bases which are
Sanskrit nom. sing., two stages also may be recognized ; a., a Sanskrit final
visarga (or ) and anuswara (or is elided ; and h., if a final short vowel
be the resultant of such elision, that vowel may or may not bo made quies-
cent, but, as a rule, is always written.
The next essay (No. IV) will set forth the proof of the positions
stated in No. 2 and No. 8, i. e., that the oblique form of the inflexional
base is identical with the Prakrit genitive ; and that the phenomenon of
the direct form of some inflexional bases retaining the original Prakrit
termination ii, is owing to the fact, that they are derived from particular
Prakrit bases, formed by means of the affix 3f.
Appendix; to Essay III.
On a closer examination of Naipali I have been convinced, that the
view of Naipali taken in the preceding Essay must be somewhat modified,
and that Naipali is much more Prdkritic than I thought at first ; though
I still think that its Prahritic element is not sufficiently strong to take it
altogether out of the second class, i. e., of the Hindi-class Gaurian lan-
guages. But it is next to Gujarati the most Prakritic of that class and
therefore the nearest in that respect to Marathi. In this general respect
as well as in many particular instances which I shall have occasion at differ-
ent times to notice in these essays, Naipali shows a remarkable affinity to
Marathi.
My observations are based altogether on a translation of the Gospel
of St. Luke into Naipali, the only Naipali work that I have been able
to procure.* The translation, I believe, was made by Missionaries ; and
therefore, having been made by foreigners to whom Naipali is yet a
new language, it must be used with caution. It is full of inaccuracies
of spelling, and even of grammatical mistakes here and there ; e. g.,
in ch. x. 24. vejt fbfTrii: 3TT the use of ^ (= Hindi fl) is surely in-
* I have been informed by the Rev. W. Macfarlane of Darjeeling, that the only
printed Naipali Grammar is one published in 1820 in Calcutta by Lt. Ayfcon, of which
only ono copy exists in the library of the Asiatic Society, I have boon unable to
obtain a loan of it.
170
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
correct ; for ^rf WT is tbe present tense like Hindi ^3^ ^T.# Again very
often consonants are spelled as compound which are in reality separated by
a quiescent 37, as an5* instead ol (in Hindi 5n«r«TT ; also sometimes
wrongly spelled sttwit). There is also a very inscientific principle followed in
attaching the virdma to words really ending in consonants, as well as to words
apparently terminating in a consonant, hut in reality in some quiescent
vowel. But as regards the phenomena which I am now about to mention,
there is every reason to believe (from general Gaurian analogy) that-the lan-
guage of the translation is correct.
As the first observation it may bo mentioned that the SansJcritio
element of the Naipali is, in proportion to its proper Gaurian and PrdJcritie
elements considerably less than in High Hindi. In this respect Naipali
is on a level with the more cultivated low Hindi dialects.
In the next place the PrdJcritie element of Naipdli includes besides
that class of nouns which is the common PrdJcritie element of all Hindi-
class Gaurian languages, two more classes of nouns. It has been observed
that all masculine nouns terminating in 3*T or 3jT and derived through the
Prd/crit are hi all Hindi-class Gaurian languages PrdJcritie. Thus Naipali
has
direct form ^TT, thine, oblique form 77TT
In regard to Gujarati, the neuter nouns in ^3 had to be added to that
class. They necessarily belong to it, as they are nothing else, but the neuter
nouns corresponding to those masculine nouns in "%t. Similarly in regard
to Low Hindi, the neuter nouns in vj (Braj Bliaska) and (Sura Dasas
Sura Sagara) had to be added. In Naipali a like addition has to be made.
It possesses probably neuter nouns in 3)t which form an oblique form in 37T.
I have met with such a neuter, however, in a very few instances only ; and
perhaps they are doubtful ;f though to judge from the fact that Naipali
* There is also apparently great confusion as to the feminine gender. The femi-
nine is made to terminate promiscuously in (like i'lVt. girl), or in •?; (like
given ; though she teas is far not fgpr), or >u 3(T (like *75fT, dust, for Hindi or
o- • ^
wf%), or in (liko fate). Now such variations are not probable in themselves,
and the terminations x, %, are contrary to all Gaurian analogy. Or are they, per-
haps, all misprints for x ?
t E. g., St. Luko x. 18, fr<n3r ^tTT S7JI mz *3HrfT Tho
neuter 'gTjg, is here used, because is construed with and is, therefore,
accusative and not nominative to tho verb. It is what tho Marathi grammarians call
tho Bliavi Prayoga, whoro the verb agrees neither with tho subject nor the object (seo
Manual §. 115,3.); as 77), >( ||
171
1872.] Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages.
stands in its general character on a level with the Low Hindi dialects, the
existence of a neuter gender is but to he expected.
To this class of Prdkritic nouns (viz. masculine in % and neuter
in which Naipali has in common with the other Hindi-class Gau-
fian languages, two further classes of Prdkritic nouns aro to be added.
Namely, 1., a small class of nouns in ^3 which form their oblique form
in "5ST, like the nouns in % ; e. g., oion in Naipali is 'WPfTW with an
oblique form ^pfTWT •, see St. Luke xxiv. 32, WT W»T
*tt% *r tin f=ir = Hindi 33T #riii "it’ ^w«tt ^qwr ww fnrfiT w wt ; but St.
Luke xviii. 14. ifT ’Wrqii WT 'ST JlilT = Hindi W? WW®] 'WW %I JTtTT.
All infinitives belong to this class. They have a direct form in ^3 but an
oblique form in ’Wr ; e. g., saying (or to say) is but order to say is
w*t»it fwfwTt or ««nrr qrr «nfjr ; see St. Luke v. 23.wkt wot wptf win vfw www
% wfsf www fvr «efrN = Hindi qm twi
'zz. liiT qwr but St. Luke v. 24
«TTWr WWWT fwfwrt = Hindi f%w f^T gw %TJI STTWh or again St. Luke
xix. 4. <3 qrr ~utji ant wt ^sr?T = Hindi #!%«} w ^«tt.
2. A class oi' nouns with an oblique form in WI- The direct form would end,
probably, in <Jt, but it never occurs. These nouns are never met with
otherwise than in their oblique form ; e. g., ajiwwir#? is knowing (men) =
Hindi 5TIWW4T# ; again qrr wufJl "3qrf<'w is in Hindi 3f3qr3~Fwqr%
T%0 €t^tt 3TTUJIF St. Luke ii. 10 ; again fAw Mfw ^ Z
= Hindi ^ <33W *fiT ^ or X3WJIT, St. Luke ix. 22 ; again
%r SlWTPsWJT fgW 1JTT W?T = Hindi STWirEIW 357 3^T St.
Luke i. 5, 7. From these examples the following conclusions may be drawn :
«., these forms aro genitives ; b., they are genitives of verbal nouns (or as
commonly called Infinitives). These two things appear clearly from the
corresponding expressions in Hindi, c., according to general Naipali ana-
logy, the final indicates that they are oblique forms. It may here at
once be noted that this proves the identity of the oblique form with the
organic genitive of the Prakrit, which these forms must be, if they are
genitives at all. The ordinary infinitives end in ^3 ; and it is possible that
the direct form corresponding to these oblique forms in WT also would end (if
instances of it did exist) in ^3. In that case the infinitives in would have
two oblique forms in and in WT. Their difference would be this, that
the oblique form in is used, when the regular and proper genitive with
the post-position q>f is to be formed (e. g., ^3*3% WTCWT Al ^rsjT JKT^
= Hindi if wrcw WFTl 3JT3JI "fTVir, St. Luke xxiv. 20) ; but the form in
is used, whenever the genitive is used objectively (e. g., *3 '3'awjr W = Hin-
di '3'3^-qi^rT WT) . I consider it, however, more probable that the direct
form of these oblique forms in WT would end in ’qji, that, e, g., to '33vt;r the
direct form would be qfWWT- For these forms in WT correspond evidently
172
Hoernle — Essays on the Gaurian Languages. [No. 2,
to the Marathi oblique forms in *JT of nouns in (for %) ; thus Marathi
has genitive irr33?l^r. I have already observed that the Marathi ijpfT
(and such like nouns) presupposes a Prakrit form hrFf'i'T (or U[f3'llT for iirf%r).
This view is confirmed by the derivation of the Naipali It stands
for a Prakrit form 7331#?% (Pr. Prak. II, 17), which would represent a San-
skrit form ^3 75! rift*? ! (from 33 + W + ^«ffq). The Prakrit genitive 33<5Yw^T
would he contracted in Naipali to <33*7?!. This, however, will he fully dis-
cussed in the IVth Essay. The adjective force is conveyed by the genitive.
The genitive is used in this manner in all Gaurian languages. As regards
Marathi, see the Manual, §. 212, p. 132, note 1, and §. 276, note. For
Panjabi, see Ludiana grammar of Panjabi §§. 43, 120. Eor Gujarati, see
Edalji’s Gujarati Grammar, §. 90, b. For Bangui!, see Shama Churn Sircar’s
Grammar p. 99, (2nd edition). In Hindi such expressions are quite
idiomatic as 3 if*JT 3T*3 377 •T^f, i. it is not my habit (or intention) to
act in this manner ; or this, 33 fiW BTHT 3TI «T^f, i. e., this thing is
useless. For some other cases of this kind, see Etherington’s Hindi Gram-
mar §. 405. In Hindi, however, in many of these cases the affix argr («rNft
fern ) may also be used. This word is really a noun (as I think, the Prakrit
equivalent of the Sanskrit CTT733f) which has merely been degraded to the
position of an affix, and moreover is often a, pleonastic addition. Its case
is exactly Hite that of the Prakrit 3iT*frr and its Gaurian (Hindi) equivalent
3fT, as explained in Essay II, and affords an illustration of what has been
said there regarding 3K+T and 3iT. Instead of saying 3 <?3? 37*3 q>T 33t
it would he equally idiomatic to say V V3t «TNf . In the latter
sentence, the word 37^3 is in reality already a genitive {viz. of 37337 ; since
it is the oblique form of it ; more an this in essay IV) ; and as such has
already all that adjectival force which the word 3773 3l«TT expresses. The
addition of 3T^TT is, therefore, in reality perfectly pleonastic, making the
word 37333T31T doubly adjectival. The word 37 ; 331317 in fact means
exactly the same as 3773 377 which, as explained in Essay Hud, is also a
double adjective or a double genitive (for Prakrit 37VfiY*rc0 ^T%). Hence
in many Hindi phrases 37T and UT~U are interchangeable : e. g., you may say
3f33 371 33; and qf^Tf*T^TT 33, i. e., the country of the west or the
western country.
Just as the Naipali nouns with a (conjectured) direct form in % and an
oblique form in 3T correspond to the Marathi nouns in 3T with an oblique
form in *71, so the Naipali nouns with a direct form in ^3 and oblique form
in W correspond to the Marathi nouns in 3 with an oblique form in 3?T.
Both have reduced the Prakrit nominative termination % (one to <3, the
other to 3) in their direct form and have preserved the Prakrit organic
genitive in their oblique form. There is this difference, however, that while
in Marathi the Prakrit nominative termination % has been worn down to
173
1872.] Hoernle — 'Essays on the Qaurian Languages.
its utmost limit 33 (i. fi., from % to ^3 and from <3 to or rather to nothing,
leaving the mere consonant), in Naipali it has been only half worn down
to *3.
Besides this class of nouns in ^ which are Pralsritic for they have an
oblique form, the Naipali possesses also another class of nouns in <3 which
are Proper Qaurian , because they have no oblique form, but retain their
inflexional base in '3 throughout all cases. Such nouns are, e. g.. ^[R
self— the Hindi e. g„ ^R «TTT *RT, i. e., Hindi RR
% %PC %:iit «tRT, St. Luke, xxiii. 39 ; IrtT sign, e. g., ^rf<T % R fR5?
Ttfjhr, i. r., Hindi vr R ^'ruT, St. Luke ii. 10 ; and_especially the
noun which serves as the formative of the plural ; i. e. RHH %iTI3R
^rr ^rrfji fRRT visit, i. e., Hindi srvr ^ ’R fR^T S"RL St. Luke,
ii. 30. The final <3 of these nouns is the substitute of the Prakrit nominative
termination '5r, by the Gaurian law of reduction. In old and poetical Hin-
di, as I have mentioned, nouns with this termination *3 are often met with.
In the modern High Hindi, on the other hand, it has always worn off alto-
gether, so that the nouns end in R or rather in a consonant. This is the
case also in Naipali in some Proper Qaurian nouns, e. g., RTJT heat for STH,
Wrfsm man for HTiRg.
In conclusion 1 add a list of words in illustration of the above remarks.
1. — PraJcritic Nouns.
* These nouns are apparently feminine.
t The nouns in sg and % are PerhaP3 neuters, and ought to he written with an
anuswara (thus : ,g or ^jf). Their ?rakrit and Sanakrit originals are neuters, and they
correspond to the Low Hindi neuters in 31 and Vjj and the Gujarati neuters in \3.
1 These nouns are feminine.
171
[No. 2,
Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
B. — Sanskritic.
Beef in Ancient India. — By Bdbu Rajeotbalaea Mitea.
The title of this paper will, doubtless, prove highly offensive to most
of my countrymen ; but the interest attached to the enquiry in connexion
with the early social history of the Aryan race on this side of the Himalaya,
will, I trust, plead my excuse. The idea of beef — the flesh of the earthly re-
presentative of the divine Bhagavati — as an article of food is so shocking to
the Hindu, that thousands over thousands of the more orthodox among
them never repeat the counterpart of the word in their vernaculars, and many
and dire have been the sanguinary conflicts which the shedding of the blood
of cows has caused in this country. And yet it would seem that there was
a time when not only no compunctious visitings of conscience had a place in
the mind of the people in slaughtering cattle — when not only the meat of
that animal was actually esteemed a valuable aliment,— when not only was it
a mark of generous hospitality, as among the ancient Jews, to slaughter the
“ fatted calf” in honor of respected guests, but when a supply of beef was deem-
ed an absolute necessity by pious Hindus in their journey from this to another
world, and a cow was invariably killed to be burnt with the dead.* To Eng-
lishmen, who are familiar with the present temper of the people on the sub-
ject, and to a great many of the natives themselves, this remark may appear
quite startling ; but the authorities on which it is founded are so authentic
and incontrovertible that they cannot, for a moment, be gainsaid.
To the more learned among my countrymen the fact is not unknown
that the Vedas, at one time, enjoined a ceremony called gomedha, or the sacri-
fice of cattle ; but they imagine it was typical, and did not involve the actual
slaughter of the animal, and accordingly envelope it in mystery, so as to
render it completely unintelligible to the uninitiated, or intelligible in a
manner that takes them entirely away from the truth. When the subject
attracted the attention of the late Professor Wilson, the attempt at mystifi-
* Vide my paper on the ‘ funeral Ceremonies of the Ancient Hindus.’ Journal,
Vol. XXXIX, p. 241.
1872.] Rajcndralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. 175
cation was so far successful that he was made to waver, # though the light of
truth could not he altogether withheld from a scholar and critic like him. In
a note in his translation of the Meghaduta, Professor Wilson said, “ the sacri-
fice of the horse or of the cow, the gomedha or as'vamedha, appears to have
been common in the earliest periods of the Hindu ritual. It has been con-
ceived that the sacrifice was not real, hut typical ; and that the form of sacri-
ficing only was performed upon the victim, after which it was set at liberty.
The text of this passage, however, is unfavorable to such a notion, as the
metamorphosis of the blood of the kine into a river certainly implies that
blood was diffused. The expression of the original, literally rendered, is
1 sprung from the blood of the daughters of Surabhi’ that is,kiue,Surabhi being
a celebrated cow produced at the churning of the ocean, and famed for granting
to her votaries whatever they desired. ‘ Daughter of Surabhi’ is an expression
of common occurrence, to denote the cow.”f This argument of the learned
Professor, however, had suggested itself to the people of this country long
before his time, and it was met by some by the assertion that the word blood
had been used only to complete the metaphor of the sacrifice. Others
more amenable to the plain meaning of the old texts, but at the same time more
daring, assume that the animals so sacrificed were immediately after invariably
revived by the supernatural powers of the sacrifieers. Such a line of argu-
ment, however satisfactory to the pious proletariat, takes the question so
entirely out of the domain of reason, that it may fairly be left to itself ; but
even the orthodox Hindu might fairly ask, how it is then that the venerable old
poet and hermit Valmiki, when preparing to receive his brother sage Vas'ish-
tha, the author of one of the original law books (Smritis) which regulates
the religious life of the people, and a prominent character even in the Yedas,
slaughtered a lot of calves expressly for the entertainment of his guests ? The
revivification in that case must have followed the consumption of the meat
of the slaughtered animals by them. The passage in which Yalmiki’s
preparation for the reception of Vasfishtha is described in the TJttara-rama-
charita is so remarkable, that I need not offer any apology to quote it entire.
The scene is laid in front of the hermitage of Valmiki, where two disciples
of the sage discom’se on the bustle within.
“ BUndayma. Behold, Saudhataki, our humble dwelling !
Valmiki’s holy hermitage assumes
The face of preparation ; he expects
Unwonted guests to-day ; the wild deer feed
* This was, however, done at the early part of his Sanskrit studies, when he had
not come to the fountain-head, and was obliged to depend on his pandits. Sub-
sequently he had no doubt whatever on the subject. Vide his note in the Uttara.
Rama Charita, Hindu Theatre, I. 31.
f Essays II., p. 353.
170 Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [No. 2,
Upon unusual fragments, and the air
Is tilled with savoury odours.
Saudhataki. There must he
Some wondrous cause, to make our grey beards lay
Their lectures by to-day.
Bhan. There is a cause,
And that of no mean import.
Saw. Tell me I pray you,
What venerable ox may we expect
To visit us ?
Bhan. For shame ! refrain from jests :
The great Vas'ishtha hither brings the queens
Of Das'arntha, with Arundhati,
From Risbyas'ringa to our master’s dwelling.
Sau. Vas'ishtha is it ?
Blidn. The same.
Sau. I crave his pardon. I had thought, at least,
It was a wolf or tiger we should look for.
Bhan. How so ?
Saw. Why else was there provided
The fatted calf for his regale ?
Bhan. Why, know you not,
The Vedas, which enshrine our holy law,
Direct the householder shall offer those
Who in the law are skilled, the honied meal
And with it flesh of ox, or calf, or goat,
And the like treatment shall the householder
Receive from Brahmans learned in the Vedas.*”
Vas'ishtha, in his turn likewise, slaughtered the “ fatted calf” when
entertaining Vis'vamitra, Janaka, S'atananda, Jamadagnya and other sages
and friends, and in the Mahdvira Gharita, when pacifying Jamadagnya, tempt-
ed him by saying : “ The heifer is ready for sacrifice, and the food is cooked
in ghee. Thou art a learned man, come to the house of the learned, favour
us (by joining in the entertainment). ”t
These are, doubtless, examples quoted from avowed fictions, but it is not
to be supposed for a moment that their authors would have alluded to such
* Hindu Theatre I, 339. This rendering is a little too free, but the main facts
remain unaltered. For a literal translation of the passage, see Mr. Tawney’s version
of the work, Act IY.
%f5m?TvrrjmT$fv *rq»sr *r: ii yp ? i
177
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
a subject, and offended the feelings of their readers, had they not ample
authority to be satisfied that their readers would go with them.
Colebrooke noticed the subject in his essays on “ the Religious Cere-
monies of the Hindus,” in which he says, “ it seems to have been anciently
the custom to slay a cow on this occasion, (the reception of a guest) and a
guest was therefore called a goghna or 1 cow-killer.’* * * § When noticing the
mantra for the consecration of the cow at the marriage ceremony, he observes :
“ The commentator whose gloss has been followed in tins version of the text,
introduces it by the remark, that a guest, entitled to honorable reception, is
a spiritual preceptor, a priest, an ascetic, a prince, a bridegroom, a friend, or,
in short, any one to welcome whose arrival a cow must be tied for the pur-
pose of slaying her; whence a guest is denominated goghna, or cow-killer. "f
Manu authorises the consumption of animal food at all seasons with
the slight restraint of first offering a bit of it to the gods, or manes, or guests.
He says, “ having bought flesh meat, or obtained it by aid of another, he who
eats it after worshiping the gods or manes commits no sin.” v. 32. But he
does not expressly name beaf as an article of food. In his list of animals
fit for human food he, however, observes ; “ the hedge-hog and porcupine,
the lizard godhd (Guana) the gandaka (rhinoceros) the tortoise, and the
rabbit or hare, wise legislators declare lawful food among five-toed animals,
and all quadrupeds, camels excepted, which have but one row of teeth. ”+
And this would include cows which were well known to him as animals
having one row of teeth. Had he wished to exclude them, he would have for
certain thought of them, and linked them with camels. It is, however, not
necessary to infer what he intended by such a line of argument, as he is
quite explicit in his directions about the use of beef on the occasion of a
Brahmachdri’s return home. He says: “ Being justly applauded for this
strict performance of his duty, and having received from his natural or spiri-
tual father, the sacred gift of the Vedas, let him sit on an elegant bed,
decked with a garland of flowers, and let his father honour him, before his
nuptials, with the present of a cow, according to the Madhuparka rite.”§
In a subsequent passaged he recommends the JHadhvparka oi the honied
meal” with beef for the reception of kings and other great dignitaries.
Asoka, who in his first edict, says “ formerly in the great refectory and
temple of the heaven-beloved king Piyadasi, daily were many hundred thou-
sand animals sacrificed for the sake of meat food, "If does not specify the kind
* Asiatic Researches VII, 288.
t Ibid VII, 289.
J Manu V., 18.
§ Ibid III, 3.
|| Ibid III, 119-120.
If Journal, Vol. VII,. p. 249.
178 Rsijendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [No. 2,
of animals which were slaughtered, but, bearing in mind that when the ani-
mals were sacrificed he was a Hindu, and followed the ordinances of the S'astra,
it is to be presumed that he did not confine himself to the meat of kids
and sheep.
The Mahabhiirata and the Ramayana allude to the gomedha or slaughter
of cattle for sacrifice ; hut they do not afford any details, nor is it clearly
mentioned that bovine meat was used as food.
The Sutras, both Kalpa and Grihya, and the Vedas themselves, however,
display no such reserve or reticence. They distinctly affirm that bovine meat
was used as food, and in detail point out the different occasions when cattle
should be slaughtered and eaten.
In the Brahmana of the Black Yajur Veda, that grand store-house
of Vedic rituals, which afford the fullest insight, into the religious life of
ancient India, mention is made of scores of different ceremonies, which
required the meat of cattle for their performance, and considerable stress is
laid on the kind and character of the cattle which should be slaughtered for
the supply of meat for the gratification of particular divinities. Thus, among
the Kdmya Ishfis, or minor sacrifices with special prayers (B. Ill, c. viti),
we have to sacrifice a dwarf ox to Vishnu ; a drooping-horned bull with a
blaze on the forehead to Indra as the author of sacrifices, or as the destroyer
of Vitra ; a thick-legged cow ( prishnisaktha ) to the same as the regent of
wind ; a white-blazed drooping-horned bull to the same, as the destroyer of
enemies, or as the wielder of the thunderbolt ; a barren cow to Vishnu and
Varuna ; a cow that has lately miscarried to Aushadhayah ; a bull that has
been already sanctified at a marriage or other ceremony to Indra and Agni ;
a polled ox to Brahmanaspati ; a black cow to Pushan ; a cow that has
brought forth only once to Viiyu ; a brown ox to Indra, the invigorator
of our faculties ; a speckled or piebald ox to Savita ; a cow having two
colors to Mitra and Varuna ; a red cow to Kudra ; a white barren cow to
Surya ; a white ox to Mitra ; a cow that has miscarried from taking the bull
unseasonably to Vayu ; a cow fit to conceive to Bhaga, &c., &e. In a rule
in connexion with the As'vamedha, the same authority lays down that sacri-
ficial animals should differ in caste, colour, age, &c., according to the gods for
whom they are designed.*
In the larger ceremonies, such as the Rajasuya, the Vajapeya, and the
As'vamedha, the slaughter of cattle was an invariable accompaniment. Of
the first two, the Gosava formed an integral part, and it ensured to the
performer independent dominion in this world, and perfect freedom in the
next to saunter about as he liked, even as the cow roams untrammelled in
the forest.f
* Taittiriya Brahmana, III, p. 658.
f W ’SfOi ^ W?f<T I Taittiriya
A r any aka.
170
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
In its account of the As 'vamedha, the Taittiriya Brahmana recommends
180 domestic animals to bo sacrificed, including borses, bulls, 1 cows, goats,
deer, Nilagaos,* &e. A number of wild animals were, likewise, on such
occasions, brought to the sacrificial posts, but they were invariably let loose
after consecration. The authority, however, does not distinctly say how
many heads of cattle were required for the purpose ; the number perhaps
varied according to the exigencies of the guests among whom crowned
heads with their unwieldy retainers formed so prominent a part, and whose
requirements were regulated by a royal standard. But even the strictly
ceremonial offering was not, evidently, completed with a solitary cow or two.
Out of the “ ten times eighteen” heads required, a great many must have
been bulls, cows and heifers of diverse colors and ages.
The Brahmaiia notices another ceremony in which a large number of
cattle were immolated for the gratification of the Maruts and the enjoyment
of their worshipers. This was called the Pcmchas' dradtya sava, or the
“ quinquennium of autumnal sacrifices.” It evidently held the same posi-
tion in ancient India which the Durgapuja does in the liturgy of the modern
Hindus. It used to be celebrated, as its name implies, for five years succes-
sively, the period of the ceremony being limited to five days on each occasion,
beginning with the new moon which would be in conjunction with the Vis'a-
kha constellation. This happened in September or October. The most im-
portant elements of the ceremony were seventeen five-year-old humpless
dwarf bulls, and as many dwarf heifers under three years. The former were
duly consecrated, and then liberated, and the latter, after proper invocations
and ceremonial observances, immolated ; three on each day, the remaining
' two being added to the sacrifice on the last day, to celebrate the conclusion
of the ceremony for the year. The Tandya Brahmana of the Sam a Veda
notices this ceremony, but it recommends cattle of a different color for each
successive year. According to it the 7th or 8tli of the waxing moon in
As'vina for the first year, and the 6th of Kartika for the following years, as
the most appropriate for it.f The origin of the Ytyna, according to a Vedic
legend, is due to Prajapati. Once on a time ho wished to be rich in wealth
and dependents ; “ he perceived the Panchas'aradlya ; he seized it, and
performed a sacrifice with it, and thereby became great in wealth and
dependents.” “ Whoever wishes to be great,” adds the Veda, “ let him wor-
ship through the Panchas'aradlya. Thereby, verily, he will be great.”]:
* TTfWT T'^Tf^TVrrvrUT^'ft TfiT!
qjr? I Taittiriya Brahmana II, (351.
t Hlfu *?5Trr I BTWB2KTT g
f^*N: I ^8^1
J Tail. Brahmana, II, 2.
23
L
180
Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [No. 2,
Elsewhere it is said that this ceremony ensures thoroughly independent
dominion, and that a sage of the name of Kandama attained it through this
means.*
In the As Valayana Sutra mention is made of several seerifices of
which the slaughter of cattle formed a part. One of them in the Gfriliya
Sutra is worthy of special notice. It is called Hula gava or “ spitted cow,”
i. e., Roast Beef. It was performed either in the autumn (sarat) , or the spring
season; when the moon was in the constellation Ardra.f The animal
appropriate for it was a cow of other than fawn color, spotted with white, J
and the choicest of the fold.§ Black spots were, however, not deemed
objectionable, || and a uniform black or blue color with a dash of red in it,
i. e. of a purplish tinge was reckoned unexceptionable. If As soon as such an
animal was selected, it was bathed with water in which paddy and barley
had been steeped, and let loose,** as long as it did not attain all its permanent
teeth, being all the while kept dedicated to Rudra, by a Yedic mantra which
says, “ May you thrive in the name Rudra the great god, &c.”ff
The proper place for the sacrifice was an unfrequented spot, outside, and
to the east or the north, of a village or town, whence the village was not
visible, nor was it visible from the village. The time was after midnight,
but some authorities preferred the dawn.Jf
All the necessary arrangements being complete, the priest, a Brahman
versed in the details of the sacrifice and experienced by former performance
of it,§§ should begin the ceremony by making certain offerings to the fire
with appropriate mantras, and then plant a sacrificial post of the usual size,
but of a green palas 'a branch, uncarved and unadorned, the practice in other
* Wfra *rr i ur i
JJ’gjTWI Taittiriya Brahmana II, 781.
f nxfK i a, «t, ^ i
t I 8, 4. 8 I
§ WW I 8 , 4, ^ I
II l 8, i i
H srrw i 8, 4, < 1
** a 1 n 1
ft wsj wii 1 8 4, 4 l
I am not sure whether the Rudra in this passage should he the noun, and Malia-
deva “ great god,” adjective, or the latter the noun, and Rudra “ fierce” the epithet. In
the present day animal sacrifices are rarely offered to Mahadeva. To Sarasvatx, likewise
no meat offering is now made, though the V edas enjoin it repeatedly.
++ I 'sftrw I 8, 1
§ § For obvious reasons this condition could not have been invariably carried out.
181
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
ceremonies being to carve and decorate the post (Yupa) very elaborately.
Two pieces of string are now to be provided, one made of kiis 'a grass, and
tlie otlier of a kind of creeping palas 'a, vratati. One of these is tied round
the post, and the other to the right horn of the victim, which is then
attached to the post facing the west ; each of these operations being performed
while repeating a mantra. The animal being then immolated in the usual
way, an offering is made to the fire with the liver held in a vessel made of
pal.ts'a wood or leaves. The mantra for the purpose is formed of the twelve
names of S iva thus — “To Ilara, Mridha, S arva, Siva, Bhava, Mahadeva,
Ugra,Bhima, Pas lipati, Rudra, S'afikara, and Ts'lna, may this be welcome. *
It is, however, optional with the priest to repeat the whole of this mantra, or
only a part of it including the last six names, or simply to say “ to Rudra,
may this be welcome !” Offerings of cooked rice and other articles being
now made, four bundles of kush grass arc spread on the four sides of the
altar, and a little cooked- rice and some beef are offered to Rudra as the
regent of the four quarters. This is followed by four mantras addressed
to Rudra from the four quarters. The husks (tusha) and broken grain
( kvnda) of the rice used in cooking the rice offering, together with the tail,
hide, tendons and hoofs of the victim are then to be thrown into the fire,
and the effused blood, which at the time of immolation was held in a
vessel, should be thrown on bundles of kus'a grass. At a time when the
people knew not how to utilize bovine hair and hoofs, their burning was a
matter of course, but the destruction of so useful an article as hide was not
in keeping with the views of the Benthamites of the day ; accordingly Sam-
batya, a sage, recommended that it should be made subservient to human use,
by being manufactured into shoes and the likc.f The priest is then to
stand up, facing the north, and, covering bis face with a cloth, repeat a mantra
offering the blood which had been spilled on the ground at the time of sacrifice
to serpents to whom it belongs. The final offerings ( svwhfakrit ) are now
made, and the spit being removed from the chest of the victim, the ceremony
is concluded by an address to Rudra in praise of his greatness. The remains
of the ceremonial offerings, says the Sutrakara, should not be admitted into
the village, nor children be permitted to approach the sacrifice. But the
sacrificers should, says the text, “ eat of the oblation in the usual way, after
the benediction {Bvastayana).”X Some forbid this consumption of the beef,
others make it optional. §
wapq Hirq
I 8. <£, 1 ^ t
t iflii i $*ff-
flfw l a, «t, f a I
+ fvripjjrn sw Tf<T I a, <f, q* |
§ qin: inrM ^ qrsrP-mr i qrsrtora qi i a, c, ^ i
182 Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [Ntr. 2,
The ceremony ensures to the performer long life, wealth, high position,
great religious merit, and numerous herds and children ; and every house-
holder is required to perform it at least once in course of liis life ; it being
reckoned among those which must be performed. A modified form of this
eeremony is recommended to be performed in a paddock, where cattle are
piquetted at night, should a murrian break out in the fold.
If is to be regretted, that the account of the ceremony given in the
Grihya Sutra, though full in other respects, is entirely silent as to how
the meat of the animal is to be cooked. The use of the spit or skewer
and its presence in the chest of the victim whence it is to be withdrawn
at the conclusion of the ceremony, leaves little doubt, however, as to the
manner in which the meat was dressed.*
The next ceremony I have to notice is named GavSmanayana, or the
sacrifice of the cow, otherwise called JEkisltaicn. It was held for four days
on the eighth of the wane in the month of Maglia, or for four days, either
immediately before, or immediately after, the full moon of Phalghna or
Cliaitra. Its details are in many respects similar to that of the ordinary
Pas’ubandha, of which some account will be given below. It seems to have
formed a part of the MaMplava, Do Ada* ‘aha and other ceremonies, and not
to have constituted a distinct ceremony by itself.
Several other ceremonies also required a supply of beef for their consum-
mation. In connexion with the Atiratra ceremony Katyayana recommends
the sacrifice of a barren cow (a spotted one being preferred)! to the Maruts,
and seventeen, black, polled, entire oxen to Prajipati, permission being granted
to dispense with one or two of the characteristics if all the three cannot be
secured. J I have not yet been able to obtain a Prayoga for the per-
formance of any of these ceremonies, and am not, therefore, in a position to
supply all the details which ware observed in performing them. I have,
however, got three short Prayogas for the performance of the Niruda pas'n-
handha, from one of which (MS. No. 1552, Sanskrit College of Calcutta)
I have compiled the following abstract of the ceremony.
This ceremony should be performed during the six months of the nor-
thern declension of the sun, when the moon is waxing in one of the Deva-
a, <t, *?£ I
t ^iffryr^uTxvrqT^Hr sfef n \a, <{, \\ \
+ I) cfiTo ^8, =?, I,’* II
igwT'rcw tot-stji *kt°\8, >?, ^ 11
vr gyrerq 38ffigym: «tt»t <TcfTT*r
^t'si *t sw*rf*i3 *r 1
183
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
nakshatras, or on the day when the moon is in the constellation Revati,
or on the day of the new moon. On the day preceding the ceremony, the
performer should celebrate the s'raditha called Ndndunuhha, and at night
observe the UdaJcas'anti and the pratinara-bandha. The first consists in
sprinkling holy water with appropriate mantras on the householder, and the
latter in tying a thread on the right wrist in a prescribed form to serve as
an emblem of engagement, to be kept on until the completion of the
ceremony for which it is tied. In Bengal this thread is now tied only
on the occasion of a marriage or the investiture of the sacrificial thread ;
but in the North-West it is used for several other ceremonies.
On the day of the ceremony, the first duty is to attend to the five
obligatory duties of bathing, offering of water to the manes, reading of
the Vedas, offering of oblations to the household fire, giving of alms to
beggars, and cooking of rice for the Vaisyadevah.* The animal to be sacri-
ficed is then to be thought’ of, while repeating the mantra beginning with the
word Priyatitm, &c. Proceeding then to the Garhapatya fire the institutor
and his wife should sit beside it on kus'a grass, holding at the same time a
bundle of that article in their hands, and then thrice inaudibly and thrice
loudly repeat a mantra, and, having duly ordained the priests, solemnly resolve
to perform the ceremony. The Adhvaryu should now come forward, pro-
duce in due form the sacrificial fire by briskly rubbing two pieces of wood
against each other, sanctify it by proper mantras, light the A'havinya fire
altar, and thereon offer oblations of clarified butter. If the fire used be
an ordinary one, and not produced by friction, a different form of sanctifica-
tion, is to be adopted to that recommended in the first instance. The obla-
tions, however, are the same, and they are five-fold, the last two being in
favor of the sacrificial post and the axe with which it is to be cut.
Now proceeding by the eastern gate, the institutor should proceed to
the tree from which the post is to be cut out. There, standing before the tree
with his face to the west, he should address a mantra to the tree, and then
anoint its trunk with a little sacrificial butter. The post being subsequently
cut, a piece of gold is to be put on the stump, a little water is to be sprinkled
thereon, and four offerings of butter made to it.
The post should be five aratnis and four fingers long, each aratni being
equal to about 16 inches, that is, of the length of the forearm from the
inner condyle of the humerous to the tip of the little finger. From nine
inches to a foot of the lower end of the post should remain unshorne for the
purpose of being buried in the earth ; but above that the shaft should be
pared and made either octagonal, or square. The top, to the extent of four
* UT3i wuw i
w u*? ifvruw: it
184 RajemlralAla Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [No. 2,
fingers, should be cut into the form of a tenon, whereon is to be fixed a round
wooden band or ferule, for regulating the proportion of which as also for
the various operations of cutting, chiselling, scraping, appropriate mantras
are provided. The shavings shoud be collected, partly for the cooking of
frumenty, and partly for fixing the post in the earth.
The place where the post should be fixed has next to bo determined.
For this purpose, a peg is to be fixed in front of the A'havanfya fire at the
distance of two feet from its northern edge. Proceeding northwards twelve
feet thereform, a second peg is to be fixed, and then taking a piece of string
18 feet long and having a loop at each end, it is to be fixed to the fore peg,
and then, drawing it tight at the thirteenth feet, a third peg is to be fixed,
a hole being dug between it and the peg at the twelveth feet, and another
at the fourteenth feet. The string being now drawn towards the south,
pegs are to be fixed as above. These opposite points are called the s'roni,
or the hips of the altar. The string is next turned to the east and west
successively, and pegs fixed at the distance of fourteen feet on each side from
the centre. These constitute the two shoulders of the altar ( gJcandha ). To
the west of the twelveth feet peg, eight inches of space should he kept for the
post, and beyond it a peg should be fixed to mark the boundary of the spot.
Beyond it, in a straight line at the distance of a yoke-pin, another peg is to
be fixed, and beyond it a square altar of tho length and height of a yoke-pin
should be made similar to the Ahavaniya altar. This is called the Uttara-
vedi. Upon this there should be another, a span square and four fingers or
a span high, having a depression in the centre like a foot-mark. This
is the northern naval, TJttarandbM. Measuring two or three feet straight
to the west of the altar pin, and then turning to the north two or three feet,
a hole is to be dug of the size of a yoke-pin. This is called Chdtvdla.
Measuring again four feet straight to the west of the altar, and then turning
to the north one foot, a peg is to be fixed marking the place of the TJtkara
or refuge field.
The Yajamana now sheds his hair, rubs butter on his body, ornaments
his eyes with collyrium, and then eats something, leaving the next operations
of the ceremony to be performed by tho priests.
The first duty of the Adhvaryu priest is now to cut two plalcsha branches
(Ficus infectoria) , and to arrange all the different articles required for the
sacrifice, including among other things a peg of Gambhari wood ( Gnielina
arlorca) of the length of the Yajamifna’s face for driving it into the victim’s
chest. Kag 'maryamaymn hridaya-s'ulam yajamana-mulclia-sammitam. Now
follows a scries of offerings to the different sacred fires, and the repetition
of a number of mantras by the different priests, the Yajamana and his wife,
which, however important in a cercmonieal point of view, are neither likely
to interest the public in the present day, nor to contribute to throw any
185
1872.] Eajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
light on the subject of this paper. I shall pass on, therefore, to the details
connected with the treatment of the sacrificial animal.
On the conclusion of the different offerings above referred to, the victim
should be brought forward, rubbed over with a paste of turmeric, emblie my-
robolan and oil, well washed, and thenledbctween the Clidtvdla and the TJtkara,
to a spot between the Ahavauiya fire and the sacrificial post, and there made
to stand before the latter, facing the west. The animal should be of the
colour appropriate for Indra and Agni, for the whole ceremony is addressed
to them. But should one of that colour be not available, any sound ox may
be employed, provided it be not defective by reason of having only one horn,
or bored ears, or broken teeth, or docked tail, or being dwarf, deaf, mangy,
or undivided-hoofed.
After the bathing the Adhvaryu should offer certain expiatory oblations
with the nitydjya, sthdlyajya, and vasdhoma havani, in course of which he
should invoke Agni, Indra, Vayu and Prajapati. Then taking a bit of
kus'a grass he should place the same with the aid of the Yajamana, on the
head of the victim between the horns, while repeating the first verse of the
Yajur Veda, Is'etvd &c. This is called TJpdkarana or emblematic sacrifice.
It is to be followed by the repetition of certain mantras declaratory of the
resolution to sacrifice the animal.
Other mantras now follow, accompanied with offerings to the different
fires, and repeated manupulations of the sacrificial vessels. Those done, the
animal is tied by the right horn, the rope passing two or three times round
the eye of that side, so as to leave the left horn free. A little water is then
sprinkled on the victim, which is allowed to have a good drink of water
from a vessel brought near it for the purpose. An offering of butter to the fire
with the s'ruk spoon is next made, and with the remainder of the sanctified
butter in the spoon, spots are marked on the forehead, the hump, and the two
hind quarters. Another series of mantras and offerings having been gone
through by the Adhvaryu, an axe is placed in the hands of the immolator,a spike
stuck into the string with which the victim is tied, and the victim is anointed
with some butter. These operations accomplished, the Agnidhra takes up a
flaming brand from the Ahavamya altar, and proceeding between the Clidtvdla
and the Utkara to the front of the Sdmitra fire, thrice circumambulates
the victim by the right side with the brand in his hand, and then, placing the
brand near the Ahavamya altar, repeats the circumambulation, while the Adh-
varyu offers an oblation after every turn, and then continues his offerings
to Prajapati Agni, Vayu, and Vis'vedevali. The Pratiprasthata now comes
forward, and taking some burning charcoal from the Gdrhapatyct altar, re-
moves it to the Sdmitra altar. The victim is then led northward between the
sacrificial post and the northern altar by the Agnidhra with a flaming brand in
his hand, and the Adhvaryu and the Yajamana touch it with the vessel intended
180
Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
[No. 2,
for holding the liver (vapdsrapami). The former next sanctifies the animal
by a mantra, and the Agnidhra places before the immolator the burning
brand which is cast aside by the Adhvaryu, who orders the immolation with
an appropriate mantra ending with the word sanjnapaya “ immolate.” The
immolator now casts the animal on spread lcusa grass so as to have its
head towards the west, and the feet pointing towards the north, and com-
pletes the slaughter, saying at the end “ it is immolated” (sanjnapta). The
institutor of the sacrifice and the priests should sit during the operation
with their faces averted, so as not to behold the . sanguinary work, and the
Adhvaryu should go on making expiatory offerings to obviate the evils likely
to ariso from the victims lowing, or shivering, or attempting to run away, or
dying by natural causes during the ceremony. A number of mantras, most-
ly from the Sanhitas of the Rig and the Yajur Vedas are given for the various
operations and offerings mentioned, as also for an interminable and unsuffer-
ably tedious series of offerings which are to follow the immolation ; but it
would be foreign to the subject of this paper, to describe them here. I must,
therefore, refer the curious to the MS. from which these details have been
taken.
That the animal slaughtered was intended for food, is evident from the
directions given in the AVvalayana Sutra to eat of the remains of the
offering ; but to remove all doubt on the subject I shall quote here a passage
from the Taittiriya Brahmana, in which the mode of cutting up the victim
after immolation is described in detail ; it is scarcely to be supposed that the
animal, would be so divided if there was no necessity for distribution. The
passage runs thus : “ celestial and human executioners, (Samitara) commence
your work ; carry the victim for the purpose of cutting it up. Anxious to
divide the victim for the masters of the ceremony, collect the ulmuJca fire for
the animal brought here (to the shambles). Spread the kus^i grass ; obtain
the permission of the mother, of the father, of the uterine brother, of the friend-
ly members of the herd of the victim. Place it so that its feet may point
towards the north ; let the eyes reach the sun ; let its vital airs attain the
regent of the wind ; let the ears attain the regents of the quarters ; let its
life reach the ether above ; let its body abide on the earth. Separate its
hide so that it may remain entire (without rents). Before cutting open
the naval separate the fat. Close its breath that it may remain within ;
(i. e. by tying up the mouth). Cut open its breast so as to make it appeal'
like an eagle (with spread wings). Separate the forearms ; divide the arms
into spokes ; cut out the shoulders (clods) in the form of tortoises ; remove
the hips (rumps) so as not to injure them ; divide the thighs (rounds)
with the bone entire in the shape of a door, or of the leaf of the oleander ;
separate successively in order the 2G ribs ; divide the different members
so that none be less than what it should be. Dig a trench for burying the
1872.]
187
Rujendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
excrements. Throw away the blood to the Rakshasas. Extract entire (and
do not puncture in the middle) that part of the entrails which is like an owl
in shape (the stomach, mnish(u). Your offspring and their children will
live in peace and never weep ( 'i . e. these operations being done according to
the ordinances of the s'astra, no injury will befall your family). O slayer
of cattle, O Adhrigu, accomplish your task ; accomplish it according to rules ;
O Adhrigu, accomplish it.”#
The Taittirxya Brahmana is silent as to what should he done with these
different parts, but the Gopatha Brahmana of the Atharva Yeda supplies the.
omission. It gives in detail the names of the different individuals who are to
receive shares of the meat for the parts they take in the ceremony. The
total number of shares into which the carcass is to be divided is thirty-six, and
the following persons are to receive one or more shares each, viz. : —
“ The Prastiita is to receive the two jaws along with the tongue ; the
Pratihartd, the neck and the hump ; the TTdgata, the eagle-like wings or brisk-
ets ; the Adhvaryu, the right side chine with the shoulder ; the Upagata, the
left chine ; the Prutiprasthatai, the left shoulder ; the Brahma and the wife
of the Rathya, the right rump ; the Brahmanachchhansi, the right hip lower
down the round ; the Pota, the thigh (leg ?’) ; the Hot:i, the left rump ; the
Maitravaruna, the left round ; the Achchhavaka, the left leg ; the Neshta,
the right arm (clod) ; the Sadasya, the left clod ; the master of the house the
sirloin and some part of the abdomen (flank ? sada and anuka ) ; his wife,
the loin or pelvic region, which she is to bestow on a Brahman ; the Agni-
dhra, the stomach ( vanishfu ), the heart, the kidneys, and the right fore leg
(vdhu) ; the Atreya, the left leg ; the householder who ordains the sacrifice,
the two right feet ; the wife of the householder who ordains the sacrifice,
the two left feet ; and both of them in common, the upper lip ; the Gravas-
tut, three bones of the neck, (vertebra) and the manirjd, whatever that
be ; the man who leads the cow, three other vertebrae and a half of the perine-
um ; the Cliamasadhvaryu, the bladder ; the Subrahmanya, the head ; the man
* “fusils ssfflKir qjivvr?4 | s^qq-qq frap I im-
ijv i w ^frr wrq i qiaitq qfq: 1 w<tt «^?if 1 fqqT 1
i ^i*r h>3t wjj; i qqq fsnrmqj
^JTWqrfriT | ?Trf MTWq;qq«Jqjqrrr | %q | | sfqqjw
I Sf^qiqfjqiq | OTT ^TTHfl qqrqqfjggqpq | -V-IWipqT-
qrC9rT( rf| qvr: 3fm<TTfTI SWHI «(r*T I ?nqj qqWp | qiTqqqi^qj I
1 ihrqwretwr 1 q^-q: , qT qjq^jiqjrqq-
*TTrT I ^yqq s?pnqTfT I sjfqqjq iq qifsjq qq 1 q j -qjqi qqj* SA -
^m«T 1 «KTPnz i 1 qqq 1 qfqqr rq-
^ftnrrc: | ^rwr t gsrfq I swlsqqfqjii »' ^fq (
24
Ai
[No. 2,
188 KajendraMla Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
who invites people to a Soma sacrifice, the hide.”* Diverse imprecations are
hurled against those who venture to depart from this order of distribution.
The luckiest recipients were no doubt those who got the tongue, the
hump, the rounds, and the sirloin ; but some of the inferior officers, such as
those who got the feet, the bladder, and the like, could have made but poor
use of their shares. They were, however, all allowed plentiful libations of
the Soma beer to wash down their meat.
The general rules to be followed in slaughtering animals including cattle,
are given by some of the Sutrakaras. They are of course liable to be modi-
fied by special rules in connexion with special ceremonies, but in the absence
of any such special rule, they should be regularly followed. As'valayana
gives these rules under the head of Bas'uhalpa in the eleventh section of
the first book of his Griyha Sutra. According to them, after offering obla-
tions of clarified butter to the sacrificial fire, a hearth is to be made
to the north of it, for the Sdmitra or cooking fire. This done, the animal
to be slaughtered is to be made to drink plentifully, then bathed, and then
made to stand before the sacrificial fire, facing the west. After this two obla-
tions of clarified butter are to be offered witb the mantra beginning with the
words Du/am, &c. The animal should then be touched on the back with a
green branch bearing leaves while announcing the resolution, “ for the
gratification of so and so (naming the god), I slaughter thee.” A little
water in which paddy and barley have been steeped, is now to be sprinkled
on the forepart of the animal, and the aforesaid resolution again repeated.
This done, tlio animal is to be made to drink a part of that water, and the
remainder of it is to be thrown on its right fore leg. It is then to be led
round the fire three times silently without any mantra, and then carried to
the north side, with a burning faggot held before it. When brought to
the spot where the cooking hearth has been made, the faggot is to be put
into the hearth, and a good fire kindled in it. The master of the ceremony
* ¥¥¥t<77a uiirfuwjf i ^Tgr^ivriffr, ¥¥
siing:, ^3: *7¥i7grg: nfd¥¥:, ¥¥ uHi' ¥f¥TO33n-’, ¥37¥<r-
Jirevit, sfinrerrg*, w^vr:, wr^wr-
nig:, flwi ¥7f<n¥Tg:, ¥¥T¥¥<ns7 gharri
¥¥n«7, ¥«c37g¥rs JaNTfr:, srruift ¥<w, wf ¥7 sftf-
¥T¥¥f?r, ^nr-wirf^T ¥7S¥7fqw, ¥¥r ^p3>ht
_ ^ C J -v _
¥7¥d 33^Uf)¥«T‘^Hr, ¥377 ¥7gJ JZ¥¥¥riT ?fTUg7¥7:, ¥¥«M¥7T7¥¥7
¥¥7¥*77f¥T, ¥fm^rq ¥S-¥rf<rI¥¥ 3fh*¥7 ¥7¥Sp7:, f<T¥§¥ aft*¥T ¥)¥797¥7-
¥%i^g:, ¥)¥ #r¥7! S7¥f¥g:, fwy: Qvra"?]¥7, *pq 75737T-
¥7*r*m, ¥¥7 Vfl, T7¥7 ¥1^ I ¥3T¥S7g¥¥;7¥T ¥77,
¥¥<ft, ¥7¥¥T ¥ ^31 T ¥¥7777 ¥ g«(7: ¥J37 #7% ¥*7¥I, ¥¥7777 ¥7*7
Stf<T¥fd, Slffrfft^fVr 77Sf¥T <?.¥ f¥«57¥I I
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. 189
then is to take up two stout sticks of Kasmarya* wood, one with, and the
other without, leaves, and successively touch the animal and the Adhvaryu.
This done, he should spread some ktis'a grass on the west of the hearth, and
the animal, having been laid on it with its head towards the east or the
west, and the feet pointing towards the north, is to be killed by the
Samita. The instrument of destruction is not named, and it is doubt-
ful whether a knife was used, or a spike of hard wt>od, one of the
gambhari sticks alluded to above, was driven into the region of the heart
to effect the destruction. Both methods are noticed elsewhere, and
the spike was called sphya. But however effected, immediately after the
immolation, the master of the ceremony should cover the right hypochon-
driac region with a little kiis'a grass, and make an oblique incision to
extract an important organ from the abdomen. If the immolation be
made with the animal’s head to the east, it will be necessary to turn the
carcass over to come to the spot. The organ to be extracted is called Vapd,
and in Sanskrit dictionaries it is set down as a synonym of fat or marrow.
Some take it to be the omentum, but the commentator of As'valayana
describes its place to be a hollow above, and to the right of the navel, f
which takes us exactly to the region of the liver, and knowing how
eagerly such Hindus as take flesh meat in the present day, like the
liver of goats, as a delicacy, I am disposed to believe that the word means
the liver. Such a tit bit would be much more worthy of the gods than
the skinny omentum, which is utterly unfit for human food.
* Gmelina arborea. The wood of this tree is reputed to bo remarkably dense,
hard and tough. The technical name of the stick is Papdsrcepcmi. A srapani is ordi-
narily a cooking pot, but in the present instance, as one of them should be ^pjfTtsiT
“ without leaves” and the other yrjjjtsix leaves, I infer that sticks are meant.
f vnfflw qfw qrnr i ‘ef ^ fsRrtnqwtr
Tfd yn I rTTrefapT
^frT I Tfrf! JTT ifTV-
<£fw«T ?rrircret'*rT frar tpt (avrcTwrer?? ftratqx msiT
’rrw l sir^fsiyi: ?j-sn
tjfrr ?f^ui 3iidT fSqTrf I fTfll I
55RTT'?r?'!i l ^^Tfsr trtfwl I 7f7(T <fgT
swtbj, gijfapi ’qq^r.
=*rrq i wrt: Ji*m^vi'=roTqre^rafjf qqj
^T’alsr: ’qqfwr vrf uqmfwuiw
^TJlft vyfrtl aT®'S)T<T ^XiTl W%ftT I
>l " 'J
190 Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [No. 2,
The liver being thus extracted, it should be cut, stuck on the two gam-
bhari sticks, washed, and then heated on the cooking fire. Proceed-
ing then to the sacrificial fire, an offering is to be made to it with a bit
of the liver. Sitting then on the south side of that fire, the meat is to be
cooked, and butter be dropped on it while cooking. The roast being in
this way completely dressed, it should be placed on the leaves of the plaksha
tree (Ficus infect oria), and further offerings made to the two fires. On this
occasion rice is likewise cooked, and the carcass being then cut up into
eleven principal parts, such as the heart, the tongue, the briskets, &c. besides
other minor parts, they are all to be cooked at the samitra fire. The heart
is to be stuck on a spit and carefully roasted over the fire so as to make it
tender, clarified butter being subsequently poured on it to complete the
dressing.* On the completion of the operation, the different kinds of cooked
meat and rice should be offered to the sacrificial fire with appropriate man-
tras, each ending with the word svdhd. If the meat and rice be offered
separately, then separate evish{aki~it or final offerings are to be made for
each of them, otherwise one final-offering would suffice for all. The roast
should be offered last without any mantra. The mantras enjoined are all
extracts from the Sanhlta of the Rig Veda.
These rules, simple as they are, are nevertheless too complicated for a
feast to be improvised whenever a respectable guest honours a house ; and for
such a purpose, therefore, a separate set of rules have been provided in which
the order of the guest to slaughter, given in a Rig Vedic verse, followed
by another when immolating, is held sufficient. The ceremony is called 11a-
dhuparka, or the offering of honied meal. The persons for whom this cere-
mony was imperative, were ritvigs, kings, bridegrooms, Vedic students on
their return home after the completion of their studies, A'charyas or tutors
coming to a house after a year’s absence, fathers-in-law, uncles, and generally
all men of high rank.t The first duty of the householder on the arrival of
a guest belonging to any of these classes was, after salutation, to offer a seat.
This was ordinarily a mat made of^kus'af grass, and in the case of ritvijas
* VTfa tot: ufuurf^rnfvr tot *gfr-
ttoto i ^>4 fsnn to l TO9ipTf*r
ssrfvr Trernfq frowsr I *nf*r *Tfro: i VTO
hi??} uvnqqffr tot jyff uqffr i to to
vq' 3TS‘Afr. frimq<?Tsrrf^r ii ^ il
t toto:, 'pKixjnm-
TjvJ; ^ || || Gautama apud Kulluka Bhatta ; Mauu,
III, 120.
i f I
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. 191
or officiating priests, it was the most appropriate ; hut the word used for it
by As'val&yana is vish(ara, which means simply an article to sit upon,
and it may have been a carpet, a stool, a chair, or a couch. \\ ooden seats
are particularly mentioned in different works.
After the guest was seated, the most appropriate article for refreshing
him, in a warm country like India, was water to wash his feet with. This was
called pddya, and the role on the subject required that a Brahmana guest
should have his right foot washed first, and then the left, the order being
reversed in the case of SYidras ; the Kshatriyas and V aisyas being left to
follow their own inclination in the matter. The washing was repeated
three times. The next offering was the argliya , which consisted of a little
water with scents and flower garlands,* and was no doubt much more appro-
priate than what is offered to gods in the present day, which consists of
sandal wood paste and a few grains of rice thrown on a flower and sprinkled
over with water. The mantra for the offering was repeated three times.
A glass of water for washing the face next followed, and the guest was ex-
pected to drink of it as much as he liked. The Madhuparka strictly so called
was next brought forward. It consisted of curds and honey held in a small
cup, butter being substituted when honey was not at hand. When bi’inging
it, the host was required to look at it and repeat a mantra three times. The
guest received the cup while repeating a mantra, then looked at it while
repeating another, and mixing the ingredients in the cup with his index
finger or the thumb or the little finger with a third, and cleared his finger
by giving it a jerk while repeating a fourth mantra. He was required then
to repeat three mantras successively, throwing a little of the mixture after
each repetition upwards into the air with the tip of his finger, offering it
to Eudra, Aditya, and Vis'vedevah. Then placing the cup on the ground,
he tasted the mixture three times, repeating a mantra on each occasion.
According to some, he had to eat the whole of the mixture in three mouth-
fuls, but according to others, a portion was left behind to be given to a
Brahman, or should such a person to receive it happen not to be at hand,
to be thrown into water. f* A drink of water after this honeyed meal was
of course a necessity, which was met in the same way as the first drink
before the meal, the mantra for it being the same ; but a second drink
followed with a different mantra. The order to give the remains of a tasted
food to a Brahman is worthy of note. It would be the direst insult to a
Brahman in the present day to ask him to receive such an offering.
* I Garganarayana s Vritti on At/valayana, 105.
fsrftripT ii \<f ii
192 Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [No. 2,
A cow was next brought forward and offered to the guest ; whereupon
he said, “ My sin is destroyed, destroyed is my sin,” and then ordered the
immolation of the animal with the words Om kuru, “ accomplish, Amen.”*
The host thereupon immolated the cow in the name of some appropriate
divinity. If it were desired that the cow should be sanctified and let
loose, then the guest repeated the mantra : “ This cow is the mother of the
Rudras, and the daughter of the Yasus, the sister of the Adityas, and the
pivot of our happiness ; therefore I solemnly say unto all wise men, kill
not this harmless sacred cow. Let her drink water and eat grass ;”f and then
ordered it to be let loose, and the same was accordingly done. Lest this
should lead to the idea that the feast at this ceremony may be celebrated
without flesh meat, A's'valayana emphatically ordains that no Madhuparka
should be celebrated without flesh meat, J and his commentator Garganaray-
ana provides for this by saying that “ when the animal is sacrificed, its meat
supplies the requirement of the feast ; should it be let loose, flesh meat
should be provided by other means, but on no account should the feast
be without that article.” §
In this he has followed the ordinance of Manu, who declares that the
man who, having in due form performed a (Madhuparka or other) ceremony,
fails to eat flesh meat, will be doomed to be bom an animal for twenty-one
generations ;|| and that Brahma having created animals for sacrifices, their
immolation at a Vedic ceremonial cannot be injurious, and that animals,
beasts, trees, tortoises, and birds, destroyed in the performance of sacred rites,
rise after death in the scale of creation.^
Convenient as the ceremony of Madhuparka was for the celebration of
a feast, it was not calculated to afford a ready and cheap supply of meat to
persons given to its use, and accordingly Manu ordained (ante, p. 176,) that
* ^irsn^r^itirq art il ^ ll
'Ttit % vrar vm « Mfr TfH sTfasu -$r$=»s<Tf<T ii ii
tit sjftraT srqrfr. i vfk; ^
TT«TT I fPT STflrfir II ^ 8 II
t «reTSifk;7!TTvrTWcr*sj srim: i vpn krk
at nrflvrwirTnrfa I i n
This mantra occurs in the ceremony of letting loose the cow which used to he
led before a corpse to the burning ground at a funeral. Vide ante vol. XXXIX p. 247.
t ^Twm wqti wtfrf v*f?r ii
§ TrywTwrervpmH Vf i 3»tt: I Tirnfv iimfrnf^sr sf%*-
fkfajj M^frT I WT5JVT,
^33J5T»r'iv? I AsValayana I, 24-26.
|| Manu V. 35.
IT Ibid V. 394.
193
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
flesh meat purchased at the butchers’ stall was pure, and fit for consumption
by pious Hindus. I have nowhere noticed that butchers were required, as
among the Muhammadans, to observe any ceremonial rite before slaughtering
animals, and am disposed to believe that none was observed, and that the
only restriction was that the person purchasing meat for food had to offer
a portion of it after dressing it to the gods, manes, guests, or beggars, which
sufficed to accomplish a i/aj/ia.
It is worthy of note here, that while killing of Brahmans, drinking of spi-
rituous liquors by Br&hmans, stealing of gold belonging to Brahmans, defile-
ment of the bed of spiritual preceptors, and association for a year with those
who are guilty of the aforesaid four crimes, are reekonedby Ya jhavalkya among
the most heinous crimes — MaMpMaJca, the mischievous killing of cattle is in-
cluded among secondary or upapdtaka offences, and the expiation for it is
comparatively slight. A Brahman guilty of drinking spirits cannot expiate
his crime without suicide produced by a draft of molten metal, while a cow-
killer is let off by Samvarta with a fortnight’s short-commons, consis-
ting of barley -meal, milk, curds and butter, a feast to Brahmans and the gift
of a cow.* Yajhavalkya is a little more exacting ; he insists upon drinking of
the five products of the cow, panchagavya, following a cow as it roams about,
sleeping in a cattle-shed regularly for a whole month, and ending with the
gift of a cow, or a fine equal to the value of the animal destroyed.f He also
recommends other forms of expiation, and his rival Smritik&ras have each
his own scheme ; but none insists upon any thing approaching to suicide.
The author of the Ndrasinhiya Prayoga Pdrijata has copied verbatim
As'valayanas rule about the necessity of eating beef at the Madhuparka
ceremony, but qualified it by a quotation from the A'ditya Purana which says
that in the present Kali age the Madhuparka should be celebrated without
slaughtering a cow. This quotation has been given at length both by IVtra-
saraj and Hemadri and other compilers, and runs as follows : — “ Protracted
Brahmacharya, carrying of the begging pot called Kamandalu, produc-
tion of issue by a brother-in-law, gift of a daughter once already given
away (widow marriage), marriage with gills of other than one’s own caste
by the twice-born classes, killing of noble Brahmanas (versed in the Vedas)
in fair warfare even if they come to the attack, entrance into the Vanaprastha
* 'Start '
VrTTfvT I
iratiWT 3 Jit H WW I
f JiT-iff 'RTU'HT’JtiT JrtTrP 1
jilt iiTqgjifJr u^Tcr ii i
J I suppose this is a compiler and not the author of the Sahhita, for the latter
does not quote authorities in support of his rules and ordinances.
194
Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
[No. 2,
state according to law, reduction of the period of mourning on account of duty,
or service, or for reading the Vedas ; expiations on the part of Brahmans
involving loss of life, condemnation for association with criminals, immola-
tion of animals at the Madhuparka, acceptance as sons, of other than le-
gitimate and adopted sons ; hoarding together on the part of the twice-born
householders with a servant, cowherd, friend of the family, and persons with
whom agriculture is jointly carried on if they be S'udras by caste ; pilgrim-
age to very remote places ; cooking of food by S'udras for Brahmans, expia-
tory suicide by falling from very high places, or into the fire ; suicide on ac-
count of extreme old age, and the like have been abstained from by noble and
learned men at the beginning of the Kali Yuga for the well-being of mankind.
The practice of revered persons is proof as potent as that of the Vedas.”* The
Vrihannaradiya Purapa follows this very closely, but at the same time it
omits somo acts and prohibits others which are not condemned by the former.
The additional acts condemned are, suicide by getting one’s self drowned in
the sea, offering of flesh meat at S'raddhas, human sacrifice, horse sacrifice,
Gomedha sacrifice, and Vedic yajfias involving sacrifices of cattle. f It is
i
^vrr^fTfgTi^^jr n
^rvn«WiTirr tTsiTfgfw: i
■^Frrmr^f^snujiwf i
fqf%r#rf^<T! n
vrvjr t
firypnf u
UTUU qifTqtj: |
ft - - -1 J - ^
qqsfvr qryq'?: h
WPSdSfrTT WlVFU^rfrT^Crr: ||
5TrmWTfgU q^TJTlfgfsftqrfq ^ \
■ggrf^TTqr’TiviT n
'nrrfsr i
f%qfw«nfiT qjfflifvr |
S\ J
’Tfl Wfq ^r|«rt srapri n
fgansfTfl»jq'Brg n
^TnfqfTnimqif qiuqg: i
g-sjT n
195
1872.] Rajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India.
worthy of note, however, that this prohibition in the Aditya Purana is not
positive and explicit, but implied : “ Because certain noble and wise men
did not do so, and the practice of pious men is proof as potent as that of the
Vedas,” ergo they should not be done, the author wished to say, but did not
do so in so many words. Both these extracts proceed from Upapuranas
of probably not more than eleven or twelve hundred years of age. Accord-
ing to Professor Wilson, the Upapuranas are not older than the twelfth
century, but seeing that the Vrihannaradiya has been quoted as an authority
by Vallala Sena in his Danas&gara, and he lived in the eleventh century, it
must be at least four or five centuries older ; but they have been so carelessly
preserved, and are so full of interpolations, and altogether are of such question-
able authenticity, that even the most orthodox Hindu holds them to be of very
secondary rank compared to the Vedas, the Smritis and the Sutras. Thus it
is said in the Prayoga Pdrijdta that where the S'ruti and the Smriti disagree,
the S'ruti should prevail. Again the Smritis are more venerable than the
Puranas, and of the Smritis Manu is the most authoritative.*
In the opinion of Paulastya, who is himself an original Smritikdra,
Manu must yield to the Kalpa Sutras, which, being derived immediately
from the Vedas, are of greater authority than the Smritis.f This has not
been contradicted by any lawgiver or commentator. The Upapuranas
hold a lower rank than the Puranas, and have nowhere been allowed to over-
ride the hitter, much loss the S'ruti and the Smriti ; the order of precedence
being according to the above, 1 ft S'ruti or Veda, 2nd Siitra, 3rd Smriti, 4th
Puranas, 5th Upapurana. It is not a little remarkable, therefore, that the last
should be allowed in the present instance to prevail over the first four.
The author of the Mr nay a nindfm assumes even a lower ground. He begins by
quoting an unnamed authority which says, “ Works which lead not to para-
dise, and are condemned by public opinion, should not be performed and
then argues, “ Thus, the slaughter of large bulls and large sheep for Brah-
manas versed in the Vedas, though duly ordained, should not be done, being
iufi'd ^ i
n
* ^ffrtnmwvTTvrf i
* i J *
HjTrj II
UT^HslT: I
25
K
196 llajendralala Mitra — Beef in Ancient India. [No. 2,
detested by the public. Further, tlie rule, let a cow fit for offering to Mitra
and Varuna, or a barren cow, or one that has ceased to bear after first calv-
ing, be sacrificed, is duly ordained ; still sucli sacrifice being opposed to public
feeling, should not be performed.”* If such he the case, the question arises,
whence comes this public feeling against the ordinances of the Vedas ? And
we can nowhere meet with a more appropriate reply than in the fact that
when the Brahmans had to contend against Buddhism, which emphatically and
so successfully denounced all sacrifices, they found the doctrine of respect for
animal life too strong and too popular to be overcome, and therefore gradu-
ally and imperceptibly adopted it in such a manner as to make it appear a
part of their Sastra. They gave prominence to such passages as preached
benevolence and mercy for all animated creation, and so removed to the back-
ground the sacrificial ordinances as to put them entirely out of sight, Such a
process is even now going on in Hinduism under the influence of Christianity,
and, as the Hindu mind was during the ascendancy of Buddhism already well
prepared for a change by the teachings of the Buddhist missionaries, nodifficulty
was met with in making faith, devotion, and love supply the place of the ho-
locausts and unlimited meat offerings ordained by the Vedas. The abstention
was at first no doubt optional, but gradually it became general, partly
from a natural disposition to benevolence, and partly out of respect for the
feeling of Buddhist neighbours, such as the Muhammadans now evince for
their Hindu fellow-subjects by abstaining from beef in different parts of
Bengal, that writers found it easy to appeal to the practice of the people and
public feeling as proofs even as potent as the Vedas, and authoritatively to
declare that sacrifices were forbidden in the present age. This once done, the
change was complete. In short, the Buddhist appeal to humanity proved too
much for the Smriti, and custom has now given a rigidity to the horror
against the sacrifice of animal life, which even the Vedas fail to overcome.
* ffafa fansrra; i *mr, ut
>rr vf<T fa Wfa l
fsHfafaw: i
1872.]
197
The Conquest of South India in the Twelfth century by Parakrama Bahu, the
great King of Ceylon. — By T. W. Rhts Davids, District Judge, Anu-
radhapura, Ceylon.
It is known from Tumour’s Epitome and Armour’s translation of the
Dambulla inscription that Parakrama Bahu’s generals made successful ex-
peditions into South India, hut no detailed account has yet been published.
The history of these expeditions is given in the Mahawansa, chapters 76 and
77 ; hut as these contain 439 verses, equal to about one-seventli of the pub-
lished part of the hook, a translation of them would occupy too much space,
and would be a formidable task to undertake, while a shorter account
from one of the many trustworthy Sinhalese histories may be useful to those
who take interest in the history and ancient geography of the Dak’hin. I
have chosen the ‘ Narendracarit-avalokana-pradipikawa,’ the account in
which, though a mere abstract, may be depended upon to contain nothing
not found in the Mahawansa, and to bo in fact as far as it goes almost a
literal translation of that work with many omissions.
The chapter translated is the 66th ; the next goes on to relate how
Kulasekhara, after his flight in disguise, fortified himself in the stronghold*
of Tondamana, and afterwards, sallying thence, retook Ivandayaru, defeat-
ing two of Lankapura’s lieutenants : how Lanka pur a again defeated him,
re-established peace, and confirmed Wirapandu on the throne, restoring the
banished Tamil noblos to their lands, and anointing Wirapandu in the city
of Madura. It is mentioned also incidentally that on the orders of Para-
krama Bahu he struck copper coins (Kakawanu, from Kaliapana = Karsha-
pana). There are three copper coins of Parakrama Bahu, two given in Prin-
sep,f of which I know of at least twenty or thirty examples, and one very
rare with a well-executed lion on the reverse by the side of the standing
figure. It will also, I think, appear from the notes to this translation
that the gold coin with the inscription Lankeswara, unassigned by Prinsep,
must have been struck by Parakrama Bahu.
The 66 th Chapter of Narendracaritdvalolcana Pradipikdwa.
After that, when the Maharaja Parfikrama Balm was promoting religion
(Sdsana) and prosperity, after in the 8th year from his coronation, as is re-
lated above, he had fought the great fight with his enemies in Ruhunu rata,];
and having conquered was livirig in security ; although both because the
* Parwata widurgga.
f Edition by Thomas, I, 419.
J The southern part of Coylon.
198
Rhys Davids — The Conquest of South India. [No, 2,
belief of the people of Ram&nya was the same as that of the Buddha-
believing-men of Ceylon, and also because it was the ancient custom so to
do, Par&krama, the King, was living in peace with the King of Ramanya—
yet the ruler of Ramanya, listening to the words of wicked men, forsook the
old custom of providing maintenance for the ambassadors of the Lanka
rajfi,* and at the sale of elephants and tuskers raised the price above the
wonted price ; and further, when he read tho royal message sent to him, bid
saying, “ These messengers are sent to go to Kamboja,” and so plundered
all their goods and put them in prison in the Malaya country. And further,
without hearing the friendly words of the ambassador (dutdmdtya) Topas-
wi, sent about this matter by the king of Ceylon, he seized their (sic)
tuskers and ships, and having tortured them made them hewers of wood and
drawers of water : and he stopped the letters and seized the presents of honour
which the king of Ceylon sent to a chief (jeshta) in J ambudwipa named Ka-
syapa. Then one day he sent for the imprisoned ambassadors and said,
“ The Sinhalese ships had no right to come to our land ; therefore give me
letters under your hand that no wrong has been done to you, the ambas-
sadors.” So he frightened them with the fear of death, and took letters un-
der their hand. Then he put them both, namely, Wagiswaraeari and Dhar-
makirti Pandita, on board a leaky vessel and sent them out to sea.
Soon after, he seized some royal virgins sent by the king of Ceylon
to the king of Kamboja : on hearing this, Parakrama Bahu was very angry,
and assembled his council, and told them all the facts, saying, “ We must
kill or bring here that king who will be our enemy, which of you under-
takes the task ?” Damiladhikari, the chief of the astrologers, accepted the
task joyfully, and quickly made several hundred ships ready for sea, and in
less than five months put to sea with his fleet properly officered and with
provisions for twelve months, and shields to stop the swiftest arrows, and
swords, and bows, and arrows and poisonedf arrows, and all other kinds of
weapons, and doctors with their assistants.
Of these one ship arrived at Kakadwipa and having fought there and
taken the king and his ministers prisoners, brought and delivered them up
to Parakrama Bahu, tho king. Two ships arrived at the harbour Kusuma
in Aramuna, and took in battle and laid waste the country from the port
Sapattota,£ over which Kurttipurapam was Governor.
Damiladhikari himself arrived at the port Papphata, and there having
fought a great battle and taken the inhabitants alive and seized the
whole land of Ramanya, went on to the city of Ukkaka, and took prisoner the
Lord of Ramanya, and overcame the land: then going round the town on
* Query, Paying the salary of a Political Resident ?
f This word is doubtful, wisadewa, the latter half of which is not clear.
J Tota = tirtha ; pam = usually parwata.
1872.] Rhys Davids — The Conquest of South India. 199
the prime minister’s own white elephant, he proclaimed the orders of the
Lord of Ceylon.
At that time great fear fell on all the people of Rfimanya. They thought,
“ This has happened by our folly : in future let us give the tribute of ele-
phants as many as are wanted : and let us do service* * * § to the king.” So
they sent letters to the priesthood of Sri Lanka stating this, and asking that
the Lord of Ceylonf might be pleased to take away their fear. This
news the priests of the three sectsj made known to Parakrama llahu, and
it was ordered accordingly.
At that time, the Pandu king Parakrama of the city of Madura be-
ing terrified by the army with which king Kulasekliara was preparing to
attack him, fled for help to the royal feet of Parakrama Bahu : who listened
kindly to the ambassadors, thinking : “ It is right to protect those who
come to us for help,” and sending for Lank&pura-danda-ndtka, the minister,
commanded him saying— “ Go and establish Parakrama as overlord (maha-
raja) in his own country and slay that Kulasekhara.” So he received the
order on his own head, and made ready for the voyage at Mahatota.§
At that time Kulasekhara, the king, had already surrounded Madura
with a large army, and had taken prisoner the Pandu king and his army.
Parakrama Bahu, the great king, hearing this, sent orders saying “ Establish
in that kingdom some one who comes of the stock of the kings of Pandu.”
So Lankapura-danda-ndtlia|| with a great army filling several hundred ships
* Mehewara, homage.
f Lord of Ceylon = Lankeswara. Parakrama Bdhu’s full titlo given in his in-
scription at Dambulla is Aprati Malla Ni?sanka Malla Kalinga Lankeswara Para-
krama Bahu Cakra wartin wahanse. The Sanskrit Gatha at the commencement of
the great inscriptions at the Palace Gate in Pulastipura concludes, “Hear then wise
counsels, they are spoken by Ni?sanka Malla (Nissan! a malloditan). The name Lan-
keswara explains tho gold coin which Prinsep (Edition, -Thomas, Yol. I„ 421) could
not understand.
J There are several examples of the peace-making propensities of the Buddhist
priests in the Mahawansa (pp. 148, LXY , last line), but not one of their having stirred
up religions war. The union of these three sects [nik&J into one is always referred to
as one of Parakrama Bahu the Great’s most glorious achievements,
§ On the main land, opposite Mannar Island, there are still extensive ruins,
or rather heaps of ruins, in which many coins and jewels have been found after heavy
rains, among others the Lankeswara gold coin above alluded to.
|| This name occurs four times in the MS., Lankapurswlanda-ma-natha, Lankara-
pura-danda-natha, and twice simply Lankarapnra. As my MS. of theNarendra-carit-
avalokana-pradipikawa is the only one I know of, I have no moans of comparing MSS.,
and have simply chosen Lankapura as a well known word and likely name, which
Lankarapura is not. The latter has, however, this MS. in its favour and is quite
possible. Dandanatha or Manntha is about equal to Lord High Sheriff. The appoint-
ment of this officer and the chief astrologer as generals seem to me to imply, not so
200
[No. 2,
Rhys Davids — The Conquest of South India.
crossed the sea, and landed at a place called Laceilla (pronounce Lach-
chilla), and there fought with and defeated the army of a Tamil named Arak.
The rulers of the five districts (mandalika) Lattirikkaya-Naclalawala, Kunda-
muttara, Willacdra, Ancukottanaclalawara, Narasinha-dewa,then came up with
an army, and after a fierce fight were routed and defeated. In the tenth
battle, Sila-megha, Raja-tungabrahma, Hankiya-rayara, Ancukonda-rayara,
Palumbiya-rayara, Panasiyarayara, these, six rulers joined their forces to those
of the above named five ; but after a fierce battle they also were overthrown.
Then on the orders of Parakrama Bahu, Lankapura-dandanatha put
up a pillar about four gems from Rdmoswara and half way between the two
seas, and bringing many people from Kandukala there, he made them re-
pair all the viharas in Ceylon which they the Tamils had themselves de-
stroyed : and he formed at that place a town called Parakrama, surrounding
it with a large rampart, two thousand four hundred cubits long, and there
he lived.
At that time when the Sinhalese army having encamped was collecting
their forces from the divisions* Lokacukundi and Colaganga, Kulasekhara
sent Sundara, the Pandu king, and many councillors to the war, but Lanka-
rapura defeated them in three pitched battles, and took the town Marukkatta.
Prom thence in the battle with Alawana Perumal, he overcame the follow-
ing countries, villages, and townsf with their inhabitants, viz., Kolinraya,
Maruluthupaya, Sokacakundiya, Marawaraya, and Kunappunalliiraya. Again,
when the three chiefs Uttaraya, Gopuraya, and Kirtigajadwiraya assembled
their forces in Sempota-marita, he defeated the three armies of Kunnawara,
Kallara, and Wallakunnara, and took all their horses, chariots, elephants,
and baggage.
Kulasekhara then prepared for a campaign in the Kandayu district,
called Wisutrippalu, and with his generals Tuwaradhipati, Welara, Nanda-
matarana, Wirajjerayara, Nigasarayara, K ala wadi- n ala wara, Kanga-rayara,
and many others surrounded Kandayuruwa. But the Sinhalese comman-
ders, the energetic Lankapura and Jagadwijaya consulted together, joined
their forces, gave battle, and broke the armies of Kulasekhara and his Tamil
warriors, who fled to their own countries, and closing all their doors and
gates made themselves fast there. Then Dewa Lankapura and his generals
mucli that generals were chosen from the high civil officers, as that the high civil
appointments were filled (as is often the case in the backward states of society) by
military men.
* This use of the word mandalika is inconsistent with that noted above ; but
the dictionaries do not give the word, and the names seem clearly to point above to
men, and here to countries. Narasinha-deva could scarcely be applied to a country,
and Colaganga is as unlikely a name for a man.
f Niyamagrama.
201
1872.] Fryer — Note on an AraTcanese Coin.
Crokanna, Danda-nayaka, Kesa-dhatu, and Loka-wunga, collected their forces
at the Western gate,* and broke in, each through a different rampart or
gate, and entered the city, and slaughtered an immense host of Tamils and
their cavalry. Kulasekhara then became afraid, and escaped through the
East gate in disguise, and got away. So the Sinhalese destroyed many
Tamils, and took much plunder, and put up flags of victory, and celebrated
a festival of victory, and made Wirapandu king with great ceremony.
Note on an AraTcanese Coin. — By Captain Gf. E. Fetee, Officiating
Deputy Commissioner of Sandoway.
The subject of this paper is a small silver coin of about the size of a
four-anna piece (Fig. 1) bearing the following device, obverse, a bull cou-
Fig. 1.
chant, caparisoned, Nagari characters imperfect : reverse, the sun, and crescent
moon and trident within a circle, outside of which is a row of round dots.
The coin is smaller than those described by Captain Latter in the Jour-
nal for February, 1846, but is of precisely the same type as two therein
figured, one of which is here reproduced (fig. 2).
Captain Latter thought that they were “ Shivite coins probably apper-
taining to a time when the emblems of the wmrship of Shiva and those of
* The name of the city being not given, there must I think be a misreading in
the word Siyft-nandawu-rata, translated above 11 to their own countries. (Srya,
one’s own from siua). Nagara in Sanskrit is nuwara in Sinhalese, and to. is the sign
of the dative case; the latter half of siyanandawu- rata should therefore perhaps be
nmvam/a and the former half the name of the city, Siyana or Siyata (there being
so distinction made in my MS. between t and n), or Some such name.
202
Fryer — Note on an Arakanese Coin.
[No. 2,
Buddhism had something in common ; for we see in them the Buddhist
triglyph represented by the trident of Shiva. On each side is a scroll and
beneath are certain round dots. These dots are curious, for they here occupy
the same position in reference to the triglyph of Shiva that the guttte do
to the triglyph of architecture,” and he called them symbolical coins, be-
cause lie considered they represented “ whatever ideas they were intended
to convey by means of pure symbolism alone, and afforded no clue by which
to connect them with any particular prince.”
The characters upon the coin now exhibited are too indistinct to admit
of their being deciphered, but those upon Captain Latter’s are clear and well
defined, and I trust to he able to show that they are not, as has been
supposed, symbolical coins, but arc, in fact, records of an ancient dynasty of
Araltan kings. The titles upon the obverse of Captain Latter’s coins, are
here reproduced.
a. b. c.
Captain Latter considered “ (c) to represent the characteristics of the
old Pali Alphabet with the exception of the first letter and may be read Sri
Vrieghau. The other two may be determined by those better versed in the
old Nagari character ; (b) is of a more ancient type than («), which last
is of the same class as the characters comprising the inscription on the tem-
ple of Shiva in the village of Darshi, described in the Society’s Journal, No.
43, July, 1835.”
With the exception of the final compound ndr in («) and {/>), which is
probably modern, the characters seem to correspond with the Sanskrit of the
fifth century A. D., as given in the table of modifications at p. 276, Vol. VII
of the Journal, for 1838.
Our Assistant Secretary, Pratapachandra Ghosh a, well-versed in Nagari
characters, has proposed the following readings for these letters — (c) instead
of Sri vrieghau , he would read Sri-vi-krama : ( b ) Sri-ta-candra : (a) Dham-
ma-chandra. Thus two out of the three end in chandra.
Captain Latter in his paper states, that a popular tradition is connected
with these coins, which shortly is as follows : — a certain Arakan king, before
setting out on a voyage to China, left with his wife a ring, and told her in
case he did not return in seven years, she was to raise to the throne and
marry any person whom it would fit. It fitted a herdsman whom she mar-
ried, and who, in commemoration of his origin, put on these corns an ox and
a goad (the trident).
In Vol. XIII of the Journal, pp. 36, 37, Captain (now Sir Arthur)
Phayre tells us in his 1 History of Arakan,’ that the monarch who set out for
203
1872.] Fryer — Note on an Arakanese Coin.
China was Gala taing candra, the ninth and last sovereign of the dynasty
of the city of Vaisali, and that his wife Cau-da-devi, in ^ .1 ai9, firs^
married and raised to the throne a chief of the Myu tribe, named Amyatu,
and on his death, seven years after, married his nephew Pe-byu, both of whom
the ring was found to fit. After Pe-byu's accession in A. D. 904, he aban-
doned the city of Vaisali, and closed a dynasty which had virtually ended
in A. D. 957, when Cula taing candra was drowned on his return from China.
All the names in this dynasty end in candra, and that of the seventh king
Siri taing candra is so like Sri ta candra on one of Captain Latter’s coins,
that the identity seems complete.
I think therefore we may rightly regard these coins as records of the
Vaisali dynasty of Arakan, of which there reigned in lineal succession nine
kings from A. D. 788 to 957, or throughout a period of 169 years, syn-
chronous with the Anglo-Saxon period of English history.
Dynasty of Vaisali. A. D.
1. Maha taing candra, 788
2. Suriya taing candra, 810
3. Mola taing candra, 830
4. Pola taing candra, 849
5. Kala taing candra, 875
6. Dula taing candra, 884
7. Siri taing candra, 903
8. Singha taing candra, 935
9. Cula taing candra, 951
26
0
20 i
[No. 2
List of the Boolcs con tained in Chand's poem, the Prithiraj a Baso. — By
John Beam eh, B. C. 8., Balasore.
I receive so many letters from enquirers in various parts of India ask-
ing for information as to whether this or that poem is to he found in the
genuine works of Chand, that I conceive the Society would be doing a favour
to scholars in publishing the following accurate list in supersession of some
defective and inaccurate list previously made public.
There are in circulation in some parts of India scraps of bardic poems
all of which are dignified by the name of Chand. Some of these are appa-
rently extracts from the real work, others are by entirely different authors.
Five MSS. may be taken to be genuine ; —
1. The Baidla.
2. Colonel Tod’s, R. A. JSocy.
3. Colonel Caulfield’s, do.
4. The Bodleian.
5. The Agra College.
All these five I have seen, and compared the headings of the chapters
in each ; with very few and trifling exceptions they all agree in this respect,
and we may, therefore, on their authority pronounce the following list to be
correct, and may reject, or at least look with suspicion on, all fragments of
old Hindi rhapsodies which do not find a place in it. If genuine, they
are at any rate not “ canonical.” I give a brief note of the contents of
those prastavas which I have read, of the rest merely the names and num-
ber of kavitts are given.
1. Adi Farva. 401 kavitts.* Invocations, legends of early sages, the
origin of the Chauhan race, their genealogy, birth of Prithiraj.
2; Da'sama. 220k. Poems on the ten avatars of Vishnu.
3. Di'li'ki'lr katha'. 39k. Story of the iron pillar.
4. Aja'nva'h. 18k. 166 lines also called Lohana Ajanvahu.
5. Kanhapatti. 64k. also called Kanhakhapatti. Kanh the Chauhan
kills PratSp Singh the Clialuk in open darbar, because he twisted his mous-
tache. Prithiraj compels him to wear a bandage over his eyes in darbar ;
hence the name of the book.
6. A'khetak bir. 113k. Marvellous story of a hunting expedition in
in which Chand sees Siva and gets a blessing from him.
7. Na'har Rai. 118k. Fight with Nahar Rai.
8. Mewa'ti' Mugal. 45k. Fight with the Mewatis.
* Each kavitt, or ckhand, contains generally about 30 lines, except Sathak, doha
and one or two peculiar and rarely used metros, which seldom exceed 8 lines each.
205
1872.] Beames — List' of Boolcs in Chattel J
9. Husen Katha. 94k. Battle with Shahabuddin, who came after
Husen Khan, one of his chiefs, who had taken refuge with Prithiraj. Shahab
is captured, but released, Husen slain.
10. A'khet Chu'k. 30k. Shah&b attacks Prithiraj when out hunting,
with very few attendants, but is defeated.
11. Chitrarekha'. 17k. Story of Chitrarekha, the Gakkhar princess,
who was the causa belli between Shahab and Husen Khan in Bit. 9. She
was the Shah’s concubine and Husen ran’away with'her.
12. Bhola Rai'. 285k. War with Bhola Rai of Gujarat.
13. Salakh Judh. 94k. Salakh takes the Sultan captive, he is re-
leased.
14. Inchhini' Vyah 118k. Prithiraj’s marriage with Inchhini.
15. Mugal Judh. 20k. Battle with the Mughals.
10. Da'himi Vya'h. 16k. Marriage with Daliimi, daughter of Chain!
Sen, the Pundir.
17. Bhu'mi Swapan. 47k.
18. Dillida'n. 47.' Gift of the kingdom of Dilli to ‘Prithiraj by his
grandfather Anangapal, the Tuar.
19. Ma'dho Bha't. 113k. Visit of Madho the Bliat, fresh attack by
the Sultan Shahabuddln ; he is captured and let go again on paying a fine in
accordance with Rajput custom.
20. Padma'vati Vya'h. 4*6k. Already translated by me in J. A. S. B.
I reckoned it as the 19th book, but it is the 20th. In Tod’s copy, the Ak-
het bir is not counted. This omission makes all the numbering of the chap-
ters wrong by one throughout.
21. Alha' TJdal. Also called P r i t h i r a j a r a y a s o, a name differ-
ing from Prithiraj raso, but often erroneously applied to the whole poem ; it is
also called M ah o b a S a m y o, 308 kavits ; occupies 52 quarto pages. The
longest but one of all the chapters.
Relates the war with Parimal, the Chandel King of Mahoba, in which
he was assisted by the two heroes A'lha and Udal of the Banaphar clan.
22. Pritha Vya'h. 99k. Marriage of Pritha, sister of Prithiraj with
Samar Singh, Raja of Chittrakot.
23. Holi Katha' 22. Short kavitts. Description of the Holi festival ,
the origin of which is attributed tc5 Siva’s gift to a female devotee, contrary
to the modern Vaishnava theory.
24. Di'pma'i Katha'. 35k. Legendary origin of the Dipmala or De-
wali festival.
25. Dhan Katha'. 314k. Prithiraj finds a treasure in the Kliattu
forest. While digging it up, is attacked by the Sultan whom, as usual, he
captures and releases.
206
[No. 2,
Beames —List of Books in Chand.
26 Sa'sibrata'. 542k. Abduction of Sasibrata, daughter of the Raja
of Deogiri, by Prithiraj, and war with Jay chand of Kanauj in consequence.
27. Devagiri. 64k. Siege of Deogiri by Jaychand and his ultimate
defeat by Chamand Rsii, one of Prithiraj ’s generals.
28. Rewa'tata. 96k. Battle with the Sultan on the banks of the
Rewa.
29. Anangpa'l 98k. Anangpal returns to Dilli, but after a short
stay returns to Badrinath. (He wanted to get the kingdom back again
from Prithiraj, but failed).
30. Gliagharki lara'i. 48k. Battle with the Shah at the Ghaghar
river (Daradwati, near Ambala).
31. Karnati Patra. 23k. Prithiraj goes to the “ Kamata des” in the
south.
32. Pi'pa' Judh. 72k.
33. Indra'vati Vya'h. 70k. Also called “ Samar Si Raja.”
33. (34) Indra'vati Vya'h. 60k. A second book with the same name
as the preceding, but with separate heading and ending.
34. (35) Jait Rao Judh. 36k. The Sultan surprises Prithiraj while
hunting ; Jait Rao seizes him (they are always doing this).
35. (36) Ka'ngura'. 32k. Prithiraj takes the hill fort of Kangura
(Kangra ?)
36. (37) Hansa'vati Vya'h. 155k. Marriage with Hansavati.
37. (38) Pa'har Ra'i. 7lk.
38. (39) Barun Katha'. 33k.
39. (40) Somesar badh. 88k. Death of Somesar, Prithiraj’s father,
(killed by Bhola Bhim of Gujarat).
40. (41) Pajjun chhonga'na'. 17k.
41. (42) Pajjun chalukya. 29k.
42. (43) Chand Dwa'rika'. 59k. Chand’s pilgrimage to Dwarika.
43. (44) Raima's Judh. 79k. Kaimas, one of Prithiraj’s generals,
seizes the Sultan in the Ivhattu forest.
44. (45) Bhi'm Badh. 148k. Prithiraj kills Bhola Rai Bhimang, the
Chalukya Raja of Gujarat, who had killed his father Somesar.
45. (46) Vinaya Mangal. 188k. In two parts. 1st of 142 kavitts,
relates the previous birth of Sanyogita. 2nd in 86k. her penance.
46. (47) Suk varnan. 78k.
47. (48) Ba'luka' Rai. 119k.
48. (49) Panga Jagya vidhwansa. 20k.
49. (50) Sanjogita nem. Sanjogita’s vow to marry Prithiraj.
50 (51) Hansi Judh. 203k. In two parts, 1st, pratham judh, 90k. ;
2nd, dwitiyajudli, 113k.
51. (52) Pajju'n mahuba. 23k.
1872.] Beames — List of Boolcs in Chand. 207
52. (53) Pajjun Pa'tisa'h Judh. 34k. Sultan gets cauglit again for the
twentieth time or so ; as he is always released again, it does not much
matter.
53. (54) Sa'mant Panga Judh. 25k.
54. (5C) Samar Panga Judh. 62k. Fight of Jaichand Rao with Sa-
mar Si.
65. (58) Raima's Badh. 186k. Death of Kaimas.
56. (57) Durga' Keda'r. 168k. Sultan gets taken again.
57- (58) Dilli varnan. 17k.
58. (56) Jangam Katha'. 7k. At end“ jangam sophi katha.”
59. (00) Kanavajja Judh. 1455 kavitts. Prithiraj ’s war with Raja Jay
Chand of Kanauj. The longest book in the whole poem, 121 quarto pages.
80. (81) S'ukcharitra 102k. Interlude.
01. (82) Akhhet chakh s'ra'p. 1181c.
02. (83) Dhi'r Pundi'r. 3121c. Exploits of Dhir, the Pundir ; takes
the Sultan again, and again lets him go — for the last time.
03. (84) Bibah Samyo. 31c. List of Prithiraj’s wives.
04. (85) Bari' lara'i. 937k. The great battle in which Prithiraj was
taken.
05. (08) Ba'n bedh. 3631c. Events following the battle. Chand s search
for Prithiraj. Conversation with the Sultan. Death of Prithiraj (I have not
read the book through, but there seem to be many historical facts in it. It
is worth special attention. I think I make out that Chand goes to Ghazni
to seek for Prithiraj, hut am not sure without fuller perusal.)
08. (07) Rayan Si. 116k. Narayan Singh (familiarly Rayan Si), son
of Prithiraj is duly crowned king, hut is soon after killed, and Dilli sacked
and everything comes to an end. _
67. (68) 3k. Three supplementary kavitts about the poem itself.
68. (89) Birbhadra. 8k. A short supplementary chapter.
The full number of 69 hooks is made up by counting the two parts of
book 33 separately as 33 and 34. I have indicated this method of counting
by the figures in brackets.
JOURNAL
OF THE
ASIATIC SOCIETY.
— ♦ —
Part I. -HISTORY, LITERATURE, &e.
No. III.— 1872.
The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. — By A. M. Beoadley, Esq., C. S.
I. Biha'r in Patna.
General Cunningham in speaking of and describing the kingdom of
Magadha writes as follows “ As this country was the scene of Buddha’s
early career, as a religious reformer, it possesses a greater number of holy
places connected with Buddhism than any other province of India. The
chief places are Buddha-Gaya, Kukkutapada, Raj agriha, Kusagarapura, Na-
landa, Indrasilaguha, and the Kapotaka monastery.” Of these seven places,
no less than live are situated within the boundary of the sub-division Bihar,
which forms a large section of the Patna Zil’ah.
The word Bihar has in turn served to designate several artificial divi-
sions of this part of India. The name originally belonged to the ancient
city, which from its far-famed seat of Buddhistic learning was distinguished
by the name ‘ Bihar’ [Sanscrit, f^TTY]. The Muhammadan conquerors of the
city extended its name to the surrounding country, of which it became the
capital ; and at the time of Akbar it came to signify that important portion
of Eastern India comprised in the seven sirkars of Hunger, Chanfparan,
Hajipdr, Saran, Tirhut, Rohtas, and Bihar. This was Sdbah Bihar. Un-
der British rule, Sdbah Bihar and Subah Bengal were united under a joint
government, while the Zil’ah, surrounding the capital and which bore its
name, was divided into Zil’ah Patna and Zil’ah Gaya. In 1861, the impor-
tant parganahs of Biliar and liajgir were detached from the jurisdiction of
Gaya, and, together with the parganahs of Tillarah, Pillich, and Biswak,
formed into a sub-division, bearing the name of Bihar and within the
* ‘Ancient Geography of India,’ Yol. I, p. 455.
27
v
L
210 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
jurisdiction of Zil’ah Patna. Sub all Bihar, for more than a century, has
ceased to exist except in name. Zil’ah Bihar has now disappeared from the
map of India, and the name can now only as a matter of fact be properly
applied to the ancient Muhammadan capital, founded by Bakhtyar Khilji,
and the five surrounding parganahs of which it is still the chief town.
The tract of country about which I shall have to speak, extends for
about thirty-five miles from north to south, and forty from east to west.
With the exception of the solitary mountain rock of Bihar, the country
presents an almost unbroken plain, sloping gradually from the foot of the
Eajagrilia Hills (which form the southern boundary of the sub-division) down
to the hanks of the Ganges. The greater part of this tract of country is
singularly fertile, being watered by various streams which descend from
the southern hills to join the Ganges below Patna. The Panchani .River
enters Bihar almost under the shade of the Indra-Sailapeak at Giryak,
and flows south-west till it reaches the ancient city. At this point several
branches of it intersect the various ‘ mahallahs’ of the town, while the
main course of the river still flows to the north, and enters the Ganges
near Barb, the chief station of a Sub-Division bearing that name, which lies
between Bihar and the banks of “ the sacred stream.” The Panchani was
once an important river. Vast sandy wastes, on either side of it, now only
serve to indicate the extent of its original channel. In the summer months,
the bed of the river is almost wholly dry. Not only has the current itself
almost ceased to flow, but what remains of it, is almost entirely carried away
into a large hollow, or “ pyne” four miles south of Bihar, in conse-
quence of a large sand bed having formed a few miles below the town. The
silting-up of this sand-bank has altered the whole appearance of the city. In
exploring its outskirts, the eye often lights on a spacious bridge now spanning
a rice field or a piece of waste-land, and on ruined ghats, which now only
serve to bound a scorching expanse of arid sand.
The archaeological and historical interest of this narrow tract of country
may be almost said to be unrivalled. It was in the midst of the rugged
range of hills, which forms its southern boundary, that once flourished the
mighty Kusfig&rapura, the metropolis of Magadha ; outside its western
walls, in the dark “ Valley of the Five Hills,” [the BanbhiSm of to-day] was
fought a great battle mentioned in theMahabharata. Here also Sakhya Muni —
still the “ Adorable Lord” of three hundred millions of men — spent a great
portion of his life. Almost within a stone’s throw of the northern foot of the
hills are still to be seen the Btately remains of New Bajagriha — Bajagri-
harapura — the capital of Ajata Satru, son of Bimbisara, the contemporary
of Buddha. In the plain itself lie the ruins of “ our holy mother Nalanda,”
the gorgeous Queen of Buddhistic convents, and of the less important
monasteries ot Tillarali, Titrawan, Ghosrawan, and Hurugawan. Still further
211
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr.
north of these places lies Bihar, once the academia, or vihara, of the country
south of the Ganges, and still later the metropolis of the Muhammadan
lieutenants, who sometimes ruled this garden of India as the delegates of
the emperor of Dihli, sometimes of the kings of Bengal.
On the 15th March, 1871, I took charge of the Sub-Division of Bihar,
and ever since that time, have devoted such of my leisure as I could spare
from my official duties, to the examination of the antiquities of the country,
he they Muhammedan, Hindu, or Buddhistic ; hut in the following pages I
speak only of the last ; the others will, I trust, one day form the subject of
separate papers. The ruins of the Nalanda monasteries have been described
in a separate pamphlet, and I therefore barely allude to them here.
II. Ancient Magadha.
The name of the ancient kingdom of Magadha dates as far back as the
time of the Mahiibharata. In the map of India, which illustrates Mr.
Talboy Wheeler’s History of these remote times, the territories of Magadha
are shewn to the south of the river Ganges, bounded on one side by Mithila
and on the other by Banga, or Bengal. In the pages of the great Sanskrit
epic, an account is given of the wars of Bliima and Iv r i sh i i a with Jaiasan-
dha, king of Magadha ; but I merely allude to it here, because I propose to
write exclusively of a much more recent period in the history of India. I
shall, however, from time to time be compelled to make some allusion to the
great Asura king, whose history is inseparably associated by the traditions
of the people with the places about which I propose to write.
Passing over a number of centuries, we come to the time when Ohi-Fah-
Hiyan left his home at Tchang’au in China, to “ follow the footsteps” of
the great sage of Magadha, whose teaching, nigh a thousand years before,
had caused a new religion to spead itself with wonderful rapidity over the
greater part of the continent of Asia.*
* The travels of Chi-Fah-Hiyan were first translated into French by MM. Bemu-
sat, Klaproth, and Landrosse. An English version of this work was published by Mr.
Lai’dlay, in Calcutta, in 1848. In 1869, the Eev. S. Beal published an original trans-
lation from the Chinese text. Great doubts are entertained as to the correctness of
portions of the French work, and M. Julien points out that it cannot be safely used
by persons nnnble to verify the translation by comparison with the original. Under
these circumstances I make reference only to the edition of Mr. Beal.
Throughout Fah-Hian’s work, distances are computed by ‘ lis’ and ‘ yojanas.’
Mr. Beal allows four or five lis to the mile, General Cunningham six, and this
estimate is doubtless correct. As to the second measure, Mr. Beal allows seven
miles to a yojana in the North-West Provinces, and only four in Magadha. Gen-
eral Cunningham counts 'uniformly 71 or 8 miles as equal to a yojana. From a
comparison of the distances given in Bihar, the very centre of the kingdom of Magadha,
I do not see how more than five or six miles can, by any possibility, be allowed, e. g.,
Bihar to Nalanda, one yojana, actual distanoe 51 or 6 miles ; Patna to Bihar, 9
212 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Rih&r. [No. 3,
In the pages of the account which he wrote of his Indian travels, Magadha
has a prominent place, no less than four chapters being occupied in the rela-
tion of his wanderings in that kingdom.* Before retracing our steps to the
time of Sakhya Muni himself, I must say something of another great travel-
ler, who, two centuries later, passed over very nearly the same route as his
predecessor. On the 1st August, 629, A. D. Hwen Thsang left his home
at Liang-cheu, on a similar errand to that of Chi-Fah-Hiyan,f and it is not
till A. D. 644 that he again arrives in the frontiers of his native land. Ac-
cording to the computation of General Cunningham, he reached Magadha on
February 10th, 637, and remained there till January, A. D. 639. It also
appears that he revisited it during the spring of A. D. 642. The Buddhist
pilgrim has bequeathed to posterity an account of his travels, and of the
places and people he visited, the historical and archaeological value of which
it is impossible to overrate. It is much to be regretted, that no carefully
annotated English translation has as yet been prepared of these invaluable
records. In this instance the French have gone before us, and it is to M.
Stanislaus Julien that the world is indebted for its knowledge of the history,
geography, and antiquities of India during the 7th century of our era. This
eminent scholar has published two entirely distinct works on the subject,
and for reasons which I shall presently state, I deem it best to give the
title of them in full.
The first appeared in 1853. It is entitled “ Histone de la vie de
Hiouen Thsang et de ses voyages dans l’Hinde depuis l’an 629 jusqu’en 645,
par Hoei-li et Yen-Thsang, suivie de documents et d’eclaircissements geo-
grapliiques tires de la relation originale de Hiouen Thsang, traduite de
Chinois par Stanislaus Julien.” The second was published at Paris five
years later, and bears the title “ Memoires sur les contrees ocoidentales,
traduit du Sanscrit en Chinois en l’an 648 par Hiouen Thsang, et du
Chinois en Francais par M. Stanislaus Julien. Paris 1857.”!
yojanas, actual distance about 54 miles ; Nalanda to Rajgir, one yojana, actual
distance, 5£ or 6 miles. For these reasons I consider a yojana as equivalent to a dis-
tance of between 5 and 6 miles.
* Beal’s « Fah-Hiyan,’ pp. 102-119.
t Cunningham’s * Ancient Geography of India/ p. 563.
X The following will shew the discrepancies between both editions, as far as
Magadha is concerned —
JT. — “ Histoire de la vie de Hiouen Thsang 1853.
213
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of RihAr.
It would be impossible to overrate the vast importance of these records,
and the travels of Fah-Hiyan and Hwen Thsang will form as it were the
basis of my attempt to describe the Buddhistic remains of this part of the
kingdom of Magadha. We can now go hack to the time of the great found-
er of the Buddhist faith, and see how deeply connected Magadha was with
many of the most important episodes in his life.
Buddhism arose in India about the beginning of the sixth century
before Christ. Its founder was Sakhya Muni, son of Suddhodana, ruler of
the country of Kapila, which appears to have been situated some distance
to the north of Banaras. The tenets of his religion may be shortly
summed up as follows.* I. — That man may become superior to the gods.
II. — That Nirvanaf is the supreme good. III. — That religion consists in
a right preparation of the heart (suppression of evil desire, practice of self-
JI — “ Memoir es sur les Contrees Occidentales ,” 1857.
It would be an almost endless task to attempt to point out the discrepancies
which exist between these two accounts, much more so to convey a satisfactory expla-
nation of them, but I have stated them in the onset to shew the extreme difficulty of
a satisfactory or positively correct identification of the places alluded to, and to de-
monstrate how little we can trust the distances and directions which form the only
data on which we can rely.
* Beal, Introduction, p. 49.
I I. e . , exemption from sorrow, complete unconsciousness of, and indifforence to,
external objects.
214 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
denial, active benevolence). IV. — That men of all castes and women may
enjoy the benefits of a religious life.
The religion, of which these are the principles, spread from the moun-
tain solitudes of the ltajgir Hills to the remotest parts of Eastern Asia,
and is at the present day professed by no less than three hundred millions
of human beings. I have not the slightest intention to dwell even for a
moment on the details of the Buddhist creed, which have been so eloquently
and clearly explained and illustrated by Messrs. Beal, Alabaster, and Bishop
Bigandet, and shall only allude to them again when I come to speak of the
causes of the ultimate decay and overthrow of the Buddhist faith in Hindu-
stan.
All writers who have attempted to gather together the half historical,
half mythical, facts connected with the life of the great sage of Magadha,
have agreed in naming Rajgir and N&landa as the scene of many of the epi-
sodes of his history.
It appears that at the very commencement of his religious career, he
was attracted by the wild mountain solitudes which surrounded the Maga-
dha capital. Alabaster, in his translation of the Siamese Life of Buddha,* gives
the following poetical account of his arrival at Iiaj agriha. ‘ He entered the
city, and visited each house he came to, that he might receive alms. As-
tounded at his beauty, the people crowded round him, wondering who it might
he. Some said, “ Surely it is the moon flowing from the Eavanaso Asura Rahu,
how else can we account for his radiant glory ?” Others made other guesses, and
they could come to no conclusion. So they went and told the king Bimbisara,
king of Rajagriha, that there was a being in the city whose beauty made
them doubt whether he were not an angel. Then the king, looking from a
window of the palace, saw him, and, filled with astonishment, gave orders to
ascertain who he might be, saying, “ Follow him ! If he is not a human
being, when he leaves the city, he will disappear ; if he is an angel, he will fly
through the air ; if a snake king, he will sink into the earth ; hut if a man,
he will remain and eat his food.”
< r[’|10 grand being that was approaching the Buddhaship, calmly con-
tinued his work, regarding but the small space of earth close around him ;
and having collected sufficient food, he left the city by the same gate he had
entered it.
• He passed on to the Banthawa Hills, and sitting down on the summit
of a lofty rock, he looked at the food collected in his pan.
‘ He — who had ever been accustomed to the most dainty meats, the most
refined delicacies — looked at the mixed mess in his pot and loathed it ; he
could scarcely swallow it. Yet even this caused no wish to return to his city
and his palace.
* P. 135.
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. 215
‘ He reflected on the foulness of his own body, and ate without further
aversion. He finished his meal, rinsed his mouth, washed his pan, and re-
placed it in his wallet, and seated himself in a position of contemplation on
the rocky clift.
‘ Then the officers who had been set to watch him, returned and told king
Bimbisara that he was certainly a man ; and the king desiring to converse
with him, called for his royal palankeen, and attended by a great train of
noblemen and soldiers, went forth to seek him at the Banthawa Hills.
< Sitting on a rocky slab, the king gazed with delight at the grand being,
and observed the grace of his manners and thus addressed him :
“ Man of beauty, whence comest thou ?”
' ‘ Most excellent lord, I come from the country of Sakya.’
“ Prom what Sakya country ?”
* Prom the royal city, Kapila.’
« The king continued to question him as to his caste, family, and name,
and was informed in answer, that he was of the royal race (caste) of the
Sakyas, the son of king Suddhodana and named Siddhartha.
‘ Now king Bimbisara and the prince Siddhartha were on most friendly
terms. Though they had never met, and did not know each other by sight,
they were in the constant habit of exchanging presents as tokens of good
will, and when the grand being announced his name, the king was assured,
beyond all doubt, by his admirable manners and language, that it was none
other than his friend.
‘ He reflected that perhaps the prince had fled from his country on ac-
count of some family quarrel, and under that impression, he invited him to
share his power — to rule over half the great country of Magadha. Then
the grand being told him the reasons, the object for which he had resigned
the empire of the world. He told him of the four sights which had in-
fluenced his thoughts, and of his determination to achieve the omniscient
Buddhahood. And the king having obtained from him a promise that after
the attainment of omniscience, he would first teach in Rajagriha, did homage,
and returned to his city.’
In Hr. Bigandet’s Life of the Burmese Buddha, we find a great deal
more allusion made to Rajgir than in Mr. Alabaster’s translation from the
Siamese.* He tells us that Buddha set out for Bajgir [Radzagio], and halt-
ed in a grove of palm trees a short distance from the city, where he was met
by Bimbisara [Pimpattara] at the head of 120,000 warriors, to whom he
delivered a religious discourse. Next day he made a triumphal entry into
Rajgir. “ Then Pimpattara, king of Magaritz [Magadha], thought within
himself of the thing which could prove acceptable to Phra, in order
to offer it to him. He said within himself : my garden, which is situated
* P. 101, etc.
216 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihar. [No. 3,
near the city, would doubtless be a very fit place for Buddha and his
followers to live in, as it lies not far from the city ; it would be a place of
easy resort to all those who would feel inclined to visit Buddha and pay
him their respect ; it is moreover far enough, that the noise and cries
of the people could not be heard therein ; the place is peculiarly fitted for
retreat and contemplation ; it will assuredly prove agreeable to Buddha.
Whereupon he rose up, and holding in bis hand a golden shell, like a cup, he
made to Phra a solemn offering of that garden, which was called Weluwana.
Gaudama remained silent in token of his acceptance of the gift. He preach-
ed the law and left the palace. At that time he called his disciples and
said to them, “ Beloved liahans, I give you permission to receive offerings.”
He next proceeds to recount the conversion from schism of Sariputra
[Thariputra] and Mogalan [Mankalan], who subsequently became the chief
disciples of Buddha. After this event, Buddha continues to preach, teach at
the Kalandavanonvana Vihara,* but at last yields to the frequent messages
of his royal father and returns to Kapila.f The next chapter, however, is
devoted to legends connected with his three years’ stay at Ra j agriha, i. e.,
the dedication of the Dzetawoon [?] monastery, the miraculous cure of
Djvika, and the avarice of Mogalan. In the succeeding chapter we leam
that Buddha spent the 11th season of his religious life at Nalanda, and 17th
and 20th again at Raj agriha. After this Sariputra set out for his native
place Nalanda, to enter into that state of unconsciousness — the much-longed
for Nirvana — which formed the consummation of religious life. I quote
Bigandet’s translation of this part of the biography, as a specimen of Bud-
dhist writing, and as peculiarly interesting on account of its close connection
with the rains of the great Nalanda monastery.
‘ It was little before dark when the great Bahan arrived at the en-
trance of the Nalaka village. He went to rest at the foot of a banian tree
close to that spot. At that time there came a young man, his nephew,
named Ooparewata, who perceiving Thariputra bowed down before him and
stood in that place. The great Rahan said to him : “ Is your grandmother at
home ?” Having been answered in the affirmative, he continued addressing
him: “ Go now to her and tell her to prepare for me the room wherein I was
born, and a place for these five hundred Rahans that accompany me. I will
stay for a while in the village, and will go to her house, but this evening.
The lad went in all haste to his grandmother’s house and said to her : “ My
uncle is come, and is staying at the entrance of the village.” “ Is he alone,”
* Beal, p. 117, note. Although he states the monastry to be called in Singalese
(as in Burmese) Weluwana, he supposes it to have been the gift of a rich landow-
ner, Kalanda. The Burmese text, however, states distinctly that it was the religious
gift of Buddha.
f Bigandet, p. 120.
217
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
inquired the grandmother, “ or has he with him a numerous retinue ? For
what purpose is he coming here ?” The young man related to her all the
particulars of his interview with his uncle. Nupathari, the mother of Tha-
riputra, thought within her self: perhaps my son who has been a Italian
from his youth, desires in his old age to leave his profession. She, however,
gave orders to have the desired room cleaned, and a place prepared for all
his attendants.
‘ In the evening the great disciple went to his mother’s house with all
his followers. He ascended to the room prepared for him and rested there-
in. He hade all the Italians to withdraw and leave him alone. They had
scarcely departed when a most violent disease seized Thariputra, which
caused an abundant vomiting of blood, so great indeed, that the vessel
wherein it flowed could not hold it. His mother, at the sight of such an
awful distemper, did not dare to approach, hut with a broken heart retired
into her own room, leaning against the door. At that time four great Nats,
a Thagia, their chief, and four Brahmas came to see him, and to minister unto
him, during his painful illness, hut he bade them retire. His mother
seeing the coming in and going out of so many distinguished visitors, and
the respect they paid to her son, drew near to the door of his room and
calling the faithful Tsanda, inquired from him wherefore so many distin-
guished individuals had come. Tsanda explained to her that the great Nats,
the chief of Thagias, had come to visit and assist her son, and enjoy the
presence of the great Kahan.
< Meanwhile he informed the patient that his mother wished to see him.
Thariputra replied that the moment was not a proper one, and asked from
his mother the motive of her untimely visit. “ Beloved son,” said she, “ I am
come here to contemplate your ever dear countenance. But who are they,
those that have just come to see you ?” Thariputra explained to her how
he had been visited by Nats, Thagias, and Brahmas. His mother inquiring
from him if he were greater than any one of these, he hesitatingly replied
that he was more excellent than any of them. His mother thought within
herself : if my son be so exalted, how much more must Buddha be. Her
heart was then overflowed with the purest joy.
< Thariputra rightly understood that the moment had come to preach
the law to his mother. He said to her : “ Woman, at the time my great
teacher was born, when he obtained the supreme intelligence and preached the
most excellent law, a great earthquake was felt throughout ten thousand
worlds. No one has ever equalled him in the practice of virtue, in under-
standing, wisdom, and in the knowledge oi, and the affection for, the trans-
cendent excellencies of the state ol a rahat. He then went on explaining to
her the law and many particulars relating to the person of Buddha. “ Be-
loved son,” said his mother, delighted with all that she heard, “ why have you
28 Si
218 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. [No. 3,
been so late in acquainting me with such a perfect law ?” At the conclusion
of the instruction, she attained the state of Thantapam. Thariputra replied :
“ Now, woman, I have repaid you for all the labours you have bestowed on me
in bearing, nursing, and educating me ; depart from me and leave me alone.”
‘ Thariputra inquired from the devoted Tsanda whether the moment had
come. Having been informed that is was daylight, he requested to be set
up. By his order all the Bahans were called to his presence, and he said to
them, “ During the last forty-four years you have ever been with me ; should
I have offended any one during all that time I beg to be pardoned.” The
Bahans answered him : — “ Great teacher, we have lived with you during the
last forty years, and have been your inseparable attendants, following you
everywhere, as the shadow follows the body. We have never experienced
the least dissatisfaction from your part, but we have to request your for-
bearance and pardon for ourselves.”
‘ It was on the evening of the full moon Satsaongmon (November) that
Thariputra went to his mother’s place, and laid in the room wherein he had
been born. During the night he was attacked with the most distressing
distemper. In the morning at daylight, ho was habited with his tsiwaran
and made to lie on his right side. He entered into a sort of ecstacy, passed
successively from the first state of Dzan to the second, third, and fourth, and
thence dived into the bottomless state of Niban, which is the complete
exemption from the influence of passion and matter.’
After the death of Buddha, his relics were brought to Bajgir and 1 juried
there by the reigning prince. The following account of then1 reception at
the capital of Magadha is given in Bishop Bigandet’s translation of the Bur-
mese life of Buddha.* 1 King Adzatathat ordered a beautiful and well levelled
road, eight oothabas broad, to bo made from the city of Kuthinaran to that
of Badzagio. The distance is twenty-five youdzanas. He wished to adorn
it, in all its length, in the same manner as the Malla princes had done for
the road leading from the place that had been decorated with all sorts of
ornaments, to that where the relics had been deposited. At fixed and pro-
per distances, houses were built for resting and spending the night. The
king attended by a countless crowd of people, went to take the relics and
carry them into his country. During the journey, singing, dancing, and
playing of musical instruments went on uninterrupted. Offerings of perfumes
and flowers were incessantly made by the people. At certain intervals, they
stopped during seven days, when fresh honors were paid to the relics, in the
midst of the greatest rejoicings. In this manner, seven months, and seven
days were employed in going over the distance between the two countries.
At Badzagio, the relics were deposited in a place prepared for that purpose,
and a dzedi was erected on them. The seven other kings built also dzedis
* P. 212-14.
219
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihdr.
over the relics they had obtained. Daima built one, too, over the golden
vessel, and the Mauria kings erected likewise one religious monument over
the coals. Thus there were at that time ten dzedis.
‘ When this was all over, the great Kathaba fearing yet for the safety
of the precious relics, wont to king Adzatathat and said to him that precau-
tions were to be taken for seeming the preservation of the relics. The king
asked him by what means all the relics could be had from those who had
obtained them. Kathaba replied that he would know how to manage such
a delicate affair. He went to the seven kings who gave to him all the prin-
cipal relics, keeping by themselves only what was strictly necessary to be
deemed an object of worship and goodwill towards Buddha’s person. One
exception was made in favour of the relics deposited in the village of Rama,
because they were, in future times, to be carried to Ceylon and placed in the
great Wira or Pagoda. All the relics having been brought to Radzagio,
Kathaba took with him the relics and went out of the city. He directed
his steps in a south-east direction, loaded with this precious burthen, which
he carried all the way. Having reached a certain spot, he made the follow-
ing prayer : “ May all the rocks and stones of this place disappear, and there
be in place thereof a fine sandy desert or soil ; may water never issue from
this spot.” Adzatathat ordered the soil to be dug very deep ; with the earth,
bricks were made and eight dzedis were built. The depth of the hole was
eighty cubits. Its bottom was lined with iron bars. To that bottom was
lowered a monastery made of bars, similar in shape and proportion to the
great Wira of Ceylon. Six gold boxes containing the precious relics were
placed in this monastery. Each box was enclosed in one of silver, the latter
in one adorned with precious stones, and so on, until eight boxes were placed
in the other. Thero also were arranged 550 statues, representing Buddha
in 550 preceding existences, described in the sacred writings, the statues of
the 80 great disciples, with those of Tliudaudana and Maia. There also
were arranged 500 lamps of gold and 500 lamps of silver, filled with the
most fragrant oil, with wicks made of the richest cloth. The groat Katha-
ba taking a leaf of gold, wrote upon it the following words : — “ In after times,
a young man named Pradatha shall ascend the throne, and become a great
and renowned monarch under the name of Athanka. Through him, the
relics shall be spread all over the island of Dzapondeba.” King Adzatathat
made new offerings of flowers and perfumes. All the doors of the monastery
were shut and fastened with an iron bolt. Hear the last door, he placed a
large ruby upon which the following words were written : — ‘ Let the poor
king who shall find this 1'uby, present it to the relics.’ A Thagia ordered a
Nat to watch over the precious deposit. The Nat disposed around it
figures the most hideous and terrifying, armed with swords. The whole was
encompassed by six walls made of stones and bricks ; a large slab of stone,
covered the upper part and upon it he built a small dzedi.’
220 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. [No. 3,
At the time of Buddha’s death Ajatasatra, the son of Bimbisara, was
reigning in Rajgir. According to Hwen Thsang he had transferred his
capital from the old city in the valley of the five hills, which, as the Bur-
mese writer expresses it, “ surrounded it like a cow-pen, to a new town in the
open plain just outside the ravine which led to the metropolis of his fore-
fathers.” The translator of the Life of Hwen Thsang* gives the following
account of the circumstance which led to the change alluded to.
‘ Dans l’origine, lorsque le roi Pin-pi-so-lo (Bimbisara) residait dans la
ville Chaug-maolcong-tch’ing (K oufagarapoura) , la population etait fort
nombreuse, et les habitations, pressees les unes contre les autres, eurent
souvent a soulfrir des ravages du feu. Le roi rendit alors un decret qui mena-
fait ceux qui faute d’attention et de vigilance, laisseraient prendre le feu
dans leur maison, de les transferer dans la Foret froide (Cdtavana). Dans
ce royaume on appelle ainsi un lieu abhorre oil l’on jette les cadavres Cmaca-
nam, (un cimetiere) . Mais peu de temps apres, le feu prit dans le palais. Le roi
dit aloi's : “ Je suis le maitre des homines ; si je viole moi-meme mes propres
decrets, je n’aurai plus lft droit de reprimer les dcarts des mes sujets.”
‘ Le roi ordonna alors au prince royal de roster a sa place, et alia
demeurer dans la Foret froide (e’est-a-dire dans le cimetiere). Pendant
ce temps-lii, le roi de Fei-che-li (Va^ali), ayant appris que Pin-pi-so-lo
(Bimbisara) habitait en dehors de la ville, dans une plaine deserte, voulut
lever des troupes, pour s’emparer de lui par surprise.
‘ Les officiers places au loin on observation en ayant 6te informes firent
un rapport au roi, qui constmisit alors une ville fortifiee. Comme le roi
avait commence a habiter dans cet endroit, on l’appela pour cette raison Wang-
che-tch’ing (Radjagriha-poura) ; e’etait prdcisement la ville nouvelle. Dans
la suite le roi Che (Adjatacatrou) lui ayant succede, y dtablit sa cour. Elle
continua a servir de residence royalc, jusquii l’epoque ou le roi Acoka, ayant
transfere sa cour a Pet’oli (Pupili-poutra), donna cette ville, on ne voit point
d’hommos de diverses croyances ; il n’y a plus que des Brahmanes, qui tor-
ment un millier de families.’
After the death of the great founder of the Buddhistic faith, Kasyapa,
on whose shoulder the mantle of the primacy seems to have descended, con-
vened the first great council of monks who had attained the Rahatship, or
highest degree of sanctity, in a hall facing the Sattapani cave, which appears
to have been situated in tho northern shade of Mount Baibhar. Under
the direction of the president, tho whole canon of Sakhya Muni’s teachings
was recited. To the convening of this council Ajatasatra lent his aid.
He is said to have gained the throne by staining his hands in his father’s
blood some years before the Nirvana of Buddha, and to have subsequently
extended his dominions to Kapila, Kosali, and Wesali. Any detailed ac-
* P. 159.
221
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
count of the proceedings of Maha Kasyapa, and his sacred conclave, is
quite heyond my province, hut 1 may incidentally mention that both Fall
Hiyan and Hvven Thsang say something on the subject.
New Eajgir seems to have enjoyed a brief existence as the capital of Maga-
dha ; for a century later, Asoka appears to have transferred the seat of govern-
ment to Patali, a town clearly identical with the Palibothra of the Greeks
and the modern Patna of the Hindus and ’Azimab&d of the Muhammadans.
I have not endeavoured in the foregoing pages to write a connected
history of Buddha’s life in Eajgir, or to give a complete account of the
rulers of that city ; but my object has been simply to show the intimate con-
nection of the Maghada of those days, and the Bihar of the present, with
the earliest days of the Buddhistic faith. This connection oneo established
and shewn, the extreme interest and importance of the Buddhist remains of
this part of the country becomes apparent. They are important to the his-
torian as throwing light on annals of a remote period, and still more impor-
tant to the archaiologist as illustrating the manners and customs, the costume
and ceremonies of another age, and as throwing light on the details of a reli-
gion which has passed to other climes. Whatever liistorical incidents re-
main untouched, I shall speak of when I come to write of the places with
which they are connected, of Tillarah and Bihar, of Ghosrawan, Titrawan,
and the Indra-Saila Hill.
III. Buddhist Remains.
The relics of Buddhism still existing in Bihar may he divided into five
groups : — (1) Ruins of Temples. (2) Those of Monasteries, or Yiharas.
(3) Votive Stupas. (4) Figures and sculptures. (5) Inscriptions.
First. — The temples seem to have varied in size and splendour at different
epochs in the history of the religion to which they belong. Amongst the
earlier temples are those of Eajgir, Dapthti, and the Indra-Saila peak, and
amongst the more modern, those of Bargaon. The most ancient of the
temples are remarkable for the extreme simplicity of their construction.
They usually consisted of an outer court, varying in size from fifteen to
twenty-five feet, the walls of which were composed of enormous bricks of rare
solidity. The roof of the building was generally nine or ten feet high, some-
times more, sometimes less, and consisted of slabs of granite or other stone,
placed close to each other, and supported by pillars of the same material. The
capitals of the pillars were generally separate from the shaft, and of such size
and form as to render the weight of the roof less difficult to sustain. Their
shape was generally either cruciform or oblong. This court generally led to an
inner chamber or shrine, smaller and less lofty than the vestibule, but of simi-
lar shape and construction. In the centre of this is generally to be found
the figure of Buddha. Carvings were often arranged round the walls of
222
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
the outer appartment, but apparently merely for the purpose of ornament.
The roof was generally covered with brick and probably surmounted by a low
cupola or turret of the same material. The lintels, &c., of the doorway were
generally composed of basalt slabs, rudely carved with a bold geometrical
pattern, having one or more figures of Buddha in the centre. The brick
work appears uniformly to have been plain, but remarkably uniform,
the outside edges being reduced to a level by the chisel. As an illus-
tration of the older type of Buddhist temple I may mention the large
one discovered by me in the side of the Baibhar hill at Uajgir. A
great number of the pillars are literally imbedded in the brickwork of
the wall. This feature is also observable in the excavated building at
the Nirmal-kund, and the series of temples at Daptliu. The more modern
temples present a striking contrast to the more ancient ones. The walls
of these buildings were adorned with the most exquisitely moulded brick
work ; the facade was lavishly ornamented with pillared vestibules, and the
richest sculptures which art could produce ; the roof was crowned with a
majestic spire or cupola abounding in profuse decoration in brick, plaster,
and basalt ; and the doors and windows were surrounded with bands of
lace-like carving. The excavated temple at Bargiion affordsk a striking exam-
ple of the religious architecture of the Buddhists from 450 A. D. to 900
A. D. I extract a description of it from the pamphlet I have already written
on the subject.
‘ liaised a few feet above the plain was an evenly paved court, as near as
possible one hundred feet square. This court was surrounded by halls and
buildings of every description on all sides except *the eastern, and these
doubtless served as the dwelling-places, refectory, &c., of the recluses of the
convent. In the centre of the court rose an enormous temple, eighty feet
long at the base on each side, and consisting of a series of several stories
tapering to a point, each about fourteen feet above the other. The main
fabric was composed of enormous bricks, each about one foot three inches in
length, three inches thick, and ten inches wide, placed so close together that
the cement which joined them is barely visible. The first two stories of the
building were uncovered, and are now almost as perfect as when Hwen
Thsang saw them fourteen hundred years ago. In order to preserve every
detail in describing this remarkable building, we will take it side by side.
The great entrance was towards the east (a custom still observed in the
construction of the Buddhist temples of Tibbat), and was faced by a terrace
of stone fifty feet in length and composed of two rows of sandstone slabs,
the first decorated by a simple triangle in the centre, the second carved with
a very beautiful geometrical pattern. These stones vary in length from
seven to three feet, and are as near as possible a foot square. In the centre
of this ten-ace, which is about six feet in front of the main building, is a
223
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bilidr.
flight of three steps exactly ten feet in length. The first court was of very
considerable proportions, fifty feet by twenty-six, and was covered by a stone
roof supported by a series of twelve large pillars. These columns rested first
on a rough pedestal of unhewn stone which disappeared beneath the floor,
and then on a cruciform base, also separate from the pillar itself, but joined
to it by a stone plug six inches long, one end of which pierced the former,
while the other was imbedded in the centre of the latter. Two of these
pillars were recovered by me intact, and are of the most elaborate workman-
ship. The cruciform base measures three feet each way, and the four arms
are uniformly carved with a curious pattern. The shaft itself is seven feet
eight inches high, of which one foot nine inches are taken up in the capital.
The upper half of this consists of a simple square, and the latter of an oval
band of a rich lace-like pattern. The rest of the pillar, down to one foot
ten inches of the lower end, where it again has a third base of oblong shape,
is oval, having a circumference of three feet eight inches, and ornamented at
regular distances by two bands of carving about twelve inches wide. Each
band consists of two parts, the first exhibiting a row of flowers strongly
resembling heraldic roses, and the second a series of gargoyle-like faces*
which form a peculiar feature in Buddhist ornamentation, and which is
employed and re-produced at every possible opportunity. On each side of
this covered terrace, but several feet behind it, is an elaborate brick mould-
ing, fourteen feet long and six 'and a half feet high, surmounted by a narrow
terrace of the same material, approached on either side by three steps from
the pillared court. This moulding has sixteen turns, and is of the most
graceful appearance. On each side of the entrance court, and above .the nar-
row terrace, the main wall is still standing ten feet high. On tho west side
of the court was the great entrance door, which was uncovered by me perfect,
but was thrown down in my absence by the workmen, who imagined I wish-
ed to remove the whole edifice to Bihar. This doorway was of extraordi-
nary beauty, and measured twenty feet across and more than twelve feet
high. It was composed of a series of eighteen slabs, nine on each side, gra-
dually lessening in height towards the centre, where they terminated in a
narrow portal, hardly three feet wide, and surmounted by a heavy slab de-
corated with elaborate carving. The whole of this enormous mass of sculp-
ture rested on three great stones, two and a half feet square and twenty -two
feet in length. Each slab was joined to the next one by a strong iron
clamp, and the upper portion of each was joined to the lower in the same
manner. The first two stones on cither side were devoi(1 of il11 ornament
and were placed nearly a foot behind the other slabs. The next pillar of the
series (or rather what remained of it intact) was eight feet in height, twelve
inches broad, and of enormous thickness. The first slab was of light brown
* See plate, Proceedings, Asiatio Society, Bengal, February, 1872, p. 32.
224 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
colour and of a soft and pliable nature, whereas this one resembled the hard-
est granite and presented a curious variety of appearance and colour. The
base of it is plain, and above it is a grotesque kneeling figure with a long
beard and hands uplifted, supporting a canopy, above which rises a long line
of geometrical pattern. The third slab is of black basalt and is scarce four
inches wide. It is taken up entirely by the representation of two enormous
snakes, one twining round the other. The next stone is of the same
material, and is of unusually elaborate workmanship. A winding stem of
flowery pattern work covers its face, and from each side of it springs a lotus-
like flower, which alternately forms the resting place of a mystic bird or
elephant rampant. The fifth slab* is plain. The sixth pillar is ornamented
at the base with a female figure eight inches high, from whose hands spring
a winding branch of foliage and flowers which stretches to the top of the
lintel. The seventh slab is a repetition of the third, and the eighth is of the
same stone as the second, containing three large female figures, one above
the other, each about one and a half feet high, and in the hands of each is
seen a musical instrument similar in shape and size to the modern ‘ sitar.’
The ninth stone has a simple beading, and is surmounted by a heavy slab
covered with carving. The two last slabs of the series, together with the
one which covers them, form the doorway which leads to the inner part of the
temple. The magnificent gate led to the second hall, twelve feet wide and
eighteen feet long ; and on each side of this chamber were smaller octagonal
rooms, from the western end of which a staircase lead to the terraces above.
These were approached by narrow doors right and left of the great gate-
way. These rooms were evidently of great height, and were decorated by
elaborately carved pannels of sandstone let into the brick-work. I have
added a series of these to my own collection. One of these consists of a
slab of Mirzapur stone covered with the most elaborate design, the chief
feature of which is two figures with arms and legs entwined. The colour of
the stone is peculiarly beautiful. Another is of black basalt, and represents
a large elephant, richly caparisoned, with a lotus flower in its mouth. Be-
yond this, one enters by another door an inner chamber twenty-two feet
square, the walls of which are in their ruined state still fourteen feet high.
This was doubtless the sanctum sanctorum of the building, and I discovered
at its western end a headless Buddha four feet high, placed on a handsome
‘ singhAsan,’ or throne, of black basalt, and was divided into five compart-
ments ; the first on each side containing single figures, the next lions-couchant,
and the one in the centre two devotees in the act of making an offering.
The wall is eighteen feet thick on either side.’
* Its baso contains an inscription. Babu Eajendralala Mitra makes tho date
‘ Sambat 856,’ and Professor Earn Gopal Bhandakar ‘ the eleventh year of the reign
of King Mahapiila Dcva.’
225
1872.] A. M. Broadley — Tlie Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
The higher stories and roofs have toppled over on the northern side, and
from an examination of their remains, it is clear that the building consisted
of at least five stories, surmounted by a spire or minaret, (not by a cupola,)
at least two hundred feet high in all.
The excavation of the western side is the most perfect of all. The up-
per story is about sixty-three feet long, and is exactly twelve feet above the
lower one, which is eleven feet wide. The wall of the high terrace is quite
plain, decorated merely by a simple moulding about throe feet from the base.
The stories consist of solid brick, and not of chambers as I first imagined.
This I ascertained by making a perforation six feet deep in its centre. Not
quite in the centre of the building is an irregular protuberance, twenty-two
feet wide and twenty-seven feet long. 1 at first imagined it to be a portico,
but on closer examination, I think it must have been a mere support, built
up to sustain the weight of the upper stories when they showed symptoms
of decay ; for on removing the great portion of it (December 5th and 6th)
the pilasters, mouldings, and statues which decorate the wall of the lower
terrace were found entire behind it. In fact this protuberance seems so
singularly out of place, that I should have imagined it to have been a por-
tion of the ruins of the upper stories, had not the existence of regular walls
precluded the possibility of such being the case. The ornamentation of each
of these sides consisted of a series of mouldings and niches filled with stucco
figures of Buddha in various positions. After the remqval of the protuber-
ance above mentioned, the west side presented the following appearance. At
the base a moulding of briclc-work, five feet three inches high, having thir-
teen distinct turns. The moulding runs along the whole facade. After the
first six feet, it recedes a foot and continues in the same line for eighteen,
feet, when it again advances a foot, and continues in that line for eight feet,
when it again recedes to the former line, and so on. Above the moulding is
a series of niches two feet ten inches wide and three feet three inches high.
These niches are separated by pilasters about four feet six inches high.
These pilasters have plain square bases, and a three-sided shaft, each shaft
being somewhat semicircuh in form, above this is a square moulded capital.
Above the niches are projec bosses of brick, lotus-shaped, protruding
from the wall, and above these another moulding similar to that below. The
niches are surmounted by arches of over-lapping brick, and each contained
a figure in plaster. The original bricks are moulded with exquisite exact-
ness, and present great variety of patterns ; some of the pilaster bases, for
instance, containing figures, &c., in different portions fitted together. The
temple has evidently twice at least been covered by a coating of plaster
moulded into different forms, but as a rule greatly inferior to the workman-
ship of the brick underneath. The southern side is precisely similar to the
western. On the top of the terrace, which doubtless ran round the three
29 K
226
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
sides- of the temple, was a verandah, and the sockets of the beams are still
visible in the upper wall. The southern side still stands more than thirty
feet high.
In order to get a more complete idea of the lofty cupola which doubt-
less once surmounted the temple of Baladitya, I have since cleared away a
great part of the rubbish in the northern side of the temple, and have been
thus enabled to design a restored elevation of the whole building. I have
also procured an illustration of the great doorway, which is of the greatest
archeological and architectural interest.
Although there was little variety in the Buddhist architect’s design,
it was peculiarly graceful and calculated to produce a pleasing and
majestic effect. The gargoyle face, the almost endless repetition of the
figure of Buddha, the quaint niches and the long lines of lotus leaves,
formed a tout ensemble which Hindu art lias never surpassed. Of the
minor sculptures which decorated this and similar religious edifices, a full
description will be given when I come to speak of the different localities in
which they were found.
The pillars which formed ono of the chief features, both in the build-
ings and in the monasteries, became more and more elaborate as know-
ledge and art increased.
Secondly. — The monasteries appear to have been quadrangles of brick
buildings (similarly ornamented to the temples), and generally having a pago-
da in the centre. According to Hwen Thsang’s account, they must have been
very magnificent. Little idea can be gained of the form, &e., by an inspection
of the ruins ; for the wood carvings and tiles have of course disappeared under
the ravages of time. The monasteries were almost invariably situated in pic-
turesque positions on the banks of ponds of the clearest water, and surround-
ed by groves of mangoe, bar, and pipal trees. They appear to have been
generally built a short distance from the villages to which they belonged.
Any further description is unnecessary, as I shall dwell very fully on all
monasteries of Bihar, when I come to speak of them separately.
Thirdly. — Votive St upas. The subject of t> ise most interesting monu-
ments of the Buddhist faith has been clearly ; aWefly summarised by Herrn
Schlagintweit.* Ho writes — “ The ancient 'stupas were originally meant
as receptacles for relies of either the Buddhas or the Bodhisattvas, and the
kings who encouraged the propagation of the Buddhist faith. But already
in the early periods of Buddhism stupas were constructed ex voto as sym-
bolical substitutes for a tomb with a sacred relic, either for marking the spot
where remarkable incidents in the sacred history had taken place, or for
decorating the Viharas and temples. Their erection is considered as an act
* Buddhism in Thibet, p. 193.
227
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
of devotion and reverence paid to the Buddhas, and was recommended al-
ready in the ancient legends as a most meritorious work.”
Few places in India are richer than Bihar in Buddhistic stupas and
ehaityas ; and I have ventured to classify them as follows : —
I, — Stupas actually containing relics of Buddha or his disciples.
II, — Stupas containing no relies, but built to mark the occurrence of
some event memorable in the history of the faith.
III, — Stupas and Chaityas purely votive, most of them serving as the
repository of images.
IY. — Chaityas, or miniature stupas, not built, but carved in one or more
blocks of stone, and generally covered with ornamentions and figures of
Buddha.
On the back of a figure of Buddha in the Titrawan ruins, I found a well-
executed drawing of a stupa which I append as an illustration. The form
of the stupa varied little, whatever class it belonged to. They seem to have
been generally surmounted by a series of umbrellas. The large tope at
Nalanda, and the tumuli to the west of the walls of Rajagrilia belong un-
doubtedly to the first class ; but their extreme antiquity (not less than 2200
years) makes it doubtful if any thing could be found there, to say nothing
of the frequent removals and abstractions of the relics we read of. I have
sunk a shaft in the second tumulus at Rajgir ; but without success, the labour-
ers cutting through a solid deposit of bricks to a depth of fifteen feet. The
topes on the summits of the hills, on the contrary, are of the second class,
and in all probability served to mark some of the most sacred episodes in
the history of Sakhya Muni ; e. his sitting on the Banthawan Hills with the
bhiksliu’s bowl, etc., etc. The small topes discovered by me in the staircase
or causeway leading to the Deoghat Hill, I imagine, served chiefly for the
deposit of images of' Tathagata. It will be seen that on opening one of them,
I found three perfect figures, of equal size, differing only in position, im-
bedded in the ruins. The small chaityas vary in size, and were doubtless
made to suit the pluses of those whose means did not permit them to raise
a lofty mass of brickwork “ for the advancement of the highest knowledge
amongst mankind.” Some of them are circular, some octagonal, some
twelve-sided, some oval ; but nearly all of them are richly ornamented and
hear several figures of Buddha. A very fine circular chaitya found by me at
Kurkihar, the Kukkutapiida of Hwen Thsang, contains more than forty
figures of Buddha, all carved with wonderful sharpness and delicacy. The
ehaityas which were composed of a number of pieces linked together, must
have contained as many as 500. These chaityas were originally surmounted
by umbrellas, which were formed very frequently of separate pieces of stone,
often possibly of metal, fitted into the top of the carving. The Buddhist
images contain numerous illustrations of these ehaityas, and I have, in some
[No. 3,
228 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
instances, counted as many as sixteen or twenty umbrellas, arranged one
above the other. The chaityas vary in height from four inches to two feet.
I have about twenty-five distinct varieties in my own collection. Buddhism
has now-a-days disappeared even in tradition from the minds and recollec-
tion of the people of BiMr, and the dedicatory chaityas of the pious followers
of Tath&gata are commonly supposed to be nothing else than a different
form of the sacred linga of the Hindus.
The question of stupas is thus treated by Bishop Bigandet.* ‘ The re-
ligious edifices that arc to be met with, in all parts of Burmah, deserve a
particular notice. They are called ‘ dzedis’ in all the Buddhist writings of
the Burmese ; but the people generally mention them by the appellation of
Payas or Phras, which, in this instance, is merely an honorific title of a reli-
gious character.
1 Dzedis, in the earliest days of Buddhism, were sacred tumuli, raised
upon a shrine, wherein relics of Buddha had been deposited. These struc-
tures were as so many lofty witnesses, bearing evidence to the presence of
a sacred and precious object, intended to revive in the memory of the faitli-
fvd the remembrance of Buddha, and foster in their hearts tender feelings
of devotion and a glowing fervour for his religion.
‘ From the perusal of this legend, it seems that dzedis were likewise
erected on the tombs of individuals, who, during their lifetime, had obtained
great distinction by their virtues and spiritual attainments among the mem-
bers of the assembly. Buddha himself ordered that a monument should be
built over the shrine containing the relics of the two great disciples, Thari-
putra and Mankalan. In Burmah no dzedis of great dimensions and pro-
portions have ever been erected on the ashes of distinguished phoungies.
In some parts, however, particularly in the upper country, there may be
seen here and there some small dzedis a few feet high, erected on the spot
where have been deposited the remains of somo saintly personage. These
monuments are little noticed by the people, though on certain occasions, a
few offerings of flowers, tapers, &c., are made around and in front of them.
The same kind of religious edifices have been built sometimes also, to be-
come a receptacle of the Pitagat, or collection of the holy scriptures. One
of the finest temples of Ceylon was devoted to that purpose. There was also
one in the ancient city of Ava, but I am not aware that there is any of this
kind at Amarapiira.
‘ Finally, dzedis have been erected for the sole purpose of harbour-
ing statues of Gaudama ; but there is every reason to believe that this
practice has gained ground in subsequent ages. When a fervent Buddhist,
impelled by the desire of satisfying the cravings of his piety and devo-
* Life or Legend of the Buddha of the Burmese, p. 141.
229
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
tion, wished to build a religious monument and could not procure relics,
he then remained contented with supplying the deficiency with images
of Buddha, representing that eminent personage in some attitudes of body
that were to remind Buddhists of some of the most striking actions of his
life. In many instances, dzedis have been built up, not even for the
sake of sheltering statues, but for the pious purpose of reminding the
people of the holy relics of Buddha and, as they used to say, for kindling in
the soul a tender feeling of affectionate reverence for the person of Buddha
and his religion. If what is put forward as a plea for building pagodas be
founded on conviction and truth, we must conclude that the inhabitants of
the valley of the Irrawady are most devotedly religious, as the mania for
building dzedis has been, and even now is, carried to such a pitch, as to ren-
der fabulously exaggerated the number of religious buildings to be seen on
an extent of above 700 miles as far as Bhamo.’
Fourthly. — As to the next division of my subject — Buddhist figures — I
shall say little here, reserving detailed descriptions of particular figures for fu-
ture chapters. The principal figure of course is that of Buddha, who is found
in every possible position, and in every possible variation of costume. The
favourite type of the image of Buddha in Bihar, is one containing a large
figure in the centre, seated on a lotus petal throne, surrounded by smaller
images, aud illustrating some famous episode in the Sage’s life ; e. g., Buddha
with one hand uplifted, denoting his character as a teacher ; a similar figure in
a sitting attitude, with one hand holding thealms bowl, the other hanging down
over the knee, showing him to be plunged in meditation, and so forth. The
hah- of Buddha, when not covered by the jewelled crown, is generally in
small tufts. This is not explained by Schlagintweit, but I take it to typify
the following* incident in his life, which is supposed to have taken place at the
time of his embracing the pursuit of a religious life. “ He reflected that his
long hair did not become the character of a poor ascetic, and he determined
to have it cut off : but as no one was worthy to touch his head, he cut it off
with his own sword, praying “ May my hair, thus cut, be neat and even !”
And by the force of his prayer, the hair parted evenly, leaving each hair
about an inch and a half in length, and they curled hr right-handed spirals,
and never grew more to the last day of his life.” To the left of the figure
of Buddha is generally seen a delicately carved female figure, holding
with one hand the branch of a luxuriant tree. This refers to the birth of
Buddha in the Simwaliwana forest, which is very poetically translated in
Mr. Alabaster’s 1 Wheel of the Law’ (p. 101).
‘ When the queen Maia entered this forest, the trees, the inanimate
trees, bowed down their heads before her, as if they would say, ‘ Enjoy your-
self, 0 queen, among us, ere you proceed on your journey.’ And the queen,
* Alabaster’s Life of Buddha, p. 150.
230 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
looking on the great trees and the forest, lovely as the gardens of the angels,
ordered hor litter to be stayed, that she might descend and walk. Then
standing under one of the majestic trees, she desired to pluck a sprig from
the branches, and the branches bent themselves down, that she might reach
the sprig that she desired ; and at that moment, while she yet held the
branch, her labour came upon her. Her attendants held curtains around
her, the angels brought her garments of the most exquisite softness ; and
standing there, holding the branch, with her face turned to the East, she
brought forth her son, without pain or any of the circumstances which
attend that event with women in general.’
To speak further of the symbols of Buddhism is quite beyond the pro-
vince I have chosen. Every information on this subject, can be gleaned with
ease from the learned writings of Schlagintweit and Alabaster, and I shall
have occasion to say more about them when I come to speak of particular
figures.
Fifthly. — Inscriptions. These vary from B. C. 200 to A. D. 1000, and
are in most cases confined to the Buddhist creed. I have, however, discovered
several dated inscriptions, which I shall give in full when I come to speak of
the monastic buildings to which they belong.
I now proceed without any further introduction to give an account of
the Buddhist remains in Bihar.
IV. Kusa'ga'rapura and Ba'j agriha.
Neither Hwen Thsang nor Chi-Fah-Hiyan visited at once the capital
of the Magadha kingdom. Both of them arrived there after spending a con-
siderable time in the various monasteries of the surrounding territory.
A description of the remains of those institutions will follow in future chap-
ters ; but 1 have thought it best for many reasons to commence my narrative
with an account of the great metropolis itself.
The ruins of Rajagriha may conveniently be classified under two heads :
1st, the remains of the more ancient city — Kusagarapura — situated within the
Valley of the Five Hills ; 2nd, those of the more modern city Kaj agriha,
which are found in the plain to the north of the mountains. The one I de-
signate as the city of Bimbisara, the other as that of Ajatasatru. These
towns were visited by both the Buddhist pilgrims, by Fah Hiyan about the
year 415, A. D., and by Hwen Thsang in March, 637, A. D. Hwen Thsang
and Fah-Hiyan have bequeathed to posterity very detailed accoimts of the
monuments and antiquities both of the towns themselves, and the sacred
range of hills which surrounded them. Their respective narratives are to be
found in the “ Memo ires sur les Contrees Occidentales,” Vol. Ill, pp. 15 — 41,
in the “ Histoire de la Vie do Hwen Thsang,” pp. 153 — 161 ; in Mr. Laidley’s
231
1872.] A. M. Broadley— The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
translation of M. Remusat’s Chi-Fah-Hiyan, pp. 201-279, and the Rev.
S. Beal’s original translation of the same writer, pp. 111-119.
According to the first named work, Hwen Thsang travelled to Rajagri-
ha from Nalanda, but the second states that he arrived first at the ancient
town of Bimbisfira via Bodh Gaya and Kukkutapada ; but both translations of
the earlier pilgrim agree in taking him to the capital by the former route.
Nalanda was the largest and most important Buddhist monastery in
India, and is identical with the modem village of Bargaon situated about
six or seven miles to the north or north-west of liajagriha. It is now the
scene of a mass of the most interesting ruins, which have been fully described
by me in a separate pamphlet.* Since the time that account was printed,
fresh excavations have been made, and I trust one day to present to the
public a still more complete account of these important Buddhistic remains.
I shall now proceed to follow in the first place the footsteps of F ah-
Hiyan.
He writes Going west from Nalanda one yojana, we arrive at the new
Rajgir.” This undoubtedly corresponds with the large circuit of fortifica-
tions (still bearing the same name) at the foot of the Baibhar and Vipula
hills, situated six miles or thereabouts to the south of the Bargaon ruins.
I, therefore, think the direction given by the translators must be a mistake.
Fah-Hian continues : ‘ This was the town king Ajasat built. There are
two Sangharamas in it. Leaving the town by the west gate and proceeding
300 paces, (we arrive at) the tower which king Ajasat: raised over the share
of Buddha’s relics which he obtained. Its height is very imposing.’
The walls of the town and its gates are distinctly traceable at the dis-
tance of about half a mile from the foot of the mountain and directly facing
the northern entrance of the Valley of the Five Hills. Its form is somewhat
difficult to describe, and authors have varied in their attempts to do so, but
after careful inspection from all points of view, and, what is still better, after
studying its form from two of the hills above, I am of opinion it cannot be
correctly called a pentagon, but is rather a quadrilateral, having, as mea-
sured from the top of the ramparts, three equal sides, viz., the north, west,
and south, each measuring 1,900 feet, and one unequal viz., the east, measur-
ing 1,200 feet. The wall appears to have had a uniform thickness of about
11 feet, and is composed of masses of stone about four feet square, the faces
of which are made uniform and placed one upon the other in close contiguity,
without any mortar or cement whatever. Starting from the north-east
corner, where a stone bastion still exists in tolerable entirety', the wall re-
mains unbroken for 200 feet, at the end of which distance a second bastion
appears to have existed and similar traces are seen at the 300th foot. The
remains of the wall now almost entirely disappear, but at the distance of
* Ruins of the Nalanda Monastery, hy A. M. Broadley. Calcutta, 1S72.
232 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
1100 feet from the north-east corner there is a portion of an entire wall measur-
ing 20 feet by 14. Further on, the wall appears clearly to have been remov-
ed and hardly a trace of it remains till towards the north-west corner, where
its elevation considerably increases, and there are enormous masses of brick,
which lead me to the conclusion that a tower must have once existed here.
At this place the bricks are very small and of remarkable solidity. At a
distance of 110 feet from the corner there are clear marks of a bastion, and
the same feature is observable at similar distances up to the great west door,
some 500 or GOO feet from the north-west comer of the fort. The rampart
throughout this distance presents an average elevation of 25 or 30 feet above
the plain beneath. Just before the west door, a fine piece of wall still
remains intact measuring 2G feet by 14. Passing out by the west gate and
going 800 feet in a direct line to the south-west, and crossing about midway
the Sarasvati rivulet, one arrives at a circular mound having an elevation of
some 30 feet and a diameter of 180. The centre is considerably depressed,
and seems to consist simply of masses of bricks similar to those on the ram-
parts and inside the fort. From the west side of the ruins a sort of terrace
leads to a semi-circular heap of somewhat loss elevation than the first. In the
centre of this I discovered three large statues of Buddha, all headless but
otherwise little mutilated ; they are all seated on lotus-petal thrones, supported
by bases ornamented by different devices. In one, several figures are seen
in the act of making an offering ; the centre of the second is occupied by the
“ Wheel of the Law,” with a deer on either side, and the third bears the
representations of two lions-coucliant. These mounds are undoubtedly the
mins of the great tower mentioned in the text. I have made at the present
time two incisions in the side of the topes, and have recovered from them
some Buddhist idols of remarkable beauty, as well as a tablet covered with
the representations of the nine planets.
From the west door the ramparts still increase in height, but the wall
is hidden by masses of brick. Not far from the end of the western side,
there is auotlier break in the wall, exactly opposite which is a small temple
containing a Buddhist idol, now worshipped by the Hindus as the image of
Beni Madhava. At each side of the Sarasvati stream is a pacca ghat, and
the ceremonies of “ Goudan” and “ Pindadan” are constantly performed
here. At a short distance from this opening, the south rampart commences,
and has an elevation nearly equal to that on the west. The wall is not
straight, but inclines towards the north-east. At about the 500th foot from
the south-west corner, there are unmistakable traces of an enormous brick
tower, and 400 feet farther on there is a long piece of wall still intact, and
terminating in the southern gate. From this point to the south-east angle
the wall is clearly visible. It lias an elevation of some 30 or 40 feet above
the valley, and there appear to have been bastions at distances varying
233
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
from 100 to 110 feet. Opposite the south-east corner and at a distance of
50 or GO paces, thore are distinct marks of a ruined tower similar to the one
near the western gate already described. The wall towards the east has a
total length of nearly 1,200 feet, and the ruins have a very inconsiderable
elevation. Bastions are clearly visible at the following distances from the
south-east angle, viz., 200, 320, 420, 520, G20, 720, 820, 920, 1020, 1120,
and 1200 feet. Montgomery Martin considers the heaps of brick to be the
remains of a second set of fortifications built by Sher Shah, but I am rather
inclined to regard them as the ruins of the ancient towers, the two monas-
teries, and the royal palace, which we know to have existed in the town and
parts of which as well as other buildings were doubtless built on the city
walls. General Cunningham gives a much larger area to the ruined city,
but it must be remembered that he made his measurements outside the ditch,
very faint traces of which are visible on two sides of the wall. I have en-
deavoured to trace carefully the rampart, and in many places removed the
heaps of brick which covered it. In most cases I succeeded m uncovering
the original wall, which uniformly presents a thickness of 14 feet. As re-
gards the outer walls which are said to have existed, if the heaps of stone
which are found at different distances from the fort are traces of them, they
are so imperfect that any attempt to follow them would be simply futile.
It now remains for us to see what Hwen Tlisang said of the “ new
town.” The description of the “ old town” comes first in his account. Af-
ter completing bis account of the deserted city, he says : “ Bn sortant par
la porte septentrionale de la ville entouree de montagnes — Kouiyigarapura —
il fit un li, et arriva au Bois de Batnbous don no par Karandavenouvana. II
y a maintenant un Yiliara dont les fondements sont en pierre et le batiment
en briques. La porte regard l’orient.” This spot can be very correctly
identified with the mass of debris found in the ravine, between the northern
gate of the old town, and the southern entrance to the new. A large plat-
form of stone-work still exists, and this is covered by a small pillared cell.
It is, straugc to say, still popularly called the Madrasah, or College, — vihara.
He then distinctly mentions the stupas referred to above. He writes, “ A
Test du bois des Bambous de Karandavenouvana il y a un stoupa qui a ete
bati par le roi Ajatugatrou. Apres le Nirvana du Tathagata les rois par-
tagerent les reliques, Le roi s en rotourna avec la poition qu il avait ob-
tenue, batit par respect un stoupa et lui offrit ses hommages. Le roi A 90k a
avant coneu une foi sincere, ouvrit le monument, prit les reliques, ct batit a
son tour un autre stoupa. A. cote du stoupa du roi Ajatuqatrou il y en a
un autre qui renferme les reliques de la moitie du corps du venerable Anan-
da.” This description agrees wonderfully with that given by me above, of
the two tumuli to the west of the new-town, of the identity of which there
* Memoiros, Tom. III., p. 29.
30
234 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
cannot be the slightest doubt. “ Au nord du Viliara du Bois des Bamhous,”
continues Hwen Thsang, “ il fit environ deux cents pas, et arriva a 1’ etang
de Karandahrada.” The remains of the tank can still be seen facing the
southern wall of the new town, and a figure I found there bore the words
“ A religious gift to the Karandahrada tank.” To the north of the tank,
at a distance of two or three feet, he saw a stupa about 60 feet in height, which
had been built by Afoka. This must be identical with one of the jungle
covered mounds just under the city ramparts ; but every trace of the monolith
which stood beside it, has disappeared.
He now arrives in new liajgir, and it is clear that the two centuries which
had passed since Fall Hiyan’s visit, had reduced the town to a ruin, very lit-
tle different from that which it has been my task to describe, a fact which
makes the contemplation of these venerable walls doubly interesting, both
to the historian and to the archaeologist. He writes,* “ L ’enceinte ex-
terieure etait deja detruite, et Von n' apcrcevait pas meme les restes des
murs” [yot General Cunningham endeavours to survey them !]. “ Quoique les
murs interieurs fussent on ruines, lour base avait encore une certaine eleva-
tion, et embrassait dans ses contours une vingtaine de li A 1’ angle sud-
ouest de la ville royale il y a deux petits Sangharamas ou s’arretent les
religieux (Strangers qui voyagent.” These monasteries are now represented
by the enormous pile of bricks and rubbish which is to be found at the
south-west corner of the town, and which I have already alluded to.
We can now return to Fah Hiyan, and follow him into the Valley of
the Five Hills.
‘ Leaving the south side of the city and proceeding southwards four li,
we enter a valley between five hills. These hills encircle it completely like
the walls of a town . This is the site of the old city of king Bimbisara.’
The valley is clearly identical with the narrow tract of country surrounded
by the five mountains of Rajgir, a little less than a mile due south of the
fortifications previously described. This spot is of the greatest archaeologi-
cal interest. Here once stood, according to tradition, the impregnable for-
tress of Jarasandha, outside the walls of which was fought one of the most
famous battles of the Mahabharata; centuries later, the valley was the
scene of many of the episodes in the life of Tathfigata ; and lastly — during
the palmiest days of Muhammadan rule in Bihar — its solitudes became the
abiding place of Makhdum Sharaf-uddin, one of the greatest saints amongst
the Faithful in Hindustan.
These five hills are by no means solitary ; they form a portion of a
rocky mountain chain stretching nearly thirty miles from the neighbourhood
of Gaya, north-west as far as Giryak in Bihar. Their sides are rugged and
precipitous, and are mostly covered with an impenetrable jungle, broken only
* Memoires, Tom. Ill, p. 38.
235
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
by irregular pathways overgrown with brushwood, which are yearly trodden
by hundreds of Jain pilgrims from Murshidabad, Banaras, and even Bom-
bay, who throng to Rajgir during the cold and dry seasons to do homage to
the sacred charanas, or ‘ foot prints,’ of then.' saints, enshrined in the temples
which crown the mountain tops.
The north side of the valley is bounded by Mount Baibhar — a rocky
hill running three or four miles north-.west, and terminating at its eastern
side in the hot wells of Rajgir. Here the valley is entered by a narrow
ravine through the midst of which the Sarasvati rivulet forces its way into
the low country to the north of the hills. On the eastern side of the stream
rises the lofty ascent of Mount Yipula, a branch of which runs as far as
Griryak, a distance of six miles. Hardly a quarter of a mile from the wes-
tern side of the hill, it is joined at right angles by a third mountain running
from the north, called Ratnagir. This hill is of inconsiderable length and
terminates in a narrow ravine branching away to the east. On the opposite
side of this ravine rises Mount Udayagir, a less important hill, running due
south and terminating in the ancient wall and fort of Banganga, the sou-
thern gate of the ancient capital of Magadha. To the west of the torrent
is the fifth and largest hill, Mount Sonar. It first takes a course to the
west, then turns northwards, and finally, exactly opposite the narrow valley
between Mounts Ratnagir and Udayagir, stretches away to the west, and
forms the southern boundary of this natural fortress, being only separated
at its western extremity by a narrow ravine from an offshoot of Mount
Baibhar, commonly called the ‘ Chhatsi.’ These five hills are called in the
Mahabharata* — Vaihara, Yaraha, Vrishabha, Rishigiri, and Chaityaka ; and
in the Pali annals of Ceylon — Gijjhakuta, Isigili, Webharo,+ Wepulo, and
Panda wo. $
Speaking of the valley, Pah-Hiyan§ goes on to say : ‘ From east to west
it is about five or six li, from north to south seven or eight li.’ It is evi-
dent that Fah-Hian excluded from his computation the eastern and western
bifurcations of the valley, and even then its dimensions are slightly under-
stated.
The description of the valley of the five hills given by Hwen Thsang||
differs very considerably from that of his forerunner. He tells us that the
city was situated just in the centre of the kingdom of Magadha, and was in
* Mahabharatn, II. 20, v. 799, 800.
f Lassen suspects the reading Vaibhdra by Tumour to be ineorroot, and proposes
to read Vcdhdra in accordance witb tbe Mahablidrata. ‘ It is surprising,’ he adds,
‘ that the first and last nainos are Buddhistic, and we may, therefore, suspect they
were given to these mountains only after the time of Buddha. Alterth., vol. II., p. 79.
J Tumour, in Jour. As. Soc. Beng., vol. VI., p. 996.
§ Beal’s Fah Hian, Chapter xxviii., p. 112.
|| Memo! res, Tom. III., pp. 15-16.
23G
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
ancient days the metropolis of the country Its name, he says, was derived
from a flowering shrub, which grew there in abundance. Ho continues :
“ De hautes montagnes l’entourent de quatro cotes et forment ses murs ex-
terieurs. A l’ouest on y penetre par un sentier qui existe entre deux mon-
tagnes ; au nord on a ouvert une entree a travers la montagne. Cette
ville est allongee de Test a l’ouest et resserree du sud au nord. Sa circonfe-
rence est de ccnt-cinquante li (30 miles). Les restes des fondements de la
ville interieure ont environ trente li detour.”
This area would make the outer walls of the old town to extend from Gir-
yak to the Chhata hill, a distance of ten or eleven miles ; and from the foot of
the Udayagir and Sonargir hills to the opposite side of the valley, a distance
of two or thi’ee miles. From a careful examination of every part of the
valley, I have little doubt that the whole of it, or very nearly so, was sur-
rounded by the fortification of the ancient capital, but the inner town, (the
ramparts alone of which I have endeavoured to trace) certainly did not ex-
tend further than the Nekpai embankment on the one side, to the Jarasan-
dha band on the other. I will now proceed to describe as shortly
as possible the present appearance of the valley of the “ sweet-scented
shrub.”
The north side of the valley is watered by two streams, both bearing
the name of Sarasvati, which rise, the one at the foot of Batnagir, and the
other at the western extremity of Mount Sonar. These rivulets join a short
distance to the south of the ravine which forms the entrance to the valley.
The sides of the hills and the plain at their feet are covered mostly by a
tangled mass of flowering shrubs and wild tulsi grass, broken only by some
protruding escarpment or the white cupola of a Jain pagoda in the one
case, and in the other, by heaps of bricks — the rums of temples and topes,
and the huge piles of stones which still mark the ancient ramparts of the
city. The form of the walls can, with a little difficulty, be traced with
tolerable accuracy. Strictly speaking, these ramparts formed an irregular
pentagon about four miles in circumference. One side faced the west, and
was about a mile in length, extending along the western branch of the Saras-
vati ; a second ran south to the foot of the Sonargir ; a third east to the
entrance of the ravine between (Jdayagir and Batnagir ; a fourth north, to-
wards the junction of the streams ; and the fifth and smallest joins the first
and fourth. A road seems to have run through the city from the new town
to Banganga. The northern side of the city, facing the ravine, appears to
have been protected by a lofty tower composed of stones of irregular shape,
placed one upon the other (not squared and arranged in courses as in the
walls of new Bajgir). Near the stream appears to have been another tower
of great height and of similar appearance, and close under it an outer gate
towards the north. From this place an enormous wall, 18 or 20 feet thick
237
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
and 15 or 16 feet high, stretched itself to the summit of Mount Vipula, and
protected the city from attacks on the mountain side. There were doubtless
similar fortifications on the side of Mount Baibhar, but their traces are very
faint, whereas those on the western slope of Mount Vipula are remarkably
perfect and distinct. Over the whole surface of the interior of the city is
spread a mass of debris covered by brushwood and shrubs, and here and there
are piles of bricks and stones, denoting the site of some house or temple.
Near the south-west corner of the city is a lofty tumulus, somewhat higher
than the ruins of the eastern entrance. This is covered by a small Jaina
cupola of brick and plaster. The sides of the tumulus are strewn with bricks
and fragments of granite pillars. I also discovered some pieces of cornice
covered with representations of Buddhas and Nag, is. I made an excavation
on the north side of the tumulus, and uncovered a considerable portion of
the northern side of a Buddhist building, of which the entrance seems to
have faced the north — a feature I have not before met with in any similar
ruin, — for the numerous temples which I have seen at liajgir and other places
are, without exception, approached from the east. A staircase of brick,
with walls on either side, led to the inner hall. The walls appear to have
been strengthened, and the roof at the same time provided with supports, by
the erection of gray stone pillars, about four feet apart, with plain square
bases and capitals. This passage led to a room about 12 feet square, con-
taining twelve pillars similar to those in the staircase — ten of which are
imbedded in the brickwork and two support the roof in the centre of the
chamber. The centre hall is directly underneath the Jaina temple, and it
consequently has been impossible to uncover it. I think the precise nature
of the original building is doubtful ; the position of the entrance leads me to
the conclusion that it was most likely a house or tower, not a religious
edifice. The doorway seems to have been surmounted by a long basalt slab
containing figures twelve inches high. I brought away two pieces of this
to Bihar. Several other figures were found in this place years ago, when it
was pierced by an avaricious road-contractor in the hope of finding treasure.
If he ever learned the Jaina traditions connected with the place, his hopes
must have been high, for they make out tho tumulus to be the ruin of the
house of Danaji and Sathadraji, two seths, or bankers, in whose honour, they
say, a small temple still exists on the eastern slope of Mouut Baibhar. If
the priests made their story known to this enterprising scion of the Depart-
ment of Public Works, they cannot solely blame him for the disaster which
followed on his researches, namely, the collapse of the stucco pagoda and its
sacred ‘ charana’ towards the end of the succeeding rains.
About a mile to the south-east of the mound is a long piece of rampart
known as * Barghaut.’ In the centre of this was the southern gate of
Kusagsirapura, flanked by two towers. The view from the top of the ruin
238
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
is very striking, for you see at once both entrances of the valley and all the
five hills. A little to the west of this, at the foot of Sonargir, is a ridge of
rock called the wrestling ground of Bhim, and various indentations in its
surface are pointed out as the marks of the feet of the combatants. Be-
neath this, to the west of the city walls, and between Mounts Baibhar and
Sonar is Baubluim, the traditionary scene of the battle mentioned in the
Mahfibharata.
A rugged path leads from this place to the southern outlet of the valley
at Banganga. Certain marks on the stones are considered by Captain Kit-
toe to be inscriptions, but if this be the case, the letters are far too imperfect
to admit of being deciphered. The valley terminates in a rocky ravine of
the most inconsiderable width, having Son.-irgir to the west and Udayagir
to the east. The Banganga torrent, which rises at the foot of the former,
rushes over the slippery rocks into the southern plain of Hisua-Nowada.
The pass is literally only a few feet wide, and its entrance was jealously
guarded by fortifications of enormous strength, which will be fully described
when I come to speak of the antiquities of the hills.
The first mountain I ascended was Baibhar to the north-east of the
northern entrance of the valley. At the foot of the hill runs the Sarasvati,
from the banks of which a large stone staircase leads to the sacred wells and
temples, which, though still venerated by the Hindus of Bihar, yield but a
scanty subsistence to the numerous Brahmans who attend them. The wells
are vaults of stone, about 10 feet square and 12 deep, approached by steps ;
and the temples are quite modern, and of the poorest proportions and work-
manship. Most of them contain fragments of Buddhist idols, mouldings,
cornices, &c., and here and there I noticed a chatty a, now doing duty as a
linga. All of these carvings, however, are very inferior to those found by
me in the mounds of Bargaon, Bohoi, and Kalyanpur. The wells at the
foot of Baibhar are seven in number, and arc all clustered round the great
Brdhmakund, which is larger, deeper and more highly esteemed than the
rest. Tho one nearest the ascent of the mountain is the Gangd-Jamuna-
Jcund. The water is warm, and enters the vault by means of two stone
shoots, the ends of which are carved to represent the heads of tigers or lions.
They remind one strangely of the gargoyles of early English Architecture.
These pipes were clearly mentioned by II wen Thsang in the narrative of his
travels. He says “ a toutes les ouvertures par oil s’echappe l’eau des sour-
ces, on a posd des pierres sculptces. Tantot on a figure des tetes de lions,
etc.”* Below tills are the Anand Ri7chi,Mdrkanda, and Byds Tcund springs.
Next to these comes the Hat, dwdra — a vault some 60 feet long by 10 feet
wide, which receives seven distinct streams on the west side, from the moun-
tain above. Several of these springs enter the reservoir through “ tuyaux
* Memoires, Tom. II., p. 23.
239
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic . Remains of Bihar.
suspendus,” and at the south end is a small subterranean temple contain-
ing rude and, apparently, very modern images of the ‘ Seven Rishis.’ At
the east side of the Sal dwdra is the celebrated Brahma Jcund. The temper-
ature of the water is about 105 deg. Fahr. It is in this that several hun-
dred thousand persons bathe at the recurrence of every thirty-first lunation.
Below this is the Kdsi tirth, which is in reality a mere outlet for the waters
of the Brahma lcupd, which escape through it, still warm and steaming, into
the Sarasvati below. Climbing a distance of 276 feet to the south-west of
the Markanda kund, one arrives at an enormous stone platform projecting'
from the face of the hill. It is composed of huge masses of unhewn stone
piled one upon the other, and is about 50 feet square and 28 high. At its
base there are a number of small grottos six or eight feet square, of which
two are in the eastern and five on the northern side. These were evidently
caves or chambers of meditation, and are up to this day inhabited at times
by 1 nagas’ or ‘ sadhus’, a jogi whose body is perpetually smeared with ashes,
and whose wardrobe seems to consist merely of a very small waisteloth, a
tattered umbrella, and a necklace of enormous boads. These beggars flock
in thousands from all parts of India to Rajgir during the great fair, and are
fed by the Maliants, or abbots, of the monasteries of Rajgir and Rajavali,
who alone exercise the jealously-guarded right of raising their crimson stan-
dards during the month in which the gathering takes place.
To return to the stone platform. It is generally known as the Jard-
sandha-kd-haithalc, and on its summit are three Muhammadan tombs, one
of which is said to be that of Raja Kamdar Khan Main, whose life and ad-
ventures during the end of the 17th and beginning of the 18th centuries
form the subject of many a rude ballad and story in Bihar, and which occu-
py almost the same place in the heart of the people as the tales of Robin
Hood and his followers do at home. Behind this platform is a large cave.
I searched for it in vain in September, but owing to the dense brushwood
and jungle which covered it during the rainy season, I failed to find it.
General Cunningham, however, was fortunate enough to light on it during
bis recent visit, and I have since completely cleared and excavated it. It is
of oval shape, and has an opening to the east. Its floor was considerably
below the surface, and was reached by a flight of eight or nine brick steps
several of which I uncovered almost entire. The chamber measured 36 feet
from east to west, and 26 from north to south. The roof (most of which
bas fallen in) was 18 or 20 feet high. The whole was lined, as it were, by
a brick wall about 2 feet thick. In the midst of the rubbish which filled up
the bottom of the cave I found a very perfect standing figure of Buddha in
black basalt. I can, I think, satisfactorily identify this cave and platform
with the account of Fah-Hiyau and also with that of Hwen Thsang. Fah-
Hiyan says — •“ skirting the southern lull” (and it is to be noted that this
240 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
part of Baibhar runs almost due south) “ and proceeding westward 300
paces, there is a stone cell, called the P'/pal Cave, where Buddha was accus-
tomed to sit in deep moditation after his mid-day meal.”*
This corresponds exactly with the position of the cave in question, and
this view is supported strongly by the succeeding sentence, — “ going still in
a westerly direction five or six li, there is a stone cave situate in the nor-
thern shade of the mountain, and called Che-ti.” This description applies
with singular accuracy to the Sonbhandar Cave in the northern shade of
Mount Baibhar, and almost exactly a mile from the haithak of Jarasandha.
Hwen Thsang’s account is still more striking, — “ A l’ouest des sources ther-
males, on voit la maison en pierre du Pi-po-lo (Pippala). Jadis, l’honor-
able du siecle, y faisait son sejour habituel. La cavern a prof onde qui s’ouvre
derriere ses murs ctait le palais des ’O-sou-lo — Asouras”f [of Jarasandha ?].
Pushing 800 feet further up the mountain side, I found another plat-
form, or haithak, almost identical in size and shape with that of Jarasandha.
The Raj wars call it Sitdmuri, but I could discover no special legend concern-
ing it. Leaving it and climbing up a steep ascent to the west for a distance
of about 1300 feet, one comes, quite suddenly, on a small Jain a temple built
some few years ago by one Hukumat Rai. Between the last haithak and
this temple there are marks of au enormous wall, 14 or 15 feet thick, and
this forms the pathway which leads up the mountain side. The Raj wars,
the sole inhabitants of the wild of Itajgir, called it Jarasandha’s stair-
case, and tell you that he built it in a single day to assemble his troops on
the mountain tops on the approach of his enemies from the west. The
temple contains (besides the usual charana, or footprint) two very fine and
perfect figures of Buddha. The first is throe feet high. Buddha is repre-
sented sitting on the lotus throne (padmasana) in the attitude of meditation.
Beneath this, the Sinhdsana is divided into three compartments — the two
outer containing lions, and the middle one the ‘ Wheel of the Law,’ (very
elaborately carved) supported by two shells. The second figure is a smaller
one and is surmounted by a canopy.
Eight hundred feet to the west of this temple is a similar building con-
taining nothing of interest. Twelve or fourteen paces to the south of it, I
found the ruins of a very small Buddhist temple covered with the densest
jungle. It appears to have contained twelve gray stone columns about six
feet high. The entrance was to the east, and in digging out the centre I
found a very curious image of Buddha — very roughly carved. The main
figure was surrounded by smaller ones, each depicting some chief episode in
his life. Piercing the jungle 400 feet to the south-west of this ruin, I found
the remains of a very large temple almost perfect. The cupola had fallen
* Beal’s Pah-Hian, Oh. xxx., p. 117.
t Memoirea, Tom. II., p. 24.
241
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
down on all sides, forming a mound about 500 feet in circumference and 16
or 17 feet high. The entrance to the east is about 6 feet wide, and leads to
a passage some 14 or 15 feet long, the roof of which was formerly supported
by gray stone pillars about 6 feet high. This leads to a square chamber or
hall some 23 or 24 feet square. Its roof is supported by twelve columns in
the chamber, and eighteen more let into the brick work. These columns
are each 7 feet high, with square bases and capitals and octagon shafts.
They rested on a detached square plinth a foot high. A sur-capital, separate
from the shaft, and cruciform in plan, supported the roof which was com-
posed of enormous granite slabs laid transversely. From this room a mas-
sive doorway and a flight of three steps leads to the inner chamber — some-
what less in size than the other, but considerably loftier — the total height
of its roof being 13 feet. The columns are of the same description as those
in the outer hall, but more lofty. The detached capital are each a foot high,
the base is 2, the octagonal shaft 6, and the second capital 3 feet in height.
The lintel of the doorway is 2 feet broad and is carved with a rude moulding.
In the centre of the lintel, is a figure of Buddha. I found no images in the
temple, but it is by far the most perfect building of the kind I have yet
seen. Its situation is magnificent, commanding at once a view of the high-
ly cultivated plain of Bihar, the “ solitary rock,” the topes and temples of
Nalanda, the walls of new Rajgir, the five hills, and the valley of Kusa-
garapura.
A short distance to the south of this is a very small Jain a temple de-
dicated to Dharmanatha and Sliantinatha, the 15th and 16th Tirthankaras.
It contains two images and a charana, with an inscription about 200 years
old. The pujari has corrupted the names to ‘ Dhanaji’ and ‘ Sathadraji,
and describes them as two wealthy bankers who lived in the house at the
Nirmul kund, i. e. the mound in the south-west corner of the ancient city.
Continuing to ascend the eastern slope of the hill for nearly a quarter
°f a mile, we arrive at a Jaina temple of very considerable dimensions. It
is square in form, and is surmounted by four handsome minarets and a
cupola. It was built by one Pratap Singh of Murshidabad, and a passage
(.pradakshina) encircles the central shrine. There is also a small octagon
chapel, containing charanas at each corner. The doorway has been taken
from a Buddhist temple, and is covered with exquisite carving. The tem-
ple is 51 feet by 58. Some two hundred yards to the west of this is the
largest temple of the group, built by one Manikchand Seth in the middle of
the last century. Manikchand was a well known character in Calcutta, and
his dedication is recorded on the charana. The building consists almost
entirely of Buddhist materials. It has a vestibule, the roof of which is sup-
ported by pillars somewhat smaller in size, though of the same shape as
those in the temple I have described above in detail. At the north side are
31 T
242 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
the remains of a Buddhist temple, probably larger than any other on the
hill. Its pillars, &c., lie about in all directions, and it seems to have served
as the quarry from which Manikehand built his. A quarter of a mile fur-
ther on, and near the crest of the hill, I had the good fortune to find an-
other Buddhist temple in the jungle, about five paces to the north of the path.
Its details resemble very much those of the great temple below, but a figure
of Buddha still occupies the centre, and the foundations of a court-yard can
still be traced.
Proceeding still westwards for nearly half a mile, the highest peak of
the hill is gained, where is an enormous tope, covered with brushwood, and
crowned with a Jaina temple. The view from the top is magnificent, espe-
cially towards the valley, the whole of which Baibhar commands.
Descending the almost precipitous southern face of the mountain, I
arrived at the Sonbhandar cave, which is situated in the “ northern shade”
of the hill, as nearly as possible a mile to the south-west of the hot wells.
I have little difficulty in identifying this with the Sattapanni cave spoken
of both by Fah-Hian and Hwen Thsang. In doing so it must be borne in
mind that the Baibhar hill runs due south- west — not ‘ west,’ and that the
Sonbhandar is near the northern end of the mountain. Fah-Hian says,
that “ going in a westerly direction five or six lis" (i. e., from just above
the hot-springs) “ there is a stone cave situate in the northern shade of the
mountain, and called Ohe-ti. This is the place where 500 Iiahats assembled
after the Nirvana of Buddha to arrange the collection of sacred books.”
This coincides exactly with the position of the Sonbhandar cave, and it also
agrees with Hwen Thsang, who places it five or six lis to the south-west of
the Karandavenuvana clump of bamboos, which both authors represent as
being close to the hot-springs. The words of Hwen Thsang are as follows
— “ au sud-ouest du Bois des Bambous, il fit cinq a six liv. Au nord d’une
montagne situee au midi,” (this I have previously explained) “ au milieu
d’un vaste bois de bambous il y a une grande maison en pierre. Ce fut la
qu’apres le Nirvana de Jauldi, le venerable Malia Kashyapa et neuf cent
quatro-vingt-dix-neuf grands Arhats formerent la collection des trois Re-
cueils sacres. En face de cette maison, on voit encore d’ancients fonde-
ments. Le roi Ajatasatru avait fait construire cet edifice, &c.”
The cave appears to have been formerly approached from the south by
a staircase or sloping path, which has now almost entirely disappeared, and
to have been faced by a broad platform nearly 100 feet square. This space
was occupied by an extensive hall, the rafters supporting the roof of which
rested in cavities in the rock that still exist. Piles of bricks and stones lie
in all directions. The face of the cave has a naked surface of rock, as
smooth and even as if built of brick. It is 44 feet in length and 16 feet
high, and is bounded on the west by a protruding rock and on the east by
243
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bilidr.
a narrow staircase of twenty steps cut in the cliff. The rock is pierced in
the centre by a door 6 feet 4 inches high and about 3J feet wide. The
thickness of the wall of rock is exactly 3 feet. At 11 feet 10 inches west
from the door, and in a line with it is an opening in the cliff 3 feet high by
3 feet wide, which serves to light the vault. The interior is a vaulted cham-
ber 33 feet long by 17 feet wide, with a semicircular roof 16 feet high. The
floor has been spoiled by the water which constantly falls from the roofs.
Outside the door, and three feet to the west of it, is a headless figure of
Buddha cut in the rock, and close to it an inscription, in the Asoka cha-
racter, recording the visit of some holy man to the cave in search of quiet
and solitude. There are also some DevanagarS inscriptions inside.
Inside the cave is a ‘ chaitya,’ so curious in shape and design, that I
think it worth while to describe it somewhat fully.
Its form is square with a conical top surmounted by a large knob.
Each side is 1 foot 10 inches broad, and its total height is 4 feet 9 inches.
On each face there is a pillared canopy, underneath which is a standing
figure of Buddha on a lotus-leaf pedestal, with a miniature attendant on
either side, each holding a torch. The hair on the head is knotted, and
the body is covered by a long cloak. The hands, instead of being raised in
the usual attitude, are held down close by the side. The attendant figures
are elaborately dressed and ornamented. At each comer of the arch of the
canopy are figures holding scrolls. In the centre of the canopy, and imme-
diately above the head of Buddha, rises a pipal tree surmounted by three
umbrellas. The bases vary in design ; on either side, beneath the pedestal,
is depicted the Wheel of the Law, supported on one side by elephants, on
another by caparisoned horses (with saddles of almost Luropean shape),
°n the third by elephants kneeling, and on the fourth by bulls. The coni-
cal top of the chaitya resembles the cupola of a temple.
To return to Mount Vipula. This hill rises about three hundred yards
to the east of the hot springs previously described. Its direction is due
north-east. The northern face of the mountain is a rugged cliff, and its
western slope is but a little less precipitous. At the foot of the hill there
are six wells, — some of which contain hot, and some cold water. They re-
semble in shape those of Mount Baibhar, and are called respectively Nana-
kuud, Sita-kund, S6ma-kund, Ganesha-kupd, and Rama-kund. Nearly a
quarter ofa mile from these wells is a spring immediately under the northern
lace of the mountain. It is surrounded by a large enclosure, and its water
is tepid. Passing through a courtyard, the visitor arrives at a small stone-
cell in the rock, and immediately above this a flight of some eighty steps
leads up the side of the hill to a platform paved with brick. This is the
celebrated Makhdum-kund of the Muhammadans, and Sringgi-rikhi-kund of
the Hindus. This well is held in extraordinary veneration alike by Hindus
244
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
and Musalmans, and is thronged by pilgrims all the year round. The spot
is celebrated as the residence of Makhdum Shfih Shaikh Sharaf-uddin Ahmad,
a saint, not only revered by the Muhammadans of Bihar, hut by the follow-
ers of the Crescent all over India. The date of his sojourn at Rajgir was,
as far as I can ascertain, about 715, A. H. The stone cell is said to be his
“ hujrah,” i. e. the scene of a forty days’ meditation andfast [Persian, chillali],
and the platform above, the place of his morning and evening prayers.
General Cunningham has been led into a strange error about this spot, and
states it to have been the dwelling of Saint Chillah, a converted Hindu.*. I
shall give a complete history of the life and writings of Sharaf-uddin, in
connection with the history of Muhammadan rule in Bihar.
About two hundred feet from the foot of the hill, almost immediately
above the northern gate of the ancient city, and nearly half a mile south-
west of the Makhdum-kund, are the remains of an enormous brick stupa or
“ tope,” now surmounted by a small temple of Mah&deva. There is a simi-
lar ruin opposite this at the foot of Baibhar, and the bed of the ravine is
also strewn with debris. I clearly identify these ruins with the description
of Hwen Thsang :f “ En dehors de la porte septentrionale de la ville, il y a
un Stoupa au nord-est de l’endroit ou fut dompte T elephant ivre il y a
un Stoupa.” Leaving this place, and going some few hundred yards to the
north-east, one arrives at two small Jama pagodas, built on a peak of the
hill. The first is dedicated to Hemantu Sadhu, and the second to Mahavira,
the 24th Tirthankara of the Jainas, who is said to have lived and died at
Pawapfiri, eight miles north-east of Rajgir. Continuing to ascend the wes-
tern face of the hill, one looks down on a rocky defile which separates Mount
Vipula from Ratnagir. There is little difficulty in identifying this from
the remarks of Hwen Thsang as well as by those of Fah-Hian. The former
says,$ “ Au nord de l’endroit ou Che-li-tseu (Saripouttra) avait obtenu le
fruit du Saint (la dignity d ’Arhat), tout pres il y a une fosso large et pro-
fonde, a cote de laquelle on a elevc mi Stoupa Au nord-est de la fosse
ardente, a Tangle de la ville entouree de montagnes il y a un Stoupa. En
cet endroit, le grand modicin Chi-po-lcia (Djivika) bat it en faveur du Boud-
dha une salle pour Texplication de la loi.” Fah-Hian writes :§ “ To the
north-east of the city in the middle of a crooked defile, Djivika erected a
Vihara .. Its ruins still exist.” I believe these places to be identical with
the remains which I shall presently describe.
Nearly a quarter of a mile to the east of the pagoda of Mahavira, one
arrives at the summit of the hill, which is exactly above the centre of the
“ crooked defile.” At this place is an enormous platform 130 feet long by
* Ancient Geography, p. 466. f Memoiros, Tom. II., p. 16.
t Memoires, Tom. II., pp. 18-19.
§ Beal’s Translation, Chap, xxviii, p. 113.
215
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr.
30 wide, and about 6 feet above the surrounding rocks. It is constructed
almost entirely of the materials of Buddhist buildings — I counted more than
30 pillars in the floor alone, — and this is easily accounted for by a large pile
of ruins at either end of the platform. The mound to the east is nearly 30
feet high, and its surface is bestrewn with pillars and stone slabs. The ruins
to the west are undoubtedly those of a temple or vih&ra, and several gray
stone columns arc still erect. The modern Jaina temples on the platform
deserve some notice, as all of them abound, more or less, in Buddhist orna-
mentation. The first of the series of four is only about 10 feet square, and
18 surmounted by a simple semi-circular cupola. It is dedicated to Chan-
draprabha, the 8th Tirthankara. The doorway is a fine specimen of
Buddhist art. In the centre is a figure of Buddha under a canopy, and
three parallel rows of exquisite geometrical pattern run round the
sides. Above the door, a large ornamental slab, about five feet long
and eight inches wide, is inserted in the masonry. It is divided into
seven compartments, the first of which, on either side, contain figures of
elephants, and the remainder — groups of figures in the attitude of the dance.
This is almost identical with the ornamentation of a very beautiful doorway
excavated by me from the mound at Dapthu, and which is now in my col-
lection of Buddhist sculptures. The next temple is divided into two cham-
bers, and is of considerable size. It is dedicated to Mahavira, and both the
mner and outer doors are very fine. The cornice of the latter is divided
into nine compartments, in the first of which a man is represented in the act
of dedicating a chaitya. The others are filled with the usual Buddhist de-
vices. The top of the temple is pyramidal in shape. The next pagoda is
faced by an open court, to the right and left of which are two slabs, the one
covered with the representation of the ten Incarnations of Vishnu, and the
other with those of the Nine Planets. The vacant space at the base of the
carving is covered with a modern inscription in Nagari. The doorway is
surmounted by a comparatively plain moulding. This temple is dedicated
to Munisuvrata, the 20th Jaiua Tirthankara, who is said to have been
born in Rajgir. Inside the fourth temple are four charanas — two of them
being of white marble. They are dedicated respectively to Mahavira [or
Vardham&na], Parshwanatha, Shanthanatha, and Kunthunatha — the 24th,
23rd, 16th, and 17th Tirthankaras respectively.
Beaving the temples and skirting the north side of the ravine, you
cross a nan’ow ridge which brings you to Mount Ratnagir. The summit is
crowned by a temple decorated with some small black basalt columns,
elaborately carved. From this a stone staircase or pathway leads down the
western slope of the hill to the plain beneath.
Between Itatnagir and Udayagir lies a narrow valley covered with
jungle, situated, as nearly as possible due north-east of the ancient city,
246
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
and stretching away as far as Giryak, a distance of six or seven miles.
I shall now proceed to establish if possible an identification of this valley,
connected with the writings of both the pilgrims. Hwen Thsang writes as
follows :* “ Aw nord-est de la ville, il fit de quatorze a quinze li” [2f or 3
miles], “ et arriva au mont Ki-li-tho-Jciu-tch'a (Gridhrakoiita Parvata), qui
touche au midi de la montagne du nord, et s’^leve isolement a une hauteur
prodigieuse. . . . Le roi P'in-pi-so-lo (Bimbisara), voulant entendre la loi, leva
un grand nombre d’hommes ; puis, pour traverser la vallee et franchir les
ravins, depuis le pied de la montagne jusqu’au sommet, il fit assembler des
pierres, et pratiqua des escaliers larges d'environ dix pas, et ayant une lon-
gueur de cinq a six li. Au milieu du chemin, il y a deux petits Stoupas :
Le sommet de cette montagne est allonge de Test l’ouest, et res-
serre du sud au nord.” He then proceeds to speak of a vihara to the west
of the mountain, a colossal stone once trodden by the sacred feet of Sakhya
Muni, a stiipa to the south, and a second on the summit of the mountain.
Fah-Hian’s descriptionf is far less minute, hut he gives exactly the same
distance [viz., 15 li], and speaks of two caves on the hill — the colossal stone
— the Vihara, and the lofty peak.
On the 20th January, I made an attempt to explore the valley. Clear-
ing the dense brushwood and jungle as I advanced, I skirted the foot of Rat-
nagir for about a mile from the old city, and then struck across into the
centre of the valley, and pushed on two miles further to the east. I then
saw that to the east of Batnagir there is another mountain terminating in a
lofty peak, which towers above the summit of the surrounding hills. This
mountain is called Dcoghit, and I unhesitatingly identify it with that
mentioned in the text of Fah-Hian and Hwen Thsang. It adjoins the sou-
thern side of Vipula. In the middle of the valley, a stone terrace or stair-
case, about 20 feet broad, runs duo north, towards the foot of the hill, for
a distance of 900 feet. At this point it branches off to the east up the
mountain side. At the distance of 300 feet from the plain, I found a small
stupa in the very centre of the staircase about 8 feet square, and in front of
it three or four steps are still almost intact, each step being about 18 or 20
feet wide and a foot high. Near tins place under a great heap of debris I
found three images of Buddha almost perfect, but of the rudest workman-
ship. They are uniform in size, and bear inscriptions. From the stupa the
staircase continues to traverse the mountain-side for a distance of 800 feet.
At this point I discovered a second stiipa and a large quantity of images,
pillars, &e. Of these, the most remarkable are a figure of Buddha seated on
a lion, a large Buddha seated on the usual lotus throne, and a standing
figure of Buddha with a long inscription. All these idols have been remov-
* Memoires, Tom. II., pp. 20-21.
+ Baal’s Fah-Hian, Ch. xxix., p. 114.
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. 247
ed to Bihar, and merit a much more detailed description. The terrace now
becomes more broken, hut its traces are visible up to the peak. From its
commencement in the valley up to the summit of the mountain it measures,
as nearly as possible, one mile. The south and west side of the hill are
covered with the debris of houses, &c., and the solitary peak which crowns
the hill is surmounted by an enormous brick stupa. Though there is no
natural cave in the southern face of the hill, as might reasonably be expect-
ed, the other features it presents are so remarkable that its identification is
beyond a doubt, and besides this everything tends to show that the caves
and grottos of Bajgir were mostly artificial.
Parallel with Batnagir and Devaghat [or Deoghat] runs Udayagir.
Two ramparts or walls seem to have traversed the valley. The first to the
west now called the Nekpai-band, and the second stretches from the foot of
Deoghat, as before described, to the centre of the valley, and this seems to have
been continued as far as the foot of the Udaya Hill. The slopes of this hill
are more gradual than any of the others, and this accounts for the fortifications
which surmount it. The steepest side of the mountain is towards the west,
and it is through a narrow ravine at the foot of it, that the valley is entered
from the south. The passage is very narrow, and in the centre runs the
Banganga rivulet, which rises from beneath Sonargir. The pass was strong-
ly fortified, and the ramparts and bastions are still remarkably perfect,
although they have been exposed to the devastations of the rain and sun
for many centuries. Just within the valley are the ruins of the two towers,
and at the entrance of the pass, where the width of the ravine is little
naore than twenty feet, two forts of considerable size — one on the slope of
Udayagir, and the other facing it, at the foot of Sonargir. The former
Measures 111 feet from the north to south, and 40 from east to west. From
this point a massive wall, 16 feet thick (and still having an elevation of
some 10 or 12 feet), stretches in a direct line due east to the summit of
the mountain. I measured it to a distance of 4,000 feet from the com-
mencement, and it thus appears to continue its course for more than two
miles on the crest of the hill, then to cross over towards the north, and
finally to pass down the northern slope, and into the narrow valley between
Udayagir and Batnagir, just opposite the staircase of Bimbisara, which leads
t° the summit of the Deoghat hill. The wall is composed of huge stones
on either side, closely fitted together without cement, the centre being filled
UP by a mass of pebbles and rubbish. There are traces of Buddhist ruins
°n the top of the hill, and I found several images, and the remains of two
mrge stupas, and one temple similar to that on Baibhar. There is also a
large enclosure containing five modern Jaina temples — the centre one square
and the others triangular in shape. Each of the small ones contains a
figure of Buddha bearing the creed, “ ye dharma lietu, etc.” There are
248
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
large numbers of gray stone columns at the foot of the mounds above men-
tioned, and the spot has evidently been once the site of a Vihara.
Although live hills are stated both in poetry and history to have sur-
rounded the ancient capital of Magadha, this can hardly be considered
literally correct, and to maintain the old description, several peaks must be
considered as forming part of the same mountain. Thus the rocky cliffs
of Chhata, (or Chhakra,) must he deemed the eastern extremity of Baibhar,
and the various parts of Sonargir must be considered as portions of one
great hill. Sondrgir, the most extensive, though the least lofty, of all the
hills, begins at the south-east corner of the valley, and runs due east from
this point till it reaches the centre of the valley just above the plain of the
Ranbhum. From this point three branches stretch eastwards ; the first
inclining slightly towards the north, and forming the southern boundary
of the valley of the five hills, the second runs due east and forms the
western side of the ravine which leads into the Hisua-Nowada plains, and
the third turns first south, then again almost due east, and finally termi-
nates, as I have before described, in the rocks and torrents of Banganga.
This was evidently the weakest point in the natural defences of the city ;
for an enemy who had once gained the entrance of the valley, (which ap-
pears to have been still further protected by a semi-circular wall outside it,)
could easily pass up the gentle slope between the two last mentioned branch-
es of the hill, and descend by an equally easy road on the northern side of
the hill into the very heart of the valley. I ascended the hill on this side,
and soon gained the summit, which, like that of Udayagir, is occupied by
an enormous pile of rums, and a modem Jaina temple. Inside the pagoda
is a large figure of Buddha, bearing the creed, and also a comparatively
modern inscription on the unoccupied portions of the pedestal. Several
columns are lying about, and also portions of cornice and other ornamental
carving. This was once, evidently, the site of some great vihara or temple.
Thirty paces south of the pagoda, one comes quite suddenly on the great wall,
almost unbroken and entire. It is uniformly sixteen feet thick, but its
height differs, at various places. It commences in the Ranbhum plain, and
then runs in a direct line to the summit of the hill, a distance of 2300 feet.
From this point an enormous embankment runs across the valley to the foot
of Baibhar, and now bears the name of Jarasandha’s band. At the top of
the mountain the wall turns to the east, following the crest of the central
branch of Sonargir, which now takes an almost semi-circular form, to a dis-
tance of 4100 feet. The wall at this point runs down the ravine, crosses it
close to the source of the Banganga torrent, then ascends the slope of the
southern branch of the hill, and passes first along its ridge and then down
its western slope till it ends in the foot to the west of the stream, as nearly
as possible 12,000 feet from its commencement in the Ranbhum plain. The
219
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
fort at which it ends is about half the size of the one on the opposite side of
the torrent. 1 have thus succeeded in tracing the great wall which formed
the artificial defence of the valley ; but strange to say, popular legends, so
far from connecting it with any such purpose, make it the evening walk of
the Asura king — the spot where he used to enjoy the cool mountain air after
the fatigues of the day.
Before giving some account of the wild ravine to the west of the valley
it may bo interesting to say something of the Jaina pagodas which still
adorn the hills. They are maintained and repaired by subscriptions collect-
ed all over India, and are yearly visited by thousands of pilgrims from
fiwaliar, Bombay, Calcutta, and Murshidabad. They all contain charanas,
or impressions of the sacred feet of the Tirthankaras— generally carved in
black basalt, but sometimes in marble, and invariably surrounded by a
Nagari inscription. I have taken copies of the whole of them, but many
have become very indistinct, on account of the oil, ghi, &c., with which they
are anointed. The following are specimens of them.* In the temple
dedicated to Munisuvr&ta, on the Vipula Hill, I found the following : — “ On
fhe 7th of the waxing moon in the month of Kartika, Samvat 1818, the
image of the supremely liberated sage who attained salvation on the Vipula
Mountain together with his congregation, was made and consecrated by
S ri Amrita Dharma Vacliaka.” In another of the series of temples : —
‘ On the 9th of the waxing moon in the month of Phalguna, Samvat 1501,
by Santha S'ivaraja, &c., of the noble .latada race.” On Sonargir : — “ In
tbe auspicious Khadatara Port [y«r/<»], the imago of S'ri Adinatha, &c.”
The other inscriptions arc similar, and the dates 1819, 1823, (on Udayagir)
1816, (Ratnagir) 1830 Samvat, occur. I will give one other at length.
It comes from Vipulagir, and rims as follows: — “ On Friday, the 13th
of the waxing moon, in the month of Aswina, when the S aka year
1572 was current, Samvat 1707, [A. D. 1650], Suyama and his younger
brother Gobardhana, sons of Lakshmid&sa and his wife Vananihala, of the
Vihara Vastuvya family, of the Dopada gotra, caused certain repairs to be
done to in Rajagriha.” Babu Raj endralala Mitra remarks, that in
this inscription all the proper names have the title ‘ sangha prefixed to
them, and this shows that the individuals in question belonged to a Buddhist
congregation.
In one of the temples at the summit of V ipulagir I found the follow-
ing : — “ On the 7th of the waxing moon in Ivartika, this statue of Mukhti-
gupta, the absolutely liberated sage, was made by Sri Sanga, on the “ Sri
Tipulachala hill, and consecrated by the preachers of salvation.” The Clia-
I'ana on Ratnagir bears the following : — “ Om, Salvation. On the 6th of
* These readings and translations were made by Babu Rajendralala Mitra, for
whose valuable assistance I cannot be too grateful.
32
v
250
A. M. Broaclley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
the waxing moon in the month of Magha, Samvat year 1829, Sha Manik-
chand, son of Bulakidasa of the Ganghigotra and Osa family, an inhabitant
of Hugli, having repaired the temple on the Ratnagiri hill in Rajagriha,
placed the two lotus-like feet of the Jina Sri Parsvanatha there.” I
conclude with the oldest inscription, which is on Sonargir — “ On the 9th of
the waxing moon in the month of Phalguna, in the Samvat year 1504
of the Jatada Gotra, Ramamala Varma Dasa, son of Sangha Manikadeva,
son of the wife of Sangha ... baraia, son of Sangha B unarm a, son of Sangha
D,evaraja.” [A. D. 1447.]
The most recent of the inscriptions is dated as late as Samvat 1912, or
A. D. 1855.
The ravine on the west of the valley is bounded on either side by a range
of rocky hills, terminating in a narrow pathway covered with almost impene-
trable brushwood and j ungle. The plain between the mountains is almost level,
and is covered with bushes, and broken here and there by heaps of stone. A
huge embankment stretches right across it, from the foot of Sonargir (exactly
below the Jaina tample which crowns its summit) to that of Baibliar. The
plain to the east of this is the RanbhAm. About a quarter of a mile beyond
this a second hand, hardly inferior in size and importance, traverses the valley
almost at right angles.
The traveller Fah-Hiyan quitted the Magadha capital through the
ravine and the rugged valley of Jeti-ban which lies beyond it. -I have tra-
versed the whole of the country as far as the hot springs of Tapoban, but a
detailed description of it, does not find a place here, as it lies beyond the
limits of “ Bihar in Patna.”
V.— Prom Tiladaka [or Tilasakya] Monastery to Kalya'npu'r.
Hwcn Thsang started from the east of Patna [Patali] and proceeded
to a monastery situated at a place called Tilayakya, but strange to say one
account makes the distance thirty-live miles or seven yojanas, and the other
twenty miles or one hundred lis. Although I am unable to explain this dis-
crepancy, except by the generally inaccurate distances given by the writer,
I have no hesitation in identifying this place with the modern village of Til-
larah or Tillardah situated, as nearly as possible twenty-four miles to the
south-west of the most easterly part of Patna, (which town is nearly eight miles
long) on a narrow strip of land between the Kattfir and the Sona streams, two
branches of the Phalgu River. The modern village consists of a straggling
line of houses and shops running from east to west, but nearly a third of
them are unoccupied and fast falling to decay. The town of Tillarah,
however, still bears the signs of a period of prosperity which has now long
since passed away. The ruins of a fine bridge of five arches still spans the
now nearly dried up course of the Sona-nadi ; a splendid masjid composed
251
1872.] A. M. firoadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
entirely of Buddhist materials is falling to decay on the eastern outskirts of
the village, and the ruined verandahs, courtyards, and tombs, which meet
the eye in all directions, serve only to testify to the fact, that oven dur-
ing the later days of Musalman rule, Tillarah had not altogether lost its
pristine importance. Hwen Thsang tells us a good deal about the splendour
of the Tillarah monastery, when ho visited it in February, 637 A.I).# He
writes : — “ The convent of Tillarah has four courtyards, and is ornamented
with verandahs, three-storied pavillions, lofty towers, and a series of gates.
It was built by the last scion of the house of Bimbis&ra, who was a man of
more than ordinary attainments, and who assembled around him men of
talent and worth for every quarter. Men of letters from distant countries
flocked there in crowds. There are a thousand recluses here who study the
doctrine of the Greater Vessel. In the road which leads to the eastern gate,
there are three viharas, each of them surmounted by a cupola hung with
bells. These buildings are several stories high, and are surmounted by ba-
lustrades. The doors, windows, rafters, columns, etc., are covered with bas-
reliefs in gilded copper, decorated with still choicer ornaments. A casket of
relics is deposited in each vihara. From time to time a supernatural light
proceeds from these, and wonders and marvels occur there.” The site of
this once magnificent pile of buildings is now marked by an enormous
mound of irregular shape, near the banks of the Sonanadi, about fifty feet
high, and covered, I regret to say, with Muhammadan tombs. Nearly every
grave that has been dug there, has yielded some specimen of Buddhistic art,
and idols of brass and basalt are constantly found there. I have secured some
very beautiful specimens of the latter, but the former are sold as soon as
discovered and quickly converted into the heavy ‘ batisi’ and ‘ kara’ which
decorate (?) the wrists and ancles of the women of the lower castes of the Hin-
dus. Few places in India, I feel sure, would yield more archaeological treasure
than this great Tillarah mound, and a shaft might be very well cut through
it, without interfering with or in any way injuring the tombs on its surface.
At the eastern side of the village is a large masjid raised by a platform
a few feet above the surrounding plains. This platform is composed almost
entirely of pillars, portions of cornice, etc., which once belonged to some great
Buddhist temple. The building is surrounded by a brick wall, and the en-
closure is entered by a porch facing the east, both doors of which are purely
Buddhistic. One bears an inscription of two lines, but is so much defaced as
to be quite illegible. The word ‘ Sam vat,’ however, is decipherable. The
masjid itself consists of one oblong chamber forty-one feet by twenty-two
broad, the roof of which, is supported by three rows of pillars numbering
fourteen in the centre of the building, while several others are almost com-
* MemoiroB, Vol. II., p. 439.
252 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
pletely imbedded in the brick work. The roof is nine feet six inches above
the floor. Most of the pillars are about six feet six inches high, and have
separate capitals and bases. They are surmounted by long stone beams
placed transversely, which in turn support the roof consisting of huge slabs
of granite and basalt. The pillars are of great variety of shape and design.
Some are square, both at the capital, base, and shaft ; others have square bases
and capitals but simple octagon shafts, while others again are oval and
covered with the richest ornament. Most of these exhibit great freedom of
design, and several of them are of the most graceful form. The ‘ Sangi Masjid’
(as it is popularly called) was built on the site of a Buddhist temple, and near-
ly all the graves dug around it, have yielded either figures, pillars, or portions
of cornice and moulding. The Musalman of Tillarah refuses to bury in
any tomb from which any idolatrous image or carving has been turned up, and
for this reason a grave has sometimes to be dug three or four times over.
Just outside the gate of the Sangi Masjid, a man pointed out a spot,
which he said had been dug out for his father’s grave, and subsequently
abandoned because a large image had been found there. I ordered an excava-
tion to be made in the place indicated, and came on a splendid figure of
Buddha, unfortunately broken in three pieces, about four feet from the sur-
face. The black basalt in which it was carved, is of the finest quality, and
the features quite perfect. It has been photographed. Outside the doors of
the masjid is a second enclosure containing the tomb of Sayyid Yusuf Iqbal,
a Muhammadan saint who lived in Tillarah about two hundred and fifty
years ago. He and his six brothers are greatly respected and revered by the
Musalmans of the Tillarah district, and the tombs of the latter are to be
found at the villages of Meawan, Mandaj, Abdalpur, Fathpiir, Parbalpur,
and Bibipur.
Down to the time of Altbar, Tillarah was a place of some considerable
importance, and the capital of one of the largest parganahs between the
Bajgir hills and the Ganges. Its area is in the A'in-i-Akbari stated to be
39,053 bighahs, and its revenue 2,920,360 dams. It also had to furnish
a force of 300 cavalry and 20 infantry.
Some of the finest figures and carvings in my collection come from
the Tillarah monastery. I extract a description of them from my catalogue
[No. LXII.]. Unmutilated alto-relievo figure in fine black basalt, two feet
seven inches high, holding a lotus in either hand. On the head is a jewelled
crown, conical in shape, with curious ornaments behind the ears. The hair
is dressed in profuse ringlets. A garland passes over the loft shoulder across
the body. The earrings consist of two parts — a jewelled ring, passed through
an oval hoop. There is a jewelled girdle around the waist. The body is
covered with a tight jacket, having an ornamental facing. The legs are
covered with pantaloons, and the feet with boots. A sword is girded below
253
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
the left thigh. Between the feet is a small grotesque booted figure, gather-
ing up a set of reins in his hands and waving a whip over his shoulders.
Below this is a row of seven horses galloping from left to right, and drawing
a chariot. On the other side of the main figure are attendants, standing
hooted, and wearing curious caps and circular earrings. Above these, dimi-
nutive female figures are seen, discharging arrows right and left. The figure
may be either Hindu or Buddhist.” The next figure [LXI\ .] is purely Hin-
du (for at Tillarah as in the Nalanda rains Hindu and Buddhist idols are
mixed together). Like the one last described, it is unbroken. It is “an
alto-relievo in black basalt two feet four inches high, containing figures of
Durga and Siva. Siva is four-handed, and is elaborately dressed and orna-
mented. He is seated on a bull. The upper hand to the right grasps a
lotus, while the other rests playfully on the chin of the goddess. His lower
hand on the opposite side passes round her body and supports her left breast.
The one above it grasps a trident. His right leg is turned outwards to the
right, but the left one is twisted over the bull’s head, so that the right leg
of the goddess rests upon it. Her right hand passes round his neck, while
the left grasps a mirror. She is seated on a lion. In his right ear is a cir-
cular ring and in his left an oblong drop. In her case the arrangement is
reversed. His hair is rolled up into a ball first, while hers is dressed almost
precisely after the fashion of George Ilnd’s time.” Another figure represents
a tfaWiie-handed goddess (quite perfect) with a Buddha seated in the hair.
Each hand contains some weapon or ornament, e. g., a string of beads, an arrow,
&c. The creed is engraved above. This idol is unique as far as Bihar is con-
cerned.
About four miles south-east of Tillarah is a village called Ongari, in
which there is a splendid tank called the Siiraj Pok har. To the north of it
there is a temple containing an image of Surjya, and a pit of broken Bud-
dhist figures. Under a heap of bricks and rubbish, I picked out two idols of
great beauty and differing essentially in design from those generally found.
About a mile and a half from Ongari, across the rice fields to the
south, arc the remains of a large town, called Biswak or Biswa. Like Tilla-
rah, this place gave its name to a parganah which, according to the Ain-i-
Akbari, once contained 35,318 bighahs, and which stretches away nearly as far
east as the banks of the Panchana. There are two enormous tanks to the
east of the village, and two mud forts of considerable size and antiquity.
To the north of the first tank is a long line of tumuli, which mark the site
of some large Buddhist vihara. I cleared away one end of it, and came on
a perfect heap of figures, some of them quite unique. With one exception
(that of an idol of Ganesh) all the remains discovered by me were purely
Buddhistic. One figure is eight-handed and somewhat resembles the many-
handed divinity of Tillarah, and another is a Padmopani Buddda nearly life-
254
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. [No. 3,
size. Besides the figures, I dug out a cliarana almost like these of Efiia-
griha.
Islampur is about four miles to the south-west of Biswak and is still
a very flourishing town, doing a good trade in rice and tobacco, and affording
a resting-place for the pilgrims who pass down in great numbers from the
north of Bengal en route for Gaya. To the extreme west of the village I
lighted on the remains of a large vihara, many of the granite columns of which
still exist intact, but I regret to say that the bulk of the building was pulled
down somo years ago by the zamindar of the place, one Chaudhri Zuhurul
Haq, to construct the platform of his now masjid, and I am told cart-loads of
figures, &c., were used for the same purpose. The old men of the place remember
the time when the building was intact, and say it resembled very much the
‘ Sangi Masjid’ of Tillarah and contained a Nagari inscription, and a great
deal of sculpture. About a mile south-west of Islampur, is a small village called
Icchos, which was doubtless the site of a great Buddhist temple and vihara.
I found the remains ol a tope close to the old mud fort, and saw in a garden a
great figure of the ascetic Buddha, nearly six feet high. A short distance
off, I found the remains of two very fine basalt columns, the largest piece
being still six feet long. The base is 2 feet high and H feet broad. Next to
it comes a circular band or ornament one foot four inches wide, each corner
being decorated by a sprig of very elaborate scroll work, the stone behind
which is hollowed out leaving the inner circle unbroken. This is a constant
feature in Buddhist pillars, and I found a miniature reproduction of this
column at Bogam, a mile to the north ol Bihar. Above the ornament in
question, the shaft becomes octagon and there is a lion-rampant at each of
the four corners. This portion of the pillar is two feet in height, and is de-
corated with small arched canopies and pillars about a foot high, surmounted
by fork-shaped pieces of scroll work. Above this is second line of niches.
The quality of the stone is very fine and holes have been rubbed in its base
by persons who imagine its touch a sovereign remedy for swollen necks and
throats ! One mile south-west of Icchos is a large village called Mubarak-
pur. To the south is a large tank and at its north-west corner a huge mound
marking the site of a temple or vihara of great importance. I moved away
a great portion of the rubbish and succeeded in recovering a large quantity of
very beautiful figures. Notably I may mention a basalt arch, with a gurgoyle
face for its (supposed) keystone and long lines of rich carving right and left, a
figure of Jama, with a background of flames, and a large mixture of Hindu
and Buddhist idols, more than forty in number. Several of there were un-
finished, and others scarcely begun. For this reason, I suppose Mubarakpur
to have been the site of a the sculptor’s studio.
About 300 yards to the south of the Mubarakpiir ruins is a village
known as Afzalpur Sarunda. Here again are the remains of a tope now
255
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr.
covered by a mud fort. To the south of the village is another large tank and
I found several Buddhistic figures on its banks. To the west of it is a fine
uncultivated plain studded with mangoe groves and stretching away as far as
the eye can reach to the distant hills of Barabar. In the western outskirts
of the plain, and not far from the side of the tank, are the marks of a
large tumulus, and several Buddhist figures surround it. Following a road
for about a mile to the south across the plain, I came quite suddenly on a
large tumulus on the outskirts of a village, the name of which is Lat. About
a hundred yards to the east of this place, in the midst of a rice field lies an
enormous column hewn from a single stone— -fifty -two feet in length. The
base is square, and seven feet long by three broad ; the capital is of the same
shape, but is five feet long and four broad. The shaft has sixteen sides, each
about six inches hi breadth. There is not a vestige of a temple or building
in this plain of rice, fields, in fact one might almost say as appropriately of
it, as of the Sundarban, that “ there is no stone big enough there to throw
at a dog.” The appearance of this enormous solitary column lying by itself,
half buried in the sandy soil which surrounds it, is very striking. The villagers
of Lat [the vernacular for ‘ a pillar’] have their own story about their venerat-
ed deity (for puja is daily offered to it), and it is as follows. More than a
thousand years ago Sibai Singh reigned in Tirhut, having Darbhangah for his
capital. The king’s servants were martial men of the Rajput daste, and his
favourite was a soldier named Ranjit Singh. One day the king went to see
the progress of the works at a tank which he was excavating near bis palace,
and Ranjit; Singh was of his guards. The king and his companions began to
throw up the earth and assist the workmen at their labour, but Ranjit stood
aloof leaning on his spear. This provoked the king who began to chide him
for his indifference. The soldier replied, ‘ I am by caste a Khatria, my busi-
ness is to fight or to execute any great commission you may entrust me
with — not to dig or build.’ On this the king wrote a letter to the prince of
Ceylon, who was no other than the mighty Raban, and requested him to send
two colossal pillars for the new tanks.* The execution of this order was
made over to Ranjit Singh. Taking the letter, Ranjit made his way to the
“ golden island of the south,” and having procured the pillars, enlisted the
aid of the “ dhuts,” or supernatural messengers to convey them to Tirhut.
These, although possessed of enormous strength could only travel by
night. The first reached Darbhangah in safety, but the bearers of the second
tarried at Sarunda to get oil for their torches, and the dawn breaking upon
* To plaoe a large pillar in the centre of a tank was a custom of the times. In
a great tank just outside Bihar there is a column about twenty feet high still stand-
ing. This custom has hardly ceased to prevail. General Claude Martin erected a
colossal pillar in the middle of the artificial lake which faces the Indo-Italian palace
which he built in Lakhnau.
25G A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic llemains of Bihar. [No. 3,
them suddenly they fled, leaving their burden in the open plain.” It is said
that the kings of Darbliangah have often tried in vain to raise the Lat.
Mitarjft Singh (who was alive in the time of Lord Cornwallis) spent large
sums in endeavouring to remove it, hut was at last deterred by an apparition
of the pillar, which warned him in a dream that the accomplishment of his
purpose would lead to his certain destruction. The village regard the Lat
■with the most superstitions veneration and declare the last time it was pol-
luted by the touch of an unbeliever, the villagers were promptly visited a
conflagration.
About a mile to the south-east of the Lat is a village called Dapthu,
the site of a great mass of ruined temples, of which a long account is given
in Montgomery Martin’s ‘ Gya and Shahabad,’ pp. 97-100. I quote it in de-
tail merely for the purpose of illustrating how quickly buildings, even of the
most solid description, disappear, under the influence of the varying seasons
of an Indian climate.
“ Immediately west from the temple called Parasnath is a line of
four temples running north and south. The two extreme temples of this
line are said to be those of Kanaiya, the images of which entirely resemble
those usually called LakslimS Narayan or Viisudeva, and are very large. I
believe that those which have two attendants on each side are usually called
by the former name, and those which have only one attendant as this, are
called by the latter, but I did not at first attend to the distinction, and can-
not say whether or not it is generally observed. The temple furthest north
consists of one chamber supported by antique columns of grauite.
“ The brick work had fallen and was rebuilt by Raja Mitrajit’s grand-
father, but has again decayed a great deal. The door is of stone and is
highly ornamented. The original sides remain, but the lintel has been
removed, and its place supplied by one of the sides of the door of Parasnath
which will perhaps show that before the repair was given, the temple had
been so long a ruin that its door had been lost. The southern temple of
Kanaiya is an entire ruin, but the image remains in its place.
“ The central temple next to this is the most entire, and contains a large
image, called Surya, and very nearly similar to that of Akbarpur. On one
side is placed the usual figure called Lakshmi Narayan. The temple consists
of a flat-roofed natmundir porch, or propylacrum and of a pyramidical shrine
or mundir. The roof of the former consists of long stones supported by
stone beams and these by columns. The interstices of the outer rows are
filled with bricks to complete the walls.
“ The shrine, except the door is constructed entirely of brick. Both the
door of the shrine and the stone-work of the porch are of much greater anti-
quity than the parts that consist of brick, which have probably been several
times renewed ; but there is no appearance that the image or stone-
257
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic . Remains of Bihar.
work has ever undergone alteration ; and this seems to he by far the
most ancient temple of the district that still remains tolerably entire.
The porch consists of four rows of columns, the interstices between
the two outermost of which, as I have said, are filled up with bricks to form
the walls. Bound the porch, but not built into the wall, have been placed a
row of small images intended as an ornament and not at all consecrated to
worship.
“ They were placed in the following order : — A Surya similar to that
worshipped, Jagadamba, as usual killing a man and a buffalo, a Haragauri
as usual, a Ganes dancing as that at Dinajpur, another Haragauri as usual,
a Lukshmi Narain or Vasudeva, as usual ; another Surya ; a male called
Vishnu, like Vasudeva but in armour ; one called Gauri Sankar represents
a male sitting between two females and leaning one foot on a crocodile.
There is here neither bull nor lion as in the common Gauri Sankar, or Ha-
ragauri. Another Ganes, another Gauri Sankar or Haragauri. Another
Ganes ; another Gauri Sankar, or Haragauri, another Ganesa, another Gauri
Sankar like the last, a Narasingha in the form usual in the ancient tem-
ples of this district, a strange male figure, called Trinilcrama Avatar, which
I have seen nowhere else ; a female sitting on a bull and leaning on a porcine
head which is called Varaha, but is quite different from that so-called at
Baragang, nor have I seen it anywhere else ; although among such immense
numbers of images as are scattered through this district, many may have
escaped my notice.
“ On the outside of the door is a very curious sculpture, which is. called
Bhairau, but seems to me to represent a prince riding out to hunt the ante-
lope. He is accompanied by archers, musicians, targeteers, women, dogs, &c.
The animal on which he rides is by the natives called a sheep, but I pre-
sume, was intended to represent a horse. The last temple of the place im-
mediately north to that of Surjya is an entire ruin, and has contained an
enormous linga, before which is placed the form of Gauri Sankar that is
common at the place.”
To the south of the village of Dapthu is a large dried up tank, now a
flourishing rice field. To the north of this is a huge mound covered with
the densest jungle. I made an excavation through it, and found a colossal
figure of Vishnu somewhat mutilated, and a doorway of great beauty. This
has been photographed. It consists of three pieces. The two lintels are
ornamented with boldly executed mouldings to the right and left, and towards
the centre by lines of figures, apparently those of dancers and musicians.
The chief feature of the upper cornice is a crowd of figures supporting a crown,
extended over some object of veneration, which has been too much mutilated
to admit of description. The musical instruments, dresses, etc., are precisely
those of the present day.
33
x
258 A. M. Broadley- — The Buddhistic . Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
Along the western side of the tank are the remains of a row of temples,
four in number, of which two have yielded completely to the ravages of
decay, and the sites of which are only marked by mounds of earth, broken
pillars, and fragments of idols. The second temple still remains in a tolera-
ble state of preservation, and the fourth, although very dilapidated, is still
perfect enough to allow the spectator to form a correct idea of its
size and proportions. The second temple of the row is built of bricks, rather
smaller than those of Bargaon, and faces the east. There is a stone
cornice at the top, and the entrance consists merely of a nai’row opening in
the brick work. This leads to a court or porch, twenty-three feet square,
and ten high, as measured from the inside. The roof consists of long slabs
of grey stone laid from east to west and covered with a thick layer of plas-
ter. This is supported by sixteen columns, twelve of which are almost
entirely imbedded in the brick work, while four are as near as possible in
the centre of the building. These pillars have square bases and capitals and
octagon shafts, and are surmounted by separate capitals oblong in shape,
being about four feet in length, and about a foot thick. Various idols are
grouped around the chamber. There is a distance of about six feet between
the pillars. At the west end of the room is a very finely carved doorway
(of which Montogomery Martin’s drawing conveys a very incorrect idea).
It measures seven feet five inches in width. The pillars on either side are
two feet wide, and six feet high, and the slab which surmounts them is of
about the same size. The whole is covered with a very beautiful geometrical
pattern. The actual doorway is only two feet nine inches wide. It leads
to a small chamber eight feet square, the roof of which has fallen in, but
which I suppose was once covered by a dome or cupola. This contains a
large looted figure of Surjya much mutilated, and a very perfect one of
Vishnu, similar to those recovered from Bargaon, and now in my collection.
The whole building resembles most strongly the Buddhist temple dis-
covered by me on the Baibhar hill at Rajgriha, of which a full description
has been given in Chapter IV. Strange to say, I only found two purely
Buddhist images amongst the ruins of Dapthu ; but I have little doubt the
temples were originally intended for Buddhist worship, and this is confirmed
by the fact that several figures [most probably of Buddhas] appear to have
been deliberately removed from the ornamentation of the doorway found by
me in the mound to the north of the dried-up tank. The other temple
has no inner room, but is otherwise similar in shape to the first. The lintels
of the door (now fallen down) are very fine, and are almost identical with
specimens from Nalanda in my collection.
Two miles to the south-east of Dapthu is another village, called Sarthua,
where I found the remains of a tope (nearly levelled by time) and a figure
of Buddha, now in my collection, and rather larger than life. It is in the
259
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic . "Remains of Bihar.
usual attitude, and the Buddhist creed is inscribed over the halo which sur-
rounds its head. Four miles east of Sarthua is a place called Mahmtida, once
the site of a vihara. There is a large mound of hriclcs to the east of the
village, at the top of which several granite columns have been collected and
arranged, forming as it were a miniature reproduction of the Sangi Masjid at
Tillarah. Leaving this village, and going seven miles to the north-east,
I arrived at a hamlet called Sawra, which is exactly two miles to the south-
west of the site of the once great N&landa monastery — the modern village
of Bargaon. We can now begin to trace again the foot steps of Hwen
Thsang, whom we left at Tillarah setting out for the Guuamati monastery,
the sacred Pipal tree of Bodh-Gya, and the other holy places to the
west and south of the mountains of Raj agriha. We must now suppose
for a moment that he has finished his inspection of the ruins of Kusa-
garapura, and having arrived within the precincts of “ our sacred mother
Nalanda,” is describing the neighbourhood of the convent.* “ Au sud-ouest
de Nalanda il tit huit a neuf li, et arriva a la ville de Koulika. Au centre
s’elevait un stoupa qui avait ete bati par le roi A^oka. C’etait le pays
natal du venerable Mogalan-pouttra. A cote de cetto ville il y a un stou-
pa. Ce fut dans cet endroit que le venerable Mogalan-pouttra eutra dans le
nirvana definitif ; le stoupa renferme les reliques de son corps.” This spot
can he most satisfactorily identified with Sawra. I found there the remains
of a large stupa and nine very perfect Buddhist idols. I again return to the
pilgrim’s narrative.f “ Apres avoir fait quelque li a Test du pays de Moga-
lan-pouttra il reneontra un stoupa.” This must be Jagdespur — one mile to
the east of Sawra. This is strangely confirmed by the existence of an enormous
tumulus there, together with a gigantic alto-relievo figure of Buddha, now
worshipped as the goddess Rukhmini. Hwen Thsang then seems to have gone
twenty lis to the south-east]; and to have arrived at the town of Kalapinika.
“ On y voit au centre,” he writes. “ un stoupa bati par le roi Ayoka ; c’^tait le
pays natal du venerable paripouttra. Le puits de sa maison existe encore au-
jourd’hui. A cote du puits il y a un stoupa. Ce fut-la que le venerable
paripouttra entra dans le nirvana. Un monument renferme les reliques de
son corps.” This corresponds almost exactly with the position of Chandi-
mau,four miles south-east of Nalanda. This singularly picturesque spot
is situated about two miles from the foot of the Rajagriha hills and near the
banks of the Panchana. The surrounding country is well-wooded, and a
beautiful tank forms the western boundary of the village, which possesses a
large mud fort, said to have been built early in the last century by Kamdar
Khan Main of Rajagriha. To the south of the tank is the ruin of a stiipa,
near which I found a pile of Buddhist idols — most of them much mutilated.
I recovered, however, one very fine figure of Buddha, the description of
* Memoires, Tom. II., p. 51. f Memoires, p. 51. ] Idem, p. 54.
2 GO
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Biliar. [No. 3,
which I quote from my catalogue. [XV.] Statue of Buddha, in black basalt,
five feet three inches high, seated on a throne, divided into two portions.
The upper consists of a double row of lotus leaves, and the lower is divided
into five compartments — containing representations of devotees at either
corner — then two lions-couehant and, in the centre, the Wheel of the Law
supported by a deer on either side. The figure is seated in the attitude of
meditation. The head is surrounded by an elaborate halo, above which rises
a three branched pipal tree ; on either side of the head is a seated Buddha,
and on either side of the body, two attendants each two feet high, and most
elaborately dressed. The one to the right has a diminutive Buddha, seated
in the hair, which is twisted into a point. These figures are very richly
ornamented with a spangled “ dhi'itf,” and highly wrought bangles and
necklace. The usual flower garland surrounds the body, and a lotus is
grasped in the left hand.” A little further to the east, I came on another
large heap of Buddhist carvings — door lintels, cliaityas, etc., and the pieces of
an enormous Buddha as large as the Telia Bhandar at Nalanda, or the Sri
Bullum Buddha at Titrawan. About half a mile to the south-west is
another village — Kalyanpur. There I also found ruins of more Buddhist
buildings, and a number of idols. The principal of these was that of a god-
dess, five feet high and seated on a throne, almost exactly similar to that
just now described. The figure is eight-handed and the breasts are mutilat-
ed. The waist is encircled by an elaborately sculptured girdle, from the
centre of which a chain and jewel depends over the pedestal. A star pat-
terned garment descends from the waist as far as the ankles of both feet.
The left foot depends from the throne, and rests on a lotus blossom, sup-
ported by the head -and arms of an attendant, while a second devotee holds
a flower in his hand a short distance off. An elaborate ornament encircles
the neck and the lower part of the arms. The hair is gathered up in a
chignon on the top of the head, but ultimately falls in ringlets over the
shoulders. Several of the hands are mutilated. The upper hand on the
right side grasps a circular shield, and the wrist is decorated by two bangles.
The second wrist is encircled by a ‘ batisi.’ The third hand (having three
bangles on the wrist) grasps a bow and the fourth a shell. The lower hand
on the right side rests on the right knee ; the next holds a sword, and has
one bangle on the wrist. The third is ornamented with the batisi, and
the fourth, having two bangles or armlets on the wrist, is in the act of draw-
ing an arrow from the quiver. On either side of the heads are two attend-
ants holding scrolls or garlands. Around the large figure were strewn
innumerable fragments of Buddhas of all sizes. Three miles to the south-
east of Kalyanpur, one arrives at the foot of the Indra-Saila hill, which rises
from the bank of the Panchana river, just above the village of Giryak.
Here again there is little difficulty in following the steps of Hwen Thsang,
2G1
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
and I cannot do better than quote his own words.* “ A Test du stoupa du
paripoutra il fit environ trente li et arriva a une montagne appeltie Indra-
fila-gouha. Les cavernes et les vallees de cette montagne sont tenebreuses :
des hois fieuris la couvrent d’ une riche vegetation. Sur le passage superieur
de cette montagne s’elevent deux pics isoles. Dans une caverne du pic meri-
dional il y a une grande maison taillee dans le roc : celle est large et basse.
Sur le pic oriental il y a un couvent. Devant le couvent il y a un
stoupa qu’ on appelle Hansa-sangharama.”
VI. — The Indra Saila Peak.
The range of rocky hills, which run in a north-easterly direction nearly
forty miles, abruptly ends at Giryak. The foot of the mountain is washed
by the waters of the Panchana river, which here leaves the Hisua-Nowada
valley, and slowly makes its way southwards through the Bihar plain to the
Ganges. On the east side of the river is an enormous mass of ruins, which
appears to mark the site of a Muhammadan town and fort, which tradition
holds to have been built by K&mdar Khan Main nearly two centuries ago, to
defend the fertile fields of Bihar from the frequent iucursions of the preda-
tory Rajwars. Above the western bank rise the two precipitous peaks
which crown the Indra-Saila hill. The reader will remember that in speak-
ing of Rajgir I described a narrow ravine which stretched away to the
east between Udayagir on the south, and Iiatnagir and the Devaghat hill
on the north. This valley terminates at Giryak, about a mile to the
south-west of the Indra Saila peak. From the northern side of this moun-
tain, a rocky hill — the Masellia-pahar, (as the Rajwars call it) — runs to the
south-west, having almost a semi-circular shape. This hill meets the off-
shoot of Udayagir, from which it is only separated by a passage, far narrower
than that of the Banganga. The face of the Masellia-pahar near the pass is
almost a sheer cliff, but towards the centre of the hill the ascent is more
gradual, and it was therefore fortified by a wall sixteen feet thick, which
follows closely the shape of the mountain. The eastern entrance to the
Valley of the Five Hills seems, therefore, to have been quite as strongly forti-
fied, both by art and nature as the Banganga and Raj agriha gates. It is
about three hundred feet from the plain, and just above the entrance of the
ravine that the Gidda-dwar cave is situated. Seen from below, it looks like
a small hole in the rock. Its entrance is gained with difficulty, for the last
eight feet of the cliff are perpendicular, and have been faced by a stone wall,
the remains of which are tolerably entire. This combination of the natural
and the artificial reminds one forcibly of the front of the Sattapanni cave on
the Baibhar hill. The entrance to the cavern is sixteen or seventeen feet wide,
and its roof semi-circular in shape. There is an outer chamber forty feet long,
from which a fissure in the rock appears to load to the interior of the hill,
* Idem, pp. 54-5.
262 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
but abruptly terminates at a distance of sixty or seventy feet from the en-
trance. This shows the tradition which makes the fissure in question a
subterranean passage leading to a tower on the Indra-Saila hill to be perfect-
ly erroneous. The atmosphere in the cave is most oppressive and, in addi-
tion to its being the home of a motley tribe of vultures and kites, a
sulphureous smell proceeds from the rock which has a sickening effect on the
explorer. Crossing the mountain in a north-easterly direction and passing
over the wall [popularly called4 Jarasandha’s baud’], one comes quite suddenly
on the eastern peak of the Indra-Saila mountain. This is crowned with a
stone platform, about twenty-five feet high, one hundred and fifty long
and one hundred broad, which appears to have been the site of a large
vihara and the usual temple. The wall of the vihara towards the east
is still tolerably entire, and was originally composed of enormous bricks
similar to those found at Nalanda and Rajagriha. Besides this wall,
the remains of the temple towards the western end can clearly be traced,
and several granite pillars in the vestibule are still erect. The whole of these
ruins should be carefully excavated at the expense of Government, for the
vihara in question was one of great importance and antiquity. I shall
afterwards have occasion to refer to the monastery again, when I come to
speak of it in relation to Hwen Thsang’s visit to the Indra-Saila hill. From
the eastern door of the vihara a broad stone staircase or roadway leads to
the eastern peak, which is crowned by a brick tower, sixty-five feet in cir-
cumference and about twenty-five feet high. This edifice is generally de-
scribed as the baithak, or resting-place, of Jarasandlia, and the Asura prince
is stated in popular tradition to have been accustomed to sit on this throne
of brick while he bathed his feet in the Panchana torrent a thousand feet below.
The length of the staircase connecting the two peaks is four hundred feet.
The eastern peak is called by the country people Mamubhagna, or Phulwaria
paha r — the western, Hawfdia-Pahar. This brick tower rests on a square
platform, now a mass of ruins, and there appears to have been a vault or well
in the centre. I have not the slightest doubt that the so-called tower is in
reality the remains of a stupa, the outer portions of which have been ruined
and removed by time. A deep inscision has been made in the base, but I
believe nothing was found there except a packet of Buddhist seals in wax.
To the south-west of the stupa are the remains of an artificial tank or
reservoir, about one hundred feet square. This is popularly supposed to have
been Jarasandha’s flower-garden. From the ruins which crown the summit
of the hill, a stone staircase or road leads to the plains beneath. This first
stretches down the south side of the hill to a distance of three hundred
feet, when one suddenly comes on a small stone stupa ; it then turns to the
east, and after traversing a distance of sixteen hundred feet, I arrived at a
spot where there are the ruins of a stupa on either side of the path. Just
263
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
at this place there is a sort of plateau, which is crowned by the remains
of a perfect cluster of topes. The path then continues to traverse the east
side of the hill (passing two small modern temples containing footprints or
charanas of Vishnu), and at a distance of eight hundred feet reaches the
hanks of the Panchana.
Dr. Buchanan visited Giryak nearly half a century ago, and a glance at
his remarks will show the devastation which an Indian climate can bring
about in a comparatively short time.*
“ I now proceed to describe the ruins on Girebraja or Giriyak hill. The
original ascent to this is from the north-east, and from the bottom to the
summit may be traced the remains of a, road about twelve feet wide, which
has been paved with large masses of stone cut from the hill, and winds in
various directions to procure an ascent of moderate declivity. When entire
a palanquin might have perhaps been taken up and down ; but the road
would have been dangerous for horses and impracticable for carriages. In
many places it has now been entirely swept away. I followed its windings
along the north side of the hill, until I reached the ridge opposite to a small
tank excavated on two sides from the rock and built on the other two with
the fragments that have been cut. The ridge here is very narrow, extends
east and west, and rises gently from the tank towards both ends, but most
towards the west, and a paved causeway five hundred feet long and forty
wide, extends its whole length. At the west end of this causeway is a very
steep slope of brick, twenty feet high and one hundred and seven feet wide.
I ascended this, by what appeared to have been a stair, as I thought that I
could perceive a resemblance to the remains of two or three of the steps.
Above this ascent is a large platform surrounded by a ledge, and this has pro-
bably been an open area, one hundred and eighty-six feet from east to west by
one hundred and fourteen feet from north to south, and surrounded by parapet
wall. At its west end, I think, I can trace a temple in the usual form of a
mandir.or shrine, and natmandir, or porch. The latter has been twenty-six feet
deep by forty-eight wide. The foundation of the north-cast corner is still
entire, and consists of bricks about eighteen inches long, nine wine, and two
thick, and cut smooth by the chisel, so that the masonry has been neat. The
bricks are laid in clay mortar. Eight of the pillars that supported the roof
of this porch project from among the ruins. They are of granite which
must have been brought from a distance. They are nearly of the same rude
order with those in the temple of Buddha Sen at Kanyadol and nearly of the
same size having been about ten feet long, but their shafts are in fact hexa-
gons, the two angles only on one side ot the quadrangle having been trun-
cated. The more ornamented side has probably been placed towards the
centre of the building, while the plain side has faced the wall. The mandir
* Montgomery Martin’s * Gya and Shahabad.’
2(3i
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
has probably been solid like those of the Buddhists, no sort of cavity being
perceptible, and it seems to have been a cone placed on a quadrangular base,
forty-five feet square and as high as the natmandir. The cone is very much
reduced, and even the base has been decayed into a mere heap of bricks.
On its south side in the area by which it is surrounded, has been a small
quadrangular building, the roof of which has been supported by pillars of
granite, three of which remain. Beyond the mandir to the west is a semi-
circular terrace which appears to have been artificially sloped away, very
steep towards the sides and to have been about fifty-one feet in diameter.
The cutting down the sides of this terrace seems to have left a small plain at
its bottom, and an excavation has been made in this, in order probably to
procure materials.
“ Returning now to the small tank and proceeding east along the cause-
way, it brings us to a semi-circular platform about thirty feet in radius, on
which is another conical building quite ruined. East from thence and adja-
cent is an area forty-five feet square, the centre of which is occupied by a
low square pedestal twenty-five feet square divided on the sides by compart-
ments like the pannelling on wainscot, and terminating in a neat cornice.
On this pedestal, rises a solid column of brick sixty-eight feet in circumfer-
ence. About thirty feet up, this column has been surrounded by various
mouldings, not ungraceful, which have occupied about fifteen feet, beyond
which what remains of the column, perhaps ten feet, is quite plain. A deep
cavity has been made into the column probably in search of treasure, and this
shows that the building is solid. It has been constructed of bricks cemented by
clay, and the outside has been smoothed with a chisel and not plastered. Part
of the original smooth surface remains entire, especially on the east side.
The weather on the west side has produced much injury. To the east of the
area in which this pillar stands, is a kind of small level, called the flower-
garden of Jarasandha, an idea perfectly ridiculous, the extent being misera-
ble, and the whole a barren arid rock.”
This description of the ruins of the so-called tower, written when it was
far less dilapidated than it is at present, confirms me in my opinion that the
original building was a stupa.
The ruins on the Giryak hill are undoubtedly identical with the reli-
gious edifices visited and described by Hwen Thsang. The subject is at
once so important, and so interesting, that I quote from him in full.
“ Apres avoir fait encore trente li a Test, il arriva a la montagne appelee
In-to’-lo-chi-lo-kiu-ho-chan (Indra-cila-gouha).
“ Devant le couvent du pic oriental de la montagne, il y a un stoupa. Ce
couvent s’appelle Seng-so-kia-lan (Hansa Sangliarama). Jadis les religieux
de ce couvent suivaient la doctrine du petit Vehicule, appelee la doctrine
graduello, et faisaient usage des trois aliments purs. Un jour, le Bhikchou,
265
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
qui etait 1’econome du convent n’ayant pu se procurer les provisions neces-
saires, se trouva dans la plus grande perplexity. II vit en un moment une
troupe d’oies qui volaient dans les airs. Les ayant regardees un instant, il
s’ecria en riant :
“ Aujourd’hui, la pitance des religieux manque completement ; mahd-
sattvas (nobles etres), il faut que vous ayez egard aux circonstances.”*
“ A peine avait-il acheve ces mots, que lo chef de la troupe tomba du haut
des nuages, comme si on lui eut coupe les ailes, et vint rouler au pied du
Bhikehou (de rdconome). Celui-ci rempli de confusion et de crainte, en in-
forma ses confreres, qui ne purent lui repondro qu’en versant dos larmes et
en poussant des sanglots : Get oiseau, dirent-ils entre eux, etait un Bodhi-
sattva ! et nous, comment oserions-nous le manger? Quand Jou-lai (le
Tathagata) a etahli ses preceptes, il a voulu par degres nous detourner du
mal. Mais nous, nous nous sommes attaches a ses premieres paroles, qui
n’avaient d’autre but que de nous attirer d’abord a lui, et nous les avons
prises pour une doctrine definitive. Insenses que nous sommes ! nous
n ’avons pas ose changer de conduite, et par 14, nous avons cause la mort de
cet oiseau. Dorenavant, il faut suivre le grand Vehieule, et ne plus man-
ger uniquement des trois aliments purs.
“ Alors ils fireut construire une tour sacree, y deposerent le corps de l’oie
(haiisa), et Fomerent d’une inscription, pour trausmettre a la posterity le
souvenir de son pieux devouement. Telle fut l’origine de cette tour.”
In the “ Memoires sur les Controes Oeeidentales,” the account varies
but little from that which I have quoted from the older volume. The writer
here tells us that the pilgrim went 30 lis from the stupa of Sariputra (i. e.,
from Chandimau), and arrived at the Indra-saila hill. The valleys and caves
of the hill were gloomy, but its sides were covered with luxuriant vegetation.
The summit of the mountain was crowned by two peaks, and in the western
one was a great chamber hewn in the rock. This answers with tolerable ac-
curacy to the position of the Gidda-dwar cave. He then proceeds to tell the
same story of the miraculous forty-two questions which Fall Hiyan relates
of the “ isolated rock” of Bihar.
In my opinion General Cunningham’s supposition that both hills are
the same, is based on insufficient data, especially as one is called
in Chinese Siao-kou-shy-shan ( i . e., the Bihar rock) and the other Yn-
tko-lo-shi-lo-kin-ho, (i. e., the Giryak liill),t which certainly seem to
be far from one and the same thing. Putting aside all question as
to position or language, I maintain that a glance at a description of
the two hills will shew them to be entirely different. “ Siao-Tcaushy-shan ” is
distinctly stated to be the little mountain of the solitary rock while Yn-
* Vie do Hwcn Thsang, p. 161-3.
f Laidley’s Fa Hiyan, p. 265.
J do. do., p. 264.
34
266 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihar. [No. 3,
tho-lo-shi-lo-lcin-ho (otherwise rendered, In-t'o-lo-cM-lo-lnin-ho-chan) is spoken
of as a lofty mountain with “ cavernes et vallees te'nehreuses.”* In the one there
is no cave — in the other there is.
I shall speak further on this subject, when I come to discuss the identi-
fication of Bihar, and hope to adduce such arguments as will put the matter
beyond the possibility of doubt.
However this maybe, it is quite certain that the great vihara of the Wild
Goose was one of the most sacred, andmost popular of the Buddhist mountain-
monasteries. I find it distinctly mentioned in the inscription of the Ghosra-
wan Vihara, which dates from about the 9th century of our era. From it we
learn that the pious Yiradeva, after the completion of numerous acts of reli-
gious merit, “ erected two crest-jewels in the shape of chaityas on the crown
of Indra-saila peak, for the good of the world.”
We must now wend our way towards the convents of the north-east of
Bihar.
VII. — The Monasteries of Ghosra'wan and Titra'wan.
The village of Ghosrawan lies exactly six miles to the north-east of the
Indra-saila peak at Giryak, eight miles to the cast of the great Nalanda
monastery, seven miles south-east of the “ isolated rock” of Bihar, and ten
miles north-east of the ruins of Baj agriha. Although the Buddhist remains
found at this place are of great interest, and the inscription, which lay
amongst the debris of its once magnificent vihara, is of more than ordinary
importance, the name of Ghosrawan does not appear either in the pages
of Buchanan or in those of the ‘ Ancient Geography of India.’ The modern
village is inhabited almost entirely by men of the Bhaban caste, who dis-
tinguished themselves by a small mutiny on their own account during the
horrors of 1857, which ended in the total destruction of the village by
fire, and the exile of a great portion of the insurgents. Although many
years have since passed away, and the poppy and rice lands which surround it,
arc as luxuriant and fertile as evor, Ghosrawan has never recovered its pros-
perity, and roofless tenements and blackened ruins still tell the story of this
“ seven-days war.” The Bhabans, which form such an important component
of Bihar society, take their origin, according to tradition, from the days of
Jarasandha’s rule in Rajagriha, and are, down to the present time, as turbu-
lent and litigious as history represents them to have been in former years.
The character of the caste has been severely handled by the national
proverbs of the Bihiiris ;f and I cite two of them below, for they are interest-
* Vie de Ilwen Tlisang, p. 161.
1" oli lyj'W Gf
Bhabans, dogs, and elephants are always fighting amongst themselves.
Even if a Bhaban swear in the midst of the Ganges stream on the sacred idol, his son’s
head, and the Shdstras, he can in no way be trusted .
2G7
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
ing, as speaking of the men who now cultivate the fields, which once, I doubt
not, yielded the necessaries of life to the recluses of the vihara of Vira-
deva, described a thousand years ago, as being “ as lofty as the mind of
its founder, and which the travellers in aerial cars mistake for the peak of
Ivailasa or the Mandara hill.” Six hundred feet to the south-east of the
village, there are the remains of four temples or topes, but time has reduced
them to nearly a level with the surrounding plain.
On a line with these tumuli is a mud fort with a tower at either corner,
which measures seventy feet from east to west, and eighty from north to
south. In the middle of the village, about two hundred feet to the north
of the fort, is a row of very fine idols commonly designated as the Singha-
bani Than. All the figures (with one exception) are purely Buddhistic. In
the centre of thorn is an idol of Durga, carved in black basalt. It is four
feet high and three wide, and is more modern than the Buddhist figures
which surround it, and very inferior to them in design and execution. The
goddess is represented as seated on an enormous lion, whose mane curiously
reminds one of the wigs in use by our Judges at home, when they go in state
to Westminster-hall on the first day of Term. The right foot is drawn
up in front of the body, while the left rests on a lotus flower. The figure
is eight-armed, and each arm grasps the usual emblems. To the left of this is
a veiy beautiful statue of Buddha, four feet high. The figure is seated in the
attitude of meditation on a cushion covered with elaborate ornamentation,
which rests on a throne supported at either comer by a lion-couchant.
Prom the centre of the throne depends a cloth, the folds of which are in-
scribed with the Buddhist creed, and covered by the representation of a
female goddess in the act of trampling upon an adversary, under the shade
of an umbrella, held by an attendant from behind. On either sido of the
cloth, a figure (one male and the other female) is seen in the act of making
an offering. The main figure is covered by a long cloak, and the hair is
knotted. A halo surrounds the head. There is a cushion at the back of
the throne. Above the head is a “ chaitya” surmounted by a pipal tree.
Around the main figure are eight smaller ones, seated in different positions
on small thrones, six of these holding lotus flowers of different design ; in
one case a bud, in another a cluster, in a third a full blown flower, and so
forth. The seventh grasps a sword, and the eighth a sword in one hand
and an unfurled banner in the other. At the bottom of the figure, that is
under the lions which support the throne, is a double row of lotus leaves, this
being the very converse of the ordinary arrangement. The details of this
figure are very curious, and I have never seen them in any other. At the side
of it is a standing one of Buddha about four feet high. The body is covered
by a long cloak and the hair is knotted, to the right an attendant holds
an umbrella over the head, and to the left is a three-headed figure holding a
bell in one hand and a torch in the other.
2G8
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
To the right of the Hindu idol is a figure of Buddha under a pillared
canopy. The next to the right is a figure of Buddha, four and a half feet high,
which resembles in almost every particular a still finer idol which I excavated
from the ruins of the Vihira. This latter being now in my own collection, I
refrain from any detailed description in the present case, but I may mention
that the main figure is surrounded by five smaller ones, the first being seated
in the hair and the others to the right and left of head and hands respect-
ively.
Five hundred feet west of the Singhabani, one arrives at the ruins of the
viliara and temple. The former now consists of a mound, having a circum-
ference of some 200 feet, and the latter of an oblong mass of bricks and rub-
bish, measuring 120 feet by 70 and about 15 or 20 feet above the level of
the surrounding country. The mound is strewn with broken Buddhistic idols,
and to the east of it was found a fine piece of black basalt one foot nine
inches long, by one foot three inches broad, and covered by a very perfect
inscription ol nineteen lines. I have had the good fortune to secure a
reading and translation of this, both by Babu RajondralSla Mitra and Pro-
fessor Rtunkrishna Gopal Bhandarkar, M. A., which I now give in original,
and for which I beg to express my thanks.
I. — The Ghosrawan Inscription. Transcript by Ba'bu' Ba'jendbaia'la
Mitba.
ii wwif:^ vgrixm towh" ttsp <st ^jt
% w i isiraiw-
S sj WUtJWUT % ^TTrTT riHnNxfSJSpTOrigUriTtTTVr l|
ST—
j c\ c\ c\
a gnlsr: i ^ fs-siTfrr^rXwTf^sT^TiWsj^nsTT^i^Ba cf<T ttst
qWu II xmireRT uirripz—
<\ J ^ ^
a. f%WjT XJlir VXT5I WT I qferaff^^r qKSTT^sn-
^ srasTHT ^ttht xrar: ii Trogmsn—
'VST »5fT: TJnTCr WWl % W | sj-TTqXJrJt-
XPUTTlfq 72% f¥r?fi: ^JtrfJTfflSTBWjif-
■° cT ii ?g;isrut?q q^^rrsr errmraf5?5*! %tw^>fsr^^q7TRi smr¥?T-
T I 9TST SJ guswagrui (jjjf) 5tUTfSm'bWSTJIR[
c ii f^T^wqTTwjft'srqwfV-
2G9
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
<t 5^T ^firaT^rfq- II 55tos8TTrqiftTHqT-
jrafhr i st rr^uufr^fwfw^'Jr
\° fcr?rr n ^nrt ufhqffigK: f^^r^wqvnfVq<?r*r-
tot i siaw sfhf^T^-qqfT?rrif: qua^rKW—
H TOT STOTT T^T*? II fimrTiTJTOTO: T? ^Siwfwi JTT^T-
J
qfrqTwpqrq fsnirr: *jffemT t: fsr<n i tj-*-
Is? Hf^vr^TTfra' ^Fq^rerehlt st^to: ^^Tsi'wsjrfq^l n
' si ^ ^ Sj
'stt^i^t ^ qfcqTf-rirrh? qajr aft«—
f^TTT^fTTTTfqwfqrrrTjT i ^Tfqwrfq v-
wrsisw qqrvr: i fqwnaqr —
<J
V.8 «T SSJT Til^^rrfq fr^TO ^rf: gnpn I ^^qfgrrmqfTq^fl^K^-
^ -N ' ®S
ft qprarT^fJSJfr^T II rf^rj^r—
I'i. ^ eroniijTflWFii^^revrej wqvf wqTffiTnjr i *j»nw ^aTw^tvs
fq^TJuiT^rf qr^mfl^TWTt^rjsu'^T ii *t4—
^ T§fiq»rT*r ^s^TmrTTsfowrcraT *r^rrer fqfr?iTrt TT’pnNiTrfsr-
r ^ d J
tW fr*ir i f*f anftrgn qvgrfsrorrT
V3 ttrt #-5i stfs<n ii %TqT5raTJrftro
^f^qTRJ SfitfflWrlt f*T3 T^qrTmgjTfT I
*,K snqrf^Tr: Tifqrjfi JT*sUJinn7 ^i^ifttifg- ^fTTfaKsiq qq n ^T^^r-
^fsrq^t wrTNT^f ftwfw E^rascjjrt
°s
qqm <Tq%r qiqqanKfj#: i f^pvn%qris fsifii^^^T ^rq-
=rnqnfiatfTi3T^rf qtq^alJJ SQ^T II
Translation’.
“ From Success to the auspicious sage Munindra ( = Buddha) whose
mind, bent on the welfare of mankind, lias mastered the principles of morality,
who is the only bridge for the oppressed to cross the ocean of worldly
trouble, infested by the frightful crocodile of sin. Women, who are our
sovereigns, cannot, even when they are all united together, reduce his mind :
what disgrace is there then, if unaided, I am powerless to overcome the Lord
of the Three Regions ? So thought the mind-born Cupid and flew away to a
distance from him. May that auspicious Yajrasana preserve the illimitable
universe in the path of Buddhism ! There exists an excellent country — the
ornament of the regions of the north, and renowned as Nagarahara. There
lived a courtier by name Indragupta, twice born by race [Dvija] and de-
scended from a very noble family. Spotless like Indra, he flourished, with
his accomplished Rani, the mistress of his household, whoso name is reckoned
the first, when people recount the virtues of faithful wives.
270 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 9,
“ A son was born unto them, who from his birth thought of the future
world and who was necessarily dispassionate. He was dissatisfied with
all the pleasures of homo, and longed to attain the ordinance of Sugata by
retirement.
“ Having studied all the Vedas and reflected on the purport of the
Sastras, he repaired to the great monastery of Kanishka,* and acquiring
there a knowledge of the dispensation of the all-knowing (Sarvajna —Buddha),
the theme of praise of all intelligent people, he performed a penance. This
person of spotless merit and manifold virtues, distinguished by all the
qualities of a worthy disciple, resplendently free from the stains of this Kali
age, even as a young man, the lauded of all sages was Vibadeva.
“ Wishing on one occasion to offer his adoration to the adamantine throne
(vajrasaua) of the great auspicious Bodhi he came to this place, f and sub-
sequently, with a view to cultivate the acquaintance of the Bhikshus of tho
country, repaired to the Vasanauvana vihara.
“ Abiding there for a long time, that person ( Viradeva) who had made
knowledge his only object, obtained the respect of the king of the country,
Devapa'i,a,J and flourished with daily increasing lustre, even as the sun,
(Puslian) the dispeller of widespread gloom.
“ He was as the soul of Bhikshus, beneficent even as one’s own hand
and the elect of Satyabodhi, he lived to promote the prosperity of Ndlandd
and the stability of the congregation (sangha). His virtues have made re-
splendent the crown jewel of chaityas on the crest of the Indra-saila hill,
which promotes the welfare of creation by the dispensation of virtue, although
addressed as the husband of many.
“ Favoured for his meritorious deeds by the faithful and well-pro-
tected lady Nalanda, whose person ivas embellished with richly endowed
vihdras, he was nevertheless praised as the pure and meritorious by all
men.
“ He, who curing by his look alone persons overwhelmed with the
fever of destruction, cast into shade even the glory of Dhanwantari ; he whom
men, having obtained all the objects of then- longing, looked upon as the all-
granting Tree of Desire (Kalpa-taru), even he caused this noble building (to
be erected), lofty as his mind, for the greatest object on earth, the adamantine
throne of Buddha ; (vajrasana) a building which, when beheld by the travel-
lers of the sky, leads to the impression of its being a peak of either Kaildsa
on the Mumlara hill.
“ By him who had given away everything he had, and thereby became the
most munificent among those who do good to mankind ; who was the most
* Seo Cunningham’s ‘ Anoient Geography,’ p. 99. + Ghosrawan.
J See Babu BijendraWla Mitra’s note on the Nalanda inscription in my account
of those ruins, published by the Government of Bengal.
271
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihar.
ardent in the knowledge of Buddha, most emulous in acquiring high merit,
who was fearless alike amongst his own people and strangers in this ever-pro-
gressing virtuous region , has raised this flag of renown in honour of his
maternal and paternal races in the northern regions.
“ Whatever fruits may proceed from this act, which may he likened to a
flight of steps to the mansion of liberation, may the same he conducive to
the attainment of the divine knowledge of Buddha by mankind at large,
foremost by his parents and ancestors !
“ As long as the tortoise supports the ocean-girt receptacle of matter, as
long as the darkness-dispelling sun sheds his fiery rays, as long as the mild
luminary continues to sooth mankind and the night, so long may this bright
act of Viradeva prosper in this world !”
Babu iUjendralala Mitra remarks, that the date of the dedication is not
given, but looking to the character, the well known Kutila, and the allusion of
Deva Pala of the Pala dynasty of Bengal, the inscription probably belongs to
the beginning of the 9th century. The dedicator was a recluse from the north-
west frontier and bore the name of Viradeva. His native town was Nagarahara,
once a famous seat of Buddhism, but now in ruins. His father, Indragupta, is
described as a friend of the king (Rajasakha), that is, as I take it, a courtier ;
but he must have held high rank in court, as his wife is styled a Rani, or
Queen. Viradeva was of a religious turn of mind, and in early manhood
retired from the busy world, to acquire a knowledge of the Buddhist faith in
the Kanishka monastery, where he devoted a great portion of his life to
study and penance, and to following the practice of his order. He started
on Ms travels and came to theNalanda monastery in Bihar, and afterwards
dwelt for a time in the Vasanauvana vihara, where he got himself noticed
and respected by the king of the country, Deva Pala.
Where the monastery was situated I cannot ascertain. It was pro-
bably somewhere near Manikyala in the Paujfib or near his home.
II. — The Ohosrdwan Inscription. — Transcript hg Professor Ra'mkrisiina
Gopa'l Biiastdarka'r, of Bombay.
rf^Rr^TT^TWi: WK’JWWp
jtcstt: vBt i ^ rrai-
|| v[?]#[?]^r fspspfv: * ^ a ^
VVT5? I
^vrfir vw ii rn«int3fT a.
272 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
qw ^«rrf fqfqft qT wr^r qq qri%fP l ^Twn^wirfa
7TU faTW nqsqqT ^Jirrirrewflwq i
7j II qgjqqhq qqtsirq aTTJ'T^rq^: q^ifqqtv I (five
letters illegible) wqq uswmiqj qsq^rjnfwiqwJTRI «
CTranrc h inn fro^qrqiiravrfq^ifl: rs^^qji vr¥ft^q^Tf«TT3?: 1
qfsfqrqvfq flq^q: il q^arew ’qtqqr?iqTfqqqnrmsqT l
hu <mr$JjT<9,?^fwfVrg'5r qtqsqKrqw <£
J S\
nr* fwqir ii ffTwaw^ qfrrqfTtTjK-' qft^qqra*jq*iTfVq^rwrq^r: I
Vj VJ 5\
qw: qfqf^^T^qfVrnw qqq ^Tfcw \°
nu: WXT XXm || fvi^rrTftrqq: X? fq;mWTSt^Tqf<-
qi^STTq fsrqWi Bffiqq q: fqflP I qWdT q?i U
qtqfqqrsiqril qtoroqrTq?|q'«T ^sjltfi: qqTqq^frfqrfT II
qnra^qr 'q qfvqTfiawqq Biqi ’7t« ^
f%qiqqfqqrrfqqfqrn«;7qr i q^Tfqwrsfq qsqftfqqqqnrw q: qra Hiarrfrr
qraaja: STOW II f^IT^T qqqcmqsrq ^
ei fqjT a^aiffq fq qq qq: q«rq: | q%fqqTqqf*rq>nqqrc£iq %qrq
qtWfrqg’qqqT Jzqtrn il qqwq; \a
q a<T«T-Ufl^Tqa|q^iqvr«J qqq qqqTriqqj I qSTTqiT q^fqq^ fanirT-
jrrqf «fi^fqq*qqqqtqvszTq^T n u
^irqqqq qsi^f ^rqrqrq [?] wi^qr »m,ar fqfqq^qq qq JTvifqqjfq-
q^[?]wiqr i qsq#q fq^a fqanfqq qqrq'qifqqfTq \i
fqjm qq wq qfri^^vr qraar vqrijq’Ntqq il biqiqqTflfqq qfai-
qq[?]qj qrtfnqqi fqqrq qq;qrqqqirq [?] \<&
?r<qrf^;rr: qfqqv jrwqqj q-R?Tfa% srsrcimqqq qq n qrqqjw ojqtfq-
Vf rf-KITat f*Wfq \t=
rrqf<T rjqa'T aiat^Tq^faji: i f%pqr#rq>T: fafqqqqqT q-r«qyqq qi^m-q^-
aqa aV’Cq;q^i ?3^r 11 » <t n
Translation.
“ Victorious is the glorious lord of Munis who, by his mind, operating for
the good of all creatures, found out the system of truth and who is the
only bridge for crossing the ocean of worldly existences ; which [bridge]
the crocodiles of sms, producing affliction, cannot approach. May he, the
* The Kev. Dr. J. Wenger who kindly undertook the laborious task of correcting
the proofs of these inscriptions, remarks that the word Vasanauvana doos not occur in
the text. The word actually used is Jas'o va'fmap-ur, varma being the title of a dynasty
of kings. Vasanauvana may of course be a synonym. The inscription appears to
be metrical, but has not been printed as such. Strange to say, the Sanskrit is far
purer than is usually found in inscriptions of the Piila kings.
A. M. B.
273
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
glorious being, seated on the seat of adamant (vajrasana) under the Bodhi
tree, protect the whole universe, — he, whom the fancy-born (god of love)
shunned from a distance, as if reflecting that there was no shame in it, if he
single-handed were powerless to attract the mind of the lord of the three
worlds, when his superiors who had gathered together, proved unable to do
so. There is a country known as Nagarahara, the land of which is the
ornament of Uttarapatha (Northern India). There was a Brahman there
of the name of Indragupta, the friend of the king, who was born in a family
that had risen high. The meritorious and excellent Brahman shone like
the moon with his spotless digits, — united to a wife, — |_one word ille-
gible] a wife of whom mention is first made by people in going over the
stories of faithful wives. From them was born a son who was exceedingly
.thoughtful, and whose mind even in childhood was filled with thoughts of
the next world, and even in his house, rich in all the means of enjoyment,
he remained unconcerned [took to no pleasure], in order, by the renunciation
of the world, to adopt the system of Sugata. Having studied all the
vedas and reflected on the shfistras, he went to the vihara of Kanishka,
and following him who was praiseworthy on account of his severity, and
who was all-knowing and free from passions [two or three words illegible],
he practised penance. The pupil of one who, by his pure virtues, had
obtained great fame, he, Viradeva — graceful by the possession of befitting
virtues, character and fame, and with a lustre free from the stains of Kali,
was like the new moon, an object of adoration even to the munis. He once
came to the great Bodhi to pay his respects to the vajrasana (adamantine
seat), and thence went to see the mendicant priests of his country to the
Yasovarmmapura Vihara. While staying here for a long time, respected
by all and patronized by the king Devapala, he, having obtained* splendour
[of knowledge or power], outfilling by his every-day rise all the quarters,
and dispelling darkness, shone like the sun. Appointed to protect (govern)
Nalanda, he, the friend of the Bhikshu, as if he were his arm, abided by
his true knowledge concerning the churchf (or congregation — sanghd), and
having already taken the vow of a S'ramana, erected, for the good of the
world, two crest-jewels in the shape of chaityas, on the crown (summit) of
Indra-saila. Though shining bright by means of NalandiiJ who having
been protected by him, had her body adorned with a splendid row of viharas,
he was praised by good people saying, “Well done, well done,” when he
became the husband of the wife Great Fame. Dispelling the fever of
* The three epithets here have a double meaning, one applicable to the sun and
the other to Viradeva.
t That it is of great importance to have a united church and to construct viharas
for congregational purposes.
$ Compared to a wife.
35
z
274 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3;
anxiety of afflicted persons by a mere look, he put to shame the might of
Dhanvantari* * * § and was regarded as equal to a Kalpa-taruf by people whose
desires he had fulfilled by granting to them all objects wished for. By
him was erected this house for tho best thing in the world, the adamantine
seat (vajrasana), as lofty as his own mind, which the movers in ©rial cars
mistake for a peak of Kailasa orMandara, when they look at it. With his
desires fixed on enlightenment (or true knowledge — sambodhi) and with
a heroism rivalling his other qualities, he, practising liberality to the friends
of all creatures by giving his all, and exercising his holy authority here,
hoisted the banner of his fame on the two poles of his familyj (family of
father and mother) in Uttarapatha. Since in the shape of his famous deeds
he erected a staircase to ascend the place of final emancipation and obtained
religious merit, may all people without exception, headed by his father and
all the elder ones, attain to real knowledge§ (sambodhi) ! May the bright
fame of Viradeva last in the world as long as the tortoise bears the earth begirt
with the seas, as long as the sun with his warm rays, the destroyer of dark-
ness, shines, and as long as the cool-beamed moon renders the nights bright !”
In the middle of the east wall of the vihara I found a very beautiful
figure three parts concealed in the ruins. It is now in my collection at
Bihar, and I extract the description of it from my catalogue : — “ No. XYI.
A magnificent alto-relievo figure in black basalt, eight feet high, probably of
Yajrasattva Buddha [Schlagintweit, p. 53]. The feet rest on a lotus
pedestal, and there is no throne underneath. The hair rises from the fore-
head, and is twisted into a pyramidieal cone which is nearly a foot in height.
In its midst a Buddha is seated in the state of contemplation. A jewelled
frontlet passes from behind the ear over the brow. The figure is four-armed,
and each wrist is ornamented with an elaborately wrought bangle or bracelet.
Other jewels adorn the feet, and the upper part of the arms, or rather the
root of the four arms, for the second pair appear only to spring from the
elbows. Above the head two winged figures support a jewelled crown with
three points. The upper hand on the left side grasps a lotus stalk springing
from tho ground, while the lower holds a large bell, the rim and clapper of
which are ornamented with a bead-work pattern. The palm of the hands
on the right side are turned outwards and exhibit the mark of sovereignty.
The upper one grasps a “ mala,” or rosary. A ribbon, or scarf, three inches
wide, passes over the left shoulder across tho body. A cloth covered with
a pattern of stars depends from a cord beneath the navel, and extends as
* Physician of the gods.
f A heavenly tree having the power of granting anything desired.
t The word • vans'a’ means ' race or family’ and ‘ a pole or lamboo,’ and is here
used in both the senses.
§ By means of his good deeds which serve as a staircase.
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. 275
far as the knee. A jewelled girdle, with a large buckle, encircles the waist.
There is a third eye in the centre of the forehead. On either side are
two grotesque attendants. The one to the right is extremely corpulent,
and is quite nude. It is in a kneeling position and grasps a lotus stalk,
the flower of which is seen behind the upper right hand. The one to the
left is clothed similarly to the main figure, and leans on a mace grasped in
the left hand. The Buddhist creed is inscribed in the background and the
donor’s name below.” On the north side of the vihSra I found another
very perfect figure. I describe it in my catalogue as follows : — “ No. IX. An
alto-relievo figure of Buddha in black basalt, three feet three inches high.
The figure is in the attitude of contemplation, and is clothed with a long
robe depending from the left shoulder, and reaching the ankle. It rests on
a lotus-leaf pedestal, supported by a lion-eouchant on either side, and in
the centre a female devotee is seen in the act of making an offering. The
hack of the throne is richly carved, and terminates in two points. It singu-
larly resembles a gothic chair. A halo surrounds the head which is sur-
mounted by a pipal tree. Above this is seen a couch on which Buddha lies
in the state of nirvana. The right hand is placed under the head which is
supported by a pillow, and the left is parallel with the side. At either end
of the couch is a kneeling devotee. Above the body, rises a “ chaitya,” and
on either side of this are musical instruments. To the right of the main-
figure is one of Mayadevi (the mother of Buddha), grasping with one hand a
tree and resting on the other arm. Above this, is a figure of Buddha stand-
ing in the attitude of instruction. At the right side is a small elephant, and
above this a seated Buddha in the attitude of instruction, a devotee kneel-
ing at his feet. On the left side of the main figure, is a seated figure of
Buddha with the ‘ fasting bowl’ in his lap ; above this, a standing figure of
Buddha ; and at the top a seated figure corresponding with that on the other
side, except that the “ Wheel of the Law” which is supported by a deer on
either side, takes the place of the kneeling devotee.”
One thousand three hundred and fifty feet to the south of the vihara
of Viradeva are the remains of another temple of considerable size. I dis-
covered there a standing figure of Buddha six feet high, resembling in every
particular the one described at the Singhabfini, except that there are
no attendants, and a “ chaitya” on each side of the head. A short distance
to the south-west of the great temple is an image ot Durga, now worship-
ped as Mahisasurmardani. To the north-west is a temple containing a simi-
lar idol, now adored under the name of Asaji. To the west of the village
lies a large tank, the Set or Sao-talab, Two miles north of Ghosrawan
once flourished a great sister monastery, the vihara of Titrawan, which I shall
presently describe at length.
Four miles due east of the convent of Viradeva, and about nine miles from
27 G A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic -Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
Giryak, the traveller arrives at the sandy bed of a once mighty river, the Sakri.
On the opposite shore there rises a solitary hill — steeper, but less lofty, than
the isolated rock of BiMr. Three sides of it are precipitous cliffs, the fourth
a series of shelving rocks sloping away to the north. The summit is an even
plateau four or five hundred feet square, literally covered with the remains
of an enormous vihara, and of numerous stiipas and temples. Some of the
piles of brick are thirty or forty feet high, and I found the remains of Bud-
dhist idols in several parts of the hill. This rock is called Parahati, and a
flourishing village of the same name lies at its foot. One mile east, or perhaps
rather north-east of the “ solitary hill,” is situated the village of Aphsar.
Aphsar is singularly rich in Buddhistic remains, and on its outskirts there
is an enormous tumulus, seventy or eighty feet high. It appears to me to
be the remains of a large temple attached to a vihara. I visited Aphsar in
September, 1871, and recovered four or five figures from it. They all of them
merit detailed description. The most important of them is a colossal male figure,
[a statue, properly so called,] about eight feet high, and four-armed. The
head is surmounted by a richly jewelled crown, almost identical in shape
with the regal cap of Banna and Siam, from underneath which long
ringlets fall profusely over the shoulders. The sacred thread \_poita~\ is»
noticeable on the body, in addition to the usual ornaments. In my opinion,
the figure represents some prince or general — certainly not a Buddha, or any
Hindu deity.
Another remarkable figure is a large, and exquisitely carved linga,
hearing on either side a face life-sized. The style of carving is 'precisely that
of the other purely Buddhist idols, and it was found close to the tumulus,
near the site of the colossal boar for which Aphsar is famous, and strange to
say, close to the place where Major ICittoe discovered an Ayoka inscription
of great length and value, but which almost immediately afterwards was
lost. During my stay in Bihar, I made every effort to trace it, but without
success, although I received every aid from my friend, Babii Bimola Charan
Bhattacharjya, then Deputy Magistrate of Nowada. likbu Bimola Charan
has succeeded me at Bilnir, and devotes much time and care to the preserva-
tion of my large collection of Buddhistic sculptures. Owing to his zeal in the
matter (for which he deserves the thanks of all scientific men), there is now
every prospect of the Bihar Museum becomiug a permanent local institu-
tion, and he tells me that it has become a sort of place of pilgrimage for all
the country round ; in fact, the descendants of Afoka’s brahmans at Raj agriha
are beginning to look on it as a serious opposition, and to tremble lest it
should cause a diminution in their income. I take this opportunity of pub-
licly thanking my successor for all he has done in this matter. To return
to Aphsar. The Parabati rock, we must remember, is as nearly as possible thir-
teen miles south-east of Bihar, and the ruins I have just described, shew it to
277
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr.
have been a place, which, in Buddhist times, was second only in importance to
Nalanda, Rajagriha and Bihar.
Travelling between three and four miles from Aphsar in a north-westerly
direction, one arrives at the great mass of ruins which marks the site of the
Titrawan monastery. Like the neighbouring monastery of Ghosrawan,
Tit n't wan escaped the notice of Dr. Buchanan, and is barely mentioned
by General Cunningham in his ‘ Ancient Geography of India.’ A glance
at the accompanying rough sketch map will shew at once the extent of
these interesting remains, and will convince the archaeologist that they
will repay a visit. We may here again return for a moment to Hwen
Thsang. After leaving the Indra-saila peak, he is stated to have gone
one hundred and sixty lis to the north east to the monastery, known as Kia-
pou-te-kia-lan, ortho ‘ Kapotika [/. e., pigeon] vihara.’ Both General Cun-
ningham and M. Vivien de Saint Martin agree in thinking the reading in-
correct, and in substituting sixty for one hundred and sixty. This must of
necessity be done, as the distance given in the text would have brought the pil-
grim almost close to the bank of the Ganges. Sixty li would coincide ap-
proximately with the actual distance between Qiryak and Bihar, i. e., from
ten to twelve miles. Bihar is strictly speaking north-east of Giryak, and
the identification made by General Cunningham is undoubtedly correct. That
Hwen Thsang should have omitted to visit Bihar is extremely improba-
ble ; for wo know of its existence nine centuries before, and its ruins at
the present day vie in grandeur and extent with the remains of Raja-
griha and Nalanda. The vihara alluded to by Hwen Thsang appears to
have been situated at Soh-Sarai, a suburb of the city, distant less than a
mile from the northern extremity of the “ solitary hill.” At Soh-Sarai,
I found several figures as well as a series of pillars thirteen feet in height
[see Chapter VIII.]. I reserve, therefore, any further allusion to Bihar,
until I come to describe the city itself. After leaving Bihar, Hwen Thsang
proceeded to another monastery, forty li, or ten miles, to the south-east. The
vihara in question is described as standing on an isolated hill, and can be most
satisfactorily identified with Parabati. Yet General Cunningham considers
that the “ bearing and distance point to the great ruined mound of Titra-
wan,” although the ruins are situated in a plain, instead of on a hill, and
there is not the smallest elevation visible within a circuit of five miles. I
have no doubt that it was via Parabati and Aphsar, and not Titrawan, that
Hwen Thsang quitted the confines of the kingdom of Magadha.
Approaching Titrawan from Parabati, one arrives at the Digi Pokhar,
an enormous tank, running almost due north and south, measuring 2481
feet by 767. Four hundred and eighty -four feet from the south-east
corner of the tank is a large mass of ruins, measuring 650 feet by 400. To-
wards the southern side of this are the foundations of a large brick building
278 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. [No. 3,
exactly a hundred feet square and apparently once flanked with a tower at
either corner, like the smaller temple recently partly uncovered at Nalanda.
The modern village of Titrawan is to the east of these ruins. Four hundred
and forty-five feet to the south-east of the building above mentioned is a
small temple, around which were grouped upwards of two hundred purely
Buddhistic figures, many of them of exquisite beauty. I shall give a detail-
ed description of them further on. Two hundred and thirty-eight feet to
the south of the temple is another enormous tank, running due east and west
and measuring 11G0 feet by 780. The distance between the ruined vihara
and the side of the pond is 505 feet. The tank bears the name of the Sri
Bullum, or Bhairau-Pokhar. At a distance of 500 feet from the south-east
corner, and facing immediately the great mass of the ruins, there is a luxu-
riant pipal tree under the shade of which is a colossal Buddha. The figure
is placed in a brick platform, which has evidently been frequently repaired,
and is supported by a small brick tower, or buttress, built behind the idol.
In front a flight of steps descends to the shore of the lake. Tho image has
been broken in two and again set up. It rests on two thrones, the lower of
which is six feet six inches long, and is in three pieces joined together by
iron clamps. It is divided into five compartments. In the outer one on
either side there is a lion-couchant, and in the centre a lion-rampant. The
two remaining ones are filled by the figures of devotees in the act of making
an offering.
The throne is exactly one foot ten inches high. The second throne is
in one piece, and is one foot two inches high and six feet long. It consists
of a double row of fourteen lotus leaves ; — the Buddhist creed being inscrib-
ed on ten leaves of the upper one — a word in each. The letters of this in-
scription are about an inch long. The figure is in the attitude of meditation,
and the hair is knotted. The nose is very little damaged. I give its di-
mensions in detail.
Feet. Inches.
Top of the head to seat of upper throne, 7
Round the head at forehead, 4 7
Across shoulders, 3 10
Across forehead, 1 2
Top of head to chin, 2
Round the neck, 3 2
Across chest, 2 2
Shoulder to elbow, 2
Elbow to wrist, 1 po
Length of hand p
Rip to knee, 2 po
Knee to ankle,... g ^
Length of foot, i a
279
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bilidr.
The body is covered with a cloak. The figure is highly venerated and
has its pfijSris and rent-free assignment of land. It is worshipped under the
names of Sri Bullum and Bhairau. On the east side of the tower behind it
there are three niches ; the first containing a figure of Yishnu, the second
a miniature reproduction of Sri Bullum (except that three elephants take the
place of the lion-rampant in the central compartment of the throne), and the
third, a standing figure of Buddha with an elephant on one side and a Bodhi-
sattva on the other. Four hundred feet to the west of the pipal tree, the bank
of the tank runs to the north for a distance of some five hundred feet and then
again turns to the west. In the angle of this piece of land I found the traces of a
stiipa or tope, and a similar ruin is to be seen on the opposite side — exactly two
hundred feet from the northern bank. . The popular traditions of Titrawan are
very poor. Any knowledge or recollection of Buddhism has entirely passed away,
and the construction of the now ruined vihara is attributed to a demon king—
Ban Asar Raja, who is also said to have consecrated the image of Sri Bullum.
Titrawan must have heen a monastery of no ordinary importance, and its
position is even preferable to that of Bargaon. The countiy around it is well-
watered and consequently fertile, and groves of trees surround it on all sides.
From the towers of the monastery, the hills of Giryak, Bihar, and Parabati are
distinctly visible, and the banks of the Sri Bullum tank are still covered at all
times of the year with luxuriant verdure. This lake at sunset would even now
charm every lover of the picturesque, and the effect must have been still more
striking when thousands of recluses from the stately monastery which rose
on its bank, left, their meditations at evening time to adore and incense the
colossal Buddha which they had erected in its northern shore and dedicated
“ to the greatest of all purposes.” I counted in one day at Titrawan two
hundred figures of Buddha of all sizes and design ; most of them bore the
Buddhist creed in the characters of the 6th, 7th, 8th, and 9th centuries A. D.,
and they were nearly all mutilated. I rarely found a single figure which I
can confidently assert to bo purely Hindu. Several of the Titr&wau idols were
beautifully polished, and not a few of them bore inscriptions of interest.
Besides the ruins at the side of the tank there are the remains of a large
stiipa in the centre of the modern village, two hundred and eightyfeet from the
south-east corner of the vihara. The only Hindu figures I saw there were
these of Siva and Durga, commonly called Gauri Sankar.
I now proceed to describe the Buddhist figures recovered by me from
the Titrdwan monastery, and now in my collection. No. [GCCXL.] A small
figure one foot high, found in the mud at the banks of the Digi Pokhar. It
represents Buddha in the state of nirvana, reposing on a couch — one arm
being under the head and the other resting on his side. The couch is sup-
ported by fantastically carved pillars. There are three attendants below ;
one has his head buried in his arms ; the back of the second is turned to-
280 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
wards the spectator and he is apparently in the act of adoration, and the
other is in the act of supplication. At each side of the body is a tree, and
in the centre rises a circular stupa on a square base terminating in a series
of thirteen umbrellas. The Buddhist creed is inscribed on the face of the
bed. [CXXLI.] The alto-relievo figure of a goddess two feet three inches
high, not in any way mutilated — seated on a cushioned throne supported by
lions at either corner. A doth hangs down from the centre of the throne
and bears an inscription. The figure is four-armed. The body is covered
by a spangled garment which descends from a jewelled girdle below the na-
vel. The usual ornaments are seen on the arms and neck, and a medallion
is suspended by a chain from the latter. A scarf passes across the breast
and shoulders. The upper hands grasp sprigs or bunches of flowers, and the
lower hand to the left support a nude male infant on her knee. The op-
posite hand holds, what is apparently meant to represent, some sweetmeat
or a cocoanut. The hair is elaborately ornamented. I take it to be the
figure of Vasti, the goddess of fecundity, and I found an almost identical idol
in the Bihar fort. There is an inscription on the plinth, of which the
following is a reading —
?jrr \3[?]jirq»Tt Itrsrfvrci
vi A
[two letters] rr [?] ^ [two letters.]
“ In the village of Nentati by Gopatichandralca, the son of Sai Yishnu,
and mistress [or master, lord] of Pundra Sai Mahanika.*”
[CCCXLII.] Portion of a figure of Buddha, containing merely the
head — the surrounding halo [within which is inscribed the Buddhist creed],
and a small kneeling figure to the left, holding a scroll, over which is in-
scribed the word Sri Magulan. [CCCXLIII.] Elaborate pedestal of
a figure of Buddha in the attitude of meditation [broken off], A double
row of lotus leaves springing from a very beautifully sculptured stem, amongst
which are the figures of five devotees. The base is covered by a long in-
scription of two lines, but I almost despair of getting it deciphered, on ac-
count of its indistinctness. [CCCLX1V.] Alto-relievo figure, of Buddha
in black basalt, and polished to resemble marble, two feet eight inches high.
The body resembles precisely that of the great figure near the lake. The
throne is divided into three compartments — the outer ones containing lions-
rampant, and the middle one two devotees and a figure of Buddha in a state
of repose under a canopy. The background consists of pillars, and dragons-
rampant. The head is surrounded by an halo, which is surmounted by a
pipal tree and the Buddhist creed. There is a seated Buddha on either side
of the head. [CCCXLV.] An alto-relievo figure in hlack basalt, two
feet ten inches high, seated on a throne, along the face of which there is an
* All the characters are nearly obliterated.
281
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistie Remains of Bihar.
inscription. The face is nearly life size and the features hideous — the hair
has been drawn like the feathers of a peacock’s tail. A cobra’s head peeps over
the left shoulder. The earrings are circular, depressed in the centre and very
large. There are two necklaces round the neck and two long flower garlands.
A spangled cloth descends from the wrist to the ankles. The upper right
hand grasps a sword and the left a trident [trisul]. The objects in the lower
hands I cannot distinguish- — one being perhaps a gourd or pumpkin. The left
foot is drawn up underneath the body, and the right rests on a lotus blossom
below the seat of the throne. Babii Ram K. Bhandarkar reads the in-
scription : — [illegible] ^ [illegible] ^ [one letter]
“ A gift to the gods by Sai Jena — Sambat 892 — 5th day — (i. e., A. D.
837.)
[VII] A veiy beautiful and perfect figure of Buddha in black basalt,
three feet four inches high. The right hand rests on the knee, and the legs are
crossed — the left hand being parallel to the left foot, which is marked with
the sign of sovereignty. The body is supported by a cushion, and the hair is
ruffled. A very beautiful halo covered with geometrical pattern surrounds
the head, and above it rise three branches of the sacred pipal tree, each leaf
of which is carved with extraordinary minuteness. Beneath the figure, a
cloth depends from the throne, the sides of which gradually incline towards
each other — disclosing at each corner a well-executed figure of a lion in the
act of tearing to pieces the skull of a fallen elephant. There is an orna-
ment in the neck and left arm, but apparently no drapery at all. — [XII]
Figure of Buddha in black basalt, very well executed and identical with
that described in the “ Ruins of Nalanda Monastery,” p. 12, except that the
base consists of a group of devotees instead of the more common Hon throne. —
[LVIII.] Standing figure of Buddha, two feet six inches high. Plain back
ground, without the usual ornamented border. The dress, etc., as in No. IV.
The figure rests on a simple lotus leaf pedestal, and there is no throne at the
base. On the right side there is an elephant and to the left an attendant in
the same costume as the main figure and holding a mace in the right hand. —
[LXXVI] Curious alto-relievo carving, two feet eleven by two. At the base
are small lotus-leaf thrones. On the two principal ones are seated crowned
figures with a back ground of snake-lioods. Right and left of these principal
figures are seated Nagiis, with enormous tails turned upwards over their heads
and the heads of the larger figures, and finally fantastically twisted into a
knot between them. The portions of the stone above the figures, between
them and the tails of the Nagds, are covered with inscriptions. The peculiar-
ity of the position of the writing renders the taking an impression more than
ordinarily difficult, but it has been attempted both by Babu Rajendralala
Mitra and General Cunningham, and I hope soon to possess a transcript of
it. It appears to contain the word Mahipala, as on the gate of the temple of
36 a a
282
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
Baladitya at Nalandsi. — [CXXVI] Remarkably perfect figure of Buddha,
carved in the finest black basalt. There are no attendants, throne, &c.
The stone around the head is of oval shape with a border. The hair is
tufted, and the body is covered by a cloak which falls over the left shoulder.
The body rests on a cushion encircled by a carved border. The reverse of
the carving is almost covered with the drawing of an enormous votive
chaitya surmounted by a series of umbrellas. This I think is almost
unique and is undoubtedly worthy of notice. It may possibly be the repre-
sentation of a chaitya at Titrawan. — [CXXIY], Curious figured Buddha,
two feet four inches high — seated in European fashion on a throne, the
hair in tufts, as on the Indra-Saila peak, an attendant on either side of the
feet, and a seated Buddha at each side of the head. — [CLXII], A slab of
black basalt, two feet high, covered with a rude carving, intended to represent
Buddha in the state of nirv .na under the sacred Bodhitree. — [CCXXVIII].
A magnificent figure of Mayadevi in very fine black basalt, four feet three
inches high. Tire pedestal is composed of scroll work of the most elaborate
description. The hair is not turned up in a conical point as in the
other figures, but is dressed in an enormous chignon which falls to the
right. The busts are largo, and the figure leans gracefully to the left.
The various ornaments are of the most elaborate description. Five Bud-
dhas surround the head. On either side are richly dressed attendants armed,
and leaning in the same position as the main figure ; the one to the left has a
background of flames. The plinth is covered by an inscription, as follows ;
n? «n wj
fb<TTt$rr (about six letters illegible).
“ This is a gift to gods, by the pious devotee Bhatta Ichchha, the son of
Bhatta Naho. May the merit abiding in this, contribute to the welfare of
all beings with his father and mother at the head ! The second year of the
king Sri Ramapati Deva ; 28th day of Vaisakha.”
The characters in this inscription look comparatively modem.
No. IV. Fine standing figure of Buddha in black basalt, five feet
eight inches. The pedestal is divided into five compartments, and is de-
corated only by a simple moulding. A devotee is kneeling at the right
hand comer. The feet of the statue rest on a double row of lotus leaves.
The figure is draped in a long cloak reaching to the knees, and a second
garment beneath it extends to just above the ankles. On either side is
an attendant, the one to the left holding an umbrella, the other (a curious
three-faced figure) grasping a lighted torch in one hand, and a water-pot in
the other. On either side of the head there are small seated figures of Bud-
dha. Behind the figure, is a very exquisitely carved moulding resting on two
283
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
pillars which culminate in tulip-shaped capitals. There is a bead-like halo
round the head, and a similar border encircles the stone itself. This figure
came from the centre of the brick building, and always bore the name of the
Telia Dhobe (an evil spirit ?)
A mile to the west of the Dig! pond at Titrawan is another village —
scarcely less picturesquely situated — called Haragawan or Hargaon [Vihara-
gram ?]. Here there is a large mound at the west bend of a dried-up tank.
Several pieces of carving were lying about it, when I first visited it in Sep-
tember, and I commenced an excavation there. I uncovered a series of cells
running north and south, each being twelve feet long by four or five broad,
and the partition walls being of great thickness. In the first cell to the south,
I found a splendid figure of Buddha, and I hope one day to completely un-
cover the mound. The Buddha I allude to, is No. XXVI, in my museum. It
is carved in black basalt of a quality equal to marble. The body rests on a
pedestal of lotus flowers, beneath which is a throne divided into seven com-
partments. These are again sub-divided by a line in the centre. The lower
ones consist merely of brackets, mouldings, and cornices, and the upper ones
are filled with figures. At the right is a female devotee ; then a lion ; next
a grotesque figure (full face) supporting the moulding above, and in the centre
the Wheel of the Law with a deer on either side. On the left side, in the
place of the female figure, are two chaityas, with a small figure above.
The signification of this is mysterious. As regards the dress, a simple sheet
extends from the waist to the ankles, and its folds are gathered up in festoons
beneath the legs. The head is covered by a conical crown, and the jewels on
the body are very elaborate. To the right of the figure is a small image of
Mayadevi, and above this a Buddha — standing and wearing a conical crown.
There is a similar figure on the opposite side, and below it is a Buddha hold-
ing the Bhikhshu’s bowl. The necklace is very beautiful, and there is a lotus
blossom behind each ear.
VIII.— Pawa'pu'ri' and Biha'r [“ The Isolated Rock”].
We must next visit one of the greatest places of Jaina pilgrimage — Pa-
wapuri, situated about three miles to the west of Hargaon and Titra-
wan, near the dried-up course of the Panch ina, and as nearly as possible due
south of the “ solitary hill” of Bihar. Pawapuri is, strange to say, sin-
gularly destitute of archaeological interest. The great temple of Mahavira is a
modem construction, — -a glaring mass of brick and plaster, totally void of
any beauty or architectural merit. Its lodging-houses, garden, “ nauratan”
summer-house, &c., all date within the past thirty years, and look as if
the workmen had only left them yesterday. To the south of the village, and
near the shores of the famous Pawapuri tank, I detected the remains of a
tumulus, but its materials have been ruthlessly used up in the construction of
284 A. M. Broadley- — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
a great circular platform, which you are gravely assured to have been the
actual scene of the preaching and teaching of the famous Jaina Tirthankara
himself. In the village I found a few Buddhist idols which probably came
from this place. Opposite the “ chabutra,” or “ pulpit,” of Mah.tvira is an
enormous tank, covered with the lotus flower and other luxuriant water plants,
and in which myriads of fish swim undisturbed by the apprehension of inimi-
cal net or hook ; for their preservation seems to bo the only care of the pujari
and his assistants. In the centre of the pond is a second temple still less at-
tractive than the first, built in the centre of a stone platform, which is connect-
ed with the shore by a narrow stone causeway five hundred and fifty feet long.
This temple is resorted to by pilgrims from all parts of India, and is
the scene of a great mela in the month of Kartika. Many of the visi-
tors are the inhabitants of native states, subjects of Sindhia and Holkar,
and it must bo a dreadful undertaking for them to pass through the tract of
country south of the rail before the autumn sun has dried up the floods,
which make the once famous Bihar almost inaccessible during the rainy
season. A good road from Bakhtiarpur to Bihar would be of infinite service
to the country, and its completion is worthy of the attention of Government.
Without it, the lakhs of rupees which have been spent on the roads from
Giryak to Bajauli and from Giryak to Munger, have been simply wasted.
Six miles north of the birth-place of Mahavira Swami is situated Bihar, —
once a famous seat of Buddhistic lore and at the same time doubtless
the capital of a Hindu or Buddhist prince ; — later still, the metropolis of one
of the richest and most powerful of Muhammadan states — and now the decay-
ed and ruined cliief station of the subdivision of Zila’ Patna which bears its
name. To the west of the town runs the Panehana, now represented merely
by a sandy hollow, winding round the foot of the solitary hill to the north-
west of the town. Prom the main stream no less than five rivulets branch-
ed off to the oast, intersecting the town in different places, and adding not
a little to the picturesqueness of its appearance. All of these have long
since dried up, and with its river seems to have ended the prosperity of Bihar.
For years a great sand-bank has been silting up in the bed of the stream
just below Paw&puri ; which forces all the water into the pynes to the east,
and renders the country to the south an arid waste. Even at the height of
the rains, the most feeble stream with difficulty forces its way along the de-
serted bod, and at all other times of the year not a particle of water is visi-
ble. To the north-east of the town is the hill, appropriately described more
than fifteen hundred years ago as an “ isolated rock.” The southern slope
is gradual, a staircase of boulders piled one upon the other, more like the
work of some architect of the past, the effect of volcanic agency. The
other side is a cliff, the side of which is varied by enormous rocks, some
perpendicular and boldly darting into the air, others lying in heterogeneous
2S5
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
piles at the foot of the precipice. Seen in the glare of the midday sun the
Bihar hill would fail to impress the traveller, but when the shades of
evening fall upon it, and darkness begins to gather around its caves and
rocks, it would be difficult to describe its beauty. Before leaving the
solitary hill, or speaking of its ruins, we must again seek for aid in the
pages of Fah-Hiyan. I follow the -text of Mr. Beal’s translation, page 110,
chapter 28. “ From this city [Patna] proceeding in a south-easterly direc-
tion nine yojanas, we arrive at a small rocky hill standing by itself, on the
top of which is a stone cell facing the south. On the occasion, when Buddha
was' sitting in the middle of this cell, the divine Sekra took with him his
attendant musicians, each one provided with a five-stringed lute, and caused
them to sound a strain in the place where Buddha was seated. Then the
divine Sekra proposed forty-two questions to Buddha, writing each one of
them singly with his finger upon a stone. The traces of these questions yet
exist. There is also a Sanghanima built upon this spot. Going south-west
from this one yojana we arrive at the village of Na-lo.”
Tlds hill is identified by General Cunningham with Giryak. “ The re-
mains of Giryak,” he writes, “ appear to me to correspond exactly with the
accounts given by Fah-Hiyan of the Hill of the Isolated liock.” His reasons
are twofold, 1st, the position, and 2nd, the supposed etymology of Giryak, i. e.,
giri-eka = ek giri. I have already given several reasons for my differing with
General Cunningham as to this identification, and I now proceed to adduce
others.
Firstly, at Giryak there is no solitary hill at all, nor any hill which
can be described as resembling in any way an eminence of that descrip-
tion. At Giryak terminates the rocky range of the Bajgir hills, which
stretch from the neighbourhood of Gaya to the banks of the Panchana, on
which the village of Giryak stands, and, as a matter of fact, the hill which
rises above the village — so far from being solitary — is a mere offshoot of
Vipulagir at llajgir, and is not less than six miles in length.
Secondly, from the “ solitary hill” Fah-Hiyan proceeded south-west,
one yojana, to Nala. Now Nala has been identified most satisfactorily with
Bargaon* by position and by the aid of inscriptions, but strange to say,
Bargaon is exactly six miles north-west of Giryak. If General Cun-
ningham’s identification of Giryak be right, Nfilanda must have been
situated somewhere to the south of the Bajagriha hills, in the middle of
the Nowada valley, but he identifies it with Bargaon which is exactly
north-west of the Bajagriha hills, in the centre of the Bihar valley. For
this reason it is clear that “ the hill of the solitary rock” could not be Gir-
yak. The two identifications involve a dilemma, because no amount of
argument can make Bargaon six miles south-west of Giryak, when actually
* ‘Ancient Geography/ p. 469.
286
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
it is six miles in the very opposite direction. The identification of
Nalandd with Bargaon (Viharagrama) is undoubtedly right, and as a
consequence, that of the “ solitary hill” with Giryak — undoubtedly wrong.
General Cunningham writes as one reason for identifying Nalanda with
BargSon — “ Fah-Hiyan places the hamlet of Na-lo at one yojana, or seven
miles, from the hill of the isolated rock, i. e., from Giryak, and also the
same distance from New Kftjagriha. Tins account agrees exactly with the
position of Barg Aon with respect to GHryak and Rdjgir." Now in reality
both translators agree in placing NalandS to the south-west of the hill, and
as a matter^of fact Bargaon is north-west of Giryak.
General Cunningham must, therefore, rely on two arguments, 1st, the
supposed etymology of Giryak, i. e. ek giri = one ( = a solitary P) hill ;
2nd, the coincidence of the fable of the forty-two questions. As regards the
first, it is entirely opposed to all principles of etymology, and I feel sure no
instance of a similar inversion of the numeral can be found throughout the
whole range of Indian names. It must be of course admitted that Fah-Hiyan
relates a certain incredible story about his “ solitary -hill,” which H wen Thsang
reproduces two centuries later in connection with his Indra-Saila peak, but
the supposed event must be allowed to have happened, or rather to have been
alleged to have happened, at least a thousand years before the visit of even
the earlier pilgrim, and it is by no means improbable that the recluses of the
one vihara contended with those of the other for the possession of the actual
site of so remarkable an event in the career of their great teacher. Scarce
two centuries have passed away since Oliver Cromwell was gathered to his
fathers, yet three museums at least lay claim to the exclusive ownership of
his scull, while no less than half a dozen cities vie with each other for the
honour, of being the birth-place of Dante, of Chaucer, and of Christopher
Columbus. An accidental coincidence as to the locality, made the scene of
a mythical fable, can scarcely be sufficient, to convert the end of a rugged
chain of mountains into a “ small isolated rock, standing by itself,” — especi-
ally when such an identification is diametrically opposed to given directions
and distances, and to distinct nomenclature.
I have no hesitation in identifying the “ solitary hill” with that rocky
peak at Bihar, which rises by itself in the midst of the plain covered with
rice and poppy fields, and which gently slopes from the northern foot of the
liajgir hills to the banks of the Ganges itself. My reasons for so doing are :
first, — correspondence of the relative distance and position of the Bihar rock'
and Patna, and of the solitary hill and Pataliputra ; second, — the agreement
of the relative distance and position of the Bihar rock and Bargaon, and the
“ solitary hill” and Nalanda ; third, — natural appearances of the hill itself.
Some great Buddhistic fane once stood on the top of the Bihar
rock. The dargali of Malik Bayu Ibrahim, which now surmounts it, is
287
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
composed almost entirely of the materials of a Buddhist temple, and chaityas
and portions of gateways, &c., have been found by me, both on its summit and
at its base, and the traditions of the people still make it the site of a famous
“ Maghaia” [Buddhist ?] Sanghat [monastery ?]. Passing slowly one day
towards the northern peak of the hill, I found a remarkable figure between
the crevices of the rock. It is unique as far as my collection is concerned,
and bears a dated inscription. I extract a description of the figure from my
catalogue, No. CCXVIII. Buddha is represented seated on a lotus pedestal
in the attitude of instruction, the five compartments of the throne which
support the figure are filled by the representations of six devotees and two
Nagas who appear to be listening to his discourse. On either side of the
principal figure, two other Buddhas are seated in European fashion. Close
to the head of the main figure are small Buddhas, and on either side
of the two seated Buddhas, two other Buddhas standing. To the right and
left are groups of Buddhas similar to the main one, and above this, supported
by four attendants, is a Buddha in the state of ‘ nirvana,’ and above this,
there is a fourth group of three Buddhas seated in the same attitude as in the
main group. The figure is two feet nine inches high, and bears an inscription
on the plinth of which the following is Babti Rajendralala’s transcript.
1st line. *rerT5lT * * rtHfvJiervf * *
2nd line.
3rd line. * * * * (ij)
4th line, ||
“ On the 24th of Vaisakha in the samvat (?) of the Jaina king,
the great king, the worshipful S'ri Madana (Pala) Deva reigning. This deed
of religious gift of Samayika.”
This inscription is doubtless of considerable historical importance, and
may well give occasion to various surmises to the religion of king Madana
Pala Deva, who is here spoken of as Jaina. May not he and his ances-
tors have been Buddhists ?
The view from the solitary rock is most striking, especially during the
rainy season, when the streams once more begin to flow in their deserted beds.
During this time of the year, a series of melas, or gatherings, take place,
which are very greatly resorted to both by Muhammadans and Hindus. The
view is bounded on the south by the rugged hills of the fhijgir chain, which
stretch far away to the west, further than the eye can reach, and which, still
covered with trees and flowering shrubs as of old, seem in the evening light
to possess a purple hue as rich as that of the Apennines at home. To the
east one catches, amidst luxuriant groves of trees, occasional glimpses of the
ancient mosques and the still more ancient fort of Bihar, and beyond it
stretches an even plain of rice and poppy lands till the gaze is arrested by the
bold outline of the Shaikhpura hills in Munger. The prospect to the north is
288 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. [No. 3,
precisely similar, a plain broken only by groves and tanks, through which the
Panchana once poured its water into the Ganges, and which is bounded only
by the banks of the sacred stream.
The Bihar fort lies'nearly a mile east of the foot of the hill, and it was
between the fort and the hill, and along the banks of the Panchana river
that the old Hindu city flourished. The shape of the fort is an irregular pen-
tagon, and its sides wore composed of large masses of grey stone, quarried, of
course, from the neighbouring hill. The ground on which the fort stands
is a natural plateau raised considerably above the level of the surrounding
country. The wall appears to have been eighteen or twenty feet thick, and
twenty-five or thirty feet in height, and its circumference measures eight
thousand five hundred feet. The distance from the north to the south gate
is two thousand eight hundred feet, and from the east to the west two thou-
sand one hundred feet. There are traces of enormous buildings of brick in
the centre, but of these I shall speak hereafter. There appear to have been
few bastions projecting from the side ; but the north gate, which is still toler-
ably perfect, was flanked by towers. The remains existing within the fort
may be divided into three classes ; — 1st. The ruin of a smaller Muhammadan
brick fort and houses belonging to the same period. 2nd. Those of Hindii
buildings and temples. 3rd. Those of the great vihai-a, or college, of Bud-
dhistic learning. As far as this book is concerned, I shall speak alone of the
latter. Nearly all the centre of the fort, on either side of the road which
crosses it, is taken up by brick quarries. The proprietor of these pays
Rs. 40 a month to the zamindar, or owner of the freehold, of the fort for the
exclusive right of excavating it, within certain limits, for bricks and brick-
dust, the supply of which commodities seems quite inexhaustible. The
workmen light daily, at a depth of from fifteen to twenty-five feet from
the surface, on the entire foundations of buildings, composed of bricks of
precisely the same shape and size, as those found at Nalanda and Raja-
griha. The larger ones sell now-a-days for as much as two pice a-piece.
In the midst of this mass of rubbish, Buddhistic carvings are daily turned
up. I have seen as many as four ehaityas dug out in half an hour. The
carvings found here are chiefly ehaityas, votive tablets, and mouldings
containing figures of Buddha in different positions. These ehaityas are of
all shapes, round, circular, square, and twelvc-sidod, and contain mostly the
usual typical figures of Buddha. They differ greatly in design and some of
them are very beautiful. A group of them appear in one of the photographs of
my collection. They were probably all surmounted by umbrellas, or rather by
series of umbrellas, which are generally broken off, and were in many instances
carved in separate pieces of stone. The tablets alluded to vary from one foot
to three feet in height, and generally contain one or more figures of Buddha
under a canopy, and often bear the Buddhist creed. The cornices contain
289
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
long rows of Buddhist figures, seated under canopies in different positions with
a moulding a little above and below. These latter are most graceful in
design. I have several specimens perfectly unmutilated. The Buddhist creed
is often engraved on the upper or lower moulding. It would be very uninter-
esting to attempt a description of all the carvings found in the fort, so I
propose to mention merely the most remarkable. 1st. A figure of Padma-
pani or Surya, in a very peculiar kind of white stone or marble, which boars
all the appearance of having been calcined by fire. It is three feet seven
inches high. The feet rest on a throne divided into seven compartments,
in each of which there is the figure of a galloping horse. The head is sur-
mounted by a conical jewelled crown, from beneath which the hair falls pro-
fusely on the shoulders in ringlets. Either hand grasps a lotus. The
figure is ornamented with an elaborate girdle and necklace ; a sword is girded
on the left side and the dhuti is twisted very closely around the legs, and
finally disappears into a pair of boots. An attendant stands on either side,
and a small figure at each corner is seen in the act of discharging an arrow
from a how. — -[L1I], Alto-relievo figure of Buddha seated in the attitude of
contemplation, two feet six inches high, covered by an elaborate canopy, sup-
ported by pillars. The background within the arch consists of pilasters,
dragons, and cliaityas. Above the arch, and surrounded by scroll work, is a
row of five inches, each containing a Buddha. — [LIII], A very fine and
unmutilated figure of Buddha, one foot eight inches high. An attendant is
standing on either side and above their heads is a chaitya. The figure is
surmounted by a pipal tree. — [LVI]. Upper portion of the canopy of a
figure of Buddha, exquisitely carved. The niches in it are surrounded by the
peculiar ribbed pattern which appears so prominently in the ornamental
brick work of the great Nalanda temple. — [LVII], A semi-circular slab
of basalt containing thirty -three figures of Buddha seated in three rows, and
in different positions, and precisely similar to those found at Nalanda. They
evidently once formed portions of a complete circle of similar figures, and still
bear marks of the metal clamps which joined them together. They evident-
ly formed portions of a dedicatory tope. — The next piece of carving I have
chosen for illustration is a portion of the canopy of a figure. The design is
singularly graceful, and I regret the portions of it are too small and
broken to admit of being joined together. Another remarkable piece of
sculpture is a figure of Buddha under a canopy two feet two inches high,
resting on a pedestal of lotus flowers supported by scroll work. The pillars
have less decoration than usual, and there are no niches above the canopy.
On either side of the principal figure there is a Buddha, seated in European
fashion on a stool or chair, and on either side of the head is a small Buddha,
cross-legged in the attitude of contemplation. There is a similar figure at
the top of each figure. The chief portions of cornice found contain small
37
B B
290 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
figures of Buddha under pillared canopies, but some are of different design,
e. g., one piece is divided into compartments by curious short pillars, with a
ribbed pattern in the centre. The compartments thus formed contain alter-
nately a lion-couchant and a richly caparisoned elephant. Another slab,
seven feet long, contains grotesque dancing figures surmounted by plain mould-
ings. This piece is particularly worthy of note ; for the costume depicted is
almost identical with that worn by the jesters of the Middle Ages of Euro-
pean history. The next carving worthy of note is a figure of Padmapani
under a canopy, one foot four inches high. On either side of the central
canopy were two carved panels. One is broken off, but the other exhibits
a fine piece of scroll work springing from the hands of a grotesque figure. A
seated figure of Mayadevi, one foot seven inches high, seated on a pedestal of
lotus leaves. The legs are crossed, and the sides of both feet are turned out-
wards, and exhibit the royal signs. The hands rest on the knees, the left
grasping a lotus stalk ; the earrings are circular and the ornaments (espe-
cially the batisi) are very large. A spangled dhuti descends from a jewelled
girdle to the feet. There are small female attendants on either side ; the
one to the right being four-armed. Portion of. the background of a figure
of Buddha. A pillaster and part of an arch covered with the most minute
and exquisite omamentalia. Inside it a dragon and rider are seen in the
act of destroying an elephant. Another specimen of the same sort of carv-
ing differing in detail and design from the last. As regards the square
tablets containing figures of Buddha, they have been generally described at
the bases of pillars, but I believe this to be wholly erroneous ; for I found
piles of them in front of the Nalandii temple, and they are met with in great
number in the Bihar fort. I believe them to have been purely votive, serving
exactly the same purpose and end as the cliaitya. These are of inconsider-
able thickness, generally oblong, sometimes rounded at the top. They vary
from one foot to two or three feet in height, and are of proportionate breadth.
Besides these Buddhistic sculptures I found very few Hindu figures, the only
one of them worthy of description being that of a bull, most artistically exe-
cuted, and wearing a string of bells round the neck.
About one hundred feet inside the great northern gate of the fort once lay
a broken monolith, about fourteen feet high, and oval in shape. Ge-
neral Cunningham gives an account of it [vide Report of Archaeological Tour
of 18G1-G2.]
Babu llajendralala Mitra writes of it as follows ; — *
“ One mile due oastf from the dargah, and about a hundred yards inside
the northern gate of the old fort of Bihar, there lies a sandstone pillar,
which bears two separate inscriptions of the Gupta dynasty. Unfortu-
* Journal, Asiatic Society of Bengal, XXXV, p. 270.
f This is a mistake. The pillar was due north of the dargah.
291
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic "Remains of Bihdr.
nately the surface of the stone has peeled off considerably, so that both
the inscriptions are incomplete. The upper inscription, which is of Kumara
Gupta, has lost both ends of every line, being probably about one-third of
the whole. The lower inscription has lost only the left upper corner, and
some unknown amount at the bottom, where the pillar is broken off. But
as the remaining portion of the upper part is letter for letter the same as
the opening of the Bhitari pillar inscription, nearly the whole of the
missing part of the left upper corner can be restored at once. This record
belongs to Skanda Gupta, the son and successor of Kumara Gupta.
“ In the plate the upper inscription is numbered 1 and the lower one 2.
The former extends to 13 lines, and bears the name of Kumara Gupta, whose
eulogium it is perhaps intended to be. I say “ perhaps” deliberately, for a
large portion at the beginning of every lino being lost, and it being im-
possible to give a connected translation, I cannot be certain that the record
did not contain same other name which has now been lost. In the fourth
line the word Kavi/a, or “ funeral cake,” may refer to Kumara Gupta, whose
name occurs in the 3rd line, and the record may consequently belong to
Skanda Gupta, but in the absence of connecting words such a supposition
cannot be justifiable. The document is most probably in verse, and the
word Chandra in the first line suggests the idea that the Kumara Gupta of
the record was the son of Chandra Gupta II. of the Kuhan Pillar. The
figure for the year in the last lhie is perfectly clear, and is indicated, as
usual in Gupta records, by three parallel lines, but the letters before and
after it ai-e very doubtful, and no reliance can be placed on the date. The
letter preceding the 3 may be a 60, and some of the letters after the letter
for S'aka may be figures, but I am not certain of their value. As Kumara
was the sixth in a direct line from S'ri Gupta, the founder of the Gupta
dynasty, it is certain that the date, whether 3 or 63, cannot be of the
Gupta era ; for according to the Udayagiri and S'anchi inscriptions, Chandra
Gupta II. lived from 82 to 93 of that era. It must therefore be either of
the reigning sovereign, or of some now unknown era, other than that used in
the Allahabad column inscription.
“ The second inscription is even more imperfect than the first, and has
no date ; hut there is no doubt of its being an edict ot the Gupta who
recorded the Bhitari inscription, or of one oi his descendants. General Cun-
ningham imagines it to be a counterpart of the Bhitari record, and says that
the portion extant “ is letter for letter the same as the opening of the Bhi-
tari pillar inscription.” Such, however, is not the case. It is true, the first
line has an epithet which occurs in the first line of the Bhitari inscription,
and lines 3 to 12 are made up of words whose counterparts are seen in that
record. It may also be admitted that Kumara Devi, the wife of Chandra
Gupta I, is named in the 5th line, and the word Gupta occurs in the 10th,
202
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
[No. 3,
which leave no doubt as to tho race of the sovereign who recorded the docu-
ment. But as no specific name is legible, and the words common to the two
records are mostly adjectives expressive of royal qualities which are generally
attributed to all Hindu sovereigns, their evidence cannot be accepted as con-
clusive as to the identity of the two records. Were it otherwise, still it
would be of no use, for we have positive proof to shew that they are not
identical. The second line of the Bihdr record has a word which does not
occur in tho first two lines of the Bhitari inscription, and the matter from
the 13th line to the end, if my reading be correct, is new. In the 18th line
there is mention made of Bhatta Guhila Swamin, whose name does not occur
in the Bhitari column. The conclusion, therefore, that I come to is, that the
two documents were put up by the same race, and very likely by the same
king, but on different occasions, and to record different occurrences. There
is nothing in the record to justify the positive opinion of General Cunning-
ham that it belongs to 8 k an da Gupta, son of Kumara Gupta.”
Tentative Readings of the Bihdr Pillar Inscriptions.
No. I. (^) *;fa ^+-=?n^TfT-t--8W
vrfTOsnjfa^THTsr *i: <33TW:
(a) fa fa
(a) ^faT^fa^rpr fagwTTO:
(if) — ■%
fa) f
fa) gqmfagiTqiffigfa
(<t) fagfarfvrg g;r^iws-j-
fa°) wsrr^rgipT ^ «st4ifa:
(U) ms-.
(\<{) ^TfaWfa^ <fa
(ff ) qfTq^fa g-gfa ^ gqrggfagTq
No. II. fa) -(-gfa^fyHqfaxrsi^i
fa) -f-g^gg*g arTW
fa)
(a) gNKT3TI
(a.) +gfaiT
fa) +<TfqfaJZ’?tm
fa) ^VTNRrn fl^TTT5ir
fa) + g’sfa^TT q: gqifar
(<t) gfqrg;rgum:
fa°)
(U) + + i TCiWTJrem
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. 293
(\i?) + + +
(\ a) ?> + + +
(i>) f^gYfwnfTwif^ir
(v*>)
(\c) ww f*rarfaHTfg? *ro farrurt^r
(U) — Hf arf^^Trarsfr
(y o) qw ^T^tr
I have removed the pillar from tlie place in which it lay, half buried in
the ground, and set it up on a brick pedestal opposite the Bihir court house.
It is much to ho regretted that so much of the inscription has disappeared,
as to make its further translation impossible, but it is curious on account of
its undoubted great antiquity, and as evidence of the Gupta rule in Bihar.
From the enormous number of Buddistic remains found on the elevated pla-
teau, which forms the site of the Bihdr fort, there can be no doubt that
a large vihara and other Buddhist buildings of more than ordinary
importance once existed on the spot, but, more than this, the colossal
fortifications which surrounded it make it more than probable that it
also formed the seat of the government of the surrounding country and the
residence of its rulers. Not only have we the Gupta pillar, but numbers of
the inscribed figures found there, bear the names of the Pala rajas of Bengal,
of Madna-pala, of Mahi-pala, of ltama-pala and of Yighara-pala. Montgomery
Martin* speaks of it as the residence of the Magha nlja, but this is exceedingly
vague, as everything not constructed within the memory of man, is univer-
sally stated in Bihar to be “ Magha.” We know that at one time Kdjagriha
was undoubtedly the capital of Magadha, and there can bo little doubt that
the metropolis was subsequently removed to Patali, but of this Bihar tradition
and history are silent. Such evidence as we have got, inclines me to the
conclusion that Bihar was, for centuries preceding the Muhammadan conquest,
both at any rate the residence of the subordinate Hindu, Buddhist, or
Jaina governors of the country, if not of the kings themselves. It seems
probable that even its occupation by the governors of the surrounding
district had ceased beforo the capture of the ancient fort at the end of
the twelfth century. The popular tradition of Bihar makes the seat of
government at this time to have been at Ilohtas, and we know that when
Muhammad Bakhtyar Khilji marched into the fort, he found nothing
there but a vihara. Minliaj i Siraj gives the following account of the fall
of the ancient scat of Buddhistic and Hindu learning in his Tabaqat-i-
Nafiri.f “ It is said by credible persons that ho went to the gate of the
* ‘ Gya and Shahabad,’ p. 92.
t “ The History of India as told by its own Historians,” by Sir H. M. Elliot, Lon-
don, 1809, Yol. II, p. 30G.
294 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr. [No. 3,
fort of BihSr with only two hundred horse, and began the war by taking the
enemies unaware.... When Bakhtyar reached the gate of the fort, and when
the fighting began, these two wise brothers [i. e., Nizamud-dfn and Samsam-
ud-din] were active in that army of heroes. Muhammad Bakhtyar with great
vigour and audacity rushed in at the gate of the fort, and gained possession
of the place. Great plunder fell into the hands of the victors. Most of the
inhabitants of the place wore Brahmans with shaven heads. They were put
to death. Large numbers of books were found there, and when the Muham-
madans saw them, they called for some persons to explain their contents,
but all the men had been killed. It was discovered that the whole fort and
city was a place of study [madrasah]. For in the Hindi language the word
Bihar (vihdra) means a college.” I feel by no means sure that the vihara thus
destroyed was not a Buddhistic institution, and that the “ Brahmans with
shaven heads” were not Buddhist monks. Strange to say, hardly a Hindu
idol has has ever been found in the ruins, and some of the Buddhist figures
bear inscriptions, certainly not more ancient than the tenth century , possibly
the eleventh. The most modem of these Buddhist figures are those showing the
Sage in the attitude of repose — the body leaning to one side, and the base
and background decorated with the most profuse and exquisite ornaments, a
very good example of which will be described when I come to speak of the
ruins of llohoi. In consequence of the extreme delicacy of tho workman-
ship, these exquisite specimens of later Buddhistic art are scarcely ever to
be found perfect, but I came on several mutilated figures of the kind in the
ruins within the Bihar fort, and their base is generally covered with inscrip-
tions, which serve to show that Buddhism flourished till a very late period
in the heart of the country from which it sprung.
The Buddhistic remains of Bihar are not confined to the mounds at the
fort. The dargah or shrine of Qadir Qumesh which occupies its centre, is
composed almost entirely of the materials of the vihara, and its pavement
is studded with enormous chaityas and pillars. The faqirs of the shrine
guard them with religious care, and eke a livelihood by permitting persons
afflicted with toothache and neuralgia, to cure (?) their ailments by touching
the afflicted parts with the very stone which their forefathers delighted to
break, in order to gain the envied title of “ the iconoclast [y^ce], A mile
away from the fort, towards the banks of the Panchaua are the remains of
several Buddhist buildings, the site of which is marked only by heaps of
bricks ; for the stones and pillars have been removed to adorn the masjid of
Hahi Khan Sur and the great dargah of Makhdum Shah Sharafud-din. A
careful examination of the places shew them to have been built almost en-
tirely of Buddhist materials. The position of these stones prevent any exa-
mination of them, but I feel sure many figures and inscriptions would come to
light, if such could be made. The beautiful masjid of Hahi Khan is now
205
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
completely deserted, and I have found several carvings in the floor. In the
enclosure which faces it, I noticed a magnificent slab of basalt more than six
feet long, and a foot thick, lying imbedded in the earth. I got it turned
over, and found in the reverse a most curious (perhaps unique) series of twen-
ty figures under pillared canopies ; — one, the god Ganesa ; two to eleven,
Incarnations of Vishnu [Hindu] ; twelve to twenty, the nine planets [Bud-
dhistic]. Again to the north of the fort, in a plain called Logan i, there are
traces of a large vilidra and many granite columns. In the same direction I
have found several beautiful basalt pillars which have been photographed.
In the dargah of Makkdum Shah Ahmad Charmposh, situated a little to the
east of Logani, I fouud a splendid monolith covered with the most delicate
carving, and the doorway of the shrine itself is a grand specimen of
Buddhistic art, and, according to tradition, once served as the great
entrance to the vihara in the old fort. A figure of Buddha once
occupied the centre, and the plinth is composed of three rows of the
most exquisitely sculptured foliage, &c., and two other mouldings which once,
doubtless, contained figures, are now covered with several yards of finely
carved Persian verse. The doorway is eleven feet high and seven
broad.
We may now leave Bihar and travel northwards along the course of the
Panchana. At Soh Serai, some two miles north of Bihar, are the remains of
a Buddhist temple. The ground is strewn with greystone columns of consider-
able size, most of them broken in several pieces. The base and capitals are
square, and the shaft varies in shape — being first octagonal, then sixteen-sided,
and lastly circular.
As I have said in the preceding chapter, I identify these remains with
the Kapotilca Sungharama of Hwen Tlisang, situated two or three lis to the
north of the isolated rock. The following extract is Julien’s terse translation
of his description of the locality.
‘ A deux ou trois li au sud de ce couvent, il y a une montagne isolee qui
est taillee en terrasse, et dont le sommet liardi et imposant est embelli par
une riche vegetation, des b assies d’eau pure, et des flours parfumees. Comme
il est un lieu remarquable par la beaute do ses sites, on y a bati un grand
nombre de temples sacres, ou l’on voit souvent des miracles et des prodiges
aussi rares qu’ extraordinaires.
‘ Dans un vihara qui oecupe le centre du plateau, s’eleve une statue, en bois
de sandal, de Ttanar-tsen-ts' ai-pon-sa (d' Avaldbrilee.vara bodhisaltva ) * * * *
On voit plusieurs dizaines d’hommes qui se privent de manger et de hone pen-
dant sept oumeme quatorze jours, pour lui adresser des veeux. Ceux qui sont
animes d’une foi ardente voient immediatement l’image entire du Bodhisatt-
va. Alors du milieu de la statue il sort environne d’un eclat imposant, lour
parle avee bienveillance et leur aecorde l’objet de leurs veeux. 11 y a aussi
290 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
un nombre considerable d’hommcs a qni il est donne de le voir dans toute sa
majesty. Aussi la multitude de ses adorateurs s’accroit-elle de jour en jour.
Les personnes qui lui rendent des hommages assidus, craignant que la foule
des visiteurs ne salit cette venerable statue, ont fait 61cver autour, a une dis-
tance do sept pas, une balustrade en bois herissee de pointes de fer. Ceux
qui vienncnt saluer et adorer la statue, sont obliges de se tenir en dehors de
la balustrade. Ne pouvant l’approcher, ils jettent de loin les fleurs qu’ils
viennent lui offrir. Ceux qui reussissent a fixer leurs guirlandes de fleurs
sur les mains et sur les bras du Bodhisattoa , regardent cela commo un heu-
reux presage, et se persuadent qu’ils verront l’aceomplissement de leurs
VOJUX.’
Three miles to the north of Soh, on the east bank of the river, which
was once of considerable width, there are distinct traces of a stupa and
monastery, and the huge piles of brick on every side induce nic to think
that a nourishing town once surrounded the religious edifices. The whole of
the ruins are encircled with luxuriant groves of pipal trees, and the villagers
had collected all the fragments of ehaityas, mouldings, &o., around their roots.
A portion of a figure of Padmapani was so firmly imbedded in the wood,
that a piece nearly a foot square had to be removed before it could be ex-
tracted. The figures found at liohoi are perfect and umnutilatod, a very
unusual circumstance in Bihar, the record on the tomb of whose saints
generally winds up by telling us that the deceased “ was a breaker of images,
and God has therefore given him a place in Paradise.” The whole of the
idols appear to have been removed (doubtless at the approach of the Mu-
hammadans) and buried some distance from the ruins the open plain. They
were discovered there by the zamindar of ltohoi — a Bundela Rajput by
caste— twenty years ago, and taken away by him to his garden, where 1
found them. They had been arranged merely for ornament, and he at once
offered them to me. The principal idols arc figures of Buddha in differ-
ent positions resembling those already described. The finest is an idol,
three feet two inches high, quite perfect, and resembling in many respects
the one found at Tillarah. The crown worn is five-sided and very tall,
and the body is not covered by a jacket. The female archers are seeD
at the feet of the attendants and not above them. Parallel to the head
are figures holding scrolls. On the shoulders of the charioteer beneath the
feet is seated a small female figure. The wheel of the chariot is in the
centre, and a horse is seen within it with its head to the left. Of the remain-
ing horses three gallop to the right and three to the left. A small figure
of Padmapani exquisitely carved. There is a Buddha seated in the hair,
and a ehaitya on either side of the head. Three alto-relievo figures of Buddha
in the attitude of repose, in very fine black basalt, three feet nine inches. Around
the body the stone has been completely removed. The body is inclined to the
297
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar.
right and is seated on a lotus throne supported by the richest scroll work. The
right hand rests on the right knee, and the right foot depends from the
throne, and is supported by a cluster of lotus blossoms. Its sole is turn-
ed outwards and bears the royal mark. The left loot is coiled up on the
throne and shows the same mark as the hand. The richest possible carving
is displayed on the ornaments. The dhuti is bound up at the waist by an
elaborate girdle, and a scarf passes across the body from left to right. The
hair is dressed in a conical chignon, five inches high, composed of innumera-
ble twists. In the centre of it a Buddha is seated. There are ornaments be-
hind the ears, from which ribbons or tassels depend. The throne (which is
nearly concealed by ornaments) is a square of scroll work, at each corner ol
which a large bird is seated. At each side of the figure is an elaborately dressed
attendant. Between these and the main figure are lotus blossoms, springing
from a delicately carved stem. The halo which surrounds the head is oval
in shape and most elaborately carved, and in the centre is a diamond-shaped
jewel on a line with the face. Right and left of the figure are groups of
grotesque attendants, from whose hands springs a flowing scroll of rich
geometrical pattern, which forms the background of the figure, and in the
midst of which live Buddhas are seated, in different attitudes and on sepa-
rate thrones. It bears the following inscription, thus rendered by Professor
R. G. Bhandarkar : —
[figure indistinct 8 or «,] TfPJl0
“ Year of the reign of Srimad Vigrahapala four [2] Maggasirslia, 19th
day. This is a religious gift of the son of Deliabu, a goldsmith.”
There are two Vigrahapalas in the Dxnajpur copper plate. The date
of the latter is given as 1027, A. D. (See Prinsep’s works, Mr. Thomas’s
Edition, vol. II. p. 271).
I also give a reading by Babu Rajendralala Mitra —
TTStJ *?*nr W
* * * Jtf ^ #
“ On the 15th of the month of Marga (November-December), in
the Samvat year 12 of the reign of S 'rimat Vigrahapala Deva, (the rest
illegible).”
Figure of Kabir, seated on a chair, with one foot resting on a stool.
The figure is three feet high. The hair is dressed in a profusion of ringlets,
and the body is very corpulent. One haftd rests on the knee grasping a well
filled money bag, and the other holds apparently a pouch or gourd. (5)
Small figure of Mayadevi quite perfect — standing on a lotus-leaf pedestal, and
holding a lotus-liower in either hand. A Buddha is seated on either side of
the head.
38
c c
298
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
To the north of Rohoi I have not succeeded in finding any Buddhist
remains, and those to the east are of very little importance. At a village
called Kalta, seven miles east of Bihar, there are the remains of a large stupa,
and at another village which adjoins it to the south, called Jeya (Jiar), there
is one of those beautiful tanks of clear water, surrounded by luxuriant groves
of mangoe and pipal trees, which generally bordered the site of a Buddhist
monastery. As might be expected there is a pile of ruins to the south of
the pond, and a large heap of broken images, chaityas, and pillars.
IX.— Ra'jagriha in the Maha'wanso.
The pages of Mr. Turnour’s elaborate work contain frequent allusions
to Bihar or, more correctly speaking, to Magadha. In the second chapter,
referring to the events which occurred some time about the year B. C. 543,
we learn that Bimbisaro was the “ attached friend” of Siddhatto (S&khya
Muni), that he had been placed on the throne of Rajagriha, (which the
translator mistakes for Rajmahall) by his father Bhatiyo in the fifteenth
year of his ago, that it was sixteen years subsequent to this event that the
divine teacher propounded his doctrines to him, and that he continued to
reign thirty-seven years after his conversion to the Buddhist faith. He was
slain by his son Ajatasatru (the founder of new Rajagrilia), the eighth
year of whose reign saw the death of the sage, and who continued to rule in
Magadha after this event for the space of twenty-four years. This inform-
ation is very important in fixing the date of the removal of the capital
to new Rajagriha. The death of S&khya Muni was succeeded by a period
of fasting and lamentation, during which the sacred edifices of the town were
repaired. After this, the the'ros, with Maha Kasyapa at their head, ap-
proached the monarch, and asked him to build for them “ a session hall.”
He granted their request, and erected a splendid chamber in the place
named by them, viz., hi/ the side of the Wehhdra [Baibhar] mountain,
at the entrance of the Sattapanni cave. This confirms in every respect tho
identification of the cave made in Chapter IV. He then records the reigns
of the four succeeding kings of Rajagriha, who all appear to have gained
the throne by the murders of their fathers and immediate predecessors, and
that finally some ninety years after the death of Buddha, the last scion of
the paricidal race was deposed, and one Susanfigo elected in his stead. A
few years later, Rajagriha became the head quarters of one of tho schisms in
the Buddhistic Church, which had now begun to spring up on all sides.
The founder of the new dynasty had a son called Kalasoko, who was suc-
ceeded by his ten sons reigning conjointly for some forty-four years. The
last surviving brother was slain in Rajagriha by a Brahman, named Chanaka,
who placed a member of the old Moriyan dynasty, (one Chandagatto) on
the throne, who reigned for thirty-four years. His son Bindusaro ruled
299
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bilidr.
over all India for twenty-eight years, and was succeeded by “ the pious and
supernaturally wise Asoka,” who caused his own inauguration to he solemnized
in the city of1 Bdtaliputto.' Rajagriha, then, appears, to have continued to
flourish for at least two hundred and eighteen years after the death of Bud-
dha. It was then that the old seat of government was given up to the
Brahmans as stated by Hwen Thsang, but Buddhism must have continued to
flourish there ; for we read almost in the next page of one Sonsiko of Bana-
ras coming to the “ mountain-girt city [Rajagriha] on trade, together with
his parents, attended by a retinue of fifty-five brahmanical devotees , who had
accompanied him thither.”* He repaired at once to the great Kalanda-Ve-
nouvana monastery, and soon appears to have attained to sublime honour of
the priesthood under the auspices of the thoro Dasako, and became the means
of converting to the faith of Buddha, Tisso, younger brother of Asoka and
‘ sub-king of Magadha.’ The great Dharmasoka himself soon after became
“ a relation of the religion of Buddha.”
In speaking of the number of Buddhist priests attracted to Ceylon
during the reign of Duttagamani, the fourteenth in succession after the
death of Buddha (B. C. 161 — 137), we find that one Indagutto, a sojourner
in the vicinity of Rajagriha, came there, accompanied by 8000 theros.
A still greater number came from Wesali, Banaras, Kausambi, and other
places. We are thus in possession of the fact that Rajagriha continued
to be one of the chief seats of Buddhism in India up to a comparatively
short time before the birth of Christ. Nalanda is not even mentioned
as one of the viharas contributing members to the Ceylon assembly, and
this lends aid to my own belief of the comparatively recent date of its
erection and prosperity.
X.— Na'landa' [Barga'on],
The village of Bargaon lies exactly six miles south-west of Bihar
and seven miles north-east of Rajagriha. From the row of conical mounds
to the south of the modern village, the “ solitary rock” of the former place,
and the rugged mountains which once surrounded the ancient capital of
Magadha, are distinctly visible, both objects presenting a break in the broad
expanse of poppy-fields and rice-lands which meet the eye in all directions,
and which gently slope from the foot of the Rajgir hills to the banks of the
Ganges itself.
By its position, by the comparison of distances, and by the aid of in-
scriptions, Bargaon has been identified, beyond the possibility of a doubt,
with that Viliara-gram on the outskirts of which, more than a thousand
years ago, flourished the great Nalanda monastery, the most magnificent
and most celebrated seat of Buddhist learning in the world. When the
* Maliawanso, p. 29.
300
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihar. [No. 3,
caves and temples of Rajagriha were abandoned to the ravages of decay,
and when the followers of Tathagata forsook the mountain dwellings of their
great teacher, the monastery of Nalandd arose in all its splendour on the
banks of the lakes of Bargaon. Successive monarehs vied in its embel-
lishment ; lofty pagodas wore raised in all directions ; halls of disputation
and schools of instruction were built between them ; shrines, temples, and
topes were constructed on the side of every tank and encircled the base of
every tower ; and around the whole mass of religious edifices were grouped
the “ four-storied” dwellings of the preachers and teachers of Buddhism.
Fah-IIiyan visited the spot in 415, A. D., and tells us that Saripiitra was
born at Nalanda, and that he subsequently returned to it to enter nirvana.
Ho also infonns us that this memorable event in Buddhistic ecclesiastical
history had been commemorated by the erection of a lofty town which he
saw, but he says nothing of the existence of any vihara or sangharama.
Hwen Thsang, according to the chronology of his travels, so ably and elabo-
rately established by Major-General Cunningham, arrived at the gates of
the great Nalanda vihara somewhere about the 1st March 637, A. D., and
spent within its precincts, and in visiting tho holy places in its immediate
neighbourhood, no less a period than twenty-two months. His description
of the antiquities of the place, of the manners, customs, and language of its
inmates, of the pious gifts of its long line of royal benefactors, and of the
architecture and decorations of its countless temples, pagodas, and shrines,
is singularly minute and vivid, and fills a large space in the first volume of
M. J ulien’s translation of the ‘ Memoires.’ Before proceeding to describe,
and subsequently to attempt an identification, of its ruins, I feel bound to
quote somewhat at length from the records of the pilgrim. He writes as
follows : “ Le dixieme jour, les religieux du couvent de Na-lan-to (Nalanda
vihara) envoyerent au-devant de lui quatre hommes d’une virtu eminente
[i. e., to Bodh-Gaya]. II partit avec eux et apres avoir fait sept yodjanas, il
arriva au village ou est situe le couvent. Ce fut dans ce village (appelle
Nalmdagra/md) quo naquit l’honorablo Meo-lien ( Mdudgalya ydna). Au
moment de son arrivee, il vit en outre deux eonts religieux et un millier de
fideles qui accouraient au-devant de lui avec des etendards, des parasols, des
parfums, et des fleurs. Ils toumerent autour lui en celebrant ses louanges
et entrerent dans le couvent de Nfllanda. Une fois arrives, ils se joignirent
a la multitude des premiers religieux. Quand le Maitre de la loi eut fini de
les saluer, ils placerent sur l’estrade du president un fauteuil particulier et
le prierent do s’y asseoir. La multitude des religieux et des fideles s’assit
pareillement. Apres quoi on chargea le wei-max (le Karmaddna, le sous-diree-
teur) de frapper la plaque sonore Kien-tehi (Gnanti) et d’inviter a haute
voix le Maitre de la loi a demeurer dans le couvent, et a faire usage en com-
ntun de tous les ustonsiles et effets des religieux qu’ils etaient rassembles.”
301
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic (Remains of Bihar.
Here follows a long account of the interview of the traveller with the
abbot Sitabhadra.
After describing with considerable minuteness the rations dealt out to
him by the ecclesiastics of the vihara with an unsparing hand, he sets about
the more difficult task of sketching its history, and writes, —
“ Be mot (Ndlemda) veut dire en chinois 1 celui qui donne sans se lassser,’
voici ce qne les vieillards racontent a ce sujet. Au sud du couvent situe au
milieu d’un jardin d’arbres An-mo-lo ( Amras ), il y avait un etang qui
etait habito par un dragon, nomme Na-lan-to ( Ndlanda ). A cote, on
construmt un couvent qu’on appela, pour cette raison, le couvent de Na-lan-
to (Nalanda vihara).
“ On rapports encore que jadis Tathagata, ii l’epoque ou il menait
la vie d’un Pan-sa (Bddhisattva), devint roi d’un grand royaume, et
fixa sa residence en cet endroit. Touche de compassion pour les orphelins
et les indigents, il repaudit constamment des bienfaits et des aumdnes. Les
habitants, pendtres de reconnaissance, sumommerent cet endroit 1 Le pays
de celui qui domic sans se lasscr .’ Bans l’origine, ee lieu etait un jardin
d’Amras, appartenant h un riche maitre de maison ( Grihapati ). Cinq
cents marchands 1 aoheterent au prix d’un million de pieces d'or et le
donnerent au Bouddha.
“ Bans cet endroit, le Bouddha expliqua la loi pendant trois mois, et par-
mi ces marchands, il y en eut beaucoup qui obtinrent le fruit (de V Intelli-
gence, Bodlii) .
“ Apres le Nirvfma du Bouddha, un ancien roi de ce royaume, nomme
Gh o-hia-lo-o' -V ie-to (pakradetya), rempli de respoct et d’amour pour le Boud-
dha, construisit il ses frais ee hia-lun (Sangharama).
“ Ce roi etant mort, eut pom’ successeur son fils Fo-to-k' io-to (Bouddha
goupta ), qui, apres avoir pris les rencs de ce grand royaume, construisit plus
loin au sud un autre lcia-lun ( Sangharama ).
“ Un peu plus loin a l’est, son fils, le roi Ta-ta-hie-to ( Tathagata ) batit
un autre couvent.
“ Plus loin au nord-est, son fils Po-lo-o' - tie-to ( Baladitya ) batit un autre
couvent.
“ Bans la suite, voyant qu’un saint religieux venait de Chine, et se diri-
goait vers lui pour rocevoir de ses mains les provisions necessaires, il fut trans-
porte de joie, quitta son trone et embrassa la vie religieuse.
“ Il eut pour successeur son fils Fa-che-lo (Vadjrd), qui plus loin au nord
construisit un autre couvent. Quelque temps apres, un roi de l’lnde Centrale
batit a c6te un autre couvent.
“ Be cette maniere, six rois, qui monterent successivement sur le trone se
livrerent chacun a, de pieuses constmctions. Le dernier de ces rois entoura
tous ces couvents d’une enceinte de murs en briques et les reunit en un seul
302
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
Une porte qu il etablit y donnait acoes. II construisit des salles separees
(pour les conferences), et partagca en huit cours l’espace qui so trouyait au
centre des Sangharamas. Des tours precieuses etaient rangees dans un
ordre regulier ; des pavilions ornes s’elevaient comme des pics (■lances ; des
domes hardis se dressaient au milieu des nues, et les faites des temples sem-
blaient voler au dessus des vapeurs du ciel. De leurs fenetres, on voyait
naitre les vents et les nuages, ct au dessus de leurs toits audacieux le soleil et
la lune entraient on conjunction. Tout autour serpentait une eau azuree
que des lotus bleus embcllissaient de leurs , calices dpanouis, et de beaux
hie-nie ( Iianabras ), “ Butca frondosa laissaient pendre leurs fleurs d’un
rouge cblouissant, et des Amras les protegeaient au dehors de leur ombrage
epais.
“ Dans les diverges cours, les maisons des religieux avaient chacune
quatre etages. Ses pavilions avaient des piliers omes de dragons et des
colonnes ornees de jade, peintes en rouge et richement ciselees, et des
balustrades. Les linteaux des portes etaient faits avec Elegance, les toits
etaient couvorts de tuiles brillantes dout 1’ eclat se multipliait en se refletant,
et variait a cbaque instant de mille manieres.
“ l108 Sangharamas de l’lnde se comptent aujourd’hui par milliers ; mais
il n’en est point qui ogalent ccux-ci par leur majesty, leur ricbesse et la hau-
teur de leur construction. On y compte, en tout temps, dix mille religieux
tant du dedans que du dehors, qui tous suivent la doctrine du grand Vehi-
cule. Les sectateurs des dix-huit ecoles s’y trouvent reunis, et Ton y etudie
toutes sortes d’ouvrages depuis les livres vulgaires, les weito ( Vedas) et au-
tres ecrits du meme genre jusqu’aux traites In-ming (Hetonvidyce), Cning-
ming ( Cahdavidya. ), la medecine (Tehikitsdvidyd), les sciences occultes
(Kryd) et l’arithmetique (Samlchydnd). On y compte mille religieux qui
peuvent expliquer vingt ouvrages sur les Castras, cinq cents qui en
comprennent trente, et dix seulement, y cornpris lo Maitre de la loi, qui en
possedent cinquante. Mais le maitre Biai-him ( Oilabhadra ) les avait tous
lus et sa virtu eminente et son age venerable lui avaient donne le premier
rang parmi les religieux. Dans 1’interieur du couvent, une centaine de
chaires etaient occupees cbaque jour, et les disciples suivaient avec zele les
legons de lours maitres, sans perdre un seul instant.”
This, then, was Nalandd, as Hwen Thsang saw it, twelve centuries ago,
let me now attempt to describe its ruins as they exist in our own times.
Approaching them from Bihar, we first arrive at an enormous tank,
running duo east and west for nearly a mile and about a quarter of a mile
broad. It is now called the “ Diggi Pokhar,” and is surrounded on all sides
by fine groves of mango trees. At the west end of the lake is situated the
modern village of Begumpur. About three hundred feet to the south of
the village is a largo square mound, once apparently Hanked with small
303
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Eemains of Bihar.
towers and having no connection with the Buddhist remains, being evidently
the ruins of a Muhammadan fort. Immediately to the south of this are two
small Buddhist topes, some fifty feet in circumference and not more than
six or eight feet high. I found in these several fine Buddhist and Hindu
idols, notably a crowned figure of Vishnu, seated on his sacred bird ; and
several iigures which I recovered from the village itself, evidently came from
the same place. One thousand eight hundred and twenty-five feet south-
west of these topes is a very beautiful square tank, known as the “ Suraj
Pokhar, which measures as near as possible four hundred feet on each side.
This pond was once flanked with a row of small pagodas on the north side
covered with massive brick cupolas, and their ruins still exist in tolerable
entirety. T clearly marked out six of these temples. On each side of the
pond were three brick ghats, and the ruins of these may still be traced.
The banks of the tank served also as the repository for chaityas.
Several of these were taken out of the tank by me, and I saw many others
beneath the clear water. About twenty feet to the oast of the tank is a
mound, evidently formed of the remains of some large brick building,
surmounted by a luxuriant bar tree. Duo south of this, and at a distance
of one thousand two hundred feet, is another enormous mound six hundred
feet in circumference, and nearly fifty feet in height. Between this and
the next tumulus, which is seven hundred and fifty feet distant in the same
direction, is a brick enclosure containing seven Buddhist figures, now regular-
ly worshipped as Hindu deities. The largest, yclept the Telia Bhanddr,
(see note m the concluding chapter), is of colossal proportions, and resembles
very much, though it is of inferior workmanship, the groat Sri Bullum Buddha
of the Titrawan monastery. The following are the measurements of the
Telia Bhandar —
Crown of head to chin,
Crown of head to seat of throne, .
Length of head,
Length of foot,
Circumference of head at forehead,
Shoulder to elbow,
Elbow to hand,
Hip to knee
Knee to ankle,
Bound the wrist,
Bound the breast,
Bound the waist,
Bound the thigh,
Bound the neck,
Feet Inches.
2 6
5 G
1 4
1 3
4 4
2 7
1 8
3 2
2 9
5 0
5 7
1 9
2 8
3 1
30i
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Biluir. [No. 3,
Three hundred feet to the south of the last-mentioned tumulus is a
third great tope, sixty high and more than one thousand feet in circumfer-
ence, the largest and most important of the mounds, surrounded by a
series of smaller topes, and forming the centre of the ruins of Bargaon.
I found this on the 15th October, 1871, literally a small hill, the surface of
which was broken only by a depression on the top, and the remains of a
former excavation on the eastern slope ; the sides covered with a tangled
mass of thicket and brushwood, and studded here and there by a solitary
mango or date tree.
The results of my excavations have been already given in the third
chapter.
Three hundred feet to the south of this is a fifth mound, of about six
hundred feet in circumference, but of greater elevation than any of the rest.
Seven hundred and ninety feet south of this is a sixth tumulus of incon-
siderable size and height. Seven hundred and thirty feet south of the sixth
mound is a large lake, called the “ Indra Pokhar,” which faces the whole of
the southern side of the ruins of the monasteries. The three central mounds
aie bounded on the west by three lakes, known respectively by the name
of DehS, 1 Bullen, and “ Kundui and some distance west of the fifth
tumulus is a pond, called Suraha, on the east bank of which are unmis-
takable traces of Buddhist ruins. South of this is another pond called
“ Dudhdeha,” and a third known as “ Satyauti,” which also is faced on its
east side by the rums of a temple or tope.
Seven hundred and twenty feet due east of the great central tumulus
is another enormous mound, which I shall designate as the seventh mound.
It is nearly as large as the central mound itself, but of much less elevation.
In the level plain between these two heaps is a mass of overgrown walls and
jungle-covered hillocks, broken here and there by a square patch of scanty
cultivation.
Some distance south-east of this seventh tope is the village of Kaptes-
wari, and the remains of an eighth temple or vihfira, nearly reduced to the
level of the surrounding plain by the toil of an industrious cultivator, who
yearly ploughs across its surface, and whose grandfather discovered some
fine idols and pillars, which are now in my collection. The east of the
ruins is faced by a tank called the “ Pansokar.” The modern village of
Bargaon lies to the north of the ruins, and is in a line between the Pansokar
and Suraj Pokhar tanks.
The wall which surrounded the whole mass of conventual buildings is
gone, and has left no trace ; nor could the most diligent search light on
the whereabouts of the great gate. Bargaon has been the brick quarry of
Bihar lor centuries ; hence it is that the walls, gates, and houses have disap-
peared, while the massive tumuli formed by the debris of the temples are as
yet untouched.
18/2.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. 305
Before leaving Bargdon, I made a careful survey of the ruins between
the mounds, and succeeded in distinctly tracing eight halls or yards. This
mass of ruins lies parallel to the great moimds numbered by me III, IV, and
V, and between them and No. VII. No. I (to the extreme south) is 114
feet east and west, and 84 feet north and south ; No. II, 72 feet east and west
by 40 feet north and south ; No. Ill, 00 feet east and west by 50 feet north
and south ; No. IV, 40 feet east and west and 70 feet north and south;
No. V, 195 feet east and west by 75 feet north and south ; No. VI, 100 feet
east and west by 70 feet north and south ; No. VII, 100 feet east and west
by 70 feet north and south ; No. VIII, 100 feet east and west by 60 feet
noith and south. I discovered in these ruins several gateways and pillars,
but no idols. These are evidently the remains of the eight “ halls of dispu-
tation,” described by Hwen Thsang as being built on the land between the
monasteries and the dwelling of the teachers of the “ right law.”
It is a remarkable fact that the line of mounds still bears the name
of “ dagop" by the country people. Is not this the ddgoba of the Pali
annals ? They are also called tild and dedra.
Subsequent to the excavations of October 1872, I employed with per-
mission, for some three or four weeks, the labour of about twenty prisoners,
and succeeded in making a deep cutting on the northern face of mound VII.
The result has been the partial uncovering of the northern fa9ade of a
square building flanked by four circular towers, about twenty-five feet in cir-
cumference. The whole of the wall is decorated with the most beautiful brick
mouldings divided by lines of niches, containing Buddhist figures at regular
intervals. The cornices which surround the towers are quite perfect, and the
whole exterior appears to have been traversed by small staircases leading to
the roof. The thorough exploration of these magnificent ruins would lead
to results as important to the historian as to the archsoologist, and I still
hope the task may be undertaken at no distant day by the Government.
Iliere are no difficulties to contend with ; the ground which is covered by
these mounds, is a barren waste, and the proprietor, Chaudhari Wahid ’Ali,
is quite willing to permit their excavation, and to facilitate matters as much
as he can.
Of the nature of these remains there can bo little doubt. Various
writers have made Bargaon the capital of a great kingdom, the seat of
the rale of some mysterious prince of Magadha ; but this theory seems
to me distinctly negatived by the appearance of the rains. At Bargaon
one sees no lofty wall ; no rugged battlements ; no rained towers and
bastions, — the characteristic features of Kusfigarapura, the royal city of
Bimbisara, or of Kajagriha, the capital of his son. The exploration of its
ruins already made, and every fresh excavation that may hereafter be accom-
plished, will, I think, lead to the conclusion that “ Vihara-gram” was merely
i> D
306 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
a great “ vihara” or college — perhaps rather a cluster of viharas — a uni-
versity, in fact, of Buddhist learning, Buddhist philosophy, and Buddhist divi-
nity— defended alone by its sanctity, patronised by a long succession of
princes, and regarded by Buddhists generally as the chief seat of their faith
from Tibbat to Ceylon.
XI.— Conclusion.
With the mound of rubbish and broken idols, which marks the site of
the once doubtless important vihara on the northern shore of the Jir lake,
ends my attempt to sketch the existing antiquities of Bihar.
Written, as it has been, at a distance from books and from those so able
and so willing to give me assistance, I feel sure that it must be replete with
errors and omissions ; but I shall feel my labours amply repaid, if I have
demonstrated to those who truly admire and understand the archaeology of
India, the vast importance of the subject. There is scarce a mile in the whole
tract of country which does not present to the traveller some object of deep
interest, and the curiosity thus awakened and intensified at almost every step,
is speedily concentrated as it were, on the ruinB of the hill-girt capital of
Magadha, or the mounds and figures which mark the site of the greatest of
great Buddhistic viharas. The associations of the former bring us back to
that far distant Brahmanical period, the obscurity of which is dispersed
only at intervals by the occasional gleam of some recovered treasure
from the poetical storehouse of the Mahabharata or the Ra may ana ;
and then passing swiftly over the space of an unknown and indefinite
number of centuries recal to our recollection the birth and growth and
glory of the Buddhistic faith. Rajagriha belongs to one age of the
religion of Sakhya Muni, and Nalandd to another : the former to the
early days of the new faith ; to the time of true Buddhistic austerity ; of rude
buildings ; of mountain solitude ; of the constant contemplation which was
alone consummated in “ nirvaga the second to the age of artistic cultivation
and skill ; of a gorgeous and luxuriant style of architecture ; of deep philo-
sophical knowledge ; of profound and learned discussions ; and of rapid
progress in the path of civilization. In Rajgir, the archaeologist lights
uniformly on rude battlements of giant proportions ; on temples of the
crudest design ; and on cave dwellings of the greatest possible simplicity of
construction. The thousand years which elapsed brought about a vast and
remarkable change : the grottoes of the “ arhata” gave place to the four-
storied and highly ornamented pagodas of the ecclesiastics of Bargaon ;
the four laws of Sakhya Muni were overladen with the interpretations and
commentaries of a countless multitude of sages and philosophers ; the simple
topes of Rajagriha were exchanged for a style of architecture more gaudy and
307
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihdr.
elaborate perhaps, than any in the world ; and intricate and profound dis-
cussions took the place of bodily austerity and mental abstraction. The
monastery, or, more . strictly speaking, the university of Nalanda, was
as it were a circle from which Buddhist philosophy and teaching diffused
itself over Southern Asia. It was here that Aryadeva of Ceylon attached
himself to the person of the great teacher Nagurjuna and adopted his
religious opinions, and it was here that Hwen Thsang spent a great portion
of his pilgrimage in search of religious instruction.
But even in the far off times when Buddhism was as yet unknown,
the remote period of Krishna and Bhima and Jarasandha, we find the
natural features of liajagriha almost the same as when Sakhya Muni trod
its mountain sides, five centuries before the birth of Christ, as when Hwen
Thsang again described them after the lapse of eleven hundred years, or as
they are seen year after year during our own time by the English traveller
or the Jaina pilgrim. Let me quote a few lines from the great Sanskrit
Epic, the deep interest of the subject being my excuse.
Mahabhdrata, Sabhdparva, 795 — 801, and 807 — 811.
wr i
srnaf i
Jiff strir? qqqt •,
iircri fjrfxT?m=5j ur i
qq UIV? ST^T^T WrfrT qqj*TTftl?q»r*Wq i
fjTKBHli imrsi: Tl«: |
q^TTT PwiTi qwqpqr i
srqr q?fqfjifwt<r T3vr^f^q^*rr: i
qw qi ir^TUKi: q4m: i
K^qflqrfsnjTO ri^rtnpT fjrfrqqr i
fsfjrgi qq wrqrf qtrfasHfsnfi I
^qfcqraiT «T»IVT SffTT-' I
stf>r flight MATTO qrujqq^ |
qq UIUJ qq qjjj ^TT^q' I
qtqtfqfeqgqqqi qjqre^Tsfwrjqw i
qqwreT^r <t*h l
qqqgffT St w; q&i qrrtTT fqqqiispj: |
J ■*
308 A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
srT^: qcr^pTJi« <ry i
l^q-garw-Tqrf I
wtaTfg^i?rnr**mre^-g 1
WWT ?TT *?RT»J[?J VXW fufxvf^ei |
TOUTSf WTJT ^TJI^TfyfH: 1
Tjurur^n^ *sf^T ^csjqrrwryTti^R^ |
Translation ly the Rev. Dr. J. Wenger.
Passing the lovely Sarayu, seeing eastward Kosala, going onward they
proceeded to (towards?) Mithild, Mala, the Charmanvati river; (796) and
passing the Ganges and the Son a, those three immortal ones, with their faces
eastward, and dressed in clothes of husa grass, went on towards the Mfigadha
territory ; and (797) having reached Goratha, that mountain ever crowded
with cattle-wealth, (abundantly) watered, (covered) with beautiful trees saw
the Magadlm city. (798) 0 king ! great, full of cattle, well watered, salubrious,
Wlth llne buildings does it look, that goodly Magadha residence.
'99i\rra’ that &rand mountain* Varaha (= Boar ?), and Yrishabha
(_ Bull.),aS weUas the Eishi-mountain,- Sir- goodly ones, having
Chaityaka as their fifth (companion)— (800) these five large peaked
mountains, covered with cool trees, (look) as if they, closely encompassing
!t with their compact bodies, protected Girwraja, (801) though they are
hidden m woods, dear to lovers, of lodhra trees, and (adorned) with boughs
dressed 111 blossoms,— fragrant and lovely (forests).
(807) Magadha (town) was made by Man u so that the clouds might
not avoid it; Kaushika and Madman also conferred favours upon it
(808) Having got a residence so lovely, and on all sides difficult to attack
Jarasandha prides himself on his success ; but on encountering him we will
to-day mar his pride. (809) Having thus spoken, the valiant brothers all,
Yarshneya and the two Prindavasa, set out for the Magadha town, (910)
and reached it, even Girivraja, frequented by a people in excellent condition
of body, crowded with men of the four castes, lidding high festival and
inaccessible to an assailant. (911) Then having reached the city ’gate,
which was a lofty hill, held in veneration by the descendants of Vrihadratha
and the (other) inhabitants of the town, they ran into the interior of (or, up
to) Chaityaka, the delight of the Magadha people, (or, the ornament of ’the
Magadha city).f
r°ad fUr this ^enng
t 1 do not profess to understand the last lino. Perhaps the clause “ they’™,' into
the interior of Chaityaka” should be inserted earlier, after the word “ hill ” Chaityaka
appears to have been a hill utilised as part of the fortifications of Magadha, (see liS
815) or it may have boon only a sacred tree, “ 9
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihar. 309
I must now bid adieu to the historical associations of Bihar, and endea-
vour to point out in as few words as possible the practical results of my
abours. First. The large number of inscriptions discovered by me, cover-
ing for the most part the base of some Buddhistic image or frieze, will tend
to throw considerable light on the history of the I>ala dynasty of Bengal.
In the chapter on Bihar I have given two of the time of Madanapala
and \ igraliapala ; in that on Ghosrawan and Titrawan three of Mahipala,
Ramapala, and Devapala ; and I now proceed to give two others belonrino'
respectively to the reigns of Gopala Deva and Mahipala. The former "was
lound.m situ at Nalamla, on the base of a very curious idol, of which the
following is a tolerably correct description : a four-armed figure of a goddess,
hree feet high, seated on the back of a lion-couchant. On either side of
the head are winged attendants. The hair is dressed in a conical shape, a
miniature figure of Buddha being seated in the midst of it. The head is
surrounded by an oval halo. The ornaments are as usual. The ri°ht lea-
is dependent from the throne, and rests on a lotus-blossom The” left is
gathered up on the lion’s back ; the sole of the foot, being turned outwards,
touches the right thigh and exhibits the “royal sign.” The upper hands'
are upraised ; the right holding a hammer, the left a mace. The lower hands
grasp pincers, and are stretched forth right and left in the act of seizins
the tongues of two unfortunate attendants who crouch at each corner of
the figure, with their hands tied with cords behind their backs
BSbu Rajendralala Mitrahas given the following transcript and transla-
tion ot the inscription in the plinth —
“ In the els,lth of the waxing moon in the month of A'svina, Samvat 7,
the most worshipful, the great king of kings, the great lord, Sri Gopala Baja,
and his wife the worshipful Vagisvari of the country of Suvallavi, erected
Labu BajendraMk remarks that the verb “ erected” is a conjectural
rendering of the doubtful letters ni md na, supposed to bo the remains of the
word nirmdna, but General Cunningham sees in the same characters the
word Nalanda. The inscription is of considerable historical importance
The next inscription also comes from Nalanda, and from the jamb of
the doorway described in the chapter on Buddhistic remains. The followi "
reading of it is by Babu Bajendralak Mitrar— “g
5iitos?rft<nsT 131U5T ii
310
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihar. [No. 3,
“ In the reign of Srimat Mahip&la Deva. Samvat 913 (= A. D. 856.)
This is a religious gift of Baldditya, the son of Gurudatta, and grandson
of Haradatta, a follower of the noble Malmyana school, a devout worship-
per, who came from (the city of) Kausambi, (wherein he was) the chief
among the wise men of the auspicious Taih'ujhaka (clan). Whatever merit
may accrue from this, may the same be to the advancement of the highest
knowledge among the mass of mankind. The end.”
The date is evolved by the translator from the words agni, “ lire,”
(= 3) ; rdgha, “power,” (= 1) ; and dvdra, “door,” (= 9), which being
transposed by the rule of ankasya vdmagati, gives 913.*
The two marks, however, which succeed the word samvat, somewhat
resemble the figure II, and Professor Eamkrishna Gopal Bhandarkar reads
it so accordingly. The inscriptions given in the present paper yield the
following royal names of the Pala race —
1. Go Pala.
2. Mahi Pala.
3. Madana Pala.
4. Vigraha Pala.
5. Deva Pala.
6. Rama Pala.
Nos. 4 and 6 arc additions to the list compiled by Babu Rdjendra-
lala Mitra from the combined results of several plates. Great light will be
thrown on the subject by the complete deciphering and translation of the
Munger plate, a task now in the able hands of the translator of the Nalan-
da inscriptions. I have, however, compiled the following list from the
sources at present available —
1. Oo Pala
2. Blianna Pala
3. Sura Pala
4. Main Pala
5. Deva Pala
6. Vigraha Pula I.
7. Madana Pala
8. Vigraha Pala II.
* Since supplying tlio above translation, I liave had an opportunity of examining
the jamb, and looking at tko smooth space after the word Samvat, just enough for
six letters, I am disposed to think that the figures or symbolical letters for the year
were never put in. The two upright strokes after the word are unmistakably ddndCs
and not figures. The word which I first read rdgha is radha, which is a name of the
month Vtmsdkha (April-May). This would give the date 3rd of Vaisakha. The words
dvaratate would in this case mean, “ spread on the door, i. e., the gift was given at
the °ate- E.Mitba.
1872.] A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic Bemains of Bihdr. 311
9. Bdjya Tula
10. Jaya Bala
11. Ndrdyana Bala
12. Mahendra Bala
13. Nay a Bala
14. llama Bdla
15. Govinda Bala.
The name of the last mentioned monarch occurs in an inscription in
Gaya, — dated, Samvat 1233, = A. D. 1175, and in another of 1135, =a A. D,
1178.
The Jcutila of the inscription of Rama Pala, is quite modern, hut
iji» exists on the plinth of a typical Buddhist figure. I place Rama
Pala, therefore, immediately before Govinda Pala, and assign to him
the approximate date of 1150. The carving in question is perhaps the
most beautiful in my collection, and its existence tends to shew Bud-
dhism in general, and the Titrdwan vihara in particular, flourishing within
fifty years of the Muhammadan conquest of Bihar. Everything 1 have
seen, tends to establish the comparatively modem existence of Buddhism in
Bihar, and even now Jain a (or in other words sectarian Buddhist') temples
crown the hills of Rajagriha, and exist and prosper, both at N a lan da and
in the city of Bihdr itself.
A careful examination of the plinths of all the idols would, I feel
convinced, disclose a greater number of inscriptions, nearly all of which would
tend more or less to throw light on the dates and succession of the great
line of Pala kings which between the eighth and the eleventh centuries at any
rate, exercised supreme power in Bihar. Everything I have found shews
the city of Bihar to have been their capital, so far at least as Magadha
was concerned, and to have been as important and prosperous during the
epoch I am writing of, as Kusdgarapura was at the time of Bimbisdra, or
Rajagriha under the auspices of his son Ajatasattru and his successors.
Secondly. — Socially speaking the figures now collected throw a great
deal of light on the domestic life of the times they belong to. They
illustrate most amply the shape and form of ornaments, weapons, and
utensils ; the character and pattern of dress (e. g., the existence of boots !),
the details of religious ceremony, the style of architecture, and every other
point connected with the manners and customs of the period. They serve
to show the effect of Buddhistic art on the national taste, and are invaluable
aids to the painter and sculptor. Thus much for the social aspect of the
question. But it may well be asked what has been the effect of the lono-
existence of Buddhism on Bihdr society, or has it merely passed over its
surface like a shallow stream, leaving no marks by which to track its
course ? Buddhism, the great leveller of caste distinctions, the social
312
A. M. Broadley — The Buddhistic (Remains of Bihar. [No. 3,
and religious system which saw no distinction between the Brahman and
the Sudra, the priest and the artificer, has had a considerable effect in
giving the great commercial clans of Bihar a position far different than
that which they would have occupied in a purely Brahmanieal community.
Nearly the whole trade of Bihar is in the hands of the Tells (or oil-sellers),
and they rank far higher than the majority of the banyan or merchant class.
This distinction has doubtless a foundation in Buddhistic times, when the
Tells had become leading men in the social scale.* The great doorway at
Bargaon was dedicated “ to the advancement of the highest knowledge”
by Baladitya — “ chief among the wise men of the Tailadliaka clan an image
near Giryak appears to have been “ consecrated by the pious devotion of a
Tell of Mathurd while the great Buddha at Bargdon is still called the Telia,
Bhanddr, and one of the most remarkable figures at Titrawan, — the Telia
Blmbe (?). In addition to this, the Ghosrawan tank is still called the Sao
Pokhar, — Sao being the common upddhi of the oilman’s tribe. I might
multiply instances of the effect of Buddhism on caste, but for the present
this will suffice.
Thirdly.— As regards the architecture and ceremonies of the Buddhistic
faith, and the history of its gradual development, the writer could receive no
little aid from a careful consideration of the Bihar sculptures. They also
tend to throw considerable light on the much vexed question of the priority
or otherwise of the Brdhmanical and Buddhist creeds. The great linya found
at Aphsar is an instance of what I mean. Everything I have found in Bihar
fully convinces mo of the anterior existence of Hinduism, the coeval duration
of both faiths, and the final decay of Buddhism, under the combined influence
of internal decay, Brahmanieal increasing power, and Muhammadan conquest.
I trust my readers will be now convinced that the historian, the artist,
and the antiquarian, may some day derive material assistance from an inspec-
tion and careful consideration of the temples and monasteries I have excavated,
and the collection I have formed. For myself I disclaim anything but the
very smallest amount of scientific knowledge on the subject, and cheerfully
leave the drawing of historical and social deductions and conclusions to
others, being more than content with the no small merit of having described
the greater part, arranged a lesser portion, and discovered a few of the Bud-
dhistic remains of Bihar in Patna.
* So largo is the proportion of Tells in Bihar society, that a common popular
refrain says —
CiPP LS) J13
Turks (Muhammadans J , Tells, and Tdr-palms, these three make up Bihar.
JOURNAL
or the
ASIATIC SOCIETY.
— ♦ —
Part I.— HISTORY, LITERATURE, &e.
No. IV.— 1872.
The. Tirthas of Vrindd-vana and Gokula. — By F. S. Gkowsh, M. A.,
B. C. S.
1. Vrinda'-vana.
Some six miles above Mathurd is a point where the right hank of the
Jamuna assumes the appearance of a peninsula, owing to the eccentricity of
the stream, which first makes an abrupt turn to the north and then as sud-
den a return upon its accustomed southern course, Here, washed on throe
of its sides by the sacred Hood, stands the town of Brinda-ban, at the present
day a rich and increasing municipality and for many centuries past one of
the most holy places of the Hindus. A little higher up the stream, a similar
promontory occurs, and in both cases the curious formation is traditionally
ascribed to the resentment of Baladeva. He, it is said, forgetful one day of
his habitual reserve, and emulous of his younger brother’s popular graces,
led out the Gopis for a dance upon the sands. But he performed his part
so badly, that tire Jamuna could not forbear from taunting him with his
failure, and recommending him never again to exhibit so clumsy an imita-
tion of Krishna’s agile movements. The stalwart god was much vexed at
tins criticism and, taking up the heavy plough which he had but that mo-
ment laid aside, he drew with it so deep a furrow from the shore that the
unfortunate river perforce fell into it, was drawn helplessly away and has
never since been able to recover its original channel.
Such is the local rendering of the legend ; but in the PurSnas and other
early Sanskrit authorities, the story is differently told, in this wise ; that as
Balarama was roaming through the woods of Brinda-ban, he found concealed
in the cleft of a kadamb tree some spirituous liquor, which he at once con-
sumed with his usual avidity. Heated by intoxication he longed above all
40
314
F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrinda-vana and OoJcula. [No. 4,
things for a bathe in the river, and seeing the Jamuna at some little distance,
he shouted for it to come near. The stream, however, remained deaf to his
summons ; whereupon the infuriated god took up his ploughshare and
breaking down the bank drew the water into a new channel, and forced it to
follow wherever he led. In the Bhigavata it is added that the Jamuna is
still to be seen following the course along which she was thus dragged.
Professor Wilson in his edition of the Vishnu Purana says, “ The legend pro-
bably alludes to the construction of canals from the Jamuna for the purpose
of irrigation ; and the works of the Muhammadans in this way, which are
well known, were no doubt preceded by similar canals dug by order of Hindi!
princes.” Upon this suggestion, it may be remarked first that in Upper India
no irrigation works of any extent are known ever to have been executed
either by Hindus or Muhammadans ; certainly, there are no traces of any
such operations in the neighbourhood of Brinda-ban ; and secondly, both
legends represent the Jamuna itself as diverted from its straight course into
a single winding channel, not as divided into a multiplicity of streams.
Hence it may more reasonably be inferred that the still existing involution
of the river is the sole foundation for the myth.
Like most of the local names in the vicinity, the word Brinda-ban is
derived from an obvious physical feature and, when first attached to the spot,
signified no more than the “ tulsl grove,” Irindu and tulsi being synonymous
terms, used indifferently to denote the sacred aromatic herb, known to bota-
nists as Ocymwn sanctum.
But this explanation is far too simple to find favour with the more mo-
dem and extravagant school of Vaishnava sectaries ; and in the Brahma
Vaivanta Purana, a mythical personage has been invented bearing the name
ofVrinda. According to that spurious composition (Brah. Vai., v. iv. 2)
the deified ltadha, though inhabiting the Paradise of Goloka, was not
exempt from human passions, and in a fit of jealousy condemned a Gopa by
name Srfdama to descend upon earth in the form of the demon Sankhachura.
He in retaliation sentenced her to become a nymph of Brinda-ban ; and there
accordingly she was bom, being as was supposed the daughter of Kedara,
but in reality the divine mistress of Krishna ; and it was simply his love for
her which induced the god to leave his solitary throne in heaven and be-
come incarnate. Hence in the following exhaustive list of Kadha’s titles as
given by the same authority (Brah. Vai., v. iv. 17) there are several which
refer to her predilection for Brinda-ban :
Jtadhd, Sasesvari, Itdsavdsini, ltdsikesvari,
hr is h. n a -p ru n a d h ih a , Krishna-priya, Krishna-swarupini,
Krishna, Vrindiivani, Vrindd, Vrinddvana-vinodini,
Chanddvati, Chandra-Jcantd, Sata-chandra-nibhdnand,
Krishna-vdmdnya-sambhutd, Parcmdnanda-rupini.
315
18?2.] F. S. Growse — The T'irthas of Yrindd-vana and OoJcula.
There is no reason to suppose that Brinda-ban was ever the seat of any
large Buddhist establishment ; and though from the very earliest period of
Brahmanical history it has enjoyed high repute as a sacred place of pil-
grimage, it is probable that for many centuries it was merely a wild uninha-
bited jungle, a description still applicable to Bhandir-ban on the opposite
side of the river, a spot of equal celebrity in Sanskrit literature. It was
only about the middle of the sixteenth century alter Christ that some holy
men from other parts of India came and settled there and built a small
shrine, which they dedicated to Brinda Devi. It is to their high reputation
for sanctity that the town is primarily indebted for all that it now possesses.
Its most ancient temples, four in number, take us back only to the reign of
our own Queen Elizabeth ; the stately courts that adorn the river bank and
attest the wealth and magnificence of the Bharatpur Bajas, date only from
the middle of last century ; while the space now occupied by a series of the
largest and most magnificent shrines ever erected in Upper India was fifty
years ago an unclaimed belt of jungle and pasture-ground for cattle. Now
that communication has been established with the remotest parts of India,
every year sees some splendid addition made to the artistic treasures of the
town ; as wealthy devotees recognize in the stability of British rule an
assurance that their pious donations will bo completed in peace and remain
undisturbed in perpetuity.
At the present time there are within the limits of the municipality
about a thousand temples, including of course many which strictly speaking
are merely private chapels, and fifty ghats constructed by as many Bajas.
The peacocks and monkeys, with which the place abounds, enjoy the benefit
of special endowments, bequeathed by deceased Princes of Kota and Bharat-
pur. There are some iifty chhattras, or dole houses, for the distribution of
alms, and extraordinary donations are not unfrequently made by royal and
distinguished visitors. Thus the llaja of Datia, a few years ago, made an
offering to every single shrine and every single Brahman that was found in
the city. The latter order constitute a fourth of the whole population, which
amounts to 21,000 ; while the Bairagis and Vaishnavas also muster strong,
being in all not less than 5000 or 0000. The Vaishnavas are of five schools
or Sampradayas, called respectively Sri Vaishnava, Vishnu Swami (this is the
predominant class at Gokul), Nimarak Vaishnava, and Madliava \ aishnava.
In the time of the emperors, the Muhammadans made a iutile attempt to
abolish the ancient name, Brinda-ban, and in its stead substitute that of
Muminabad ; but now more wisely they leave the place to its own Hindu
name and devices, and keep themselves as clear of it as possible. Thus,
besides an occasional official, there are in Brinda-ban no followers of the
prophet beyond only some fifty families who live close together in its out-
skirts, and are all of the humblest order, such as oilmen, lime-burners, and
the like.
316
F. S. Growse — The Tvrfhas of Vrindd-vana and Gokula. [No. 4,
But, as said above, the foundation of all this material prosperity and
religious exclusiveness was laid by the Gosains who established themselves
there in the reign of Akbar. The leaders of the community were by name
Bupa and feanatana from Gain* in Bengal, They were accompanied by six
others, ol whom three, Jiva, Madhu and Gopul Bhat, came from the same
neighbourhood, Swami Hari Das from Rajpur in the Mathura District, Hari
bans from Deva-ban in Saharanpur, and Byas Hari Earn from Orcha in
Bundelkhand. It is said that, in 1570, the emperor was induced to pay
them a visit, and was taken blindfold into the sacred enclosure of the Nidh-
ban,# where such a marvellous vision was revealed to him, that he was fain
to acknowledge the place as indeed holy ground. Hence the cordial sup-
port which he gave to the attendant liajas, when they declared their inten-
tion of erecting a series of buildings more worthy of the local divinity.
The four temples, commenced in honour of this event, still remain,
though in a ruinous and sadly neglected condition. They bear the titles of
Gobind Deva, Gopi-niith, Jugal-kishor, and Madan Mohan. The first named
is not only the finest of this particular series, but is the most impressive
religious edifice that Hindu art has ever produced, at least in Upper India,
the body ol the building is in the form of a Greek cross, the nave being a
hundred feet in length and the breadth across the transepts the same. The
central compartment is surmounted by a dome of singularly graceful propor-
tions ; and the four arms of the cross are roofed by a waggon vault of point-
ed form, not — as is usual in Hindu architecture — composed of overlapping
brackets, but constructed of true radiating arches as in our Gothic cathe-
drals. The walls have an average thickness of ten feet, and are pierced in
two stages, the upper stage being a regular triforium, to which access is
obtained by an internal staircase. At the east entrance of the nave, a small
n art hex projects fifteen feet ; and at the west end, between two niches and
incased in a rich canopy of sculpture, a square-headed doorway leads into
the choir, a chamber some twenty leet deep. Beyond this was the sacrarium,
flanked on either side by a lateral chapel ; each of these three cells being of
the same dimensions as the choir and like it vaulted by a lofty dome. The
general effect of the interior is not unlike that produced by St. Paul’s cathe-
dral in London. The latter building has greatly the advantage in size, but
in the other, the central dome is more elegant, while the richer decoration
of the wall surface and the natural glow of the red sandstone supply that
relief and warmth of colouring which are so lamentably deficient in its Wes-
tern rival.
* The derivation of this word is a little questionable. It is the local name of the
actual Brinda grove, to which the town owes its origin. The spot so designated is now
of very limited area, hemmed in on all sides by streets, but protected from further
encroachment by a liigh masonry wall.
1872.] E. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Yrindd-vcina and Gohnla. 317
There must originally have been seven towers, ono over the central
dome, one at the end of each transept, and the other four covering respec-
tively the choir, sacrarium and two chapels. The sacrarium has been utter-
ly razed to the ground, and the other six towers levelled with the roof of the
nave. Their loss has terribly marred the effect of the exterior, which must
have been extremely majestic when the west front with its lofty triplet was
supported on either side by the pyramidal mass of the transepts and backed
by the still more towering height that crowned the central dome. The
choir tower was of slighter elevation ; occupying the same relative position
as the spirelet over the sanctus bell in Western ecclesiology. The ponderous
walls, albeit none too massive to resist the enormous thrust once brought to
bear upon them, now, however much relieved by exuberant decoration, ap-
pear out of all proportion to the comparatively low superstructure. As a
further disfigurement, a plain masonry wall has been run along the top of
the centre dome. It is generally believed that this was built by Aurangzib
for the purpose of desecrating the temple ; though it is also said to have
been put by the Hindus themselves to assist in some grand illumination.
In either case it is an ugly modern excrescence, and steps should be at once
taken for its removal.
Under one of the niches at the west end of the nave is a tablet with a
long Sanskrit inscription. This has unfortunately been much mutilated,
but enough remains as record of the fact that the temple was built in Barn-
hat 1617, i. e., A. D. 1590, under the direction of the two Gurus Kupa and
Sanatana. The founder, Baja Man Sinha, was a Kachhwaha Thakur, son of
Raja Bhagawan Das of Amber, founder of the temple at Gobardhan, and an
ancestor of the present Raja of Jaypur. He was appointed by Akbar suc-
cessively Governor of the districts along the Indus, of Kabul, and of Bihar.
By his exertions, the whole of Orisa and Eastern Bengal were reannexed ;
and so highly were his merits appreciated at court, that though a Hindu, he
was raised to a higher rank than any other officer in the realm. He married
a sister of Lakshmi Narayan, Raja of Koch Bihar, and at the time of his
decease, which was in the 9tli year of the reign of Jahangir, he had living one
son, Bhao Sihha, who succeeded him upon the throne of Amber, and died in
1621, A. D.# There is a tradition to the effect that Akbar at the last, jea-
lous of his powerful vassal, and desirous to rid himself of him, had a confec-
tion prepared, part of which contained poison ; but caught in his own snare
he presented the innoxious portion to the Raj a and ate that drugged with
death himself. The unworthy deed is explained by Man Sinha’s design
which apparently had reached the Emperor’s ears, to alter the succession in
favour of Khusrau, his nephew, instead of Sali'm.f
* Vide Professor Blochmann’s Ain i Akbari, p. 34.1.
t The above tradition is quoted from Tod’s Rajasthan.
318
F . S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrindd-vana and Oolcwla. [No. 4,
In anticipation of a visit from Aurangzib, tiro image of the god was
transferred to Jaypur, and the Gosaiu of the temple there has ever since
been regarded as the head of the endowment. The name of the present in-
cumbent is Syam Sundar, who has two agents resident at Brinda-ban.
There is said to be still in existence at Jaypur the original plan of the temple,
shewing its seven towers, but there is a difficulty in obtaining any de-
finite information on the subject. However, local tradition is fully agreed as
to their number and position ; while their architectural character can be
determined beyond a doubt by comparison with the smaller temples of the
same age and style, the ruins of which still remain. It is therefore not a
little strange that of all the architects who have described this famous
building, not one has noticed this, its most characteristic feature : the
harmonious combination of dome and spire is still quoted as the great crux
of modem art, though nearly 300 years ago the difficulty was solved by
the Hindds with characteristic grace and ingenuity.
It is much to bo regretted that this most interesting monument has
not been declared national property and taken under the immediate protec-
tion ol Government. At present no care whatever is shewn for its preserva-
tion : large trees are allowed to root themselves in the fissures of the walls,
and in the course of a few more years the damage done will be irreparable!
As a modern temple under the old dedication has been erected in the
precincts, no religious prejudices would be offended by the state’s appropria-
tion of the ancient building. If any scruples were raised, the objectors
might have the option of themselves undertaking the necessary repairs.
But it is not probable that they would accept the latter alternative ; for
though the original endowment was very large, it has been considerably
reduced by mismanagement, and the ordinary annual income is now
estimated at no more than Rs. 17,500,* the whole of which is absorbed
in the maintenance of the modern establishment.
The next temple to be described, viz. that of Madan Mohan, one of
Krishna’s innumerable titles, stands at the upper end of the town on the river-
bank near the Kali-mardan Ghat, where the god trampled on the head of the
great serpent Kali, It consists of a nave 57 feet long, with a choir of 20
feet square at the west end, and a sanctuary of the same dimensions beyond.
The total height of the nave would seem to have been only about 22 feet,
but its vaulted roof has entirely disappeared : the upper part of the choir
tower has also been destroyed. That surmounting the sacrarium is a lofty
octagon of curvilinear outline tapering towards the summit ; and attached to
its south side is a tower-crowned chapel of precisely similar elevation, and
differing only in the one respect that its exterior surface is enriched with
, , * 0f‘lT smn only Rs' <t>500 are derivod from laud and house property : the
balance of Rs. 13,000 is made up by votive offerings.
310
1872.] F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of VrvnM-mna and Golcula.
sculptured panels, while the other is quite plain. Over its single door,
which is at the east end, is a Sanskrit inscription, given first in Bengali and
then in Nagari characters, which runs as follows :
^ftqrn
jrfwfwfc^r W i
J J
f»J tTfwfsf^^rPJT II
The above, it is believed, has never been copied before. As the letters
were raised, instead of incised, and also much worn, a transcript was a
matter of some little difficulty ; and the Brahman in charge of the shrine
declared the inscription to he absolutely illegible, or at least if the letters
could be decyphered, quite unintelligible. The information it gives is
certainly not very perspicuous, and there is no indication of a date ; hut we
are enabled to gather thus much that the chapel at all events was founded
by a Guhavansa,* hearing the name of Gunanand. The main building,
which may possibly bo a little older, is popularly ascribed to one Bam Das,
a Kshatriya of Multan. The court-yard is entered, after the ascent of a flight
of steps, through a massive square gateway with a pyramidal tower, which
groups very effectively with the two towers of the temple. As the buildings
are not only in ruins, hut also from peculiarities of style ill-adapted to
modern requirements, they are seldom if ever used for religious service, which
is ordinarily performed in an elegant and substantial edifice erected on the
other side of the street under the shadow of the older fane. The annual
income is estimated at Es. 10,100 ; of which sum Es. 8,000 are the
voluntary offerings of the faithful, while only Es. 2,100 are derived from
permanent endowment. A branch establishment at Eadha Kund with the
same dedication is also supported from the funds of tho parent house.
The temple of Gopinath, which may bo slightly the earliest of the
series, is said to have been built by B&esil Ji, a progenitor of the Shaikhawat
branch of the Kachhwaha Thiikurs. This great K&jput family claim ultimate
descent from Baloji, the third son of Eaja Uday Karan, who succeeded to
the throne of Amber in 1389, A. D. To Baloji fell by inheritance the district
of Amritsar, and after him to his son Mokal. This latter was long childless
till through the blessing of the Muhammadan saint Shaikh Burhan, he
became the father of a son called after his spiritual progenitor, Shaikh Ji.
He is accounted the patriarch of all the ShaikMwat race, who for more than
four centuries have continued to observe the obligations originally contracted
with him. At the hirtli of every male infant, a goat is sacrificed, and while
the kalimah is recited, the child is sprinkled with the blood. He is invested
with the baddhiya, or cross-strings, usually worn by little Muhammadans ;
* This word is a little quostionublo and may bo read “ Guruvansa.”
320
F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Yrindd-vana and OoJcula. [No. 4,
and when ho laid them aside, he was bound to suspend them at the saint’s
dargali still existing six miles from Achrol. For two years he wears a blue
tunic and cap, and for life abstains from hog’s llesh and all meat in which
the blood remains. Shaikh J i, by conquest from his neighbours, consolidated
under his own sway 300 villages, in complete independence of the parent
state of Amber : and they so continued till the time of Sawai Jay Sinha, the
founder of Jaypur. Shaikh Ji’s lioir Haemal had three sons, Non-karan,
Raesil and Gopal. By the advice of Devi Das, a shrewd minister, who had
been dismissed by Non-Karan, Raesil proceeded to Dihli with a following
of 20 horse men, and so distinguished himself in the repulse of an Afghan
invasion, that Akbar bestowed upon him the title of Darbari with a grant of
land and the important command of 1,250 horse. Khandela and Udaypur,
then called Kasumbi, which ho conquered from the Narbhans, a branch of
the Cliauhans, after contracting a marriage with the daughter of the prince
of that race, because the principal cities of the Shaikhawat confederation .
He accompanied his liege lord, Raja Man Sinha of Amber against the Mewrr
Rana Pratdp, and further distinguished himself in the expedition to Kabul.
The date of his death is not known.* The temple, of which he is the
reputed founder, corresponds very closely both in style and dimensions with
that of Madan Mohan already described ; and has a similar chapel attached
to the south side of the sacrarium. It is, however, in a far more ruinous
condition : the nave has entirely disappeared ; the three towers have been
levelled with the roof ; and the entrance gateway of tho court-yard is
tottering to its fall. The special feature of the building is a curious arcade
of three bracket arches, serving apparently no construetural purpose, but
merely added as an ornamental screen to tho bare soutli wall. The choir-
arch is also of handsome design, elaborately decorated with arabesque
sculptures ; but it is partly concealed from view by mean sheds which have
been built up against it, while the interior is used as a stable and the north
side is blocked by the modern temple. The votive offerings here made are
estimated at Rs. 3,000 a year, in addition to which there is an endowment
yielding an annual income of Rs. 1,200.
Tho temple of Jugal Kislior, the last of the old series, stands at the
lower end of tho town near the Kesi Ghat. Its construction is referred to
the year Sambat 1GS4, i. e. 1027 A. D., in the reign of Jahangir, and the
founder’s name is preserved as Non-Karan. He is said to have been a
Chauhdn Thakur ; but it is not improbable that he was the elder brother of
Raesil, who built the temple of Gopinath. The choir, which is slightly
larger than in the other examples, being 25 feet square, has the principal
entrance, as usual, at the east end ; but is peculiar in having also, both north
Hie above particulars are extracted from Tod’s Kajastkan and Professor
Bloohmaim’s don i Akbari.
321
1872.] F. S. Growse — The Tlrthas of Vrindd-vana and Qoleula.
and south, a small doorway under a hood supported on eight closely-set
brackets carved into the form of elephants. The nave has been completely
destroyed. Three other temples, dedicated respectively to Radha Ballabh,
Chir Bihari, and Radha Damodar, put forward claims to considerable anti-
quity ; hut, as buildings, they possess no special architectural merit. The
same may be said of the Bengali temple of Sring&r Bat, near the Madan
Mohan, which, however, enjoys an annual income of its. 13,500, divided
among three shareholders, who each take the religious services for four
months at a time. The village of Jahangirpur, on the opposite bank of the
river, including the sacred grove of Bel-ban, forms part of the endowment.
Of the modern temples five claim special notice. The first in time of
erection is the temple of Krishna Chandrama, built about the year 1810,
at a cost of 25 lakhs, by the wealthy Bengali Kayath, Krishan Chandra
Sinha, better known as the Labi 156 bu. It stands in a large court yard,
which is laid out, not very tastefully, as a garden, and enclosed by a lofty
wall of solid masonry, with an arched gateway at either end. The building
is of quadrangular form, 160 feet in length, with a front central compart-
ment of three arches and a lateral colonnade of five bays reaching back on
either side towards the cella. The workmanship throughout is of excellent
character, and the stone has been carefully selected. The two towers, or
sikharas, are singularly plain ; but have been wisely so designed, that their
smooth polished surface may remain unsullied by rain and dust.
The founder’s ancestor, Babu Murli Mohan Sinha, son of one liar Krish-
na Sinha, was a wealthy merchant and landed proprietor at Kdndi in Murshid-
abad. His heir, Bihari Lai Sinha, had three sons, Radhd Gobind, Gangs
Gobind, and Radha Charan : of these the last-named, on inheriting his share of
the paternal estate, broke off connection with the rest of the family and has
dropped out of sight. Radha Gobind took service under Allah Virdi Khan and
Siraj-ud-daulah, Nawabs of Murshiddbad, and was by them promoted to posts
of high honour. A rest-house for travellers and a temple of Radha -ballabh
which he founded, are still in existence. He died without issue, leaving his
property to his brother, Ganga Gobind, who took a prominent part in the
revision of the Bengal settlement under Lord Wm. Bentinck in 1828. He
built a number of dharmsalas for the reception of pilgrims and lour temples
at Ramchandrapur in Nadiyd. These latter have all been washed away by
the river, but the images of the gods were transferred to Kdudi. He also
maintained several Sanskrit schools in Nadiya ; and distinguished himself
by the extraordinary pomp with which he celebrated his father’s obsequies,
spending moreover evei’y year on the anniversary of his death a lakh of
rupees in religious observances. Ganga Gobind’s son, Pran Kishan Sinha, still
further augmented his magnificent patrimony before it passed in succession
to his son, Krishan Chandra Sinha, better known under the soubriquetof ‘ the
11 F F
322
F. S. Groiyse — The Tirthas of VrindA-vana and GoTcula. [No. 4,
Lala Babu.’ He hel<l office first in Bardwan and then in Orisa, and when
about thirty years oi ago, came to settle in the holy land of Braj. In con-
nexion with his temple at Brinda-ban he founded also a rest-house, where a
large number of pilgrims are still daily fed ; the annual cost of the whole
establishment being, as is stated, Rs. 22,000. He also enclosed the sacred
tanks at Radlia-kuud with handsome ghats and terraces of stone at the cost
of a lakh. When some forty years of age, he renounced the world, and in
the character of a Bainigi continued for two years to wander about the woods
and plains of Braj, begging his bi'ead from day to day till the time of his
death, which was accidentally caused by the kick of a horse at Gfobardhan.
He was frequently accompanied in his rambles by Mani Ram, father of the
famous Seth Lakhmi Chand, who also had adopted the life of an ascetic.
In the course of the ten years which the Lala Babu spent as a worldling in
the Mathura district, he contrived to buy up all the villages most noted as
places of pilgrimage in a manner which strikingly illustrates his hereditary
capacity for business. The zamindirs were assured that he had no pecuniary
object in view, but only the strict preservation of the hallowed spots. Again,
as in the days of Krishna, they would become the secluded haunts of the
monkey and the peacock, while the former proprietors would remain undis-
turbed, the happy guardians of so many new Arcadias. Thus the wise man
fiom the Bast picked up one estate after another at a price in every case far
below the real value, and in some cases for a purely nominal sum. How-
ever binding his fair promises may have been on the conscience of the pious
Babu, they were never recorded on paper, and therefore are naturally ignor-
ed by his absentee descendants and their agents, from whom any appeal ad
misericordiam on the part of the impoverished representatives of the old
owners of the soil meets with very scant consideration. The villages which
he acquired in the Mathura district are fourteen in number, viz., in the Kosi
Parganah, Jiiu ; in Chhiita, Nandg.,nw, Barsana, Sanket, Karhela, and Hathi-
ya; and in the home Parganah, Mathura, .Tait, Maholi and Nabi-pur, all
these, except the last, being more or less places of pilgrimage. He also ac-
quired by purchase from the Giijars the five villages of Pirpur, Gulalpur,
Chamar-gaphi and Dhlmri. For Nand-ganw he gave Rs. 900 ; for Barsana,
Rs. 600 ; for Sanket, Rs. S00 ; and for Karhela, Rs. 500 ; the annual revenue
derived from these places being now as follows ; from Nandg&nw, Rs. 6,712 ;
from Barsana, Rs. 3,109 ; from Sanket, Rs. 1,642 ; and from Karhela, Rs.
1 ,900. It may also be noted that payment was invariably made in Brinda-
ban rupees, which arc worth only 13 or 11 annas each. The Babu further
purchased seventy-two villages in ’Aligarh and Balandshahr from Raja Bir
Smha, Chauhiin ; but twelve of these were sold at auction in the-time of his
heir, Babii Sri Narayan Sinha. This latter, being a minor at his father’s
death, remained for a time under the tutelage of his mother, the Rani Kai-
323
1872.] F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrindd-vana and O alula.
tani, who again, on his decease when only thirty years old, managed the
estate till the coming of age of the two sons whom his widows had been
specially authorized to adopt. The elder of the two, Pratap Chandra,
founded an English school at Kandi and Dispensary at Calcutta. He was
for some time a Member of the Legislative Council of Bengal, received from
Government the title of Bahadur, and was enrolled as a Companion of the
Star of India. He died in 18G7 ; his brother Isvarchandra in 1803. The
latter left, one son, Indrachand, who with his three cousins, Puran-ehandra,
Kari-cliandra, and Sarad-chandra, the sons of Pratap-chandra, are the pre-
sent owners of the estate, which, during their minority is under the control
of the Court of Wards, the General Manager being Mr. Robert Harvey of
Calcutta.
The great temple, founded by Seth Gobind Das and Radha Krishan,
brothers of the famous millionaire Lakhmi Chand, is dedicated to Rang Ji,
a Dakhani title of Vishnu. It is built in the Madras style, in accordance
with plans supplied by their guru, the great Sanskrit scholar, Swami Rang&-
chari, a native of that part of India, who still presides over the magnifi-
cent establishment. The works were commenced in 1845 and completed in
1851, at a cost of 45 lakhs of Rupees. The outer walls measure 773 feet in
length by 440 in breadth, and enclose a fine tank and garden in addition to
the actual templc-court. This latter has lofty gate-towers, or gopuras,
covered with a profusion of coarse sculpture. In front of the god is erected
a pillar, or dhwajastha stamhha, of copper gilt, sixty feet in height and also
sunk some twenty-four feet more below the surface of the ground. This
alone cost Rs. 10,000. The principal or western entrance of the outer court
is surmounted by a pavilion, ninety-three feet high, constructed in the Ma-
thura style after the design of a native artist. In its graceful outlines and
the elegance of its reticulated tracery, it presents a striking contrast to the
heavy and misshapen masses of the Madras Gopura, which rises immediately
in front of it. A little to one side of the entrance is a detached shed, in
which the god’s rath, or carriage, is kept. It is an enormous wooden
tower in several stages, with monstrous effigies at the corners, and is brought
out only once a year in the month of Chait during the festival of the Brah-
motsav. The mela lasts for ten days, on each of which the god is taken
in state from the temple along the road a distance of 690 yards to a garden
where a pavilion has been erected for his reception. The procession is
always attended with torches, music, and incense, and some military display
contributed by the Raja of Bharatpur ; and on the closing day, when only
the rath is used, there is a' grand show of fireworks, which people of all
classes congregate from long distances to see. The image, composed of the
eight metals, is seated in the centre of the car, with attendant Brahmans
standing beside to fan it with chauries. Each of the Seths, with the rest of
324 F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrindd-vana and Gokola. [No. 4,
the throng, gives an occasional hand to the ropes by which the ponderous
machine is drawn ; and by dint of much exertion, the distance is ordinarily
accomplished in the space of about two and a half hours. On the other days
of the mela the god has a wide choice of vehicles, being borne now on a palki,
a richly gilt tabernacle (j>unya-ko(hi ), a throne (sinhdsan) , or a tree, either the
kadamb, or the tree of Paradise (kalpavriksha) , now oil some demi-god, as
the sun or the moon, Gar ura, llanuman, or Sesha ; now again on some ani-
mal, as a horse, an elephant, a lion, a swan, or the fabulous eight-footed
Sarabha. The ordinary cost of one of these celebrations is over Rs. 20,000,
while the annual expenses of the whole establishment amount to no less than
Rs. 57,000, the largest item in that total being Rs. 30,000 for the religious
services or hhorj. Every day 500 of the Sri Yaishnava sect are fed at the
temple, and every morning up to 10 o’clock a dole of ata is given to any
one who chooses to apply for it.
If the elfoct of the Seth’s lavish endowment is impaired by the ill-
judged adoption of a foreign stylo of architecture ; still more is this error
apparent in the temple of R&dha Raman, completed within the last few years.
The founder is Sail Kundan Lai of Lucknow, who has built on a design sug-
gested by the modem secular buildings of that city. The principal entrance
to the court yard is, in a grandiose way, decidedly effective ; and the temple
itself is constructed of the most costly materials and fronted with a colon-
nade of spiral marble pillars, each shaft being of a single piece, which though
rather too attenuated, is unquestionably elegant. The mechanical execution
is also good, but all is rendered of no avail by the abominable taste of the
design. The fa9ade with its uncouth pediment, flanked by sprawling mon-
sters, and its row of life-size female figures in meretricious but at the same
time most ungraceful attitudes, resembles nothing so much as a disreputable
London casino ; a severe, though unintended, satire on the character of the
divinity to whom it is consecrated. Ten lakhs of rupees are said to have
been wasted on its construction.
In striking contrast to this tasteless edifice is the temple of Radha
Indra Kislior, built by Rani Indrajit Kunwar, widow of Het Ram, Brah-
man, zamindar of Tik6ri by Gaya. It has been six years in building, and
was completed at the end of 1871. It is a square of seventy feet divided
into three aisles of five bays each, with a fourth space of equal dimensions for
the reception of the god. The si/chara is surmounted with a copper halos, or
finial, heavily gilt, which alone cost Rs. 5000. The piers are composed of
four conjoined pillars, each shaft being a single piece of stone, brought from
the Paharpur quarry in Bharatpur territory. The building is raised on a
high and enriched plinth, and the entire design is singularly light-and grace-
ful. Its oost has been three lakhs.
The temple of Radlia GopSl, built by the Maharfija of Gwaliar, under
325
1872.] F. S. Growse — The Tlrthas of Vrindd-vana and GoTcula.
the direction of his guru Brahmacliari Giri-dhari Das is also entitled to
some special notice. The interior is an exact counterpart of an Italian
church, and would be an excellent model for our architects to follow, since
it secures to perfection both free ventilation and a softened light. It
consists of a nave 58 feet long, with four aisles, two on either side, a
sacrarium 21 feet in depth and a narthex of the same dimensions at the
entrance. The outer aisles of the nave, instead of being closed in with solid
walls, have open arches stopped only with wooden bars ; and the tier of
windows above gives on to a balcony and verandah. Thus any glare of light
is impossible. The building was opened for religious service in I860, and as
it stands has cost four lakhs of rupees. The exterior has a mean and
unsightly appearance, which might be obviated by the substitution of
reticulated stone tracery for the wooden bars of the outer arches below and
a more substantial balcony and verandah in lieu of the present rickety
erection above.
There are in Brinda-ban no secular buildings of any great antiquity.
The oldest is the court, or Ghera, as it is called, of Sawai Jay Sinha, the found-
er of Jaypur, who made Brinda-ban an occasional residence during the time
that he was Governor of the Province of A'grah (1721-1728). It is a large
walled enclosure with a pavilion at one end consisting of two aisles divided
into five bays by piers of coupled columns of red sandstone. The river
front of the town has a succession of ghats reaching for a distance of about
a mile and half ; the one highest up the stream being the Kali-mardan Ghat
with the kadamb tree from which Krishna plunged into the water to
encounter the great serpent Kaliya ; and at the other end Kesi Ghat, where
he slew the equine demon of that name. Near the latter are two handsome
mansions built by the Itanis Kishori and Lachhmi, consorts of Eanjit Sinha
and Randhir Sinha, two successive Rajas of Bharatpur. In both, the arrange-
ment is identical with that of a mediaeval college, carried out on a miniature
scale but with extreme elaboration of detail. The buildings are disposed
in the form of a quadrangle, with an enriched gateway in the centre of one
front and opposite it the chapel, of more imposing elevation than the ordinary
domestic apartments which constitute the two Hanks of the square. In
Rani Lachlimi’s kunj, (such being the distinctive name for a building of this
character) the temple front is a very rich and graceful composition, with a
colonnade ol five arches standing on a high plinth, which like every part of
the wall surface is covered with the most delicate carving, and shaded above
by overhanging eaves supported on bold brackets. The work of the elder
Rani is of much plainer character ; and a third kunj, which stands a little
lower down the river, close to the temple of Dhir Samir, built by Thakur
Badan Sinha, the father of Suraj Mai, the first of the Bharatpur Rajas,
though large, has no architectural pretensions whatever. The most striking
326
F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrindd-vana and Gokula. [No. 4,
of the whole series is, however, the Ganga Mohan Kunj, built in the next
generation by Ganga, Suraj Mai’s Rani. The river front, which is all that
was ever completed, has a high and massive basement story, which, on the
land side as seen from the interior of the court, becomes a mere plinth for
the support of a majestic double cloister with broad and lofty arch and
massive clustered pier. The style is precisely the same as that which
prevails in the Garden Palace at Dig, a work of the same chief ; who,
however rude and uncultured himself, appears to have been able to appreciate
and command the services of the highest available talent whether in the
arts of war or peace.
2. Gokula.
The town of Malia-ban is some five or six miles from Mathura, lower
down the stream and on the opposite bank of the Jamuna. It stands a little
in land, about a mile distant from Gokul, which latter place has appropriated
the more famous name, though it is in reality only the modern water side
suburb of the ancient town. All the traditional sites of Krishna’s adven-
tures, described in the Puranas as being at Gokul, are shewn at Maha-ban,
which in short is the place intended whenever Gokul is mentioned in
Sanskrit literature. However, in consequence of its retaining the more
famous name, Gokul is popularly credited with a far greater amount of
sanctity. From the opposite side of tho river it has a very picturesque
appearance ; but on nearer approach its tortuous streets are found to be
inconceivably mean, crowded, and unsavoury, in the rains mere channels for
the floods, which pom1 down through them to the Jamuna, and at all other
times of the year so rough and broken by the action of the wator, that the
rudest wheeled vehicle can with difficulty make its way along them. Stre-
nuous efforts have been made within the last few years to improve its sanita-
tion, but the Gosain Mu’afidars, the descendants (through his only son
Bitthal-nath) of the famous Vallabhaeharaj, who settled there in Sambat
1535, are most impracticable and intolerant of reform. The filthy condi-
tion of the place is largely owing to the enormous number of cattle driven
within its walls every night, which render it really what the name denotes
a cow-stall,’ rather than a human habitation. The temples amount to a
prodigious number, but they are all mean in appearance and recent in date ;
and the only noteworthy ornament of the town is a large masonry tank
constructed some thirty years ago by a Seth, named Chunna.
The trees on its margin are always white with flocks of large water-fowl,
of a quite distinct species from any to be found elsewhere in the neighbour-
hood. They are a new colony, being all descended from a few pairs which
casually settled there no more than 10 or 12 years ago. Their plumage is
peculiai and ornamental, but difficult to obtain, as the birds are considered
327
1872.] F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrindd-vana and GoJcula.
to enjoy the benefit of sanctuary ; and on one occasion when a party of
soldiers from the Mathurk cantonments attempted to shoot some of them,
the towns people rose en masse for their protection.
Maha-ban, the true Gokul, is by legend closely connected with Mathura ;
for Krishna was bom at the one and cradled at the other. Both, too, make
their first appearance in history together and under most unfortunate circum-
stances as sacked by Mahmud of Ghazni in the year 1017, A.D. From the
effects of this catastrophe, it would seem that Maha-ban was never able to
recover itself. It is casually mentioned in connection with the year 1234
A. I)., by Minhaj i Siraj, a contemporary writer, as one of the gathering-
places for the imperial army sent by Shams ud-din against Kalinjar ; and
the' Emperor Babar, in his Memoirs, incidentally refers to it, as if it were
a place of some importance still, in the year 1526, A. D. ; but the name
occurs in the pages of no other chronicle ; and at the present day, though
it is the seat of a Tahsili, it can scarcely be called more than a consider-
able village. Within the last few years one or two large and hand-
some private residences have been built with fronts of carved stone in
the Mathura style ; but the temples are all exceedingly mean and of no
antiquity. The largest and also the most sacred is that dedicated to
Mathura-nath, which boasts of a pyramidal tower, or sikhara, of some height
and bulk, but constructed only of brick and plaster. The Brahman in
charge used to enjoy an endowment of Rs. 2 a day, the gift of Sindhia, but
this has long lapsed. There are two other small shrines of some interest :
in the one the demon Trinavart is represented as a pair of enormous wings
overhanging the infant god ; the other bears the dedication of Maha Mall
Rae, the great champion Prince, a title given to Krishna after his discomfi-
ture of the various evil spirits sent against him by Kansa.
Great part of the town is occupied by a high hill, partly natural
and partly artificial, extending over more than 100 bighas of land,
where stood the old fort. Upon its most elevated point is shewn a small
cell, called Syam Lala, believed to mark the spot where J asoda gave birth
to Maya, or Joga-nidra, substituted by Yasudeva for the infant Krish-
na. But by far the most interesting building is a covered court called
Nandas Palace, or more commonly the Assi Khamba, i. e. the Eighty Pillars.
It is divided by five rows of sixteen pillars each into four aisles, or rather
into a centre and two narrower side aisles with one broad outer cloister.
The external pillars of this outer cloister are each of one massive shaft, cut
into many narrow facets, with two horizontal bands of carving : the capitals
are decorated either with grotesque heads or the usual four squat figures.
The pillars of the inner aisles vary much in design, some being exceedingly
plain and others as richly ornamented with profuse and often graceful
arabesques. Three of the more elaborate are called respectively the Satya,
328
F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrinda-vana and Golcula. [No. 4,
Dwapar, and Treta Yug ; while the name of the Kali Yug is given to another
somewhat plainer. All these interior pillars, however, agree in consisting as
it were of two short columns set one upon the other. The style is precisely
similar to that of the Hindu colonnades by the Qutb Minar at Delhi ; and
both works may reasonably be referred to about the same age. As it is
probable that the latter were not built in the years immediately preceding
the fall of Delhi in 1194, so also it would seem that the court at Mahd-ban
must have been completed before the assault of Mahmud in 1017 ; for after
that date the place was too insignificant to be selected as the site of so
elaborate an edifice. Thus Fergusson’s conjecture is confirmed that the
Delhi pillars are to be ascribed to the ninth or tenth century. Another long-
mooted point may also be considered as almost definitely set at rest, for it*can
scarcely be doubted that the pillars as they now stand at Maha-ban occupy
their original position. Forgusson, who was unaware of their existence, in
his notice of the Delhi cloister, doubts whether it now stands as originally
arranged by the Hindus, or whether it had been taken down and re-arranged
by the conquerors ; but concludes as most probable that the former was the
case, and that it was an open colonnade surrounding the Palace of Prithi
Kaj. “ II so,” he adds, “ it is the only instance known of Hindu pillars being
left undisturbed.” General Cunningham comments upon these remarks,
finding it utterly incredible that any architect, designing an original build-
ing and wishing to obtain height, should have recourse to such a rude
expedient as constructing two distinct pillars, and then without any disguise
piling up one on the top of the other. But, however extraordinary the
procedure, it is clear that this is what was done at Maha-ban, as is proved by
the outer row of columns, which are each of one unbroken shaft, yet precisely
the same in height as the double pillars of the inner aisles. The roof is
flat and perfectly plain except in two compartments, where it is cut into a
pretty quasi-dome of concentric multifoil circles. Mothers come here for
their purification on the sixth day after child-birth — chhathi p vja — and it is
visited by enormous crowds of people for several days about the anniversary
of Krishna’s birth in the month of Bhddon. A representation of the infant
god’s cradle is displayed to view, with his foster-mother’s chum and other
domestic articles. The place being regarded not exactly as a temple, but as
Nanda and Jasoda’s actual dwelling-house, Europeans are allowed, to walk
about in it with perfect freedom. Considering the size, the antiquity, the
artistic excellence, the exceptional archaeological interest, the celebrity
amongst natives, and the close proximity to Mathura of this building, it is
perfectly marvellous that it found no mention whatever in the archaeological
abstract prepared in every district by orders of Government a few years ago,
nor even in the costly work compiled by Lieut. Cole, the Superintendent of
the Archseologieal Survey, which professes to illustrate the architectural
antiquities of Mathura and its neighbourhood.
329
1872.] F. S. Grows e—The Tirthas of Vrindd-vana and GoJcula.
Let into the outer wall of the Nand Bhavan is a small figure of Bud-
dha ; and it is said that whenever foundations are sunk within the precincts
of the fort, many fragments of sculpture — of Buddhist character, it may be
presumed — have been brought to light : but hitherto they have always been
buried again, or broken up as building materials. Doubtless, Maha-
ban was the - site of some of those Buddhist monasteries, which the Chinese
pilgrim 1 a Hian distinctly states existed hi his time on both sides of the
river. And further, whatever may he the exact Indian word concealed un-
der the form Klisoboras, or Clisobora, given by Arrian and Pliny as the name
of the town between which and Mathura the Jamuna flowed — Amnia Jomanes
in Gancjem per Palibothros decurrit inter oppida Methora et Clisobora,
Pliny, Hist. Nat. vi, 22 — it may be concluded with certainty that Maha-ban
is the site intended. Its other literary names are Brihad-vana, Brihad-aran-
ya, Gokula, and Nanda-grama ; and no one of these, it is true, in the slight-
est resembles the word Clisobora, which would seem rather to be a corrup-
tion of some compound in which ‘ Krishna’ was the first element, possibly
some epithet or descriptive title taken by the foreign traveller for the ordi-
nary proper name. General Cunningham in his ‘ Ancient Geography’ identi-
fies Clisobora (read in one MS., as Cyrisoborka) with Brinda-ban, assuming
that Kalikavartta, or ‘ Kalika’s Whirlpool,’ was an earlier name of the town,
in allusion to Krishna’s combat with the serpent Kalika. Butin the first place,
the Jamuna does not flow between Mathura and Brinda-ban, seeing that both
are on the same bank ; secondly, the ordinary name of the great serpent is
not Kalika, but Kaliya ; and thirdly, it does not appear upon what autho-
rity it is so boldly stated that “ the earlier name of the place was Kalika-
vartta. Upon this latter point, a reference has been made to the great
Brinda-ban Pandit, Swfimi Rangaehari, who if any one might be expected
to speak with positive knowledge, and his reply was that in the course of
all his reading, he had never met with Brinda-ban under any other name
than that which it now bears. In order to establish the identification of
Clisobora with Maha-ban, it was necessary to notice General Cunningham’s
counter theory and to condemn it as unsound ; ordinarily the accuracy of
his research and the soundness of his judgment are entitled to the highest
respect.
The glories of Maha-ban are told in a special (interpolated) section of
the Brahmanda Purina, called the Brihad-vana Mahatmya. In this its
tirtlias, or holy places, are reckoned to be twenty -one in number as follows •
JEka-vinsati-tirthena yuktam bhurigunan vitam.
YamaUdrjuna punyatam, JVanda-kupam tathaiva elm,
Chinta-harana Prdhmdndam, kundam Sarasvatam tatlia,
Sarasvati Slid tatra, Vishnu-kunda-scmanvitam,
Kama-kiipam, Krishna -kundam, Gopa-kupam tathaiva cha
42
o u
330
F. S. Growse — The Tirthas of Vrmdd-vana and Golmla. [No. 4,
Mamatum-ramana-sthdmm, Ndrada-sth&nmi eva clui,
Putand-patana stlidnam, Tnnavarttdkhya pdtanam,
Nanda-liarmyam, Nanda-geham , Ghd(am Ramana-samjnakam,
Mathurdndlhobha-kxhetram puny am pdpa-praudsanam,
Janma-sthanam iu Sheshasya, jananam Yogamdyaya.
Some little distance outside the town, a small bridge carries the Mathu-
ra road ac oss a ravine called Piitan.i khar, the Putana-patana-sthanam of
the above lines. It is a mile or more in length, reaching down to the bank
of the Jamuna, and as the name denotes, is supposed to havo been caused by
the passage of Pdtana’s giant body. Similarly in Mathura, when Kansa’s
corse was dragged down to the Visrant Ghat, it made a deep channel in the
ground like a torrent in flood, as described in the Vishnu Purina :
Gauravendti mahatd parikhd. tena kruhyatd
Kritd Kansasya dehena, vegeneva mahdtnbhasah.
This is still known as the Kans Khar. It has been arched over, and
like the Fleet Ditch in London, forms now the main sewer of the city, dis-
charging itself into the river at the very spot where Brahmans most delight
to bathe. The remainder of the twenty-one tirthas have either been already
noticed in the course ol this sketch, or commemorate such well-known inci-
dents in Krishna’s childhood that any further explanation is unnecessary.
On the high road to Sa’dabad, some six miles beyond Maha-ban, is the
modern tirtha of Baladeva Ji. The temple, from which the town derives its
name, is of considerable celebrity and well-endowed, but neither handsome
nor well kept. It includes within its precincts several cloistered quadran-
gles, where accommodation is provided for pilgrims and the resident priests
The actual temple stands at the back of one of the inner courts, and on each
of its three disengaged sides has an arcade of three arches with broad
flanking piers. On each of these three sides a door gives access to the cella,
which is surmounted by a squat pyramidal tower. Beside the principal
figure, Baladeva, who is generally very richly dressed and bedizened, it con-
tains another life-sized statue supposed to represent his spouse, lievati.
Apparently she was an after-thought, being put away in a corner off the
dais. In an adjoining court is shewn the small vaulted chamber, which is
said to have been the original shrine before the present more pretentious
edifice was erected by a Delhi Seth, named Syam Das, some time in the last
century. Outside the temple is a brick tank about eighty yards square,
called variously Kshir-Sagar, ‘ the sea of milk,’ or Kshir-kund, or Balbhadra-
kun<j. It is in rather a dilapidated condition, and the surface of the water
is always covered with a repulsive thick green scum, which, however, does not
deter the pilgrims either from bathing or drinking. In this tank it is said
that about the year 1550 was accidentally discovered the image of Baladeva
which has ever since been regarded as the local divinity. The original
1872.]
331
H. Blochmann — On a new king of Bengal.
village, called Rir.i, still exists as a hamlet of tlie modern town. It belonged
to a family of Jfits ; but their estate was transferred by sale to the temple
Pandas, who also enjoy an endowment of four other villages rent free, a
grant from Siudhia. They are all descendants of the Bairagi by whom the
image was produced, and are by caste Ahivasis, a singularly low and illiterate
pseudo-Brahmanieal tribe, who as it would seom are not known in any
part of India beyond the Mathura district. The name is said to be derived
from the great serpent (a hi) kaliya, and they represent the village of San-
rakh, near the Kali-mardan Ghat at Brin da-ban, as their first home.
Note. — The interesting temple of Hari-deva at Gobardhan was in perfect preserva-
tion, excepting only the loss of its two towers, till the end of the year 1871. The roof
of the nave then bogan to give away, and now has entirely fallen in, all save one com-
partment, which happily remains as a guide to the architect, in case a restoration
should be undertaken. Funds for the work are not altogether wanting, as there is
now in the local treasury a deposit of more than Its. 3000 available for the purpose.
This sum arises from the rents of the mu’nfi village of Bhagosa, a permanent endow-
ment, with regard to which, after long dispute, the Civil Court has decided that it
must be oxpended strictly on the maintenance of the temple and its services, and
cannot be appropriated by the shareholders to their own private uses It could not
be devoted to a better purpose than the repair of the fabric ; and in case of want of
unanimity among the shareholders a further order of the Court to that effect is all
that is required.
On a new king of Bengal (Al&uddin Firuz Shah), and notes on the
Husaim kings of Bengal and their conquest of Gha.tgd.on (Chittagong).
—Bg H. Blochmann, M. A., Calcutta Madrasah.
Some time ago, Mr. Walter M. Bourke sent me two Arabic and Persian
Inscriptions from Kalnah, on the Bhagirathi, one from a ruined mosque, and
the other from the Dargah of a saint of the name of Shah Majlis. The latter
inscription has not been deciphered, the stone being worn away ; but the
name of Husain Shah was legible. The former, of which a yellowish impres-
sion had been taken, revealed the name of a new king. It was, however,
too unclear to admit of more than a tentative reading, and I was fortunate
to obtain, in June last, two clear black impressions. The stone of this
valuable inscription, I am informed, lies on the ground in front of a ruined
mosque, and is, like all inscriptions in this part of the country, of black
basalt. The mosque, called the ‘ Shahi Masjid,’ lies outside Kalnah, about
half a mile from the river, and is overgrown with jungle. Occasionally
prayers are read in it, and the Khadims in charge hold a few bfghahs of
land. The Darg&h, mentioned above, is called Shah Majlis A'stanah,’ lies also
near the river, and is said to be under the Mutawalliship of the Maharajah
332
H. Blochmann — On a new king of Bengal. [No. 4,
of Bardwan. It consists of a vault and a masjid, and is frequented
by numerous pilgrims. The only information regarding Shah Majlis
(an Afghan name) is that he fought with the Hindus and died a martyr,—
a legend repeated in almost every A'stanah in Lower Bengal.
The inscription is —
ji. Ja+J| J.j| AliJl ^3 j-olxA |i,<k
ID AllaL, } aXLe 0.1A — If ^IkLjl f l£> )}jXf
XjiJl alii jJjj } lAll/c tyla. jj| }
|| J j jtfj aiw jytA/O) viljL+lt ^yo
Tliia Jami’ Mosque was built in the time of the just king ’Alauddunya
w a d d f n A b u 1 M u z a f f a r Firuz Shah, the king, son of N n 9 r a t Shah, the
king— may God porpetuate his kingdom and rule ! Erected by the great and generous
Malik, Ulugh Masnad Khan Malik, commander and Vazir, — may God pre-
serve him m both worlds ! Dated, 1st day of the blessed month of Ramazan, 939,
[27th March, 1533].
This important inscription proves the existence of a new king, and helps
us to correct the histories as far as the death of Nufrat Shah is concerned.
A few other valuable inscriptions of kings of the same dynasty having been
received by the Asiatic Society, I have used the opportunity to put
them together, and append a few notes on the chronology of the reigns of
Husain Shah and his descendants. As they are Sayyids, they may be con-
veniently called ‘ the Husain! Dynasty.’
Anticipating the results arrived at below, we have the following
genealogical tree —
A 1 a u d d 1 n Husain S h a h, son of Sayyid Ashraf ul-Husaini, 899 to 929, A H.
1 . Danyal, invades
A'sam in 9u4, and
perishes.
2. Ndijiruddm N u 9 r a t
Shah (or N^ib Shah),
929 to 939 (murdered)
’Alauddin Firuz Shah,
939, ( murdered by Mahmud
Shah).
3. Ghiasuddin Mahmud
Shah, 940 to 944 j dies
in 945. J
Two sons, killed by Jalal
Khan.
Mr. E. Thomas (Useful Tables, p. 312) has —
A.H. A.D.
397 1491 Firuz Shah Habshf.
899 1494 Mahmud Shah, son of Ffruz Shah.
900 1495 Muzaftar Sliah Habshi.
9u3 1498 ’Alauddin Husain Sliah, son of Sayyid Ashraf.
9^7 1521 Nufrat 8hdh, son of Husain Shah.
•HO 1534 Mahmtid Sliah, son of Husain Shah.
944 1537 Slier Shah.
1872.]
338
H. Blochmann — On a new "king of Bengal.
In order to explain the discrepancies between the above tree and the
years given in Prinsep and all other histories, I shall take the kings singly.
1. ’ Alauddin .Husain Shah. I have fixed 899 A. H. as the first year
of his reign, on the testimony of Marsden’s coin (Marsden, p. 576), and I
extend it to the beginning of 929. The year 903, given by Prinsep, has
been obtained by adding the years assigned by the Tabaqat i Akbarz and
Firishtah to Firuz Shah Habshi’s successors, of whom Mahmud Shah is
said to have reigned 1 year, and Muza (far Shah 3 years 5 months.
Firishtah says, Husain Shah died in 927, after a reign of 27 years, —
so at least in the Lucknow edition, and in the Society's MS. of the Biyaz-
ussalafm, from which Stewart compiled his ‘ History of Bengal.’ The
Biyaz adds that the length of Husain Shah's reign is variously given at 24,
27, and 29 years 5 months. Of these three statements, Stewart and Prinsep
have taken the first (24 years, from 903 to 927). Firishtah counts 27 years,
i. e. from 900 to 927. The Tabaqat seems to take the last (29 years 5
months) ; for it says that Husain Shah died in 929 A. FI.# I do not know
from which source the Biyaz has taken the “ 29 years 5 months.”
Of several unpublished inscriptions of this king, I select the following,
which General Cunningham found in Sunnargaon —
j«L*| j Ui j &U0 aJj| ^11*3 allj U5
csP'l J1-* - e.,xi ui1 <*B| Si f j tiff I j
- aJ aUi lj.jisJifia.s~** j aj.JLc alb
Ljo.l| fe i£j.l*.l| £.Jj (SjC) (Ja.1 — f fj
ajLi j ^Li j ajiLl -vo 3 aO-x all| o.1a jSila+'Iji] ^joJi j
) |*Jkc i ffi G* j
AXw^A U| ^iLl| ^3 (j-Jjloil ^3 all) dALwa 2
) | aj 1 ^ ^ ~3
God Almighty sayg, ‘ Surely he will build the mosques of God who believes in God
and the last day, and who establishes prayer and gives the legal aims, and fears no
one except God. Such perhaps shall belong to those that are guided’ [Qoran, lxi,
13], The prophet— may God bless him I — has said, ‘ He who builds a mosque in this
woi-ld, shall have seventy castles built for him by God in paradise.’
This mosque was built in the reign of the Sultan of the age, the heir of the
kingdom of Solomon, ’Alfiuddunya waddin Abul Muzaffar Husain
Shah— May God perpetuate his kingdom and rule, and elevate his condition and
dignity, and render, in every minute, his proof victorious ! — by the great and noble
* MS. 87 of the Asiatic Society’s Library, p. 1164. There are two misprints on
this very point in the quarto and octavo editions of Stewart's History of Beno-al. In
the Tables prefixed to the work, 905 is mentioned as the year of Husain Shah’s
accession ; and in Sect, iv, (pp. 109 and 71, resp.), the margin gives A. D. 1489
for 1498.
334
H. Blochmann — On a new king of Bengal. [No. 4,
Khan, namely Khawai; K li fin, governor of the Land of T i p u rah and Yazir
of the District M u ’ a z z a m fib fi d, — may God preserve him in both ■worlds ! Dated,
2nd Rabi’ II, 919. [7th June, 1513.]
The inscription contains the phrase TgVim Mu'tmarnaldd, which Mr.
Thomas discusses in Iris ‘ Chronicles of the Pathan Kings,’ p. 153. The
union oi Tripurah (Tiparah) and Mu’azzamahad confirms my conjecture
that Mu azzamabad belongs to Sunnargfion. The form ijf* 3 is intended
to be Arabic for tjy* 3.
The various statements regarding the beginning of Husain Shah’s reign
are, no doubt, due to the fact that he was a usurper, and that his power,
therefore, extended gradually. One source, indeed, makes him murder
Muzaffar in his palace ; but other sources speak of a great struggle, ending
in a great battle under the walls of Gaur, when Husain Shah was victorious.
Another proof for the correctness of the year 929 lies in the fact
that the Tabaqat assigns to Nugrat Shah only eleven years as reigning
king.
There is some confusion regarding the real name of Husain Shah.
The Tabaqat merely calls him ’Alauddin, the j ulus-name, whilst Pirishtah
calls him Sayyid Sharif i Malriri, i. e. Sharif from Makkah ; and Stewart
gives “ Sherief Mecca,” evidently confirmed by a gratuitous remark of the
author of the lligdzussald(in, who, as he says, thinks that Husain’s father, or
one of his ancestors, might perhaps have been a Sharif of Mecca !* To make
the confusion greater, the Riy&z adds that he had seen “ in some pamphlet
that Husain Shah and his brother Yusuf had come with their father Sayyid
Ashraf Husaini from Tirmiz in Turkistan, and having accidentally
come to Bengal they had settled in the Rarah District at Chandpur, where
they studied under the Qazi of the place. When the Qizi had convinced
himself of the nobility of their descent, he gave his daughter to Husain in
marriage, and introduced him at the court of Muzaffar Shah, who made him
Yazir.” None of the numerous inscriptions and coins of Husain Shah call
him Sayyid Sharif or “ Makki.”
Prince Danydl. He is mentioned by Badaoni (I, 317) as having met
Sultan Sikandar Lodi as ambassador from his father Husain Shah, near the
town of Bihar, in 901 A. H. This is another and independent testimony
shewing that Husain’s reign commenced before 903 A. H., and that he was,
in fact, fully established in 901.
Danyal is also mentioned in the following inscription which I owe to
the kindness of Maulawi ’Abdul Jabbar, Deputy Magistrate, Munger. The
inscription is attached to the eastern wall of the Dargah of Shah Nafah,
* The Sharif, or ruler, of Makkah, is called Sharif i MaUah, not Sharif i Makkl.
The latter can only mean ‘ a man of the name of Sharif, born in Makkah.’
1872.] H. Bloclimann — On a new king of Bengal. 335
which lies on an elevated spot, reached by a flight of steps, near tho old wall
of Munger. At the foot, there are many tombs in a dilapidated state. The
Khadims of the D argali say that when the fort of Munger was built,
or rebuilt, Prince Danya l dreamed that a grave near the new wall emitted
a smell of musk. The grave was discovered, and the Prince built a vault
over it, for the inmate was evidently a saint. From this circumstance the
saint is up to this day called ‘ Shah Nafah,’ from the Persian nafah, a
‘pod of musk.’
j f3 3 a i. J' t aiJ|
3 3^ m>|,sU~Ji j.s:^ o!el~^l JcWt AxiAl)
% lJ laif a A ? ci b # Ailk-Lw^ &.Lo all | t>lA ^jf
It j *i.Jj axw # all 1
In the name of God, the merciful and the clement 1 A victory from God, and
a near favour, and announce the joyful tidings to tho faithful [Qoran, lvi, 3], The
erection of this vault (took place) in the reign of the just king, the Sayyid of Sayyids,
the receptacle of auspiciousness, ’A 1 an d d u ny a w a ddi n Ab u 1 Muzaffar
Husain Sha h, — May God perpetuate his kingdom and rule ! The builder of this
religious edifice is Prince Danya 1 — may God Almighty preserve him in both
worlds 1 A. H. 903 [A. D. 1497-98],
When I exhibited this inscription at the meeting of the Society in July
last, I alluded to the following passage from Prinsep’s Antiquities (Thomas’s
edition, Useful Tables, p. 273) regarding the invasion of Asam by Husain
Shah-
1498 Asam invaded by Dulal Ghazi, son of Husain Shah
Musundar Ghazi
Sultan Ghiasuddin.
As ‘ Dulal Ghazi’ is scarcely a Muhammadan name, the prince alluded
to is evidently this DanySl. A short description of the invasion was given
by me above, p. 79. The author of the Bigaz gives a few particulars, but
without quoting his source. As Stewart has passed over the details,
I translate the passage, as given in the MS. of the Riydz in the Asiatic Society’s
Library. “ After having reduced the Rajahs of the Districts as far as Orisa,
Husain took tribute from them. After this, he resolved to invade the kingdom
of Asam, in the north-east of Bengal, and he set out with a large army of
foot and a numerous fleet, and entered the kingdom and subdued it as
far as Kamrup and Kdrntah and other districts, which were under powerful
Rajahs as Bap Ndrdin, Mul (Pal ?) Kunwar, Oost't Lak’han (?) and Lachhmi
N drain. and others, and collected much wealth from the conquered land
so that the Afghans, after destroying the palaces of those [Rajahs], erected
palaces. The Rajah of the country, unable to withstand, withdrew to the
mountains. Sultan Husain left his son with a strong army in Asam to
complete the settlement of the country, and returned victoriously to Bengal.
336
H. Blochmann — On a new Icing of Bengal. [No. 4,
After the return of the Sultan, the Prince pacified and guarded the conquered
country ; but when the rains set in, and tire roads were closed, the Kajali
issued with his men from the hills, surrounded the Prince, and cut off his
supplies. In a short time, they were all killed.”
It is not said who 1 Musundar Ghazf and ‘ Sultan Ghiasuddin’ are,
whom Prinsep mentions as having gained a footing in Asam.
2. Nupiruddtn Nw;rat Shiih. Historians also call him Nagtb Shah,
but this name docs not occur on inscriptions. I do not know whether the
Na^bpur in Tandah is connected with his name. His other name, Nuijrat,
occurs often enough in Bengal geography, as also those of his brother
Mahmud and his father Husain Shah. We have —
1. Husainshahi, in Maimansingh,
Nuijratshahi, in Pabnah, Jasar.
MahmiidshahS,* in Pabnah, Jasar.
2. Husainabad, in Tandah and in the 24-Parganahs.
Nugratabad, in Ghoragh.it.
Mabmiidabad, a whole Sirkar (Northern Jasar and Bosnah).
3. Hueainpur, in Nadia, &c.
Naylbpur, in Tiindah.
Mahmtldpur, in Dlnajpur.
4. Husain Ujyal, in Nadia.
N ucrat Ujyal, in Maimansingh.
It may also be of interest to remark here that the people of Chatgaon
(Chittagong) ascribe the first invasion of their District and their conversion
to Islam to \ iKTat Shah. I extract the following passage from a Persian
History of Chatgaon, entitled ‘ Ahadis ul-Kha wanin’ or 1 Tarikh i Hamidi.’
This History was written by the late Maulawi Hamidullah Khan Bahadur,
and was printed last year at Calcutta (Svo., 441 pages, with 34 pages
of errata and additions). It contains many interesting facts. The author
says (p. 17) —
In former days, wandering Faqirs and poor Muhammadans came to Chatgaon
district, and built opposite to Hindu shrines and Mug temples spurious graves,
giving out that they were the resting-places of the renowned saints Biiyazid of Bistamf
and ’Abdul Qadir of Gilsin, who never put their feet on this heathenish shore.
These faqirs made some money and attracted Muhammadan pilgrims from tho neigh-
bouring districts. And about 250 or 300 years ago, Nagiruddiu Nugratshaii,
a king of Bengal, conquered the territory, fighting with the Mugs, and introduced in
* In consequence of the Bengali spelling “ Mahamodshahee,” this name is often
corrupted to Muhammadshahi. Thus in Mr. Westland’s valuable Jessoro Report.
‘Husainabad’ occurs on Husain Shah’s coins.
t Vide Westland’s Jessore Report, p. 19. He calls him 1 Bazid Bostan,’ evidently
a Bengali corruption.
1872.]
337
H. Blochmann — On a new Icing of Bengal.
Chatgaon Muhammadan rites, so that it booame a Parte? fcldm. From rains and
legends it would appear that this N nf rat Shah Padishah, who was a king or a prinoa
of Bengal, wont after the destruction of Gaur, with a large number of Musalmau and
Hindu emigrants, to Eastern Bengal, and attacked the Mugs, took their town, and
made it a domicile for his mon. The reason for his emigration to these parts was
this. Ono Alfa Hu saint of Baghdad, a descendant of Fatimah [the daughter of
the prophet], a great merchant, who possessed much wealth and many slaves and
owned fourteen ships, had repeatedly been to Chatgaon, and housed afterwards to go
to Bengal, where he urged the king to conquer the district. He also assisted him with
ships and material, and thus raised tho standard of victory (mifrat) in that country.
Husaini, for this reason, became the king’s son-in-law, and lived honored and dis-
tinguished. In fact up to tho beginning of the present time, his descendants were
the aristocracy here, and the late Mir Yahya Islamabad!, founder of the well-known
Madrasah, MullaMu’inddm Soudipi, and others, traced their descent from Husaini.***#
Of the antiquities which point to this religions king, I may mention Mauza’
Fathabad, which was so called in remombranoo of tho conquest (fath), and also tho
great tank in Fathabad, and the mosque there, which was built of enamelled bricks.
I have myself seen Nuqrat's mosque with its coloured bricks ; but it is now broken
and ruined and filled with rubbish. His great tank, the length of which is 700 paces,
more or less, still exists, but the water has become bad. On account of the wicked-
ness of the neighbouring people, the. trade of the place has declined. People also say
that apucca houso stood near it, which decayed and got covered with jungle and
was full of snakes. Hence people set it on fire, and burned it down with the serpents
and all. But prior to Anrangzib’s conquest, no Muhammadan king besidos Nuqrat
Shah is said to have come here.
Of the antiquities from the time before tho Mughul conquest, but after that o £
Nuqrat Shah, I must mention the old mosque near F a t h a b a d, in Hat Hazari
[12 miles north of Chatgaon], A very strong pillar is said to stand in it, from
which water constantly trickles. The foundation of the town of Bhaluah, and
the digging of the Bhaluah tank, are generally referred to tho time of Nucrat
Shah.
Of the inscriptions belonging to the reign of Nuqrat Shah the earliest
is one found by General Cunningham on a mound near Sa’ dipur, Sunnargaon
I read it as follows :
alj| jlj' j ip.a.1 aJU| ^ l^-co.3 ill all j jjlbo alii jlj'
I aUaj a! aIJ i^ij a1J| sj all lo.qz"''0 j able
LjpJly-cti ^tlnJ — f ( j- .x+J ( x+Jl jylk-L* !| Ail o.ur~~.l| ! Ait xj
ulJ| olA. ^Itl-J) jjt jy*~a. jy:1 jytkL-Ji y£Ja«.f| jy.jO.Jl j
*lj.sij| ijjiki tljjjJl J L*Il/0 Ajlia~J| on £« <dJ| Aoj.1 gUj j Ailklw y
fxx* jyj l_rlj=*',| lilU jUj vjjya.ll jyjC.il yjt jyJl jyJ O J f | }
|| AjU*~J j jyyy.-t.e_j £_J An- jyJjIbil , ji jIjiGi aL/| ^jI
God Almighty says, ‘ Surely tho Mosques belong to God j worship no one else be-
sides God. The prophet says, ‘ He who builds a mosque for God, seeking thereby the
reward of God, will have one like it built for him by God in Paradise °
43
n h
338
H. Bloclimann — On a new king of Bengal. [No. 4,
This mosque was built in the reign of the great, the liberal king, the son of a
king, Naqiruddunya waddin Abul Mnzaffar Nu cjra t 8 hah, the king,
son of Husain Shah the king, the descendant of Husain [A1 Husaini], — May God
continue his kingdom and rulo ! It was erected, in order to obtain the reward of
God, together with the well, by the Malik ul Umara wal-Wuzara, the chief of the
lawyers and teachers of the Hadis, Taqi nddin, son of ’Ain uddin, known as
Bar Malik ul-Majlis, son of Mukhtir nl-Majlis, son of Sarwar. May God pre-
serve him in both worlds ! In the year 929 A. H. [A. D. 1523]
It is a pity that this inscription does not mention the month ; for if it
did, tvs could approximately fix the death of Husain and the accession of
Nugratshah.
Another inscription of Nugrat Shah, referring to A. H. 93G, was pub-
lished in this Journal, Vrol. xxxix, 1870, p. 278, and I now add a reading of
the Qadam Rasul inscription of 937, of which the Society has received two
rubbings, one from Mr. W. L. Heeley, C. S., to whom the Society owes a large
collection ot Gaur rubbings, and another by General Cunningham, whose
splendid collection of Hindu and Muhammadan inscriptions of Upper India
and Bengal has just reached the Society.
S,.#h.»ll jAa # LjJU/Cl <vl» o xlJijli
|*ii**J| j XiH ilJl ill| -■* Oa I (sic) j
uil -iylW-.il ^ UiaJi ^ikl—li
lly6! J AHhlw j &\*/c &1J f oiA On-*
II j J AXw . XjUo j
God Almighty says, ‘ He who brings the good deed, will bo rewarded ten fold.’
[Qoran, vi. 161], This pure dais and its stone, on which is the foot print of the Pro-
phet— May God bless him ! — were put up by the great, generous king, the son of a
king, Nfiijiruddunya waddin Abul Muzaffar Nugrat Shah, the king,
son of Husain S h & h, the king, son of Sayyid Ashraf ul Husaini, — May God
perpetuate his kingdom and rulo, and elevato his condition and dignity ! In the
year 937, A. H. [A, D. 1530-31.]
The Jiii/dx and Stewart give the date of the Qadam Rasul to be A. H.
939, but the rubbing clearly shews 937.
Nugrat Shall was murdered by his ennuchs in 939. This year, though
not mentioned in the Riydz, is yet implied by his account, whatever his
source may have been. The Tabaqul gives a short account of Nugrat’ s reign
till 939, and then says — “ After this, the history of the Bangalis has not
come to hand. Nagib Shah reigned eleven years, and shortly afterwards,
Bengal was taken by Slier Shah.” Firishtah’s account is extraordinary and
unreliable. He says that Nagib died in 913, but that the manner of his
death was unknown. Ho was succeeded by Mahmud, a Bangdli nobleman ,
who being attacked by Sher Shall fled to Humayun. The Riydz adds that
some historians say, Nugrat Shah reigned sixteen years, others thirteen,
others still less,
1S72.] H. Bloehmann — On a new Icing of Bengal. 339
3. ’ Aland din Firuz Shah, son of Nuerat Shall. The Figiiz is the
only history that mentions him under the name of Firuz. His source
is unknown to me. The existence of this king is now proved by the above
inscription (p. 332). General Cunningham has had for some time in his
possession a sealing-wax impression of a coin belonging to this king, The coin
is, I believe, in the British Museum. Stewart and Marsden give Firuz Shall
only three months. The MS. of the lli>/az in the Society’s Library unfor-
tunately appears to be defective in this part, tho passage being —
Jl Si (%* ) (i) zy Xz?? (sic)
ISeto ^dlj^w ojbotJ \j _j| IstA zuyAs y zy yile Xzj*
Ml*zyc , * ul-w £ s S z,'\ G j gtA ci b _j zy
II zy*> zy^yj fay yy y X zjyf J>nb Ij jL£ yyi iiiGylJ
He had reigned (?) three years (?), when Sultan Mahmud of Bengal, one of the
eighteen sons of ’Alauddin Husain Shah, who had been raised by Nuijrat Shah to the
position of an Amir, and who daring tho life of Nacc&t Shah had been treated as such,
found an opportunity and killed Firuz Shah, and ascended the throne of royalty
among the heirs of his father.
4. Ohiasuddin Mahmud Shah, the last independent king of Bengal
(940 to 944). He is the “ El liey Mamud do Bengala” with whom Alfonso
de Mello made a treaty, as will be found in Barros’ 1 Da Asia.’ When be-
sieged in Gaur by Slier Shah’s army under Jalal Khan and Khawih; Khan,
he applied to Nunode Cuna, the governor of the Portuguese settlements, for
help ; but the nine ships sent to him did not arrive in Bengal till after the
surrender of the city (944). Mahmud’s fate is known the TariJch i Sher
ShaM* The Akbarnamah (Lucknow Edition, I, p. 184) calls Mahmud
“ Naeib Shah.” According to the Rigttz, Mahmud died at K’halgaon (945),
from grief at the loss of his two sons or from the wounds he had received in
defending Gaur.
The only inscription that I have seen of Mahmud Shah is the following
from General Cunningham’s collection. It refers to the building of a mosque
in Sa’dullahpur, Gaur, by a lady whose name is not mentioned.
> <xlLc IAj &J apt all ^ij c,x> ^.1^, , <XjJ.£ ilh ^l-o JLS
IxjzJl £,Ui ^IkLJl ^,-1 wlkLJ| zy y .XK:“~*"I| | out.
*£I/o AlJ| 0.1A gLi 8 1 A zy*^* j
(Zji*Vl Al J\ j.!ol y O/Olo Axils , ailklw }
|| AjI*+.J ,
The Prophet says, ‘ He who builds a mosque for God, will have a house liko it
built for him by God in Paradise. This Jami’ Mosque was built during the reign of
* Vide the translation of this interesting history by the Hon’ble E. C. Bayley
in Dowson’s edition of Elliot’s History of India, IV, pp. 360 and 364. T he ‘ Bahr-
kundah’ mentioned there, is Bharkundah in Birbhum (vide Ain text, I, 406).
340
Babu RSjendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India. [No. 4,
the kin", the son of a king, Ghiasuddunyk waddfn Abu] Mnzaffar
Mahmud Shah, the king, son of Hnsain S h k h the king, — may God per-
petuate his kingdom and rnle. Its builder is a lady,— May she long live, and may
God oontinuo her high position! 911 A. H. [A. D. 1531-35.]
A Picnic in Ancient India. — By Ba'btj Ra'jendraia'xa Mitka.
The Vedas represent the ancient Indo-Aryans to have been eminently
religious in all their actions. According to them, every act of life had to be
accompanied by one or more mantras, and no one could rise from his bed,
or wash his face, or brush his teeth, or drink a glass of water, without going
through a regular system of purifications, salutations, and prayers ; and if lie
really did practice all the rites and ceremonies enjoined in those works, his life
doubtless must have been an unbroken chain of religious observances from
birth to burning-ground. It would seem, however, that the bulk of the
community did nothing of the kind. Certain sacraments and initiatory
rites everybody had to go through, and well-to-do persons had to celebrate
feasts and fasts from time to time ; but in all such cases, the heaviest bur-
den they had to bear was a pecuniary one, the actual performance of the
ceremonies being left to the priesthood. Before the Tantric form of wor-
ship got currency in the country, the S'udra had literally nothing to do by
way of religious exercise beyond evincing a reverential devotion when he em-
ployed one or more Brahmans to perform a sacrifice, or get through a sacra-
ment, and to salute and bow as often as required. No Vedic mantra could
be repeated by him even when offering water to the spirits of his ancestors,
and there was for him no other set form of prayer wherewith to address the
Great Father of the universe. The Vais'ya and the Kshatriya, as belonging
to the twice-born classes, and having the right to wear the sacrificial cord,
were at liberty to repeat Vedic mantras, and had to repeat them when going
through particular sacraments, or performing s'raddhas ; but like the S'udras
before the Tantric period, they had no regular service for daily observance
beyond one or more salutations to the great soul of the sun, or the repetition
of the Gayatri. At the periodical feasts and fasts they, as Yajamanas, or
the institutors of sacrifices, provided the wherewithal to perform the rites
and ceremonials, installed the priests in their respective offices, and
recompensed them for their labour. But in the actual work of repeating
mantras, offering oblations, and going through the ritual, they took but
a slender share.
It was the Brahman only for whom the Vedas enjoined an endless
round of rites, ceremonies and observances, innumerable mantras for repetition
on different occasions, and a host of fasts and penances extending from three
341
1872.] Bdbu Bajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India.
nights to many years. But as they formed but a small section of the
general community, their examples, however well calculated to restrain
immorality and induce a religious spirit, did not keep the people engaged in
actual religious ceremonies for any protracted period, or too frequently. At
any rate, the claims of religion on their time and attention were not greater
than what they were on those of other nations of antiquity ; aud the people
at large ate and drank and enjoyed life without any serious let or hindrance.
Even Brahmans, when not actually engaged hi the performance of sacrifices,
were not debarred from the sweets and pleasures of the world, and the most
ancient treatise* on the various ways of enjoying the society of women, i. e.
on the ars erotica, is due to a hoary sage named S'ankhayana, whose ordin-
ances arc held to be quite as sacred as the Vedas themselves.
Little is, however, known as to how the people enjoyed themselves in
their light moments, and of the games, pastimes, recreations and entertain-
ments which pleased them the most. I think, therefore, that the following
extract from the Harivaiis'a Parva of the Mahabharata, (chapters 146-47 )t
affording a most graphic picture of an ancient Indian Picnic, will not be unin-
teresting to the readers of the Journal. It depicts a state of society so entirely
different from what we are familiar with in the present day, or in the later
Sanskrit literature, that one is almost tempted to imagine that the people who
took parts in it were some sea-kings of Norway, or Teuton knights carousing
after a fight, and not Hindus ; and yet if the S'sistras are to bo believed,
they were the Hindus of Hindus, the two most prominent characters among
them being no less than incarnations of the Divinity, aud another a holy
sage, who had abjured the world for constant communion with his Maker,
and whose law treatise ( Narada Sanhita) still governs the conscience of the
people.
The scene of the Picnic was a watering-place on the west coast of
Guzerat near Dvarka, named Pindaraka. It is described as a tiriha or
sacred pool, and the trip to it is called tiriha ydtrd, or a pilgrimage to a holy
place ; but the sequel shows that the trip was one of pleasure aud had no-
thing religious about it. The party, headed by Baladeva, Krishna, and Ar-
juna, issued forth with their families and thousands of courtezans, spent the
day in bathing, feasting, drinking, singing and dancing, and returned home
without performing any of the numerous rites and ceremonies, which pil-
grims are bound by the S'astras to attend to.
The presence of the courtezans in the company is a fact worthy of spe-
cial note, for although Hindu society has always looked upon fallen women
with kind, indulgent eyes, and instances are on record of such persons having
* S'ankhayana Kama Sutra.
f Owing to an error in numbering in the Asiatic Society’s edition of the
Harivaiis'a, the chapters there appear as 147 and 148.
312 Biibu Rajendraldla Mitra— A Picnic in Ancient India. [No. 4,
been admitted into respectable household after proper expiations, the S'astras
are peremptory in condemning all association with them as long as they remain
unreclaimed, especially on the part of women of family, and modern and
mediaeval custom has never permitted any such association as is implied by
bathing, eating, drinking, dancing, and singing together. It indicates a sad
laxity ol morals, and the state of society which permitted this, cannot but be
condemned. The Yadavas, however, felt no compunction in that respect, and
not only allowed their wives and daughters freely to mix with harlots, but
themselves joined the party, and indulged in unrestrained debauchery in the
presence of parents and seniors. The only person who formed an exception was
Baladeva. His constancy to his only wife, Bevati, is the theme of praise
everywhere ; and never has his character been assailed for even the slightest
neglect of his conjugal duty. At the Picnic he appears, as was his wont,
tottering with drink ; but he is always beside his consort, and gratifies himself
by bathing and singing and dancing with her, and her, alone.
Drinking appears to be another indulgence to which the Yadavas were
extremely addicted. Family women and prostitutes freely joined the men
in these bacchanalian orgies, and the poet who records their deeds, seems to
take a delight in pointing how some tottered, and others fell, and others be-
came reckless. The stuff they drank was of five kinds, namely, Tcddam-
Onri, mndhmlca, maireya, asava, and surd — all strong spirits prepared in differ-
ent ways. The first was distilled from the ripe fruit of the kadamba
(Nauclea kadamba ), which is highly saccharine, but not edible in its natural
state. Baladeva was particularly attached to this drink, and his name is rare-
ly mentioned in the Purauas without some reference to it. In the present
day, the fruit is not used in any way, and only affords a repast to the large
frugivorous bats called flying-foxes. The second was distilled from the ripe
petals of the Bassia lat folia, —the mowa of the North West Provinces,
where it is to this day extensively manufactured for the use of the lower
orders of the people. The third was rum seasoned with the blossoms of the
Ly thrum jruticosum. The fourth was pure rum ; and the last arrack distilled
from rice meal. These spirits were, I imagine, always drunk neat, for there
is no mention any where of their having been diluted ; and hence probably
was the necessity of eating a little of sugared or salted cake or subacid
fruits after every draft to take off the pungency of the diink from the mouth.
At the picnic, fried birds are especially mentioned for this purpose. There are
several words in the Sanskrit language to serve as generic names for these
wine biscuits,” and no description of a drinking bout is complete without
reference to such eatables. Even in the present day, no native ever thinks
of drinking without having some such food by his side.
The description of the banquet is also remarkable. The piece de
resistance at the meal was not rice or bread, as one would expect in India,
313
1872.] Bfibu Rajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India.
but roast buffalo, which seemed to have been a favourite dish with the Hin-
dus in former days, and I find in tho Yana Parva of the Mahabhfirata that
buffalo meat was publicly sold in the market,* and the stalls displaying it
were crowded by customers. In Kashmir, such meat, I am told, is regularly
sold in the present day to Hindu purchasers, and the lower orders of the
people in Bengal, such as Muchis, are particularly fond of it. The meat
was roasted on spits, glii being dropped on it as the dressing proceeded,
and seasoned with acids, sochel salt and sorrel leaves. Yenison was liked
in a boiled state, dressed in large haunches, and garnished with sorrel,
mangoes, and condiments. Shoulders and rounds of other kinds of meat
in large pieces were boiled, roasted on spits, or fried in ghi, and sprinkled
over with sea salt and powdered black pepper.
Beef, however, is not mentioned as forming an ingredient in the feast
although the Maliabhfirata elsewhere describes a king named Rantideva,
who used to slaughter daily two thousand heads of cattle, besides as many
other animals, for use in his kitchen. Ho is described as a most virtuous
king who acquired great religious merit by daily feeding innumerable
hosts of beggars with beef.f
Curries were likewise prepared with meat, but did not take a prominent
part in the bill of fare. Even little birds were preferred roasted on spits
to being fried or curried. The text is silent as to the species of the birds
used ; but in the Griliya Sutra of A'svalayana, partridges (tittiri) are
recommended as appropriate for infants just beginning to take solid food,
and ducks, doves, pigeons, and ortolans were formerly in common use.
Eor sauces and adjuncts, tamarind, pomegranates, sweet basil, acid herbs,
ginger, assafoetida, and radishes were largely used.
The text is not clear as to whether the buffalo meat was roasted
entire, or in cut pieces, but the haunches, shoulders, and rounds, dressed
entire, must have necessitated some kind of carving. As no allusion is,
however, anywhere made to knife and fork, it is to be supposed that “ the
cooks, who, under the superintendence of diligent stewards,” served at the
’irem f%5j: i
t Tm fVsr I
% 7Tg;T i
% *3^*3 JRT WSfr I
wN fsrTiw i
firsrewr i
344 Liabu Rajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India. [No. 4,
feast, must have carved the meat before offering it to the guests, in the same
way as is done in Persia, Arabia and other Moslim countries. It was in
fact tire French custom of carving' cn the side-hoard, which is so fast
gaining ground in England. The idea of such carving just before serving, is
horrifying in India in the present day, and no meat food is dressed in
larger pieces than what can be served to one person* Sweetmeats and
cakes, when intended for offerings to gods, are sometimes made very bulky,
but when prepared for man, they are seldom made larger than what would
suffice for one individual.
Of cakes, the text does not afford a good list, nor does it mention
their constituents in any detail. Sugar and cheese are the only substantial
materials named, and salt, ginger, saffron, and glii as adjuncts. The only
three kinds of made cakes I can recognize are cirdra, a cake made of sugar
and cocoanut gratings spiced with ginger, now called adraki ; candied sugar
coated with tila seed — khandaka, now known as virakhandi ; and glirita-
pwrnaJca a compound of flour, sugar, and ghi, common in the present day in
the North-West under the name of ghewar. These were partaken along
with wine, as dessert, after the lirst course of meat had been finished.
It is not distinctly mentioned whether the ladies joined the party at
the first meal, hilt as they were present at the dessert and regaled themselves
with spirits, roasted birds, and sweetmeats ; and the elders, who did not
partake of flesh meat and spirits, remained in the company, and made
their repast on vegetables, fruits, curds, milk, whey, cream and the like, the
inference becomes inevitable that the woman-kind did sit with their lords
at the first course, and partake of the meat food. This may appear
shocking to modern Hindu ideas of propriety, but where the whole course of
life and rules of social relationship were entirely different, this departure
from strict etiquette, even when opposed to the maxims and canons of the
S astras, cannot be taken to be such as not to be probable.
The descriptions of dancing, singing, music, and dramatic exhibitions
speak for themselves and call for no remark. In danciDg, the practice seems
to have been for each man to take his wife for his partner, and accordingly
we see Baladava dancing with his wife Revati, Krishna with Satyabahma,
and Arjuna with Subhadra. Those who had no wives with them, danced
with public women ; but they all danced and sang together, in the same arena
without any sort of restraint. Those who were so unfortunate as not to get
partners danced by themselves, and often became the butt of their neighbours’
wit and humour. The part which the sage Niirada takes in dancing, gesticula-
tion and mimicry, and as the butt of every practical joke, is worthy of
particular note, as showing that the saintly character of ancient Indian sages,
was by no means a bar to their joining in fun and frolic, and partaking of
the pleasures of the world. Dancing with one’s own wife will doubtless
345
1872.] Babu Rajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India.
appear to Europeans in the light of a sample of Eastern jealousy ; but to
modern Indians the mere fact of ladies of rank dancing before a large
assemblage, and in the presence of seniors, will not fail to strike as highly
reprehensible. To qualify the ladies for taking a becoming part in such
entertainments it was formerly necessary to employ a music master in every
respectable household. As in Italy two centuries ago, so in India many
centuries before that, eunuchs were much esteemed for the sweetness of their
voice, and held in great requisition as teachers of music, and in the Virata
Parva of the Mahablnirata, Arjuna becomes a eunuch, in order to serve as a
music master to the daughter of a king.
I do not find any reference to maidens as forming members of the picnic
party, and the description in a subsequent chapter of Bhanumati, the maiden
daughter of Bhanu, a Yadava chief, having been abducted from her home by
the demon Nikumbha, while the Yadavas were away from Dvarka, engaged
in their carousals, would suggest the inference that they were not taken to
such gatherings.
The description of the picnic in the Harivansa runs as follows : The
translation is anything but literal, and many epithets and repetitions
have been omitted, but not a single word has been put in of which there is
not a counterpart in the original, or which has not been rendered necessary
for the sake of idiom.
“ When Vishnu of unrivalled vigour dwelt at Dvaravati,* he once desired
to visit the sea-side watering-placof of Pindaraka. Appointing king Vasu-
deva and Ugrasena regents for the management of state affairs, ho started
with the rest (of his family).
“ The wise Baladeva, the lord of regions, Janardana and the princes,
earthly lords of god-like glory, issued forth in separate parties. Along with
the handsome and well adorned princes, came thousands of prostitutes.
These dealers on their beauty had been originally introduced into
Dvaravati by the mighty Jadavas, who had brought them away from
the palaces of the Daityas whom they had conquered. These wore common
harlots who had been kept for the entertainment of the Jadava princes.
Krishna had kept them in the city with a view to prevent unseemly brawls
which, at one time, used to take place on account of women.
“ Baladeva went out with his only affectionate wife, Revatf, on whom the
glorious chief of the Yadu race, entertained the feeling which the Chakravaka
has for his mate. J Adorned with garlands of wild flowers, and jubilant with
draughts of kadamba wine, he disported with lievati in the ocean waters.
* Dvarka, so called from its having had many doors, “the city of a hundred "ates ’’
t Lit. tirtha a sacred pool, hut tlio sequel will show that the trip was one in quest
of pleasure and not a pilgrimage for religious merit.
{ The Bnihmani drake, Anas ratila, is said to bo the most constant of husbands.
34G
Babu Bajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India. [No. 4,
“ Govinda of the lotus eye entertained himself in many forms with his
sixteen thousand wives, so pleasing every body, that each thought Krishna was
most attached to her, and it was for her only that he was in the ocean water.
They were all exceedingly gratified and delighted with Krishna. Thinking
herself to he the greatest favourite, each cast the most bewitching glances
on him, sang in great delight, and seemed to drink him with her .eyes.*
Each carried her head high at the idea of being the greatest favourite, and,
without any feeling of jealousy for their rivals, loved him with the most tender
passion. Thus enjoyed Krishna his sport in the clear water of the sea, (even
as if) he had assumed a multiplicity of shapes for the gratification
of his numerous consorts. By his order, the ocean then circulated clear and
fragrant water, devoid of all saltness. Standing ankle-deep or knee-deep, thigh-
deep or breast-deep, each according to her choice, the ladies in great glee threw
showers of water on Krishna, even as the heaven pours on the sea; and Krishna,
in his turn, showered water on the ladies, as gentle clouds drizzle on flowering
creepers. One fawn -eyed nymph leaning on his shoulder, cried out “ Help,
help, I am falling others swam leaning on floats of diverse forms, some
shaped like cranes, others like peacocks, others like serpents, or dolphins or fish.
Some, resting on their breasts like pitchers, swam about in great joy for the
gratification of Janardana. Delighted with the sight, Krishna sported with
Bukmini, even as the lord of the immortals sports with his consort ; and
his other wives did what each thought likely to please him most. Some
gazelle-eyed damsels disported in the water with very thin raiment on their
persons ; and Krishna, knowing their feeling, did for each just what she
would like most at the time. The ladies thought that in birth and accom-
plishment he was in every way worthy of them, and so they devoted them-
selves to his gratification, to win his sweet smile, and delightful converse, and
charming affection.
Separated at night from each other, the drake and the duck, mourn their hard fate, and
send forth from the opposite hanks of a river their lamentions to each other ; “ Chakwi,
shall I come ?’* “ No, chakwa.” “ Chakwa, shall I come P” “ No, chakwi,” being the
burthen of their woe. The legend has it that two lovers, for some indiscretion, were
transformed into Brahmani drake and duck, and condemned to pass the night apart
from each other on opposite banks of a river. A Bengali epigram says, a fowler shut
up a drake and a duck in the same cage at night, whereupon said the duck : “ How
happy even this sad state when the fowler appears kinder than our fate.”
frt^ira i
Trcfr i|
B<ff *c*i B^tf#«r i
ftfl *Jt«f ■flvS £SC*T ||
* Very loosely rendered and several words omitted.
1872.] Babu Rajendraldla Mitra— A Picnic in Ancient India. 317
“ The accomplished and heroic princes, in a separate company, entertained
themselves in the sea waters with the damsels that had come with them, and
who were proficient in dancing and singing. Though forcibly brought away
from their homes, these women had been overcome by the suavity of the prim
ces ; and the latter in their turn were delighted with the singing and acting
and dancing of these excellent creatures.
“ At this time, Krishna sent for Panchaelmda, Ivauveri, Mahendri, and
other accomplished Apsaras to heighten the pleasures of the entertainment,
and when they, with folded hands, appeared before him, and saluted him, the
Lord of the universe spoke to them most encouragingly, and desired them to
join the fete without fear. ‘ For my sake,’ said he, 1 O fair ones, entertain the
ladus ; exhibit to them your rare proficiency in dancing and singing, as
well as in acting and music of diverse kinds. These are all myself in diifer-
ent persons, and if you entertain them well, and acquit yourselves becom-
ingly, I shall grant you all your desires.’
“ The charming Apsaras respectfully received the orders of Hari, and
entered joyfully the pleasant throng of the noble heroes. Their advent on the
waters shed new lustre on the wide ocean, like lightning playing on the breast
of heavy dark clouds. Standing on water as on land, they played on aqua-
tic musical instruments, and enacted heavenly scenes of delight. By their
aroma and garlands and toilette, by their coquetry, blandishment, and wanton
dalliance, these sweet ones with beaming eyes robbed the minds of the he-
roes. By their side glances and hints and smiles, by their assumed arro-
gance and mirth and complaisance, they completely charmed their audience.
When the princes were overcome with wine, these bewitching actresses
lifted them high in the air, and anon held them in their hands, looking at
them with enchanting grace.
“ Krishna himself commenced the same pastime with his sixteen thousand
wives for their gratification, and this did not excite the ridicule or wonder
of the Yadus, for they knew his worth and nature, and preserved their gra-
vity. Some ran to the Raivataka hill, some to houses, and some to the
jungle, whatever suited them best, and returned immediately after. By order
of Vishnu, the lord of regions, the undrinkable water of the ocean then be-
came drinkable, and the damsels with beaming eyes, taking each other by the
hand, walked on the water as on land, now diving deep, and anon risino- 0n
the surface.
“ Of eatables and drinkables, of things to be chewed, of things to be swal-
lowed, of things to be sucked, and of things to be licked, there was nothin-'-
wanting, and whatever was desired was immediately forthcoming.
“Wearing fresh garlands, these faultless women, never to be overcome
entertained themselves in private in the cabins of pleasant boats even as
do the gods.
348
Baku Rajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India. [No. 4,
“ Having thus bathed, the Andliakas and the Vishnis in the afternoon
entertained themselves by perfuming their persons with unguents on
board their boats. Some of the cabins in these vessels were wide, others
square, others circular, others like the svastika, others like the Mandara hill,
while others like the Kailasa and the Sumeru mountains. Some were shaped
like birds, some like wolves, some like the painted Garuda, some like cranes,
some like parrots, and some like elephants ; some painted with gateways of
lapis lazuli, some gilt, some bedecked with rubies and pearls and lapis lazulis,
and other gems, — all designed for the purpose by Vis'vakarma. Guided by
able seamen, these boats, bright as gold, added new lustre to the billows.
Pleasure boats and tenders and large vessels with commodious cabins
adorned the bed of the flowing main. When these noble vessels moved
about on the sea, they seemed like the abodes of Gandharvas floating in the
air. The heavenly architect, Vis'vakarma, had, in these cabins, depicted gar-
dens and trees and tanks and festal halls and cars in imitation of those in the
Nandana Park of Indra, and they were in no way inferior to their heavenly
archetypes.
“ By order of Vishnu birds were singing sweetly and delightfully in the
forest ; white cuckoos of paradise cooed melliflucntly for the gratification of
the heroes ; peacocks, surrounded by their hens, danced gracefully on the tops
of the cabins resplendent as moonbeams. The flags of the vessels bore the pic-
tures of birds ; and the garlands on the vehicles were musical with the hum of
bees. By order of Narayana the trees (in the neighbourhood) produced fragrant
flowers of all seasons ; the zephyr, loaded with the pollen of various flowers
and the aroma of the sandal-wood, blew gently, driving away all exhaustion-
now warm and anon cool according to the varying desires of the picnicians.
No hunger, no thirst, no langour, no ennui, no grief assailed them, when
through the grace of Vasudeva, they were engaged in this delightful fete of
music, singing, and dancing.
“ Thus did these god-like heroes, protected by the wielder of the discus,
occupy themselves in their aquatic recreations, spreading over many leagues
(yojana) of the sea, the abode of waters.
“ For the sixteen thousand wives of Krishna, Vis'vakarma had provided
appropriate vessels bedecked with the choicest jewels to be found in the
three regions of the universe, and furnished with becoming wardrobes. Each
wife had her separate cabin, decorated with lapis lazuli, gold, and floral trea-
sures of every season, and redolent with the finest perfumes.
“ The long-armed and handsome Bakuleva, covered with sandal paste,
with eyes glowing crimson under the influence of kadambari wine, and un-
steady steps, paid his attention solely to I lev at i. Dressed in two pieces of
sky-blue cloth, bright complexioned as the moon, and languishing-eyed, he
appeared charming like the moon partially hidden under a cloud. With a
319
1872.] Bfibu Rajendralala Mitra —A Picnic in Ancient India.
beauteous earring on the left ear only, and a pretty lotus on the other, be-
holding the smiling face and arching glance of his love, he entertained him-
self with her.
“ Now, by order of Krishna, the destroyer of Kansa and Nikum-
bha, the charming band of heavenly nymphs repaired to the place of Bala-
deva to enjoy the sight of Revati. They saluted Revati and Baladeva,
and then spreading around them, some of the fair and lovely one3 danced, while
others sang to the sweet cadence of music. Earnest in their desire to enter-
tain Bala and his consort, the lovely daughter of king Revata, and by their
desire, they exhibited various dramatic scenes, such, as they thought would
prove entertaining. Some of the damsels of fascinating forms, assuming the
dress, language, and action of particular places, acted with great delight, beat-
ing time with their hands. Some sang the auspicious names of Sankarsliana
Ad'nokshaja, Nandana, and others. Some enacted romantic scenes from the life
of Krishna, such as the destruction of Kahsa and Pralamba ; the overthrow
of Chanura ; the tying of Janardana round the waist by Yasoda which
spread wide her fame ; the slaughter of the giants Arishta, Dhenuka, and
S'akuni ; the life at Vraja ; the breaking of the two Arjuna trees ; the
execution of Vrikas, (wolves) ; the discomfiture of the wicked Naga king
Kaliya in a whirlpool of the river Yamuna ; the recovery of certain blue
lotuses from a lake after destroying the demon S'ankha ; the holding up of
the hill Govardhana for the protection of kine ; the straightening of the hump-
back of the sandal-paste-grindress Kubja ; the reduction of Krishna’s own
faultless body into a dwarf ; the overthrow of the Saubhas, the aerial city
of Harischandra ; the assumption of the namo Hahiyudha, or wielder of the
ploughshare ; the destruction by him of the enemies of the Devas ; the defeat
of the mighty kings of Gandhara, tying them behind his car, and the rape of
their daughters ; the abduction of Subhadra ; the victory over BaMhaka and
Jambumali; the loot of jewels, through his soldiers, from Indra. These
and others, most delightful subjects, gratifying to Baladeva and Krishna,
were enacted and sung by those beautiful women.
“ Inflamed by plentiful libations of kadamba liquor, Balarima the majes-
tic, danced in joy with his wife, the daughter of Revata, sweetly beating re-
gular time with his own hands. Beholding this, the damsels, were delighted.
The wise and noble Krishna, to enhance the enjoyment of Bala, commenced to
dance with his wife, Satyabhama. The mighty hero Partha, who had come
to this sea-side picnic with great delight, joined Krishna and danced with
the slender and lovely Subhadra (his wife). The wise Gada, Sarana, Pra-
dyumana, Samba, Satyaka, the heroic son of the daughter of Satrajit (Satya-
bhama), the handsome Charudeshna, the heroic princes Nisata and Ulmuka
the sons of Baladeva, Sankava, the generalissimo of the army of Akrura
and others of the heroic race, danced in joy. By the grace of Krishna, the
350
Babu JMjeiulralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India. [No. 4,
pleasure boats flourished under the dense crowd of the foremost dancers of
the Bhaima race. Through the godlike glory of the heroic and most ardent
dancers of tho Yadu race, the creation smiled in joy, and all the sins of the
princes wore subdued.
“ The Brahman sage Narada, the revered of the gods, came to the scene
for the gratification of Madhustidana, and in the midst of the noble Yadus
began to dance with his matted locks all dishevelled. He became the cen-
tral figure in the scene, and danced with many a gesticulation and contor-
tion of his body, laughing at Satyabhama and Keshava, at Partha
and Subbadra, at Baladeva, and the worthy daughter of the king of Bevata.
By mimicking the action of some, the smile of others, the demeanour of a third
set, and by similar other means, he set all a-laughing who had hitherto pre-
served their gravity. For the delectation of Krishna, imitating the mild-
est little word of his, the sage screamed and laughed so loudly and repeatedly,
that none could restrain himself, and tears came to their eyes (from immoderate
laughing). By desire of Krishna, the ladies gave to Narada presents of
costly jewels and dresses of the rarest description ; they showered on him
also pearls and celestial garlands ol the choicest kind, and flowers of every
season.
“ When the dance was over, Krishna took by the hand the venerable sage
Narada of imperturbable mind, and coming to the sea water along with his wife
Satyabhama, Arjuna and others, addressed Satyaki with a smile, saying, ‘ let us
enter the delightful water with the ladies in two parties. Let Baladeva with
Revati be the leader of one party, consisting of my children and half of the
Bhaimas ; and let the other half of tho Bhaimas and the children of Bala be
on my side in the sea water.’ Turning then to tho regent of the sea, who
stood with folded hands before him, the delighted Krishna said to him : ‘ Let
thy waters bo fragrant and clear, and divested of noxious animals ; let them
be cheering to the sight, and ornamented with jewels, and pleasant to walk
upon. Knowing by my grace what is in each person’s mind, render yourself
agreeable to one and all. Render thy waters drinkable or undrinkable,
according to each individual’s choice ; let thy fishes be inofi'ensive and
diversified in colour like gold and jewels and pearls and lapis-lazuli. Hold
forth all thy jewels, and lotuses, red and blue, blooming and fragrant and
soft, full of sweet-flavored honey, over which the bees should pour their hum.
Place on thy waters urns full of mairaya,* madhvika,f sm'a.J and asava,§
and supply the Bhaimas golden goblets wherewith to drink those liquors.
Let thy mighty waters be cool and calm and redolent with rafts full of flowers ;
and be mindful that my Yadus he not in any way incommoded.’
* Spirituous liquor made of the blossoms of Lythrum fruticosum with sugar.
t Ditto made of the blossoms of tho Bassia latifolia.
% Ditto of rice meal, — arrack.
§ Ditto of sugar, — rum.
351
1872.] Balm Bajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India.
“ Having thus issued his orders to the sea, he commenced to play with
Arjuna, while Satyabhama, incited by a wink of Krishna, began to throw
water on Narada. Then Balarama, tottering with drink, with a-reat
glee fell into the water, and beckoning the charming daughter of Bcvata by
his side, took her by the hand. The sons of Krishna and the leading Bhai-
mas, who belonged to the party of Kama, joyous and bent on pleasure, un-
mindlul of their dresses and ornaments, and excited by drink, followed him into
the sea. The Bhaimas belonging to the party of Krishna, headed by Nisha-
tha and Ulmuka, arrayed in many-colourod garments and rich jewels and be-
decked with garlands of parijiita flowers, with bodies painted with sandal wood
paste and unguents, excited by wine, and carrying aquatic musical instruments
in their hands, began to sing songs appropriate for the occasion. By order
ot Krishna, hundreds of courtezans, led by the heavenly Apsaras, played various
pleasing tunes on water and other instruments. Always bent on love, these
damsels, proficient in the art of playing on musical instruments in use on the
aerial Ganges,* played on the instrument called laladardduraf and sweetly
sang to its accompaniment. With eyes glorious as lotus buds and with chaplets
of lotuses on their crowns, these courtezans of paradise appeared resplendent as
new-blown lotuses. The surface of the sea was covered by the reflection of hun-
dreds of moon-like feminine faces, seeming as if by divine wish thousands of
moons suddenly shot forth in the firmament. The cloud-like sea was relieved
by these damsels like dazzling streaks of the charming mistresses of the
thunderbolt, — even as the rain-bearing cloud of the sky is set off by lightning.
Krishna and Narada, with all those who wero on their side, began to pelt
water on Bala and his party ; and they in their turn did the same on the
party of Krishna. The wives of Bala and Krishna, excited by libations of
arrack, followed their example, and squirted water in great glee with
syringes in their hands. Some of the Bhaima ladies, over-weighted by
the load both of love and wine, with crimson eyes and masculine garbs
entertained themselves before the other ladies, squirting water. Seeing
that the fun was getting fast and furious, Krishna of the discus-hand
desired them to restrain themselves within bounds ; but ho himself
immediately joined in play with Narada and Fartha to the music of the
water instruments. Though they were ardently engaged in their entertain-
ment, still the moment Krishna expressed his wish, the Bhaima ladies at once
desisted, and joyously commenced to dance for the gratification of their
lovers.
“ On the conclusion of the dance, the considerate lord Krishna rose from
the water, and, presenting unguents to the learned sage, put them on himself
The Bhaimas, seeing him rise from the water, followed his example, and, put-
* It is supposed that thero is a counterpart of the terrene Ganges in the air
t I cannot find any description of this instrument in treatises on Music.
352 Babu Rajendralala Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India. [No. 4,
ting on their dress, repaired by his order to the banqueting hall. There they
took their seats according to their respective ranks, ages, and relationship,
and cheerfully commenced the work of eating and drinking. Cleanly cooks,
under the superintendence of diligent stewards, served them large pieces of
meat roasted on spits, and meat cooked as curries, and sauces made of tama-
rinds and pomegranates ; young buffaloes roasted on spits and dressed by
dropping ghi thereon ; the same fried in ghi, seasoned with acids and
sochel salt and sorrel leaves ; large haunches of venison boiled in different
ways with sorrel and mangoes, and sprinkled over with condiments ; shoulders
and rounds of animals dressed in ghi, well sprinkled over with sea salt
and powdered black-pepper, and garnished with radishes, pomegranates, lemon,
sweet basil, Ocymum gratissimum, assafretida, ginger, and the herb An-
d ropey on scluenanthus. Of drinkables, too, of various kinds, the party partook
most plentifully with appropriate relishes.* Surrounded by their loved ones,
they drank of maireya, madhvika, sura, and asava, helping them on with
roasted birds, seasoned with pungent condiments, ghi, acids, sochel salt, and
oil ; cakes of rich flavour, some made with clayed sugar, some colored with
saffron, and some salted ; ginger comfits, cheese, t sweet cakes full of ghi,
and various "kinds of candied stuffs.
“ Udhvava Bhoja and others, respected heroes who did not drink, heartily
feasted on various kinds of cooked vegetables and fruits, broths, curds, and
milk, drinking from cups made of shells fragrant rasala of diverse kiudsf and
milk boiled with sugar.
“ After their feast the gallant Bhaima chiefs, along with their ladies,
joyfully commenced again to sing such choice delightful songs as were
agreeable to the ladies. The Lord Upendra (Krishna) was pleased at night
to order the singing of the chJtdlikya song which is called Devagandharva.
Thereupon Narada took up his Vina of six octaves whereon could be played all
the six musical modes (raga) and every kind of tune, Krishna undertook to
beat time with cymbals, and the lordly Arjuna took up a flute, while the de-
lighted and excellent Apsaras engaged themselves in playing on the mridanga
and other musical instruments. Then ltambha, the accomplished actress,
* Upadarsa. The commentator Nilakantha, takes this word for drinking goblets.
Wilson in his dictionary explains it to mean, “ a relish, or something to jiromote
drinking.” The last has the support of ancient lexicons.
t ltasala is a kind of sherbet mado with cream, curds, sugar and spices largely
diluted with water.
t The commentator Nilakantlia has failed completely in explaining some of tho
words ; Kild(a for instanco, he takes to bo an adjective meaning things made of buffalo
milk, whereas its true meaning is cheese, and the word in the mutilated form lat is still
current in the vernacular for decomposed or curdled milk. The two words preceding
it in tho text aro lawimannitan, ardrtln, salted and moist or juicy, i. c., saltod plump
chcose. The commentator, however, takes tho word ardran for a noun meaning
ginger comfits.
1872.] Babu RajendraMla Mitra — A Picnic in Ancient India. 853
cheerfully rising from one side of the court delighted Rama and Janardana
hy her acting and her exquisitely slender figure.
“ Then Urvasi, of the sparkling eye, HemS, Mis'rakc's'i, TilottamS,
Menaka, and others, for the gratification of Krishna, acted and sang whatever
was calculated to prove agreeable and pleasing to the company.” Here
follows a eulogium' on the Ckkalikya tune, which was sung in six
octaves, and in various modes. The young and the old alike joined in the
song, in order, evidently, to bring all the six octaves into play which no
single human voice could compass. Originally, it was a speciality in the
concerts of Indra in heaven. On earth Baladava, Krishna, Pradyumna,
Aniruddha and Samba were the most proficient in it, and they taught
it to the other Yadavas. Songs for this tune, I understand from my
young friend, Babu Sureudramohan Tagore, who has made the Hindu
science of music his special study, and possesses a critical knowledge
of the subject, were composed of lines of 26 syllables, and scanned in
groups of four syllables, the first two being long, the next short, and
the last circumflex. The measure of time (tala) for singing it was the
same, i. e., of two double instants, then one single instant, and lastly
a triple instant, making together a measure of eight instants. This
measure was called Chachchatpufa. The subject of the song was always
something fierce and heroic. I annex at foot the Sanskrit quotations from
the Sangita Ratnavali and the Sangita Darpana furnished me hy my friend
in support of his explanation.* On the conclusion of this song which
was sung hy different parties, and repeatedly encored, Krishna rewarded
the dancing girls and the heavenly actresses, and the company broke up.
UT<?wfij*opr<ffTwr5T<T-
Uolfjiy 55TJT: I
TjTfi W,
<Tlif fk THRU |
w: II Tf«T |
vrrfk ^qjmTcrirr q^fuqw!3T<n^trWi7rrn»tf<¥ih tp^
jp ^ ss I ^ I •ja^cntr-
•14
a. k
v
: 1 a
INDEX
AbhiptSr, .,.
Abors,
Abor, the name of,...
Adhvaryu, the officiating priest, . .
ALivasis, a tribe in MathurS,
Ahoms,
Ahavaniya fire,
Akbarnagar (liajmahall),
Akbamamah, ,,, ...
A’lapiir,
Akyah Pahari, ...
’Ala uddin of Delhi,
’Alauddin, tomb of,...
’Alamganj Golah,
’Alamshah, ... ...
’Alauddin Firuzshah, of Bengal, ...
All Burari, ...
Altamsli,
Alwari, a dialect of Low Hindi,
Ambar- Jaipur,
Anandapdr, ...
Anangpdl,
Aphsar, a village in Bihar, ... ...
Ankas, an Asamese tribe,
Arakan, ... ...
Aramuna,
Aratni, a measure,...
Arghya, an offering, performed with beef, . .
Arrian quoted,
Artocarpus, Chaplaska,...
„ integrifolius, ...
Asam, .,
Assi Khamba, the, in Cokul,
Page
.;. ... 86
... 9
25
.:. 183
... 331
32
... 183
... ... 49,64
49
112
61
105
... Ill
... ... 50
110
... 332, 339
94
112
... 122
... ... ... 98
53
' ... 205, 206
... 277
... 76 note
49, 63, 202
... ... 198
••• ... 183
191
... 329
14
ibi
9, 32, 49, 52, 68, 77, 82, 335
327
356
Index.
358
Index.
Page
360
Index.
Ghargaon, in Asam, . . . .
Ghazni, ... .. ... ,,
Ghoraghat, . .
Ghosrawan Inscription, . . , ,
„ Monastery, in Bihar, . .
Chusulkhanah, at the Dihli Court,
Giryak Hill, . ,
Gmelina arborea, . . . . , .
Gokarnesvara Siva at Dharjnsala, , , , ,
Gokula, , , , . , , , ,
Gomedha sacrifice, . , . . . . , ,
Gonaser Hills, . . . , , . . .
Gond Tribe, clans of, . . . . ... , ,
Grammar, comparative, of the Gaurian Languages,
Grehya Sutras, on beef,
Growsc, F. S., the Tirthas of Vrmda-vana and Gokula, .
Guana lizard, eaten,
Gujadhar river,
Gujarat,
Gwaliari, a dialect of Low Hindi,
Gwalpara, in A'sam,
Habraghat, in Asam,
Hajo, (vide Azo) in Asam, , ,
Hamidullah Khin, a historian,... , ,
Hamorii grass, . . , ,
Hatsilah, in Karibari Parganah,
Hat Hazin', in Chittagong,
Hindi, Low, dialects of, . . , ,
Hirapdr, in A'sdm,
Hoernle, A. R. F., on Gaurian Languages, . .
Hot springs,
Hulugurinagar, ... .. ..
Hugli,
Huru Muton chang, the,
Husaini Dynasty of Bengal,
Husain Shah of Bengal, . . . .
Hwen Thsang,
Ibn i Muhammad Wali, or Sliihabuddin Talisli,
Ibrahim Bayu,
Ilyas Shah, of Bengal,
India, I he use of Beef in Ancient, . . .
Page
22, 32, 33, 34, 36, 74
. . . . . . 207
.. .... 52
. . . • • • 268
* . • • . . 266
• • * • • • 66
234, 235, 236, 263, 277, 285
. . 184
• • . • 8
313, 326
. . . . 174
.. 76
.. .. 115
120
178
.. 313
. . 177
54
. . 205, 206
... 122
50
55 note
. . . . 55
.. 336
s . . . 13
... 50, 65
. . . . 337
... 121
„ . . 60
120
238, 239, 243
.. 32
• . 36, 250
14
. . 331
49, 50, 77, 106, 332
. . 211, ff.
51
. . . . 286
. 105, note
. . 174
46
L L
362
Index.
364
Index.
Mu’azzam Khan, Mir Jumlali,
Mu’azzamabad,
Mughuls mentioned in Chand,
Muhammad Shah Tughluq,
Mukarram Khan, the conqueror of Hajo,
Mukarrampur Parganah,
Mukindra, Zamindar of Bosnah,
Munger (Monghyr),
Music, Hindu, . . . .
Muton, Chang, The, , .
Muttok river, . . . .
Muzaffardbad, . .
Muzaifar Shah, of Bengal,
Naga Bih, a poison, . .
Nagas, a tribo in Asirn,
„ vocabulary,
Naipali, Prakritie Gaurian, . .
Nakirani, in Asam,
Nalanda, in Bihar, . .
Namdang, in Asam, . .
Namrup, . . . ,
Namsangias, an Asamese tribe,
Nancowry, language spoken at,
Nandimukha, , .
Narainganj, ■ .
Nardin Bupees coined, . .
N arendracharitavalokana Pradipika wa,
Nashudani, nickname of Shahryar,
Nashuja’ nickname of Prince Shuja’
Naugaon, a village in Asam,
Nawakhali, in. Bengal,
Nazirah in Asam, • •
Netia, a clan of the Gond Tribe,
Neyowlung Nagas,
Nicobar Vocabulary,
Nilgai, . .
Nimaya Sindhu,
Niriida Pasnabandha, . .
Nirmalkund,
Nityajya an oblation, . .
Nokrong village,
10,
Page
33, 49, 63
.. 336
201, 205
79, note
50
60
59
54, 335
.. 353
20
74, note
.. 106
107
31
9, 76, 84
29
.. 169
. . 76, 94
231, 299
. . 74, 75
. . 74, 85
24
1
.. 183
96
66
.. 197
68
68
24
49
d, 49, 82, note
115
14
1
.. 179
195
182
222
185
14
3GG
Index.
Index.
367
368
Index.
Tiger bhut, or ghost,
Tik Mauza’, in Asam,
Tiladaka, (Tillarah),
Till&rah, in Bih&r,
Tiparali district,
Tirliut, . ,
Titrawan Monastery, in Bihar,
Tocoopalm, the,
Tondamana,
Trinkutt, Language spoken at,
Tulsi Das, a Hindi poet, ...
Udakasanti,. .
Udayagir Hill, in Bihar,
Ukkaka,
Upakarana, , . , .
Urdu, ...
Utkara, or refuge field,
Uttaranabhi,
Uttara llamacliarita quoted, . .
Uttaravedr,
Uttarkol, in A'sam,
Vaisali Dynasty,
Vkjapeya, . .
Vallala Sena,
Vapa,
Vapasrapani, . . , .
Varuna, ox sacrifice to,
Vasishtha,
Vindhyft Range, southern boundary of Hindi,
Vipula Mount,
Yishnu, ox sacrifice to, . . . ,
Yishtara, a seat for priests,
Yisvamitra, . . . .
Yisvedevah, ..
Vocabularies, Nicobar,
„ Naga,
Vrihamaradya Purana,
Yrind^bana, . .
Wattu bamboo, . . , ,
Waqi’ahnawis, or newswriters, . .
Yajna, origin of,
Yak Duar,
Page
... 118
.. 86
250
251, 252
49, 336
52, 255
266, 278, 283
13
.. 197
.. .. 1
... 122
. . 183.
236, 245, 247
... 198
... 185
.. .. 121
... 184
184
51
... 184
. .. 59
203
. . 178
195
189
185
. . . 178
176
... 121
235, 237, 243
.. 178
191
.. 176
. . 191
1
29
194
313
13
51
179’
. . . 64
Journal, Asiatic Socy., Bengal, Pt. •!, 1372.
INSCRIPTION ON THE TOMB OF’aLA-UDDIN SHAH AT BADAON.
FI: U
Journal, Asiatic .Society of Bengal, Ft; T. 187?
Naan.- Uoimm
Nohjin
Jo boh<i/ . 3 GOO fceit ,
Jo boh a., CtuuroQ
LoTujiJrnj
Jounn: A. Soc: B eng’al . Pt •. 1. 1872
PL IT.
AK, or tattoo, of the BA N PA FI AS •
MU TONS and JOBOKA CHANG L.
Joupn: A. Soc: Beng’al . Pt: 1 . 1872.
PI:
Na,y<h Morrama, or jshuXL house (p. 19)
Net yd Drum (p. 19.)
Nftyd Jakoi’S
Hu,rorup% to cctvvy
Load*. The titvap
pa^ 6( vi rottnd the
forehead .
Btvmboc loop* for wiUebvruj (p. in.)
Afogcu With, Jus dhuLO dUmbuxcf cu tx***.
Journal, As iaAic S o oie t y oF B exigaL , Ft: L 187 2 .
Journ: A. Soo: Bengal. Pt:1.1872.
PI: VI.
A NAC,A WOMAN unththe DHAO.
( the
waistband or Mekla
2 jt 5 fz inch
)
PL.W.
7 heJia/a/t&PcUare at ffharacwrVjA. s<x?n, .
Stucco 0 rrui r/tecit# irv the- J’aZoLce.
i
\
RESTORED ELEVATION OF THE GREAT NALANOA TEMPLE.
Journ: AS. Bengal. Pt:1. 18 72
7
p
Nr
l- a.
! PILLAR AND CAPITAL, /-ram- the* Vestibule* -of the great NALAND A TEMPLE
N-E STUPA) fountlin. TITRAWAN.
7WTT-
_a
M
n.,.n
can □ □
d □ □ □ □
□ □ □ □
u "nr
■ j
>4
r-O
Scale 10 Feet to an Inch.
BUDDHIST TEMPLE ON THE BAIBHAK HILL RAJGIR
Litho. at the Survr, Genl’s. Office. Calcutta, Dec. 1873.
If. A n A J J I T
«
Hf-
'i
c
PLAN
jjilcio. at the Survr. Geni’s. Office. Calcutta, Dec. 1872.
Journal Asi& PI; Kill.
zz
Jo urn etl Asiatic S ociety Bengal. Pt: I. 1872.
mm
PILLARS, from the Sctrujuv M*xsjid out TILL.ARAH (T Mcuihakee).
( /Suje i of the Oriofun^U- ) .
I
Joum. As. 800 Bengal, Part I. 1873.
Plate XIV
p? ^52 £ l> • t! -> IS 43 -« Jl
£$ 'Hi > r» ,i? ^ "■ A ^ l->
-> "•« £j Xi j£, o -£J jP Ai >> x £ ~js F
=%32-*' §SS£
» £ X* -M
^ ^ ;2j*£'
£ -, 5 -£ rr^u?i "3 ^ ^ ^ ^ p* 5
^ £*»
,AQ Cx
2 a,K
2 ' S3 ->
"v x £ •>' £
45 0“ r* r. -*
^ < § S ^
S -.c S *2 ■.
| ȣ ng ^ IJ x* i-i* ^ 3* s Nl> J'' Cm >"
<2v^=‘ £* ^ rt • <=± -£ C2 >- ^ /n jb< ir] 4> ,£*
j&sz-p^ £ 5 £ ^ > '% .*• -g > "M* ^
-£ £ Is € £>• £, 5 -?■’ v Ji't s £
^ 2S-?-'gc>7- «!£££ Js* b “ -'
H 3^ | 5 $ " * is % £#2 Jl
5 2^#^15tf«S®l'§l£ft5.:&i
« 2t
* it
2j '*•’ £ >’
jM y ^ X /S _>4 3^ £j XI 4*^ -T7: - >j 9* ■*» f* J2,
f* ^ ^ ^ 5S £ >£; ? j* ^ "*"S <£ 2f 5;
£2
JN ^ >s 'i ^ ‘> ^ 'E' ^ *g - ^ y>
- iS fl Jgr S 5 ^ -** ^ '*■
% !%£■
f
r 54
•Miotn nr»«tr»^ Qed st 'Jw Surwvor iicutnl's Ot‘lif*o Ca,
THE GH08RAW Atf INSCRIPTION.
irrJAV'A KfLlM.8
.SV8C .r , 60s -A am
■ ‘.V —
Journ. A. Soc. Bengal, Part I. 1872.
Plate XV.
%
*-%•
0001
o
o
Setpokxxr
tr Scurpcfoocr
'i
I
°l°
0^0
w
o
t H
w
►-<
p
p
co
Lifcho. at the Survr. Genl's. Office. Calcutta, Dec. 1872.
OHOSRAWAN RUINS
i ' RZl’Jff KHT *0
.YJ13T8AKOM KAWAflTIT
Journ. A- Soc. Bengal, Part I. 1872.
Plate XVI.
ROUGH PLAN
OF THE Kinss OF
TITRAWAN MONASTERY.
BT A. M. BROADLEY, ESQ. C. S.
Srt Bu.Ustsn BndsjhxtJ
f A Q
*• a 400
2
JS.
Srt. BitZhan or BaiJ'cu*.
/'ctn/c |
Stupa
■ .2,60
Teotple.tiMfci
I
I
StupaJ
•*</ - JOO_
! 4*- "7 V\ihAraJ
J DiriO-
Tjjujis
stup<xjf^y
VtllatjeJ cf* Trfrawfxn
Litho. at the Survr. Genl’s. Office. Calcutta, Dec. 1872.
AND HINDU RUINS.
Dm
jrgPardbafo Monastery
Aphsccr
REFERENCES.
Route of Fah-Hiyan, in 415 A. D
Route of Hwen Thaang, according
to the •’Vie.”
Route of Hwen Thaang, according
to the “Memoirea”
PATNA^
?i xttooluu St
JTiZsa,
i Kdhov\
MonasU)
mTillarah
Vy-or Tiladakxx/
'<y xM'oruLsUry
.Jahanabad
ixjare*,
Jiiawak.
Biswa Monastery
\ ,%2f
y 1 stamp ur
/ Miibarakpiet'
i S or undo.
'tar
’ Nalatida
Saura
yteswari
■ Mahnulda
ftwapu-rL
,Varabair Monastery
Aphsccr
sroMton
lewdery
Dharawaih
< luindi nuuv
Kaiyanpur
;,Ht r,7fc i}
REFERENCES.
Mi\f' f?**
idcLadwdr Caf/t
Barabtrn
SirKaida.. (
Route of Fah-Hiyan, in
Route of Hwen Thsang,
to the ••Vie. 11
Route of Hwen Thsang,
to the “Memoires,Y
according
according
lBu dokhura
SUB-DIVISION BIHAR IN DISTRICT PATNA, “WITH THE SITES OF BUDDHISTIC AND HINDU RUINS.
Litho. ah the 8urvr. GenVa. Office. Calcutta, Dec. 1873.
JOURNAL
OF THE
ASIATIC SOCIETY OF BENGAL.
— ♦ —
VOL. XLI.
PART II. (Natural History, &c.)
(Nos. I to IV. — 1872.)
EDITED BY
T HE j-fONORARY ^SECRETARIES.
“ It will flourish, if naturalists, chemists, antiquaries, philologers, and men of science
in different parts of Asia, will commit their observations to writing, and send them to
the AsXc Safety at Calcutta. It will languish if such commumcaUons shall be long
intermitted ; and it will die away, if they shall entirely cease. but VVm. Jones.
CALCUTTA :
^INTBD BV p. P. PEWIS, pAPTIST /ilSSION fRESS.
1872.
■Notice* to Members and (correspondents.
The duties of the London Agency of the Society
will hereafter be carried out by Messrs. Trubner
and Co. of 60, Paternoster Row, London, and it
is requested that all applications in Europe for
the publications of the Society, hitherto made to
Messrs. Williams and Norgate, may be addressed
to Messrs. Trubner and Co., and that all com-
munications for the Society’s Journal and Pro-
ceedings and all books, &e., for the Society’s
Library may be sent to the same firm.
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS.
Page
Bah, Y. ; — Notes on Collection of Birds, made in the Andaman
Islands by Assistant Surgeon Q-. E. Dobson, M. B., during the
months of April and May, 273
Blaneoed, W. T. ; — Account of a visit to the Eastern and North-
Eastern Frontiers of Independent Sikkim, &c., Part II, Zoology, 30
; — Notes on a Collection of Birds from Sikkim
(with Plates vii and viii), 152
; — Monograph of Himalayan, Assamese, Barmese
and Cingalese Clausilise (with Plate ix), 199
Brooks, W. E. ; — Notes on the Ornithology ofCashmir, 73
; — On two undescribed Cashmir Birds, 327
Dat, F. ; — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidae, Part IV, (with Plate I), 1
• ; — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidae, Part Y, 171
; — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidae, Part YI, >318
; — Notes on Fish, collected by Dr. Stoliczka, in Kaehh, 258
Dobson, G. E. ; — On the Osteology of Triasnops persicus, (with
Plate VI), 136
; — On the Osteology of some species of Bats, 334
■ ; — Brief descriptions of five new species of Khinolo-
phine Bats, 336
Godwin- Austen, H. H. ; — Third list of Birds obtained in the Khasi
and Garo hill ranges, 142
Ktjez, S. ; — New Barmese Plants, (Part I), 291
Schwendleb, L. ; — On Differential Galvanometer, 144
Stoliczka, F. ; — Notes on various new or little known Indian Li-
zards, (with Plates II and III) 86
; — Notes on various new or little known Indian Li-
zards, (with Plates IV and V), 177
; — Postscript to the Monograph of Himalayan and
Barmese Clausilise, (with part of Plate IX), 207
Notice of the Mammals and Birds, inhabiting
Kaehh, 211
— ; — On the Land-shells of Penang Island, Part I,
Cyclostomacea , (with Plate X), 261
Theobald, W. and Stoliczka, F. ; — Notes on Barmese and Ara-
kanese Landshells, &e., (with Plate XI), i# 329
Date of issue of the different numbers of Part II, Journal.
No. I, — containing pp. 1 — 116, with pis. i — iii, — was issued on 1st May,
1872.
No. II, — containing pp. 117 — 170, with pis. iv — viii, — was issued on 25th
June, 1872.
No. Ill, — containing pp. 171 — 271, with pis. ix and x, — was issued on 12th
November, 1872.
No. IV, — containing pp. 273 — 351, with pi. xi, — was issued on 22nd Decem-
ber, 1872.
2
[No. 1,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprmidce.
1.
2,
3.
4.
6.
6.
7,
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
*22.
Synopsis of Species.
A. With four barbels. (Pachystomus.)
Barilius rerio, D. 2/7, A, 3/12, L. r. 26 — 28. With blue horizontal bands.
India.
O Q
„ piscatorius, D. 2/7, A. — , L. 1. 42. With 10 vertioal bars. Hi-
malayas and Nipdl.
„ radiolatus, D. 2/8, A.. 2/10, L. 1. 56. Uniform. Central India.
10—11
2—3
, L. 1. 43. Back dark, sides silvery.
modestus, D. 2/7, A.
Pa/njdb.
Bleeleeri, D. 2/7, A. L. 1. 43. Seven vertioal bars. Panjdb.
shacra, D. 217, A. 218, L. 1. 53. Twelve vertioal bars. Bengal,
N. W. Provinces and Asdm.
bendelisis, D. 2/7, A. 3/8, L, 1. 43. Short vertioal bars. Southern
India.
2 2
cocsa, D. A. L. 1, 42. Yertioal bars. Throughout India.
B. With two barbels. (JBendilisis.)
vagra, D. 2/7, A. L. 1. 42. Indistinct vertioal bars. Ben-
gal and N. W. Provinces.
barila, D. 2/7, A. 3/10, L. 1. 43 — 46. With 14 or 15 vertical bars.
Bengal, Orissa.
wigrofasciatus, D. 2/7, A. 2/11, L. r. 30. A dark lateral band,
Bv/rma.
C. Without barbels. (Barilius.)
Bdkeri, D. 3/10, A. L. 1. 38. A row of large spots. Tra-
vcmcore.
Canmensis, D. 2/10, A. 2/13, L. 1. 38. Two rows of spots. Camara.
2 3 o
gatensis, D. — g— , A. — L. L 40. With 15 vertioal bars.
Western Chits and Neilgherries.
tileo, D. 2/8, A. 2/12, L. 1. 70. Two rows of spots. Bengal and
Asdm.
papillatus, D. 3/7, A. L. 1. 39. From 7 to 9 vertioal bands.
Orissa.
bola, D. 3/7, A. 3/10, L. 1. 88. Two rows of blotches. Orissa,
Bengal, Asdm.
g Vilnius, D. 2/7, A. 3/11, L, 1. 44. Two rows of spots. Burma,
imterruptus, D. 2/7, A. 2/12, L. 1. 34, incomplete. Short vertical
bars. Hatha.
barna, D. 2/7, A. 3/10, L. 1. 42. Nine vertioal bands. Orissa,
Bengal, Asdm.
o
borelio. D. 2/7, A. Silvery. Bengal and N. W. Provinces,
hoalius, D. 9, A. 10. Uniform. N. W. Provinces.
1872.]
3
j\ j)ay — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
A. With four barbels. (Pachystomus.)
1. Bamlius (Pachystomus) n ratio.
Cyprinus rerio, Ham. Bach., Fish. Ganges, pp. 323, 390 ; *Cuv. and Val., xvi,
p. 406.
Perilampus striatus , McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 290, 397, pi. 46, fig. 1, (from IT. B.
MS.)
Sa/riUns rerio , * Giinther, Catal., vii, p. 292.
Danio lineatus, Day, Free. Zool. Soo„ 1808, p. 198, and 1869, p. 378.
Poncha-geraldi. Uriah.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 13, Y. 8, A. 3/12, C. 19, L. 1. 26—28, L. tr. G.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/4, height of body 1/4, of dorsal fin
2/13, of the total length.— Eyes : diameter nearly 1/3 of length of head, 1/2
a diameter from end of snout, and 1 diameter apart. Lower jaw the long-
er; rostal barbels short, maxillary ones reaching the opercle.— Teeth :
pharyngeal, crooked, pointed, 5, 3, 1/1, 3, 5.— Fins : dorsal commences oppo-
site the anal, and slightly before the middle of the total length ; dorsal and
anal highest anteriorly ; caudal deeply forked. Lateral line : absent.
Colours': about four metallic blue lines along the sides and forming three
bands on the caudal fin. Dorsal with a blue edging. Anal with three
longitudinal blue bands.
Hab. — Bengal and Madras, attaining to about 2 inches in length.
Hamilton Buchanan and McClelland give 17 rays as existing in the anal fin.
2. Bamlius (Pachystomus) piscatobitjs.
Opsari'iis piscatorius, McClell., Cal. Joura. Nat. Hist. 11, 1842, p. 582.
Barilius albumus , Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 289.
Chari , Panj.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 16, Y. 9, A. ?==?, C. 19, L. 1. 42, L. tr. 8/4,
Vert. 16/23.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the total
length.— Eyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of snout.
The posterior extremity of the maxilla extends to beneath the middle of the
orbit ; lower jaw slightly the longer. Third suborbital bone twice as deep
as the uncovered portion of the cheek below it. Humeral process very
short. Itostral barbels nearly half as long as the head, maxillary pair very
short. — Teeth: pharyngeal, crooked, 5, 3, 2/2, 3, 5. Fins : doisal higher than
long, commencing midway between the posterior edge of the orbit and the
root of the caudal, its last two rays being over the anal ; pectoral not quite
so long as the head; caudal deeply forked.— Colours : ten dark bands
descend from the back to the lateral line ; fins yellowish, the edge of the
caudal stained greyish.
jpdb. Rivers in the Sub-Himalayas and Ganges, where it attains above
five inches in length. Also Nipal and Sikkim. It does not appear im-
4
F. Bay —Monograph of Indian Oyprinida). [No. 1,
probable that specimens “ a — b, 4 -Jr inches long, from the collection of the
East India Company” now in the British Museum, may have been a por-
tion of the ten typical specimens of O. piscatorius, McClelland, which
were presented by him to the East India Museum, (see McClelland’s list in
Cal. Journ. of Nat. Ilist.,) and now form types of E. alburnus, Gunther.
3. Barilitts (Pachystomus) radiolatrs.
Barilius radiolatus, Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 287.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 15, V. 9, A. 2/10, C. 19, L. 1. 56, L. tr. 5/6.
Length of head 2/9, height of body 2/9 of the total length, excluding
the caudal fin. The specimens in the British Museum are in a very bad
state, having apparently been dried and subsequently placed in spirit by the
Messrs, von Schlagintweit, or else when just caught immersed in alco-
hol which was too strong, and subsequently shaken about until their
tails were destroyed. — Eyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1 diameter
from end of snout, and rather more apart. The posterior extremity of the
maxilla extends to a little behind the front edge of the orbit ; lower jaw
projects slightly when the mouth is closed. The third suborbital bone near-
ly reaches the proopercular ridge, Humeral process short. Two pairs of
short barbels. — Fins : the dorsal higher than long, commencing midway
between the eye and the root of the caudal fin, its last ray not extending so
far as to arise above the anal. Caudal apparently deeply forked.
.flab. — Central India.
4. Barilitts (Pachystomus) hodesttjs.
? Opsarius bicirrhatus, McClelland, Cal. Journ. Nat. Hist., ii, 1842, p. 582.
? Barilius bicirrhatus, *Guntlier, Catal., vii, p. 290.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 15, V. 9, A. _A_, C. 19, L. 1. 43, L. tr.
10 — 11 4£
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 2/11, height of body 2/9 of the total
length. — Eyes : situated in the anterior half of the head, and 3/4 of a
diameter from the end of snout. Suborbital ring of bones wide, the third
nearly touching the preoperoular ridge. Upper jaw slightly the longer ; the
posterior extremity of the maxilla reaches to below the middle of the orbit.
Rostral barbels extend to beneath the front margin of the eye ; the maxil-
lary pair minute. Humeral process short. Fins : dorsal two-thirds as high
as the body below it, commencing midway between the posterior extremity
of the caudal lobes and the snout ; it is entirely, or all but the last ray, in
advance of the anal. Pectoral nearly as long as the head, but not reaching
the ventrals, which last extend half way to the base of the anal. — Lateral
line : very slightly concave.— -Scales deciduous, two and a half rows between
the lateral line and the base of the ventral fin. — Colours : back brownish,
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidw. 5
strongly defined from tlie silvery sides ; caudal edged with dark ; the other
fins yellow.
Hah. — The Ravi river at Lahore, where it attains four inches in length
and is not uncommon,
This fish differs in coloration from McClelland’s, which, he observes, has
nine incomplete bars on the sides. The reason of this may be, that his speci-
mens were obtained from the Ivhyber pass and Kabul river, where coloration
is probably more vivid ; as, however, the species possesses a pair of minute
maxillary barbels, McClelland’s name, (provided both are identical), is a mis-
nomer.
5. Baetijus (Pachystomus) Bleekebi.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 13, Y. 9, A. L. 1. 43, L. tr.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal, 1/6, height of dorsal 1/7, of body 1/5
of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 1/3 of length of head, 3/4 of a diame-
ter from end of snout. Lower jaw slightly the longer, having pores on its
lower surface, but none on the snout ; the posterior extremity of the maxilla
extends to beneath the middle of the orbit. Third suborbital hone not
quite half as wide as the uncovered portion of the cheek below it. Humeral
process small. Four long barbels, the rostral extending to below the pos-
terior third of the orbit, the maxillary to about the same place. Fins :
dorsal rather higher than its base is long, but not so high as the body below
it, commencing midway between the snout and middle of the length of the
caudal fin, its last one or two rays being over the anal ; the lower caudal
lobe slightly the longer. Pectoral as long as the head without the snout, and
extending three-fourths of the distance to the ventral which does not reach
the anal. — Scales : with several raised lines on each ; two and a half rows
between the lateral line and base of the ventral fin.— Colours : silvery, be-
coming white beneath, and having a purplish tinge along the back ; seven
short vertical blue bars along the middle of the side. Fins orange ; caudal
stained on its outer edge.
Hah. — A river at Gangrete, which joins the Beeas in the Sub-IIima-
layan range. It is a small species and out of six specimens obtained the
largest was only three inches in length, and was said to he adult ; it was full
of ova.
6. Baeilius (Pachystomus) shacba.
Cyprinus shacra, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 271, oS5.
Barbus schagra, *Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 196.
Opsarius cirrhatus, McClell., Indian Cyp., pp. 296, 416, pi. 56, fig. 5,
(from H. B. MS.)
Shacra cirrhatus, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 294.
Ourha, Panj.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 15, V. 8, A. 2/8, C. 19, L. 1. 53, L. tr. 11/9.
0
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce. [No. 1,
Length of head, of caudal and of height of body each 2/9, of the dorsal
fin 2/13 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head,
1 diameter from end of snout. Maxillary barbels as long as the eye, the
rostral slightly longer. The maxilla reaches to below the anterior margin of
the orbit ; third suborbital bone as wide as the uncovered portion of the
cheek below it. Humeral process extends to rather behind the origin of the
pectoral fin. — Teeth : pharyngeal, 5, 4/4, 5, crooked.— Phis : dorsal commences
midway between the posterior margin of the orbit and the base of the
caudal fin, its last ray is over the first of the anal. The four outer pectoral
rays strong. Caudal deeply forked. — Gill rakers absent. — Lateral line :
goes to the centre of the base of the caudal fin .—Colours : back olive, rest
of the body pinkish silvery ; about twelve incomplete bars go from the back
downwards towards the lateral line. The lower two-thirds of the vertical
fins stained.
Hab. — Bengal, Bihar, N. W. Provinces and As am. The species is
said to attain 5 inches in length.
7. Bari i.ius (Pachystomus) bendelisis.
Cyprinus bendelisis, Buchanan, Joum. Mysore, iii, p. 315, pi. 32, and Fishes of
Ganges, pp. 270, 385 ; *McClellaud, Ind. Cyp., pp. 297, 118.
Gobio bendilisis, *Cnv. and Val., xvi, p. 316.
Barilms bendelisis, Giinther, Catal., vii, p. 288.
B. I IT. D. 2/7, P. 13, V. 9, A. 3/8, C. 19, L. 1. 43, L. tr. 8/4.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 2/9, of dorsal fin
1/6 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1 diameter
from end of snout and apart. No pores on snout ; the posterior extremity
of the maxilla reaches to below the anterior third of the orbit. The third
suborbital bone more than twice as high a« the uncovered portion of the
cheek below it. Four short barbels. Humeral process styliform and scarce-
ly elongated. — Fins : dorsal much higher than its base is long, commen-
cing slightly nearer the snout than the posterior extremity of the caudal,
and not extending to over the anal ; caudal forked, lobes rather pointed. —
Lateral line : with 2} rows between it and the ventral fin. — Colours : silvery,
with greenish vertical bars, descending towards the lateral line ; dorsal fin
stained greyish in its centre, externally white ; caudal likewise stained grey.
Some of the scales have occasionally a black spot at their bases. Humeral
process silvery.
I Lab. — Mysore and Southern India, attaining 4/ inches in length.
8. Barilius (Pachystomus) cocsa.
Cyprinus cocsa, Ham, Bueh., Fish. Ganges, pp. 272, 385, pi. 3, fig. 77.
„ chedra, Ham. Buoh., 1. c. pp. 273, 385 ; Gray and Hardw., 111. Ind.
Zool., (from H. B. MS.) ; McClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 293, 409 ; *Cuv. and
Val., xvi, p. 421.
„ tila, Ham. Buch., 1. c. pp. 274, 385 ; *Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 422.
7
1872.] F. Day — Monograph, of Indian Cyprinidce.
Leuciscus cocsa, Imnchiatus, et bracfoiatus, McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 293, 291, 409,
411, pi. 42, fig. 5, *Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 469.
Barbus cocsa, Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 197.
Cyprinus apiatus, Val., in Jacq. Voy. Ind. Or., Atl., t. 15, fig. 3; McClelland Ind.
Cyp., pp. 293. 408.
Leuciscus apiatus, Cnv. and Val., xvii, pp. 351, 495, pi. 510.
Opsarius dualis (?) Jerdon, M. J. L. and S., 1849, p 330.
Chedrus cocsa, Stein., Sitz. Ak. Wiss. Wien, 1867, lvi.
Barilius cocsa, Gunther, Catal., vii, p 288.
Kholcsa, Beng. Pitch wahree, Panj. Johra, Mali.
B. III. D. * , P. 13, V. 9, A. C. 18, L. 1. 42, L. tr. 8±=?.
Length of head 1/4, of caudal 2/9, height of body nearly 1/4, of dorsal
fin 1/6 of tho total length.— Eyes : diameter 1/4 of length of head,
1 diameter from end of snout, and II apart. In large specimens the snout
is generally covered with pores. The posterior extremity of the maxilla
extends to below the anterior third of the orbit. Third suborbital bone as
wide as the uncovered portion of the cheek below it. Humeral process
generally very broad, and posteriorly produced in a lancet shaped form, more
or less elongated in dilferent specimens. Four short barbels. — Teeth : pharyn-
geal, 5, 4, 2/2, 4, 5. — Fins ; dorsal much higher than its base is long, it
commences midway between the snout and the centre of the caudal fin, and
does not extend to over the anal ; caudal forked, lower lobe the longer.—
Lateral line : 21 rows of scales between it and the base of the ventral fin. —
Colours : silvery shot with purple ; back of a slaty grey descending in bars
towards tho lateral line and most distinct in immature specimens. Each scale in
adults with a black spot at its base, and two on each forming the lateral line.
Fins whitish, tinged with orange. A grey margin to the dorsal and caudal,
the lower lobe of which is sometimes stained black. Humeral process black-
edged.
JTuh. — Continent of India, not recorded from the Malabar coast. It
attains 6 inches in length.
B. With two barbels, (Bendilms)
9. Bari Lies (Bendilisis) vakea.
Cyprinus vagra, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 269, 385 ; *Cuv. and Val., xvi,
p. 420.
Opsarius isochcilus, McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 298, 421, pi. 56, fig. 1, (H. B. MS.)
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 15, V. 9, A. C. 19, L. 1. 42—45, L. tr. ||-
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/4, height of body 1/4, of dorsal fin
2/11 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 1/3 of length of head, 3/4 of a
diameter from end of snout, 1 diameter apart. The posterior extremity of
the maxilla extends to below the middle of the orbit ; the third suborbital
8
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinulw.
[No. 1,
bone nearly touches the preopercular ridge. Two short rostral barbels.
Humeral process short. — Finn : dorsal commences midway between the pos-
terior margin of the orbit and the base of the caudal fin. — Lateral line :
1|- rows between it and the base of the ventral fin. — Colours : silvery with a
light band and indistinct vertical bars.
ILab. — Bengal and N. W. Provinces, attaining 5 inches in length.
10. Bauti.tus (Bendilisis) bakila.
Cypnnus ha/rila, Ham. Buch., Fish. Gang., pp. 267, 384 ; #Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 418.
„ chedrio, Ham. Buch., 1. c. pp. 268, 381; #Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 419.
Opsarius amsoclieij/us, McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 298, 422, pi. 48, fig. 8.
Barilius morarensis, Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 290.
„ larila, Gunther, 1. c. p. 291 ; Day, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 378*
Gilland and Caedra, Beng. Persee, Hind. ,
B. III. D. ? P. 13, V. 9, A. i C. 19, L. 1. 43—16, L. tr. 61/5.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal nearly 1/5, height of body 1/4, of dorsal fin
1/6 of the total length. — Fyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1 diameter from
end of snout and apart. The posterior extremity of the maxilla reaches to be-
low the anterior third of the orbit. Third suborbital bone wide and nearly
touching the preopercular ridge. Rostral barbels, small. — Teeth : pharyngeal,
crooked, pointed, 5, 4, 3/3, 4, 5. — Fins : dorsal commences midway between
the posterior margin of the orbit and the base of the caudal fin. — Colours :
silvery, with fourteen or fifteen vertical blue bands in the middle third of
the side of the fish.
Sab. — Bengal and Orissa, grows to 4 inches in length.
11. Babilxtjs (Bendilisis) nigbofasciattts.
Barilius nigrofasciatm, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 620.
? Cyprmus clwpalio. Ham. Buch , pp. 324, 390, *Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 416.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 15, Y. 7, A. 2/11, C. 19, L. 1. 30, L. tr. 7.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal nearly 1/3, height of body 2/7 of the
total length. — Byes : diameter nearly 1/2 of length of head, 1/4 of a
diameter from end of snout, 1 diameter apart. Lower jaw prominent.
No rostral barbels apparent, the maxillary extend to below the middle of the
orbit. — Fins : dorsal situated over the first portion of the anal, and midway
between the posterior extremity of the orbit and the base of the caudal,
which last is lunated. — Lateral line, absent.— Colours : very similar to
B. rerio, H. B. A dark band passes along the side of the body, and a
second dotted line below it. Dorsal and anal spotted with black in lines.
In some specimens the body is intensely blue.
Hub. — Pegu and Moulmein. Out of 20 specimens none exceeded 7/10
of an inch in length.
1872,]
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinulas.
9
0. Without barbels (Barilius).
12. Barilius Bakebi, PI. I, Fig. 2.
Barilius Balceri, Day, Proc. Zool. Soo., 1865, p. 305, and Fish. Malabar, p. 218,
pi. 18.
Pteropsarion Balceri, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 281.
B. III. D. * P. 15, Y. 9, A. C. 17, L. 1. 38, L. tr. 9/4.
Length of head 1/4, of caudal 2/9, height of body 2/7, of dorsal 1/6 of
the total length. — Byes : diameter about 1/4 of length of head, 1 diameter
from end of snout, 1} diameters apart. Mouth compressed, lower jaw the
longer, the posterior extremity of the maxilla extends to nearly below the
centre of the orbit. Some pores exist along the margin of the lower lip, on
the snout, and on the anterior edge of the preorbital. No barbels. — Teeth ;
pharyngeal, curved and pointed, 5, 4, 2/2, 4, 5. — Fins : dorsal commences
nearly midway between the end of the snout and the base of the caudal,
extending to above the fourth anal ray ; caudal forked, lower lobe very
slightly longer. — Lateral line : 2 rows of scales between it and base of the
ventral fin.- — Colours : greyish becoming white on the abdomen. A row of
large bluish spots along the side. Dorsal, anal, and pectoral fins margined
with white, and having dark grey bases. Caudal, grey in the centre.
Hah. — Hill ranges of Travaneore, whence I received several specimens
collected by the Rev. H. Baker. It attains six inches in length.
13. Babtlitjs Canarexsts.
Opsarius Ca/nwensis , Jerdon, M. J. L. and S., 1849, p. 329.
Barilius Canarensis, Day, Proc, Zool. Soc., 1870, p. 374.
B. III. D. 2/10, P. 15, V. 9, A. I, C. 21, L. 1. 38, L. tr. 9/4.
13
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 2/9, height of body 1/4 of the total
length. — Byes : diameter 1/4 of length of head, more than 1 diameter from
end of snout. This species is veiy similar to the B. gatensis, C. and V., differ-
ing however in a few points : less rays in the dorsal fin, the lower caudal
lobe decidedly the longer ; the dorsal fin commences midway between the
snout and the base of the caudal ; the lower jaw the wider, the maxillary
extends to below the anterior margin of the orbit. No barbels. — Lateral
line : 2j rows between it and the base of the ventral fin. — Colours : greenish
above, golden on the sides, a double row of large green spots along the body
as far as to above the base of the anal fin where they become confluent.
Fins grey, with broad white margins.
Hub. — Canara on the Western coast ; attaining 6 inches in length.
2
10
[No. 1,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cgprinidco.
14. BaEILUTS GATEHSIS.
Lcuciscm gatensis, Cuv. mid Val., xvii, p. 309, pi. 503.
Opsa/rius gatensis, #Bleeker, Pro. Gyp. , p. 288.
„ Malabaricus, *Jerdon, M. J. L. and S. 1849, p. 328.
Barilius gatensis, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 291 ; Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1870, p. 378.
BariUus rugosus, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 294 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 291.
Aart-candee, Tam. “ River carp.”
E. III. D. ?=?, P. 15, V. 9, A. _JL_, C. 18, L. 1. 40, L. tr. 8/5.
Length of head nearly 1/4, of caudal a little above 1/6, height of body
1/4, of dorsal 1/8 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head,
1 diameter from end of snout, 1 J diameters apart. Cleft of mouth extend-
ing to below the centre of the orbit. The third suhorbital bone is about
three times as broad as the uncovered portion of the cheek below it. The
anterior portion of the snout and the sides of the jaws covered with large
glands ; a few more likewise on the lower jaw. No barbels. — Teeth : pharyngeal,
crooked, pointed, 5,4, 2/2, 4, 5. — Fins: dorsal commences midway between
the end of the snout and the middle of the caudal fin, extending to above
the third anal ray. Caudal moderately lobed, the lower very slightly the
longer. — Lateral line : 2 rows of scales between it and the base of the ven-
tral fin. — Colours : silvery grey with about 15 vertical bars descending from
the back. Dorsal and anal with dark bases and light margins. The females
and young generally have smooth scales, whereas most of the adult males
have one or more rough spots on each.
ILab. — -Western Grhats and Neilgherry hills, attaining 6 inches in
length.
15. Baeilitjs TILEO.
Cyprinus tileo, Ham. Buch., Pish. Gang. pp. 276, 385 : *Cuv. and Yah, xvi, p. 426.
Opsarius maculatus, McClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 297, 417, pi. 47, f. 4.
„ braclviaUs, McClell., loo. cit. pp. 297, 418, pi. 48, fig. 6 ; #Cuv. and Val. xvi,
p. 471.
Barilius tileo, Steind., Sitz. Ak. Wiss. Wien, 1867, Ivi; Gunther, Catal. vii,
p. 287.
Tilei, Asam.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 15, V. 9, A. JL, C. 19, L. 1. 70, L. tr. 14/5.
1 a
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 2/11, height of body 2/7 of the total
length. The posterior extremity of the maxilla extends to below the anterior
margin of the orbit. The third suborbital bone is more than twice as broad
as the uncovered portion of the cheek below it. No barbels. — Colours : two
rows of greenish blue spots along the sides.
Hab. — Bengal and Asam ; attaining 8 inches in length.
1872.]
11
F. Day — Monograph of Indian OyprinidcB.
16. Bautlius papillatus.
Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 378.
B. III. D. 3/7, P. 15, V. 9, A. -JLj, C. 21, L. 1. 39, L. tr.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 2/7, of dorsal fin 2/11,
of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 1/3 of length of head, nearly 1 diameter
from end of snout. Third suborbital hone thrice as deep as the uncovered por-
tion of the cheek below. Humeral process rather narrow. The posterior extre-
mity of the maxilla reaches to below the anterior margin of orbit. No bar-
bels.— Fins: dorsal commences midway between the posterior margin of the
orbit and the base of the caudal, its last ray is thickened and reaches the caudal
when laid flat. The inner rays of the ventral are likewise thickened. Cau-
dal with rounded lobes. — Scales, with a few elevated spots on each. — Lateral
line : 3 ij rows of scales between it and the base of the ventral fin. — Colours :
yellowish, the hack grey, and from seven to nine broad and deep blue hands
from the back to the abdominal profile. Dorsal fin stained grey in its upper
third and caudal in its last third.
Hob. — Cossye river ; attaining 3 inches in length. A variety exists in
the Mahanuddi with the eye somewhat smaller, and the opercle narrower, but
in other respects it agrees with the typical form. Also found at Birbhum
in Bengal, where it is tolerably abundant in the Mora river.
17. Barilius bola. PI. I, Fig. 3.
Cyprinus bola , Ham. Buch., Pish. Gang., pp. 274, 385; #Cuv. andVal., xvi,
p. 423.
„ goha, Ham. Buch., loo. cit. pp. 275,385 : Gray and Hard, (from H. B.
MSS.) ; *Cuv. and Yal. xvi, p. 424.
Opsarius graeilis, McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 297, 419, pi. 47, fig. 1.
„ megastomus, McClell., loo. cit., pp. 298, 420, pi. 48, fig. 5.
Leuciscus saXmoides, Blyth, J. A. S. of B. 1858, p. 289.
Barilius goha, Steind., Sitz. Ak. Wiss. Wien, 1867, lvi.
Bola goha, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 293.
Opsarius goha, Day, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 379.
Bugguah, Uriah. Korang, Asani. Bola, Beng. Buggarah, Hind.
B. III. D. I P. 13, V. 9, A. 1, C. 19, L. 1. 88, L. tr.
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 2/11, height of body nearly 1/5, of dor-
sal fin 1/8 of the total length.— Ayes : diameter 1/5 to 1/6 of length of head,
11 diameters from end of snout, and apart. Dorsal profile rather more con-
vex than the abdominal. Head compressed, snout pointed, a well developed
knob on symphysis of the lower jaw. Suborbital ring of bones wide,
especially the third which is wider than the opercle. Mouth deeply cleft,
the posterior extremity of the maxilla extending nearly one diameter of the
12
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce. [No. 1,
orbit behind the posterior margin of the eye. No barbels. — Fins : dorsal
commences midway between the origin of the ventral and anal fins, its last
ray being over the first of the anal. Caudal lobed, the lower lobe slightly the
longer. — Colours : silvery with two or more vortical rows of bluish blotches
along the sides, the upper being about twelve to fifteen, and the lower inter-
mediate ; some spots also on the head. Lower half of the dorsal fin slightly
grey. Caudal orange, stained with grey and black. Pectoral, ventral, and
anal orange, the colours being somewhat similar to those of a trout ; it
often goes by that name amongst Europeans.
Hab. — Orissa, Bengal, N. W. Provinces and Asam, attaining a foot in
length.
18. Babtlius guttatus.
Opsarhis guttatus, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 620.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 15, Y. 9, A. 8/11, C. 17, L. 1. 44, L. tr. 9/5.
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 2/9, height of body 2/11, of dorsal fin
2/13 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter nearly 1/5 of length of head,
1/ diameters from end of snout and apart. Cleft of mouth deep, extending
nearly one diameter behind the orbit. A well developed knob above sym-
physis of lower jaw. Suborbitals very broad, more especially the last which
is nearly behind the vertical from the posterior margin of the orbit. No
barbels. — Fins : dorsal commences midway between the posterior extremity
of the orbit and the base of the caudal, being opposite the interspace between
the ventral and anal fins. Caudal forked, lower lobe slightly the longer. —
Colours : silvery, shot with purple, two rows of blue spots along the side.
Lower caudal lobe orange, its upper lobe with a dark edging.
Hab. — Irawadi from Prome to Mandalay ; attaining 7 inches in length.
19. BaEIMTTS ENTEEBUPTCrS.
Barilius inierrwpims, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 559.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 10, V. 7, A. 2/12, C. 19, L. 1. 34, L. tr. 6i.
4^
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 1/5, height of body 2/7, of dorsal fin
2/11 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 2/5 of length of head, rather
more than 1/2 a diameter from end of snout, and 1 diameter apart. Lower
jaw slightly the longer. Third suborbital bone about twice as wide as the
uncovered portion of the cheek below it. The posterior extremity of the
maxilla extends to below the anterior third of the orbit. Humeral process
very slightly developed. No barbels. — Teeth : pharyngeal, uncinate, 5, 4, 2/2
4, 5. — Fins : dorsal commences in advance of the anal, and midway
between the posterior margin of the opercle, and the base of the caudal fin,
which latter is forked in its posterior three-fourths, — Lateral line ; descends
13
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
gently for five scales, then more abruptly for two more, and having been
continued along five more scales to above the ventral fin, it ceases. — Colours :
silvery, with short vertical bars along the middle of the side. The upper
scales with black spots.
Ilab. — Hotlia, whence Dr. J. Anderson brought many specimens mea-
suring up to 2 inches in length, having collected them when attached to the
Yunan expedition.
20. Barilitts barka.
Cyprinus barna, Ham. Buck., Pisli., Ganges, pp. 268, 384 ; *Cuv. and Val. xvi,
p. 419.
Opsanvs fasoiatus, Mo.Clell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 269, 417, pi. 48, fig. 9.
,, latipinna tax et acantlwpterus, McClelland, Ind. Cyp., pp. 298, 422, f
pi. 48, fig. 7; *Cuv. and Val. xvi, p. 472.
Sarilius barna, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 290 j Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 378.
Bahri, Uriah. Balisundree, Asamese.
B. III. D. | , P.13, Y. 9, A. C. 19, L. 1. 42, L. tr. ?=*
7 10 5
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 2/7, of dorsal
fin 1/6 of the total length. — Byes : diameter 2/5 of length of head, 2/3 of
a diameter from end of snout, 1 diameter apart. Third suborbital bone
twice as broad as the uncovered portion of the cheek below it. Humeral
process slightly developed. The posterior extremity of the maxilla reaches
to beneath the anterior third of the orbit. — Bins : the dorsal commences
rather nearer the snout than the base of the caudal, its posterior rays, when
laid flat, merely reach half way to the base of the caudal fin. — Lateral line :
2]- rows of scales between it and the base of the ventral fin. — Colours : nine
bluish black vertical bands on the body, Dorsal and caudal fins tipped with
black.
Mob. — Orissa, Bengal, AsSm, attaining 4 inches or more in length,
A variety exists in the Mahanuddi river, which has the dorsal fin more
elevated, the eye slightly larger, and the cleft of the mouth a little greater.
21. Baktlius borelio.
Cyprinus borelio, Ham. Bnch., Pish. Ganges, pp. 336, 392; *Cuv. and Val., xvi,
p 443.
„ solio, Ham. Buch., loc. cit. pp. 337, 392 ; *Cuv. and Val., xvi, p. 444.
It Orel i and Soli, Beng.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 15, Y. 9, A. 2/9, C. 18, L. 1. 39, L. tr. 7/7.
Length of head nearly 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the
total length. — Byes : diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of
f McClelland in his errata directs 0. latipiimatus to be substituted at p. 422 for
0. acanthopterus.
It
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce. [No. 1,
snout. Suborbital ring of bones broad, the third nearly covering the cheek.
The posterior extremity of the maxilla reaches to below the anterior third of
the orbit. No barbels. — Fins : dorsal arises midway between the eye and the
base of the caudal, its anterior rays as long as the head without the snout,
the posterior rays extend half way to the caudal fin which is lobed. — Scales :
21; rows between the lateral line and the base of the ventral fin. — Colours :
silvery, above tinged with green, lighter below ; fins yellowish, the upper half
of the dorsal stained greyish. Eyes silvery.
Ilab. — Gangetie provinces ; attaining 4 inches in length. The Solio is
said to differ in its abdomen not being yellow, and having a scale-like
appendant above both pectorals and ventrals.
22. # Babilius hoaiitts.
Oyprinm hoalius, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 336, 392; #Cuv. and Yal., xvi,
p. 442.
Hayali, Beng.
B. III. D. 9, Y. 9, A. 10.
“ Eorm much compressed, straightish above and prominent below. # # #
The head is small, the jaws equal in length, # # * the lateral line is bent
parallel to the edge of the belly.” — Fins : “ The fin of the tail is divided into
two lobes.” — Colours : green above, silvery below.
Ilab.-— Eivers in Northern Bengal ; attaining six inches in length.
Genus. Danio, Ham. Buch. sp. (see PI. I.)
Perilampus sp., McClelland.
Paradanio et Devario, Bleeker.
Body compressed , abdomen rounded. Pseudobranchice present. Mouth
narrow , directed obliquely upwards. Stcborbitals broad. Barbels four , or
two , or none. Pharyngeal teeth hoolced, 5, 3, 2/2, 3, 5. Dorsal fin moder-
ately elongated , its posterior rays being opposite the anal which is long.
Scales of moderate size. Lateral line concave, passing to the lower half of
the tail. Gill rakers short.
Geographical distribution. — These prettily marked little fish are found
throughout India, Burma, and Ceylon.
Synopsis op Species.
a g
1 Danio devario, D. - ■ , A. — — tt, L. 1. 41. No barbels. Orissa, Bengal,
' Is — 14 14 — lo
Asam..
2. „ spinosus, D. A. L. 1. 62. No barbels, or a short rostral pair,
One or two spines on the margin of the orbit. Pegu.
3. ,, aMA-olineatus, D. A. L. 1. 34 — 40. Rostral barbels. South Malabar.
15
1872.]
4.
5.
*6.
7.
8.
9.
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidas.
O Q
„ Uneolatus, D. — , A. — , L. 1. 33. Rostral and maxillary barbels. Sik-
kim, Tenasserim.
„ dangila, D. 2/11, A. — . Two pairs of long barbels. Bengal and Bihar.
„ chrysops, D. 13, A. 20. No barbels. Bengal.
„ Neilgherriensis, D. A. b. 1 Rostral and sometimes
maxillary barbels. Neilgherry Hills, Madras.
„ osteographus, D. 2/11, A. -jjp. L. 1. 35 — 37. Rostral and usually
maxillary barbels. India and Ceylon.
„ aquipinnatus, D. 13, A. 13, L. 1. 32.
1. DANIO DEYAEIO.
Cypriwus devario, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 34*1, 393, pi. 6, fig. 94 ; *Cuy.
and Val„ xvi, p. 446.
Perilampus devario , McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 288, 391, pi. 45, fig. 2.
Devario Macclellandii, *Blceker, Proo. Cyp. p. 283.
Danio devario, #Giintber, Catal. vii, p. 284 ; Day, Proo. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 377.
JB onlcuaso, Uriah ; Debari, Beng.
B. III. D.
12—14 (17)
, P. 13, Y. 6, A.
14—16
C. 19, L. 1. 41,
L. tr. 11/5.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/4, height of body 1/3, of dorsal fin 1/5
of the total length. — Eyes : diameters 1/3 of length of head, 3/4 of a
diameter from end of snout, 1J diameters apart. Posterior extremity of
maxilla extends to beneath the anterior margin of the orbit ; lower jaw the
longer. Third suborbital bone broad. No barbels. — Fins : dorsal commences
slightly anteriorly to the anal, and midway between the anterior margin of the
orbit and the base of the caudal. In some specimens from Asam the anal
had 19 rays. In a few from the Garo Hills there are D, 2/17, A 2/17. —
Caudal lunated. — Lateral line : 2 j rows of scales between it and the base of the
ventral fin. — Colours : greenish superiorly, silvery white inferiorly. The anterior
part of the body is reticulated in its centre by steel-blue lines, divided from
one another by narrow yellow bands. Three bluish lines are continued to-
wards the caudal fin, where the two lower amalgamate, and passing up-
wards become lost on the superior half of the caudal fin.
Hub. — Orissa, Bengal, N. W. Provinces and Asam ; attaining 4 inches
in length.
2. Daoto sphtostts.
Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 621.
B. III. D. ?=?, P. 13, Y. 7, A. ® C. 19, L. 1. 52, L. tr. 15/4.
lo A *
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/3 of the total
length. — Eyes : diameter 2( 7 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of
1G
[No. 1,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidae.
snout and apart. Body strongly compressed : a slight concavity over the
occiput. Lower jaw prominent, having a strong hook fitting into an emar-
gination in the upper jaw when the mouth is closed. In adults there is a
sharp spine directed forwards above the anterior superior margin of the
orbit, and a second broader and blunter before the centre of the anterior
orbital margin. In immature examples these spines are equally sharp. No bar-
bels.— Fins : the dorsal commences midway between the posterior extremity
of the orbit and the base of the caudal, its first five or six rays are in
advance of the anal. Caudal lunate. — Lateral line : 3 1 rows of scales
between it and the base of the ventral fin. — Colours : silvery, with an ill-
defined lateral band, and some vertical yehow lines in the anterior half of
the body. Dorsal and anal greyish, with reddish margins anteriorly. In
the immature there is a dark humeral spot, and a steel-blue lateral hand goes
to the centre of the caudal fin, which has a scarlet stripe along the last half
of its centre.
Hab. — Pegu ; attaining four inches in length.
3. Damto auroliseatcs, PI. I, Fig. 1.
Penlanvpus aurolineatus, Pay, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1805, p. 300.
„ a/radanio, Day, Fishes of Malabar, p. 219, pi. xvii, fig. 2.
Danio malabarims, Gunther, Catal, vii, p. 283 (not Jerdon).
B. III. D. 2/12, P. 14, Y. 7, A. 3/15, L. 1. 34—40, L. tr. 8/4.
Length of head nearly 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/3, of dorsal
fin 1/7 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 1/3 of length of head, 3/4 of
a diameter from end of snout, 1 diameter apart. Lower jaw anterior,
having a distinct knob at its extremity. Itostral barbels present, half as
long as the eye. — Teeth : pharyngeal, curved, pointed 5, 4, 1/1, 4, 5. — Fins :
dorsal commences nearer the snout than the posterior extremity of the
caudal fin, and opposite the anal. Colours : three or four steel-blue lines pass
along the body.
Hal. — South Malabar, attaining 3 inches in length.
4. Dakio lxneolatu s .
Leuaiscus lineolatus, Blyth, J. A. 8. of Bengal, 1858, p. 289.
Perilom/pus aflvnis, Blyth, loc. cit. 1860, p. 163.
Danio lineolatus, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 282.
B. III. D. 3/10, „P. 13, V. 8, A. 3/14, C. 19, L. 1. 33, L. tr. 7i/3.
Length of head 1/4, height of body 1/4 of the total length. — Fyes :
diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of snout. Barbels
well developed, the rostral ones being nearly as long as the eye, and the
maxillary one-third shorter. — Colours : a dusky spot behind the gill covers.
17
1872. J F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidre.
Three straight bluish hands, divided from one another by yellow ones, pass
along the sides to the tail.
Hab. — Sikkim and Tenasserim provinces. Mr. Blyth gives D. 12,
A. 14, for D. lineolatus, and D. 13, A. 16, for D. of finis : as, however, I find
those numbers in the former, as does also Dr. Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 282, 1
have considered that some error must have occurred.
5. Danio dan GILA.
Cyprirms dangila, Ham. Buck., Fish. Ganges, pp. 321, 390 j *Cuv. and Val. xvii
p. 403.
Perilampus rcticulatus, McClell., Ind. Gyp, pp. 290, 397, ph 45, fig. 1, (from H.
B. ’s MSS-}
Danio dangila, #Bleeker, Atl. Ich. p. 29;#Gunthor, Catal., vii, p. 282.
B ™- D- io=u- r. 12, V. 7, A. jjA. , C. 20, L. 1. 38, 1. tr. 1.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 2/7 of the total
length. — Eyes : diameter 1/3 of length of head, 3/4 of a diameter from
end of snout. Lower jaw the longer, with a distinct knob at symphysis,
mouth oblique. Rostral barbels a little shorter than the headj maxillary
pair slightly longer. — Fins : the posterior dorsal rays are above the anterior
ones of the anal. Caudal slightly emarginate. — Colours : back olive colour,
abdomen silvery, sides with several narrow blue lines which in the ante-
rior half, or two-thirds, of the body form a beautiful network ; a dark spot
behind gill covers. Anal fin with two or three blue stripes.
Hub. — Bengal and Bihar ; grows to 5 or 6 inches in length. Darjil-
ing.
(!.* Danio ciieysops.
Leuciscus chrysops, *Cuv. and Val,, xvii, p. 308.
B. III. D. 13, A. 20, C. 19, L. 1. 45.
Length of head 1/5, of body 3/11 of the total length. — Eyes .- diameter
2/5 of length of head. Snout obtuse, upper jaw the longer. — Fins : dorsal
and anal pointed ; caudal slightly forked. — Lateral line curves downwards
in the pectoral region. — Colours silvery.
Hab. — Bengal, size of recorded specimen 3 inches and 9 lines.
7. Danio Neilgheebiensis.
Pamdanio Nilgherriensis , Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 296.
Danio Nilgherriensis, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 283.
Cowlie, Tamil.
B. III. D. -JL^, p. 15, V. 9, A. lTjL., C. 19, L. 1. 35, L. tr. G^L,
Vert.
20
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 2/9, height of body 1/4, of dorsal fin
1/8 of the total length —Eyes .- diameter 1/3 of length of head, 2/3 of
3
a
IS
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidos.
[No. 1,
diameter from end of snout, 1^ diameters apart. Abdominal profile more
convex tlian the dorsal one. Lower jaw anterior, with a slight knob at its
extremity ; a pair of short rostral barbels, and sometimes rudimentary maxil-
lary ones. — Teeth : pharyngeal, crooked, pointed, 5, 4, 2/2, 4, 5. — Fins : dorsal
commences midway between the end of the snout and the middle of the
caudal fin, it extends to above the fourth or fifth anal ray. Caudal emarginate
in its last fourth. — Lateral line : curved downwards in the pectoral region. —
Colours : back greenish, sides silvery, with a purplish tinge along the abdomen;
a badly marked broad, steel-blue stripe, extending from behind the eye to the
caudal fin and bounded above and below by a narrow yellow edging.
Sab. — Pavers on Neilgherry Hills ; attaining 3 | inches in length.
8. Daisho ostkograimics.
Perilampus osteographus, McClelland, Ind. Cyp., pp. 289, 392, pi. 45, fig. 3,
(erroneously numbered, pi. 56, fig. 9,) *Cuv. and Tal. xvi, p. 468.
? Chela alburna, Heckel, Fiscke Kasclimir, p. 390, c. fig.
Perilmnpus Malabaricus, Jerdon, M. J. L. & S. 1819, p. 325, (Male).
„ Canarensis, Jerdon, 1. c. p. 325, (Female).
? „ Mysoricm, Jerdon, 1. o. p. 325.
? Danio albumus, *Guntlier, Catal. vli, p. 283.
„ micronema, Bleeker, Mem. Soc. Holl. Haarlem, 1864, Ceylon, p. 19, t. 4,
fig. 2 ; Giinthor, Catal. vii, p. 282 ; Day, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 560 ;
1870, p. 374.
„ lineolatus, Bleeker, 1. c. p. 19, fig. 3.
Deva/rio cyanotcenia, *Bleeker, Prod. Cyp p. 283.
Pamdanio aurolmeatus, Day, Proo. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 296.
B. III. D. 2/11, P. 15, Y. 8, A. 3r± C. 19, L. 1. 35—37, L. tr. 7 i/3.
lo
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 2/11, height of body 2/7, of dorsal fin
1/8 of the total length. — Fyes : diameter 1/5 of length of head, 1 diameter
■from end of snout. Itostral barbels half as long as the orbit, maxillary
ones very short. In some specimens the latter are entirely absent. — Colours :
back steel-blue ; some irregular vertical yellow lines on the fore-part of the
body, and three or four blue bands along the sides, the central ones
coalescing, so as to form a broad bluish band down to the middle of the
caudal fin.
Sab. — India and Ceylon ; attaining 6 inches in length.
• 9. Dasio A'QurriNXATirs,
Perilampus oequipinnahis, McClelland, Ind. Cyp. p. 393, pi. 60, f. 1.
Fteropsarion cequipinnatus, *Giinther, Catal. vii, p. 285.
B. III. D. 2 P. 17, Y. 8, A. - 2 ■, C. 19, L. 1. 32-34, L. tr. 1 .
10 12 —14 3£
Length of head 1/5, of caudal nearly 1/5, height of body 1/4 of the
total length. — Fyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of
snout. Bostral barbels extend to the middle of the orbit, the maxillary ones
19
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
minute. Cleft of mouth oblique and extending to under the anterior mar-
gin of the orbit, a bluntish knob at the symphysis. Tongue thick and trans-
versely corrugated. In large specimens, the posterior 2/3 of the inferior
surface of the lower jaw is dilated, so that they nearly meet at the anterior
extremity of the enlarged portion ; a row of well-developed glands along the
margin of the mandible. — Fins : the dorsal arises midway between the centre
of the orbit and the base of the tail, extending to over the anterior anal
rays, it is 2/3 as high as the body. Pectoral as long as head without the
snout, reaching the ventral which last does not extend as far as the anal.
Caudal forked. — Colours : several horizontal blue bars, the largest along the
middle line of the body and continued on to the tail.
Sab. — Base of Garo Hills.
B. A pout r ox ob the whole op the abdominal edge trenchant.
a. Dorsal fin opposite the anal, which latter is elongated (9 to 21
branched rays.) .
Genus Peeilamphs, McClelland.
Paradanio, sp. Day.
Cachius et Eustira, Gunther.
Pseudobranchice present. Body oblong, compressed, with a cutting ab-
dominal edge. Mouth obliquely directed upwards. Barbels absent. Pha-
ryngeal teeth in three rows 5, 4 or 3, 2 or 1/1 or 2, 3 or 4, 5 uncinate. Dor-
sal fin rather short, without any osseous ray, and commencing opposite or
behind the origin of the anal, which last has many rays. Scales of moderate size.
Lateral line concave, passing to the lower half of the base of the caudal fin.
Geographical distribution. Fresh waters of India, Ceylon, and Burma.
Synopsis op Species.
1.
2.
3.
Perilampus atpwr, D. 2/7, A.
„ laubuca, D. 2/9, A.
19—21
2
17—20
, L. 1. 55.
, L. 1. 34,
„ Ceylonensis, D. 2/10, A. L. 1. 35.
15
India generally, and Burma.
Orissa, Bengal, and Burma.
Ceylon.
1. Peeilamphs atpae.
Oyprinus cachius, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 258, 384 (young) ; *0ur. and
Val., xvi, p. 453.
Oyprinus atpar, Ham. Buch., 1. c. pp. 259, 384, (adult) ; *Cuv. and Val. xvi, p 454
Perilampws cachius, McClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 289, 396, pi. 46, f. 6.
„ psilopteromus, McClell., 1. c. f. 4, (from II. B. MSS.)
„ macropodus, Jerdon, M. J. L. and S., 1849, p 325.
Paradcmio elegans, Day, Proe. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 297.
Cachius atpar, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 339.
20 F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidw. [No. 1,
Bonkuaso, Uriah ; Nga-man-dcm, and Ya-paw-nga and Nga-phyin-gyan,
Burmese ; Kachhi, Beng.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 10, V. 5-6, A. ig_^— , L. 1. 55, L. tr. 11/4.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/4 of the total
length. — Byes : diameter 1/4 of length of head, 3/4 of a diameter from end
of snout, 1| diameters apart. Body strongly compressed, the abdominal
edge being cutting. Cleft of mouth deep, oblique, extending nearly to be-
neath the anterior margin of orbit. Lower jaw the longer. — Teeth : pharyn-
geal, 5, 4, 1/1, 4, 5, crooked, pointed. — Fins : dorsal commences opposite the
beginning of the second third of the anal. Pectoral elongate. Ventral with
an elongated ray extending to the middle of the anal. Caudal forked, lower
lobe the longer. — Lateral line: concave. — Colours : greenish with a silvery
lateral band.
Hub. — Throughout India and Burma ; attaining 4 inches in length.
2. Perit.ampus laubuca.
Cyprinus laubuca, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp, 260, 384 ; *Cuv. and Yal., xvi,
p. 456.
? „ da/ncerm, Ham. Buch., 1. cit. pp. 342, 393.
Perilampus guttatus, Model]., Ind. Cyp., pp. 289, 394, pi. 45, f. 4 (erroneously-
marked pi. lvi, f. 10, from H. B.’s MSS.)
? „ persrns, MoClell., 1. c. pp. 289, 395, pi. 46, f. 5 ; *Cuv. and Val. xvi, p.
469.
Leuciscus laubuca, Blooker, Verh, Bat. Gen. xxv, Beng. and Hind. p. 138.
Chela laubuca, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 335.
Penlampus limbuca, Day, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1869, pp. 380, 614.
„ fulvescens, Blyth, J. A. S. of B. 1860, p. 163 ; Day, Proc. Zool. Soc.
1869, p. 559.
Bankoe, Uriah ; Nga-me-loung, Burmese ; Layubuka and Dankena,
Beng. ; Dannahmh, Hind.
B. III. D. 2/9, P. 13, V. 7, A. — 8 ■ ■ , C. 19, L. 1. 34, L. tr. 7/5.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/5, height of dorsal 1/8, of pectoral
1/3, of body 1/4 of the total length. — Eyes : high up, diameter 1/3 of length
of head, nearly 1 diameter from end of snout, H diameters apart. Body
strongly compressed with the abdominal edge cutting from the pectoral to
the anal tin. — Teeth : pharyngeal, 5, 4, 1/1, 4, 5.— Fins : dorsal arises slightly
posterior to the origin of the anal. Caudal deeply forked. Pectoral reach-
ing anal. — Lateral line : curved downwards, 3 s rows of scales between it and
the base of the ventral fin. — Colours ; silvery with some golden vertical stripes
during life. Fine dots over the body, and a black mark, shot with green, above
the base of the pectoral fin, and another at the base of the caudal, in which
the last third of the lobes is, in Burmese specimens, tipped with black.
Hob. — Orissa, Bengal and Burma ; attaining 3 inches in length.
1872.]
21
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
3. Peeilamptts Ceylonensis.
Eustira Ceylonensis, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 331.
B. III. D. 2/10, P. 17, Y. 7, A. 1, C. 19, L. 1. 35, L. tr. 7ty2.
Length of head 1/4, of caudal 1/4, height of body 1/4 of the total
length. — Eyes : diameter 1/3 of length of head, 3/4 of a diameter from end
of snout. Posterior extremity of maxilla extends to below the anterior mar-
gin of the orbit ; lower jaw the longer. — Fins : origin of dorsal opposite com-
mencement of anal. Pectoral reaching the ventral. — Colours : uniform silvery.
Hah. — Ceylon. The specimens in the British Museum are nearly 2
inches in length.
Genus. Chela, Ham. Such. (PI. I.)
Oxygaster, v. Hass.
Leuciscus, sp. Cuv. and Val.
Lwubuca, Mowrochirichthys, et Pwralaiibuca, Bleeker.
Body rather elongate and compressed ; abdominal edge cutting. Pseu-
dobranchm present. Mouth directed somewhat upwards, with the lower jaw
prominent, and generally with a knob above the symphysis. Barbels absent.
Pharyngeal teeth hooked and slender, in two or three rows. Dorsal Jin short,
without any osseous ray, situated principally or entirely opposite the anal
which latter has an elongated base ; pectorals long ; caudal forked. Scales
of moderate or small size. Lateral line concave.
Dr. Gunther suggests the following sub-genera.
a. Tho trenchant thoracic edge anterior to the pectoral supported by
the dilated bones of tho forearm. Oxygasteb.
a. Pharyngeal teeth in three rows. Oxygaster.
P n n two „ Macrochirichthys.
b. The thoracic edge not supported by the dilated bones of the fore-
arm. Sectubicula.
Geographical distribution: India, Burma and extending almost through-
out Asia. Generally termed Vellache-candee in Tamil ; Bay-ree-saie, and
Baarsee, Tel. ; Bounce-putti, Uriah ; Took, Panjab.
Synopsis op Species.
1.
2.
*4.
5.
6.
Chela SUdoni, D. 2/8, A. 2/19, L. 1. 68, L. tr. 10/8. Burma.
„ argentea, D. A. L. 1. 43-45, L. tr. f . Southern India.
„ bacaila, D. 2/7, A. L. 1. 110. Bengal, ft.
ft
novacula, D. 9, A. 17, L. 60, L. tr. 15/3. Ind/ia.
flcmpinnis, D. 2/7, A. 14r_1y L, 1. 65, L. tr. 9/5. Southern India.
untralvi, 11. 2/7, A. 3/17, L. 1. 52, L. tr. 7/5. Orissa.
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidee. [No. 1,
phulo, D. 2/7, A. 3/17, L. 1. 87, L. tr. 12/6. Bengal, Orissa, Sfc.
Sardinella, D. 2/7, A. 2/19, L. 1, 48, L. tr. 3. Burma.
4
Pamjdbensis, D. |,A. L. 1. ca. 110, L. tr. 12/9. Punjab,
dlkootee, D. 10, A. 10. Bekhan,
jorah, D. 10, A. 11. Dekhm.
teehmee, D. 10, A. 14. Belehan.
gora, D. 3/7, A. 2/13, L. 3. 140 — 160. Bengal , Orissa , $*c.
clrupeoides, D. ~g, A. L. 1. 80, L tr. Southern India.
1. Chela Sladom.
Day, Proo. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 622.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 11, Y. 8, A. 2/19, C. 21, L. 1. 68, L. tr. 10/8.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/4 of the total
length. Eyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head, 3/4 of a diameter from end
of snout. Edge of thorax rounded ; the serrated abdominal margin com-
mences opposite the base of the pectoral fin. Posterior extremity of the
maxilla reaches to beneath the anterior third of the orbit. Suborbital ring
of bones is half as deep as the diameter of the orbit.— Teeth ; pharyngeal,
crooked o, 4, 2/2, 4, 5. Fins : dorsal commences opposite the anal ; lower
caudal lobe the longer. — Colours : silvery, caudal black edged.
Hal. — Irrawaddi in Burma, extending northwards as far as Mandalay.
2. Chela aegewtea.
Day, Proo. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 301 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 334.
? Pelecus diffusus , Jerdon, M. J. L. and S. 1849, p. 327.
P Chela diffusa, *Giinther, Catal. vii, p. 334.
TVclla chee-candee, Tam. “ The white carp.”
B. III. D. P. 15, V. 8, A. C. 19, L. 1. 43—45, L. tr. 6|/3.
Length of head nearly 1/5, of pectoral rather above 1/5, of caudal a
little more than 1/5, height of body above 1/5, of dorsal fin nearly 1/9 of
the total length.- Eyes ; diameter not quite 1/3 of length of head, nearly 1
diameter apart and from end of snout. Cleft of mouth extending to below
the anterior third of the orbit, a knob at the end of the lower jaw. Suborbi-
tal ring of bones broad and covering the cheek, the third being as wide as the
preorbital. The median edge in front of the pectoral fins is not supported
jy the dilated bones of the fore-arm. Thorax without a sharp edge. — Fins :
dorsal situated in the posterior third of the distance between the snout and
6 b^se of tlle caudal fin, extending to over the commencement of the anal.
JJorsal and anal highest anteriorly. Caudal deeply \ohe&.— Lateral line ]
< eseenc s gently in the first twelve scales, finally attaining the centre of the
22
7.
8.
*9.
10.
*11.
12.
13.
14.
1872.]
23
P. Day — Monograph of Indian Gyprinidce.
caudal. — Teeth ; pharyngeal, curved, pointed, 5, 3, 2/2, 3, 5. Colours, silvery
with a lateral hand which fades after death.
H al. — Bowany river at the base of the Neilgherries, attaining 6 inches
in length.
Dr. Jerdon gives about 50 scales in C. diffusa, along the side, and
observes that his species is found in the Cauvery and all its tributaries.
I did not obtain it in the lower portions of the Cauvery, but C. argentea
was likewise absent, and I suspect the two are identical.
3. Chela bacaila.
Oyprinus bacaila, Ham. Buoli., Pish, Ganges, pp. 265, 384, pi. 8, fig. 76 ; *Cuv.
and Val. xvi, p. 460.
(ypsarins bacaila, MoClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 295, 414.
„ leucerus, MoClell., loc. oit. pp. 295, 415, pi. 47, fig. 3 ; *Cuv. and Val., xvi,
p. 470.
Leuciscus bacaila, Bleeker, Verh. Bat. Gen. xxv, Bong, and Hind. p. 137.
„ cultellus, Cuv. and Val., xvii, p. 341, pi, 507.
Felecus cultellus, Jerdon, M. J. L. and S. 1849, p. 326.
Chela bacaila, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 332 ; Day, Proc, Zool. Soc. 1869, p, 382.
Jellahri, Uriah. Chelliah, Hind.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 13, Y. 9, A. 2 -, C. 19, L. 1. 110.
Length of head 1/0, of caudal 2/9, height of body 2/11 of the total
length. — Eyes : snout slightly longer than the eye. Bones of the fore-arm
not dilated, and not supporting the abdominal edge anterior to the pectoral
fin. Suborbital ring of bones broad, nearly covering the cheek. — Teeth :
pharyngeal 5, 4 or 3, 2/2, 3 or 4, 5.- — Fins : first anal ray is below the middle
of the dorsal fin. — Scales : extend forwards on the head to nearly opposite
the posterior margin of the orbit —Colours : uniform silvery.
Sab. — Throughout India except Malabar. It may exist according to
Dr. Gunther in Moulmein, but I could not find it there. It attains six inches
in length.
4. *Chela xovacula.
Leuciscus novacula, Val. in Jacq. Voy. Ind., pi. 15, fig. 2 ; Cuv. and Val. xvi;
p. 345.
Chela novacula, *Giintlier, Catal. vii, p. 334.
B. III. D. 9, A. 17, L. 1. 60, L. tr. 15/3.
Length of head 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the total length. — Eyes :
large. — Teeth : pharyngeal — 5, 4, 3/3, 4, 5. — Fins : dorsal above the anterior
anal rays ; the pectorals nearly reach the ventrals. — Colours : silvery.
Sab. — India.
24
[No. 1,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidw.
5. Chela FLAVirnons.
? Lcuciscus scapellus, Cuv. and Val. xvii, p. 347.
Pelecus fiavipinnis, Jerdon, M. J. L. and S. 1849, p. 327.
Chela flavipinnis, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 382.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 13, Y. 9, A. —5—, C. 19, L. 1. 65, L. tr. 9/5.
Length of head 1/6, of pectoral 2/9, of caudal 2/11, height of body
1/5, of dorsal fin 1/12 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 1/3 of length of
head, 3/4 of a diameter from end of snout, 2/3 of a diameter apart. Cleft
of mouth oblique, knob on symphysis well developed. Suborbital ring of
bones half the width of the diameter of the orbit, and nearly covering the
cheek ; five small erenulations along the lower preopereular margin. — Teeth :
pharyngeal, 5, 4, 2/2, 4, 5. — Finn : dorsal situated over the anterior anal rays ;
caudal lobed, the lower lobe the longer. — Chill rakers : short. The bones of
the fore-arm do not support the thoracic edge. — Lateral line : continuous,
eventually attaining the centre of the caudal fin. — Colours : silvery ; fins
tipped with orange.
Sab. — Cauvery and Coleroon rivers in Madras Presidency.
6. Chela toteaui.
Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 381.
Untrahi, Uriah.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 13, V. 7, A. 3/17, C. 17, L. 1. 52, L. tr. 7/5.
Length of head 1/6, of pectoral 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body
1/5, of dorsal 1/9 of the total length. — Eyes : upper margin near the profile,
diameter 1/3 of length of head, 2/3 of a diameter from end of snout, nearly
1 diameter apart. Dorsal profile nearly horizontal ; abdominal profile with
a cutting edge from opposite the base of the pectoral fin. Mouth very
oblique, knob on symphysis minute. Lower jaw in advance of the upper, the
maxilla extending to below the anterior margin of the orbit. Suborbital ring
of bones moderately wide. — Fins : pectorals reaching ventrals, and a dilated
humeral supports a smooth thoracic edge. Dorsal arises midway between
the posterior margin of the orbit and the posterior extremity of the caudal
fin, and situated over the anterior anal rays. Caudal lobed, the lower lobe
the longer. — Scales: deciduous, extending forwards on the nape to opposite the
posterior margin of the orbit. — Lateral line : curves downwards, 1 row of
scales between it and base of ventral fin ; it ceases a few scales anterior to
the caudal fin. — Colours, silvery.
Sab. — Mahanadi river ; attaining five inches in length.
7. Chela phhlo.
Cyprmus phuln, Ham, Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 262, 384 ; *Cuv. and Val. xvi,
p. 457/
25
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Oyprvnidce.
Opsarius albubis , McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 296, 416, pi. 48, fig. 10.
Chela Oivewii, Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soo. 1841, p. 361, pi. 63, fig. 1.
Pelecus Owenm, *Jerdon, M. J. L. and S. 1849, p. 328.
Chela plvulo, “Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 334; Day, Proo. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 381.
JPhul chela, Beng. Dunnahree, Hind. Took, Panj.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 13, V. 9, A. 1, C. 19, L. 1. 87, L. tr. 12/6.
Length of head 2/11, of pectoral 1/5, of caudal above 1/5, height of
body 1/5 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 2/5 of length of head, 1/2 a
diameter from end of snout, 1 diameter apart. Abdominal profile cutting
posteriorly to the base of the pectoral fin. Third suborbital bone two-thirds
as deep as the uncovered portion of the cheek below it. ihe maxilla extends
to under the hinder margin of the orbit. — Tins : dorsal commences midway
between the posterior extremity of the orbit and the posterior exti emity of the
caudal fin, and slightly behind the origin of the anal. Caudal deeply forked,
lower lobe the longer.— Lateral line : curves gently downwards.— Colours :
silvery, with a bright silvery lateral band.
JJctb. Bengal, Orissa and Central India as far southwards as the Tam-
boodra and Kistna rivers ; attaining 1 inches in length.
8. Chela sardinella.
Leuciscus sa/rct/inella , Cuv. and Val., xvii, p. 344.
Chela sardinella, #Gtinther, Catal. vii, p. 338.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 13, V. 8, A. 1, L. 1. 48, L. tr. 7X
Length of head 1/6, of pectoral 1/6, of caudal above 1/6, height of
body 2/9 of the total length. — Eyes : diameter 2/7 of length of head ; 1 dia-
meter from end of snout ; nearly 1 diameter apart. The bones of the fore-
arm are not dilated and do not support the thoracic edge which is smooth,
the keeled portion commencing opposite the pectoral tin. Suborbital ring
of bones broad. — Teeth : pharyngeal, 5, 4, 3/3, 4, 5 .—Fins : dorsal commences
above the anterior anal rays. — Colours, silvery.
Hab. — Irawati river at Rangoon ; to 6 inches in length.
9. Chela Pahjabensis.
Took, Panj.
B. Ill D. 2/7, P. 11, V. 6, A. -j|, C. 19, L. 1. ca. 110, L. tr. 12/9.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/6, height of body 2/9 of the total length.
— Eyes : diameter 2/5 of length of head ; 1/2 a diameter from end of snout.
The posterior extremity of the maxilla extends to nearly beneath the anterior
margin of the orbit. Lower jaw the longer. The suborbital ring of bones
is broad, and the third three times as deep as the uncovered portion of the
cheek below it. Dorsal profile nearly horizontal ; abdominal edge cutting
4
2f?
[No. 1,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
from opposite the base of the pectoral fin. — Fins : dorsal arises midway be-
tween the posterior margin of the opercle, and the posterior extremity of the
lobes of the caudal. Pectoral longer than the head, but does not quite reach
the base of the ventral, which last fin only extends half the distance to the
anal. Lower lobe of caudal the longer. — Scales : moderately deciduous, they
extend forwards to opposite the suborbital ring of bones ; there is a slight
elevation along the centre of each ; 5-| rows between the lateral line and the
base of the ventral fin. — Colours : silvery with a burnished silvery band along
the side.
II ah. — Lahore, in the Eavi river. In appearance it is very similar to
the C.phulo, H. B.
10. *C'n£lA AJ.KOOTF.E.
Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soc. 1811, p. 362.
B. III. D. 10, P. 10, V. 7, A. 10.
“ Sides slightly compressed ; the hack and belly rounded ; back straight.’'
— Fins : “ lobes of the tail sharp, lowest the longest.” — Scales : “ excessively
minute.” — Lateral line : “ quite straight.” — Colours : “ the gill covers quite
smooth, and of a polished silver ; pupils black ; a black circle surrounds the
eyes, and there is a patch of faint yellow on the forehead ; all the rest of the
fish is of a silver white colour, and the body is semi-diaphanous.
Hab- — Dekhan ; attaining 1 inch in length.
11. *Chela joeah.
Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soc. ii, p. 361.
B. III. D. 10, P. 12, Y. 8, A.. 11, C. 18..
“ A somewhat compressed fish ; straightish back, convex belly. Co-
lours : “ back dark, with a purplish shade, softening into silver down the sides
and abdomen.”
II ah. — “ Found abundantly in the Beema river, near Pairgaon. 5
12. *Chela teekajiee.
Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soc. ii, 1841, p. 362.
B. III. D. 10, P. 12, V. 9, A. 14, C. 8.
“ A compressed fish ; hack very slightly arched ; snout nearly in a con-
tinuation of the same line ; body deep ; belly convex.” — Fins : “ dorsal situat-
ed far back.” — Colours : “ on the back light reddish brown, softening into
silver.”
JEIab. — Beema river at Pairgaon ; attaining 2 J inches in length.
1872.]
- 27
P. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
13. Chela goha, PI. I, Fig. 4.
Cyprinus gora, Ham. Bucli., Fish. Ganges, pp. 263, 384; #Cuv. and Val, xvi ,
p. 458.
Opsarius pholicephalus, MoClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 295, 415, pi. 47, fig. 2.
Chela gom, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 332; Day, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 381.
Ilum-catohari, Uriah. Gliora chela, Beng. Chel-hul, Hind. Sown-
chi and Kundul, Panj.
B. III. D. 3/7, P. 15, Y. 9, A. 1, C. 19, L. 1. 140—160, Vert. 46.
lo
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/6, height of body l/o of the total
length. — Eyes : diameter 1/5 of length of head, l j diameters from end of
snout, li diameters apart. The bones of the fore-arm do not support the
abdominal edge, the keeled portion of the abdominal prolile commences pos-
terior to the ventral fin. Suborbital ring of bones broader than the diame-
ter of the eye, but only covering two-tliirds of the cheek. Teeth : pharyngeal,
5, 3, 1/1, 3, 5.- — Gill ralcers : very short, curved, 8 in the lower branch of the
outer bronchial arch. — Fins : dorsal commences slightly in advance of the
anal. — Scales : extend forwards on the head to above the nostrils. Colours :
silver y.
Ilah. — Bengal, Orissa and Asam ; attaining 8 inches in length.
14. Chela clupeoides.
Cyprinus clupeoides, Bloch, xii, p. 49, t. 408, fig. 2.
■Civ, pea cyprinoides, Schn., in Bloch. Syst. Ich. p. 427.
Chela baloolcee, Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soo. ii, p. 360.
Leuciscus clupeoides, Cuv. and Val. xvii, p. 342.
„ Cussumieri, Cuv. and Val. xvii, pi. 508.
f „ aci races, Cuv. and Val. xvii, p. 347, pi. 509.
Velecus afiinis, Jerdon, M. J. 1,. and S. 1849, p. 327.
Chela clupeoides , *Giinther, Catal. vii, p. 333.
Netteli, Tam.
B. III. D. yJL, P. 13, V. 9, A. C. 19, L. 1. 80, L. tr.
Length of head from 2/9 to 1/5, of pectoral 1/5, of caudal 2/11,
height of body 2/11, of dorsal fin 1/10 of the total length. Eyes : diameter
1/3 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of snout, 3/4 of a diameter
apart. Rather a strong knob on symphysis ; opercle as broad as high.
Abdominal edge trenchant. — Teeth : pharyngeal, 5, 4, 2/2, 4, •>. Fins : dorsal
situated in the posterior 2/5 of the body, and very slightly in advance of the
anal. Caudal lobed, the lower lobe the longer. — Scales : deciduous and
placed in sinuous rows. — Lateral line : at its termination passes upwards to
the upper portion of the inferior lobe of the caudal fin. — Colours : silvery.
JJab. — Madras Presidency, Mysore and the Dekhan ; attaining 6 inches
in length, and very good eating.
[No. 1,
28 • F. Day —Monograph of Indian Ci/prinidce.
11. Sul-Fam. HOMALOPTERINA.
Apdlopterinai, MoClell.
Pseudobranchice absent. Body elongated and depressed anteriorly,
having a broad smooth abdomen. Snout prominent before the mouth, which
latter is small, transverse, inferior and central, with fleshy lips. Barbels
present. Branchial aperture vertical and narrow. Pharyngeal teeth in a
single row, conical. Pectoral and ventral flm horizontal, forming half discs.
Body scaled. Air bladder absent.
Geographical distribution. — -Streams and mountain torrents in the Hills
of India, and extending as far as Java and Sumatra.
Oku one known genus.
Homaloptera, 6 barbels, none on mandibles.
12. Genus. Homaloptera, v. Hass.
Balitora, Gray.
Flatycara, McClelland.
Head and anterior part of body depressed ; snout more or less spatu-
late. Mouth small, inferior, with two pairs of rostral barbels, and one at
either angle of the mouth. Pharyngeal teeth small, from 5 to 16 in one row.
Pectoral and ventral fins with many rays, the outer of which are simple.
Dorsal short, situated opposite to the ventrals ; anal likewise short.
Geographical distribution. — Java and Sumatra, and through some of
the hilly districts of the Himalayas to the Wynaad in Madras Presidency.
Synopsis op Species.
M
1. Homaloptera Brucei, D. 3/8, A. 2/5, L. 1. 70. Brown blotched with darkor.
Wynaad Mils in Madras.
2. „ maculata, D. 11, A. 2/5, L. 1. 78. Butan and Khasi Hills.
3 ,, bilineata, D. 9, A. 6. Horizontal bands. Tenasserim Provinces.
1. Homaloptera Brucei.
Balitora Brucei, Gray and Hard., Ind. Zool. j *McClelland, Ind. Cyp., p. 299, 428,
pi. 49, fig. 1. (From Gray and Hard.) ; *Cuv. and Val. xviii, p. 101,
Flatycara cmstraUs, Jerdon, M. J. L. and S., 1849, p. 333.
Homaloptera Brucei, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 348 ; Gunther, Catal. vii,
p. 340.
Cal-eandee, Tam. “ Stone carp.”.
B. III. D. 3/8. P. 19, V. 9, A. 2/5, C. 17, L. 1. 70.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/6, height of body 1/7 of the total
length. — Byes : directed upwards and outwards, diameter 1/5 of length of
head, 3 diameters from end of snout, 2 diameters apart. Snout broad,
depressed ; lips fringed. Rostral barbels short, then- length equalling about
29
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
2/3 of the diameter of the orhit, the pair at the angle of the mouth thicker
and slightly longer. — Teeth: pharyngeal, in one row, 5/o. Fins : dorsal high-
est in front, arising midway between the end of the snout and the base of
the caudal. Pectoral nearly reaching the ventral. Caudal lobed in its
posterior third. — Scales : cycloid. — Lateral line : complete. Colours : dull
olive, becoming yellowish beneath. Large brown blotches on the body.
Dorsal fin with three rows of dull spots ; pectoral and ventral with three or
four, anal with two, caudal with three irregular bands, and black tips.
Ilab. — Wynaad ; 8 specimens taken up to 3| inches hi length.
2. HoMAXOPTERA MACULATA.
Balitora maculata, Gray and Hard., Ind. Zool. ; *Cuv, and Val. xviii, p 102.
Platy caret mac: tlata, McClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 299, 427, pi. 49, fig. 2. (From Gray
and Hard.)
„ cmisura, McClell., Cal. Jonrn. Nat. Hist, ii, p. 587, pi. 16, L
Homaloptera maculata, Gunther, Catal. vii, 340.
B. III. D. 3/8, P. 21, V. 11, A. 2/5, C. 17, L. L 70, L. tr. 10/7.
Length of head 2/13, of caudal 1/5 of the total length. — Eyes : 2%
diameters from end of snout, 1 diameter from end of opercle. Snout broad and
depressed, with sharp margins ; rostral and maxillary barbels small. — Teeth :
pharyngeal, conical, in one row, 15/15. — Fins : pectoral nearly reaches the
ventral, its anterior nine rays are unbranched, as are also the first two of the
ventral. Lower caudal lobe the longer. — Scales : absent from chest and as
^ fur as the posterior margin of the base of the ventrals. — Colours : dark brown
with darker blotches ; caudal banded.
Rah. — Himalayas from about Darjeeling through Butan, Asam and
the Khasi Hills.
3. * Homalopteea bixxneata.
Blyth, J. A. S. of Bengal, 1860, p. 172.
B. III. D. 9, A. 6.
Said to he affined to H. erythrorhina , Cuv. and 1 al., xviii, pi. 524.
“ A minute knob on the muzzle.” — Colours : “ A narrow dark line from
the muzzle to eye, continued behind the eye as a broad, irregular, somewhat
zigzag band, set off laterally with whitish, and joining its opposite behind
the dorsal fin. A corresponding but obscure band below the lateral line,
little seen on the hind half of the body. Dorsal with a large blotch of
black, and one small posterior spot. Caudal fin also black, with the sides of
its base and the forking tips white (or yellow ?), but the extreme tips black.
Pectorals, ventrals, and anal, blotched with black ; sides of body somewhat
nigrescent.”
Hal. — Tenasserim provinces ; the largest specimen obtained was 2f
inches long.
(To be continued.)
30
[No. 1,
Account of a visit to the Eastern and Nobtiiebn Frontiers of
Independent Sikkim, with Notes on the Zoology of the Alpine
and Sub-alpine eegions, Paet II, Zoology, — by William T.
Blanfoed, F. G. S., C. M. Z. S.
(Received 29th September, 1871.)
Tlie present paper will contain notes on the Vertebrata collected, or
observed, in the Alpine and Sub-alpine portions of Independent Sikkim, a
few remarks being added on some of the animals inhabiting the neighbour-
ing regions in Tibet. Only those species will be noticed which are found
in the region of pine forests, or in the Rhododendron bushes and open ground
above the limit of trees, and consequently no animals will as a rule be
mentioned which are not found above 10,000 feet on the eastern Chola
ranges, and above 8,000 feet in Northern Sikkim. This elevation, which is
about the lower limit of pines, is also a fair approximation to a boundary
line between the two faunas which meet in the Eastern Himalayas, the Malay
and the Palrearctic.
The fauna of the plains of India appears to penetrate deeply into the
Western Himalayas and to meet the Palaearctic fauna ; hut, as a rule, it stops
suddenly at the base of the mountains in Sikkim. A few birds found in the
outer valleys are species which inhabit the Indian Peninsula, but they form
but a very small percentage of the avi-fauna ; the great bulk of the
animals of every class are either peculiar to the South-western Himalayas, or
common to it and the Malay Peninsula. The most striking characteristic of
the fauna of India proper is the presence of numerous forms with western
and generally African affinities, such as Hyaena, Canis, Mellivora, Zepus,
Antilope, Gazella, amongst mammals ; Neophron, A quit a, (restricted,)
Thamnobia, Malacocircus, Pastor, Ammomanes, Pyrrliulauda, Calandrella,
P ter odes, Cursor ins, amongst birds ; Cabrita, Ophiops, Sitana, Eryx, Ediis,
amongst reptiles ; Oyclotopsis amongst land mollusca, &c. All of these
disappear in the Himalayas of Sikkim, and their place is taken by a far
richer lamia. Amongst the mammals Arctonyx, Helictis, Arctictis, Una,
Bhizomys and Nemorhcedus, almost all Malayan forms, make their appear-
ance ; amongst birds the sub-families Eurylaiminee, Ldotridiinae, Macropy-
yinte, Phasianina, entirely unrepresented in India, are found, whilst the
number of Bidden* Cuculides, Capitonhlw, Nectarinidce, Crateropidce,
* In the plains of India exclusive of Malabar there are 12 species of Woodpeckers
enumerated as found by Jcrdon. All except two or three being very local. In
tropical and temperate Sikkim alone 17 are found. Of the Timalinae of Jerdon 13
are found in various parts of India exclusive of Malabar, nine are peculiar to Malabar,
and no less than 48 have been found in the South-eastern Himalayas.
1872.] W. T. Blanfori Zoology of SiTcJcm. 81
-3 luscicapidcs, Merulidce (especially Buticillinw), Pycnonotidce and Treroniclis
is greatly increased.
In the higher elevations of Sikkim, an entirely distinct fauna appears,
which is almost purely Palsearctic, although a lew Malayan types are met
with. Arctomys, Laqomys, Mosclius and Ovis appear amongst the mam-
mals, whilst nearly all the species found at lower elevations disappear. Of
the birds, scarcely any of the Pica-rue, and only a single species of the
Timalince are found at 12,000 feet ; the Pycnonotidce and TreronUhe are
wanting, and the only families which gain in numbers are the Cinclidce,
Fringillidce, and Phasianidce. Amongst the genera which are deficient at
the lower elevations, but common in the higher ranges, are Oypaetus
Troglodytes, Lophophanes, Accentor, Propasser, N uc if rag a, Fregilus,
Ithagenis and Lerva.
The principal object of my visit to the higher ranges of Sikkim was to
examine and collect this Palsearctic fauna, and the principal result has been to
ascertain that in these mountains two well marked sub-divisions of it are
found : one inhabits the damper southern slopes of the hills, while the other is
peculiar to the dry Tibetan climate. The latter we only entered in the
upper Lachen valley, close to Kongra Lama, and to it belong the peculiar
forms, Otocoris El ires i, Leucosticte Juematopygia, Mont if ring ilia rufcolhs,
Fregilus pyrrhocorax, Cinclus sordidus and Accentor rubeculoides.
A second object in my visit was to learn, so far as practicable, which of
the migratory Passerine birds, found in the Indian plains in the winter,
breed in the South-west Himalayas. My journey was undertaken rather
too late in the year to render it at all probable that I should find any birds
actually breeding, but still, as I was amongst the higher ranges at the
migrating season, I had some opportunity of seeing which birds were
previously there, and which appeared to arrive from the north. The result,
so far as I was enabled to make observations, is rather surprising ; for it
appears probable that scarcely any of the Indian migratory birds breed in
Sikkim, but, in some cases, species which visit India during the winter and
cross the Himalayas to breed, arc represented by allied forms which rarely or
never leave the mountain ranges. Thus Chelidon urbica , which is a rare
visitant to the plains of India* is represented by C. Nipalmsis and
C. Cashmwiensis ; Erythrostcrna parm and E. leucura by E. maculata, which
is but rarely found in the plains, and by the various species of Siphia ;
Pratincola hulica by P.ferrea; Ruticilla mfiventris by B. frontalis, and
others, Calliope Eamtschatkcnsis by C. pectoralis ; Motacilla per sonata and M.
Luzoniensis by M. Hodgsoni ; Carpodacus erythrinus by species of Propasser.
* I have shot it in Chhatisgarh in the Central Provinces in April. Tickell,
J. A. S B 1855, p. 277, records it from Chota Nagpur and Moulmain ; Captain Irby
from Oudh ; Blyth, Ibis, 1867, p. 338.
32
[No. 1,
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Silckim.
Almost the only migrant which we found in Sikkim commonly, before the cold
weather birds appeared from the north, was Phylloscopus lugubris, and in the
sub-family to which this belongs P. tristis, P. fixed t us, P. viridanus , and, per-
haps one or two species of Peguloides breed, so far as is known, in Central or
Northern Asia, and visit India in the cold weather, whilst Phylloscopus
fuliginiventer, Peguloides erochroa and several species ol Alrornis are
peculiar to the Himalayas.*
It should be remembered that the collections made by Captain Elwes
and myself were procured under great disadvantages. For the greater por-
tion of the time, on the Chola range especially, the weather was most unfa-
vourable. Every field ornithologist knows how in wet and misty weather birds
are silent and skulk amongst the bushes where it is most difficult to see
them, whilst in bright sunshine they are constantly in the open. It is
probable that any one visiting the highlands of Sikkim at a more favourable
season, such as May, or October and November, would find very much to add
to our observations.
I much regret having been unable, from want of time, to give any notes
on invertebrata. My collections, however, were very small.
MAMMALIA.
QUADRUMANA.
Presbytis schistaceits, Hodgs.
Jerdon, in the ‘ Mammals of India,’ says that this monkey has not, to
his knowledge, been obtained in Sikkim. Hooker mentions large monkeys
near Lamtengt and again on his road from LachungJ to the Tankra pass, in
both cases in pine woods. I saw none myself, hut several were shot by a
shikari of Captain Elwes near Lachung, thus rendering it nearly certain
that it was this species which was noticed by Hooker, for no other large
monkey is likely to be found at an elevation of 9,000 and 10,000 feet.
1 greatly doubt if the Langurs mentioned by Jerdon as occurring near
Pankabari belonged to this species, because it is extremely improbable that
an animal found at considerable elevations in the Western Himalaya, should
also occur amongst the purely Malay forms of the Sikkim Terai. P. schis-
taceus has never to the best of my knowledge been found on the outer
bills of' Sikkim, the fauna of which is Malay, and it is perfectly natural to
* More Indian birds appear to breed in the Western Himalayas, bat even here
many cross the principal snowy range. I cannot agree with Lord Waldon’s opinion
in this matter, (Ibis, 1867, p. 214 note), but much has been added to our knowledge of
the summer haunts of tho Indian Passerines during the last two or three years.
Comp. Stoliczka, J. A. B. S., 1868. Tristram, Ibis, 1871, p. 109, &c., &o.
t Himalayan Journals Vol. II., p. 37.
J Ibid, Vol. II., p. 108, all references are to the first or octavo Edition, 1854.
33
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
find it in the pine forests of Northern Sikkim together with other forms of
the Western Himalayas.
The following are the measurements of a fine adult female, taken on
the body : —
Feet Inches.
Length of head and body measured in a straight line,
Ditto ditto, from nose to insertion of tail measured along the curve of
the back,
Ditto of tail,
Ditto of fore leg,
Ditto of radius
Ditto of hand,
Ditto of hind leg,
Ditto of tibia,
Ditto of foot from heel,
Girth of neck,
Ditto of chest behind shoulders
Ditto of head,
2
2
3
1
0
0
1
0
0
1
2
1
4
6 .
0
7
81
51
8
81
8
0
0
3
CHEIROPTERA.
Vespeetelio Blanfoedi, Dobson, Proc. As. Soc. Bengal, 1871, p. 214.
Two specimens of a bat which I obtained at Lachung (8,000 ft.) are,
Mr. Dobson informs me, identical with a species he had received from the
North-west Himalayas, from both Simla and Dalhousie, and which he de-
scribed under the above name.
A rather larger hat was noticed at the same place, but no specimens
were obtained.
CARNIVORA.
Uesus Tibetaktjs ? P. Cuv. I presume this was the species common in
the upper Tista valley. I did not see any, although their tracks on the hill
sides with marks of scratchings for roots and insects abounded. I noticed
no tracks above about 12,000 feet. Bears are said by the people to be very
destructive to the grain crops. I could not learn whether Zkrsus isahellinus
is found in Sikkim or not.
Aimtbtts fvlgea'S, P. Cuv., A. ochraceus, Hodgs. We heard of the
occurrence of this animal in the pine woods around Lachung, but neither
of us saw it. Hooker was more fortunate (Him. Jour. Vol. II, p. 108).
It is not common.
Oasis (Vulpes) MONTANA'S, Pears., (v. Y.flavescens, Hodgs.). Elwes
picked up a perfectly fresh brush of a fox close to the Kangra Lama pass.
It had a fine white tip. It is difficult to tell what animal could have killed
the fox ; for we saw no large birds of prey except Lamunergeyers which I am
disposed, with Mr. Hume and others, to consider carrion-feeders ; and the
only large carnivorous mammal likely to occur at this elevation is the ounce.
5
34
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
[No. 1,
RODENTIA.
Abctomts.
Marmot holes were abundant around Momay, but I never caught sight
of one of the animals.
I was singularly unsuccessful in procuring specimens of small rodents ;
• on several occasions I saw a rat-like animal with a short head, probably
Neodon Sikkimensis, but I could never capture a specimen.
? Arvtcola sp. In the stream at Momay Samdong, on one occasion
I saw a “ water rat.” This also may possibly have been Neodon, as that
animal is said to he fotuid at this elevation (15,000 feet), but it is not known
to haunt streams. The animal I saw was swimming some distance beneath
the surface, so much so that at the first glance I took it for a fish, but it
soon came up and I could distinguish its form. It is scarcely necessary to
say that my gun happened to he at an unusual distance, and not available.
The water coming down from the Kinehinjhao glacier is icy cold, and it
would be surprising to find a forest denizen like Neodon Sikkimensis in a
glacier stream traversing a treeless region. I think it most probable that
the animal I saw was either Arvicola amphibia, which is known to occur in
Siberia, or some allied form, perhaps undescribed. It was certainly a much
larger animal than Hodgson’s Mus JiydropMlus, which appears, moreover, to
be a tropical or sub-tropical form.
The absence of squirrels in the pine woods of Northern Sikkim is very
remarkable.
? Lepus Tibetanus, Waterhouse, P. Z. S., 1841, p. 7, and Nat. Hist.
Mam. Yol. II, p. 58.
L. oiostolus, Hodgs. J. A. S. B., Yol. IX, p. 1186. Hooker, Him. Journal
Vol. II, p. 158.
Hooker mentions the occurrence of slate-coloured hares with white rumps
around Cholamu lake. I turned up two in one day in the Lachen valley
near Kongra Lama pass, one of them about five miles on the Sikkim side of
the frontier, so that if the Indian fauna is to he limited by the frontier of
Tibet, this animal must be included in it. I doubt myself whether any
of these Tibetan forms ought to be comprised in the Himalayan fauna; even
Ovis Nahura is only a Tibetan form which strays into the higher ranges across
the frontier.
Until more specimens can be procured and examined, it is impossible to
say how far the various Central and Northern Asiatic races of hares, belong-
mg to the type of the European Lepus variabilis, should be distinguished.
There are — L. variabilis, Pall., identical with the European species found
throughout Siberia ; L. tolai, Pall., peculiar to the high steppes of Mongolia
85
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
and Central Asia ; L. hybridus, Pall.,* Altai mountains ; I. Tibetanus
Waterhouse, described from specimens from Little Tibet ; L. oiostolus, Hodgs.,
from the snowy region of the Himalaya ; and L. pallipes, TIodgs., from
Central and Eastern Tibet. Although Hodgson’s L. oiostolus is considered
by Waterhouse as probably the same as his Tibetanus, and this view has been
accepted by Gray, Blyth and Jerdon, it should be borne in mind that the
opinion is founded on very imperfect materials, and that Waterhouse himself
was by no means certain of the identification.
Lagomys Eoylei, Ogilby. Jerdon, Mam. Ind. No. 210.
L. nipalensis, Hodgs. — L. Hodgsonii, Blyth.
L. Curzonice, Hodgs., J. A. S. B., 1857, p. 207, nec Stoliczka, J- A, S. B., 1865,
pt. II, p. 108.
? L. badius, Hooker, Himalayan Journals, Vol. II, p. 156,
G&mchen, Butia.
I feel some surprise at Hooker having overlooked the occurrence of this
tail-less hare in Sikkim. That he did so is, I think, evident, because he
especially refers (Vol. II, p. 156,) to the abundance of a Lagomys (which
he calls L. badius ) in the Tibetan portion of the Lachen valley, whilst at
p. 132, he distinctly states that this animal, like the wild horse, fox and hare,
does not cross the Donkia pass.
I first saw a Lagomys at about 12,000 feet on the Chola range near the
Jelep-la; it abounded in the pine forests below Chumanako at the foot of the
Chola, and I found the same kind again common in the pine forests, about
Yeomatang, at 12,000 to 13,000 feet, in the Lachung valley, and at similar
elevation in the Lachen. I observed none above the limit of trees.
It is of course quite possible that the species seen by Hooker in the
Tibetan part of the Lachen valley, at 16,000 to 17,000 feet, is a different
species from that which inhabits the Sikkim pine forests. The name given
by Hooker, L. badius, is probably one of Hodgson’s numerous unpublished
terms, and it is difficult to say, whether it was intended for the species
subsequently named by him L. Curzonice or not.
I shall first describe the Sikkim Lagomys, and then proceed to the
difficult question of nomenclature.
The Sikkim Lagomys is a small species, the largest specimen obtained
being barely seven inches long. The fur above is rufescent brown externally,
more rufescent and paler on the head and shoulders, mixed with black
towards the middle of the back and the rump, in consequence of the hairs
having longer black tips on those parts. All the hairs are blackish leaden
* Gray in Ann. and Mag. N. H., Sept. 1867, p. 223, gives L. altaicus, Brandt, as
distinct from L. liybridus, but without any reference to a description. L. altaicus
Eversman, is L. hybridus, teste Waterhouse and Gray.
33
[No. 1,
W. T. Man ford — Zoology of Silckim.
grey near the skin and for the greater part, fully two-thirds of their length ;
some have much thicker terminations of pale brown tipped with black on the
back. The longest hairs on the back are about three-fourths of an inch in
length. The sides are the same colour as the back, the breast is brown ;
muzzle, chin and belly whitish or isabelline, the latter being browner in the
middle than towards the sides, but more conspicuously so in some specimens
than in others. Hair on the belly about one-tliird of an inch in length. The
feet are pale isabelline above, pinkish brown beneath ; ears oval, thinly haired
outside, except near the margin, where they are covered with very short close
rich brown hair, the edge itself being whitish.
Mr. Hodgson, in his description of Lagomys Curzonice, says the fur is
of two sorts, woolly and hairy. I believe the fur is the same in all species
of Lagomys, and it is only so far of two sorts that some hairs have thick-
ened tips.* Under the microscope all the hairs are the same towards the
base, and appear to be cylindrical and colourless, with opaque granules at
short and nearly regular intervals. A small portion only of the hairs are
larger and have thickened tips which are not circular, but triangular, or
quadrangular, apparently with three or four rounded longitudinal grooves.
All the under fur is beautifully soft, but the terminations are harsher.
The following are the dimensions of two apparently adult specimens,
taken from the bodies just after death. I unfortunately have not noted the
sexes, but there is very little if any difference between them in measure-
ments : —
Inches. Inches.
Length from nose to rump, 6'5 6 5
Nose to between ears, 1'5 0
Ear to nose, - 0 1'5
Eye to nose, 0 07
Length of ear (measured behind the ear,) 0'7 08
Breadth of do 0 06
Hind foot from heel with claws, l'l 1'2
Tibia, 0 1-4
Fore foot and olaws, 0 7 0 7
Radius, 0 10
Longest whiskers, 1'7 0
In a young specimen 4-5 in. long, the hind foot from the heel measured
09, the fore foot 05, the ear 05. The intestines in a specimen nearly 9
inches long measured 50 inches, and the coecum 8 inches. f
* I find this is noticed by Ogilby in the description of Lagomys Roylei, Boyle’s
IUust. Bot., &c., p. Ixix.
+ This appears so much that I thought there must be a mistake in my note, but
on measuring the intestines of a young specimen about 4 inches long in spirit, I
find they are 38 inches long, and all membranes contract greatly in spirit.
1872.]
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
37
I have extracted the skull of an adult in spirit, proved to be full grown
by the teeth and by the epiphyses of the limb bones being firmly united to
the shafts by ossification. This skull measured only 1'45 in length and 07
in breadth across the zygomatic arches ; the orbits are very small, the longi-
tudinal diameter being 035", and the transverse 0‘2 8 inches only, lhe nasal
bones are of equal breadth above throughout, and the anterior palatine
openings broadly confluent behind. This skull agrees very well with the
figure in Itoyle’s illustrations of the Botany, &c. of the Himalayas,* except that
it is smaller and that the orbits appear rather shorter ; the general form is
strikingly similar. The description of the skin of L. Boy lei both by Ogilby
and Waterhouse ( Bodentia , p. 26,) agrees well with the Sikkim animal,
except that the variety from the western Himalayas appears to be of
somewhat larger size, but as all the dimensions appear to be taken from skins,
they are of small value, and Jerdon’s measurements, which arc probably from
fresh specimens, exceed mine by very little. The specimens in the Indian
Museum also agree with those from Sikkim, except that the fur is much
harsher, but it is difficult to say how far this is the result of preparation and
of exposure. I am inclined to attach less value to it, because the different
specimens in the Museum vary greatly in the softness of the fur.
But I am also persuaded that the Sikkim species must be Hodgson s
Lagomys Curzonice. The description agrees very fairly, and the dimensions!"
only slightly exceed thoso of my specimens, whilst they agree with Jerdon s
dimensions of L. Boylei. It is true that Hodgson does not mention the
black tips to the hairs, but as he uses the somewhat indefinite expression
“ murine fulvous” for the colour, I can only suppose that there were probably
dark tips. Hodgson’s specimens were said to come from the Chumbi valley.
Now I found Lagomys Boylei along the west slope of the range separating
Sikkim from Chumbi, in climates as different, and places as far apart as
Chola and the upper Laehung valley, and it is very surprising, if a different
species inhabits the other side of the range.
My friend Dr. Stoliczka has described a very distinct species+ from Ladak
as Lagomys Gurzonia, J. A. S. B„ Pt. II, pp. 108-111. I believe that this
* The type of Ogilby’s L. Roylei, but namod L. alpirms in the plate ; comp. Eoyle’s
lllust. p. lxix. The coloration of the animal in this plate is very moorrect.
f The length of the palma and nails ono-eighth inch must be a misprint, and it
is evident that all the measurements have been taken from a skin, so that they are
approximations.
t [I do not think that there is sufficient evidence for this statement. On compar-
ing Hodgson’s description of L. Nipalensis with that of Curzonim, the differences
between the two can be noticed with little difficulty. The size of Cwrzonim varies
greatly, many specimens equalling Nipalensis in size, but the fur is very distinct.
Hodgson’s description of Curzonice appears to me rather to apply to the species which
I have ro-desoribed under the same name, than to Roylei. — F. Stoliczka].
38
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
is a distinct and undescribed species. Adults are very muck larger than
Hodgson’s original specimens, being nine inches and upward in length,
rivalling or exceeding L. rufescens in size, and the prevailing colour is isa-
belline. This species which has been excellently described by Dr. Stoliczka,
1. cit., is easily distinguished from L. rufescens , by its longer and softer fur.
It may be objected that Hodgson having already described Lagomys
Hoy lei under the name of L. Nipalensis, must have had a distinct species
before him when he described L. Citrzon ice. But L. Nipalensis is of a very
different colour from the typical L. Roylei, being, as described by Hodgson,
deep bay from the snout to mid body. It was so distinct in appearance
that Blyth described the young of L. Hoylei as L. Ilodgsonii, immediately
after Hodgson had described and figured L. Nipalensis, and the latter species
is kept distinct from L. Hoylei by Waterhouse (Bod. pp. 21, 26,) and by
Dr. Gray* Ann. and Mag. Nat. Hist. Sept. 1807, p. 220. I am myself
inclined to believe that Mr. Blyth was quite right in uniting L. Nipalensis
with L. Roylei, because the structural differences pointed out by Waterhouse
appear scarcely of sufficient importance to prove the animals distinct, whilst
the presence or absence of rufous coloration in mammals is not usually of
much importance. But at the same time there do appear to be some slight
differences between the forms inhabiting the Himalayas, and the divergence
is greatest between the Nipal and the Sikkim races, a far greater difference
existing than between other forms which Mr. Hodgson, who held extreme
ideas on the subject, described as distinct species. The materials before me
are insufficient to justify an accurate judgment in this matter, but they in-
dicate the possibility of the three races being distinguishable in this
manner.
Lagomys Hoylei , verm. Six to eight inches ; fur less soft, brown with a
greyish tinge.
Do. var. Nipalensis. Length seven to eight inches, fur chesnut or bay
above.
Do. var. Curzonice. Length six to seven inches, fur mouse brown, very
soft.
At the same time the differences are so small that a good series of sjjeci-
mens would probably show a complete passage from one to the other.
Even if the Lagomys seen by Hooker north of the Sikkim frontier were
different from the Sikkim species, the name applied to it by him L. badius,
implies a very different coloration from that of Dr. Stoliczka’s L. Curzonice.
* Dr. Gray also keeps L. Hodgsonii distinct, though it is considered by Water-
house identical with L. Nipalensis, and both were united to Roylei by Mr. Blyth
himself in his Catalogue of the Mammalia in the Asiatic Society’s Museum, p. 133.
1872.]
W. T. Blanford —Zoology of Sikkim.
39
RUMINANTIA.
Cerytts aittkis, Hodgs. Jerdon, Mam. Ind. No. 218, p. 251. — Blyth,
Cat. Mam. Mus. As. Soc. No. 480.— Blyth, J. A. S. B., Vol. xxx, 1861,
p. 188.
C. Wallichii, Cuv. apud Blyth, J. A. S. B., Vol. xxiii, p. 736.—
Hooker, Him. Jour., Vol. II, p. 214, (wood-cut of horns).
This animal must he expunged from the list of mammals found in
Sikkim and, consequently, has no right to appear in J erdon s Mammalia.
After much enquiry in the country, I am satisfied that it is not found in
Sikkim at all, nor yet in that portion of the Chumbi valley which is near
the Sikkim frontier. I could not hear of its occurrence in the country
north of Sikkim, and 1 am inclined to believe that its range is entirely
eastern.
This opinion, at which I had arrived quite independently, (for I had
not looked at the paper in J. A. S. B., 1851, Vol. xx, p. 388, until after
writing it) entirely confirms Mr. Hodgson’s account of the animal’s range.
I think I)r. Jerdon must have overlooked this paper, or he would scarcely
have given the animal so inappropriate an English name as the Sikkim Stag.
Captain Elwes was especially desirous of obtaining a pair of the horns, and
enquired about them from the people who came to meet us with the Sikkim
Raja. All declared that this Stag is only found at a considerable distance
beyond Chfimbi. Mr. Hodgson, 1. c. p. 392, learned that it only occurs as
a straggler in the Chumbi valley, that it is unknown in Northern Butan, and
that the region inhabited by it is entirely Tibetan.
Moschtjs MOSCHii-'ERUS, L. — Jerdon, Mam. Ind. No. 224, p. 266.
Hooker, Him. Jour., Vol. I. p. 269.
The musk deer occurs, but is not common on the Chola range ; it is found
much more frequently in the upper Lachen and Lachung valleys.
Procapra ficticaudata, (Hodgs.). Blyth, Cat. Mam. No. 534, p. 1/3.
Hooker, Him. Jour., p. 157, and wood-cut, p. 139.
Hooker records 1. c. his having seen both this animal and the Chiru
(Ke/mas Hodgsonii) at Lake Cholamu. I did not hear of it in Sikkim, nor has
it, so far as I am aware, been met with. The Suba of Kambajong, as men-
tioned in the first part of these notes, brought a fresh skin to Kangra Lama.
Kemas Hodgsonii, (Abel). Blyth, Cat. Mam. No. 535, p. 1/3.
Antilope Hodgsonii, Hooker, Him. Jour., \ ol. ii, pp. 132, 156, and
wood-cut, p. 157.
Hooker found the horns of the Chiru near Momay Samdong in the
Lachung valley, and saw the animal at Cholamu Lake. The Tibetans assured
us that it is not now found within a long distance of the frontier, and appear-
ed greatly surprised when we told them it had been seen by Hooker. It
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
40
[No. 1,
may occur near Cholamu only at particular seasons, but it is not probable that
Hooker was mistaken about so fine and conspicuous an animal.
Nemobhcedtjs bubal inch, Hodgs. Jerdon, Mam. Ind. No. 230, p. 283.
Gya, Butia. Sichi, Lepcha.
The Serow is not rare in Sikkim, but like all other mammals, it shuns the
leech-infested belt between 5,000 and 10,000 feet during the rainy season,
at which period it is said in the outer hills to descend into the deep valleys.
I frequently saw the tracks of this goat-antilope in the forests around
Lachdng which are out of the leech region at 8,000 to 10,000 feet. It
does not ascend to any groat elevation.
N. goeaIi, Hardwicke. Jerdon, Mam. Ind. No. 231, p. 285. “ Ragen”
Hooker, Him. Jour. Yol. ii, p. 9S.
The goral is common on the grassy and rocky cliffs west of the Lachiing
valley from Chungtam to L&chung, and is also found in the Lachen valley.
At the period of my visit all were between 8,000 and 10,000 feet, but in
winter they are said to descend much lower. I could not hear of any being
found on the Chola range, and I suspect the animal is only to be met with
in the interior of Sikkim. I saw goral several times near Lachiing. It
keeps to rocky cliffs and grassy slopes, and does not appear to inhabit
forest.
Hemiteagus jemlaicits, H. Smith. — Jerdon, Mam. Ind. No. 232
p. 286.
I have been assured that the Tehr is found in Sikkim, but I did not
see it, nor has any one else whom I know. It is said to inhabit the forests
high up on the sides of the Tista valley near Chungtam. As it is well-
known to be a native of Nipal, its occurrence in Sikkim is highly probable.
An animal was described to us by the Tibetans as inhabiting parts of
Tibet north of Jigatzi, which was probably the Himalayan Ibex, Capra
Sibirica.
Otis nahttea, Hodgs. Jerdon, Mam. Ind. No. 237, p. 296. — Ovis
Ammon, Hooker, Him. Jour. Yol. ii, p. 132, wood-cut, p. 140. Nao or
Gndo, Tibetan.
Ovrs ammotj, L. Hooker, Him. Jour. Yol. i, (? p. 243), wood-cut,
p. 249, Nyeng, Tibetan.
The burhel is not known to occur on the Chola range to the southward,
but it is found near the Tankra pass, and scattered over the grassy hills in
the higher valleys of the Lachen and Lachiing. In September and October
I never saw any below 14,000 feet.
The burhel is undoubtedly the wild-sheep to which Hooker refers under
the name of Ovis Ammon, and of which he speaks as being seen occasionally
near Momay Samdong. That such is the case is proved by the name he
applies to it “ gnow.” I cannot help thinking it highly probable that he
41
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
only saw burhel also in the Yangma valley, in East Nipal. A herd of rams
of O. nahura, although inferior in size to the true Ovis Ammon, would certainly
strike any one seeing them for the first time by their proportions, but it is
possible that the sheep seen on this occasion may have been the larger kind.
So far as Sikkim is concerned, however, every enquiry made by us elicited
the assurance that the true Ovis Ammon, or Nyeng, never occurs south of the
Donkia and Kongra Lama passes, though frequently met with at a short
distance do the] north in Tibet ; so that in this respect, at all events, Jerdon
is perfectly correct in excluding it from his Mammals of India, p. 298, as
not found on the Indian side of the Himalaya.
AYES.
Order Kaptoees.
Vulturidce.
A large vulture was occasionally seen, but not sufficiently near to enable
either Captain Elwes or myself to ascertain the species or even the genus.
Probably it was Gyps Himalayensis, Hume, Scrap Book, Part I, p. 12,
which has now been determined by Mr. Gurney to he a good species and
distinct from G. fulvus, Gm., to which the Himalayan bird was assigned
by Dr. Jerdon.
Falconidce.
7* Gvpa-ETUS BAEBATTrs, (L.) — The Loemmergeyer has not previously
been recorded from the Himalayas east of Nipal. I did not meet with it
on the Chola range, nor within the limit of forest in northern Sikkim. It
is, however, common in the upper Lachcn and Laehung valleys above 14,000
feet. Neither of us succeeded in obtaining a specimen, although several of the
birds passed at no great distance. They looked small both to me and to
Captain Elwes, and I hope that specimens will hereafter be obtained for
comparison. I should not have mentioned the apparent size, but that the
only Lcemmergeyers I have ever seen alive are the small G. meridionalis,
Keys, and Bias., of Abyssinia.
17 TrrauKCBXtrs abaudabitts, (Gm.).
24 Accipiteb msus (L.).— Both the Kestril and Sparrow-hawk were
common in the upper Lachen and Ldchung valleys after the middle of
September, evidently migrating southwards. None were seen on the Chola
range at the end of August. The kestril was seen a few days sooner than
the sparrow-hawk.
47 Buteo plumipes, Hodgs.
A single example of this rare buzzard was shot by a shikari at an
elevation of about 13,000 feet near Yeomatang in the Laehung valley. It
proved to be, as ascertained by dissection, a female in fine plumage. It agrees
* The numbers are those of Jordon’s Birds of India.
6
42 W. T. Blanford — Zoology of SikJcim. [No. 1,
excellently with Hodgson’s original description. The following is a full
account.
Plumage throughout, above and below, dark umber brown, a little
darker, if anything, below than above, slightly paler on the rump, faintly
glossed above with purple except on the head. Shafts of the body feathers
black. Lores covered in front with white feathers, behind with radiating black
hairs. About the nape there are some faint rufous edgings to the feathers ;
a few white spots appear on the scapularies, only to be detected by turning
back the upper feathers. Primary quills very dark for a considerable length
near the tip, paler, with transverse white or whitish bars near the base, shafts
white at the base, becoming black at the tip only. Secondaries a little paler
than the primaries and with white or whitish bars. Under-wing coverts
umber. Tail feathers dark umber, rather indistinctly barred with pale umber,
above pale with white hairs beneath, the bars becoming obsolete towards the
base, about one and a half inches at the tip of each feather unbarred,
extreme tip pale.
Iris pale brown ; bill black towards the tip, pale towards the base ; cere,
gape and legs yellow, claws black. The first four primaries deeply emargi-
nate on the inner webs, the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th, but not the first, on the
outer.
The principal dimensions were taken on the fresh carcase, only those
of the beak, tarsi and toes are from the skin. Length 20 inches, wing 16,
tail 9'25, tarsus 2'9 feathered in front for P5, mid too without claw 1’5,
its claw measured round curve 0.9, outer toe 1, its claw 0.65, inner toe
0 95, its claw 1T5, hinder toe 0’8, its claw 1'15, bill straight from end of
cere 0'88, round curve 1, from gape 1'47. The 4th primary is the longest,
the 3rd shorter by 0'2 in one wing, 0'35 in the other, 2nd by l-6, 1st by
4'75 in one wing, 4’4 in the other. The closed wings reached to within one
inch of the end of the tail.
The tarsi have 9 or 10 broad scutes behind for the lower half of their
length, above this are hexagonal scales. In front are hexagonal scales only,
a little larger than those at the sides above, but becoming small near the feet.
The discovery of a second specimen of this buzzard, coinciding in color-
ation with that lirst obtained by Mr. Hodgson, renders it far more probable
that this is really a good species, and not a mere accidental phase of plumage
of some other.
Of the Indian species to which it might be referred, Buteo ferox (B.
canescens, Hodgs.) is out of the question, being much larger. B. desertorum
(B. ru/lventer, Jordon), which comes nearest hr size, is distinguished by its
rufous colouring, especially on the underparts, of which there is not a trace
in B. plimipes. B. vulgaris, which is now excluded from the Indian fauna,
does not appear to assume so uniform a plumage. Moreover, on comparing
43
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of SilcJcim,
the Sikkim specimen with the series in the Indian Museum, I found that
in no case have any of the three species named small hexagonal scales in
front of the tarsi as in B. plumipes * There is some variation in this charac-
ter, hut all differ widely from my specimen. Both B. vulgaris and B.
desertorum also appear to have shorter toes.
Mr. Blyth (Ibis, 1866, p. 245) considers B. japonicus, Sehl., (Fauna
Japonica, Av., t. vi. and vii.) probably identical. This is of less importance
at the present moment, because Mr. Hodgson’s name has priority, but dis-
regarding the question of plumage, the scutes on the tarsus of B. japonicus
are said to be broader, but less high than in B. vulgaris, and there are about
8 in front and 12 to 15 behind. The dimensions are a little smaller than
those of B. plumipes, wing 13| inches (french, = 14'4 english) in the adult
female. The only conclusion at which I can arrive is that B. plumipes is a
good specios, and that B. japonicus is probably distinct. f
56 M u.rrs GovrsmA, Sykes. — The only kite I have brought from the
upper Lachung valley, shot at 8,000 feet, belongs to the common Indian race,
but a specimen from Tamlung and another from Darjiling are of the large
M. melanotis, Tern, and Sell., M. major of Hume. Kites, M. Govinda, I
believe, were seen up to about 12,000 feet.
The paucity of Raptorial birds in Upper Sikkim is most striking. I
did not notice a single true falcon or eagle ; and kites, kestrils, sparrow-hawks,
and LEemmergeyers are the only kinds at all frequently seen.
Order — Iksessoees. — Sub-order — Picaelze.
Picidce.
161 Pices htpeetthbes, Vig. — This is the only woodpecker which I saw
in the pine forests of upper Sikkim. Even this is rare ; only two specimens
were obtained during our stay, one at about 10,000 feet in the Lachung
valley, the other at about 9,000 in the Laclien. The latter is a young bird,
and has dusky bars on the breast. The change from the fauna of outer Sik-
kim, where woodpeckers abound as they do throughout Malayasia, is strikingly
exemplified by this family. It is doubtful, if P . hyperythrus has been obtain-
ed in the neighbourhood of Darjiling ; specimens reported to have been brought
thence were probaby shot in the interior.
* Mr. Hodgson’s original specimen of B. plumipes, however, is described, P. Z. S.,
1845, p. 37, as having the tarsus scutillate before and behind.
f Since writing the above, I have seen Dr. Jerdon’s remarks on this species in
the July number of the Ibis, p. 340. He also" considers the species distinct, but says
the toes are peculiarly short. I trust to be able hereafter to compare my specimen
in Europe.
44
[No. 1:
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
Cypselidw.
103 Collocalla fucipilaga (Thunb.).
Common on the Chola, range up to at least 12,000 feet, and throughout
the Tista valley at low elevations. I did not meet with any swift in Upper
Sikkim,
TJpupidce.
254 Upupa Epops, L. — Not rare at high elevations in Northern Sikkim.
I saw it as high as 15,000 feet at Momay Samdong. Very probably all seen
were migrating from beyond the Himalayas, as it is scarcely probable that
any breed at this elevation.
Sub-order — Passebes.
jSfeclarinidcE.
629 TEthopyga igfticauda (Hodgs.). — Common in rhododendron and
pine jungle at about 11,000 feet on the Chola range in August, feeding
upon flowers in open glades. All seen were young males in non-breeding
plumage, or females.
I have no specimen, but I believe the identification of this bird is
correct. Several were shot by Captain Elwes. No Nectarinidcs were seen
in Upper Sikkim.
Amp elides.
629 Myzoknts pybbhouba, Hodgs. — Common in the same place as the
last species, hunting amongst the brushwood and over the mossy banks. I shot
one on the ground. It was evidently hunting about the moss for insects.
Mr. W. S. Atkinson obtained specimens on the Singalela range. None were
seen in Upper Sikkim.
In Mr. G. K. Gray’s new Hand list of birds Myzornis is placed as a
subgenus of Yuhvna, between Phyllornis and Griniger in the Phyllornithince ;
a view not borne out by the structure of the birds, nor by then’ nidification,
so far as that is known. I doubt its being an improvement on Jerdon’s
classification.
627 Yuiirsw occipitalis, Hodgs. — This bird, which Dr. Jerdon says is
rare near Darjiling, is very common and abundant in the pine forests between
8,000 and 10,000 feet in the Lachen and Lachdng valleys. It is found in
small flocks usually associated with other species. The following measure-
ments were taken on a freshly killed bird ; length 5, wing 2'4, tail 2,
tarsus 0 7, bill 055 inches.
626 Y. GUT, APIS, Hodgs. — This is less common than the last in the
pine forests about Lachung, though still by no means rare. It is common
abovo 10,000 feet on the Chola range, where I did not meet with
Y. occipitalis.
45
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
623 Ixttlus flavtcollts, Hodgs. — I obtained two specimens near
Lamteng in the Laehen valley at about 9,000 feet, which seem rather smaller
than Darjiling specimens, as appears by the following comparison :
G22 Pbopaetts vrx'T pectus, Hodgs. — Tliis species does not appear to
have been noticed from Sikkim before ; at least I can find no mention of its
occurrence so far east. I obtained two specimens, one from pine foiests in
the Laehen valley at about 11,000 feet, the other on Sinchal, close to
Darjiling. The measurements rather exceed those given by I erdon.
Length. Wing. Tail. Bill from forehead. Tarsus.
1. — Laehen valley, 5 2'25 1'9 0.3
2. — Sinchal, 5 2.35 2-0 0 32
Iris yellow with a reddish tinge, bill dusky above, livid below, legs
livid. The head is not crested.
621 P. cniiYSiEUS, Hodgs. — P. chrysotis, Blytli, and Cr. R.Gray. I ob-
tained a single specimen in the Laehen valley at about 9,000 feet. Captain
Elwes shot two or three in the same valley at a somewhat lower elevation.
In my specimen, a male, the measurements are — wing 2T5, tail 1’8, bill from
forehead 0'32, tarsus 0'88 inches.
The name chrysotis is evidently inappropriate, and so clearly due either
to a misprint or an error in a label that although first published, I think
Jordon quite right in using Hodgson’s name for this bird. Surely the law
of priority does not extend to misprints.
618 Mcru igxpotixct.v, Hodgs. — Common in both the Ldchen and
Lachung valleys up to about 9,000 feet, but not higher, in company with
Yuhincn, tits, and other birds.
616 SrvA STETOtur.A, Hodgs.— I met with this bird at about 10,000
feet on the Choi a range, and again in the Lachung valley at about 9,000. In
the latter locality it appeared not to be very common. The only specimen
preserved has the orange of the head confined to the forehead, the crown
being rufous olive. As the colours of the lower parts also are duller,
this is probably a female ; comp. Stoliczka in J. A. S. B., 1868, Pt. ii, p. oO.
Alloteius XAOTHOCHLOEUS, Hodgs. I obtained one specimen at
9,000 feet in the Laehen valley. It was in a mixed flock of small Sylviads ;
( Philloscopi , &c.), M yithalisci , and Yuhinas. I have since received another
specimen from Darjiling, probably a male. My specimen from the Laehen
valley is a female, and agrees well with Dr. Stoliczka’s description, J. A.
S. B. Part ii, 1868, p. 50. The back is a rather yellower green than that
of the (supposed) male, abdomen greenish yellow. Dimensions taken before
46
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
skinning — length 47, wing 2'4, tail 1-85, tarsus 075, bill from forehead 03,
from gape 055 inches. Iris dark brown, bill black above, bluish grey below ;
legs purplish horny.
Crateropidce.
376 Hetebomoeeba uxtcolois, Hodgs. — This I only saw in one place
in the Lachung valley, between 7,000 and 8,000 feet of elevation. The birds
were in flocks, skulking in dwarf bamboo jungle in the usual Crateropidine
manner.
381 Colostoma osmodittm, Hodgs.— This also I met with but once.
I came upon a flock making a great noise amongst dwarf bamboos at about
11,000 feet elevation on the Choi a range.
Perhaps neither of the last two birds should have been comprised, as
neither was found above the lowest limit of pines.
417 Tbochaioptebum sebtoicoloe, Hodgs. — This appears to range
much higher than its congener T. chrysopteru/m. I shot it at about 11,000
feet on the Chola range, and about 9,000 in the Lachung valley. Iris
yellowish grey.
I cannot at all admit the justifiability of separating this species, T.
phceniceum and T. squamatum from the other forms of Trochalopterum, as is
done by Horsfield and Gray. To place these three forms in a distinct genus
from T. chrysopterwm and T. affine appear to me a violation of natural affinity.
There is no difference in the shape of the wing to which any importance can
be attached. As a rule the 6th primary is the longest in all, but both the
5th and 7 th are so nearly the same length, that specimens may be found in
which either of them slightly exceeds all the others. Then, as to the bills,
T. subunicolor differs quite as much from T. 'phceniceum, as the latter does
from T. chrysopterwm or T. affine. The structure of the feet, general dimen-
sions, the plumage, and habits are precisely similar in all, and I thoroughly
agree with Dr. Jerdon in classing all together. If any of the group deserve
separation, it appears to me that the forms from the Malabar hills T.
cacchinans, Jerdoni and Fairbanki, are better entitled to distinction than
those placed in Mr. Gray’s genus Pterocyclus, a name long previously
employed amongst the Moflusca, as has repeatedly been pointed out before.
419 T. affine (Hodgs.). — This is the only Crateropidine which can be
said to belong fairly to the fauna of sub-alpine Sikkim ; it ranges much
above all other forms, and Jerdon is quite right in his suggestion that it fre-
quents the higher mountains. On the Chola range it abounds at 11,000 to
about 13,000 feet, in rhododendron scrub and on the skirts of the pine woods,
and in Northern Sikkim I found it far from rare at the same elevation or a
little lower. Its habits are precisely the same as those of T. chrysopterum,
and other allied forms. Iris olive.
1872.]
47
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
Hirundinidce.
93 CheIjIDON Casiimieiensis, Gould. — Common on the Chola range
about the upper limit of forest, 12,000 to 13,000 feet. It was chiefly seem
hunting over streams and lakes.
Laniidce.
258 Lantus TEPHBONOTrs (Vigors). — Common at Lachung, 8,000 to
9,000 feet in the beginning of September, but three weeks later all had disap-
peared. Many of those seen were in young plumage with hair on the breast,
back, and scapulars.
Campepliagidce.
274 Pebicrocotus Solaris, Blyth. — I shot a female from amongst a
flock at about 10,000 feet elevation near Lachung.
There is evidently a misprint in Jerdon’s description of the female of this
bird. It is the back which is olive green, the lower parts are deep yellow
passing into whitish on the throat. The rump is dark yellow with a slight
brownish tinge.
The female of P. Solaris is distinguished from that of P. irevirostris
by its shorter bill, greyer head, ashy ear coverts, whitish throat, and especially
by wanting the broad yellow forehead of the last named species, which I
found abundant in the Tista valley at elevations below about 6,000 feet.
Muscicapidee.
296 Hemickelihon siberica, (6m.) . — H.fuliginosa, Hodgs.
One young specimen obtained in the Lachen valley at about 9,000 feet.
294 Chelidoehtnx iiypoxantiia (Blyth). — Common in pine forests
at the foot of the Chola pass at about 12,000 feet elevation. In the interior
I did not notice it above about 8,000 feet, below that it abounded. It was
usually seen in small flocks, hunting about trees.
319 Siputa stbophiata, Hodgs. — The only fly-catcher commonly seen
in the pine woods of the Lachung and Lachen valleys. Here it was found
up to an elevation of 12,000 feet, associating with tits, Sylviads, and Ixuli.
It was also common on the Chola range at the same elevation. The white
on the rectrices decreases on the outer feathers, as noticed by Stoliezka in
specimens from N. W. Himalayas. (J. A. S. B., 1868, Bait ii, p. 32).
The plumage of the young bird does not appear to have been described ;
the following is that of a specimen shot at Yeomatong, hi the upper Lachi'mg
valley, on September 12th. Upper parts and sides of the head and neck brown,
the feathers of the head with narrow brownish yellow streaks down the centre ;
these increase in size till, on the back, the feathers are brownish yellow with
dusky brown margins ; the same on the rump, but the colour is a little less
brilliant. Quills and coverts dark brown, broadly edged with rufous brown,
48
[No. 1,
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
the last secondaries (or tertiaries) being entirely rufous ; tail as in the adult ;
throat and breast brownish yellow, the feathers with dusky edges, giving a
scale like appearance ; flanks duller ; lower abdomen, vent, and under-tail
coverts white.
Cnroim®.
348 Cikclus cashmiriensis ? Gould. — Blyth has already mentioned
the occurrence of this dipper in Sikkim, Ibis, 1S6G, p. 374. I found it
far from rare in the upper parts of the Laclien and Laehung valleys, at
elevations exceeding 14000 feet.
The specimens vary much in plumage. The only two I have retained
are smaller than the dimensions given by J erdon and Salvin (Ibis, 1867,
p. 117), and they do not exactly agree, in coloration. In that which I
look upon as adult, or near adult, the head and neck above and at the sides,
and the upper part of the back are dull brown, a white spot above the eye,
and another smaller one below, middle and lower back cinereous with dark
brown margins, tail cinereous, quills and whig coverts brown, the outer webs
cinereous, the secondaries and greater coverts with narrow white tips ; throat
and breast white, abdomen brown, the feathers with slight white edges,
flanks and under tail coverts cinereous ; bill black, tarsus (when alive)
purplish grey, whig 3.4, tail T9, tarsus IT, bill from gape 09, from
forehead O' 65 inches.
Another specimen, probably younger, has some grey mixed with the
brown of the head feathers, and the centre of the abdomen, as far back as the
thighs, white, not so pure as on the breast, the feathers behig brownish
below ; there arc traces of dusk margins to the breast feathers also ; wing
3'6, tail 2,05, tarsus 1T3, bill from gape G'9, from forehead 0.65 inches.
If these birds belong to 0. Cashmiriensis, it is evidently a variable species.
347 C. ASiATictrs, Swains. — This ranges, in the summer, as high as
12.000 feet at least, and I have a specimen shot at that elevation at Yeoma-
tong in the Laehung valley. I saw brown birds which I noted at the time
as belonging to this species up to 14000 feet, and I believe they were
correctly identified, but as I secured none, they may have belonged to the
next. Towards the end of October, I saw this dipper in the great Itangit
river, not 1000 feet above the sea.
349 C. soEDiDtrs, Gould. — A single dipper which I shot at about
15.000 feet on the Chachd stream below Phalung, close to the Kongra
Lama pass, only differs from the description of this species by its rather
larger size ; it is a little darker in colour than Gould’s figure in the Birds of
Asia. I took it at the time for C. asiaticus, and was surprised at seeing that
bird at so great an elevation, in a place where the fauna is distinctly Tibetan.
There is a cinereous tinge on the outer margins of the quills on the upper
coverts, which have dark margins, and on the tail. Whig 4 in., tail 2'3, tarsus
49
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Siklcim.
1-17, bill from forebead 063. Jerdon’s measurement of the bill, |, must be
from the gape.
It is quite possible that this may be a distinct local race, inhabiting
Eastern Tibet, but I scarcely like to separate it without better means of
comparison.
Triton)
350 Zootheea monticola, Vigors. — I obtained one specimen at about
10.000 feet in the Lachen valley, but I did not shoot it myself.
362 Meettia albocencta, (Eoyle). — This black bird is common in
rhododendron scrub, and on the skirts of forest on the Chola range at 11,000
to 13,000 feet. I saw it also at Lachiing in Upper Sikkim at about 8,000 feet.
It appears to haunt hanks of streams.
352 Oeeocietes e it YTiDioti aster, ( Vigors) .—Obtained by Captain
Elwes near Laeliung.
478 Geandala ccelicoxob, Ilodgs. — The systematic position of this
bird is very puzzling. I cannot see much affinity for Myiomela, and even less
for Calliope, next to which Mr. G. E. Gray classes it in his * Hand list.’ I was
wrong in placing the African Pkolidauges leucogaster , in the same genus
(Ohs. Geol. and Zool, Abyssinia, p. 367), but I still believe that there is some
affinity between the two. The bill of Otrandala is certainly Saxicoline, but I
am strongly disposed to doubt whether, as a nde, far too great importance
is not attached to characters of the bill by ornithologists.
Were I to judge Grandala by its flight, habits, and form of wing, I
should unhesitatingly place it amongst the Starlings. The tarsi are, it is
true, less strongly scutcllated than in the Sturnidce, but still the scutellation
towards the base is well marked, and the tarsus has no more resemblance to
that of a Saxicola than to that of Sturnm. On the whole perhaps the most
natural position is in the thrushes, some of which, as the fieldfare, assemble
into flocks in the winter.
Captain Speke was quite correct as to the gregarious habits of this bird,
Mr. Hodgson’s information, however, may have been derived from its being
found solitary or in pairs in the summer. We first met with it at Momay
Samdong (15,000 feet). A flock entirely composed of young birds or females
used to visit a small grassy flat, close to our encampment, lor several evenings
after our arrival, and hunt about for insects which were atracted by the
yak’s dung, exactly as stai-lings do. All which I shot proved to be young
males. I saw none at a lower elevation, but near Donkia pass, at above
17.000 feet, I met with a flock in which were some males in adult plumage,
one of which I shot.
483 Pbatevcola ikdica, Blyth. — Common in the Lachiing and Lachen
valleys in September and the beginning of October, and apparently
7
50 W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
migrating. I doubt if tbis bird breeds on the mountains of Sikkim ; none
were observed on the Chdla range.
386 P. fereea, Hodgs. — Seen in Northern Sikkim occasionally at about
7,000 to 9,000 feet, but less common than about Darijiling.
497 RuTrcrr.LA nuFTVT.NTRrs (Vieil.). Not seen on the Cluila range, but
abundant in the Lachen and Lachung valleys during the latter parts of our
stay in them. The first specimen was shot at Momay Samdong (15,000 feet)
on September 21st. In this case there could bo no question that the birds
migrated from beyond the passes, because none were seen before the date
mentioned, even in the highest parts of the valleys at 15,000 to 18000 feet,
whilst afterwards they were abundant everywhere, and on our return in the
middle of October we saw them at 4,000 feet in the Tista valley. It is
mentioned by Dr. Stoliczka as breeding in Western Tibet. It certainly, I
should say, does not breed in Sikkim.
503 R. frontal! s (Vigors) . — In contrast to the last species which abounds
in the plains of India in winter, but crosses the snows to breed, this redstart,
which rarely, if ever, visits the plains, but which Jerdon found abundantly
around Darjiling in winter, evidently breeds in the higher hills of Sikkim. I
met with it on the Chola range and again abundantly in the Lachung and
Lachen valleys at from 12,000 to 14,000 feet, and at Yeomatong on Septem-
ber 12th and 14th I shot three birds in spotted plumage. These young
birds have the upper parts dark brown with isabelline spots, quills and
wing coverts hair brown, the secondaries and coverts with rufous edges,
throat and breast feathers dirty white in the centre, with broad brown mar-
gins, the white centres pointed at the end, presenting a peculiar scale-like
appearance. Abdomen dull rufous or isabelline with some brown edgings
which, however, have disappeared in one specimen ; tail precisely as in the adult.
The outer tail feathers in all have the outer web, except near the base,
black, as well as the tip.
I several times at high elevations, both on the Chola range and in
Northern Sikkim, saw another species of Huticilla, but I never succeeded
in shooting a specimen, nor did my fellow traveller. It was perhaps It.
caruleocephala, (Vigors).
505 R. [Rhtacornis] fttiiguitosa (Vigors). Jerdon’s description of the
habits of this bird, are, as usual, admirable. It is, however, found at a great-
er elevation than stated by him, and on the Chola range I occasionally saw
birds up to 11000 and 12000 feet, but at the same season I saw and shot
others below 3000 feet elevation. In Northern Sikkim it did not, in Sep-
tember and October, range above 7000 feet. Mr. Blyth, in the Ibis for 1867,
p. 16, refers to Dr. A. Leith Adam’s second species allied to this, seen in
Kashmir (P. Z. S. 1859, p. 179, No. 82 of the birds of Kashmir and Ladak).
It is described as “ smaller ; colour a leaden ash, whith several white fea-
thers in the tail." Surely the female is referred to.
1872.]
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Slide im.
51
I am quite of the same opinion as my friends Dr. Jerdon and Dr.
Stoliczka (J. A. S. B. 1868, p. 43,) as to the difference between this species
and other Buticillcv, but I rather doubt whether it should be placed m Cln-
marrliornis, as proposed by Mr. Hodgson and Dr. Stoliczka The bill undoubt-
edly shews some similarity in form, a modification probably connected with
aquatic habits of both birds, and the tail is rounded as noticed by er on
but the wings are B utioilline, and the general characters of the p umage o
both sexes — structural character which, viewed in the light of evolution y
descent from common forms, I should be inclined to think of more impor-
tance than the slight modifications of the bill and tail, -dissociate B fuhgi-
nosa altogether forms Ohmarrhomi*. It appears to me, as it did to Dr^
Jerdon, to form the type of a distinct subgenus which might be called
Bhyacornis ;* and which appears to me to have as good claims o sepaia ion
as Adelura and Ohmarrhornis. The characters are :
Bhyacornis, subg. nov. Ruticilke : Bostrnm brevius et latius qmm -
cilia,, cauda magi* rotmdata. Fcemina a man valde divena, et rectncibu
extevioribus basin • vcvsus (ilbis. . ..
499 B. ( Adelura ) erxtiirooastra (Giild.) — Bill and plumage sum ar
to Chimarrhomie, but the wings and tail are those of Butictlla, and so aie
the habits to a great extent. I have seen this bird on the banks ol streams
and of lakes, but more frequently on rocky hill sides, and at times on the edges
of glaciers. It was only met with at great elevations, never below 1 >
but in the highest parts of the Lachen and Lacliung valleys it was iar lorn
rare, and Captain Elwes shot it at Cholamu Lake. I saw no ema es, k
I only saw birds in the plumage of the male, and all the specimens s 10 jy
me were males. , . i n «
The following measurements were taken on fres i specimens e oi e
skinning.
Bill from forehead.
0-45
Length.
7
7-3
Wing.
4'4
4-2
Tail.
32
3-
Tarsus.
IT
IT
0T5
Iris brown, bill and legs black.
B. Vigonii, Moore, quoted by Jerdon as the female of this species, is
considered distinct by G. B. Gray (Hand-list, I, p. 221). It » certainly very
different from the bird figured as the female or young male by Gould m the
Birds of Asia, and as it differs from If. erythrogaster in having the central
rectriees dark coloured, and in the absence of a wing spot, (both rather impro-
bable sexual differences), it is probably a distinct species
500 B ( Chimarrhorn is) leucocephala (Vigors).— Common on streams
and around the edges of lakes, at elevations above 12,000 feet on the Chola range
* From pva( a stream and if puts.
52
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
and above 10000 in Northern Sikkim in August, September and the begin-
ning oi October. It evidently breeds in the higher ranges, and descends in
winter to the valleys, as described by Jerdon. In the middle of October all
the birds of this species in the Lachen valley had descended to below 10,000
feet elevation.
508 Ianthia ritftlata, (Hodgs.)— This is another bird found in the
winter around Darjiling, which evidently breeds in the pine forests. I shot
specimens at about 12000 feet both on the Chola range and in the Laclmng
valley. One bird, a female, killed in the last named locality, is immature and
has only partially assumed the adult plumage. It has pale spots on some of the
back and head feathers, whilst the nestling feathers remaining on the breast
are isabelline with dark margins.
Detmochares stellattjb. — Gould P. Z. S. 18G8, pp. 218, 219. Birds
of Asia, Pt. XXI. A single male was shot by my shikari at Yeomatong in
the Lachung valley at 12000 to 13000 feet. The specimen is in poor condi-
tion and much injured, so that I can give no trustworthy dimensions.
This form, although well distinguished by its peculiar coloration, appears
to be scarcely entitled to rank higher than a sub-genus of Brachypteryx. I
have elsewhere, in another paper on Sikkim birds, given my reasons for placing
Brachypteryx near Ianthia in preference to classing it with the wrens, as is
done by Jerdon. The usual position assigned to the genus amongst the
Timaliince {Crater op idte) or Leiotrichinm appears to me quite incompatible
with the structure and habits of the Himalayan species.
513 Calliope pectoralis, Gould,— Common on the Chola range, but
less abundant in northern Sikkim ; in both localities only seen, in August and
September, above 12,000 feet, and usually above the limit of forest. It
haunts rhododendron scrub in which it doubtless breeds, and is frequently
seen on the hill side near bushes.
In the only male I possess there is no white moustachial stripe, and I
can only find one male specimen out of 5 (4 mounted and 1 skin) in the
Indian Museum, exhibiting this character. This specimen also has the white
spots at the tip of the tail feathers much larger than in others. In my
specimen, and in one apparently from the N. W. Himalayas, as presented by
Jerdon to the Museum, there is a broad white forehead, not mentioned in
Jerdon’s description, and wanting on other specimens to which I have access.
The adult females (2 in number,) shot by me, do not agree well with
Jerdon’s description, which may perhaps betaken from a young male. At
all events in 2 adult females, and 2 young birds obtained in Sikkim, as also
m the skin of a hen bird in the Indian Museum, there is no white whatever
at the base of the tail. Adult females have the upper parts brown with a
slight greyish tinge, wings hair brown with paler margins to the quills ; tail
blackish, feathers tipped white (not fulvous), but without any white at the
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. 53
base, supercilia dull white, sides of head greyish brown, sides of neck, breast
and flanks ashy ; chin and middle of throat white, abdomen white also, but
less pure, lower tail coverts slightly fulvous, thigh coverts dark brown. A
rather younger female has a browner back and flanks and indistinct super-
cilium.
The young birds agree with Dr. Stoliczka’s description, (.T. A. S. B.
1868, Part II, p. 45) except that my specimens, which are perhaps females,
have no white at the base of the tail.
The measurements of my Sikkim specimen, except the tarsus and bill,
are less than those given by Dr. Jerdon.
Wing. Tail. Tarsus. Bill from forehead. Bill from gape.
514 Cxanecula sttecica, (L.) — This was seen occasionally in the latter
part of September, and more frequently in October, apparently coming from
the north and migrating southwards. I shot one bird at Momay Samdong
on the 19th September.
In Mr. G. lv. Gray’s ‘ Hand list,’ the Indian blue-throat is still classed
as C. ccerulecula, Pall., but Mr. Blyth, in the Ibis for 1867, p. 17, note, has
shewn that it is identical with the Swedish form, the type of Motacilla suecica
of Linnseus, and until Mr. Blyth has been proved to be in error on this point,
the Indian race must bear the latter name.
SylviadcB.
558 Phtiioscopus* lugitbeis, Blyth. — This appears to be the com-
monest warbler in Sikkim, and in all probability breeds abundantly in the
higher parts of the hills. I met with it very frequently, solitary or in families,
amongst the rhododendron bushes at elevations from 12,000 to 14,000 feet
on the Chola range, and again from 10,000 to 13,000 or 14,000 in the pine
forests of Liichung valley, associating in flocks with LopTioplianes and other
birds. The specimens shot hy me have distinct whitish tips to the larger
wing coverts, whereas in birds shot in the plains these are usually wanting,
doubtless from their being gradually worn off ; my birds also are more yellow
beneath, and the axillaries and edge of the wing are clear pale yellow, whilst
birds shot near Calcutta are mostly greenish on these parts. There is,
however, some variation in this respect.
* If the type of Phyllopneuste, Meyer, be P. trochilus, the Indian birds ascribed
to Phylloscopus by Jerdon must be placed in that genns. G. E. Gray, in his recent
Hand-list, separates the Indian birds, which he places under Phyllopneuste, from P.
trochilus, P. rufa, &c. classing these as Asilus, Moehring. I greatly doubt if the
separation is justified by the structure of the bird. As I have not the means of
clearing up this question, I use Jerdon s generic names.
54
W. T. I!1 an ford — Zoo logy of SiTclcim.
[No. 1
525 P. fuligixitexte n (Hodgs.) — Blyth, Ibis, 1867, p. 21. Horornis
fuliginiventer, Hodgs. Jerdon, Birds of India, II, p. 162. Short as is Mr.
Hodgson’s description, it contains the only characters worth noting. There
is a mere trace of a pale supercilium, and the under side of the wing is of the
same dusky olive as the breast. The tail appears rather rounded, and the
legs strong resembling those of P. Indicus and P. affinis , and probably indi-
cating similar wren-like habits. There is also a decided resemblance in the
peculiar coloration of these three species. Wing 2'2 in., tail 1.75, tarsus 085,
bill from forehead 0.4, from gape 0'5.
I obtained a single specimen in 'Rhododendron scrub at about 14000 ft.
elevation near Momay Samdong. This bird is probably a resident in the
higher regions of the Himalayas.
561 P. appdstS, Tickell. I shot two or three specimens of the birds in
the Lachen and Lachung valleys at moderate elevations, 8000 to 9000 feet.
None were killed before 26th September, but I saw a small bird at Laeliung
about the 9th September which might very possibly have been this species,
as it had the same peculiar habits. It may migrate to Tibet to breed, but
it is, I think, quite as probablo that it nidificates in Sikkim.
The specimens obtained by me were hunting in high grass and low bushes
for insects in a very wren liko manner, or like a Calamodyta or Acrocephalus ;
they were very difficult to flush, and settled again at a short distance. The
habits of this bird, and its near ally P. indicus, appear to me quite different
from those of other Phylloscopi. I have before (J. A. S. B., 1869, Part II,
p. 181) called attention to the Sitta - liko habits of P. indicus when on trees,
an observation I have frequently had opportunities of repeating since.
566 Reg clot lies PEOBEGELtrs (Pall.),. B. chloronotus, Hodgs. — Two
specimens obtained in Upper Sikkim at the end of September and beginning
of October.
568 R. ebocheoa (Hodgs.). — I shot a specimen at about 13,000 feet
on the Chola range, Eastern Sikkim. It is doubtless a resident.
569 Cttlicipeta Bubkii (Burton) .- — A single specimen only procured
at Lachung on the 28th September, together with Pkylloscopus affinis, hunt-
ing in the same manner as that species, amongst low bushes and long grass.
578 Abboeots castaneiceps, Hodgs.— Jerdon does not mention the
broad yellow rump and upper tail coverts, which are much more brightly
coloured and more conspicuous in this species than in Beguloid.es proregulus,
(Pall.), and are shewn in the figure in Gray’s genera of birds PI. XLIN.
There are one or two other slight omissions in the Birds of India, I therefore
venture to give a fresh description.
Head chesnut above with a dusky streak at each side, increasing in
breadth and distinctness posteriorly, lores, sides of head and neck, nape, throat,
and breast grey, darker on the cheeks and nape ; orbital feathers whitish ; back
•Lg72 ] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. 55
green • rump and upper tail coverts bright yellow ; wings and tail brown,
edged ’externally with green, the two outer tail feathers on each side with the
inner webs white ; wing coverts tipped with pale yellow ; margin of the wing,
under wing coverts, belly and under tail coverts the same bright yellow as
the rump. Iris brown, bill dusky above, deep yellow beneath, legs horny,
soles yellowish. Measurement taken before skinning. Length nearly 4 in.,
wnm 2.1, tail 1.65, tarsus 065, bill from forehead 0'28, from gape 04.
°Mr. Blyth, Ibis, 1867, p. 26, says this bird is decidedly a Beguloides.
So far as the hill is concerned, it appears to me that it might be classed in
either of the two genera, between which in part there is no clear distmction ;
the plumage is rather that of an Abrornis.
Troglodytida.
333 Troglodytes nipalensis, Hodgs. — The Nipal wren is common at
high elevations. On the Chola range I especially noticed it above the range
of forest, hunting over the loose moss-covered stones, which frequently form
so large a portion of the hill sides, constantly entering the crevices between
the blocks, and emerging again at a considerable distance. In the Lachen
and Lachiing valleys, it was common in pine forests, at elevations above
10,000 feet. I usually saw the birds in small families, 3 or 4 together,
hunting on the ground and low hughes, and with the same predilec-
tion for exploring hollows under stones. One of two specimens, fr om c ose
to the Chola pass, is an old bird and measures, wing 2 in., tail T25,
tarsus 0'75, bill from forehead 0 44, from gape 0'53. The other, from
Yeomatong, is of decidedly more rufous tint, the bill is shorter an J e ow
beneath ; this is probably a young bird. Its measurements ta en e ore
skinning were : Length 41, wing 2, tail 1*2, tarsus 0-8, foot l’3o, bill from
forehead 0 4 inch.
329 P.nokpvga sqttamata, Gould.— This ranges up to about 8 ,000 feet
in Northern Sikkim. All the specimens I saw belonged to the form called
Tesia rufiventer by Hodgson which I am disposed to believe distinct from
P. squnmata = albiventer, Hodgs., but I have not sufficient specimens for
comparison. .
327 Sesta CASTAXEO-COROXATA, (Burton) .-Not uncommon m Northern
Sikkim at 7,000 to 10,000 feet. I saw several, but have only a single specimen.
This bird is quite wren-like in habits, but keeps much less to the ground
than Troglodytes Nipalemis. It is constantly on the move m low brushwood
and grass, keeping up meantime a sharp monotonous single note repeated at
regular intervals.
527 Horeites brttoteierons, Hodgs.— Mr. Blyth long since, J. A. S. B.,
XIY 1845, p. 585, pointed out the similarity of this bird to Tesia ; except the
much longer and slightly more rounded tail of Iloreites, there is but little
•56 W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikicim. [No. 1,
difference in structure between the two genera. The habits are remarkably
similar, TToreites brunneifrons resembling Troglodytes in its movements
even more than Tenia does. I watched a bird of the present species for at least a
quarter of an hour one day, hunting over mossy rocks and diving into the
hollows beneath them. If Tesia be a wren, 1 suspect Horeites must be
classed with it. The note is precisely similar.
I shot IT. brunneifrons twice in the Lachung valley between 10,000 and
12,000 feet. Both specimens were moulting their tails, so that I could not
take complete measurements. The wing measures T85, tarsus 075, bill from
forehead 0‘32, from gape O' 5 inch. The iris is brown, legs pale horny, bill
blackish above, yellow near the base of the lower mandible.
Sittides.
218 Sitta Himalayensis, J. and S. — A single specimen, shot at
about 11,000 feet on the Chola range, differs from Darjiling birds in the paler
colour of the head, in a distinct pale spot at the back of the neck, and in the
bill being rather shorter. The latter character, however, is slightly variable
in most Sittw, and the pale head may be due to immaturity. Length,
measured before skinning, 175, ins., wing 2 0, tail 1-15, tarsus 075, foot 1 "5,
bill from forehead 0'5. The two outer roctrices on each side have a distinct
white spot near their tips much larger, farther from the tip and extending
obliquely across the feather in the outer pair smaller, and often confined to
the inner web close to the tip in the next.
In Northern Sikkim I observed no Sitta above about 7,000 feet.
CertMadm.
244 Certhia nipalensis, Hodgs— Common from 8,000 to 13,000 feet
in the pine woods of Northern Sikkim, in which at the time of my visit I
found it associating with flocks of Lophophanes and Pliylloscopi. It
appears in this region entirely to replace C. discolor of Outer Sikkim.
Measurement of a fresh specimen : Length 5'5, wing 2'8, tail 2'8, bill from
forehead 0'5, tarsus 07, foot 15 inch. Iris brown, legs horny, bill blackish
above, white below.
Paridce.
637 Lophophanes dichrous (Hodgs.).— I at first thought that this
must be a new species, as it agrees very poorly with both Hodgson's
original description and Gould’s figure in the Birds of Asia. In neither is
any notice taken of the conspicuous whitish half collar. I find, however,
that Dr. Stoliczka has received specimens from the Western Himalayas
closely resembling Sikkim birds, and he tells me that on examining Mr.
Hodgson s type specimen he found traces of the collar. I give a fresh
description of this tit.
57
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of SilcTcim.
Upper parts dull ashy with a greenish tinge especially on the rump,
quills and tail feathers brown with rather grayer margins. Forehead, sides
of head and under parts (bill huff or dark isabelline rather more rufous
behind, sides of the neek isabelline forming a whitish half collar, paler than
the underparts. Iris blood red, legs leaden gray, hill black. Length, taken
before skinning, 4'G, wing 2'8, tail 1'9, tarsus 08, bill from forehead 033 inch.
Far from scarce in the higher pine forests of the Chola range, and
common in Northern Sikkim from 8,000 to 13,000 feet, associating with the
next two species.
641 L. Beavaht: (Blyth). — ? Pams AtMnsoni, Jerdon, Birds of India
II, p. 276.
Adult. Head above with moderately long crest, glossy black ; nuchal
spot and a large white spot on each cheek commencing in front at the gape
and including the ear coverts white, often tinged with yellow ; back dark
ashy grey, often with an olivaceous tinge, wings and tail dark brown with
bluish grey edging, inner margin of quills white ; chin, throat and upper breast
black without gloss, lower breast and abdomen rather pale grayish brown,
more rufous behind ; axillaries, under wing coverts and lower tail coverts pale
ferruginous. Iris brown, legs leaden gray, hill black. Wing 2'6 to 2-8, tail
1'84 to 2'05, tarsus 073 to 08, bill from forehead 033 to 038 inch. These
are the extreme measurements of six specimens.
Young bird. Top of head glossless black, spots on nape and cheeks usu-
ally pale primrose yellow, sometimes white, the black of the chin and throat
ill-defined and passing gradually into the dull olivaceous gray, more or less
rufescent on the abdomen. Crest very slightly developed. I cannot help
suspecting that this is Dr. Jerdon’s Pams AtJcinsoni, the only difference ap-
pears to be the length of the tarsus in that form, which is less than in any
specimen of Loph. Beavani which I possess, otherwise the measurements cor-
respond exactly.
Loph. Beavani is by far the most common tit in the pine forests of
Sikkim. Both on the Chola range, and in the northern valleys, I met with it
in abundance.
I am inclined to believe that the upper figure in the plate of L. rubidi-
ventris in Gould’s Buds of Asia, pt. XI, represents this species.
642 L. /Ewan rtrs, (Hodgs.). Mr. Blyth pointed out in the Ibis for
1867, p. 34, that this bird is a Lopliophanes. Not only is it so, hut the
crest is comparatively longer than in allied species. No complete description
appears ever to have been given of it.
Adult. Head above and a long recurved crest glossy black ; a rather large
spot on the nape, and on each side of the head and neck, extending from
the gape below the eye to a considerable distance behind the ear coverts,
pure white ; back dark ashy, often tinged with olivaceous, passing into
8
58 W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
dull olive on the rump, wings and tail brown, edged olivaceous exter-
nally, the quills with whitish inner margins ; all the larger wing coverts and
some of the smaller primary coverts with white or isabelline spots, forming
two very well marked bars ; chin, throat, and upper breast, with the sides of
the neck and breast, behind the white spot black, lower breast and abdomen
fawn colour, flanks and under tail coverts rather olivaceous. Iris dark brown
legs leaden gray, bill black. Length before skinning 4 to 4'1, wing 2 3 to
2 4, tail l'G5 to 1-8, tarsus, 0 65 to 0 7, bill from forehead 027 to 0'3 inch.
In the young bird the head is dull black, cheek spots primerose yellow,
back olive, chin and throat brown, breast and abdomen olivaceous.
This is rather less common than the other two species but it is far from
rare in the Sikkim pine forests and has the same distribution. It is closely
allied to L. melanolophus, (Vig.), but the coloration of the under parts is
different.
In September and October, these three crested tits were found, old and
young, associating in large flocks, together with JPhylloscopi , Certliici n ipa-
lensis, and, below 10,000 feet, with Yuhinoe, Minla ignotincta and some
other Lew trichina, and Siphia strophiata. The tits are perhaps the most
abundant of all, and may be seen actively hunting over the stems and
branches of the different trees, pines, birch, &e. for insects.
635 iEoLTHAnscus iouschistus, (Hodgs.). — Forehead, centre line of
head and nape, a collar completely encircling the neck, a band from the base of
the lower mandible on each side, passing below the ear coverts, and all the
lower parts, except the chin and throat, rufescent fawn, or dull ferruginous,
lores and sides of head including a broad stripe over each eye, and a narrower
one underneath, uniting behind and running back past the nape, glossy black ;
ear coverts fawn colour with black mixed ; back grey with an olivaceous
tinge, quills and wing coverts dark brown with slightly paler edgings exter-
nally, the quills with whitish inner margins ; lower wing coverts paler fawn
than the breast. Tail brown, the central rectrices darker on the inner web,
the three inner pairs with bluish grey edges, the three outer pairs with the
terminal half or rather more of the outer web whitish, and a small portion
of the inner web near the tip. Chin dusky black, throat and centre of
foreneck silky white, mixed with black. Iris yellow, (not brown as stated
by Hodgson), legs yellowish brown, bill black. Length taken before skinning
4'5 inches, wing 2’25, tail 2T, tarsus 0 7, bill from forehead 0‘28 inch.
I met with this bird but twice. On the first occasion a flock of 20
or 30 were hunting about on birch and pine trees at about 10,000 feet near
Lachung ; on the second occasion a smaller flock were similarly occupied at
about 9,000 feet in the Lachen valley. It is probably only found in the
pine forests of Northern Nipal and Sikkim.
But for Gould’s figure in the Birds of Asia, it would be difficult to
recognise this bird.
1872.]
59
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
Motacillida.
MotACQLA Hodgsohi, G. B. Gray, Ibis, 1865, p. 49. ? M. lugubris
Pall. ? M. Cashmiriensis, Brooks.
I am rather surprised to find that all the Motacilla; shot in Up-
per Sikkim are of a species distinct from any found in the plains of
India. I can scarcely have any doubt but that they belong to M.
Hodgsoni of Gray, although it is probable that skins upon which that
species was founded represent the winter, or at least the autumn plumage.
I have two specimens agreeing well with Mr. Blyth’s very brief account in
the Ibis, having very little of the throat white and a distinct black line from
the gape below the eye, but from the appearance of the chin and fiom
another specimen in which the change to winter plumage has not proceeded
so far, it is evident that in full summer garb the whole throat and chin are
black, just as in personata, from which this form is chiefly distinguished
by its black back in the breeding season, and its rather longer bill. I will
give a somewhat more complete description of the summer and winter
plumage of this bird.
Summer. — Forehead and forepart of crown and superciliary stripe, a
large wing patch formed of the secondary, greater and medium coverts,
narrow edges and tips to the primary quills and broad ones to the seconda-
ries, two outer tail feathers, frequently but not always with the exception of
the inner edges of the inner of the two or of both, and lowci paits from
the breast white, the rest of the plumage black. Perhaps the extreme chm
and a narrow stripe running back from each side of the base ol the lower
mandible may remain white, but I suspect not.
In winter plumage, the bird appears scarcely to differ from M. Luzonien-
sis. In a specimen shot on October 4th, there is still a broader gorget on the
breast than in that species, but otherwise there is no difference. The whole
face is white, the moustachial. stripe having vanished. The back is grey,
hinder part of crown and nape black, wings and tail feathers as m summer
plumage, except that the wing patch is not quite so pure a w e- 10
flanks are greyish. It is possible that this may be an examp e o Jl
Luzoniensis, but I think not. All these species of wagtail are nearly
undistinguishable in whiter dress.
The intermediate plumage, which I suppose to be that on which the
species was founded, has the face white, except a line from the gape below
i-i ...i +v„. Dar coverts. The dimensions are
Wing.
1 3-7
2 3-7
3 345
4 winter plumage 3 '7
gape.
60 w. T. Blanford — Zoology of SiJclcim. [No. 1>
Young birds are uniformly grey on the head and hack, sides of head and
lower parts white, with a narrow black pectoral gorget.
Without specimens I cannot tell if this bird differs from M. lugubris,
Pall. Tho Japanese bird called M. lugens by Temminck and Schlegel in
the Fauna Japonica {HI. japonica, Swinhoe), and considered by them to be
Pallas’s bird, is shewn hy Tristram (Ibis, 1866, p. 291,) to be entirely distinct,
it being easily recognised by the greater portion of the primary quills being
white, and Mr. Tristram considers the true _3 [. lugubris, Temminck, to be an
African species. But Mr. J. It. Gray in bis ‘ Hand list’ gives the locality for
Jlf. lugubris, Pall., (a different bird probably from Temminck’s) as Northern
Asia and Persia, and quotes the figure in Gould’s birds of Europe.
Now the bird in winter plumage on Gould’s plate agrees very well with
JtT. ILodgsoni, and the bird in summer plumage only differs in having a
narrow white line from behind the eye to the lower breast somewhat as in
M. alba. The figures rather exceed the Sikkim birds in size, but in most of
Gould’s figures the dimensions are a little too large. The bill too in the plate
appears a little shorter. I cannot, therefore, feel sure that the forms are
identical, but I think it very probable that they are.
I met with no wagtails in Eastern Sikkim, but on ascending to about
12,000 feet in the Lachung valley I found them common. It is probable that
they breed here, for I had seen none in the lower valleys, and but few
migratory birds had made their appearance on September 11th when I first
met with them. All were beginning to change their plumage.
Bun i'tes vi hi nis, Gm. — A single young specimen in grey plumage was
obtained at Yeomatong (12,000 feet) on the 13th September. It was
doubtless migrating.
Alaudidce.
696 Pipastes agtxis ? Sykes. — Whether the common Indian tree pipit
is to be called P.plumatus, Mull., P. arboreus, Bechst,, P. agilis, Sykes or
P. maculatus, Hodgs., I must leave others to decide. On Mr. Blyth’s
authority, Dr. Jordon in his appendix refers Ant 1ms agilis, Sykes, to A.
arboreus, and substitutes Mr. Hodgson’s name maculatus for the Indian
race. Mr. Blyth in his commentary in the Ibis, 1867, p. 31, uses Sykes’s
name, but says that Sykes’s type has more the appearance of the European
trivialis (= arboreus— plumatm teste Gray Hand list, p. 251). Von Pelzeln
(Ibis, 1868, p. 312,) is inclined to unite the Indian and European forms, but
almost all European writers keep them distinct.* Lastly Mr. Hume (Ibis,
1870, p. 287,) points out that in his large collection he has representatives
of all the varieties of the Eurojiean tree pipit, together with numerous forms
intermediate between them and the forms described by Hodgson and Sykes,
* Comp. Walden, Ibis, 1868, p. 312 note. Gray, Hand list 1. c., &c.
G1
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of SikJcm.
but he adds that there are several of his Indian types unrepresented by
European specimens. Under these circumstances I cannot help thinking it
highly probable that there are really two distinct races, one found in Europe
and Western Asia, the other in Eastern Asia, and that the two meet in
India, and in the countries due North of India in which they interbreed.
We know that India is the limit of Eastern and Western forms in several
migratory birds, as Motacilla Luzoniensis and M. alba ;* Erythrosterna parva
and E. leucura, &c., and the same may very possibly be the case with the
tree pipits. Chinese examples would go far to settle this question. If they
are identical with the species from Bengal, whilst birds from Western India
are, as we are assured, undistinguishable from European examples, it will be
fair to look upon intermediate forms as hybrids.
I saw no tree pipits in Eastern or Northern Sikkim until about the
20th September, then they appeared in considerable numbers. Two
specimens which I have preserved are more olive above and more fulvous
below than those usually shot in the plains of India. They have broad
fulvous edges to the wing coverts and green margins to the quills, whilst
these are whitish in birds from Central India.
Comparing my specimens with the figure of Antlins arboreus in Gould s
Birds of Europe, the bill in the former appears decidedly larger.
601 Atvttttts stiuolatus, Blyth. — Common in all the northern parts
of Sikkim. I found it in clearings at a little below 7 ,000 feet early in
September, and at Phalung above 15,000 in the beginning of October.
605 A. eosaceus, Hodgs. — It is, I believe, pretty generally admitted that
this bird is distinct from (A. Cecilii, Sav. (= A. cervinus, Pall.). Mr. Hume
is doubtful on the subject (Ibis 1871, p. 35), but Mr. Tristram (ib. p. 233,)
is decidedly of opinion that it is a diflerent race, and he further separates as
A. japonicus, Temm. and Schl., the race found in China, Eastern Siberia, f &c.
Whether the latter be. not A. rosaceus, Hodgs., in winter plumage
remains to be determined. I cannot believe that the birds with olive backs
and yellow axillaries which abound in Sikkim are represented by any stage
of plumage of A. Cecilii ; at least such specimens as I have seen are
certainly different. Specimens obtained by Major Godwin-Austen on the
Khasi Hills were precisely like mine from Sikkim.
I found Anthus rosaceus common on the Chola range in August, and in
the valleys of Northern Sikkim, from 12,000 to 15,000 feet. It doubtless
breeds at these elevations, and it is, I believe, a constant resident in the
Himalayas, rarely or never descending to the plains. I presume Mr.
* Can if. dulchunensis be a hybrid race between these two. Some specimens from
Western India have no more white on the wings than the European bird.
+ Mr. G. B. Gray does the same in his Hand list, but marks A jwponicus as
doubtful.
62
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of SiJcMm. [No. 1,
Tristram means the Himalayas by North India, when he says that this
bird is common in the latter at all seasons. The distinction is important.
Most Anglo-Indians when they speak of North India, mean the Panjab and
North-West Provinces, not the Himalayas, and the fauna of the two regions
is quite different.
761 Alauda ( Oalmdrella ) bbachydactyla, Temm.— Common in flocks
in all the higher valleys of Northern Sikkim above 12,000 feet. I found it
especially abundant at Yeomatong 12,000 feet, Momay, 15,000, and Phalung
10,000. At the latter place early in October the short toed larks were in
flocks of several hundreds, just as they are found in March in the plains of
India.
Jeidon, in the generic character of Calandrella, assigns a minute first
primary to this bird. I cannot find it in any Indian specimens, and I have
examined skins from Bengal, the North-West Provinces, aad Nagpur besides
those from Upper Sikkim. That it is also absent in European and African
specimens is, I think, clear, because Cabanis in the Museum Heineanum,
places Calandrella ( Calandritis , Cab.) with Otocorgs in a distinct subfamily
fiom the other larks on account of their wanting the rudimentary first
primary.
Otocobis Elwesi sp. nov. O. torque frontali tenui, loris, genis,pileo
cristis duobus sincipitalibus , et fascia lata pectorali nigris ; f route superiori
superciliis latis, regione auriculari , lateribus colli, rnento, gula, pectore,
inferiori abdomineque alb is ; nucha, cervice, uropggio et tectricibus alarum
pallide griseo-lilacinis ; dorso pallide brunneo, und cum supracaudalibus
fusco-striato ; remigibus brunneis : primi pogonio eaterno albo, primariis
cceteris albescente-, sccundariis albo margimtis et terminatis ; tribus remigi.
bus ultimis elongatis, et rectricibus mediis brunneis, latissime fulvo-limbatis,
cceteris rectricibus nigricantibus, duobus extemis utrinque albo limbatis et
terminatis ; rostro nigro, subtus ad basin pallido, pedibus nigris. Long, tota
7'75 : long, alee 4'7, caudee 3'2, tarsi 0.9, digiti posterioris cum ungue 0 75,
unguis rnodo 0'3S, rostri a f route 0-4, a rictu 0 6.
Narrow frontal band, lores, sides of head below the eye, and a band
running back below the ear coverts, but not extending down the sides of the
neck, crown of the head, two sincipital tufts, and the upper part of the breast
black ; forehead above the black band, broad supercilia running back from it,
with the ear coverts, sides of the neck intervening between the black of the
cheeks and that of the breast, throat lower breast and abdomen white ; nape,
back of neck, rump and wing coverts pale greyish lilac ; back pale fulvous
brown with narrow dusky central stripes to the feathers, upper tail coverts
long, pale brown with narrow central stripes and whitish edges ; quills brown,
the fn st primary with a white outer web, remaining primaries with narrow
isabelline edges and tips which become whito on the secondaries, the three
63
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Silckim.
last quills (tertiaries) and the central tail feathers brown with hroad fulvous
margins, the other tail feathers blackish with very narrow pale tips which
can only he apparent in a freshly moulted specimen, the t\\ o outer rectrices on
each side edged aad tipped with white, most broadly on the outermost in
which nearly the whole outer web is white ; wing lining white ; flanks lulvous ;
bill black above, pale near the haso below ; legs black, soles of feet yellowish.
This species is nearer to O. penicillata than to O. longirostris. It is
distinguished from the former by the black of the sides ol the neck not
joining that on the breast, and apparently by its more lilac coloration. From
O. longirostris it differs in its much shorter bill, black legs,* paler tints of the
upper plumage, and the purer white of the lower parts. Specimens of O.
longirostris in the Indian Museum have no black frontal band at the base of
the bill, and the black of the crown is not distinctly defined, but passes into
the brown of the nape, whereas in the new species the margin is distinct.
From O. alpestris it differs entirely in coloration, it is much paler above
and purer white below, it wants the broad dark centres to the feathers of the
mantle, and although my specimen is evidently in freshly moulted winter
plumage, there is no trace of yellow on the head. Judging from Gou s
figure in the Birds of Europe, O. alpestris wants the black frontal band of
0. Elwesi, and the hind claw in the former is decidedly longer.
Three specimens of this homed lark were shot by Captain Elwes close
to Kongra Lama pass, between 15,000 and 16,000 feet. I did not myself
notice any at this spot, but I believe I saw some near the Donkia p 1 ^
nearly 18,000 feet elevation. The only specimen I possess, for w ic am
indebted to Captain Elwes, is in beautiful condition, having evi en y is
completed its autumnal moult.
Accentoridce.
So far as I can judge, the Accentors have as good a claim to form a
distinct family as the buntings or larks have. Scarcely any two ornithologists
assign the same poition to them, they rank alternately as thrushes, warblers,
Amvelidce and finches.
652 Accentor nipalenbis, Hodgs.-This bird was by no means rare at
high elevations in the Lacin', ng valley. Elwes obtained it at the Tankra-la. I
shot it on the hills above Yeomatong, and near Momay Samdong. I never
saw it below 14,000 feet, nor far from a glacier indeed the moraines of
glaciers appeared to me its most common haunt Sometimes it was solitary,
but more frequently three or four birds occurred together, on the ground or on
rocks In the Lachen valley I did not meet with it, and in the upper part
of that valley, it appeared to be completely replaced by A. ruleculoides.
* Two specimens of 0. longirostris from the Western Himalayas in the Indian
Museum have brown legB, like the figure in P. L. S. 1855, Aves, pi. CXI.
61
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of SiJcJcim. [No. 1,
654 A. steophiatus, Hodgs. — I obtained at Yeomatong, about 12,000
feet above the sea, a single specimen of wliat may be the young of this
species. It differs in the breast being fulvous with broad black streaks
instead of uniformly ferruginous. The claws too appear to be a little
straighter. It is possible that this may be distinct, but it is at least equally
probable that it is a young bird.
I am indebted to Mr. W. S. Atkinson for an adult specimen of A.
strophiatu# obtained on the Singalela range.
656 A. lurliKCUU)fi>KS, Hodgs. — This bird was only seen in the Upper
Lachen valley above 14,000 feet, together with Leucosticte hcematopygia,
Otocoris JElwesi, and other birds belonging evidently to the Tibetan fauna.
Whole head and neck greyish brown, rather browner above, and greyer
below, back feathers blackish brown with broad rufous brown margins,
shoulder of wing greyish brown, the quills and coverts dark brown with
rufous or fulvous brown margins, broader on the last secondaries and coverts,
and both ranges of the latter with whitish tips, tail feathers the same colour
as the quills with very slight pale edges, breast ferruginous, abdomen whitish,
flanks fulvous with a few dark streaks ; iris clear pale brown, bill black, legs
reddish brown. Dimensions taken before skinning : length 6 3, wing 2'9,
tail 2'55, tarsus 0’95, bill from forehead 0P45 in.
This bird was met with on hill sides, and had, like A. nipalensis, an
especial preference for the piles of loose blocks of rock and stones so com-
mon at high elevations and in glacier regions.
Fringillidce.
Mycebobas MEEATTOXANTTnis, (Hodgs.). — Two or three specimens were
seen at moderate elevations in Northern Sikkim. For the only one I have
I am indebted to Captain Elwes. It was shot at about 11,000 feet in
the Lachung valley near Yeomatong.
PrEEiitrLA eeythbocephala, (Vigors). — I shot one specimen at about
11,000 feet on the Chola. range, and another at the same elevation in the
Lachen valley. It appears not to he a common bird in Northern Sikkim.
The head in the male is dull scarlet or bright ferruginous rather than
dull crimson, chin black, and the white tips to be larger wing coverts are
wanting in adults ; the primary coverts in both sexes arc dull black through-
out, outer secondary coverts black with grey tips, the black decreasing in
amount towards the body.
A young male has the head greenish like the female, but with some
dashes of red, the throat and flanks also greenish, middle of the breast
ferruginous.
Wing. Tail. Tarsus. Bill from forehead.
Male 3 1 2.55 065 0'3G
Female, 3- 25 0‘35
65
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
Central tail feathers in both sexes about half inch short of the outer ones.
P. nepaxeitsis, Hodgs. — One specimen obtained on the Laehen valley
at about 10,000 feet. Like the last it did not appear to ho of frequent
occurrence. Neither Captain Elwes nor I obtained the rare P. erythaca, Blyth.
733 PvTinirorLECTF.s efauletta, Hodgs. — A male was shot by Captain
Elwes at about 11,000 feet on the Chola range. No specimens were obtained
in Northern Sikkim, nor was this bird seen there.
Carpadacus. A female or young male shot near Lachung differs both in
coloration and structure from the female of C. erythrinus. The bill is
longer and more pyrrliuline, the colour is uniformly hair brown above, darker
than in C. erythrinus, and with no dark centres to the feathers, nor pale tips
to the wing coverts, the rump alone having an olivaceous tinge. Beneath
it is white, sullied on the throat, breast and flanks ; darkest and with faint
brown mesial streaks to the feathers on the breast. Wing 3'2, tail 2 2,
tarsus 072, hill from forehead 0 45 inch.
About Chungtdm and Latong at the end of September I found flocks
of rose-finches which at the time I took for O. erythrinus in summer plum-
age. I only preserved a male, but this also appears to have a larger bill than
the common Indian rose-finch. I find another male specimen in the Indian
Museum from Leh in Western Tibet, apparently of the same race. It is
highly probable that these buds are the males of the above species.
It is doubtless also to this form that Bonaparte alludes (Consp. Gen.
Av. I, p. 534,) under the head of Carpodacus erythrinus, when he says
“ Specpnina ex Kamschatka a cl. Kittlitzo allata in Mus. Maguntia vidimus,
1 rostro latiore, mag is incurvo ; ruhro colore vividiore, nec roseo, nec coccineo,
‘ tergo magis rubente."
740 Pkopassee thuea, Bon. P. frontalis, Blyth. This beautiful rose
finch is common on the Chola range above 12,000 feet, keeping mostly to
the rhododendron bushes, but sometimes seen on grassy hill sides. It was
rare in Northern Sikkim. The birds at the time of our visit were single or in
pairs, and were probably breeding ; but I saw no young ones. It was
doubtless later in the year that they were found in flocks on mount Tonglu
by Captain Beavan, at a lower elevation than any were seen by us. (Ibis,
1868 p. 177).
The following are the dimensions of P. thura taken from freshly killed
specimens : —
Length. Wing. Tail. Tarsus. Bill from forehead.
Male, 6-5 325 3‘ 1 0-48
Female 65 3'2 275 0-98 0.46
Since returning from Darjiling I have received from Mr. Mandelli an
undescribed species of the genus, obtained on the Singalela range. This I
have called P. saluratus.
6G
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
747 PvuimosPiZA punicea, Hodgs. — A single male of this large finch
was shot by me at about 14,000 feet elevation on the Chola range, on a
grassy hill side, with scattered hushes, and in the neighbourhood of rocky
crags.
746 Peocaedtjelis Nipalensis, Hodgs. — I saw this bird once or twice
on the Chola range at about 13,000 to 14,000 feet elevation, and a specimen
was, I think, shot by Captain Elwes. It was seen on open grassy ground
with scattered rocks and scrub rhododendron.
750 Chbtsomitets spotoides, (Vigors). — Common in small flocks up
to about 9,000 feet locally in the Lachung valley, keeping to clearings or
grassy hill sides. I did not notice the Siskin either on the Chola range or
at high elevations in Northern Sikkim. It probably breeds at moderate
altitudes. I found flocks early in September as low as 7,000 feet, at Kedam,
between Chdngtam and LacMng.
753 FEiNGiLr.AunA nemo bicola, Hodgs. — Elwes obtained one speci-
men which, 1 believe, belonged to this species, at the Tankra pass. I did not
meet with the bird myself, nor have I compared Elwes’s specimen since
returning, but this bird has been frequently obtained in Sikkim before.
(Blyth, Ibis, 1867, p. 45).
Leucosticte HiEMATOPYGiA, Gould. — I only met with this bird within
a mile or two of Kangra Lama pass, at an elevation exceeding 15,000 feet.
There it was abundant in flocks of 15 or 20. It has a rather swift flight,
and from the nature of the country it inhabits, in autumn at all events,
must always settle on the ground or on rocks.
In none of my specimens are the pink edges to the feathers of the rump
much developed, and in some, doubtless young birds, they are entirely want-
ing ; the distinction is not sexual, for I have more than one female in which
they are fairly developed. The head too is much paler in colour than in
Gould’s figure in the Birds of Asia ; some specimens have the head feathers
dark at the base with broad brown margins, which would doubtless wear off
in the spring as in JSuspixa melanocephala. The iris is brown ; bill black,
except at the base of the lower mandible, where it is greenish ; legs black.
Dimensions taken on fresh specimens.
Length. Wing. Tail. Tarsus. Bill from forehead.
Male 7 4 6 31 0 85 0'45 inch.
Female 7 4'3 31 0’85 0'42 „
Moktieeingilla btjficollis, sp. nov. Mas capite dorsoque pallidescente
hrunneis, hoc late fuscescente slriato ; frontc albescent c, uropygio rufescente ;
superciliis, genis, mento et gala media albis ; loris, linea infraoculari, (postice
supra regionem auricularem producta et brunnesoente,) et slriis duobus
gularibus, una ut cinque ab mandibuli producta, postice diver gent ibus, nigris ;
regione auricular i et colli laleribus ferrugineis, spatio parvo cilbo subtus ad
67
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
gulam interveniente ; remigibus brunneis, extus, primo exeepto, fulvo-, intux
alio marginat is ; prirni pogonio externo et pennarum singularum, propter 4
primus et tres ultimas, maeulis magnis basin versus pogonionm internorum
albis ; tectricibus alarum minoribus plerumque albis ; angulo alee grisescente ;
supracaudalibus fulvis elongatis, rectricibus mediis fusco brunneis, fulvo mar-
ginatis, cceteris basin versus pallide cinereis, postice et ad margines albescen-
tibus, terminationibus semipollicaribus cum rectricibus mediis concoloribus ;
pectore abdominergue albis, vix fulvo tinctis ; iridibus rufescenti-brunneis,
rostro pedibusque nigris. Long, tota 6, long, alee 3 75, caudce 2’35, tarsi 082,
rostri a fronts 042, poll. (Angl.).
Fiemina f route albcscente et uropggio rufescente ; torque collari subtus
hand interrupts, postice brunneo. Habitat in Tibet.
Male. Forehead whitish passing into the rather pale umber brown of
the head ; supereilia white ; lores and a line from them passing under the eye
black, this line is continued posteriorly over the ear coverts, and its colour
changes to dark ferruginous ; hack umber brown with broad central dusky
streaks to the feathers, rump more ferruginous ; wings brown, the first prima-
ry with the outer web white, the others with fulvous outer margins, all with
white internal edges, and a broad white wing band, only visible on the ex-
panded wing, formed by a large spot on the inner webs of all the primaries
except the first four, and the whole basal portion of the inner web of the
remaining quills except the last three, which have broad fulvous borders ;
smaller wing coverts mostly white, angle of the wing greyish. Upper tail
coverts very long, pale umber with a fulvous tinge ; central tail feathers and
the tips of the remainder for about half an inch dark brown with fulvous
margins, basal portion of all the tail feathers except the central pair pale
ashy with some white on both inner and outer webs between the grey por-
tion and the brown tips, increasing in quantity on the outer feathers, and
running up the external web which is entirely white in the outermost pair.
Sides of the head below the black eye streak, chin and throat white, with two
black lines, one from each side of the base of the lower mandible, running back-
wards and diverging ; ear coverts bright ferruginous, sides ot the neck the
same, hut a little paler, the rufous tint forming a demi-collar, only inter-
rupted for a very narrow space in front ; remainder of the lower parts white
with an isabelline tinge. Iris reddish brown, bill and legs black.
The female wants the whitish forehead and the rufescent tinge on the
rump ; the demi-collar is brown posteriorly, and, in the only specimen ob-
tained, it is continuous round the front of the neck.
The dimensions given above were taken from a male before skinning.
The following are taken from two other skins, a male and a female.
Wing. Tail. Tarsus. Hind claw. Bill from forehead. Bill from gape.
Male, 363 223 0'85 036 042 053
Female, 356 21 0'87 032 0'43 0’54
68
[No. 1,
W. T. Blanford— Zoology of Sikkim.
This bird differs widely from every described form. In structure it is
closely allied to M. nivalis, and differs from Leuoosticte in its shorter wings
and tail. The plumage may become whiter in the winter.
I met with one flock of this new finch near Kangra Lama pass, and
with another at Phalung, both places inhabited by purely Tibetan forms, and at
elevations of 15,000 to 16,000 feet. It is probably common in Tibet. Dr.
Stoliczka is of opinion that it is the same as the undescribed Montifringilla
found by him in Ladak (J. A. S. B., 1868, pt. II, p, 62), but of which his
specimen is not now in Calcutta.
Corvidco.
657 Cobvtis corax, L. (O. Tibetanus, Hodgs.). — I give the measure-
ments of four birds taken before skinning. They do not exceed those given
by II. von Pelzeln (Ibis, 1868, p. 316,) from Dr. Stoliczka’s notes, so that it
is improbable that the Eastern race is really distinct. Mr. Blyth appears to
consider the Tibetan bird identical with the European, (Ibis, 1870, p. 169,
note,) and I learn from Captain Elwes that Dr. Jerdon is of the same opi-
nion, indeed ho placed O. Tibetanus amongst the doubtful species in his
Appendix.
1. 2. 3. 4.
Male. Female. Sex not ascertained.
Length,,.. 27* 25"5 2e>*75 25 5
Wing, 19*25 19* 18*75 19-
Tail, 11*5* 10*75 11* 11-
Tarsus, 3* 2-lf 2*75 2'75
Length of bill from gape, 3 '25 2*85f 3* 3*
Height of ditto, 1*3 l'lf 1*25 1*25
The wings when closed just reach the end of the tail which is very
distinctly wedge-shaped. Iris very dark brown.
Ravens were not seen much below 14,000 feet, but above that elevation
they were common both on the Chola range and in Northern Sikkim.
660 Corvus Vaillaxti,J Less. (O. culminatus, Sykes). — Some specimens
from Northern Sikkim are so much larger than any from the plains of India
that I am strongly disposed to think them distinct, but other specimens from
the same locality are no larger than those from Calcutta.
There is considerable variation in the size of this species in India, as
the following series of measurements will shew : —
* In the dried specimen the tail moasures only 10*5, and the height of the bill is
1*15, tarsus 2*7.
t These measurements are from the dried skin.
1 Lord Walden in the Ibis, 1868, p. 165, note, has pointed out that Lesson’s name
C. Levaillantii (potius Vaillo/ati) has priority over Sykes’s.
1872.]
5 Ditto ditto,.
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of SikJcim.
G9
Godavar
Ditto, ..
valley,.
21-75
20-
Wing. Tail. Tarsus. Bill from gape.
1, 14-25 9-5 2-4 2 35
2, 13-25 8-75 2-4 2 35
Neither of these had completed its moult, hut probably the longest
quills and tail feathers are full grown. A specimen obtained by Dr.
Stoliczka in Western Tibet measures
Tail. Tarsus. Bill from forehead.
Wing.
135
2-4
245
And in all the bill, although not longer from the gape, is stouter and higher,
and the gonys apppears longer. But on the other hand a specimen brought
by Captain Elwes from Lac-hung has the wing only 12'2, tail 8 me ies,
whilst a specimen from the Cliola range has the same measurement precisely.
The sexes are unfortunately not recorded on my specimens.
Under all the circumstances I do not like to propose a new name, but i
is quite possible that the Himalayan form is larger than that found m ie
plains of India. The dimensions given by Jerdon for . cu mma us .
length 21 inch, whig 13£, tail 7J, equal those of Himalayan specimens.
This variability in size probably explains the difference ot "l1’1'11
Mr. Blytli, (Ibis, 1868, p. 132,) and Captain Beavan with Colonel y
(Ibis, isG7, p. 328), as to the distinction, or otherwise, oft ie m aman crow.
Specimens of C. Vaillanti from Malacca precisely resemble those from
Crows were common up to about 13,000 feet, above which elevation
they seemed to be replaced by ravens. They appeare ar more a mm an ^
about 8,000 feet in the higher valleys than below that e ev a ion , Wl~' )
large flocks of them near most of the villages, but, as usual with (7. Taillanti,
not about houses like the Indian C. splendent.
„ ig rare on the outer ranges
666 NxrcmiAGA tiEMism.A, Vigors.— fins is
of Sikkim, but common in «h. pi™ fact. of, the mfno. It is not a very
war, bird but is usually to be seem on the edges of open ^glades or on trees
outside the forest. Its cry and Oigbt am both dccdcdl, eorvme. I once sow a
pai, hawking after butterfito just a crow. may .omet.mes bo observed to do ;
tbe White of the outer tail feathers becomes very conspicuous when the birds
are thus engaged. The iris is dark brown.
679 FbeoiluS GRACirrxs, L., F. Simalayanus, Gould. Von Pelzeln
has pointed out (Jour. f. Ornith. for 1868, and Ibis, 1868, p. 317), that
70
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
there is no constant difference in size between the Western Himalayan choughs
and F. gracwlus. But my specimens from Sikkim with one exception, a
female and probably a young bird, somewhat exceed the dimensions given by
v. Pelzeln.*
Wing. Tail.
Male from Sikkim, 12‘75 6‘5
Three females, ditto, 11-5 to 12-3 5-8 to 6'8
Male from Switzerland, v. Pelzeln, 1217 5-52
Tarsus. Bill from gape.
2-4 23
2'2 to 2'35 2- to 2 3
207 2-41
I have unfortunately only one male specimen. In the smallest specimen
brought down by me the wing does not exceed eleven inches.
The red-billed chough is rather scarce on the Chola range. I only saw
it once at about 13,000 feet elevation. In Northern Sikkim it abounded
from about 9,000 to 10,000 feet ; at Momay Samdong there were many
about the houses, as noticed by Hooker, and at first they were not wary,
but a few shots soon made them wild. They are usually seen about places
where yaks have been herded, hunting for insects under the dung, but they
also feed on berries and seeds. The iris is brown.
680 F. PYRiuTocoitAx, (L.)— Dr. Stoliczka found the yellow-billed
chough common in Western Tibet, whilst the red-billed bird was com-
paratively scarce. In Northern Sikkim precisely the reverse is the ease.
The red-billed chough abounds, whilst the Alpine chough was only seen once.
I found a flock, five or six miles, below Kongra Lama in the Ldchen valley
at a little below 15,000 feet, and at a place where the fauna was principally
Tibetan, and I shot one bird which measured : length 16 inches, wing 1125,
tail 7-5, tarsus T75, bill from forehead IT. The iris is brown, bill yellow'
feet red. The crop contained small black berries. I fail to see the necessity
for placing the two choughs in distinct genera.
Oarrulus lUpecularis was not seen during the journey, although
Captain Elwes obtained a specimen from, I believe, the Singalela range.
TJrocissa flavirostris I saw at Lachung frequently, but not above 8,000 feet.
Order — ComiMBiE.
Columbida.
783 Alsocomfs Hodgsoni. (Vigors) .—Captain Elwes shot this wood
pigeon at about 13,000 feet elevation near the Tankra-la. I did not meet
with it.
790 Columba i.euconota, Vigors.— Locally distributed throughout the
igher ranges of Sikkim, very common in places, rare in others. This is of
course the pigeon to which Hooker refers as almost the only animal food he
could obtain at this place (Him. Jour. II, p. 72).
h * VonPe,zeln’3 measurements are, I presume, in Vienna inches and lines; these I
are ^ P • 6 °f comParisoll> converted into English inches. If his measurements
ans inc ies and lines, they would be rather more.
71
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim.
1 never noticed tliis pigeon above about 13,000 feet. Its habits and
flight are very similar to those of the common rock pigeon.
Order — Galt.is.i:.
PteroclidcB.
Sybbhaptes Tibet ayus, Gould. — This fine sand-grouse does not oc'eur
in Sikkim, but it appears to be found just north of the frontier in Eastern
Tibet, and four live birds were presented to us by the Governor of Kam-
bajong. They differed from Gould's figure in the Birds of Asia in having the
ferruginous gorget extending completely round the back of the neck, although
narrower behind than at the sides.
In captivity these birds were rather noisy, their double cry being
frequently uttered. I succeeded in bringing two to Calcutta alive, but they
only survived a few days, although apparently in health when they reached
the plains.
Pliasianidce.
804 LorHOPHOETJS Impeyantts, (Latham). — The monal is not a com-
mon bird in Sikkim, it is, however, found throughout the higher parts of the
country at a higher elevation than any other species. In September I
occasionally saw birds as high as 14,000 and 15,000 feet, above the level of
forest. They are very wary, and keep much to the rhodondendron sciub
which usually covers the sides of the valleys for some distance above the
limits of the pine trees ; I have occasionally seen them feeding in the open
towards evening.
805 Cerioenis sat yea, (L.)— The horned pheasant is always called
Monal by the Ghorkas and other Hindustani speaking people of Sikkim. It
inhabits a lower zone than the true Monal, but I never saw it below 8,000
feet in Northern Sikkim. In winter it may descend lower. It appeared to me
to be decidedly scarce in the Lachen and Lachung valleys ; far more so than
it is on the higher hills around Darjiling, or than we found it to be
on the Chola range.
807 Ithagexis crtjextcs, (Hardwiclce). — Not rare on the Chola range,
but more common in the pine forests of the Lachung valley. I shot it
only in the latter, in September, in flocks of 10 to 15 birds, males and
females in about equal proportions, and the young birds of the year in
the same plumage as the old ones, but easily distinguished by the ab-
sence of spurs on their legs. The old birds had recently moulted and
their tails were not full grown.
All that I saw were in the pine forests around Yeomatong, where
they were tolerably abundant. They rarely take flight even when fired
at, but run away and often take refuge on branches of trees. I have shot
five or six out of one flock by following them up ; they usually escape up hill,
72
W. T. Blanford — Zoology of Sikkim. [No. 1,
and if, as frequently takes place, the flock has been scattered, after a few
minutes they commence calling with a peculiar long cry, something like the
squeal of a kite. The only other note I heard was a sharp monosyllabic
note of alarm ; I have heard a bird utter this when sitting on a branch
within twenty yards of me.
In their crops I found small fruits, leaves, seeds, and in one instance
what appeared to be the spore cases of a moss ; there were no leaves or
berries of juniper, and the birds were excellent eating. We did not notice
the unpleasant flavour mentioned by Hooker, probably because better food
is abundant at the season when we shot our birds, and they consequently do
not then feed upon pine or juniper.
Tctraonidce.
81/ Lebva xivtcola, Hodgs. — I found the snow partridge abundant on
the bare slopes of the hills near Yeomatong, at elevations above the limit of
bushes. Their habits are admirably described by “ Mountaineer” as quoted
by Jerdon. They appear to be local in Sikkim. I only saw them at one
other locality, near Tangu, and Captain Elwes came across some near the
Tankra-la. They are excellent eating, and by no means tough, if kept for a
few days.
Teteaogallus Tibetans ? Gould. — A species of Tetraogallus was
shot by Captain Chainer at Phalung ; of one specimen he brought the skin
to Darjiling, and gave it to Captain Elwes, who considered it to be the
above species. I did not examine it, but the identification is probably
correct, since the fauna of Phaldng is quite Tibetan.
The biids seen by Major «X. L. Sherwill south of Kinchinjanga, and
which he thought were probably Tetraogallus Himalayensis (J. A. S. B.,
1863, p. 468,) could scarcely have been that species, as he says they closely
resembled Pturmagan ; and the snow cock is so much larger than Pturmagan
that no one who had ever seen the latter could have thought the former
resembled it. In all probability the birds seen by Major Sherwill were
Lena nivicola.
Order — Gball.e.
ScolopaculcB.
8/9 InnxnuivxcTics Stbutheesii, Vigors. — We met with several of
these birds around Yeomatong. Apparently these were one or two families
which had bred in this broad portion of the Lachdng valley. They were,
for the most part, solitary or in pairs, keeping in the gravel flats or on the
turf beside the stream, and rather waiy. I found remains of insects, appa-
rently coleoptera, in their stomachs.
The paucity of both waders and ducks in the higher regions of Sikkim,
is remarkable. I once saw a snipe at Momay Samdong, which looked larger
W. E. Brooks — Gashmir Birds.
73
1872.]
than usual, and may have been Gallinago solitaria. It appears probable
that the majority of the migratory birds which are found in winter on the
plains of India pass from Tibet to Hindustan without halting in the Hima-
layas. The absence of herons and moorhens is surprising.
Order — Anseees.
954 Casabca eutila, (Pallas). — A pair were seen on the lake Bidan,
near the Jelep-la in the Chola range, and one was shot by Capt. Elwes.
Notes ojt the Ounituologt of Cashmib, — by W. E. Bhooks, C. E.
Etawah.
[Received 1st September, 1871.]
A few short notes on some of the birds I met with in Cashmir, last
May and June [1871], will probably interest some of the readers of the
Asiatic Society’s Journal. The first requiring notice is —
Polio jet us httmilis, (Schlegel and Muller). — I procured one on the
banks of the Tawi river. I also have one from Dhurmsala. A third speci-
men was killed near Etawah. The measurements of my birds accord with
those given by Mr. Wallace in his article in the Ibis for January 1868, on
the Raptorial Birds of the Malay Archipelago.” All three specimens have
a dark terminal tail band. This was overlooked by Dr. Jerdon who has
named this bird P. plambeus, Hodgson ; this and P. humilis are identical.
Accipiteb vibgatus breeds up the Scind valley. The eggs are boldly
blotched, like those of A. nisus. The eggs of M. badias are plain bluish
white without spots.
Buteo deseutobcm:. — I procured one at Gulmurg. This is the Buteo
vulgaris ” of Dr. Jerdon’s Birds of India. B. vulgaris does not occur
in India. Milvus major, Hume, is the common kite of Cashmir. It
may always be distinguished from M. Govinda by the large amount of
white on the lower surface of the wing. How this bird differs from Milvus
melanotis, Temm. and SchL, is a question I should like to see answered.
I took the eggs of the Cashmir kite which resemble those of M.
Govinda, but are rather larger. The eggs are laid in the latter end of April.
Mebops apiasteb is common hi Cashmir and bleeds there.
Cobacias gaebula is stiff more common. It nests in holes in trees
and in river and other banks.
Cobacias Indica. — Only found in the lower ranges south of the Ruttun
Pir Mountain ; in fact for the first twenty or thirty miles beyond the Panjab
frontier.
10
74 W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds. [No. 1,
Alcedo BETOAEEireis. — Excessively abundant in Cashmir and breed-
ing there very freely.
Yuinc xouquilla. — Not unfrequent. Breeds in the large orchard at
Bamu.
Ceethta Hodgsohi, n. sp.
The Cashmir creeper is closely affined to C. familiaris, but differs in the
following respects : —
1. A much longer bill, which is also much lighter coloured.
2. Not nearly so rufous in tone, especially as regards rump and upper
tail coverts.
3. The spots on the head and back are very white, and the brown of
the upper surface, especially that of the head, is almost black. This gives
the Cashmir species a general grey tone, as opposed to the rufous or fulvous
tone of the European bird.
4. The English bird has the three outer primaries (including the
diminutive first) plain brown ; and the fourth is marked with a buff patch
on the outer web. In the Cashmir bird there are four plain primaries,
and th affth is marked with the buff patch on outer web. On opening the
wings of the two birds, it will be found that ' the arrangement of the buff
and brown of the quill feathers generally differs in position and extent. I
have no hesitation whatever in separating the Cashmir species. It has also
a lighter coloured bill and lighter feet and claws. It is found sparingly in the
pine woods near the snows. It was seen at Gulmurg and also at Sonamurg,
where Captain Cock took a few nests. The egg is much more densely
spotted than that of the English creeper, so as almost to hide the reddish
white ground colour. Size 0 59 to 0 65 long, by 0'48 broad ; time of laying,
the first week in June.
I give dimensions of the two species : —
Mr. Blyth, Ibis for January 1867, identifies a Western Himalayan bird
with familiaris. I think this specimen will prove to be the present species
and not familiaris. O. JUmalaycma is found on the south side of the Pir
Panjal Mountain, but I did not meet with it in Cashmir proper, where it
is replaced by C. Hodgsoni.
1872.]
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
75
Sitta Cashmieehsis, nov. sp.
In colouration very like $. Himalayana, but the Cashmir bird is much
larger, with the white on the tail differently distributed. The wing measures
3 '3 in. The white of the chin, throat and side of the head is not abruptly
defined, but shaded gradually into the rufous of the lower parts. It is very
like S. Europcea, but is distinct. The abdomen, flanks and lower tail coverts
are darker than in S. Himalayana. There is no white edging to the under
tail coverts as in Europcea and ccesia. I procured this bird in the pine
forests of Cashmir.
Sitta ieucopsis. — Captain Cock took the eggs at Sonamurg up the
Scind valley. They are like those of S. Europcea, but glossier and more
delicately marked.
U pupa epops. — Abundant. I took a nest with ten (!) eggs out of a
hollow willow at Eamu. The distinctions pointed out by Dr. Jerdon as
separating the plains’ species from this one do not hold good. The only
certain distinction is the depth of the red colour hi the Indian hird, which
generally has also a vinous tinge. U. epops arrives from the north in
great numbers in September and October.
Hemichelidon euliginosa, Hodgson. (? H. Siberica, Gml.)
Abundant in the pine woods of Cashmir about 7,000 feet elevation
where it breeds. It was especially numerous at Gulmurg. This is the
species described in detail by Dr. Stoliczka in his notes on the Ornithology
of the Sutlej valley,
I think there can be but little doubt that it is the Muscicapa fusce-
dula of Pallas. Dr. Stoliczka informs me that Gray, in his ‘ Handlist , I,
page 324, unites M. Siberica, Gml., M. fuscedula, Pallas, and H. fuliginosa,
Hodgson, giving the two latter names as synonyms only. I am not satisfied
that our North-West bird is the original fuliginosa, described by Hodgson.
The measurements, especially of the wing are much larger ; and even a young
spotted bird I have, has the whig fully three inches in length. I am also
not satisfied that Mr. Hodgson had not two species under the same name,
for the dimensions on the back of the drawing of the nest of H. fuliginosa ,
give the wing of two specimens as each three inches in length. The tails are
each two inches long. Of this species on another drawing Mr. Hodgson says
“ H. fuliginosus. Uniform sooty brown, darkest on alars and caudals and
shaded with white on lower belly, vent and under tail coverts. The body below
paler than above. Length 4| inch ; bill to gape J,- ; tail 2 ; tarsi to sole -j’j ;
central toe and nail rather less ; closed wing 2 J ; legs blackish ; bill sooty car-
neous.” It will be observed that Mr. Hodgson does not mention the whitish
patch on the front of the neck, nor the bright rufous on the inner webs of the
wing feathers. I have had a good many specimens of the North-West species,
and find the wing to range from 283 to 305 ; and the tail from P9 to 2
inches.
7G
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
[No. 1,
I am very strongly of opinion that there are two species closely allied,
both being found hi Nepal ; the larger one ranging from thence to the
extreme West and North, even to Siberia, and the shorter winged one extend-
ing eastwards. I am borne out in this conviction by both Dr. Jerdon and
Mr. Hume. On Mr. Hume shewing Dr. Jerdon his specimens of H.
fuliginosa, the latter said they were not fuliginosa, and that he did not
know the bird ! In proof of this statement, Dr. Jerdon after a hunt among
his box of skins produced at last a singularly broad billed little sooty fly-
catcher, labelled H. fuliginosa in Mr. Blyth’s handwriting. This bird I
saw. It is smaller ; agreeing with Hodgson’s measurements, and has an
entirely different bill ; broader and more convex on the outline, as looked
upon from above. The bill is so thoroughly diflerent in shape, that it could
not be easily confused with the larger bird. I, therefore, conclude that our
bird is not the original fuliginosa, as described by Mr. Hodgson. The
dimensions on the back of the drawing of the nest above referred to, are
in native character only ; not by Mr. Hodgson himself, and there is no evid-
ence to show that he contused the two birds. If Mr. Gray is correct in his
identifications, our North-West bird should probably stand as 11. Siberica,
Gml., being distinct from II. fuliginosa, Hodgson.
Captain Cock found a nest of our bird with three eggs at Sonamurg up
the Scind river. It was placed against the side of a tree trunk, and the
eggs were of a pale greenish ground colour minutely mottled with pale reddish
brown, especially towards the larger end ; size of eggs '65 by '46 inch.
Siphia leu c cm E LANTJ ha. — Not uncommon in Cashmir wherever there
are pine woods. As in the case of Iantliia ruflata, many pairs of these
birds which were breeding had the male in the plumage of the female ! Only
two pairs which I shot had blue males.
The nest is a neat little cup, placed in a hollow in the side of a tree
trunk. The eggs 4 in number are of a pale buff color, clouded with dull
pale rufous towards the larger end. Size, '62 by '48 inch.
Ebythhostehna pabva.- — Breeds sparingly in Cashmir at from 6 to
7,000 feet elevation. The males in breeding plumage have the red of the
breast bordered on each side by a stripe of velvet black. This is not shewn
in Dr. Bree’s illustration. In winter the black border disappears, nor is it
regained before the birds leave the plains of India in March and April. The
song is sweet, loud and Bobin-like, but short. I failed to find a nest.
Pbatencola Indicia. — The small black Indian species is the stonechat
of Cashmir. It is not an abundant bird anywhere, as it is in Kumaon.
The first place in Cashmir where I met with it was at Thunna Mundi, south
of the Itultun Pir mountain, at about 4,000 feet elevation. Up to this point
Bratincola caprata is the very abundant stonechat ; extending through all
the lower ranges, but not beyond Thunna Mundi, nor did I see it at all
1872.] W. E. Brooks — Gashrnir Birds. 77
beyond the Pir Panjal range. In Cashmir proper, the only stonechat
I observed was P. Indica, which extends up to tlieScind valley nearly as far
as Gloond.
1 A yi h I .v rtjfilata. — This bird, like Si ph id leucomelanura, breeds in
the immature or female dress. I shot several pairs which were nesting, and
saw others. Only one pair had the male mature, and differing from the
female. It nests in holes in bank sides, under tree roots, or fallen tree
trunks. The eggs, 4 in number, are bluish white, very faintly marked
towards the larger end with the palest reddish brown. Iliose markings can
only be seen upon a close inspection. Length ’74 by '56 inch.
Calliope pectoealis. — Found beyond the Pir Panjal pass, frequenting
large heds of broken rock on the grassy hill sides, where they breed. The
song is pretty and rather Accent or -like.
Aceocepjialus bhtosescens. — Breeds abundantly in the Cashmir
lakes. The nest is supported, about 18 inches above the water, by three or
four reeds ; and is a deep cup, composed of grasses and fibres. The eggs are
four ; very like those of A. turdoides, but the markings are more plentiful,
and smaller.
Acrocephaltts duhetobuh. — Migrates abundantly through Cis-Hima-
layan Cashmir in the beginning of May. As I returned in June, I neither
heard nor saw one.
Acrocephalus agricolls. — Near Shupyion I found a finished empty
nest of this truly aquatic warbler in a rose-bush which was intergrown
with rank nettles. This was in the road side where there was a shallow
stream of beautifully clear water. On either side of the road were vast
tracts of paddy swamp, in which the natives were busily engaged planting
the young rice plants. The nest strongly resembled that ol Curruca garrula.
The male with his throat puffed out was singing on the bush, a loud
vigorous pretty song like a Lesser White-throat s, but moic varied. I shot
the strange songster, on which the female flew Horn the nest. This was
the only pair of these interesting birds that I met with. I think, therefore,
that their breeding in Cashmir is not a common oceunence.
Dpmeticola major, sp. nov.
Similar to I), affinis, Hodgson, but much larger ; measuring from 6
inches to 6'3 inches ; wing 2'28 to 2'3 ; tail 2 7 ; bill at front '55 ; from
gape *75 to *8 ; tarsus "87 ; mid toe and claw / 2 ; hind toe and claw *6 j tail
excessively graduated, the outer feathers being 1 12 in. shorter than the
central ones. The bill is long and compressed at the sides ; generally quite
black, but sometimes dark brown with the lower mandible pale, except
towards tip. Legs and feet pale flesh colour, with the claws a trifle darker.
Irides dark brown ; lores whitish. A cream coloured supercilium. Cheeks
78
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
[No. 1,
whitish, finely mottled with light brown. Chin, throat and upper breast pure
white, finely spotted with dark brown on the breast. These spots are
confined to the breast, and in some specimens they are faint or entirely
wanting. Centre of belly and abdomen white ; sides of breast and flanks
shaded with olive brown ; under tail coverts pale brown, each feather being
broadly bordered with dull white. Whole upper surface dark dull olive
brown, the crown of the head being conspicuously the darkest. Primaries,
secondaries, and tertials, also wing coverts with the edges of the feathers,
rather rufescent. Lining of wing white, with a few small brown markings
towards ridge of wing, the tail feathers are obsoletely cross-rayed.
The longer, straighter and stronger bill, and the differently formed wing,
with tolerably large 1st primary, separate this bird from true Locustella.
The upper surface is also devoid of streaks. I obtained several specimens. It
ranges from 6,000 feet upwards, even to 10,000 feet elevation, and frequents
exclusively places where the ground cover is abundant. It is seldom seen.
The song is strictly that of a Locustella; similar to that of L. Bayi, but
slower and louder. By beating the cover where I heard the birds, I was
enabled to get an occasional snap shot, and thus secured my specimens.
They were all males.
For the sake of comparison, I give Mr. Hodgson’s dimensions of 4
specimens of Dumeticola affinis as recorded on the drawing of the bird.
Tip of bill to tip of tail,
Bill to gape,
Tail,
Closed wing, 2®-
Tarsus to sole, i
Central toe and nail,
Hind do. do.,
The bill of the Cashmir bird is nearly one quarter of an inch longer.
The tail and total length are also much longer.
Hobeites bkunneifron's, Hodgson. — Occurs sparingly on the south
side of the Pir Panjal pass. My specimens agree very well with Mr.
Hodgson’s drawing. I heard the song of this bird which is very curious
and unmusical. Any description of the strange discordant song would be
impossible. It sings in a most energetic impassioned manner, and was so
engrossed with its own performance, that it did not mind my approach to
within four yards.
Hobeites paibiotts, sp. nov.
A larger bird than the last, but of very similar construction. It is
found in dense jungle at lower elevations. Its song is a strange prolonged
whistle with a sudden turn at the end, the second strain consists of 5 or 6
W. E. Brooks — Cush. mir Birds.
79
1872.]
notes in a different key ; after a short silence, the long whistle is begun again.
I have heard more than one visitor to Cashmir call this bird “ the
whistling bird.”
The description is as follows : Length 5T5 inch. ; wing 2'2 ; tail 2 2,
hill '33 and '5 from gape; tarsus '9; irides hazel brown; bill light brown ;
lower mandible paler, except the tip ; legs, toes and claws light fleshy brown.
Whole upper surface dull greyish olive or rather pale olive grey ; a
slight tawny tinge on the wings and basal half of tail, on the outer webs of
the feathers. Lower back and upper tail coverts rather lighter and brighter
in tint than the rest of the back ; being more of a pale brown with slight
tinge of yellow in it. A dull whitish grey supercilium. Pale brown streak
through the eye. Cheeks and ear-coverts brownish white, mottled with pale
brown. Chin to abdomen greyish white. Sides of breast, flanks, tibial
plumes, and lower tail coverts, pale brownish grey ; the flanks being slightly
tinged with fulvous, and the lower tail coverts still more so ; lining of wing
creamy white.
This bird has none of the depth of rich colouring of the Horornis group.
Its mode of coloration is rather like that of Acrocephalus dumetorum in
faded summer plumage, but paler and lighter. The tarsi, feet and claws are
strong and stout. Tail much graduated, the outer feathers being '42 shorter
than the central ones. In the wing the 5th primary is the longest, and a
shade longer than the 6th ; 4th a little shorter than 6th ; 3rd equal to 8th ;
2nd very short, and '48 short of tip of wing. The rictal bristles are distinct
and almost '22 in. long. The bill has a very faint notch at the end like that
of lloreites Irunneifrons.
Pjiylcoscopus magnieostbis. — Rather common in parts of Cashmir.
It frequents rocky banks of mountain rivers, where they are well wooded.
Its song is singularly sweet, but very short. I never found its nest owing to
the great difficulty of the ground on account of the excessive steepness. It
was most abundant up the Chitterpani from Burrangulla to near the top of
the Pir Panjal mountain ; also along the banks of the Rembiera river
between Aliabad serai and Hirpore. I heard a few singing in the woods about
Gulmurg. I may here remark that P. trochilus does not occur in India, not
even in Cashmir, and may be safely expunged from our lists.
Phylloscopus Tyileei, sp. nov.
In plumage resembling P. viridanus , but of a richer and deeper olive ;
it is entirely without the " whitish wing bar which is always present in
viridanus, unless in very abraded plumage. The wing is shorter ; so is the
tail ; hut the great difference is in the bill, which is much longer, darker and
of a more pointed and slender form in P . Tytleri. The song and notes are
utterly different; so are the localities frequented. P. viridanus is an
80
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
[No. 1,
inhabitant of brushwood ravines, at 9 and 10,000 feet elevation ; while
P. Tytleri is exclusively a pine forest Phylloscopus. In the places frequented
by viridanus it must build on the ground, or very near it ; but our new
species builds 40 feet up a pine tree a compact hall-domed nest on the side
of a fir branch. Eggs pure white. Captain Cock took the only nest obtained,
shooting the old bird oft' the nest. Properly speaking, none of the notes of
P. Tytleri could be called a song, but the song of P. viridanus is not at all
a bad one, and quite Phylloscopine. I give measurements of the new bird,
and also of P. viridanus for the sake of comparison. Here let me observe
that Colonel Tytler is, properly speaking, the discoverer of this interesting
Phylloscopus ; for four years ago he shot one at Simla which, together with
one of my own specimens, I have sent to Dr. Tristram for examination. Col.
Tytler had labelled the bird Sibilatrix affinis ; while Phylloscopus affinis
stood in his Museum as Asilus affinis. As most ornithologists do not recog-
nize the generic distinctions of Sibilatrix and Asilus, and as Asilus has been
applied to a genus of insects, I have, with Col. Tytler’s permission, altered
the name of his bird to Phylloscopus Tytleri. The only question remaining
is, whether it is distinct from the Phylloscopi described by the Russian
naturalists. Dr. Tristram identifies P. viridanus with P. Schwarzi, liadde ;
but it is possible that he may have compared the Russian specimens with
some of P. Tytleri. The measurements of my specimens are —
P. Tytleri.
No.
Only one specimen was measured in the flesh, No. 1.
P. viridanus.
Neither Captain Cock nor I found a nest of P. viridanus. I searched
hard, for I was anxious to ascert ain to what extent the nest and eggs differed
from those of P. Tytleri.
1872.]
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
81
Piiylloscopus affents, — frequents the same brushwood ravines as
P. viridanm. The song is very poor and the call note a sparrow-like chirp.
I did not find the nest.
PnrLLOscoiH's n minus. — I shot one (about 7th May) in the lower
ranges, hut I never met with either P. Indicus or P. tristis in Cashmir.
Reguloides occipitalis. — Is perhaps the commonest bird in Cashmir,
even more so than Passer Indicus. It is a very noisy bird, with a short
poor song. I found several nests which were placed in holes under the roots
of trees ; one nest was inside a decayed stump. The nest is a loose one of
moss, lined with a few hairs. Eggs 4 or 5, and pure white, without any spots.
REaunorDES trociulotbes. — I shot one in the beginning of May on
the Pir Panjal mountain. I never met with it again.
ItKGUf.oiDES suPERdT.losrs. — Is very abundant in Cashmir, and I
believe in all hills immediately below the snows. It would be vain to look
for this bird at elevations below 8,000 feet, or at any distance from the
snows. It was common even in the birch woods above the upper line of
pines. I found many nests. It builds a globular nest of coarse grass on a
hank side ; always on the ground, and never up a tree, as stated by Mr.
Hume’s native informant ; the nest is lined with hair in greater or lesser
quantities. The eggs, 4 or 5 in number, average -56 by *44 inch ; are pure
white, profusely spotted with red, and sometimes have also afew spotsof purple
grey. On the 15th of June I found a nest with four young ones in the south
side of the Pir Panjal pass. This bird has no song ; only a double chirp
in addition to its call note. The double chirp which is very loud is intended
for a song, for the male bird incessantly repeats it, as he feeds from tree
to tree near where the female is sitting upon her nest.
Reguloibes peobegubtts.— Tolerably abundant in the Cashmir pine
woods. It has a short twittering song and also a faint shivering sibilant
note, like that of P. sibilatrix ; so that the song ascribed by Mr. Blyth
to Beguloides superciliosus belonged to the present bird. In addition to
these it has its call note.
Captain Cock took the nest and eggs at Sonamurg. It builds, like
the golden -crested Begulus, up a fir tree at from 6 to 40 feet elevation, on
the outer ends of the branches. The nest is of moss, wool and fibres and
profusely lined with feathers. Eggs 4 or 5, pure white, profusely spotted
with red, and a few spots of purple grey. Size "53 by 13.
Cueetjca affenes. — Tolerably numerous in Cashmir proper, above the
elevation of its plain. The song is loud, full, and sweet. The nest and eggs
precisely resemble those of C. garrula, which bird, I may observe, has no
more right to be included in the Indian list, than Phglloscopus trochilus.
11
82
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
[No. 1,
Motacti.t.a Cashmibensis, sp. nov.
Is quite distinct from N, Luzoniensis, Scopoli, with which I com-
pared it. The latter is, as noted by Dr. Jerdon, identical with M. Hodg-
soni, Blyth, vel M. alhoid.es , Hodg. My new bird is coloured very like M.
lugens , Temm. and Schleg., except that the chin and throat are black.
The black extends down the breast for 2-J- inches from base of lower mandi-
ble. White portion of face as in M. 'per sonata of Gould and M. lugens ;
remainder of head and whole of back deep black. All the wing coverts,
except a few at upper portion of bend of wing, pure white. All the quills
edged with white, the tertials very broadly so ; so that when the wing is
closed, it looks almost entirely white. I need not notice that the tail is the
same as that of all other black and white wagtails. Total length 7'6 ;
wing 3'55 ; tail 4 inches, bill at front '5 ; tarsus '97. My bird has a
grey back in whiter, and some of those shot in May were only partly chang-
ed. If Mr. Gould’s specimens of M. persona! a were not midsummer ones,
my bird may prove to be M. personata. It nests in holes under large stones
in shingle beds of rivers and in accumulations of drift wood. The eggs are
like those of M. alba, but slightly larger.
Calobates m i'.i.anoi'e. — Breeds plentifully on the Cashmir streams
above 6000 feet elevation. Nest and eggs similar to those of G. sulphured.
It is distinguished from the European bird by a very much shorter tail.
Btthytes calcakatus, Hodgson.- — Plentiful in the Cashmir marshes.
Breeds on ploughed land and in broken banks near streams of running water.
I could not find the nest. The female has a dark grey and black mottled
back, with a black grey crown to the head ; supercilium and lower parts
yellow. Some females are more grey and "without a shade of black.
The males have velvet black backs.
Bu bytes cttbeoIiA, Pallas. — -Common with the last in the Indian mar-
shes in the cold season, and migrates through Cashmir in May. In June
they were entirely gone from Cashmir. This bird never has a black back,
but only a crescentic half collar at the back of the lower neck. The back is
always grey. The female has not the collar, nor has she a pure yellow
head ; the top of her head being yellow olive. The supercilium and lower
parts yellow, hut duller than in the male. She is a smaller bird than the
female of the last species.
Budytes cineeeocapibea. — Migrates abundantly through Cis-Hima-
layan Cashmir in the beginning of May. The dimensions of this bird
average greater than in IS. flam and B. melanocephala ; especially as
regards the length of wing. The mature female approaches the male closely
in size and brilliancy, which is not the case with the other two species. The
mature females of cinereocapilla and jlava are very easily separable both by
size and colour; the latter being far from a brilliant bird, which the female
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
83
1871.]
cinereocapilla is. The males of each are notably distinct. All three are abun-
dant in the plains of India in the cold weather. The young grey and white
birds of each moult direct into mature jlava, cinereocapilla or rnelano-
cephala, as the case may he, as my large series shews. The voice of cinereo-
capilla differs from that of the other two, and is rather like the note of
B. citreola. It comes up to Etawah in full plumage, after the other two
have migrated north. It is curious that it was the only one of the three
that I met with in Cashmir. I shot numbers every time I fell in with a
flight, hut never procured either of the other species. These three very
marked birds have all been confounded under the name of jlava , which is
simply absurd. My series consists of about 600, shot in every month ex-
cept June, July and August. 11. jlava can always, whether mature or im-
mature, he separated from either of the others by its broad white supercili-
um. The young of cinereocapilla and melanocephala are closely alike. They
would be difficult to separate until they change some of the head feathers.
The supercilium of B. jlava is occasionally strongly tinged with sulphur
yellow, so are the edges of the wing coverts and the margin of the tertials
when newly moulted ; but this yellow tint wears off, leaving the supercilium
quite white. All three are subject to yellow margins to wing' feathers.
Pipastes AiinoitrXR. — Migrates abundantly through Cis-Himalayan
Cashmir in the end of April and beginning of May. I shot numbers, but
never met with a single example of the other very distinct species, P. ma-
culatus, which I did not even hear in Cashmir. It has a long drawn
sibilant note, never uttered by P. arbor eus, and its haunts are never strictly
arboreal. The general green tinge ; the green edgings to the tail ; the very
pure white on the posterior part of the supercilium, which changes to a deep
buff anterior to the eye ; and the utterly different mode of striation on the
back', separate this bird from arborcus. Pew people who study the two
birds will agree with M. Yerreaux that they are one and the same. Mr.
Hodgson rightly distinguished them.
Antiius eosasexts, Hodgson, which has been confounded with A. cer-
vinus, is common on the upland grassy hills of the Cashmir Himalayas, where
it breeds at and above 10,000 feet elevation. I saw the old birds carrying
food to their young on the 15th of June. The song of this species is good,
and second only to that of P. arborcus, as far as a pipit s song goes.*
* Since I wrote the note on Anth/us rosaceus X have seen Mr. Swinhoe’s paper
on the birds of China, from whioh I make the following extract.
“ 208. Anthus cervinus, Pall., Zoograph, i. p. 511 ; Ibis, 1870, p. 317 ; P. Z. S.
1863, p. 273.
Anthus ihermophilus, Ibis, 1860, pp. 55, 429 ; 1861, pp. 36, 411 ; 1863, p. 311.
Anthus Japonicvs, Ibis, 1861, p. 333.
Throughout China, Hainan, Formosa. It is a mistake to identify the Eu.
ropean A. Cecilii, Audouin (= A. rafogularis, Brchm), with our eastern A. cervinus.
84
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
[No. 1,
Sturnts niters, Ilume.
The “ Stumws unicolor" of Jordon. This is described in the forth-
coming work which includes the ornithology of the Yarkand expedition.
It is like S. unicolor, but smaller with shorter wing and more beautiful reflec-
tions. It is excessively abundant in Cashmir at moderate elevations and
in the valley, and breeds in holes of trees, and in river banks. The eggs are
like those of S. vulgaris, but rather smaller. The latter bird occurs plenti-
fully in the plains of India in the cold weather, and is as profusely spotted
as English specimens. The bills vaiy in length, and are not longer as a rule
than those of the British birds. I did not meet with S. vulgaris in Cash-
mir. It appears to migrate more to the west, for it is said to be common in
Afghanistan. 8. nitens also occurs hi the plains in the cold season. I have
Etawali specimens. They are at that time slightly spotted, but can always
be very easily distinguished from 8. vulgaris.
Emberiza cia, E. Stewarti and E. eucata, all breed in Cashmir.
The latter bird has the best song of the three.
Hesperiphoka. .icterioides. Lays a large egg like a hawfinch. It
builds in pine trees.
Carpodacus ergthrinus and Carduelis caniceps had not laid when I
left in June. They are numerous in Cashmir. The former, by dissection,
would not lay till late in July, I think.
Chrysomttrts SEDroiDES. — Frequent on the south side of the Pir Panjal
pass. This bird is not a siskin, but a greenfinch allied to C. chloris. It does
not possess the merry song of a siskin, nor any siskin like notes. Its song is
the characteristic “ beez” of a greenfinch. Any one who has heard the song
of the English green grosbeak will know what I mean by the “ beez.” The
“ beez” of the Indian so-called “ Siskin” is, however, far inferior to that of
the greenfinch.
Metoponxa pus ill a. — I saw this bird in flocks at Shupyion in May.
The female as well as the male has a red forehead. They breed late.
Friygtlauda hemoricola. — Abundant on the grassy upland slopes of
the Pir Panjal mountain. It breeds there, as they were paired and singing
Ours is a smaller bird, -vfith shorter wing, and in summer is easily distinguished by
the rosy hue of its eyebrow and breast, which in the other ar-e rust-colour, the breast
being streaked with black. The streaks on the flanks, too, in the latter are much
longer and broader.”
From tbo above note I conoludo that there are only two species of red-breasted
pipits, and that tho following are the synonyms :
1. A. Cecilii, Audouin, ) „ TTT , , . ,
. „ , . _ , l the European or Western bird.
A. rufogulans, Brehm. J
and
2. A. cervinus, Pall.
A. rosaceus, Hodgson.
A Japonicus.
■ The Eastern or Asiatic bird.
W. E. Brooks — Cashmir Birds.
85
1872.]
in June ; but I did not find the nest. Their shrill song consists of one or
two monotonous notes, frequently repeated from the top of some rock or
stone.
Alauda guttata, sp. nov .
Is the common skylark of the Cashmir plains. Larger than A.
qulqula, with a longer wing and tail; not so rufous, and with a far bolder
mode of marking on the breast. At each side of the breast the spots
coalesce and form a couple of dark patches like those of Calandrella
Irachydactyla. This is not the case in A. gulgula. The white on the
outer tail feathers is also of a clean white, as in Alauda arvensis. From
the latter it is, however, quite distinct. I have several specimens of arvensis.
A. guttata is, with the exception of the excessively spotted breast, an
intermediate bird between A. arvensis and A. gulgula; with a song, as
might be expected, equal to that of either.
Description. Much less rufous than gulgula and of a darker and du er
brown above. The lower surface is also colder and greyer in tone. Tail
much whiter on outer feathers. Breast much more- profusely and boldly
spotted and with generally a coalition of spots on each side, similar to that
of C. Irachydactyla. Length 6 3 to 6 9 ; wing 37 to 3 9 ; tail 2'6 to 2'8
inch. . . .
Dr. Jerdon has made great confusion amongst the larks by giving A.
dulcivox, Hodgs., as a synonym of A. triborhyncha, Hodgs. Mr. Hodgson s
drawings shew them to be quite distinct. A. dulcivox is a very large lark,
measuring 7-j inches long ; wing 4J ; tail 2} ]. Breast spotted as in ai veil
sis. In character it is the only lark which closely approaches arvensis. .
triborhyncha is, as far as I can ascertain from Mr. Hodgson s beautiful y
finished drawing, identical with A. gulgula; and so is Alauda orientalis,
vel leiopus of Hodgson.— Dimensions of triborhyncha : Length 6 4 and b, ;
tail 2 and 2 The drawing shews the wing of triborhyncha to be 34
inches, and that of orientalis to be not quite 3f inches which is e range
the wing of gulgula is subject to. The tails also agree \u 1 la o gu -
gula, and the coloring agrees exactly. ,
I am satisfied that the Cashmir bird is distinct; for independently of
size it differs by the peculiarly dark grey hue. There is another large
lark found up the Scind valley at Sonamurg, which may turn out to be
Hodgson’s large species A. dulcivox. Capt. Cock took several nests of this
bird and the eggs are large and well marked, but I regret to say, he did not
bring a specimen of the bird itself.*
* I have since received several specimens of A. dulcivox from Amritsar and Nao-
sliera, collected by Capt. Marshall and Capt. Cock in the cold season. Length 7'5 to
7-7, wing 4-4 to 4‘7 inch. It is a finer and larger lark than arvensis.
8G
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. [No. 1,
(Note). I have only noticed some of the birds I met with in Cashmir.
To have included the whole would have made this paper too long. I should
observe in conclusion that Tot anus hjpoleucos breeds plentifully on the Cash-
mir streams, and Ibidorhynchus Struthersii sparingly. Two ducks breed
there A. loschas and Fuliyula Nyroca. Ardetta minuta, Ardea cinerea,
Nychcorax yriseus, Seolopax rusticola, Fulica atra, Hydrochelidon Indica
and Or ox Railloni, all breed in the Cashmir valley.
Notes on vaeious new oe little known Indian Lizaeds,—
by De. F. Stoliczka.
(With Plates II— V.)
[Received and read 6th September, 1871.]
In continuation of my notes on some Ophidians* I have in the present
paper placed on record observations respecting different species of Saurian
Eeptiles. In obtaining materials for this purpose, I have received constant
support from Dr. F. Day, (collecting in the N. W. Provinces and Panjab)
from Major Beddome (8th. India), Mr. Kurz, (Burma), Mr. Wood-Mason’
(Bengal andN. W. Provinces), Mr. Mandelli (at Darjeeling) and Mr. Martin
(at Pankabaree). Numerous specimens, thus brought together from almost
all parts of India, have enabled me not only to discriminate several imperfect-
ly known species, but also to prove the identity of several others. As far as
it appeared practicable, I have supported my descriptions by drawings of the
typical specimens.
To indicate briefly the results : — I have noted at length some variations
in different species of Lacertidm, and have shewn that little reliance can often
be placed in the form and number of the anterior head-shields, a character
which is occasionally considered by herpetologistsf to be of primary import-
ance in the definition of genera. A complete list of all known Indian and
Burmese Hemidactyli is given and a few new species described. The genera of
the Indian ground Agamidw require serious revision, and a few notes on this
subject will be found embodied in the subsequent pages. The Charasia
dorsalis, recorded some little time ago by Mr. W. T. Blanford from Central
India, proves to be a new species. As regards Stellio a conspectus is given
of the four Indian species at present known. In the Seine family I have dis-
criminated three Indian Rinulice, H. indica, maculata and Dmsumieri, and
commented upon various species of Mocoa, Riopa, Fuprepes, &c.
* Jour. A. S. B., vol. XL, 1871, p. 421 &c.
t Comp. Dr. J. E. Gray ‘ Lizards Steindachner, Sitz. Akad. Wien, Math Nat.
Klasse, vol. LXII, 1870, p. 336.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. 87
In connexion with the descriptive details, (often necessarily tedious), I
have noted the geographical distribution of most of the species, as far as I
had been able to obtain reliable information.
Fam. LACEBTIDAE.
From observations which I made on Tachydromus, Ophiops, and Acan-
thodactylus, I presume that the form, size and number of shields on the
antero-superior part of the head, and also partially the nasal shields are un-
reliable for generic, and often even for specific, distinctions.
Tacuyurowus sexlinicatus (I. R.,# p- 69.)
I have from the low valleys of Sikkim 25 specimens which I believe
to be Daudin’s T. sexlincafws ; they certainly belong to the same species
which occurs in Asam and in Burma, those from the latter piovince avm0
also been referred to the above named species by Dr. Gunther ■, and another
specimen of the same species was noted by Blyth from Mergui. (Jouin. A.
S. B., 1855, xxix, p. 71G).
The Sikkim specimens present, however, certain variations. which deserve
special notice, because they arc important as regards comparison with allied
forms. The two nasals generally form a distinct suture between rostral and
anterior frontal, rarely do these four shields meet in one point. In one spe-
cimen the anterior frontal is regularly divided into two shields. The nasal
is followed at the hinder inferior edge by a triangular shield, which rests on
the posterior upper half of the first upper labial. In two specimens e
anterior comer, and in one the upper corner is detached from the inferior
postil asal and forms a separate little shield by itself. One specimen has on
one side 3, on the other 4 chin-shields, and four specimens have regularly 4
pairs of chin-shields, the two first pairs representing m size exactly, or very
nearly, the first pair of such specimens as have only 3 pairs of clim-shields.
There are always 8 longitudinal rows of enlarged scales on the upper
side of the neck, separated from the occipitals by only a few smaller scales.
Of those 8 rows the outermost on each side has the smallest scales and, al-
though it can generally be traced at the side of the body, it always remains
indistinct, somewhat irregular and is occasionally broken up, an t e scales
never enlarge in size. The other six rows are well marked on the neck and
have most probably given rise to the specific name sexlmeatus. The outer
row on each side becomes somewhat obsolete before it reaches the shoulder,
while the remaining four rows of enlarged scales continue on the body, and
down to the tip of the tail. To these four rows Daudin’s name quadnhnea.
tus evidently applies.
* The reference 1 1. R.’ stands for Dr. Gunther’s ‘ Reptiles of British India.’
88
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
On the lower side of the body I find constantly only six longitudinal
rows of scales on the chest between the axils, one ridge connects the axil
with the groin at the edge of the belly and above this follow always two,
only in very old specimens sometimes three, shorter rows of enlarged keeled
scales. Thus there are on the lower half of the circumference of the body,
strictly speaking, 12 series of longitudinal rows of enlarged scales, 6 on the
lower side of the belly and 3 (rarely 4) on each side of it. Dum. and Bibron
correctly refer to the “ six series longitudinales” along the lower side of the
belly, and besides to the enlarged scales on the flanks, not, however, defining
their exact number, most likely because they found them to be variable.
Dum. and Bibron’s statement cannot, therefore, be attributed to a probable
misprint, as suggested by Dr. Gunther (1. cit., p. 69).
The coloration and size and proportions of the Sikkim specimens exact-
ly correspond with those of sexlineatus. Some have a white iridescent
stripe along the edge of the back ; others are uniform green above, with a
more or less distinct bronze tint. The fore-limb reaches to the rostral and
the hind-limb nearly, or exactly to the axil, when laid forward. Of all the
specimens examined, there is only one with two inguinal pores on each side,
several have 3, but most 4 or 5 pairs, often succeeded by a sixth imperfectly
developed one.
What follows from these observations is :
Is#.— That the Tachydromi canno.t be grouped with sufficient reliance,
either by the number of chin-shields, or by the number of inguinal pores, as
suggested by Dr. Gunther, these two characters being evidently very variable
within the limits of one species ; and that the most important difference
must rest in the number and size of the scales of the body, the proportions
of the limbs and the general form.
2nd. — That the specific distinction between T. meridionalis and sexli-
neatus is not so definite, as it would appear to be from Gunther’s descrip-
tion of the former species. Both appear to have an indistinct short fold
before the shoulder, when adult, but in meridionalis there are said to be 2 or
3 more transverse rows of scales between axil and groin, and the limbs would
seem to be slightly shorter. Whether these points represent sufficiently
characteristic distinctions, can only be shewn by the examination of a larger
number of specimens.
3rd. — That T. Hauglitonianus (Jerdon, Proc. A. Soc. B., Feb. 1870,
p. 72) must range with Gunther’s septemtriomlis (and not with T. Japonicus),
and as the number of chin-shields is not characteristic, the two are evidently
closely allied, but in the former the median row of dorsal scales is not smaller
than the lateral ones ; the fore limb does not reach the rostral shield, when
laid forward, nor the hind-limb the axil.
1872.]
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
89
Oruioi's Jekboot, Blyth.
Blyth in Joum. Asiat. Soo. Bengal, 1853, vol. xxii, p. 653. —Gunther I. B., p. 72.
Tropidosav/ra Jerdoni apnd Theobald, Cat. Bept. Asiat Soc., 1868, p. 22.
Pseudophiops Jerdoni et Theobaldi,* Jerdon in Proc. A. S. B., Feb. 1870, p. 71 &o.
I have lately received from the neighbourhood of Agra and the country
northwards, towards Ambala, about 20 specimens of the form describ-
ed by Jerdon as Pseudophiops Theobaldi. The characters given as distinc-
tive from the only type of Ophiops Jerdoni are not constant ; therefore,
O. Theobaldi must be considered as identical with Jerdoni, as has already
been suggested by Major Beddome (Madras J. Med. Sc., for 1870). More-
over, the genus Pseudophiops proves to he perfectly identical with Ophiops,
Already in the somewhat injured type of Ophiops Jerdoni in the Museum
there is on one side a distinct groove seen to proceed from behind the nostril
and dividing the nasal. In one of Jerdon’s specimens of Theobaldi, present-
ed to the Indian Museum, the nasal is, as far as it can be traced, in one shield,
but in the other it is distinctly between two shields, followed by two post-
nasals, which is also the usual number in the type of the genus, Ophiops
elegans, while three postnasals are evidently of much rarer occurrence. In
nearly all the specimens which I lately received, the nasal is exactly as in
O. elegans, between two shields, only few have them anteriorly, and others
also posteriorly, entire ; therefore the name Pseudophiops must he cancelled.
As regards the species, O. Jerdoni, I have to record the following
variations. As a rule there is one frontal ; in one specimen this is obliquely
divided into two unequal shields, and in two specimens it is divided regularly
along the middle into two halves. The posterior frontals are sometimes in
contact with each other, or they are divided by one elongated, linear shield,
or by two smaller ones following each other. Each posterior frontal is
behind separated from the respective supraorbital by a small shield, but
occasionally the latter is united with the frontal. The elongated vertical,
the two largo supraorbitals, the pair of anterior occipitals forming a suture,
and the larger posterior occipitals separated by two unequal shields, following
each other, are persistent in all. There are 8 upper and 7 lower labials, the
last in each case smallest, and there are 5 or 6 pairs of chin-shields, the last
generally followed by two smaller shields. In one specimen the two, rather
larger, anterior pairs are in contact, in others, three anterior pairs form a
suture. The number of scales round the body is generally 30, sometimes 32,
very rarely 34, of these the 6 ventral longitudinal rows are enlarged and
smooth, as are also one or two adjoining rows on either side, while all the
other scales are very sharply keeled. The fore-leg, when laid forward, very
* Beddome notes the M. S. name CivUtata, which was evidently suppressed hy
Dr. Jerdon himself. Comp. Beddome in Mad. Jour. Med. Sc. for 1870.
12
90 F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. [No. 1,
nearly or exactly reaches the nostril, and the hind limb extends to somewhat
beyond the axil, rarely as far as the ear. Some of the largest specimens
measure very nearly 5 inches, the body being 1} inch.
The coloration also is variable ; it is usually bronze brown, sometimes with
an olive and often a greenish metallic tint. Tho four white bands, two along the
edge of the back and two at the sides, aro generally well marked ; however, in
some specimens the dorso-lateral bands are very indistinct. Again, there are as
a rule two series of black dots, separated by reddish brown ones, on the back
along each white band, and similar black spots, almost forming irregular bare,
are at the sides between the white bands, and also below the lateral band. In
two specimens all these black spots are remarkably small, and in one of a dis-
tinct greenish brown coloration they are nearly absent, but the white bands are
well marked. This specimen is one of the two which I noticed as possessing a
pair of anterior frontals, and very closely corresponds with Ophiops Beddomei,
Jordon* (= monticola apud Beddome, Mad. Jour. Med. Sc. for 1870).
I collected near Kandala, on the Western Ghats, a specimen which
agrees in every point with Boddome’s description of monticola. It has the
uniform greenish brown coloration with the dorso-lateral white stripes very
indistinct, but the lateral ones well defined ; there is a pair of anterior frontals
present, and the femoral pores are more widely separated in tho preanal re-
gion, than in any of the specimens of true 0. Jerdoni which I examined.
Considering tho variations which I have noticed in undoubtedly identical
specimens of O. Jerdoni , I cannot but doubt that O. Beddomei (== monticola )
will prove a really good species. However, more specimens must yet be ex-
amined, in order to settle this point.
Graxors micbolepis, Blanf.
B1 an ford, Jour. Asiat. Soc. B., 1870, xxxix, p. 351, pi. xv, figs. 1 — 5.
A few specimens of this species, which was described from a single spe-
cimen from the Central Provinces, were collected by me at the coal mines of
Kurhurbali, W. Bengal.t One specimen has 5, tho other 6, pairs of chin-
shields, the last pair in each case followed by a smaller shield. In other
respects of structure of shields and scales, proportions of body and coloration
tho specimens perfectly agree with Blanford’s description, except that the
number of scales in one transverse row between the G longitudinal enlarged
rows on the belly, and counted across the back, is generally 56-64 instead of
about 50 ; hut this is evidently a character which may be expected to vary with
the size of the lizard. There is a good deal of variation in the number and dis-
tinctness of the dark spots accompanying the white bands ; in some specimens
the former nearly become obsolete. The tail is reddish in young specimens,
* Jerdon, in Proc. Asiat. Soo., Feb. 1870, p. 73,
t 1 found it sinco abundant in Katch,
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
91
1872.]
and the lower side of adults often with a distinct yellow tinge, particularly on
the lower side of the thighs. One of the largest specimens measures 5},
another 5 ) inches.
Qymnops is distinguished from all known species of Ophiops by the
peculiar small size of smooth scales, being almost granular on the neck ; they
altogether resemble those of Eremias. It further differs from Ophiops by
haying one instead of two postnasals, this is, however, a character not of
great generic value, as already observed by Mr. Blanford, when suggesting
the separation of the present species into a special genus or subgenus.
Acanthodactylhs Cantoris (I. R., p. 73).
I received numerous specimens of this species from the neighbourhood
of Agra, Ambala and Ludiana, together with Ophiops Jerdoni, both of
which have also been found associated by Dr. Jerdon (Proc. A. S. B., Feb.
1870, p. 71) in the country a little westward in the Panjab.
The specimens measure between 4 and9 inches, the length of the body being
1 ?, to 2f inch. When young they are usually marked with S longitudinal black
stripes, separated by white ones of equal width. Four of these stripes are on the
upper side of the body, the two inner coalescing into one before they reach the
middle of the back, while the two outer unite on the anterior part of the tail.
One dark band runs on the upper edge of the sides of the body, and one connects
the ear with the groin. In more adult specimens the dark bands become
gradually less distinct and are first dissolved into spots, until they gradually
quite disappear ; and the same is more or less the ease with the white bands
and other spots. The general colour changes from brownish to pearly grey,
and there is always a more or less distinct purplish irndescent lustre trace-
able on the scales. This is particularly clearly seen in the more uniform
coloured adult specimens, which often shew an indistinct reticulation oi a dull
reddish tinge on the upper side of the neck and back. Limbs above white
spotted, top and sides of head dark spotted or marbled ; the dark spots dis-
appearing with age ; below uniform white or greenish white. I have to
note three points in which nearly all the specimens I examined differ from
the type described by Dr. Gunther : —
1 st. — There are always 3 or 4 scales at the front edge of the opening of
the ear, slightly projecting into its space, unless the edge be accidentally
turned inwards.
2nd. There are very often 14 longitudinal, along the median dorsal line
convergent, rows of enlarged, keeled scales across the middle of the back,
and the adjoining 2 or 3 rows on either side are equally large, but beyond
this the size considerably diminishes. Across the middle of the belly there
are 14-16 enlarged smooth scales, 10 being in a row on the flat lower sur-
face of the belly, and the remainder at the side of it.
92
F. Stoliczka — On Indian lizards.
[No. 1,
3rd. — The fore limb, when laid forward, at least reaches the nasal shield
and more often the tip of the snout and the hind limb extends rarely only
to the collar, usually somewhat beyond it, and occasionally as far as the
tympanum.
None of these points indicate, I believe, a specific distinction from typi-
cal A. Cantoris, as described by Gunther. Some of my specimens agree in
every point of size with the measurements given by Gunther ; the largest
is 9 inches.
Of other variations may be noted : — the anterior frontal is, as a rule,
single, sometimes split into two unequal portions, and in one instance it is
represented by a regular pair of equal shields. The posterior frontals gene-
rally form a suture, but sometimes they are partially or even entirely
separated by an intercalated shorter, or longer, or by two, shields. The
posterior supraciliaries are often broken up into two shields. The form and
number of verticaland occipitals is persistent. The large shield below the orbit
sometimes rests on two or on three labials, and occasionally it touches the
labial margin itself.
Fam. GECKO TID2E.
Gecko guttattjs (I. E. p. 102).
The young of this, and indeed of most other speciesf of Geckoes, are
dark, or blackish brown, with white spots. F ew small spots are on the hinder
part of the head, while on the body they are larger and generally arranged
in 7 irregular cross series, the first series being placed immediately behind the
occiput and the last between the hind limbs ; tail blackish with 7 white
rings, the last occupying the tip.
The general structure is exactly as in the old, but the tubercles are
much flatter ; there are (in several specimens) only 34 longitudinal series
in the middle of the belly, while in old ones the number rises to 50.
PlTCHOZOON H0MA10CEPHA1TJM.
I. R., p. 105 and Journal A. S. B., xxxix, p. 159.
This species occurs both at the Nicobar and Andaman islands.
* Gunther says it only reaches * the front edge of the orbit,’ but ho gives the
fore limb 11 lines, which is exaotly tho distance between the axil and the nasal shield
in all my specimens measuring 7 inches.
f It is, therefore, very probable that the specimen of Gecko Smithii, Gray, which
I noticed on p. 161 of Jour. A. S. B., 1870, Yol. xxxix, has still the coloration of the
young, and may lose most of tho white spots, when adult. Dr. Anderson when
re-describing the same in Proo. Zool. Soc. for 1871, p. 159, subsequent to the
publication of my paper, omitted to notice the identity of the specimen, which it is
necessary to do, because a misprint occurred in my statement (1. cit. on p. 162) as re-
gards the total measurement, this being 4'8 inches (instead of 5'8 inches), but the
other detailed measurements are correct.
1872.]
F. Stoliczka — On Indian lizards.
93
Hemidacttltts.
I liave observed in several hundreds of specimens of different species of
Hemidactylus, (as restricted, and of the section Doryurd) , as well as hi the
allied genera Peripia and JStycteridium, that the total absence, or the presence,
of a few enlarged tubercles does not constitute a sufficiently distinct specific
character. The variations in this respect cannot be accounted for either
by age, sex, or the locality, but they are simply accidental. The species
belonging to the section Doryura have generally a nearly uniformly granular
body, well developed paratoid glands and normally a smooth tail, while in
Hemidactylus the tail is normally spiny, but, when reproduced, it becomes
smooth.
The distribution of the Indian and Burmese species of Hemidactylus
is the following :
1. H. TBtEDEtrs, Daud. (I. B,., p. 107). Ceylon, South and Central
India (Bundelcund).*
Nothing reliable is as yet known about the form for which Jerdon
suggested the name H. subtriedrus (Jour. A. S. B., Yol. xxii, p. 467).
(see pi. ii, fig., If).
It is perhaps not specifically different from triedrus, but there certainly
exist some forms which possess the distinctive characters noted by J erdon of
his subtriedrus. Mr. W. T. Blanford kindly allowed me to examine two
specimens which he lately collected near Ellore, and which, although agreeing
in form, general structure and coloration with triedrus (for instance the figure
in Belanger’s Voyage), differ somewhat from the description usually given
of that species. The two specimens are both females, apparently not full
grown, and measuring on the average 4^- inches, of which the head is about
f inches, and rump lj inch. None of the tubercles on the back is as
large as the opening of the ear ; the head does not appear to bo shorter than
in typical triedrus, but the scales on muzzle and throat are certainly very
small ; a great nmnber of moderately enlarged tubercles on tho hinder part of
the head ; two enlarged shields behind the rostral separated by two small
azygous shields ; nostril situated between rostral, suprarostral, first labial and
two moderate shields behind ; 10 to 12 upper labials, not constant, a row of
conspicuously enlarged scales above them ; 10 very distinct and well
developed lower labials ; 2 pairs of chin-shields, first forms a suture ; 32 long
rows of scales across the middle of the belly. The coloration, which was
noted by Mr. Blanford during life is : body generally bluish grey with 5 olive
brown, black-edged bands on the body and about 6 on the tail : of the
former the first is situated on the neck, 2nd on the shoulder and the last be-
# Proc. A. S. B. for 1870, p. 74.
f Side and lower views of head ; natural size.
94
F. Stoliczka— On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
tween tlio hind limbs. The band on the neck is darkest. The edges of all are
darker and more irregularly undulating in front than behind ; a yellow black
edged band passes from the nostril to the eye, slightly continuing behind,
the lower black margin is the more distinct one and continues through the
ear to the cross band on the neck, with the anterior black margin of which
it is confluent ; upper half of orbit and some spots below eye yellow ; head
pale, uniform ; tubercles on back yellowish, those on the edges of all the
blackish bands and at the sides of the belly more distinctly so, brightest on
neck ; limbs unspotted ; below yellowish, all scales minutely punctated.
In spirit the whole of the yellow coloration has turned pure white and the
dark bands are now white edged.
2. H. mactjlattts, D. and B.
(Giintlier, I. B., p. 107. — Stoliczka in J. A. S. B., vol. xxxix, p. 164, ancl Blanford,
ibidem, p. 361.
3. H. Piehesi, Kelaart, ( = II. Sylcesi, Gunther, I. R., p. 108).
It is, I think, clear that Dum. and Bibron, when describing their II.
maculatus, had under examination the two forms which Gunther separated,
and for one of which (considered as the young by D. and B.) he retained
Dum. and Bibron’ s name. The two forms arc, no doubt, extremely closely
allied, and it has yet to be satisfactorily proved, whether H. Pieresi should
more appropriately be considered as a large local variety of maculatus, or as a
distinct species, but, I believe, the view taken by Kelaart and Gunther, and
first of all by Gray, is the correct one. It is certain that maculatus, as restricted
by Gunther, never appears to attain on the continent of India and Burma a
larger size than 5) inches, and this measurement was observed only in two
cases among about 200 specimens from South India, Central India, N. W.
Provinces, the Sub Himalayan hills, and almost all parts of Bengal, Burma and
the Andamans. The usual size is 4 or 4) inches.
In all these specimens the head and body is brown spotted, the
spots on the latter have a tendency rather to arrange themselves in
longitudinal than in cross series ; in the three median rows the spots are
larger and more distinct than at the sides, where they generally become
rather confluent. The brown spots are equally distinct, or equally indis-
tinct, in males and females, the variations apparently depending upon the
seclusion of the locality in which the lizards live. However, I have repeatedly
observed, that in specimens which bad the tail reproduced, the brown spots do
not retain the same distinctness which they had before. South Indian speci-
mens are generally of dark hue, and often have some of the enlarged tubercles
white. Young specimens are always dark brown, with still darker spots,
while the majority of the enlarged tubercles is purely white.
As regards structure I find the enlarged tubercles slightly vary. They are
always well marked, along the back distinctly trihedral, on the sides often more
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
95
1872.]
rounded ; they are arranged, as a rule, in 16 to 20 alternating, longitudinal,
but not very regular rows ; they are slightly larger and sharper in adult males
than in females. The enlarged scales on the middle of the belly somewhat
extend to the sides and are usually in 38 or 40 longitudinal series. The
femoral pores in the male are 10-14 on either side, very rarely united
in the preanal region ; as a rule, they are separated by 1 or 3 or 5 scales ;
if 3 intermediate scales are present, which is very often the case, they are
arranged in a triangle.
The specimen recorded by Theobald in Cat. Kept. Asiat. Soc., p. 30,
under the name “ H.fasciatus, Gray (?)” is II. maculatus ; the former having
been described from an unknown locality must, therefore, provisionally remain
under that doubtful head, and not be added to the Indian fauna.
The four specimens in the Museum from Ceylon, recorded by Theobald
in Cat. Eept. Asiat. Soc. p. 30, No. 41, as II. maculatus, belong to the larger
form; two of them have the body about 3-J- inches and in one the tail is
3f, giving a total measurement of nearly 7 inches. In structure of scales,
tubercles and shields, the specimens do not exhibit any important difference
from maculatus, as usually understood, though at the first sight they
appear quite distinct. The two other specimens equal in size typical
maculatus, but when closely compared with specimens of this species,
they evidently possess a certain, aspect of immaturity and tenderness
of the skin, &c. ; their heads are proportionately larger, and the same
is the case with the trihedral tubercles, which are present in a slightly
smaller number (14-16 rows) ; their colour is almost uniform whitish.
In the two adults, the differences are still more marked, and the
brown marbling has an inclination to form transversely arranged bands,
very similar to a spechnen described by Gunther under the name of IT.
Sylcesi.* The number of femoral pores is 32-36, in a slightly interrupted
series. For this Ceylonese form, Kelaart proposed the name II. Pieresi
(Prod. Faunae Ceyl. 1852, p. 159), and as far as can be seen from the
drawing of H. Sykesi (in Gunther’s Reptiles), the latter does not in any
way differ from the former, therefore, Kelaart s older name must take
priority. It also seems to me clear that Dam. and Bibron s largest specimen
of maculatus, of which they give measurements, is the Sykesi of Gunther ;
it is said to occur in the neighbourhood of Bombay, wherefrom Dum. and
Bibron received it. Dr. Gray is evidently the original observer of the two forms,
the small maculatus and the large Pieresi, as shewn by him in his ‘ Lizards’
p. 153, where he gives “ II. Sykesi, Gray, B. M.” as the synonym of
maculatus ; and among the specimens of that species he quotes “ a. In
spirits. Female ? India, Dukun. Presented by Col. Sykes.” This is to all
appearance the only type of Gunther’s species, bearing the name II. Sykesi.
* Of Gray ?
96 F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. [No. 1,
Kelaart (Prod. Fauna) Ceyl., 1852, p. 158) also gives H. Sylcesi, Gray, as
the synonym of his doubtful maculatus. The history of the specios appears
to have been overlooked by Dr. Gunther.
H. maculatus , as restricted, occurs in Ceylon, throughout India, Burma
and the Malayan Peninsula extending to Sumatra, Java, &c. Peters in
Yan der Deelcen’s Eeisen gives it also from the Seychelles. It is a very com-
mon species in houses about Calcutta.
H. Pieresi is as yet known only from Ceylon and from the Dakhin
(Dekan) .
4. H. Gracilis. — A very beautiful species described by "YV. T. Blanford
from Berar and Baipur in Central India (Journ. A. S. B., Vol. xxxix
p. 362, pi. xvi, figs. 4-6).
5. H. ret I c u l at us, Beddome. Madras J. Med. Sc., 1870, p. 33.
6. H. fre.vatus, Schlegel, (I. E., p. 168).
Hem. sublavis, Gray, apud Theobald, Cat. Ropt. Asiat. Soo., p. 30.
H. frenatus, in Joarn. A. S. Beng., vol. xxxix, p. 161.
? If. punc talus, Jordon, 1853, Journ. A. S. B., xxii, p. 467.
This species which usually grows to about 5 inches, (rarely attaining
5J) is readily recognised from all other Indian Hemidactyli by the small
size of the thumb and inner toe ; the claw on it is setiform and often so
fine as to bo hardly traceable. The body is finely granular, but there are
always some enlarged rounded tubercles present. In Bengal specimens, two
alternate series of those very usually run along the centre of the back, and
there are besides about 3 irregular rows on each side of the body. Dakhin
(Dekan) and Upper India specimens generally have no enlarged tubercles in
the middle of the back. The tail is spiny, unless it has been reproduced, in
which case it remains smooth. The femoral pores are either interrupted by
one enlarged scale, or they are continuous above the preanal region. The
colour is very variable, — uniform grey, or greenish grey, very closely marbled
and spotted with dark ; or grey with some irregular stripes and close mar-
blings, the former most distinctly marked on the neck and the sides of the
belly ; or dark brown with some irregular blackish stripes ; there is, however,
always a more or loss distinct pale (during life sometimes yellowish orange)
band present, passing from the rostral through the eye and either disappear-
ing above the ear, or continuing along the side of the body down to the
groin ; this pale band is margined above and below by a dark line. The tail
has sometimes an orange tinge, particularly after the cuticle had been shed.
II. frenatus is the commonest Gecko from Ceylon and through India, ex-
tending in a northwesterly direction as far as the Panjab, and occurring all
tluough Bengal, Burma and the whole of the Malayan Archipelago, includ-
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
97
1872.]
ing the Andamans and Nicobars. From all these parts I have examined
specimens. It occurs in houses as well as on trees, and among stones. Ac-
cording to Peters it is also found at the Seychelles.
I am strongly disposed to believe that Jerdons II. punctatus was
based upon a young female specimen of frenatus. I possess specimens
which in every point of colouration, and structure and measurement, agree
with Jerdon’s description, the only apparent discrepancy lying in Jerdon s
statement to the effect that “ the thumb appears as well developed as in
maculatus! In some respects this is really the case, the basal portion
of the thumb being in the two species nearly equally developed, occasionally
almost more so in frenatus, but the free claw hearing portion ol the thumb
is always somewhat shorter in frenatus than in maculatus.
7. H. LESCHENAtriiTI, D. AND B.
Gunther, I. R., p. 109. — Idem, Jerdon, J. A. S. B., xxii, p. 468. — 3. Oocteci, apud
Kelaart, Prod. F. Ceyl., 1852, p. 160, — H. KelaarUi and Leschenaultii, Theobald, Cat.
Kept. Asiat. Soc. Mas., p. 29 and 30. — H. marmoratus, Blf., Jour. As. Soc. Bengal, vol.
xxxix, part ii, p. 363, pi. xvi, figs. 1-3. — 3. marmoratus, Kelam-ti and Leschenaultii,
Blanford in Proc. A. S. B. for August, 1871, p. 173.
The present species generally has, like the previous one, some enlarged,
rounded tubercles on the hack, at least on the femoral region, more rarely
are the tubercles scattered over the entire body. The colour is rarely uni-
form silvery grey, generally there are some transverse, zigzag dark marblings
traceable, and there is usually a dark band through the eye present ; 10-16
femoral pores on each side, widely separated in the preanal region.
The species can readily be distinguished from frenatus by the well de-
veloped thumb, and from Coctmi by the greater number of femoral pores,
somewhat less widely separated in the preanal region. Kelaart s Coctmi is
evidently this species, and was named Kelaarti by Theobald, as pointed out
by Mr. Blanford, who formerly separated a small Central Indian variety,
with a nearly uniform granulation, as II. marmoratus.
II. Leschenaultii occurs in Ceylon, whence some years ago specimens
have been identified by Professor Peters* and Dr. Steindachner ; it is com-
mon all through South India according to Jerdon and in Central India ac-
cording to Blanford. I have obtained a few specimens on the Parisnath hill
and near Ranigunj in Bengal, and others from near Patna and Agra. It is
not known from North-Eastern Bengal, and thus may he regarded as a true
Indian species.
8. H. Mortoni, Theobald, Journ. Linn. S., Zool. X, p. 32. Close to
frenatus, but having the thumb and inner toe well developed. — Burma.
* Berlin Akad. Monatsb. 1860, p. 183.
13
98
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1
9. H. Coctjei* (I. K, p. 109).
Theobald, Cat. Rept. As. Soc. Mus. 186?, p. 29.
Steindaohner, Novara Rept , Pt. I, p. 13.
H. BengaMensis, Anderson, Jonrn. A. S. B„ vol. xl, p. 14.
This is the most common species all through Bengal, whence it was
originally described by Dum. and Bibron. The thumb is well developed, as
noted by the French authors and by Cantor, but the claw small, as observed
by Dr. Gunther, who identified Bolt, sublcevis, Gray, with the present species.
The back is generally equally granular ; sometimes there are a few larger
rounded tubercles present on the sacral region, more rarely also on the sides
of the back, the variations being in this respect exactly similar to those
noticed in II. Leschenaultii. The larger tubercle on the side of the neck,
stated by Dr. Anderson to distinguish Bengaliensis from Coetmi is quite as often
present as it is absent. Tail, when original, segmented, with one or two
large elongate scale-like lateral tubercles near the base, and 2 to 3 smaller
ones on the upper sides, but as a rule none along the middle ; subcaudals
enlarged. On reproduced portions of the tail, there are sometimes a few large
scales present at the lateral edges, but more commonly the tail remains quite
smooth. I have never seen, even in the largest specimens, more than 8
femoral pores in each row, they being widely separated in the preaual region ;
the usual number of pores is six in each row, rarely less.
During life, the general colour is greenish grey, with 5 transverse, broad
undulating greenish brown bands, the first on the neck, the fifth on the loin,
and all edged with white posteriorly ; the tail is similarly banded above, and
the white edgings are often more conspicuous ; a pale band through the eye
on the side of the head, margined with dark above and below, and generally
becoming obsolete on the neck. The iris is reddish golden, pupil narrow, black
with undulating edges. The animal changes its coloration very rapidly
during life, sometimes the transverse bands turn almost to blackish brown,
and another time they become quite obsolete. In spirits the brown tints
partially, and in time entirely, fade. Below white, most of the scales
generally very minutely punctated with black. Old specimens, particularly
the females, have the tail at the base often very bulging, depressed, and
nearly three-fourths of an inch broad.
I have not seen specimens of this species from farther southwards than
Orissa, but it is very numerous in Western Bengal, extending through the
North West Provinces up to the foot of the hills at Kangra and Hurdwar,
westward into the Panjab and eastward into the lower parts of Sikkim, the
Khasi hills, Cachar and the whole of the Gangetic delta. I did not obtain
it in Burma, but two specimens have been sent to me stated to have been
procured in Pegu. Dum. and Bibron record it from Bombay, which very
# ? Is the right name Coctecmi f
1872.] F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. 99
likely refers to some locality in the Western Ghats. Jerdon does not quote
it from South India and Kelaart’s Ceylon Coctcei is Leschenaultii. Cantor
(Mai. Rep., J. A. S. B., xvi, p. 629) gives it as occurring in Penang, and notes
a specimen 7 inches long, the head above being 1-jf inches, which is a
somewhat unusual size.
In general structure and coloration, S. Coctcei is very closely allied to
Leschenaultii, differing from the latter by the smaller number of femoral
pores, and somewhat more elongated and narrower fingers and toes, with
more numerous and thinner plates below, the toes being in Leschenaultii
more broadly oval, shorter and the plates below coarser ; the thumb also is
somewhat shorter. Judging from the known geographical distribution, it
appears to me very probable that 11. Coctcei replaces in the Gangetic delta
II. Leschenaultii, which is a more southern form ; and both appear to meet
together in Western Bengal and the southern part of the N. W. Provinces.
In Calcutta this is the largest llcmidactijlus, usually seen on the outer
walls of houses or godowns. It is readily known by its coloration. The
usual size is 6-7 inches, the body being 3-3* inches, while the tail is often
reproduced. On one occasion I obtained two specimens, each of nearly 9
inches, the body being 3|, and the tail (perfect) a little above 5 inches.
10. H. attract r a crs, Beddome, Madras J. Med. Sc., No. 1, 1S/0, p. 33.
A uniformly granular species, without any enlarged chin shields.
Shevaroys and Anamallays, South India.
11. Hemidacttlits oigantets, n. sp. PI. II. fig- 2.
PI. II, fig. 2, 2 a, 2 b, top, side, and lower view's of head, 2 o, inside view of the
sacral region and right foot ; all figures in natural size.
General form very similar to that of II Coctcei. Head and body above
uniformly granular, the scales on the snout being, as usually, slightly laip,u,
and sharper, and those on the hinder part of the head smallest ; tw o enlarged
shields behind the rostral, separated by one or two minute scales, nostril situat-
ed between the rostral, the suprarostral and a semicircular shield behind, on
the lower side in contact with the rostral, excluding the first labial from
entering the nostril, 14-17 upper and 11-13 lower labials ; two pairs of
chin-shields, the first in contact, anteriorly partially separated by tliepantagonal
inferior rostral ; the second chin-shield about half the size of the first, slightly
elongate or rounded and followed by a few smaller scales along the labials;
scales on belly slightly hexagonally elongate, in 40 to 44 lougitudmal series ;
some on the pubic region are pointedly elongate, but none are particularly
enlarged ; in the males 18-20 femoral pores on either side of the thigh,
separated in the preanal region by an interspace of about 7 scales width ;
tail indistinctly segmented, generally reproduced and then without any
100
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
segments, rather abruptly tapering, occasionally very bulging near the base,
uniform scaly above and at the sides without any enlarged spiny tubercles ;
subcaudals moderately enlarged, beginning to be so a short distance from the
anus ; about 11 transverse lamelke on the first, and 14-15 on the fourth toes,
the two or three basal lamella! and the terminal one being in each case simple ;
thumb well developed.
This species is very closely allied to II. Coetcei, and I might have
considered it as a gigantic variety of the same, had it not the peculiarity of
the first labial being excluded from the edge of the nostril, which is a
character constant in all the specimens, none of them also have any
enlarged spiny scales at the side of the tail ; but the most important
distinction lies in the presence of a large number of femoral pores, which
are also somewhat less widely separated in the preanal region, than they
are in 11. Coctwi.
The general colour during life is, according to Mr. Blanford, olive
grey to blackish olive, with irregular dark, pale edged marks in imperfect
circles, inclined to form 4 or 5 transverse undulating bands on the body.
In spirit these irregular markings are slightly traceable, and the whole body is
besides rather finely mottled with brownish olive. Below uniform white.
Hah. I have examined 9 specimens which were kindly lent to me for
description by Mr. W. T. Blanford, who obtained the same in a solitary
locality on the Godavari river near Badrachalam, on trees. The body of
the smallest measures 4f inch., and of the largest a little above 5 inches.
All have their tails partially reproduced, and the longest is only about
4 J inches, in its original state it must have been at least 6 or 7 inches. In
one of the largest specimens, the length of the head is If inches, and the
width at the occiput If inches.
12. H. [Doeyuba] Bebdmoeei, (Blyth). PI. II, fig. 3.
Leiurus Berdmorei, Blyth, Journ. A. S. B., 1853, xxii, p. 646.
Doryura, Berdmorei, apud Theobald, Journ. Linn. S., Zool. x, p. 29.
PI. if, fig. 3, upper view of a male specimen, 3a and 35, side and lower views of
head, 3c saoral region with a part of the tail j all figures in natural size.
Body and tail covered with small, equal, granular scales, those on the
snout being somewhat coarser ; 'tail depressed, rounded at the sides, contracted
at the base, indistinctly segmented ; numerous small scales behind the
rostral and the nostril ; 10 to 12 upper, and 9-10 lower labials ; two pairs
of chin-shields, the first large, separated above by the rostral, below forming
a suture, those of second pah- barely half the size, and each forming a suture
with the respective anterior chin-shields and the second labial ; there is usual-
ly a row of slightly enlarged scales along the lower labials, while those on
the throat are very minute, almost granular, and greatly contrasting with the
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
101
1872.]
larger scales on the abdomen ; ear opening rather small, rounded ; a moderate-
ly developed gland on each side in the place of the paratoids, generally
more distinctly seen above than below ; thumb small, well developed, with
a minute claw ; about 38 long, rows of scales across the middle of the belly,
extending somewhat on the sides ; 14-16 femoral pores in each series,
separated by a width of about 3 scales in the preanal region ; a row of
transversely enlarged shields along the middle of the lower side of the tail.
Grey or light brown, slightly mottled with dark brown and four
longitudinal series of blackish spots interrupted by white ones ; two of the
series originate on the superciliary region and two in continuation of a
blackish streak, originating at the lower half of the eye ; head above and labials
black spotted ; tail also with dark transverse spots above ; below uniform
white, with the shields of the belly generally very minutely punctated. The
brown series of spots are not in all specimens equally distinct, and some-
times they are almost obsolete. Specimens which have shrunk much in
spirit shew, like all other Geckos, a fold on the side of the body, and the tail
becomes also slightly angular at the sides.
Blyth’s original description of the coloration of this species is decidedly
better, than the supposed improved one by Theobald. The type specimen came
from Mergui ; Theobald found it common in Pegu ; I have received it from
the Khasi hills, and collected a great number of specimens about Pankabari,
just above the Sikkim Terrai, mostly on the outside walls of houses ; one
specimen was also sent to me by Mr. A. W. Lawder from Almorah, in
Kamaon.
The largest specimen from Pankabari measures 4J inches, of which
the body is 2g inch.
13. Hemedactylus [Doetttea] Mantjelltantts, n. sp. PI. iii, figs. 1 — 2.
PI. iii. fig. 1, upper view of a full grown specimen ; 2, 2 a, 2 b, 2 c, different} views
of the bead and sacral region of another specimen ; all figures in natural size.
Body and tail depressed, covered with numerous small rounded tuber-
cles, there being in old specimens generally a few larger ones perceptible at
the side of the body and on the sacral region ; snout elongate, depressed,
with the scales larger than on the body ; tail depressed, gradually tapering
to a point, moderately convex above, somewhat flattened below, indis-
tinctly segmented, laterally sharply keeled and serrated, the tubercles at the
end of each segment being white and more prominent than others. There
is a pair of somewhat enlarged shields behind the rostral, separated by- a
slightly smaller shield ; the nostril lies between the rostral, the 1st labial,
the supra-nasal and two moderately enlarged post-nasals ; 12 — 14 upper, and
10 12 lower labials, the last in each case, as usually, very small ; 2 pairs of
enlarged chin-shields, the first forms with the lower halves a suture below the
102
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
inferior rostral, the second is smaller, generally only half the size of the first,
each shield rounded, placed immediately below its respective first chin-sliield,
but separatedfrom the second lower labial by a smaller shield ; a row of slightly
enlarged shields adjoining the lower labials ; scales on the throat very small,
flattened, those on the belly much larger and roundly hexagonal, and in about
36 longitudinal, alternating series ; a median row of transversely enlarged sub-
caudals. The ear opening is moderate, rounded ; the glands in the place of the
paratoids very large, occupying abnost the whole of the side of the neck ; toes
elongate, united with a short web at the base, provided with rather coarse lamel-
lae, there being 9 or 10 pairs of them on the fourth toe ; nearly the first half
of the lamellae on all the toes is either undivided or only slightly grooved ;
thumb well developed, with a minute claw. Out of 10 specimens examined
of various sizes none had femoral pores, but the scales in the preanal region are
conspicuously enlarged in all.
Grey, more or less densely marbled and punctated with blackish brown
and spotted with pale white. Generally the brown colour is arranged in
6 or 8 longitudinal stripes, more distinctly regular in young than in old
specimens, and these stripes are separated by irregular, alternate rows of
white spots ; limbs, and tail at the base above, also white spotted, upper labials
brown ; paratoids yellowish brown ; lower side uniform white, most of the
scales very minutely punctated.
I Lab. I have obtained a few specimens at Pankabari, just above the Sik-
kim Terai, and Mr. Mandelli sent me several from the i tungnu and Tista val-
leys, where the species occurs between 1,000 and 3,000 feet. The body of the
largest measures 2\, tail 3, = 51 niches. As nearly half of the plates below
the toes are undivided, the species forms a connecting link between the section
Dory ura and those small species of Geckos which are represented by G.
Swinhoenis, and are mostly peculiar to Southern China, Japan and adjacent
islands.
14. Hem. [Doeyuea] Gatxdama, — from Tonghu in Burma.
Theobald, Joum. Linn. S., Zool. x, p. 30.
Unless authentic specimens are received, it will be difficult to identify
this species from Theobald’s description. It appears to be somewhat allied
to II. Mmdellianus, but the edges of the tail are said to be in the former
minutely “ denticulate with an obsolete marginal spine “ sides” of body
“ keeled” and “ femoral pores nineteen on each thigh,” &c. “ Grey with
no definite markings.” Body equal to tail.
15. Hem. [Doeyuea] Kabeitoeum, Theob. (ibidem), from Tonghu, Burma.
Back granular, regularly shagreened with about twenty longitudinal
rows of small whitish tubercles,” &c.
1872.]
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
103
Pehipta, Gray (I. R., p. 110.)
Peripia might, like Doryura, he considered as a subgenus of Hemidac-
tylus. It connects Doryura with Nycleridium , having the general form and
usually flattened pointed tail and small equal granular scales of the former,
while the toes are distinctly webbed at the base, and there is also a distinct
expansion of the skin at the hinder side of the femora and tibise. In Nycteri-
dium only the lateral expansion of the skin of the body is added to the
character of Peripia. If we characterize the later genus from the two Indian
species, P. Peronii and Cantoris, we cannot say that the thumb and inner
toe are without an ungual phalanx. I have examined very numerous
specimens of the former, and a few of the latter species, and I find that the
ungual phalanx on the thumb is very nearly, hut never entirely obsolete, it,
however, always appears to be clawless. On the inner toe the ungual phalanx
is extremely small, but in nearly all my fresh specimens I find there is a very
minute, thin, transparent, setiform claw present ; only in some old specimens
I have not been able to detect it.
P. Cantoris occurs in Penang, Burma, the Andamans and Nicobars ;
from all the localities I have examined specimens.
P. Peronii is very common on Penang,* and in the Wellesley Province,
rarer in Burma and on the Andamans. The type was from Mauritius, and ac-
cording to Kelaartf it is also found in Ceylon. Andamanese specimens agree
in their very distinct brown tinge with those from the two later islands, while
Penang specimens are brown, when young, but when adult usually greenish
ashy, rarely with a rosy tinge. Two adult fresh specimens from the Andamans
perfectly agree in structure with those from other places ; the general colour
above is pale chocolate brown with a rosy tinge, all over speckled with darker
brown and with numerous round white spots, about a m.m. in diameter ; below
white, pinkish towards the sides, and all scales minutely punctated.
1\T YCTEitl DTCM platttjbus, Schneider.
1792. SteUio platywms, Schneider, Spec. Physiol. Amph., li, p. 30, and Denk.
Acad. Miinchen for 1811, p. 62, pi. i, fig. 3.
1802. Lacerta Schneideriana, Shaw, Zool., Ill, 278.
1864. NycteridiurnX Sclmeklerianwm, apud Gunther, I. B-, p. Ill-
1870. N. Simalayanvm, Anderson, J. A. S. B., vol. xl, p. 15.
I have Asam, as well as Himalayan (from near Darjiling) specimens
for comparison, and they certainly belong to the same species. They also do
* Comp. Jonrn. A. S. B., vol. xxxix, p. 163.
f Prod. Faun. Zeyl. p. 187.
J Gray’s name Platywms certainly has the same derivation, as Platimis, and as it
has been at an early date replaced by Nyctmdium, it seems advisable not to revive the
former name, particularly as it would involve a change in the specific denomination,
and may besides lead to misunderstanding.
104
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
not differ in any essential point of structure from the description given by
Gunther, who has evidently seen specimens from various parts of the Malay
Archipelago, from Ceylon, and also from Asam and Bengal, considering them
all to be identical^ The same conclusion has been arrived at by Dum. and
Bibron in comparing Bengal and Javanese specimens. The Darjiling
specimen described by Anderson as N. Himalayanum must have had
accidentally a somewhat “ flatter and more rounded” snout, as in four speci-
mens from the same locality the outline exactly agrees with that of Dum.
and Bibron’s figure ; I also cannot trace any stronger webbing between the
fingers and toes, said to distinguish Him a layanum from platyurus. Darjil-
ing specimens agree admirably with Schneider’s original figure, (in which
only the head at its base is shewn too broad) ; the proportion and form of
the feet and their toes is exactly the same, the latter being contracted at
their bases, connected by a membrane* and provided with 5—7 transverse,
divided lamella;. Schneider says there are 56 large suhcaudals, and this is
exactly the number I count in a full-grown specimen, with the tail perfect,
and not reproduced. The femoral pores (16 — 20 on either side) are slightly
interrupted in the middle of the preanal region. The only difference consists
in the shortness of the first pair of chin-shields, but this cannot be more
than an individual distinction, if really correctly drawn. The glands which
are situated behind the ear, chiefly towards the lower surface of the head,
are quite as often absent as present. Out of four Darjiling specimens they
are very distinct in an old female, in one nearly full grown male they are
small, and in two somewhat younger specimens of opposite sexes they are not
at all developed. One of the principal distinctions of the specimen, named by
Dr. Anderson JSf. Himalayanum , might be sought in the presence of some
enlarged tubercles on the side of the body. A $ specimen from the Naga
hills (Asam) has no enlarged tubercles ; of the four Darjiling specimens
one full grown 5 , and one half grown 3 , each have a distinct row of slightly
enlarged tubercles at the side of the body, above the attachment of the
lateral dermal expansion. One nearly full grown <? has an enlarged tubercle
on one side and two on the other, just a little in front of the sacral
region ; the fourth specimen, a female, has the scales uniform granular. It
will be seen from these observations that no specific value can be attached
to the total absence, or occasional presence, of a few enlarged tubercles, as I
had already occasion to notice in different species of Hemidactylus.
What is, however, very marked in all Asamese and Himalayan speci-
mens, as compared with the usual descriptions of platyurus, is the large
amount of dark coloration they possess. The general colour is olive, with
a slight bluish cinereous tinge ; the whole upper surface is densely variegated
* Which is clearly shewn on the right hind foot between the 1st and 2nd and 2nd
and 3rd toes.
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
105
1872.]
and streaked with blackish brown, intermixed with some pale spots, particu-
larly on the limbs ; tail with dark brown and alternate irregular white spots.
Some specimens have a kind of indistinct transverse, dark bands, one on
neck, one on the sacral region and three on the back, they are separated
respectively from each other, as in Schneider’s figure, by three confluent
white spots, - placed in a triangle, with the point directed backwards ; the
three series of spots on the back are the most distinct. A whitish, or pale
orange, band rims through the eye, indistinctly continuing on the side of the
body ; it is margined below by a blackish band, most distinct and broadest
at the side of the head. Lower side of body and tail uniform whitish, the
scales very often finely punctated.
CvETODACTYUTS SUBEDITS, (Blytll).
Comp, Journ. A. S. B., vol. xxxix, p. 165.
This species occurs on the Andaman, as well as on the Nicobar, islands.
CrETODACTYBUS AITONIS, Stol.
Stoliczka in Journ. A. S. B., xxxix, p. 167, pi. x, fig. 1.
The young of this species is reddish brown with some darker brown
marks on the upper side of the body, and a series of rather large white
spots along the middle of the back. Penang.
GrMNODACTTLUS Lawdeeattus, n. sp.
PI. IX, fig. 4, side view of tlio animal, nat. size ; 4 a lower side of head and
4 b, Bacral region, both twice the natural size.
Body rather slender and elongate, depressed, covered above with numer-
ous small roundish tubercles, between which larger ones of a similar shape,
but of about double the size of the former, are intermixed. Upper side of
head equally granular, the granular scales being somewhat larger on the
snout. Rostral large, broad, reaching well on to the upper surface of the
snout ; it is followed by 5 small granular scales. The nostril is situated
somewhat laterally in the angle between the rostral, first upper labial, one
small scale above and another similar ono posteriorly. There are 9 upper, and 8
lower labials, the last three in each case very much smaller than the preceding
ones. The lower rostral is triangular, partially wedged in- between two
elongated chin-shields, forming a suture below it. Each of the chin-
shields is followed along the labials by 3 other somewhat rounded shields,
none of which are in contact. Opening of the ear small, rounded. Scales
on the chin small, equal, rounded; on the belly slightly elongated, and in
about 32 longitudinal scries across the middle ; on the tail, which, however,
appears to have been twice reproduced, the scales are also elongate, slightly
smaller above than below, but not transversely enlarged, and without any en-
larged spines at the sides. The fore limb reaches to the snout, and the hind limb
very nearly to the axil, when laid forward. The 3rd and 4th fingers and toes
14
106
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
respectively are perfectly equal, and close together. All the claws are well
developed, lying between enlarged scales, at the sides and above, but they
are not retractile. A few slightly enlarged scales above the anus, superseded
by two pairs of pores, close together, and forming an angle.
General colour above greyish brown, very densely marbled and spotted
with dark brown, with some indistinct, undulating, whitish cross bands on
the body, margined on the anterior edges with blackish brown ; a somewhat
indistinct dark band from the nostril through the eye to the ear ; front and
hind edges of the eye white ; labials spotted and speckled with brown ; below
whitish.
Length of body nearly two inches ; tail imperfect, only about one inch
long, slightly swollen at the base.
Sab. — The single specimen from which the above description is taken
was sent to me by Mr. W. A. Lawder, District Engineer of Kamaon ; it
was obtained in the neighbourhood of Almorah.
Cantor says, when speaking of Gymnod. pulchellus (Journ. Asiat. Soc.
Bengal, 1847, vol. xvi, p. 633) that there are two new Gymnodactyli preserved
in the Museum of the Asiatic Society, one marked P. lunatus, Blyth, based
upon one specimen from Midnapore and two from Chaibassa,* the other,
a nondescript species from Almorah, Gymnodactylus ncbulosus, Blyth, MSS.,
allied to Cyrtodactylus marmoratus, Gray. I am not acquainted with any
further notice as to the second species indicated, nor have I been able to find
the specimen itself among the Society’s collections ; it is also not mentioned
in Theobald’s Catalogue. Under these circumstances it is of course impos-
sible to accept the suggested name for the present species, particularly also as
Major Beddomo described already a quite distinct species from near Vizaga-
patam under the name G. ncbulosus (Madras Joum. Med. Sc., for 1870).
I may also at this opportunity mention that Beddome’s name G.
maculatus, published in the same Journal, must be replaced by another
one, there having been a G. maculatus described by Steindaehner already
in 1866 (Novara Kept. p. 16). A similar change is required with regard to
Beddome’s Gymn. marmoratus (M. J. M. Sc., 1870, p. 31), there having
been a species described under the same name by Dum. and Bibron already
in 1836 (Herp. Gen., Ill, p. 426).
Fain. A G AMID A3.
Japax/TTba vaeiegata, Gray.
Gunther, Kept, of India, p. 133.
Anderson, Proo. Zool. Soc. Lond,, 1871, p. 164.
This species has the power of greatly changing its colour. In some speci-
mens (irrespective of sex) the irridescent green bands, in others the metallic or
* Those are to all appearance the two Eubleph, Hardwiclcii, mentioned by Theo-
bald on p. 33 of Cat. ltept. Asiat. Soc. Mus.
p, Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
107
1872.]
reddish brown ones, are prevalent, the green is during lifemuch mixed with yel-
low or white, and the width of the bands and spots themselves is very variable
during life ; a bluish tinge is often seen on the neck and on the sides of the
body of male specimens. The end of the gular sac in the male is deep blue, (not
black). The male also has the lower labials generally bluish brown, the
upper often bright yellowish white, sometimes, however, both are reddish or
pale brown. Numerous brown streaks radiate from the eye, one of these
directed towards the tympanoid region is about twice as broad as any of the
others ; sometimes it is divided by a median lino in two, but very rarely it is
indistinct. In the females the contrasts between the eohvurs is always less,
they very often have uniform greenish and pale reddish tints prevalent. The
larger scales occasionally form a distinct row on each side ol the back, which
thus becomes apparently tricarinate, as in the form noticed by Jerdon under
the specific name microlepis. (See Proc. Asiat. Soc., Peb. 1870, P' 70).
Very common in Sikkim from elevations of 1,000 up to 9,000 feet.
It is, strictly speaking, a ground lizard, hunting between stones and low
bushes, but also takes refuge on a tree. It appears to be more common on
higher than on lower elevations, but those living between 9,000 and 5,000
seem to reach the largest size.
I was somewhat surprised in reading Dr. Anderson’s results (loc. cit.)
of the examination of 21 specimens “ of all ages and both sexes, from one
locality,” that is, the neighbourhood of Darjiling. Dr. Anderson arrived
at the conclusion that Jordon’s microlepis is the female, and Jerdon s plani-
dorsata the young of variegata. Now as I have* not only observed hundreds
of living specimens of Japalura variegata in Sikkim, hut have also collected
and examined them, I may be allowed to say a few words on this subject.
I find 1st, that the males of variegata often are smaller than the
females, or at any rate that the latter generally grow to a larger size than
the former ; 2nd, that the males have the enlarged scales on the back and
particularly the spiny ones on the sides of the occiput comparatively larger
and more numerous than the females, the difference being most marked in
full grown specimens and in the breeding season, but I have collected male and
female specimens in which the scales were nearly equally laigely developed,
and there is no apparent difference in the size of the smaller scales between
the two sexes ; 3rd, that the nuchal and dorsal crest in the male is,
especially on the neck, comparatively higher than in the female, and that
it generally is on either side accompanied by a series of somewhat enlarged,
closely set scales, more conspicuous in smaller than in laiger specimens, but
they are not equally distinct in the female ; 4i th, that the colours in
both sexes are similar and equally variable, but always brighter and more
variegated in the male, particularly the green and yellow ; 5 th, that in young
* And so undoubtedly had Dr. Jerdon.
108
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
male and female specimens of variegata, the bodies of which vary between
one and a half, and two inches in length, there is a similar, simple, continu-
ous nuchal and dorsal crest present, as in the adults, with the usual respective
difference in size noted as regards the two sexes.
These observations, on undoubted J. mriegata “ of all ages and both
sexes,” do not exactly agree with those recorded by Dr. Anderson. They
do not exclude the possibility that J. mierolepis might have been suggested for
a specimen of variegata with accidentally somewhat smaller scales, but as I
do not remember having seen Jerdon’s type specimen, and at the same
time I know, how very often Dr. Jcrdon must have seen J. variegata in all its
stages, I would defer the identification for the present. As regards planidorsata
I have no hesitation in saying that Dr. Anderson is mistaken. I well re-
member Jerdon’s two type specimens ; they did not appear to be very young
and were in beautiful preservation. Among the great number of specimens
of variegata in the Indian Museum, which Dr. Anderson had been good
enough to shew me, I could find none which would correspond with Jerdon’s
briefly indicated distinctive characters of planidorsata.
SlT AN A PONTICEEIANA,* CuV.
iS itrna minor, Gunther, I. R., p, 135.
The smaller form described by Gunther as Sit. minor, and noticed by
Blanford in Journ. A. S. B., xxxix, Pt. II, p. 365, also occurs in Western
Bengal at the Parisnath hill, and on the Sone river in Bihar, extending
northwards through the North-West Provinces as far as Rurki, near the
base of the Himalayas, westwards into the Panjab, Kattiawar and Katch, but
it is not known from any part of Bengal East of the Ganges.
Colour : pale or darker brown above and at the sides, a dark band be-
tween the eyes ; snout and occiput irregularly spotted and variegated with paler
brown ; 5 or 6 quadrangular spots on the back, followed by a few smaller ones
on the tail ; a pale yellowish line along the centre of back is generally present,
and the edges of the back are also pale ; a yellowish band on each side from
below the eye through the ear to the groin, in full grown specimens only well
marked at the sides of the neck. All these pale or yellowish bands, as well
as some of the large scales at the side, and particularly the front side and the
hind base of the femora, and the transverse pale bands on the limbs, have a
very marked fleshy or rosy tinge, most distinct in full grown males. The
pouch is tinged with blue and red in the males only during the breeding
season, at other times it is slightly blue, but a blue line always continues from
it along the chin to the lower rostral. The labials are often blackish.
Below, yellowish white.
* Dr. Anderson informs mo that he believes this form to be specifically distinct
from true Ponticeriana, differing from the latter by the intermixed larger scales &o.
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
109
1872.]
The enlarged scales on the hack, and especially at the sides of the body,
are invariably well marked, but less numerous in female than in male speci-
mens ; they are during life yellow or golden, and during the breeding season
often tinged rosy, or even vermilion. In Northern India the species does not
appear to attain the size which it does in Central India, for none of the
specimens from the former country are above 5) inches, the tail being generally
more than twice the length of the body. The claws on fingers and toes are
always black. The tympanum is usually covered by a yellowish hardened
shield.
Jerdon (Proc. Asiat. Soc. Beng., Feb. 1870, p. 76) is, I think, correct
in retaining the name Ponticeriana, for the smaller Sitana with long limbs,
but I doubt that the larger form, for which he proposes the name Deccanen-
sis, is really specifically distinct from Ponticeriana. I collected hundreds of
them, in all sizes from 3 to 8 inches ; they are all of the same type, as those
I received from Ceylon and from South India, and I find the fore limb
scarcely ever reaches the vent, while the hind-limb extends usually beyond
the snout, except in a few full grown specimens.
Chaeasia, Oeiocalotes and Oeiotiaeis.
The name Charasia has been proposed by Gray (Lizards Brit. Mus.,
1845, p. 246) for the South Indian species, Ch. dorsalis, as type. I have
examined numerous well preserved specimens of this and of another species
inhabiting the greater portion of Central, and perhaps also of Northern,
India, and this induces me to propose a somewhat different definition of the
genus. t .
Char. Body elongate, somewhat depressed, covered with imbricate,
or subimbricate, keeled scales, between which some slightly larger ones are
intermixed, the scales being arranged in more or less indistinct transverse
series ; those on the lower side are often less distinctly keeled than those
on the back ; tympanum naked ; a small tubercular spine at the posterior
end of the supraciliary edge ; some spines above the tympanum ; nuchal
and dorsal crest present, but low ; (generally) a fold across the throat ; scales
on the tail subimbricate, not arranged in regular cross series ; (no distinct
gular sac, no femoral, or preanal pores) .
Charasia must bo classed next to Trapelus, to which it is very nearly allied.
Sab.— Terrestrial, generally found between blocks of gneissose rocks.
The distinctive points in the structure of Charasia are 1st, the
presence of a small tubercular spine on the hinder supraciliary edge ; 2nd,
the presence of some slightly larger scales intermixed between the smaller
ones at the side of the body. It is true that these larger scales are very
difficult to trace in Ch. dorsalis, but I have observed them in various young
and old specimens. Were it not that they are, as a rule, better developed
110
F. Stoliczlca — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 1,
in the allied new species, presently to be described, I would attach hardly any
significance to these enlarged scales, but the variability of this character will
be important in a comparison with other allied genera ; 3rd, the ventral scales
are in young specimens of Cli. dorsalis distinctly keeled, and even in old ones
the keels are generally traceable on the breast and in front of the anus. A
peculiar character of the type species, Ch. dorsalis, consists in the very
small scales of the body, but this character loses its value by the other
species, Ch. Blanfordana, having all the scales comparatively much larger.
If, after this brief explanation, we compare with the above noted
characteristics of Charasia those of Oriocalotes, as recorded by Gunther, (I.
K., p. 146), we find that there is no essential distinction between the two.
According to the description of the species, the body of Oriocalotes minor
would seem to be less depressed, and there is besides a shoulderfold noticed,
but I doubt that these characters can be looked upon as generic differences ;
they are certainly not regarded as such in the genus Calotes. The type
species described by Gunther, O. minor, is from Sikkim, but I have unfortu-
nately never met with it. The only other species, O. major, noted by
Jerdon from the Sutlej valley, (Proc. Asiat. Soc., Bong. 1870, p. 77) I con-
sider intermediate between O. minor and Cliarasia Llanfordana.
There also appears to be very little difference between Charasia and
Acanthosaura, and I think it doubtful that the species of the latter are
arboreal in their habits ; however, I have never observed them alive.
A third form is Gunther’s Oriotiaris (I. R., p. 150). The only known
species, O. tricarinata, was often observed by me in Sikkim ; it is like Chara-
sia a ground lizard. The sole important difference from the latter genus, and
the so-called Oriocalotes, consists in the absence of a shoulder or gular fold,
a character which I do not consider to possess generic value. I believe,
therefore, that Charasia, Oriocalotes, and most probably also Oriotiaris
should form only one genus, to which Acanthosaura is very closely allied, if
at all distinct. The three former are certainly ground lizards, as are also
Japalura, Agama, Stellio, while Calotes is often not much more arboreal than
terrestrial, Bronchocele is chiefly, and Haris entirely, arboreal.
Charasia Bbaufobdana, n. sp.
Charasia dorsalis, Gray, apud Blanford, Jonrn. Asiat. Soc. B., 1870, vol. xxxix, p. 368.
PI. Ill, fig. 5 and 5a. Upper and side views of the head, natural size.
Head elongately ovate, or subtrigonal, considerably shorter and blunter
in young than in old specimens, with the paratoids very much swollen in the
adult male. Head covered with small, subequal, carinated scales, those at the
sharp edge of the canthus rostralis and above the eyes somewhat larger than
others. Nasal shield large, swollen, single, the opening directed laterally
upwards ; a minute spine, or a tubercle, at the posterior end of the superciliary
edge ; two spines above the tympanum, one situated on the occiput and the
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
Ill
1872.]
otlier somewhat posterior, but close to the tympanal edge. In size the
tympanum very nearly equals the eye. A longitudinal series of about 7 or 8
enlarged scales below the eye. There are generally 10 or 11 flat upper, and
12 or 13, somewhat more convex, lower labials, both squarish, except the last
which are much elongated. Lower rostral posteriorly much elongated, fol-
lowed on each side by a row of 4 — 6 enlarged scales, separated by smaller
ones from the lower labials.
All the scales of the head, body and tail above and below are imbricate,
being arranged in somewhat indistinct cross series, and all are keeled. In
young specimens the keels below are very distinct, in older ones they
often become less marked, but except in the middle of the belly never entire-
ly obsolete. At the sides' the scales are intermixed with a few slightly larger
ones, the latter being in younger specimens generally easily seen, but in
adults they are more difficult to trace. There are SO — 100 longitudinal rows
of scales round the middle of the body. The scales on the tail are larger
than those of the body, and again those along the upper median line exceed
the adjoining somewhat in size. A distinct, though low, nuchal and dorsal
crest is present in both sexes, disappearing on the tail ; it is more developed
in the male than in the female.
The fore leg reaches to the groin when laid backward. The hind leg
generally reaches to the front edge of the eye, when laid foreward ; in some
few very old specimens it only reaches to the posterior edge.
Young specimens are olive brown above, marbled and spotted with dark
brown, with two dark cross bands on the upper snout, and one connecting
the middle of the supraeiliary edges. Along the middle of the back there
are usually some enlarged, lozenge-shaped, brown spots. The sides are
speckled with white, orange or red, this colour being generally confined to
the enlarged scales. A brown band proceeds from the eye to the shoulder,
margined below by a more or less distinct white band. Ihe tail is encircled
with brown and alternate whitish bands, generally interrupted on the lower
side which is uniform dingy white. Full grown females retain the same
colouration as the young, except that the series of lozenge-shaped spots on the
back is more distinct, but males vary enormously in colour, exactly as in
Charasia dorsalis. The lateral black streak on the neck is always distinct,
but the entire head and anterior part of the body above and below become
brilliant scarlet, or more often zinnabar red, while the posterior part is nearly
entirely black ; all the colours, however, change very rapidly after death.
The largest specimen measures 12 inches, of which the body is very
nearly 4 inches.
Although closely allied to the South Indian Cliarasia dorsalis, the
present form is fairly separable by its comparatively longer limbs, larger, more
distinctly imbricated and stronger keeled scales, which are present round the
112 P. Stoliczka — On Indian lizards. [No. 1,
middle of the body in a considerably smaller number, there being 130-140
series of squarish scales in Charasia dorsalis, while there are only 80-100
sub-imbricate ones in Blanfordana. Also, the nuchal crest is much better
developed in the latter than in the former species.
Oh. Blanfordana is given by Mr. Blanford from a large number of
localities in Central India. I found it not uncommon on the gneissose rocks
composing the Parisnath hill, in Western Bengal ; it is a true rock lizard, as
noted by Mr. Blanford, who describes (loc. cit.) its habits at some length.
It is also very likely the species noticed by Blyth on one or two
occasions from Birbhum, and also, I think, from the Panjab, under the name
of Oh. dorsalis. Anderson in Proc. Zool. Soc. Loud., 1871, p. 168, repeated
Blanford’s incorrect identification of the present species, without, however,
acknowledging the source he took it from.
CiLutASTA ( Oriotiaris ) ttctcahtxata, Blyth.
This species was originally described by Blyth as Calotes tricarinatus
(J. A. S. B., xxxi, p. 650), and afterwards by Gunther as Tiaris JElliotti,
subsequently made the type of a distinct genus under the name Oriotiaris ;
(Kept, of India, p. 150, and Jerdon in Proc. A. S. B., Peb. 1870, p. 77, and
Anderson, in Proc. Zool. Soc., 1871, p. 167.
I have already noted the great similarity of the generic characters of
this species to typical Charasia.
Blyth’s name ‘ tricarinatus' refers to the presence of three keels
on the anterior part of the body, there being besides the median
crest a row of larger scales on each side of it, disappearing towards
the middle of the body, but becoming again better traceable on the
femoral region. The large spiny tubercles above the tympanum are
always multicarinate on the upper 3ide, and often bluish during life. The
colour of the live lizard is generally bright grass green above, with the
angular series of larger scales (directed backwards) often chocolate brown ;
the lateral keels on the neck are yellowish, sometimes margined with a
dark line below. The sides of the body are either entirely green, with only
two brown streaks above and below from the eye, or the sides of the head,
tympanoid region, neck and anterior part of belly, are deep chocolate brown.
There are, however, always some light yellow or whitish spots on the labials,
and generally a yellowish streak at the base of the neck on each side. Lower
side yellowish white. In spirit the green colours gradually change to more
or less distinct brown.
As noticed by Jerdon, the species is by no means common about
Darjiling ; I found it between 3000 and 8000 feet, generally about large
stones in sunny places on the scarp of the road. The largest specimen
does not exceed 7 inches.
1872.]
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
113
Cat.otes Elliotti, Gunther.
Gunther I. It., p. 142. — Jerdon, J. A. S. B., xxii, p. 471, and Proc
A. S. B. for 1870, p. 77.
I collected this species at Matheran,* near Bombay. It is quite distinct
from Rouxii. The shoulder-fold is bluish black. It seems to he quite as much
terrestrial, as arboreal in its habit. The small scales of the body (about 56
round the middle of it) , and the little spine behind each superciliary edge
strongly recall Oharasia. Some of the scales at the side of the body are
yellow, but they are not apparently larger than others. Colour — pale brown,
bright red on the head and about the shoulders, rest of upper side with indis-
tinct dark stripes ; lips and the knees dark ; claws above black ; throat reddish,
tinged with bluish ; rest of under-side white. The fore limb reaches to the
groin, when laid backward, and the hind limb to the anterior edge of the eye,
when laid forward.
In one specimen the head and body are ,2i) and the tail 5|, = 8 inches.
Steleiq, Daudin (I. B., p. 157).
Four species of this genus can be distinguished in India, all appear to
inhabit the Himalayas, or the country close to the base of the hills.
1. St. Dayanas, n. sp. Scales of the back moderate, smaller but conti-
nuous on the neck ; enlarged scales at the side numerous. Hardwar.
2. St. tuberculatus, Gray. Scales of the back small, very much smaller
or granular on neck ; enlarged scales at the sides scattered, generally few, or
nearly all obsolete. Southern slopes of the Himalayas.
3. St. melanurus, Blyth (comp. Proc. A. S. B., Sept. 1871, p. 189).
Enlarged scales of the back unequal, those composing a few median rows
considerably larger than others on either side. Panjab and Kashmir.
4. St. Himalayanus, Steindachner, (Novara Bept., Pt. I, 1S67, p. 22).
Enlarged scales of the hack smooth ; Ladak, Northern Indus valley.
I shall note in greater detail the two first mentioned species, as they
are closely allied to each other, while the two remaining are so entirely dis-
tinct that there can be no mistake about them.
Stellio Dayantts, n. sp.
PI. Ill, fig. 4. "Upper view of the anterior part of tlie body.
Head depressed, covered with small sharply keeled shields, irregular
in form, slightly larger on the canthus rostralis and becoming gradually im-
bricate on the hind occiput ; nostril in the hinder part of an elongate swollen
shield, narrow in front, but usually separated from the rostral, as well as from
the first labial, by a separate shield ; a ridge of somewhat larger scales origi-
* Giinther refers, I suppose, to the present species when noticing C. Rouxi from
Matheran (Proc. Zool. Soc., 1869, p. 501).
15
114 F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. [No. 1,
nates a short distance behind the nostril, and passes below the eye in a slight
ascending curve to the upper edge of the tympanum ; 10 — 12 upper and as
many lower labials ; a short ridge of spiny scales is in continuation of the
upper labials directed towards the lower edge of the tympanum, but separat-
ed from it by a tubercular group of spines ; tympanum slightly smaller
than the eye, with a group of spines in front of it ; numerous groups or
irregular short ridges of enlarged spiny scales at the side of the neck, the
skin on it being rather loose. Lower rostral sharply pointed behind ; first
pair of chinshields large and nearly touching below the rostral ; one or two
rows of enlarged scales follows on either side along the labials, separated
from them by one or two rows of smaller scales. The throat fold extends
laterally in front of the shoulder, where only a small naked pit of soft skin
exists. Enlarged dorsal scales moderate, sharply keeled, in about 13
longitudinal series in the centre of the back ; they are considerably smaller,
but distinctly continuous on the neck and up to the occiput ; nuchal crest
small, composed of separate, sharply keeled, compressed scales ; numerous
enlarged, almost spiny, scales at the side of the body interspersed between
the smaller ones ; scales on the upper side of the limbs larger than those
of the body ; on chin small, subtubercular, very sharply keeled ; on breast
and belly indistinctly keeled or nearly smooth, often with a patch of enlarg-
ed, hardened, scales in the centre of the belly, where they are arranged in
about 40 longitunal series. Each thickened scale in the preanal patch is
soft or spongy in the middle, and evidently secretes a similar fluid, as do
the preanal and femoral pores of other lizards. Scales on the tail irregular at
the base, but farther on arranged in verticils ; their size is equal to those on
the upper side of the feet.
The fore-limb when laid backward fully reaches the groin, but more
often extends a little further on the sacral region, the fourth finger is a
trifle longer than the third ; the hind leg, when laid forward, sometimes
reaches the snout, but usually only the front edge of the eye ; the fourth
toe is longer than the third by its claw.
General colour, in young, above and at the sides pale olive, variegated and
spotted with black and yellowish white; throat reticulated with dusky
blackish ; rest of lower side white. Adults are throughout brownish or
blackish, or with some indistinct darker spots along the back ; head uniform,
much paler ; body above all over densely spotted with yellow, throughout
reticulated with bluish, and there is, in adult male specimens always, some
blue tinged with red, on the chest, on the sides of the head, neck, and
of the belly, most strongly marked in the breeding season ; sometimes the
entire throat is purplish blue ; lower side of body and of tail yellowish white ;
terminal two-thirds of tail blackish.
Ilab. — I have received some 40 specimens from Dr. Day, who collect-
1872.] F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. 115
ed them at Hardwar, where the Ganges leaves the hills for the plains.
They measure from 4 to 18 inches, in all stages of growth, the tail when
perfect is fully \ of the total length. I find that in former years I also
obtained this species at Misoun, and on the road from K alka to Simla, hav-
ing noticed the difference of the scales on the neck and back, as compared
with those of the next species, but unfortunately I have no specimens by
me now.
Stellio tuberculatum, (Gray), (I. R-, p- !•”)•
PI. Ill, fig. 3. Upper view of the anterior part of the body.
This well known species is readily distinguished from the last by the
much smaller size of the enlarged scales on the hack, which are in from 13 to 17
longitudinal series in the middle of it ; on the middle of the neck the scales
are not at all enlarged, but there is a low, often minute, nuchal crest present.
The structure of the head-shields is in both species very similar, but they
are always less distinctly keeled in St. tuber culatus, sometimes nearly, and
above the eye3 always, smooth ; the enlarged row of scales below the eye
is well marked ; the nasal sometimes touches the rostral and first labial, but
more generally it is separated from them by smaller shields ; the enlarged
spiny scales on the side of the neck are less prominent in this, than in the
former species ; the scales of the belly are proportionately smaller, in 48—54
transverse series ; the enlarged scales at the sides are generally few, occasion-
ally arranged in transverse rows, but sometimes they are nearly entirely absent ;
rarely, in male specimens, are these spines nearly as numerous and irregularly
distributed, as in the former species. The patch of enlarged callous scales on
the middle of the belly is much more often present, than in Dayanus. The fore-
limb, when laid backward, generally does not reach the groin, but occasionally
it does so ; the hind-limb, when laid forward, usually reaches the tympanum,
sometimes the eye, rarely the front edge of the eye, but I have not seen one
specimen in which it extends to the rostral shield. I he largest specimen I
measured is 13 j inches, of which the body is very nearly 5, and the tail 85-
inches. On the whole, both the limbs and the tail are somewhat shorter in
the present species than in the former.
There is also a difference in coloration. Toung and adult specimens
are above on body and limbs of a dark olive brown or almost blackish colour,
with numerous darker spots in the young, indistinct in the adult, and inter-
mixed with yellowish spots, these being fewer, but often larger than in Daya-
nus ; occasionally they are entirely absent. The head in the adult is above
cinereous olive, spotted black and yellowish at the side ; in front of the shoulder,
on the breast, and also at the sides of the body, there are often numerous
bright yellow or orange spots present. Lower side uniform dull white in young,
generally spotted with dusky on the throat. In adults the throat becomes
116 F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. [No. 1,
more or less spotted and tinged with reddish blue, extending partially on the
chest, and in adult males the whole of the under side, including the lower side
of the limbs, is bluish black, brightest aud strongly tinged with purple on the
throat, the same tinge extending on the neck, the shoulders and sides of the
belly. An adult male is really a gorgeously coloured lizard. The usual
habitat is between large rocks on bare or opeu slopes of hills.
Sab. — I have received numerous specimens of this species from Karnaon
(near Almorah) through Mr. A. W. Lawder ; from Kangra and Dalhousie
through Dr. Day, and from Mari through Mr. A. B. Wynne. About
Simla; in Kulu, all through Chamba, Kishtw.ir and in Kashmir, I have in
former years collected this species largely, it ranges up to 12,000 feet,
and if the Spiti form is the same species, I have observed it up to nearly
14,000 feet.
There can be no doubt about Blyth’s St. indicus being the same as tuber -
culatus , but whether the sjiecies really occurs in the plains near Mirzapur
and Wuzirabad, I have not as yet been able to ascertain.
Tiatus scbcristata, Blyth.
In addition to my description of this Andaman and Nicobar lizard in
J. A. S. B., vol. xxxix, p. 180, 1 have to note the following. — The number of
scales round the body varies between 90 and a little above 100, 18-22 scales
being on the ventral side. The two groups of enlarged, or rather often only
more pointed, scales on the upper side of the occiput usually exist only in old
males. The subcaudals are slightly larger than the scales above and at the
sides of the tail, the latter being more distinctly imbricate. The fore-limb
when laid backward occasionally reaches as far as the anus, and the hind-
limb when laid forward exceeds the tip of snout by one-third the length of
the fourth toe.
As regards coloration I may add, that there is occasionally a distinct
yellowish band present, extending from the occiput along each side of the
middle of the back, on the lower side margined blackish. The two yellow
bands form an outward angle opposite each femur and then unite into one, a
short distance beyond the base of the tail, and are accompanied on either
side by a series of large blackish spots. Extremities spotted or indistinctly
barred with brown and yellowish white.
(To be continued.)
JOURNAL
OF THE
ASIATIC SOCIETY.
Part II.— PHYSICAL SCIENCE.
No. II.— 1872.
Notes on vabious new oe little known Indian Lizaeds, —
by Dk. F. Stoliczka.
[Continued from p. 116.]
Fain, SCIATCTDsE.
Genus. Eupeepes, Wagler, (as rest, by Gunther).
Eupeepes [Tiliqua] maculabius, Blyth.
PI. Y, fig. 1, upper view of tlie anterior part of the body ; la, side view of the
head ; natural size.
See Blanford in Journ. Asiat. Soo. Bengal, 1870, xxxix, pt. II, p. 3o8, and Anderson
in Proo. Zool. Soc. Loud., 1871, p. 157.
This species is readily distinguished from F. cariruxtus by proportionately
shorter and stouter limbs, and by a somewhat shorter head. As a rule the
scales are in full grown specimens seven-carinate, the middle earina being
separated from the adjoining by a somewhat deeper and wider sulcus, than
exists between the other ridges. In Sub-Himalayan specimens this is
particularly well marked.
Blanford reported the occurrence of the species in various parts of
Central India. The Indian Museum received specimens from Cachar and
Asam, reported upon by Dr. Anderson. I obtained some on the Parisnath hill,
exactly identical in the small size and uniform coloration with those noted
by Blanford. There are only a few whitish spots at the side of the neck and
the dusky colour of the sides of the belly gradually passes below into the
white one. Specimens sent by Dr. Day from the Sone river in Birbhum
10
118
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
have no dark spots on the back, but numerous white spots at the side of the
belly. The stripes at the side of the tail are in Central Indian specimens,
and in those from W. Bengal, and also from northwards near Hardwar, very
thin and often rather indistinct. Young specimens have 5, old ones 7 keels on
each scale. Sikkim specimens from the Rungnu valley, (one of which attains the
large size of 6# inches, of which tail is 3f, and has 30 longitudinal and about
28 transverse rows of scales between the fore and hind-limb), generally have
two or four rows of brown spots along the back, the spots becoming some-
what irregular and more prolonged on the posterior body ; sides with
blackish and more or less numerous white spots, the black spots inclining to
form longitudinal series ; sides of the tail very distinctly streaked with brown
and white, but when the terminal half, or third, of the tail is renewed, it is
uniform. In Sikkim I only saw the species in the lower valleys, up to about
3,000 feet, but generally at lower elevations, and by no means common.
Asamese specimens do not differ in any particular from the Sikkim ones, and
similarly coloured varieties were also collected by Dr. Day at Rurlri, only
the specimens are smaller, and the white spots at the side of the body fewer,
and somewhat indistinct.
The species also occurs in the neighbourhood of Calcutta, where I
obtained three specimens during the last winter (1860 to 1871). Each of these
has on the back two distant, almost continuous rows of brownish black spots,
and the brown colour between these rows is darker than that between them
and the respective edges of the back. On the hind part of the body, the spots
become broken up and finally disappear. The sides are either distinctly
spotted, with white as in Darjiling specimens, or they are more uniform
dusky ; the tail is on the anterior half always longitudinally streaked with
brown, intermixed with white. The lower side is uniform whitish, with the
edge between each two scales slightly darker, forming the longitudinal “ obscure
dark striae,” to which Jerdon alluded in his note J. A. S. B. xxii, p. 479.
Some of the specimens obtained at Pankabari, on the northern edge of the
Sikim Terrai, agree in coloration with those from Calcutta, having the middle
back darker brown than the sides of it, while others again have as many as
eight longitudinal, more or less continuous, black bands along the back.
Pegu specimens do not differ from those from Asam and Darjiling,
and I suspect that Theobald’s Burmese species, identified by him with
Kuhl’s E. multicarinatus from the Philippines, is the same as Blyth’s
macwlarius, but the two are by no means identical, as suggested by Theo-
bald, (Joum. Linn. Soe. Zool. x, p. 26). In comparing specimens from
various localities, it struck me that the hill forms generally have stouter
legs and shorter toes than specimens found in low country.
E. macularim appears, at least partially, to replace E. carinatus in Cen-
tral India, but not apparently in South India ; it is, however, in all the locali-
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
119
1872.]
ties East of tlie Hooghly much rarer, than the latter species. There are
evidently two distinct races : a smaller and almost uniform coloured va-
riety, occurring all through the Central Provinces and extending northwards
to the haso of the hills at Hardwar, and westward probably into southern
Panjab ; and a larger, and generally striped, variety, occurring eastwards
all through Bengal, As&m and extending into Pegu.
Beddome (Madras Journ. Med. Sc. for 1871) appears to question
the distinctness of macularius from carinatus ( = rufescens), but there can,
I believe, be no doubt on that point. Whether his 5-keeled specimens are
carinatus , and the 7-keeled ones true macularius, must be decided on a re-exa-
mination of his specimens. Both species often occur together.
Ettpbepes [Tjxiqua] CAMNATirs, Schneider.
Colour above brown or olive brown, with or without dark edgings to
the scales, a pale band on the edges of the back ; upper half of sides blackish
with or without white spots, lower half pale, a short pale streak from ear to
shoulder ; below whitish, tinged with orange or red in males during breeding
season, particularly at the sides of the belly. This is the usual colouration
in specimens from Bengal, Central Provinces, Dakhin (at Puna) and Bombay.
(Comp. Gunther, L 1!., p. 79 and Blanford, J. A. S. B., 1870, xxxix, pt. ii,
p. 356). Specimens from Burma and the Malayan Archipelago are very
similarly coloured (see J. A. S. B., xxxix, pt. ii, p. 169). Bengal specimens,
of which I examined a very large number, have quite as often 5 as 3 keels
on the scales, those from the Dakhin (Dekhan) and Bombay are mostly only
tliree-keeled. As a rule there are 32 longitudinal rows of scales round the
middle of the body in full grown specimens, in younger ones often 30, very
rarely only 28.
Eupeepes [Tiliqua] TEivm'ATL's, Gray.
Gray, Ind. Zool.-Jerdon, J. A. S. B„ xxii, p. 478,-Theobald, Cat. Kept. Asiat.
S. B , p. 24. — Blanford, J. A. S. B., xxxix, pt. ii, p 357. — Anderson, Proc. Z. S., 1871,
p. 158.
This is undoubtedly a species distinct from Tiliqua carinata, and in part
combining the characters of the latter, and of T. monticola which it con-
siderably resembles in coloration. I received two specimens from Puna (in the
Dakhin, =Dekhan) through my collector. They are both young, only 4 ‘ inches
long, but when compared with equally large specimens of carinata, the head
is, as stated by Jerdon, shorter and somewhat higher, the rostral is flattened
above, the supranasals form a distinct suture, frontals proportionately smaller,
(the anterior in one specimen obliquely divided in two shields), posterior
frontals form a suture, the vertical is longer and posteriorly narrower, than in
any specimens of T. carinata I saw. The other shields of the head do not dif-
fer. Edge of ear in front with 3 or 4 small, pointed, subequal lobules. Scales
120
E. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
round the middle of tho body in 30 longitudinal series, and in 40-42* trans-
verse series between fore and liind-limb ; each scale with 3+ median well
defined keels, two others at the sides being only occasionally indicated.
Colour, above, olive brown, with three narrow, equidistant, greenish white
bands, margined with blackish brown, and with one on each side of the body,
passing through the ear ; all five bands continue on the tail, but are less dis-
tinct ; shields of head margined with dark ; edge of eyelids yellow ; feet
above brown. Below, uniform yellowish white, tinged with fleshy posteriorly.
The head and body together are proportionately shorter than in the
preceding species :
Eupeems monticola, (I. I!., p. 80).
This species has been found by Mr. Wood-Mason at Sahibgunj on the
Ganges, and I obtained it also at Jabbalpur in the Central Provinces ; in both
cases in the plains. The specimens exactly agree in structure with Giinther’s
figure and description, but there usually is on each scale (particularly towards
the edges of the back) a third median keel, between the two more distinct ones,
traceable. Scales in 35 or 36 longitudinal series round the middle of the
body, and in 34-40 transverse ones between the limbs. The lower eyelid has
a distinct transparent simple disc, a character not noticed by Gunther.
Colour, above and on the upper half of the sides greenish brown, with
numerous black spots, sometimes inclined to arrange themselves in transverse
series, a yellowish white band on each side and in the middle of the back,
about one scale broad, but generally running along the sutures of two rows ;
sides greenish, spotted with pure white, their lower halves more or less tinged
with black and white, and sometimes with an indistinct white band between
the limbs, appearing better marked at the side of the tail ; a yellowish black-
edged streak below the eye, continued to near the ear, the frontal denticula-
tions of which are yellow ; edges of eyelids bright yellow. Below, uniform
yellowish white.
I very much doubt that this is an inhabitant of the highlands of Sikkim,
and Sehlagintweit’s specimens were most likely obtained in a low valley of
that province, at 1000 or 2000 feet elevation, but not at 8000 feet, though
probably preserved and ticketed in a comfortable station at that height ; or
* 49 rows in adult, loc. cifc.
t 5 keels are recorded in an adult, loc. cit.
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
121
1872.]
else those gentlemen’s barometers must have been, as usually in similar cases,
out of order.
What Theobald quotes as Tiliqua monticola in Cat. Kept. Asiat. Soe.
Mus., p. 24, is not this species, but to all appearance Euprepes olivaceus ;
there are three very slight keels on the dorsal scales, 30 longitudinal series
round the body, and about 34 between fore and hind-limb ; anterior frontal
in contact with rostral, but separated from vertical by a short suture of the
posterior frontals. Uniform olivaceous above, paler below.
Exjmeoes, Pi.estiodox, Htnulia, Eistekla and allied genera.
I adopt the name ELmulia as originally proposed by Gray.
The name Eumeces cannot any longer be retained for the species which
are referred to it in Gunther’s 1 Reptiles of Brit. India’. Already in J. A. S.
B., vol. xxxix, p. 174, I have drawn attention to Dr. Peters’ observation, that
Wiegmann’s name Eumeces had been proposed for GeoSroy’s Scincus pavimen-
tatus - Sc. auratus, Sehneid.,— Scincus Schneideri, Geoff., = Plestiodon Al-
drovandi, Dum. and Bib. &c. Therefore, Plestiodon is to be considered as
identical with Eumeces, which is the oldest name. The only as yet known
representative, we have of this restricted type of Lizards in India, is Blyth’s
Eurylepis from the Panjab, which province has to a large extent an admix-
ture of African forms in its fauna (Comp. Jour. Asiat. Soc. Bengal, xxiii,
p. 739). Blyth, when describing Eurylepis, correctly refers to the figure
of Sc. pavimentatus in the ‘ Descr. de l’Egypt’., but he was not aware that
the species is identical with Sc. Schneideri, and that it is the type of
Eumeces. * There does not appear to be a differencef between Eurylepis and
* Dr. Anderson (Proc. Asiat. Soo. B., for Sept. 1871) suggests that Fitzinger’s
name Mdbov/ia, (or rather Mabuya, as invariably written by Fitzinger), should replace
Eumeces. 1 do not think that there is sufficient reason for this. Fitzinger, when sugges-
ting the name Mabuya in 1826, (in Verz. Rept. p. 23), certainly says that the lizard
possesses palatine teeth, and the author places the genus in opposition to Gray’s Tiliqua
which, he says, does not have palatino teeth. Bnt Gray’s old genus Tiliqua includes
a vast number of Seines with and without palatino teeth. Moreover, Fitzinger, when
giving in the same work (p. 52) a list of the species of Mabuya, quotes as the first species
Scincus quvnque-cari>uitus, Kuhl, as the second Sc. carinatus, Daudin, as the 12th Sc.
agilis , Radde, and as one of the last Sc. ocellatus, Dandin, the Mo.bouya par excellence of
old author’s ; but neither for the first nor for the last species has Fitzinger’s name
Mabuya been retainod. When writing his Syst. Rept, published in 1813, Fitzinger was
perfectly woll aware of this confusion, and dropped the name Mabuya altogether,
most likely because it had not been accepted by Dum. and Bibron. He quotes (1.
cit.) Lacepede’s “ Mabouya” (Sc. ocellatus, Daud.) as the type of Wiegmanu’s Gongylus,
and distributes the other species which he formerly referred to Mabuya into about
half a dozen genera. In 1845 Gray wished to rescue Fitzinger’s name, (more correctly
written in the form of Mabouya), retaining it for Radde’s Sc. agilis as type, and only in
this signification can, I believe, the name Mabouya find a place in our literature, if we
wish to avoid a greater confusion than already exists,
f Compare Anderson in Proc. A. S. B., Sept. 1871.
122
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
Eumeces. The dorsal scales of pavimentatus are often very irregular in their
size, and enlarged, as are also those of Blytb’s species.
The Indian and Malayan species, referred by Gunther in his ‘ Iteptiles of
India’ to Eumeces, are arranged by the same author under two groups. One
includes Ilinulia, Mocoa, and Podophis, the other Mabouya (type Sc. agilis,
Radde) and liiopa, to which Senira has to be added, if Mr. Theobald is cor-
rect in identifying a lizard from Rangiin with Senira bicolor of Gray (Linn.
Soc. Jour., Zool., x, p. 27). Whether the three first named should be consi-
dered only as subgcnera of Lygosoma, Gray, as adopted by several contin-
ental herpetologists, or whether they should be retained as distinct genera,
is for the present not of very material importance. I can only say that the
Indian species of Ilinulia and Mocoa are fairly divisible, and the same is
the case with Mabouya and Ihopa. All have the palatal notch situated
far backward and the palate itself toothless, but this is a very general
character, and equally applies to Hagria, Iiistella and several other well
distinguishable genera.
Of Ilinulia there aro as yet only three species known from British
India, and as they had been rather misunderstood, I shall give a figure of
the head and of the solo of the hind foot of each, shewing the characterstic
distinctions between them. II. indica is as yet only known from Sikkim
and the adjoining hills ; H. maculafa occurs throughout Bengal and Barma ;
H. Bussumieri is from the Malabar coast. Of Mabouya and Podophis I
do not know a single species which occurs within the limits of British India,
as now understood (excluding Penang). Of Mocoa and Biopa, the species
are numerous and mostly of small size.
Hinudia indica, Gray.
PI. iv. fig. 1, la, side and upper views of the head, natural size; 16, sole of left
hind limb, twice the natural size.
Eumeces indicus apud Gunther, I, R„ p. 89, exclusive of the synonyms quoted
under Lygosoma and Mocoa. — E. indicus, apud Anderson in Proc. Zool. Soc., 1871,
p. 158 (in part).
The general structure of scales is as described by Gunther. The number
of longitudinal rows is usually 36 or 38 ; there are 60-70 transverse rows
at the side of the body between fore and hind limb, but there are only 46-55
scales in a row at the edge of the vent between axil and loin. The fore foot,
when laid forward, scarcely ever reaches the snout, but it usually extends
in front beyond the eye. The four supraciliaries are followed by two small
shields ; ear opening large, without any denticulations in front.
The usual coloration is as originally described by Gray. Upper side
lown, generally bronze, rarely with an olive tinge, uniform, or with a few
F. Stoliczlca — On Indian Lizards.
123
1872.]
scattered dark spots ; limbs above almost uniform brown ; sides towards
the back with a dark brown or blackish band, separated from the back by an
indistinct, partially interrupted, narrow, white band ; on the lower half of
the sides the colour gradually passes into dull brown, more or less spotted or
marbled with paler, which markings are generally also traceable in the
dark band ; sides of tail greyish brown with an upper dark edge, and marked
with darker and paler small spots, or indistinct stripes. Below, uniform green-
ish iridescent white ; limbs and tail of a pale fleshy brown colour during life.
This is a much larger species than any of the two following, but it is by
no means common in Sikkim. I found it from the base of the valleys up
to about 6,000 feet, and also received it from the Bhutan hills. It very
likely extends eastwards into Asam.
The young specimen referred to by Dr. Anderson (1. cit.) under the
head of Mu. indicus belongs to the next species ; and judging from the
description of the coloration in Gunther’s I. K. (1. cit.), it appears probable,
that specimens of the next species were also referred to this one as young.
There can, however, be no mistake about the distinctness of the two. H- in-
dica, as compared with H. maculata, is a much stouter and larger form, with
comparatively larger scales, arranged in a smaller number of transverse rows
between fore and hind limb ; the former has 10 rows of scales on the back
between the dark bands, the latter only 8 ; in indica the rostral, anterior
frontal, and the supraorbitals are slightly convex, the interspace between the
latter moderately wide, the preanal shields comparatively small ; the palm
and sole entirely covered with spinous tubercles, with some larger ones on the
posterior edge of the sole. In H. maculata on the contrary the rostral reach-
es far backwards, is flat or almost concave above, the anterior frontal is also
flat, the supraorbitals tumid with a very narrow space between them, and
the palm and sole are only partially tubercular. There is also a difference in
coloration ; the lateral band at the side in indica is never very distinct, and
is not margined below by a white line, which is always well marked in ma-
culata.
In six specimens examined the length of the body varies between 3 and
3.75 inches, the tail being, when in its natural growth, about twice that length,
but often it is reproduced and then about equal in length to the body.
Hinulia maculata, Blytli.
PI. iv, fig. 2, 2a, side and upper views of the head, natural size, 2h, sole of hind
limb, twice the natural size.
Comp. Stoliczka, in Journ. Asiat. Sc. B., xxxix. 1870, p. 174.
The 5th and part of the 6th labial are below the orbit, both are nearly
equal in size ; the median pair of the enlarged preanals is sometimes (though
124
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
rarely) united into one largo shield. The hand has no tubercles on the
extreme inner edge, and the sole is only partially tubercular, being generally
smooth all along the bases of the 3rd and 4th toes ; there are 17 -22 sharp
tubercles on the 4th free toe.
I have examined specimens from the Andamans,* Moulmein, various
parts of Pegu, Asam, Sikkim and from the Parisnath hill in W. Bengal. The
Moulmein specimens are the largest, attaining 7 inches ; next come those
from Asam and the base of the Sikkim hills, just above the Terrai at
Pankabari ; specimens collected at greater elevations, as for instance those
about Darjiling (7-8000 feet) very rarely appear to attain 6 inches in length,
and on the Parisnath I did not get (in April) a single specimen above 3
inches. All from the latter locality are, above, distinctly bronze brown, while
those from the Himalayas are generally somewhat olivaceous or, when young,
with greenish metallic lustre ; they also often have the back much spotted
with blackish, and the sutures between the head shields are more or less
black, but in every point of structure the two forms are identical.
In all the specimens, I saw, the fore foot when laid forward, reached
beyond the eye, but never to the front of the rostral. The fifth or last
supraeiliary is the smallest, but rarely united with the fourth, which is then
followed by one or two small shields. The number of transverse rows of
scales on the side of the body between fore and hind limb varies from 80 to 95,
but the number of scales in one row at the edge of the belly is only about 60,
Huotlia Dussttmieeii, Dum. and Bib.
PI. iv, fig. 3, 3a, Bide and upper views of.tlio head ; 3i>, sole of left hind limb.
Lygosoma Dussumierii, D. and B., Erpet. Gen., v, p. 725.
Eumeces Dussmnieri, apud Beddome, Madras Journ. Med. So. for 1870.
I am indebted for a specimen of this very rare speciesf to Major Beddome,
who obtained it in Malabar, where also the original specimens have been
procured by Mr. Dussumior. As the species is rare, a slightly verbal altera-
tion of Major Beddome’s description may not be out of place.
Head conical, depressed above ; body high, roundly subquadrangular ;
tail much longer than the body, gradually tapering to a point. The fore
leg, when laid forward reaches to the tip of the snout, and the hind leg ex-
* One of the two specimens, noted by Theobald in Cat. Kept. Asiat. Soc. Museum,
18G8, p. 25 (letter 6.) as coming from the Andamans is an Ewprepes which, if not
’ identical with Steindachner’s E. macro tin, from the Nicobars, belongs to a now species.
Scales in 30 longitudinal series, each sharply three-keeled; supranasals not quite in
oontact, frontal forms a broad suture with vertical, occipitals as usually distributed ;
lower eyelid scaly, but the scales are rather larger in the middle j greenish olive above ;
ear large with scarcely any projecting denticles in front ; sides blackish, below white.
f In the specimen described by Major Beddome the fii’st and second supra-
orbitals appear to have been united.
P. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
125
1872.]
tends with half of the fourth toe beyond the shoulder. Rostral large, reaching
far backward, and flat above ; anterior frontal above broadly truncate, but
very narrowly behind, the two posterior frontals nearly meeting ; vertical very
narrowly in contact with the anterior frontal, and much contracted and elon-
gated posteriorly ; supraorbitals 5, much swollen, the last followed below by
two small shields ; interorbital space very narrow ; a pair of anterior occipitals,
narrowed in front, broad behind ; median occipital obtusely pointed in front,
acutely behind, and in size subequal to one of the anterior occipitals ; posterior
occipitals larger, meeting behind with a narrow suture, in front in contact
with the anterior occipital, the fifth supraorbital, and a small shield following
it ; shields on the side of the head regular ; 8 upper and 7 lower labials, the last
very small ; first chin-shield single, second in a pail1, forming a suture, follow-
ed by 3 other separate and widely diverging pairs ; opening of the ear a long
vertical slit, not denticulate in front ; 40-42 longitudinal rows of scales
round the middle of the body, those on the sides considerably smaller than
on the belly ;* about 76 transverse series on the side between fore and hind-
limb, but only 66 on the edge of the belly ; preanal scales moderately
enlarged ; of the subcaudals there are very few in front enlarged, but near the
middle and posteriorly all ; palm nearly entirely covered with tubercles, sole
only at the bases of the 1st and 5th toes, and on the posterior edge, the re-
mainder being smooth ; about 23 sharpened tubercles under the free portion
of the fourth toe.
Colour, above, fulvous, tinged olive in front and reddish posteriorly, with
two longitudinal, submarginal, black bands, partially or entirely broken up
into spots and becoming obsolete on the tail, which is red ; along the edges of
the back runs a metallic greenish white line, originating on the supraciliary
edge ; it is most distinct on the neck, but gradually disappears on the tail.
A pure black band originates at the nasal, continues through the eye along
the upper side of the body, and on the tail, disappearing towards its termina-
tion ; the black band is bordered below by a narrower white band, which ori-
ginates below the eye, passes through the lower part of the ear to the loin,
and is below, particularly at the side of the vent, again bordered with black.
Legs above olive brown with darker marblings and indistinct fulvous spots ;
tips of toes dark. Below, uniform greenish iridescent white ; tail red.
Total length 4.75 inches, body 1.87, tail 2.87 inch. In general structure
of the scales, the flattened upper rostral, tumid supraorbitals, narrow vertical,
imperfectly tubercular soles, and in general style of coloration, the Malabar
form agrees with the Bengal maculata , but the limbs are longer in proportion,
and the details of coloration considerably different. The black band is at the
side of the body broader, and the white one, bordering it below, originates in
the present species below the eye and passes through the lower angle of the
opening of the ear, while in maculata it begins almost behind the eye and
* This is also the case in H. maculata.
17
126 F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. [No. 2,
passes through the upper edge of the ear ; the number of longitudinal
rows of scales also appears to be slightly larger in the present species.
Mocoa Sikkimeitsis, Blyth.
PI. v, figs. 2, 2a, side and upper views of tlie head j three times the natural size.
Journ. Asiat. Soo. Bengal, 1854, xxii, p. 652.
Body slender, head short, obtuse and rather flattened above ; no
gupranasals ; lower eyelid with a transparent disk in the middle. Shields of
the head regular, anterior frontal in contact with the rostral and vertical, which
is much attenuated posteriorly ; posterior 1'rontals small, aud not in contact,
unless exceptionally ; 4 supraciliaries ; posterior pair of occipitals about
twice the size of the anterior, middle shield small, shaped like the vertical,
but shorter ; 3 to 4 pairs of elongate transverse shields behind the oc-
cipitals ; 2 loreals and 2 pre-oculars, each pah- sometimes united into one
vertically, or horizontally, elongated shield ; 7 upper labials followed by two
smaller shields, the 5th under the orbit, but not much elongated ; 8 lower
labials, the last smallest ; anterior chin-shields enlarged ; ear small rounded,
generally with 2 or 3 small projecting shields on the front-, and a few still
smaller lobules on the hinder, edge. Seales generally in 24 longitudinal series,
and in 46 transverse series between fore and hind-limb ; these numbers vary
very little ; young specimens have occasionally only 44, but the largest never
appear to have more than 48, transverse series. A pair of large preanals.
Subcaudals also enlarged, except the first few. The fore foot reaches to the
anterior angle of the orbit, when laid forward, and the hind foot is three
fifth the distance between fore and hind-limb. Palm and sole tubercular ;
fourth finger barely longer than the third ; fourth toe nearly a quarter longer
than the third.
Colour , above, bronze brown, (sometimes with an olive tinge and a metallic
lustre dining life,) uniform, or with three to five irregular series of small dark
brown dots, the centre ones often arranged into dark lines ; sides darker, near
the back more or less blackish brown, commencing with a dark band at the
rostral shield. Above, at the edges of the hack, the black is margined by
a somewhat indistinct pale line or band, occasionally dissolved into more or
less confluent white spots ; below, there is also an indistinct pale, undulating,
hand, passing from the ear to near the loin ; the upper portion of the sides is
less, the lower more numerously, spotted with white ; the brown, as well as
the somewhat indistinct whitish, spots extend on to the sides of the tail. Tipper
labials whitish, spotted with brown. Chin uniform greenish white in young,
spotted with greenish dusky in older specimens. Yent below greenish white,
on the posterior part, but especially between the femora and below the tail,
reddish, this colour being more or less bright according to sex and season.
The brown spots on the back are very variable, both hi number and distinct-
1872.]
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
127
ness. Young specimens generally have a distinct greenish metallic tinge
on the whole hody.
Largest specimen measures 5.25 inches, of which the body is 2", or a
little less ; some specimens have a stouter tail than others.
Hab. Sikkim, at elevations of from 3,000 to 10,000 feet ; generally
found between large stones in places exposed to the sun.
Jerdon* says that Gunther’s Bumeces Himalayanusf is identical with
Sikkimensis, which latter Gunther quoted as doubtfully belonging to Hinulia
indica.% Dr. Anderson (Proc. Zool. Soc. 1871, p. 158) also says, that the Sik-
kim form “ agrees in its transparent eyelid and all its other details with G iin-
ther’s Bum. himalayanus he has, however, I believe, never seen an example of
the true Mocoa Himalayana of Gunther. I have specimens of the latter from
Simla and the hills to the West, and I find that although they closely resemble
Sikkimensis, they are nearly as well distinguishable, as are Sin. indica and
maculata. Among five specimens of Himalayana only one has 2b longitudi-
nal rows of scales, the four other specimens have each 28 longitudinal rows ;
there are 48 to 50 transverse rows between fore and hind-limb, but only 42 to
44 scales in a row along the edge of the belly. On the back there aie, as in
Sikkimensis, only 4 longitudinal rows, but at the sides and below the st ales
of Himalayana are decidedly smaller. Other differences are : the limbs,
though not longer than in Sikkimensis, are in Himalayana somewhat more
slender, the transparent disk on the eyelid is larger, the ear-opening is also
larger and with much more distinct lobules in front, the posterior frontals
are more developed, almost meeting the anterior frontal and the vertical in
a point, as stated by Dr. Gunther, while in Sikkimensis the two posterior
frontals always remain well separated.
The colour of Himalayana is, as described by Gunther, above, greenish
olive (not bronze brown, or only tinged with olive, as in Sikkimensis'), with a
few interrupted series of dark and whitish dots ; a blackish band commences at
the nasal and continues through the eye along the upper side of the body to
near the tip of the tail, it is either uniform or with a few white spots, and on
the tail it becomes generally less distinct. At the edge of the back the black
band is margined by a white line, (most distinct on the neck), and below by a
much broader white band, commencing at the lower edge of the orbit and ter-
minating at the hind limb. Below this white band the sides are mottled or
speckled with dark. The lower surface is uniform greenish white ; tail reddish *
below (seasonal). All this strongly contrasts with specimens of Sikkimensis
of which I collected a very large number of specimens in Sikkim. I do not
wish to say that the two forms may not be shown to represent mere varieties of
* Proc. Asiat. Soo. for February ]870, p. 73.
f lieptilee of India, p. 86. J Ibidem, p. 89.
128
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
one type species, but unless direct transitions, or transmutations, from one form
into the other had been proved by observations, we have no right to ignore the
distinctions which had been pointed out, and which do in reality exist.
M. Sikkimensis appears to be, however, more closely related to Mocoa
SeJilegelii, Gunther (1. c., p. 86), which also has been described from a Sik-
kim specimen. In size, form and general structure there does not appear to
be a great difference between the two ; the number of longitudinal rows of
scales round the body is given as 25, and that between the axil and groin
as 35, the latter number is, however, too small for Sikkimensis. The colour
of Schlegelii is said to be black above, blackish below, which I certainly
never observed among a few hundreds of Sikkimensis.
Mocoa sacka, n. sp.#
PI. iv, fig. 4, side view of the animal, natural size ; 4a, 46, 4c, upper, side, and lower
views of the head and neck, enlarged.
Habit slender, head somewhat depressed, obtuse in front, body shorter
than the tail, the latter gradually tapering to a point. No supranasals, eyelid
with a perfectly transparent disc ; scales in 22 longitudinal series round the
middle of the body, and in 40 transverse series between fore and hind-limb.
Head shields regular, like in Sikkimensis, but the postnasal scarcely reaches
the top of head, and the fifth upper labial is comparatively longer than in
that species. A few enlarged scales behind the occipitals. Subeaudals single,
enlarged, except the two first pairs. A pair of large preanals. Ear in front
denticulated with three equal lobules.
Total length 3.37 inches of which the tail is 2* ; feet slender ; the fore foot
reaches to the middle of the eye, when laid forward, the 3rd and 4th fingers are
equal or subequal ; the hind foot is two-third the distance between fore
and hind limb, or half that between the latter and the ear ; the 4th toe is
slightly longer than the 3rd.
Above, light iridescent bronze brown, with a few dark brown spots
scattered on the head and body, each of these dark spots being accompanied
by an indistinct pale spot, on both, or only on one side ; a narrow black band
from the rostral through the eye, passing above the ear and becoming
indistinct on the sides of the belly ; a white band below the black, best marked
through the ear and above the fore foot, but becoming also indistinct on
the belly where a few whitish spots separate the lower light from the upper
darker parts ; labials somewhat spotted with dark ; chin white ; breast and
belly, below, greenish iridescent white ; femoral region and tail below pale
vermilion, that colour passing also on the sides of the tail, where only a few
indistinct pale spots exist.
This species is very closely allied to Sikkimensis, differing from it by
its more slender and comparatively longer hind feet, smaller number of
# See Proc. A. S. B., September 1871, p. 195.
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
129
1872.]
longitudinal rows of scales, those on the vent being decidedly more trans-
versely elongated, than in the Himalayan form ; further in the more elongated
5th upper labial, few enlarged shields behind the occipitals, and by the
subcaudals being enlarged almost from the beginning. There is also a slight
difference in coloration.
Sab. Parisnath hill in West Bengal. The only specimen was obtained
near one of the Jain shrines on the top of the hill.
Ristella, Gray.
Ann. and Mag. Nat. Hist., Ser. X, 1839, p. 333.
Cat. Lizards B. M., 1845, pp. 71 and 85.
Body and tail elongate, subcylindrical ; limbs four, feeble, anterior with
4, posterior with 5 toes, thumb and inner toe shortest ; all toes •provided with
retractile claics, lying between two terminal enlarged shields ; head shields
regular; nostril in a single lateral shield; supranasals none; lower eyelid
scaly ; ear opening small ; scales of body keeled or nearly smooth ; gape
situated far backward ; palate toothless ; teeth of the jaws small, equal,
numerous, compressed.
This generic character has been derived from a specimen, kindly sent to
me by Major Beddome ; it belongs, I believe, to a genus which was originally
established by Gray for a North Indian specimen, Ristella Rurkii (1. cit. p.
86), but the species appears to be different ; at least it is impossible to
identify both from the short description given of R. Rurkii, and it is not
noted in Gunther’s Reptiles of India.
The 4 anterior toes and the retractile claws are important distinctions
of the genus which must be classed next to Seteropus.
Ristella Tbavancoeica* Beddome.
Ateuchosawms Trow anconeus, Beddome, Madras Jo urn. Med. Sc., 1870, p. 33.
PI iv, fig. 5, Tipper view of the animal, natural size ; 5a, 56, 6c, upper, side and
lower views of the head, enlarged; 5d, inner view of hand with the claws retracted,
5e, sole with the claws drawn out.
Body very elongate, subeylindrical, but somewhat depressed ; muzzle short,
obtuse, tail considerably longer than the body and very gradually tapering.
Rostral convex in front, reaching to the upper surface of the head ; one large
prefrontal, two small posterior frontals, widely separated ; the vertical forms a
broad suture with anti-frontal and is posteriorly much elongate ; four or five
supraciliaries, slightly elevated, the first shield largest, but it is sometimes
divided in two, last shield smallest ; five occipitals, the two anterior and the
median one subequal, the posterior pair larger, and the adjoining scales are
* R. malabaricus, (olim), Proo. A. S. B., 1871, p. 195.— Since my description of
this species was drawn up, I observe that Major Beddome redescribed the species, in
Mad Med. Journal for 1871, also under the name Ristella, which name I had pointed
out to him.
130
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
slightly larger than the rest on nook. Nasal shield moderate, pierced nearly
in the middle by the nostril ; one loreal, one preocular separated from the
angle of the eye by a few minute shields ; 3 or 4 small shields at the hinder
angle of the eye, followed by regular scales. Upper labials 6, the eye above
the 3rd and 4th ; lower labials 5, narrow but long ; lower rostral large, follow-
ed by one single and 3 pairs of enlarged chin shields. Scales on neck smooth,
on body slightly two-keeled, round the middle of body in 26 longitudinal
rows, there being 6 rows on the back, exclusive one row on either edge ; on
the belly there are also 6 rows, the scales being slightly larger than those of
the back ; 35 transverse rows between fore and bind limb ; the two median
preanal shields somewhat larger than the others ; subeaudals not very conspi-
cuously enlarged, (but they are generally enlarged in this group of Scincidje
when the tail has been reproduced) . The fore limb, when laid forward, reaches
to the angle of the mouth, and the length of the hind limb is equal to half
the distance between axil and groin. Total length of specimen 3.62 inches,
head and body being 1.5 inches.
General colour, above, dark fulvous brown, each of the scales in the 6
dorsal rows with a median black streak, forming black longitudinal lines,
continued on the tail ; edge of back a little more distinctly fulvous brown,
sides blackish with small white spots ; below, yellowish white, spotted with
black on chin and throat ; tail below variegated with black and yellowish
white, (during life probably reddish).
Hah. According to Major Beddome, common in moist jungles of the
Western Ghats between 2000 and 5000 feet elevation.
Eiopa angotSa, Theobald.
PI. v. fig. 4, animal, natural size ; 4 a, 46, 4c, top, side and lower views of the
head, enlarged; 4 d, upper side of hand; 4 a, inner side of foot.
Theobald, Journal Linn. Soc., Zool. vol. x, p. 27.
Anderson, Proc. Zool. Loud. 1871, p. 159 (in part).
BlOl’A CYATfELLA, n. Sp.
PI. v, fig. 3, 3d — 3c, exactly corresponding figures with 4, 4a — 4c.
? Rwpa Bowringi apud Theobald, Linn. Soo. Journ.', Zool. x, p. 26.
Binpa angu/ina, apud Anderson, P. Z, S., p. 159, (in part).
Theobold’s description of It. anguina is somewhat incomplete. Dr. Ander-
son having kindly shown me the specimens in the Museum, I found that they
belong to two distinct species, and that his description, as regards coloration
at least, partly refers to anguina, partly to cyanella. In order to prevent
misapprehension I give a brief description of the characters of both, and add a
figure of each species.
It. anguina. Body elongate, subcylindrical, slightly depressed ; head
conical, rather short ; supranasals in contact behind the rostral ; anterior
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards .
131
1872.]'
frontal in contact with the vertical which is rather narrow, and barely reaches
beyond a straight line connecting the middle of the orbits ; four supraciliaries
followed by a small shield ; anterior pair of occipitals nearly equal to,* or only
slightly larger than, the median occipital shield, the formernarrower in front, the
latter attenuate behind ; posterior occipitals elongate, each being antoriorly in
contact with the 4th supraciliary and the small shield following it, or sometimes
it also touches an additional small shield placed obliquely behind that small
posterior supraorbital ; two scales, touching on each side the posterior occipi-
tals, are enlarged ; other head shields regular, as usual in Hiopa, (they are
indicated in the figure). The upper labials are sometimes 8 instead of 7, the
3rd or 4th being occasionally divided. Lower eyelid with a large translucent
shield. Ear small, sometimes one or the other of the front scales slightly
projects in the space. Scales in 22 longitudinal rows round the middle of
the body, those on the lower side scarcely larger than those on the back ;
the two median preanal shields are only very little larger than those supersed-
ing them ; 65-70 transverse rows between fore and hind-limbs.
Limbs very short and rather stout, with very short toes and distinct
claws ; palm and sole coarsly granular. The fore limb when laid forward
does not reach the ear, and is only a little longer than the lateral gape of
the mouth. The hind-limb equals the distance between the ear and the tip
of snout, or it is a trifle longer.
Colour, above, uniform brown or greyish brown, pale at the sides, and
whitish or brownish white below, the brownish or yellowish tint being
especially conspicuous on the lower side of the tail. There is no lateral streak
at the side of the body, but the sutures between the dorsal scales are in
young specimens conspicuously darker than the rest, and form longitudinal
dark lines, which in mature specimens become indistinct, or obsolete. In
some specimens there is also a transverse, submarginal, dark line to each scale.
Usual size about 4 inches, of which the tail is generally somewhat less
than one half. Length of head and body of the largest (figured) specimen
2.25 inches.
Hub. Pegu, British Barma.
Hiopa cyanella. Body slender, with a conical head. Head-shields quite
similar to those of the last species, but the vertical is somewhat longer and
more slender ; the median occipital is conspicuously smaller than one of the
anterior pair ; scales adjoining the posterior occipitals moderately enlarged.
Lower eyelid with a translucent large shield. Opening of the ear small, a
front scale very little projecting into the space. Scales of body in 22
longitudinal rows, 60-64 transverse rows between fore and hind limb ;
preanals scarcely larger than the preceding scales. Limbs of moderate
* Theobald in Ms oi'iginal description rightly places particular stress upon this
character.
132
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
length and slender. The fore-limb, when laid forward, nearly or fully reaches
the opening of the ear, and is only a little shorter than the distance between
the snout and the ear ; the hind limb is less than half the distance
between the axil and loin, and it barely exceeds the distance between the
fore limb and the anterior angle of the eye.
Colour, above, olive brown, with an iridescent blue tinge, purer brownish
on the tail, pale brownish olive at the side of the body ; each scale, above
and at the sides, is indistinctly mottled with dark, and there are generally
a few white spots on the side of the neck and about the shoulder ; a narrow
white, slightly black margined band rises from behind the orbit and continues
on each side of the back ; it becomes indistinct in the middle of the body,
but is again slightly more conspicuous above the hip, gradually disappearing
on the tail, which is indistinctly speckled with dark brown at the sides ;
limbs above with longitudinal, broken up, dark lines ; chin and anterior neck
below yellowish, vent whitish ; tail below brownish white.
This description is drawn up from a specimen which was presented to
the Indian Museum by Mr. W. Theobald, and is not unlikely the same which
he in his Catalogue of Burmese Reptiles noticed under the name of R. Bow-
rvngi. The greater length of the limbs and the coloration readily distinguish
this from the preceding species.
Sab. Pegu ; British Barma.
ElOPA ALBOPUJTCTATA, (I. R., p. 92).
PI. v, fig. 6, 6a, upper and side views of head, enlarged.
Riopa Haedwickii, (I. R., p. 92).
PI. v, fig. 5, 5a, same views as in figure 6.
Riopa puacxata, (I. R. p. 93).
The differences in structure between these three species are very few.
In the first and third the vertical and the median occipital shield are
comparatively narrower and longer, than in the second.
In R. albopunctata the scales of the body are slightly smaller and more
quadrangular, the number of longitudinal rows varies between 2G and 28, (the
two numbers being almost equally common, at least in Bengal specimens), the
transverse rows between fore and hind limb vary between 50-60, 56 being the
most usual number, as stated by Gunther. The fore leg reaches, when laid for-
ward, to the froht edge of the ear, or a little beyond it, rarely to the angle of the
mouth ; the length of the hind leg is generally a little less than fth of the
body, rarely exactly Jth.
In It. Hardwickii all the scales are somewhat larger and more trans-
versely elongate, the number of longitudinal rows varies between 24
and 26, both being almost equally common ; the transverse rows between
lore and hind limbs vary between 48 and 56, 53 being the most usual
F. Stoliczka — On Indian lizards .
133
1872.]
number; the fore leg extends generally somewhat beyond the ear, and
often as far as the angle of the mouth, but very rarely beyond it ; the hind
leg is generally somewhat more than one fourth the length of the body.
In the form, greater or lesser thickness, and in the length of the
body and of the tail, the two first mentioned species are identical, and equally
variable ; both have in front of the ear two lobules, the upper oi which is
the larger one, while the lower becomes occasionally obsolete. Both species
also have the shields on the preanal edge slightly larger than those above
them, and both have the lower eyelid covered with enlarged shieldsj
but in the former the centre large shield is opaque, and generally broken up in
two or three smaller ones, while in the latter it always remains entire, but it
is generally only in young specimens perfectly transparent, the usual size
of either species is a little above 4 inches, the tail if normal being about
equal to the length of the body, but often it is reproduced, becoming thinner,
or thicker, and shorter, and with the subcaudals often somewhat enlarged.
The coloration is generally tolerably distinct in the two species.
In albojmnctata of South India the back is often uniform brown ; in
Bengal specimens, each of the six median rows of scales of the back has a
black dot, forming longitudinal lines and continuing on the tail, the extieme
edges of the upper back are sometimes pale coloured, and some varieties of
this type occasionally very much resemble those of Hardwick ii ; sides
purplish black, spotted with white ; lower side of the tail uniform white, like
the vent, or more often each scale with a blackish dot. Legs above black
spotted. — This species extends from South India through Central India, the
whole of Bengal, into N. -Eastern Asam, and westwards into Pegu. At Cal-
cutta it is very common during the winter months, but I have seen extremely
few specimens in the time between May and the end of the rainy season.
It. Hardwickii is more variable in colour. The back and sides of the
body are sometimes entirely purplish black ; the edges of the upper back
from the nostril, and the whole of the lower side purely white, tail vermilion in
young, pale brownish above, white below, in older specimens. Other specimens,
particularly those from Northern India, (about Agra and northwards towards
the base of the Himalayas), have the four median rows of dorsal scales each
with a large blackish spot, or rather the spots are generally situated on the
suture between each two scales, and the scales in the two middle rows have their
lower margins apparently serrated ; the upper edges of the back have the usual
white or yellowish bands ; the sides are abovepurplish black, further down paler
and each scale has a black spot; white dots occur either over the entire side, or
only on the anterior half, or they are restricted to the side of the neck ; vent
always uniform white ; tail with a black spot to-each scale, sometimes absent
on the lower side, its general colour fleshy. The reddish or purplish tinge is
gradually lost in spirit. — This species is found in South India,* extending
* According to Blyth also in Ceylon,
18
134
F. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards.
[No. 2,
through Central India northwards as far as Rurki and Hardwar, and east-
wards as far as Calcutta, but it is very rare here. I have only within the
last year obtained two specimens on the western side of the Hughli river
at Howrah, hut do not know of any record of the species eastward of the
Hughli, that is even in Calcutta itself.
A third species which I have to notice is Linne’s It. 'punctata from
South India and the Dakhin (Delihan). The structure and colour of
this closely corresponds with that of albopunctata from Bengal, but the
difference in size is very great, the former often attaining 12 inches. The
number of scales round the body is usually 24, and those between fore and
hind limb 78 — 84. Colour, brown above and at the sides, pale below, all
scales with blackish, and the anterior half of sides with white, spots.
At Matheran near Bombay (about 2,500 feet on the trappean plateau) I
have met with a peculiar form, which might be looked upon as a hybrid or a
transitional form, between It. albopunctata and It. Ilardwickii. The form of
the body, its structure, proportions of the limbs and the posteriorly narrowed
vertical shield best agrees with punctata, as described. The largest specimen
measures only 7 £ inches, the body being 3) inches. Of eight specimens examined,
all have 26 longitudinal rows of scales, a number tolerably common in
Ilardwickii, but rarely to be met with in typical punctata. There are 74 — 80
transverse rows of scales between the limbs, agreeing with punctata. The co-
louration is exactly the same as in a pale It. Ilardwickii : above and at the sides
more or less dark brown, a pale brown or yellowish band on each side from the
snout to the base of the tail, anterior half of sides of body with white dots ;
below whitish ; all scales have blackish spots which sometimes become obsolete
on the lower side. It is really difficult to decide to which species this particular
form, which I have just noticed, should be referred. The structure and form
of the body agrees best with punctata, while the colouration is that of
Hardivickii, and the size is intermediate between both. To consider the
Matheran form as an independent species, seems to me quite unnatural ; it is
certainly nothing else than a local variety, and most probably the same which
Jerdon notices as It. Ilardwickii from the Carnatic, ‘ 9 inches’ long (J. A. S.
B., xxii, p. 478). The question to be answered is : do we know the young
punctata in all its progressive stages up to the adult ? I got the adult from
Puna, and with it one younger specimen which has the general colouration
of Ilardwickii, the body is 2'6 inches, greater than in any known Ilardwickii
from the N. West or Central Provinces, tail reproduced, short, 24 longitudi-
nal rows round the body, and 80 transverse rows of scales between the
limbs. If we have to look upon this specimen as the young of punctata, what
I do not doubt it really is, and take into consideration what I said about true
Ilardwickii and the Matheran form, the only reasonable conclusion we can
draw is, that punctata and Ilardwickii are actually only one species which
1872.] E. Stoliczka — On Indian Lizards. 135
attains its greatest size and development on the Ghats of South India, and
gradually diminishes in size as it extends further north, and into the plains.
Careful observations of the younger stages of punctata must settle this pre-
sently doubtful point, hut it is one of extreme interest for the study of the
development of our Indian fauna.
Chiameixa ltneata, Gray.
Gray, Cat. Lizards B. R., p 97. — Gunther, I. R.> p. 95.
I obtained an adult specimen* of this very rare form near Puna (Dak-
hin), on the sandy hanks of the river between shrubs.
Body very slender and long, muzzle moderately obtuse, head flattened
above. Rostral shield broader than high, slightly reaching to the top ot
head. Anterior frontal large, single ; posterior frontals small, separate ;
vertical small, in contact with anterior frontal, angular in front, obtusely
rounded (sub-eliptically) behind ; supraciliaries four ; anterior occipitals united
into one obtusely triangular shield, median occipital small, pointed behind
and the posterior occipitals elongate, forming a suture posteriorly. Aostrils
lateral, in a single elongate shield ; supranasals narrow, separated by the
anterior frontal which is in contact with the rostral. Two loreals. Lower
eyelid transparent. Seven upper labials, fifth largest and under the orbit,
six lower labials. Ear small, with smooth edges. Scales perfectly smooth,
shining, in 22 longitudinal rows round the middle of the body, and in 82-84
transverse series between the limbs ; preanals and subcaudals not perceptibly
enlarged. Limbs very short, each with four toes, the inner toes on both
very small, the fourth toe on the fore-limb is only a little longer than the
second and sensibly shorter than the fourth ; on the hind-limb the thiid is
very little longer than the fourth. When laid forward the anterior limb
does not reach the ear, and the hind-limb is equal to one sixth the length
between it and the fore-limb.
Colour, above, iridescent bright golden brown, sides paler with a"
greenish tinge, lower side whitish ; all scales with blackish median spots,
forming continuous lines above, but they are slightly more interrupted at the
sides and on the belly, and are least distinct on the throat; head shields
marbled with dark ; edge of lips yellowish ; limbs and tail similarly striped
as the body.
Gray’s characteristic of the genus is excellent, with the exception that the
contiguity of the supranasals cannot be considerate of generic value. My
specimen measures 43 inches, body 2' (head alone 0'2), tail 2 2, reproduced
towards the tip ; fore-limb 0 2, hind-limb very nearly 0'3 inch.
* The only type specimen in the British Museum is a young one, and its proper
locality was unknown.
136
[No. 2,
On the Osteology op Trllnops pebsicus, — by O. E. Dobson, B. A.,
M. B., Assistant Surgeon, H. M's British Forces.
(With plate VI.)
[Received and read 6th March, 1872.]
The construction of the bony skeleton shows a closer relationship with
Pliyllorhina than expected by me, when writing my description of the genus,
founded on the typical species of which I had not then obtained a perfect
skeleton.
The genus is connected with Pliyllorhina, principally, in the relative
number and length of the hones of the fingers, supporting the wing mem-
brane ; in the relative number and length of the hones of the toes ; in the
shape of the iliac bones ; and less markedly in the flattened form and verti-
cal height of the nasal bones. In some other respects, especially in the form
of the bones entering into the construction of the basis cranii, and in their
foramina, its relations are more closely with Ithinolophus, while it differs
from both genera, not less importantly, in some peculiarities of structure to
be described hereafter.
I shall, therefore, in describing the bones of the skeleton compare them
generally with those of the species of Phyllorhina and Ithinolophus, and
particularly with those of Ph. larvata, Horsf., portions of the skeleton of
which are figured in the accompanying plate for the purpose of comparison.
In its general outline the skull resembles that of Phyllorhina more
closely than Ithinolophus, especially in the flattened form and less vertical
height of the nasals, which are, however, relatively, much more developed
laterally and vertically, than in the former genus. From both genera it
differs remarkably in the form of the zygomata which are greatly com pressed ,
and expanded in a vertical direction.
The superior margin of the zygoma rises vertically to a height of 015
inch immediately in front of the posterior origin of the arch, maintaining
this height for more than two-thirds its length, then suddenly narrowing to
half near its connection with, the maxillary ; the inferior margin is straight,
and the intervening bony structure very thin and diaphanous. The zygo-
mata are not curved outwards, as in Phyllorhina and Ithinolophus, and then-
flattened arches form straight lines with the sides of the maxilla-.
The basis cranii is much narrower than in Phyllorhina ; the basi-occipi-
tal is less than half the width of that of Ph. larvata, the total lengths of the
skulls being, respectively, 085 and 095 inches.
The following table of dimensions shows the principal measurements of
the skulls in Tr. persicus and Ph. larvata : —
1872.] G. E. Dobson — Osteology of Tri-cenvps persicus. 137
Tr. persicus Ph. larvata
inches. inches.
Extreme length of skull, 0-85 0 95
Breadth between upper margins of zygomata, 0'30 0’50
Breadth across nasal prominences, 0'28 0'28
Greatest vertical height of zygoma, 0'15 0T0
Length of zygoma, 0'18 0'23
Length of bony palate, laterally, O' 24 0 23
Width of basi-occipital between the cochleae,... O' 04 010
Length of base of skull from posterior margin
of palate to edge of foramen magnum, 0'37 0 43
Width of the base of the skull behind poste-
rior roots of zygomata, 0-32 0'42
The auditory bullw ossecE are very large and prominent ; the cochleae
are deeply grooved externally by the intervals between the spiral chambers,
contrasting with the smooth external surface of the much less prominent
cochleae of Bhyllorhina, and resembling more closely the same parts in Ilhi-
nolophus.
The par-occipital processes are long and slender, club-shaped, narrow
above, expanded beneath, directed downwards and slightly forwards, termi-
nating in a small, acutely pointed projection directed forwards, supporting
the inferior surface of the petro-mastoid. In Bhyllorhina the par-occipital
processes are very short and blunt ; in Rhinolophus long and slender, direct-
ed downwards and forwards, slightly thickened beneath.
There is a minute precondyloid foramen on each side, and in front of,
and external to it, a wide opening — having for its anterior boundaries the
petro-mastoid and cochlea — the jugular foramen. There is no distinct
carotid foramen. In Bhyllorhina larvata the pteeondyloid foramen is sepa-
rated from the jugular opening by a considerable interval ; the latter is
small, circular, and occupies the angle between the petro-mastoid and cochlea.
The basi-sphenoid is perforated, posteriorly, in the middle line by an
oval aperture, a defect of ossification, represented in Bhyllorhina by a circu-
lar thinning of the roof of the basis cranii in the same situation. Between
this aperture and the glenoid fossa is a circular opening, the foramen ovale, •
placed posterior and slightly external to the sphenoidal fissure. More pos-
teriorly and externally, behind the glenoid fossa, separated from the petro-
tympanic bulla by a narrow bony process, a large post-glenoid foramen exists,
while immediately external to and above it the squamosal is perforated by a
small venous canal directed upwards.
The roof of the meso-pterygoid fossa is pierced posteriorly by two small
foramina placed one on each side of the middle line, and separated by an
exceedingly narrow bony lamella, and similarly in front, near the junction
138
G. E. Dobson — Osteology of Trioenops pensions.
[No. 2,
of the basi-sphenoid with the pre-sphenoid. The cribriform plate is perfor-
ated by two large triangular foramina separated by a narrow bony process.
The pterygoid plates are greatly expanded, forming broad, acutely
pointed, triangular projections directed downwards and slightly outwards,
giving width to the meso-pterygoid fossa which quickly narrows as it pro-
ceeds backwards, exposing the wide sphenoidal fissures. Posteriorly its roof
becomes continuous with the under surface of the basis cranii, as in Phyl-
lorhina, its sides curve outwards, forming the posterior boundaries of the
sphenoidal fissures which extend backwards as far as a line drawn between
the glenoid fossae. There is no distinct foramen rotundum.
In Phyllorhina the sphenoidal fissures are much narrower and shorter,
terminating posteriorly at some distance in front of a line joining the
glenoid fossa;. They are concealed in their whole extent by the lateral walls
of the meso-pterygoid fossa. The foramen rotundum is represented by a
small aperture in front of, and internal to the foramen ovale which occupies
the same position, relatively, as in Truenops. The post-glenoid foramen
is small or absent. The meso-pterygoid fossa maintains the same width from
before backwards, or is slightly expanded posteriorly. About the middle its
lateral walls develop small, acutely pointed, hamular processes, curved back-
wards.
In Rhinolophus the basi-occipital is extremely narrow between the audi-
tory bull® ; the foramen rotundum is united, as in Triwnops , with the
sphenoidal fissure which extends as far backwards as in the latter genus ; the
meso-pterygoid fossa is relatively wider anteriorly than in either Phyllorhina
or Truenops, and conceals the narrow sphenoidal fissures to within a short
distance of its termination where its sides suddenly narrow, disclosing the
sphenoidal fissures posteriorly, and slightly further backwards curving out-
wards limit their posterior extent ; its roof is traversed by a narrow groove
terminating posteriorly in an excavation, thus differing from both Phyllor-
hina and Truenops,
The bony palate extends as far back as the middle of the last molar
tooth ; in Phyllorhina, it is limited by the posterior margin of the second
molar.
The coronoid process of the mandible is very small, and in vertical
height less than the canine tooth, thus resembling Bhinoloplms more than
Phyllorhina ; the upper margin of the articular surface is level with the
summits of the molar teeth, and the ramus is pierced immediately beneath
and in front of the condyle by a large circular foramen directed upwards,
and slightly outwards.*
* This infra-condyloid foramen of the mandible is probably unique in Triamops,
in no other genus of Hhinolophidm have I found it, nor, so far as I can ascertain has
such a foramen been discovered in any other species of Chiroptera,
Gr. E. Dobson — Osteology of Triamops persicits.
139
1872.]
In Ph. larvata the coronoid process of the mandible exceeds the canine
tooth considerably in vertical extent, and the upper margin of the condyle
is raised above the summits of the molar teeth.
The dental formula corresponds with that of Phyllorhina : —
T 2 1—1 2—2 3—3
In‘ 4 5 c- i=T ; P- 2=2 5 m. 3— 3-
The upper incisors are deeply bifid, and, as in all genera of Ilhinolophi-
d<e, minute, placed near each other in the centre ot the space between the
canines at the extremities of rudimentary premaxilhe suspended in the nasal
cartilages. Tho upper canine has a well developed, acutely pointed talon
behind, in front a raised ridge extending nearly half its vertical extent and
terminating in a small blunt projection. The first upper premolar is minute
with a slightly concave crown, it is placed outside the tooth-row ; the last
molar is considerably more developed than in Phyllorhina and resembles that
of Iihinolophus, equalling, in tho antero-posterior diameter oi its crowm
more than three-fourths the second premolar, while in Ph. larvata, Ph.
nobilis, and other species of Phyllorhina, it is less than half.
In the lower jaw the incisors are deeply bilobed ; a faint indication
of a third lobe is discernible with the aid of a lens, on the outer side of the
outer incisor.
The first premolar has the cingulum largely developed, expanded horizon-
tally on all sides, and sending upwards, anteriorly and posteriorly a small
process, so that the tooth appears, at first sight, tricuspidate. The posterior
process is much more vertically extended than the anterior one.
The third molar equals the second in size, contrasting with the imper-.
fectly developed last molar of Phyllorhina.
The manubrium stertii differs remarkably from that oi Ph. larvata which
may be taken as characteristic of the form of this bone in Phyllorhina. The
lateral processes behind the sterno-clavicular articulation are triangular and
acutely" pointed, contrasting with the irregularly blunt processes of Ph.
larvata ; the Carina is greatly developed, forming a deep, quadrilateral pro-
jection arising from the entire length of the bone. The second sternal bone
is provided with a deep triangular projection, the anterior margin of which
is separated from the posterior margin of the carina manubrii by a wide
triangular space ; behind, the projecting posterior angle conceals the junc-
tion of the third sternal bone. The third bone is small, narrow, and spine-
like ; its posterior extremity supports a thin, semicircular cartilage.
In Phyllorhina the carina manubrii is shallow, forming a slightly raised
ridge for more than two-thirds its length in the anterior third it is pro-
duced into a blunt spine. The second sternal bone develops a shallow keel
along its entire length ; the third bone is short, expanded laterally, termina-
ting in a semicircular margin.*
* This is the most usual form of the sternum in insectivorous bats. (See Blain-
ville, Osteographio). The number of bones here given is the number of separable
bones distinguishable in the sternum of an adult specimen.
140 G. E. Dobson — Osteology of Tricenops persicus. [No. 2,
The ribs are very much flattened and separated by very narrow inter-
vals.
The ento-condyloid tuberosity of the humerus develops an exceedingly
long styloid process, directed slightly upwards, contrasting with the similar,
short, blunt process of Phyllorhina ; the ecto-condyloid tuberosity is obso-
lete ; the articular surface is marked with a very deep sigmoid notch.
The ulva is strongly curved backwards.
The bones of the fingers exhibit nearly the same relative proportions in
length as in Phyllorhina. The terminal phalanx of the third finger only is
bifid at the extremity, as in Galops Prithii. From the proximal extremity
of the same phalanx, close to the joint, on the under surface, and slightly to
the outside, a process of bone, 0T5 inch long, arises, directed downwards,
slightly forwards, and outwards.
The anterior portion of the ilium develops, at right angles to its in-
ferior surface, a broad quadrilateral process of bone. The antero-inferior
angle of this process is connected by a narrow bony isthmus with the ileo-
pectineal spine, thus bridging over the space between, and forming the in-
ferior boundary of a large oval opening, larger than the obturator foramen
which is placed posterior to it, and, owing to the oblique position of the iliac
bones, on a somewhat lower level. The rim of the pelvis thus forms a
straight line from the pubic symphysis to the antero-inferior angle of the
quadrilateral process on the anterior extremity of the ilium.
In Ph. larvata, and other species of Phyllorhina, the iliac bones develop
very similar processes, but that rising from the antero-inferior surface of the
ilium is much narrower, more of a triangular than of a quadrilateral shape>
and directed downwards and slightly backwards ; its antero-inferior angle is
rounded off, and doe's not develop any spine, as in Tricenops.
In Phinolophws the eminentia ileo-pectinea develops a long, acutely
pointed spine, not connected by bone with the antero-inferior surface of the
ilium.
The fibula is complete as in other Ehinolophine bats. The toes are
equal in length, each with two joints, as in Phyllorhina and Galops.
The genera of Rhinolophida may be arranged, osteologically, under two
subfamilies as follows : —
Subfam. I. Ruixolopiiin^.
Toes unequal ; outer toe with two, remaining toes with three joints each ;
ileo-pectineal spine not connected by bone with the antero-inferior surface of
the ilium.
Genus. 1. Phinolophus.
Metacarpal bone of fourth finger exceeding that of second finger in
1872.] G. E. Dobson — Osteology of Trieenops persicus.
Ill
length ; foramen rotundum united with sphenoidal fissure ; roof of meso-
pterygoid fossa with a longitudinal groove terminating in an excavation pos-
teriorly ; basi-oecipital between auditory bull* very narrow, in most species
linear ; par-occipital processes slender, produced ; antero-posterior diameter
of last molar equal to more than three-fourths that ol antepenultimate molar ;
premolars |^|.
Sltbfam. II. PHYLLOBHINTNiE.
Toes equal, with two joints each ; ileo-pectineal spine united by bone
with a process derived from antero-inferior surface ol ilium.
Genus. 2. Phyllorhina.
Metacarpal bone of fourth finger less than that of second finger m
length; foramen rotundum distinct; auditory hull® sepaiatcdhy a bioad
basi-occipital ; roof of mcsopterygoid fossa continuous with under suiface o
the basis cranii , not grooved, nor perforated by foramina ; pai -occipital pio
cesses short, blunt ; zygomata narrow, slightly expanded posteriorly, cui vet
outwards ; antero-posterior diameter of last molar less than halt o t ic
antepenultimate molar ; premolars or
Genus. 3. Trieenops,
Metacarpal bone of fourth finger less than that of second finger m
length ; foramen rotundum united with sphenoidal fissure , basi-occipita
tween auditory bull® narrow, not linear ; roof of mesopterygoid ossa Pieice
by foramina, not grooved, continuous posteriorly with under surface of asut
cranii ; par-occipital processes long, slender ; zygomata greatly expanded ver-
tically, not curved outwards ; last upper molar equal to three fourths of the
antepenultimate molar ; mandible pierced by an mfra-condyloid foramen ; pre-
molars
2—2
Genus. 4. Ccelops*
Metacarpal bone of index finger very long, extending ; beyond the first
phalanx of the second finger; metacarpal bone of fourth finger exceeding
that of second finger in length ; basi-occipital broad between auditory bull* ;
zygomata slender, curved outwards ; last upper molar equal to three-fourths
of the antepenultimate molar ; tail very short or absent ; premolars ^
Explanation of plate vi.
Fi^s. 1.9. Triarn ops versions, Dobson. 1. Side view of skull , U, base of skull ,
lb, iower jaw; all enlargedjdouble the natural size; 2 scapula, double size ; 3 sale
view of thorax, showing the very prominent e anna sterm, enlarged double natural
Bize • 4 4a distal extremity of humerus, enlarged four times the natural size ; 5, third
* Type Calops Trim, Blytli, Journ. As. Soo. Bengal. Dr. W. Peters has noted the
relations of this genus with Fhyllorhina. (See Monatsber. Berlin Akad., 1865, p. 644,
and also for 1871).
* 19
142
H. H. Godwin-Austen — Khasi and Garo Sills' Birds. [No. 2,
finger showing peculiar form of terminal phalanx, enlarged double natural size ; G,
proximal third of forearm, enlarged double ; 7, front view of pelvis ; 8, side view of
pelvis, both enlarged double ; 9, tibia and fibula, enlargod double.
Figs. 10-14, Phyllorhina larvata, Horsfield. 10, 10a, 106, side and base of skull
with lower jaw, all enlarged double natural size; 11, Bide view of thorax, double
sizo ; 12, 12a, distal extremity of humerus enlarged about three timos the natural
size ; 13, proximal third of forearm, enlarged double ; 14, side view of pubic and iliac
bones, enlarged double.
Thied List of limns obtained in the Khasi and Gabo Hill eanges,
WITH SOME COEEECTIONS AND ADDITIONS TO THE FOBMEE LISTS, — by
Majob H. H. Godwin-Austen, F. K. G. S., Deputy Superintendent,
Topographical Survey of India.
[Received 10th December, 1871.]
23.* Micronisus lading, Gmcl. Foot of Garos.
211. Chrysoeoccyx Sodgsoni, Moore. Garo Hills.
234. Arachnechthra asiatica, L. Bologunj.
297. Alseonax latirostris, Baffles. Garo Hills.
304, Cyornis rubiculoidet. Vigors.
312. Muscicapula sapphira, Tickell. Shoton Dorengo Peak, Garo range.
318. Siphia tricolor, Hodg.
350. Zoothera monticola, Blyth.
358a. Turdus dissimilis, Blyth. ' T. hortulorum of Sclater. Garo Hills.
399 a. Fellorneum palustrce, Jerdon, n. sp. Obtained in the beels be-
tween Bolagunj and Cliatak,
468. Iora typhia, Linn.
453. Ixo8 tristis, Blyth.
476. Kittacincla macroura, Gmel.
519. Dmneticola afjinis, Hodg. Banks of Megna, Sylhet.
522. Tribura luteoventris, Hodg.
544. Drymoipus longicaudatus, Tickell.
547. Suya criniger, Hodg.
562. Phylloscopus indicus , Jerdon. Base of Garos.
594. Budyt.es citreoloides, Hodg.
693a. Oalornis affinis, Walden.
704. Estrelda qmandava, Linn.
738. Carpodacus crythrinws, Pallas.
829. Goturnix communis, Bonaterre. Cherra Punji. October.
904. Gallicrex cristatus, Latham.
* Numbers samo as in Jerdon’s Birds of India.
143
1872.] H. H. Godvvin-Austen — Khasi and Oaro Hills’ Birds.
941. Threskiornis melanocephalus, Linn. In this specimen all the
quills are pure white. Shot in Mymensing in February.
The following alterations in nomenclature have to be made in my former
papers.
358. Tardus chrysolaus, $ recorded as from Cherra Punji, proves, on
further comparison, to be Tardus pollens, Pallas. T. dissimilis, Blytli, is very
close to this last, but may ho known at once by the very rich rufous colouring
on the sides of the breast and lining of the wings, it also wants the pale
supercilium of T. pollens. The hill is far stronger, of greater length, and pale
yellow in colour.
396. Timalia pileata, Horsf., is the Java species, and our Indian bird
differs somewhat. On comparing my specimens with the true 1\ pileata in
Lord Walden’s collection, the difference was at once apparent, a fact antici-
pated by Lord Walden at the time tlie comparison was made. I propose
that our bird should he called T. Bengalensis. The Indian form differs from
the Javanese, in the white on the forehead being larger, of darker brown on
the head, the darker tint of the back, and decidedly darker hue of the tail.
In size there is no perceptible difference. It is an interesting instance of a
race changing on its extreme limits.
146a and 1466 are both Bhyticeros plicatus ; the first being the fe-
male, the second the male.
146c. Anorhinus galeritus Dr. Jerdon now pronounces to be a new
species altogether, and he will describe it under the name of A. Austeni. I
shot the bird in the N. Cacliar Hills near Asalu.
141. Hydrocissa coronata, is albirostris, the large variety, named by
Hutton affirm, from the DeyraDoon.
405, (in 2nd list of birds), PomatorUnus erythrogenys should he P.
hypoleucos, Blyth, originally described from Aracan.
231a. Anthreptes t is Chalcoparia Singalensis, Gmelin.
With reference to some notes on my lirst paper by Mr. A. O. Hume,
where he says that 139, Serilophus rubro-pygea with the collar of shining
white must be the other species S. lunatus, I must remark that my two spe-
cimens are identical in every point, only that one has the collai well develop-
ed, in the other it is scarcely perceptible. A lunatus I never got, the points
of difference between the two species are well marked especially in the outer
tail feathers and general hue throughout the upper parts.
London, Novb. 1871.
144
[No. 2,
On Differential Galvanometers,
by Louis Schwendler, Esq.
There is one very interesting question connected with the construction
of these instruments which, as far as I know, has not yet been answered, and
which is of sufficient practical importance to form the subject of an investi-
gation.
This question may best be put as follows :
A certain battery of given electromotive force ancl given internal re-
sistance has to supply the two coils of any differential galvanometer with a
current ; what must be the resistance of either coil in order to obtain the
most delicate reading when measuring a given resistance ?*
The solution of this problem in its most general form would naturally
be extremely intricate, and could not be effected without tedious calculation,
but there is one special case where it is comparatively easy to determine the
law which connects the resistance of the coils with the external resistances
to be compared, in order to have the greatest sensitiveness of the instrument.
Suppose for instance that the two coils of a differential galvanometer
have equal resistances and equal magnetic momenta, and further that the
battery which supplies the two coils with current has an internal resistance
sufficiently small to allow of its being neglected against the resistances to be
compared. Then, on account of the battery resistance being so small, it
follows that the current through one coil is entirely independent of the total
resistance in the other, and as the two coils are supposed to have equal
magnetic momenta and equal resistances, balance can only be established by
the currents becoming equal, that is to say at or near balance each coil must
receive a current
g + w
where g is the unknown resistance of either coil,
w the resistance to be measured, and which is supposed to be known,
and E the given electromotive force of the testing battery.
At balance the diagram of this differential galvanometer is, therefore,
represented by Fig. 1.
* In tie Philosophical Magazine of May, 1866, and January, 186V, I solved a
similar question, viz. the proper resistance of the galvanometer to be employed when
testing by Wheatstone’s balance, and the result of that investigation has led me to
examine the present question.
1872.] Louis Schwendler — On Differential Galvanometers.
Fig. 1.
Now, as far as the
magnetic effect of the
two coils is concerned,
we may substitute for the
parallel circuit, Fig. 1,
the simple circuit, Fig. 2,
if we only reverse the
magnetic action of one
of the two coils, (say the
right one).
145
(Fig. 2).
And in order to have, in
this case, for the same
electromotive force E the
same current C flowing
through the coils as be-
fore, (see Fig. 1), we
must necessarily intro-
duce a resistance x
hence —
E
c =
E
E
2y + x
9 + w
therefore w — g -f- CD .
But to obtain the maximum magnetic effect in any single circuit (Fig. 2),
it is necessary that the resistance of the coil should be equal to the total
external resistance* and therefore in this case (Fig. 2)
x =2g (ID
Eliminating x from equation I and II we have
w m
(I)
To oltain the most delicate reading with a differential galvanometer , the
two coils of wh ich have equal magnetic momenta, and also equal resistances,
* This law holds good, — as can easily be shown, — for any number of coils con-
nected into a single circuit, no matter if the magnetio effects of these coils have the
same or opposite Bigu with respect to a given magnetic point.
146 Louis Sckwendler — On Differential Galvanometers. [No. 2,
the resistance of each coil should always be the third part of the resistance to
be measured.
This relation is so exceedingly simple that at first I thought it must be a
well known one, and that I only was unacquainted with it. However, I have
since carefully read the literature on the subject, and I find the above law no-
where stated, and as a further proof of its being new, I may add that none of the
differential galvanometers with which I have had occasion to deal, fulfil it.
That this relation is of the greatest importance in the construction of differ-
ential galvanometers cannot be doubted, and I have accordingly thought it
worth while to bring my investigation before the Society,
Solution of the Problem in its most general form.
Fig. 3 gives the diagram of a dif-
ferential galvanometer in its general
form, w and w' are the two resistances to
be compared and which we suppose to
be given. E is the given electromotive
force of the testing battery, and f the
total resistance in the battery branch ; — -
g and g' are the resistances of the two
coils, and their values are to be deter-
mined under the condition that the
reading, when near balance, is most de-
licate, i. e. that the slightest variation in
iv or w' causes the greatest possible
variation in the deflection of the needle.
The magnetic moment of the coil
g, when a current G passes through
it, may be designated by Y, and the mag-
netic moment of the coil g' , when
a current G ' passes through it, may be called Y'. Both these magnetic
momenta are taken with respect to the same needle, or system of needles, and
we may suppose that neither Y nor Y' alter perceptibly, when the needle, or
system of needles, slightly alters its position towards the coils, which are
supposed to be fixed. (This condition will be fulfilled as closely as possible
near balance, when the needle is approximately always in the same position
with respect to the coils, and it is only for such a case that the following
investigation is of any practical interest).
According to the principle of tire dilferential galvanometer, we have —
«° OC Y — Y'
where a represents the deflection of the needle, before balance is arrived at,
Fig. 3.
147
1872.]
Louis Schwendler — On Differential Galvanometers.
and which may be positive, zero or negative, depending on the relative
strength of the currents which at the time are acting through the coils, on
the relative position of the needle towards the coils, and on the shape and
size of the latter.
Approximately we have further
Y = m U G
Y' = m'D' G'
U and U' being the number of convolutions in the coils g and ^'respec-
tively, and m, m' representing the magnetic momenta of an average convolu-
tion (one of mean size and mean distance from the needle) in the coils g and
g ' respectively, when a current of unit strength passes through them.
Further, as the space of each coil to be filled with wire of constant
conductivity is given, we have —
D —n a/ g
U'= n Vy7
as can he easily proved.
n and n 1 are quantities independent of g and g ', so long as it may he
allowed to neglect the thickness of the insulating covering of the wire against
its diameter, which for brevity’s sake we will suppose to be the case.
With this reservation n and n ' depend entirely on the size of the coils and
on the manner of coiling.
Substituting these values, we get
a° a in n >Jg G — m1 n‘ g ' G ' I
which general expression for the deflection we may write in two different forms
either
a a m n
m n
i/0 /
a° oc in ' n
■Jj (
v J \ m‘ n’ Vy
)
r
which means that any deflections observed may he naturally considered due
to either coil. In the first form (equation I) it is considered due to the
coil g, when a current Gr
m‘ n1 \/g'
G/ flows through it, in the latter
in n \/ g
form (equation I') it is considered due to the coil g\ when a current
_ “/JL G — G ' flows through it.
m ' n ' \/g '
Now considering that the same battery E has to supply the current
to both the coils we have
, g' + v>'
N
G = E 1
Louis Schwendler — On Differential Galvanometers.
[No. 2,
US
and G ' = E
9 + 10
N
where N = (g + w) (y/ + w7) +y + w + g' -f- w')-
Thus substituting in I and I ' we get either
A
:m n E
^ (V + „._ («, + „,) i
N V «» » v9 /
t'E
and either A or A
The coefficient
^r({gl+wl)^Li^L-{g+w)\ r
N \u m n' ffg' )
on
on ' n ' ffg '
is the factor which at balance becomes zero.
m n means, therefore, nothing else than what is
on n */ g
generally called the constant of the differential galvanometer, i. e., the num-
ber by which the total resistance in one branch of the differential galvanometer
has to be multiplied, in order to obtain the total resistance in the other branch,
when balance is established. This constant of the differential galvanometer
is a given function of g and g the resistance of the coils, and as g and g '
are to be determined, by being variable, it cannot be considered a constant
-) ft I
in this investigation. But the factor is entirely independent of any
of the resistances, it represents what may appropriately be called the
‘mechanical arrangement ’ of the differential galvanometer, and may be
designated by p. It must be borne in mind that p represents an absolute
number, which theoretically may be anything with the exception of o and oo.
If p has a value equal to either of these two limits, the instrument would be
a simple galvanometer with a shunt, and not a differential galvanometer.
The deflection a may now be written more simply, as follows : —
A
K (g' +W'—P~^ C 9 + w)) = K
A'
_A
:Iv
+ v7 ( + w)\ =
N V p o/g' y ' 7
K'
v7 A
IT A
•Sg'
N
I
I'
p v7'
K and K ' being independent of g and g ', and also of w and w
N is a known function of all the resistances in the differential circuit.
A and A ' arc similar functions of g and g\ w and w' and which functions
become both zero at balance.
For the further investigation, only one of the two possible expressions
of a will be used, viz. equation I.
1872.]
Louis Schwendler — On Differential Galvanometers.
149
s°aK^i
N
Differentiating this expression with respect to w the external resistance
belonging to the coil g ', we get
da
= K
( \/ff __ A hi \/;t )
In n*
i
where II =
dN
dw'
or the variation of the deflection a, when w 1 varies, is
Sat = K {^- Jdw' = K^5w'.
Now it is clear that the instrument is most sensitively constructed
when, for the slightest variation in w /, the variation in a is greatest, lliis
will he the case if the factor <f> = ^ is as great as possible.
This factor <f> is a known function of the resistances in the circuit, and as
w and w ' are given, <f> can only be made a maximum with respect to g and
g ', the resistances of the two coils.
Thus our physical problem is reduced to the following mathematical
one :
A function <j> containing two variables is to be made a maximum, while
the two variables are fixed to each other by the relation
k/<]'
A = g ' + w' — j> ( g + id),
A being a constant with respect to g and g ' and becoming zero at balance.
Solving this question (relative maxima), we get
y _L etr -4- f 1
... II.*
(10 — g) (w ' + g') +f(w + to ' + g ' — g) _ 2 (y 4- w +/)
v (y — «’)y'
2 ffg v/y'— p (y + «0
* To some of the readers, a more detailed working out of the mathematical pro.
blem may, perhaps, be welcome; and as this will also prove to be an easy control
over the equations (II) and (II'), I will give it here in a somewhat condensed form.
We had
„ A
“ K^r A'
where K represents a constant, i. e. a quantity independent of any of the resistances
/o'
in the differential circuit (Fig. 3), while 6 = g’ + wf — p A_ (</ + w), i. c. a re-
sistance which at balance becomes = 0 ; and further
n = (g + w) (s' +»') + / (a + w +/ + “')•
Differentiating a with respect to w', and remembering that -A_ = 1, and substitut-
150
Louis Schwendler — On Differential Galvanometers .
[No. 2,
which equation with the other
g ' +■ w ' — p (g + w) — A = 0 1
v 9
gives all that is required to determine g and g and the values thus obtained
d a
d w‘
= K
j^-A
l N
W8 )
N2 I
Sa = K
l N
A ^ j Sw‘
Na
“v~
Set = K </> Siv '
Thus the variation of a is always directly proportional to </>, a known function of g
and g’, and to make 8<x for any Sw' as large as possible, we have to make <p a maxi-
mum with respect to g and g’, while g and g' are connected by the following equation
/ /
A= gr' + w'— p — j- (gf + w) I
v0
p being a constant with respect to g and g ', as also is A.
We have, therefore, to deal here with a relative maximum, and in accordance with
well known rules, we have to form the following partial differential coefficients :
d tj> _
d g
N — 2 g
d N
d g
R\ /g
d A
d g
2 v'-jN2
N2
+ A S
d N
R = — ' = 3 + W + /
s_ n/3
S“TF
d (p
d g '
2 R.
d N
d g
\/s.
N
d N
d R R_ (
dg 2 g )
d g'
N2
d R
dg
R n /g
d A
Tf'
N2
V-7 /dR 2Ri£x
= -w(jp--±L)
+ A S'
d A
d g
d A
Tp
— g p \/g'
g 2 */g
. 2 */g s/g* — p (a + ">)
2 */g >Jg'
At or near balance when A is = 0, or very small, the terms A S and A S' in the re.
spective differential coefficients are to be neglected, because neither S nor S' become
infinite for any finite values of g and g'.
Thus we have approximately :
d
N-2 g
d N
d g
R s/g
d A
d g
VjN'
N2
= P-Q
1872 ] Louis Schwendler — On Differential Galvanometers. 151
would be those which would make the reading most delicate near balance,
when the variation takes place in w', i. e., the external resistance belonging
to the coil g
If instead of differentiating the expression for a with respect to tv by
using the expression I, we had done so with respect to w by using the expres-
sion I we should have obtained in a similar way the following relation
between g and g'
(tv1 — g') ( w + g) +/ (w + io' + g — ff') 2 (g + iv J_)_ — ,
~g „ /-/ u JrU\
n'
r
which equation connected with the other
2 -Jg Vh'
P
Cl(f)
dg '
further we will substitute :
dg
- +
dA_
E y/f> dg '
N2
= — (P ' + Q ')
d A
d g
d A
d g •
= $
Thus we have the following differential equation :
(P_Q)d3_(P'+Q')^'+ « dg + /3dg,y)= 0
\ being the undetermined factor. From this equation we have .
P_ Q + Aa = 0
and — (P' + QO + X 0 = 0
or A. eliminated : p _ Q p/ + Q/
5 -8
but we have always : n y
Q hs
ot £
thus we have as end-equation :
P __ P'
ot 0
or the value for P, P a and 0 substituted we have :
2 g dN 2dN.
N“ ST _
further substituting
p g'(g — W)
dN
dg
dN
dg'
and reducing as much as possible, we have
(w - g) (w' + g ')+/(«’ + >«' + !>'— g)
a s/g n/s ' — p (? + M)
= g'+ w'+/
— g + w +f
2 (g + w + f)
II
p (s - u-7? a V? >/»'— P(3 + ,u)
which is the equation II as given above.
In quite a similar manner, equation II ' can be found, it must only be remembered
that it is more simple to use expression I ' for the purpose than I.
[No. 2.
152
W. T Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim .
+ = 1
gives all that is necessary to determine g and g ', being those values which
would make the reading at or near balance most sensitive when a variation
in w, the external resistance belonging to coil g, takes place.
Now it is clear that equations II and II' are not necessarily identical,
as long as p does not fulfil certain conditions, and therefore the first set of
equation II and 1 may give entirely different values for g and g ' from those
obtained from the second set II ' and I), which means that a simultaneous
maximum sensitiveness with respect to an alteration of the external re-
sistances w1 in either of the two differential branches, is not always
possible. The following very important and interesting question, therefore,
remains to be solved.
What general condition must he fulfilled in the construction of any
differential galvanometer in order to make a simultaneous maximum sensi-
tiveness possible , with respect to an alterat ion of external resistance in either
of the differential branches ?
[To bo continued.']
Notes on a collection of birds from Sikkim,
by W. T. Blanford, F. G. S.— C. M. Z. S.
(With Plates VH and VIII.)
[Received and read 6th September, 1871.]
Mr. L. Mandelli of Darjiling lias sent to me for determination a most
interesting collection of Sikkim birds, together with a few obtained from the
plains near the base of the Himalayas. The birds sent are from various
elevations, some being evidently from considerable altitudes. Strange as it
may appear, after this chosen land of the feathered tribes bad been explored
and ransacked for years by such ornithologists as Hodgson, Jerdon, Tickell
and many others, it yet yields novelties to so energetic a collector as Mr.
Mandelli. Amongst the birds sent is a sixth Himalayan species of Propasser,
indicated, it is true, some years since by Mr. Blyth, but not hitherto described,
and the male of which was previously unknown. There is also a new
Pellorneum, and apparently one or two undescribed warblers. Two other
birds are additions to the fauna of India, and new localities are furnished for
a few others.
To my notes on Mr. Mandelli’s collection I have added some on birds col-
lected by myself at low elevations in Sikkim. In another paper (antea p. 30),
I have given a complete list of all the birds observed or collected by mo in the
1872.] W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim. 153
«
alpine and subalpine parts of the country, hut as the fauna of the Sikkim
pine forests differs entirely from that of the warm valleys, I have restricted
the notes in my other paper to the former.
[The numbers prefixed to the birds refer to those in Jerdon’s Birds of
India.]
56 a. Milvus melanotis, Temm. and Schl.
Fauna Japonica, Aves, PI. iv and v.
Milvus major, Hume. Rough notes, Pt. I, p. 326.
After comparing a good series of specimens from the Godavari valley
with Temminck and Schlegel’s figures and description in the Fauna Japonica,
I have come to the conclusion that Mr. Hume’s first idea, J. A. S. B., 1870,
p. 114, was correct, and that the large Indian kite is identical with the
Japanese. Mr. Hume has evidently been misled by Radde and Schrenk,
who identify M. melanotis with M. migrant, and he especially mentions
(p. 325) that he has not access to the original description or measurements.
Of course a bird only as large as M. migrant would be much smaller than
M. major.
In the Fauna Japonica, however, it is expressly stated that M. melanotis
is as large as II. regalis, but distinguished by the tail being less deeply forked,
not more than in M. cetolius (i. e. migrant). The measurements given are ;
length 23 to 24 French inches, wing 17] to 18, tail 101 to 11, tarsus 2r\,
mid toe If. The sexes are said to differ in size. The above are the
dimensions of males of II. major, (the corresponding English measures
being, whig 19*, tail Ilf, tarsus 2f,) and the adult female is considerably
larger. There is, therefore, an element of doubt in the identification,
because one of the birds described by Temminck and Schlegel is said to
be an adult female. But as it is admitted by everybody that there is
no distinction in the plumage, and as the male of Milvus melanotis clearly
equals the male of II. major in size, it appears to me more probable
that there has been a mistake as to the sex marked on one of the dried
skins examined by the European naturalists, than that two representatives
of II regalis should be found in Eastern Asia.
This magnificent kite appears to be more widely spread in India than
was supposed at first, and it is remarkable it should have been so long
overlooked. I obtained two specimens in Sikkim, one shot by Captain
Elwes’s shikari at Tamldng, the other a young bird in the plumage described
at p. 327 of Mr. Hume’s “Bough Notes” as that of a young female. The
wing measures 19 5 in., so the bird was probably a male.
I have also in February and April of the present year 1871 shot Milvus
melanotis on the Godavari near Bhadrachalam, about one hundred miles
north of Yelaur (Ellore). I obtained three specimens, one of them as late
154
[No. 2,
W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim.
as April, and I suspect the bird to be a permanent resident in the plains,
and probably spread elver the northern and eastern part of India. Like
other Chinese birds, it may be wanting in Western India.
My observations on the habits of M. melanotis differ from those of Mr.
Hume so far, that although at times it is certainly wary and difficult of
approach, in other cases I have met with it close to human habitations.
I shot one flying over my tent, and another a few paces away, near a village
in each case, and a third, a fine adult female, I shot sitting on a tree in the
middle of a village. I expect Milvus govinda, if it found itself limited,
would prove equally wary.
71. H iram a Nipalensis, Hodgs.
I obtained a single specimen of this fine owl in the Tista valley, Sikkim,
a little below Chungtam at an elevation of about 4000 feet. It was sitting
on a high tree, in lofty, rather open forest, and calling at about 3 o’clock
in the afternoon.* The cry is a single deep hoot. Unfortunately the body
was thrown away without my determining the sex. I took measurements
before skinning, and the following is a brief description of the plumage which
differs somewhat from that noted by Dr. Jerdon.
Above dark hair brown, all the feathers, except those of the head, having
the margins mottled with pale fulvous, the amount increasing on the lower
back, until some of the feathers are mottled throughout. Upper tail coverts
with several rather broad fulvous bars. Scapularies with broad irregular
mottled bands and tips, and some of the largest with nearly the whole outer
web pale isabelline fulvous, forming a distinct bar. Ear tufts 3y inches long,
blackish brown on the greater portion of the outer webs, mottled with white
on the inner and base of the outer, the white prevailing towards the base on
the longest feathers. Lores with long bristly plumes, which are dirty white
near the base, and tipped brown ; ear coverts greyish white, the upper ones
tipped brown ; quills earthy brown, the primaries faintly banded, secondaries
with broad mottled bars on the outer webs becoming white on the inner.
Outer tail feathers similar to the secondaries, central with about six mottled
bars ; all the rectrices tipped pale brown, whitish at the extreme end. Chin
with greyish bristly feathers like the lores, all the rest of the under parts,
under wing coverts, tibial and tarsal feathers white with huge brown spots.
Toes feathered nearly to the base of the claws. Iris brown, bill and toes
yellow, claws dusky at points, pale at base. Length (of fresh specimen) 21),
expanse 58, wing 17'5, tail 9'25, tarsus 3,f bill from gape 2'1, from end
* Mr. Hodgson, in his original description of this bird, As. Bos. XIX, p. 172,
mentions its diurnal habits.
+ This I find in my note book, but I make the dried tarsus about 2f to 2f, it is
very difficult to measure on account of the thick feathers. Jerdon gives 2 in., which is
certainly too little, but his measurements are those of H. pectoralis.
1872.] W. T. Blanford — On Birds from SihJcim. 155
of cere P43, mid claw straight to point 12, inner claw 16, hind claw
1‘3 inch.
This bird differs from Jerdon’s original description of R. pectoralis,
Madras Journal, Lit. and Sc., Vol. x, p. 89 in the following characters :
The aigrettes are not barred, the feathers of the throat are not barred
but spotted ; there is no distinct pectoral band, a slight fulvous tinge on the
sides of the breast is all that appears. The bill is yellow, not greenish homy,
the toes bright yellow, not reddish yellow. The tarsus appears to be decid-
edly longer. I should say, judging from the description and Jerdon s figure,
that the two forms are distinct species, (conf. Blyth, Ibis, 1866, p. 25-1).
The Butia name of this owl is Migdori.
80. Gi.aitcidtum bbodiei, (Burton).
The differences in plumage in this bird are remarkable. I have thiee
specimens lying before me, one being from Mr. Mandelli s collection. In the
first, probably a young bird the whole plumage lias a rufous tint. The
head feathers with broad bars of reddish buff, the tail with 8 bars, each
in. broad, extending right across the feather. In the second, the whole
prevailing colour is very dark brown, the head with small buff spots, the tail
(newly moulted and not fully grown) with narrow bars not extending across
the central part of the feather. The third specimen is more rufous than the
second, but less than the first, the tail feathers are crossed by 7 bars, interrupt-
ed near the shafts, whilst the head is greyish brown, unspotted behind and
with only a few faint spots on the forehead. This evidently leads to the
form described by Mr. Hume in the Ibis, 1871, p. 26, and referred to under
the name of G. immaculatus in his Bough Notes, Part I, p. 4^0.
156. Piers cATHPUABirs, Hodg.
In two males, sent by Mr. Mandelli, the bars on the outer rectrices are
fulvous, not white. The wings measure 375 and 39 in.
157. P. Macei, Vieil.
Specimens from Sikkim differ from those shot near Calcutta m having a
somewhat dingy grey tinge with faint subobsolete streaks below, instead of
buff. I doubt if the distinction be worthy of specific rank, hut so far as I
can judge it seems to be constant* I have two specimens, including one sent
* Sinco writing the above I have received from Mr. Mandelli a very peculiar
specimen of a woodpeeker, which I can only suppose to be an old bird ofP. Macei in a
state of semi-albinism. The back is brown, instead of black, and the middle rectrices
have one distinct white spot on each web, and a second a little fainter about a quarter
inch further back. Otherwise it agrees with-P. Macei. The dimensions exceed those
givon by Jerdon, the wing being 4i inch long, but I find Bengal specimens equally
large.
15G
W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Si/cHm.
[No. 2,
by Mr. Mandelli, and I find a third in the Indian Museum collection, which
contains an abundance of Calcutta specimens. If the Himalayan race be
seperahle, it might bear Hodgson’s name pyrriceps. The figures in the
Planches Colories and in Malherbe’s Monograph are of the Bengal race.
1G3. Yu.xorncus pyGMJeus (Vigors). Sikkim.
94. Chemdojt Nipalensis, (Hodg.)
I found this bird tolerably common in the Tista valley between Chung-
tam and Tamlung, often hunting in company with Collocalia nidifica. None
were seen above about 5000 feet elevation.
2G3. Tephbodornis pei.vica, (Hodgs.)
An adult (male ?) is sent by Mr. Mandelli, and I have two skins pur-
chased at Darjiling, one perhaps that of a female, agreeing with Swinhoe’s
description of that sex from a Hainan specimen, Ibis, 1870, p. 242, except
that the eye streak is well marked, and the lower points brownish. It is
probably a young bird, for there are some pale markings on the edges of the
secondary quills. The bill, however, is black throughout. The dimensions
(in inches) rather exceed those given by Jerdon and Swinhoe.
wing. tail, tarsus, bill from forebead, bill from gape.
1. Adult (? male),... 4 65 3 7 0 83 0 85 1-15
2. ? Female, 4'6 3-35 0 83 0'8 11
3. Young, 4'7 3-6 0 83 0 77 IT
The third has the plumage above rather light brown, with traces of
white bars on the hack, the feathers of the head with pale centres, eye streak
brown, secondary quills and tail feathers with rufous borders, and an
interrupted dark streak, inside the pale border, the tips being mottled ;
lower parts brownish, but paler than in No. 2 ; hill pale coloured throughout.
270. Graitcaiyjs Macei, Less.
A young bird from Sikkim is moulting, and exchanging its nestling
plumage for that of the adult. Some of the nestling feathers remain, those
on the back are earthy brown with pale edges, those on the lower parts
brownish grey, also with pale edges, hut there are not many left, so that it
is difficult to say to what extent tho under surface is barred in this stage.
It is evident, however, that the bars, if they exist, are much broader than in
the form commonly described as the young,* and much browner in colour.
The new feathers on the other hand are pure ashy grey on the throat and
upper breast, barred on the lower breast, abdomen and thigh coverts, the
vent being white. Wing 7*2, tail 5'6, tarsus 1T2 inch.
This is a very interesting specimen, because it proves that it is not the
young bird, nor the bird of the second year, which is barred underneath
* Hartlaub Jour. F. Ornith, 1864, p. 440.
1872.] W. T. Blanfoi'd — On Birds from Sikkim. 157
throughout. I know that in the race inhabiting the Central Provinces the
female is barred beneath at all ages. I have four specimens from Chfinda and
the Godavari valley, all females, and there are three more in the Indian Mu-
seum from Singbhum, Chutia Nagpur, &c. Several are evidently adults, all are
barred beneath on the throat and breast. Indeed, I am far from sure that the
male of the Central Indian form is not also barred, one specimen in the
Indian Museum marked as a male from Chutia Nagpur certainly is so, but a
male from Manbhum resembles the Himalayan bird, except that it is a little
smaller, wing 6'75. This, however, may belong to the Eastern Bengal race,
which is found in the Himalayas and East of the Bay of Bengal. The Indian
form proper is, as a rule, rather smaller with a slightly smaller bill.*
G. Lm/ardi, Blyth (fO.ptmllus olim) Ibis, 1866, p. 368, is apparently
quite distinct, for it is said to have the anterior under wing coverts barred,
which is never the case in adults of the Central Indian form, and, according
to Mr. Blyth, the breast in the female of G. Layardi is not barred. A descrip-
tion of the adult female of G . Macei from Chanda may be useful to enable
ornithologists with better collections to determine how far the Indian form
is separable from the Himalayan, Eastern Beugal and Burmese race.
Upper parts bluish grey, the feathers of the rump and upper tail coverts
with whitish edges. Central tail feathers a rather browner grey, outer tail
feathers brown, passing into white at the tips, the white tips, being veiy
narrow and soon worn off on the central feathers, so that they can only be
detected in freshly moulted plumage, but increasing progressively in length
until in the outermost restrices they are f in. to an inch long. Quills brown,
all but the 1st narrowly edged inside and outside with white, the last second-
aries (tertiaries) with the outer web grey. Lores dusky grey, a dark band
from them passing through the eye and comprising the ear coverts. Lower
plumage greyish white barred with darker grey on the throat and breast ; ab-
domen and under tail coverts white, with a few dusky bars, further apart
than on the breast, on the upper part of the belly and on the flanks.
Measurements (in inches) taken before skinning
Length wing tail tarsus bill from forehead bill from gape
12 6 6 to G-75 5-25 1‘ °'9 14
Young birds have the grey of the head less pure, and the lower parts white,
barred with dusky, the bars in some cases extending to the vent.
If the races from Central India and the Himalaj as be distinguishable,
it remains to be seen which is G. Macei of Lesson. The Himalayan and
Barmese races are identical, I believe.
631 a. Zosteeops simplex, Swinhoe.
Two specimens from Eastern Nipal, sent to me by Mr. Mandelli, belong
to this race, which must be added to the Birds of India. The difference
* This has been, I find, noticed by Beavan, Ibis, 1867, p. 322.
21
158
W. T. Blanford — On Birds from SUckim .
[No. 2,
from Z. palpebrosus is very slight, being precisely, as mentioned by Mr.
Swinhoe, Ibis, 1870, p. 848, the smaller size of Z. simplex, and the greener
tinge of the upper parts. I find other specimens from the Western Himalayas
in the Indian Museum also referable to the Chinese race, whilst, as so frequent-
ly happens, specimens from the base of the Himalayas are intermediate in
colour. But as there is no distinction either in hue or size between birds from
China and others from the Himalayas, and as those from the plains of India
appear equally constant, I think these two races are fairly distinguishable,
and that the intermediate forms are hybrids. I append the dimensions (in
inches) of the Himalayan birds and of two specimens of Z. palpebrosus.
The Nilgiri race is a little larger than Z. palpebrosus, and of the same
colour as Z. simplex, but the difference is not great, and I have hut one
specimen for comparison, (Confr. J. A. S. B. 18G9, Pt. II, p. 170).
308. C tortus magnirostris, Blyth.
A female of this rare bird is amongst Mr. Mandelli’s specimens, and I
find a male in the Indian Museum collection, also from Darjiling. The latter
agrees well with Major Godwin- Austen’s description, .1. A. S. B. 1870, p. 100.
The central tail feathers are the same colour as the black. Mr. Blyth Ibis,
I860, p. 371, compares the coloration with that of Oyornis rubeculoides,
but C. magnirostris has not the blue throat of that species, on the other
hand the coloration approaches so closely to that of O. Jerdoni, that the
two species can only he distinguished by the rather darker blue of the back,
and the larger size and powerful bill of C. magnirostris.
The female has, I think, been described by Jerdon from the rather
faded type specimen in the Asiatic Society’s collection, the following is an
account of the coloration in a fresh specimen. Upper parts olive, forehead
and lores rufescent, feathers around eye pale ferruginous, tail browner than
back, with a ferruginous tinge on the margins of the feathers ; quills dark
brown, all but the first two broadly margined with dull rufous. Major
Godwin-Austen has overlooked Mr. Blyth’s description of the male of this
species from Hodgson’s drawings, Ibis, 18G6, p. 371.
Under parts ferruginous, deepest on the breast, flanks olive, lower
abdomen and under tail coverts white.
159
1872.] W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikleim.
325. ? Ekttheostebna acoebaus, Hodgs.
(Conf. J. A. S. B. 1869, Pt. II, p. 174).
A specimen from Darjiling which I am disposed to refer to this species
has the upper parts olivaceous, whilst on the forehead there is a single blue
feather. Can the male bird be blue ? I have nothing else to add to the
suggestion of Mr. Hume that this form may be the female of B. maculata
(J. A. S. B. 1870, Pt. II, p. 116).
320. SlPHIA LEUCOMELATOJEA, (HodgS.)
Of two specimens sent by Mr. Mandelli, one has the whole chin, throat
and upper breast white, and the lower breast and abdomen sordid brown,
the other has only the chin and throat white, and the rest of the lower parts,
except the lower tail coverts, isabelline. In both the quills are brown, the
primaries and all the secondaries, except the last 4 or 5, with rufescent
margins. The female has been described by Dr. Stoliczka, J. A. S. B. 1868,
Pt. II, p. 32.
321. S. strPEBcnjAEis, (Blyth).
Of this also two specimens are sent by Mr. Mandelli. The quills are
brown with rufous margins, the central rectrices the same colour as the
back, lateral rectrices darker, those nearest the centre with narrow faint
subobsolete transverse bands, all margined with cyaneous ; extreme base of
all rectrices, except the centre pair, white. In one specimen the ferruginous
colour of the breast is mixed with olivaceous. Wing 2'3, tail 1'75, tarsus 0 7,
bill 0-32 inch.
313. Xitidui.a Hodgsoni, (Moore).
The only specimen differs somewhat, both in colour and dimensions
from Dr. Jerdon’s description. The quills are dark brown, not black, the
secondaries externally with blue edges, the lores and ear coverts appear to
be blue, and the colour below is rich ferruginous, as deep as in Larvivora
superciliaris. Wing 1'9, tail 1'25, tarsus 0'63, bill from forehead 0'35, from
gape 048 inch.
This bird appears to me rather to consort with the Buticillmce than with
the Muscicapime. Its bill is slightly more depressed than that of Icmlhia
or Larvivora, and its legs a little shorter, but the difference is very small.
The fact is, that the distinction between the two families is rather difficult
to determine in these Himalayan forms. The bird was described by Moore
as a Nemura 0 =Ianthia ). Mr. G. E. Gray, in his very useful Hand-list of
genera and species of birds, evidently by oversight, quotes it twice ; as
Nemura Hodgsoni (3188) at p. 222, and as Nitidula Hodgsoni (4903) at
p. 327.
ICO
W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim.
[No. 2,
329. Pnoepyga sqtjamata, (Gould). Tesia rufi venter, Hodgs.
Of two specimens received one has the upper parts nearly uniform
olivaceous brown, the other has a small bright ferruginous spot at the apex
of nearly every feather. Both have the lower parts ferruginous, the feathers
with olive centres and narrow dusky margins. Prom the differences in the
upper plumage, it is evident that the colour of the lower parts does not
change with age, (vide antea, p. 55).
338. Brachypteeyx ceueaxis, Blyth.
A pair, male and female, are sent by Mr. Mandelli, and I have a young
bird, shot by myself, which I am inclined to refer to this species, although
the tarsi are longer than in the adult specimens, whilst the bill is much
shorter. It may belong to an undescribed form, so I give a description.
Plumage generally olive brown, all the feathers of the upper parts,
throat and breast with rufous centres, upper tail coverts rufous, belly pale
brown. Wing 2’55, tail 1*7, tarsus 1*3, bill from forehead 0'43 inch.
336. Brachypteeyx ntpaxensis, Hodgs.
A single specimen from Darjiling has the wings rufous brown, the
margins being more rufous than the rest of the feathers. The grey of the
breast is mixed with white, and there is a greyish tinge on the feathers of
the throat and abdomen in places. This may be a young male. Wing
2'4, tail 1'5, tarsus 1'08, bill from forehead, 0'47.
I fully agree with Mr. Hume (Ibis, 1870, p. 529) in considering
Hodgsonius as closely alied to Larvivpra, but I cannot see the possibility
of dissociating it, and Callene, from Brachypteryx, as is done by Mr. G. R.
Gray, in his recent “ Hand-list of Birds,” in which he places the last
named in the Leiotlirichince* (a position unsuited for it in my opinion,) and
all the other genera named, with Ruticilla, in the Lusciniince. Brachypteryx
nipalensis is very much like a Calliope, and- although there is also a
similarity to Pnoepyga, it is I think not so marked, partly perhaps because
there is no resemblance in the general coloration.
It is a pity we have no details of the nidilication of Brachypteryx, as it
would aid in shewing its affinities. The nest of Callene frontalis is said to
be wren-like, Ibis, 1866, p. 373, but the allied O. albiventris, (P. Z. S. 1867,
p. 834), nidificates in a hole of a tree, and lays but two eggs. Unless the
length of a bird’s tail be taken as the most important point in its structure,
I do not see how Callene and Brachypteryx can be classed apart, and I am
* Prof Newton, in the Zoological Record places Brachypteryx amongst tha
Timaliidm. Some Malayan forms, formerly assigned to Brachypteryx belong to this
family, (Ibis, 1865, pp. 33, 47), bat the Himalayan species differ greatly in structure
and habits from the Timaline birds.
161
1872.] W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim.
disposed to separate both from the wrens, and also from Myiophonus, and
class them with Hodgsonius, Imthia , Larvivora, Tarsiger, and Calliope, either
in the JRuticillina, or as a distinct subfamily. I am not sure but that
Nitidula might be added.
529. Hobeites majob, Hodgs.
I obtained a specimen on Sinchal near Darjiling.
498. RimcrLLA HoDGSOirci, Moore. Sikkim.
570. Lanthia supeeciiiabis, (Hodgs.)
The female appears rather smaller than the dimensions given by Dr.
Jerdon. I find in one from Darjiling, wing 305, tail 2 5, tarsus, 117, bill
from forehead 0'45 inch. The distinctions between this form and lanthia
rtf lata scarcely appear to warrant generic separation.
507. Laevitoea sitpeectliaeis, (Jerdon).
The chin in the male is white, with a black streak on each side, thigh
coverts mixed with grey. Wing 2'82, tail l-/ 5, tarsus 1 , bill flora forehead
0'45, from gape 0'03 inch. _ ,
Placing this species beside a series of flycatchers, including got ms
Jerdoni, C. magnirostris , Siphia superciliaris and Nitidula Hodgsom, it is
curious to remark the extraordinary similarity in the colouring, an i .
distribution, whilst, except the bill, there is really very little structural
difference between these various birds. The tarsi vary in len0 i cer am y,
but all have rather long than short tarsi.
477. Mi’IOMF.la letjcttba, Hodgs.
I shot a male of this species at Darjiling ; it was running along a road
in the evening at dusk. Mr. Mandelli has sent a female The white on the
tail, judging from these specimens, occurs on all the feathers except the
central and outer pairs, audit increases inwardly, not outwardly, as stated by
Jerdon.
594. Bttdttes citeeoltjs, (Pall).
A Sikkim specimen has the wing 8* in., and is consequently the larger
race, if there be two, or B. citreolus , Pall., verus.
766. Axattda aetexsis.
Amongst the specimens procured by me at Darjiling is a skin of a lark,
which to the best of my recollection, was purchased with some other skins
of birds, evidently shot in the neighbourhood, from a shikari. It only differs
from English specimens of the skylark by its greyer tint on the back and
hind neck! Wing 4 2, tail 2'55, bill 045, tarsus 0 98, hind toe and claw 1'08,
claw alone 0'65 inch.
162 W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim. [No. 2,
The occurrence of A. arvensis so far to the eastward strongly confirms
Mr. Blyth’s view of the identity of A. triborhyncha, Hodgs. (Ibis, 1867,
p. 47) with it.
560a. PiiYr.i.oscopUS paltudipes, sp. nov. PI. vii.
P. supra umbrino-olivaceus, uropygio magis rufesoenti ; loris ei lined
postoculari umbnnis, superciliis albis, postice elongatis ; remigibus umbrinis,
extus rufeseente olivaceo marginatis, rectricibus mediis cum dorso fere
concoloribus, carter is umbrinis, olivacco-marginatis ; gastro sericeo-albo,
pectoris lateribus olivaceis, axilld albu ; rostro supra fusco, infra pallido ;
pedibus albescentibus. Long, alas 2 '05, caudae 17, tarsi 0 76, rostri a fronte
0'4, a rictu 0'55 unc.
Brownish olivaceous above, supercilium white, extending far back, a
dark line from the lores through the eye to the upper part of the ear coverts,
the lower portion of which are light brown, central rectrices very little darker
than the back, outer rectrices and wing feathers earthy brown, margined with
olive which is rufescent on the edges of the quills. There is also a rufescent
tinge on the rump. Lower parts silky white, sides of the breast dusky
olivaceous, and the middle of the breast not quite so fine a white as the
throat and abdomen, but this may be an individual peculiarity. Lower
wing coverts, axillaries, and forepart of wing white. Bill dark above, pale
below ; feet very light coloured. The fifth quill is the longest, it exceeds the
first by 0-87 in., the second by 04, the third by 015.
This form of which a single example in beautiful order has been sent
by Mr. Mandelli appears to me quite new. It is near P. neglectus, Hume,
Ibis, 18/0, p. 143, but differs in its olivaceous tint above, smaller size and
in the very pale coloured tarsi and feet. It is also quite distinct from
P. tristis, Bl., P.fuscatus, Bl., P. lugubris, Bl., and from the various species
described from China by Mr. Swinlioe, P. tenellipes , Swinh., alone resembling
it in its pale feet, but differing in colour.
Beocloides sp. ?
A single specimen from Mr. Mandelli’s collection closely resembles It.
proregulus, Pall. (B. chloronotus, Hodgs.) in appearance and size, and has a
similar minute bill though a little broader and more Abrornis- like, but the
head is dusky grey, almost black, with a white central line and white
supercilia, a distinct dusky line from the lores through the eyes ; cheeks,
throat and breast greyish white, lower breast and abdomen pale yellow, the’
two outer tail feathers on each side have the whole inner web white, and’ the
third has nearly the whole, a very narrow border inside the web near the tip
emg brown, but the tip of the inner web itself white, not dark as in It.
163
1872.] W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim.
erochroa. The wings and central rectrices are earthy hrown with green
outer margins, margin of wing yellow, inner whig coverts and inner margins
of quills white, a little pale yellow on the axillaries, hack olive, rump
yellowish white. Bill dark throughout, without the pale base beneath of
II. proregulus. Wing T82, tail 1’2, tarsus 07, bill from forehead 03,
do. from gape 0-38 inch.
This appears to me to he an undescribed species. It is possible that it
may be Abrornis maculipennis, Blyth, but in that case the measurement of
the wing, Ibis 1867, p. 27, given as 275 in. must be a misprint for 1 75.
This is possible, for the length of the tarsus is misprinted evidently. The bill
in the specimen before me is somewhat between that of Reguloides and
Abrornis, but the plumage is that of the former genus.
Reguloides sp. P
This is again a single specimen, and may possibly be a variety of the last.
It differs in being larger, but having a still shorter bill, and m the tips of the
larger wing coverts being golden yellow, almost orange. There is a yellow
tip in the outer web of the last few secondary (tertiary) quills which aie in
bad condition in the specimen last described, thus adding to the similarity
to Abrornis maculipennis. The legs appear to differ in colour from those in
the speeimen last described. Wing 2, tail T35, tarsus 0'/ , bill from forehead
0'27, from gape 0'35 inch.
570. Cplicipeta caetatok, (Tickell).
Mr. Blyth calls this an Abrornis (Cat. Birds As. Soc. Mus. p. 183, and
Ibis, 1867, p. 26). Two specimens which I can only refer to this bird are
amongst Mr. Mandelli’s despatch. The bill appears to me intermediate
in form between Abrornis and Culieipeta, whilst the plumage is that of the
latter genus, or rather of Reguloides. In fact but for the bill, the skins
might be considered small specimens of R. trochiloides.
As there is no specimen of O. cantator in the Indian Museum, it is just
possible I may be in error in the present identification. The birds do not
agree very closely with Jerdon’s description. The following are their
characters.
Head greenish dusky above with an irregular whitish central streak,
supercilia pale yellow, sides of head mixed dull green and whitish. Back dull
green, a little lighter on the rump. Wings and tail brown, edged with green
externally, the three outer rectrices on each side having the inner web mar-
gined and tipped with white, most broadly on the outer feathers. Tips of
wing coverts pale yellow, forming two bars ; edge of wing and axillaries pure
yellow ; under parts greenish or yellowish white. Bill dusky above, pale
below ; feet rather dark.
574. Abeoenis sitpeeciliabis, Ticlcell.
J. A. S. B., 1859 p. 414, — A. flaviventris, Jerdon, Birds of India, vol. ii, p. 203.
As pointed out by Mr. Blytli, Ibis, 1867, p. 26, Daijiling specimens
appear to agree with those from Tenaserim.
577. A. ABBOGTTBAEIS, HodgS.
Top of head rufous olive, with a black band on each side above the rusty
supercilia, wings yellowish white within.
579. Tickelbia Hodgsoni, (Moore).
Mr. Mandelli has obtained three specimens of this rare bird, two of
which appear to have no yellow in the middle of the rump, only the sides
being of that colour. The fifth and sixth quills in both specimens slightly
exceed the fourth in length.
519«. Dumeticoia bethweipectijs, Blyth, Ibis, 1867, p. 20.
The following is the description of a specimen sent by Mr. Mandelli.
Upper parts uniform olive brown, quills and outer rectrices brown with
margins of the same colour as the back ; lores whitish, chin, throat and
middle of belly dirty white, sides of neck and breast the same colour as
the back, middle of the breast pale brown, thigh coverts, vent and under
tail coverts olive brown, the last named with white tips of no great breadth,
about OT in. ; bill black, feet brown. Wing 2'3 in., tail 2, the central
feathers exceeding the outer by 03, tarsus OS2, bill from forehead 0 38, from
gape 0'55. The fifth quill is the longest, the fourth very little shorter,
third less by OT, second by 0'37 and first by 1 inch.
522. Teibtjea luteoventbis, -Hodgs.
I refer to this species a specimen sent by Mr. Mandelli, but which has
not a trace of yellow on the lower parts.* The only example of Hodgson’s
species in the Indian Museum is in very bad order, and the colours have
* In Hodgson’s original description P. Z, S. 1845, p. 30, the bird is said to be
above olive brown with a luteous lustre, below lutoscont laterally, and albescent cen-
trally, a pale line over the eyo. This agrees much better with the speoimon before
me than does J erdon’s account in the 1 Birds of India.’
W. T. Blanford — On Birds from SiJcIcim.
105
1872.]
faded so much that it is difficult to form an idea of what they originally
were. I append a description of Mr. Mandelli’s bird.
Above uniform rufescent brown with an olivaceous tinge, wings and
tail rather darker brown, the former with the margins of the feathers rather
more rufous, sides of head and indistinct supercilia paler. Beneath, the
chin and throat are dirty white, the remainder of the lower parts a similar
colour to the back but paler, albescent towards the vent. W ing 2T, tail 2'4,
much graduated, the outer feathers 1’2 shorter, tarsus 073, bill from forehead
039, from gape OG2 inch.
The figure of Galamodyta offinis in Gray’s Genera of Birds, PI. xlix, stated
by Mr. Blyth, Ibis, 1867, p. 19, to represent this species, is altogether paler
and more rufous than the specimen sent to me. It might have been taken
from a faded specimen, but I cannot help thinking it possible that two forms
are confounded under this species. Can one of them be ILorornis fortipes ?
535. P n inly Stewakti, Blyth.
A specimen sent by Mr. Mandelli is probably from Pamiya or Tirhut.
It is certainly smaller than specimens of P. socialis which I possess from
the neighbourhood of Yelaur (Ellore), and the grey of the back is darker and
purer, but the bill, though rather shorter, appears decidedly broader at the
base. Wing 1'82, tail 2T, tarsus 085, bill from forehead 0'42, from
gape 055 inch.
537. P. cikeeeo-capilia, Hodgs.
Head, nape and hind neck, lores and upper ear-coverts rather earthy
brown, remainder of upper parts very rufous brown, ochraeeous on the rump,
most rufous on the wings and tail ; quills hah brown, margined with rufous ;
tail feathers more rufous, with pale tips, and a distinct dark spot just before
it. Supereilium and lower parts white, with a faint creamy tinge, sides of
breast olivaceous, flanks rufous, thigh coverts ferruginous ; wing 175, tail
1-78, tarsus, 0'8, bill from forehead 04, from gape 055 inch.
This differs a little from Jerdon’s description ; his length of the bill f in.
must be a misprint for -J. From P. gracilis the much more rufous lower
back, wing and tail, and the darker head, serve easily to distinguish the
present species, but the under parts with the exception of the thigh coverts
are not more rufous. The bill appears to be a little stouter.
391. Staciixeis x io in ceps, Hodgs.
A specimen wants the white supereilium and has the fore-neck bright
rufous, much more rufous than the abdomen. Wing 2'2, tail 1'85, tarsus
085, bill 0'G5 inch.
399a. Pelloeneitm Mandeleii, sp. nov. PI. VII.
P. per affine P. ruficepi, Swains., sed statura minori, collo postico et
laterali macalis fuscis magnis signato, maculis pectoralibus majoribus et
22
[No. 2,
166 W. T Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim.
satmatioribus. Long, alee 2'65, caudce 2'5, tarsi 0 95, rostri afronte 0'6, a
rictu O' 75 me.
Crown of head and nape ferruginous, lores, over and under the eye, pale
pinkish isabelline, most of the feathers of the forehead, lores and supercilia
with slight dusky tips, ear coverts pale rufous brown, also with dark tips,
back of the neck isabelline, or pale brown, each feather with a large dusky
spot, frequently confined to one web, mantle and tail brownish olive, all the
rectrices except the centre ones with narrow pale tips, quills hair brown mar-
gined with brownish olive externally, internally, like the lining of the wing,
pale brown. Chin and upper throat pure white, remainder of lower parts
isabelline, breast and sides of neck with large elongate dusky spots, flanks
also spotted, but the spots are paler, abdomen unspotted. Bill dusky above,
pale below, legs very pale coloured.
This species differs from P. rufeeps, Swains., and P. Tickelli, Blyth, (J .
A. S. B., 1859, Yol. xxviii, p. 414 ; = P. subocliraceum, Swinhoe, A. and
M. N. II. , April, 1871, p. 257), by having the neck spotted all round and by
the spots in front being much deeper and darker. In size it resembles P .
Tickelli , being smaller than P. rufeeps. It may perhaps be the new species
from the Khasi hills mentioned by Dr. Jerdon in Birds of India, II, p. 28.
A single specimen has been sent to me for identification by Mr. Mandelli,
after whom I have named it.
620. Mixla cdteeea, (Blyth).
The type of this species is a very dull coloured grey specimen. I am
almost inclined to doubt, if the much more brightly coloured birds described
by Jerdon, and of which a specimen is sent by Mr. Mandelli, are really iden-
tical, but a series is necessary for deciding this. In the bird sent to me the
wing measures 2T, tail T5, tarsus 0'82 inch. ; the dimensions are rather less
than those of the type specimen, so that, if the differences are sexual, the
female would appear to be the larger bird.
625. Ixttlus steiattjs, Blyth.
Neither Mr. Blyth in his original description of the Tenaserim speci-
men, nor Dr. Jerdon in the characters taken doubtless from his Darjiling or
TChaiaf birds, mentions one of the most characteristic peculiarities of this
form, — its ferruginous brown ear coverts and supercilia. In the type from
Tenaserim, which is in the Indian Museum, I can detect these, although
they are paler (perhaps from fading) than in a fresh specimen obtained by
Mr. Mandelli, which otherwise agrees perfectly with Dr. Jerdon’s descrip-
tion. Wing 2'35, tail 2T, tarsus 0'6, bill from forehead 0'35 inch.
1872.] W. T. Blanford — On Birds from SilcTcim. 167
630. Herpobis-is xaxttcolecca, Hodgs.
Of two specimens sent, one has a decidedly rufoscent tinge on the back.
The colour is dull yellowish green above, under wing coverts and inner mar-
gins of both remiges and rectrices bright yellow. The coronal feathers have
not black shafts and the margin of the whig is yellow, these being distinc-
tions from the new Hainan and Formosan species, R. tyr annulus, recently
described by Mr. Swinhoe (Ibis, 1870, p. 317, pi. x), besides the duller co-
lour of the plumage.
632. Stlvtpabtjs modestus, Burton. Single specimen.
647. Machlolopiies xanthogents, (Vigors).
A specimen was obtained in Eastern Xipal. Its representative form,
M. sjpilonotus, occurs around Darjiling.
694. Ploceus baya, Blyth. J. A. S. B., xii, p. 945.
P. megarhynchus, Hume, Ibis, 1869, p. 356, and 1871, p. 36.
Mr. Hume has pointed out that there are two species of Ploceus in
India of the form originally confounded under P. philippinus, L. To one
of these, which is larger than the other, and distinguished by a larger bill,
he has given the name of II. megarhynchus. I And, however, that the large
hilled form is that inhabiting the Himalayas, Eastern Bengal, Asam, Malacca
and probably Barma, and that it was upon specimens of it that Mr. Blyth s
P. laga was founded, as it is the species found at Calcutta, and all the ex-
amples in. the Asiatic Society’s collection appear to belong to it
There is of course a possibility that I may he mistaken in this, and that
Mr. Hume’s P. megarhynchus may he, in the breeding plumage, something
weU distinguished from P. baya, but I can detect no difference of the least
importance in the description of the birds in non-breedmg plumage At the
same time it is clear that there are two varieties of P. baya, but I am not
quite sure that the difference is sufficiently constant to deserve specific dis-
tinction. I append measurements (in inches) of the two forms.
tarsus bill from front
0-82 0-69
to to
09 0-77
0-79 0-65
to to
0-9 0-69
I can detect no constant difference between males and females. Bona-
parte’s remark in the Conspect. Gen. Av. p. 442 fwmvna minor, must nave
wing
P. baya, six specimens : four males, two 2-8o
females from Calcutta, Sikkim and to
Cackar. ° ^
P. baya, small var.,tbreespecimens : one 2 6
male and two females from Singh- to
bum and Chanda. ~
tail
1- 87
to
2- 15
1-7
to
1’8
168 W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Bilekim. [No. 2,
been due to his having seen females, or males, in non-breeding plumage of
the smaller form.
The smaller form is of course the P. baya of Jerdon’s Birds of India.
723. Etjspiza eutlla, (Pall.)
Fauna Japonica, Aves, p. 95, pi. lvi, B.
This is an addition to the Indian fauna. The specimen sent by Mr.
Mandelli agrees perfectly with Mr. Blyth’s description of that shot by my-
self near Bassein in Pegu, (J. A. S. B., 1863, p. 77), and with the description
and figure hi the Fauna Japonica. I add characters taken from the Sikkim
specimen which is doubtless a male.
Head and neck, upper breast, back, wing coverts, and broad edges to the
last secondary quills (tertiaries of some authors) uniform reddish ferrugi-
nous, with slight hoary edges to some of the feathers (doubtless disappear-
ing in spring), especially on the chin, lores, and round the eyes ; wing and
tail brown, the quills narrowly edged with yellowish white, second, third and
fourth quills emarginate on the outer webs, margin of wing yellow, inner
wing coverts and inner margins of quills white, lower parts from breast yel-
low, not very bright, flanks olive.
Wing 3 in., tail 2'4, tarsus 0'77, bill from forehead 0'43.
1 learn from Mr. Mandelli that this bird was shot in British Sikkim on
the great Bangit river in March, and that he has a second specimen from
Dalingkot in Butan, shot in April.
745a. Pbopassee satubatus, sp. nov. PL viii.
2 P. thura, Blyth, Museum Asiat. Soc., nec Bonaparte, vide Ibis, 1865, p. 44
et 1867, p. 44.
$ juv. ? P. tlvwra, 2, (nec $ ) Moore P. Z. S. 1855, p. 216, PI. cxiv.
P. masfronte, superciliis latis et genis pallide argentato-roseis, capite
insuper nucha et lateribus colli cum regione auriculari saturate coccineis,
vertice nigro striatulo ; dorso brunneo, plimarum marginibus pallidis, cocci-
neo lavatis, uropygio vise lotion ; remigibw cum tectricibus alarum rectrici-
b usque mtbrinis, rubro-marginatis, tectricibus et 3 ultimis pennis ad ex-
tremitates externas roseis, flexwra alee tectricibusque subalaribus partim
roseo-marginatis ; mento grisescente, gula Iccte coccined, nitore argenteo splen-
dente, pectore saturation, plwmis pallide marginatis, abdomine pallide roseo,
und cum pectore subobsolete fusco striatulo, subcaudalibus brunneis, roseo-
marginatis, tibiis et hypochondriis rufo -brunneis. Long, ala 3'22, caudce 2'6,
tarsi 095, rostri a fronts 0 49, a rictu 0'52, l. tola circa 6 uuc. angl.
Fcemina umbrina, capitis et dorsi plwmis pallide marginatis, superciliis
latis isabettinis ; alis caudaque umbrinis, pennis extus pallide marginatis,
W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim.
169
1872.]
maculis ad ext remit ates externas tectricum et 3 pennarim ultimtmm al-
bescentibus, uropygio ochraceo-tincto, gastro fulvo, fusco striato, ahdomine,
pallidiore et magis rufescente. Long alee 3'15, caudce 2-5, tarsi 095, rostri a
fronts 047, a rictu 0.5 unc.
Male with a general brownish tint above, richly glossed with crimson,
lores, forohead, supercilia and cheeks pale silvery pink, the bases of the fea-
thers brown, head above dark crimson with blackish centres to the feathers,
ear coverts and sides of the neck duller crimson, the centres of the feathers
broader and less distinct, back with broad dashes of dark earthy brown, the
edges of the feathers pale with a gloss of deep rose colour, approaching crim-
son, rump and upper tail coverts nearly the same colour as the back, the
dark centres of the feathers being less marked, and the paler margins with
their crimson gloss broader. Wing and tail feathers earthy brown with red
brown exterior margins, and pale rosy spots on the tips of the outer webs ot
the wing coverts and of the last three quills. Chin greyish, throat full rose
colour, darker than the cheeks, with a silvery gloss. The breast is deeper
and darker red, the feathers having pale rosy edges and narrow dark central
stripes, abdomen pink, also with narrow streaks ; under tail coverts brown,
edged with pink ; thighs and flanks brown, slightly tinged here and there
with pihk. Bill dusky, legs brown.
The female is earthy brown, the feathers of the upper parts with pale
margins, and the wing coverts and last three quills (tertiaries) with albes-
cent tips to the outer webs, supercilia isabelline, rump with an ochraceous
tinge. Under parts fulvous, all the feathers with dark centres, broader on
the breast, narrower on the abdomen, which has a rufescent tinge.
Another bird, apparently a young male is much more ochraceous than
the female in colouring, especially on the under parts, sides of neck and head ;
the margins of the quills and tail feathers are olivaceous.*
This beautiful rose finch is evidently the species of which a female exists
in the Asiatic Society’s Museum, labelled P. thura by Mr. Blytli, and to which
that gentleman refers in the “ Ibis” in the two instances cited above. It is
altogether of a richer and darker colour than any of the other Himalayan
species with which I am acquainted, via., P- rhodopeplus, thura, rhodochla-
mys and rhodochrous, and easily distinguished from all at once by the absence
of the rosy rump. P. pulcherrimus is said to be near rhodochrous , which
differs perhaps more from the present species than any of the others, it too
* Another pair of this bird since received from Mr. Mandelli confirms the above
description, except that the throat of the male is the same colour as the cheeks, in.
stead of being rather deeper red; they measure (in inches) —
170
W. T. Blanford — On Birds from Sikkim.
[No. 2,
has a crimson rump. On the whole the present form approaches rhodopeplus
more than any of the other species, but besides the differences already noted
the forehead in rhodopeplus is not brighter in colour than the crown of the
head.
The bird figured as the female of P. ilium by Mr. Moore in the Pro-
ceedings of the Zool. Soe. of London for 1855, Aves, PI. cxiv, does not be-
long to that species. It may perhaps be the young male of this bird but its
general coloration appears too rufous. The colour differs greatly from that
of the female of P. saturatus.
At this time it is surprising to find that so beautiful a bird as , this has
hitherto been overlooked in the Sikkim Himalayas. Mr. Mandelli informs
me that the specimens were shot on Tonglu, about 10,000 feet high near
Darjiling.
Amongst other interesting birds sent by Mr. Mandelli are Xiphoram-
phus superciliaris, Sui/a criniger, Neornis flavolivacea, Pteruthius erytlirop-
terns, Accentor strophiatus, JEmberiza pusilla and Chrysomitris spinoides.
JOURNAL
OF THE
ASIATIC SOCIETY.
— • —
Part II.— PHYSICAL SCIENCE.
No. III.— 1872.
Monograph op Indian Cyprinid^, Part Y,—by Surgeon Major F. Fay.
[Received 7th March, 1872; read 1st May, 18/2. J
3. Sub-family. — Cobitidina.
[Continued from p. 29.]
Pseudobranchiee absent. Body elongated, oblong, compressed or cylin-
drical, but never depressed. Snout and lips fleshy. Mouth small, inferior
and furnished with from six to twelve barbels. Pharyngeal teeth few and
in one row. Vertical fins spineless. Dorsal fin with a varying number of
rays (8-30); anal with few (7-8); ventrals absent in one genus. Scales
small and cycloid, when present, and usually immersed in mucus. Lateral
line single. Air vessel entirely, or partially, enclosed in a bony capsule.
Geographical distribution. Loaches are found in tanks and nvers
throughout the hills and plains of India and Barma, hut apparently are
absent from the Andaman islands. All the recognised genera seem to be
represented in the East. These fish are mostly captured by lading out
tanks commencing to dry np, but as they dive about in the mud, they are
usually difficult to capture.
Uses. — They are all good as food.
Synopsis of Genera.
A. With an erectile spine near the orbit.
1 Apm, eight barbels, two rostral, four maxillary and two mandibular. Spina
suborbital Dorsal fin short (8 rays) in the posterior third of the body, but anterior
to the anal. No ventrals. Barma.
2. Acanthophthalmus, six barbels, two rostral, four maxillary. Spine suborbital.
Dorsal and anal fins as in Apua. Ventrals present. N. E. India, Assam, Barma.
23
172 F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidw. [No. 3,
3. Lepulocephalus, six barbels, four rostral, two maxillary. Spine suborbital
Dorsal fin short, in hist two fifths of the body. Malay Archipelago.
4. Acanthopsis, eight barbels, two being mandibular. Spine before the orbit.
Dorsal fin of moderate leugth (12 rays), placed opposite the ventrals. Barma.
5. Colitis, six barbels, all rostral and maxillary. Spine suborbital. Dorsal fin short
(9-10 rays), placed opposite the ventrals. India and Barma.
6. LepidocephalicMli/ys, eight barbels, two mandibular. Spine suborbital. Dorsal
fin short (8-9 rays), placed opposite the ventrals. India.
7. Botia, six to eight barbels, it six, all are rostral and maxillary, should there
be eight, the extra pair are mandibnlar. Spine suborbital. Dorsal fin of moderate
length (10 to 15 rays), commencing anterior to the ventrals. Northern and Eastern
India and Barma,
8. Jerdonia, eight barbels, two being mandibular. Spine suborbital Dorsal fin
long (30 rays), commencing anterior to the ventrals.
B. Destitute of spine near the orbit,
9. Nemacheilus, six to eight barbels, rostral and maxillary ; if eight, the extra pair
at the posterior nostril. Dorsal short or of moderate length (8 to 17 rays) commencing
opposite the ventrals. India and Barma.
10. Oreonectes, six barbels, rostral and maxillary. Dorsal fin short (9 rays), far
behind the ventrals. China.
11. Misgumus, ten to twelve barbels, four being mandibnlar. Dorsal short (9
to 10 rays), cmmencoing opposite the ventrals. Barma.
A. With an erectile spine near the orbit.
Genus. Apua, Blyth.
Body elongated and compressed. A small, erectile, bifid, suborbited
spine. Bight barbels, one rostral pair, one in axillary pair, and two mandibu-
lar pairs. Dorsal fin in the posterior third of the body, but anterior to the
anal. Ventral fins absent.
Geographical distribution. —The single species of this genus, which has
yet been discovered, was obtained near Pegu in British Barma.
A SINGLE SPECIES.
1. Apua fusca, D 2/6. A. 2/6. Barma.
1. Apua eusca.
Blyth, Journal Asiatic Society of Bengal, 1860, p. 169 s #Giinther, Oatal vii
p. 371 ; Day, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 349.
B. III. D.2/6. P. 11. A. 2/6. C. 16.
Length of head 1/8, of caudal 1/9, height of body 1/8 of the total length.
Byes, small, diameter 1/9 of length of head, 4 diameters from end of snout.
A small erectile bifid spine below the orbit. Fins.— Dorsal half as high as the
body ; caudal rounded. Colours, brownish, with a longitudinal darker band.
There are three specimens in the Calcutta Museum, the largest beino- 21
inches long. b
Sab, — Barma.
1872.]
173
P. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
Genus. 2. Acajtthophthaxmxjs, v. Mass.
Pangio, Blyth.
Body elongated and compressed. A small, erectile, bifid, suborbital
spine. Six barbels, one rostral and two maxillary pairs. Dorsal Jin situated
in the posterior third of the body, anterior to the anal, but posterior to the
ventrals.
Geographical distribution. — North-east Bengal, Assam and Barma.
A SINGLE SPECIES.
1. Aemthophthalmm pangia. D. 2/6. A. 2/5, Cinnamon colour. N. E. Bengal
to Upper Barma.
1. ACANTlIOPirnTALilUS PANGIA.
Colitis pangia, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 355, 394 ; *Cuv. and Yal. mi, p. 75.
Colitis cinnamomea, Mc.Clell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 304, 435, pi. 51, f. 5. (from H. B. MSS.).
Fangio cinnamomea, Blyth, J. A, S. of B. 1860, p. 169.
Acanthophthalmus Ja/uanicus, Bloeker, Cyp. Pro., p. 75, and Atl.Ich. Cypr. p. 11,
t. 2, f. 3.
Acanthophthalmus pangia, Gunther, vii, p. 370.
Bangya, Beng. Nga-tha-lay-doh, Barmese.
B. III. D. 2/G. P. 10. Y. 6-7. A. 2/5. C. 17.
Length of head 1/8, of caudal 1/8, height of body 1/8 of the total
length. Eyes, minute. Scales, distinct. Colour, light cinnamon.
llab. — North-East Bengal, the northern portions of British and Upper
Barma. I obtained many specimens at Mandalay, from the canal then in
the course of construction. I have also received one from below Darjiling,
collected by Mr. Mandelli; the specimen agrees with the others, except in
having no scales, but as it is not in a good state, I conclude they may have
been rubbed off.
Genus. 3. Lepidocephalits, Bleelcer.
Body elongated and compressed. An erectile, bifid, suborbital spine.
Six barbels, four rostral, two maxillary. Dorsal fin placed in the posterior
tieo fifths of the body, some distance behind the root of the ventrals. Caudal
truncate.
Geographical distribution— Ike species of this genus are found in
Java and Sumatra.
Genus. 4. Acanthopsis, v. Mass.
Brostheacanthus, Blyth.
Body very elongated, snout long and compressed. Barbels eight, two
being mandibular. A small, bifid, erectile spine, situated in advance of the
orbit. Dorsal fin opposite to the ventrals ; caudal forked.
Geographical distribution. — Tenasserim and Barma.
174
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidcc.
[No. 3,
A singie species.
1. Acamthopsis choirorrhynchus. D. 3/9. A. 3/5. Burma, 8fc.
1. ACANTHOPSIS CnOTTiORRHYNCHL’S.
Colitis choirorrhynchus, Bleeker, Nat. Tyds. Ned. Ind. vii, p. 95.
Prostheacanthus spectalilis, Blyth, J. A. S. of B. 1860, p. 167.
Acanthopsis choirorrhynchus, Bleekor, Atl. Ich. Cyp. p. 9, t. i. f. 3 ; Gunther, Catal.
vii, p. 365 j Day, Proo. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 549.
Nga-tlia-lay-doh, Barmese.
B. III. D. 3/9. P. 11. Y. 7. A. 3/5. C. 11.
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/9 of the total
length. Eyes situated in the posterior 2/5 of the head. Fins ; dorsal
arises midway between end of snout and base of caudal, which latter is
forked. Colours — brownish, with twelve bands across the back, and an equal
number of blotches along the lateral line. Two rows of spots along the
dorsal, aud three along the anal fins.
Hah, Barma and Sumatra.
Genus. 5. Cobitis, Artedi.
Somileptes, Bleekor.
Body elongated and compressed, dorsal profile nearly horizontal. Six
barbels on the snout and upper jaw. A small erectile, bifid, suborbital spine.
Dorsal Jin inserted opposite to the ventral ; caudal truncated or rounded.
Geographical distribution.- — The Indian species of this genus extend
from Orissa through Bengal to Barma.
Synopsis, op species.
1. Colitis gongota, D. 10. A 8 j barbels short. Assam.
2. „ guntea, D. 2/7. A. 2/5 j barbels long. Orissa, Bengal and Barma.
1. Cobitis gongota.
Ham. Buch. Fish. Gang. pp. 351, 394. ; Gunther, vii, p. 363.
Colitis cucura, Ham. Buch. pp. 352, 394 j McClelland, Ind. Cyp pp. 303, 434,
t. 51, f. 2, (from H B.’s MSS.), young; #Cuv. and Val xviii, p. 70.
Colitis ocvlata, McClelland, Ind. Cyp. pp, 303, 433, t. 51, f. 1, from H. B.’s MSS.,
adult.
p Colitis maya, Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soc. ii, p. 367.
p Colitis amnicola, Cuv. and Val. xviii, p 68.
Somileptes gongota, *Swainson ; Bleeker. Atl. Icb. Cyp. (no description).
B. III. D. 10. V. 7. A. 8.
Barbels moderately developed, extending about half way to below the
eyes which are small, prominent, and somewhat before the middle of the
length of the head. Fins. — Origin of dorsal opposite the root of the inner
ventral ray ; caudal rounded. Scales minute. Colours. — An undulated
hand along the side of the body, giving off vertical bars towards the back.
Dorsal and caudal fins with transverse rows of blackish dots.
Huh. Assam.
1872.]
175
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
2. COBITIS GITXTEA.
Ham. Buoli. Fish. Ganges, pp. 353, 394 ; McClelland, Ind. Cyp. pp. 303, 434,
t. 51, f. 3. (from H. B.’s MSS.) ; Cuv. Yal. xviii, p. 67 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 363 ; Day,
Proc. Zool. Soe. 1869, p. 383.
Acanthopsis Berdmorei, Blyth, J. A. S. of Beng., 1860, p. 168.
? Acanthopsis micropogon, Blyth, 1. o. p. 168.
Colitis Berdmorei, Day, Proo. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 550.
Kondatwri and gupkari, Uria ; Nga-tha-leg-doh, Bwrmese.
B. Ill, D. 2/6-7. P. 9. V. 7. A. 2/5. C. 16.
Length of head 1/6, of pectoral 1/9, of caudal 1/6 of the total
length. Eyes ; — diameter 1/5 of length of head, 2 diameters from end of
snout, and one diameter apart. Body strongly compressed, its height equal
to the length of the head. Barbels large, well developed and all longer
than the orbit. Fins. — Dorsal arises midway between the posterior margin
of the orbit and the base of the caudal fin, its first three rays are in
advance of the ventrals ; caudal generally entire, its centre rays, how-
ever, may be somewhat shortened or even lengthened. Scales distinct.
Lateral line absent. — Colours; generally dirty yellowish, with a daik
band extending from the centre of the snout, and ending in a black ocellus
above the middle of the base of the .caudal fin ; along this band are a seiies
of dark blotches, whilst the back is similarly stained. Dorsal and caudal
with rows of dark spots. I have obtained it at Kangra, coloured, as given by
McClelland.
Mob. — From Orissa through Bengal and Barma, also in Bombay
Presidency. It attains four inches in length.
Genus. 6. Lepidocephalichthys, EleeJcer.
Platacanthus, Day. .7177 „ , . 7
Body elongated and moderately compressed. Eight barbels, two of which
belong to the mandible. A large, erectile, bifid, suborbital spine. Dorsal fin
short, commencing opposite, or nearly so, to the ventral ; the internal ray of the
pectoral fin may be modified into a flat osseous spine; caudal truncate or
slightly emarginate.
Geographical distribution. — India, Barma and Ceylon.
Synopsis op species.
1. Lepidocephalichthys thermalis, D. 3/6. A. 2/5. S. India and Ceylon.
2. Lepidocephalichthys balgara, D. 8, A. 7. Wynaad, Bengal and Assam.
1. LePEDOCEPHAIiICHTHYS THEBMALIS.
Colitis thermalis, Cuv. and Yah, xviii, p. 78.
Lepidocephalichthys thermalis, Bleeker in Yerh. Holl. Maat. Haar. 1864, Cyprin.
and Cobit. Ceylon, p. 6, t. i. f. 1 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 364 ; Day, Proo. Zool. Soc.
1869, p. 383.
176
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
[No. 3,
Colitis Mysorensis, Jerdon, M. J. L. and S., 1849, p. 332.
Platacanthus ayrensis, Day, Pishes of Malabar, p. 201, pi. 14, f. i.
Assaree, Tam. ; Jubbi cowri, Uriah ; Bdlu, Hind.
B. III. D. 3/6. P. 7. V. 7. A. 2/5. C. 16.
Length of head 1/11, of caudal 1/8, height of body 1/8 of the total
length. Barbels eight, the longest extending to below the anterior margin
of the orbit. Suborbital spine, strong. Fins. — Origin of dorsal slightly in
advance of the ventral, and nearer the root of the caudal than the snout.
Caudal slightly emarginate. The inner pectoral ray is modified in adult
males into a flat osseous spine which is used for diving down into the mud.
Scales distinct. I found 2,500 eggs in one female. Colours, sandy, with
irregular blotches on the lateral line, and others along the bach ; a black
spot generally exists, at the base of the upper half of the caudal fin. Dorsal
fin with black spots, caudal with four bands. A dark streak often extends
from the eye to the end of the snout.
1 lab. — Southern India, the Malabar coast and Ceylon.
2. LEPIBOCEPHABICHTHYS BALGAKA.
Colitis lalgara, Ham. Buch., Pish. Gang. pp. 350, 394 j Cuv. and Val., xviii p. 74.
Schistura lalgara, McClell., Ind, Cyp., p. 307, pi. 53, f. 2. (from H. B.’s MS.).
„ aculeata, McClell , 1. o. p. 307 ; Cuv. and Val. xviii, p. 70.
Lepidocephalichthys lalgara, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 365 ; Day, P. Z. S. 1870, p. 70.
? Colitis Camaticus, Jerdon, M. J. L. and S., 1849, p. 331.
Jubbi cowri, Uriah.
B. III. D. 2/6. V. 7. A. 2/5. „
This species closely resembles the preceding. Suborbital spine small,
and decreasing with age. Dorsal fin not in advance of the ventrals ; caudal
cut square. In one male specimen, taken in the Ganges at Hardwar, the
inner pectoral ray was of the same character as in the last species. Colours,
clouded with brown along the back, lighter on the abdomen ; the whole of
the body dotted over with lines of black spots ; a black mark at the top of
the base of the caudal. Six to eight rows of spots along the dorsal fin, and
about ten sinuous and broken up lines of spots on the caudal.
Hub. — India generally. In some specimens from the Soane river, the
mandibular barbels are sub-divided.
Genus. 7. Botia, Gray.
Bymenophysa, McClelland.
Body oblong, compressed, with the dorsal prof le more or less convex.
Fyes with a free, circular eyelid. Barbels six to eight ; if six, all are
on the snout and upper jaw, if eight the extra ones are on the mandible.
A bifid, erectile, suborbital spine present. Dorsal fin commences anterior
to the root of the ventral ; caudal forked. Air bladder in two divisions, the
177
1872.] F. Day— Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
anterior being partially enclosed in a bony capsule, whilst the posterior por-
tion floats free in the abdominal cavity.
Geographical distribution. — Found, in the plains and hills in Eastern
Bengal, and in both Upper and Lower Barma.
Synopsis OP SPECIES.
1. Botia nebnlosa, D. 3/12, A. 2/5, Barbels six. Darjiling.
2. Botia dario, D. 3/10, A. 2/6. Barbels eight. Bengal, N. TV. Provinces, Oachar.
3. Botia hymenophysa, D. 13 — 15, A. 8. Barbels six. Barma.
4. Botia Almorhce, D. 12, A. 8. Barbels eight. Almorah.
5. Botia rostrata, D. 12, A. 8. Barbels eight. Assam.
6. Botia Berdmorei, D. 2/9, A. 2/5. Barbels eight. Darjiling.
7. Botia histrionicu, D. 2/8, A. 2/5. Barbels eight. Pegu.
1. Botia nebuiosa.
Blyth, J. A. S. of B., 1860, p. 165 j Day, Proo. Zool. Soe. 1869, p. 550.
B. III. D. 3/12. P. 13. V. 8. A. 2/5. C. 17.
• Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the total
length. Eyes, — in the middle of the length of the head, two diameters from
the end of the snout, and the same distance apart. Colours, — brownish,
with a leaden band along the side. Dorsal and caudal barred in spots.
An ocellus at the upper margin of the base of the caudal fin.
Sab.- — Darj iling.
2. Botia daeio.
Cohit is dario, Ham. Bucli., Fish. Ganges, pp. 354, 394, pi. 29, f. 9a ; *Cnv. and
Val,, xviii, p. 85; Bleeker, Verh. Bat Gen. Ned. Ind., xxv. Beng. and Hind. p. 143;
McClell. Ind. Cyp, pp 306, 444, pi 61, f. 8.
? Cobitisgeto, Ham. Buch., 1. o. pp. 355, 394, pi. xi, f. 96; Cuv. and Yal. xviii,
p. 84 ; McClo’ll., Ind Cyp. pp. 306, 444, pi. 61, f. 9.
Botia dario, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 366.
ISahinga, Panj.; Buck tea, Hind. ; Shee-nharo, Sind.
B. III. D. -5-. P. 14. V. 8. A. 2/6. C. 19.
9—10
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the total
length. Eyes — small, situated in the anterior portion of the posterior half of
the head, and from H to 2 diameters apart. Barbels eight. Posterior
portion of air vessel free in the abdominal cavity. Colours ; seven or eight
oblique hands descend from the back to the abdomen, and two or three, or
even more, cross either lobe of the caudal fin. In some specimens, especially
from the Jumna, there are about five vertical bands, which arch superiorly
so as to coalesce with the next on either side, between each arch is an
intermediate vertical blotch. Sometimes there are two bars on the pectoral
and the same number on the ventral fins.
Sab. — Bengal, N. W. Provinces and the Panjab, also Cachar. I have
generally taken it in the rivers of the plains, except in the Sind bills
178
[No. 3,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cgprinidw.
3. Botia hymenophysa.
Oobitis hymenopliysa, Bleeker, Nat. Tyd. Ned. Ind. iii, p. 602.
Hymenophym Macclellamli, Bleeker, Cyp. Prod. p. 63.
Botia hymenopliysa, Bleeker, Atl. Ich. Cypr. p. 6, t. i, f . 2 ; Gunther, Cat. vii, p. 368.
Nga-tha-lay-doh and Shoay-zagay , Burmese.
B. III. D. -1 V. 8. A. 2/6.
11—13
length of head nearly 1/4 of the total length. Eyes — slightly behind
the middle of the length of the head. Suborbital spine small, only reaching
to below the middle of the eye. Barhels six. Colours brownish, with eleven
darker cross hands.
Hah. — The northern portions of British and also Upper Burma.
4. Botia Almobhaj.
Gray, Zool. Misc. 1831, p. 8 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 367.
Botia grandis, Gray and Hardw. Ind. Zool. j* Cuv. and Yal., xviii, p.86 ; McClell.
Cal. J. N. H., ii, p. 586.
B. III. D. 12. V. 8. A. 8.
Length of head 1/4, height ofbody nearly 1/4 of the length, excluding the
caudal tin. Eyes in the middle of the length of the head, 2 diameters apart.
Snout pointed, half as long, as the head. Suborbital spine extending nearly or
quite to behind the posterior margin of the orbit. Barhels eight. Free
portion of the tail as deep as long. Fins ; — dorsal commences midway between
the end of the snout and the base of the caudal. Colours ; — body reticulated
with brown, the yellow ground colour being broken up into spots ; all the
fins with more or less regular brown cross hands, three or four on each
caudal lobe, three across the anal fin, and about six across the pectoral.
Hab. — Almorah.
5. Botia eosteata.
Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 367.
B. III. D. 12, P. 14, V. 8, A. 8.
Length of head 1/4, of caudal 1/5, height ofbody 1/5 of the total length.
Eyes, — diameter 2/15 of length of head, 4 diameters from end of snout ;
interorbital space not quite equal to 2 diameters of the orbit. Snout pointed,
longer than the remaining portion of the head. Suborbital spine not
extending to below the posterior margin of the orbit. Barhels eight.
Depth of free portion of tail li in its length. Fins ; — dorsal arises midway
between the posterior margin of the orbit and the base of the caudal, which
last has sharp lobes. Colours ; — body with irregular and partly confluent
brown cross bands, which enclose variously sized round yellowish spots.
Dorsal and anal fins with two, pectoral, ventral, and each lobe of the caudal
with three, black cross hands.
Hab. — Bengal and Assam.
1872.]
179
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
6. Botca Berdmorei.
Syncrossus Berdmorei, Blyth, J. A. S. of Bongal, I860, p. 166.
Botia Berdmorei, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc., 1869, p. 519.
B. III. D. 3/9, P. 13, V. 8, A. 2/5, C. 17.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the total
length. Eyes ; diameter 1/5 of length of head, 2 diameters from end of snout
and apart. Suborbital spine damaged in the unique example. Barbels
eight, j Fins ; dorsal commences midway between the snout and the posterior
margin of the anal fin. Colours , brownish, with a leaden band along the
side. Dorsal and caudal barred in spots. An ocellus at the upper margin
of the base of the caudal fin.
Sab. — Darjiling and Bengal generally.
7. Botia histrionica.
Blyth, J. A S. of Bongal, 1860, p. 166 j Day, Proc. Zool. Soo. 1869, p. 550.
B. in. D. 2/8, P. 15, V. 8, A. 2/5, 0. 19.
Length of head 1/4, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/4 of the total length.
Eyes ; diameter 1/5 of length of head, 2£ diameters from end of snout, 2
diameters apart. Suborbital spine not very strong, extending to opposite
the posterior margin of the orbit. Barbels, eight. Fins ; dorsal commences
nearer to the caudal than to the end of the snout. Caudal forked. Colow s,
olive, with five dark vertical bands on the body, and two or three on the
head. All the fins with two broad brown bands.
Sab. — Pegu.
Genus. Jerdonla,* Day.
Platacanthus, sp. Day.
Body elongated, and moderately compressed. Eight barbels, two of which
are mandibular. A free, erectile, bifid, suborbital spine. Dorsal fin long
(twenty -seven branched rays), commencing before the centrals ; the internal
ray of the pectoral fin modified into a fiat osseous spine ; caudal slightly
emarginate.
Geographical distribution. Madras Presidency.
The single species.
1. J erdonia maculata, D. 3/27, A. 3/6. Madras.
1. Jerdonta macttlata.
Platacanthus rmculatus, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 911, and 1870, p. 700.
B. III. D. 3/27, P. 5/1, Y. 8, A. 3/6, C. 21.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/6 of the total
Ien°-th. Eyes ; diameter 1/6 of length of head, two diameters from end of
snout. Dorsal profile ascends to the commencement of the dorsal fin. Sub-
orbital spine reaches to beneath the anterior third of the orbit. Scales, small,
* This name has been also applied in Conohology and Ornithology, [Editor.]
24
180
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Oyprinidte. [No. 3,
but distinct. Colours, greyish, becoming dirty white along the abdomen. A
dark lateral band extends from the eye to the tail ; along its first half are
three black spots, whilst the whole extent of the back is irregularly lineated.
Fins, yellow. Dorsal with four black bands. Caudal with three bands and
a dark margin. A black mark at the base of the tail, with a smaller one
above and another below it.
Mob. — Madras.
B. Without an erectile spine near the orbit.
Genus. 9. Nemacheiiiis, v. Mass.
Acnura and Acourus, Swains.
Acanthocobitis, Peters.
Dody elongated. Dorsal profile nearly horizontal. Darbels eight or
six, when the former number is present, the extra pair belongs to the
posterior nostril, none on the mandibles. No spine on the head. Dorsal
fin of moderate length, or short, situated opposite the ventrals.
This genus has been subdivided into those species which have upwards
of twelve dorsal rays, (Acanthocobitis), and those with less than twelve. As
this arbitrary division is not a natural one, it is not adopted here. Another
subdivision has been instituted into those in which the tail is forked, and
those in which it is entire. The genus may, however, be subdivided into
those with eight and those with six barbels.
Geographical distribution. — Fresh waters of India, Ceylon, and Barma.
Synopsis op species.
A. With eight barbels.
1. N’crmcheilm Evetsa/rdi, D. 2/7, A. 2/5. Greenish, with small dark blotches.
Tuna (in the Dakhin).
B. With six barbels.
2. „ paxonaceus, D. 2/15, A. 2/5. Body barred'; caudal wedge-shaped.
Assam and Tenasserim Provinces.
3. „ wrophthalimis, D. 14, A. 7. Body with cross bands ; caudal
emarginate, and with rounded angles. Ceylon.
4. „ botia, D. 8/11, A. 2/5. Body irregularly blotched. Caudal emar—
ginate. Throughout India, except in the South.
2 3
5. „ BupelU, D. -jjj-, A. 8. Short bars along the lateral line. Caudal
emarginate. Puna.
6* „ moreh, D. A. 7. Bars along the side of the body. Caudal
wedge-sbaped. Puna.
1* „ monoceros, D. 12. A. 6. Caudal and dorsal fins barred. Caudal
rounded. Assam.
8. „ aweus, D. 2/10, A. 2/5. Immature blotched ; caudal and dorsal
fins barred. Caudal forked. Jabbalptir.
9. i, rupicola, D. , A. 2/5. Eleven to seventeen brown bands on
1872.]
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
181
the body, as wide or wider than the ground oolonr. Dorsal and caudal banded or spot-
tod. Caudal forked. India generally, except Sind and the South.
10. „ semiarmatus, D. 3/8, A. 2/5. Irregular spots and bars on the
body and fins. Caudal forked. Nilgherries.
11.# n tenuicauda, D. 11, A, 7. Mottled and spotted with brown. Caudal
forked. Tibet.
12. „ eondltemans, D. 2/9, A. 2/5. Ten to eleven vortical bands, with
intermediate ones superiorly. Dorsal and caudal spotted. Caudal ontire. Tenasserim
provinces,
13. „ Ladacensis, D. 11, A. 7. Nine blackish bars across the back.
Caudal rounded. Tibet.
14 nonata, D. 3/7, A. 1/5. Eleven to thirteen dark zones encircle the
back, not meeting on the abdomen and not half the width of the ground colour. Caudal
forked. Assam, Bengal, N. W. Provinces.
15. „ subfuscus, D. 2/8, A. 2/5. Ten brawn zones encircling the body,
and wider than the ground colour. Caudal slightly forked. Upper Assam and Ba/rma.
16. „ sinuatus, D.gig, A. 2/5. Vertical brown bands, with shorter
intermediate ones. Dorsal and caudal barrod. Caudal cut square. Wynaad.
17. „ Stolictskce, D. 3/7, A. 2/5. Spotted and marbled with brown.
Caudal slightly emarginate. Tibet.
18. „ chlorosoma, D. 3/6, A. 2/5. A darkish line long the middle of the
body. Caudal cut square. Upper Assam a/nd Kistna river.
19. „ phoxocheila, D. 2 A A. 2/5. Upper Assam.
20. „ serpentarius, D. 2/8, A. 2/5. A dark baud from snout through the
eye to the base of dorsal fin.
21. microps, D. 11, A. 7. Sixteen to seventeen cross bands on the
back, and vermiculated stripes on the body. Caudal slightly emarginate. Tibet.
22. „ striatus, D. 2/8, A. 2/5. Numerous narrow vertical bands.
Caudal slightly forked. Wyn aad.
23. „ mugah, D. 2/7, A. ^ Fifteen brown bands, one third as wido
as the ground colour. Caudal forked. Cossy '> iver,
24. „ notostigma, D. 2/8, A. Dark blotches. Caudal forked. Ceylon
and Southern India. „ , , , . , _ , .
25. „ montanus, D. 3/7, A. 2/5. Twelve vertical brown bands. Caudal
forked. Himalayas.
26. „ spilopterus, D. 2/7, A. 2/5. Eleven to fifteen irregular bands.
Caudal slightly emarginate. Himalayas, Assam and Cochin China.
gy savona, D. — , A. 2/5. Ten to twelve very narrow white bands.
Caudal slightly emarginate. Ramiganj m Bengal. ...... „ ,
28 Beavarvi, D. 10, A. 7. Dark bands, wider than interspace. Caudal
forked. Cossy river.
29t „ Denisonii, D. g_9,
zones Caudal forked. Nilgherry and Coorg hills.
30‘ triangularis, D. 2/8, A. 2/5. Seven black edged triangular bands.
Caudal emarginate. Travancore hills.
2 , A. 2/5. Nine to twelve yellowish olive vertical
182
F. Bay — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce. [No. 3,
31. * „ mannoratus, D. 10, A. 7. Mottled with brown. Caudal some-
what oonvex. Kashmir.
32. „ GriffUhii, D. 10, A. 7. Marbled with brownish black. Caudal
emarginate. Assam.
33. ,, corica, D. 2/8, A. 2/5. About thirteen blotches along the side.
Caudal forked. N. E. Bengal, Panjab and Assam.
34. „ Gumtheri, D. 2/8, A. 2/5. Reticulated with brown. Caudal
lobed. Nilgherries.
35. „ Bbjthvi, D. 2/7, A. 2/5. Brownish. Caudal forked. India ?
36. „ Butcmensis, D. 9, A. 7. Caudal rounded. Butdn.
37. „ rubripinnis, D. 2/6, A. 2/5. Nine vertical bars. Caudal emargi-
nate. Malabar.
38. * ,, turio, D. 8, (10 ?) A. 7. Spotted and blotched. Caudal emargh
nate. Assam.
39. * guttatus, D. 8. Dark blotches. Caudal entire. Upper Assam.
1. Nemacheilus Evezardi,
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 12, Y. 8, A. 2/5, C. 17.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/6 of the total
length. Egos in the commencement of the anterior half of the head. Head
broad, its width equalling its length without the snout, which is rounded.
No spine on the head. Barbels well developed, one pair of nasal, two pair of
rostral and one pair of maxillary. Fins ; dorsal commences opposite to the
ventrals and midway between the anterior margin of the orbit and the base
of the caudal ; upper edge of dorsal fm slightly convex ; pectoral longer
than the head, and reaching three quarters of the distance to the base of
the ventral. Caudal rounded. Scales, very minute. Lateral line, absent.
Colours, greenish with small dark blotches.
Hah. — Puna. A single specimen received amongst a collection which
Colonel Evezard assisted in procuring.
2. Nemacheilus pavonaceus.
Cobitis pavonacea, McClelland, Ind. Cyp., pp. 305, 437, pi. 62, fig. 1 ; *Cuv. and
Val., xviii, p. 37.
Nemacheilus pavonaceus, #Gunthor, Catal. vii, p. 348.
Cobitis semizonata, Blyth, J. A. S. of B., 1860, p. 171.
Nemacheilus semizonatus, *Giinther, Catal. vii, p. 348.
Cobitis rubuUpimmis, Blyth, 1. c., p. 170.
Nemacheilus rubidipinnis, * Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 348.
Acanthocobitis longipinnis, Peters, Mon. Ak. Wiss. Berl. for 1861.
B. III. D. ~Ta’Y- 8’ A-2/5’ 19‘
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/6, height of body 1/6 of the total
length. Byes ; diameter 2/9 of length of head, 2 diameters from end of
snout. In some specimens the pre-orbital forms a blunt spine. Bins ;
183
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
dorsal commences nearer to tlie snout than to the base of caudal, which latter
is slightly emarginate. Colours ; body crossed by about twenty half bars of
a darkish grey ; a dark ocellus surrounded by a light margin exists upon
the upper portion of the base of the caudal fin. Dorsal and caudal barred.
Hal. — Assam and Tenasserim Provinces.
3. NEMACHEIlirS BEOPHTHALKTTS.
Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 848.
B. III. D. 14, P. 13, Y. 8, A. 7, C. 19.
Length of head, of caudal, and height of body 1/5 of the total length.
Eyes ; diameter 1/4 of length of head, H diameters from end of snout.
Body, compressed. Free portion of tail as deep as long. Pre-orbital termi-
nates posteriorly in a slight and obtuse projection below the eye, either
moveable, or concealed by the skin. Fins ; origin of dorsal midway between
the snout and the base of the caudal, which latter is emarginate with
rounded angles. Scales, distinct. lateral line, incomplete. Colour's ; from
ten to thirteen dark brown cross bands, somewhat lighter in the middle,
and separated from one another by narrow yellow streaks of ground colour.
Head spotted with brown. A black, white edged, ocellus on the base of the
upper caudal lobe. Dorsal and caudal with six transverse series of black
dots.
Hal. — Ceylon.
4. Nemacheii/es botia.
Colitis botia, Ham. Buck., Fish. Ganges, pp 850, 391 ; *Cuv. and Val., xviii, p. 72.
„ Ultimo, Ham. Buoh., 1. c. pp. 358, 395 ; *Cuv. and Val., xviii, p 35.
„ bimucronata, McClell., Ind. Cyp„ pp. 304, 435, pi. 51 , fig. 4, (from H. B.’s MS.)
„ ocellata, McClell., 1. e. pp. 304, 436, pi. 51, fig. 6, (from H. B.’s MS.)
Nemacheilus botia , Giintlier, Catal. vii, p. 349 ; Day, P. Z. S., 1869, p. 382.
Bil-turi, Assam ; Soon-da-lee, Panj.
B. III. D. 3/11, P. 11, V. 8, A. 2/5, C. 17.
Height of body 1/G of the total length. Pre-orbital has in some
specimens a projection which is moveable below the orbit, (N. lotia), whilst
hi others it is entirely concealed by the skin (N. Ultimo). Colours, greyish,
with from 12 to 14 short bars on the lateral line, and a number of irregular
blotches above it. Dorsal fin spotted ; caudal with about seven irregular
bars, and a black ocellus on the upper portion of the base of the fin.
JJal. Throughout India, except its most southern portion.
The Colitis scalurigina, McClell., described from one of H. B.’s draw-
ings may he this species, badly delineated, the ocellus at the base of the
caudal and the bars on that fin not being distinctly shown.
184
[No. 3,
P. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidw.
5. Nemacheixus Rotexxi.
Colitis Bupelli (?) Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soc. ii, p. 366, pi. 64, fig. 1.
B. III. D. ?=?, P. 12, V. 8, A. 8, C. 19.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the total
length. 1 fyes, slightly before the middle of the length of the head, 2| dia-
meters from end of snout. Head pointed, four moderately developed rostral
and two maxillary barbels. Fins ; dorsal arises midway between the snout
and base of the caudal which is slightly forked ; the upper margin of the
dorsal fin straight. Scales, moderately developed. Lateral line, distinct.
Colours, greenish yellow except the abdomen which is white, short brown
bars along the lateral line, and the rays of the dorsal and anal barred.
Caudal with four posteriorly directed Y-shaped brown bars. A black spot
at the base of the upper caudal lobe.
Mob. — Rivers near Puna (in the Dakhin).
6. * Nehacheixus moeeh.
Colitis morel, Sykes, Trans. Zool. Soo. ii, p. 366.
B. III. D. S, P. 12, V. 8, A. 7, C. 19.
Head said to be more pointed than in the last species. Fins ; tail wedge-
shaped. Scales, minute. Colours ; more dark blotches on the head than in
jY. Bupelli. The transverse dark marks on the body are not (? now)
arranged along the lateral line and over the back, alternating with each
other. The fins have a very light orange tinge,
Mab. — Mota Mola river at Puna.
7.* Nemacheixtts monoceeos.
Colitis monoceros, McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 305, 438, pi. 52, fig. 2 j #Cuv. and
Val., xviii, p. 38.
Nemachilus monoceros, #Giinther, Catal. vii, p. 358.
B. III. D. 12, P. 12, Y. 8, A. 6, C. 18.
Length of head 1/4 of the total without the caudal fin. A short blunt
spine on the snout. Fins (according to the figure) ; upper margin of
dorsal nearly straight, caudal rounded. Colours ; body greenish yellow with
a silvery lustre, opercles tinged with green. Caudal and dorsal streaked
with numerous small brown bars.
Ilab. — Assam.
8. Nemacheixus aueexs.
B. III. D. 2/10, P. 15, V. 8, A. 2/5, C. 19.
Length of head, of caudal and pectoral 1/5, height of body 2/13 of the
total length. Eyes, large, not prominent, situated in the middle of the
length of the head and 1) diameters from the end of snout. Snout very
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce. 185
obtuse, the pro-orbital (in the adult) ending posteriorly in a free blunt pro-
cess. Width of head two-thirds of its length. Free portion of tail as high
as long. Barbels elongated, the internal rostral pair reaching to the eye, the
external to the middle of the orbit, and the maxillary to beyond its hind
margin. Fins ; dorsal commences somewhat in advance of the ventrals, and
in the adult midway between the snout and the base of the caudal, but in
the immature nearer to the former ; the pectoral reaches to above the ven-
tral, and the anal when laid flat extends to the root of the caudal, which
last is forked in its last fourth with sharp lobes. Scales, very distinct.
Lateral line, ceases opposite the posterior end of the base of the dorsal.
Colours, light, with a green tinge and destitute of marks on tho body in the
mature, but in the young there is a row of seven or eight dark blotches
along the middle of the body as wide as the ground colour, whilst superiorly
there are intermediate blotches extending downwards from the back. Fins
and the barbels of a deep orange colour, a dark ocellus at the base of the
upper caudal lobe, and 5 or 6 7 shaped bars on tho tail. Several rows of
black spots along the dorsal fin. A dark streak from the eye down the
snout.
Sab. — Jabbalpur, specimens obtained in September 18/1 were full
of ova.
9. Nemachehtis ioxpicota.
Scliistura mpicola, McClell., J. A. S. of B., vii, pi. pi. 65, fig. 8, and Ind. Cyp.
pp. 309, pi. 57, fig. 3.
Colitis rapeouXa, *Cnv. and Val., xviii, p. 10.
Nemachilus rupecula, Gunther, vii, p. 351.
33. III. D. JL, P. 10, V. 7, A. 2/5, C. 17.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5 to 1/6, height of body 1/5 to 1/6 of
the total length. Byes small, diameter 1/7 of the length of the head and
situated in the middle of its length, or more anteriorly in young specimens.
Head, broad, depressed. Barbels, short but stout. Fins ; dorsal commences
midway between the posterior margin of the orbit and the base of the
caudal fin. Pectoral reaches above half way to the root of the ventral ;
caudal with rounded lobes in the adult, more pointed in the young. Free
portion of tho tail as deep as long. Scales, minute. Colours ; eleven to
seventeen vertical brown bands, each from as wide to three times as broad as
the buff interspaces. Caudal with a black band at its base, and four or five
irregular bars. Dorsal with a black base and a black mark between its two
first rays, the fin also spotted with black, the other fins with badly marked
bands.
Jlah. — Bengal, N. W. Provinces, Panjab, Assam, and the Himalayas j
attaining 3J inches in length.
18G
[No. 3,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
The appearance of this fish alters considerably with age. In the young
the head is only 2/3 as wide as long, hut the two dimensions are equal in the
adult.
10. Nemactieiots semiaematus.
Day, Proo. Zool. Soo. 1867, p. 286 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 353.
B. III. D. 3/8, P. 12, V. 7, A. 2/5, C. 18.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 2/9, height of body 2/11 of the total
length. Eyes ; diameter 1/4 of length of head, 1-J diameters from end of
snout, 1 diameter apart. A cartilaginous knob on pre-orbital. Free portion
of tail as deep as long. Fins ; origin of dorsal nearer the snout than the
base of the caudal. Pectoral as long as the head, the basal half of some
of its rays being generally stiffened by osseous matter. Caudal lobed in its
last half. Scales, indistinct. Lateral line, complete. Colours, light
brown, with numerous irregularly shaped spots and bars proceeding from the
back towards the lateral line ; head brownish, with a dark lipe from the
snout through the orbit. Dorsal lin with about three rows of dark spots ;
caudal irregularly barred ; a dark line runs along the centre of the back.
I lab. — Bowani and Sigur rivers along the base of the Nilgherry hills- ;
also imported into tanks on those mountains.
11. * NeMACHEJXTTS TENET CAUDA.
Colitis tcmicaucla, Stein., Verb. Zool.-bot. Ges. Wien, 1866, p. 792, t. 17, fig. 3.
Ncmacldlus tenmcauda, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 357.
B. III. D. 11, V. 8, A. 7.
Length of head nearly 1/5, height of body less than 1/5 of the length,,
without the caudal. Free portion of tail very low, its depth being rather
less than 1/3 of its length. Fins ; upper margin of dorsal oblique, with
its anterior angle rounded ; it arises nearer to the root of the caudal than to
the end of the snout. Pectoral extends rather above half the distance
to the base of the ventral. Caudal emarginate. Scales, absent. Colours ;
upper part of side, dorsal and caudal fins irregularly mottled with brown,
and some spots along the sides.
Mai. — Tibet.
12. N EMACTTETLUS ZONADTEENANS.
CobiUs eonalterrums, Blyth, J. A. S. of B. 1860, p. 172.
Nemacheihis xonaltemans, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc., 1869, p. 551.
B. III. D. 2/9, A. 2/5.
Eyes of moderate size, rather above one diameter from end of snout.
Fins ; dorsal commences rather nearer the snout than the base of the caudal,
which latter is entire. Scales, distinct. Colours ; ton to eleven bars descend
down the lower two-thirds of the body to the abdomen, with intermediate
half bands superiorly between them. Dorsal and caudal fins spotted in bands.
Mai. — Tenasserim Provinces.
1872.]
187
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
13. NEMACHEIIVS LADACENSIS.
Nemacliilus ladacensis, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 356.
B. III. D. 11, V. 8, A. 7.
Length of head 1/5, height of body less than 1/5 of the total length
without the caudal fin. Eyes ; diameter 1/5 of length of head, 2 diameters
from end of snout. Snout obtuse. Free portion of tail one-fourth as high
as long.' Fins; upper margin of dorsal oblique, with its anterior angle
rounded, commencing nearer the end of the snout than the root of the
caudal, which latter is roimded. Pectoral extends rather above half way to
the base of the ventral. All the fins are somewhat elongated. Scales ,
absent. Colours, reddish olive, with about nine blackish bars across the
hack, a few small scattered spots upon the sides and caudal fin.
Hal. — Tibet, from whence the single typical specimen, three inches
long, was procured.
14. Nemacheilvs zonata.
Schistu/ra sonata, Mc.CIell., Ini Cyp., pp. 308, 441, pi. 53, fig. 1.
Cobitis sonata, *Cnv. and Val., xviii, p. 39.
B. III. D. 3/7, P. 11, Y. 8, A. 1/5, C. 17.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/6, of dorsal fin a
little above 1/6 of the total length. Eyes ; diameter 2/7 of length of head,
and situated in the middle of its length. Snout rather compressed. Ji Ur-
iels well developed, being about as long as the orbit. Fins; dorsal com-
mences rather nearer the base of the caudal, than the end of the snout.
Caudal forked. Colours ; eleven to thirteen dark zones encircle the back,
but they do not meet on the abdomen, and are not half the width of the
ground colour.
Hal. — Upper Assam, Bengal, and N. W. Provinces.
15. Nemacheimjs SUIil'USCUS.
Schistura subfusca, Mc.CIell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 308, 443, pi. 53, fig. 5.
Cobitis subfuscus , *Cuv. and Val., xviii, p. 80.
Nemachilus subfuscus , *Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 351.
Cobitis cincticwuda, Blytl), J. A. S. of B. 1 800, p. 17-.
Nnnacheilns cincticauda, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 55-.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 11, V. 8, A. 2/5, C. 19.
Length of head 1/5, of pectoral 1/5, of caudal 2/11, height of body 1/7
of the total length. Eyes, situated in the middle of the length of the head,
3 diameters from end of snout, H diameters apart. Barlels well developed,
and nearly as long as the orbit. No projection on the pre-orbital. The free
portion of the tail longer than high. Fins ; dorsal with its upper margin
straight, it arises midway between the posterior margin of the orbit and the
base of the caudal, which last is slightly emarginate. Pectoral extends
25
188
[No. 3,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
three-fourths of the distance to the ventral. Scales, minute. Colours, yel-
lowish, with ten regular brown zones encircling the body and broader than the
ground colour ; a dark bar at the base of the caudal, and a dark band be-
tween the eye and the mouth. Dorsal with some black spots.
Having obtained numerous specimens in Barma, since my paper in the
Proc. Zool. Society was published, I have been enabled to compare them
with Mr. Blyth’s typical one, and Mc.Clelland’s description and figure, leav-
ing no doubt as to their specific identity.
Hal. — Upper Assam and Barma.
16. Nemaciieilus slx'uatus.
Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1870, p. 871.
B. III. D. 2/8-9, P. 12, Y. 8, A. 2/5, C. 18.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/6, height of body 1/6 of the total
length. Fyes, situated in the middle of the length of the head, 2 diameters
from end of snout, If diameters apart. Barbels, long and thin. Fins;
dorsal arises slightly in advance of the ventrals, and midway between the
snout and the base of the caudal, which last is cut square, but some of the
outer rays are rather the shortest. Scales, distinct. Lateral line ceases
opposite the end of the dorsal fin. Colours, olive, with irregular vertical
brown bands, having shorter intermediate ones. A black ocellus at the base
of the upper portion of the caudal fin. Dorsal yellow, with three or four
rows of black spots. Caudal orange with four ~y shaped bars, the centre of
each of which however is inverted.
Ilab. — Wynaad.
17. Nemacheieus Stoliczk.e.
Cobitis StoUcxkce, Stein., Verli. Zool.-hot. Ges. Wien, 18G6, p. 793, t. 14, fig. 2.
Nemachilus Stoliczhce, # Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 360.
B. III. D. 3/7, V. 8, A. 2/5.
Length of head 1/5 of total without the caudal, height of body much
less. Fyes; diameter 2/11 of length of the head. Fins; origin of dorsal
nearer root of caudal than end of snout, its upper margin oblique with the
anterior corner rounded. Caudal slightly emarginate. Pectoral extends a
little above half way to the root of the ventral. Scales, absent. Colours,
darkish, spotted and marbled all over with a darker colour.
Ilab. — Tibet, 15,500 feet above the level of the sea.
18. Nemaciieilus chiobosoma.
Cobitis chlorosoma, McClelland, Ind. Cyp., pp. 305, 437, t. 52, fig. 3 ; *Cuv. and
VaL, xvii ; p, 38.
Wattara, Tel.
B. III. D. 3/6, P. 11, Y. 7, A. 2/5, C. 16.
189
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Oyprinidce.
Length of head 1/7, of caudal 2/11, height of body 2/11 of the total
length. Eyes, high up, diameter 2/9 of length of head, 2 diameters from
end of snout, | a diameter apart. Snout somewhat swollen, barbels about
equal in length to the diameter of the eye. Fins ; dorsal arises midway
between the posterior margin of the orbit and the base ol the caudal. Uic
anal in the last third of the body. Caudal cut square. Scales, distinct.
Lateral line, absent. Colours, straw coloured with a badly developed dark
line along the centre of the body, and irregular greyish pencilling* along
the back. Pectoral, ventral, and anal yellowish ; dorsal with several irre-
gular and badly marked black bands. Caudal with a dark mark at its base,
and several irregularly directed vertical bands.
Hah. — Upper Assam. The specimen from which this description is drawn
up was taken at the Bezwada anicut on the Kistna, and it agrees moderate-
ly well with McClelland’s figure and definition.
19. NEMACItEIUTS riTOXOCHT.TLA.
Colitis phoxocheila, McClelland, Ind. Cyp., pp. 305, 439, t. 52, fig. 4; *Cuv. and
Val., xvii ; p. 79.
Nemachilus photcocheila, #Giinther, Cat-., vii, p. 361; Day, Pioc. Zoo. oc. ,
p. 551.
B. III. D. 2/9, A. 2/5.
Length of head more than height of body. Lyes, situated be oie e
middle of the length of the head, and 2 diameters from end of snout.
Snout rather depressed, no ridge between the orbits. Barbels ; four rostral,
as long as the diameter of the orbit, and two shorter maxillary ones.
Fins; dorsal commences midway between the anterior margm of the orbit
and the base of the anal, and slightly hi advance of the ventral. . The
pectoral does not reach the ventral, nor the latter the anal. Scales, minute.
The two specimens from which this description was drawn up were labelled
as above in the Calcutta Museum, but their colours were bleached, whilst
their tails were destroyed. The caudal fin should be rounded and entire.
McClelland’s description gives an apparently different fish ; he says that
the head is raised obliquely as in the Ferilamps, but this is a frequent
post-mortem appearance ; the ridge between the eyes being sharp and bony.
Colours, above clouded with brown, silvery beneath, with a dark nebulous
streak along the side. Several small bars across the caudal fin.
D. 8, P. 8, Y. 6, A. 0, C. 16, and according McClelland only four barbels,
j Hah. — Mislinii mountains in Northern Assam.
20. Nemacheilus SEKPENT ABIES.
Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 551.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 17, V. 9, A. 2/5, C. 19, L. 1. 64, L. tr. 12/17.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body nearly 1/5 of the
total length. Eyes, small, behind the middle of the length of the head,
190 r. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidoe. [No. 3,
about four diameters from end of snout, and three diameters apart. Snout,
pointed. .Barbels, short, the maxillary pair the longest. Upper lip fim-
briated. Scales, distinct, with a raised keel along their centre. Lateral
line, complete. Fins ; dorsal arises slightly in advance of the ventrals, and
midway between the snout and the base of the caudal fin, its upper margin
straight. Pectoral reaches two-thirds of the distance to the ventral, and
the latter above half way to the anal. Caudal deeply emarginate, its lobes
pointed. Colours, brownish, with a wide dark chestnut band passing from
the snout through the orbit to the base of the dorsal fin, which last has a
black centre. Caudal deep brown with white margins. A black bar across
the base of the ventrals.
Hub. — Doubtful, three specimens are in the Calcutta Museum.
21. Nemacheilus micbops.
Cobitis microps, Stein, Verh. Zool.-bot. Ges. Wien, 1866, p. 794, t. 13, f. 3.
Nemachilus nvicrops, *Giintker, Catal. vii, p. 357.
B. III. D. 11, V. 8, A. 7.
Length of head 1/5 of total without the caudal ; height of body less.
Eyes, small, in middle of length of head. Head, broad, depressed. Snout,
thick. Fins ; dorsal arises rather nearer the root of the caudal than the
end of the snout. Caudal slightly emarginate. Pectoral reaches half way
to the base of ventral. Scales, absent. Colours ; body with many narrow,
vermiculated transverse stripes, which on the back coalesce, and form sixteen
or seventeen broad cross bands.
Hah. — Tibet, 16,000 feet above the sea.
22. Nemacheu/iis stbiatus.
Day, Proe. Zool. Soc. 1867, p 347 ; *Giinthor, Gatal. vii, p. 353.
Cul-irum, and Kul nahura, Tamil.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 11, Y. 8, A. 2/5, C. 17.
Length of head, pectoral and caudal, each 1/7 of the total length.
Height of body 1/11 of the total length. Eyes, diameter nearly 1/4 of
length of head. Barbels, well developed, the external rostral pair reaching
the posterior, and the internal to the anterior margin of the nostrils, to
beneath which same place the maxillary ones extend. Fins ; dorsal arises
slightly in advance of the ventrals, and midway between the snout and the
posterior extremity of the caudal fin ; the caudal slightly lohed at its post-
erior extremity. Scales, well developed. Lateral line, well marked. Colours,
light reddish brown, with narrow vertical bands darker than the ground
colour, and most distinct in the posterior portion of the body, where there
are sixteen posterior to the commencement of the dorsal fin, and several
more between that and the head, which last is marked all over with black lines
191
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinictce.
and spots. A black band at the base of tbe caudal fin. Dorsal brilliant
orange, with a black edge having a light external margin, and a dark base.
Anaf orange with some dull black spots; caudal likewise yellow and
spotted.
Mob. — Wynaad at 8,000 feet elevation. It grows to 2} inches in
length.
23. Nemacheiltts mttgah.
Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 382.
Mugah, Beng.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 11, Y. 8, A. ~-G, C. 17.
Length of head 1/5, of pectoral 1/7, of caudal 1/5, height of body
2/13 of the total length. Eyes, diameter 1/5 of length of head, two diame-
ters from end of snout, 1 f diameters apart. Body with compressed sides.
The free portion of the base of the caudal as long as high. Snout pointed ;
no enlargement of pre-orbital. Barbels, all about as long as the eye.
I1 ins ; dorsal arises midway between snout and base of caudal, its upper mar-
gin is straight ; pectorals extend above half way to the base of ventials ;
caudal emarginate in its posterior length. Scales, small, but distinct ; there
being twelve rows above the lateral line, and thirteen between it and the base
of the ventral fin. Lateral line, commences by two roots, which soon coal-
esce, when it is continued to the base of the caudal. Colours, yellowish, with
a green tinge ; about fifteen brown bands, one-third as wide as the ground
colour, pass across the back and descend on either side below the lateral
line ; a few near the head, and some in the posterior third of the body are
interrupted. Upper surface of head marbled with black. I ins immaculate,
but the two anal rays are black anteriorly, and there are also slight black
marks near the end of the ventrals and on the outer side of the pectorals.
Rostral barbels orange.
Hal. — Cossy river at Midnapore, where it attains two inches in length.
24. Nemacheiltjs stotostigha.
? Bleeker, Verb. Holl. Maatsch. Haarl, 1864, Cobit. et Cyp. Ceylon, p. 5, t. 1,
fig 2 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 352.
B. III. D. 2/8, V. 7, P. 13, A. ?=p*, C. 19.
Length of head 1/5, of pectoral 1/7, of caudal 1/4, height of body
1/8 of tbe total length. Eyes, diameter 1/4 of length of head, 1’- diame-
ters from end of snout. Body elongated and compressed. Pre-orbital some-
what moveable and slightly enlarged at its posterior angle close to the
orbit. Barbels, all longer than the eye. Fins ; dorsal highest in front, it
arises midway between snout and base of the caudal fin, being a little in
advance of the ventrals ; caudal with pointed lobes in its posterior third.
192
[No. 3,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
Scales, moderately distinct. Colours, brownish with dark blotches, almost
bands, on the upper half of the body, and some also upon the fins. Occiput
nearly black. A dark mark at the base of the caudal, which is irregularly
banded. A black spot at the base of the anterior dorsal rays, and a bar
across the lower portion of the fin.
Hab. — Cauvery above Trichinopoly, also ? Ceylon.
25. Nemaciteii/cs mootajtijs.
BcTiistura montana, McClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 307, 440, t. 57, fig. 1.
Colitis montana, #Cuv. and Val., xviii, p. 69.
? Nemacheilus montanus, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 350.
Saant-al, Panj.
B. III. D. 3/7, P. 10, Y. 8, A. 2/5, C. 18.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/6, height of body 1/8 of the total
length. Eyes, small, in the middle of the length of the head. Mead, rather
above half as wide as long. Free portion of tail as deep as long. Eins ;
the dorsal’s upper margin straight and oblique, it commences midway
between the anterior margin of the orbit and the base of the caudal fin ;
pectoral extends a little above half the distance to the ventral. Caudal
with rounded lobes. Scales, absent. Colours , yellowish, with twelve verti-
cal brown bands, much narrower than the intermediate ground colour, and
decreasing in width below the lateral line ; a dark band across the base of
the caudal, which fin as well as the dorsal has a single row of indistinct spots
forming a sort of greyish band ; a dark mark at the base of the anterior
dorsal rays.
Ilab . — Himalayas.
26. Nemacheilus spilopteeus.
Colitis spitopterus, Cuv. and Yal., xviii, p. 27, pi. 522.
Nemachilus spitopterus, Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 358.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 10, Y. 7, A. 2/5, C. 19.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 1/7 of the total length. Height of
body scarcely equals the length of the head. Eyes, near the summit of the
head and in the middle of its length. Barbels, short. Free portion of
tail about twice as long as high. Fins ; dorsal with an oblique upper mar-
gin, it commences midway between the end of the snout and the root of
the caudal. Pectoral reaches half way to the base of the ventral. Caudal
very slightly emarginate. Scales, absent. Colours, greenish yellow, with
from eleven to fifteen irregular bands crossing the back, and a black band
across the root of the caudal fin. A black blotch at the base of the three
first dorsal rays.
Sab. — Himalayas, Assam and Cochin China.
1872:]
P. Day — Monoyrapli of Indian Oyprinidw.
193
27. NeMACHEHATS SAVONA.
Colitis 8M>om, Ham. Buch., Fist. Ganges, pp. 357, 394; McClelland, Ind. Cyp.,
pp. 308, 442, pi. 53, fig. 3, (from H. B.’s MS.) ; *Cuv. and Val., xviii, p. 32.
Nemachilus savona, #Giintker, Catal., vii, p. 354.
Savon-klborka, Beng.
B. III. D. ?=?, P. 10, V. 7, A. 2/5, C. 19.
Lengtli of head 2/9, of caudal 1/6, height of body 1/6 of the total
length. °Eyes, rather large in the anterior half of the head, and 1| diame-
ters from end of snout. Head , as broad as it is long without the snout.
Barbels, long, the four rostral and two maxillary ones reach the eye. Fins ;
dorsal with its upper edge rather convex, it arises midway between the
anterior edge of the orbit and the base of the caudal fin, and its c ommence
ment is before the origin of the ventrals. Pectoral extends two thirds of
the distance to the ventrals, which last does not reach the anal. Caudal
very slightly emarginate, its lobes being rounded. Lateral line, incomplete.
Scales, small, most distinct in the posterior portion of the body. Colours,
brown, becoming lighter on the abdomen, having from ten to twelve very
narrow vertical white bands, not above 1/8 or 1/6 as wide as the ground
colour, a black band at the root of the caudal fin ; a black blotch at the
base of the first few dorsal rays, and four or five rows of dark spots on the
fin. Caudal with narrow bands of dark spots.
Hab. — Bengal. I received some specimens from the lulls near liam-
gani.
28. Nemacheilus Beavani.
Nemacheihis beavani, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 350.
B. III. D. 10, P. 11, V. 7, A. 7, C. 19.
Leno-th of head 2/9, of caudal 2/9, height of body 2/11 of the total
length. Eyes, small, in the middle of the length of the head. Free portion
of the tail rather longer than deep. Barbels, six, four rostral and two
maxillary. Fins; dorsalwithanobhqueupperedge.it arises midway be-
tween the end of the snout and the base of the caudal. Pectoral extends
two-thirds of the distance to the root of the ventral. Caudal lobed.
Colours ; body with nine dark cross bands, broader than the lighter inter-
spaces, a black streak across the root of the caudal. Dorsal and caudal
rays with blackish dots.
Uab. — Cossy river up to 2 inches long.
29. Nemachehats Dentsonii.
P Cobitis montanus, Jerdon, M. J. L. and S. 1849, p. 332 (not McClelland).
Neinacheilus Denisonii, Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 287 ; Guntlier, Catal. vii,
p. 352.
B. III. D. -A-, P. 11, V. 7, A. 2/5, C. 17.
o — y
194
[No. 3,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
Length of head 2/9, of caudal 2/9, height of body 2/13 of the total
length. Eyes ; diameter 1/5 of length of head, 2 diameters from end of
snout, 1 diameter apart. Barbels, short. Fins ; the dorsal commences mid-
way between the end of snout and base of caudal, which last is lobed.
Pectoral extends two-thirds of the distance to the ventrals. Scales, minute.
Lateral line, complete. Colours , reddish brown, having from nine to twelve
yellowish olive vertical zones, those anterior to the dorsal fin coalescing
rather irregularly across the back. Dorsal fin with three rows of fine
black spots. Caudal irregularly spotted in bands. Some dull spots on the
ventral and anal fins. Most of the head marbled with black dots.
Sab. — Nilgherry and Coorg hills, and rivers at their bases.
A variety of this species with longer barbels exists in Mysore, where
it attains four inches in length.
30. Nemacheilus triangularis.
Day, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1865, p. 295, and Fishes of Malabar, p. 203, pi. 14, fig. 1 ;
Gunther, Catal. vii, p 352.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 11, Y. 9, A. 2/5, C. 19.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/4 of the total
length. Eyes ; diameter 1/4 of length of head, 2 diameters from end of
snout and one apart. Barbels, short. Free portion of tail rather deeper
than long. Fins ; upper margin of dorsal fin oblique, it commences midway
between the end of the snout and the base of the caudal, which latter is
emarginate. Scales, distinct. Lateral line, complete. Colours, yellowish,
with about seven black edged bands on the body disposed in a ~7 shape ;
likewise, one passes over the opercles, a second through the eye, a third from
the orbit to the angle of the mouth. Dorsal with three irregular rows of
black spots. Pectoral, ventral, and anal unspotted, but stained at their
margins. Three oblique bars across each lobe of the caudal which has a
black mark at its base.
Sab. — Travaneore hills.
31. * Nemacheilus marmoratus.
Cobitis marmnrata, Heckel, Fisch. Kaschmir, p. 76, t. 12, figs. 1 — 2, and Hugel,
Kaschmir, iv, p. 380; *Cuv. and Yal. xviii, p. 41.
Cobitis vittata, Heckel, 1. c. p. 80, figs. 3, 4 ; and Hugel, Kaschmir, iv, p. 382 ;
*Cuv. and Yal., xviii, p. 42.
NemacMlus marmoratus, *Giinther, Catal. vii, p. 356.
B. III. D. 10, V. 7, A. 7.
Length of head 2/9, height of body less than 2/9 of the length without
the caudal fin. Eyes, small, situated in the middle of the length of the
head. Free portion of tail not elongated. Fins ; upper margin of dorsal
fin oblique, its commencement being nearly midway between the end of the
195
1872.] P. Day — Monograph of Indian Chjprinidte.
snout and tlie root of the caudal, which latter is somewhat convex at its
extremity. Pectoral reaches rather above half way to the root of the
ventral. Scales, absent. Colours ; mottled with brown. In some speci-
mens a dark band exists along the body and some bars over the back of
the tail. (N. vittata.)
Hob. — Kashmir.
32. Nehacheiltts grtffitktt.
Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 360.
B. III. D. 10, P. 11, V. 8, A. 7, C. 15.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/6, height of body 1/8 of the total
length. Eyes; diameter 1/7 of length of head, 3 diameters from en o
snout, which is produced. Free portion of tail low, its dept i eing / o
its length or even less. Fins; upper margin of dorsal oblique, with its
anterior superior angle rounded, it commences midway between e
the snout and the root of the caudal, which latter is emaigina e. ec 0
reaches rather above half way to the root of the ventral. caes, p
Lateral line, complete. Colours; sides of the body, dorsal and cauda ns
irregularly marbled with brownish black, several similar bancs cros
back.
Hah. — Probably Assam, attaining 5J- inches in length.
33. Nemacheiltts cortca.
Colitis conca, Ham. Buch., Fish. Ganges, pp. 359, 395 s *Cuv. and Val . , xvi ii, p . 36.
Schistwa punctata, McClell., Ind. Cyp. pp. 308, 442, pi. 53, fig. 4, (from . .
NcmacMlus corica, #Giinther, Catal., vii, p. 361.
KhoriJca, Beng.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 18, V. 8, A. 2/5, C. 17.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/6 of the total
length. Eyes, of moderate size, in the middle of the length of the head.
Barbels, well developed, the external rostral pair longer than the orbit.
Fins ; dorsal commences anterior to the ventral and nearer t e snou an
the base of the caudal, which last is lobed in its posterior half the lower
being the longer. Upper margin of dorsal fin oblique. Third and fourth
pectoral rays produced, reaching the base of the ventral fin. Scales, visible
in the posterior half of the body. Colours, bluish, with about thirteen
black blotches along the middle of the side, and smaller ones above and
descending to between them.
Hab. — N. E. Bengal, Panjab and Assam.
34. Nemacheiltjs cr'ENtiieri.
Day, I’roc Zool Soc. 1867, p. 285 ; Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 361.
B. III. D. 2/8, P. 11, V. 7, A. 2/5, C. 19.
19G
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinida. [No. 3,
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 2/13, height of body 1/7 of the total
length. Eyes; diameter 2/7 of length of head, 1/ diameters from end of
snout, 1 diameter apart. Head rather compressed. Free portion of tail
longer than deep. Fins ; upper margin of dorsal oblique, the fin commences
midway between the end of the snout and the base of the caudal, which
last is lobed. Pectoral extends three-fifths of the distance to the base of
the ventral. Scales, distinct. Lateral line, incomplete. Colours, pinkish,
coarsely reticulated with olive brown markings, leaving three rows of large
spots along the side ; a black band at the base of the caudal fin, which has
two indistinct dark bands across either lobe, the extremities of which are
stained. Two rows of fine black dots along the dorsal fin, and one across
the anal.
Sab. — Iiivers along the lower slopes, and base of the Nilgherry hills.
35. N EMACHEH.US BLYTHIT.
Day, Proo. Zool. Soo., 1869, p. 552.
B. III. D. 2/7, Y. 9, A. 2/5, C. 19.
Length of head 1/5, of pectoral 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body
2/13 of the total length. Eyes; diameter 2/9 of length of head, 1
diameter from end of snout, 1-} apart. Barbels, longer than one dia-
meter of the orbit. Fins ; dorsal commences midway between the snout
and the base of the caudal fin, which latter has sharp lobes. Scales,
minute. Colows, brownish, becoming lighter on the abdomen ; a dark band
at the base of the caudal.
Sab. — Doubtful. Two specimens 3 inches long exist in the Calcutta
Museum.
36. Nemacheotts butaxexsts.
Colitis Butanensis, McClell., 0. J. N. H. ii, p. 586.
NemacMlus butanensis, Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 358.
B. III. D. 9, Y. 7, A. 7.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 2/11, height of body 1/11 of the total
length. Eyes small, in the middle of the length of the head. Free portion of
tail elongated and compressed, its depth being nearly half of its length. Lips
fringed. Fins, upper margin of dorsal convex, it commences nearer to the
end of the snout than to the root of the caudal, which latter is rounded.
The pectoral does not extend half way to the base of the ventral. Scales,
distinct. Colours, doubtful.
Sal. — Butan, where it attains five inches in length.
37. Nemacheiltts RtTBBipnwis.
Cobitis nibripinnis, Jordon, M. J. L. and S. 1849, p. 332.
NemacheiVus nibripinnis, Day, Fishes of Malabar, p. 203.
B. III. D. 2/6, A. 2/5, C. 13.
Length of head 1/6, of pectoral 1/8, of caudal 1/6, height of body
197
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
1/5 of the total length. Eyes ; diameter 1/0 of length of head, 2 diameters
from end of snout and apart. Fins ; dorsal commences midway between
end of snout and base of caudal fin, which is slightly emarginated. Scales,
minute. Lateral line , complete. Colours, dirty olive along the back
becoming light on the abdomen. Nine bars pass from the back towards
the lateral line, and also a number of irregular bands descend to the same
distance ; a dark bar at the base of the caudal. Dorsal with two bars, the
lowest sometimes red. Caudal with three wide bars.
Hah . — Malabar.
38.* Nemacheilvs ttjeio.
Colitis tuno, Ham. Buck , Fish. Ganges, pp. 358, 395 ; #Cuv. and Val., xviii, p. 33.
„ gibbosa, MeCIell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 304, 436, pi. 52, fig. 7, (from H. B.’s MS.).
„ arenata, Val. in Jacq. Voy. Ind. Poiss., pi. 15, fig 1 ; Cuv. and Val., xviii, p. 28.
Nemacheilas turio, *Giinther, Catal., vii, p. 360.
Tu/ri, Assam.
B. III. D. 8 (10 ?), F. 12, V. 8, A. 7, C. 19.
Length of bead (according to figure) about 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height
of body 1/5 of the total length. Eyes, of moderate size. 1 ree portion ot
tail appears higher than long. Back elevated. Fins; pectoral nearly
reaches the ventral. Caudal emarginate. Colours ; body irregularly spotted
and blotched.
Hub. — Assam.
39.* Nemacheilvs guttatvs.
Colitis guttata, McClell., Ind. Cyp., pp. 305, 438, pi. 52, fig. 5, 6 ; *Cuv. and Val.
xviii, p. 79.
*NemachAlus guttatus, Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 360.
B. Ill, D. 8.
Tliis species is said to have only four barbels. Colours, light green
with dark blotches.
Sab. — Joorhatli in Upper Assam.
Genus. 10. Oeeonectes, Gunther.
Mead depressed, body scarcely compressed. No suborbital spine. Six
barbels round the upper jaw. Dorsal fin placed far backwards at some
distance behind the root of the ventrals ; caudal rounded.
Mob. — China.
Genus. 11. MisGutous, Lacep.
Cobitichthts, Bleeker.
Body elongated and compressed. No suborbital spine. Ten or twelve
barbels, four being on the mandible. Dorsal fin arising opposite the ven-
trals. Caudal rounded.
198
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinida. [No. 3,
Geographical distribution. — This genus which exists in Central and
Eastern Europe has also its representatives in India and China.
Synopsis op species.
1. Misgurms lateralis, D. 10, A. 8. Barbels ten ; body longitudinally banded,
ooellns on base of caudal. Bengal.
2. „ anguilUcmdatus, D. 2/7, A. 8. Barbels tens body irregularly dot-
ted, a black spot on base of caudal. China. Japan.
1. Mr so hunts latekalis.
Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 346.
B. III. D. 10, Y. 7, A. 8.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/6, height of body rather lass than
1/6 of the length. Eyes ; diameter 2/9 of length of head, nearly 2 diame-
ters from end of snout. Head and body compressed. Barbels ten, the
inner mandibular pair vory short. Free portion of tail rather longer than
deep. Fins ; dorsal arises midway between end of snout and the root of the
caudal, and slightly in advance of the root of the ventral. Pectoral rather
longer than the head. Caudal rounded. Scales, very distinct. Colours ;
a broad brown band, runs along the middle of the side, and is separated from
the brown back by a yellowish band ; a narrow and indistinct brown band
on the abdomen; a black ocellus edged with white on the base of the
upper half of the caudal fin. Dorsal and caudal finely mottled with brown.
Sab. — Bengal from whence one specimen 3| inches long was received.
2. MiSOUENUS ANCHriLLICAIIDATUS.
Colitis anguilliccmdata, Cantor, Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist., 1842, p.485; Bichard.,
Voy. Sulph. Fish., p. 143, pi. 55, fig. 9, 10.
Colitis hi/u.rcuta, McClell., C. J. N. Hist., 1844, p. 400, pi 23, fig. 1,
? „ pectoraUs, McClell., 1. o., fig. 3, (Pect. fins elongated).
„ micropus, Cuv. and Val., xviii, p. 29.
„ psa/mmismus, Richard, Ioh. China, p 300.
„ rubripinwis et rmculata, Temm and Schleg, Fauna Japon, pp. 220, 221,
t. 103, fig. 1, 2.
,, decemcirrhosus, Basilewsky, M£m, Soc. Nat. Mosc. 1855, p. 239,
? Colitichthys enalios, Bleeker, Act. Soc. Sc. Indo. Neerl., viii, Japan, vi, p. 88,
t. 2, fig. 4, (Pectoral fins elongated.)
Misgumus anguUlicaudatus, Gunther, Catal., vii, p. 345.
B. III. D. 2/7, P. 9, V. 7, C. 13, L. r. 140, L. tr. 30.
Barbels ten, four being mandibular. Fins ; origin of dorsal midway
between occiput and base of caudal. Pectoral shorter or as long as the
head. Scales, distinct. Colours ,• body and fins irregularly dotted with
brownish black, and generally a small black spot at the upper portion of the
root of the caudal fin.
Sab. — China, Japan, Formosa.
(To be continued.)
109
1872.]
Monograph of Himalayan, Assamese, Barmebe and Cingalese Clau-
silias, — by William T. Blanford, F. G. S., C. M. Z. S., Ac.
(With Plato IX.)
[Received 19th January, read 2nd February, 1872.]
Not a single species of Clausilia has hitherto been found in India proper,
South of the Himalayas, not even in the semi-Malay fauna of the Malabar
coast, although one kind occurs in Ceylon* The few forms hitherto
described from the territories belonging to the British Indian Empire are
from the mountains to the north, or from the countries to the eastward.
Several of those described are rare and local, and some are from places very
difficult of access. .
By the kindness of my friends, Major God win- Austen, Mr. .Theobald,
Dr. Stoliczka, and Mr. G. Nevill, I have been furnished with specimens of
all the species not in my own collection, hitherto described from British
Barma, Assam, the Himalayas and Ceylon, except Clausilia vespa, Gould,
C. insignis, Gould, and O. bulbus, Benson. I have copied authentic figures
of the last two, and I add a representation of a shell from Moulmein which
may possibly be a variety of C. vespa.
I am unable, without access to a greater number of types, to assign all
the Himalayan and Burmese Clausilia to the proper sub-genera. Those to
which the known species hitherto been referred do not always appear to me
to include them. Thus C. insignis, Gould, C. Philippiana, Pfr., and
C. cylindrica, Gray, have all been classed in Phcedusa, to which I am in-
clined to doubt if any except the first really belong. I have classed the
species in natural sections, and I have given the most conspicuous characters
of each group ; and in one case only I have proposed a new sectional or
sub-generic name.
Section I.— Shell homy, smooth, elongate ; the apical portion decidu-
ous ; lunule rudimentary or wanting, palatal plicae few, the uppermost
elongate.
l.f Clausilia cylindrica, Gray.
Pfeiffer, Symbol. Ill, p. 93. Mon. Hell. II, p. 428 III, p 590 IY, p. 725
VI, p. 412. Kiistor, Mart, and Chemn., PI. XI, f. 12—16. Hanley and Theobald,
Conchologia Indica, PI. XXIV, f. 4.J
* But a single species C. Jennaarensis, Pfr. , has hitherto been obtained in the
Ethiopian region. The genus is fonnd throughout the temperate portion of the
polmarctic region, in the Malay (or Indo-Malay) province, and in part of the neotro-
pical region.
■[ The figures in PI. IX correspond in their numbers with the species, thus :
1, C. cylind/rica, is fig. 1. 2, 0. Ios, fig. 2, &c.
j The full synonomy being given in Pfeiffer’s Monograph, I do not repeat it,
but only add references to figures.
200 W. T. Blanford — Monograph of Clamilice. [No. 3,
Hah. — Western Himalayas from the western frontier of Nipal to the
Satlej valley, at elevations from 5000 to 9000 feet.
The figure in the Conchologia Indica is that of a specimen which,
although adult, has retained its apex. This is a very rare occurrence. The
figure now given represents the shell as it is usually found.
Three palatal plaits, the upper elongate, are always present, and beneath
them there is occasionally to he found a rudimentary lunella. The charac-
ters both of the shell and of the internal plication differ widely from
those of typical Pheedusa, in which sub-genus I do not think that the
present species can be included. It stands by itself, and I am inclined to
look upon it as the type of a peculiar section.
Section II. — ? Medora H. and A. Adams. Shell fusiform, horny, costulate
or smooth, apex not deciduous. Lunule develoj>ed, with few, usually two,
palatal plicse above it, the upper elongate.
2. Clausibia Ios, Benson.
Ann. and Mag. Nat, Hist. 1852, Ser. 2, Yol. X, p. 350. Pfeif. Mon. Hel, III, p. 612 j
— IV, p. 761 ; — VI, p. 495. Hanley and Theobald, Conch. Ind., PI. XXIV, fig. 10.
Hal.- — Temperate regions of Sikkim and Butan, in the Eastern Hima-
layas, from about 5000 to 9000 feet. It doubtless also exists in Nipal.
It is generally met with at the roots of oaks and other large trees.
In this species, as was noticed by Mr. Benson, the lunule is sometimes
broken up into short oblique plaits above, and consequently the number of
palatal plicse varies. Sometimes there is only the long lamellar plait above
the lunule, in other specimens there are, besides the long one, two short plicse.
3. Cr.Arsir.TA bacillum, Benson.
Hanley and Theobald, Conch. Ind. PI. XXIV, fig. 1, nec Thoabald, J. A. S. B.,
1858, p. 321.
f C. ignota, Thoob. J. A. S. B., 1858, Vol. XXVII, p. 321, (descriptio nulla).
Testa subrimata.fusiformis, solidula, glabra, vix striatula, nitidula, su-
perficie scape in exempt is veteribus erosa, albulo- vel cereo- cornea; spira
superne regulariter attmuata ; apice obluso, papillari ; sutv/ra simplice impres-
sa. Anfr. 9 context, ultimas validius striatus, pone aperturam vix compres-
sus ; apertura verticals, piriformi-ollonga, lamella sup era valid iori, columel-
lari antice vix conspicua, parum torta, intus subfurcata ; lunella distincta,
plicis palatalibus 2, sutures parallelling, supera clongata, altera brevi, a lunel-
la vix disjuncta. Peristoma continuum, solutim, album, breviter expansum et
incrassatum, margine parietali vix sinuato. Long. 15, anfr. penult, diam. 3'5
m.m. ; apart, cum perist ornate 3’33 longa, 2'33 m.m. lata.
Hub. in montibus Khasi et JVctga dictis, ultra fines meridionales vallis
Assamensis. TV. Theobald ad Nanclui in montibus Khasi invenit, II. Godwin-
Austen baud procul ab Asalu in Cachar septentrionali.
201
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Monograph of Clmsiliee.
This species is near C. Ios, but easily distinguished by the absence of
costulate sculpture. I think there can be but little doubt of the identity of
the form found by Major Godwin-Austen, from which my figures and de-
scription are taken, with the C. lacillum of the Oonchologia Indica, but as
only one single figure is given in that work, and there is no description, I
may be mistaken. I doubt, however, that this is the C. lacillum of Mr.
Theobald’s paper in the Journal for 1858, 1. c., because that was said to be
of the type of C. insignis, which can scarcely said to be the case with the
present species, but as no descriptions were furnished in Mr. lheobald s paper,
his names cannot be retained. The name, in the present instance, must be
considered as founded on the figure in the Conchologia Indica.
4. Clattsilia Ceylanica, Bens.
Ann, and Mag. Nat. Hist., February, 1863, Ser. 3, Vol. XX, p. 89.
Pfeiffer, Mon. Hel. VI, p. 427.
Hal. — The mountains in the southern part of Ceylon.
This shell was first found by Mr. Layard, and has since been obtained
by Mr. H. No v ill. I am indebted to Messrs. G. Nevill and Stoliczka for
the loan of specimens.
Benson, in his original description, has overlooked the lunule, which is
well developed, as in the two preceding species.
5. Clausilia Theobaldi, sp. nov.
Testa rimata, fusiformi turrita, cornea, confertim flexuose costulata,
translucens. Spira turrita, sensim attenuata, laterilus superne suhectis,
apice acutiusculo, sutura impressa. Anfr. 11 convexi, antepenultimus et
penultimus majores, ultimus juxta suturam tumidiusculus, infra plica/m
palatalem superam compressus, sultus rotundatus. Apertura vix olliqua,
piriformis, lamellis approximate, mediocribus, supera acuta, infera immersa,
lunella distincta, plicis palatalibus 2, supera elongata, altera brevi. Peris-
toma rectum, expansum, solutum, margine palatali laud sinuato. Long. 22
mm., diam. 3'5 ; apert. 3'5 mm., longa, 2' G lata.
Hob. — Tonghu in provincia Barmana. Detexit W . Theobald.
This is the only species of the present group hitherto found in Barma.
Section III .—Phoedusa, H. and A. Adams. Shell fusiform, generally
rather thick ; apex not deciduous. No lunule, palatal plicae numerous, the
uppermost produced nearly to the aperture.
A. Sutures crenulated.
6. Clausal ia loxostoma, Bens.
J. A. S. B., 1836, Vol. V, p. 353. Pfeiffer, Mon. Hel. II, p. 404 III, p. 590
IV, p. 725 j — VI, p. 411. Hanley and Theobald, Conch. Ind. PI. XXIV, fig. 7.
0. Bengalensis, Von dem Busch, Pfeiffer, Symb. II. p. 60.— Kuster, Mart, and
Chem. p. 24, pi. 2, fig. 11-13,
202 W. T. Blanford — Monograph of OlamiUee. [No. 3,
Hab. — Khasi hills, Nortli-east of Bengal, and South of the Assam val-
ley-
The locality usually assigned to this shell, Bengal, conveys a false
impression, as neither this nor any other Clausilia is found in the plains of
India. Teria ghat, the locality mentioned in the Conchologia Indica, is at
the southern base of the Khasi hills, and the shell is found at many places
along the range, from the base up to a height of, I believe, 4000 or 5000 feet.
Major Godwin- Austen sent me this species from Habiang on the Khasi
plateau. I do not know if O. loxostoma occurs also on the northern or As-
sam flank of the range ; I have never seen specimens from any place in that
direction, and as the climate is much drier, many of the shells common on
the southern watershed are wanting to the north.
The form of this species varies considerably, some specimens being much
more fusiform than others. I have figured three varieties, of which figure 6
may be considered as the typical form.
7. Cr.Arsir.iA febtutootea, sp. nov.
Testa subrimata, clongato-fusiformis, solida, fere glabra, striatula, baud
nitida, sordide et interdum pollute ferruginca ; spira alta, lateribus sursum
subrectis, apice obtuso papillari, sutura impressa, valde crenulata. Anfr.
11 convexi, ultimus capillaceo-striatus, basi rotundatus. Apertura fere verti-
calis, subtrapezoidalis, margimibus lateral ibus fere parallelis, basali rotundato ;
lamella supera acuta , smistrorsim inflexa, colmnellari mediocri, plicis pala-
talibus circa 5, supera elongata, baud procul ab apertura desinente, sutura
parallels, cceteris magis obliquis curvatisque. Peristoma continuum, album,
expansum, parum incrassabum, margine supero repando, leviter sinuato.
Long. 30, diem. 5'5 mm.; apert. cum perist. G'5 longa, 4'GO lata.
Hab. — In montibus Naga dictis, ultra fines mcrulionalcs provincial As-
sam, (ditexit Masters).
la. Var. tumida, anfractibus ultimis aperturaque majoribus. Long,
circa 33, diam. 6'5 mm., apert. 7 longa, 5 lata.
Hab. — In “North Cacliar,” (Godwin -Austen).
This fine species, the largest hitherto found in Assam or the Himalayas,
resembles O. loxostoma in its strongly crenulated sutures and in form, but
differs in its larger size and more numerous whorls. It was first found by
Mr. Masters in 1860, in the hills south of Golaghat, together with Spiracu-
lurn Mastersi and other interesting shells. The more tumid variety has late-
ly been obtained in North Caehar by Major Godwin- Austen.
8. Clausilli AsAT.ijF.NSrs, Godwin-Austen, MS.
Testa nonrvmata,fusiformi-turrita, alba vel pallide castanea, solidula,
striata, ad anfractus duos ultimos capillaceo-striata. Spira sensitn attenuata
lateribus superne concaviusculis, apice obtusiusculo, sutura impressa, confertvm
203
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Monograph of Clausilice.
minuteque crenulata. Anfr. 12-13, convexi, antepenultimus maximus, penul-
timm parum minor , ultimus ad latus compressus, ad basin rotundatus. Aper-
tura subverticalis, piriformis, lamella supera compressa, columellari immersa,
lunella nulla, plica palatali supera elongata, suturas parallels, secunda etiam
parallela, mediocri, cwteris obliquis. Peristoma leviter sinuatum, album, in -
crassatum, continuum, breviter solutum. Long. 23'5, diam. 5 mm. ; apert. c.
perist. 5 longa, 3'66 lata.
Hah. ad Asalu in North Cachar, ad altitudinem 7000 ped. angl.
(Godwin- Austen.)
This species is easily distinguished from both C. loxostoma and C. fer-
ruginea by its more numerous whorls and finely crenulate sutures. In size
it is intermediate between the two, some specimens being as much as 2G mm.,
or rather more than an inch in length.
B. Sutures simple.
9. Claus ri.Lv ftjslfobmis, W. Blanf.
J. A. S. B„ 1865, Tol. XXXIV, Pt. 2, p. 80. Pfeiffer, Mon. Hel. Vol. VI, p. 410.
Hanley and Theobald, Conch. Ind. PI. XXIV, fig. 6.
Hah. — Arakan hills, Barma. _
This shell was described from a single immature specimen. Mr. Iheo-
bald has since found several adult shells from one of which the figure now
given is taken. These differ a little from the type, they are smaller, and the
lower whorls are rather more couvex. The peristome is thickened, expanded
and continuous. The following are the characters of the form now figured.
Testa non rvmata,fusiformis, albo-cornea, minute oblique preesei tvm a
anfractum ultimum eostulato striata ; spira supra anfr. antepenultwmm
lente de crescents, versus apicem acutiutculum rapide attenuata , su ura sim
plice parum impressa, versus apicem profundi ore. Anfr. 8-9 , supen convexi,
cceteri convcxiusculi, antepenultimus tumulus, pemltimus nnnor, ultimus ad
basin rotundatus. Apertura rotund at o-pir if brmts, parum obliqua, lamella
supera mediocri, infera paulum immersa torla ; lunella nulla, plica palatali
supera lonqissima, casteris brevioribus subparallelis, vui o iquis. et istoma
album, incrassatum, expansum, continuum, non solutum leviter sinuatum.
Long. 22 5, diam. 6 mm. Apert, c. perist. 6 mm. longa, o lata.
This species closely resembles the next, hut appears to be distmgmshed by
having 1 to 2 whorls less, by the apex being less attenuate, and the lower
palatal plaits much less oblique. It is quite possible, however, that connecting
links may be found, in which case I should be inclined to unite the two.
10. Clatjsilia Gouldlvxa, Pfr.
Malabo*. Blatter, 1856, Vol. Ill, P- 259,-Mon. Hel. IV, p. 724, -VI, p. 409.-
Nov. Conch. I, p, 123, PI. XXXIV, fig. 18—20.
jpab Mergui and Moulmain, Tenasenm provinces, British Barma.
27
204 W. T. Blanford — Monograph of Clausilits. [No. 3,
This species was first described by Pfeiffer from Mergui specimens in
Mr. Hugh Cuming’s collection. It has since been found abundantly by Mr.
Theobald near Moulmain. It varies much in colour, some specimens being
brown, others rosy pink, others nearly white ; the peristome is either pink
or white. Some shells from Moulmain are only 22 milkynetres long, others
are nearly 26.
11. CliAUSILIA msiGNis, Gould.
Proc. Bost. Soc. Nat. Hist. Yol. I, p. 140. — Boat. Jour. Nat. Hist. Yol. IY, p. 458,
pi. XXIV, fig. 8. Pfeiffer, Mon. Hel. II, p. 423.
Sab. — Tavoy, Tenaserim provinces, Barma.
The figure given is copied from Gould’s. I have never seen this species.
12. ClATTSIXIA SP.
C. insignis , Pfr. (nec Gould), Mon. Hel III, p. 589 — IV, p. 725. — YI, p. 409. —
Nov. Conch. I, p. 122, PI. XXXIV, fig. 15—17.
C. insignis, Hanley and Theobald, Conch. Ind. PI. XXIV, fig. 2.
Sab. — Tenaserim provinces. Yar. gracilior, Conch. Ind. PL XXIV,
fig. 3, is from Moulmain.
The figure now given is copied from that in the Concliologia Indica, but
reduced to the natural size.
It appears to me evident, either that Gould’s figure of C. insignis in the
Boston Journal is incorrect, or that a different shell has been figured under
the same name by Pfeiffer and Hanley. The first is improbable, because the
other shells represented on the same plate are excellently figured, and I can
only conclude that two forms have been confounded under this name. The
C. insignis of Pfeiffer and Hanley requires naming, but as 1 have no speci-
mens, and the system of giving names to figures is highly objectionable, I
shall not attempt to supply the deficiency.
The C. insignis, var. gracilior of the Concliologia Indica is probably a
variety of the present form. Prom the references given in the Concliologia
I am inclined to believe that Mr. Hanley has already noticed the differences
between Gould’s and Pfeiffer’s shells described as C. insignis, and that he
believes the former to be represented by fig. 2, the latter (his var, gracilior')
by fig. 3, of PI. XXIV, of the Concliologia. It appears to me, however, that
Pfeiffer’s figure in the Novitates Concliologicce agrees far better with fig. 2,
than with fig. 3, and that Gould’s original figure in the Boston Journal re-
presents a shell quite distinct from both.
13. Clausiua monticola, Godwin-Austen. MS.
Testa rimata, exilis, elongata, fusiformi-subulata, solidula, brunnea vel
brunnescente-grisea, striata, paruin nitida ; supcrjicie scepe erosa ; spirce
lateribus antice rectis, apicem papillarem versus concaviusculis ; sutura
simplice, impressa. Anfr. 13 convexi,primi 4 fere cylindrici, antepenultimus
205
1872.] W. T. Blanford — Monograph of Clausilice.
vix quam penultimus major, ultimas ad basin rotundafus, hand compressus.
Apertura piriformis, fere verticals, lamella palatali sinistrorsim deflexa,
acuta; colwnellari subprof unda ; lunella nulla, plicis palatalibus fere paral-
lelis 6-7, supera valde elongata. Peristoma continuum, vix solutum, leviter
sinmtum, superne repandum, expansiwculum,mediocriter incrassatum, album,
margins parietali leviter sinuato. Long. 21, diam. anfr. penult. 4 mm. ;
apert. cum perist. 3'6G longa, 2'66 lata.
Hob— In montibus Burrail dictis, ad latus meridionals vallis Assamen-
sis, in “ North Cachar,” ad alt, circa 6500 ped. angl. detexit H. H. Godwin-
Austen.
This species is well distinguished from its allies by its slender shape and
numerous whorls.
I have a single specimen of a Glausilia from the Arab an hills, somewhat
similar to C. monticola, but with only ten whorls. As it is bleached and
the surface in had condition, I do not desribe it.
Section IV. — Oospira,* sect. non. Shell with but few whorls, usually
five or six, and of a peculiar more or less oval form with a very blunt apex.
Lunule wanting, palatal plaits as in Phcedusa. Type C. Philippiana, Pfr.
The known shells of this section are solid deeply coloured Clausilice,
smooth or with very slight sculpture. So far as is hitherto known, the tj pe
is peculiar to Martaban and Tenasserim.
14. Clausilia Philippiana, Pfr.
Zeitschr. f. Malak. 1847, p. 69— Mon. Hel. II, p. 423 III, P- 690 IV,
p. 725 VI, p 401, Kiister, Mart, and Chem. p. 100, PI XI, fig 7—9. Stoliczka,
J. A. S. B j 1871, Vol. XL, Pt. II, p. 174, PI. VI, fig. 7-10 (lingual teeth, jaw and
anatomy).
glob, Moulmain. According to Pfeiffer this shell is also found at Mer-
gui, but I have never seen specimens from the latter locality.
15. Clausilia vespa, Gould.
Proc. Boston Soc. 1859, Vol. VI, p. 12,-Otia Conchologica, p. 220, Pfeiffer,
Mon. Hel. VI, p. 409.
Hab. — Tavoy (and Moulmain ?).
I have figured a shell from Moulmain which may possibly be this form,
as it agrees in its measurements with Gould’s type ; but it is barely separa-
ble from C. Philippiana. Gould’s description is so meagre that, it is very
difficult to identify the species, and it has never, so far as I am aware, been
figured.
The shell here represented has a most astonishing resemblance to Clau-
silia Bartletti, H. Adams, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1866, p. 441, PI. XXXVIII, fig.
2, from Peru. We shall presently see that this is not the only instance of
resemblance between Burmese and South American Clausilice.
* Ltyrn. aov an egg and airupa a spiral.
20G
[No. 3,
W. T. Blanford — Monograph of Clamilw.
1G. Claijsilia bulbub, Bens.
Ann. and Mag. Nat. Hist. 1863, Ser. 3, Yol. XI, p. 321. Pfeiffer, Mon. Hel. VI,
p. 409. Hanley and Theobald, Conoh. Ind. PI. XXIV, fig. 5.
I Tab. — Banks of the river Attaran, near Moulmain. I have never seen
this species. The figure in the Conohologia Indioa is, I believe, taken from
Mr. Benson’s original specimen ; I have therefore given a copy reduced to
the natural size.
17. Claus ilia oVata, sp. nov.
Testa vix subrimata, elongato-ovata, pwpiformis, intense rufo-ferruginea,
regulariter confertimque striata ; spira tumida, apice convexo, sutura parum
impressa. Anfr. 5'5 convexiasculi, primi rapide accrescentes, antepenultimus
maximus, penultimus vix minor, ultimus ad basin rotundatus. Apertura
auriformis, fere verticalis, juxta anfractum penultimum repanda, lamella
swpera acuta, antice validiore, fere verticali, infera stricta ; lunella nulla,
plicis palatalibus 7, supera producta, in fauce apertura; conspicua, sutura
parallela, sccunda curvata, cateris brevibus obliquis. Long. 19, diam. 7 mm.
Apert, oblique 6 longa, 4'5 lata.
LLab. Ad Nattoung , juxta ripam Attaran fluminis, baud procul a
Moulmain in Burma.
This is a fourth species of this little group. It is more ovate than C.
Bhilippiana and C. vespa, smaller and less tumid than C. bulbus.
Section Y. — ?Nenia II. and A. Adams. Shell elongate, mouth entire-
ly free from the last whorl, and broadly expanded, both the lamella: of the
aperture on the parietal margin and close together, subcolumellar lamina
large and not concealed by the columellar, a large lunule and one or two
parietal plaits above it.
This group includes one species from British Barma, and one ( 0 '. tuba*
Hanley) from the Shan States of Upper Barma, outside of the British terri-
tories. It appears to differ from the South American forms which compose
the subgenus JSTenia in the possession of a lunule, but I have no sufficient
means of comparison, and in other respects some of the Neotropical forms
closely resemble those of Barma.
18. Clausilia Masoni, Theob.
J. A. S. B., 1864, Vol. XXXIII, p. 246, Hanley and Theobald, Conch. Ind. PI.
XXIV, fig. 8.
Hah. — Near Tonghii in the mountains between Pegu and Martaban.
The lamella: of the aperture are as above described. Those of O. tuba
are precisely similar.
* Ann. and Mag. Nat. Hist May, 1868, Ser. 4, ol. I, p. 313. By mistake, in
the Conclwlogia Indica, the Proceedings of the Zoological Society are quoted as the
work in which this species was described.
1872.]
207
Postscript to the Monograph of Himalayan and Barmese
CiAHSiHiE, — by Dr. F. Stoliczka.
(Received 31st July, 1872.)
(See plate IX.)
In looking through the proof-sheets of Mr. Blanford’s paper, while they
passed through the press, and comparing his descriptions with the specimens
of Indian and Barmese Glamilim in my collection, I find that a few additions
can be made to the Monograph. The new species are figured on the same
plate, IX. I would have gladly handed over the additional materials to
Mr. Blanford, hut as he is now engaged on an expedition in Persia, and may
not for some time return to Calcutta, I do not think it advisable to defer
on that account the publication of these notes.
I have only to observe that I had an opportunity of comparing some of
Mr. Theobald’s original specimens, and have thus been enabled to add some
information regarding the synonymy of one or two doubtful species.
1. Cl. cylindrica. (Ad p. 199.)
I have specimens of this species from near Tezpiir (Asam), and Dr.
Waagen very recently brought one from near Mairi ; the gco_,iap ica
tribution of the species may, therefore, he said to extend ovei the w o e o
the southern slopes of the Himalayas, though its head-quarter appears to be
about Nyni-tal, or near the centre of the range.
3. Cl. bacillum. (Ad p. 200.)
This species varies considerably both in the form an eng i o e s it
The specimen figured may be taken as the type, but others longer and s eafarer
are quite as common, they very closely resemble Theobald, m form differing
from it by their smooth shining surface. One of the most slender speci-
i i y i xi i « 4-WMmPss 3 mm. ; it has 10^ whorls and is
mens measures : total length 15, thickness o >
much attenuated towards the apex.
The representation in the ‘ Conch. Indica’ must evidently be taken as
that of true bacillum, of which, the authors of that work say two specimens
were known at that time: one in Benson’s and the other in Theobalds col-
lection. These are the two specimens to which Theobald (Journ. A. S B.,
1858, p. 321) refers under the name of ignota, as a provisional name, while
the single specimen which he quotes 1. c. as ‘ G. Bacillun B.’ is a somewhat
worn Cl. Asnhiensis, and hence Theobald’s reference that the species is of
the type of G. insignis. I have carefully examined with Mr. Theobald his
type specimens, and the question as regard the synonymy may be considered
as settled ; the species must stand as recorded by Blanfoid.
208
F. Stoliczka — Postscript to Monograph of Glausilice. [No. 3,
6. Cl. loxostoma. (Ad p. 202.)
The typical specimens of this species are pale brownish or dull ferru-
ginous, and nearly smooth or obsoletely striated. Together with these a white,
solid variety occurs on the Khasi hills ; in form it tolerably agrees with
Blanford’s fig. (5b (plate IX), some specimens arc, however, still a little
thicker, and the transverse costulation on all the whorls is very distinct,
while the crenulation along the suture is generally not so coarse, as in typi-
cal loxostoma, though evidently stronger than in Asaluensis, which latter
also differs by a more slender shape and smaller aperture. Although the above
noticed form appears to be a well marked variety of loxostoma, the differences
do not seem to be constant, and both shells unquestionably are of the
same type. The crenulation on the two last whorls is often most regular,
each alternate rib somewhat projecting into the sutural impression. In other
specimens two ribs unite to a sutural tooth. The stronger or finer costula-
tion, or striation, of the whorls appears to depend upon the character of the
locality in which the specimens live.
I have added a figure (6 <T) of one of the shortest costulated varieties
from the Khasi hills.
10. Cl. Gotjxdiana. (Ad p. 203.)
This also is one of the most variable species, both in colour and form.
Young specimens are either brown or of a beautiful rosy tinge ; older shells,
after they become solidified, either retain the brown or pink colour, or the lip
becomes yellowish brown or perfectly white ; the 3-5 top-whorls are always
white. The form differs from fusiform to highly turreted, as may be indi-
cated by the following measurements—
a. long 23, lat. 6, long, apert. S'2, ej. lat. 4 2 mm.
b- ,, 28, „ 6 3, ,, „ 6'2, „ „ 5' „ ,,
c* » *12, ,, 6 5, ,, ,, 6* „ ,, 5. „ ,,
All three specimens are from near Monlmain ; a is almost exactly identical with
Pfeiffer’s original figure of the speoies ; b and c are a white and a yellowish liped va-
riety from. Mr. Theobald’s collection ; c has an almost abnormally small aperture as
compared with the length of the shell.
11 and 12. Cl. insignis. (See also fig. 12«; ad p. 204).
Mr. Blanford is of opinion that Pfeiffer’s insignis is not the same as
Gould’s, but that it is identical with the form figured by Hanley and Theobald
in the Conch. Iconica.
There is undoubtedly . a slight discrepancy between Gould’s original
figure and description. He states the number of whorls to be 8 or 9, and the
apex 1 mamillated,’ while the figure shews it shortly pointed ; then again he
gives ‘ length 1 inch, breadth ^ of an inch.’ The original figure (whether
enlarged or not, it is not stated) represents a shell of 28 mm. in length arid 7
m thickness ; the second dimension is, therefore, only one fourth of the total
209
1872.] F. Stoliezka — Postscript to Monograph of Clausilice.
length, instead of one fifth ; if the latter were the case, the shell would be an
extremely slender one, and comparing it with Oouldiana, as a shell of the
same type, I would prefer to consider Gould’s figure as more probably correct,
than his measurement. Now, allowing for these discrepancies in Gould’s ori-
ginal statements, I am inclined to think that Pfeiffer’s species is very closely
allied to, if not exactly identical with, ti-ue insignis, hut Hanley and Theo-
bald’s figures certainly seem to he somewhat different from both the preced-
ing ; however, they do not exclude the possibility ol representing mere
variations of one and the same species. Whether the form of the aperture in
Gould's original figure is slightly exaggerated or not,' I think the great ex-
pansion of the outer lip is decidedly somewhat abnormal, and setting aside
this point the remaining differences between the shells figured as insignis
are not greater than those between the different varieties ol loxostoma or
Oouldiana.
In order to clear up the matter more easily I add here (fig 12«) a copy
of Pfeiffer’s figure of insignis. I greatly regret that I have not got the oppor-
tunity of examining Mr. Theobald’s two type specimens, figured in the
Conchologia Indica as ‘ insignis' and var. gracilior, but possibly I may be
in a position to supply the deficiency in the next number of the Journal.
15. Cl. vespa. (Ad p. 205.)
The shell delineated by Mr. Blanford as a variety of vespa may be con-
sidered as a fair representation of that species ; but I add a figure (15a)
and description of a specimen obtained by Mr. Theobald at 1 avoy , whence
vespa was originally got, and which is undoubtedly Gould s species.
(15a). Cl. testa ovato-cglindracea, ad apicem obtusiuscula, albida, medio
subinflata, ultimo anfractu sensim attenuate, haud rimata, fusco castanea ;
anfractibus sex, convexiusculis, sutura simplici junctis, transversim oblique et
confertissime striolatis ; aperlura subovata, postice rotundate subungulata,
antice late sub-efusa, intus violaceo rufa, peritremate modice expanso, interno
oblique fere recto, libero, biplicato ; plica antica, vel infer iore, vaJde obliqua,
sub-immersa ; plicis palatalibus novem tenuibus, supera longissima, ciiciter
1-2 m.m. a margine suturali distante, alteris brevioribus et inter se valde
inaqualibus.
Long. 24.6 m.m., lat. 7 ; long, apert. cumperist. 6 3, ejusdem lat. 4'8 m.m
Although allied to Phillippiana the present form is undoubtedly quite
distinct, differing from Pfeiffer’s species by a piore slender shape, smaller
aperture, free inner lip, peculiarly flattened or almost canaliculated aperture
on the anterior end, and by the larger number ot palatal plicae.
19. CiiATisn-rA Waageki, n. sp.
Ol. testa conoideo-turrita, corneo-fitsca, apice obtusiuscula, sub-rimata
anfractibus 11, paulo convexis, sutura simplici junctis, lateraliter api-
210
F. Stoliczka — Postscript to Monograph of Clausilice. [No. 3,
cent versus paululum concava ; omminis transversim oblique confertim con -
stulato-striatis, ultimo antecedents vix latiore, prope aperturtlm costulato,
basi paulum contracts, convexiusculo ; apertura verticali, postice (vel supra)
angulata ; peritremate modice incrassato, vix expanso, albescente, antice re -
cedente, interno soluto, antice rectiusculo, biplicato, plica postica (put 'supe-
riore) brevi, altera vix conspicua ; lunella distincta, plica longa, tenuissima
superposita, altera brevi, a terminations supera lunella baud separata.
Long, tota 18, diem. 4 ; long, apert. obliq. 4, ejusdem lat. 2 "7 m. m.
Hab. — Changligalli, prope Marri, Himalaya Occident., ad altitudinem
circa 9000 ped. angl. detexit TP. Waagen.
This is the most westerly known species of the genus in India. A sin-
gle, hut perfect, specimen was found by Dr. W. Waagen, together with Cl.
cylindrica, under the bark of an old tree at the above mentioned locality.
The nearest allied species is Cl. Ibs, but the larger size of the shell, .com-
parative shortness of the two last whorls, larger and more straight aperture
readily distinguish this new form.
20. Cl.. Abakana, Theob. (M.S.)
Cl. testa stramineo-albida, subfiisiforme-turrita, apice attenuata, apertu-
ram versus subangustata, non rirnata ; arfractibus 10-12, paulum convexius-
culis, sutura profunda simplici junctis , transversim oblique capillaceo striola-
tis ; apertura rectiuscula, sub-rectangulari, antice subrotundata, marginibus
modice dilatatis et incrassatis, labio breviter libero,fere recto, biplicato, plica
antica (seu inferiore) wide oblique intrants ; plicis palatalibus quinque,fere
cequidistantibus et inter se parallelis, supera longissima, ewteris subcequalibus.
Long. 17 — 20; lat. 3 '8-4 ; long, apert. 4-4 '4, hit. 3-3'2 m.m.
Hab. — In montibus Arakanensis et ad Mai-i in provincia Sandoway
dicta detexit W. Theobald.
This is the new Arakan species to which Mr. Blanford alludes at p. 205,
when speaking of Cl. monticola ; it differs from this last by its more fusiform
instead of conoidally turreted shape, its thinner texture, larger aperture and
somewhat differently arranged palatal folds. I have given illustrations of a
shorter form with ten whorls and of another with twelve whorls, the former
is a single specimen from the hills S. E. of Akyab, the other was collected by
Mr. Theobald at Mai-i in the Sandoway district. These two forms represent
the extreme variations which were noticed among a large number of speci-
mens.
1872.]
2 LI
Notice of the Mammals and Birds inttabitinq Kachh, —
by Dr. F. Stoliczka.
[Received 28th May, read 3rd July, 1872.]
The study of local faunas must, for some time at least, continue one of
the most important means of leading to a lull undei standing of Indian
Zoology. India combines such an enormous variety of physical conditions,
namely, differences in level, climate and vegetation, all of which have to be
studied in connection with the animal life, that one is almost lost in the
chaos of information required, and is very apt to overlook conditions, which
may be essential for the explanation not only of peculiarities as regards dis-
tinctions of species, but also of those relating to geographical distribution.
Researches limited to single districts are not necessarily liable to these
disadvantages, because they can more easily command the smaller amount
of observations, and obtain an acquaintance with the physical conditions
which may lead to their explanation.
It is with this view that I have ventured to place on record what little
I observed of the Zoology of Kachh. I scarcely need to add that I greatly
regret the incompleteness of the lists, but as the duties of the geologist aie
entirely different from those of a zoologist, he can hardly pretend to give
satisfaction to both. During my rather hurried visit, my attention was
chiefly directed towards the Vertebrate* and in this branch I attempted to
* Invertebrata are also by oomparatively small numbers represented, as may be
indicated by the following notice : .
Of Crustacea I have obtained only two species in the streams, a small Palamon
which is tolerably common, and a Chiroeephalus ( Ilravdapus apuc in,.-
Edwards) ; the latter only occurred in a slightly brackish stream west of Bhuj. Mr
Wood-Mason who examined the two species tells mo that the latter presents a remark,
able modification of the antomuo-The Arachnoids, which were specially looked after,
did not yield more than twenty species, chiefly of the families Bpemd* and l Lyconte,
and a few Baltic; id*. Of Scorpions I got four species ; Scokpe^r* three >i Juh two or
three. The Coleoptem commonly seen mostly belong to the Blapsuht, which form an
important article of food to the hedgehog ; Bcarabvid* and Oorabrto are comparatively
few, and still rarer other kind of beetles. Butterflies, on account of the almost con-
stant strong winds, are very rarely seen, indeed with the exception of a few small
Pieridce and LyccenM*, and a number of Microlepidoptera 1 have scarcely seen any
other species. The Hymenoptera are mostly represented by Ichneumonul* Ants are
a real pest in houses and in the camp, in spite of the dryness of the climate. Of
Rtvynchota my collection barely contains a dozen species, including the Nepce and
Cicada, but they must be more numerous during the wet season. Of Ubellulida l
obtained about ten species, and not many more are, I thmk, procurable in winter.
BUttidte I have seen three, the most common is Pcriplaneta cjmrmxka. Of Acridid*
&e., about a dozen or more species occurred.
28
212 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
note down and to collect what was possible, without interfering with my
other more important work. The list of the mammals and birds will be
given in the following pages ; on the reptiles and amphibians I have already
reported, (see Proc. A. S. B., for May, 1872, p. 71) ; and the examination
of the fishes was kindly undertaken by Surgeon Major Bay, whose paper
on the subject follows the present one.
However, before entering upon any details, it will be probably desira-
ble to say a few words regarding the principal physical features of the coun-
try, particularly in connection with the mammals and birds to be met with ;
only adding here that my remarks solely apply to the aspect of the country
during the cold and dry season between November and February.
The province of Kachh extends for about 150 miles along the Tropic of
Cancer, having a breadth of about 40 miles on either side of it, and the Meri-
dian of 70° eastern longitude passes through it a little eastward of the centre.
The main land stretches along the seacoast from the most eastern
branch of the Indus to Kathivar, from which it is separated by the Gulf of
Kachh ; to the North and East it is entirely isolated from Sind and the
eastern Rajputdna states by the so-called Ran, which was no doubt formerly
an arm of the sea, but is now very much silted in. It has a varied breadth
from 40 to nearly 100 miles. During the dry and hot weather some por-
tions of it are under water and others are so thickly covered with a saline
deposit, or almost pure salt, that the ground becomes unfit for the support
of animal life. A wild ass may be seen in the distance, or a desert-lark
( Certliilauda desertorum) running along the trodden track, but scarcely any
other animal exists, unless a bird may accidentally migrate from one place to
another. During the rainy season by far tbo greatest portion of the Ran
is inundated, and a good number of the larger water birds are said to be seen
on it. The slightly elevated ground, which locally forms strips in the Ran
proper, supports a very scanty vegetation of rough grasses ( Cyperacece ), and
of a few scattered bushes of tamarisk &c. ; this part is callod the Buni and, if
the monsoons are not heavy, it affords rich pasture for cattle during that
time, but in the dry season even the nomadic Sindees are often obliged to
Of freshwater shells which, however, also occur in slightly brackish streams, I met
with the following : Planorbis exnstus ; Plan. n. sp., allied to Cantoris ; Lymncea luteola
and amygdalus, the latter olosely allied to acuminata ; Palviina dissvmilis, (melanastoma)
exactly identical with South Indian and Ceylon specimens ; Bythinia pulchella and
two other specieB of the same genus ; Melania tuberculata ; Unto car ulcus and leioma ;
and a small Corbicula, apparently very rare.
Of landshellB I found Bulimus insularis, B. abbysiniens, B. punctabus, B. comopictus
and two ether Bulimi , allied to the last, one slightly and the other very much, thinner,
' almost cylindrical ; Ennea tier, lor (cylindrical and perfectly smooth variety) ; Stenogyra,
gracilis; Helix fallaoiosa and Tranquebarica, Macrochlarmjs pedinus, Succinea vitrea
and crassiuscula, With the exception of Bui, in sulwris none of the shells is common.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting KctcTili. 213
leave it for want of water. Wlierever intercalations of clayey beds between
sandy layers make a slight accumulation of fresh water possible, Kunda-
treelets (Pros op is) grow rather abundantly and form little forests, sometimes
of one or two miles in length, but generally very narrow in breadth. How-
ever, little life animates these isolated tracts.
Among the Kunda Sylvia curruca, Phylloscopus tristis, Lanins lahtora
and vittatus, Saxicola desertorum (= airogularis ), Turtur Cambayensis,
JJpupa Ceylonensis, Athene brama and perhaps a few of the smaller hawks,
and the ubiquitous Sciurus palmarum are almost all the birds and mammals
to be observed, in addition to the usual camp followers, kites, crows, pigeons,
&c. The herds of cattle and sheep are invariably accompanied by Dicrurus
albirictus, and wolves, hyaena?, and generally also a leopard are not far off.
On the woodless portions of the Buni, almost the only birds to be seen are
Spizalauda deva, Alauda triborhyncha, Pterocles exustus, Cursorius Jamesoni
(—? gallicus), Chettusia gregaria, and one or two others of the cursorial tribe.
The little islands in the Ban, called Beyts, are nearly quite unin-
habited, and on the slightly larger ones a harrier and a stonechat ( Circus
Sivainsoni and Saxicola picata ), or perhaps locally a stray dove, the pur-
suer and the pursued are all that an ordinary observer would notice of animal
life.
The more elevated ground can be physically divided into three, (or
perhaps four) nearly parallel ranges, extending almost due east and west.
Each of these ranges has an abrupt declivity on the northern and a
very gradual slope on the southern side. Thus the greatest elevation in
each range lies near the northern edge, where precipitous cliffs and mo-
derately hilly tracts occur ; but as the greatest height of any of the hills in
Kaehh does not exceed 1500 feet, and as the entire breadth of the hilly
portions is rarely more than three or four miles, they are not capable of
producing any essential effect upon, or change in, the general climatal
conditions. The hills are as a rule only thinly covered with brushwood,
mostly consisting of leafless and thorny bushes, and oftener they are almost
entirely bare.
The first of the ranges occupies Pacham, Karir, Bela and a few adjoin-
ing small islands in the Ban ; their northern declivities are for want of water
entirely uninhabited, but each has a long and gradual, though very thinly po-
pulated, slope to the south. On the eastern and western sides, the ridge ra-
ther abruptly disappears under the Ban, to the south the slope gradually passes
into the Buni, and Bela is scarcely separated from Wagur, which is the
most eastern district, moderately but very irregularly hilly, composed of short
ranges and a few isolated basalt hills ; and towards the west connected by low, -
mostly cultivated, ground with Kaehh proper. The second (the Jora-Hula-
man) range stretches along the northern edge, and the third, the Charvar
214 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. [No. 3,
and Ivatrol range, nearly through the centre of the mainland of Kachh.
These two ranges more gradually decrease in height towards their ends and
join each other near the western extremities, hut diverge on the eastern side,
the former passing in its prolongation through Wagur. The fourth range is
the lowest, lying south only a short distance from the Charvar-Katrol range,
and is sometimes not very distinctly separated from it ; it entirely consists of
basaltic trap and is locally rather thickly covered with bushes and Kunda.
As the configuration of the ground very much depends upon its lithologi-
cal structure, I may notice that sandy or shaley limestones only occur in the
axes of the first and second ranges, hut far more prevalent are sandstones
and shales. Solid basalt and quartzitic rocks occur in isolated hills, or in
dykes, and there are also a few shorter and longer ridges consisting of varied
trap-rocks which easily break up in fragments and, if any moisture exists,
readily decompose. Decomposition goes on, however, at a much more rapid
pace in the softer rocks, namely, the sandy limestones, sandstones and shales.
It is indeed often not easy to meet for days with a rock, that would not
crumble almost under the fingers, unless it be accidentally hardened, by a
neighbouring basalt dyke, or some other causes producing dislocations of
strata, &c.
On account of this rapidity with which the disintegration of the rocks has
been going on from time immemorial, all the depressions between the hills,
the ravines and river courses, had been deeply filled up with sand, which with
equal facility also spread into the longitudinal valleys separating the princi-
pal ranges. Thus instead of fertile valleys, we meet with extensive sandy
plains, which arc capable of supporting only a very scanty vegetation, and
the monotony of which is merely interrupted by an isolated basalt hill, or a
trap or quartz dyke of a few miles in length. There exists some geological
evidence which indicates, that at least along the northern precipitous slopes
of the ranges locally a very large accumulation of water had taken place in
comparatively recent geological time, and then moisture, vegetation and
animal life might no doubt have in equal proportion been greater and more
prosperous. It was probably also at that somewhat remote time, when the
great and deep ravines had locally been cut, the existence of which, with the
present comparatively insignificant water supply, it is almost impossible to
explain. But now the fine water sheets have given way to desert ground,
on which the sand is shifted about at the will of the agitated atmosphere.
The prevailing, and usually heavy, winds within the greater part of the
year, appear to come from South-West or West, although during the cold
season North-east winds are by no means uncommon. But instead of bring-
’ ing any moisture from the sea side, they seem to take away the little which
exists. The ground is so dreadfully heated under the powerful glare of a
rarely covered sky, that it seems entirely to prevent even the approach of
1872.] F. Stoliczka — -Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 215
moisture, unless the atmosphere be near the point of saturation ; and this
seems indeed to be of very rare occurrence.
Mr. Wynne, in whose Memoir on the Geology of Kachh* the physical
geography of the province is briefly referred to, states that the average rain-
fall for the last twenty-one years up to 1869 was only 14i'3 inches ; within
the three past years the annual fall scarcely exceeded ten inches. Some tracts
of the country had actually barely a drop of rain during the whole year, and
these had to be deserted during the dry season by the inhabitants, who
generally on such occasions betake themselves with their cattle to Sind, re-
turning to their homes during the following rainy season.
This state of affairs is not in any way mitigated by a marked change in
the general temperature of the air. Ice is apparently quite unknown in
Kachh. On very cold mornings in December and January, I occasionally
saw the thermometer as low as 35,° but it never sank to freezing point, and
that comparatively low temperature was observed only along the Ran, where
the wind blowing across the wet Ran was cooled down. Even in those two
months the thermometer was rarely under 80° or 90° after midday in the
shade, and in February, it generally rose to about 100.° In the sun I
have not seen it a single day under 100 degrees.
In consequence of this scarcity of ram, on account of the great heat,
and further on account of the abundance of superficial sandy deposits, large
rivers are entirely unknown, at least during the greater part of the year.
The little water, which is supplied by a few springs in the hills, is generally
lost in the sand before it reaches the desert plain, or it accumulates into
small pools and hollows in suitable places, where clayey beds retard or stop
the percolation through the sand. But in slowly passing through the sand,
the water becomes more or less saturated with various salts, the consequence
being that, if any running water at all is to he met with in a stream, it is in
nine cases out of ten brackish, — not wholesome for beasts and deadly for men.
But even in the wells, which the people sink for purposes of raising
water for irrigation, this is often brackish, and it is sometimes with the
greatest difficulty that perfectly fresh water can at all be obtained near a
village. The simple recollection of the foul and dirty fluid, that one is oc-
casionally obliged to accept in order to quench his thirst, is enough to make
one shudder.
All these elements of physical condition, to which I have briefly refer-
red, tend towards making the country a terra hospitibus Jerox, an expression
often repeated for want of a more suitable one, or, as an early traveller ex-
pressed himself, a country fit only, for a geologist to travel in. The general
result of those unfavourable physical conditions is, that we have before us a
few ranges of low hills of 80 or 100 miles in length, varying in height from
* Mem. Geol. Survey of India, vol. IX, p. 12 et seq.
216 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
about 300 to 1400 feet, either bare, or covered with scanty grass or low
thorny bushes, and intersected by dry ravines filled with debris and sand.
Except along their edges those hilly tracts are scarcely at all inhabited. The
depressions separating the longitudinal ranges more resemble in the average
time of the year a desert than a habitable country. The ground is mostly
very sandy, and although naturally not unproductive, it is sterile for want
of moisture. Enormous bushes of Euphorbia neriifolia take the place of what
elsewhere might be a forest, or at least a thick jungle. A few fig-trees near
the villages is all that may deserve the name of a tree, and even these are by no
means plentiful. During a tolerably good rainy season, the fields generally
yield a crop of either barley or wheat, or other seasonal fruits ; during the
cold weather, however, scarcely anything but a very inferior crop of cotton can
be earned ; and this only locally. A fair crop is, however, generally possible,
wherever the people are able to obtain a sufficient quantity of water from
the wells for irrigation. In this they often succeed best in those localities
which lie along, or not far from, a fault hi the rocks, because this usually
stops the escape of water. Whatever mischief the numerous trap-dykes and
basaltic eruptions might have produced at no very distant geological period,
it is very fortunate for the country, that they are so numerous ; for I would
scarcely hesitate to say that without them by far the greater part of Kachh
would long ago have become a perfect desert. Each village has, it is true,
its small tank, but unless the retention of water is facilitated by some na-
tural cause, it is sure to have dried out about the middle of the cold season.
Wherever a tank with good deep water exists by the end of February, it is
almost certain to have been washed out in a hollow of clayey beds, or it
rests towards a fault of the rocks, or a quartzite or trap-dyke. In some
cases men might have taken advantage of the natural situation, and assisted
the reservoir by an embankment, but as a rule, the Kachh people seem to be
rather indifferent to this necessity of human and animal comfort, and in this
special case, one might justly say, the necessity of life.
Out of the great number of tanks, which are, strictly speaking, the only
water reservoirs, five or six average a mile, or a little more, in length, and
might deserve the name of small lakes. In other parts of India they would
probably be little thought of, but in a dry country, such as Kachh is, they
are of no small importance. In the monsoon time they are of course of
greater extent, but even at the greatest height of the water supply, the low
situation of those reservoirs, sometimes in deep hollows, precludes the use of
the water for purposes of irrigation ; they are, however, during the cold
season the only places to which a large number of waterfowl of all kinds
resort.
Having thus become acquainted with an outline of the physical features
of Kachh, we may better be able to understand the association of the mam-
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. 217
mals and birds which I shall enumerate in the following pages. Of course
judging from both the uniformity, as well as the scarcity, of favourable natural
conditions, one could a priori only expect a very poor fauna and flora. The
vegetation of the country in general, setting aside that of the cultivated
tracts, may indeed he regarded as a picture of sterility. Very few flowering
plants are to be seen in the dry season. Among the herbaceous plants*
those growing on sandy or saline ground naturally prevail over others, and
their leaves are often leathery and thick, or sometimes reduced to spines and
thorns. Among saline plants the most common are Statice Stoclcsii, Solanwm
trilobatum, and a Pluchea. Of other more common species of herbaceous
plants I may notice : Trichodesma indicmi, Heliotropium supinum and
strigosum, Solarium nigrum, Crotalaria Burhia, Orygia decumbens, Phalan-
gium graminifolium, Vahlia viscosa, Salvia wgyptiaca, Convolvulus pluricaulis,
Cressa Creiica, Polygala Vahliana, Olinws mollugo, Polygonum plebejum.
Euphorbia tliyihifolia and Eadraownculoides, Evolmlus alsinoides, Aristida
depressa , Err, a Javanica, Vernonia cinerea, Trianthemum crystallinum and
T. decandrum, and others. Mr. Kurz determined about one hundred
species out of a small collection I made ; a few appear to be new. The low
jungles barely deserve this name, for they are almost entirely composed of
thorny bushes ( Oapparis aphylla) with little or scarcely any foliage. Among
others I may mention Tamarix orientals, Celastrus senegalensis, two species
of Oreivia, and Oratceva Boxburghii, the last growing into a tree, also Kunda
( Prosopis spicigera,) is locally numerous, but scarcely more generally
distributed than the Cactus like Euphorbia neriifolia, which often for miles
suppresses all other semiarboreal vegetation. The only fine trees to be occa-
sionally seen are Ficus religiosa and F. Bengalensis, in the neighbour-
hood of villages or near wells, where they are planted as a shelter against
the heat of the day.
Extensive forests are, as already observed, unknown, and, naturally,
we would look in vain for any of the large Carnivora, (except as
mere stragglers), and the existence of large Pachyderms or Ruminants is
made entirely impossible. Equally so we almost entirely miss the true
forest denizens of the feathered tribe, such as the Bucerotida, Picidce, Cer-
thiidcB, Sitt idce, Pliasianidce ; a few of the Eastern type of birds like the Eury-
laimultE or Treronidie are also entirely absent, their geographical distribu-
tionf being rather limited. But other families, which might he expected to
* I am indebted to Mr. S. Knrz for the names of the plants.
+ Too much importance is, I think, occasionally attributed to the so-called laws
of geographical distribution, independently of other agencies, as if these laws were
innate to the animal. When speaking of the geographical distribution of a species,
one is apt to forget, that these geographical limits are mainly dependent upon the
physical conditions, required for, and suitable to, the existence of a certain species.
218 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. [No. 3,
occur, likewise shew very few representants, such as the Muscicapidce, Am-
pellidcD, Bring illidte, Corvidre, &e.
Among the brushwoods the common birds are Pycnonotus chrysorrhoides
Otocampsa leueotis, Lanius vittatus, Iora Zeylaniea, Sylvia curruca, Mania
Malabarica, &c., less numerous are Phyllopneuste rama, Pericrocotus pere-
grinus, Orthodomus longicaudus , Drymoipus Jerdoni, Phylloscopus tristis,
Teplirodornis Pondiceriana and a few others, while Pams nuchalis or Leu-
cocerca aureola are great rarities. Hunting between the bushes on the
ground, we meet with Thamnobia Cambayensis, Citrinella Huttoni and Clia-
torhea caudata , always in company with Pranklinia Buchamni, and on still
more open ground Saxicola picata and deserti ( = atrogularis) . The above
are actually the only very common birds, and five of each may at any time
be seen for every one of any other kind.
In the sandy plains we meet with a great number of GbalTjJ3, particu-
larly Otitidce&ni Gharadridas. Among these Oursoriw Jamesoni (?= gallicus),
Chettusia gregaria, Lobivanellus indicus, Sarcioplwrus bilobus, Grus cinerea,
Houbara Macquenii, are characteristic of the country ; several of these depart
during the summer, but are replaced during the rains by the Florikan, Sypheo-
tides auritus, which is said to arrive in large numbers in the rainy season.
The starlings, grey partridges, pigeons, and doves keep, naturally enough,
near the villages. In the fields few other larger birds except Geronticus
papillosus and Buphus coromandus, and occasionally Grus antigone, are to
be seen ; of smaller birds Agrodroma campestris and several species of larks
are common. Both Grallatores and Natatores are abundant on the small
lakes and tanks. Indeed scarcely a pool of water, if only thirty or forty
feet in length, will be met with without some species of Aetitis or Totanus,
but particularly common are Uimantopas intermedins, Spatula clypeata
and Qiterqucdula crecca. On the somewhat larger tanks one is certain to
meet besides these with the gadwall ( ' Ohaulelasmus strep eras), the pintail
( Bafila acuta), the little grobe ( Podiceps minor), and also Limosa cego-
cephala and one or the other of the white Herodias. Naturally in an open
country, where sport is comparatively easy, birds of prey would not be want-
ing, and amongst these Palco jugger, Hypotriorchis chiqucra, Aquila fulves-
A change in the physical conditions of a country will be rapidly followed by a corre-
sponding change in the fauna, either decreasing or increasing, and thus the geogra-
phical limits of a species become mainly dependent upon physical conditions. To give
an example, I mean, that if for instance one of the low hill ranges of Kachh,
averaging a height of a few hundred feot, was replaced by one of similar mineralogical
character and of an average height of 5000 feet, wo would very soon find it wooded,
and then inhabited by an abundance of Malabar forms, although these would be absent
in the intervening desert country. An actual example of this may be seon on Mount
Aboo, as known from Dr. King’s list of birds.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. 219
cens and Buteoferox are to be seen almost everywhere ; many others are
more local.
Perhaps a better general idea of the character of the vertebrate fauna
might be formed, when we inquire what the country is capable of support-
ing all the year round, and at the same time exclude those animals, the
existence of which mainly, or entirely, depends upon the presence of man
and his habitations.
Among the mammals we find the Rodents most prevalent, — Gerhillus
erythrourus, Sciurus palmarum, Lepus rujlcaudus, — the first being by far the
most common, and next come the Indian antelope and gazelle ; thus all
vegetable feeders.
If we exclude from the 160 species of birds, which I obtained, the so-
called camp-followers, we find that about half the remainder are migratory,
therefore merely winter visitors. And although some of the migratory birds
may in a favourable hot season remain in the country, others which are gen-
erally considered as permanent settlers often partially migrate to more suit-
able localities in India. Among these I may mention for instance Ceryle,
Pratincola, dorados, Ptionoprogne, Caprimulgus, Oitrinella. Therefore, in
an ordinary summer season I certainly do not expect that more than about
one hundred species of birds are to be met with in Kachh, really a very small
number, when compared with what one is used to observe on a similarly
large area in many other parts of India.
Of Reptilia and Amphibia I have observed thirty species ; and,
although this number is decidedly larger during the rains, not more than
half a dozen of them are really of common occurrence. (Comp. Proc. A. S.
B., May, 1872, p. 71).
The fresh-water fishes, which I collected, belong, according to Dr. Day,
to eighteen species ; there is only one Siluroid among them, most of the
others belong to the Cyprinidce, and one is a Cfyprinodon, the fust species
of the genus known in Indian fresh-waters. However small the number may
appear to be, I almost doubt if it could be much increased ; for where
rivers are almost unknown, and where half of the tanks are liable to disap-
pear for several months during each year, and where besides such a number of
skilful fishers* are eagerly employed during a time when the water is lowest,
fish have not much chance to prosper.
* About forty species of Qrallatores and Natatores.
29
220 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
MAMMALIA .*
Primates.
I have only on a single occasion seen a Presbytes which appeared to he
in a wild state. It came towards the evening to drink at a tank some dis-
tance from the fort Kanmir (in the south-eastern part of the Wagur district),
and as its entire face was jet black, I presume, it was more likely P. pria-
nius than the Bengal P. entellus, but I could not approach sufficiently near
to ensure the identification.
Besides that, I saw both Inuus rhesus and Macacus radiatus in capti-
vity, but they appear to have been imported.
Chiroptera.
The notes on this order have been kindly communicated to me
by G. E. Dobson, Esq., B. A., M. B.
Pam. Ehinolophidje,
Pui'LLOiiiriNA fui.ta, Gray.
Of the specimens of this species obtained, two, a male and female, were
taken at the same time and place. The fur of the female specimen is bright
golden yellow, that of the male white at the base of the hairs for more than
three-fourths their length, the remaining portion to the tip dark purplish
brown. The male is larger than the female which is apparently not quite
adult.
This proves the identity of Ph:. fulva with Ph. murina and Ph. cinera-
ccns, and leads to the belief that Ph. ater and atratus are also synonyms of
the same species. This remarkable variableness of the colour of the fur is
not, however, confined to this species, it is met with also in other Rhinolo-
phine bats ; in Ph. larvata, Horsfd., for example, where the colour of the fur
varies from bright orange fulvous, with brownish or ferruginous tips, to
bluish black with black tips, a circumstance which has given rise also to
much confusion, as the species has received as many names as the different
colours of its fur. The same remarks apply to the species of other families
of Chiroptera, notably to the Pteropiiue,
Other male and female specimens of this species were also obtained about
the same time, the fur of all presents the same colour : — white with dusky
tips to the hairs. This shows that the colour of the fur in Ph. fulva
does not depend on locality, or season. The smaller size of the fulvous
female specimen referred to above, taken with its less perfectly developed
* The systematic names and further observations on the species recorded will be
found in Jordon’s ‘ Mammals of India,’ except in a few cases where a special reference,
or a description, is added.
221
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh.
teeth, and apparently not quite complete ossification of the extremities of
the metacarpal and phalangeal bones, indicates age as a very probable cause
of the differences of colour that have been observed. The young of the first
and second year most probably present this golden fulvous hue which gra-
dually changes to white, as the animal attains the adult condition.
The following table gives the measurement of the two specimens first
referred to ; and of another, an adult female, from the same locality, with
white fur, tipped with purplish black.
Length, head and hody,
» ta'b
,, head,
„ oar, anteriorly, .
Breadth, ditto,
Length, forearm,
„ thumb,
„ second finger,
„ fourth ditto, . . ,
„ tibia,
„ foot and claws,
Generally distributed, but not common.
Earn. Ehinopomatidje.*
II i UNO pom a Habdwickxt, Gray.
This species is extremely common, usually taking up its abode in
wells. All possess large accumulations of fat posterior to the anus, in much
greater quantity than usually observed, the mass of fat in many individuals
probably much exceeding in weight the remainder ol the body.
Earn. NocrmoxiDiE.
Taphozous Kachiiexsis, Dobson, n. sp.
In form, colour of the fur, and size corresponds very closely with T.
saccolaimws , Geoff., but easily distinguished by the complete absence of the
gular pouch in both male and female. A small fold of wing-membrane forms
a shallow pouch in the angle between the radius and fifth metacarpal bone,
much less developed than in T. longimanus, Hardw. Ears as in T. saccolai-
mus, but slightly larger, and the tragus is naked ; inner margin bordered
with a row of small papules.
* I have formed this family, provisionally, for the reception of the genus Rhino-
poma of which the type, Rh. Hardwickti, is the sole representative. This genus has
been classed by Drs. Gray and Peters with tbo Mecjadermatidce, but, on carefully com-
paring the skeleton of Megaderma lym with that of Rhinopoma UardwicHi, I find not
the least ostcological connection. The genus is, evidently , far more closely related
to some of the genera of Noctilionidt £ than to Megaderma,
222
F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
$ 2
Inches. Inches.
Length, head and body, 3 35 3-6
„ tail M5 L25
„ ditto, free from membrane, 0'5 0 4
„ head 1'2 13
„ ear (anteriorly), 0'9 0'9
Breadth ditto ditto, 0 5 0'5
Length, tragns, 0'24 0 24
Breadth, ditto (greatest), 0’17 0’18
Length, forearm, 2'65 2 95
thumb, '. 0-45 0-45
„ second finger, 4*4 5 0
,, fourth ditto, 2 3 2'8
„ tibia, 10 11
,, caloaneum, 0-85 0’9
„ foot and claws, 0'55 0 65
Fam. V espebt i lion i d m.
Genus. Yespeettgo Keys. Bias. Sub-genus Pipistrellus, Gray.
PiPiSTEEiiLus leucotis, Dobson, n. sp.
Ears triangular with rounded tips ; outer margin slightly concave be-
neath the tip, then convex, emarginate opposite the baso of the tragus, and
terminating in a small lobe. Tragus slightly curved inwards and rounded
at the tip. Glands of upper lip well developed, causing a slight depression
on the face behind the nostrils. Tail long, wholly contained within the
interfemoral membrane. A well-defined, rounded lobe posterior to the cal-
caneum.
Ears, sides of face about the eyes, interfemoral membrane, ante-
humeral membrane, and that portion of wing-membrane along the sides of
the body, white, very translucent ; remaining portion of wing membrane
sepia, traversed by white reticulations. Fur, on the upper surface, black at
the base of the hairs for about half their length, remaining portion light
yellowish brown ; beneath, somewhat similar.
The fur of the head extends forwards as far as the labial prominences
which aro thinly covered with a few short hairs ; in front of the ear and
about the eye the side of the face is almost naked. On the upper surface
the fur of the body extends outwards, covering the proximal third of the
humerus and the wing-membrane thence, backwards, to the knee joint ; pos-
teriorly, the anterior tim’d of the interfemoral membrane is covered ; beneath
the fur of the abdomen extends upon the wing-membrane to nearly the same
extent as on the upper surface, and the interfemoral membrane is clothed
with a few, short hairs.
223
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh.
Upper incisors long, blunt, with a distinct cingulum ; outer incisors
minute, scarcely exceeding in vertical extent the cingulum of the inner ones,
placed close to their sides, and separated from the canines by a small space
on either side. First small premolar in the upper jaw, in the angle between
the closely approximated canine and second premolar, very minute, not dis-
tinguishable without a lens.
' The following are the measurements of two adult male specimens. The
measurements in the first column are those of a specimen in the Indian
Museum from Rajanpur, sent by Dr. W. F. Murray, Assistant Surgeon
3rd Panjab Cavalry, and not previously described ; the second column relates
to the Kachh specimen.
Hub. — Rajanpur, Panjab frontier ; Kachh.
tail, ...
head,
tibia,
Pteropm, of the size of Pt. medius, Tern. ; I saw it on several occasions
about liliuj , but failed to secure a specimen.
Inseetivora.
The only shrew which X obtained, and which is far from common, be-
longs, according to Dr. Anderson’s determination, to Crocidura m/urina, Lin.
Of hedgehogs also one species occurs. It represents a new species.
Ejuxaceus (Hemiechintts*) pictus, n. sp.
Head elongate, pyramidal ; snout produced, considerably extending be-
yond the lower jaw, with the nostrils somewhat swollen, representing a longi-
tudinal slit on the upper side ; ears moderate, obtusely rounded at tip, and
rather abruptly truncate laterally ; a very conspicuous, almost perfectly nude,
# Fitzinger (Sitz. Akad. Wien, M. N. Klasse, 1867, vol. 56, part I, p. 858,) uses
this name in a generic sense, as distinct from hrinaccus.
224 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and J Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
tolerably broad space extends from the bind head towards the middle of
neck ; spines, beginning on neck slightly in advance of a line connecting the
anterior basal edges of the ears, almost regular in young, but distinctly ir-
regularly* interwoven in the more adult ; each spine white on the basal half,
then with a broad blackish brown ring, followed by a yellowish white
tip, only the extreme point appearing slightly dusky ; each is further
surrounded by sixteen to twenty longitudinal grooves, separated by much
broader and very finely tuberculated ridges ; the minute tubercles being
laterally compressed. Limbs long and slender, each with five claws ; tail
very short and concealed.
Snout, extending on the upper side as far as between the eyes and from
there stretching as an oblique band through the eyes to the base of the neck,
dark brown with very few whitish hairs intermixed ; ground colour of ears
brown, but thickly set with whitish hairs, lower jaw round the edges brown,
chin and throat whitish tinged with brown in the young, almost perfectly
white in adults ; fore-limb beginning at the middle of the forearm, the hind
limbs entirely, including the region of the vent between them and at their sides,
and the tail chocolate brown ; soles of feet blackish and all the claws white.
Moustaches brown, whitish towards their tips, the longest nearly two inches.
An oblique streak in front of and below the eye to the angle of the mouth,
hind head and all round the neck, involving the base of the ears, the entire
lower side from the chin, including nearly half the length of the fore-limbs,
and extending backwards as far as the region between the liind-limbs white,
the lower side being thinly clad wi th hairs which are throughout arranged in
small tufts, each tuft evidently corresponding to a dorsal spine, as if each of
the spines had been dissolved into its original component parts.
Total length of a specimen 5'5 inches ; distance from tip of snout to
anterior angle of eye 0'8 ; length of ear 055, and the greatest breadth
about 04 ; length of carpus to tip of claws 08, the same of foot 1 inch, the
heel tubercular ; tail 04 inches, thickly covered with hair.
Besides this specimen which is the only one I preserved, I saw several
others in the western part of Kachh, and some were decidedly larger ; one
measured 63 inches, the distance from the tip of snout to the eye being
nearly 1 inch, and to the base of the ear nearly T5 inch. There are also
several specimens of tins species in the Indian Museum from the North West
Provinces about Agra, and from Edjputfina. One of these measures nearly
7 inches from tip of snout to end of tail.
* The regularity of the spines seems very much to depend upon the attitude of
the animal. When the animal is at rest, and the spines are in their natural position,
they are as a rule regularly directed backwards, but the moment the animal rolls in its
body, they become interwoven.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 225
In comparing tho present species with the descriptions of hedgehogs known from
Asia and adjoining territories, and which belong to the section Hemiechinus, — charac-
terized by having the ridges on the spines tuberculated and five toes on all feet, — I find
that E. cethiopicuB, Ehronberg, = E. brachydactylus, Wagner, is most closely allied to it.
It slightly differs in coloration, in having the forehead white, the ohoBt brownish ; each
•of the tubercles on the spines is seated on a separate eminence, and the tail is
longer. Other similarly coloured species are E. algirus, (Egyptians, palUdus and Ubicus,
all from North Africa, but they more or less differ in structure. Besides that there
are two other African species E. platyotis and pectoralis * both of which are quite
different in coloration, and E . auritus , Balias and hypomelas, Brandt, aro from Nor-
thern Asia.
From India Jordon describes out of the section Hemiechinus, E. collaris and mi-
cropus, the former being found in Northern, the latter in Southern India.
In collaris the ears are externally somewhat indonted, but not to any particularly
large extent. The spines are rather long and cylindrical, usually with a broad black
tip, each is surroundrd by 22 to 21 longitudinal grooves separated by equally broad
ridges, which are rathor sharp and somewhat distantly finely tuborculated.
Very closely alliod to collaris are no doubt Bennett's E. Qrayi and spafauq/ws, both
from the Himalayas ; but until authentic specimens had been examined, it does not
appear advisable to identify all throe.
In E. Qrayi eaoh spine is stated to be yellowish white for more than half its
basal length, followed by a narrow blackish ring, and again white at the tip. The
coloration of the head and underside does not appear to differ from that of collm-is. The
ears are said to bo long, obtusely pointed, but scarcely thickened towards the tip,
and laterally not emargmate.
E. spatangus is said chiefly to differ by the regular position of the spines, but
this is a character which very much depends upon the position of the body. It seems
probable that the type specimen is only a young one of E. Qrayi, should this really
prove to bo distinct from collaris,
E. mentalis, Gray, also from the Himalayas, is recorded as distinguished from
others by a black chin ; nothing further is known of it.
In micropus, which is undoubtedly the same as nudiventris, the spines aro thin,
rather short, with a long point and of a similar colour as in E. pictus, but each is sur-
rounded by 17 or 18 longitudinal grooves, separated by only very little broader ridges
which are provided with moderately distant blunt, and nearly rounded tubercles.
From Afghanistan, Blyth described E. megalotis,f winch in colouring more resem-
bles hypomelas than auritus, each spine boing dusky at base and near the middle, and
blackish brown towards the tip, which again is paler. Eaoh spine is further surrounded
by about 28 to 30 longitudinal fine furrows, separated by about equally broad and fine
ribs, which are minutely tuberculated ; some of the ribs are occasionally thinner than
others. This character alone separates megalotis from the two other allied species
with large ears.
In looking over the specimens of hedgehogs in tho Indian Museum I noticed an
apparently new species which was lately collected by Dr. Henderson when accompany,
ing the Yarkand expedition, and I shall give a short description of it under the
name of
* Fitzinger in Sitzb. Akad. Wien, M. N. Klasse, vol. 56, part I, p. 859.
t Journ. Asiat. P. B. vol. XIY, p. 353 and vol. XV, p. 170.
226 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
Erinaceus (TJevmechAwus) albulus, n. sp.
Snout very long and pointed, ears moderate, ovate at tip ; spines irregularly-
placed, much os in pictus, but comparatively longer and thicker ; each of - them is
dusky at the base, then up to half its longth purely white, followed by a blackish
brown ring, its breadth being only about one fifth of the total length, tip largely white
and rather abruptly pointed, the result being a prevalence of white colour on the upper
surfaco of the body. There is no perceptible nude spaco between the ears, and the spines
begin immediately on the hind neck, and the largest on the back are fully one inch
long. Each spine is surrounded by 24 to 26 fine longitudinal furrows, separated by
minutely tuberculated ridges, scarcely wider than the furrows. The tail is almost as
short as in pictus.
Head entirely rnfescent above and at the sides, except upper mandible towards
the angle of the month, this being white ; base of ears alBO whits, as well as the entire
underside, which is thickly set with long hairs, passing into a slight rufescent shade
on the sides of the belly. Ears, lower portions of front and hind feet and tail dusky
brownish, being thickly intermixed with short, white hairs ; moustache brown, whitish
towards the tip. Claws strong, five on each foot, very pale brownish.
The only specimen measures veiy nearly seven inches j the ear slightly exceeds
one inch ; distance from tip of snout to the angle of the mouth not quite one, to the ear
slightly more than one and a half inch. Dr. Henderson gives the locality, ‘ Langur
near Sanju; Yarkand,’ and the native name 1 Keepa.’
The only known form to which the present species is closely allied is lybicus ,
Ehrenb., which has similarly grooved and similarly coloured spines, but they are de-
cidedly shorter, and the coloration of the other parts of the body is different.
From all the above noted species which, as I stated, aro referable to the section
Hemiechinus, E. albiventris, Wagn., differs by having only four toes on the hind feet,
and the spines sulcated and smoothly ridged. The typo specimen, which is 65
inches long, is believed to have eomo from the East Indies, but its precise locality is
unknown ; it is in the Berlin Museum. The distinctive characters noticed also occur
in the iEgyptien E. Pnmeri, and Fitzinger separates both as ‘ Peroechinus.’
The true Erinacei have five toes on each foot and smoothly striated spines. Of
the five species known only E. ewopaem, namely the Siberian variety, may be found
in the Himalayas.
Carnivora.
TTrsns labialus occasionally occurs in theWagur district, and I was told
of a specimen having been shot on Bela, hut it is evidently only a very rare
straggler.
I have not on a single occasion seen either a marten ( Maries ) or a weasel
( Mustella ), though I was told that at least one species of each does occur.
Of the Felidce, both the lion (F. led) and the tiger (F. tigris) extremely
rarely occur as stragglers from Kathivar, they had been formerly shot in
Kachh territory, and a century ago they might have been more common.
The larger variety of the pard (JF. par dm), usually called panther, is up
to the present time not uncommon in some districts. It keeps to the thinly
wooded and rocky parts of the country, and its favourite sport constitutes
a monopoly with the present Rao of Kachh.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 227
The common jungle cat (F. chaw ) is the only representant of the small-
er Felidce, and though not abundant it is met with occasionally throughout
the country.
The red lynx (F. caracal) is, however, certainly rare, as it likewise is in
other parts of India. I have only seen one animal shot some years ago by
the Bao of Kachh, but I heard of it in different parts of the country. Like
the pard, it seems to be very fond of digging after TJromastix llardwiclcii,
which in common with some of the inhabitants it appears to find a very
tasty meal.
F. jubata, the hunting leopard, was soon by me only on one occasion
in the Wagur district (north of Cliitrore), but I could not obtain any in-
formation as to its further occurrence. It seems to be scarcely known in the
western and southern parts of Ivachh.
The striped hyaena {H. striata) also occasionally occurs in the eastern
parts of Kachh, and about the Eann islands. I have, however, nowhere
heard of a single Viverra or a Paradoxurw, which no doubt prefer forest to
open country.
132. Jlerpestes griseus, called by Jerdon the ‘ Madras Mangoos,’ is
the only species of this genus, and generally distributed, though not very
common. Body of a male 18", tail 15" ; a female which I shot was somewhat
larger. The general colour of the fur above is (in winter) brown, grizzled
with white ; the longer hairs are adpressed and very long, particularly at the
sides, each with four to five dark brown rings, separated by pale white, the
two colours passing into each other by a rufous brown tint, which, during
the summer, in some individuals at least, appears to prevail over the dark
brown, and when in older skins the brown fades, the rings may be described
as rufous, but they certainly are not so in fresh skins. The white rings
generally have barely a tinge of yellow, in some specimens they may be said
to be pale fawn colour. The elongated hairs at the lower side arc broadly
tipped with fulvous fawn, and those at the end of the tail are mostly of that
colour, which in so far may be said to be concolbrous with the body. The
sides of the snout, particularly in front and about the eyes, are distinctly
rufous, more so in the male than in the female, and the entire head is also
tinged with more rufous, than airy other part of the body. Lars light brown,
thickly set with short hair, more mixed with white in front than behind.
General colour below fawn, the rings on the hair being pale brown and on
many nearly obsolete. Feet in front rufous brown, speckled with white ;
claws brown, pale towards the tips ; soles dark fleshy brown ; muzzle
reddish brown.
The Indian Wolf {Cams pallipes) is tolerably common in the Wagur
district and on the Eann, but less so in Western Kachh, while the jackal
(C. aureus) abounds everywhere. Pariah dogs are, as may be imagined eom-
30
228 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachli. [No. 3,
mon enough, and some very much resemble in structure and colour the
wild dog ( Cuon rutilans), but I have not heard of the occurrence of this
latter in a wild state.
Both the Indian and the desert fox, Vulpes bengalensis and leucopus, the
latter generally called the silver-tailed fox, occur ; the former I have shot only
in the north-eastern districts, hut the latter appears to he more generally
distributed, though not very common.
Rodentia.
The homely Sciurus palmarum is the only species of squirrels to be met
with, both about habitations and in the Kundu jungles.
The ground is claimed by the desert Jerboa-rat, which Jerdon identified
with (No. 171) Gerbillus* erythrourus, Gray.f I do not think that
there is any other animal equally common throughout Kachh, as is this rat ;
it does of course not frequent stony and hilly ground, but is most abundant
in the sandy districts between bushes, as well as between fields and on grassy
plains ; its barrows sometimes extent over hundreds of square feet without
interruption. The size and colour of Kachh specimens perfectly tallies with
Jerdon’s description. Near habitations it usually comes out only in the
morning and evening to feed, but far away from them it is to be seen out of
its hole at all hours of the day. As a rule, it feeds, I believe, on roots of
various herbaceous plants, and more rarely on seeds.
I hardly need to mention the occurrence of the brown rat (Mus decu-
manus) and of the common Indian mouse (M. urlanws).
Hystrix leucura is the common porcupine of the country ; it is usually
found on higher undulating desert ground, thinly covered with jungle, or
on more elevated plateaus where brushwood occurs.
Lepus rujicaudatus is very abundant throughout Kachh. There is, (at
least in younger specimens) a conspicuous white band from the nostril
through the eye ; the ears are lined internally with dull white, and externally
towards the tips with blackish brown or black ; the tail has in the young
only a slight rufous tinge above.
Ungulata.
JSqwus onager, the wild ass, is entirely confined to the most uninhabita-
ble and desert parts of the country near the Rann, or the Bann itself with its
small islands. I have seen it on two or three occasions in crossing the Bann,
but an approach to it even within half a mile was out of question.
Sus indiews is generally distributed, and fine sport may be had in suit-
able, temporarily swampy, localities, mostly near the Bann. Occasionally,
* MoBfc naturalists accept for the Africo-Asiatic species the name Menones.
t Comp. Jerdon, Mamm. Appendix, p. III.
229
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh.
I also met with solitary specimens, or small families of young, within the
hills, as at Jora.
The common Indian antelope, Antilope bezoartica, is only found in
the eastern parts of Kachh, towards Eajputana, while the Indian gazelle,
Gazella Bennetti, occurs abundantly throughout the country. Jerdon
(Ind. Mamm. p. 281) says that ‘ Gazella Christii, Gray, from Sind and
Kachh, is said to be paler, and with the horns more slender, and smaller than
in the Indian gazelle, and with the tips abruptly bent inwards.’ I have seen
a great number of animals shot in different parts of Kachh, and preserved
also a few skins, hut they do not exhibit the least difference from the
‘ Chinkara’ of Central and Northern India.
Aves.
In the subjoined list I have included only those species of which I
procured specimens, and of the identity of which I had been able to satisfy
myself. In addition to these I observed a small number of others, and
although the identity of some of them appeared to me at that time toler-
ably certain, I shall note them separately ; for with the number of very
closely allied forms one cannot be cautious enough in avoiding mistakes in
determination. Among the species which I have not procured are : Astur
palumbarius which I saw on several occasions kept by falconers, but I could
not obtain information that the specimens were procured in Kachh. At
the beginning of November, I noticed on the Jora bills a solitary speci-
men of a Centropus, it was either rufipennis or viridis. Both, Alauda
gulgula and crista/a, do, I believe, occur, and I was under the impres-
sion that my shikari secured specimens, but on examination none were re-
presented. Carpodacus erythrinus was seen on two occasions in January.
I am also tolerably certain of the occurrence of Tringa minuta, Nwme-
nius arquata, Eero diets alba, Anas boschas, Mergus castor, Casarca ratil-
la, Podiceps cristatus, Anser indicus and cinereus ; all these, besides a
great number of other water-fowl, were seen on the large lake at Bhimsir
near the Denodur hill, and also S. W. of Barasir in the Charvar range. At
the former locality I also observed one or two species of Gallinula, and a
small Porzana. On two occasions I saw in the western part of Kachh
what at the time I took for solitary specimens of Ciconia alba, and on one
occasion a solitary Cic. nigra. When crossing the Kann from Kachh to
Pacliam early in November, I noticed several swans, but at too a great
distance for it to be possible to form an idea as to the species the birds
belonged to ; a large Cursorial bird was also rather common, but I could not
get a shot at him. It had the appearance of a gigantic Chettusia, being
about double the size of Ch. gregaria, and somewhat similar in coloration.
230
F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
2* Otooyps cai.vus. Not common.
5. Gyps Bengaiensis. Very common.
I examined several nests in the second half of December and in January ;
all contained only one egg. On the 11th January at Kunria, one nest had
a nestling which must have been a week old.
6. Neophron Gin otni anus. Very common.
8. Falco peregiun us. Not common.
10. F. juggeb. Very common.
During January, I have generally seen them in pairs, and on the 10th
Feb., near the village Tappur in Eastern Kachh, a pair had a nearly finished
nest on a large Kundu, near the edge of a tank. The bird is a great
favourite with native Falconers.
12. F. Baisylontcus.
Comp. Jerdon in Ibis for 1871, p. 240.
Only a single male specimen was seen and shot near Kantkote in Wag-
gur district, on 12th January.
16. Hypotbioechis (Turamtia) cmcQUEEA.t Very common.
17. Tinuncuecs alaudaiuus. Common.
23. Micron isus badhjs. Common.
I shot one male and two females in December and J anuary, all had the
iris bright yellow. Af.— wing 7 5, tail 6, tarsus 1'8. F. — wing 8'6— 8’9,
tail 7 '2 — 7’4, tarsus 2 inch.
24. Accipiteb nisus. Not common.
25. A. (IIieeaspiza) virga'tus. Not common.
29. Aquila bifasciata, Gray and Hardw. Not common.
Comp. Bi’ooks in Proo. Asiab. S oc. Bong., April, 1872, p. 65.
Jerdon says that bifasciata, Gray, is the same as vittala of Hodgson.
29. A. FUEVEHCKNs. Very common.
45. Buteo ff.rox. Very common.
I have seen hundreds of these birds, all were of the B. cannescens type,
but not one of the uniform coloured type, called fuliginosus by Hume. The
latter I got from Kotegurli near Simla. (Comp. Jerdon in Ibis, 1871,
p. 338).
48. Polioeuts TEESA. Common.
51. Circus pallid us, Sykes = Swainsont, Smith. Very common.
Gray (Handlist, I, 37) gives Sykes’s name the priority.
55. HALIASTtTE INDUS.
Only seen near the sea shore.
* The numbers prefixed to the names correspond with those in Jordon's ‘ Birds of
India,’ or their nearest allies.
t I would decidedly prefer adopting the subgeneric name Tummtia for that of
Chiquem, than altering the latter well known specific denomination to ‘ typus.’
231
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh.
56. Miltps goviuda, Very common.
The details in coloration arc exactly as recorded of govinda, though
they do not in any essential point appear to differ from those of a (finis
(Comp. Hume, Scrap-hook, p. 320). Measurements of two specimens :
wing' 17'5 and 17 ; tail 10‘6 and 1125 ; tarsus 2T, midtoe without claw
1'6 and 1'8, its claw straight 0 7 and 0'75 ; bill from gape 1'7 and 165
inch. This is as far as I saw, the only kite found throughout Kachh.
A pair was breeding on a tree near Sumrasir on the 14th November.* Gray
(Handl., I, 26) gives melanotis, Tern, and Schlegel, which was shewn by
Blanford to be identical with M. major of Hume, as a synonym of govinda,
but he places a (finis of Gould in a distinct subgenus. M. ajjinis is added to
the Indian fauna by Jerdon in Ibis for 1871, p. 343; but are these two
races really specifically distinct ?
67. Otus vulgaris. I have seen it only on three occasions.
69. Bubo (TJrrua) Benoalensts. Not uncommon in rocky ravines.
76. Athene brama. Very common.
82. IIiuundo rustic a. Common.
Wing 46 ; outer tail feathers 3'6, central T8 ; tarsus 04 ; midtoe and
claw nearly 07 inch.
84. H. (Uromitus) ftetfera. Common.
This, Jerdon writes, ‘ must stand, it appears, as H. ruficeps, Lichtenstein,’
but he thinks that the differences, said to exist between the Indian and
African form, as pointed out by Mr. Gould, ‘ may perhaps still hold good.
Mr. Gould (Birds of Asia, Part xviii) says, that African examples differ by
being smaller, by having a lesser amount of rufous on the top of the head,
and a shorter tail. Now, these must be admitted to be very variable charac-
ters, in the Indian bird at least. I measured specimens with the wing
varying from 4*4 to 4’8, and with the central tail-feathers from 1 3 to 1 6
inches long. The rufous on the head changes in Kachh specimens, (shot
in winter), from deep rufous brown to a pale rusty.
85. Us H. (L telia) erytro pvot a. Very common.
Wing 4T to 4.3, tail 2'8 to 3 3. True daurica occurs in the Satlej
valley, where it is far from rare, and I also have a specimen of it from Western
Bengal, shot by Mr. Ball during the winter of 1870 ; it is, therefore, not a
restricted hill form. It differs not only in size, but also in the form of
the bill, this being in daurica more contracted towards the tip and slightly
longer.
90. Ptionoproone coxcoior. Very common.
Wing 4 to 4'2, tail 19 to 2 inches, the central feathers from 01 to 0 2
* I have seen a pair of govinda copulating on 5th September, and before I left
Calcutta on 10th October, they had their nest ready in front of my window.
232 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. [No. 3,
inches, shorter than the outer ones. The species is very abundant and its
favourite haunt are tanks or grassy slopes of hills.
91. Ptioivopbogne rupesthis. Not very common.
I saw the species repeatedly hunting over tanks, in company with H.
rustica. The measurements arc; slightly smaller than those given by Jerdon.
112. CAPRiMuiiGtrs Asiaticus. Not common.
113. C. M a 1 1 n vtte vs I s . Shot a single specimen on 26th January,
at Daiselpur in Wagur district, between fields. The bird perfectly agrees
with that described by Jerdon.
117. Merops viredis. Very common.
123. Coracxas otdica. Common.
129. Haectojv Smtrnensis (= pusctts) . Common.
The largest specimen measures 5 wing 5, tail 35, bill at front 23, from
gape 29 inch. (Comp. Ibis, 1872, p. 4.)
134. Ai.cedo Bengaeensis. Not common.
Wing 2 8, tail T3, bill at front 1'5, from gape 1’9, tarsus 035 inch.
136. Certle rudis. Common.
Wing 5 2 to 5-6 ; tail 275 to 3, bill at front 2 2 to 2 5, tarsus 04 inch.
Of two pairs shot the males are slightly larger than the females.
148. Paljeornis torqeatus. Very common.
160. Pious (Leiopicus) Mahrattehsis, var.
An idem P Blanfurdi, Blyth !
This is the only woodpecker which I have met with in Kachh. It would
be difficult to identify it from Jerdon’s account, and I give, therefore, a more
complete description.
Forehead and part of top of head pale yellowish brown, with a more
or less distinct golden lustre, (not pure yellow as Malherbe calls it) ; in
the male occiput crimson, laterally extending to above the eyes, in the
female dull yellowish brown, in both the occipital feathers are conspicuously
lengthened ; neck above with a broad uniform dark brown streak from
the occiput downwards ; lower neck, back and rump with longitudinal brown-
ish black and white streaks, each feather being black along the centre ; on
the base of the lower tail coverts the white predominates, but of the longer
tail coverts each has a large triangular central spot ; tail blackish, each
feather with 5 or 6 transverse, on the quill interrupted white bands ; shorter
wing coverts nearly uniform brownish black, longer coverts and all the
wing feathers with along the middle of each feather interrupted bands,
primaries dusky brown, and the white on them suffused with pale sulphur,
secondaries and tertials much darker, particularly on the outer web. Lores,
round the eye, about the angle of the mouth and chin in front fulvous white,
ear coverts fulvous-asliy white or pale ashy ; sides of neck, chin and breast
1872.] F. Stoliczlca — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 233
in the middle almost pure white, a brown broadisli band extends from behind
and below the ear coverts to the sides of the breast ; lower plumage and
under tail coverts dull white with a brownish streak to each feather, a
crimson patch on the middle of the abdomen ; the white bands on the tail
feathers are tinged with pure yellow, particularly towards the tips of the
feathers. Bill plumbeous ; feet blackish ashy. Wing 3'75 to 3-9 ; tail 2'3
to 2'4 ; bill at front 0'8 to 09, from gape 1' to l'l ; tarsus OG inch ; foot
about 1'5. Fourth primary the longest, first 2'2 inch, shorter, second
0'4 and third 005 shorter than the fourth which exceeds the fifth by only
a trifle.
These are the average measurements (from skins) of three males and
two females ; the former differ from the latter only by the crimson occiput,
and sometimes also by a slightly smaller size, &c.
Not common, but occurring throughout Kachh, in the thinly wooded
parts of the province, on trees as well as on Euphorbia bushes. It is a rather
shy bird, and has a particular liking to hunt for insects towards dusk ; I
shot it often when it was almost dark, flatly clinging to the bark of a tree.
Looking at the comparative small size of the Kachh birds, I was at first
inclined to separate them as a distinct species, but, on the suggestion of Mr.
Hume, and after careful comparison, I am convinced that they represent no-
thing more than a local race of Maharattensis. I find that all the specimens
of the latter from Bengal and Central India in the Museum have less white
above, the white spots on the feathers being smaller, and that their 1st pri-
mary is a little shorter and narrower, being 0'8 inch, long, while in the Kachh
variety it is usually broader and 09", or even 095" long. But in both it has
three white spots on the inner web and one at the base of the outer web. The
proportions between the other primaries agree in both. The bill in Central
India Maharattensis is a little slenderer at the base and altogether some-
what longer. The wing, I find, to differ between 4 and 4'3 inches, but a
specimen said to be from Simla has the wing only about 3 8 inch., and
Beavan (Ibis, 18G5, vol. I, p. 410) gives the wing of a female from Manbhum
as 3'88 inch.
Blyth’s P. Blanfordi (Joum. A. S. B., XXXII, p. 75), ‘ is just barely
separable as a race,’ as its author truly remarks. I do not believe that it
differs specifically ; that is, I believe, that the Barmese bird is connected with
true P. Maharattensis by intermediate forms of indefinable gradations. The
type specimen has the wing 4, tail 2'45, tarsus 0 7, bill at front 0 9 inch.
The white blotches on the upper plumage are again slightly larger than in
the Kachh variety, but in all details of coloration both perfectly agree.
The first primary is in the Barmese type only about 06 inches long, and the
2nd and 3rd are comparatively also a little shorter, hut they do not
appear to have attained their full size in that specimen. It is noteworthy
234 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
to observe that such a marked form of a wood-pecker, as P . Maharattensis
represents, deviates from the type on the two extreme limits of its geogra-
phical distribution in an exactly similar manner, namely, by decreasing in
size and adding more white to its plumage.*
214. Eudxnamys HONOttATA, Linn.
E. orientalis apnd Jerdon. Comp. Ibis for 1869, vol. v, p. 338 and for 1872, p. 15.
Rare during the cold and dry seasons, but said to be very common in
the rains, when it breeds.
220. Taccocita sibkee.
Above dusky brownish grey with a slight greenish lustre, which is most
distinct on the tail, tertials, secondaries and tail feathers with close duller
crossbars, only perceptible in certain lights ; top of head with a slight rufescent
tinge ; feathers on head and neck black-shafted, glistening, bristly in front,
the remainder on the upper side brown shafted ; lores and chin whitish,
sometimes with a faint reddish tinge, above and below the eye narrowly
white, bristles on eyelashes black, pure white at base ; upper breast ashy
very slightly tinged with ferruginous, lower breast, vent, sides, lower wing
coverts and tibial feathers pale ferruginous ; lower vent and lower tail coverts
dusky ashy brown ; outer tail feathers dark brown, broadly tipped with
white. Average measurement of 3 specimens : Wing 6 — 6’25 ; tail 9 to
9 5 ; tarsus 16 to 17 ; bill from gape 15 inch., cherry red, yellow towards
the tip and the upper mandible blackish at the side.
I have seen this bird only on a few occasions ; it hides itself usually in
Euphorbia bushes, and is most difficult to flush. Often it manages to run
from one bush to another at a tremendously rapid pace, pressing its body
to the ground like a rat. I have seen it feeding on insects on the ground.
I take this opportunity of drawing attention to what appears to me to be often
an a priori somewhat unnatural explanation of facts. When a naturalist has noticed
and described a form which combines the characters of two .well marked races, or
species, and the geographical distribution of which falls within the limits of the two ;
other naturalists are, often without hesitation, ready with an explanation in stating, that
the intermediate form is ‘ evidently a hybrid between the two.’ This in many instances
looks very plausible, but is it natural ? or even a priori probable ? Those questions
seem to me to require thorough study and examination. Why should we a priori
presume .that there exist two entirely distinct types ? Does it net look more natural
to assume a priori that the so called intermediate form within the geographical limit
of a certain type is the typical species, and that, as it extends, it deviates in a some-
what different manner in various directions ? and that the peculiarities acquired in
order to maintain subsistence at certain localities may even remain constant and be
inherited within those certain local limits ? — I think in many cases this latter explana-
tion will prove to be the more probable ouo, although I do not by any moans wish to
abandon altogether the former.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 235
234. Auaciinkcutra asiatica* = crrbtj c aeia, Linn. Common.
On one occasion I shot a young male while sitting on the top of a tree,
about 40 feet high, and engaged in occasionally darting after passing insects,
which it appeared to catch, every time returning to its perch like a fly-catch-
er. In four males, wing 2 05 to 2'2 inches, tail 125 to 15 ; bill 0 65 to
0'7 ; tarsus 0'6.
255. Uptjpa XTmupExxis, Gould, vel Ceylonensis, Reich.
Comp. Jerdon, Ibis, 1872, p. 22.
Wing 5’3, tail 3\8, bill at front 1'75, tarsus 0'8 inch. The posterior
feathers of the crest have distinctly white preceding the black tip, but the
first primary has no white and the succeeding have it on both webs. The
4th primary is barely longer than the 5th, the 1st is 2 5 inches shorter than
the 4th ; the 2nd is 0 7 inches shorter, and the 3rd OT shorter than the 4th.
There is scarcely any ashy colour on the sides of the neck or breast.
Jerdon says, that the ‘ white spot on the first primary is occasionally pre-
sent,’ I may add, it is also the case as regards the white on the crest. What
is then to remain to be the distinctive character between the present form
and epops ? I have great doubts about the Indian hoopoe being separable
as a sufficiently distinct and definable species. There is no distinction in
plumage, and the only difference 1 can see, in comparing about half a dozen
specimens of each, is, that nigripennis, or Ceylonensis, is a smaller and
lighter bird, with the first primary shorter and narrower. Still I cannot
but doubt, that even these characters are so far constant, as to be of any
use in defining distinct species. I am sure the European, Indian and even
the Barmese hoopoe are merely local races of one species, not possessing a
single character constantly distinct in one from the other.
I only saw few specimens at the end of October and in the beginning of
November, but towards the end of the latter month, they became more
numerous ; it is, however, not a very common bird in Kachh, and must be,
to a certain extent at least, migratory.
256. Lam us (Coi/LYBiof) lahtojia. Very common.
Wing 4'1 to 4'4, tail 4'4 to 5 ; bill at front 0 6 to 07 ; tarsus IT
to 1'3 inch.
Some specimens have a distinct white superciliary edge above the black j
others no trace of it ; the inner plumage on breast and vent sometimes has
a very slight creamy wash, exactly as is often the case in the European
* I do not see tho benefit of changing the name asiatica to that of currucaria as
suggested by Jerdon, both being Linne’s names The former is retained by G. E. Gray
in his Hand-list.
t G. B. Gray adopts Collyno, Moehr., 1752, for the group of Lami as excubitor,
reserving Linne’s name Lomus for the type of L. cristatus.
31
230 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
excubitor ; all the tail feathers have at least their extreme tips white, even
the central ones, but only visible after a fresh moult, (which is also the case
in the two next species).
A full account of this species will be found in Proc. Zool. Soc.
London, for 1870, p. 595, by Mr. Dresser. On p. 596 the author says, ‘ rump
and upper tail coverts white,’ the description being taken from an old Pan-
jab bird. Now, it is strange that in about a dozen of specimens which I
shot in Kachh, and some of which are decidedly very old birds in full
plumage, the rump and upper tail coverts are albescent grey, in some the
latter may be called greyish white, but that is the utmost limit of white.
In fresh moulted old specimens the extreme terminal edges, of the upper
tail coverts are blackish, but they appear very soon to wear of. Perhaps the
distinction of possessing the rump and upper tail coverts white applies to the
winter plumage, which I do not know.
257. L. erytheottottts. Bare.
260. L. vittatus* (= HardwicJcii, auctorum). Very common.
262. L. arenariits.-}- Bare.
Bill at front 042 to 0 45, wing 3*5 to 3 6 ; tail 3*3 to 3*45, tarsus 0*9.
These measurements are somewhat smaller than those generally given of the
species. The young is striped in the usual way on the sides of neck and of the
body, and on the chest. The light coloured band on the rectrices, such as is
noticed by Viscount Walden in Ibis, vol. Ill, p. 224, is only occasionally
present, perhaps in old birds. The species migrates during the summer
to Western Tibet, where I saw it in the Indus valley.
265. Tephrodornis Pondiceeiatta. Not common.
The wing varies (in four specimens shot) between 3'3 and 3*4, none is
3-5 inch, The two outer tail feathers on each side are white, except at the
base and towards the tip, there being only the sub-terminal outer, or both
webs dusky ; the 3rd and 4th last tail feather on each side generally have
also a white edge about the middle of the outer web.
276. Peeiceocotes pebegeiyts. Very common.
The orange wing patch does not extend on any of the outer webs of
the first 5 primaries. Wing 2*5 to 2*6, tail 2*7 to 3 ; tarsus 0*6 inch.
(not -jo).
277. Periceocottts erythropygies. Not common.
I have occasionally seen flocks of this species hunting over high grass
on dried up portions of tanks. In the jungles it is more often seen single,
or in pairs.
* Ibis, 1868, iv, 316.
f Comp also Jordon in Ibis, 1872, p. 115.
237
1872.] F. Stoliczka — -Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih.
278. Drcituirtis* aebiricttts, Hodgs. Very common.
Average of four specimens, young and old : bill 0 7 to 0'8 ; wing 5 '4
to 5’65 ; tail 5'8 to 6'4, tarsus 0’8 inch.
I have never seen a herd of either cattle, or sheep, or goats, without a
number of these birds accompanying it ; they start with the herd in the
morning and return with it in the evening.
The specific name macrocercus is restricted for the Java species.
292. Leucocerca aureola, Less. = albofrontata, Frank. Very rare.
361. Petrocossypiius ctayeus. Bare.
365. I’r.ANESTicvs atuooulajus. Bare.
(Comp. Journ. A. S. B., 1868, vol. xxxvii, Pt. II, p 35. )
Bill at front 06 to 0'7 ; wing 5 3 to 54 ; tail 4- to 41, tarsus 125.
385. Ptctoris srffKNsrs. Very rare.
Bill 0'43 ; wing 2 ’55 ; tail 3 7; tarsus 1 inch.
438. Chatorhea caudata. Extremely common.
459. Otocampsa leccotts. Very common.
Wing 3’1 to 3'4 ; tail 3’2 to 3'5 ; tarsus 0 75 to 0-8 inch.
462. Pycnonotus chrysoreuoides, Lafr. — pusillus et pseudocafer,
Blyth. Very common.
467. Iora Zeylanica. Very common in low tree jungle.
Size the same as that given by Jerdon. Males and females had exactly
the same colouring, during the winter, but no blade above, the hind head
and back are, however, in most specimens blackish green. In this stage they
appear only to differ from typhia by their triflingly smaller size. (Compare
Hume, Jour. A. S. B., vol. xxxix, pi. ii, p. 117, and Stoliczka, ibid, p. 310).
480. Thamstobia cambayensis.
(Comp. Journ. A. S. B„ 1868, vol. xxxvii, Pt. II, p. 40.)
Extremely common throughout the country. The size is exactly the
same as that of the southern form, known under the name fulicata in India.
Male specimens which I shot in February had the upper plumage decidedly
rather darker, in fact almost black, tinged with blackish brown, while speci-
mens which I shot in November and December are almost entirely brown
above, but the upper tail coverts are in all greenish glossy black. It seems
to me clear that the two forms, as presently distinguished, merely represent
seasonal or local faces of plumage of the one and same species.
I observe that Gray (Hand-list, I, p. 211) unites them under the name
Cambayensis, reserving the name fulicata, Lath., for a South African species.
* This generic name is retained by G. R. Gray, and Bhuchanga of Hodgson
considered as a synonym of it ; but if the birds of the type of D. Umgicmdatus should
at all be distinguished in a separate group from those of the type of D. fmcatus,
Gm., Hodgson’s name should be retained as a subgenus for them, though I almost
doubt that a real necessity exists for it.
238 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. [No. 3,
481. Piiattxcola caphata. Very rare.
483. P. Indica, ? = bttbiOOLA. Very common.
Corap. Ibis, 1870, vi, p. 167, and 1871, p. 27 .
$ Wing 2’65, tail 2, tarsus 0’85, bill at front 0'4 inch.
This is the only specimen I saw during tha whole winter ; I shot it near
Bhuj on 2nd January. Gray (Hand-list, I, 228) retains the Indian Bush-
chat as distinct from the European, but I still think their identity can
hardly be questioned, although Indian specimens may generally be smaller ;
I certainly disbelieve the existence of two separable species in India as
rubicola and indica, As far as I remember I have seen in 1867 European
specimens with all the distinctive peculiarities in colour of P. indica, Hi-
malayan specimens of which I then compared with the former.
483S». Pratincola macbobhyncha, n. sp.
I shot at the beginning of 1872 two specimens of a Pratincola, (pro-
bably females, the sex was unfortunately not determined), which appears
to be distinct from any other as yet known.
General plumage, above, dull brown, all the feathers margined with
pale isabellino or fulvescent whitish, most broadly on scapulars and tertials,
narrowly on the quills ; upper tail coverts nearly entirely uniform pale ful-
vescent or sandy, only along the centre of a darker hue. Central tail feathers
brown, the succeeding also brown and very pale rufescent fulvous about
the basal half of both webs, (not along the shafts), the rufescent colour
gradually, not abruptly, passing into the brown ; outer web of last tail
feather wholly sandy or pale fulvescent white, and all have pale'tips which,
however, easily wear of. Lores and supereilium sandy white ; ears dusky.
Lower plumage fulvescent white throughout, with a slight shade of cream
colour, all the feathers on their basal halves are dark slaty, which is also
the case on the upper plumage. Bill and feet nearly quite black. Total
length about 5 -2" to 5 5" ; wing 2’85" to 2 9 inch., first primary nearly 1",
and 1’2" shorter than the second, which is very nearly equal to the 6th and
0'24" shorter than the fourth, this being tho longest ; the 3rd and 5th are
subequal and very little shorter than the fourth ; tail 2'1 to 2'25, tarsus
0'95 to 0 97 ; bill at front 0'48 to 0'5, from gape 072 ; hind toe and claw
0'57, hind claw alone 0'3 ; mid toe with claw 0.72 to 073 inch. The size
of the bill, which is rather narrow and Saxicoline, and the length of the legs
readily distinguish this apparently new species ; it is not the female of
P. rubetra, this having the basal half of the tail white, and the bill shorter
and broad at the base. It is also not a female or young of P, caprata,
moreover the length and slenderness of the hind claw does not agree with
any Pratincola, nor even with Saxicola, but strange enough with Oreicola
(= Ithodopkila,
1872.] F. Stoliczlca — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 239
One of the two specimens was shot in January near Rapur in the
Wagur district, and the other in February near Bhuj, in both cases in
an open desert country with scanty low hushes. These were the only two
specimens, which I saw, but possibly the bird may not bo so very rare ; for I
could never pay undivided attention to an ornithological subject.
489. Saxicola picata.
Comp. Hume, in Ibis, 1870, vi, p. 283.
Wing 3-6 to 3 75, tail 25 to 2-8 ; tarsus 09 to 095 ; bill 04 to 05.
The female has exactly the same distribution of the colours as the male,
but the black is replaced by blackish grey, the chin is rather whitish grey
and the ear-coverts somewhat rufescent.
One full plumaged male has an indistinct white stripe above the lores,
and all the tail feathers are distinctly tipped white, the black being subterminal.
Some apparently younger males with a dusky black plumage have the fore-
head paler, but none shews the very marked creamy colour noticed in Gould’s
capistrata, which was shown by Hume to be a young male of picata.
491. S. isaueij.in'a, Riippel, (= saltatrix, Menet.). Rare.
Comp. v. Pelzeln in Jonrn. fiir Ornithologies fur 1868, p. 27.
Wing 3'75, tail 2'3, tarsus IT 7, bill at front 057. A specimen from
the the Somali country, determined as isabellina by Blyth in the Asiatic
Society’s collection (now Indian Museum), only differs in having the wing
about 0-2 inch longer, (comp. Tristram’s statement in Ibis, 1867, p. 94) ; both
have the blackish streak between the base of the bill and the eye, and the
plumage is in every detail the same.
4:1) lb is. S. Krxoi, Hume. (Ibis, 1871, p. 29).
A single specimen was shot in Wagur in January, and I do not
remember of having seen another. Wing 3 55, tail 2'3, tarsus T, bill at
front 056 inch. The first primary is 175 shorter them the 3rd. The
coloration exactly agrees with the specimen described by Mr. Hume, who
kindly pointed out to me the bird amongst a number of females of the next
species.
492. S. deseiiti, Riippel, = atrogularis and montana, Gould.
Very common. The wing of five males varies between 3’6 and 3'9, tail
2 5 to 2 7, tarsus 095 to 1'05, bill 045 to 05 inch. Most of the females
are a trifle smaller (wing 3'5 inch.), than the males.
I have no doubt that Mr. Hume is correct (Ibis, 1870, vi, p. 283) in
considering Gould’s 8. montana as the summer or breeding plumage of
atrogularis. In Journ. As. Soc., 186S, xxxvii, Pt. II, p. 42, I have parti-
cularly noticed the pure white on the median portions of the wing feathers
on Tibetan specimens, shot during the summer, and regarding which von
Pelzeln (Ibis, iv, p. 308) says that they agree with an Egyptian specimen of
8. desert i, except that the latter is smaller.
240 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. No. 3,
I perfectly remember African specimens of S. deserti which I repeatedly
compared in 1SG7 ; they were no doubt on the whole a little smaller (on the
average, I find in a note : wing 3'5, tail 2'5, bill at front 0'45, tarsus 0'95),
than most of Indian specimens, but there was not the least difference in
structure and colour between the two. Now, as Indian specimens occasion-
ally equal in size African ones, and as the former, which undoubtedly
represent one species, differ in the size of the wing from 3'5 to 4 inches, I
do not see, — with all respect due to the opinions of Messrs. Gould, Blyth
and other eminent ornithologists — any reason in regarding the Indian birds
as specifically distinct from the African deserti. All we can say is, that
African specimens are as a rule lighter and smaller, while Indian specimens
are as a rule slightly heavier and larger, but I do assert that there are to be
found specimens perfectly equal in size from both countries.
494. Cercomela fusca.
I have only seen solitary specimens in the hilly districts, between low
bushes. The birds have much of the habit of a Betrocossy phus.
497. ItUTICILLA RUFIVEXTRIS.
This is the only redstart which has been observed ; it was tolerably
abundant from November until the end of February.
I shot 3 males and two females, and the measurements of all are con-
siderably smaller than those given by Jerdon : $ , wing 3'2 to 3’3 ; tail
2 '4 to 2 G, tarsus 0'9, bill at front 0'1 inch. The females are a little
smaller.
530. Orthotomtts longtcaudus. Common.
Lores and eyelids white. Tibial feathers pale rufous. I shot a specimen
while hunting for insects between large stones of an old embankment at
the Sir-talao in the south-western part of Kachh. It looked in every crevice
or hole, disappearing and emerging again from among the stones, just like
a wren. Other specimens I often saw hunting on the ground in Euphorbia
bushes.
536. P iiT.vrA gracilis. Not common.
Lores extending on the supraciliary edge white, tibial feathers pale
rufous.
544 bis. Drtmoipus Jerdoxt, (Blyth).
P. ? n. sp , Journ. A. S. B., xi, p. 883 and xiii, 376.
P. Jerdoni, Blyth, J. A. S. B,, xvi, p. 459.
Upper plumage entirely, and more or less distinctly, rufescent brown ;
margins of wing coverts, tertials and upper tail coverts slightly more tinged
with rufescent, primaries on the edges of the outer webs pale rufescent ;
shoulder edge of wing, lower wing coverts and all wing feathers about the
edges of the inner webs (not quite extending to the tip) rufescent whitish.
Lores, supereilium and round the eye white ; ear coverts white at the base,
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Raclih. 241
greyish towards the tips, the grey colour also tinging the sides of neck.
Lower plumage very soft, luteo-rufescent whitish, white on chin and ab-
domen ; tigh coverts and lower tail coverts pale rufous. Tail above with
rather close, hut not very distinct, dull cross bars, all except the two centre
feathers with an indistinct subterminal dark band and a well developed dull
white tip. Bill above dark brown, paler towards the edges and below ; feet
pale fleshy.
Length about 7 inches ; wing 205 to 2'20 ; tail 2'75 ; tarsus 0 75 ;
bill at front O' 12, from gape 0'62 inch. (These measurements are taken
from two carbolised specimens.)
This is undoubtedly the bird which Blyth first noticed as distinct from
2). syhaticus, naming it subsequently 2). Jerdoni , but uniting it afterwards
with D. longicaudatus. Jerdon (Birds, India, II, p. ISO) doubts the cor-
rectness of this identification, and very properly so, I think. I have carefully
compared the type specimen, presented by Jerdon, and I have no doubt that
it is a distinct and good species. The type measures : wing 21, tail 2'6,
tarsus 0'72 inch., (bill imperfect). This type specimen exactly agrees in
plumage with those from Kachh, and there is another specimen received since
by the Indian Museum from Nagpur, very likely presented by W. T.
Blanford. It is also exactly of the same size, as the type.
I found the species not unfrequently between low bushes, but secured
only two specimens, which I prepared with carbolic acid. Mr. Hume kindly
informed me that he named the bird 2)rgmoipus rnfescens, noting the
distinctions from allied Indian species.*
544. Duyiioirrs loxgicaudatcs.
In two specimens shot on 26th December, the primaries are edged with
very pale rufous. There is no dark subterminal band on the tail, but all
except the middle feathers pass into albescent towards the tips, which are
conspicuously narrowed in one specimen. Lores, supercilium and round the
eye white. The two specimens were procured in moderately high grass at
the edge of a tank near the village Wandra, in the S. Western part of
Kachh. Wing 2'85 and 2 95 ; tail 2'4 and 2'8 ; tarsus 0'75, bill at front
0-42 inch. .
551. Feaniclinia Bttchanani ? (an Cleghomies Jerdon) .
Out of three specimens shot in November and December, in one the
upper coloration is rufescent brown and the head above almost quite rufous
* Since my account was written, Mr Hume’s description of the bird appeared
in ‘Ibis,’ vol. ii, No. 6, for 1872, p. 110. A full account of the bird will be found in
that place. Mr. Hume gives the wing of a male as 2'62 inches, and the tail 3'38
tarsus 0'95, and bill at front 0'5 inch. Other specimens are smaller, particularly the
young, and the females, ho says, are always much smaller than the males. (Sentb
1872. '
242 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
with paler shafts to the feathers ; a second specimen is paler, being slightly
olivaceous brown. Wings dull brown, primaries edged with olivaceous
white, secondaries with pale rufescent ; edge of wing white ; middle tail
feathers very conspicuously cross barred, the others dark or blackish brown
with white tips, the outer edge of the outermost feather is wholly white.
Lores, round the eye and the lower plumage white ; ear-coverts whitish, tinged
with pale ashy towards their tips ; sides of neck and breast tinged with
bluish ashy ; sides of belly, the abdomen and lower wing coverts, with ful-
vescent, and the tibial feathers are slightly rufescent. Bill brown, basal
half of lower mandible whitish ; legs fleshy, darker on the toes. Wing 2 05
to 2T ; tail 25 to 2'6 ; tarsus 0'7 ; bill at front 0 42 inch.
In the third specimen the upper plumage is still paler than in the other
two, ashy brownish, and the rufescent on the head very slight ; in other
respects it is exactly the same. Wing 195 ; tail 2-45 inch, bill and tarsus
the same, as in the two previous specimens. The more ashy and little smaller
bird is probably the female or young, but I had not determined the sexes.
The birds were very abundant, flying from bush to bush, almost invari-
ably in company with Chatorhea caudata, and feeding mostly on the ground
between the bushes.
Should this bird be Jerdon’s F. Cleghorniee ? (Comp. Ibis, 1867,
p. 24). It is a trifle smaller than Jerdon’s measurements of j Buchanani,
but I can see no very perceptible distinctions between specimens of that bird
in the Museum and those from Kachh. Gray gives F. Cleghorniee , in Hand-
list, Pt. I, p. 196, as a distinct species, and Blyth says that it differs from
Buchanani by 1 having the upper parts pale rufescent brown.’ I dare
say a good series of the birds from the N. West Provinces will easily settle
this question, but several specimens of Buchanani, which 1 saw from the
North-West, are paler than the Kachh birds.
553. Pn v llopnetj ste KAMA, (apud Jerdon). Not common.
In all birds which I observed, and which are referable to this species,
[as distinguished from the smaller Calomodyta (? Iduna) agricolensis,
Hume], the first primary was about 0'7 inch, long, but in some birds
the third is equal to the fourth, in others the fourth is a trifle longer than
the third primary, there is, however, no possibility of distinguishing the birds
either by plumage or size. The roundness of the ridge of the bill towards
its tip also slightly varies. Wing 2'4 ; tail 2 to 2T5 ; tarsus 075 to 0’77 ;
bill at front 0'4.
This species is referred to by Gray (Handlist, I, p. 209) as a synonym
of Calamodyta (Iduna) calligata, Licht., a Siberian and Eastern European
species. The identification is very probably correct.
554. Phylloscopus tkistis. Not common.
Wing 2'4 ; tail nearly 1‘9, tarsus 0 75 ; bill at front G'33, from nostril
213
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh.
025 ; from gape O' 18. Although this specimen slightly differs in size from
others, as usually recorded, and although its upper plumage has a decided
greenish tinge, it agrees in every other respect with the Indian tristis, and
not with tlie European rufus ; but the difference can scarcely be made out
without well preserved examples of the latter species, such as I had occasion
to see in Mr. Brooks’ collection. Slightly faded specimens of rufus are
scarcely distinguishable from tristis , but I doubt that many specimens of the
latter occur without a trace of green tinge in the upper plumage, as represent-
ed in Gould’s figure in 1 Birds of Asia.’
581. Sylvia (Adophaneits) oefiiea. Rather rare.
The measurements of two $ specimens perfectly accord with those
given by Jordon. Top of head black in both. The outer tail feathers are
nearly all white on the outer webs, and also on about the terminal (not
basal) half of the inner web.
Gray (Hand-list, I, 214) retains for the Indian species Blyth’s name
8. Jerdoni, as distinct from true orphea of Europe, Africa and Palestine.
But what are the definable distinctions between these two ?
583. Sylvia (Stebfaeola) cttrruca. Very common.
Average measurements of four specimens : wing 2’5 to 2 65 ; tail
225 ; tarsus 075 to 08 ; middle toe with claw O'G to 07 ; bill 036 inch.
Comparing these measurements with those of Jordon, the bill and tarsus
are exactly as in curruca, but the wing and tail are very nearly as large as
in the South Indian 8. affinis* and as Blyth says (Ibis, 1867, p. 28)
that the latter only differs from the former by a somewhat larger size, and
not in plumage, it is, I think, after all not improbable that they represent
only one species with slight variations in the size. The amount of white
and its purity on the outer tail feathers varies : the latter are nearly all
white, or with the basal half of the inner web dusky, and again in others
the inner web is nearly to the tip dusky, but the shaft is always black.
The white is pure in some birds, but certainly less so in others. The
second last tail feathers are generally tipped white, but not invariably.
Tristram gives as a ‘ constant distinction’ between the Indian and the
European birds, ‘ the outer tail feathers are nearly all pure white, and the
others tipped with pure white’ in the former, but these are most decidedly
very variable characters, as far as the purity of the white is concerned. Gray
(Hand-list, I, 213) does not allow curruca in India, but only affinis ; and
Brooks (J. A. S. B., XLI, Pt. II, 1872, p. 81) seems to have no doubt on that
point. Before accepting this decision, I should like to see the differences
pointed out which exist between affinis of all India and curruca of Europe
* One of the two original types in the old Asiatic Society’s collection has the
wing 2'7, and the other 275, the bill is slightly larger than in any curruca I saw
from Northern or Central India.
32
244 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
and Palestine. I can only say that it appears to me far more probable,
that all are curruca, than that the Northern Indian bird is specifically
separable from the European.
'589. Motaciela Madeeaspatensis, Gm. Not common.
Wing 3'G to 3 7 ; tail 3'9 ; tarsus 1 ; bill (Hi. These measurements
are somewhat smaller than those given by Jerdon, but the coloration agrees
perfectly. A male and female, which I shot on 24th October, had the chin
and throat still black, with only very few white feathers intermixed.
591. Motaciela Dekhekensis. Common.
$ wing 3 6 ; tail 3'75 ; tarsus 0'95 ; bill at front 05.
2 „ 3 3, „ 3 5 ; „ 0 9 ; „ „ 0 5.
These arc the measurements of a pair which I shot together on 31st
January at Edpur in the Wagur district. The female is slightly smaller
than the male ; it has the ashy above and the black on the wings, on the
tail and on the gorget, less pure, and the head above and nape are uniform
with the upper plumage, i. e., grey. The white on the forehead is of less
extent and less pure. Jerdon’s description of Luzoniensis is so general that
it could equally apply to the present species, which has the white band at
the side of neck continuous.
593 his. Bedytes m e e ano c e ptt a la .
There were few of these birds seen before the end of December. Of
several which I obtained, none has a trace of a white or yellow supercilium.
Specimens shot in January had the top of head partially brownish grey,
some of the feathers, however, changing to black. Chin whitish in front
and the breast with some dark spots. About the middle of February I
saw a great number of these birds with the underparts very bright yellow,
and the top of the head perfectly black.
Wing 3-2, tail 2 75 to 2 9, tarsus 085 to 0’95 ; bill 045 to 05 inch.
Mr. Brooks has kindly shewn me his series of Indian and European
B. flava, cinereocapilla and melmocephala, and I can only say that
the male adult birds of these species are very well marked and easily
distinguished, whatever difficulty there may exist in discriminating young
and female birds, or those not in full plumage.
(Comp. Notes on B. fiaoa and its varieties, in Ibis, 1871, p. 138, and
Brooks in J. A. S. B., XLI, Pt. II, 1872, p. 82).
594 Us. Bedytes oaecaeates, Hodgs. Bare.
A specimen shot on 2nd January near Bhiij agrees in colour with Jer-
don’s account of B. citreola ; the back begins to change from grey to black
which latter colour, according to Brooks, distinguishes calcaratus from
citreola ; the former also has a slightly larger bill and tarsus. The measure-
ments are : wing 3 25, tail 3, bill at front 0 55, tarsus 0 90, hind claw 0‘4
inch.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — -Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 245
602. Aobodboma campestbis. Common.
646. Pabus nuciia i. is.
I shot two specimens during December in the Western part of Kachh,
and I saw a few more at various other localities, but the species is decidedly
rare. It frequents low jungles, thin and thorny, such as they are in
Kachh.
Above, glossy black, somewhat duller on back and tail ; nuchal patch,
a band about the middle of the wing, extending only to the basal por-
tion of the inner web of the second primary, the extreme tips of all wing
feathers, the greater part of the margins of the outer webs of the three or four
last primaries, a narrow subterminal outer edge of three or four last seconda-
ries, the broad outer margins, also involving the tips of the tertials, the first
outer tail feather entirely, the second nearly so (except on shaft and on the
edge of inner web), the outer web of the third last, and the tips of all the
succeeding feathers, (decreasing to the centre one), white. A broad black
band from the lower mandible along the centre of the underside to the
abdomen, broadest in front and on breast. Sides from the angle of the
mouth to the lower tail coverts including white, on the side of breast, the
belly and abdomen, tinged with very pale but distinctly fulvous green.
Tibial feathers white in front, black behind ; some of the longest lower tail
coverts are blackish at the base of the inner web, the remainder all white.
Wing 2’7 to 2-75, tail 2T to 2'25 ; tarsus 065 ; bill at front 0-3 5. Dill
black ; legs plumbeous, very stout.
This is probably the most northern part of the country in which the
species occurs. The two specimens above described slightly differ in size and
coloration from Jordon’s description and figure of a South Indian example,
but both evidently are the same species.
663. Cobvtjs (Anomalocobax) imptjdictis, Hodgs.
This name is adopted by G. II. Gray (Handl., II, 14) for the Indian
crow, O. splendens, Tem., being referred to Java and Sumatra. It is the
only representant of the Corvidce, but is very common throughout Kachh.
684. Acbldothebes tbistis. Very common.
In several places I saw this species associating at dusk in great num-
bers near tanks where there was high grass growing, and at night fall they
disappeared under a tremendous noise like shooting stars in the arundinaceous
forest, with the peculiar rapid turn in then' flight, exactly as Sturnus vul-
garis does in Europe.
The entire plumage is much duller in winter than in summer, and is
exactly like that of A. fuse, us. The first primary is minute and the fourth
the longest. In one specimen, the second primary is entirely white, and
some of the first tertials are also white. This is evidently an accidental
246 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Iiaehh. [No. 3,
variation in the plumage, perhaps the first step to albinism. The wing
varies in four specimens from 5'5 to 5 9 ; tail 3'5 to 3'75 ; tarsus 1’4 to
16 ; bill at front 065 to 0’7 inch.
685. Aceidotheees GnrartfiAmrs.
Not very common, except locally in the eastern parts of Kachli ( Wagur
district). In young specimens from Bengal the bill is blackish green at
base, the wing spot pure white and the under tail coverts and tips of tail
feathers dusky white, intead of pale ferruginous.
In addition to the three species, given by Jerdon, G. It. Gray (ITandl.,
II, 20) separates A. grand is, Hodgs. = cristatellm, Vig., from Nepal,
and ? ater, V., = griseus, Blyth (part), from Pondicherry.
687. Tementjchus eaoodaetjm.
Bare. I have seen it only on three or four occasions in pairs. Jerdon’s
description is rather short. It should state that the lengthened brown fea-
thers pass round the whole neck. The two middle tail feathers are ashy
brown, and blackish along the shafts, the remainder dark brown, tipped
with white, the latter colour increasing in amount towards the outer feathers ;
lower tail and under coverts of the wings white, tihial feathers ashy white ;
there is a small black spot at the base of the lower mandible, and the chin
quite in front is also tinged blackish.
690. Pastor eosees.
Very common from about the middle of November. G. B. Gray (Handl.
II, 19) quotes the Indian bird as distinct from the European and Western
Asiatic under the name P. ? pegmnus, Less. I do not know whether a second
species exists in Barma, but surely the Western Indian bird is not different
from the European one, which in former years I had very abundantly seen
in various parts of Hungary. It is a rare bird in Western Europe.
694. Ploceus baya.
This is the smaller bird,* described by Jerdon under the above name.
Although nests were very numerously seen on branches overhanging river
banks &e., the buds themselves were very rare ; most of them must have
retired to some other more wooded districts, but they are said to return in
the rainy season, when they breed.
703. Munta Maeabaeioa.
Extremely common. I found the species breeding abundantly during
November, December and January in deserted nests of the weaver bird, P.
baya ; and I was told by my shikari that the Munia never builds its own
nest, always using that of baya , as soon as the latter had finished breeding
at the end of the rains. However, I have at least on two occasions seen a
Munia working on an imperfect nest of the P. baya, evidently the birds
* Comp, ante, p. 167.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. 2 17
were repairing it. There certainly were other apparently finished nests
with eggs in them, their bases were rather flat, irregular and the entrances
were lateral ; these looked to me as nests repaired by Munice. I found from
6 to 12 eggs in one of them ; more than one pair appeared to lay in the
same nest, or rather the birds did not seem to he very particular in which nest
they lay ; they appear to he very communistic in this respect. The eggs
are white, varying in shape from elongately oval to almost globular. The
former is the prevalent type, averaging in size about 16 by 12 (changing to
11 and 13) m.m. ; one of the extreme forms of the globular type measures
19 by 17 m.m.
706. Passes indices. Very common.
I have seen the wing of this species in India vary from 2 -75 to 3 '25
inch. I wonder, if really good series of the European and the Asiatic spar-
rows were made, whether it would be possible to define in words the dis-
tinction between indicus and domesticus ; I doubt it.
711. Feingidla (Gymnoets) flavicollis. Common.
The bill of this species certainly more resembles Fringilla than Passer,
and so does the habit, the call, and the general tone of plumage of the bird.
71 ibis. Fhi no r i, lari a* stbiolata.
Comp, Hunio in Ibis, 1870, vi, p. 399.
Local and usually seen in pairs, between low bushes on slightly elevated
or hilly ground.
$ wing 3‘1 ; tail 2'35 ; tarsus 063 ; bill at front 036 inch.
^ ^ i » ^ ^ ) 77 »))))>» 77 77 •
This bird was only lately added to the Indian fauna by Mr. Hume.
Kachh specimens perfectly agree with Mr. Hume’s account.
716. ClTIUNELLAf (Gl/YCYSPINA.) Huttont. Very common.
Males have the head lighter ashy than females ; and in both sexes the
feathers on top of it arc slightly darkened along the middle line. The males
are also more rufous below, having a broad patch of that colour on the breast.
A dark streak from the base of the lower mandible on each side is well marked
in both sexes, and the pale mandibular streak has a slight yellowish rufescent
tinge. I cannot help doubting the specific distinctness of this bird from
hortulana, as far as I remember the European bird. The note of both is
exactly the same.
756. Mibafea erytiieopteba. Not common.
I shot once a specimen sitting on a bush about 5 feet high, and pouring
forth a rather pleasing song.
* The species of this genus are almost entirely African, the present species
appears to be the most eastern straggler.
t Tho generic name Emberiza has been restricted for the typo E. nivalis, L.,
therefore nearly all Indian Emberizince are referable to Citrinella.
248 F. Stoliczka — . ’Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
758. Ammomanes pikenicltua. Common.
Wing 4 to 4‘3'; tail 2’3 to 2'5 ; tarsus 0'8 to 0'86 and bill 0.5. *
760. PrEEmiiiATroA grisea. Common.
Gray (Handl. II, 123) gives ajfiiiis, Blyth, as a distinct species from
‘ Madras.’
761. Axauda (CaIiANDrebt.a) brac ify dactyla. Common.
Wing in tlirco specimens only 3 6 to 3'7 inch, tarsus 0'75 to 0'8.
765. AiiAiiBA (Spizalatjda) deta. Very common.
The measurements agree with those given by Jerdon, the length of the
wing only varying between 3’3 and 3'4 inch. Mr. Hume (Journal A. S. B.
xxxix, pt. ii, p. 120) separated a very closely allied and slightly smaller
form as Sp. simillima. The length of the wing of the Kachh lark is inter-
mediate between his measurements (loc. cit.) of the two forms ; and so
also appears to be the general tone of the plumage, not being either parti-
cularly rufous, nor pale or sandy colour. The lining of the wing is slightly
tinged with rufous in a young, but is of a purely fawn or sandy in two adults.
The male has the hind toe and claw 0’8, the female 0'7, the former has also
the feathers of the crest somewhat longer than the latter.
770. C HUTim.AL'DA (Ai./EMOX) besehtorum.
Wing 5'1. to 5'3 inch. Jerdon does not mention the dark mustaehial
streak which is always well marked. All my specimens have the upper plu-
mage brownish sandy-grey, exactly like those obtained by Mr. Blanford in
Abyssinia, while Jerdon noticed an Indian example with dark plumage, pro-
bably resembling Gould’s figure in Birds of Europe. They are evidently the
same birds. (Comp. Blanford, Gcol. and Zool. Abyssinia, 1870, p. 385).
Gray (Handlist, II, 121) gives Finsch’s Jessci as distinct from desertonm,
although their identity has been, I believe, unquestionably proved by Finsch
himself (vide Append. II, to that author’s Report on birds from Abyssinia,
&c., p. 3L6).
I have obtained this desert lark only on the Rami, between the main-
land of Kachh and the islands of Pacham, Kharir, &c., but even in these
true desert localities it seems to be rare ; for I have not seen more than a
dozen examples altogether ; generally two of them in society were seen busily
hunting after grain on the soft, muddy track, leading through the Rann.
788. Columba intermedia. Very common.
There is scarcely a well in Kachh in which a colony of these pigeons
would not breed, and they appear to do this all the year round, as if domes-
ticated.
794. Turtur cambatensis. Very common.
796. „ risorius. Very common.
* The numbers referring to tlieso two last measurements are evidently trans-
posed in Jerdon’s book, loc cit. p. 422.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. 249
797. Turtt.'r httmitjIS, Common.
799. Ptebocees akenabigs..
Tli is is by no means a common bird in Kachh. I only met with it in
the south-eastern parts of the province on large grassy plains or fields.
800. Ft i' roci.es fasciattxs. Very common.
The crepuscular habit of this bird must be explained by its coming
to drink at, or little after, dusk. Hundreds of them used to arrive, under
a loud chuckling call, to the wells or tanks where I was usually encamped.
After they had satisfied their thirst they generally walked away quietly and
remained for the night in the neighbouring fields, although they were often
constantly alarmed by other animals who came to the wells during the night.
When flushed for the first time in the jungles during the day, they generally
take only a short flight and drop down again, but when flushed a second time
they betake themselves a much greater distance. On the 22nd December, I
came across a couple of old birds with 3 young ones, only about one or two
days hatched. This must have been exceptional, as the usual breeding
season of these birds is much earlier, during the rains.
802. Ptekoci.es excstus. Very common.
Comp. Journ. A. S. B. xxxviii, pt. ii, p. 189.
In many females the central rectrices are quite as much elongated as
in the males, at least during the winter. A young male shot in November
is coloured above like the female, but the chin is whitish, the pectoral band
altogether absent, and the sides of the abdomen are nearly as rufous brown,
as in the adult male.
8C3. Pavo cbistattts. Very common.
The sacred bird of the Thakurs of the country.
818. Fb.XNCOIJ-VITS VULGABIS.
S . Wing ()'3, tail nearly 4, tarsus F75 inch. ; $ a trifle smaller. Out
of eight specimens none has the wing under 6 inch. The birds are larger than
usual, and though generally distributed, they are not common, and solitary.
I shot two or three in the Wagur district, but have not seen nor heard
through the whole of Kachh of a different kind of black partridge, as
indicated by Capt. MeMurdo and Mr. Hume, (comp. Joum. A. S. B.
vol. xxxviii, pt. ii, p. 190 and vol. xxxix, pt. ii, p. 121) ; and I can only
conclude that Capt. MeMurdo was misled by the size of the bird, so as to
regard it as a different species. To what species Mr. Hume’s bud belonged,
it is really difficult to say.
They generally roost on low trees.
822. Okttgoenis Ponticektaxus. Very common.
<? . Wing 5’5 to 5'75, tail 3'3 to 3'6, tarsus l-4 to 1'5.#
The wing in two females in 5'25 and 5 o inch, they have the throat
distinctly tinged with ferruginous, while in the males it is almost quite
* Jerdon says 1 not quite 2"’ !
250 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
white. This partridge is extremely common throughout the country, it is
quite a homely bird and often enters houses. It invariably roosts on trees,
particularly on the Kundu, two or three generally sitting together on a
branch between a thick cover of foliage. It generally goes to roost shortly
after sunset.
827. Pebdictji.a, asiatica, Not common.
All the feathers of the upper plumage have in the male one, or generally
two, tawny spots along the shafts, bordered with dark.
829. Cotubntx communis. Local.
832. Ttjenix taigook. I have seen and shot this quail only on two
occasions, they were solitary males.
836. Eupodotis edwajiusii. Not common. (The bustard of Europeans).
837. Hotjbaba Macqueenit. Common, and though generally distri-
buted, it is most abundant in the eastern and southern portions of Kachh.
839. SvpniooTinES auritus. The florican is not found during the
winter, but is very abundant during the rains.
8405**. Cuesorius Jamesoni, Jordon, ? = gaulicus. Very common.
Wing G-3 to 0-75, tail 24 to 27, tarsus 27 to 27, bill at front 78 to
1 inch. In the young the whole of the upper plumage is isabellino, crossed
by somewhat, undulating dark lines or narrow bands, and the black wing
feathers are margined towards the tips with pale ; the lower plumage is
generally albescent throughout, pale isabelline on breast and with a few
brown cross lines. The first change is indicated by the appearance of the
white occipital band, then comes the ashy on the occiput, then the lower
black band from behind the eye, and at last the cross black band, separating
the ashy from the white on the hind occiput. As this gradual change in
the occipital bands takes place, the brown lines on the other plumage are
gradually disappearing, and young birds shot in January still had them on
the wing coverts and on the vent, but somewhat later every trace of the
brown lines disappeared, and in the adult the isabelline plumage has a
conspicuous rufcscent tinge on forehead, hind nock, scapulars and on the
upper side of the tail.
I have no specimen of the European bird to compare, but as far as I
remember it from having often seen it in former years in Southern Hungary,
it strikes me that the flight and the habits of C. gallicus are somewhat
different. The Indian bird appears to be more solitary, its flight seems to
be slightly heavier, and the voice more shrill.
849. 2Egialites cueonicus. Common.
Gray (Hand!, HI, 15) gives curonicus, Besck, as synonym of Jluvia-
tilis, but quotes PJiilippinm , Lath., from India.
8o2. Cuettusia ? gregaiua. Very common in open country, and
often seen with Oursorius.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting KqcTih. 251
Winter plumage: Forehead and superciliary band passing round the
occiput white, the former slightly, the latter distinctly tinged with rufous ;
top of head impure blackish brown ; back of neck pale rufescent ashy, many
of the feathers being usually tipped pale ; general plumage above slightly
olivaceous ashy brown, somewhat darker on the rump ; primaries black, secon-
daries white, tertials olivaceous, the last feathers much lengthened ; upper tail
coverts white ; tail white, with a black subterminal band, not extending on
the outermost feathers. Lores white, with the shaft of the feathers black and
the nude terminations somewhat prolonged ; a narrow blackish streak through
the eye ; ear coverts, and sides of neck slightly rufescent brown, passing
on to the breast, on which most of the feathers are subtermiually darkened,
forming subtrigonal marks. Chin, throat, and the whole lower side from
beyond the breast, including lower wing and lower tail coverts, pure white.
Wing 8 to 8'3 ; tail 3'5 to 3'7 ; tarsus 2'2 to 2'3 ; bill at front T1 to 1-2.
Gray (Handlist, III, 11) adopts the name Wagleri for the Indian bird,
but I do not know in what our bird differs from the European gregaria. A
comparison of authentic specimens is needed.
855. Lobivaxelt/ijs indicus, (Bood.) Very common.
G. R. Gray, (Hand-list, III, 11,) gives L. indicus, Bodd., = goensis, Gm.,
= atrogularis, Wagl. Wing 8'5 to 8'9 ; tail 4 '2 5 to 4 '75 ; tarsus 2'75 to
29 ; bill at front 1’2 to 1'3 inch. It generally keeps near villages about
tanks and wells. At the first dawn its characteristic call is heard and re-
peated all round the habitations.
856. Sahciophoeus •'bilobus. Very common.
Average measurements of six specimens, shot in December and Janu-
ary. Whig 7'7 to 8, tail 3'1 to 3'3, tarsus 2'3 to 2'5 ; bill at front l'l to
1-2 inch. The black of the top of head is in winter generally mixed with
greyish brown, and in younger birds it is almost entirely brown ; the chin
in the young is whitish, while in adults apparently it is in winter much
mixed with black.
Gray (Hand-list, III, 12) gives Roplopterus Brmonii, Wagl. =
bilobus, Aliq. = ludoviciana var fS., Lath., from India; and H. (Lobipluvia)
malaharicus, Bodd., = bilobus, Gm. = myops, Less., from Malabar. If the
latter reference applies to our bird, it has in that case to stand as
malabaricus, which would not be a very appropriate name for itT
859. GSdicnemus indices, Salvadori. Common.
Comp. Atti R. Aoad. Sc. Nat. 1866, viii, and Ibis, 1866, II, p, 415.
Average measurements of six specimens : Wing 8'5 to 8'8 ; tail 4'25 to
4'5 ; tarsus 2'8 to 3'3, bill at front 1'45 to 1'05 inch. The bird is called
CkacTcua by the natives.
Gray (Hand-1., Ill, 9) questions the distinctness of indicus from
33
252 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
crepitans of Europe ; it certainly barely differs ; the nude space behind the
eye is in the European bird of less extent, than it is in the Indian.
863. Gars Antigone. Tolerably common.
A sacred bird with the Mahomedans, who will not kill a Saras. It is
almost always seen in pairs.
865. Gars cinerea. Common.
About the beginning of February the birds collected in very large flocks,
and by the middle of that month nearly all of them were gone, only solitary
and probably sickly birds remaining.
871. Gallinago scotoPAcrtrrs.
As there are very few swampy grounds, the bird is of course very rare.
1 have not seen more than about a dozen pairs. One has the wing 5 '2, tail
2 2, tarsus 13 ; middle toe with claw 1'5 ; bill 2'9 inch. The shorter lower
wing coverts are white with blackish bars and the longer ones grey with
white edges, which in O. stenura are replaced by white and dark bars.
875. Limosa JEGOCEritAiiA. Very common.
All the specimens I shot had the white of the face round the bill, ex-
tending over a portion of the superciliary band, tinged with golden. It is
a very restless and quarrelsome bird, whenever two of them meet each other
on the edge of the water. Before the end of October few birds were seen,
but they became plentiful about the middle of November. In February
none had yet changed their winter garb.
880. PniLOMACmis PTTGNAjf. Very common.
Male : wing 7'3 to 7'7 ; tail 2’25 to 2'6 ; tarsus T8 to 2 ; middle toe
with claw 1.'6 ; bill at front l-3 to 1'4, The general tone of the upper
plumage above is ashy brown, the wing coverts are uniform dark brown,
more or less tipped with white, but not barred. Bill blackish, more or less
variegated with yellowish fleshy at the base.
In the female the general tone, above, is slightly richer, all the pale color-
ation having a faint rufesccnt tinge. In other respects both sexes are exact-
ly similarly colored, all the feathers of the upper plumage being darker about
the centres. Her bill is black and the feet greenish black. Wing 6T5 ;
tail 2’2 ; tarsus 1'55, mid toe with claw 1'1 ; bill at front 1'2 inch.
I have seen them generally feeding in company with pigeons near places
where grain was collected after the harvest.
885. Tiuxga Temminciui. Not common.
891. Actitis glaeeola. Very common.
Specimens, shot in December and January, have the longer upper and
lower tail coverts with dark blackish cross bars, the latter besides streaked
with the same colour along the shafts. The outermost tail feathers as a
rule have some dark spots on the outer webs.
1872.]
F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclili.
253
892. A. ocintopus. Very common.
The outermost tail feathers have as a rule a minute subterminal dark spot
on the outer web, and the same applies to the longest upper tail-coverts.
893. A. nvPor.EUCUS. Very common.
894. Totautts glottis. Very common.
Average measurements of four specimens : wing 7 '2 to 7'8 ; tail 3 2 to
3'4, tarsus 24 to 2 6 ; hill at front 2T to 2 2 inch. Most of the upper tail
coverts have dark cross bars, like the tail. There is a dusky streak from the
base of the upper mandible towards the eye, superseded by a pure white band.
Outer web of first minute primary and the shaft of the second, the longest
one, white.
896. T. Frscirs. Very raro.
The middle tail feathers have in a specimen distinct dark cross bars
along the margins of both webs. First long primary with a white shaft, all
are towards the margins of the inner webs minutely variegated with white
and dusky brown.
897. T. CALiDitis. Eare.
Wing 6'5, tail 2 '5, tarsus 2T, bill at front 1'8 inch. The first long
primary has a white shaft, and all are albescent on the margin of the inner
web ; lower tail coverts more or less streaked or spotted with dusky ; breast
cinereous, all feathers dark-shafted.
898. Himantopus iNTHUMKoms, Blyth. Very common.
The birds with brownish back and scapulars, blackish hind-head, and with
a grey neck, are young. In some specimens the whole neck is white and the
occiput black. One adult male, shot in February, had the whole head white,
somewhat dusky behind the eye,*on the occiput and a little lower below the
occiput pure black, then purely white, back and wing glossy greenish black,
rump white, tail ashy ; below entirely white. It is difficult to imagine what
the specific distinction should be between such a bird and, for instance, Gould’s
figure of II. autumnal is, Hasselq. = melunop terns, Tern., in 4 Birds of Europe.’
Gray (Hand-1., Ill, 47) quotes II candidus, Bonn., as synonym of the Eu-
ropean autumnal is, reserving Blyth’s name intermedins for the Indian bird,
but I do not think that the question as to the specific distinctness of the two
can be considered as settled.
As regards size I found in Kachh specimens the following variations :
wing 9 to 97 ; tail 32 to 33, tarsus 4'25 to 53 ; bill 2‘5 to 3 inch.
899. Eecubvibostba avocetta. Not common.
In what appear to be rather young birds the dark upper coloration is
mixed with brown, and the short wing coverts are mostly pale brown.
An adult in full plumage, shot at the beginning of January, measures : wing
9'3, tail 35, tarsus 37, bill in a straight line from front to tip 335, this
254 F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh. [No. 3,
being equal to the length of lower mandible from chin to tip, measured along
the curve.
901. Hydeophasianits sinensis.
I have seen only a few specimens on the larger lakes. The species
breeds in Cashmir.
903. Fuxica atba.
Is generally only seen on the larger lakes. One, rather a largo specimen,
measures : wing 8'6, tail 2'3, tarsus 2 '5, mid toe with claw 3'S, bill to base of
disk T9, from gape 1'5, height of bill at base 0*7. The bird is evidently an
old one, it was one of a pair ; the plumage in the middle of the breast is
conspicuously mixed with white ; the extreme edge of wing is white and the
secondaries albescent.
923. Aedea cineeea. Not common.
There is a great deal of pure black at the sides of the base of neck and
of the anterior breast, extending on either side to the middle of the abdomen,
in other respects the plumage agrees with Jerdon’s description which is of
course that of the winter garb.
926. Heeodias inteemedia, v. Hasselquist, = egeettoides (Tern.).
Very common. Wing 13, tail 475, tarsus 5, mid toe with claw 3 75 ;
bill at front 3'5 inch. Comp. G. It. Gray, Handl. Ill, 28.
927. H. gaezetta.
Rare, and while the former species is usually seen near tanks, the pre-
sent one prefers streams, and appears to be more solitary. Wing 11-25, tail
4-25, tarsus 4-25, mid toe with ckw 3, bill at front 3 '6 5 inch. This speci-
men was shot on 21st February ; it had the occipital crest not fully, but the
dorsal train and lengthened pectoral feathers well developed.
928. Demigeetta sacba, Gmel., — asha, Sykes. Not common.
Comp. G. R. Gray, Handl. Ill, 28.
In a couple of young birds, with brownish ashy plumage and white
on the throat and winglet, the wing is 10 75, tail 3'5, tarsus 3'9, mid toe
with claw 2'8, bill at front 3 5 inch.
929. Btrpmrs coiiomandus. Very common.
Birds shpt on 19th December (i. e. in the middle of the winter months)
had the upper head tinged golden, and a few golden occipital crest feathers
about one inch in length. Wing 975, tail 3 '5 to 3'8, tarsus 3-5, mid toe
with claw 2.75, bill at front 2‘3 to 2’4, the same from gape 3 '2 inch.
930. Aedeola leucopteba. Not common. Wing 9 and tail 3-5 inch.
931. Butoeides javanica. I have only seen, and shot, a solitary
specimen, with the pale triangular spots on all the wing coverts.
937. Nyctiabdea nycjticoeax, L. = Nycticorax griseus.
Is also decidedly rare in Kachh. I have seen only a few specimens
in the plumage of the young, which in general tone is very like that of the
1872.] F. Stoliezka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kuchh. 255
previous species, but without the strong metallic lustre. One measures : wing
barely 11 inches, bill 2'5, the other measurements exactly agree with those
given by Jerdon.
938. Tantalus ueucocephaxus, Very local, and a shy bird.
An apparently old specimen, but with a broad dark brown band (the
feathers in it being, however, tipped white) across the hind breast, shot on
8th February, measures : wing 215, tail 7, (the longer lower tail coverts
being very much lengthened, soft and decomposed) , tarsus 10, mid toe with
claw 5 ’2 ; bill at front 11 inch.
939. Platalea ueucoeodia. Pare.
941. Theeskioenis melanocephalus.
The single specimen seen, and shot in December, has the entire plu-
mage white, merely the lengthened tertials are pale silvery ash towards their
terminal halves. Measurements the same as those given by Jerdon.
942. Geeonticus papillosus. Very common.
The bill of this species is slenderer, but not longer than that of the
last.
944. Phjenicopteeus antiquoeum, Temm.
Comp. Gray in Ibis, 1869, v, p. 441.
I saw only two or three flocks of this species at some large tanks in
the Wagur district, young and old birds associating.
952. Dendeocygna aecuata. Hare.
957. Spatuua cl ape at a. Very common.
There was scarcely a pool of water to be met with without a few
of these birds on it.
9G1. Chaulelasmus steepeeus. Very common.
On the 1st November, I met with six half grown ducks on a small lake
near the village Dhosa. I shot one, but unfortunately did not preserve it.
At the time I had the impression that I shot a young gadwall, and certainly
it could only have been either this species, or Anas boschas which I saw on
the same lake ; but I rather think it was the former. I did not know at the
moment that the breeding of the gadwall had not been recorded in India.
962. Dafila acuta. Common.
964. Queequedula ceecca. Very common.
968. Aythya fertna. Pare.
An apparently young female with the upper plumage as in the old, but
with the whole of the underparts dull white mixed with pale brown, tinged
rufous on chin, neck and breast, and of a somewhat darker hue on the vent,
measures : wing 8, tail 2, tarsus P45, mid toe with claw 2'6, hind toe with
claw 075, bill from gape 2 inch.
969. Aythya nykoca. Pare,
256
F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kaclih. [No. 3,
971. FutjTX* cbistata. Not common.
975. Podiceps minor ? = Philippensis, Bonn. = minor, var. /?., Gm.
Very common.
Wing 4 to 4'25 ; tarsus T3 to 1'4, mid toe with claw 2, bill at front
07 to 0'8, from gape l’l to l-2 inch.
980. L ARC'S (ChbOICOCEPIIAIjTTS) BBTOICEPHALTTB.t
Not common, except along the coast and locally in the Rann. The
respective measurements of two specimens are : wing 12 '3 and 13 '4, tail
4'4 and 4'8 ; tarsus 2 and 2'22 ; mid toe with claw T65 and l-8 ; bill at
front 1-3 and P5 ; from gape 2'2 and 2 6 inch. The iris is chocolate brown,
bill yellowish, black towards tip ; feet yellowish brown. The quills are black;
except towards the base, and beginning with the fourth all have a small
white tip, gradually increasing in extent on the succeeding feathers. Both
specimens, although somewhat small in size, agree perfectly in coloration,
which does not appear to differ from the whiter plumage of this bird, as
usually recorded.
983. Gelichebidon NILOTIC a, Hasselq., = anglica, Mont.
Local, and not common, except on or along the Bann. Average measure-
ments of three birds, with the loreal region blackish, the occiput and top of
head ashy white, and the grey primaries externally tipped darker on both webs :
wing 11'2 to 11-8 ; tail 4 '5 to 4'8 ; tarsus 13 to 1'35 ; mid toe with claw
1T5 ; bill at front P35 to 1'5 inch. Iris, feet and bill entirely black.
984. HrilEOCUELIDON INDICA.
I saw a considerable number of these birds on the tanks in the Bann
islands, Pacham and Kharir, but scarcely any on the tanks in Kachh proper.
Iris and bill in fresh specimens black}: ; feet blackish brown.
1005. Geacbxtjs carbo. Not uncommon on the larger lakes.
1007. Geacbltjs (Micbocabbo) melanognathus, Brandt.
G. R. Gray (Hand!, Ill, 129) gives javanicus of Horsfield as a syno-
nym of the above, but he allows niger, Vieillot, as a distinct species from
‘ S. Asia.’
1008. P LOTUS MEL ANO CLYSTER.
I met with only solitary specimens of both this and the preceding
species.
* FuUx, Sundev., 1835 = Fuligula, Seph., ex parte ; vide G. E. Gray, Hand!,
Ill, 86.
+ Gould has besides this and ridibundus a new species, named Tibetanus.
1 In dried specimens the bill has distinctly a reddish tinge.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — Mammals and Birds inhabiting Kachh.
257
Postscript .
While the preceding pages were passing through the press, I received
from Dr. W. de Tatham at Bhuj a few additional specimens of mammals
and tortoises, of which I had not been able to obtain examples at the tune
of my visit. They are —
Pteroput medius, mentioned at p. 223. The specimen sent agrees in
all essential points of structure and coloration with those from other parts
of India ; it has a total length of about 11*6 inches, which is very nearly
the length of the middle finger ; the ears are 1*2 inch long and only
07 inch broad, while hi other specimens from India the ears generally have a
greater breadth. Most of the Indian specimens also have a considerably
longer middle finger.
JSrinacem pictus, see p. 223. An adult specimen of this species is
65 inches long ; in coloration it exactly agrees with the half grown one
from which my description was taken, except that the lower belly is less
brown, the white extending to nearly within the interfemoral space. In the
younger specimen the dentition is normal, agreeing (according to Owen’s
Comparative Anat. and Phys., Ill, p. 308) with that of E. curopccus, the
formula being i. ~ + c. 777- + p. ^ + ni. — = 3G. The two ante-
rior incisors are very far apart and have the form of canines of Carnivora , the
third on each side is very much larger than the second, which again is con-
siderably smaller in the upper than in the lower jaw. What is considered
as a canine in the upper jaw, is by other Osteologists often accepted as the
first premolar. The true first premolar in the upper jaw is smaller than
the canine, the second premolar is minute, and in the adult specimen it is
altogether absent, it has probably become obsolete ; the last premolar is
tricuspid in upper and bicuspid in lower jaw ; the formula, of the adult
3.3 2*2 3'3
dentition would, therefore, appear to bo ^ ^ + 3^ = 34,
but there is a short space visible between the two premolars in the upper jaw,
while the first premolar is very close to the canine.
Of tortoises Dr. Tatham sent me a specimen of the Testudo, mentioned
in my notice* on the Reptiles of Kachh ; it proved to be T. elegans, Schoef,
as recorded by Gunther, or Peltastes stellatus, (Scliweig.), according to Gray.
(Suppl. to Cat. of Shield Kept., 1870, p. 8).
The Emyda referred to in the same notice is, Dr. Anderson informs me,
* Proceedings for May, p. 72. By an error, I stated that the species, which was
described to me by a native, is like T. Grayi , which specific name should be Leithvi
of Gunther.
258
[No. 3,
F. Day — Notes on Fish from Kachh.
most probably vittata of Peters. He sent a drawing of a middle-aged
specimen to Prof. Peters, wbo says that there is no distinction traceable
between the figure of the Kachh specimen and the type of vittata. The
head, above, is spotted with dark, and the entire carapace is marked with
very numerous irregularly radiating dark streaks. The granulation of the
carapace becomes apparent after the epidermis has (hied up, in fresh specimens
no trace of it is to be seen. Young specimens are rather flat, but in old
ones the convexity of the carapace is very considerable, and the shell is
somewhat depressed along the centre. The species is common both in rivers
and tanks, and is often met with crawling from one pool of water to another ;
I have seen specimens up to a length of 15 inches. One, recently received,
has the carapace 105 inches long, and 7'7 broad across the abdomen ; and
the total height is nearly 3'5 inches. The odd osseous antero-eentral plate
of the sternum is broadly rounded, somewhat narrower in front than behind,
1-3 inch long and l-5 inch broad ; the two posterior plates form a suture,
2’3 inch long, they are perfectly united, as in E. Ceylonensis, which has a
quite similar coloration, and to which vittata is united by Gray in Shield
Kept., 1870, p. 117.
Notes on Pish, collected by De. Stoliczka in Kachh, —
by Surgeon Major P. Day.
[Received 2Gth Juno, read 3rd July, 1872.]
I am indebted to Dr. Stoliczka for the following eighteen species of
fish with their local names, collected by him during his recent tour through
Kachh. They are interesting as extending our knowledge of the localities
to which species spread, and also as first demonstrating the existence of the
Genus Cgpriuodon in the fresh waters of India.
Fam. — GoniiD.L.
1. Oobius giuris, Ham. Duel). Kharba Mah. Tulli, Kachh.
Five specimens up to 6 inches in length.
The inferior pharyngeal bones are each of a triangular shape, the base
being external, whilst the two bones are closely approximated together
along nearly two-thirds of their internal margins.
Fam. — OPHIOCEPHALIDiE.
2. Ophiocephalus punctatus, Bl. Dhor, Kachh ; Dhaka by foreigners.
Fam. — Cypelnodontidj:.
3. Cypkinodon Stoliczkanps, sp. nov.
B. Ill, D. 1/8, P. 17, V. 7, A 2/7, C. 15, L. 1. 27, L. tr. 8. .
Length of head 1/4, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/4, of dorsal and anal
fins 1/3, (in the males), about 1/8 in the females, of the total length. Eyes :
1S72.]
259
F. Day — Notes on Fish from Kachh.
diameter 1/3 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of snout, and 1^
diameters apart. Head thick, snout somewhat obtuse, upper jaw rather
protractile. Teeth in a single row, compressed, tricuspid. Fins : dorsal,
in the males, commences midway between the middle of the eye and the
base of the caudal fin, opposite the ninth scale of the lateral line, whilst in
the females its origin is between the opercle and the base of the caudal, but
still opposite the 9th scale of the lateral line. In the males the dorsal
and anal fins when laid flat reach the base of the caudal ; the anal com-
mences below the last dorsal ray. Caudal lunate, its outer rays being
slightly produced. The ova are exceedingly large, almost equalling the
diameter of the eye, of the same size as in ffaploohilus panchax, H. B.
The length of the intestinal canal equals about three times that of the
abdomen. Colours : male, yellowish green, reticulated with brownish green,
a small black spot on the shoulder behind the opercle ; dorsal fin spotted,
anal more sparingly so ; caudal yellowish with a crescentic black band in its
outer third, and a second less wide (but still broader than the ground colour)
between the outer one and the root of the caudal fin. Female, silvery,
with about nine vertical black bands extending from the back to the abdo-
men. Out of 28 specimens the largest is l'G inches in length ; they were
obtained in a small nearly quite fresh- water stream at the village Joorun,
and also at Lodai, along the edge of the Batin.
4. Haplochilm rubrostigma , Jerdon. I found this species likewise
in the fresh waters of the hills between Sind and Biluchistan.
Fam. Ctpbexidje.
5. Discognathus lamta, Ham. Buch. Maleic, Kachh.
6. Labeo calbasu, Ham. Buch. Dai, Kachh.
Out of five specimens three have D. and in the majority the length
of the head is 1/5 of that of the total length. This fish is found in Sind,
and I have also taken it at Jabalpur in Central India &o.
7. Labeo boggut Sykes. Loi, Kachh.
B III. D. 2/9, P. 17, Y. 9, A. 2/5, L. 1. GO— 65, L. tr. 12J/15.
Length of head 2/11, height of body 2/5 of the total length. Fyes :
diameter 2/9 of length of head, 1| diameters from end of snout and 2 dia.
meters apart. Snout thick and somewhat projecting beyond the lower jaw,
having a small lateral lobe. Interorbital space convex. A small maxillary
but no rostral barbel. Lower lip fimbriated, sometimes having a distinct
inner fold ; pores on the snout in some specimens. Fins : dorsal commence
somewhat in advance of the ventrals, and nearer the end of the snout than
the root of the caudal. Lateral line : eight to nine rows of scales
between it and the base of the ventral fin. Colours : silvery, darkest superi-
orly, occasionally a series of light vertical bands descend along the middle of
the side ; fins orange.
34
2 GO
[No. 3,
F. Day — Notes on Fish from Kachh.
Several specimens up to G inches long from Kachh ; others from Puna
and J abalpur, where it was termed “ Kolees,” as stated by Sykes; and one
specimen in the Calcutta Museum came from Nagpur.
Very probably this species may prove to be identical with Tylognathus
striolatus, Gunther, which is stated to have come from Puna.
8. Cirrldna mrigala, Ham. Buch. Mo’raka, Kachh.
Snout tuberculated ; length of head 1/5 in the total length ; five speci-
mens up to 8 inches in length.
9. Cirrldna lata, Ham. Buch. Tchirri, Kachh.
Several specimens up to 6 inches in length.
10. Cirrldna dero, Ham. Buch.
B. III. D. 3/9, P. 19, V. 9, A. 2/5, C. 19, L. 1. 39, L. tr. 71/7.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5, of dorsal fin 1/6
of total length. Fyes rather high up, diameter 1/5 of length of head, li dia-
meters from end of snout, and 2 diameters apart. Maxillary Uriels minute
and. concealed in the groove. Snout rather overhanging the mouth and
having some open glands across it. Lower jaw the shorter, with a ridge
above the symphysis. Fins: dorsal commences midway between the end
of the snout and the posterior border of the base of the anal fin, its last
ray divided to the root, its upper border very concave, the anterior two
and the last ray being elongated ; pectoral rather shorter than the head, and
not reaching so far as the ventral ; caudal deeply forked, its lobes being of
equal length. Scales: 5 J rows between the lateral line and the base of the
ventral fin. Colours : greyish superiorly as low as the row of scales above
the lateral line, wherefrom it becomes silvery white. Several specimens up
to G inches long. I also obtained two others in Calcutta.
I should have hesitated identifying this fish with Hamilton Buchanan’s
merely from the engraving ; for that shows very long barbels, but is otherwise
correct, even to the relative proportions, but in the text he observes “ at
each corner of the mouth is a minute tendril.
11. Barlus sarana, Ham. Buch. Fopri, Kachh.
12. Barlus ticio, Ham. Buch. Fldari, Kachh. No black spot at the
commencement of the lateral line ; dorsal and anal fins tipped with black.
13. Barlus stigma, Cuv. and Val. Very numerous.
14. Barlus vittaius, Day. Twelve specimens up to 1'5 of an inch in
length. The last undivided dorsal ray is articulated.
15. Nuria danrica, Ham. Buch.
K5. Baslora daniconius, Ham. Buch. Jonir or Goner, Kachh.
17. Chela lacaila, Ham. Buch. Vai matchi, Kachh.
Family. — Silurllue.
18. Macrones carcio, Ham. Buch.
Local, only found in the deep recesses of streams. Another larger species
also occurs, it is probably Macrones aor, H. B.
1872.]
2G1
On the land shells oe Penang island, with descriptions oe the
ANIMALS AND ANATOMICAL NOTES ; 'part first , CyCLOSTOHACEA,
by De. F. Stoliczka.
(Read and received 6th August, 1872).
[With plate X.]
Penang, or Prince of Wales island, although possessing a rich vegeta-
tion, growing on old metamorphic soil, a moderately hilly ground, and a moist
warm climate, — all elements most favorable to Molluscous life, — has up the
present time yielded a comparatively very small number of land shells, and
this in spite of the repeated visits which it had received from numerous
travellers to the East. I can scarcely find record of more than ten species
of both Cyclostomacea and Helicacea, which had been reported to occur on
Penang. The paucity of shells seemed to me scarcely credible ; but, when
visiting the island hi 18G9, I was not a little astonished to meet for days
with nothing else except JBulimua atricallosus and citrinus, and Helix simi-
laris in the low country, cultivated with coco-palms and nutmegs, while in
the hills the only common species were a It o tul a and Cycloph. Malayanus ,
Benson’s Helix Cymatium, described from Lancavi, being much rarer. After
many days wanderings I noticed that all those portions ot the ground,
which at any, even remote, time shewed signs of having been once under
cultivation, were hopeless in a malacological point of view, and I turned
into the more wild and deep ravines of the North- Western pait of the
island. There, after some days search, particularly in the extensive and very
dense forests along the edges of more open tracks, abounding with a rich
under-vegetation, 1 was more successful by adding a good number of land
shells to the few already known. Many of these are new to science, and as
I had obtained all the species alive, and noted the peculiarities of the
structure of the animals, my observations, even as regards the few formerly
described species, may be useful in supplementing the information which we
already possess.
I shall begin in this first part of the paper with the Ctclostomacea,
of which ten species will be reported. My remarks will on this occasion not
enter into anatomical details, because I wish to reserve these for a com-
prehensive study on the anatomy of all the Indian and Burmese species of
this group, and the isolated facts would not prove equally interesting as
when related in connection with others.
In the second part, which will treat of the Helicacea, I will, however,
give all those anatomical details, which are in many instances essential for
the correct determination ol the different genera.
262 F. Stoliczka — On the Cyclostomacca of Penang. [No. 3,
Group.— CYCL O STOMA CM A.
Fain. Crcr.ornoRTD.u. Genus, Cxclophobus, Montf.
Ctclophobiis Mjllatanits. PI. X, Figs. 1-5.
Benson, A. and M. N. H., 2nd ser., vol. x, p. 269. Pfoiffer, Monograph Pneumo-
nopomornm. Bnpph I, p. 42. Reeve, Conch, vol. xiii, Cydophorus, pi. I, fig. 2.
This is a tolerably common species on Penang, being generally distri-
buted from near the seashore to the top of Penang bill, about 2500 feet.
I have given a whole series of illustrations in order to shew the diffe-
rent stages of growth, although Reeve’s figure is a very good representation
of an adult specimen.
Ordinarily the shell is smooth, exhibiting only the usual finer and
stronger striae of growth, hut the pale brown and thin cuticle when well
preserved is spirally striated, the striation being more conspicuous in young-
er shells than in more adult ones.
Young specimens of only two or three volutions have very conspicuous
transversely oblhpie cuticular striae, and in this stage the shell with its
angular last whorl perfectly resembles Pfeiffer's Cyclostoma (Leptopoma)
Birmanum,* which is no doubt either a young of the present species or of
C. Siamensis. Nearly all young Cyclophori have these transverse filiform
striae of the cuticle.
When larger the shell scarcely differs from that of C. Cantori, Benson,
of which figures are given by Pfeiffer in Chemnitz’ Conch. -kab., and also by
Reeve. I have not obtained in Penang any such small specimens with fully
developed lips as are represented in those figures, but I have observed that the
usual difference of the male being often slightly smaller than the female
also exists in the present species, and an illustration of a nearly full
grown male, given in fig. 4, comes very close to that of Reeve. Judging
from the difference observed in the size of the sexes of other species,
as is for instance very often the case in O. Pearsoni, I am inclined
to the opinion that the specimens described as G. Cantori are males
of C. Malay anus, the latter being females. If this were the case, the
former name would have priority over the latter, but even if the expla-
nation of sexes would not in this case hold good, I believe that the form
described as Cantori can scarcely be looked upon as anything else than a
smaller race of Mai ay anus, and vice versd.
The animal is grey, darker on the head, brownish on the tentacles, pale
towards the tip of the rostrum and at the basal edges of the foot.
* Chemnitz’ Conchy lienkabinet, Yol.IX, p. 363, and Mon. Pneum. Suppl. II, p. SB.
1872.] F. Stoliczka — On the Oyclostomacea of Penang. 263
Wliat Hanley figures, in Conch. Indica, pi. xlviii, fig. 4, as C. Malay -
anus from the Shan States, has, I believe, nothing to do with the Penang
shell, though it may represent a variety of Siamensis, or a peculiarly
depressed one of flavilabris, but it is impossible to form a good idea of the
character of the species from the insufficient illustration given.
CxcLOPiiORtrs Bobneensis, var. PI. X, Fig. 6.
Metcalfe, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1851. — Pfeiffer in Chem. Conch., XIV, p. 362 and
Mon. Pnenmon. p. 63, — Martens, Ost.-As. Exped., p. 136. — Reeve, Conch. Vol. xiii,
Cyclnplwrus, pi. xii, fig. 50.
The Penang variety of this species is flatter, somewhat sharper keeled
at the periphery, and with a slightly more expanded lip than exists in any
Bornean specimens I saw, but the general type of the shell is unmistakable.
It is a rare species on Penang hill ; I found during many days search only
two adults* and one young. The former are covered with a rather thick
dark brown cuticle, marked with very fine transversely oblique and also with
spiral striiE, by which a kind of a very minute granulation is produced.
There is a row of larger brown spots along the suture, while the rest of the
whorls is densely variegated with reddish brown, most conspicuous after
a partial removal of the cuticle, and the keel is slightly funieulate. This
coloration is almost exactly like that of O. porphyriticus, as figured by
Pfeiffer in Chemnitz’ Concliilienkabinet.
One of the most important characters of Porneensu is the straight-
ness and slight concavity of the inner portion of the peristome along the
umbilical margin, followed by the basal portion being somewhat produced.
This character also occurs in C. aquila and perdix, with the last of which
Benson’s C. porphyriticus has been considered as identical. E. v. Martens
already observes (l. cit. p. 135) that it is impossible to give a well defined
diagnosis of C. aquila, as the species is very variable and readily passes into
Porneensu and perdix. I have not a sufficient series of authentic specimens
from different localities, but the few from Penang, Singapore and Borneo
entirely support the view expressed by E. von Martens, and make it most
probable that the different names noticed only refer to the principal varieties
of one and the same species. It is unquestionable that even in true Bornean
specimens the upper convexity of the whorls is sometimes greater sometimes
less, the keel on the last whorl sharp, or obtuse, or again almost obsolete,
and in consequence of this the sharp edged last whorl passes into an
obtusely angular or even slightly rounded one, and that with these variations
the height of the entire shell must naturally vary.
I possess Singapore specimens of Porneensis which exactly agree with
C. porphyriticus, as figured by Pfeiffer in Chemnitz, and as this figure is
* The figured specimen is the more depressed one.
264 F. Stoliczka — On the Cyclostomacea of Penang. [No. 3,
authentic, being taken from the type in Benson’s collection, I would not
hesitate to add porpliyriticus as a synonym of Borneensis. Sowerby’s origina
figures of perdix (at least fig. 127 in Tlies. vol. I) and of aquila scarcely differ,
and both very well agree with the form of Borneensis as usually obtained at
Singapore, having the whorls above rather inflated and the periphery very ob-
tusely angular. The same applies to Chemnitz’s figure of aquila, while
that of perdix, after Tenaserim specimens, very closely corresponds with
one of my Penang specimens of Borneensis, except in having a greenish
cuticle. Reeve’s' figure of aquila is probably taken from a specimen obtained
inland north of Singapore ; those specimens are particularly fine and pro-
bably most aberrant from the type shell, which Reeve figured as Borneensis
while his figure of perdix has the whorls as round as Siamensis, and though
it may belong to the same species as represented by Sowerby’s figure 128 m
Thes. vol. I, I do not think that it can at all be referred to the Borneensis
group, because it appears to want the peculiar straightness of the inner
portion of the peristome.
The solution of this question of identity depends now upon a com-
parison of the type-specimens of Sowerby’s G. perdix and aquila with a good
series of typical Borneensis, as represented in Borneo, near Singapore,
Malacca and Penang ; for it will also determine the nomenclature of the
latter species. . , , ,
The animal of the Penang variety of Borneensis is uniform pale brown
with a slight pinkish tinge, and covered with numerous flat greyish warts ;
the foot is rather narrow and very long posteriorly, the lateral basal portion
below the pedal row is warty, not sulcated ; head slightly darker than the
body, tentacles blackish near the tip ; eyes on small bulgings, surrounded by
a pale ring ; mantle greyish, thick near the margin. There is scarcely
a noticeable difference in the size ol the sexes.
The only other species of Cy'clophorus which I have to mention, and which
has been described from Penang, is C. Pfefferi of Reeve. It belongs to the
section of C. tuba with a very much expanded peristome, without any
markedly straight inner, or produced basal portion. E. v. Martens (1. cit.
p. 134) states that it is probably not constantly different from C. tula, but,
setting aside the more inflated whorls of the latter species, I believe, Pfeiffei i
also differs from the last by a much more rapid increase of the volutions.
In this point, as well as in the flattened and angular shape of the whorls,
it, however, quite agrees with expansus, and a large specimen of this last
from Tenaserim scarcely at. all differs from Reeve’s illustration ; I would,
therefore, be inclined to regard Pfeifferi as identical with expansus.
1872.]
2G5
F. Stoliczka — On the Cyclostomacea of Penang.
Genus. OPISTIIOPOKUS, Bens.
There is no apparent distinction between the shells of Opisthoporus and
those of Spiraculum. A cursory examination of the animals of a few species
also shewed, that no essential distinction exists in the general anatomical
structure, and hut a very slight one in the dentition.
The only difference, which as far as known is a constant one, consists
in the structure of the operculum. In the former genus this is discoid,
horny on the inner side, calcareous on the outer, and composed of spiral
lamin® entirely covering a tube. In Spiraculum the upper spiral layer is
also generally calcareous, and more or less elevated, but the spiral canal
is always open, not forming a closed tube. The former structure of the
operculum is peculiar to Gyclotus, the latter to Pterocyclus and some species
of Oyclophorus.
OrisTiioPonrs Pestaitgensis, n. sp. PI. X, Fig. 7.
O. testa sub-discoidea, apice paulum exserta, latiuscule umbilicata, corneo
solidula ; anfractibus 4'5 ad 5, teretibus, sutur a profunda junclis, epidermide
brunnea vel nigrescente, transversvm confertissime striata, in ultimo an-
fractu ad peripheriam superam et inf cram breviter ciliata, indutis, sub epi-
dermidem albescentibus atque strigis transfer sis, brunneis vel fuscis, paulo
undulatis, aut plus minusve acute angulatis, notatis ; apice sub-mammillato,
nigrescente vel 'pall lido ; umbilico modico,fere dimidium Jatitudinis anfractus
penultimi exponente ; ultimo anfractu ad aperturam valde descendente, sed
baud dissoluto, ad suturam tubalodjrcvi tenuique, secpissime retrorsum curvato,
rare fere verticali, rarissimeque antice versus directo, in specimmibus adultis
circa 15 ad 2 mm. a margins aperturali distante, instructo ; apertura cir-
culari, ampla, obligua, peristomate in junioribus simplici,in adultis breviter
bilabiato, margins lahii interni paululum incrassato, gape rubcscente tincto,
baud distincter discreto, externo expansiusculo ; ambobus supra paulum pro-
ducts atque prope suturam modice inslnmtis. Operculum discoideum,
interne fix, externe dislinctc, concavum et album, multispiratum, medio
corneo-testaceum, laminis duabus separate ad peripheriam acutissimis.
Diam. maj. 11'5 ; diam. min. 9'5 S altit. testa G’G ; diam. apert. int. 4,
extern <e cum perist. 4'7 m.m.
This species is evidently closely allied to E. v. Martens’ O. Sumatra-
nus* which is of nearly exactly the same size, hut its whorls are decidedly
thinner and on the upper side more flattened, the upper apertural margins are
considerably more produced, the plaiu of the aperture being, therefore, more
oblique to the axis, while the sutural tube appears to he more distant from
the margin. The direction of the tube was observed in four specimens of
O. Sumatranus to he nearly vertical, while in about eighty specimens of the
* Preuss. Expect naeh Ost-Asien., Zool. Theil, vol. II, p. 112.
[No. 3,
2GG F. Stoliczka — On the Cyclostomacea of Penang.
Penang form it is directed backwards, being sometimes when well preseved
perfectly parallel to tbe suture ; in a few specimens, however, it is nearly
vertical, and in two or three even slightly directed forward. The character
is, therefore, evidently variable. Young shells, sometimes measuring up to
9 mm. in the longer diameter, still have no sutural tube developed, while
others (mostly males) roach the adult stage already at even a somewhat
smaller size.
Ilab. I found the species common under dead leaves on the ground
along the base of the Penang hill, mostly in dense jungle.
Animal stout, blackish, sometimes mottle with grey and tinged with
pink, nearly smooth, with few little warts, paler at the sides and at the end
of the foot which is, when fully extended, about twice the longer diameter of
the shell ; it is pointed at the end ; operculigerous lohe slightly more
thickened in front than behind ; tentacles paler at base, blackish on terminal
half, slightly thickened towards the end, but pointed terminally ; eyes small,
on laterally slightly prominent bulgings, united to the base of the tentacles ;
rostrum wrinkled, cleft in front, and with pale lips ; penis of male long,
thin and black, without any appendage.
OpiSTHOPomrs solutus, n. sp. PI. X, Figs. 8-10. •
O. testa planorbulari, apice paulo exserta, late wmbilicata, corneo soli-
dula ; anfractilus 4'5, fere teretibus, supra et infra paululum depress-
imculis, suturn profunda acsimplici junctis, in spec, junioribus ad peripheri-
ani suh-angulatis ; ultimo ad lerminationcm dissolulo, paulo expansiusculo
modiceque deflexo, tubulo suturali antice directo, drciter 2 m.m. a margine
aperturali distanle, instructo ; anfraclibus superioribus epidermide fusco-
olivacea, transversim rugata, in ultimo fere simpliciter confertimque striolata,
indutis, omnibus sub epidermidem albidis, sparse scrobiculatis, transverse
minutissime striatis ; apice albido ; umbilico magno, anfractuum omnium
maxvmam partem exhibente ; apertura lata , circulari, peristomate duplici,
inferno tenui, paulum proficients, externo undigue rnodice dilatato, in facie
antica concaviuscalo cl concentrice striato, in regione supra-suturali sensim
producto ; atnlobus ad suturam anguste emarginatis. Operculum normale,
in utroque latere vix concavum, multispiratum, medio corneo-solidum.
Piam. maj. 15’5 ; diam. min. 11'5 ; alt. testae 7'3 ; diam. apert. int. 4'3,
ext. cum per ist . 5'5 m.m.
Young shells of this species (comp. fig. 8) are regularly planorbular,
with a simple, continuous, thin lip of the aperture, and the olivaceous
epidermis is rather coarsely rugose, forming darker transverse bands ; under
the lens also a very fine spiral striation is to be observed. In the 'middle
stage (fig. 9), when the shells possess 3'5 to 4 whorls, and a diameter of 10
to 13 m.m., the margin of the aperture has a short, open, sutural canal,
1872.] F. Stoliozka — On the Cyclostomacea of Penang. 267
exactly as in the South Indian Pteroc. (My xo stoma) tristts, Blf., and which
canal is the origin of the sutural tube, becoming fully developed in the
more adult shell, as soon as the end of the last whorl begins to detach itself
from the previous one.
Sab. Penang ; I have only obtained about 15 specimens of this species,
also under dead leaves on the ground in dense jungle together with the last,
which is, however, the more common one.
The animal is entirely of a rather pale grey colour, nearly smooth, slight-
ly mottled with darker ; tentacles blackish, with a few darker spots about
and between their bases, entirely black at tip ; rostrum cleft, wrinkled, with a
pale lip ; lateral pedal row rather indistinct, as also in the preceding species.
Pam. PuriNiDiE.
Paphaulus Zoraini, which was described by Pfeiffer from Penang out
of Cuming’s collection, was not met with by me.
PuPINA ATJEEOLA, n. sp. PI. X, Figs. 11-12
Pm testa oblique ovata, apicc breviter sub-acuta, glaberrima, politissima,
moderate solida, intense vel luteole succinea, prope peristoma aurea ; an-
fractibus sex, convexiusculis, in adultis sutura indistinct a junctis, primis
duobus sub-mammillatis, ultimo spira breviore, valde descendente ; apertura
parva, circulari, labio inerassato, sulco satis prof undo ah anf penultimo
separato ; incisionibus angustis sed prof midis ; labro antics sensim producto,
extus paulum inerassato, aureo tincto. Operculum orbiculare, album, corneum,
ad utrumque latus paulo coneavum, ex lamella sprialiter torla tenuissima
compositum, nucleo depresse circulari, paullulum inerassato instructum.
Long, testw 8'8, lat. ad medium 5, diam. apert. ext. 2 3 m.m.
Hab. Penang ; haud f requeue.
This species is closely allied to P. aurea. Hinds, differing from it by a
smaller aperture, a more laterally produced, shorter and slightly contracted
last whorl. The solidity of the shell and the intensity of coloration naturally
varies with age ; young specimens are thin, and nearly transparent, pale
straw-coloured, the suture is distinctly impressed and the outer lip very
slightly produced. In adolescent specimens the upper labial rib is rather
distant from the posterior anglo of the mouth (see fig 11), as in the
Tenaserim P. arula, hut the Penang shell is shorter and stouter. Old
specimens are entirely covered with a polished glaze, and are intensely or
yellowish rufous brown, with a yellow inner and outer peristome.
The animal is of the usual Cyclophorid type, uniform, intense or greyish
black, paler along the sides of the foot, which is of about the same length
as that of the shell.
35
268 F. Stoliczka — On the Cyclostomacea of Penang. [No. 3,
Megalomastoma sectilabbttm, Gould. PI. X, Fig. 13.
Penang specimens agree with those from Tavoy in having a smaller
aperture and a slightly slenderer spire, with somewhat convex sides, while in
M. anostoma from Borneo the spire is more regularly conical and the aper-
ture larger.
Animal blackish grey with a slight ‘reddish tinge ; the edges of the
foot, including the posterior end and the tentacles are vermilion, tips of
rostrum pale grey. The length of the foot equals about three fourth of
that of the shell when the animal moves about ; the entire body is rather
distinctly warty, but no well defined pedal row exists ; the rostrum is
adpressed to the foot, strongly wrinkled and cleft at the end ; posterior
end of foot obtusely pointed, eyes small, the bulgings united at their bases
to the tentacles. The mantle is pale, entire, closely attached to the
peristome of the shell, and not protruding beyond it.
Operculum horny, circular, composed of several spiral layers arranged
round a slightly thickened or mammillated centre so that the width of each
lamina equals the radius of the whole operculum. This structure is some-
what peculiar, it agrees with that of the South Indian Cataulus recurvatus,
but not with that of the other Oatauli or Megalostomata examine# ; in all
these the operculum is distinctly multispiral.
The species occurs at elevations from 400 to about 2400 feet on the
Penang hill, but it is evidently a very scarce shell ; I found only one live
specimen at the top of the hill.
Pam. — DiraoHMATnaDJE. Sub-fam. Aivc^rra.
Alycjetts gibbosities, n. sp. PI. X, Fig. 14.
A. testa gibboso turrita, anguste umbilioata, violaceo rubente, ultimo an-
fractu pallidiore, lutescente, apice albescente ; anfractibus quinque, valde
convexis, sutura profunda et simpliei junctis ; primo Icevigato, tribus sequen-
tibus transversim densissime striato-costellatis atque spiraliter striatis,
ultimo gibbose injlato, paulo distinctius costellato, prope aperturam breviter
sed valde constricto, sub-lcevigato, vix dejlexo , post constrictionem tubulo
tenui, circiter duo ad tres m.m. longo, nonnunquam fere immerso, instructo ;
apertura circulari, modice lata , in adolescentibus margine simpliei undique
expansiusculo circumdata, in adultis bilabiata, labio interna extus tubuli-
forme producto, crassiusculo, externo dilatalo atque tenui. Operculum
solidum, latere inferno corneo, convexiusculo, medio submammillato, multi-
spirato, impressione musculari transverse ovata atque excentrica instructo,
externo calcareo, concavimeulo, in superficie irregulariter rugoso. Diam.
maj. 9 '2, diam. min. 7, alt. testes 9'6 ; diam. apert. int. 3'S, externa - 4'8 m.m.
In general character this interesting new species closely resembles the
type of the genus, Al. gibbus, F6\, but the latter conspicuously differs by
1872.] F. Stoliczka — On the Cyclostomacea of Penang. 269
having the constricted portion of the last whorl much more produced and
very, much deflected, the height of the shell being also considerably les3 than
the larger diameter of the shell. Eydoux who collected the species at
Touranne in Cochin-China, says in his original description,* that the
operculum is membranaceous and not multispiral.
The species is not uncommon along the base of the hills in thick jun-
gle, under and on large blocks of rocks, generally between half decomposed
vegetable matter.
The animal is dusky grey, foot pale; tentacles long, pale at the base,
further on dark, especially at the tips which are slightly thickened ; eyes
small, placed laterally at the bases of the tentacles, hut the bulgings are
not distinct ; rostrum long, cleft at the end, reddish at the base on account
of the fleshy colour of the manducatory apparatus.
Pam. — Lagocheilida:.
Genus. Lagocheilus, Theobald.
Comp. Blanford in Ann. and Mag. N. H., third Ser., 1864, vol. XIII, p. 452.
Shell conoid sub-turbinate and perforated, thin, covered with a horny
cuticle ■ aperture round with a narrow incision in the upper or posterior
angle ; operculum thin, horny, multispiral. A.nimal of the usual Cyclopho-
rid type, hut with a glandular slit at the upper posterior end of the foot.
The shell of Lagocheilus, when the cuticle is removed, merely differs
from Leptopoma by the slight incision in the posterior angle of the aper-
ture. When Mr. Theobald suggested the above name, it could scarcely
have been anticipated that such a comparatively insignificant character will
be accompanied by a most important structural distinction iu the anatomy of
the animal. Mr. Blanford, already many years past, noticed that the animal
of the Barmese Lagocheilus leporinus f has the peculiarity of possessing a
groove down the middle of the upper caudal portion of the foot. Since then
I had observed the animals of L. tomotrema, of two new species from Penang,
and of two other species from the Nieobars, and I find that all the
animals posses a long glandular slit at the upper end of the foot, and
that the incision in the apertural margin is the result of the presence of
this pedal slit. This instance is an excellent illustration of the occasional
intimate structure and the relation of the animal to its shell.
Lagocheilus, together with Lermatocera, has evidently among the Cyclo-
stomacea the same systematic position, as the Zonitidje have among the
Helicacea. The external character of the animal of Lagocheilus is accom-
panied by some peculiarities in the dentition and in the internal organs with
which I hope to deal at some future occasion, in connection with a general
account of the anatomy of the Indian Cyclostomacea.
• GuiSrin-Meneville’s Magasin do Zoologio, for 1838.
f Journal A. S. B, for 1865, PI. II. p. 82.
270 F. Stoliczka — On the Cyclostomacea of Penang. [No. 3,
The species which are at present known to belong to the genus
are : L. tamotrcma, Bens., (Sikkim, Assam and Cachar), leporinus, Blf.,
(Barma), trochoides and striolatus from Penang, Wiillersdor/i, Pfr. and
Zel., and another as yet undescribed species also from the Nicohars ; scis-
simargo, Bens., from Tenaserim. These localities indicate the geographical
extent of the genus. Reeve in his Monograph of Cyclophorus, when
speaking of L. scissimargo, says that there is more or less an indication of
a notch in the aperture of C. triliratus, Pfr. (= quadrifilosus, Bens.,) while
Pfeiffer in his second Supplement to the Pneumonopoma (p. 29) refers the
latter species to Cyclotus.
Lagocheiltjs teochoides, n. sp. PI. N, Fig. 15.
L. testa turrito conica, sub-anguste umbilieata ; anfractibus sex, sutura
profunda smplici junct is, primis duobv.s conevxis, ceteris supra medium an-
gulatis, ultimo bi-angulato ; omnibus cuticula opaco-fusca indutis, transver-
sim striolatis, spiraliter striatis, striisfilformibus : duabus in anfractu penul-
timo supra angulmn subdist antibus, infra angulum 4-5 approximatis ; in an-
fractu ultimo angulis duobus ad intervalla breviter ciliatis ; basi in adultis
prope peripheriam et ad umbilieum, in junioribus omnino, confcrtim striata ;
testa sub cuticulam albida, ad apieetn rubescente ; apertura rotundata* modice
obliqua, in angulo superiore velpostico distinele ineisa, bilabiata : labio interno
breviore, violaceo tinclo, externo fere plane expansiusculo, in facie concentrice
striolato, ad marginem exteriorem atrato. Operculum multispiratum, tenue,
corneum. Bum. maj. 10, diam. min. 8, alt. testae 9 '6, diam. apert. int. 4-2,
externce 5 m.m.
This is the largest species as yet known of the genus, the more regu-
larly conical form, angular whorls, numerous spiral strise, absence of brown
spots on the shell, etc., readily separate it from L. scissimargo. The fine
transverse striolation of the cuticle is very easily worn off, but the spiral
striation is always very distinct, and well marked even after the removal of
the cuticle. Young shells have a striking resemblance to those of Cremno-
conchus Syhadrensis ; they are comparatively more largely umbilicated than
adult ones, and their cuticle is more or less distinctly olive, while in the
latter it is dark brown in fresh specimens, often becoming reddish brown in
dried ones.
Sab. Penang. I found the species on large stones between decaying
vegetable matter at an elevation of from 200 to about 1000 feet ; it is scarce.
The animal is pale grey, the body itself being slightly darker than the
foot ; the rostrum is long, deeply cleft in front, reddish at the base ; tentacles
long, and thin, dark grey, blackish towards the tips ; eyes on their outer base
on indistinct bulgings ; a dark pedal row, moderately swollen, extends from the
lower base of the rostrum to behind the operculum, from which a deep, narrow
glandular slit proceeds along the middle to the end of the foot.
271
1872.] F. Stoliczka — On tie Oyclostomacea of Penang.
LAOOCITF.rTXS sxmoLATrs, n. sp. PI. X, Fig. 1G.
L. testa turrito conoidea, anguste wmbilicata ; anfractibus 5'5 con-
vexis, sutura simplici junctis, ultimo ad peripleriam inferiorem vix-
angulato ; apice Ixvigato , olivaceo ; anf. ceteris cuticula fusca vel brun-
nea indutis, transversim oblique subdistanter, ct spiraliter densissime, strio-
latis ; Iasi sub-hcvigata vel sub-obsolete spiraliter striatula ; apertura ampla,
sub-circulari, peristomate postice ad angulum prof unde inciso, infra ad latus
basale conspieuiter producto, bilabiato, labio interno in junioribus violaeeo, in
adultis ad marginem albido, externo undigue fere cegualiter planegue dilatato,
corneo. Operculum tenue, corneum, multispiratum. IJiam. mqj. 6, diam.
min. 5, alt. testce G'G ; diam. apert. int. 2-G, ext. 3'2 m. m.
This smaller form resembles L. tomotrema ancl leporinus, but it is
distinguished from both by a slightly larger spiral angle, rounded (not
angulated) whorls, and by the very dense, filiform, spiral striation.
Hob. Penang. Under dead leaves on the ground along the base of the
hills, together with the last species ; rare.
Animal leaden grey, with moderately elongated, darker, cylindrical ten-
tacles ; eyes on minute bulgings, joined on the inner side to the base of the
tentacles ; upper posterior part of the foot with a narrow glandular slit, ex-
tending from the operculigerous lobe to the end ; lateral pedal row very
thin.
JOURNAL
OF THE
ASIATIC SOCIETY.
— • —
Part II.— PHYSICAL SCIENCE.
No. IV.— 1872.
Notes on a collection or Birds made in the Andaman Islands by
Assistant Surgeon (I. E. Dobson, M. B., during the months oe
April and May, — by Y. Ball, Esq., B. A.
[Bead 6th, roceived 16th August, 1872.]
A short time ago Dr. Anderson placed in my hands for determination
a collection of birds, made in the Andamans by Dr. Dobson,* subsequently
adding two received from Mr. Homfray.
The collection contains 184 specimens belonging to sixty-two species, of
which eighteen are new to the hitherto recorded avifauna of those Islands ;
but they are for the most part migratory birds (Qralla), whose occurrence
might safely have been predicated from their being known from the coasts
on both sides of the Bay of Bengal, and to some extent from Malayana.
One species only is described in the following list as new, but there are
four others presenting certain peculiarities which may hereafter justify
their separation from the species under which they are now enumerated.
As these are represented by single specimens, I think it undesirable to
exaggerate the importance of what may ultimately prove to be only individual
variations from the type. The species are : EplnaUes spilocephalus, Blyth ? ;
Balteomis Alexandri, Linn. ; Brachypodius melanocephalus, Gmel. ; Ballus
striatus, Linn. One result of the examination ot this collection has been that
while it supports Col. Ty tier’s views as to the distinctness of certain Anda-
* Mr. Wood-Mason and Dr. Dobson visited the Andaman Islands to collect for
the Indian Museum. The vertebrate portion of the collection was under Dr. Dobson’s
care.
84
274
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
[No. 4,
man species, it furnishes almost conclusive evidence against others being so.
Mr. Blyth has already pointed out that Spilornis Biff ini, Tytler = 8. bacha,
Bodd. ; Collocalia qffinis, Tytler = C. Linchi, Horsf. ; Palwornis qffinis,
Tytler = 9 P. erythrogenys, Blyth, and Herodias Andamnensis, Tytler
= II. concolor, Blyth.
In so far as the present collection afforded material, I have endeavoured
to give full descriptions of those species which have hitherto only been
partially described, and to amplify the information regarding others.
According to the present state of our knowledge, the avifauna of the
Andamans includes 109 species ; possibly this number may have to be
reduced by four.* But it is made up in this way. The late Capt. Beavan’s
list gives 94 species from which three, viz. — Hcematornis Cheela, Bodd.,
Palceornis qffinis, Tytler, and Pericrocotus Andamanensis, Tytler, must, I
think, be subtracted, and 18, the number of additional species in the present
collection, added, or 18 + 94 — 3 = 109. It should be stated, however,
that five of the species mentioned by Capt. Beavan were introduced into the
Islands by Col. Tytler. The number of indigenous birds should therefore
stand at 100 4- 4 ? Of this number twelve are local species and six ? are
known only from the Andamans and Nicobars.
In the Nicobars there are about fifty-three species known at present, of
which number seven are local.
Excepting the migratory birds, particularly the Grallce, from our con-
sideration, the hulk of the non-local species in the Andamans are Indian,
and in the Nicobars Malayan.
Where there are two allied species, or two races or varieties of a species
in India, the Andaman, as a general rule, corresponds with the southern
form. To this rule there is an exception in the case of Graucalus Macei
which is the northern species, G. Layardi being the southern. However,
the Andaman bird seems to be intermediate between G. Macei and Javensis
from Java which two, according to Blyth, only differ in size.
Judging from the number of species of birds known to occur in the
several groups of islands in the Malayan Archipelago we may feel confident
that much yet remains to be done both in the Andamans and Nicobars,
before a list approaching completeness can be prepared.
The present, and to a certain extent, all previous collections were made
in the vicinity of Port Blair, throughout an area, probably not exceeding
30 or 35 square miles, or by a rough estimate about one-hundredth part of
the total area occupied by these islands.
* Tlie species of Nectarinia, JEgialitis, Herodias and Querq'uedula of Col. Tytler’s
and Capt. Beavan’s fists may possibly be only the same species as four birds which
are given under other names in my fist.
Y. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
275
1872.]
Several families and genera, which all analogy would lead us to believe
must find a place in the Andaman avifauna, are as yet unrepresented in any
of the collections of which descriptions have been published.
The following is a list of the purely local speoies which are not known
to occur elsewhere :
Spizatus Andamanensis , Tytler.
Muelleripicus Hodgii, Blytli.
Centropus And/imcmensis, Tytler.
Graucalws Dolsoni, n. sp.
Dicrut'us Andmnaniensisy Tytler.
Dissemurus ajfinis, Tytler.
Myiagra Tytleri, Beav.
Oreocincla infra~marginata, Blyth.
Oriolus Andamanensis f Tytler.
Kittadncla albiventris , Blytli.
Dendrodtta Bay lei , Tytler.
Temenuchus Andamanensis , Tytler.
Ewryzona Ctmningi , Tytler.
The species found in the Andamans and Nicobars, but not elsewhere,
are :
? Ninons affinis, Tytler.*
Palteomis erythrogenys, Blyth.
Oeocichla innotata, Blyth.
Pulabes Andamanensis, Tytler.
Treron chloroptera, Blyth.
Macropygia mfipennis, Blyth.
In the following enumeration and description a dagger (thus f) pre-
fixed, indicates that the species has not been previously recorded from the
Andamans.
Fam. Aquilina.
1. Spixobnis bacha, Daud. H. lido, Horsf. No. 87 of Blyth’s Cata-
logue, (S', spilogaster. Blyth Hcematornis Elgini, Tytler.
H. Elgini, Tytler, is considered to be identical with H. lacha by Mr.
Gurney, and both Mr. Blyth and Dr. Jerdon confirm this opinion (Ibis,
N. S. IV. 1868, p. 131 and 3rd Series, 1871, Vol. I, p. 335). Dr. Jerdon
writes : “ It appears fully agreed on by all that the small Serpent Eagle
of Ceylon and Southern India is the same as the Andaman bird.”
In my previous paper, from not having seen Mr. Blyth’s remarks, I en-
tered my specimens as Gheela, as they had the wing longer than in Tytler’s
Elgini. In the present collection, which contains five specimens in various
stages of plumage, all belong to the small species. The variations in
plumage correspond with those observable in the different stages of Gheela,
* I am rather inclined to Believe that this bird will prove to be the same as
Temminck’s Strix hirsuta which Pelzeln records from the Nicobars.
276
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
[No. 4.
I could not see any constant characters which would serve to distinguish
the two species other than that of size. Measurements of a male in inches :
wing 14-2 ; tail 9’2 ; bill to gape 1'8 ; tarsus 3 4.
2. Halijetus ef.ucogastf.k, Gmel.
Three specimens in various stages of plumage. Length of wing of
adult 208 inches.
Fam. Strt.gt'die.
3. E PFITAT.TES SPILOCEPItALUS, Blyth. (?)
So far as it is possible to make out one of these difficult birds without
a good series for comparison, the specimen of Andaman scops before me
appears to correspond most nearly with Blyth’s description of E. spilocepha-
lus ( ■= 8. Malayanus, Hay ?) J. A. S. B. XV. p. 8, and with a specimen
of that species from Masuri in the old collection, No. 147, I, of Blyth’s Cat.
Mr. Hume only doubtfully refers spilocephalm, Blyth, to gymnopodus,
Gray, so that for the present I think it safer to give Blyth’s name. The
bird certainly belongs to the pennatus type as distinguished by Mr. Hume,
though Col. Tytler records E. Lempiyi from the Andamans.
Authorities are so divided as to the nomenclature to be adopted in
reference to this genus, that without attempting to discuss the question as
to what species spilocephalm should be finally referred to, I shall confine
myself to shewing the points of resemblance between the Andaman bird and
spilocephalm, Blyth, by the description of the former which is as follows :
Above. Rufous inclining to bay, each feather of the head, back of neck,
scapulars, wing coverts, back and rump with two fawn colored spots edged
with black. Primaries — first two not grown, fourth and fifth equal, five
white spots on the outer webs. Tail rufous brown, darker on the inner webs
of the rectrices, with four white bands.
Beneath. Facial disk fawn colour. Loral bristles black, white towards
the base. Breast and abdomen finely mottled with brown and fawn or dusky
white, each feather with two brownish black spots which are separated by a
white bar. Tarsi covered for three-fourths of their length with short rufous
colored feathers, barred with brown. Feet and claws not quite so slender as
in the Masuri specimen.
Measurement in inches : wing 5P6 ; tail 3 ; tarsus 1.
Fam. Hieundinim.
4. Coi/localia Ldvchi, Horsf. Hirundo fuciphaga, Thun.
Trans. Linn. Soc. XIII, p. 143, 0. Linclvi et C. fuciphaga, Wallace, P. Z. S. 1863,
p. 384. 0. affinis, Tytler ?
The present collection contains three specimens of Collocalia which
appear to have been taken from the nest as the primaries are not fully grown.
Y. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
277
1872.]
They correspond in length of body and coloration with specimens of C.
fuciphaga from Batavia and the Nieobars (Blytb’s Cat. No. 429). They
appear also to be the same species as that figured as G. Linchi in 1 Reise
der Novara,’ Vogel, T. II, f. 2, save that the metallic lustre as represented
is far too brilliant. The following is a description of our specimens.
Above. Black with dark green reflections, an indistinct white band on
the rump, no spots on the tail. Underneath. A white rictal spot ; from
chin to breast cinereous, the edges of the feathers lighter, thence to vent
greyish-white, feathers centered cinereous ; under tail-coverts centered
greenish-black. Length to end of tail 3’3, wing 2 95, tail 1’1 inches.
Col. Tytler’s specimens from the Andamans, which he described as
C. a finis, had the following dimensions : —
Bam. Meeopidje.
6. Mebops QTJumcoLOE, Yieil.
The collection contains six specimens of this bird.
Bam. Coeaciadj3.
f 6. Etjeystomtjs obtentalis, Linn.
Three specimens. Is said to be common, but has not been previously
recorded from the Andamans.
Bam. AiCEDrarDiE.
7. Alcedo Asiatica, Swains. (A. meningting, Horsf.) Two specimens.
8. Pelaegopsis Burmanica, Sharpe. Halcyon Gurial, Pearson.
In this list I follow Mr. Sharpe’s classification and geographical
distribution of the five races of Halcyon leucocephalus, at the same time I
feel strongly inclined to believe that a critical examination of the whole
series at present in the Indian Museum will shew that it cannot stand in
its integrity.
Our present specimen closely resembles some of the duller plumaged in-
dividuals of H. Gurial from Bengal, and also agrees to a certain extent
with Sharpe’s description of Burinctnica , but differs from the figure given
of that race in the following particulars : the feathers of the head and nape
are much more albescent, the ochreous collar is broader and the blue of the
wings and tail has no tinge of greenish. Length 13’2 ; wing 6, tail 4'4, bill
at front 3, tarsus 6 inches.
9. II AM! VON Coeomanoa, Lath. Two specimens.
278 V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds. [No. 4,
10. Halcyon Smybnensis, Linn.
This resembles specimens from Southern India and Ceylon in the bril-
liancy of the coloration. Length 10\8, wing 5, bill at front 2 4 inches.
11. Halcyon chlobis, Bodd. Sharpe, Monograph of Alcedinidce,
p. 229. Todiramphus collaris, Scop.
The collection contains several specimens of this bird which is said to
be one of the commonest on the Islands.'
Bam. Psittacidje.
12. Paljeoenis Alexandbi, Linn. ?
While aware of the considerable amount of variation which Palceornis
Alexandri is subject to, I should be disposed to claim for the Andaman bird
now before me a position as a distinct species, were I able to affirm that the
characters which it exhibits are constant ; but on this point I have no in-
formation at present. The specimen, a male, at once attracted notice by
the enormous size of its bill ; and on closer examination and comparison
with a good series of Indian specimens, I found that it possesses other
characters which distinguish it from the Indian bird of normal, plumage.
The black stripe from the lower mandible to the demicollar of peach-
rose, so marked in ordinary specimens, is in this reduced to a narrow line
which commences half an inch from the mandible and terminates at the first
point of contact with the peach-rose, not being continued as a border to it,
as it commonly is for three-fourths of an inch or so in Indian specimens.
The head and cheeks, down to the collar, are of a vivid emerald green
without a trace of the purplish grey or hoary bloom which is present in
all Indian birds which I have examined. The dark red spot on the
shoulders is smaller than usual ? and the blue of the central tail feathers
of a much more decided hue. The wing is somewhat shorter than in any of
the Indian specimens with which I have compared it.
Dimensions of bill. Gape to point. Width at gape.
A. B. A. B.
Up. mandible 115 inch. 115 inch. -95 inch. 85 inch.
Lr. mandible, -75 „ '65 „ -9 „ -8 „
Depth of both mandibles dosed A. V7, B. 15.
A is the Andaman bird, B a specimen of ordinary dimensions from
the Rajmahal Hills. Should all the Andaman birds prove to have the
above characters I would propose the name P. fnagnirostris for the
species.
It the characters be constant, they are as sufficient to distinguish the
two races as are those which distinguish the two races of P. rosa. I may
perhaps mention that in looking through a drawer full of these latter, I found
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
279
1872.]
that Cachar and Darjiling (? Terai) specimens agreed with Barmese in
having the under wing coverts green, &c.
13. PaMOENTS EHYTHBOOENYS, Blyth.
J. A. S. B., XV, 1846, p. 23, and XXVII, 1856, p. 81. P. Nicolaricus, Gould,
P. Z. S. p. 555. B. of Asia, 1857, Pt. IX.
Mr. Blyth (Ibis, IV, 1868, p. 132,) has pointed out that although the
name erythrogenys has been applied to three species of this genus, in the
case of two it is reduced to the rank of a synonym, and therefore his name
is entitled to stand.
In my former paper I agreed with Blyth in considering Tytler’s P .
qffinis to be only the female of this species. If it be not, then we might ask
what is the female like ? neither the present nor any previous collection con-
tains any specimen of the red-billed birds which do not correspond exactly
with authentic males.
There is one point about the female not noticed by Blyth, the mous-
tache is deep green, not black as in the males.
Measurements in inches.
Length. Wing. Bill from gape. Tarsus.
$ 14- 68 '85 '55
5 10-7 6'8 '76 '55
t 14. Paiaeobnis Javaiiices, Osheck.
Blyth writes “ P. Javanicws differs only from P. Yibrisca, in the Javan
bird having a red lower mandible, while the other has a black one ; but in
some Javan specimens the lower mandible is blackish and Mr. Gould has a
specimen from Siam with a red under mandible ; the Hainan birds have it
black.” Finscli in his Monograph ‘ die Papageien' includes both under P.
Lathami, Fiusch.
The specimen in the present collection, a male, has the under mandible
black. Length 13 ; wing 6 8 ; tail 7 '8 ; tarsus '6 inches.
15. Loiticur/cs Vf.hnalis, Sparrm.
Identical with Indian specimens, wing 3'5 inches.
Pam. Pieros.
16. Meellebipices Hodgii, Blyth.
The collection contains a good series of this bird which appears to be
common. The measurements of one are somewhat different from those of
my own specimen (J. A. S. B., XXXIX, p. 241) : wing 6 8 ; tail 6 2 ; bill at
front l-6 ; tarsus 1'2 inches.
17. Piers Andamanensis, Blyth.
Blyth distinguishes this bird from P. pcctoralis by its having three
pair of distinct white spots on the middle rectrices, while P. pectorcilis has
four. “But the Andaman bird is specially characterized by the large
280 V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds. [No. 4,
round black spots upon its breast, each margined with whitish ; the ear
coverts also are longitudinally more conspicuously rayed than in the others.
In other respects this bird resembles P. macei.”
The present collection which contains five specimens shews that the
number of spots on the middle tail feathers is not a constant. In three (2
S and 12) there are four pairs of spots and in the remaining two (1 £
and 12) there are only three.
2 Length 625 ; wing 3'87 ; tail 225 ; tarsus '75 inches.
Mr. Blyth has seen this bird in a collection from Sumatra.
Fc.m. CucTTim*.
t 18. Cucm.us micboptebtjs, Gould.
One specimen. This bird has not been previously brought from the
Andamans.
19. Centbopus Andamanensis, Tytler. Ibis, N. S. Ill, 1867, p. 321.
The collection contains four specimens. Head, neck to middle of back,
chin, throat and breast rufous grey. Abdomen, thigh-coverts and under
tail coverts the same with an ashy tinge. Back, rump and upper tail-
coverts ashy. Wings and scapulars rufous bay. Tail brown, paling from
the centre to the margins of the feathers. Bill black. Length 17 to 18 ;
wing 7’5 ; bill at gape 17 ; tarsus L9 inches.
Fam. NiiCTAiiiNrn.E.
t 20. Abachtteohthea ebenata, Mull. ?
The specimens of Arachnechthra hitherto received from the Andamans
have been identified as pectoralis, and following suit in my previous paper
on Andaman birds I stated that species to be “ common on Mount Harriet.”
The birds in the present collection are distinguished from pectoralis by
wanting the slightest trace of a metallic blue frontal patch. With the
characters of A.frenata, Mull., given by Lord Walden in the Ibis for 1870,
p. 26, they agree and the wing exactly corresponds with that of Muller’s
figure ; but there is no trace of a maroon pectoral band represented, which
though slight, is present in all our £ specimens. The yellow supercilium is
distinctly marked. Another character which distinguishes this from
pectoralis, and helps to separate it from several other species, is the size
of the bill which closely approximates to that of A. intermedia , Hume.
Length 4'2 ; wing 2'1; bill at front '8, tail 1-1 inches.
Fam. Laniada:.
21. L ANTES LUCIONEKSIS, Scop.
A specimen of this bird is identical in coloration with one in the In-
dian Museum from Mr. Swinlioe, Amoy. It differs from the ordinary Indian
Y. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
281
1872.]
specimens of cristatus in the silvery white of the forehead, chin, and throat,
and in the almost entire absence above of any tinge of rufous except on the
upper tail coverts. Length 7'1, wing 3’5, tarsus ’95, hill at front ’5 inches.
22. Graucat.us Macei, Lin.
The collection contains five specimens of Graucalws, three of which
answer very closely to the characters of G. Macei or G. Javensis, being
indeed of intermediate size and thus affording a link between the Indian and
Javan birds which, according to Blyth, only differ in size. They have the
wings white underneath, and the outer tail feathers broadly tipped with
white. One specimen has the abdomen slightly barred, in the others it
is simply albescent.
Length. Wing. Tail. Bill from gape. Tarsus.
II inch. 6 62 inch. 6 inch. 1-58 inch. IT inch.
III „ 6-75 „ 5T2 „ 1-5 „ 1-
The remaining two specimens I at at first thought might be the young
of the above ; but closer examination convinced me that they are adults in
full plumage belonging to a distinct species.
t 23. Gr.vucai.us Dotisoxi, n. sp.
So far as the literature available in Calcutta has enabled me to com-
pare this bird with the hitherto described species of this genus it appears
to be distinct. I at first supposed it might be striata, BoAA..-=Nov(S-guine(e,
Gmel. &c., but it differs in several particulars from Lesson’s description of
that species. The following is a description.
Above dark slatey, darkest on the head ; wings and tail brownish-black,
primaries, secondaries and tertiaries lighter on the inner webs, faintly edged
with white on the outer ; two outer rectrices on each side narrowly tipped
with dusky white ; a black stripe from the lores round the eyes to the ear
coverts, thence faintly continued as a collar in one of the specimens. Un-
derneath white barred with black from chin to under tail-coverts inclusive ;
under wing-coverts similarly barred. Bill conspicuously smaller than in
G. Macei. Length, 10'2, wing, G'2, tail, 5 '4, bill from gape, 1'23, tarsus,
'95 inch.
I have named the species after Dr. Dobson.
24. Peimcrocotus seeciostts, Lath. — Gould, B. of Asia, pt. IX, pi. 4.
A good series of this bird has been brought. It includes several young
males with the transitional plumage. I have little doubt that _P. Anda-
manensis, Tytlcr, is only P. speciosus in immature plumage. It is said to
have “ the plumage of P. speciosus with more yellow or flame-colour min-
gled with the scarlet. It is also apparently smaller.” The amount of red
on the central tail feathers of this bird varies much in specimens from
various parts of India and Barma. Four out of five males in this collection
have the central tail feathers wholly black.
35
2 82
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
[No. 4,
I have shot in Bengal and examined from other parts of India many
specimens of P, speciosus, none approach in size Gould’s figures which are
said to be life.
25. Pebicbocotus PEBEGBrNtrs, Linn.
Andaman specimens correspond with the darker plumaged variety of
this bird from Madras and Ceylon, from one of which Gould’s figure is taken.
I have not seen any description of P. fl aprons, Boie apud Bonaparte,
from Borneo and Sumatra, possibly the southern form should be referred to
that species.
20. Buchanga (Dicbubus) Andamanensis, Tytler.
This is, I believe, a good species, somewhat resembling T>. balicassius*
hut distinguished from that species by its large sharply keeled bill and hair-
like feathers, which spring from the nostril. The bill is more like that of
a Dissemurus than a JDicrurm ; so much is this the case that in a former
paper J. A. S. B., XXXIX, pt. II, p. 241, I was inclined to refer a very
young bird of this species with the tail feathers only partly grown to the
former rather than to the latter genus. I have compared it with all the
specimens mentioned in Blyth’s Catalogue including edoliformis, but it is
certainly distinct from any of them.
Above and below black, with a greenish metallic gloss ; primaries brown,
fourth and fifth longest and equal, outer tail feathers with a slight curl up-
wards, under wing-coverts spotted with white lunules ; no rictal spot.
27. Dissembbtis (Edoliiis) a f ftnis, Tytler et Beavan.
The late Capt. Beavan, (Ibis, N. S. Ill, p. 323) discussed the reasons
which led him to the conclusion that the Andaman bird is distinct ; since
that time much has been written on the subject, but the nomenclature of the
species is far from being in a satisfactory state. To start with, it is uncer-
tain whether the three following species should be regarded as really belong-
ing to three, two or one : E. Bangoonensis, Gould, E. Malayensis, Blyth,
E. setifer, Temm.
Dr. Jerdon (B. of I. Yol. I, p. 438,) and Mr. Gray (Hand list, p. 287),
maintain that Malayensis and setifer are identical ; but Lord Walden
(Ibis, 3rd Series, I. p. 174), states that the Javan E. setifer is distinct from
Malayensis, and asks whether the latter is distinct from Bangoonensis ?
calling it the Barmese species. Mr. Blyth has stated (B. of I. Vol. I, p. 438),
that Bangoonensis is not from Banna but from the Philippines, and so far
* D. balicassius, Linn., was obtained at sea near the Nicobars, according to Blyth.
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
2S3
1872.]
as I can see there is no authentic case of a non-crested speeimen having
been obtained in Barma. There are certainly none in the Indian Museum.
Several specimens collected by Dr. Williams and now in that collection are
well crested and should be ranked as paradiseus according to Jerdon’s classi-
fication. From J). Itangoonensis , as described by Gould, P. Z. S. 1836, the
Andaman bird is distinguished by its larger bill and longer wing, if not by
other characters ; from D. Malayensis ( =z setifer ? ) as represented in
the Indian Museum (As. Socy. Coll.) by its very much larger size. Other
doubtful species of non-crested Bissemuri are D. brachyphorus, Temm.,
apud Bonap., and D. singular is, Gray.
In the present Andaman collection there are three specimens which
have only a very slight trace of frontal crest, their measurements are :
Length to end of Wing. Bill from gape. Tail. Outer T. feathers. Tarsus,
ordinary tail.
Sex p 12 inch. 6'2 inch. 1'45 inch. 62 inch. 1 inch.
$ 12 „ 6‘4 „ 1'5 „ 65 „ 15. inch. IT „
Sex? 13 3 „ 6 5 „ 15 „ 7 „ 17. „ IT „
28. Aetames ieucopxghaJjIS, Gould, P. Z, S. Lon. 1842, p. 17.
Lord Walden, P. Z. S. 1866, p. 555, has identified the Andaman bird
with Gould’s Australian species. I have compared with it Gould’s plate and
can see no difference in the plumage, but the bill of the Andaman bird seems
larger.
Fam. Muscic a vidt;.
29. Myiagra Tttleri, Beav.
Both Mr. Blyth (Ibis, 1868, p. 132) and Dr. Jerdon (ibid. 1872, p. 122)
doubt the distinctness of the Andaman bird from the widely distributed M.
azurea, Bodd. ; but chiefly, I, believe on the ground of that wide distribu-
tion. With the specimens, 2 $ and 2 9, now before me, and not having
been able to discover, in the Indian Museum, any specimens, or any publish-
ed description of Indian birds shewing the same departure from the typical
coloration, I am inclined to follow Capt. Beavan in his determination of the
Andaman bird as distinct.
M. Tytleri, Beav., is said to “ differ conspicuously in entirely wanting
the black gorget on the throat of the male.” (Ibis, N. S. Ill, 1867, p. 324).
This character as suggested by an editorial footnote is only an individual
peculiarity. In the two males before me, the gorgets are distinctly marked ;
but the other specific characters, the brighter coloration of the upper parts
and the continuation of the blue of the breast to the abdomen which becomes
slightly paler towards the vent, serve to distinguish this bird, if not as a
species, at least as a well marked variety of M. azurea. The under tail
coverts are white with a sky-blue tinge. The female like the male has no
white on the abdomen ; wings and tail brown.
284
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
[No. 4,
Measurements in inches.
30. GeOCICHLA HWOTATA, Blyth.
One specimen. Length 7'2 ; wing 3 5 ; bill at front -7 ; tarsus IT—
inches.
Bam. Bhachypodidie.
31. Otocompsa jocosa, Linn.
The Andaman appears to be identical with the Indian species.
t 32. Bbachypoditts melanocephaltts, Gmel. ?
One specimen in immature plumage may belong to this species. The
metallic feathers of the head have not appeared. The outer edges of the
primaries are yellowish green.
33. I hey a ptjella, Lath. Vide Ann. and Mag. Nat. Hist. 4 Ser.
Vol. Y, 1870, p. 417.
The Andaman species of Irena corresponds with that found in Southern
India (Travancore). It has the short tail coverts which, according to Lord
Walden, distinguish Irena puella from I. cyanea and I. turcosa. The collec-
tion contains males, females, and young males in transitional plumage.
Wing. Tail. Bill at front. Tarsus.
$ 5 inches. 4 inches. *9 inches. *75 inches.
2 5 „ 4 „ -9 „ '75
Young $ 49 „ 4 „ -8 „ -7
34. Oeioltjs melatjocephalijs, Linn. One specimen.
35. Oeioltjs Andamanensis, Tytler.
In his last published remarks on this species (Ibis, IV, 1868, p. 132)
Mr. Blyth states his belief that the Andaman Oriole is distinct from Hors-
Jieldi, Bonap. ; previously having relinquished his original supposition
as to its identity with coronatus, Swainson. He considers it to be “ most
nearly akin to O. macrurus of the Nicobars, but is rather smaller.” It is
distinguished from O. macrurus not only in size but in the amount and dis-
tribution of the yellow on the wings and tail and black on the head. From
CMnensis, L may readily be distinguished by the black on the nape being
much narrower, Indicus having it of intermediate size.
A specimen in full adult plumage, has the wings black save the extre-
mities of secondaries and tertiaries which are narrowly tipped with yellow,
and a bar formed of yellow tips to the wing-coverts of the primaries.
The collection contains three specimens, and there are six in the old
collection which were described by Blyth. Dimensions of one ; length 8'8 ;
wing 5 3 ; bill at front 1 ; tarsus '9 ; tail 335 inches.
1872.]
Y. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
285
Fain. Sylviam.
86. Copsychus saulabis, Linn.
Three specimens belonging to the Indian, not the Malaccan species (Q.
Mindtmensis). A fully grown male has the four outer rectrices on either side
white, this is a character according to Blyth, which distinguishes C. saularis
from both Mindanensis and Ceylonensis.
37. Kittaciacla albiventbis, Blyth. Three specimens.
Measurements of & : length 7'8 ; wing 3'55 ; bill to gape ‘87 ; tarsus
9 ‘5 inches.
38. Abtoddsax oeiyaceus, Blyth, J. A. S. B. XIV, p. 595. A.
cedon Pallas ?
Three specimens of this not very well known bird. They correspond
very closely with Blyth’s original description and type specimens so far as the
faded condition of the plumage of the latter admits of comparison. In
dimensions, however, they are somewhat smaller :
A, is the Andaman bird ; B, a bird in the Museum labelled by Blyth.
The measurements of both are less than those given in Blyth’s original de-
scription and in the “ Birds of India,” II, p. 157. Another of Blyth’s speci-
mens on the same stand is larger than B, and more nearly corresponds with
the published measurements.
Fam. Cokyth.e.
39. Deydeocttta Baylei, Tytler, Ibis 1863, p. 119.
A good series of this bird.
Measurements in inches.
Length., Wing. Tail. Bill to gape. Tarsus.
S 12 2 40 7 2 1- 1 ' inch.
Sex? 11-8 4-6 7’ IT 1 „
In my previous paper J. A. S. B. XXXIX, p. 242, “ wing 2J,” “ was misprinted
for 4J.”
Fam. Stueyid.e.
40. Caloenis paxayensis, Scop. = O. cantor, Gm. Vide Ibis, 3rd
Series, Yol. I, 1871, p. 176.
The Andaman specimens (five), including both young and adults, appear
to be identical with the Indian species.
41. Tementjchus Axiiamayeysts, Tytler.
The specimens in this collection (both $ and ? ) go far to establish
Tytler’s opinion as to the distinctness of the Andaman bird from T. erytliro-
pyr/ia, Blyth, from the Nieobars. Nope of them shew the slightest tendency
286
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
[No. 4,
to rufescence on the rump, upper tail coverts, under tail-coverts or tail fea-
thers, as 1S so distinctly marked in the Nicobar birds.
•n 1 °bserve to°’ thm[gh I doubt its being a constant character, that the
ill of the Nicobar bird is somewhat more slender and less conical than in
the Andaman specimens.
£ Wing 4 3 ; tail 3'2 ; hill at front l'l ; tarsus 1 inch.
42. Eulabes Andamanensis, Tytlpr.
,, . Previous paper I simply confined myself to pointing out
that the Andaman and Nicobar birds are identical, feeling that without a
larger series for comparison, and in the state of opinion on the subject of the
different races of Euiabes, my safest course was, to follow Lord Walden, who
as pronounced the Andaman bird to be a distinct and good species. Since
that time, Dr. Stoliczka has discussed the subject at length (J. A. S. B,
XXXIX, pt. II, p. 326) and has been replied to by Lord Walden (Ibis, 3rd
Senes, YoL I, p. 177). Dr. Stoliczka believes the Nepal, Arracan, Anda-
man, Nicobar, Wellesley province and Malacca birds to be “ geographical
races of the same species” viz., E. Javanensis, Osbeck.
Lord Walden maintains not only the distinctness of intermedia and
Andamanensis ; but from recent examination of specimens from Malacca ques-
tions their identity with the true Javanensis from Java.
I have before me two specimens from a dealer’s collection from “ the
Straits” which I take to belong to the large Malacca species generally
known as Javanensis. In these the bill is well curved and high ; the naked
space^ below the eye is quite disconnected with the wattles.
The Andaman and Nicobar specimens are smaller and have the bill
lower and straighter. The bare patch underneath the eye is not absolutely
disconnected from the wattles. So far as I can see the colour of the bill and
the size of the lappets are extremely variable in specimens from the same
locality. In my Nicobar specimen, the commencement of the wattles behind
the eye is broader than in either of the Andamanese, but in other respects,
the size and shape of1 the bill, feet &c., there is no perceptible difference.
Measurements in inches of a specimen in Dr. Dobson’s collection.
Wing 6'3 ; tail 3'25 ; bill from gape 15 ; tarsus. L4.
Earn. Fein gillidjE.
43. Munia eeuconota, Tern.
Two specimens. Feathers not striated.
men
Earn. Teeeokidje.
44. OsMOTEEEON CHXOBOETEEA, Blyth.
Tins bird is said to be common, the collection contains only one speci-
lhere aie grave suspicions that the bird-skinner made the
1872.]
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
287
discovery, — and acted upon it pretty frequently — that like other green
pigeons, it is very good eating. Measurement in inches : wing 6'35, bill at
front '65, tail 4'25, tarsus '85.
45. Caepophaga sylvattca, Tiekell.
The identity of Andaman with Indian specimens of this bird has been
fully established. The collection contains three specimens.
Bam. Coittmbhue.
46. Teethe httmixis, Temm.
One specimen. The upper parts are of a rather deeper tint than in
most Indian specimens.
47. Maceopygia ehfipennis, Blyth, J. A. S. B. XV, p. 371.
Three specimens, two of which, marked <J, have the rufous of the
neck, upper part of the back, breast and abdomen barred with dark brown
slightly undulating lines, which are close and distinct to the breast ; thence
to the vent they are wider apart, broken and fainter.
In a fourth specimen which is somewhat smaller, and may be either a
young bird or the female, the bars are confined to the back of the neck, and
the rufous of the wing coverts, edges of the wings, throat and abdomen is
of a deeper tint approaching to bay.
Mr. Blyth in his original description has pointed out the characters
which distinguish this species, — the smaller size, and rufous underneath the
wings — from M. phasianella, Gould.
The following are the dimensions of a male : length 14T5 ; wing 7'5 ;
bill at front '6 ; tarsus '9 inch.
Bam. Goueidje.
48. Chalcopiiaps I \btctjs, Linn.
Three specimens. Mr Blyth observes (Ibis, N. S. IV, 1868, p. 133) :
“ I could perceive no difference between Andaman specimens and those from
India and Barma, whereas the Nicobar race accords with the description of
C. augusta, Bp. [Oomptes rendus, 1855].”
Bam. Gbaeeoeida;.
t 49. Geaeeola oeientalis, Leach.
The collection contains two specimens which correspond exactly with
specimens in the Indian Museum from the vicinity of Calcutta (Blyth’s Ca-
talogue, No. 1543).
Bam. CHAEADEIDiE.
t 50. CiiABADEius longipes, Temm.
Two specimens shot in May. In one the black of the summer plumage
is beginning to appear.
288
V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
[No. 4,
t 51. iEOTALITIS geofpeoyi, Wagler.
Two specimens sliot in May, have the winter plumage as described and
figured by Mr. J. E. Harting (Ibis, 1870, p. 379) :
Length. Wing. Bill at front. Tarsus.
8 3 6-4 1 1-4 inch.
8,1 53 X 1-4 „
Col. Tytler says that be only obtained a distant view of the bird which
is enumerated in Beavan’s list as M. pyrrhothorax ( = Ad. mongolicm
apud Harting) , so that it is not improbable that it was this species which
he saw. It may have been this species too, which I observed in the Nico-
bars.
f 52. Eudeomias veeedus, Gould, P. Z. S. 1848, p. 38, B. of Aus-
tralia, YI, pi. 14. Harting, Ibis, 1870, p. 209.
Mr. Harting’s paper loc. c. enables a specimen in winter plumage to be
identified with certainty. Length 8'2 ; wing 6'4 ; bill '9 ; tarsus IS ; un-
covered portion of tibia '9 inches.
Fain. Scolopacidie.
53. Numenius phieopus, Linn.
One specimen in the collection. The bird is said to be common in the
clearings and cultivated grounds. It is enumerated in Blyth’s list of Anda-
man birds but not in Beavan’s.
It was obtained in the Nicobars by the Novara expedition, and also by
myself ; J. A. S. B. XXXIX, pt. II, p. 33.
t 54. Actitis glaeeola, Gmel.
f 55. Actitis uypoleucos, Linn.
One specimen of each of the above.
Fam. It allii) a;. _
56. Eubyzona Canningi, Tytler, Ibis, 1863, p. 119.
This collection contains one specimen of the above rail which was first
described by Tytler and Blyth in the Ibis.
Mr. Wood Mason says the bird is rather common in the grass bordering
cieeks. The specimen was shot near Hopetown.
Measurement : wing 6 3 ; tail 3 3 ; bill at front LI ; tarsus 2 inches.
f 57. Ramus steiatus, Linn. ?
Thls bil'd dilfers from 11 ■ striatus, as represented in the Indian Museum
(Blyth’s Catalogue, No. 1671), in its longer and more powerful bill and in
the abrupt termination of the rufous of the head and back of the necli,
Wf .f “ ?rdinary specimens is continued for some distance along the sides
ot the bluish grey of the breast. In other respects it corresponds with the
common Indian bird. Wing 515 ; bill at front 17 ; tarsus L55 inches.
1872.]
Y. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds.
289
Should specimens obtained hereafter shew that the above characters are
constant, it may be then determined whether the Andaman bird must be
regarded as belonging to a distinct race.
The present specimen was received from Mr. Homfray.
Fam. ABDEiDiE.
t 58. Akdea rnu’irnEA, Linn.
Two specimens in immature plumage.
t 59. Hebodias egeetoides, Temm.
One specimen which differs slightly in measurements from those given
by Jerdon: wing 1T2, bill at front 29, tarsus T-l, middle claw 35
inches. Tho bill is yellow with a brown tip to the upper mandible.
Col. Tytler mentions having identified II. garzetta in the Andamans.
60. Hebodias concoloe, Blyth. H. Atidamanensis Tytler.
Col. Tytler (Ibis, N. S., Ill, 1867, p. 333) proposed for tho Andaman
bird a new- name in consequence of “ the young being black ah ovo, whereas
those of the species for which it has been mistaken are white to which Mr.
Blyth replied (lbis,N. S., IV, 133) “ II. Andamanensis is decidedly identical
with H. concolor of which I never saw a white example. It also inhabits
the Nicobars and Arakan.”
I have carefully compared all the specimens available from the three
localities and the only difference which I can discern, is that the Andaman
birds are on the whole a little smaller, but one of the Nicobar birds is about
the same size as the largest Andaman.
Measurements in inches.
36
290 V. Ball — Notes on Andaman Birds. [No. 4,
The white on chin and throat exists in Nos. 2, 5, 6, 7 and 8 ? Nos.
1, 3 and 4 have no trace of it.
61. Bittortdes .Tavantca, Horsf.
Two specimens are conspicuously smaller than any of a good series of
Indian birds with which I have compared them ; but correspond closely in
coloration and other details of plumage. $ Wing 6'5 ; bill at front 2'4 ;
tarsus T65 inches.
Fain. Anatid.u.
t 62. ? Mabeca punctata, Cuv. Gould, Birds of Australia, vol. VII,
pi. 11. M. castanea, Eyton.
What Col. Tytler’s Querquedula Andamanensis may be I am unable
to say, as it has not been described, and the original specimen appears to have
been lost. Prima facie it is improbable that a local species of Querquedula
exists in the islands. Be that as it may, the present collection contains
specimens of what is commonly known as the ‘ teal’ of the Andamans to the
residents there. Except that they have a patch of white surrounding the
eye and that the plumage of the head is somewhat darker, they correspond
very closely with Gould’s figure of Mareca punctata, Cuv. Erom his
description it is evident that the plate exaggerates the bluish tinge of the
velvet black speculum.
Two of the specimens shew an incipient stage towards the full breeding
plumage of the male, scattered patches of bright ferruginous or chesnut ap-
pearing on the feathers of the breast and abdomen.
The occurrence of this species in the Andamans would be very interest-
ing. It has previously only been found in Australia, Van Diemen’s Land,
the Moluccas and New Caledonia.
• »
Note. — While the preceding pages were passing through the press the sad news
of the death of Col. Tytler at Simla reached us, His name, so frequently mentioned
above, will ever be inseparably connected with the avifauna of the Andaman Islands.
1872.]
291
New Baemese Plants,* (Paet Fiest), — by S. Ktjez, Esq.
DILLENIA CE2E.
1. Dillenia pilosa, Roxb. FI. Ind. II. 652, non Ham.
Arbor decidua magna ; folia adulta oblongo-obovata v. elliptico-oblonga,
basi attenuata, obtusa v. rotundata, brevissime (2 — 3 lin.) petiolata, acuta
v. obtusa, obsolete repando-dentata, 10 — 12 poll, longa, supra glabra, subtus
secus nervos wiagis minusve pubescentia, juniora herbacea utrinque sparse
pubescentia et petiolo foliaceo-alato subamplexicaulia ; florcs aurei, 2 — 2}
poll, in diametro, solitarii ex apice ramulorum verrueiformium, pedunculis
c. pollicaribus pubescentibus suffulti ; series interior staminum exteriori
duplo longior ; styli et carpel la 6 ; carpella matura calyce aucto aurantiaco
tomentello carnoso globoso circa pollicem crasso inelusa. — Andamans.
AN0NACE2E.
2. Miliusa scleeocaepa, (Uvaria scle.rocarpa, DC. Mom. 27).
Arbor decidua, 40 — 50 pedalis, novellis tenuiter adpresse sericeis ; folia
elliptico-oblonga ad oblonga, breviuscule petiolata, basi acuta, apieulata,
chartaeea, glabra ; flores flavidi, dioici, 7 — 8 lin. longi, pedicellis brevibus
gracilibus pubescentibus sustenti, fasciculos depauperatos brevissime pedun-
culatos axillares efformantes ; sepala lincari-lanceolata, brevia, fulvo-tomen-
tosa ; petala exteriora sepalis conformia sed paullo longiora ; petala interiora
7 — 8 lin. longa, lanceolata, obtusa, extus puberula, intus canescenti tomen-
tosa ; stamina numerosa, in toro subgloboso dense aggregata ; flores feminei
(cf. Hf. et Tli. FI. Ind.). — Martaban, Tenasserim.
MENISPEBMACEAE.
3. Melodoettm (Pteamxdanthe) maceanthem, nov. sp.
Arbuscula 15 — 20 pedalis glabra gemmis fulvo-velutinis ; folia oblonga
v. elliptico-oblonga, crasse et breviuscule petiolata, basi acuta, 6 — 7 poll,
longa, brevius v. longius acuminata ; membranacea, glabra, nervis lateralibus
arcuato-anastomosantibus, laxissime reticulata, utrinque pallide viridia;
flores albi, speciosi, pedunculo pollicari puberulo suffulti, solitarii et late-
rales ; sepala patentia, lato-ovata, 5 — 6 lin. longa, obtusiuscula, glabra,
coriaeea ; petala alba flavoscentia, exteriora lineari-lanceolata, sub-5-polli-
* Further particulars regarding stations, affinity of species, &o., will be given
in my forthcoming Contributions towards a Imowledge of the Burmese Flora, which I
hope to have ready for publication as soon as the acquittal of other engagements allow
me the necessary leisuro for arranging and preparing the large materials already
worked up.
292
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
[No. 4,
caria, acuminata, basi paullulo attenuata glabra, interiora brevia, pollicem
circiter longa, conniventia, lanceolata, obtusa, extus puberula glabrescentia,
intus minute villosula ; carpella oblique oblonga, stylo subrecurvo ovario
ipso Iongiore tenuinata ; stamina numerosa, linearia ; connectivum capita-
turn. — Andamans.
4. TrxospoEA nt nTFLOTiA, ( Cocculus nudiflorus, Griff. Not. Dicot. 307) .
Frutex scandens deciduus, caulibus sparse tuberculatis junioribus dense
subalbido-pubescentibus ; folia adulta ignota, novella petiolis longis pubes-
centibus instructa, ovato-oblonga, basi sinuato-rotundata, breviter acumi-
nata, subtus molliter et subalbido-pubescentia ; flores feminei brunneo-lutci,
solitarii, gracilitcr pcdicellati bractcati raceinos 3 — 4 pollicares glaberrimos
in axillos foliorum delapsorum solitarios formantes ; bracteol® subulate,
parvic ; sepala 6, exteriora parva reflexa, interiora magna recurva ; petala
6, ocbraceo-lutea ; staminodia totidem setacea petalis opposita ; ovaria 3,
toro semigloboso inserta ; drop® cerasi majoris magnitudine v. majores
aurantiaeo-lute®, laives et lucid®, putamen 5 — 6 lin. long., album, carinatum,
lffiviusculum nec tuberculatum, endocarpo limpido aquoso nidulans. — Pegu,
Martaban , Tenasserim.
CAP P ABIDE AS.
5. CltATTYA HY GEOPHI1A, nov. Sp.
Frutex 2 — 3 pedalis simplex v. 4 — 6 pedalis, parce ramosus, glaberri-
mus, cortice brunneo leucosticto ; folia eadem ac in C. religiosa ; flores
solitarii axillares, parvuli ? ; bacc® 1 — 2 pollicares, oblongo-cylindric®,
longe (1 — 2 poll.) stipitatse, l®ves, brunne®, leucostict®. — Pegu.
POLY GALE AS.
6. Salomonia loxgiciitata, nov. sp.
Herbula annua ramosa, alis membraneis secus ramos ramulosque et
foliorum marginibus longe albido-ciliatis, c®torum glaberrima ; folia vulgo
obovata, raro ovalia, semipollicem circiter longa, basi in petiolum brevissi-
mum attenuata, superiora ssspius sessilia, obtusa et mucronulata, membrana-
cea, 3-norvia, ciliata ; flores rninuti, purpurei, longius v. brevius spicati,
spicis terminalibus et sspius lateralibus ; bracteol® minut®, subulat®, s®-
pius persistentes ; capsul® transverse oblong®, compress®, l®ves (nec reti-
culat®), lato truncato-emarginat®, lateribus dentibus subulatis biseriatis
cristat®, sursum ad sinum nud® ; semina nigra, nitentia. — Pegu.
7. Poly gala Kakensiym, nov. sp.
Fruticulus vulgo 2 — 3 pedalis glaberrimus ; folia lanceolata ad lato-
lanceolata, 4 — 8 poll, longa, basi in petiolum longiusculum attenuata,
acuminata, membranacea, glabra, subtus glauca ; flores majusculi, 6 — 7 lin.
longi, albidi, apicibus lilacinis, breve et graciliter pedicellati, racemosi,
secundi ; racemi terminales et axillares, glabri, 2 — 3 poll, longi, foliis bre-
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
293
1872.]
viores ; ala; carina paullo hrc viores, obovato-lan ceolat®, obtus® ; carina
petalis interioribus duplo longior, cristata ; crista biloba lobis multifidis ;
capsule parv®, c. 2 lin. long® et lat®, rotundat®, membranace®, ala duplici
lata apice profunde emarginata emetic, glabra; ; semina obovata, sericea,
carunculo brevissimo albo suffulta. — Martaban.
8. Poly gal a cariiiocarfa, nov. sp.
Herbula debilis glabra, habitu P. glaucescentis, cauli a basi vulgo
efoliato apieem versus rarnoso ; folia 1J- — 2 poll, longa, ovata v. oblongo-
lanceolata, basi aeuta v. acuminata ot subdeeurrentia, longiuseulo petiolata,
acuta, tenere membranaeea, flaccidissima, glabra, subtus glauca ; flores
parvi, racemosi ; racemi axillares et terminates, graciles ; capsul® brevissime
sed gracillime pedicellat®, chartaee®, ovales, validinerves, ala duplici lata
apicibus valde products, et profunde emarginata quasi formam obcoi'datam
assumentes. — Tenasserim.
HYPERICINE 'M.
9. Teidesmis protifloea, nov. sp.
Arbuscula 25 — 30 pedalis, decidua, trunco ramulis spiniformibus
armato, novellis tomentellis ; folia lineari- ad lanceolato-oblonga, juniora
obovato-oblonga v. oblonga, 4 — 5 poll, longa, breve et graciliter petiolata
(petiolo tomentoso), basi obtusa v. acuta et nonnunquam subinsequalia,
cbartacea, supra asperiuscule tomentella, subtus tomentella et crasse reti-
culata ; flores puleherrimi, lilacini ; pedicelli 3 — 4 lin. longi, tomentosi,
3 — 5-ni fasciculati v. subeymosi, supra foliorum cicatricibus orientes ;
sepala fulvescenti tomentosa ; petala fimbriata, glandul® oblonga;, teretes,
obtus® ; phalanges plan®, basin vorsus latiusculse, filamentis supra medio
liberis; capsula; oblong®, acutie. ( Crutoxylon prUniflorum, Kurz, MS.
olim) . — Rarma.
10. Cbatoxylon keeiifoltum, n. sp.
Arbor decidua, 40 — 50 pedalis, glaberrima ; folia lanceolata v. elliptico-
lanceolata, c. 4 poll, longa, brevissime petiolata v. subsessilia, basi sub-sagit-
tata, glabra, acuta v. obtusiuscula, subtus pallida et distincte reticulata ;
flores parvi, pedicellis brevissimis, 3 — 2-ni cymosi, pedunculi breves com-
pressi terminales et vulgo in paniculam longiusculam glabram coflecti ;
sepala oblonga, obtusa, coriacea, glabra ; petala c. 3 — 4 lin. longa, rotunda-
ta ; phalanges plan®, filamentis a medio liberis ; glandulae hypogyn® ovarii
longitudine, carnosse, clavat®, obtus® ; capsul® sepalis paullo longiores,
ovat®. — Chittagong, Pegu, Sfc.
GUTTIFER2E.
11. Gaecotia sttccifolia, nov. sp.
Arbor 30 — 35 pedalis, glaberrima ; folia lanceolata ad oblongo-lanceo-
lata, c. 2 — 4 poll, longa, breviuscule sed gracillime petiolata, basi acuta,
294
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants. [N0. 4,
camescente-herbaeea (succo salino aeido), vulgo acuta, glabra, nervis subtili-
bue secus margines anastomosantibus ; flores albidi, parvi, solitarii v. terni,
2—3 lin. in diametro, breve crasseque pedicellata, torminales v. axillares ;
flores masc. : sepala 2 mteriora petalis majora et tenuiora, nervosa ; stamina
numerosa, antheris oblongis marginatis planis 2-locularibus, in phalange erecta
brevi (lobata ?) subsessilibus ; fl. fern, et fruct. ignoti .—Pegu, Martaban.
TILIACEJE.
12. GrREWIA RETTJSLFOLIA, nov. gp.
Frutex 3—4 pedalis, velutino-tomentosus ; folia obovata v. subobcor-
data, v. obcordato-ovalia, 2 — 3 poll, longa, brevissime petiolata,profunde retusa
cum denticulo, argute duplieato-serrata, subcoriacea, supra minute et scabriu-
scule tomentella, subtus dense caneseenti v. flavescenti tomentosa ; flores
pedunculi breves, solitarii, axillares, hirsuti; torus brevis, dense hirsutus";
drupse rubicundm, sparse liirsutae, glabreseentes, pisi magnitudine, 2 lob®
lobis pyrenam solitariam 2 — locularem ineludentibus. — Pegu.
13. ElijKOCARPUS QUANDIFOLIUS, nov. Sp.
Arbor novellis fulvo v. ferrugineo-tomentosis ; folia largissima, 1— li
pedes longa, obovato-oblonga v. ovalia, petiolis crassissimis 4 — 6 lin. longis
tomentosis suffulta, basin versus subattenuata et ssepius subdeeurrentia°v.
rotundata, membranaeea, acute v. breve acuminata, minute et remote ser-
rato-dentata, subtus prajsertim secus nervos pilosula, supra Habra et
subnitentia ; flores majores, pedicellis *— 1 poll, fulvo-tomentosis, in racemos
lulvo- v. ferrugmeo tomentosos collecti ; sepala lincari-lanceolata, ferrugineo-
tomentosa, semipollicaria ; petala paullo longiora, extus ferrugineo-pubes-
centia, bifida, lobis fimbriato-fissis ; ant her® numerosa?, graciles, filamentis
ongiores in aristam anther® loculorum longitudine desinentes ; ovarium
dense pubescens ; drupse pollicares, compressiuscule oblongs®, fulvo-puber-
ulas ; putamen compressiusculum, rugosum .—Pegu, Martaban, Tenasserim.
LINE2E.
14. Erytiieoxylon Kcytiitayum, nov. sp.
Arbor glabra ; folia 3—4 poll, longa, oblongo-lanceolata, basi obtusa,
breve et graciliter petiolata, breve et obtuse acuminata, raro obtusa,
Integra, chartacea, subtus glauca ; stipul® subulat® ; flores parvi, albi,
pedicellis 6 lin. longis sursum incrassatis suffulti, vulgo bini in foliorum axillis
v. supra cicatncibus petiolomm delapsorum ; petala oblonga, ligula magna
, , ; stamina altematim breviora, filamenta basibus latis cum staminum
1 isercutia , ovarium ovatum ; styli 3, breves et crassi, a basi liberi ;
irupse monosperm®, ofliptico-ovales.— Martaban.
1872.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
295
BTJTACE2E.
15. Atalaxtia longtsptxa, nov. sp.
Arbuscula spinis 1 — 1| pollicaribus reetissimis cylindricis horride ar-
mata, glaberrima ; folia elliptica v. elliptico-oblonga, petiolis glabris 2 — 3
lin. longis inarticulatis, 3 — 1 poll, longa, acuta v. obtusa, glabra ; flores
solitariiv. bini in foliorura axillis, parvi, brevissime pedicellati (pedicellis
glabris) ; calyx glaber, 5 — dentatus ; ovarium verosimiliter glabrum, 3 — an-
gulare, in stylum brevem attenuatum ; bacc® (immatur®) pruni magni-
tudine, ovat®, acuminat®, toro brevi suffult®. — Pegu, Martaban.
0CKNACP2E.
16. Ochna Andamantca, nov. sp.
Arbuscula decidua, glaberrima ; folia oblonga, v. elliptico-lanceolata,
c. 4 — 5 poll, longa, brevi-petiolata, acuta et mucronata, setaceo- v. subti-
liter serrulata, ehartacea, supra nitentia ; flores speciosi, aurei, pedicellis
gracilibus breviusculis demum elongatis articulatis ; pedunculi brevissimi
simplices in ramulis lateralibus efoliatis terminales ; filamenta antherarum
longitudine v. paulluin longiora ; petala 5, sepalis paullo longiora, obovata,
in unguem latam sensim attenuata ; calycis fruetigeri sepala omnia erecto-
conniventia ; styli apice omnes liberi et patentes. — Andamans.
17. Ochna Fitu'ricrr.osA, nov. sp.
Prutex pygmaeus, 1 — 3 pedalis, glaborrimus, deciduus j folia vulgo
cuneato-oblonga ad oblongo-lanceolata, cire. 4 — 5 poll, longa, acuminata,
acuta v. sub-obtusa, basi in petiolum brevissimum atteuuata, cliartacea, ar-
gute serrata ; flores speciosi, aurei, pedicellis longioribus v. brevioribus sup-
portati ; pedunculi omnino reducti v. breves simplices s. ramosi ; petala
5, obovata, unguieulata ; filamenta antherarum longitudine ; stylus sepa-
lorum longitudine v. paullo longior, gracillimus, filiformis ; stigma minutum,
truncatum ; calycis fruetigeri sepala erecto-conniventia, — Pegu,.
B Ull S ERA CPAS.
18. Canaeium etjehyllem, Kurz (in Andam. Rep. Append, B. 4).
Arbor magna, glabra ; folia 2 — 3 ped. longa, impari-pirmata, glabra ;
foliola 9 — 10 poll, longa opposita pinnulis inferioribus minoribus, oblonga v.
ovato-oblonga, basi oblique rotundata, abrupte apiculata, longiuscule petio-
lulata, ehartacea, serrulata, nitentia, glabra, inter nervos utrinque 12 — 9
laterales valde reticulata ; stipul® nulla; ? ; flores majusculi, albi, breve et
distanter racemulosi, in paniculam 1 h ped. longam axillarem glaberrimam
collecti ; calyx 3 — fidus, lobis latis obtusiusculis ; petala 3, lanceolata, acuta,
crassiuscula, i poll, circiter longa, extus tomentella ; glandul® hypogynte
6, elliptic®, obtusa, geminatim cohserentes, lute® ; stamina 6, filamentis
basi cohffirentibus ; stylus simplex ; drup®.... — Andamans.
206
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
[No. 4,
19. Caxaiuum ? coccineo-beacteattjm, (Kurz in Andam. Kep. Ap-
pendix E. 4).
Arbor mediocris, novellis fulvo velutinis ; folia impari-pinnata, 1 — 2
ped. longa, glabra ; foliola 3 — 4-juga, 5 — 7 poll, longa, opposita, breviuscule
petiolulata, oblonga v. ovato-oblonga, basi insequali-obtusa, in eademque ar-
bore mtegerrima et setaceo-serrulata, acuminata, sub-coriacea, glabra, sub-
tus inter nervos utrinque 10 laterales laxe reticulata, stipulte majusculie,
proiunde bifida; et iterato fiss®, segmentis rigidis grosse dentatis pube-
rulis ; flores (in alabastro) paniculas axillares coccmeas tomcntellas termi-
nales efficientes ; bracte® oblonga;, acut®, tomentell®, coccine®. — Anda-
mans.
ME LI A OB AH.
20. ScmzocniTON gbandiflobum, nov. sp.
Aibor mediocris novellis velutino-tomentosis v. pubescentibus ; folia
alterna, abrupte pinnata, raro impari-pinnata, rhaebide dense fulveseenti-
tomentosa ; foliola 4 — G-juga, bine inde cum impari, opposita v. subopposita,
breve crasseque petiolulata, oblonga v. oblongo-laneeolata, breve acuminata,
Integra v. submtegra, G — 10 poll, longa, supra (nervis exceptis) glabres-
centia, subtus molliter pubescentia ; ilores mediocres, c. G bn. longi, sub-
sessiles et bracteolis lato-oblongis dense fulvo-pubeseentibus sustenti,’ race-
mulosi, paniculas longe pcdunculatas graciles dense fulvo-tomentosas axillares
formantes ; calyx campanulatus, dense pubescens, obsolete 4 — dentatus ;
petala (teste Wight et Arn. s®pe 6) apicibus imbricata, circ. G lin. longa,
dense pubescentia ; staminum tubus basin versus petalis adnatus, parce
pubescens, apice crenato 6 — 7-lobatus, lobis truncatis oblongis et integris ;
anther® G v. 7 ; ovarium stylusque fulvo-pubescentes ; capsul® 3-lob®
et pyriformes, circ. 1|- poll, long®, pericarpio crasse coriaceo lutescente,
3— valves ; sernhia solitaria, magna, arillo completo aurantiaco .—Martaban,
Tenasserim.
21. Wabsuba iivpoJjEuca, nov. sp.
Aibor mediocris novelbs minute puberulis ; folia impari-pinnata, gla-
beirima, rhachide laevi v. sparse lenticellata ; foliola bijuga cum impari,
petiolulis 1— (terminalibus 2— 2*-) poll, longis glabris, elliptico ad oblongo-
laneeolata, 6 — 8 poll, longa, basi obtusa v. acuta, chartacea, glabra, obtusius-
cule et breve v. longiusculc acuminata, subtus glauca, inter reticulationes
loevia (noc albido-tessellata) ; flores parviuseuli, albi, podicellis 1 — 2 lin. lon-
gis puberulis sullulti paniculam corymbosam sessilem v. subsessilem puberu-
lam axillarem formantes ; calyx puberulus, lobis oblongis obtusiusculis ; pe-
tala 5, hinc inde ad 8 augmentata, lineari-lanceolata, acuta, puberula, 2 lin.
fere longa ; stamina 10, nonuunquam usque ad 15, omnia libera ; filamenta
earia, ®quilata, antberis multo angustiora, integra, villosa ; discus eras-
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
297
1872.]
sus, ruber ; ovarium immersum, dense fulvo-tomentosum ; baccas immaturse
canescenti-velutinse, oblonga;, acuminat®. — Andamans.
22. Walsuba (IIeynea) ptjbescens, nov. sp.
Arbuscula gracilis, 25 — 30 pedalis, novellis molli-pubescentibus ; folia
impari-pinnata, raebide terete pubescente ; foliola 4-juga cum, impari, bre-
vius v. longius petiolulata (petiolulis pubescentibus), ovato-oblonga v. oblon-
ga, basi nonnunquam parum insequali acuta v. rotundata, 3 — 5 poll, longa,
breve acuminata, integra et vulgo undulata, membranacea, subtus molliter
llavescenti pubescentia ; ilores parvi, albi, pedicellis brevibus pubescentibus
sustenti, paniculam longe pedunculatam corymbosam brachiatam axillarem
fonnantes ; calyx pubescens ; pcCtal a circ. lin. longa, extus pubescentia ; sta-
minum tubus fere a medio liber, fllamentis latis, glaberrimis, apice bifidis ;
capsulse cerasi minimi magnitudine, globosae v. ovoidese, glabrae, rubrse,
bivalves, semen unicum arillo (albo ?) indutum foventes. — Martaban.
23. Cf'IDIiELA multi.) uga, nov. sp.
Arbor elegans, 70 — 90 pedalis, novellis minute fulvescenti-puberis ; folia
usque ad 3 ped. longa, impari-pinnata, petiolis teretibus junioribus pube-
rulis ; foliola 12 — 15 juga cum impari, alterna, petiolulis 2 — 3 lin. puberulis
suffulta, ovato-lanceolata ad lanceolata, subobliqua, basi inaiquali rotundata,
5 — 6 poll, longa, acuminata, membranacea, integra ; Ilores parvi, albi, pedi-
cellis semi-liueam longis suffulti, paniculam strictam glabram racemose-con-
tractam fonnantes ; petala et sepala 5, urceolato-convergentia, oblongo-
lanceolata, acutiuscula, lisec lj — 2 lin. longa, minute ciliolata ; stamina 10,
libera ; ovarium 10-sulcatum. — Pegu.
CBAILLETIA CBM
24. Ch. HklI'-ebtaxa, nov. sp,
Frutex scandens ? novellis flavescenti— v. canescenti-puberulis ; folia
elliptico-oblonga v. oblonga, petiolis 3 — 4 lin. longis caneseenti-tomentosis,
breve acuminata, basi acuta v. obtusa, integra, pergamacea praesertim dum
juvenilia subtus secus costam marginesque adpresse pubescentia, nervis late-
ralibus tenuibus et inconspicuis ; ilores parvi, pedicellis brevibus et canes-
centi-pubescentibus, in eymulas v. corymbos parvos axillares canescenti-
pubescentes pedunculo -g-f pollicari crasso libero supportatos collecti ; sepala
petalaq !§ extus sericea. — Tenasserim.
OLACINEM.
25. Anacalosa PtTBEIUJLA, nov. sp.
Frutex magnus, glaber ; folia G — 5 poll, longa, breve petiolata, oblonga
ad ovato- et elliptico-oblonga, acuminata, basi acuta, integra, coriacea, glabra ;
flores parvi, pedicellis brevibus strictis puberulis, e pedunculo conico v. glo-
boso brevi crasso minute braeteato orientes ; calyx fulvescenti-puberulqs ;
drup;e . . . . — Andamans.
37
298
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
[No. 4s
26. Cansjera parvtfoeta, nov. sp,
Partes novelise, folia et inflorescenti® pilis furcatis tomentell® v. pu-
berulse ; folia vulgo pollice breviora, ovata, basi rotundata v. obtnsa, coria-
cea, emarginata v. obtusa, integra, utrinque petiolusque brevis tomentella ;
flores parvi, sessiles, calyce magis distincto, spicas breves axillares formantes ;
corolla puberula. — Tcnasserim.
27. Stemo'NUeus tomenteu.uk, nov. sp.
Ramuli, petioli ct infloresoentise fulvescenti-tomentellae ; folia 6 — 7
poll, longa, longiuscule ot graeiliter petiolata, oblongo — v. elliptico-lanceo-
lata, abrupte et obtusiuscule acuminata, basi acuta, subcoriacea, integra,
subtus puberula ; flores parvi, sessiles, cymas 3 — 4-tomas, dense tomen-
tosas, longiuscule pedunculatas axillares formantes ; calyx hirsutus ; corolla
glabra ; filamenta sursum elevata. — Banna.
28. Stemonurtt s ? crasstpes, nov. sp.
Arbuscula 25 — 30 pedalis, glaberrima ; folia 5— 7 poll, longa, lanceo-
lata ad oblongo-lanceolata, basi acuminata, petiolo 4 — 5 lin. crasso sufful-
ta, obtusiuscula, pergamacea, glabra, opaca, subtus obscure colorata ; flo-
res parvi, pedicellis lin. longis, in cymas brevissimas (petioli longitudine)
glabras paucifloras axillares collecti ; calyx coriaceus, cupularis, obsolete
dentatus; drup® immatur® obovatie, pedunculo crassissimo 2 — 3 lin. Ion-
go sustent®, apice truncato disco prominenter acuminato terminate, basi
calycis limbo rupto angusto eircumdat®. — Pegu.
29. Apodttes Andamanica, Kurz in Andam. Rep. Append. B. 5.
Arbuscula glabra gemmis sparse puberulis ; folia 7 — 8 poll, longa,
breviuscule petiolata, elliptico-oblonga v. oblonga, acuminata, basi obtusa v.
acuta et ssepius sub-obliqua, coriaeea, glabra, opaca ; flores parvi, subsessiles
cymas breve et crasse pedunculatas densas puberulas axillares formantes ;
calyx puberulus, obsolete 5- raro 6-dentatus ; petala extus puberula, lanceo-
lata, apicibus acutis incurva ; stylus brevis vix exeentricus ; drup® semi-
baccat®, pollicem circiter long® ; nux lignoso-fibrosus, ovato-oblongus, plano-
convexus et subnavicularis, acumine inflexo terminatus, appendice crasso
carnoso albo nucis superficieni totam planam obtegente ; semina elliptica,
compressa. — Andamans.
30. Saecostigma edule, ( Chailletia edulis, Kurz in And. Rep. App.
B. 6).
Frutex scandens, glaber ; folia elliptica ad oblonga, breviuscule petiolata,
basi obtusa, coriaeea, obtusiuscule apiculata, integra, glabra, utrinque crasse
et eleganter reticulata ; racemi ferrugineo-tomentosi ; drup® inaequali-ob-
long®, eompressiuscul®, obtus®, aurantiac®, dense tomentell®, pulpa tenui
dulciusculo edibili. — Andamans.
31. Yokes Brandish, nov. sp.
I rutex scandens tomentellus ; folia 6 poll, longa, elliptico-oblonga, basi
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
299
1872.]
obtusa, petiolis longiusculis gracilibus tomentosis, acuminata et costa excur-
rente mucronata, integra, membranacea, subtus inter nervos prominenter et
laxe reticulata, supra secus nervos subtusque tota pagina tenui-tomentosa et
viridia ; flores minuti, tomentosi, pedicellis brevibus sed gracilibus, paniculas
laxas tomentosas geminas sub-oppositifolias formantes ; panicula una alterave
v. ejusdem ramulus in cirrhum tortuosum transmutatus ; fruetus.... — Tenas-
serim.
ILICINEAE.
32. Ilex gaultheblefolia, nov. sp.
Frutex glaber ; folia lineari-lanceolata, basin versus attenuata v. cu-
neata, breve crasseque petiolata, acuta, 3 — 3^ poll, longa, coriacea, serrata,
nervis subtus conspieuis, glabra ; flores minuti, pedicellis glabris gracilibus,
cymas breves graciles axillares petiolorum longitudine formantes ; calyx 5-
lobatus, lobis lato-oblongis, obtusiusculis ; petala rotundata ; stamina 5,
filamentis gracilibus, cum petalis alternantibus ; drupa).... — Tenasserim.
CELASTRINEAE.
33. Evoxymus calocabpuh, nov. sp.
Prutex ? glaber, ramulis teretibus ; folia textura et coloratione iis gene-
ris Microtropis slmillima, elliptica v. oblongo-lanceolata, petiolis 3 — 4 lin. lon-
gis, breve et obtusiuscule acuminata, integra, subcoriacea, 4-6 poll, longa,
subtus pallida ; flores... ; capsule cerasi fere magnitudine, pedunculo glabro
brevi su Suit® v. subsessiles, vulgo obsolete 4-lob® et 4-valves, laves ;
semina in loculis solitaria arillo rubescente induta. — Tenasserim.
34. Evoxtmus (Glyptopetahtm) sclebocarptjm, nov. sp.
Arbuscula 8 — 12 pedalis cortiee rubra, glaberrima ; folia oblonga ad
elliptico-lanceolata, petiolis 3 — 4 lin. longis erassis, basi acuminata, 6 — 8
poll, longa, coriacea, serrata, acuminata ; flores vireseenti-purpurei, pedicellis
longis gracilibus instrueti, cymas pedunculatas laxas glabras solitarias v. per
plures in foliorum axillis v. supra eorum delapsorum cicatrieibus orientes
formantes ; sepala alba, lato-orbicularia ; petala suborbicularia, concava, extus
viridia, intus virescenti-purpurea exappendieulata ; stamina 4 ; anther® in
disco lato obsolete 4-gono subsessiles ; stigma sessile, obsolete 4-gonum :
capsul® subglobosse v. bilobse, pisi majoris magnitudine, rimos®, et ver-
ruculoso-scabr® ; arillus sanguineus. — Pegu.
35. Lophopetalum Wallicjui, nov. sp.
Arbor magna, glaberrima ; folia oblonga ad elliptica, raro ovato-oblon-
ga, petiolis 1 — 1^ pollicaribus, obtusa v. obtusiuseula v. acuta, basi rotun-
data, 4 — 6 poll, longa, integerrima, supra glaucescenti-viridia et nitentia,
subtus opaca et inter nervos conspicuos laxe reticulata ; flores c. 3 lin. in
diametro, pedicellis 2 — 2i lin. longis albis glabris instrueti ; panieulae
300
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
[No. 4,
axillares et terminates rigidiusculse, virescenti-albidce ; petala virescenti-
alba, nuda et integra ; discus magnus, carnosus, luteus ; stamina 5, deflexa,
disco inserta ; ovarium triquetrum, sanguineum ; capsul® c. 4 poll. long®,
v. longiores, 2 poll, lat®, 3-loba? et 3-valves, valvis lasvibus ; semina com-
pressa, imbrieata, cum ala 2 — 2 !2 poll, longa, oblonga, ala elliptico-oblonga
membranaceS, complete cireumdata. — Burma.
36. Hlppocbatea fuscebcens, nov. sp.
Frutex ? glaber ; folia oblongo-lanceolata v. oblonga, petiolis crassis
4 — 5 lin. longis, breve acuminata, basi acuta, 2| — 3 poll, longa, coria-
cea, obsolete crenato-serrata, glabra, supra nitentia, in sicco fuscescentia v.
nigrescentia ; paniculse cymosae, glabrae, a basi ramosae v. pedunculat®
axillares, foliis paulo breviores ; flores parvi, circ. 2 lin. in diametro, pedi-
cellis 1 — If lin. longis, sepala minute eroso-ciliata ; petala obovato-oblonga,
concava, basin versus attenuata, lineam circiter longa, imbrieata ; antherae
3, filamentis rellexis brevissimis disco elevato insertis; carpella..,. — Terns-
serim.
37. Sa.la.cia geandiflora, ncrv. sp.
Prutex scandens, glaber, ramulis teretiusculis ; folia elliptica ad ellip-
tico-oblonga, apiculata, basi acuta, petiolis f — f poll, longis crassissimis,
integra et marginibus parum revolutis, 8—9 poll, longa, subcoriacea, glabra,
utrinque nitentia, in sicco fuscescentia ; flores conspicui ; pedicelli crassi,
2 lin. longi, 2 — 4-ni, e tuberculis minute bracteolatis axillaribus v. laterali-
bus orti ; sepala lato-rotundata, glabra, lin. circiter longa ; petala sessilia,
rotundata, 3 — 4 lin. longa ; stamina 3, disco intus inserta, filamenta bre-
vissima dilatata et reflexa ; ovarium heve ; stylus brevis; baccte.... —
Tenasserim.
38. Saiacia flavescens, nov. sp.
Frutex P glaber, ramulis teretiusculis ; folia lanceolata, opposita v. alter-
na, petiolis 3 — 4 lin. longis crassis, utrinque acuminata, integra v. obsolete
crenata, marginibus parum revolutis, tenuiter coriaeea, 4—5 poll, longa,
glabra, supra nitida, subtus pallida, in sicco luteseentia ; flores minuti, albi P
pedicelli 1—2 lin. longi, e tuberculis axillaribus v. lateralibus minute brac-
teatis orti ; sepala oblongo-lanceolata, obtusiuscula ; petala f lin. longa,
oblonga, obtusa ; antheree 3 ; filamenta disco intus inserta, brevissima,
dilatata; ovarium Iseve ; baccse.... — Tenasserim.
BILAMNEAB.
Afteeok, nov. gen.
Calyx 5-fidus, tubo brevi obconico, lobis patentibus acutis. Petala 5,
obovata, minuta, inter calycis lobos inserta. Stamina 5, petalis paullo longio-
ra ; iilamenta flliformia. Discus planus, liber. Ovarium disco immersum,
subglobosum, 2-loculare ; stylus brevissimus, stigmatibus 2 brevibus. Dru-
1872.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
301
pa (?) globosa, Gouaniee more calyce aucto inclusa eidemque adnata, apico
limbo coronata, abortu l-locularis, monosperma ? semina. ...Frutex scan dens
foliis serrulatis penninerviis. Flores parvi, fascieulati, panicnlas racemosas
formantes.
39. Aptebon ian ceolat'Cm, nov. sp.
Frutex magnus scandens, novellis tomontellis ; folia lanceolata, petiolis
2 — 3 lin. longis crassis puberulis glabrescentibus, longe et obtusiuseule acumi-
nata, serrata, chartacea, secus nervos fulvescenti-pubescentia mox glabres-
centia, 4 — 5 poll, longa, utrinque nervis lateralibus numerosis (7 — 9) promi-
nentibus percursa ; Soi'es parvi ; pedieelli graciles v. crassiusculi, 1 lin.
longi, puberuli, fascieulati v. subsolitarii, racemosi et panieulas terminales
et axillares canescenti- v. llavescenti-tomentosas formantes ; calyx dense v.
parce puberulus, circiter 1| — 2 lin. in diametro ; ovarium pubescens, stylo
brevi bifido terminatum ; drupa (?) adhuc nimis immatura globosa, grani
piperis magnitudine, calyce aucto glabrescente limbo calycis coronato usque
ad apicem fere inclusa. — Tenasserim.
40. SMTTHEA ? CALPICABPA, nov. sp.
Frutex scandens ? ramulis fulvo-pilosis ; folia lanceolata, petiolis -j — 1 lin.
longis crassis magis minusve pilosis, acuminata, serrata, chartacea, 4 — 3) poll,
longa, subtus secus eostam pilosa, cseterum glabra; Sores...; capsul®
(immatur®) 1]- poll, long®, oblong®, apice oblique truncat®, folliculis
Calpicarpi non absimiles, dense fulvescentipubeseentes,coriaee®. — Tenasserim.
41. CoiUBEtNA PUBESCENS, nOV. Sp.
Frutex scandens, habitu omnino C. Asiatics, novellis dense fulvo-pubes-
centibus ; folia C. Asiatics sed juvenilia dense fulvo-pubescentia magis
minusve glabrescentia ; Soros parvi, viridiusculi, pedieellis lin. longis graci-
libus pubescentibus, cymas breves robustas fulvo-pubescentes axdlares
efformantes ; semina minora, compressa. — Pegu.
AMPELTBE2E.
42. VlTTS EBYTHBOCIADA, nov. sp.
Frutex alte scandens, ramulis terctibus fulvis novellisque parce pubes-
centibus ; folia decidua, digitatim — 5-foliolata, petiolis 4 — 5 pollicaribus
glabris instructa ; petiolulis 1 — 2 pollicaribus glabris gracilibus, lato-obovato-
oblonga, 4 — G poll, longa, breve acuminata, basi acuta, serrata, membranacea,
novella subtus secus nervos parce pubescentia mox glaberrima ; cirrhi biSdi ;
stipul®... ; Sores parvi, virescenti-Savi, pedieellis li — -3 linearibus puberu-
]is suffulti, cymulosi, cymam axillarem dichotomo-ramosam breviusculam
laxam puberulam magis minusve glabrescentem formantes ; calyx brevis,
puberulus ; potala et stamina 4 ; stylus simplex, subulatus ; bacc® globos®,
cerasi magnitudine. — Pegu, Martaban.
802
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants
[No. 4,
43. VlTTS ASSIMILIS, nov. sp.
Frutex alte scandens, glaber, ramis terotibus tuberculafcis ; folia petiolis
terotibus 1 1) poll, longis, constanter 3-foliolata ; foliola pctiolulis ( — 1 lin.
long.) crassis instructa, oblongo-lanceolata (lateralia obliqua et altero latero
basi rotundata) 3 — 4 poll, longa, acuta, crenato-dentata, coriacea, glabra ;
ilores parvi, virescenti-albi, hermaphroditi, pedicelbs lin. longis crassis dense
fulvo-pubescentibus suflulti, cy mam axillarem breve pedunculatam saspius
nutantem ramosissimam puberulam efformantes ; petala 4 ; ovarium sursum
in stylurn brevem crassum attenuatum, stigmata 4, brevia, patentia. — Mar-
taban.
44. Vitis campyiocaepa, nov. sp.
Frutex alte scandens, glaberrimus, ramis teretibus et cirrbis crassis
oppositifoliis ; folia digitatim 5— (—7 ?) foliolata, petiolis 2—3 poll, longis
laevibus ; foliola petiolulo — li pollicari gcniculatim inserta, obovata, basi
acuta sub-decurrentia (lateralia sub-obliqua), 4 — 6 poll, longa, abrupte acumi-
nata, remote et leviter crenato-dentata, succulente coriacea, glabra ; flores,
... in cymam dichotomo-ramosam brevissime pedunculatam v. subsessilem
glabram axillarem collecti ; baccse oblongse, ) poll, fere longae, subcurvatae,
laeves et lucidie, pedicellis lin. longis suflultae, semen solitarium colfciforme
sulcatum transverse lineatum includentes. — Pegu.
45. Yitis Wax,lichii, nov. sp.
Caulis teretiusculus, subherbaceus, glaber ; folia simplicia, petiolis 2—3
pollicaribus glabris subangulatis, cordato-oblonga v. oblonga, basi 5-nervia,
subtriloba, acuta, setaceo-serrata, membranacea, subtus in nervis parce
puberula, 6 — 7 poll, longa; eymae axillares, parviuscube, foliis multo
breviores, pedunculatae et paucirameae, glabraj ; flores... ; bacca) pisi minoris
magnitudine, globosae, longe (4 — 5 lin.) et crasse pedunculatae, monospermae.
— Ava.
46. Leea pumha, nov. sp.
Herba perennis pumila simplex dense fulvo-v. cinereo-pubescens ; folia
imparipinnata, adhuc juvenilia dense pubescentia ; rachis et petiolus teretes,
crassi ; foliola juniora bijuga cum nnpari, petiolulis brevissimis crassis tereti-
bus, ovato-oblonga, serrata, plicata, utrinque dense pubescentia v. subtomen-
tosa ; stipule magnae, petiolo adnata;, angustae, extus tomentoss ; cym;e
breves et compactiusculae, pubescentes, subsessiles v. pedunculo terete dense
pubescente suffultae, breviter ramosae ; flores (in alabastro) subsessiles ; calyx
tomentosus ; petala extus puberula. — Pegu.
BAP INI) A CP AS.
47. Cupanta Fuscmur.A, nov. sp.
Arbor, partibus omnibus puberulis ; folia vulgo abrupte pinnata v.
nnpan pinnata; rachis ferrugineo — tomentosa, exalata ; foliola c. 4 poll.
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
303
1872.]
longa, alterna, insequalia et subfalcata, oblongo-lanceolata, basi in petiolo
brevissimo crasso subdeeurrentia, apiculata, integra, chartacea, in sicco
fuscescentia v. nigreseentia, utrinque (prsesertim subtus) puberula ; bores
parvi, panieulas axillares ramosas ferrugineo-tomentosas folio breviores
formantes ; sepala oblongo-rotundata, eiliata et plerumque sparse hirtula ;
petala lato-oblonga, eiliata, squama supra ungue instructa bifida, intus lanata ;
stamina vix exserta; capsulae.... — Tenasserim.
48. CUPAHXA. GLABBATA, nov. sp.
Arbuscula glabra, 25 — 30 pedalis ; folia abrupte pinnata, brevius
petiolata, glaberrima et lucida ; foliola vulgo bijuga, laneeolata v. oblongo-
lanceolata, utrinque acuminata, 4 — 7 poll, longa, integra, subcoriacea, laxe
sed prominenter reticulata ; flores parvi, albi, pedicellis lin, longis instructi,
pauci fasciculati, paniculam axillarem glabram simplicem v. compositam
racemiformem efformantes ; sepala 5, rotundato-obovata, exteriora 2 majora
lin. fere longa, glabra, villoso-ciliata ; petala totidem, c. ) lin. longa, spatu-
lato-linearia, extus glabra, intus dense albo-lanuginosa ; ovarium fulveseenti-
hirsutum.- — Pegu, Martaban,
49. Nephemum Gbipeititiaitum, nov. sp.
Arbor, gemmis fulveseenti-velutinis ; folia glabra, impari-pinnata,
petiolis glabris 2 — 3 poll, longis glauccscentibus ; foliola 3 — 4 juga cum
impari, breve petiolulata, ovato-oblonga ad oblonga, basi insequali obtusa v.
subobtusa breve acuminata, chartacea, subtus glauca, reticulatione utrinque
conspicua et prominente ; flores... ; fructus (racemosi teste Griflithii) abortu
1- lobati, subsessiles, oblongi, ovi gallinaeei parviusculi magnitudine, murici
bus angulato-eompressis conieis g poll, fere longis tecti, semen unicum mag-
num arillo succulento albo indutum includentes. — Ava.
Zollingebia, nov. gen.
Calyx 5 — partitus, sepala decidua, insequalia, imbricata, interiora 2
majora. Petala totidem, subunguiculata, basi squama obtusa petalorum
dimidio breviori lanuginosa instructa. Stamina 8, disco obsoloto intus inserta;
filamenta non exserta, longa et gracilia ; anther® ovales, 2-loeulares, loculis
2- locellatis obtusis. Ovarium triquetrum, conicum, in stylum triquetrum
simplicem tridentsitum attonuata, 3-loculare, loculi uniovulati, ovulum a
medio axis centralis suspensum. Capsules magn:e, chartace®, maceratione
dissepimentomm vulgo 1-loculares, 3- v. abortu nonnunquam 2-alatse, sep-
ticide deliiscentes, semen solitarium v. duo continentes. Seminum testa
membranacea, cotyledones magnse, virides, plicatse. Albumen nullum.
Arbores ssepe magn® decidua; foliis impari-pinnatis foliolisque integris.
Flores parvi, albi, in panieulas breves ssepius compositas axillares collecti.
50. Zolexn gebia macbocaepa, n. sp.
Arbor usque 80 pedalis, novellis fulvo-puberulis ; folia vulgo iuipari-
rarius subabrupte pinnata, glabra ; foliola altema, basi magis minusve
304
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants. [No. 4,
inaequalia, petiolulis 2 — 3 lin. longis suffulta, lanceolata ad oblongo-lanceolata,
obtusiuscule acuminata, 5 — 8 poll, longa, chartacea, integra, laxc reticulata ;
flores albi, pediccllis 2 lin. longis, paniculas iis Nodonaece similes breves
subnutantes obsolete puberulas axillares v. terminales formantes ; sepala lin.
ciiciter longa, obovata, ciliolata, subemarginata; petala 2 lin. longa, cibata
oblonga, obtusa, basi unguieulata squama lanata obtusa aucta ; filamenta
pubescentia ; ovarium basi parce pubescens ; capsul® 2 poll, circiter long®,
oblongie, glabra), .3 v. raro abortu 2-alate, alis latis striatis basi angustatis
rotundatis apice sub trim eat is. — Prome.
51. Aceh isoioiujm, nov. sp.
Arbor magna, glabra ; folia 5 — 6 poll, longa et lata, basi rotundata,
*onge petiolata, 3-loba, lobis patentibus acuminatis, utrinque glabra, 3-
nervia et reticulata ; flores et fruetus ignoti. — Martaban.
SABIAOEM.
52. Sabia viHinissnrA, n. sp.
Frutcx glabcrrimus ; folia obovato- ad elliptieo-lanoeolata, petiolis 6 8
hn. longis, utrinque acuminata, membranacoa, glabra, G — 8 poll, longa;
flores parvi, albi, pedicellis c. 3 lin. gracilibus dein sursum incrassatis suffulti’
paniculas 1 v. 2 laxas breves glabras axillares efformantcs ; calyx glaber
segmentis ovatis obtusis ; petala 2-lin. fere longa; stylus 3-fidus, stigmati-
bus hippocrepiformibus ; fruetus . . . —Andamans.
ANA GAEL I A GEM.
53. Buchananta eaxifeoba, nov. sp.
Arbor decidua, novellis canescenti-tomentosis ; folia ovato-oblonga,
basi obtusa, G 7 poll, longa petiolo erasso semipollicari, coriacea, integra,
tomentella, supra glabrescentia ; flores minuti, pedicellis brevibus sed graci-
libus suffulti, in panieulam terminalcm laxam diffusam ramosissimam canes-
centi v. fulvescenti-pubescentem collecti; bractese minutso, subulate; calyx
canescenti-puborulus, lobis oblongis acutis vix i Hn. longis ; petala obovato-
oblonga, vix liueam longa; iilamenta subpuberula; ovarium glabrum.—
Martaban.
54. Semecaiipus subbacemosa, nov. sp.
Fruticosa ? novellis fulvo-puberulis ; folia verosimiUter decidua, dis-
tantia, oblonga v. oblongo-lanceolata, obtusa v. obtusiuscula, basi in petio-
lum latum 1 poll, longum glabrum subdecurrentia, c. 3 — 4 poll, longa,
Integra, tenui-ehartaeea, supra glaucina, glabra et nitentia, subtus glauca°et
um juvenilia minute puberula, dein in costa crassa nervisque paralleUs anas-
omosantibus puberula, retieulatione laxa et conspicua interjecta ; flores
parvi, pedicellis brevissimis dense puberuHs suffulti, fasciculato-cymulosi,
pamculam gracilHmam puberulam v. subpubescentem axillarem et ramorum
JS72.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
305
apices terminantem ramosam formautes ; calyx pubcrulus ; petala 5, lineam
circiter longa, valvata ; stamina 5. omnia fertilia, filamentis capillaribus ;
discus hispido-tomentellus ; ovarium glabrum stylis 3 crassis apicibus
capitato-stigmatosis coronatum ; nux.... — Pegu.
55. Hoeigaena Geahamii (Semecarpus Grahamii, Wight, Fc. t. 235).
Arbor 20 — 30 pedalis, novellis pubescentibus ; folia 1 — 2] ped. longa,
elongato-obovato-lanceolata, basi cuneato-acuminata, petiolo i — 1 poll,
longo erasso utrinque appendicibus barbseformibus gcminis augmento, breve
acuminata, iutogra, coriacea, juvenilia molli-pubcscentia, dein supra glabres-
centia subtusquo glaueescentia et obsolete puberula ; flores parvi, subsessiles,
dense ferragineo-tomentosi, paniculas breviusculas dein elongatas dense ferru-
gineo-tomentosas axillares efformantes ; bracteobe lineares, intus glabrse,
deciduae ; calycis lobi lanceolati, utrinque ferrugineo-pubescentes, pedi-
celli brevissimi sub fructu usque ad i poll. long, olongati ; nucis elliptico-
obovatffi monospermsB pars summa tantum exserta. — Pegu, Martaban.
CONN ABA CINE.
56. ET.LirANTiius CAT.opitTr.r.rs, Kuiz, Andam. Rep. Append. B. 6.
Arbuscula 20 — 30 pedalis glabra gemmis fulvo-pubescentibus ; folia
unifoliolata, petiolis glabris pollicaribus suffulta ; foliola brevissime et crasse
petiolata, ovato-oblonga v. oblonga, obtusiuscule acuminata, 5 — 6 poll,
longa, subcoriacea, integra, glaberrima, ncrvis subtus rubescentibus, utrinque
crebre et eleganter reticulata ; llores mediocres, pedicellis strictis brevibus
dense puberulis geniculatis ; racemi vix pollieares, dense fulvo-puberuli ;
petala lineari-oblonga, dense tomentella, plus quam 3 lin. longa ; folliculi
oblique oblongi, in stipitem brevem et crassum attenuati, apiculati, compres-
siusculi, pollicem circiter longi, velutino-tomentosi, coriacei, intus glabri.
Andamans.
57. Eliipaothus tomentosus, nov. sp.
Arbuscula ramulis dense fulvo-tomentosis ; folia unifoliolata, petiolis
circ. semipollicaribus dense fulvo-pubescentibus ; foliola oblonga ad oblongo-
lanceolata et lanceolata, breve obtusequo acuminata, 4 — 6 poll, longa, inte-
gra, coriacea, supra glabra, nitentia et eleganter reticulata, subtus plus minus-
ve fulvo- v. flavescenti-tomentosa, nonnunquam glabrescentia ; flores parvi-
usculi, pedicellis tomentosis brovissimis crassis geniculatis instructi ; racemi
breves, tomentosi, axillares, ramosi, ssepius panieulaeformes ; petala oblonga,
obtusa, dense tomentella, 2 bn. circiter longa ; folliculi oblique oblongi,
apiculati, compressiusculi, bipollicares, in stipitem longiusculum crassum
attenuati. — Pegu, Martaban, Tenasserim , Siam.
38
30G
S. Kurz — Neiv Burmese Blunts.
[No. 4,
BOSAOEAE.
58. Pygetjm perstmibe, nov. sp.
Arbor, novellis parce adpresse pubescentibus v. puberulis ; folia elliptica
ad elliptico lanceolata, petiolo 3 lin. longo gracili ferrugineo-pubescenti sufful-
ta basi obtusa sequalia v. subaequalia, obtuse et saepius longissime acuminata,
integra, submembranacea, supra glabra v. secus nervos impressas minute
tomentella, subtus secus costam adpresse pubescentia ; racerni sublanuginoso-
tomentosi, bini v. terui supra foliorum delapsorum cicatricibus v. irregu-
lariter e rarnis orientes ; pedicelli brevissimi, semilineam longi ; calycis tu-
bus brevis, urceolatus, fulvo-tomentosus ; ovarium dense fulvo-hirsutum ;
stylus longe exsertus stigmate lato. B. Lampongo, Mig., proximum. — Ten-
nasserim,
59. Piece Karensium, nov. sp.
Arbuscula 25 — 30 pedalis, glabra ; folia oblonga ad ovato-oblonga,
basi inasqualia, petiolo c. pollicari glaberrimo, acuminata, 4 — 5 poll, longa,
subcoriacea, apicem versus crenato-dentata, glabra ; flores... ; poma cerasi
majoris maguitudine, globosa, iis B. Bashice subconformia et leucosticta,
maturescentia purpureo-atra, podicellis brevissimis crassis suffulta, in pani-
culam depauporatam robustam glabram terminalem v. in axillis foliorum
superiorum lateralem disposita. — Martaban.
60. Eriobotrya ? macrocarpa, nov. sp.
Arbor 30 — 40 pedalis, glabra ; folia obovato- ad oblongo-lanceolata, basi
in petiolum i — | poll, longum crassum attenuata, breve et obtuse acuminata,
integerrima, 5 — 6 poll, longa, coriaeea, lsevissima et lucida ; flores... ; pedun-
culi fructigeri crassissimi et simplices, 1 — 2 poll, longi, glabri, ex axillis
foliorum superiorum orientes v. in ramulis crassis terminales ; fructus magis
minusve globosi, cerasi majoris magnitudine, glabri, calycis limbo coronati.
— Begu.
COMBBETA CEAE.
61. CoMBRETUM TETRAGONOCARPCM, nov. Sp.
Erutex scandens glaber ; folia petiolo crasso lin. longo suffulta, oblonga
ad elliptico-oblonga, obtusa v. subretusa, cliartacea, utrinque conspicue
nervosa et reticulata, glabra, 3 — 5 poll, longa ; spicse robust®, fulvo-villo-
sse, solitariae, foliis breviores v. sequilongse, axillares v. in paniculas termi-
nales braebiatas depauperatas dispositse ; flores parvi, albidi, bracteola parva
subulata villosa sustenti ; calyx cupulari-infundibuliformis cum tubo ovali
brevi ferrugineo-villosulus ; limbus intus dense villosus, extus pubescens et
lepidotus, 4-dentatus, dentibus brevibus acutis ; petala minuta ; fructus
pollicem longi v. longiores, glabri, pallide brunnei, elliptico-ovati, 4-angu-
lati, angulis crassis coriaceis et sub-alato-prominentibus, nucis diametro
multo angustioribus. — Begu.
1872.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
307
MELA STOMA CEAi.
62. Memecylov eeegaks, nov. sp.
Frutex glaberrimus ramulis sub 4-alatis v. lineis 4 decurrentibus magis
minusve obsolete elevatis notatis ; folia oblonga ad ovato-oblonga, basi in
petiolum 2 — 3 lin. longum attenuata, obtusa v. subretusa, 3 — 4 poll, longa,
coriacea, nervis lateralibus teneris in statu juvenili tantum visibilibus, gla-
bra ; flores azurei, pedicellis 2 — 3 lin. longis suflfulti, cymam umbelliformem
simplicem vel tricbotomam pedunculo } — } poll, longo acute tetragono
suffultam efformantes, et bin® v. solitari® ex foliorum axillis v. supra folio-
rum delapsorum eicatricibus orientes ; ramilicationes brevissim® v. sub-
reduct® ; calyx lsevis, 1£ lin. fere in diametro, parte adnata hemispherica
parva, limbus latus et explanatus, undulatus et obsolete lobatus, intus radia-
to-plicatus, plicis subnerviformibus ; petala, baccse &c. desiderantur.- — Anda-
mans.
63. Memecylox peteciirum, nov. sp.
Frutex glaberrimus ramulis sub-teretibus ; folia larga, sessilia, lato
ovato-oblonga, basi rotundata v. suboordata, obtusa v. paulo obtuse pro-
ducta et subretusa, 5 — 6 poll, longa, crasse coriacea, nervis venisve haud
visibilibus, glabra, supra lucida ; flores azurei, pedicellis ^ — 2} lin. longis
teretibus, depauperato-umbellulati, cymam ampliusculam pedunculo com-
presso 4-gono | — 1 poll, longo suffultam formantes, vulgo tern® v. 4-nse
supra foliorum delapsorum eicatricibus orientes ; bracte® distinct®, ovato-
laneeolat®, aeutse ; calyx campanulatus, c. 1 lin. in diametro, lasvis, lim-
bus truncatus, intus radiato-plicatus ; petala, baccse etc. desunt. — Andamans.
LYTIIBABIE2E.
64. Lageestecemia htpoeeuca, Kurz in And. Eep. 1868, Append,
p. VIII.
Arbor vasta 60 — 70 pedalis glaberrima ; folia lanceolata ad ovato-lan-
ceolata, basi in petiolum brevem decurrentia, acuminata, integra v. undulata,
chartacea, 6 — 8 poll, longa, subtus albido-glauca ; flores mediocres, 1 — 1}
poll, in diametro, lilaeini, pedicellis articulatis albido-puberis instructi, soli-
tarii v. in cymas depauperatas breve pedunculatas minute canescenti-pube-
ras collecti et paniculam elongatam tcrminalem formantes ; calyx in alabas-
tro turbiuatus, pubescentia subvelutina miriuta albescens, sulcato 10-cos-
tatus, costis altornantibus in 5 lobos triangulares minute mueronatos excur-
rentibus ; petala oblonga, undulata, £ poll, longa ; capsula oblonga, mucro-
nata, lign®, e. | poll, longa. — Andamans.
65. Laoeestecemia calycitlata, nov. sp.
Arbor vasta, 60 — 70 pedalis, novellis tomentosis ; folia oblonga, acu-
minata, basi insequali rotundata et in petiolum brevem subdecurrentia,
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants. [No. 4,
5—7 poll, louga, subeoriaoea, supra glabra et minute reticulata, subtus
puberula ct inter nerves prominentes erasse reticulata; flores... ; panieube
ferrugineo v. fulvo-tomentosae, terminales, e racemis longioribus v. brevior-
ibus composite ; calyx fructigerus eupulari-eampanulatus, capsulam arete
amplectens, 2 2$ lin. altus, teres, absque costis v. sulcis dense ferrugineo-
tomentosus, pedicello brevissimo crasso instructus, 6-lobatus, lobis brevibus
ti iangularibus reflexis planis acutis ; capsula oblonga, mucronulata, lucida,
Pro i § parte e calyce protrusa, 6-locularis et -valvis, 3 — 4j lin. longa.
— Martaban.
SAMTDA CBM.
60. Homaiittji minutifloeum, nov. sp.
Aiboi glabra ; folia oblonga, petiolo 3 — 4 lin. longo crasso, obtuse
apiculata, 3 — 5 poll, longa, grosse crenata, tenuiter coriacea, glabra ; flores
minuti, % lin. cire. in diametro, pedicellis brevibus filiformibus glabris in-
structi, fasciculati, racemos solitarios v. binos axillares simplices v. parce
ramosos glabros formantes ; calyx glaber, segmentis oblongo-linearibus
villoso-ciliatis ; filamenta gracillima, singula petalis opposita .—Martaban ?
CUCURBlTACEsE.
67. Tbichosanthes macbosiphon, nov. sp.
Herba volubilis parce et minute puberula ; folia cordato-ovata, petiolo
la 2 pollicari puberulo, 6 — 8 poll, longa, basi sinuato-cordata, obsolete
remote repando-dentata, siepius in lobos 2 laterales acuminatos producta,
acuminatissima, herbacea, glabra, subtus sparse et minute puberula ; flores
masculi desunt ; feminei solitarii, axillares, pedicello puberulo brevi in-
stiucti ; calyx puberulus, supra ovario in tubum 1 k poll, longum gracilem
attymuatus, dentes lineari-subulati, puberuli ; petala fimbriata.- Tenasserim.
BEGONIA CEJE.
68. Begonia flaccidissima, nov. sp.
Herbula flaccidissima tenora caulescens, 4 — 5 pollicaris, minute et spar-
se pubescens ; folia alterna, cordato-orbicularia, obtusa, petiolo 2—3 poll,
longo gracili sparse pubescente, c. 2 poll, longa et lata, grosse crenato-den-
tata et sublobata, tenerrime membranacea et flaccida, utrinque pilis minutis
teneris adspersa ; stipulie oblongse, hyalime, obtusie, c. 2 lin. longa; ;
flores parvi, albi, pedicellis eapillaribus instructi, cymas dicliotomo-ramosas
sparse ct minute pubeseentes pedunculo petioli dimidio longitudine axillari
giacili suflultas lormantes ; bractea? minuta?, lin cares ; sepala in maribus
r°tundato-ovata, c. 2 i lin. longa ; petala nulla ; perianthii lobi fl. femin.
4, sepalis subconformia ; stamina numcrosa, subobovata, filamenta usque ad
medium fere in columuam brevem gracilem connata ; styli 2, a basi liberi,
apice in laminam concavam semilunatam stigmatifero-marginatam dilatati ;
1872.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
309
ovarium sparse et crispato-pilosum, 2-loculare, ovatum, acuminatum ; cap-
suite. . . . — Tenasserim.
UMBFLLIFEBJE.
69. PiMPiifELLA Paeishiaata, nov. sp.
Herba bumilis 1 — 2 pedalis pilis brevibus adspersa ; folia ternatisecta,
petiolo basi vaginante, foliola cordato-ovata, magis minusve 3- lobata, acu-
minata, grosse duplicato-serrata, 3 — 3i poll, longa, pilis brevibus albis
adspersa, foliola lateralia petiolulo subpollieari, medianum petiolulo sub 2 —
pollicari suffulta, folia superiora sensim minora, integra et supra petiolum
vaginantem sessilia ; llores albi, pedieellis 2 lin. longis strictis puberulis inserti,
involucellato umbellulati, umbellam involucratam compositam fonuantes ;
involucri ot involucelli foliola linearia, longa, et ssepius apicem versus in
dentes 2 laterales producta ; fruetus.... — Tenasserim.
70. HeBACLEUM liAEMAXICUM, nov. sp.
Herba robusta annua 4 — 6 pedalis, caulibus liirsutis ; folia caulina
superiora ternatipinnata, foliola lateralia ovato-lanceolata, sessilia, grosse
serrata et ssepe in lobum lateralem producta, foliolo terminali petiolato
decurrenti 3-lobo serrato-lobato ; involucri foliola linearia, brevia ; meri-
carpia 3 lin. eirciter longa, elliptico-oblonga, lato-marginata. — Pegu.
I OP ANT II A GFjK
71. Lobanthus iiypoo laughs, nov. sp.
Frutcx parasiticus glaberrimus ; folia opposita v. subopposita, lanceolata
ad elliptico-lanceolata, in petiolum brevem attenuata, magis minusve acu-
minata, integra, 2| — 3 poll, longa, coriacea, nervis lateralibus vix conspicuis,
glabra, subtus glauea ; llores — 1|- poll, longi glabri, pulcherrime coccinei,
pedieellis 2 lin. longis instrueti, geminatim v. ternatim pedunculis brevibus
glabris sulfulti et fascicules 2 v. plures axillares formantos ; bractea et brac-
teolse 2 parvas, triangulari-ovatffi, basi unitee ; calyx glaber, cylindricus,
limbo integro truncato ; corolla glabra, tubo curvulo et leviter ampliato,
limbo profunde 6-fido, lobis linearibus reflexis ; stamina 6 ; antlierse linea-
res ; filamenta stylusque gracillimus, filiformis, glabri ; baccae.... — Martaban.
72. G in a lloa Axdamaxica, nov. sp.
Frutex parasiticus glaberrimus ramis dicbotomo-ramosis ; folia oppo-
sita, obovalia ad ovali-oblonga, basi subobliqua in petiolum brovissimum
crassum planum contracts, apico rotundata, integra, subundulata, crasse co-
riacea, nervis 3 — 5 in sicco vix conspicuis, If — 2 poll, longa, glabra ; flores
ininuti, dioici ? sessiles, terni v. .quatemi (v. plures f ) separatim in rbacbidis
crassse genieulis dilatatis cpasi involucrantibus iinmersi ; spicte 1 — 4 polli-
cares, robusti, glabri, e fureationibus ramorum orientcs, v. tcrminales ; calycis
limbus obsolctus v. nullus ? ; petala 3, minuta, 3-angularia, conniventia ? ;
310
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
[No. 4,
stigma ohsolete conieurn, parvum ; bacc® immaturae elongato-ovat®, las-
ses, truncat® v. petalis diutius persistentibus coronatae. — Andamans.
RUB I ACE, E.
73. Wenbiandia glomerui.ata, nov. sp.
Ai’bor v. frutex ? novellis indistincte puberulis ; stipulae foliaceae, cor-
datae ; folia lineari-lanceolata ad lanceolata, in petiolum brevissimum 1 — 3
lin. longum puberulum attenuata, longe acuminata, 3 — 4 poll, longa, in-
tegra, membranacea, glabra, subtus secus costam minute adpresse pubes-
centia ; flores... sessiles, in fasciculos breve pednnculatos congregati et pani-
culam terminalem parce pubescentem brachiatam formantes ; calyx fructi-
ger adpresse pubescens, deutibus li neari-lanceolatia apparenter tubo lon-
gioribus ; capsul® globos®, lineam vix long®, pubescentes. — Tenasserim. ‘
74. Wendlandia scabba, nov. sp.
Arbor seabro-pubescens ; stipule cordato-reniformes, semiamplexi-
caules ; folia obovato-elliptica ad elliptica, basi acuta v. acuminata, petiolo
i — I longo brevi pubescente instructa, breve et obtuse acuminata, 3 — 4
poll, longa, Integra, membranacea, utrinque scabro-puberula ; flores minuti,
albi, sessiles, in spiculas congregati et paniculam amplam puberulam bra-
chiatam terminalem formantes ; calyx adpresse hispidus, semilineam vix
longus, dentibus parvis, 3 angulari-acutis ; corolla glabra, 1 — L j lin. longa,
lobis brevibus , capsul® globos®, lin. in diametro, minute adpresse his-
pid®.— Am.
75. Aesostemma sonebieoides, nov. sp.
Herba annua succulenta cauli simplici apice folioso plus minusve villo-
sulo , lolia subvertieillata, ovata ad subcordata, petiolo brevissimo crasso
villoso, 1 — 2 j poll, longa, acuta v. obtusiuseula, utrinque pilis brevibus albis
adspersa et subtus seous nervos pubeseentia ; flores parvi, pallide rosei v.
albi, pedicello lineari villoso instructi, umbellam parvam villosam v. cymam
umbellatam pedunculo 1 — ,j- pollicari villoso terminali sustentam formantes
v. rarissime solitarii v. subsolitarii ; bracte® vulgo majuscule, 2— 4-nae in-
volucre specialia efformantes ; calyx villoso-pubescens, 3 lobus, lobis lato-
triangularibus ; corolla subcampanulata, 3-loba, lobis lineam tantum longis j
anther® oblong®, obtus®. — Pegu ; Andamans.
76. Spibadiciis bifida, nov. sp.
Herba annua erecta parce ramosa 1 — 1 i pedalis, caulibus puberulis ;
folia obovato-lanceolata, basi cuneata et in petiolum i — ^ pollicarem magis
minusve pubescentem decurrentia, 2 — 5 poll, longa, breve acuminata, in-
tegra membranacea, glabra v. subtus secus nervos puberula ; flores minuti,
albi, sessiles, in spicas longiores v. breviores bilidas collecti et in paniculam
plus minusve puberulam elongatam terminalem dispositi ; capsul® globoso-
2- lob®, lin. circiter in diametro. — Martaban.
1872.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
811
77. Ophioehiza GiuctLis, nov. sp.
Herba annua, erecta, simplex j — 1 pedalis, glaberrima ; folia oblongo-
lanceolata ad lanceolata, basi acuminata, petiolo gracili i — 1 poll, longo,
longe acuminata, 3 — 5 poll, longa, integra, membranacea, glaberrima, sub-
tus pallida ; flores parvi, albi, pedicellis brevissimis instructi et sessiles, spi-
cam secundam bifidam form antes et in cymam longe pedunculatam termi-
nalem glaberrimam gracilem dispositi ; bracte® et braeteol® lineari-subu-
lat®, parv® ; corolla glabra, tubo circa 3- lineari, lobis obtusis, — Tenasserim.
78. IIedqotis Andamantca, nov. sp.
Herba annua subsimplex v. ramosa erecta, j — 1 pedalis, ramis minute
puberulis ; stipule lat®, apice longifimbriat®, puberal® ; folia variabilia,
ovata ad oblonga et obovata, basi acuta v. in petiolum 1 — 3 lin. longum
puberulum attenuata, membranacea, 1 — 2 poll, longa, obtusa v. subobtusa,
saepius cum mucrone, integra v. undulata, subtus secus nervos minute pu-
berula ; flores parvi, albi, subsessiles, glomerati ; capitula pedunculo longo,
solitaria, v. vulgo in cymam laxam tricbotomam puberulam disposita, axil-
laria et terminalia ; calyx subglaber, lobis linearibus lineam fere longis et
calycis tubo longioribus ; capsule compresso-didym®, semiorbilucares, circ.
2 lin. in diametro, pilis adpressis minutis adspers®, carinis 4 nonnunquam
subuliformibus notat® et calycis lobis lanceolatis longis coronat®. — An-
damans.
79. W FTiTMf A GIOMEBIFLOEA, nOV. Sp.
Arbuscula 20 — 30 pedalis, glabra v. gommis pubeseentibus ; stipul®
eaducse ; folia obovato-lanceolata ad elliptieo-lanceolata, basi acuminata,
petiolo 2 — 4 lin. longo glabro, 3 — 4 poll, longa, acuta v. apiculata, integra,
crasse membranacea, glabra, crassinervia ; flores subsessiles, in cymam ter-
minalem subsessilem pubescentem conglomerati ; calyx pubescens ; corolla... ;
baccaa atr®, globos® v. ovoide®, pisi minoris magnitudine, laves, basi caly-
cis limbi coronat®, pedicello lineam circiter longo suffult®. — Pegu.
80. Gaedehia ebytheoclada, nov. sp.
Arbuscula rigida 15 — 25 pedalis, trunco ramisque lateritiis et spinis
oppositis (ramulis reductis) armatis, novellis pubeseentibus ; stipule cadu-
cissimse ; folia obovato- ad cuneato-obovata, basi swpius in»quali in petiolum
a — 1 poll, longum pubescentem deeurrontia, 4 — 6 poll, longa, obtusa, integra
v. subintegra, membranacea, utrinque (pnesertim subtus) pubescentia ; flores
viridiusculi, dimorphi, fertiles in individuis iisdem v. separatis solitarii, sessiles
v. subsessiles, apicibus ramorum abbreviatorum crassorum terminantes, fl. ber-
maphrodito-steriles pedicellis longis gracilibus pubeseentibus instructi, fasci-
culos sessiles v. breviter pedunculatos terminates v. subaxillares formantes ;
calyx pubescens, tubo in fl. fertilibus magis evoluto, lobis foliaceis, obovatis,
4 — 6 lin. longis ; corolla pubescens, tubo brevi amplo ; »bacc® florum fer-
tilium sessiles, ovi anatis magnitudine, ovoide®, scabreseentes, bruunese ob-
312
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
[No. 4,
solete-costat® ; oaj 11. sterilium pedunculo 1 \ — 2 poll, longo stricto brunneo-
pubescente s n f 1 1 1 ; . cerasi minoris magnitudine, magis minus ve globosae,
calycis limbo rnagno foliaceo coronatse. — Ava, Pegu. &c.
81. Gardenia dasycabpa, nov. sp.
Arbuscula rigida spinis oppositis longis strictis armata, 12—15 pedalis,
novellis villoso-pubescentibus ; stipulae deciduas ; folia obovato-oblonga, basi
acuta v. acuminata, petiolo 1—2 lin. longo instrueta, 1—2 poll, longa, In-
tegra, obtusa v. acuta, coriacea, supra rctrorse puberula, subtus adpresse
villoso-pubescentia ; flores...8essiles, solitarii e ramulorum crassorum verru-
ciformium apicibus ; baec® globos®, corticosse, pomini mayoris magnitudine,
calycis limbo tubulari coronatse. — Prome, Tcnasserim.
82. Gardenia hygrophiia, nov. sp.
Fruticulus 1 3 pedalis, ramis ssepius diffusis, glaberrimus ; stipulse
connatae, glabrae v. sparse hirsutae ; folia obovata ad obovato- et elliptico-
oblonga, basi acuta, petiolo 2 — 3 lin. longo gracili, obtusa v. acuta, 2 — 21-
poll. longa, integra, membranaeea, supra lucida, glabra ; flores mediocres,
albi, iu sicco nigrcscentia, subsessiles, solitarii ex apicibus ramulorum v. in
eorum furcatiouibus ; calyx glaber v. parco adpresse pubescens, 4 lin. fere
longus, limbo campanulato, 5-fido, lobis lincari-lanceolatis acuminatis sparse
eiliatis; corolla lineam circiter longa, subirregulari-campanulato-infundi-
buliformis, lobis insequalibus c. \ poll, longis ; bacc;e — Pegu , Siam.
83. Gardenia pulcherrima, nov. sp.
Aidior 30 35 pedalis, glabra ; stipulie lato-triangulares,liberse v. sub-
liberse ; folia lato- ad oblongo-lanceolata v. elliptico-oblonga, basi acuta,
petiolo crasso 3 4 lin. longo, 3 — 5 poll, longa, breve acuminata, integra,
coriacea, glaberrima, subtus in nervorum axillis glandulosa ; flores magni
ct speciosi, pedicello 2 — 3 lin. longo bracteato tomentoso instructi, terni
v. plurcs cymam breve pedunculatam fulvescente tomentosam in ramulorum
furcationibus v. pseudo-axillarem formantes ; calyx c. 3— 3J lin. longus,
tomentosus, limbo amplo 5-dentato, dentibus ovatis acutis ; corolla glabra,
alba, intus in (undo roseo-punctata, 1J- poll, longa, v. paullo longior, supra
tubo brevissimo ventricoso-efllata ; baccae globes®, aurantii minoris magni-
tudine, corticosse et scabr®, brunnese, calycis limbo coronatse. — Andamans.
84. Acranthera dnifloea, nov. sp.
Herba perenuis 4 — 6 poll, alta v. altior, parce pubescens ; folia ovalia
ad ovali-lancoolata, basin obtusam v. rotundatam versus attenuata, petiolo
gracili pubesceute suffulta v. superiora subscssilia, 1 — L i poll, longa, meni-
branacea, obtusiuscula v. acuta, integra, supra parce adpresse hirsuta, sub-
tus secus nervos spai’se pubescentia ; flores majuseuli, albi, solitarii, sessiles
v. subsessiles, terminates ; calyx fulvo-adpresse-hirsutus, tubo 2 lin. fere
longo, lobis linearibus, 2 — 2.V lin. longis ; corolla hypocraterimorpha, tubo
pollicem fere longo, adpresse pubescento, lobis dimidio longis elliptico-ovatis
1872.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
313
acutis ; stylus profunde bifidus ; baccaj ellipticfe, pisi magnitudine, hirsu-
tissimas, calycis lobisdinearibus terminate. — Tenasserim.
85. Ubophthttm bilocular®, nov. sp.
Arbor 25 — 30 pedalis, glabra ; stipulso e basi lata subulato-acuminatse.
parce adpresse pubescentes ; folia oblongo-lanceolata ad lato-lanceolata, basi
acuminata, petiolo 1 — 2 lin. longo suffulta, obtuse acuminata, 4 — 5 poll,
longa, integra, ebartaeea, glabra ; llores minuti, sessiles, in fasciculos parvos
axillares collecti ; calyx (in alabastro) truncatus, minute puberulus ; baccse
globosse, aurantiacae, pisi minoris magnitudine, obsolete bilobse, calycis limbo
brevi coronatse, 2-loculares ; semina in loculo singulo 3 — 4, nigra, majuscula,
placentae eentrali medio aflixa. — Martaban.
86. MORTNDA LEIANTHA, nov. sp.
Arbuscula ? scabrido-pubescens ; stipulse ovato-lanceolatse, acuminatse,
scabrse ; folia oblongo-lanceolata ad lanceolata, basi acuta v. acuminata, petio-
lo scabro 1 — 11 poll, longo sulfulta, 5 — 8 poll, longa, acuminata, integra v.
sub integra, ehartacea, utrinque prsesertim subtus scabrido et parce pubes-
centia ; flores albi, majusculi, sessiles, in capitula parva oblonga pedunculata
solitaria v. pluria ex axillis foliorum superiorum orientia v. terminalia con-
glomerati ; calyx truncatus ; corolla hypocraterimorpha, glabra, fauce gla-
bra, tubo gracili £ poll, circiter longo, lobis ovato-lanceolatis ; baccse
— Tenasserim.
87. MoiumtA wallichii, nov. sp.
Arbuscula ? , glaberrima ; stipulse... ; folia oblongo-lanceolata ad ob-
longo-linearia, utrinque acuminata, petiolo 1 — li poll, longo, 3 — 5 poll, lon-
ga,.integra, crasse membranacea, glabra, subtus pallida ; flores parviusculi,
albi, terni v. quaterni in capitula parva cymam terminalem glabram stricte
pedunculatam formantia collecti ; calyx truncatus ; corolla glabra, tubo (in
alabastro) \ poll, longo, lobis sequilongis, oblongo-linearibus obtusiusculis.
— Tenasserim.
88. PsiLOBTUM CAPILLABE, nov. sp.
Arbuscula 20—25 pedalis, glaberrima, lucida ; stipulse acuminatae, ri-
gidse ; folia variabilia, iis Pavettce parviflorce similia, lanceolata ad oblongo-
lanceolata et elliptieo-oblonga, basi acuta, petiolo brevissimo 1 — 3 lin. longo
suffulta v. subsessilia, magis minusve acuminata v. subobtusa, 3 — 5 poll,
longa, integra v. undulata, rigide sed tenui coriacea, utrinque lsevia et luci-
da ; flores parvi, albidi, sessiles v. subsessiles, pauci v. numerosi in capi-
tulum parvum basi bracteis paucis lineari-subulatis rigidis involucratum
peduneulatum congregati ; pedunculi axillares v. supra-axillares, solitarii,
strict!, graciles v. capillares, 1 — 2 poll, longi, sursum sensim incrassati ;
calyx lineam circiter in diametro, cupularis, 4-dentatus, dentibus triangu-
laribus ciliolatis ; corolla brevis, hypocraterimorpha, fauce dense villosa,
tubo I-? lin. circiter longo ; baccfc — Pegu ; Martaban ; Tenasserim.
39
314
S. Kurz — New Parmese Plants.
[No. 4,
89. Vattgitebta pitbescens, nov. sp.
Arbuscula decidua, 20 — 25 podalis, pubescens, spinis oppositis rectis ar-
mata ; is ti pul to subulat®, pubescentes ; folia ovata ad elliptico-lanceolata,
basi acuta v. cuneata, petiolo 2 — 3 lin. longo pubescente, breviter acuminata
v. acuta, 2 — 3 poll, longa, integra, membranacea, supera breve et scabrido-
subtus molli-pubesceutia ; flores parvi, viridiusculi, pedicellis 2 — 3 lin. longis
pubescentibus, in cymulas v. fasciculos e ramulis reductis verrucil'ormibus v.
ex foliorum axillis ortos dispositi ; calyx pubescens, lobis linearibus ; co-
rolla pubescens ; stigma capitatum ; baccse cerasi minoris maguitudine,
1 — I poll, crassse, laves, lutescetites, pyrer.as 5- — 4 osseas monospermas con-
tinentes. — Parma.
90. Cantu nm geacilipes, nov. sp.
Frutex inermis, ramulis parce pubescentibus ; stipulte ovata, subu-
lato-acuminatse, adpresse fulvo-pubescentes ; folia ovato-oblonga ad oblongo-
lanceolata, basi acuta v. obtusa, petiolo tenui 1 — 2 lin. longe pubescente
sufiulta, 2 — 4 poll, longa, integra, acuminata, membranacea, nervis fulvo et
tenui pubescentibus exceptis glabra ; flores parvi, pedicellis | — f poll, longis
capillaribus sparse adpresse pubescentibus instructi, solitarii v. gemini, e
ramulis abbreviatis lateralibus orientes 5 calyx glaber, bemispbajricus, £ lin.
longus, dentibus 3-angularibus ; corolla... ; drupse didymo-reniformes, apice
siiiuatso, compressiuscula), lseves, pyrenas 2, (v. abortu 1) obsolete rugoso-
tuberculatas dorso rotmidatas includentes. — Andamans.
91. Gynochthodes macboph v’lla, nov. sp.
Frutex scarldens, glaber, partibus omnibus in sicco nigrescentibus ;
stipulae geminatse et breves, truncatse ; folia elliptica ad elliptico-oblonga,
basi acuta, petiolo semipollicari sustenta, magis minusve obtusiuscule apicu-
lata, 3 — 5 poll, longa, integra, pergamacea, glabra, subtus in axillis nervorum
fimbriato-glandulosa ; flores parvi, pedicello crasso 2 — 3 lin. longo sustenti,
4 — 5-ni in pedunculo verruciformi breve bracteato fasciculati ; calyx lineam
circiter longus, glaber, tubo subgloboso, limbus tnmeatus, cyatbiformis, tubi
longitudinis ; corolla &c. ignota. — Andamans.
92. Psyctiotbia Helfeiuana, nov. sp.
Frutex fulvo- v. brunneo-hirsutus ; stipulte lanceolatae, acuminatte, fere ad
basin bifidte, dense adpresse ferrugiueo-hirsutae ; folia lanceolata, utrinque ac-
euminata, petiolo adpresse brunneo-hirsuto — 1 pollicari sustenta, 3 — 4-|
poll, longa, integra, membranacea, utrinque breve-hirsuta ; flores minuti, vire-
scenti albidi, sessiles, in capitulas densas breve pedunculatas congregati et cy-
mam compactiusculam v. laxam triehotomam ferrugineo-hirsutam termi-
nalem (et axillarem ?) formantes ; calyx brunneo-birsutus, lineam circiter
longus, dentibus lanceolatis ; corolla glabra, fauce barbata, tubus lineam fere
longus, lobi tubi longitudinis ; baccse ovales, calycis limbo hirsute coronat*
1872.]
S. Kims — New Burmese Blunts.
315
pisi magnitudine, sparse hirsut®, aurantiaese ; pyrene cariuato-triangulares j
albumen sequum. — Tenasserim or Andamans. (?)
93. PsrCHOTBIA MONTTCORA, nov. sp.
Frutex bumilis 1 — 3 pedalis glaber ; stipule bifid®, lanceolat® v. a basi
lata acuminate, decidua! ; folia lanceolate ad oblongo-lanceolata, utrinque acu-
minata, pctiolo — 1 pollicari, 4 — 6 poll, longa, integra, crasse membranacea,
glabra, paullulo glaucescentia ; ilores parvi, albi, sessiles, in capitula 3 breve
pedunculata v. subsessilia bracteata dense congregati et cymatn depaupe-
ratam pedunculo erasso s®pius villosido J — 11 pollicari suflultam termi-
nalem v. e ramulorum furcationibus orientem formantes ; calyx lineam cireiter
longus, glaber v. obsolete pubescenti-ciliatus, 5-fidus, lobis lanceolatis subu-
lato-acuminatis ; corolla glabra, finite villosa, tubus lineam cireiter longus,
lobi tubi longitudinis ; baccse oblongae, pisi magnitudine, rubrae, lucid®,
calycis limbo coronal ;e ; pyrense longitudinaliter sulcat® et costatse (costis
3 — 4) ; albumen epurie ruminatum. — Martaban, Tenasserim.
94. PSYCIIOTIUA VIHIDISSIMA, nov. Sp.
Fruticulus 11 — 2 pedalis glaberrimus ; stipulm verosimiliter lato- et bre-
ve triangulares, valde deciduae ; folia ovato-oblonga ad elliptico-lanceolata,
basi cuneata in petiolum subgracilem I — 1) poll, longum decurrentia,
magis minusve acuminata, 4 — 7 poll, longa, integra, tenere mombanacea et
flaccida, glabra, viridia ; Ilores parvi, albidi, pedicello erasso c. lin. longo
suffulti cymam corymbiformem trichotomam breve Q — 1 poll.) peduncu-
latam glaberrimam terminalem formantes ; calyx glaber, brevissimus, obso-
lete dentatus ; corolla fauce barbata, tubo amplo infundibuliformi lin. longo v.
paullo lorigiore, lobis paullo brevioribus ; baccse.... — Martaban, Tenasserim.
95. PsVCIlOTRIA CALOCABPA, nov. sp.
Suffrutex 1 — l .V pedalis subherbaceus, rhizomate repente, ramulis juni-
oribus magis minusve crispulo-puberulis ; stipulaj bifid®, e basi latiori subu-
lato-acuminatcrj et ssepius apicibus brunnescenti-pubescentes ; folia oblonga
et ovata ad ovato-oblonga, basi acuta, petiolo erasso crispo-tomentosulo
suffulta, acuta ad acuminata, 3 — 7 poll, longa, integra, pergamacca, glabra v.
vulgo subtus secus nervos indistincte puberula ; floras parvi, albi, pedicellis
brevissimis crassis, cymam breve (- j poll.) pedunculatam contractiusculam
ereetam v. nonnunquam nutantem tomentellam terminalem v. spurie axil-
larem efibrmantes ; calyx lineam fere longus, 4-fidus, lobis lanceolatis ob-
tusis viridibus ; corolla intus albo-villosa, tubus calycis segmentorum longi-
tudine, limbi lobi breves, oblongi, obtusiusculi ; bacc® calycis lobis con-
spicuis coronatas, elliptic®, pisi magnitudine, lucid®, coccineas ; semina mem-
brana alba tenui tantum induta, plano-convexa, fievia ; albumen sequum.
. — Begu, Martaban, Tenasserim.
9(>. Ixora (Pavetta) compaotifloea, nov. sp.
Frutex ? glaber ; stipul® breve ovat®, acut® ; folia elliptica ad lato-
316
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
[No. 4,
lanceolata, basi cuneata in petiolum i | polliearein crassum attenuata,
longiuseule acuminata, 3 — 5 poll, longa, integra, subpergamacea, glaberrima,
in sicco nigrescentia ; flores parvi, sessiles v. subsessiles, capitulum densum
circiter pollicem crassum involucratam terminalem v. spurie lateralem for-
mantes ; involucri braetere parvre et inconspicua;, lato-ovat®, imbricatse ;
calyx lineam circiter longus, glaber, dentibus oblongis obtusis semilinealibus;
corolla glabra, tubo 3 lin. tan turn longo,' ampliuscula, lobi oblongi, obtusi,
tubi longitudinis ; baccse. — Tenasserim.
97. Ixora (Pextadu’m) Helff.m, nov. sp.
Frutex ? glaber ; stipulas lato-ovat*, acuminata;, glabrae ; folia oblon-
go-lanceolata, utrinque acuminata, petiolo 3 — 4 lin. longo, integra, 5 — 8
poll, longa, tenui membranacea, in sicco nigrescentia ; flores majusculi,
pedicello crasso puberulo usque ad lineam longo sustenti, cymulosi et pani-
culam thyrsoideam brachiatam longe pedunculatam sparse puberulam eff’or-
mantes ; bracteolse lineari-subulat® unacum bracteis glabrae ; calyx 1) lin.
fere longus, minute puberulus, dentibus 5 laneeolatis acutis ealycis tubi lon-
gitudine ; corolla (in alabastro) extus minute fulvo-pubescens, lobi duplo
breviores ; baccre — Tenasserim.
98. Ixora sessiliflora, nov. sp.
Frutex magnus ramosus glaberrimus ; stipul* e basi lata rotundata
abrupte acuminat* ; folia oblonga ad oblongo-lanceolata, basi rotundata,
petiolo crasso 2 — 3 lin. longo suft'ulta, breve acuminata, 3 — 4 poll, longa,
integra, tenui coriacea, glabra ; flores (inprimis tubus) pallide rosei, par-
viusculi, sessiles, corymbum parviusculum tricbotomum glabrum efficientes ;
pedunculus semipollicaris ; calyx ^ lin. longus, glaber, dentibus brevissimis ;
corolla glabra, tubo gracili fere pollicari, lobi ovato-oblongi, acutiusculi ;
stigma breviter exertum ; bacc® — Martaban.
99. Ixora memectejfoma, nov. sp.
Frutox glaber ; stipules e basi lata abrupte et longe subulat® ; folia
ovata v. ovato-oblonga, subsessilia, basi rotundata v. subcordata, 2 £ — 4 poll,
longa, acuminata, integra, tenui-coriacea, glabra, in sicco nigrescentia v. fus-
cescentia ; flores parvi, albi ? v. pallide rosei ? , sessiles, corymbum longius
v. brevius peduneulatum tricbotomum glabrum terminalem vulgo ad basin
diminute bifoliolatum formantes ; bractese parvse, lineares ; calyx glaber,
lineam circiter longus, dentibus fere calycis tubi longitudine laneeolatis ; cor-
olla glabra, tubo circ. 4 lin. longo, lqbi dimidio fere breviores ; stylus longe-
exsertus, apico bilobus ; baecse — Tenasserim,.
100. Ixora Brasdisiana, nov. sp.
Frutex glaber ; stiprdin e basi lata subulato-acuminatae ; folia oblongo-
ovata ad oblonga, petiolo brevissimo crasso suffulta v. subsessilia, basi rotun-
data, 4 — 6 poll, longa, acuminata, integra, tenui-coriacea, glabra, in sicco
nigrescentia ; flores longissimi,. albi ? , brevissime pedieellati,- cymam par-
1872.]
S. Kurz — New Burmese Plants.
317
yam triehotomam minute puberulam brevissime peclunculatam termiualem
formantes ; bracte® parv®, lanceolate, acuminata}, superiores angustioros et
miuores ; calyx liueam longus, glaber, lobis lanceolatis acutis, calycis tubi
longitudiue ; corolla glabra, fauce villosa, tubo gracillimo 1$ — -2 pollicari,
lobi lineai-i-oblongi, acuti, 3 — 3£ bn. longi ; stylus exsertus lobis stigmaticis
brevissimis ; baccae..,. — Tenasserim.
101. IxOEA BEUOTESCENa, noV. sp.
Arbuscula 20 — 25 pedalis glabra ; stipulae e basi lata abrupte subu-
lato-acuminat® ; folia magis minusve obovata, basi rotundata v. obtusa, cras-
se et brevissime (-1 lin.) petiolata v. subsessilia, 4 — 6 poll, longa, obtusa v.
obtusiuscule apieulata, integra y. uudulata, coriacea, glabra, nervis laterali-
bus approximatis et subparallelis ; flores...graciliter pedicellati, cymulosi,
corymbum braehiatum trichotomum breve (l — 1 j poll.) pedunculatum
glabrum terminalem formantes ; calyx parvus, glaber, dent i bus minutis
triangulari-acutis ; corolla... ; baccse globosse, calycis limbo coronate, pisi
minoris magnitudine, lffives. — Andamans.
102. IxOEA EOSELLA, noV. Sp.
Frutex glaber ; stipulae ovate, acuminate ; folia oblongo-lanceolata ad
elliptico-oblonga, basi acuminata, petiolo crasso | — 1 poll, longo sutfulta, bre-
ve et subabrupte acuminata, 6 — 9 poll, longa, integra, coriacea, glabra, subtus
pallida ; nervis lateralibus tenuibus, satis approximatis et leviter curvato-
parallebs ; bores minores, pallide rosei, pedicellis 1 — 3 lin. longis suffulti,
cymulosi, in corymbum subsessilom brachiato-trichotomum minute puberum
terminalem dispositi ; calyx | lin. longus, minute puberus deutibus minutis
lato-triaugularibus acutis et obtusis ; corolla glabra, tubo pollicem circiter lon-
ga, lobi oblongi, obtusi, quadruplo breviores ; stylus breviter exsertus lobis
stigmaticis crassis vix separatis ; bace® globosae, pisi minimi magnitudine,
calycis limbo coronatse, lseves. — Andamans.
COMP O SITAE.
103. Lf.UCO MEETS DECOEA, noV. Sp.
Arbuscula 12 — 15-pedalis, decidua, novellis albido-villosis ; folia ellip-
tico- ad oblongo-lanceolata, basi insequali acuta, petiolo -g — 1 poll, longo gla-
bro suffulta, 5 — 7 poll, longa, membranacea, acuminata, glabra v. subglabra ;
capitula brevi squamato-pedunculata in ramorum apicibus dense aggregata;
involucrum elongato-cyatbiforme, in pedunculum imbricato-sqamatum, 3 — 4
lin. longum attenuatum ; squamto lanceolate, deorsum sensim minores, ri-
gid®, tenui-araclmoideee, virides ; flosculi fragrantes, albi, pollicem fere lon-
gi ; pappus pallide l'ulvesceus, semipollicaris ; achenia semipollicaria, sulcata,
dense adpresse villoso-serieea. — Prome.
318
[No. 4,
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce.
104. Ainst/lea Brandisiana, nov. sp.
Herba perennis, erecta, 1 — 3-pedalis parce villosa ; folia rosulata, cor-
dato-oblonga ad cordato-elliptica, petiolo | — 2 poll, longo, stupposo-villoso
crasso suflulta, 2 — 4 poll, longa, acuta v. obtusiuseula, marginibus integris
dense villosis, crasse membranacea, prsesertim subtus plus minusve liirsuta,
supra seepius glabroseentia ; capitula in soapo radicali paniculata, pedunculis
i — 1-poll icaribus glanduloso-puberis stiflulta ; bracteeo minutoo, subulatse
subrigidro ; involucri squama) lineari-lanceolatro, acutse, rigid®, 4-lin. longa),
inferiores duplo v. triplo breviores, lreves, virides, albido-marginatee ; flosculi
albi, poll, fere longi ; acbenia 2 — 3 lin. longa, adpresse pubescentia ; pap-
pus flavidus, c. 4 lin. longus. — Martaban.
105. Tbicholepis Karensium, nov. sp.
Herba annua, robusta, ramosa, 2 — 3 pedalis, parce pubescens ; folia
caulina linearia ad lineari lanceolata, 2J — 3 poll, longa, basi in petiolum bre-
vissimum attenuata, acuminata v. acuta, remote setaceo-denticulata, mem-
branacea, parce arachnoideo-pubescentia, supra glabrescentia ; capitula mag-
na, 2 poll, fere in diametro, terminalia, solitaria, sessib'a ; involucri squamae
numerosissimm, denaissimse imbricatse, subulatse, 1 — 11 poll, long®, albido-
pilosse ; flosculi purpurei ? acbenia 3 — 4 lin. longa, lcevia ; pappus inaequalis
achenio duplo circiter longior, flavescens, pilosus. — Martaban.
Monograph op Indian Cyprinida:, (Part VI), — by Surgeon Major
Francis Day.
Since the commencement of this Memoir on the carps of India, in the
Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, (vol. XL, Pt. II, 1871) several new
or little known species have been personally collected, or received through
the kindness of friends. All of these require to be fully described, (except
Labeo boggut, Sykes, and CirrMna dero, Ham. Buch., see ante J. A. S. B.
1872, pp. 259 and 900) ; likewise a few corrections have to be noted.
Discognathtjs lamta.
In Journ. A. S. B. for 1871, Pt. II, p. 110, for D. f, V. 10, read D.
V. 9, Vert. 18/14.
A very interesting variety of this species has been kindly collected for
me by Dr. Waagen from the Nilwan ravine near the Shapur salt ranges.
The depression across the snout is very deep, and the dorsal fin is concave
along its upper margin and higher than the body.
1872.]
319
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cgprinidce.
Genus. Oeetnus.
Oapoeta micracanthns, Gunther, Catal. yii, p. 81.
Four specimens of this fish “ stuffed from 18 to 23 inches long. Puna-
ka. From the collection of the East India Company,” exist in the British
Museum, and are now correctly labelled Oreinus, to which genus they
belong.
LABEO BICKOEHTNCntTS.
1. c. p. 123, erase “ ? Cyprinus musiha, H. B. pp. 333, 392.”
Lajseo nukta.
Cyprinus nulda, Sykes, Trans. Z. S. ii, p. 325.
„ mwatus, Sykes, 1. o
Camssius auratus, Gunther, Catal. yii, p. 32 (not syn.).
B. Ill, D. 2/9, P. 15, V. 9, A. 2/5, C. 19, L. 1. 38, L. tr. 8/9.
Length of head nearly 1/5, of caudal 2/9, height of body 2/7 of the
total length. Eyes, diameter 1/6 of length of head, 2^ diameters from the
end of the snout, and slightly nearer the posterior margin of the opercle
than to the end of the snout. L lead compressed, snout projecting over the
mouth and having a deep groove passing from one orbit to the opposite one,
thus occasioning the appearance as if there were a blunt compressed knob,
between and before the orbits. Mouth transverse. The lips with a distinct
inner hold at the angle of the mouth and extending across the outer third of
the lower jaw, from which the tip is reflected and rough, but neither are
fringed. Some large pores on the snout, forehead and in the rostral
groove. Barbels, a fine maxillary pair. Fins, dorsal without any osseus
ray, arising midway between the snout and the posterior extremity of
the base of the anal fin, its anterior three rays are much elevated and
higher than the body, the last besides being divided to its root, being also
somewhat prolonged, so the upper margin of the fin is concave. Ventrals
arise under the middle of the dorsal and scarcely reach the anal. Pectoral
as long as the head. Caudal deeply forked. Lateral line complete to the
centre of the base of the caudal, but very badly marked, 4^ rows of scales
between it and the base of the ventral fin. Colours silvery with some red
marks on some of the scales.
Hah. — Dakhin (Deccan) ; through the assistance of Colonel Evezard, I
obtained two specimens from Puna, 10 and 12 inches respectively in length.
Genus. Cieehena.
ClBBHENA. SlNBENSIS.
B. Ill, D. 3/10, P. 15, V. 8, A. 2/5, C. 19. L. 1. 43, L. tr. 8/8.
Length of head, of caudal fin, and height of body each 1/5 of the total
length. Eyes, situated in the middle of the length of the head, 2 diameters
320
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Oyprinidee. [No. 4,
from the end of the snout. Interorbital space nearly flat. Snout rounded,
covered with glands and having a deep groove extending across it from eye
to eye. Mouth transverse, inferior. Mandibles sharp not enveloped in lip,
and having a tbiu horny covering. Lips entire. Barbels, a pair of very short
maxillary. Fins, dorsal commences midway between the end of the snout,
and the posterior extremity of the base of the anal, its third undivided ray
weak, fin rather higher than the body. • Pectoral as long as the head with-
out the snout, not reaching the ventrals, which last arise under the middle
of the dorsal. Lateral line nearly straight, 6^ rows of scales between it
and the base of the ventral fin. Colours silvery with a reddish tinge, the
bases of the scales the darkest, fins red.
Sab. — Sind Hills, attaining 8 inches in length.
Although this fish is evidently a Cirrhina, as seen by the position of
its ventral fins, still the horny covering to its lower jaw is remarkable.
ClEBHIFA BATA, H. B.
Day, J. A. S. of Beng, 1871, p. 140.
Cyprinus bata, H. Buoh., is said to be “ found in the rivers and ponds of
Bengal” (H. B.), its native name is given as bata. From the same loca-
lities and called by the same name ‘ bata' I obtained numerous specimens
of a fish agreeing in nearly every respect with H. B.’s description and a
figure which still exists amongst his MS. drawings ; the only exception
being that the drawing gives 12 dorsal rays instead of 11, whilst the text
states “ the last of them being divided to the root,” which division to the
root is not shown in the last ray in the original drawing. To me (but I
do not assert that I cannot be mistaken) it appears that the artist has sepa-
rated the bases of the last two rays which should be shown as arising from
one common root. Were this so in the drawing, the figure and the descrip-
tion would agree with my specimens (see Proe. Zool. Soc. 1871, p. 636).
Whilst seeing no reason for changing my views, I think it but fair to
give Dr. Gunther’s opinion that “ Hamilton Buchanan’s fish has more than
nine branched rays, (Zool. Record, 1870, p. 135). “ The words of Hamilton
Buchanan that this fish has “ twelve rays in the fin of the back” “the
first” and “ second” being “ undivided, the others are branched, the last of
them being divided to the root” have always conveyed to my mind the idea
that this fish was described as clearly as possible as a fish with 10 branched
dorsal rays.” # * “ Finally to set the matter beyond further dispute also
with regard to the C. bata, I give (p. 765) an exact tracing of Hamilton
Buchanan’s MS. drawing of this fish, in which the ten separate branched
dorsal rays are as clearly shown as could well be done.” (Proc. Zool. Soc.
1871, p. 764).
1872.]
321
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprmidts.
It may perhaps he regretted that an addition has been made to the
original figure, by numbers 1 — 10 having been added above the branched
rays. Number 10, it will be perceived in the drawing, is not divided to the
root, consequently if 9 and 10 sprang from one common root, the fish would
agree with the species I have described in its native name, its description,
its figure and the locality it inhabits ; whereas such a fish with 10 branched
rays, the last divided to its root, has not been collected, so far as I am aware.
Still as the species is very largely domesticated, such a variety doubtless
might easily occur.
Finally I may observe that, although Dr. Gunther appears so decidedly
of opinion that my fish with 11 dorsal rays cannot be H. B.’s C. lata, the
following occurs in the Catalogue of Fishes of the British Museum, vii,
p. 35. “ 5. Cyprinus bata, Ilam. Buch., p. 283 ; ? = Cyprinus acra, Ham.
Buck., p. 281 ; = Cyprinus cura, Ham. Bitch., p. 284.” In Hamilton
Buchanan’s work he gives the number of rays of the dorsal fins of these
species thus. O. lata, D. 12, C acra, D. 11, O. cura, D, 12, and the species
C. acra, with D. 11, and C. cura, with D. 12, are set down as identical even
by Dr. Gunther, whilst Hamilton Buchanan observes that the O. acra, “ has
the utmost resemblance to the Bata',' and the C. cura is another fish nearly
allied to the Bata. McClelland, Ind. Cyp. J. A. S. of B. 1839, p. 356,
observes “ Cyprinus acra, Buch., is also said to have the upper lobe of the
caudal longer than the lower, but it has only eleven rays in the fin of the
back ; now whether a species can be said to have eleven or twelve rays in
the dorsal depends entirety on the degree to which the last ray is separated
or divided, which in this group it always is, more or less ; there can, there-
fore, be little doubt the Cyprinus lata and Cyprinus acra arc the same
species.” Thus agreeing with McClelland who considered these fish identi-
cal, and Dr. Gunther who supposed them to be so, I have taken Buchanan’s
first specific name lata instead of his second acra, and which I see no reason
for altering.
C l Hit IIIS A FULUNGEIi.
Chondrostoma fulungee, ? Sykes, T. Z. S. ii, p. 358.
Gynmostomus fulunijee, •UuntliGi1, Catal. vii, p. 76.
B. Ill, D. 2/S, P. 15, V. 9, A. 2/5, C. 19, L. 1. 44, L. tr. 8/9.
Length of head 1/6, of caudal 1/5, height of body 1/5 of the total
length. Byes, diameter 1/4 of length of head, 1 diameter from end of snout.
Dorsal and abdominal profiles equally convex. Snout overhangs the mouth,
a few pores upon it. Lips smooth. Barbels, a pair of short rostral, but no
maxillary ones. Scales, 6J rows between the lateral line and the base of the
ventral fin. Colours silvery, edges of scales darkest ; fins stained.
Hal. — Puna, growing to 6 inches in length.
40
322 F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce. [No. 4,
Whether this is Sykes’ species is of course doubtful, as he has not (so
far as I know) left any figure of it, but the resemblance, considering these
specimens came from the Dakliin (Deccan), is sufficiently strong to avoid
giving another name. Sykes states A. 6, but I conclude he may have counted
the two first undivided ones as one.
#ClBRnOTA EOSTRATA.
Crossochilm rostratus, Gunther, Catal. vii, p. 72, and Zool. Record, 1870, p. 135.
B. Ill, D. 11, A. 7, L. 1. 38, L. tr. 5^/7.
The height of the body is somewhat more than the length of the head,
which is one-fifth of the total without the caudal. Eyes, diameter 2/7 of
length of head, and situated somewhat behind its middle. Snout conical,
long, and much protruding beyond the mouth. Earhels two, rostral, shorter
than the eye. Fins, origin of dorsal considerably in advance of that of the
ventral, and midway between the end of the snout and the posterior end of
the anal fin ; pectoral a little longer than the head, terminating at a great
distance from the vehtrals. Scales, 4 rows between lateral line and ventral
fin. Colours, a black spot (composed of about four smaller spots) on the
fifth and sixth scales of the lateral line.
Sah. — Cossye river, from which a single specimen 4 inches long has
been obtained.
Dr. Gunther (Proc. Zool. Soc. 1871, p. 762) appears surprised at my
not having perceived the difference between this species and C. bata from
his first description (Catal. vii, p. 72) ; his definition thore of genus Orosso-
chilus, p. 71, gives “ Barbels two or four : if two, the upper only are present.”
C. bata having only two and those the lower or maxillary ones, seemed to
show that some inaccuracy existed in the definition of the genus ; whilst in
the text of C. rostratus all that is said about these appendages, is — “ Two
barbels only, shorter than the eye,” without stating whether they are rostral
or maxillary, otherwise the description agreed pretty fairly with O. bata
which came from the same locality. Subsequently in the Zool. Record. 1.
c. he states that C. rostratus “ has a pair of upper barbels only, hut no maxil-
lary barbels,” thus clearing up this point. I have stated this much because
Dr. Gunther in tho Pro. Zool. Soc. 1871, p. 762 asks : “ Will Mr. Day
point out where I have given this second description, or whether I have
added one iota to my original description in 1S68 P”# This date I conclude
* As some time must elapse before my SHuraids find a place in the Journal, I pro-
prose offering a few remarks upon Psc-udeutropius taalcne, Sykes. Dr. Giinther in
the Proc. Zool. Soc. 1871 in remarking on my having been mistaken in considering the
skin of this fish, received from the Zool. Soc. as being one of Col. Sykes’ types of his
paper, states, tho registry does not give liis name as a donor once, and of the East
Indian Museum “although I searched carefully that Museum (boforo and after the
1872.]
323
F. Day — Monograph of Indian Cgprinidce.
is only another inaccuracy, as Yol. vii of the Catalogue is dated November
1st, 1867, and contains the description I have adverted to.
Genus. Scaphiodon, Heckel.
Capoeta, sp. Chondrostoma, sp. Cuv. and Val.
Dillonia and Gymnost-omus, sp. Keck el.
Abdomen rounded , snout rounded ; mouth transverse, inferior, having the
mandibular edge nearly straight and sharp), the mandibles angularly bent in-
wards. A horny layer inside the lower jaw, which last is not covered by lip.
JVo lower labial fold. Barbels four, two, or absent. Pharyngeal teeth com-
pressed, truncated, 5 or 4, 3, 2/2, 3, 4 or 5. Dorsal Jin of moderate extent (up
to about ten branched rays'), its last undivided ray being osseous and serrated,
or else articulated ; anal rather short. Scales large, of moderate or small
transfer of its fish collection to the British Museum) for types of Colonel Sykes’s paper
X failed to discover them,”
In the Catalogue of the fishes of the British Museum, by Dr. Gunther, Yol. v, p. 46,
is “ a. b. eight and a half to nine and a half inches long. Dukliun. From Colonel Sykes’s
collection, types of Schilbe pdbo, Sykes.” At p. 76, uudor Maeroncs cavasius is a specimen
“ from the collection of Colonel Sykes” about the same size as his published figure. At
page 187 under Glyptnstemnm lonah is “ a. Type of the species from the collection of Col.
Sykes.” Thus in the Catalogue of the fishes of the British Museum the possession of
some of Sykes’ types is assortod, but where they came from I believe is not known ; Col.
Sykes’s name is not referred to, that I see, when the collections in E. I. Co. Museum are
mentioned, though Cantor’s, Griffith’s and McClelland’s are. Still it seoms that I was
mistaken in considering this skin as one from the collection of the Zoological Society,
whose donor’s name was omitted from tho Catalogue, and which had on it a label with
one of Col. Sykes’s names, as being one of his types.
Kespocting my being assisted, as Dr. Giinthor more than insinuates, in determin.
ing the species by his having erroneously (as he believes) written P. taakree on the
bottle, a slight reference to dates again disposes of this. My first inspection of this
skin was in 1870, whilst in the Proo. Zool. Soc. 1869, p. 617, I observed whon writing
from Barma — “ The Psendeutrapius taakree, Sykes, or P. bngimanus, Gunther, . is to-
lerably abundant in the Irrawadi and its branches.” Since thon I have received
it from Puna in the Dakhin (Deccan).
Lastly Dr. Gunther states the skin which is 6 inches long (Sykes’s figure is 5 T’j.)
“ had been presented with othors to the Society by Mr. Willie in 1834, — that is five
(four ?) years before Col. Sykes communicated his papor to the Zoological Society.”
To complete this observation, I may continue that Col. Sykos loft India in 1831, and
though tho “ fishes of the Dekhun” wore published in 1841, he expressly observes in
a note, that “ although the preceding details respecting the fishes of the Dekhun were
comprised in a report to tho Court of Directors of the East India Company in June,
1831, they were only communicated to the Zoological Society on the 27th November,
1838.” Thus the Zoological Sooiety obtained the specimen (Pimelodus vacUa as regis-
tered, not very closely resembling a Pseudeutropius') three years after Col. Sykes re-
turned to Europe and subsequent to the timo when his manuscript had been complet-
ed and given to the E. I. Company.
324 F. Day — Monograph of Indian Gyprinidce. [No. 4,
size and sometimes irregularly disposed. Lateral line passing to the centre
of the base of the caudal fin.
Geographical distribution. Bivers of Western Asia extending east-
wards to those in the Sind hills.
Synopsis op species.
A. Barbels two
1. Scaphiodon Watsoni, D. 3/10, A. 2/7, L. 1. 33. An osseous serrated dorsal ray.
Scales regularly arranged. Sind hills.
2. „ irregularis, D. 3/10, A. 2/7, L. 1. 36. An osseous, serrated, dorsal
ray. Scales irregularly arranged. Sind hills.
1. ScAPiiioDOw Watsoni.
B. Ill, D. 3/10, P. 15, V. 8, A. 2/7, C. 19, L. 1. 33, L. tr. 6/6.
Length of head 1/5, of caudal 1/5, height of body 2/9 of the total
length. Eges situated in the commencement of the anterior half of the
head, diameter 2/9 of length of head, L| diameters from the end of the snout.
Interorbital space somewhat convex. Snout rounded and covered with
glands ; mouth transverse, inferior, mandibles sharp not enveloped in lip,
and having a horny layer inside. A pair of maxillary barbels as long as
the eye. Fins, dorsal commences rather in front of the ventrals, and mid-
way between the end of the snout and the base of the caudal, its last undi-
vided ray strong, osseous, serrated, as long as the head without the snout,
and nearly as long as the branched rays, which are two thirds as high as the
body Pectoral as long as the portion of the head posterior to the angle of
the mouth, but not reaching the ventrals. Caudal forked. Lateral line,
very slightly curved, 31 rows of scales between it and the ventral fin. Cb-
lours silvery, dashed with gold, lightest on the abdomen. Various and very
irregular black spots on the body.
llab. — Sind hills. I have much pleasure in naming this species after
H. E. Watson, Esq., who largely assisted me in making collections of speci-
mens of natural history whilst in Sind.
2. SCAPHIODON IHEEGULAEIS.
B. Ill, D. 3/10, P. 17, V. 8, A. 2/7, C. 19, L. 1. 36, L. tr. 9/9.
Length of head, caudal fin and height of body, each 1/5 of the total
length. Lyes, situated in the commencement of the anterior half of the
head, 1| diameters from end of the snout and apart. Interorbital space
nearly flat, snout somewhat rounded, covered with glands and having a de-
pression across it from eye to eye. Fins, dorsal commences rather before
the ventrals midway between the end of the snout and the base of the cau-
dal fin, its third undivided ray is osseous, weak, and serrated, nearly half as
long as the head, whilst the fin is three fourths as high as the body. Pec-
toral nearly as long as the head ; caudal forked, its lower lobe the longer.
1872.] F. Day — Monograph of Indian Gyprinidm. 325
Scales, two or three rows above the lateral line are of a large oblong form,
above these are numerous small irregular ones, whilst the scales on the chest
are likewise very small ; four and a half rows exist between the lateral line
and the base of the ventral. Colours olive, shot with gold.
Hah. — Rivers in the Sind hills up to 3500 feet elevation. I have also
received from Dr. W. Waagen,* four specimens of a species of this genus
obtained from Marri, and which are scarcely separable from the foregoing ;
they have L. 1. 38, L. tr. 7 i/9, whilst the rows of scales above the lateral
line are not so distinctly irregular. The largest of these specimens is 6
inches in length.
Barbus (barbodes) Him at. at ant s .
Chit-rah-too, Panj.
B. Ill, D. 3/8, P. 15, Y. 9, A. 2/5, C. 17, L. 1. 32-34, L. tr. 5|/6.
Length of head nearly 1/4 (4/13), of caudal 1/6, height of body 1/4 of
the total length. Eyes, diameter 2/11 of length of head, 21 diameters from
end of snout, and 2 diameters apart. Dorsal and abdominal profiles equally
convex. Read, much compressed, a depression across the snout just ante-
rior to the orbits, lower lip lobed as in B. lor ; upper jaw the longer with-
out thickened lips. Barbels, the rostral pair of the same length as the
maxillary, and they equal 11 diameters of the orbit. Fins, dorsal commen-
ces midway between the nostrils or the anterior margin of the orbit and the
base of the caudal fin, its spine is moderately stout, entire, and equals the
length of the head without the snout, upper margin of fin concave ; pecto-
ral as long as the head without the snout, it does not reach the ventral,
which is slightly shorter and does not extend so far as the base of the anal,
which last reaches the root of the caudal when laid flat ; caudal forked, lobes
of equal length. Scales, 3) rows between the lateral line and the base of
the ventral fin. Colours golden above, becoming silvery below ; the mar-
gins of the scales with numerous fine black dots, in the young a black mark
behind the gill openings ; fins reddish.
Sab.— Ussun river, about four miles from Simla. Out of five specimens
the longest was 7 inches in length.
Barbus (puimus) Waageki.
B. Ill, D. P. 15, V. 9, A. 2/5, C. 17, L. 1. 23-24, L. tr. 4/7.
Length of head 1/4, of caudal 2/9, height of body 1/3 of the total
length. Eyes, in the anterior half of the head, 3/4 of a diameter from end
* Besides the fishes alluded to in this paper, the collection contained the follow-
ing from Marri in the Panjab : Macrones Lamarrii,V al., Labeo ricnorhynchus, McClell.,
Barbus tor, H. B. Likewise Barilius piscatonus, McClell., from a fresh water stream
near Wallus. Also one small specimen of Cirrhina gohama, H. B., and several of Ne-
macheilus corica, H. B.
326
F. Bay — Monograph of Indian Cyprinidce. [No. 4,
of snout. TJpper surface of the head flattened ; mouth horse-shoe shaped,
compressed, and anterior, lower jaw not covered by lip ; the posterior extre-
mity of the maxilla reaches half way to below the orbit. Barbels absent.
Fins, upper margin of dorsal straight, the fin is half as high as the body and
without any osseous ray, it commences midway between the posterior margin
of the orbit, and the base of the caudal ; pectoral as long as the head with-
out the snout, not reaching the ventral, which arises under the anterior dor-
sal rays and does not extend to the anal ; caudal forked. Scales, rows
between the row which contains the Lateral line and the base of the ventral
fin. Lateral line ceases on the seventh scale. Colours silvery, darkest
above ; a black blotch on the 17th and 18th rows of scales, and posterior to
the anal and dorsal fins.
Hob. — From Chua Saidar Shah, Salt Eange ; specimens up to 2f inches
in length were collected by Dr. Waagen who kindly furnished me with
them.
Babbits (puxtius) vittatus, Pt. II. p. 107.
From a recent examination of several fine specimens of this fish obtain-
ed by Dr. Stoliczka in Kaclih I find its last undivided dorsal ray is articulat-
ed, not osseous ; so it must be removed to the division of Puntius, being with-
out osseous dorsal ray.
Genus. Babiliits.
BAEmrs Evezabdi. ,
B. Ill, D. 2/7, P. 13, V. 9, A. jJL-, 0. 17, L. 1. 40, L. tr. 7/4.
Length of head 2/11, of caudal 2/11, height of body 1/5 of the total
length. Eyes, diameter 1/3 of length of head, 3/4 of a diameter from the
end of the snout and apart. Barbels absent. Tho maxilla extends to be-
neath the anterior margin of the orbit. Humeral process short, being
scarcely produced. Third suborbital bone twice as deep as the uncovered
portion of the cheek below it to above the angle of the preopercle. A well
developed knob at the symphysis of the lower jaw. Fins, pectoral as long
as the head, the dorsal commences midway between the hind edge of the
orbit and the end of the caudal fin, whilst its posterior half is above the anal.
Lower caudal lobe the longer. Colours silvery ; dorsal, caudal and anal deep
orange, the first two having a black edge.
Mob.— Puna; growing to 4J inches in length. Out of the specimens
collected through the assistance of Colonel Evezard were two of this species,
and subsequently I have received one obtained in the same locality by Dr.
Stoliczka.
1872.]
W. E. Broolcs — Two Undescribed Cashmir Birds.
327
Nemacheiltjs montanus, Pt. Y. p. 192.
Having been able to collect near Simla numerous specimens of tins fish,
from whence McClelland obtained his types, I find that considerable varia-
tions occur in the species.
The first, apparently typical form, has D. Head nearly 2/3 as wide
as long ; preorbital terminating posteriorly in an obtuse projection. Scales
very minute, but most distinct in the posterior paid of the body. In some
the dark bands on the body are as wide as, in a few narrower or wider than,
the ground colour. The dorsal has one row of spots, which are present or ab-
sent on the caudal.
The second variety has D. Head at least 2/3 as wide as long, no
projection to preorbital. Colours the same.
The third form has D. — U Head almost as wide as long, depressed)
muzzle rounded ; no preorbital prominence, the pectoral a little longer than
in the two previous forms. Colours the same except that some have several
rows of black spots both on the dorsal and caudal fins, others have only a
single row.
On two undescuibed Cashmie Bieds, — by W. E. Brooks, C. E.
Assensole.
[Received 16th October, read 4th December, 1872.]
Accentoe Jeedoni, sp. nov.
Bill shorter, feebler and sharper pointed than in A strophiatus, and not
nearly so black. One specimen has the basal portion of the lower mandible
pale brown. Total length 4'5 inches ; wing 2'51 to 2'G2 ; tail 2'3 to 2'51 ;
bill at front -35 ; tarsus '75.
This bird in mode of coloration strongly resembles A. strophiatus, yet
it is very distinct ; being altogether a paler, and less boldly marked species.
The striation of the back is comparatively cloudy, and resembles that of
Bipastes arboreus. The upper surface is a mixture of brownish grey and
dark brown, and there is none of the warm rufous tint observable on the back
of A. strophiatus. The rump and upper tail coverts, which are strongly
streaked in strophiatus, are plain greyish brown in our bird, with hardly the
faintest streak perceptible. The anterior portion of the supercilium is whi-
tish, as in strophiatus, but the remainder, instead of being deep rusty red, is
merely warm buff or fulvous. Above the supercilium is a dark band on each
side of the head, which is continued to the occiput. The crown of the head
is brownish grey, mottled indistinctly with palo brown. The back is brown-
328
W. E. Brooks — Two TJndescrihed Cashmir Birds. [No. 4,
ish grey, streaked with dark brown. Ear coverts dark slatey brown, slightly
mottled with greyish white. A patch of pure grey, very faintly streaked
with brown, between the ear coverts and bend of wing. From chin to upper
breast white, with small neat dark brown spots ; below this white, a broad
(3/4 inch) pectoral band of rufous, not nearly so deep and bright as in stro-
phiatus and devoid of dark streaks ; strophiatus sometimes has the pectoral
rufous strongly streaked. Rest of lower- surface dull whitish with the flanks
tinged with brown, the latter having also broad cloudy brown streaks.
Lower tail coverts pale brownish, with broad whitish edges ; wings and tail
brown, of a much lighter shade than in strophiatus, and having pale brown
margins to the feathers, particularly so in the case of the wing coverts and
tertials.
I have thought necessary to refer comparatively to A. strophiatus in
this description, on account of the similar distribution of colours, and size of
the two birds. They can only be understood by contrasting them. I have
one specimen of the new bird from Dhurmsala, and others from Cashmir.
A. strophiatus ranges from near Simla to Darjiling; but at what point west
of Simla is its western limit, and where the eastern one of A. Jerdoni begins,
is not yet known. Captain Cock took some nests of the new bird with eggs
(uniform greenish blue) at Sonamurg, up the Scind valley in Cashmir.
The other bird which I have to describe is
Troglodvtes neglectus, sp. nov.
It is of the same size as T. Nipalensis, but very much lighter in colour
and having a strong resemblance to the English wren. It is dull reddish
brown above, becoming brighter in tone towards and on the tail. The
whole of the upper surface is covered with wavey dark brown bars, which are
very indistinct on the head, but increase in distinctness as the tail is reach-
ed, upon which they are very well marked. Below pale brownish, with the
abdomen and belly nearly white, the whole of the under surface, like the
upper, being barred with brown. Lower tail coverts brown, spotted with
white. Bill brown, paler on lower mandible at base ; legs and feet brown.
Length 3-5 in. ; wing 1'8 ; tail 12 ; bill at front '42 ; tarsus '63, central toe
and claw '57 ; liind toe and claw '53. The sexes are alike in size and plum-
age.
Apart from its comparatively pale tone of colouration its much smalle r
and slenderer tarsus and foot easily distinguish it from T. JTipalensis, which
is a very dark brown sooty looking little bird. Of T. Nipalensis the central
toe and claw measure '7 ; hind toe and claw '62.
The Cashmir wren is not uncommon in the pine woods of Cashmir,
and in habits and manners it strongly resembles its European congener. Its
song is very similar, and quite as pretty. It is a shy active little bird, and
1872.] W. Theobald & F. Stoliczka — Notes on Burmese Land Shells. 329
very difficult to shoot. I found two nests. One was placed in the roots of a
large upturned pine, and was globular with entrance at the side. It was
profusely lined with feathers and composed of moss and fibres. The eggs
were white, sparingly and minutely spotted with red ; rather oval in shape,
measuring -66 by '5. A second nest was placed in the thick foliage of a
moss grown fir tree, and was about 7 feet above the ground. It was simi-
larly composed to the other nest, but the eggs were rounder, and plain
white, without any spots.
Notes on Baemese and Arakanese land shells, with descriptions
op a FEW SPECIES, — by W. Theobald, Esq., and Dr. F. Stoliczka.
(Received and read 7th August, 1872.)
(With plate XI.)
The accompanying notes were suggested by the recent discovery of
several new species of landshells, chiefly in the Arakan hills and in the
neighbourhood of Moulmain. In addition to these a few species were
found which proved to be identical with those formerly described from
Sikkim, the Khasi hills, and Upper Pegu ; the slight variations and the
geographical distribution of these species will be noticed in connection with
the descriptions of the new species.
CYCLOSTOMA CL A.
Kaphaulus pachysiphon, n. sp. PI. XI. Fig. 1.
B. testa cylindraceo ovata, anguste perforata , solida, fusca; spira
obtusa, apice ad latus inclinato , excetitrico ,* anfractihus 5 i convexiusculis ,
transversim confertissime striolatis, ad suturam simplicem adpressis ;
anfractu pen ultimo sens im, ultimo valde , descendente, prinio supra aperturam
deplanato, altero ad suturam paulo const rid o . ad basin convexiusculo ; aper~
tura fere vcrticali, circulari , peristomate pallide fuceseente , plane expanso
atgue crassot supra ad anfractum penultitnuin labio attenuato et fere horizonli
adnato, postice (aut supra) ad suturan tubulo crasso, deflexo instructo.
Long. 12'6, lat. anf. penult. 7'6, diam. apert. cum perist. 6'2, apert. int.
3'6 m.m.
Bab. Prope Moulmain , valle Ataran fliminis.
A rare and very distinct from any of the other known species by its
distorted spire and externally bent down sutural tube. The figures 1 and
la are of the natural size, 16 and lc are the corresponding figures, enlarged
twice the natural size.
41
330 W. Theobald & F. Stoliczka — Notes on Burmese Land Shells. [No. 4,
Genus, Alycusus.
Of this genus several species were found which were previously only
known to occur in Sikkim, and in the Khasi and Garo hills. A. pusillus
was met with at Nattoung in the Mendon district, Pegu ; A. urnula, and a
small variety of A. Inrjrami, at Mai-i in the Arakan hills ; A. crispatus at
Maianoung and near Moulmain ; at this last named locality also occurred
a large, red-liped variety of A. urnula, and several specimens of A. Bichtho-
feni, the shells slightly vary in the height of the spire, but all are of
exactly the same character.
Alycasits Kubziaots, n. sp. PI. xi. Fig. 2.
A. testa subglobose conoulea, late umbilicata, pallide rubescente ; anfrac-
tibus 4, wide convexis, sublwvigatis, transversim distanter obsolete costellatis,
ultimo anfractu medio ambitus modice inflate, confertim costulato, tmn
wide constricto Iccvigatoque, in constrictione costa obtusa transversd in-
structo, rursusque expansiusculo atque paulo deflexo; aperture magna, obliqua,
subrotundata, supra obtuse angulata, infra anguste canaliculata ; preritremate
modice incrassato, duplici, externo paulum expanso, labro interno plicatulo,
labio sublcevigato. IHam. maj. specim. maximi 3'5, minor 3, alt. 2'7 m.m.
Nab. Nattoung in provincia Barmana, Bronte dicta.
The peculiarly formed aperture with the lower canal and its internal
plication on the outer lip readily distinguish this species from A. polygona,
which besides differs by more rounded and higher whorls. Mr. Kurz
brought some years ago a specimen of this interesting species from Pegu ;
more recently Mr. Theobald collected it near Nattoung in the Western
Prome district. The measurements above given are those of one of the
largest specimens.
Genus, Diplommatina.
Several remarkable varieties of formerly described species occurred with
other known forms, both in Arakan and at Moulmain. Among these the
following deserve special notice.
1. I), sperata, Blf., was found at Mai-i in the Sandoway district. It
is a very rare shell.
2. I), polypleuris, Bens., occurs abundantly in the Sandoway district
and at Nattoung, more rarely near Moulmain.
3. B. olygopleuris, Blf. Very fine specimens, measuring 3 m.m. in
length and l-5 m.m. in thickness, were collected on the Kumah hill in
Arakan, and a solitary specimen was found at Baom, also in Arakan. The
latter exactly agrees in form and size (length 2 m.m.) with typical Cachar
specimens, but while in these the costulation generally becomes obsolete on the
two last whorls, the same is well developed and comparatively slightly closer
1872.] W. Theobald & F. Stoliczka — Motes on Burmese Land Shells. 331
on all the whorls of the Arakanese specimen ; the difference is, however
not sufficient to indicate a specifically distinct shell from the one above
named.
4. L). exilis, Blf., was found on the limestone hills at Damotha and at
the Farm-caves near Moulmein. Most of the specimens somewhat exceed
in size those from Upper Banna ; the costulation of the whorls also is a shade
finer, though variable in different specimens, and the outer lip of the aperture
a little more expanded ; however, the general form, character and proportion
of the whorls is exactly the same. One of the largest specimens measures :
total length 3 2, diameter of penult, whorl 1", diam. of apert. with perist. 0'9
m.m. ; it has nine whorls.
5. Z>. nana, described by Mr. W. T. Blanford from Pegu, also occurs
near Moulmein ; the specimens only are a trifle smaller than the type shell,
but they are very distinctly transversely costulated.
6. Diflommatina angulata, n. sp. PI. xi. Fig. 3.
L). testa ovoto elongata, dextrorsa, vix rimata, sordide alhida, anfractu
penultimo latissimo, apice obtusiusculo, pollute rulido, submammillato ;
anfractibus sex, primis duobus hevigatis, cceteris valde convexis, ad peri-
pheriam plus minusve distincter angulatis, transversim confertissime costellatis
aut acute striatis ; ultimo basi contract o ; sutura profunda, simplice ; aper-
tura late circulari, peristomate undique expanse, bilabiato, inferno subrecto,
ad marginem columcllarem dente obliquo instructo, externo ad anfractum
penultimum constrictum modice ascendente. Long. 2, lat. maxima 08, diam.
apert. 06 m.m.
Sab. Prope Moulmain, provincia Martaban.
The peculiar angulation of the whorls, combined with the very close
transverse costulation, or almost striation, and the proportionately large
aperture readily separate this species from any other as yet known. Mr.
Theobald obtained numerous specimens on the limestone hill near Damotha,
and also south of Moulmain, together with JJ. carneola, Stol.
7. Difiommatina Richthofeni, n. sp. PI. xi. Fig. 4.
Dipl, testa ovate elongata, iurrita, dextrorsa, alhida, , rimata ; spira
conoidea ; anfractibus septem, convexis, ad medium subangulatis, sutura
simplici junctis, penultimo ultimo latiore : primis d yob us apiccm formant ibus
Icevigatis, cceteris transversim conferte costellatis, ultimo basi convexo, angus-
tato, supra ad anf. penultimum ascendente ; apertura parva, circulari, peris-
tomate duplici : inferno tubuliforme modice producto atgue dilatato ; labio
ad basin dente obliquo et inaguo instructo. Long. 2'5, lat. maxima 0'8, diam .
aperturce 0’5 m.m.
Sab. Prope Moulmain ; {testa rarissima).
332 W. Theobald & F. Stoliezka — Notes on JBarmese Land Shells. [No. 4,
A species closely allied to D. angulata, but more slender, with less dis-
tinctly angulated whorls, non-mammillated apex, with a slightly more dis-
tant costulation and with a comparatively smaller aperture.
Only the solitary figured specimen of this shell was obtained on the
limestone hill at the so-called Farm-caves.
Genus, Geoeissa.
1. Georissa Blanfordiana, Stol., (J. A. S. B., 1871, vol. xl, pt. ii,
p. 158, pi. vi, fig. 6,) described from a single specimen, occurred abundantly
both at the 1 arm-caves and South of Mbulmain. The type specimen is
rather a young shell, which, when adult, attains a very distinct ovately
conoid form, the whorls being in proportion somewhat less convex ; the inner
lip is strongly thickened. One of the largest specimens measures : total
length 2-8, greatest width of the last whorl 2, height of aperture 2'2, its
width 1 m.m.
When alive, the shell is rather deep succineous and semi-transparent ;
old specimens become white. The operculum is of the usual form, very
thin, with a long internal process, pale coloured, becoming blackish towards
the centre.
2. G. Itawesiana, Bens., also known from a single specimen, found at
the Farm-caves near Moulmain, occurred in numerous examples on two
limestone hills in the Ataran valley. The shell differs from G. liratula* by
a more conoid shape, particularly in the adult, and by a much finer spiral
striation, there being on the penultimate whorl as many as seven or eight of
these spiral stria?, while in liratula there are only five of them. Young
specimens of both species are equally globose, and of a succineous structure”
One of the largest specimens of G. Itawesiana measures : length 2 4, largest
diam. T8, height of aperture 1, its width 08 m.m. In adults the fine
sculpture wears off remarkably easily, and such specimens closely resemble
G. Blanfordiana , but have the whorls more convex, and the aperture pro-
portionately smaller.
3. G. pyxis, Bens., a species common about Prome, also occurs on the
Kumah hill in the Sandoway district.
4. Geoeissa feateena, n. sp. PL xi. Figs. 5 and 6.
G. testa cyhndraceo conoidea, solidula, pallida, imperforata, regione
umbilicali paulo impressa ; anfractibus 3J, convexis, supra modice subtrun-
catis, sutura per-profunda junctis, spiraliter crasse liratis, liris in anfrac-
tu penultimo quinque, svpera a sutura remotiuscula ; apice valde mam-
millato ; ultimo anfractu spird breviore, basi convexiusculo , spiraliter
* J. A. S. B. vol. xl, pt. ii, 1871, p. 157, pi. vi, fig. 5.
1872.] W. Theobald & F. Stoliczka — Notes on Burmese Land Shells. 333
striato ; apertura fere semicircular i, labro simplici, antice modice recedente,
margine subobtuso instructo, lahio recto, incrassato ; operculo testae to, tenui,
subdiaphano, paucispirato. Alt. tested IT, diam. max. 0‘95 m.m.
Hub. In valle jhaninis Ataran, prope Moulmain.
Allied to O. pyxis in having the uppermost spiral ridge on the whorls
somewhat remote from the suture, but the ridges themselves are stronger,
the whorls somewhat less numerous, the apex very distinctly mammillate,
and the entire form of the shell more slender and cylindrical. Only three
specimens were discovered by Mr. Theobald.
The slight variation in the shape is indicated by the figures given of
two specimens.
Acmelia hyaltya, n. sp. PI. xi. Fig. 7.
Ac. testa ovato conica, modice perforata, hyalina, sordide ahbida ; spira
obtusa ; anfractibus 4} convexinsculis, sutura simplici et profunda junctis,
ad suturam subtruncatis, loevigatis, ultimo spira paulo breviore, basi convexo ;
apertura regulariter ovata, supra (vel postice) subangulata, baud obliqua,
peristomate tenui fere continue. Long. 1, lat. 07 m.m. ( Operculum deest).
Bah. Incollis calcareis prope Moulmain.
Of the two known species of the genus, A. tersa and the doubtful
milium, both described by Benson from the Khasi hills, the present new
form closely agrees in the shape of the shell with the first, and in the.smooth-
ness of the surface with the second.
Acmella, Blanf., is evidently quite distinct from Georissa, or Bydrocena,
the latter being one of the HEmciNinjE, while the former is most likely
a Cyclophorid, or possibly one of the intermediate forms close to Assiminea
and Omphalotropis, connecting the Cvcr.oi'HoiUDA: with the liissoi u.e.
(Comp. Blanford in Ann. and Mag. N. H. for March 1869).
BE LIC ACL A.
Pupa eelosa, n. sp. PI. xi. Fig. 8.
_P. testa ovato cylindracea, cornea, pellucida, apice obtusiuscula, rimate
umbilicata ; anfractibus 41 con vexi usculis, sutura simplici junctis, trans-
versim striis cuticularibus, obliq uis,fliformib us ornatis ; ultimospira breviore,
basi vix angustato, convexiusculo ; apertura subguadrangulari, recta, intus
dentihus quinque instructa, labro undique paulo expansiusculo, alque incras-
sato, infra suturam subangulato, ad latus dentihus duobus parvis profunde
sitis instructo ; labio tenuissimo, prope medium dentihus pliciformibus duobus
approximate, anteriore multo minore, prxdito ; columella unidentata. Long.
2, diam. max. 1 m.m. ; apert. cum perist. 0 75 longa, antice 0 55, postice
0 75 m.m. lata.
Bab. In littore AraJcanense ; satis Jr equens.
334
G. E. Dobson — On the Osteology of some species of Bats. [No. 4,
A well marked species, botli by its peculiarly subcylindrial shape and
by the denticulations of the apertural margins ; it is not uncommon on the
Arakan coast.
Macrochlamys [Durgella] Kttmahensis, n. sp. PI. xi. Fgs. 9 and 10.
Macr. testa convexiuscule orbiculata, polita, tenui, cornea, anguste
perforata, spira modiee elevata ; anfractibus 4|- convexis, regulariter accres-
centibus, sutura simplici adpresssa junctis, infra suturam distincte depressis
atque subcanaliculatis, transversim exilissime obsoletegue striolatis ; ultimo
anfractu ad ambitum regulariter convexo, ad basin convexiusculo, in spatio
umbilici rugulose spiraliter striato ; apertura ampla, semilunata, paulo
obliqua, marginc externo simplici, columellari supra reflexiusculo, umbilicum
partim tegcnte. JHam. mag. 9'6, min. 8-3. alt. 6 ; lat. apert. perist. incl.
5'4, ejusd. alt. 4r3 m.m. Specimi/nis secundi ejusdem maguitudinis altitudo
testae est 6'5 m.m., apertura 5'2 lata, et 4‘5 m.m. alta.
Sab. ‘ Kimah hill ’ in montibus Aralcanensibus, regione Sandoway.
Only the two figured specimens of this shell were found by Mr. Theobald
at the above named locality. The species is intermediate between Blanford’s
compluvialis and nebulosa, differing from the former by being somewhat
depressed, by a comparatively slight sutural depression and larger umbilicus ;
from the latter it differs by its polished surface, less numerous and regularly
convex whorls, particularly at the periphery of the last. These differences
also apply in a comparison with M. honesla of Gould.
Besides the above described new species, Olessula Peguensis, Gless.
liastula, (somewhat larger than the Sikkim type shell), Succinea semicerica,
Sesara Basseinensis, Selicina Arakanensis , Papina Blanfordi, Pterocgclus
parvus, several Alyccei and IJiplommatinm occurred on the Kumah hill and
near Mai-i in the Sandoway district of Arakan.
On the osteology of some species of bats, — by G. E. Dobson, B. A.,
M. B., Assistant Surgeon, H, M.’s British Forces.
Having lately obtained additional specimens of Macroglossus spelaeus,
from Mr. Theobald,* I have been enabled to have a complete skeleton made
from an adult male.
As previously remarked by me, the index finger possesses no trace of a
claw, but has instead a small, but distinct third phalanx connected with the
* Collected at tho Farm Caves near Moulmain where the specimens, from which
the description of the species was taken, were obtained by Dr. Stoliczka. (See Journ.
As. Soc. Beng. Vol. xl, p. 261.)
335
1872.] G. E. Dobson — On the Osteology of some species of Bats.
second phalanx by a perfect joint. This phalanx is scarcely ,-0 inch in
length, and is wholly contained within the wing membrane.
If we compare the skull of ill. spelccus with that of Pteropus medius,
it will be found to resemble it very closely, differing from it only in size,
and in the following points : —
In Pt. medius, the sagittal crest is very prominent, forming a sharp
ridge continued forwards beyond the middle of the zygomatic arches,
dividing at a short distance behind the post-orbital processes of the frontal
into two ridges which become continuous with their posterior margins. In
31. spelieus, the sagittal crest is very short, dividing, at a point correspond-
ing to a line connecting the mastoid processes, into two widely separated
very slightly elevated ridges continued forwards to the posterior margins of
the post-orbital processes. In Pt. medius, the frontal is deeply furrowed
between the roots of the post-orbital processes, in 31. spelieus it is elevated.
In Pt. medius, the post-orbital processes are very long and curved downwards,
separated by a very short interval (in a skull before me 0'15 inch) from a
corresponding process sent upwards from the zygoma, thus almost com-
pletely circumscribing with bone the margin of the orbit. In M. spelieus,
the post-orbital processes of the frontals are short, and almost horizontal ;
the zygoma is slender, and there is no trace of an ascending process.
The bases of the skulls of Pt. medius and 31. spelceus are very similiar,
the only difference noticeable being, that, in the former the foramen rotun-
dum and foramen ovale are represented by a single opening, in the latter they
are distinct.
In Pt. medius, the caudal vertebrae are wanting, in 31. spelceus they are
five in number, very short and rather thick.
The remainder of the skeleton of 31. spelceus corresponds closely in form,
and in the relative proportion of its parts, with that of Pt. medius.
I have read with some surprise Prof. Flower’s statement* that, in the
genus Pteropus, “ there is no corresponding ascending process from the zygo-
matic arch,” — for, in a skull of Pteropus medius, Tern., (compared, above,
with that of 31acroglossus spelceus) the post-orbital process sent upwards
from the zygomatic arch measures 0T5 inch along its anterior margin, 0T5
inch across its base, with a vertical height, posteriorly, of more than 0T0
inch.
The same author, at 1. c. p. 153, remarks that Insectivorous Bats have
no post-orbital processes of the frontals. This statement is only partially
correct, for although many, perhaps most, genera of insectivorous bats do not
possess post-orbital processes, yet in some genera they are not only present,
* Introduction to the Osteology of the Mammalia, by W. H. Flower, F. R. S.
1870, page 152.
33G
G. E. Dobson — Brief Descriptions office new Bats. [No. 4,
but also, — in one genus especially, — quite as well developed as in the frugi-
vorous.
In every species of the genus Taphozous , Geoff., examined by me, I have
found well developed post-orbital processes. In a skull of T. melanopogon,
Tem., before me, a long and slender post-orbital process of the frontal extends
more than half the distance between the frontal bone and the zygomatic
arch, forming nearly one-third of the entire circumference of the orbit.
Post-orbital processes of the frontals are also found in the genera Meja-
derrna and Nycteris. In the latter genus the post-orbital process may be
described as a triangular expanded lamina of bone, of which the base extends
from the sagittal crest to the maxilla ; in the former it is short and blunt,
and its base is perforated, as in Bteropus, by a supra-orbital foramen.
In Vesperus pachypus, Tem., a small post-orbital process exists.
The above examples show that in many species of insectivorous bats
post-orbital processes of the frontals are present. In no species, however,
have I succeeded in detecting corresponding zygomatic processes, as in the
genus Bteropus.
Bbiee descriptions op pive new species op Rhinolophine Bats, —
by G. E. Dobson, B. A., M. B.
The following short descriptions of new species of Rhinolophine bats in
the collection of Chiroptera in the Indian Museum are intended as prefatory
to more detailed descriptions, to be published hereafter with illustrations.
1. Ehinodophds Yunanensis, n. sp.
Ears large ; antitragus separated from the outer margin by a deep, an-
gular incision. Nose-leaf large ; the horizontal horse-shoe shaped portion
concealing the upper lip as in Bh. luctus. The upper edge of the central
erect, anteriorly flattened, nasal crest meets, at the same level, the upper
edge of the posterior vertical membrane. Lower lip divided by a single ver-
tical incision. Wings from the ankles ; tail contained within the interfemo-
ral membrane, with the exception of the extreme tip ; interfemoral mem-
brane cut square behind, or slightly concave.
Length, head and body, 27 inches ; tail 0 9 ; ear (anteriorly) TO ; nose-
leaf 07 ; forearm 2'2 ; tibia IT.
Sab. — Hotha, Yunan ; collected by Dr. Anderson during the Yunan
expedition.*
* Other new species of bats obtained by Dr. Anderson during the Yunan Expe-
dition have been shortly described by the writer in the Proc. As. Soc. Beng. for Sept.
1871.
1872.] 6. E. Dotson — Brief Descriptions office neiv Bats. 337
2. Rhixolophits Gaeoensis, n. sp.
Ears acutely pointed with a well developed antitragus. Upper edge of
the posterior vertical connecting process of the central nose-leaf forming an
acutely pointed elevation ; posterior nose-leaf terminating behind in a broad,
triangular, pointed process.
Wings from the ankles, interfemoral membrane cut square behind ; tip
of tail free.
This species is closely allied to Ith. cornutus, Tern., from Japan, from
which it differs mainly in size.
Length, head and body 1.'5 inches ; tail 07 ; ear (anteriorly) 05 ; fore-
arm, l-3 ; 2nd linger 2-0 ; 4th finger 1'7 ; tibia 06.
Sab. — Garo Hills, Assam. Collected by Major H. H. Godwin- Austen.
3. llinxoLOPiius Amiamanensis, n. sp.
This species resembles Rh. a finis, and may be referred to the same sec-
tion of the genus. The anterior horizontal horse-shoe shaped portion of the
nose-leaf is very broad and flat, concealing the muzzle when viewed from
above, as in Rh. Yunanemis. The posterior triangular nose-leaf is long, and
produced backwards between the ears.
Wings from the ankles, or from the tibia slightly higher up. Interfe-
moral membrane cut square or slightly concave behind ; tip of tail project-
ing.
Length, head and body, 2'5 inches ; tail 0 9 ; ear (anteriorly) 0'85 ; ear
(posteriorly) 0 75 ; forearm 2 '05 ; thumb 0'45 ; tibia l'O.
Sab. — Andaman Islands. Collected by Mr. Homfray, Assistant Super-
intendent, Port Blair, to whom the Indian Museum is indebted for many
specimens illustrative of the zoology of the islands.
4. IlmyoLOPiius Peteesii, n. sp.
Ears acutely pointed, with an emargination immediately beneath the
tip ; antitragus large, separated from the outer margin by a deep angular
incision.
Nose-leaf about same size as in Rh. a finis. The upper border of the
posterior connecting portion of the central nasal crest is produced into a
subacute point ; the sides of the terminal pari of the posterior nose-leaf are
deeply emarginate, so that it ends in a small narrow projection.
Wings from the ankles ; interfemoral mcmbrano slightly triangular be-
hind ; tip of tail free, projecting about -j1^ inch beyond the membrane.
This species resembles Rh. acwminatus, Peters, from Java, but differs
from it, as Dr. Peters informs me, in having the terminal portion of the tail
free, and in other respects, as in measurement, slightly, and in the form of
the ears, &c.
42
338
Gr. E, Dobson — Brief Descriptions office new Bats. [No. 4,
Length (of a male) head and body 2 '5 inches, tail 10 ; ear (anteriorly)
0 75 ; breath of antitragus 0'3 ; length of forearm 2 0 ; thumb 04 ; tibia
0'9 ; foot and claws 05.
Ilab. — Sent from some part of India, precise locality not known.
5. Phyllorhina Masokt, n. sp.
This species belongs to the same section of the genus as Pit. Nicoba-
rensis, Dobson. As in that species, the concave front surface of the base of
the transverse nose-leaf is divided into two cells only by a single central lon-
gitudinal fold ; the upper margin or crest of the transverse nose-leaf, and the
thickened eordiform ridge behind the nasal orifices develop acute projections
in the centre of their front surfaces as in Bit. diadema, Geoff. The horse-
shoe shaped membrane is simple, with three secondary vertical processes of
membrane on each side.
Prom the under surface of the symphisis of the mandible a small coni-
cal bony process projects downwards, about equal to the lower canine tooth
in vertical extent.
Wings from the ankles ; tip of tail free ; interfemoral membrane trian-
gular behind.
Length, head and body, 3-65 inches ; tail 1'65 ; ear (anteriorly) IT ;
forearm 335 ; 2nd finger 5'0 ;• 4th finger 39 ; thumb 0-6 ; tibia T35.
Hub. — Moulmain, Barma.
This fine species was first submitted to me for examination by Mr.
Wood-Mason, with the remark that it was most probably new ; I have,
therefore, much pleasure in connecting his name with it.
INDEX
85° Names of new species have an asterisk (*) prefixed.
Abrornis albogularis, 164
,, castaneiceps, 54
,, flaviventris, 164
i, maculipeimis, 163
,, snpcrciliarie, 164
Acanthocobitis lougipinnis, 183
Acanthodactylus Cantoris) 91
Aoanthophthalmua javanicus, 173
„ pangia, 173
Acanthopsis Berdmorei, 175
„ clioirorrhynclius, 174
„ mioropogon, 175
* Accentor Jerdoni, 327
„ nipalensis, 63
,, rubeculoides, 63, 64
,, strophiatus, 64, 170
Accipiter badiua, 73
„ nisns, 41, 73, 250
„ virgatus, 73, 23u
*Acmella byalina, 333
,, milium, 333
„ tersa, 333
4-cridotheres ator, 246
cristatellus, 216
fuaous, 245
ginginianus, 246
grandis, 246
griseus, 246
triatis, 245
Acrocephalus agrieolus, 77
„ brunneseens, 77
„ dumetoram, 77
„ turdoidos, 77
Actitis glarcola, 252
,, hypoleucus, 253
„ ochropus, 253
Adophaneus orpliea, 243
.xEgialites curonicus, 250
„ fluviatilis, 250
-iEgitkaliscus iouschistos, 58
AEgialitis phillippinus, 250
Agrodroma campestris, 218, 245
Ailurus fulgens, 33
„ ochracous, 33
Alsemon desertorum, 248
Alauda arvensis, 85, 161
„ braohydactyla, 62, 248
„ cristata, 229
Alauda deva, 248
„ dulcivox, 85
„ gulgula, 85, 229
* „ guttata, 85
„ cricutalia, 85
,, triborhyncha, 85, 162, 213
Alcedobengalensis, 74, 232
Allotrius xantkochlorus, 45
Alsocomus Hodgsoui, 70
Alseonax latirostris 142
Altai mountains, 35
Alycmus crispatns, 330
* „ gibbosulus, 268
„ Ingrami, 330
* „ Kurzianus, 330
„ ■ polygona, 330
„ pusillus, 330
„ Bichthofeni, 330
„ uriiula, 330
Ammomanos pkasnicura, 248
Anas boschas, 86, 229, 255
Auomalocora impndica, 245
Anorhinus galeritus, 143
„ Austeni, 143
Anser cinereus, 229
„ indicus, 229
Anthus agilis, 60
„ arboreus, 60
„ Cecilii, 61, 83
,, corvinus, 61, 83
,, japonicus, 61, 83
„ rufogularis, 83
„ rosaceus, 61, 83
„ stx'iolatus, 61
,, tbermophilus, 83
Autilope bezoartica, 229
„ Hodgsonii, 39
Apua fusoa, 172
Aqnila bitasciata, 230
„ fulvcscens, 218, 230
Arachuechthm asiatica, 142, 235
„ cuiTuoaria, 235
Arden cincrca, 86, 254
Ardoola leucoptera, 254
Ardetta miuuta, 86
Artistida deprossa, 217
TKrv.n jav-auica, 217
Arvicola amphibia, 34
340
Index.
Asam, 6, 10, 12, 13
Asilus affinis, 80
Astur palumbarius, 229
Athene brama, 213, 231
Ateuchosaurns travancoricns, 1 39
iEthopyga ignioauda, 14
Aythya ferina, 255
„ nyroca, 255
Balltora maculata, 29
Barillas alburnus, 3
„ Bakeri, 8
,, barila, 8
,, barna, 13
„ bendelisis, 6
„ bicirrhatns, 4
,, Bleekerj, 5
„ bola, 11
„ borelio, 13
„ Braoei, 28
,, eanarensis, 9,
„ cocsa, 6, 7
,, gatensis, 9, 10
, , goha, 1 1
„ guttatas, 12
„ hoaline, 14
„ interruptns, 12
,, modes tag, 4
„ morarensia, 8
„ nigrofasciatus, 8
„ papillatug, 1 1
,, pisoatorias, 3
„ radiolatns, 4
„ rerio, 3
„ ragoaus, 10
,, ghaora, 5
„ tileo, 10
„ vagra, 7
Barbus sarana, 260
,, sehagra, 5
„ stigma, 260
,, ticto, 260
„ vittatns, 260
Bendilisis barila, 8
„ nigrofasciatus, 8
„ vagra, 7
Bengal, 3, 6, 10, 13
Bidan, 73
Bala goha, 11
Botia almorlno, 177, 178
Berdmorei, 177, i79
dario, 177
grandis, 178
hpnenophysa, 177, 178
histrionica, 177, 179
nebulosa, 177
rostrata, 177, 178
Brachypteryx cruralis, 160
» nipalensis, 160
Budytes calcaratue, 82, 244
„ ciuereocapilla, 82, 244
» eitrooloides, 142
Budytes citreolus, 161, 82, 244
„ flava, 82, 244
„ melanooephala, 82, 244
„ viridis, 60
Bubo bengalensis, 231
Bulimus abbysinicus, 212 note
„ atricallosus, 26 1
„ coenopictus, 212 note
„ citrinus, 261
„ insnlaris, 212 note
„ punotatns, 212 note
Buphus coromandus, 218, 254
Buteo canescens, 42, 230
„ desertorum, 42, 73
„ ferox, 42, 219, 230
„ fuliginosus, 230
„ japonicus, 43
„ plnmipes, 41, 42
„ rufiventer, 42
„ vulgaris, 42, 73
Butorides javanica, 254
Bythinea pulohella, 212 note
Caching atpar, 19
Ccelops Fi'ithii, 140
Calamodyta affinis, 165
„ calligata, 212
„ agricolensis, 242
Calandrella brachydaetv la, 85, 248
Callene albiventris, 160
„ frontalis, 160
Calliope kamtschatkensis, 31
„ pectoralis, 52, 77, 31
Collyrio lahtora, 235
Calobates melanope, 82
,, sulphnrea, 82
Calornis affinis, 142
Calotes EUiotti, 113
„ Kouxi, 113
„ trioarinatus, 112
Canis montanus, 33
„ pallipes, 227
Capparis aphylla, 217
Caijrimulgus asiaticus, 232
„ maharattensis, 232
Cardnelis oaniceps, 84
C arpodacus eiy thi'inus, 31, 65, 84, 142,229
Casarca rntila, 73, 229
Colastrus senogaleusis,.217
Centropus rafipennis, 229
„ viridis, 229
Cercomcla fusca, 240
Ceriorais sotyra, 71
Certliia discolor, 56
„ familiaris, 74
„ himalayana, 74
* ,, Hodgsoni, 74
,, nipalensis, 56
Certhilauda desertorum, 212, 218
Corvus affinis, 39
„ Wallichii, 39
Ceryle rudis, 232
Index.
341
Chalcoparia singalensis, 143
Charasia tricarinata, 112
* „ Blanfordaua, 110
„ dorsalis, 86, 109
Chatorhea caudata, 218, 237, 242
Chaulelasmus strepcrus, 218, 255
Chedrus cocsa, 7
Chela allcootee, 26
„ alburua, 18
,, argentea, 22
„ bacaila, 23, 260
„ balookee, 27
„ clupeoides, 27
„ dill'usa, 22
,, flayipinnis, 24
„ gora, 27
„ jorah, 26
„ laubuca, 20
„ novacula, 23
„ Owenii, 25
„ panjabensis, 25
„ phulo, 24
,, sardinella, 25
„ Sladoni, 22
,, teekantee, 26
„ untrali, 24
Chelidom cashmiriensiB, 47
„ nipalensis, 31, 156
„ urbioa, 31
Chelidorhynx hypoxantha, 47
Chettusia grogaria, 213, 218, 229, 250
„ YVn.gleri, 251
Chiamella lineata, 135
Chimarrhornis leuoooophala, 51
Cholamu, 34
Chola range, 39, 65
Chroicocephalus brunieephalus, 256
Chumbi valley, 39
Ckungtam, 40, 65
Chrysoooeoyx Hodgsoni, 142
Chrysomitris ehloris, 84
„ Bpinoides, 66, 84, 170
Cioonia alba, 229
„ nigra, 229
Cinclus asiatieus, 48
„ cashmiriensis, 48
„ sordidas, 48
Circus pallidas, 230
„ Swainsoni, 213, 230
Cirrhina bata, 260
„ dero, 260
„ mrigala, 260
Citrinella hortulana, 247
„ Ituttoni, 218, 247
#Clausilia Ax-akana, 210
„ Asaluensis, 202, 207
„ baoillum, 200, 207
,, Bartletti, 205
„ bengalensis, 201
„ bnlbus, 199, 206
„ ceylanica, 201
Clausilia cylindrioa, 199, 209, 210
* „ fei-rugiuea, 203
„ fusiformis, 203
„ Gouldiana, 203, 208
,, ignota, 20o
„ insignia, 199, 201, 204, 208
„ Ios, 200, 210
,, Jennaarensis, 199 note
i, loxostoma, 202, 208
„ Masoni, 206
* ,, monticola, 204
* „ ovata, 206
„ Philippiana, 199, 205
* „ Theobaldi, 201
„ vespa, 199, 2u5, 209
„ tuba, 206
* „ Waageni, 209
Clupca cyprinoides, 27
Cobitichthya enalios, 198
Cobitis amnicola, 174
„ anguillicaudata, 198
„ arenata, 197
„ balgara, 176
„ Berdmorei, 175
„ bifuroata, 198
„ bilturio, 183
„ bimucronata, 183
„ botia, 183
„ butanensis, 196
,, carnatioa, 176
„ chlorosoma, 188
„ choirorrhynchus, 174
„ eincticauda, 187
„ einnamomea, 1 73
„ coriea, 195
,, oucura, 174
„ dario, 177
„ decemcirrhosus, 198
„ geto, 177
„ gibbosa, 197
„ gongota, 174
„ guntea, 174, 175
„ guttata, 197
,, hymenophysa, 178
„ marmorata, 194
„ maya, 174
„ microps, 190
„ micropus, 198
„ monatonns, 193
„ monoceras, 184
„ montana, 192
„ moreh, 184
„ mysorensis, 176
„ ocellata, 183
„ oculata, 174
„ pangia, 173
„ pavonacea, 182
„ pectoralis, 198
„ phoxocheila, 189
„ peammiamus, 198
„ rubidipinnis, 182
3 ±2
Index.
Cotumix commnuis, 142, 250
Crocidura marina, 223
Cratasva Roxbnrghii, 21 7
Cremnoconchus Syhadrensis, 270
Cressa cretioa, 217
Crex Bailloni, 86
Crotalaria, Burliia, 217
Culioipeta Bnrkii, 54
„ oantator, 163
Cuon ratilans, 228
Carraca affinis, 81
„ garrala, 77, 81
Carsorias gallioas, 213, 218, 250
„ Jamesoni, 213, 218, 250
Cyanecala saeoioa, 53
„ oceralecala, 53
Cyclophorns aquila, 263
„ borneensis, 263
„ Cautori, 262
„ malayanns, 262
,, perdix, 263
,, porpkyritions, 263
„ Efeifferi, 264
„ Pearsoni, 262
„ qaadriiilosns, 270
„ Siamensis, 262
„ triliratns, 270
„ taba, 264
Cyclostoma Birinaimm, 262
Cyornis Jerdoni, 158, 161
„ magnirostris, 158, 161
„ rabicaloidos, 142, 158
Cyrtodactylas affinis, lu5
,, rabidas, 105
Dafila acata, 218, 255
Danio affinis, 17
„ albarnas, 18
„ aarolincatas, 16
„ chrysops, 17
„ daugila, 17
„ devario, 15
„ lineatas, 3
„ lineolatas, 16, 18
„ malabaricas, 16
„ micronoma, 18
„ neilgherriensis, 17
„ asteographas, 18
,, spiaosas, 15
Dondi'ocygna arcaata, 255
Demigrotta sacra, 254
Devario cyanotEeida, 18
„ Mac’lellandji, 15
Dioraras albirietas, 213, 237
„ bbaebanga, 237 noto
„ farcatas, 237 noto
„ longicaadatas, 237 note
*Diplommatiiia angalata, 331
,, earneola, 331
„ exilis, 331
„ nana, 331
„ olygoplouris, 333
„ polyplearis, 330
* „ Eickthofeni, 331
„ sperata, 330
Index.
3-13
Discognfithns lamta, 259 Enprepes monticola, 120
Donkia Pass, 35 . „ malticarinatus, 129
344
Index.
Graculus carbo, 256
„ melanognathus, 256
Graucalus Layardi, 157
„ Macei, 156
Grandala ocolicolor, 49
Grus antigone, 218, 252
„ cinerea, 218, 252
#Gyninodactylus Lawderanus, 105
„ maculatus, 106
„ mannoratus, 106
„ nebulosus, 106
„ pulohellus, 106
Gymnops miorolepis, 90
Gymnoris flavicollis, 247
Gypaetus barbatus, 41
„ moridionalis, 41
Gyp8 bengalensis, 230
„ fnlvus, 41
„ himalayonsis, 41
Halcyon fuscus, 232
„ smyrnensis, 232
Haliastur iudus, 230
Haplochilus panchax, 259
„ rubrostigma, 259
Heliotropium strigosum, 217
„ supinum, 217
Helicina Arakanonsis, 334
Helix cymatiuin, 261
„ fallaciosa, 212 note
„ simi laris, 261
Hemichelidon foliginosa, 47, 75
„ siberioa, 47, 75
#Hemiecliinus albnlns, 226
* „ piotus, 223
Hemidactylus anrantiacus, 99
„ bengaliensis, 98
„ Bordmorei, 100
„ Cocta'i, 97, 98
„ fascia t ns, 95
„ frenatus, 96
„ gaudama, 102
* „ gigantena, 99
„ gracilis, 96
„ Karenorum, 102
„ Kelaartii, 97
„ Lesobenaulti, 97
„ maculatns, 94
„ Mandellianus, 101
„ marmoratus, 97
„ Mortoni, 97
„ Pieresi, 94
„ pnnctatns, 96
„ reticulatua, 96
„ EiibloDvis, 96
„ subtriedrns, 93
» Sykesi, 95
,, triedrns, 93
Hemitrngus jomlaicus, 40
Herodias alba, 229
„ garzetta, 254
>» intermedia, 254
Herpornis tyrannnlus, 167
. „ xantlioleaca, 167
Herpestes grisens, 227
Hesperiphona ioteroides, 84
Heteromorplia nnicolor, 46
Hieraspiza yirgata, 250
Himanotopus autumnalis, 253
„ candidus, 253
„ intermedins, 218, 253
„ melanopterns, 253
Hinulia maculata, 86, 122, 123
„ Dussumicri, 86, 122, 124
„ indica, 86, 122
Hirundo dauricn, 231
„ erythropygia, 231
„ filifera, 231
„ ruficeps, 231
,, rustica, 231
Homaloptera bilineata, 29
„ Brucei, 28
„ erytlarorhinns, 29
„ maculata, 29
Hoplopterns bilobus, 251
„ Brissonii, 251
„ ludoviciana, 251
„ malabaricus, 251
Horeites branneifrous, 55, 78
„ major, 161
* „ pallidus, 78
Horornia fortipes, 165
„ fuliginiventer, 54
Houbara Macquenii, 218, 250
Hubna Nipalensis, 154
„ pectoralis, 154
Hyama striata, 227
Hydrocbolidon indica, 86, 256
Hydropbasianus sinensis, 254
Hydroeissa affinis, 143
„ albirostis, 143
„ coronata, 143
Hymenophysa MacClellnndi, 178
Hypotriorcliis chicquera, 218, 230
Hystrix leucura, 228
„ superoiliaris, 161
Ibidorbynchns Strnthersii, 72, 86
Idnna agricolensis, 242
„ calligata, 242
Inuns rhesus, 220
Iora typhia, 142, 237
„ zeylauica, 218, 237
Imiwadi, The, 12, 22, 25
Ithagenis cruentus, 71
Ixos tristis, 142
Ixulus flavicollis, 45
„ striatus, 166
lanthia rufilata, 52, 76, 161
Japalura miorolepis, 108
„ planidorsata, 108
„ variegata, 106
Jelep-ld, 73
Jerdonia maculata, 179
Index.
34
Kaehh, Zoology of, 179
Kambajong, 39
Kashmir, 50
Kemas Hodgaonii, 59
Khasi Hills, 29, 142
Khyber Pass, Tho, 5
Kittacincla macroura, 142
Kongra Lama, 31
Labeo boggnt, 259, 318
„ calbasu, 259
,, nukta, 319
„ rionorhynchns, 319, 325 noto.
Lacorta Sehneideriana, 103
Lachen valley, 47, 34
Lac hung, 32
Ladak, 50
#Lagerstrcemia calyoulata, 307
„ hypoleuca, 307
Lagooheilus leporinus, 269
scissimargo, 270
striolatus, 271
tomotreiua, 269, 271
trochoides, 270
Willersdorli, 270
Lagomys badius, 35
„ Cnrzonisc, 35
„ Hodgsonii, 35
„ nipalensis, 35
„ Boylei, 35
„ rufoscens, 38
Lamteng, 32, 45
Lanius aronarius, 236
„ erythronotus, 236
„ lahtora, 213, 235
„ lueiouensis, 280
„ tephronotus, 47
„ vittatus, 213, 218, 236
Larus brunicephalus, 256
Larvivora superciliaris, 159, 161
#Leea pumila, 302
Leiurus Berdmorei, 100
Lepidocephalichthys balgara, 175, 176
„ thermalis, 175
Leptopoma Birmanum, 262
Lepus liybridus, 35
pallipcs, 35
oiostolas, 34
ruficaudatus, 228
tibetanus, 34
tolai, 34
variabilis, 84
Lerva nivicola, 72
Leuoiscus aoinaces, 27
,, apiatus, 7
„ baoaila, 23
„ branchiatus, 7
„ cbrysops, 17
„ clupeoides, 27
„ cocsa, 7
„ cultellus, 23
„ Dussumieri, 27
43
Leuoiscus gatensis, 10
„ laubuoa, 20
„ lineolatus, 16
„ novacula, 23
,, salmoides, 11
„ sardinella, 25
„ sqapellus, 24
Leucosticte hmmatapygia, 64, 66
Loucoceroa aurepla, 218, 237
“Leucomcris decoro, 317
Lillia erythropygia, 231
Limosa mgocephala, 218, 252
Lobipluvia malabarioa, 251
Lobivanellus atrogularis, 251
„ goenis, 251
,, indicns, 218, 251
Lophopetalum Wallichii, 299
Lophophaues semodius, 57
„ Beavaui, 57
„ diclinous, 56
,, melanolophus, 58
Lophophorus Impeyanns, 71
Loriculus vemalis, 279
Loranthus hypoglaucus, 309
Lygosoma Dussumieri, 124
Lymusea acuminata, 212 note
„ amygdalus, 212 note
,, luteola, 212 note
Macaous radiatus, 220
Machlolophus spilonotus, 167
,, xauthogenys, 167
Macrochlamys pedinus, 212 note
„ bonestus, 334
„ Kumahonsis, 334
Macroglossus spelteus, 334
Macrones carlio, 260
,, cavasius, 323 note
,, Lamarrii, 315 note
Macropygia phasianella, 287
„ rnfipcnnis, 275, 287
Magnetic momenta, 144
Mareca punctata, 290
Megalomastoma anostoma, 268
„ sectilabrnm, 286
Melania tuberculata, 212 note
*MeIodorum macrantimm, 291
*Memocylon elegans, 306
* ,, pulohrum, 307
Mergus castor, 229
Merops apiaster, 73
,, quinticolor, 277
„ viridis, 232
Morula albocincta, 49
Metoponia pusilla, 84
Microcarbo melauognathus, 256
Micronissus badius, 142, 230
Milvus mtolius, 153
„ affinis, 231
„ govinda, 43, 73, 231
„ melanotis, 43, 73, 153, 231
„ major, 43, 73, 153, 231
346
Index.
Milvus migrans, 153
„ regalia, 153
Miliuaa selerocarpa, 291
Minla einerea, 166
„ igaeotiucta, 45, 58
Mirafra erythroptera, 247
Misgurnus angnillicaudatus, 198
„ lateralis, 198
Moooa himalayaua, 127
* „ sacra, 128
„ Schlegelii, 128
„ sikkimensis, 126
Momay samdong, 39, 54
■ Mongolia, 34
*Montifringilla rulicollis, 66
„ nivalis, 68
*Morinda Leiantha, 313
* „ Wallichii, 313
Mosclius moschifera, 39
Motacilla alba, 60, 82
„ alboides, 82
„ Cashmiriensis, 59, 82
„ Dukkhunensis, 61 note, 244
„ Hodgsoni, 81, 59, 82
„ lugonB. 82
„ lugnbi’is, 69
„ Luzonionsis, 31, 59, 82, 244
„ madaraspatensis, 244
„ peraonata, 81, 82
„ suecioa, 53
Muelleripicus Kodgii, 275, 279
Munia leuoonota, 286
„ malabarioa, 228, 246
Muscicapa fnsoednla, 75
„ siberioa, 75
Muscicapula sappliira, 142
Mus decumanus, 228
„ hydrophilus, 34
„ nrbanus, 228
Myeerobas melanoxantlms, 64
llyiagra azorea, 283
„ Tytleri, 275, 213
Myiomola lonoura, 161
Myzomis pyrrhoura, 44
Nomuoheilus aureus, 180, 180
„ Blythii, 182, 196
„ Beavani, 181, 193
„ botia, 180, 183
„ butauensis, 182, 196
„ cinctieauda, 187
„ clilorosoma, 181, 188
„ corioa, 182, 195, 325 note
„ Denisonii, 181, 193
„ Evezardi, 180, 182
„ Griffiths, 182, 195
„ Guentheri, 182, 195
„ guttatus, 182, 197
„ ladaoensis, 181, 187
„ marmorafcus, 182, 194
„ microps, 181, 190
„ monooeros, 180, 184
Nemaoheilus montanus, 181, 192, 327
„ moreh, 180, 184
„ mugah, 181, 191
„ notostigma, 181, 191
„ pavonaoeus, 180, 182
„ phoxooheila, 181, 189
„ rubidipinnis, 182, 196
„ rupeoula, 185
„ Biipelli, 180, 184
„ rupioola, 180, 185
„ savona, 181, 193
„ semiarmatus, 181, 186
„ semizonata, 182
„ sinuatus, 181, 188
„ serpontarius, 181, 189
„ spilopterus, 181, 192
„ Stoliczkro, 181, 188
,, striatus, 181, 190
„ subfusea, 181, 187
„ tenuicauda, 181, 186
„ triangularis, 181, 194
„ turio, 182, 197
urophtlialmus, 180, 183
„ zonata, 181, 187
,, zonalteruans, 181, 186
Nemorhtodus goral, 40
„ bubalinus, 40
Nemura Hodgsoni, 159
Neophron ginginianus, 230
Noodon sikkimensis, 34
Neornis flavolivacea, 170
♦Nephelium Griffithiauum, 303
Nitidula Hodgsoni, 159, 161
Nucifraga hemispila, 69
Numenius arquata, 229
„ phajops, 288
Ninox affinis, 275
Nuria danrioa, 260
Nycteridium himalayannm, 104
„ platyurus, 103, 104
„ Schnoidorianum, 103
Nyotiardoa nyotioorax, 254
Nycticorax griseus, 86, 254
♦Oolina audamaniea, 295
* „ fruticulosa, 295
Gldionemns indicus, 251
Ophiocephalus punotatus, 258
Ophiops eiogans, 89
„ Beddomei, 90
„ Jerdoni, 89
„ mouticola, 90
„ Theobald!, 89
♦Ophiorkiza gracilis, 311
#Opisthoporus penangensis, 265
• ,, solutus, 266
„ sumatranus, 265
Opsarius acanthopterus, 13
„ albulus, 25
„ anisocheilus, 8
,, bacaila, 23
„ bicirrliatus, 4
Index.
347
Oriocalotes minor, 110
„ tricarinata, 110
Oriolua andamanensis, 284, 275
„ chinensis, 284
,, coroiwit.ua, 284
„ Horsfleldi, 284
,, melanocepkalua, 284
„ macrurus, 284
Orissa, 8, 12, 13
Orthodomns longioandns, 218, 240
Ortygornis ponticerianua, 249
Orygia decumbens, 217
Osmotroron ckloroptera, 286
Otocompsa jocosa, 284
,, loncotis, 218, 239
Otoooria alpestrls, 63
* „ Elwesi, 62
longirostria, 63
„ penicillata, 63
Otogyps oalvns, 230
Otus vulgaris, 231
Ovis ammon, 40
,, nahura, 34, 40
PaJsBornis affinis, 274, 279
„ Alexandri, 273, 278
„ erythroganys, 274, 275, 279
„ javanicns, 279
* ,, magnirostris, 278
„ nicobaricns, 279
„ rosa, 278
„ torqnatns, 232
„ vibrisoa, 279
Paludina melanostoma, 212 note
,, dissimilis, 212 note
Pachystomns vide Barilius, 5
Pangio oinnamomoa, 173
Paradanio aiirolineatus, 18
„ elegans, 19
„ neilgherriensis, 17
Parns Atkinsoni, 57
„ nnchalis, 218, 245
Passer domesticus, 247
Pericroootns andamanensis, 274, 281
„ brevirostris, 47
„ erythropygins, 236
,, peregrinns, 236, 218, 282
„ solaria, 47
„ speciosns, 281
Perilampus affinis, 16
,, aradanio, 16
,, atpar, 19
„ aurolineatns, 16
,, sequipinnatus, 18
„ canaronsia, 18
„ ceylononsia, 21
„ caohina, 19
„ devario, 15
„ fnlvescena, 20
,, guttatus, 20
„ laubuca, 20
„ macropodns, 19
,, malabaricus, 18
„ myaoricus, 18
„ oateographua, 18
,, persons, 20
,, psilopterns, 19
,, reticulatua, 17
„ striatns, 3
Periplaneta germauica, 211 note
Peripia Cantoris, 103
„ Peronii, 103
•Poycbotria viridisaiina, 315
Petroeoasyphna oyaneua, 237
PhamicoptorU8 antiquorum, 255
Plmlnng, 48, 68
Phalanginm graminifolinm, 217
Philomachus pugnax, 252
Pholidauges leucogaster, 49
Phyllopneuste rama, 218, 242
„ rnfa, 53
,, troohilns, 53 note
Phyllorhina atra, 220
„ atrata, 220
„ cineraeea, 220
348
Index.
Phyllorhina diadema, 338
fulva, 220
larvata, 136, 220
Masoni, 338
murina, 220
Nicobarensis, 338
Phylloscopus affinis, 54, 80, 81
„ lugubris, 53
„ fuseatns, 32, 162
„ fuliginiventer, 54, 32
,, indicus, 54, 81, 142
„ Iugubris, 32, 162
,, magnirostris, 7 9
„ neglcctus, 162
„ nitidns, 81
,, pallidipeg, 162
' „ rufus, 243
,, Sohwarai, 80
„ tenellipes, 162
„ tristis, 32, 81, 162,
218, 242
„ troehilus, 79, 81
„ Tytleri, 79
„ viridanus, 32, 79, 81
Pious andamanensis, 279
,, Blanfordi, 232, 233
,, cathpavius, 155
„ hyperythrus, 43
„ Macei, 155
„ maharattensis, 232, 233
„ poctoralis, 279
*Pimelodus vaclia, 323 note
Pimpinella Parishiana, 309
Pipastes agilis, 60
„ arboreus, 60, 83, 327
,, maculatns, 60, 83
„ plumatUB, 00
*Pipistrellus leucotis, 222
*Pirus Karensium, 306
Planestieus atrogularis, 237
Planorbis exustus, 2 1 2 note
Plataoantbus agrensis, 176
„ inaoulntus, 179
Platycara australis, 28
„ maoulata, 29
„ auisura, 29
Plestiodon Aldrovandi, 121
Plooeus baya, 167, 246
„ raegarhyuobus, 167
„ philippinus, 167
Plotus melanogaster, 256
Platalea leucorodia, 255
Pnoepyga albiveuter, 55
,, squamata, 55, 160
Podioeps cristatns, 229
„ minor, 218, 256
Poliornis teesa, 230
Poliosetus plumbens, 73
„ humilis, 73
*P°lygala cardiooarpa, 293
» Karensium, 292
*PolygaIa Vahliana, 217
Polygonum plebejum, 217
Pomatorliinus erytbrogenys, 143
„ hypoleucos, 143
Pratinoola caprata, 76, 238
„ ferrea, 31
„ indioa, 31, 49, 76, 238
* „ macrorhyncba, 238
„ rubioola, 233
. Presbytes entellus, 220
,, priamus, 220
„ scbistaeeus, 32
Prinia ciuero-capilla, 165
,, gracilis, 165, 240
„ Jerdoni, 240
,, socialis, 165
,, Stewarti, 165
Procarduolis nipalonsis, 66
Procapra picticaudata, 39
213, Proparua chrysams, 45
„ vinipectus, 45
Propasser frontalis, 65
,, pulchorrimus, 169
„ rhodoolirous, 169
,, rbodopeplns, 169
,,’ rhodoehlamys, 169
* „ saturatus, 65, 168, 170
„ thura, 65, 1 68
Prosopis spicigera, 217
Prostheacanthus spoctabilis, 174
Pseudeutropiua lougimanus, 323 note
„ taakroe, 322 note
Pseudophiops bivttafca, 89 note
„ Jerdoni, 89
,, Theobaldi, 89
*Psychotria calocarpa, 315
* „ Helferiaua, 314
* ,, monticola, 315
Psilobium capillars, 313
Pteroclcs areuarius, 249
„ exustus, 213, 249
„ fasoiatus, 249
Pterocyclus parvus, 334
Pteropsafion mquipinnatus, 18
„ Bakeri, 9
Pteropus medius, 257, 223, 234
Pteruthius erythropterus, 170
Ptiouoprogne concolor, 231
,, rupestris, 232
Ptychozoon bomalocsphalum, 92
Puntius vittatus, 326
*Puntius Waageni, 325
•Pupa filosa, 333
Pnpina arula, 267
* „ aureola, 267
„ Blanfordi, 334
Pycnonotus obysorrhoides, 218, 237
Pyctoris sinensis, 237
*Pygeum persimile, 306
*Pyramidanthe macrantbum, 291
Pyrj hospiza punioea, 66
Index.
349
Pyrrhoplectes opanletta, 65
Pyrrhula erythaea, 65
„ erytliroeephala, 64
„ nipalensis, 65
Pyrrhulauda affinis, 248
„ grisea, 248
Querquedula anadamanensis, 290
,, orecca, 218, 255
Rallus striatus, 273, 288
Ran, The, 213
KRaphauhis paehysiplion, 329
Rasbora danioonius, 260
Recurvirostris avoeetta 253
Reguloides ehloronotus, 54, 162
„ erochroa, 32, 54, 163
,, occipitalis, 81
„ proregnlus, 54, 81, 162
„ snperciliosus, 81
,, trochiloides, 81, 163
Rhinolophus aenminatus, 337
affinis, 337
Andamauensis, 337
comutus, 337
Garoensis, 337
luctna, 336
Peters), 337
Yunanensisj 336
Rhinopoma Itardwiekii, 221
Rhyacornis fuliginosa, 50
Rhyticeros plicatus, 143
Riopa albopunctata, 132
,, anguina, 130
* „ cyanella, 130
,, Hardwkikii, 132
,, pnnetato, 132
Ristella malabarica, 129 note
„ travancorica, 129
Ruticilla caoruleocephala, 50
„ erythrogastra, 51
„ frontalis, 34, 50
,, fnliginosa, 50
„ Hodgsonii, 161
„ lencocephala, 51
„ rufiventris, 31, 50, 240
,, Yigorsii, 51
Rnttun Pir, Mountain, 73
*Sabia viridissima, 304
*Salacia flavcsccns, 300
* „ grandiflora, 300
*Salomonia longiciliata, 292
Salvia asgyptiaca, 217
Sitrciophorns bilobns, 218, 251
Sarcostigina edule, 298
Saxicola atrognlaris, 213, 272, 259
„ capistrata, 239
„ deserti, 218, 239, 218
„ isabellina, 239
„ Kingi, 239
„ montana, 239
Saxicola picta, 213, 218, 239
*Scaphiodon irregularis, 324
* „ Watsoni, 324
Schilbe paleo, 323
Schistura acnleata, 176
„ balgara, 176
„ montana, 192
„ punctata, 195
,, mpicola, 185
„ subfosca, 187
,, zonata, 187
*Scliizochiton grandiflorum, 296
Scincus agilis, 121 note
„ auratus, 121
„ carinatus, 121 note
,, ocellatns, 121 note
„ pavimontatus, 121
„ quinqne carinatus, 121 note
,, Schncideri, 121
Sciurns palmarum, 213, 219
*Semecarpus snbraeemosa, 304
Senira bicolor, 122
Serilophus lonatns, 143
„ rubro-pygoa, 143
Sesara Basscinensis, 339
Sibilatrix affinis, 80
Sikkim, Independent, 3, 30
Singalea range, 65
Siphia Ioucomelannra, 76, 159
„ strophiata, 47, 58
„ superciliaris, 159, 161
„ tricolor, 142
Sitana doecanensis, 189
„ minor, 108
„ ponticeriana, 108
Sitta cassia, 75
* „ casbmirensis, 75
„ enropasa, 75
,, bimalayaua, 75
„ bimalayensis, 56
„ lencopsis, 75
Siva strigula, 45
*Smythea oalpicarpa, 301
Solauum uigram, 217
„ trilobatum, 217^
Somileptes gongota, 174
Spatula ciypeata, 218, 255
Spilornis bacha, 274, 275
„ Elgini, 274
„ spilogastor, 275
Spiraculnm Masters!, 202
*Spirudieklis bifida, 310
Spizaotus andamanensis, 275
Spizalauda deva, 213, 248
,, simillima, 248
Stacliyris nigriceps, 165
Statice Stocksii, 217
♦Stellio Dayanus, 113
„ himalayanus, 113
„ indicus, 116
„ rnclmuirus, 113
„ platym’us, 103
350
Index.
Stellio tuberculatus, 113, 115
*Stemourus crassipes, 298
* „ tomentellns, 298
Stenogyra gracilis, 212 note
Sturnus nitons, 84
„ nnicolor, 84
„ vulgaris, 84, 245
Suooinea crassiusoula, 212
„ somicerioa 339
„ vitrea, 212
Sus indioa, 228
Suya criniger, 142, 170
Sylvia affinis, 243
„ curruca, 213, 218, 243
„ Jordoni, 243
„ orphoa, 243
SylviparuB modestus, 1G7
Syncrossus Bordmorei, 179
Sypheotides auritus, 218, 250
Syrrhaptes tibetanns, 71
Taccocua sirkee, 234
Tackydromus Haughtonianus, 88
„ japonicus, 88
„ meridionalis, 88
„ septemtrionalis, 88
,, sexlineatus, 87
Tamarix orientalis, 217
Tamlung, 43
Tankra Pass, The, 32, 72
Tantalus leucocephalus, 255
Tapkozous longimanus, 221
* „ Kaohhensis, 221
„ melanopogon 336
„ saccolaimus, 221
Temenuobus andamanensis, 275, 285
„ orytliropygia, 285
„ pagodarum, 246
TepbrodomiB pelvica, 156
„ pondioeriana, 218, 236
Terai, Sikkim, 32
Tesia oastaneo-eoronata, 65
„ rufiventer, 55, 160
Testudo elegans, 257
Tetraogallua himalayonsis, 72
„ tibetanus, 72
Thamnobia cambayensis, 218, 257
„ fulioata, 237
Threskiornis molanooephalus, 143, 255
Tiaris Elliotti, 112
„ subcristata, 116
Tickellia Ilodgsoni, 164
Tiliqua oarinata, 119
„ maoularia, 118
„ monticola, 119
„ trivittnta, 119
Timalia pileata, 143
Tinnunculus alaudarius, 41, 230
Tinospora nudiflora, 292
Tista valley, 47
Todiramplms collaris, 278
Totanus oalidris, 253
Totanus fnsens, 253
„ glottis, 253
„ hypoleucos, 86
Treron chloroptera, 275
Triamops persicus, 136
Triantkemum orystallinum, 217
„ decandrum, 217
Tribura luteovontris, 142, 164
Trichodesma indicum, 217
“Tricholepis Karensium, 318
*Trichosantbes maorosiphon, 308
*Tridesmis pruniilora, 293
Tringa minuta, 229
„ Temminokii, 252
Troohalopterum affine, 46
„ cacobinans, 46
,, chrysopterum, 46
,, Fairbunki, 46
„ Jerdoni, 46
„ pkmnioeum, 46
. „ squamatum, 46
,, subunioolor, 46
*Troglodytes neglectns, 328
„ nipalensis, 55, 328
Tropidosaura Jerdoni, 89
Tm-dus Bengalensis, 143
,, chrysolaus, 143
„ dissimilis, 142, 143
„ hortulorum, 142
„ pallens, 143
Turtur cambayensis, 213, 246
„ kumilis, 249, 287
,, risorius, 248
Turnix taigoor, 250
Tylognathus striolatus, 260
Unio cserulous, 212 note
„ leioma, 212 note
Upupa ceylonensis, 213
„ epops, 44, 75
,, nigripennis, 235
Urocissa flavirostris, 70
Uromastix Hardwickii, 227
Uromitus filifera, 231
*Urophyllum biloculare, 313
Urrua bengalensis, 231
Ursus isabelliuus, 33
„ labiatus, 226
„ tibetanus, 33
Uvaria solerocarpa, 291
Yablia viscosa, 217
•Vanguoria pnboscens, 314
Vornouia oinei'ea, 217
Vesperus pachypus, 336
Vespertilio Blanfordi, 33
*Vitis assimilis, 302
„ campylooarpa 302
,, erytlrroclada, 301
„ Walliebii, 302
Vulpos bengalensis, 228
„ flavesoens, 33
„ leuoopus, 228
Index.
351
Vulpes montanns, 33
*Walsura hypoleuca, 296
* „ pubescens, 297
*Wobora giomorifiora, 311
*WendIanclia glomerulata, 310
„ soabra, 310
Xiplioramphus superciliaris, 17
Yeomatang, 41, 47
*Jodes Brandisii, 298
YuLiina gnlaris, 44
„ occipitalis, 44
Yungipicus pygmoous, 156
Yunx torquilla, 74
•Zollingeria macrocarpa, 303
Zoothera monticola, 49, 142
ZosteropSjSimplex, 157
„ palpebrosus, 158
ERRATA.
Page 55, line 9 from below for Sesia read Testa.
» 219, „ 9 „ above for ruficaudus read ruficaudatw.
F. DAY. Join** : A. S . B . VoLXLI. Pt-JL 187k.
PM.
,r
-Jr sYe dg/ield }Lith:
2. JJanio' wiroMneatuf. 2.£arUiutr Bake.nl-.
•3 . B ajV-J'iiio- lo7<i . /. CfieZ-as tjpovs
Calcutta- .
STOLIC^KA. Journ: A. S.B.VolrXLI.Ptrll. 1878.
PL JL .
c
& SwtyfielcC.Liik-
1 He rnidacty'liis ^icl—trtecfvuff- , JercC.f?) 3. He, 't . (DoryuPa) Be-rdmopci Blyth, .
2. - " yiy&nteicy, rv.^fv. 4. G.yrruwddctyluj' La.{t/i&.nm.misj ns ft.
Calcutta..
STOLICZKA Jourii: A. S .B.VoLXLI.Pt 11.1872.
PI: m.
J-Z Hsm (Bo T-yur.y M a ihdi lli-a. nu.-s, ruafi. ■# . BteUio Dayanua, , iv.aji. Jf’.&.LvUuCdMMa,.
3.St»lH-o tuBcroutMu#, (Iri.y. S.Chfiraaia. BUmfoniein*,, ru .pi. .
ST0L1CZKA.. Jcrora: A. S E .Vol: XLI.Pt =11,1872 .
PI - IV.
3 T>.
.-...—Mm,,. - -
■"(*?'
1. Hvnu2xJ)u isvcLu:a, Grey.
2 ,, rruXjC'.iZa±et> , Bb/tfv.
3 ,, Dassurru^rv, D 4" g .
4« MocccL' souzra, tv. sp .
S. Bistelleu TroMouvcericcv, BeeLcC.
I
PI: V.
STOLICZKA.. Journ: A. S.B. VoL XU , Ft:Il, 1872.
4 JUopcv cunxjuAruxs, Theob.
5- „ HardMrvchii, Gr'ay-
6. n alb op urrvtatcc ,
1. Euprepes rrvcvc alarms , Bb-
2. JMbcocv SikkurvensCs , Bb.
3. Riopou cyanellcv, tv, sp
PI VI.
G.K DOBSON.. Journ: A S. B. Vol = XL I, Ft: II, 1S72
W. T. BLANFORD. Journ: A. S. B. Vol: XLI. Pt: II. 1873.
PI: Till.
BLANFORD 8f STOLIC ZKA . Journ. AsiaV. Sac : Bengal. Vol: XL1. Ft: II .1872 VI IX
. cylindriccu p- 1998;Z07. 6 C. Ipxoaipnuxp Z01&-Z08. //. C. wsigrias)Goul<l.p.Z04- 8c"ZOB. 16 C bulb us p 7.06
.Ids. p. ZOO 7. C.ferrwgirvea. p.Zoz 12 C. ir\siqni*?fi ,H 8rTpZ04- 17. / oYcctcu. „
baxiHuxw -p-ZOO 8c 207. 8. C.Asatu^rvsis <t *t 13. C. merUvcola * M C. Mnsonl ..
Uylomxccu. p.ZOl. 9. C fujevComus p. 203 14CThilippva*iap.20S. 79 C tycuujeiu, p. 20.9.
TheobaisLb „ „ 10. C. Goirfcbuarwu >< ,, IS C vespco, p Zos&'iod 20. c. AraJuirux- p 'Uo
PI X
r. S TOLI C ZKA, J*urn:A5iat: Soc Bengal- Vd:"XI. I. :11. 1872
I- 5 Cycl4>phortL6 McUxiyairus . p ‘462.
6. „ JiorneensLS, p 263.
7. OpisLhoporusPenangcnsls. p 7.66
8-10. » sohutuA, p.%66.
II- 12. Pupincv aureolas, p- 267
13 AbsjuLonuXjStlwui se-clilabriwth p ’467,
14- . /lOfcHULS (jibbosuLu# , p 266
16 Lugoehailus 1,1'OcJvouLes , p 4 7o
16 „ str-voLcUis , p 27}
t b
PI XI
THEOBALD and .STOLTCZKA. Journ:Asiai.Soc:Bengal,Vol:XLI,Pt 11,1872.
9.0 9 b-
1 RaphaJthiK pachy-siphoTis p.329.
2 dlycaes&s Kurxjtanxi* , pzzo
3. DiploTtvni-ajbiJUi arujul&tco, p-331-
4 „ RickthoiirvL, p 331.
•> t> >
7r
5_6'. Grerussa frate.mcb , p. 332
7. /JcrrMUa' kyaJ.ina,, p 333
£. VupOLPilxisvu, p-333.
JO Masrochl. Kttmah-endi* , p. 333 .
>
Wo