oad
{ee
THE ANNALS -S¥ )
AND
MAGAZINE OF NATURAL HISTORY,
INCLUDING
ZOOLOGY, BOTANY, ann GEOLOGY.
(BEING A CONTINUATION OF THE ‘ ANNALS ’ COMBINED WITH LOUDON AND
CHARLESWORTH’S ‘MAGAZINE OF NATURAL HISTORY. ’)
CONDUCTED BY
CHARLES C. BABINGTON, Ese., M.A., F.R.S., F.LS., F.G.S.,
JOHN EDWARD GRAY, Ph.D., F.R.S., F.LS., F.Z.S. &.,
WILLIAM S. DALLAS, F.LS.,
AND
WILLIAM FRANCIS, Ph.D., F.L.S.
es pot
y ~~ A a ere vay ~
\
| 9X MOL, XL—FOURTH SERIES.
ae aye
DANS
LONDON:
PRINTED AND PUBLISHED BY TAYLOR AND FRANCIS.
SOLD BY LONGMANS, GREEN, READER, AND DYER; SIMPKIN, MARSHALL,
AND CO.; KENT AND CO.; WHITTAKER AND CO.: BAILLIERE, PARIS:
MACLACHLAN AND STEWART, EDINBURGH :
HODGES, FOSTER, AND CO., DUBLIN: AND ASHER, BERLIN.
1873.
“Omnes res create sunt divine sapientiz et potenti testes, divitie felicitatis
humanze :—ex harum usu donitas Creatoris; ex pulchritudine sapientia Domini;
ex ceconomia in conservatione, proportione, renoyatione, potentia majestatis
elucet. arum itaque indagatio ab hominibus sibi relictis semper xstimata ;
a veré eruditis et sapientibus semper exculta; malé doctis et barbaris semper
inimica fuit.”—Linnavs.
“Quel que soit le principe de la vie animale, il ne faut qu’ouvrir les yeux pour
voir qu’elle est le chef-d’eeuvre de la Toute-puissance, et le but auquel se rappor-
tent toutes ses opérations.’—Bruckner, Théorie du Systeme Animal, Leyden,
1767.
no oO 6 a6 fo. 6 The sylvan powers
Obey our summons; from their deepest dells
The Dryads come, and throw their garlands wild
And odorous branches at our feet; the Nymphs
That press with nimble step the mountain-thyme
And purple heath-flower come not empty-handed,
But scatter round ten thousand forms minute
Of velvet moss or lichen, torn from rock
Or rifted oak or cavern deep: the Naiads too
Quit their loved native stream, from whose smooth face
They crop the lily, and each sedge and rush
That drinks the rippling tide: the frozen poles,
Where peril waits the bold adventurer’s tread,
The burning sands of Borneo and Cayenne,
All, all to us unlock their secret stores
And pay their cheerful tribute.
J. Taytor, Norwich, 1818.
CONTENTS OF VOL. XI.
[FOURTH SERIES. ]
NUMBER LXI.
I. Transformation of an entire Shell into Chitinous Structure by
the Polype Hydractinia, with short Descriptions of the Polypidoms
of five other Species. By H. J. Carrer, F.R.S. &c. (Plate L) ..
Il. On a new Species of Nettapus (Cotton-Teal) from the River
Yangtsze, China. By R. Swinnor, H.M. Consul at Ningo ......
II. On Berardius and other Ziphioid Wales. By Dr. J. E. Gray,
Lon 2S a 0TH J 5S iS OO nia OI COOnMpiac OM ono tc oc an
IV. On the Peregrine Falcon from Sardinia. By R. BowpLeRr
Suarpg, F,L.S., F.Z.S., &c., Senior Assistant, Zoological Department,
eberetsin, Mineateriaaas vo. die fy s)halayeie o's ale oY ayaa si de Aaieiw ayete lve ewie's
V. Notes on the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. By
He ree Amp ey 51517... ciatats o)a/eis) ats: oie cloelelstalsiols shave wie’ a 6 aye eis
VI. Growth or Evolution of Structure in Seedlings. By Joun C,
Dnaren, MDs. itis sie e Rote eardelele okra Mere cinerea dae sada
VIL. Sequoia and its History. By Professor Asa Gray, President
of the American Association for the Advancement of Science......
VIII. Physico-chemical Investigations upon the Aquatic Articu-
Pinoy Ma herik PLATEAU.) bart My cen incon celeue snes
IX. Additional Notes on Spatulemys Lasale. By Dr. J. E. Gray,
HRs. we. (Plate Il)... See COM DE UO MOC aar On OC HORE ETC
X. On the Macleayius australiensis from New Zealand. By Dr. J.
EB Ye CCMEAN NE ERS GUC rect ors state Mt wrote orbiter ov cbShorhe oe ole ans corel alesis tates
On the Reproduction and Development of the Telescope-fish of China,
by M. Carbonnier; Additional Observations on Codiophyllum,
by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S, &e.; The Bell Collection of Reptiles ;
Answer to Herr Ritsema’s “ Note on Crinodes Sommeri” &c.,
by A. G. Butler, F.L.S. &c.; On a Mite in the Ear of the Ox;
The Horns of Antilocapra, by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.; Notice
Page
of a new and remarkable Fossil Bird, by O. C. Marsh...... 76—80
1v CONTENTS.
NUMBER LXII.
Page
XI. Summary of Zoological Observations made at Naples in the
winter of 1871-72. By E. Ray Lanxestrr, M.A., Fellow and Lec-
turer of Exeter College; Oxford <3. ....02 50s 0) eee 81
XII. On the Geographical Distribution, Migration, and Occasional
Habitats of Whales and Dolphins (Céete). By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.RS.
XIII. Notes on the Whales and Dolphins of the New-Zealand
Seas. By Dr. James Hector, F.R.S. With Remarks by Dr. J. E.
GRANGE ASI RG. cpio siks doe Wald dete ee Cae ee ee eee 104
XIV. A Monographic List of the Species of the Genus Gonyleptes,
with Descriptions of three remarkable new Species. By ArnTHUR
GaRDINER BUTLER, F.L.S., F.Z.S., &e. (Plate TIL) ....5...00 112
XV. Notes on the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. By
BLOW. BATES, ELAS, i. 0204 also sislties eeletees eet aioe ee eee 117
XVI. On a new Species of Turkey Vulture from the Falkland
Islands and a new Genus of Old-World Vultures. By R. Bowpier
SHarpeé, F.L.S., F.Z.S., &c., Senior Assistant, Zoological Depart-
ment, British Museum: oseccc ect dve ce dd cd dd ddd de dee deen 133
XVII. On some Fossils from the Quebee Group of Point Lévis,
Quebec. By H. ALLEYNE Nicwotson, M.D., D.Sc., M.A., F.R.S.E.,
Professor of Natural History in University College, Toronto ...... wb.
XVIII. Notes on Tortoises. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &..... 143
New Books:—Records of the Rocks; or Notes on the Geology,
Natural History, and Antiquities of North and South Wales,
Devon, and Cornwall, by the Rev. W. 8S. Symonds, F.G.S. &c.
—A Manual of Palzeontology for the Use of Students, with a
General Introduction on the Principles of Paleontology, by H.
A; Nicholson; MDD Se, G0: iia etéais deste ee he ee 149—151
Anatomical Investigations on the Limuli, by A. Milne-Edwards; On
the Boomdas (Dendrohyrax arboreus), by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S.
&c. ; On Deep-sea Dredging in the Gulf of St. Lawrence, by J.
F. Whiteaves, F.G.S. &c.; Nitophyllum litteratum, a new Bri-
tish Alga, by Prof. T. G. Agardh; On a new Freshwater Tortoise
from Borneo (Orlitia borneensis), by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e. ;
Descriptions of three new Species of Crustacea parasitic on the
Cetacea of the N.W. coast of America, by W. H. Dall, U.S.
Coast Survey; Orca stenorhyncha (the Narrow-nosed Killer) ;
Preliminary Descriptions of new Species of Mollusks from the
North-west coast of America, by W. H. Dall, U.S. Coast Sur-
vey; Projectile Power of the Capsules of Hamamelis virginica,
py Mr.-T. Meehan}. .:...::4..6<i . dba dee eRe eee ae ek 152—160
CONTENTS. : v
NUMBER LXIZ.
Page
XIX. On the Original Form, Development, and Cohesion of the
Bones of the Sternum of Chelonians; with Notes on the Skeleton of
Sphargis. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &. (Plates IV., V., & VI.) 161
XX. On the Homologies of the Shoulder-girdle of the Dipnoans
and other Fishes. By THroporE Gitx, M.D., Ph.D., &c......... 173
XXI. Additions to the Australian Cureulionide. Part IV. By
Pa AG apes ASCO, Ech G61 vidiclals alale's!t oiets ale ola vieleje ove iess sie ere 178
XXII. On the Silurus and Glanis of the Ancient Greeks and
Romans. By the Rev. W. HoveurTon, M.A., F.LS..........-.. 199
XXIII. Remarks on certain Errors in Mr. Jeffreys’s Article on
“The Mollusca of Europe compared with those of Eastern North
America.” By A. E. Verrix1, Professor of Zoology in Yale College,
eum SIV ety CONT MISA wra.c<1c <i wel sole: aie. eralalelala ain orarelsleneale 2 at 206
XXIV. Remarks on Cervus chilensis and Cervus antisiensis. By
P. L. Sctarer, M.A., F.R.S., Secretary to the Zoological Society of
RAR Gaal Se, NaF h. oy 5 FICO 5%) ev oS ho Siete ont Ske fol la] rast alot abe, 218
XXV. Further Remarks on the Guémul of Patagonia (Huamela
Peco an by Dr: J. EGray, BOR.S. &e.. 2.2.5.2 2 2-0 seer tn tean 214
XXVI. On the Peregrine Falcon of the Magellan Straits. By R.
Bowo er Suarpe, F.LS., F.Z.8., &c., Senior Assistant, Zoological
Department, British Museum ..........cccsesseecccsvcerccces 220
New Book :—Dr. Ehrenberg’s Microgeological Studies ............ 224
Proceedings of the Royal Society. ............-seecereseeeseees 227
On Whales in the Indian Ocean, by H. J. Carter, F.R.S. &c.; Ona
new Subclass of Fossil Birds (Odontornithes), by O. C. Marsh ;
On two new Free Sponges from Singapore, by Dr. J. E. Gray,
F.R.S. &c.; On the “Capreolus”’ of Zonites algirus, by E. Du-
breuil; On the Developmental History of Petromyzon, by A.
Schneider; On the Parasites of the Cetaceans of the N.W.
Coast of America, with Descriptions of New Forms, by W. H.
Dall, U.S. Coast Survey .........ce cece eneeseesoees 231—238
NUMBER LXIV.
XXVIL. On the Calcispongie, their Position in the Animal King-
dom, and their Relation to the Theory of Descendence. By Pro-
PeSHOr PANST) EVACKEL © o.0 05 carth wh aes lel ntaa Relea ale oie vate 241
vi CONTENTS.
Page
XXVIII. Remarks on a few Species belonging to the Family
Terebride, and Descriptions of several new Forms in the Collection
of the British Museum. By Epe@ar A. Smiru, F.Z8., Zoological
Departaaent, British Museum 2.4...) tec. oct odes ou Eee Ae 262
XXIX. On the French Species of the Genus Geomalacus. By
D. F. Heynemann, President of the German Malacozoological
Society, Frankfort-on-Maine. . 3. coe eo wow e ny ees rea vw QU
XXX. Description of Labaria hemispherica, Gray, a new Species
of Hexactinellid Sponge, with Observations on it and the Sarco-
hexactinellid Sponges generally. By H. J. Canter, F.R.S. &c. .. 275
XXXI. On a Crustacean of the Genus Za. By the Rey. Toomas
IR. AR OTREBBING, MGA. eo ais vanes stejeisi.e ce) eiaisie syeiace eno er 286
XXXII. Description of a new Species belonging to the Genus
Vitrina. By Epa@ar A. Smit, F.Z.8., Zoological Department,
Britishy Museum 5 oo cic< ve ope soos meine pos. oes alte Ge 288
XXXII. Observations on Chelonians, with Descriptions of new
Genera and Species.. By Dr. J. HE. Gray, FURS. 6.) 05 jae ater 289
XXXIV, Additional Notes on the Guémul. By Dr. J. E. Gray,
BBS. 2G. false wid 5 shed in sine Sid ole ot ae ied tale he Sec 308
Proceedings of the Royal Society: 20. c... <5 «+ «sein <> de eo ae eee 310
Fabulous Australian Animals, by Gerard Krefft; Preliminary De-
scriptions of three new Species of Cetacea from the Coast of
California, by W. H. Dall, U.S. Coast Survey ; On Hyper-
metamorphosis in Palingenia virgo, and on the Analogies of its
Larva with the Crustacea, by M. N. Joly ; Deep-water Fauna
of Lake Michigan, by P. BR. Hoy, MD... ........00ssa0ee 315—319
NUMBER LXV.
XXXYV. On the Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo as the Basis
of Genealogical Classitication of Animals, and on the Origin of Vas-
cular and Lymph Systems. By E. Ray Lanxester, M.A., Fellow
and Lecturer of Hxeter College, Oxford ......0..7.. «4nce eee 321
XXXVI. On a new Australian Species of Thyrsites. By Prof.
PREDERICK M‘CO¥- 55 ..cicsamelekiciay a vislacle cms «eon 8s ae 308
XXXVI. Notices of British Fungi. By the Rev. M. J. BerKELEY,
M.A., F.L.S., and C. E. Brooms, Esq., F.L.S. (Plates VII.-X.).. 389
XXXVIII. Description of two new Species of Frogs from Aus-
tralia. By Dr. ALBERT GUNTHER, F.R.S.........00000000 esas . 349
CONTENTS. ; vil
Page
XXXIX. Description of a new Saurian (Hyalosaurus) allied to
Pseudopus. By Dr. ALBERT GUNTHER, F.R.S. ......... 0.0 eee 351
XL. Points of Distinction between the Spongiadee and the Fora-
monies, (By TH. J.) Cantera, ERS, &el)) cit us .cculasbwh. 351
XLI. On the Dentition of Rhinoceroses (Rhinocerotes), and on the
Characters afforded by their Skulls. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
PEASE) cha Mahe DEE ae MRblsete Si<Lab YI HAS wholes Slevslels Uae 556
XLI. On some Works relating to a new Classification of Ammo-
FDOT RMNG TS WAVED ¢ cicidis orefars.o i s.calels cientinas teaetels cece s 562
XLUI. Description of a new Snake from Madagascar. By Dr. A.
Bea MeAey HEED ES ERD Soh tage 2e a alec 's (nto oy) cSer a) eve! tenes PN ciple aye Sy sy0's. «Py yess 4's # p, 2 374
XLIV. Reply to Professor Verrill’s “ Remarks on certain Errors
in Mr. Jeffreys’s Article on the Mollusca of Europe compared with
those of Eastern North America.” By J. Gwyn Jerrreys, F.R.S. 375
New Books :—Birds of the Humber District, by John Cordeaux.—
Lecture on the Fere Nature of the British Islands, by John
EDLC (LED 70S 2 ae ni I le eA te et Aa Repeat ir Mirae ara 3877—881
Proceedinesiof the Boyal Societys i. . .ec kw alece cet Seas wae 383—391
Preliminary Notice of some Extinct Tortoises from the Islands of
Rodriguez and Mauritius, by Dr. Albert Giinther, F.R.S, ; On
the Dorsal Shield of Tolypeutes, by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e. ;
Observations on the Structure of the Proboscis of an Herma-
phrodite Nemertian from the Marseilles Coast, by M. E. Zeller ;
French Measures, by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.,....... 397—400
NUMBER LXVI.
XLV. On the Advantage of a Dominant Language for Science.
By ALPHONSE DE CANDOLLE, Corresponding Member of the Aca-
démie des Sciences, Foreign Member of the Royal and Linnean
PIDELOUICR CN PRIS LION F% A1ats Wiel ehoar aces dolce did cube k ees creer 401
XLVI. Notes on the Paleozoic Bivalved Entomostraca. No. X,
Entomis and E£ntomidella. By Prof. T. Ruperr Jonrs, F.RS.,
LEAS JSR ee eS ese alae vin ig Siayns Sina pi eh a 413
XLVII. Contribution to our Knowledge of Ceratophrys and
Megalophrys. By Dr. ALBERT GUNTHER, F.R.S................. 417
XLVIII. Note on the Discovery of Zngidium agile, Persoon (= Zia
Saundersii, Stebbing), in Great Britain. By the Rev. A. M. Norman,
vill CONTENTS.
Page
XLIX. On the Calcispongie, their Position in the Animal King-
dom, and their Relation to the Theory of Descendence. By Pro-
fessor Ernst HACKEL
L. Observations on Pigs (Sus, Linneeus; Setifera, Iliger) and
their Skulls, with the Description of a new Species. By Dr. J. E.
GRAY, FIRS. B66... os winre.o «5 ereiemiole ele bc)a «0m toietar ep ee 451
LI. Note on the Appearance in Australia of the Danais Archippus.
By Freprrick M‘Coy, Professor of Natural Science in the Mel-
bourne University, and Director of the National Museum of Victoria,
LIT. Descriptions of new Species of Fossorial Hymenoptera in the
Collection of the British Museum. By FrEepERIcK SuitTH, Assistant
in the Zoological Department, British Museum
LIII. Observations on M. Favre’s Paper on a New,Classification
of Ammonites. By Dr. J. 1H. Gray, FR. &c. 20.201 «eer 451
Proceedings ‘of the Royal Society... .. 2. <1... nse hee eee 454
Habits of Xenurus unicinctus, or Cabassou, by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S.,
F.Z.S., &e. ; On the Fauna of Nowaja-Semlja, by Prof. Ehlers ;
On “Le Rat de Madagascar,” by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &c. ;
Note on the Anatomy of Comatula rosacea, by E. Perrier ; On
Mammalia from the Neighbourhood of Concordia, in New
Granada, by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.; Additional Note on
Tolypeutes conurus, by Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &c.; On the Re-
spiration of the Psammodromt, by M. J. Jullien; M. Gervais on
the Skeleton of the Luth (Sphargis coriacea); On an adult
Skeleton of Zyrse nilotica in the British Museum, by Dr. J. E.
Gray, F.R.S. &c.; Bryozoa of Florida; The late Robert
Mi Andrew, Eisq., BURUS! of. ...:.emctna +c «125 t ee 463—471
TU OK tis iosie's cio sire sine Eh aid SELLS 2c ee 472
PLATES IN VOL. XI.
PuaTeE I. Alteration of Shell-substance by Hydractinia.
II. Spatulemys Lasale.
II. New Gonyleptide.
DV
vt Development of the Sternum of Chelonians.
MAGE
“a New British Fungi.
X.
XI. Ceratorhinus niger.
THE ANNALS
AND
MAGAZINE OF NATURAL HISTORY.
[FOURTH SERIES. ]
ee EE erectceect per litora spargite muscum,
Naiades, et circiim vitreos considite fontes:
Pollice virgineo teneros hic carpite flores:
Floribus et pictum, diye, replete canistrum.
At vos, o Nymphe Craterides, ite sub undas;
Ite, recuryato variata corallia trunco
Wen bee anaconie e rupibus, et mihi conchas
erte, Dez pelagi, et pi i conchylia succo.””
Herth "W. Parthenii Giannettasii Ecl. 1.
No. 61. JANUARY 1873.
_—>-——
I.—Transformation of an entire Shell into Chitinous Struc-
ture by the Polype Hydractinia, with short Descriptions of
the Polypidoms of jive other Species. By H.J. CARTER,
F.R.S. &e.
[Plate I.]
ALL who are acquainted with the Spongiade know that there
are certain species which enter the substance of shells and
there grow to such an extent that finally the whole shell which
they inhabit may become absorbed or destroyed, and the sponge
itself, thus left alone, become unattached ; after which it may
still go on increasing in size until, drifted about by the currents
in the sea, it may at last in some storm be thrown ashore
upon the beach. Cliona celata, which attacks the oyster-shell,
is one of these, and after having absorbed the whole valve
grows into ashapeless mass, which is brought up by the trawl-
or dredge-net, or cast ashore, as before stated, in which con-
dition it has been called “Raphyrus Griffithsii”’ by Dr. Bower-
bank. Halichondria suberea, Johnst., is a species which
attacks univalve shells—but often retains more or less of the
outward form of the shell, and almost always that of the in-
ternal cavity ; for a hermit crab (Pagurus) generally inhabits
the latter, and so prevents the sponge from encroaching in
this direction. Hence, if the outward form of the shell is lost,
the internal one is, for the most part, so perfectly preserved
that there is no difficulty whatever in concluding that it was
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi.
2 Mr. H. J. Carter on the Alteration
once a Gasteropodous shell, although not a particle of the cal-
careous matter may remain, and the whole be transformed into
sponge-structure.
The same thing, mutatis mutandis, may take place with the
flexible polype called Hydractinia, which for the most part
also forms a parasitic crust on univalve shells.
Thus in the British Museum there is a specimen of
Hydractinia echinata covering a whelk-shell (Buceinum un-
datum) both inside and out; and the same was tenanted by a
Pagurus, now dead in situ; while the horny skeleton or m-
crustation of the polype, having shrunk by contraction .on
drying, has become cracked about the lip, and the pieces so
curled up that their edges have become exposed, and thus show
that, although the outer part presents its natural dark amber-
colour, the inner one becomes gradually whiter, until it appears
to differ very little from the shell itself.
Carrying on our examination with a simple lens, we observe
that the pieces have brought away with them a portion of the
shell-substance on which the crust grew ; and when both their
lower side and the corresponding surface of the shell are re-
spectively examined, it will be found that the former presents
a surface of whitish crystalline matter punctated by amber-
coloured points, which are connected above with the horny
structure of the Hydractinia, while the surface of the shell
opposite presents nothing of the kind, and is therefore uni-
formly white,—thus showing that the horny or chitinous in-
crustation has brought away with it just so much of the shell-
substance as the horny portion of the polype had penetrated.
Hydractinia echinata 1s so common on our coast that it does
not seem necessary for me to describe here more than the part
immediately connected with our subject, viz. the polypidom,
which includes the transformation of the substance of the shell
into the horny structure of the Hydractinia. For the rest I
refer the reader to the ample descriptions, illustrations, &e.
contained in Mr. Hincks’s ‘ History of the British Hydroid
Zoophytes,’ vol. i. p. 19 &e., and vol. 11. pl. 4 (1868).
The skeleton or polypidom of Hydractinia consists of a
clathrate mass of horny solid fibre (I use the word “ horny ”
here synonymously with “ chitinous,” as the most expressive
term, although chemically not so correct as the latter), which
spreads horizontally in a thin layer over the shell on which the
polype may be growing, rising above into a forest of pyramidal
serrated spines, averaging about one sixteenth of an inch high,
and descending below by simple advancement of the clathrate
fibre into the shell-substance, as before mentioned.
The insterstices of the clathrate network are filled by the
of Shell-substance by Hydractinia. 3
granular plasma called “ccenosare ;” and the external parts of
the skeleton serve to support the polype-mass; all of which,
being extremely delicate, fail, after being once dried, to present
under any circumstances a recognizable form.
If we now, with a very sharp and thin knife, cut off verti-
cally a slice of the dried curled-up crust above mentioned (PI. I.
fig. 8) and place it under a microscope, we may see the white
crystalline shell-substance (d d) gradually decreasing upwards
among the interstices of the chitinous network, until it gives
place entirely to the dark amber-colour of the latter and its
granular plasma (c, figs. 8 & 9) ; while in the opposite direction
the white substance increases to the confines of the lowermost
layer of the network, until it can hardly be distinguished from
the substance of the shell itself (fig. 8, 7).
Again, if we put a similar slice (fig. 9) into dilute nitric
acid, we shall not only observe an effervescence, but when
this slice is placed under the microscope we may also observe
that the whole of the white crystalline substance has dis-
appeared (fig. 9,dd), leaving nothing but the clathrate fibre
of the skeleton (fig. 9, e), of which the increasing thinness,
pale colour, and wide interstices towards the shell evince its
young or progressive stage of development.
It thus appears evident that Hydractinia echinata trans-
forms the calcareous shell on which it may be growing into
its own horn-like skeleton.
We have now to prove this more satisfactorily ; and this can
be done by another specimen in the British Museum, where
the whole of the shell has become transformed into the horn-
like skeleton of a Hydractinia.
The shell thus transformed was somewhat less in size than
a Buccinum, but of a totally different family, as may be seen
by the form of the aperture, which resembles that of some tur-
binated shell, though of course the species is now undeter-
minable, at least to one possessing such a limited knowledge
of conchology as myself (fig. 1, a,6). Nor is the Hydractinia
the same specifically as H. echinata; for all the spines are
smooth (fig. 3), and not, as in the latter, serrated (fig. 4).
Hence there is here a marked difference between the two
polypes, although in every other respect the skeleton-mass or
polypidom, which is the only part left in the transformed shell,
is almost identical with that of Hydractinia echinata.
As the transformed shell now exists, it is empty and entirely
composed of parallel layers of clathrate chitinous fibre (fig. 2,
a,b). ‘The internal cavity is smooth, and the columella pre-
served; so that we may fairly infer that the shell had been
originally tenanted by a Pagurus, which had remained there
1%
4 Mr. H. J. Carter on the Alteration
until the whole of the shell had become transformed into the
chitinous skeleton of a Hydractinia, when, probably finding it
too light for its purpose, the Pagurus betook itself to a heavier
habitation.
Although the internal surface of the transformed shell
remains smooth and perfect (fig. 2, a, 6), the external surface
has become changed into the peculiar growth of the Hydractinia,
which presents a more or less irregularly tubercled appearance,
each tubercle of which, being more or less separate from the
rest and varying in size and shape, consists of a little monti-
cule of clathrate fibre involving one or more of the smooth
erect spines which characterize the species (fig. 1, a, 2); whereas
in Hydractinia echinata there are no such tubercles, the sur-
face being for the most part even and equally spined throughout.
So much, then, for the internal and external surfaces re-
spectively of the transformation ; we have now to go to the
layers of which it is composed. And these together present a
thickness varying with that of the original shell, being in the
section (which was made for the purpose, and forms part of
the illustrations, fig. 2) 4-12ths of an inch thick at the base,
and 2-12ths in the parietes. Moreover these layers show, by
the presence of smooth spines upon them here and there (fig. 2,
dd), that the growth of the Hydractinia had been outwards as
well as inwards or towards the shell. Nor does it seem quite
clear how much of the shell has been absorbed by the layer of
the Hydractinia which lined its cavity (fig. 2, e e), smee im the
specimen of Hydractinia echinata betore me the polype-crust,
although smoothed by the Pagurus internally, covers the cavity
as well as the exterior of the shell. At the same time, in
the transformation, the presence and direction of the spines
on its layers (fig. 2, ec) point out, to a certain extent, the limit
of the crust vertically, leaving about one third of the thickness
of the transformation inside it for what may have been effected
by the lower part of the outer crust and that lining the cavity
respectively. In this case the original shell could not have
been very thick.
A microscopic examination of the structure gives the same
results, minus the soft substance and presence of calcareous
matter, as that of Hydractinia echinata; and thus it is satis-
factorily proved that this kind of polype can effect a change in
the composition of a shell analogous to that produced by the
sponges mentioned.
This is a point of interest to know, inasmuch as it bears on
fossilized as well as recent structure, and therefore every
clathrate structure of this kind ina fossil shell must not be too
hastily set down as sponge-transformation.
ae a le
am OC
of Shell-substance by Wydractinia. 5
The transformed shell bears the museum no. “ 2461,” which
appears to me to be preceded by a P; and the former shows
that it must have been in the museum for many years, since
for upwards of twenty this kind of numbering has been dis-
continued.
In its maximum measurements it is about two inches long
from apex to base, two inches broad, 7. e. from left to right
side, and one inch thick.
The outer layer is rendered more or less green by the
presence of the gonidia and thallus of a lichen, which here and
there appears in little groups of gymnocarpous apothecia all over
the surface. So it is just possible that, after the comparatively
heavy calcareous matter of the shell had been replaced by the
lighter chitinous structure, the Pagurus, as before stated, lett
his habitation ; and the latter, having floated into an estuary,
may have been left on its banks, where its surtace became in time
grown over by this lichen, and where, probably, it was found,
unless all this took place on the sea-shore, or the Pagurus carried
the transformed shell inland, as they appear to do in the island
of Cuba (Sir C. Lyell, Princip. Geol. vol. ii. 1872).
The largest apothecia are about 1-48th of an inch in diameter,
and more or less circular, the thalamium dark brown, and ex-
ciple white ; the spores ellipsoid, generally eight in the theca,
but varying in number, and for the most part confusedly
arranged.
My attention was first called to the specimen of Hydractinia
echinata above mentioned from its likeness to the figures of
the sponge named “ Terpios echinata” by De Fonbressin et
Michelotti (“Spongiaires de la Mer Caraibe,’ p. 102, pl. xxiv.
figs.4 & 5, Haarlem, 1864). And then, when I observed
coupled with it in the museum another shell like it, but entirely
transformed into horny structure, I began to think that the
skeleton of Hydractinia echinata must be a sponge, not being
aware at the time that any organism but a sponge could effect
such a transformation, and observing microscopically that the
horny substance was formed of concentric layers. However,
placing the specimens before my friend Mr. Parfitt for his
opinion as to the habitat and species of the lichen, this imtel-
ligent naturalist immediately recognized Hydractinia echinata,
and handed out from his cabinet a specimen dredged up off the
Otter-mouth, close to the place where am living. The nature
of the organism on the whelk-shell thus having become known
to me, that of the organism which had transformed the other
shell still remained enigmatical, but was subsequently worked
out in the way above mentioned.
It would appear from a section of the crust that the poly-
6 Mr. H. J. Carter on the Alteration
pidom of Hydractinia echinata is formed of horizontal layers
(figs. 8 & 9), each of which is marked by a row of knots
(e, figs. 8 & 9), which indicate the points of union of the
clathrate chitinous fibre, corresponding to the knots in network ;
and, judging from a microscopic examination of the part ad-
vancing into the shell, it would also seem that these knots first
appear in the form of separate cells (fig. 7,dd), which, gene-
rating concentric layers of chitine around them, may be termed
“horn-cells.”” The horn-cell then sends off two sets of
branches, one of which (fig. 7,¢e) becomes the clathrate chi-
tinous fibre, which is solid and formed of concentric layers, and
the other set (fig. 7, ff) spread out into a chitinous membrane
(fig. 7, 7) on the same plane as the horn-cells, which membrane
thus acts as a framework to the whole. These horn-cells
appear as dark points in the last layer of shell-substance that
is about to be absorbed, and which remains adherent to the
contracted and curled-up fragments of the dried and thus
broken-up polypidom, as above mentioned (fig. 5, a; fig. 8, g).
The chitinous membrane therefore lies above this (fig. 6, 0;
fig. 8,f). But if a fragment of these two layers, viz. the chi-
tinous and calcareous ones (which are of course very thin, but
can be occasionally picked off together), be mounted in Canada
balsam, it will be observed that the calcareous layer, which is
the undermost, presents a worm-eaten appearance (fig. 7, 7), as
if it had been subjected to the dissolving influence of a surface
formed of pseudopodial villi, about 1-6G000th inch in diameter.
In the layer lining the cavity of the wholly transformed shell
(fig. 2,ee), treated in a similar manner, we have the same cha-
racters, minus, of course, the calcareous layer, as in fig. 9, g,—
that is to say, the chitimous membrane alone, in which are set
the horn-cells and their clathrate structure, as in a, figs. 6 & 7.
How the absorption of the shell-substance is effected in
Hydractinia is unknown to me; but (referrmg to like phe-
nomena) when we observe that the protoplasm of the plant-cell
can, as required, work its way through the thick cellulose cell
(as in Spirogyra under conjugation), that the tender Amceba-
like entophyte Pythiwm (also an inhabitant of the cell of
Spirogyra) will do the same thing, &c., that the excavating
sponges, whose sarcode is equally soft and delicate, will do the
same in the oyster-shell as well as in limestone rock, it does
not appear strange that the coenosare of Hydractinia should be
able to perforate a whelk-shell under similar circumstances.
Also, when it is observed that, in the excavations made by
Cliona celata in the concretionary limestone formed and found
about the rocks of the New Red Sandstone on the shore here,
the siliceous grains which are mixed up with it still project
of Shell-substance by Hydractinia. 7
above the otherwise smooth surface of the excavation, it does
seem (as my friend Mr. Parfitt has sagaciously observed) that
these excavations are produced by an “ acid or erosive agent”
of a chemical rather than of a physical nature, which, not
being able to dissolve the silex, thus leaves the grains of
sand projecting into the excavation (Parfitt on the boring of
Mollusks, &c., Trans. Devon. Assoc. for Advancement of
Science, 1871).
May we not assume, then, that this process is one of animal
chemistry like that of digestion (wherein the gastric juice will
dissolve calcareous matter, but fails to affect a piece of glass)?—
the action in Hydractinia being produced not by cells but by
the intercellular sarcode, which, like that of the sponge, can
prolong itself into villous pseudopodial processes (fig. 7, ¢, 2),
which possibly may be the pioneers of all vital changes of this
kind, in exercising on their confines that catalytic power of
which life alone is capable.
Indeed Professor Allman has long since demonstrated the
existence of sarcode among the Hydroid polypes, which, to use
his own words, ‘‘ comports itself exactly like the pseudopodia
of an Amaba, which it also resembles in structure” (‘ Annals,’
1864, vol. xii. p. 204); so that the worm-eaten appearance
presented by the lowermost layer of the crust of Hydractinia
echinata (that is, in the calcareous surface of the shell just about
to become transformed) may be produced, as before stated, by
a villous layer of minute pseudopodial prolongations from the
coenosare.
Lastly, as regards the power of animal chemistry in these
operations, which is chemistry directed by an unknown agent,
as the production of alcohol by the yeast-plant, &c., it signifies
that there is an instinctive power acting here, which is far
beyond any possessed by the highest cerebrated being, if I
may use the expression.
When I observe the delicate mycelium of a minute fungus
growing or creeping (for the terms are synonymous here)
through the hard crystalline layers of the shell of a Bucetnwm—
when I observe on the surface of a lancet which has been care-
fully protected by a layer of animal fat a similar kind of my-
celium, which has wriggled its way not only over but 7m the
surface of the polished blade by oxidation of the iron in its
course, so as to leave a rusty image of itself—and when I ob-
serve a plant-like form of glauconite in the substance of an
agate which has been formed in a geode of an igneous rock,
so much like a Conferva that it might easily pass for one if
not otherwise understood, to say nothing of the dendritic
markings of rocks, &c.,—these facts, taken in connexion, seem
8 On the Alteration of Shell-substance by Hydractinia.
to signify not only that the law of form is the same both in
the vegetable and mineral kingdoms at least (for the glauconite
form in this respect is almost typically that of a Conferva),
but that vztal influence also is the primum mobile in all—that
indomitable power which rules the world independently of
man!
Having ascertained that the transformed shell, which had
been thrown in among the sponges, had been produced by a
polype and not by a sponge, I turned my attention to certain
branched organisms, or rather their skeletons, which had also
been placed among the sponges, and had therefore come be-
fore me for examination, when, noticing that they also pos-
sessed a clathrate chitinous structure closely allied to that of
the polypidom of Hydractinia (fig. 9), while the characteristic
feature of most sponges, viz. the branched system of canals
terminating externally in large outlets or oscula, was absent
from them, I submitted to microscopical examination a por-
tion of the stem of a beautiful form from New Zealand, which
had been presented to the museum by Sir G. Grey; and
I found not only that it was identical with the structure of
the polypidom of Hydractinia, but that attached to its fibre
internally, where the water had failed to destroy the whole of
the soft parts with which the clathrate structure had originally
been filled and covered, a few thread-cells still remained. I
then sought for the hydrothece, and found them also.
Next I took portions from two other species, which came from
the Cape of Good Hope—and obtained similar results, so satis-
factorily that in many of the thread-cells their contents had
become half extruded.
Finally I examined the two species from Australia which
Dr. J. E. Gray, under the family name of “Ceratellade,” had
described and figured provisionally as sponges in the ‘ Pro-
ceedings of the Zoological Society’ for November 26th, 1868
(p. 575), designated respectively Ceratella fusca and Dehitella
atrorubens ; and here, again, I met with similar results.
Hence it becomes necessary for me briefly to describe all
these polypidoms, beginning with that of the transformed shell,
in order that henceforth they may be relegated to their proper
place. Were they possessed of their soft parts, and pertect as
the Hydractinia of our own shores when carefully dredged up
from its natural abode can only be, I should have proposed
their being handed over to some one more conversant than
myself with this department of zoology: but who can say
when perfect specimens of the polypidoms of these species,
with all their soft parts recognizable, may be similarly taken,
when those we have come trom foreign shores, where they
On new Species of Hydractinide. 9
have apparently been washed about in the surf for years before
they were picked up for preservation? Meanwhile, as the
description of a polypidom alone is comparatively easy, as it
may be a long while before the soft parts can be obtained, and
as it is desirable at once to separate these skeletons from the
sponge-structures which I am examining, it is hoped that
the following diagnoses may not be unacceptable.
Hydractinia levispina, n.sp. (PI. I. fig. 1, a, b.)
Zoophyte incrusting and eroding univalve shells. Poly-
pidom formed of clathrate, subrectangularly meshed chitinous
fibre (as in fig. 9), solid, concentrically laminated, surmounted
by smooth, erect, conical spines (figs. 3 & 1, 6,e), grouped
together in the midst of proliferous tubercles (fig. 1, d,e),
seattered more or less over the surface. Increasing by layers,
so as finally to absorb the whole of the shell on which it grows
(fig. 2, a,b). Height of transformed shell 2 inches from apex
_ to base; extreme breadth, viz. from left side to margin of outer
_» lip, ldinch. Spine variable, about 1-30th inch high by 1-60th
inch diameter at the base.
Hab. Unknown.
Loc. Unknown.
Obs. This specimen, which is in the British Museum, bears
the number “2461,” which mode of marking, as before stated,
shows that it has been there for a very long time ; the number
also appears to be preceded by a “P.” ‘There is no further
history attached to it than that which its own structure reveals.
It evidently grew ona shell a little less im size than a Buccinum,
but of a totally different species, as the margin of the aperture
is continuous like that of the Turbinide. While there it
gradually transformed the whole of the shell imto its own
chitinous polypidom; meanwhile a Pagurus or hermit crab
inhabited the interior and so preserved the form of this part.
Subsequently it probably got into some tidal estuary, where,
having been left high and dry on its banks, a gymnospermous
lichen took up its habitation on its surface, and, spreading its
thallus throughout the external layer of the imperishable
chitine, at last threw up the groups of shield-like conceptacles
(apothecia) now scattered over the greater part of the shell-like
polypidom. Of course this might also have taken place on the
sea-shore, or the Pagurus itself might have carried it inland.
Hydractinia levispina differs trom H. echinata in the
tubercled state of its surface, but especially in the smoothness
of its spines (fig. 3); the latter possesses a more or less even
surface with serrated spines (fig. 4).
10 Mr. H.J. Carter on new Species of Hydractiniide.
Ceratella fusca,
Gray, Proc. Zool. Soc. Nov. 26, 1868, p. 579, fig. 2.
“Coral expanded, fan-shaped, forming an oblong frond ;
branches divergent from the base, with numerous lateral, sub-
alternate, subdichotomous branches; similar but smaller lateral
branches.
“Fab. Australia, New South Wales, at the head of Bondy
Bay.”
Dehitella atrorubens, ;
Gray, Proc. Zool. Soc. Nov. 26, 1868, p. 579, fig. 1.
“Sponge or coral dichotomously branched, expanded, growing
in a large tuft from a broad, tortuous, creeping base, of a dark
brown colour, and uniform hard rigid substance. Stem hard,
cylindrical, opake, smooth; branches and branchlets tapering
to a point, cylindrical, covered with tufts of projecting horny
spines on every side; those on the branches often placed in
sharp-edged, narrow, transverse ridges; those of the upper
branches and branchlets close but isolated, and divergent from -
the surface at nearly right angles.
“This genus is distinguishable from Ceratella by the greater
thickness and cylindrical form of the stem, by the more tufted
and irregular manner of growth, and by the tufts of spicules
(oscules or cells) being more abundant and equally dispersed
on all sides of the branches and branchlets.”
The above descriptions are copied from Dr. J. E. Gray’s
excellent account of these two organisms, published in the
‘Proc. Zool. Soc.’ for November 26, 1868 (p. 575), to which
the reader is referred for more extended descriptions of them,
and for equally excellent illustrations, which, being almost
typical forms of the following species from the Cape of Good
Hope, will, until the latter are also illustrated, very well serve
for their identification.
It will be observed that Dr. Gray was by no means satisfied
that they belonged to the Spongiadee, and therefore only pro-
visionally placed them among the sponges. Had he been aware
of what I have above stated, his views probably would have
been different, and the real nature of these organisms would
have been then told by him at once; and but for his encou-
ragement now, it would most probably have never been eluci-
dated by myself.
Ceratella procumbens, n. sp.
Zoophyte procumbent, compressed, thickly branched on the
same plane; the larger stems chiefly on one (the lower) side,
Ie
Mr. H. J. Carter on new Species of Hydractinude. 11
hard, flexible, of an ochre-brown colour, tinged here and there
with purple. Trunk short, solid, compact, compressed verti-
cally, soon dividing irregularly or subdichotomously into round
branches, which are confined to the lower surface, ending in
branchlets with subclavate ends, that appear on the upper or
opposite side, not reuniting or anastomosing. Hydrotheca
consisting of a little semitubular plate, extending outwards and
forwards from the side of the stem on the proximal border of
an aperture in the latter ; scattered thickly over all the branches,
but most prominent on the branchlets ; frequently represented
by the little hole alone in the stem where the projecting portion
has been worn off; scanty on the lower side of the main
stems. Minute structure: composed of clathrate chitinous
fibre throughout, whose meshes are subrectangular ; hydrotheca
formed of the semitubular scoop-like plate mentioned, sup-
ported on its proximal side by an extension of the clathrate
structure of the stem, and bordering the little hole also above
mentioned, which extends into the centre of the stem ; surface
of the larger stems bluntly microspined. Size of largest spe-
cimen 11 inches long by 5 inches broad, and about 1 inch thick,
or vertically.
Hab. Marine ; procumbent.
Loc. Cape of Good Hope and Port Natal.
Obs. ‘There are five specimens of this species in the British
Museum, viz. one with no. 67. 3. 22. 1, and “Cape of Good
Hope” written on it, and the others ticketed no. 72.8.1. 1, and
“Port Natal.” Friction among the sand and waves has worn
down some of them so much as to leave nothing but the fora-
mina in the stems; whereby the most worn might be looked upon
as a different species, did not the gradation from the more per-
fect ones point out that this is not the case, and thus that they all
belong to one and the same species. Some parts still retain a
purple colour both externally and internally, showing that, as
with the other species in some parts also, this has for the most
part been washed out, and that the brown colour has been de-
rived from the chitinous fibre alone. In most cf the specimens
thread-cells are numerous in the clathrate tissue, especially
towards the centre of the stems, where they can not only be
distinguished by their subconical form from other globular and
nucleated cells present (which appear like ova), but, by the
addition of liquor potasse, may be made to extrude the thick
portion of the thread. ‘Their procumbent habit has been inferred
from the main stem and its branches being flattened on one
side, while the branches and hydrothece are chiefly on the
other—much in the form of a wall fruit-tree, viz. with a flat
back.
12. Mr.H.J. Carter on new Species of Wydractinide.
Ceratella spinosa, n. sp.
Zoophyte procumbent, thickly branched, hard, flexible, of a
dark rich red-purple colour. Main branches round, brownish,
covered with small, smooth, often subspatulate, erect spines.
Stem dividing subdichotomously into purple branchlets, which
terminate in abruptly pointed extremities. Hydrothece the
same as in the foregoing species; most prominent over the
round branchlets, to which they give, en profil, a serrated,
somewhat Sertularian, appearance, the teeth of which are in-
clined forwards. Minute structure: main stems composed of |
clathrate chitinous fibre, of which the meshes are more or less
oblong, passing into prominent longitudinal lines on the
branchlets, where they terminate on the backs of the semi-
tubular plates which respectively form the floors of the hydro-
theese, to which they thus give support. Size of specimen,
which is merely a branch, 44 inches long by 2 broad.
Hab, Marine ; procumbent.
Loc. Port Natal.
Obs. The spines on the surface distinguish this from the
foregoing species, add to which its longer and more pointed
branches, longitudinally ridged clathrate fibre, and rich red-
purple colour. It bears the no. “72. 8.1.17, from Port Natal.”
In Dr. Gray’s two Australian species there are no actual
spines independently of the projecting portion of clathrate struc-
ture on the proximal sides of the hydrothece, and the “ spimu-
lose” little knobs on the surface of Ceratella fusca.
The hydrotheca in Dehitella atrorubens is formed of a simple
scoop-like projection of the subrectangular clathrate structure
of the stem, stopped at the bottom by a septum of the same ;
there is no decided hole there larger than the diameter of the
common mesh, for the ccenosare of the interior to communicate
with the sarcode of the polype, as in the Cape species; while
in Ceratella fusca, which is almost as delicate in its branches
as a Sertularia, and not unlike it in the alternate, but here
spiral not opposite, position of its hydrothece, the latter are
formed by a projection of the clathrate tissue in the shape of
a clam-shell, whose ribs, extended beyond the margin, end
respectively in an inflated tubercle of the same kind as that
which characterizes the surface of the stem, rising up like
little knobs on the knots of the clathrate network, to which
Dr. Gray (/. c.) has appropriately applied the term “spinulose;”’
the bottom of the hydrotheca is filled up with a clathrate
septum, in which there is no decided hole present as in the fore-
going species; and in this way both of these from Australia
differ trom those of the Cape of Good Hope.
Mr. H. J. Carter on new Species of Hydractiniide. 13
Chitina ericopsis, n. gen. et sp.
Zoophyte erect, bushy, fragili-flexible, fawn-coloured.
Trunk long, hard, irregularly round, composed of many stems
united clathrately and obliquely into a cord-like bundle, which
divides and subdivides irregularly into branches, that again
unite with each in substance (anastomose) when in contact,
and finally form a straggling bushy head. Hydrotheca long,
clathrate, tubular, terminating the ends of the branchlets or
prolonged from some of the proliferous tubercles which beset
the surface of the trunk and larger stems. Minute structure:
composed of clathrate chitinous fibre throughout, whose mesh-
work is subrectangular and massive in the stems, where there
is no difference between the centre and circumference, with the
exception that the fibre is stouter in the former or oldest part ;
hydrotheca composed of several longitudinal fibres or ridges lat-
tice-worked together transversely into a tubular form, somewhat
contracted at the extremity, in the centre of which is an aper-
ture of the meshwork a little larger than the rest. Height
of specimens about 14 inches, trunk about 1 inch in diameter ;
hydrotheca averaging 1-3rd of an inch long by 1-60th of an
inch in its broadest part, and the aperture 1-90th of an inch in
diameter.
Hab. Marine ; erect.
Loc. New Zealand.
Obs. There are several specimens of this beautiful polypidom
in the British Museum ; one of which (bearing the no. 57. 1. 2.
36) was presented by Dr. Sinclair, and the rest by Sir G.
Grey; all from New Zealand. From their worn state they
appear to have been long subjected to the friction of the waves
and beach before they were picked up for preservation. Hardly
any of the hydrothecee on them are perfect; and it is only by
looking carefully over the specimens that one can be found
answering the description above given; and then it requires to
be viewed with an inch compound power ‘end on” (as it is
termed) to see the aperture at the extremity; the least incli-
nation to one side will bring the surrounding network into
focus, and thus defeat the object of the observer. In some the
dried remains of the polype are still present, which mark the
position of the tubular cavity. Conical ovoid thread-cells may
be seen in the clathrate structure of the polypidom, which
hang about the fibre in a dried fleshy substance that appears also
to be the remains of the ccenosare ; and on some of the larger
stems there are little superficial holes, which appear to be the
remains of canals through which the ccenosare was continued
into the cavities of the hydrothece respectively, now worn
off. The specimen differs so markedly from all the rest in its
14 Mr.H.J. Carter on new Species of Hydractiniide.
erect habit, and in the form and position of its hydrothece, that
it must be considered the type of a new genus, to which I
have given the name of Chitina and designated the species
ericopsis, from its being so much like the stems of the common
heather here used for making brooms.
These species may be provisionally tabulated thus :—
Family Hydractiniide.
Incrusting species :—
Hydractinia echinata.
HZ, levispina.
Branched procumbent species :—
Ceratella fusca, Gray.
Dehitella atrorubens, Gray.
Ceratella procumbens, 0. sp.
C. spinosa, ni. sp.
Branched erect species :—
Chitina ericopsis, n. g. et sp.
In this way I hope to get rid of them from among the Spon-
giade, and to bring them to the notice of those who have
specially devoted their attention to the Hydroid Zoophytes.
EXPLANATION OF PLATEL
Fig. 1. Upper and lower surfaces respectively of a turbimated (?) shell
wholly transformed into clathrate chitinous fibre structure by
Hydractinia levispina (n. sp.): a, upperside; 6, lower side ; e,
smooth area on the latter, produced by friction during the time
the shell was tenanted by a Pagwrus; d, tubercular excrescences
of the chitinous structure involving one or more spines, which
the dark points (e) are intended to represent; ff, line of section.
Natural size.
Fig. 2. Section of the same through the line ff, fig. 1, showing that the
columella and every particle of the original shell-substance has
been replaced by the chitinous structure: a, right side; b, left
side ; ec, layer surmounted by spines (d d) projecting outwards ;
ee, surface-layer of the cavity. Natural size.
Fig. 3. Hydractinia levispina, n. sp., spine of, with portion of subjacent
clathrate structure at its base, showing that it is merely a conical
form of the latter; magnified. Real length of spine about
1-30th inch, diameter of base of spine 1-60th inch. To contrast
with the serrated form of the following figure.
Fig. 4. Hydractinia echinata, spine of, about the same size as the fore-
oing. To contrast with fig. 5.
Fig. 5. The same, incrusting Buccinum undatum, which contains the re-
mains of a Pagurus. Magnified portion of lower surface of a
fragment of the crust, raised by contraction and fracture from the
inner surface of the outer lip close to the canal, showing that it
is composed of calcareous matter, through which points of the
superincumbent chitinous structure (aa@) project. Horizontal
view.
Mr. R. Swinhoe on a new Species of Nettapus. 15
Fig. 6. The same, with the calcareous matter removed by acid, showing
that the “ points ” of the superincumbent chitinous structure are
the knots of the network, and continuous with or set in a chi-
tinous expansion or chitinous membraniform layer: a, chitinous
network; 5,chitinous membrane. Horizontal view.
Fig. 7. The same portion much more magnified, showing :—a, chitinous
structure and membrane, from which the calcareous matter
has been removed by acid,=fig. 6; 6, where the former is still
covered by the calcareous layer,=fig. 5; e, where the calcareous
layer alone remains; dd, points or knots (originally horn-cells)
in which the branches (ee) arise that {form the network; ff,
branches which are continuous with, and probably form by ex-
pansion, the chitinous membrane; g, points which project
through the calcareous layer; 4 (=fig. 5), peculiar worm-eaten
appearance of the calcareous layer, as if produced by a villous
surface of pseudopodia in connexion with the ccenosare (7).
Horizontal view.
Fig. 8. The same. Thin vertical section of same fragment of crust,
much magnified, showing that the ecenosare of the lower inter-
stices of the chitinous structure is charged with white calcareous
matter; the latter is here represented by the dark shade: a, free
surface formed of aborted or ill-developed spines, from being in
contact with the Pagurus; 6, surface next the shell; ce, older
chitinous structure without calcareous matter ; e, incised knots
of the chitinous network, showing that the latter is formed in
layers; f, chitinous membrane or layer, &c., =fig. 6 & fig. 7, a;
g, calcareous layer, =fig. 5 & fig. 7, b. Diagram.
Fig. 9. The same. Similar portion, from which the calcareous matter
has been removed by acid: a, free surface ; 6, surface next the
shell; c, older chitinous network, now much thickened ; d, in-
terstices of lower part emptied of their calcareous material by
the acid; e, chitinous network of the same, much thinner in fibre
than that above it, from being younger and therefore presenting
wider interstices ; f, chitinous membrane or layer ; g, points of
chitinous structure projecting through calcareous layer, =fig. 5
& fig. 7, c, the latter now removed by the acid. Diagram.
Il—On a new Species of Nettapus (Cotton-Teal) from the
River Yangtsze, China. By R. Swinnoe, H.M. Consul at
Ningpo.
In the Abbé Armand David’s “Catalogue d’Oiseaux de Chine,”
published in the ‘ Bulletin’ of the ‘ Nouvelles Archives du Mu-
séum d’ Histoire Naturelle de Paris,’ t. vill. (1871), is entered,
under number 442, Nettapus coromandelianus,Scop.,as occurring
on the Yangtsze. In 1869 I spent some months of the early
year on the Yangtsze and did not notice this bird; I therefore
made inquiries of my friends at Kiukiang and Chinkiang as to
whether they had seen such a bird. Mr. Russell (son of the
‘Times’ correspondent) said that last spring he had noticed a
pair of such birds as I described perch on the yard-arm of a
| gun-boat lying off the settlement, but that he was not allowed
| to shoot them. Mr. Kopsch, Commissioner of Customs at
16 Mr. R. Swinhoe on a new Species of Nettapus.
Kiukiang, gave me a more particular account of the species:
he said that in spring they are frequently seen perching on the
roof-tops of the houses in the place, that they were somewhat
tame, and that in summer he noticed a female and two or three
young ones paddling about in the patch of water behind their
houses ; he further stated that they were called by the French
priests there the ‘‘ Canard d’été,” and by the Chinese Yew Ya.
He was fortunate enough to procure two couples on the 25th
of September, and has sent me a male and two females. What
surprises me is the appearance of the male bird of this trio,
which, otherwise attired in the garb of a male, has the neck
and upper breast marked as in the female, and wanting the
pectoral collar. Can the species have a winter dress different
from that of summer ? if so, it would scarcely begin to acquire
it in September. I think, however, that the peculiarity is due
to its partially assuming after nidification the plumage of the
female, a strong anatine character, which shows its affinity
with the true ducks rather than with the geese. I would dedi-
cate this interesting novelty to Mr. Kopsch, who has taken
much pains to procure me specimens.
Nettapus Kopschit, n. sp.
Male. Crown of the head, upper back, and scapulars brown,
reflecting purple and green. (In a spring specimen in the col-
lection of Pere Heude at Shanghai the eyebrow, nape, throat,
cheeks, and lower neck were white, the back of the neck dingy,
with a collar on the lower neck, about a quarter of an inch broad,
of deep iridescent brown.) Our specimen has the white
markings dingy, the back of the neck brownish, the upper back
finely mottled with whitish, the lower neck and upper breast
waved with brown, each feather having two or three concentric
semicircles of wavy brown. These are the feminine peculiarities
it acquires after breeding; but the markings are dingier and
not so well-defined as in the female.
The rest of his dress, which I will now describe, is as in
spring. Back deep glossy green; tertiaries like scapulars, but
reflecting a brighter green ; coverts and secondaries deep duck-
green; primaries black, reflecting deep green; a broad bar of
white extends across the middle of the primaries, broadly
tipping the secondaries and edging the tertiaries; upper tail-
coverts yellowish grey, with brown stems; tail of twelve
feathers, angular at tips, 2°8 inches long, the outer quill ‘7 inch
shorter than the longest, greyish brown with green gloss; under-
parts dingy white, the feathers being brownish on their con-
cealed parts ; flanks light liver-brown ; under tail-coverts pure
white; axillaries and dark parts of underwing deep black.
Dr. J. HK. Gray on Ziphioid Whales. 17
Male: length 113, wing 6 inches. Female: length 13, wing
6:5, tail 3°2 inches.
The female has whitish eyebrows meeting at the occiput ;
her cheeks and throat are whitish; her neck all round and
upper breast are beautifully waved with blackish brown; her
upper parts are liver-brown, with a faint sheen of purple or
or green according to the fall of light; her upper tail-coverts
are lighter and mottled; her secondary coverts are lightly
tipped with whitish ; her secondaries broadly tipped, her ter-
tiaries edged, and a few of her inner primaries marked near
their tips with whitish ; her tail is coloured as her back; and
her underparts are dingy white, the feathers being brownish
at their hidden portions ; axillaries and underwings light liver-
brown. The soft parts I will leave till I get fresh specimens ;
they have changed much in colour in the dry skins before me.
The birds were extremely fat.
IlIl.—On Berardius and other Ziphioid Whales.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.B.S. &c.
ProressorR FLOWER has given an admirable description and
figures of the skeleton of Berardius Arnouxi sent to England
by Dr. Haast and purchased for the Museum of the Royal
College of Surgeons. It is very pleasant to see these excellent
and beautifully illustrated essays on the skeleton of Cetacea,
which Professor Flower is now publishing in the ‘ Transactions
of the Zoological Society.’
Professor Flower makes some observations on the other
ziphioid whales.
I. He observes that the small skull in the Museum at
Wellington, described and figured in the ‘ Trans. New-Zeal.
Inst.’ as the young of the Berardius Arnouxt, and which I
have called Berardius Hector’, belongs to a different section
of the group (Trans. Z. 8. vol. viii. p. 216)—which must be
stated on the authority of Dr. Hector’s figure, for the skull has
not been seen in Europe; and he speaks of it under the genus
Mesoplodon, observing (“‘from the conformation of the skull’)
that the position of the teeth on the side of the jaw is of “ little
importance as a generic character.” I think zoologists will
prefer to take their characters from the position of the teeth
rather than from a small modification in the form of the bones
of which the skull is composed, which no doubt varies more
or less in every species. At any rate, this is either a Berardius
with the bones of which the skull is composed more like in
shape to those of the skull of Mesoplodon, or a Mesoplodon with
the teeth of a Berardius.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 2
18 Dr. J. E. Gray on Ziphioid Whales.
It makes very little difference which we choose; perhaps some
day it will be a genus; but zoologists and comparative anato-
mists, or rather osteologists, look at these things with very
different eyes: the one only knows the structure of a very limited
number of animals; and the other has to arrange and classify
all that come under his or others’ observation.
I always understood the name Mesodon or Mesoplodon was
given to the genus because the teeth were more or less in the
middle of the side of the jaw, which is the case in all the
species; but if Berardius Hector? be referred to it, this species
will be the ziphioid whale with the teeth in the middle of the
side of the jaw, with its teeth at the end of the jaw. To be
sure there are examples of such nomenclature as Chrysanthe-
mum (the golden flower) lewcanthemum (with white flowers) ;
but it is quoted as an example to be avoided.
II. Speaking of Petrorhynchus capensis, he observes :—
“A skull of this animal has been brought from the Cape of
Good Hope, of which an excellent description has been pub-
lished by Professor van Beneden, under the name of Ziphius
indicus ;”’ and he goes on to complain that I retain the name
of Petrorhynchus capensis, “ although its specific identity with
the last-named previously described specimen is admitted ” by
myself.
ee good may be M. van Beneden’s “ description,”’ his
figure is most inaccurate, both in form, proportion, and detail ;
and { could not have believed that it belonged to the same
species, or, scarcely, genus, until M. van Beneden sent me a
cast of the beak of his specimen. I do not see how we can
use the name dndicus for a species which has only been
found in the seas around the Cape of Good Hope. The
Indian zoologists object to our giving the name of India to
the whole of Hindostan ; but what would they say if we used
indicus for a species only found in Africa? I believe that
the name indicus was given under the belief that it was not
a native of Africa, but only “ brought from the Cape” as an
entrepot. I have a further objection: I am informed that
in the Indian seas a species of the genus is found which, from
the description I have received of it, is distinct.
Professor Flower says that the skeleton of the ‘ Hyperoodon
de Corse” of Doumet is preserved at Cette, and that the skull
is figured by M. Gervais in the ‘ Ostéographie des Cétacés,’
t. 21. f. 8,9, which certainly is called “ Ziphius de Corse ;”
but I was not quite sure that they were from M. Doumet’s
specimen. Mr. Flower, I suppose, has private information on
this head from M. Gervais, as M. Gervais’s text of these plates
has not been published yet.
Dr. J. E. Gray on Ziphioid Whales. 19
I also observe that Duvernoy gave the name of ‘‘ Hyperoodon
Gervaisti”” and Fischer’s “ Ziphius Gervaisii” to the skull
in the Paris Museum, from the Hérault, which I proposed, in
the ‘Annals,’ 1872, x. p. 469, should be called Hpiodon
Heraultit, but which I gladly change to that of Hpiodon Grer-
vaistt. I see Professor Flower erroneously refers to ‘ Ostéogr.
Cét.’ t. 21. f. 1-6 for this specimen ; it should be f. 1-4.
Mr. Krefft, some time ago, sent me a photograph of the
skeleton of a ziphioid whale which is in the Museum of
Sydney, and was obtained from an animal stranded in Little
Bay, about six miles from Sydney, which he marked as
Mesoplodon longirostris, Krefft. It appears to be, from the
scale appended, 18 feet long. The angle and symphysis of
the lower jaw appears to be rather elongate and attenuated in
front; and the beak is about twice and a half the length of the
brain-cavity, measuring from the notch; and the head is one
fifth of the entire length. The photograph does not show any
teeth ; and the skull resembles that of the figure of Berardius
Hectori ; but the beak is rather longer in proportion to the size
of the head.
In the ‘ Annals and Magazine of Natural History, 1871,’ vii.
p- 368, I published a note which I had received and the figure
from the photograph of a tooth which Mr. Krefft sent to me,
as “the photograph of the tooth of a new whale, 18 feet long,
caught in Little Bay. It is allied to the genus Mesoplodon ;
and I propose to call it Mesoplodon Giiinthert.” He says,
“ We have the entire skeleton ;”’ so that there can be no doubt
of its being the same as the one he named, but did not describe
or publish, as Mesoplodon longirostris, which Professor Flower
thinks is closely allied to, if not identical with, Ziphius Lay-
ardi. 'The form and surface of the tooth which is figured
from Mr. Krefft’s photograph appeared to me so unlike that
of any other ziphioid whale known that I regarded it as in-
dicating a new genus, which I proposed to call Callidon.
Dr. Krefft explains that the tooth is not visible from with-
out; it is imbedded in the mandible, and the tip is bent
towards the margin. It is as unlike the strap-shaped tooth of
Ziphius Layardi as it is possible to be ; and as longirostris has
not been published, I propose to call it Callidon Giinther?.
The skeleton seems, from the photograph, to be one of the
most perfect known.
9%
20 On the Peregrine Falcon from Sardinia.
IV.—On the Peregrine Falcon from Sardinia. By R.
BowDter SuHarpe, F.L.S., F.Z.8., &c., Senior Assistant,
Zoological Department, British Museum.
For the last two years I have been endeavouring to show
that, owing to the insulated position of our native land, a ten-
dency to vary from the continental forms exhibits itself more
or less in all our resident birds ; and that this will be found to
be more and more the case I am firmly convinced, if ornitho-
logists will view the matter calmly and endeavour to get
together good series for comparison. Great difficulty exists to
some minds in believing that our insular forms do really vary ;
and this scepticism is the more curious because, if we had been
considering the avifauna of some distant land, every one would
have expected, rather than otherwise, that an island lying off
the coast of a large continent would possess a more or less
modified fauna: but the difficulty consists in recognizing the
fact after it has been ignored for nearly a century by every
English writer on birds; and I have been called to task by
several ornithological friends because, as I contend, I refuse
to disbelieve the evidence of my own eyesight, which proves
to me the distinctness of some of the British birds from their
continental relations. What I do maintain is, that ornitholo-
gists commit an error in applying to our English birds the
titles which Linneus bestowed upon his Swedish species.
Whether the birds which I have from time to time named
with Mr. Dresser will ultimately be recognized ag distinct
species, or will merely be considered climatic races or sub-
species, the future will decide ; but as long as those differences
exist it will be wrong to affix “ Linneus” as the namer of
birds he never saw.
It is with regard to the differences exhibited in a like
degree by the avifauna of Sardinia that I have been led to
make the above remarks; and I believe that the latter island
will be found to contain a modified fauna from that of the
mainland. We know that it contains a species of Warbler
almost, if not quite, peculiar to itself. So nearly does Sylvia
melanocephala resemble the true Melizophilus sardus im some
of its plumages, that I have reason to believe that it has often
been mistaken for it. I myself have never seen an example
of the latter bird from any other locality but Sardinia; nor do
I know any one else who has done so. Until the fact of its
wandering is clearly proved, therefore, I think we may look upon
S. sarda as peculiar to the island of Sardinia; and we may
expect from this to find other modifications in its avifauna.
My friend Mr. A. Basil Brooke has lately lent me two
On the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 21
Falcons from Sardinia which can hardly be any thing but a
new species; for they differ from every other Peregrine which
I have ever seen from Europe, and more closely approach
the southern forms F. melanogenys and F. nigriceps. The
Sardinian birds, however, differ from these as well as the
common Peregrine in the very strongly marked oval or tear-
shaped spots on the chest, and the very broad and closely
marked bars on the breast. They approach /. melanogenys
in having a greater extent of black on the ear-coverts, which
nearly meets the cheek-stripe along the whole of its length.
Both specimens are fully adult females, and agree entirely ;
they were shot by Mr. Brooke in April 1869 and April 1871
respectively. I have no doubt that the characters above men-
tioned will be found to be constant, and therefore propose to
describe the Sardinian bird as
Falco Brooket, sp. n.
F, similis F. peregrino, sed statura paullo minore, facie laterali tota
nigricante, et pectore latissime nigro transfasciato distinguendus.
Hab. Sardinia (A. B. Brooke).
Mr. Brooke has very kindly presented one of the typical
specimens to the national collection; so that the species can
be examined by any one visiting the British Museum. The
measurements of /. Brooke (in skin) as compared with F.
peregrinus are as follows :—
Long. tot. culm. alee. caudee. tarsi.
F. peregrinus, 9 ad..... 19°0 1-45 13°8 76 2°15
F. Brooke, 9 ad....:.. 17:0 1:35 135 7:0 2-00
V.—Notes on the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America.
By H. W. Bates, Esq., F.L.S.
Subfamily RarworracivZ.
The “groupes,” corresponding to our subfamilies, under
which Lacordaire classed the genera of Longicorns, and of
which he established about eighty in the family Cerambycidee
alone, are seldom distinguished by definite group-characters.
The rule seems to be that in each “groupe” modifications of
form appear which do not occur in the same conjunction in
any other; but every single modification is liable to disappear
in some members of the “groupe.” Thus there is a looseness
and uncertainty of definition in the classification of this family
which cannot be agreeable to rigid systematists ; but they are
22 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
inevitable, and the more attentively the Longicorns are studied
the more hopeless rigid definitions of genera and subfamilies
appear. 2
The Rhinotragine are a subfamily of the same section of
the Cerambycide to which the familiar genera Callichroma,
Necydalis, &c. belong, 7. e. having finely faceted eyes. They
are remarkable for the very general abbreviation of the elytra
in the species, and the mimetic resemblances that many of them
bear to wasps, bees, Ichneumonidz, and so forth—aresemblance
which is much aided by the subrudimentary condition of the
elytra and the prevailing style of coloration. In the imago
state they frequent flowers, in company with the Hymenoptera
many of them resemble, and are very nimble fliers, probably
in consequence of the abbreviation of the elytra and great
development of the membranous wings. An almost universal
character of the group is the large volume of the eyes, especially
of the lower lobes, which in the males nearly meet in front :
this forms the nearest approach to an exclusive character of
the group; butit disappears in some few species. ‘The head,
too, is very generally elongated below the eyes, forming a
muzzle; but this character exists in several other subfamilies
of Cerambycide. The palpi are short, and their terminal joints
nearly cylindrical or cylindric-ovate, truncated at the apex.
The antenne are almost always more or less serrated from the
sixth jomt; and the third to sixth joimts are furnished with
setee on their outer sides. The thorax is cylindrical or ovate,
always unarmed at the sides. The prosternum forms a distinct,
though narrow, level plate between the anterior cox; and the
episterna of the metasternum are always triangular and very
broad in front. The anterior coxe are generally obliquely ex~
serted ; but this is an inconstant character.
In deciding whether a Cerambycid with finely faceted eyes
belongs to this group or not, the characters chiefly to be looked
to are (1) the volume of the lower lobe of the eyes and the
extent to which this has become frontal, (2) the presence of a
distinct prosternal process, and (3) the prolongation of the head
below the eyes. Species in which the eyes are lateral and the
prosternal process narrow or obsolete are either Necydaline or
Molorchine. 'The abbreviation of the elytra is not an essential
character. The triangular shape of the metasternal episterna
ought, however, I think, to be considered a sine gud non; this
would exclude Trichomesia, an Australian genus which La-
cordaire places in the “groupe,” and which is the only form in
it not belonging to Tropical America.
Although so forbidding to the pure systematist, the Rhino-
tragine are full of interest to the general naturalist, on account
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 23
of their mimetic disguises and the beautiful illustrations they
offer of the mode in which divergent modifications occur in
nature. For example, it is most instructive to observe, in forms
so very closely allied, that whilst some species have rudimentary
elytra, ample wings, and wasp-like bodies, or bee-like hind -
tibie (such as many of the species of Odontocera, Charis, and
Tomopterus), others have elytra developed to the opposite
extreme, and, aided by colours and facies, become the mimetic
analogues of various Coleoptera—such as Oxylymma_ (re-
sembling Galerucide), Aichmutes (resembling Lycidz), and
Erythroplatys (resembling Hispide). The lesson plainly taught
here, to those who believe in the origin of species by natural
variation and selection, is that the Rhinotragine have varied
in many directions, and that, a protective disguise of one kind
or other being necessary to the species, the variations have
been gradually drawn out in many different directions, ac-
cording as they resembled some object at hand which it was
advantageous to resemble. In the present stage it cannot be
said that the species are remarkable for variability in the parts
of their structure involved in the adaptations here mentioned :
but they are generally insects of great rarity ; and wherever a
large number of examples are at hand (e. g. Acyphoderes auru-
lentus, femoratus, and hirtipes, Ommata (Agaone) notabilis),
there is a large amount of variation in general form and colour.
If, however, we look at the differences between very closely
allied species the most abrupt changes are seen—such, for in-
stance, as those between Odontocera fasciata (resembling a wasp)
and O. compressipes (resembling a bee, with pollen-gathering
apparatus to the hind tibie). In fact the abruptness with
which important parts of structure change from species to
species renders the definition of genera impossible in this group;
almost every species offers structural characters sufficient in
amount to render generic separation plausible.
Genus OxyLymMa, Pascoe.
Pascoe, Trans. Ent. Soc. ser. 2, v. p. 21; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p. 500.
1. Oxylymma lepida, Pascoe, l. c. p. 22, pl. 11. f. 3.
Ega, Amazons.
2. Oxylymma telephorina, Bates.
Oxylymma telephorina, Bates, Trans, Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 516.
Ega, Amazons.
3. Oxylymma gibbicollis, n. sp.
O. flavo-testacea, erecte pilosa ; occipite, articulis antennarum 2°-5™
24 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
vittaque angusta laterali et suturali elytrorum, et metasterno,
nigris; thorace antice valde convexo, postice abrupte depresso, rufo,
maculis fuscis. Long. 4 lin.
Bahia (coll. W. W. Saunders).
Head with much-elongated muzzle, testaceous yellow, shi-
ning; occiput and neck black. Antenne with basal and fifth
and sixth joints yellowish, streaked with black exteriorly,
second to fourth joints shining black, rest yellowish. Thorax
strongly rounded on the sides, disk anteriorly gibbous, base
strongly depressed and constricted ; reddish, with four dusky
triangular spots on the anterior part, which spots have numerous
large circular punctures, the rest of the surface being smooth.
Elytra depressed, pale yellow, clothed with long, erect, pale
hairs, apex briefly sinuate-truncate, with acute angles to the
truncature; surface closely punctured. Body beneath and legs
waxy yellow, shining ; metasternum black. .
This species has a close resemblance to a species of Diabro-
tica (fam. Galerucide).
Genus RurwotraGcus, Germar.
Germar, Ins. Sp. Noy. p. 513; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p. 500.
1. Rhinotragus dorsiger, Germar, l. c.
Var. Rhinotragus marginatus, Perty, Del. An. Art. Bras.
pos, t, 194.1.
R. anceps, Newm. Ent. Mag. vy. p. 495.
8. Brazil.
f. marginatus is considered a distinct species by some ento-
mologists.
2. Rhinotragus apicalis, Guérin-Méneville.
Rhinotragus apicalis, Guérin-Méney. Icon. R. A. p. 236.
Bolivia. Prov. Parand, Brazil.
3. Rhinotragus analis, Serville.
Rhinotragus analis, Serv. Ann. Soc. Ent. Fr, 1833, p. 550.
S. Brazil.
4. Rhinotraqus festivus, Perty.
Rhinotragus festivus, Perty, Del. An. Art. p. 94, t. 19. f. 2.
R. suturalis, Sery. Ann. Soe. Fr. 1833, p. 550.
S. Brazil.
5. Rhinotragus trilineatus, White.
Rhinotragus trilineatus, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p.
R. Amazons.
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 25
Genus EryTHRopLatys, White.
White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 201.
1. Erythroplatys corallifer, White, 1. c. p. 202, pl. v. f. 2.
Santarem, Amazons, on flowers. Resembles to deception
the Hispid Cephalodonta spinipes.
2. Erythroplatys rugosus, Lucas.
Rhinotragus rugosus, Lucas, Voyage de Castelnau, Entomologie, p. 182,
pliadiet. 7.
Interior of Brazil.
3. ?Hrythroplatys Lucasii, Thomson.
Rhinotragus Lucasit, Thoms, Classif. des Céramb. p. 178.
Interior of Guiana.
Genus AUCHMUTES, Bates.
Bates, Entom. Monthly Mag. iv. p. 23 (1867).
Syn. Ornistomus, Thoms. Syst. Ceramb. p. 166 (1864).
The differences between these two genera are too small to
}). warrant their separation. ‘Thomson’s genus is not mentioned
in Lacordaire’s great work ; but there can be no doubt that
| this is its right place, and not in the neighbourhood of Ptero-
| platus, with which it was possibly confounded by Lacordaire.
The species of the genera here united, although differing very
greatly in size and in the form of the apex of the elytra, both
resemble the Lycide. I hesitate to admit M. Thomson’s name,
as 1t may prove, when its faulty grammatical construction is
corrected (as it is sure to be by subsequent authors), to have
been already employed in zoology.
1. Aichmutes bicinctus, Thomson.
Ormstomus bicinctus, Thoms., J. e. p. 167.
8. Brazil.
2. dichmutes lycoides, Bates.
Aichmutes lycoides, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 382.
Ega, Amazons.
Genus OREGOSTOMA, Serville.
Serv. Ann. Soc. Fr. 1833, p. 551; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p. 501.
1. Oregostoma rubricorne, Serv. l. c.
Rhinotragus coccineus, Guérin-Méney. Icon. R, A., Ins. pl. 44. f. 7.
S. Brazil.
26 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
2. Oregostoma luridum, Klug.
Stenopterus luridus, Klug, Entom. Bras. Spec. alter. p. 470, pl. 44. f. 3.
S. Brazil.
Genus OmMATA, White.
White, Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 194; Lacord, Genera, vol. viii. p. 502.
White founded the genus Ommata on a species from Vene-
zuela, distinguished by its very long antenne, thickened and
not serrated towards the apex; with this character are associated
vitreous narrowed elytra and tufted hind tibie. Lacordaire
considers these features of less generic importance than the
normal relative forms of the metasternum and abdomen and
the exserted anterior cox. In these latter points White’s
insect agrees with a large number of species of the most diver-
sified forms and colours; and an examination of very copious
material has not yielded me any more definite generic distinc-
tions than those mentioned by Lacordaire. It is true that the
type, Ommata elegans, and a second species that may be asso-
ciated with it, O. Mara of Newman, differ from all the other
Ommate (sensu Lacord.) in their vitreous elytral surface ; but
O. clavicornis and some other species with opaque elytra come
very close to O. Maza, and the genus would have to be split up
into a large number of smaller genera if Ommata were to be
restricted to the two species here named. The genus com-
prehends a series of species which for the most part are at once
distinguishable by their facies from Odontocera ; and in cases
of doubt I have treated the opaque and punctured elytra as a
differential character.
The genus Agaone, Pascoe, which I formerly adopted, I find
on the examination of further material to be quite untenable ;
or if it be maintained, it must be restricted to the typical species,
A. notabilis.
I. Legs long and slender ; middle femora gradually and moderately
clavate.
A. Elytra entire or nearly so. (Pheenissa.)
1. Ommata (Phenissa) nigripes, Serville.
Oregostoma ngripes, Serv. Ann. Soc. Ent. Fr. 1833, p. 552.
8. Brazil.
2. Ommata (Phenissa) bipartita, n. sp.
O. nigripede gracilior, thorace magis cylindrico, elytrorum plus quam
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 27
dimidio apicali nigro; nigra, thorace et fere dimidio basali ely-
trorum coccineis. Long. 43-52 lin. 9°.
) Prov. Parané, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
|) Very closely allied to O. nigripes (Serv.). Smaller and
| narrower, thorax narrower and more regularly cylindrical, the
black portion of the elytra extending rather more than halfway
) towards the base. The head is coarsely scabrous-punctate as
in O. nigripes; the antenne are very slightly thickened
}towards the tips, with the third to fifth joints linear and the
) following moderately serrate. The thorax and elytra are
| closely reticulate-punctate, the latter more deeply so than in
| O.nigripes ; they are slightly narrowed in the middle, and reach
) the apex of the abdomen, with the tips broadly and obliquely
) truncate and the sutural angle briefly spinose. The abdomen
) is dark blue and shining.
3. Ommata (Phenissa) punicea, Newman.
Rhinotragus puniceus, Newm. Entom. Mag. v. p. 495.
S. Brazil.
There are many examples in the British-Museum collection,
j all distinguished from O. nigripes by their slenderer shape and
j)two small black spots placed transversely on the disk of the
| thorax.
4, Ommata (Phenissa?) discoidea, Serville.
Oregostoma discoidea, Serv. Ann. Soc. Ent. Fr. 1833, p. 552.
S. Brazil.
AA. Ktytra moderately narrowed posteriorly.
a. Elytra scarcely abbreviated, apex truncated. (Chrysaéthe.)
5. Ommata atrata, Bates.
Ommata atrata, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc, 1872, p. 184.
i (. Brazil.
| _— 6. Ommata asperiventris, Bates.
Ommata asperiventris, Bates, Trans, Ent. Soc. 1872, p. 184.
8. Brazil.
7. Ommata cyanipennis, Bates.
Ommata cyanipennis, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1872, p, 184.
Chontales, Nicaragua.
8. Ommata aurata, Bates.
Ommata aurata, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 320.
R. Amazons.
28° Mr. H. W. Bates on the
9. Ommata smaragdina, Bates.
Ommata smaragdina, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 320.
Rk. Amazons.
10. Ommata Beltiana, Bates.
Ommata Beltiana, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1872, p. 184.
Chontales, Nicaragua.
aa. Elytra narrowed and rounded at the tip ; antenne elongated and
thickened at apex, not serrated.
* Elytra shining or vitreous. (Ommata, typical.)
The elytra have an elevated line along their posterior part,
parallel to the outer margin.
11. Ommata elegans, White.
Ommata elegans, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 194, pl. v. f. 6.
Venezuela.
12. Ommata Maia, Newman.
Odontocera Maia, Newman, Entomologist, p. 92.
Rio Janeiro, Brazil. Not uncommon in collections. .
I have seen a third species of this group in Dr. Baden’s
collection, in which the antenne are half as long again as the
body ; but the specimen is.in too imperfect a state for description.
** Elytra opaque. (Rhopalessa.)
13. Ommata clavicornis, n. sp.
O. gracilis, nigra, longe erecte pubescens, thorace (marginibus antico
et postico nigris exceptis) sanguineo, breviter cylindrico, polito,
plagiatim punctato ; elytris integris, crebre punctatis; antennis
elongatis, articulis 3°-6™ linearibus,9°-11"™ valde dilatatis, leviter
serratis. Long.4lin. 9°.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W.
Bates).
Allied to the typical species, O. elegans, in the form of the
antenne, but differing in the elytra being very nearly entire
and without vitreous polish on their surface. The head has a
short muzzle, the eyes (female) widely distant, and the forehead
coarsely but sparsely punctured, with silvery pubescence. The
sixth to eighth antennal joints are pale at the base. The thorax
is short, smoothly convex and shining, with moderately small.
punctures in patches. The elytra are very little narrowed,
and reach to the middle of the pygidium, their apex being
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 29
very obtusely truncated, and their surface closely punctate-
rugose and clothed with curled whitish hairs. The under
surface is clothed with similar hairs. The legs are slender,
| the thighs somewhat suddenly clavate, and the hind legs
| distinctly elongated ; their colour is pitchy, with the base of
the hind thighs pale testaceous.
14. Ommata tenuis, Burmeister.
Rhinotragus tenuis, Burmeister, Stettin. ent. Zeit. 1865, p. 173.
Parana.
Burmeister describes the antenne as strongly thickened at
| the tip and the elytra punctured and opaque. As he does not
mention the form of the elytra, and places the species in Rh7-
| notragus, it is to be inferred they are subentire and perhaps
| truncated.
II. Legs slender ; middle femora abruptly but not very broadly
| clavate ; elytra with sides subparallel, apea truncated. (Kclipta.)
A. Elytra abbreviated.
15. Ommata Hirene, Newman.
Odontocera Eirene, Newman, Entomologist, p. 92.
8. Brazil.
| The elytra reach the middle of the third abdominal segment,
) and are obtusely truncated ; the antenne are thickened and
serrate from the seventh joint.
There is a sexual difference in coloration. The female,
| described by Newman, has unicolorous greenish-black elytra
| and white hind tarsi; the male has a pale testaceous vitta near
the suture, extending from the base to two thirds the length
| of the elytra, and the hind tarsi are black with cinereous hairs.
16. Ommata castanea, n. sp.
O. linearis, breviter pubescens, antennis basi pedibusque nigris;
elytris abbreviatis ad suturam dehiscentibus. Long. 5 lin. 9.
Proy. Rio Janeiro, Brazil (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W. Bates).
| Head thickly punctured, except the lower part of the fore-
| head; muzzle elongated, not narrowed. Antenne (female) three
| fourths the length of the body, thickened but scarcely serrate
towards the tips, joints 3 to 6 linear; basal joints black,
apical pale tawny. ‘Thorax elongate cylindrical, densely re-
| ticulate-punctate. Elytra considerably narrowed from near
| the base, but parallel afterwards to the apex, which is truncated
) and scarcely reaches the base of the penultimate ventral
30 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
segment; they are widely divergent at the suture. The legs
are black, the hind pair much elongated, with distinctly clavate
femora.
17. Ommata thoracica, n. sp.
O. elongata, angusta, plumbeo-nigra, cano breviter pubescens, thorace
angusto, rufo, crebre reticulato-punctato ; elytris paulo abbreviatis,
apice recte truncatis. Long. 4} lin.
Prov. Parané et Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. W. W.
Saunders, Dr. Baden, and H. W. Bates).
A slender, narrow species, with elytra very moderately
narrowed and parallel from a little beyond the base, and
reaching a little beyond the base of the penultimate segment,
their apices sharply truncate, and their suture slightly gaping.
Head rugose-punctate, with much-elongated muzzle. Antenne
(female) two thirds the length of the body, black ; third to
sixth joints linear, but rather short and stout, the following a
little thickened and but slightly serrated. Thorax elongate,
convex, uneven ; surface entirely covered with shallow circular
pits, leaving narrow reticulated interstices. Elytra closely
punctured. Legs rather slender, shining black; thighs some-
what abruptly clavate, hind legs elongated.
I have seen this species labelled O. collaris of Serv.; but
Serville says this species has the elytra “acuminées postérieure-
ment,” which character applies neither to this nor the following
similarly coloured species.
18. Ommata flavicollis, n. sp.
O. postice angustata, nigra, thorace flavo-aurantiaco, opaco, haud
distincte punctato; elytris abbreviatis, versus apicem paulo an-
gustatis, apice truncatis. Long. 4 lin. ¢ 9.
Prov. Parand, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Closely allied to the preceding, but the antenne shorter and
the elytra not reaching the apex of the antepenultimate ventral
segment. Head coarsely punctured ; muzzle much elongated ;
eyes (male) almost contiguous, (female) separated by only a
short distance. Antenne scarcely two thirds the length of the
body ; third to sixth joints linear but rather thick, and fifth and
sixth a little widened at apex; they are black, but in the male
the seventh to eleventh joints are pale at the base. Thorax
opaque, orange-yellow, without visible punctuation. Elytra
very closely subconfluent-punctate. The legs are moderately
slender, the thighs clongate-clavate.
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 31
19. Ommata Hunomia, Newman.
Odontocera Eunomia, Newman, Entomologist, p. 92.
8. Brazil.
Described by Newman from a single specimen. In colours
the species is variable—the upper surface of the thorax being
either wholly black, slightly embrowned in the centre, or
wholly fulvous; and the yellow vitta of the elytra sometimes
extends to the suture, and is sometimes confined to the disk, or
wholly wanting. ‘Throughout all the varieties, however, the
front of the head, the four anterior femora, and the basal half
of the hind pair are bright fulvous. The elytra scarcely pass
the base of the antepenultimate segment, and are sharply
sinuate-truncate at the apex. The antenne have the third to
sixth joimts linear; and the rest are not thickened, and only
slightly serrated. The thorax is somewhat irregularly reticu-
late-punctate. The elytra are closely punctate and obscured
by soft incumbent silky pile.
20. Ommata brachialis, n. sp.
O. gracilis, fusco-nigra, infra dense cano pubescens; femoribus
anticis fulvis, femoribus posticis basi albo-testaceis. Long. 3-4
lin. g.
Prov. Rio Janeiro, Brazil (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W. Bates).
Very closely allied to O. Hunomia. Elytra more elongate,
passing the base of the penultimate segment, and obtusely (not
sinuate) truncate at the apex. The head is wholly black; and
the anterior thighs only are fulvous, the extreme base of the
other pairs being whitish. The eyes (male) are separated by
a narrow space on the forehead. The antenne are three fourths
the length of the body, and thickened towards the apex; they
are dull black, with bases of seventh to eleventh joints
fulvous ; the third to fifth joints are long, slender, and linear.
The thorax is narrow, and reticulate-punctate in three longi-
tudinal patches, the interstices being scarcely punctured. The
elytra are closely punctured. The legs are long, especially
the hind pair, and the thighs distinctly clavate.
21. Ommata monostigma, Bates.
Agaone monostigma, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1869, p. 384.
Chontales, Nicaragua.
22. Ommata liturifera, n. sp.
O. linearis, angusta, fulvo-testacea; occipite lituraque magna pro-
32 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
thoracis (H simulante) nigris; elytris paulo abbreviatis, late
truncatis, crebre punctatis. Long. 27-4 lin. ¢ Q.
Prov. Rio Janeiro, Brazil (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W. Bates).
Head tawny testaceous; occiput, and in female a frontal
streak, black; coarsely punctured; muzzle moderately elongated,
not narrowed; eyes in male contiguous in front, in female
widely distant. Antennee rather short, filiform, serrate, joints
3-5 linear; tawny testaceous, tips of jomts brown. Thorax
cylindrical, a little constricted in front and behind, very coarsely
punctured; tawny, with two broad vitte on the disk, jomed
in the middle by a fascia, black, a black vitta also on each flank.
Elytra reaching to the middle of the penultimate ventral
segment, moderately narrowed from near the base and parallel,
apex sharply truncate ; colour light tawny brown, thickly but
separately punctured. Body beneath yellowish, breast and
middle of abdomen black. Legs slender, thighs rather abruptly
clavate, hind legs moderately elongate; testaceous yellow,
femoral clava ringed with black, tibize and tarsi also black.
AA. Elytra nearly reaching the tip of the abdomen.
23. Ommata prolixa, n. sp.
O. elongata, angusta, setosa, testaceo-rufa ; capite (epistomate ex-
cepto), maculis thoracis duabus dorsalibus alteraque utrinque
elytrorum humerali, pectore et pedibus nigris, femoribus basi
albo-testaceis ; elytris pallide fuscis postice obscurioribus ; an-
tennis modice elongatis apice vix incrassatis, nigris, articulis basi
pallidis ; thorace antice angustato, supra inzequali, grosse disperse
punctato ; elytris subintegris, crebre punctatis, apice oblique trun-
catis. Long.4 lin. 9.
Prov. Parand, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders).
Closely allied to O. ertbripennis, but more elongated,
especially the elytra. The eyes (female) are more distant on
the forehead, and the space between them is wide, plane, and
(like the rest of the head) coarsely punctured. The antenne
have the third to fifth joints lear, and the following very
gradually thickened, but not produced, at their inner apical
angles. The hind legs are very little elongated, and the thighs
moderately clubbed.
24. Ommata lanuginosa, n. sp.
O. linearis, fulvo-testacea, aureo breviter pubescens, opaca ; occipite,
thoracis disco femoribusque (partim) nigris; antennis filiformibus,
articulis 7°-10"™ yix serratis haud incrassatis ; thorace cylindrico,
supra longitudinaliter biimpresso, reticulato-punctato ; elytris
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 33
vix abbreviatis, acute truncatis, fulvo-fuscis, creberrime punctatis.
Long. 4 lin. ¢.
Prov. Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden).
Opaque, clothed with a fine incumbent golden pile, short on
the elytra, but longer and denser on the sides of the thorax, on
the breast, and in the middle of the abdominal segments. The
head is tawny testaceous, with the crown and occiput and part
of the epistome black ; the eyes (male) do not reach the median
line; the muzzle is much elongated. The antennz are dull
tawny brown. The thorax is cylindrical, almost bisulcate
along the disk, closely reticulate-punctate, with the whole disk
dull black, and margins (like the under surface) tawny testa-
ceous. The elytra reach the base of the terminal segment and
are sharply sinuate-truncate ; their surface is very regularly
and closely punctured and opaque. The legs are moderately
slender, the femora rather abruptly but not thickly clavate,
and the first joint of the hind tarsi is equal in length to the
remaining three ; the femora and tibie are indistinctly clouded
with blackish.
25. Ommata cribripennis, n. sp.
O. linearis, angusta, setosa, melleo-flava ; occipite supra maculaque
basali pronoti nigris ; antennis apicem versus vix incrassatis, nigris,
scapo infra articulisque 3°-10™ basi melleo-flavis ; elytris pallide
fuscis, subintegris, crebre sed discrete grosse punctatis, apice
oblique truncatis ; pedibus posticis elongatis, femoribus omnibus
clavatis. Long. 3 lin. ¢ Q.
Prov. Parana, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Closely allied to 0. (Agaone) malthinoides (Bates), but the
elytra less attenuated than in that species ; in fact these organs
are entire, with the exception of the narrowness of the epi-
pleure from a little beyond the base, and they leave only the
tip of the pygidium exposed. The eyes of the male do not
approach so closely on the forehead as in the allied species.
The third to fifth antennal joints are linear, and the rest are
only very slightly produced at their inner apical angles. The
thorax is cylindrical and very coarsely, but irregularly and not
closely, punctured. The legs are clear honey-yellow, with the
exception of a brown spot at the apex of the hind femora.
26. Ommata erythrodera, n. sp.
O. clavicorni simillima, differt antennis brevibus gracilibus, articulis
6°-11"™ basi flavis. Linearis, fusco-nigra nitida, sparsim pubes-
cens ; thorace cylindrico, angusto, supra conyexo, paulo inquali,
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 3
34 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
grossissime sparsim punctato, lete rufo nitido, marginibus anticis
et posticis nigris; elytris vix abbreviatis, acute truncatis, nigro-
fuscis, passim grosse regulariter punctatis, nitidis ; femoribus sub-
abrupte haud fortiter clavatis, basi albis. Long. 4 lin. 9.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden).
Deceptively similar to O. clavicornis in general form, colour,
and in the form and proportions of the legs ; but differs at once
in the moderately short slender antenne, ringed with pale tes-
taceous at the base of joints 6 to 11; this character would
bring it into a different genus were the antenne taken as
guides. The head is shining black, regularly punctured, with
much longer muzzle than in O. clavicornis and not pubescent ;
the space between the eyes on the front (female) is quite plane
and very moderate for this sex. The elytra reach beyond the
base of the terminal segment and are broadly and subsinuately
truncate ; their surface is shining, free from incumbent pubes-
cence, and covered with separate punctures decidedly larger
than those of O.clavicornis; in shape they are parallel-sided
from after the base. The underside of the body is shining black,
scantily clothed with grey pubescence. ‘The basal joint of the
posterior tarsi is narrow, but shorter than the remaining joints
taken together.
27. Ommata vitticollis, n. sp.
O. linearis, angusta, nigra; capite angusto, grosse punctato melleo-
flavo; thorace elongato antice angustato, supra inzequali, grosse
disperse ocellato-punctato, nigro, vitta dorsali etinfra melleo-flavis ;
elytris subintegris, apice obtuse truncatis, passim crebre ocellato-
punctatis. Long. 33 lin. 9°.
Prov. Parand, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Differs in form from the allied species, the head and thorax
being small in proportion to the elytra, and the thorax narrowed
anteriorly. ‘The antenne are three fourths the length of the
body, and scarcely thickened towards the tips; the third to
sixth joints are linear; they are black, with the exception of
the pale bases of joimts ninth to eleventh. The femora are
distinctly clavate and the hind legs elongated, as in the typical
forms of the genus.
28. Ommata malthinoides, Bates.
Agaone malthinoides, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 319.
R. Amazons.
29. Ommata ruficollis, Bates.
Agaone ruficollis, Bates, Trans, Ent. Soe. 1870, p. 319.
R. Amazons.
—a4 jT— => ce. £
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 35
30. Ommata anoguttata, n. sp.
O. elongato-linearis, supra plana, subtiliter pubescens, fusca, elytris
apice macula transversa flava. Long. 5lin. 9.
Prov. Parandé, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Head fulvo-testaceous, shining, thickly punctured, muzzle
elongated ; space between the eyes (female) in front moderate ;
occiput black. Antenne more than three fourths the length
of the body, slightly thickened and serrate towards the tips,
joints three to five linear; colour pitchy testaceous, basal joints
beneath paler. Thorax elongate cylindrical, disk with four
tubercles and a median raised wheal, rest of surface ocellate-
punctate, black above, central line and sides fulvous. Elytra
elongate-linear and plane, leaving the pygidium uncovered,
not dehiscent ; apex truncate and tumid on the surface where
lies the pale transverse spot; the surface rather finely and
closely rugose-punctate, with soft, inclined, and curly pubes-
cense ; colour brown, suture paler. Body beneath dark brown,
with golden pubescence; abdominal segments ringed with
yellow. Legs tawny testaceous, base of thighs blackish ;
hind legs moderately elongated, thighs rather abruptly clavate.
31. Ommata egrota, Bates.
Odontocera egrota, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1872, p. 288.
Chontales, Nicaragua.
I described this species as an Odontocera, following Lacor-
daire’s definition of the genus; but the closely punctured and
non-vitreous elytra bring it within the genus Ommata, ac-
cording to the classification here adopted.
32. Ommata Xantho, n. sp.
O. robustior, pallide flava; capite, elytris, tibiis, tarsis femoribusque
supra nigris, fronte flava; antennis filiformibus, nigris, articulis
6°-10"™ basi pallidis ; thorace lateribus paulo rotundatis, margine
antico crasso, reticulato-punctato opaco ; elytris subintegris re-
ticulato-punctatis, apice oblique truncatis angulo exteriore longe
spinoso ; metasterno late nigro-fasciato ; pedibus robustis, femori-
bus elongato-clavatis. Long. 4} lin. ¢.
Prov. Parandé, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders).
A robust species, with hind legs not disproportionately elon-
gated, and filiform antenne, of which the third to fifth joints
are linear.
33. Ommata pecila, n. sp.
O. linearis, pallide flava, thoracis macula dorsali, elytrorum macula
36 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
quadrata humerali, fascia mediana alteraque apicali nigris; an-
tennis elongatis, apice gradatim incrassatis, nigris, flavo annulatis ;
thorace cylindrico, convexo, crebre reticulato-punctato; elytris
vix abbreviatis, basi excepta angustatis parallelis, apice oblique
truncatis, dense reticulato-punctatis. Long. 43 lin. ¢.
Prov. Parand, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Linear, thorax and elytra closely covered with round punc-
tures forming narrow reticulated interstices. Clear pale yellow,
with an irregular spot on the disk of the thorax, a belt across
the middle and apex of the elytra, and a square spot on the
shoulder black. The antenne (male) are nearly as long as
the body and considerably thickened towards the apex, the
third to fifth joints are linear; the colour is black, with the
base of fourth to tenth joints and first to fourth joints beneath
pale testaceous. Beneath there is a broad stripe on each
side of the metasternum and across the abdomen, black. The
legs have a streak on the upperside of the femoral clave, the
apex of the tibize and the tarsi black ; the hind legs are not elon-
gated ; all the femora are clavate, the anterior and middle pair
more abruptly so than the posterior. The elytra are moderately
narrowed trom a little behind the base, and are thence parallel
to the apex; they are not dehiscent at the suture; and the ex-
ternal angle of the apical truncature has a longish spine.
A variety occurs in which the middle and apical black fascie
of the elytra and the humeral spots are united, and the head
and whole apical half of the abdomen is black.
34. Ommata fenestrata, Lucas.
Oregostoma fenestratum, Lucas, Voyage de Castelnau, Ins. pl. 12. f. 8.
Interior of Brazil.
Ill. Legs robust ; middle femora abruptly and very thickly clavate ;
first joint of hind tarsi greatly elongated ; elytra entire. (Agaone,
Pascoe).
35. Ommata notabilis, White.
Rhinotragus notabilis, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 199.
R. Amazons.
Genus ODONTOCERA, Serv.
Serv. Ann. Soc. Ent. Fr. 1833, p. 546; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii.
p. 503.
[ have nothing to add to the definition of this genus given
by Lacordaire, except that I think it better to exclude every
species which has not a vitreous surface to the elytra. This
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 37
character, added to the enlarged metasternum, slender abdo-
men (often constricted at the base), subcylindrical or oval tho-
rax, and elytra never much abbreviated or subulate, will di-
stinguish Odontocera from all the allied genera. The antennz
vary in thickness and length; in most species they are short,
thick, and strongly serrated from the sixth or fifth joint ; but
many have very slender, filiform antenne. Some of these I
formerly placed in the genus Agaone, notwithstanding the
slender or constricted abdomen; but this course is the less
admissible, as the type of the genus Odontocera (O. vitrea of
Serville) is described as having slender antenne.
I. Antenne elongate, slender.
1. Odontocera molorchoides, White.
Rhinotragus molorchoides, White, Cat. Long, Col. Brit. Mus. p. 200.
R. Amazons.
2. Odontocera vittipennis, n, sp.
O. nigra, cano pubescens; thorace oblongo-oyato, rufo-aurantiaco,
reticulato-punctato, opaco; elytris nigris, vitta albo-testacea,
vitrea; tarsis posticis albis; antennis elongatis gracilibus, articu-
lis a sexto leviter serratis basi flavo-testaceis. Long. 4 lin. ¢.
Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders).
Head black, clothed with hoary pile; muzzle elongated ;
eyes (male) nearly touching the median line in front. Antenne
as long as the body, black ; joints sixth to eleventh yellow at
base, third to sixth linear, seventh to tenth elongate, moderately
dilated and serrate at their apices. Thorax rather broader
than the elytra, subovate, the sides being much rounded near
the middle; the surface is opaque, covered with shallow round
pits, and with the flanks light red. The elytra nearly reach
the apex of the penultimate segment; they are subparallel
from the middle, with tips obliquely and sharply truncated ;
their surface is very closely and coarsely punctured and deep
black, except a narrow well-defined central vitta from the base
to near the apex, which is whitish, faintly punctured, and
shining. ‘The legs are black, with the exception of the hind
tarsi, which are white, and have their basal joint longer than
the remaining three together, but not slender; the middle
femora are abruptly a | very broadly clavate; the hind legs
greatly elongated, and their femora very gradually and mode-
rately thickened. ‘The under surface of the body is densely
clothed with short hoary pile; the abdomen is moderately
slender, and the anterior coxe scarcely exserted. |
38 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
3. Odontocera clara, n. sp.
O. valde elongata, nigra; thorace aurantiaco-flayo, pectore abdo-
mineque cinereo-tomentosis; elytris disco omnino vitreo albo-
testaceo. Long. 54-73 lin. ¢ @.
Chontales, Nicaragua (coll. T. Belt and H. W. Bates).
An elongate narrow species, similar in form to O.chrysostetha,
but resembling O. vittipennis in colours. Head black, shining,
scabrous-punctate ; muzzle elongate and narrow. Antenne
long and filiform, moderately serrate from the sixth joint,
shining black; extreme base of joints 7 to 11 pallid,
especially in the male. Thorax long, cylindrical, gradually
narrowed in front, orange-testaceous, moderately shining,
closely subreticulate-punctate, with a short, smooth, raised
dorsal line on the fore part of the disk. Elytra reaching to
the middle of the fourth segment, moderately narrowed behind
the base, thence parallel to the apex, which is sharply truncate,
with the angles prominent ; surface pallid brownish and glassy,
faintly punctulate ; margins (except the basal) narrowly black
and coarsely punctured. Meso- and metasterna and abdomen
black, clothed with a laid ashy pile; metasternum moderately
voluminous, and abdomen linear, coarsely punctured. Legs
much elongated, black, shining; all the femora rather gradually
clavate; hind pair reaching the tip of the abdomen.
This is one of the latest discoveries of Mr. Thomas Belt.
4. Odontocera colon, Bates.
Agaone colon, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 319.
R. Amazons.
5. Odontocera monostigma, Bates.
Agaone monostigma, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1869, p. 384.
Chontales, Nicaragua.
6. Odontocera parallela, White.
Odontocera parallela, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 189.
R. Amazons.
7. Odontocera mellea, White.
Odontocera mellea, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus, p. 188.
R. Amazons.
8. Odontocera chrysostetha, Bates.
Odontocera chrysostetha, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 320.
R. Amazons.
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 39
9. Odontocera vitrea, Serville.
Odontocera vitrea, Serville, Ann. Ent. Soc. Fr. 1833, p. 547.
Cayenne.
Serville describes the antennz in his Odontocere as “ filifor-
mes, presque setacées, 5 ou 6 articles en scie.’’ His species
would therefore come in the present section.
10. Odontocera cylindrica, Serv. l.c. p. 548.
Brazil.
It is not stated in the description that the elytra have vitre-
ous disks; the position of the species is therefore doubtful.
Il. Antenne more or less abbreviated and dilated.
A. Thorax narrow, cylindrical.
a. Disk of thorax even.
* Antenne much thickened towards the apex.
11. Odontocera crocata, n. sp.
O. gracillima, postice attenuata, fusco-niger; antennis, pedibus et
elytris fulvo-croceis, his marginibus et apice late nigris, valde ab-
breviatis, apice late truncatis. Long. 3? lin. ¢.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W.
Bates).
Head coarsely punctured; eyes voluminous, contiguous in
front; muzzle moderate, narrow.. Antenne two thirds the
length of the body, thickened towards the tip, saffron tawny ;
third to fifth joimts slender, linear, seventh to tenth serrate.
Thorax very narrow, cylindrical, with longitudinal patches of
shallow circular punctures, the patches connected by transverse
wrinkles. Elytra just passing the base of the antepenultimate
segment, moderately narrowed from after the base, dehiscent
at the suture, sharply and broadly truncated at the apex ; sur-
face moderately punctured, very sparsely so on the disk, which
is shining. Body beneath rufous tawny; thorax, sides of
breast, and belt across middle of abdomen black. Legs saffron
tawny ; hind pair elongated; thighs distinctly clavate. Meta-
sternum (male) voluminous; abdomen slender, linear.
** Antenne robust, all joints thickened.
12. Odontocera sanguinolenta (Dej.), n. sp.
O. elongata, robusta, sanguinea; capite, antennis, vitta thoracis lata
dorsali pedibusque nigris; femoribus posticis annulo sanguineo;
40 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
elytris fere apicem abdominis attingentibus, angustis, testaceo-
flavis, vitreis, marginibus nigris, apice macula oblonga leete flava.
Long. 7-8 lin. ¢ @.
Rio Janeiro (coll. W. W. Saunders, Dr. Baden, and H. W.
Bates).
ne elongated and narrow but robust form. Head black,
coarsely punctured. Antenne about half the length of the
body, stout, of equal thickness to the apex, third to fifth
joints being much dilated, and the following serrated, dull
black. Thorax elongated, cylindrical, closely punctured, sides
broadly blood-red, the rest dull black. Scutellum white.
Elytra reaching nearly the tip of the body, narrow, and nearly
parallel from after the base; apex sharply truncated, with
angles somewhat produced; surface shining, black, with a
central vitta straw-colour and vitreous, the black borders
coarsely punctured; an elongate spot brighter yellow at apex.
Breast and abdomen sanguineous, the former black in the
middle, the latter with margins of the segments black. Legs
robust, black ; hind femora with a blood-red ring, and gradu-
ally clavate.
13. Odontocera apicalis, Klug.
Stenopterus apicalis, Klug, Entom. Bras. Specim. alter. p. 54, t. xliv.
f. 6.
Brazil.
Apparently allied to O. sanguinolenta.
aa. Disk of thorax tuberculated.
14. Odontocera gracilis, Klug.
Stenopterus gracilis, Klug, Entom. Bras. Spec. alt. p. 54, t. xliv. f. 7.
St. elegans, Guérin-Ménev. Icon. R. A. pl. 44. f. 9.
Brazil.
It has been suggested that this species should be excluded
from the genus Odontocera, on account of its tubercled thorax,
the great length of the peduncle of the hind femora, and other
characters. Its peculiar facies and metallic colouring ill consort
with the other congeners; but all its essential structural cha-
racters are shared in by one or other members of the genus.
For instance, the tuberculated thorax is possessed in still
higher development by O. flavicauda, which has nothing ab-
normal in its colouring, and quite moderately clavate and pe-
dunculate hind femora.
15. Odontocera flavicauda, n. sp.
O. elongata, linearis, castaneo-rufa; capite, antennis basi pedibus-
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 41
que nigris ; elytris pallide brunneis, vitreis, marginibus anguste
nigris, apice flavis. Long. 5-6lin. g Q.
Prov. Parandé, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Elongate and narrow in form. Head coarsely punctured.
Antennz rather more than half the length of the body, not
| thickened, regularly serrate from the sixth joint; fifth also a
| little dilated at the apex; basal half black, apical half cas-
_ taneous. Thorax rather short, cylindrical; surtace with four
tubercles and a central raised line; interstices with large,
circular, scattered punctures. LElytra reaching nearly the
| base of the pygidium, moderately narrow and subparallel
| from a little beyond the base; apex broadly sinuate-truncate ;
surface glassy, although finely and sparsely punctured and
| setose; margins coarsely rugose-punctate and black; disk
pale brown (palest near the base) ; apex with a longish yel-
low spot. Beneath shining chestnut-red; thorax blackish ;
| Legs black; hind pair much elongated; thighs abruptly
clavate. Abdomen of male slender and linear, of female sub-
| petiolated.
AA. Thorax subovate.
a. Hind legs elongate, slender ; femora abruptly clavate.
| 16. Odontocera nigriclavis, n. sp.
| O. elongata, nigra; pedibus posticis (clava femorali scapoque tibiali
nigris exceptis) et tarsis omnibus flavo-testaceis; vitta discoidali
elytrorum albo-testacea, vitrea. Long. 5-6 lin. ¢ @.
| Prov. Rio Janeiro and Parana, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders,
Dr. Baden, and H. W. Bates).
Closely allied to O. dispar (Bates), but having longer elytra,
yellow tarsi, and female concolorous with the male, &c. Head
with elongated muzzle. Antenne half the length of the body,
_ thickened from the fifth joint; black, bases of the joints testa-
/ceous tawny. Thorax elongate, gradually narrowed behind ;
| surface longitudinally impressed, clothed with long hairs, and
_ closely reticulate-punctate. Elytra reaching to middle of the
third segment, nearly parallel from after the base, truncate
at the apex, thickly punctured and black on the borders ;
disk occupied by a whitish vitreous vitta. Legs black; tarsi
testaceous yellow ; the hind legs moderately elongated ; femora
abruptly clavate; tibiz with a dense brush of black hairs
round the apical half; base of thighs and of tibiz testaceous
yellow.
42 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
17. Odontocera pecilopoda, White.
Odontocera pecilopoda, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 191.
Amazons.
18. Odontocera dispar, Bates.
Odontocera dispar, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 321.
Amazons.
19. Odontocera aurocincta, n. sp.
O. valde elongata, nigra; antennis, tibiis et tarsis fulvis; femoribus
basi et tibiis posticis dimidio basali albo-testaceis ; thorace breviter
cylindrico-ovato, grosse punctato, tomento aureo marginato; elytris
modice abbreviatis, angustis, apice obtuse truncatis, fulyo-testaceis,
vitreis. Long. 7 lin. 9.
Tehuantepec, Mexico (coll. H. W. Bates).
Closely allied to O. nigriclavis, but destitute of brush on
the hind femora. Head coarsely punctured, black. The an-
tenne are tawny, moderately short, thickened towards the
tips, serrate from the sixth joint. The elytra reach nearly to the
middle of the third segment, and are much narrowed but not
subuliform, being little dehiscent at the suture and truncated
at the tip; they are unicolorous pale tawny brown, with the
exception of a narrow blackish line along the anterior part of
the suture and of the lateral margins. ‘The underside of the
body is closely punctured ; it is black, becoming castaneous on
the abdomen, the two basal segments of which have a broad
pale testaceous belt. The hind legs are moderately elongated,
and the femora somewhat strongly clavate. The metasternum
is voluminous, and the abdomen very elongate and slender
towards the base.
20. Odontocera leucothea, n. sp.
O. albicanti (Klug) simillima; differt elytrorum margine suturali late
incurvo, maculaque triangulari circumscutellari nigra. Long. 7—
9ln. 9.
Novo Friburg (Rio Janeiro); Minas Geraes and Parand.
(coll. W. W. Saunders, Dr. Baden, and H. W. Bates).
Deceptively similar to O. albicans, Klug (Entom. Bras.
t. xliv. f. 5); colours the same, except a broad, triangular,
black spot in the scutellar region. The silvery pile of the
thorax, however, is concentrated in rounded spots, of which
there are four (in quadrangle) on the disk, and others more
irregular on the flanks; and there are slight differences in the
distribution of colours on the antenne and legs. The white
ring of the antenne in O. albicans embraces joints seventh to
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 43
ninth; in O. lewcothea joints sixth, seventh, and the apical half
of the fifth. In the anterior legs the femora are chestnut-red, and
| the tibia and tarsi testaceous yellow (in O. albicans these
| colours are exactly reversed); the middle tibize and base of the
| femora are testaceous yellow. Notwithstanding this close
| general similarity, it is likely the two insects belong to diffe-
| rent genera, the antenne (according to Klug’s figure) appear-
| ing to be simple, like the typical Ommate, and the elytra
parallel. In O.-leucothea the antenne are serrate from the
fifth joint, and the sutural margin of the elytra is strongly in-
) curved from before the middle. The disk of the elytra is
| vitreous. The abdomen is red, and in the female vespiform.
| Ihave seen four examples, all females, and exactly similar.
21. Odontocera? albicans, Klug.
Stenopterus albicans, Klug, Entom. Bras. Specim. alter. p. 53, t. xliv.
eee
Rio Janeiro.
aa. Hind femora gradually thickened.
22. Odontocera hilaris, n. sp.
O. nigra, thorace supra aurantiaco-rufo, elytrorum disco femoribus-
| que posticis basi flayo-testaceis. Long. 43 lin. 9°.
Odontocera punctata, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc, 1870, p. 823 (nec Klug).
R. Tapajos, Amazons (coll. H. W. Bates).
Short and rather robust. Head with broad and not very
elongate muzzle; the eyes in the unique specimen approach
| tolerably near to the median line in front, and seem to show it
|} to be a male; but the short and broad sessile abdomen is that
| of a female. The antenne are short, thickened and serrated
| from the fifth joint. The thorax is strongly rounded on the
| sides and constricted at the base, the surface closely reticulate-
| punctate. The elytra reach nearly to the middle of the third
| segment, with the suture dehiscent only from the middle, rapidly
| narrowed but truncated at the apex; the margins are narrowly
| deep black, leaving the whole disk pallid and vitreous, with-
| out visible punctures, except at the base. The hind legs are
| greatly elongated, the femora very gradually clavate, the tarsi
short and slender.
| Thaderroneously referred this species to O. punctata (Klug),
| with which it agrees in colour and general form ; but O. punc-
| tata (of which I have now an example before me) has longer
elytra, with their vitreous disks covered with strong dark
punctures. The eyes in the female approach the median
44. On the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America.
frontal line as closely as in O. hilaris; but the hind legs are
short and wholly black.
23. Odontocera punctata.
Stenopterus punctatus, Klug, Entom. Bras. Spec. alt. p. 53, t. xliv. f. 4.
Bahia (coll. Dr. Baden).
Klug gives the locality as “ Pard interior,” which is pro-
bably an error.
24. Odontocera ornaticollis.
Odontocera ornaticollis, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 323.
Tapajos, Amazons.
The abdomen in the male is very elongate, slender at the
base, and slightly thickened and curved downwards at the
tip.
25. Odontocera petiolata, n. sp.
O. elongata, fusco-nigra, pedibus fulvo-testaceis ; elytris elongatis
modice subuliformibus, apice subacute rotundatis, flavo-testaceis,
vitreis, marginibus anguste rufo-castaneis, fascilaque curvata pone
scutellum et vittula humerali nigris; abdomine utriusque sexus
valde petiolato. Long. 4-7 lin. ¢ Q.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W.
Bates).
Head above and down the middle of the forehead black, the
rest tawny testaceous; eyes in male not touching the median
line of forehead, in female a little more distant. Antenne
short and stout, black; apex tawny. Thorax ovate, much
narrowed behind and convex in front, densely pubescent,
coarsely and closely punctured. Elytra reaching nearly to the
apex of the penultimate segment, subulate, but not very nar-
row, parallel from after the base, obtusely pointed at the apex ;
the vitreous yellowish disk has a few very fine setiferous
punctures; a black fascia curves near the base behind the
scutellum, and joins on each side a short streak on the top of
the shoulder; the margins elsewhere are narrowly castaneous.
The legs are moderately stout; the hind thighs not clavate,
but gradually and moderately thickened. The petiolated
basal segment of the abdomen is partly yellow; the very convex
metasternum and margins of the ventral segments are clothed
with golden pile.
26. Odontocera fasciata, Newm.
Necydalis fasciata, Oliv. Ent. no. 74, p. 10, pl. 1. £9.
Odontocera chrysozone, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 192, pi. v. f. 5.
R. Amazons.
The abdomen is strongly vespiform, as in the two preceding
species.
On the Evolution of Structure in Seedlings. 45
27. ? Odontocera Dice, Newm.
? Odontocera Dice, Newm. Entom. p. 91.
Rio Janeiro.
aaa. Hind legs short and stout ; femora thickly clavate.
28. Odontocera triliturata, Bates.
Odontocera triliturata, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 324.
R. Amazons.
29. Odontocera compressipes, White.
Odontocera compressipes, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit, Mus. p. 191.
R. Amazons.
In this species the hind tibiz are much dilated exteriorly
near the apex and tufted with hairs, evidently an adaptation—
the result, combined with colour and shape, being a close imi-
ation of a common yellow species of Melipona bee.
30. Odontocera furcifera, Bates.
Odontocera furcifera, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 323.
R. Tapajos, Amazons.
In this species the elytra are of the same form as in the
ical Acyphoderes, 7. e. subulate and pointed at the apex.
31. Odontocera simplex, White.
Odontocera simplex, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 825.
R. Amazons.
32. Odontocera bisulcata, Bates.
Odontocera bisulcata, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 326.
R. Tapajos, Amazons.
[To be continued. |
VI.— Growth or Evolution of Structure in Seedlings.
By Joun C. Draper, M.D.*
HE continuous absorption of oxygen and formation of car-
onic acid is an essential condition of evolution of structure,
th in plants and in animals.
The above proposition, so far as it relates to animals, will
robably be admitted by all; the opposite opinion, however, is
* From the‘ American Journal of Science and Arts,’ vol. iv. November
872.
46 Dr. J. C. Draper on Peamiier
commonly held as regards plants. Yet we propose to show that
in these organisms, as in animals, growth, as applied to evolu-
tion of structure or organization of material provided, is inse-
parably connected with oxidation.
The discussion of the proposition in question necessarily
involves a preliminary review of the character of the gases ex-
haled from various plants. Commencing with the lower orga-_
nisms, as Fungi, the uniform testimony is that these plants at —
all times expire carbonic acid, while it is chiefly in the higher
plants, and especially in those which contain chlorophyl or
green colouring-matter, that carbonic acid is absorbed and oxy-
genexhaled. The inquiry, then, in reality narrows itself down
to the examination of the growth of chlorophyl-bearing plants.
Regarding these plants the statement is made and received
that they change their action according as they are examined
in the light or in the dark, exhaling oxygen under the first con-
dition, and carbonic acid under the second. Various explana-
tions of this change of action have been given, that generally
accepted accounting for it on the hypothesis of the absorption
of carbonic acid by the roots, and its exhalation by the leaves
when light is no longer present.
The change, on the contrary, appears to arise out of the
fact that two essentially different operations have been con-—
founded, viz. the actual growth or evolution of structures in the
plant, and the decomposition of carbonic acid by the leaves |
under the influence of the light, to provide the gum or other |
materials that are to be organized. These two factors are
separated by Prof. J. W. Draper in his discussion of the con-
ditions of growth in plants. We propose to show that, by |
adopting this proposition of two distinct operations in the higher |
plants, all the apparent discrepancies regarding the growth of
these plants are explained. |
The growth of seedlings in the dark offermg conditions in
which the act of growth or evolution of structure is accom-
plished without the collateral decomposition of carbonic acid,
I arranged two series of experiments in which growth under |
this condition might be studied and compared with a similar
growth in the light. That the experiments might continue
over a sufficient period of time to furnish reliable comparative |
results, I selected peas as the subject of trial, since these seeds
contain sufficient material to support the growth of seedlings’
for a couple of weeks.
To secure as far as possible uniformity of conditions between
the dark and light series, and also to facilitate the separation,
cleansing, and weighing of the roots, each pea was planted in a.
glass cylinder, 1 inch in diameter and 6 inches long. These
Evolution of Structure in Seedlings. 47
cylinders were loosely closed below by a cork, and filled to
within half an inch of the top with fine earth or vegetable
mould. They were then placed erect in a covered tin box or
tube-stand, in such a manner that the lower end dipped into
water contained in the box, while the whole of the cylinder
except the top was kept in the dark. Thus the first condition
for germination, viz. darkness, was secured; the second, warmth,
was supplied by the external temperature, which varied from
| 70° to 80° F.; while regularity and uniformity in the supply of
| moisture in both series was secured by having a box of cylin-
ders or tubes for each and keeping the level of the water the
| same in both. The supply of oxygen was also equal and
uniform, since the upper part of each tube presented a similar
| opening to the air.
Thus prepared, one box, containing five cylinders, was kept
mf in a dark closet, while a second, similar in all respects, was
.| placed in a window of the adjoining room, where it was ex-
_ posed to direct sunlight five or six hours every day. To each
| tube a light wooden rod thirty inches in length was attached ;
and on this the growth of the seedling was marked every
twelve hours. The hours selected were 7 A.M. and7 P.M. I
' thus obtained the night and day, or dark and light growth of
.| every seedling, as long as those in the dark grew. ‘The seeds
were planted on June Ist, and appeared above the ground on
| June 6th, when the measurements were commenced. In each
ile] Series one seed failed to germinate ; the record consequently is
| for four plants in each. ‘The history-of the evolution of
.) structures is as follows :—
_. Evolution of structure in the dark.—In Table I. the seeds are
designated as A, B, C, D; and each column shows the dates on
which leaves and lateral growths appeared. These constitute
| periods in the development of the plants, which are indicated
in} by the numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,6. The weight of each seed is
| given in milligrammes.
a TABLE [.—Seedlings grown in the dark.
nl A. B. C. D.
inl) Weight of geed.... 431. 436. 456. 500.
a Period 1...... 7thday. 7thday. 7thday. 7th day.
BY a ae Sth sa eOths.« 1) SED satawenstibels
ae, 3.3 .- 10th ,, 10th , lth , 10th ,,
ee (oth. 19th. | 15th ieart BLSERY
| 14th ,, 15th ,, 15th , 14th ,.
de. 6...... 17th. sth sth ah
A glance at the above shows the uniformity as regards
48 Dr. J. C. Draper on Growth or
time with which the structures were evolved in each plant.
It also indicates for each plant an equality in the number of |
periods of evolution, viz. 6, notwithstanding the difference in
the weights of the seeds, and suggests that the power of
evolution of structure in seedlings resides in the germ alone.
The character of the evolution in the six periods shows a
steady improvement or progression.
In the first, the growth consists of the formation close to the
stem of two partially developed pale yellow leaves.
The second period is similar to the first, except that the
leaves are a little larger.
The third presents a pair of small yellow leaves close to the
main stem, from between which a lateral stem or twig about
one inch long projects, and bears at its extremity a second pair
of imperfectly developed yellow leaves, from between which a
small tendril about a sixteenth of an inch long is given off.
The fourth resembles the third, the lateral twig being longer,
and the tendril three times as long as in the third.
The fifth is like the fourth, except that the tendril bifurcates.
The sixth is similar to the fifth, except that the tendril
trifurcates.
Stem, leaves, twigs, tendrils of various degrees of complexity,
all are evolved by the force preexisting in the germ without
the assistance of light.
Evolution of structure in the light.—
TABLE I].—Seedlings grown in the light.
E. 1 G. iat
Weight of seed.... 288. 426. 462. 544,
Period 1. cre Sp 6th day. .. 6th day.
Bertin ely 7th day. 7th ,, ith day. ~" Vii
Bam hte. Sth™";; 8th ,, Sth" oth;
i ae ae ae L2th.;, Sth ,, - 10th ,; 9) a0teee
30 Dees 15th %; llth ,, - 14th.) seine
3 Oe ey ASth: 45 ee 14th ,,
Table II. was obtained in the same manner as Table I., the
columns representing the days on which lateral growths and
leaves appeared. Though there is not the same uniformity as
in Table I., the periods are identical in both as regards the
visible character of the evolution. Nothing appears in the
second that did not preexist in the first ; and im the case of the
seeds E and G the evolution is even deficient as regards the
first and the sixth periods.
While the general character of the evolution in both series
is similar, certain minor differences exist. In Table II. the
Wl
Evolution of Structure in Seedlings. 49
leaves and tendrils are many times larger than in Table L.,
and they with the whole plant are of a bright green colour,
instead of the sickly pale yellow of Table I. : but the light has
not developed any new structure; it has only perfected those
which preexisted, and converted other substances into chloro-
phyl, which is not an organized body.
Not only did the plants in the two series present similarities
in evolution of structure, but the average weight of dry plant
in each was very nearly the same; for
mer. mgr.
455 of seeds in the dark produced 184 of dry plant,
while 455 ie Rehiievegy f02la 4 '
A comparison of the parts below the ground with those
above (both being dried at 212° F.) shows that the proportion
of root to total weight of plant was also nearly identical,
being
| ° 25 of root for 100 of plant in the dark, and
23 ~ 100 Bs light.
The close similarity in the evolution of visible structure in
the light and in the dark, the small difference in the total
weights of the plants grown in the same time in both series,
and the close approximation in the proportional weight of root
to plant, all justify the conclusion that the growth in darkness
and in light closely resemble each other, and that it is proper
to reason, as regards the nature of the action, from the first to
the second.
Another interesting fact which lends support to the opinion
that the process of growth in seedlings developed in the dark
is very similar to that occurring in those grown in the light, is
the character of the excrements thrown out by the roots. It is
well known that many plants so poison the soil that the same
plants cannot be made to grow therein until the poisonous
excretions from the roots of the first crop have been destroyed
by oxidation. In the case of peas this poisoning of the soil
takes place ina very marked manner ; and I have found that in
the pots in which peas have been grown in the dark, the soil is
so poisoned by the excrements from the roots that a second
crop fails to sprout. Does it not follow that since, in the two
series with which I experimented, the excrements from the
roots possessed the same poisoning action, the processes in the
plants from which these excrements arose must have been
similar ?
There remains an important argument, concerning which
nothing has thus far been said. It is to be derived from the
“) consideration of the rate of growth in the light series during
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi.
50 Dr. J.C. Draper on Growth or
various periods of the day of twenty-four hours. If the evolu-
tion of structure in a plant in daylight is the result of the
action of light, that evolution should occur entirely, or almost
entirely, during the day. If, on the contrary, it is independent —
of the light, it should go on at a uniform rate as in plants in
the dark.
For the elucidation of this portion of the subject, I present
the following tables; the first of which shows the growth by
night, 7 P.M. to 7 A.M., of the seedlings in the dark series, com-
pared with their growth by day, 7 A.M. to 7 P.M. The mea-
surements were taken from the sixth to the twentieth of the
month, the day on which growth ceased in the dark series.
TABLE III.—Seedlings grown in the dark.
Night growth. Day growth.
Nios ae 72. 122 inches. 14 inches,
Gio -teeke 13t" 33 TS nas
35 5S fate US Ss 11; Ae
pas. Gee 125 Te oy
5 3
Average.. 123 ,, Average.. 123 ,,
The total day growth and night growth under these cireum-
stances are nearly equal, though there is a shght excess in
favour of the night, amounting, as the table shows, to 2 of an
inch in 12 inches.
In Table IV. the growth of the light series is given in the
same manner, by day and by night, for the same time, viz. to
June 20th. The thermometric and hygrometric conditions in
both series were very similar, as indicated by the dry- and
wet-bulb thermometers suspended in the vicinity of each set
of tubes.
TABLE [V.—Seedlings grown in the light.
Night growth. Day growth.
NONE eee 37 inches. 4 inches.
Sp Ona ate see 8 ss iPad ce
PAA rier oF "5, Ap
Pe GRU s OAS tas
Averaper. G4) 91/55 Average. . a
In the average, and throughout the table, with a single ex-
ception, not only is the uniformity in the rate of growth during
the day and night shown, but the slight excess of night growth
found in the series kept in the dark is likewise copied. We
must therefore accept the conclusion, that the act of growth or
Evolution of Structure in Seedlings. 51
evolution of structure is independent of light, and that the
manner of growth during the day is similar to that at night.
It will be noticed that the total average height attained in
the light is only about half that in the dark series. ‘The ex-
planation of this we have already seen in the fact that.in the
former the leaves and tendrils were much larger than in the
latter, while the dry weights were nearly the same. The
material of the seed in the light series was consumed in ex-
tending these surfaces, while in the dark series it was spent in
lengthening the stem.
Having established the continuous character of growth in
seedlings, and the similarity of rate and nature of the process
by night and by day, and admitting that night plants throw
off carbonic acid, it is not improbable that this carbonic acid
arises, not from mechanical absorption by the roots and vapori-
zation by the leaves, but as a direct result or concomitant of
the act or process of evolution of structure.
To put the matter in the clearest form, let us first under-
stand what growth is. It appears in all cases to consist in the
evolution or production of cells from those already existing.
According as the circumstances under which the cells are pro-
duced vary, so does the tissue ultimately produced vary ; cells
formed in woody fibre become wood; cells formed in muscle
in their turn form muscles ; but the starting-point of the process
in every instance is the formation of new cells.
If, now, we examine the evolution of cells under the simplest
conditions, as, for example, in the fermentation that attends the
manufacture of alcohol, we find that with the evolution of the
Torula-cells carbonic acid is produced. The two results are
intimately connected ; and it is proper to suppose that since the
carbonic acid has arisen along with the new cells, the latter
operation must in some way involve a process of oxidation.
Accepting the hypothesis that oxidation is attendant on these
processes of cell-growth under the simplest conditions, we pass
to the examination of what occurs in the lower forms of veget-
able organisms found in the air.
The fungi, and, indeed, all plants that are not green, with a
few exceptions, exhale carbonic acid and never exhale oxygen.
In this case, in which cell-production often occurs with such
marvellous rapidity, the carbonic acid must have arisen as a
consequent of the cell-growth. It is improbable that it has
been absorbed by roots and exhaled from the structures, either
in these plants or in those produced during fermentation. In
the latter there never are any roots; and in the former, even
where roots are present, they bear a small proportion to the
whole plant. The quantity of moisture exhaled by such
52 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History.
growths is also insignificant, and out of proportion to the car-
bonic acid evolved. We must therefore in this case decline
to accept the root-absorption hypothesis, and admit that the
carbonic acid has arisen as a result of the cell-growth in the
lant.
: Passing to the chlorophyl-bearing plants, we find that in the
Phanerogamia it is only the green parts that at any time exhale
oxygen, and then only under the influence of sunshine. The
other parts of the plant above the ground that are not green,
viz. the stem, twigs, flowers, &c., are at all times, day and
night, exhaling carbonic acid. The whole history of the plant,
from the time the seed is planted till its death, is a continuous
story of oxidation, except when sunlight is falling on the leaves.
The seed is put into the ground; and during germination oxygen
is absorbed and carbonic acid exhaled. If the seedling is kept
in the dark, oxygen is never exhaled, only carbonic acid, and
the plant not only grows, but all visible structures, except
flowers, are formed in a rudimentary condition. In the light,
the growth during the night time is attended by the evolution
of carbonic acid, while during the daytime the bark of the stem
and branches is throwing off carbonic acid. When flowers
and seeds form, the evolution of carbonic acid attending this
highest act of which the plant is capable is often greater than
that produced at any time in many animals.
Every thing in the history of plants therefore tends to show
that the evolution of their structures is inseparably attended
by the formation of carbonic acid; and it seems impossible,
when we consider the evolution alone, to arrive at any other
opinion than that already expressed—that all living things,
whether plant or animal, absorb oxygen and evolve carbonic
acid, or some other oxidized substance, as an essential condition
of the evolution of their structures.
College of the City of New York,
Sept. 12th, 1872.
VII.—Sequoia and its History. By Professor ASA Gray,
President of the American Association for the Advancement
of Science*.
THE session being now happily inaugurated, your presiding
officer of the last year has only one duty to perform before he
surrenders his chair to his successor. If allowed to borrow a
simile from the language of my own profession, I might liken
rok address delivered at the meeting held at Dubuque, Iowa, August
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History. 53
the President of this association to a biennial plant. He
flourishes for the year in which he comes into existence, and
performs his appropriate functions as presiding officer; when
the second year comes round, he is expected to blossom out
in an address and disappear. ach president, as he retires, is
naturally expected to contribute something from his own in-
vestigations or his own line of study, usually to discuss
some particular scientific topic.
Now, although I have cultivated the field of North-American
botany with some assiduity for more than forty years, have
reviewed our vegetable hosts, and assigned to no small number
of them their names and their place in the ranks, yet, so far as
our own wide country is concerned, I have been to a great
extent a closet botanist. Until this summer I had not seen
the Mississippi, nor set foot upon a prairie.
To gratify a natural interest, and to gain some title for ad-
dressing a body of practical naturalists and explorers, I have
made a pilgrimage across the continent. I have sought and
viewed in their native haunts many a plant and flower which
for me had long bloomed unseen, or only in the hortus siccus.
I have been able to see for myself what species and what forms
constitute the main features of the vegetation of each succes-
sive region, and record (as the vegetation unerringly does) the
permanent characteristics of its climate.
Passing on from the eastern district, marked by its equably
distributed rainfall, and therefore naturally forest-clad, | have
seen the trees diminish in number, give place to wide prairies,
restrict their growth to the borders of streams, and then dis-
appear from the boundless drier plains, have seen grassy
plains change into a brown and sere desert—desert in the
common sense, but hardly anywhere botanically so,—have seen
a fair growth of coniferous trees adorning the more favoured
slopes of a mountain-range high enough to compel summer
showers—have traversed that broad and bare elevated region
shut off on both sides by high mountains from the moisture
supplied by either ocean, and longitudinally intersected by
sierras which seemingly remain as naked as they were born—
and have reached at length the westward slopes of the high
mountain-barrier which, refreshed by the Pacific, bears the
noble forests of the Sierra Nevada and the coast-range, and
among them trees which are the wonder of the world. As I
stood in their shade in the groves of Mariposa and Calaveras,
and again under the canopy of the commoner redwood, raised
on columns of such majestic height and ample girth, it occurred
to me that I could not do better than to share with you, upon
this occasion, some of the thoughts which possessed my mind.
54 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and tts History.
In their development they may, perhaps, lead us up to ques-
tions of considerable scientific interest.
I shall not detain you with any remarks (which would now
be trite) upon the size or longevity of these far-famed Sequoia
trees, or of the sugar-pines, incense-cedar, and firs associated
with them, of which even the prodigious bulk of the dominating
Sequoia does not sensibly diminish the grandeur. Although
no account and no photographic representation of either species
of the far-famed Sequoia trees give any adequate impression
of their singular majesty, still less of their beauty, yet my
interest in them did not culminate merely or mainly in con-
siderations of their size and age. Other trees in other parts of
the world may claim to be older ; certain Australian gum-trees
(Hucalypti) are said to be taller. Some, we are told, rise so
high that they might even cast a flicker of shadow upon the
summit of the pyramid of Cheops; yet the oldest of them
doubtless grew from seed which was shed long after the names
of the pyramid-builders had been forgotten. So far as we can
judge from the actual counting of the layers of several trees,
no Sequoia now alive can sensibly antedate the Christian era.
Nor was I much impressed with an attraction of man’s
adding. ‘That the more remarkable of these trees should bear
distinguishing appellations seems proper enough; but the
tablets of personal names which are affixed to many of them
in the most visited groves (as if the memory of more or less
notable people of our day might be made more enduring by
the juxtaposition) do suggest some incongruity. When we
consider that a hand’s breadth at the circumference of any one
of the venerable trunks so placarded has recorded in annual
lines the lifetime of the individual thus associated with it, one
may question whether the next hand’s breadth may not
measure the fame of some of the names thus ticketed for ad-
ventitious immortality. Whether it be the man or the tree
that is honoured in the connexion, probably either would live
as long, in fact and in memory, without it.
One notable thing about these Sequoia trees is their ¢solation.
Most of the trees associated with them are of peculiar species ;
and some of them are nearly as local. Yet every pine, fir,
and cypress in California is in some sort familiar, because it has
near relatives in other parts of the world; but the redwoods
have none. ‘The redwood (including in that name the two
species of “big trees”) belongs to the general cypress family,
but is su¢ generis. Thus isolated systematically, and extremely
isolated geographically, and so wonderful in size and port,
they, more than other trees, suggest questions.
Were they created thus local and lonely, denizens of Cali-
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and tts History. 5d
fornia only—one in limited numbers in a few choice spots on
the Sierra Nevada, the other along the coast-range from the
Bay of Monterey to the frontiers of Oregon? Are they veri-
table Melchizedecs, without pedigree or early relationship, and
possibly fated to be without descent ?
Or are they now coming upon the stage (or rather were
they coming but for man’s interference) to play a part in the
future ?
Or are they remnants, sole and scanty survivors of a race
that has played a grander part in the past, but is now verging
to extinction? Have they had a career? and can that career
be ascertained or surmised, so that we may at least guess
whence they came, and how and when?
Time was, and not long ago, when such questions as these
were regarded as useless and vain, when students of natural
history, unmindful of what the name denotes, were content
with a knowledge of things as they now are, but gave little
heed as to how they came to be so. Now such questions are
held to be legitimate, and perhaps not wholly unanswerable. It
cannot now be said that these trees inhabit their present re-
stricted areas simply because they are there placed in the
climate and soil of all the world most congenial to them.
These must indeed be congenial or they would not survive.
But when we see how Australian Hucalyptus trees thrive upon
the Californian coast, and how these very redwoods flourish
upon another continent—how the so-called wild oat (Avena
sterilis) of the Old World has taken full possession of California
—how that cattle and horses, introduced by the Spaniard,
have spread as widely and made themselves as much at home
on the plains of La Plata as on those of Tartary, and that the
cardoon-thistle seeds, and others they brought with them, have
multiplied there into numbers probably much exceeding those
extant in their native lands; indeed, when we contemplate our
own race and our own particular stock taking such recent but
dominating possession of this New World—when we consider
how the indigenous flora of islands generally succumbs to the
foreigners which come in the train of man, and that most weeds
(7. e. the prepotent plants in open soil) of all temperate climates
are not ‘to the manor born,” but are self-invited intruders,
—we must needs abandon the notion of any primordial and
absolute adaptation of plants and animals to their habitats,
which may stand in lieu of explanation and so preclude our
inquiring any further. 'The harmony of Nature and its ad-
mirable perfection need not be regarded as inflexible and
changeless. Nor need Nature be likened to a statue or a cast
in rigid bronze, but rather to an organism with play and
56 Prof, Asa Gray on Sequoia and its {History.
adaptability of parts, and life and even soul informing the
whole. Under the former view Nature would be “ the faultless
monster which the world ne’er saw,” but inscrutable as the
Sphinx, whom it were vain, or worse, to question of the whence
and whither. Under the other, the perfection of nature, if
relative, is multifarious and ever renewed, and much that is
enigmatical now may find explanation in some record of the
ast.
P That the two species of redwood we are contemplating ori-
ginated as they are and where they are, and for the part they
are now playing, is, to say the least, not a scientific supposition,
nor in any sense a probable one. Nor is it more likely that
they are destined to play a conspicuous part in the future, or
that they would have done so, even if the Indian’s fires and
white man’s axe had spared them. The redwood of the coast
(Sequoia sempervirens) had the stronger hold upon existence,
forming as it did large forests throughout a narrow belt about
300 miles in length, and being so tenacious of life that every
large stump sprouts into a copse. But it does not pass the
Bay of Monterey, nor cross the line of Oregon, although so
grandly developed not far below it. The more remarkable
Sequova gigantea of the Sierra exists in numbers so limited that
the separate groves may be reckoned upon the fingers, and the
trees of most of them have been counted, except near their
southern limit, where they are said to be more copious. A
species limited in individuals holds its existence by a precarious
tenure ; and this has a foothold only in a few sheltered spots,
of a happy mean in temperature and locally favoured with
moisture in summer. Even there, for some reason or other,
the pines with which they are associated (Pinus Lambertiana
and P. ponderosa), the firs (Abies grandis and A. amabilis),
and even the incense-cedar (Libocedrus decurrens) possess a
great advantage, and, though they strive in vain to emulate
their size, wholly overpower the Sequoias in numbers. ‘ T'o
him that hath shall be given ;” the force of numbers eventually
wins. Atleast, in the commonly visited groves Sequoia gi-
gantea is invested in its last stronghold, can neither advance
into more exposed positions above, nor fall back into drier and
barer ground below, nor hold its own in the long run where it is,
under present conditions; and a little further drying of the
chmate, which must once have been much moister than now,
would precipitate its doom. Whatever theindividual longevity,
certain if not speedy is the decline of a race in which a high
death-rate afflicts the young. Seedlings of the big trees occur
not rarely, indeed, but in meagre proportion to those of asso-
ciated trees ; and small indeed is the chance that any of these
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History. 57
will attain to “the days of the years of their fathers.” “Few
and evil”’ are the days of all the forest likely to be, while man,
both barbarian and civilized, torments them with fires, fatal at
once to seedlings and at length to the aged also. ‘The forests
of California, proud as the State may be of them, are already
too scanty and insufficient for her uses ; two lines, such as may
be drawn with one sweep of a small brush over the map, would
cover them all. The coast redwood, the most important tree
in California, although a million times more numerous than its
relative of the Sierra, is too good to live long. Such is its value
for lumber and its accessibility that, judging the future by the
past, it is not likely in its primeval growth to outlast its rarer
fellow species. . ‘
Happily man preserves and desseminates as well as destroys.
The species will probably be indefinitely preserved to science,
and for ornamental and other uses, in its own and other lands ;
and the more remarkable individuals of the present day are
likely to be sedulously cared for, all the more so as they become
scarce,
Our third question remains to be answered: Have these
famous Sequoias played in former times and upon a larger
stage a more imposing part, of which the present is but the
epilogue? We cannot gaze high up the huge and venerable
trunks, which one crosses the continent to behold, without
wishing that these patriarchs of the grove were able, like the
long-lived antediluvians of scripture, to hand down to us
through a few generations the traditions of centuries, and so
tell us somewhat of the history of theirrace. Fifteen hundred
annual layers have been counted, or satisfactorily made out,
upon one or two fallen trunks; it is probable that close to the
heart of some of the living trees may be found the circle that
records the year of our Saviour’s nativity. A few generations
of such trees might carry the history a long way back; but
the ground they stand upon, and the marks of very recent
geological change and vicissitude in the region around, testify
that not very many such generations can have flourished just
there, at least in an unbroken series. When their site was
covered by glaciers these Sequoias must have occupied other
stations, if, as there is reason to believe, they then existed in
the land.
I have said that the redwoods have no near relatives in the
country of their abode, and none of their genus anywhere else,
Perhaps something may be learned of their genealogy by in-
quiring of such relatives as they have. ‘There are only two
of any particular nearness of kin; and they are far away. One
is the bald cypress, our southern cypress ( Zaxodium), inhabiting
58 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and tts History.
the swamps of the Atlantic coast from Maryland to Texas,
thence extending into Mexico: it is well known as one of the
largest trees of our Atlantic forest-district ; and although it
never (except perhaps in Mexico, and in rare instances) attains
the portliness of its western relatives, yet it may equal them
in longevity. The other relative is Glyptostrobus, a sort of
modified Taxodium, being about as much like our bald cypress
as one species of redwood is like the other.
Now species of the same type, especially when few and the
type peculiar, are in a general way associated geographically,
2.e. inhabit the same country or (in a large sense) the same
region. Where it is not so, where near relatives are separated,
there is usually something to be explained. Here is an instance.
These four trees, sole representatives of their tribe, dwell almost
in three separate quarters of the world—the two redwoods in
California, the bald cypress in Atlantic North America, its near
relative, Glyptostrobus, in China.
It was not always so. In the tertiary period, the geological
botanists assure us, our own very Taxodium, or bald cypress,
and a Glyptostrobus exceedingly like the present Chinese tree,
and more than one Sequota coexisted in a fourth quarter of the
globe, viz.in Europe! This brings up the question: Is it
possible to bridge over these four wide intervals of space and
the much vaster interval of time, so as to bring these extra-
ordinarily separated relatives into connexion? ‘The evidence
which may be brought to bear upon this question is various
and widely scattered. I bespeak your patience while I en-
deavour to bring together in an abstract the most important
points of it.
Some interesting facts may come out by comparing generally
the botany of the three remote regions, each of which is the
sole home of one of these three genera—i. e. Sequota in Cali-
fornia, Taxodium in the Atlantic United States, and G'lypto-
strobus in China, which compose the whole of the peculiar
tribe under consideration.
Note then, first, that there is another set of three or four
peculiar trees, in this case of the yew family, which has just
the same peculiar distribution, and which therefore may have
the same explanation, whatever that explanation be. The
genus Torreya, which commemorates our botanical Nestor and
a former president of this association (Dr. Torrey), was founded
upon a tree rather lately discovered (that is, about thirty-five
years ago) in northern Florida. It is a noble yew-like tree
and very local, being known only for a few miles along the
shores of a single river. It seems as if it had somehow been
crowded down out of the Alleghanies into its present limited
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History. 59
southern quarters; for in cultivation it evinces a northern
hardiness. Now another species of Zorreya is a characteristic
tree of Japan ; and the same, or one very like it indeed, inhabits
the Himalayas—belongs therefore to the Eastern Asiatic
temperate region, of which China is a part, and Japan, as we
shall see, the portion most interesting to us. ‘There is only
one more species of Torreya; and that is a companion of the
redwoods in California; it is the tree locally known under the
name of the California nutmeg. In this case the three are near
brethren, species of the same genus, known nowhere else than
in these three habitats.
Moreover the Yorreya of Florida has growing with it a
yew tree, and the trees of that grove are the only yew trees of
HKastern America; for the yew of our northern woods is a de-
cumbent shrub. The only other yew trees in America grow
with the redwoods and the other Torreya in California, and
more plentifully further north, in Oregon. A yew tree equally
accompanies the Torreya of Japan and the Himalayas; and
this is apparently the same as the common yew of Europe.
So we have three groups of trees of the great coniferous order
which agree in this peculiar geographical distribution :—the red-
woods and their relatives, which differ widely enough to be
termed a different genus in each region; the Torreyas, more
nearly akin, merely a different species in each region ; the yews,
perhaps all of the same species, perhaps not quite that (for
opinions differ and can hardly be brought to any decisive test).
The yews of the Old World, from Japan to Western Europe,
are considered the same; the very local one in Florida is
slightly different; that of California and Oregon differs a very
little more ; but all of them are within the limits of variation
of many a species. However that may be, it appears to me
that these several instances all raise the same question, only
with a different degree of emphasis, and, if to be explained at
all, will have the same kind of explanation. But the value of
_ the explanation will be in proportion to the number of facts it
_ will explain.
Continuing the comparison between the three regions with
which we are concerned, we note that each has its own species
of pines, firs, larches, &c., and of a few deciduous-leaved trees,
such as oaks and maples; all of which have no peculiar sig-
nificance for the present purpose, because they are of genera
which are common all round the northern hemisphere. Leaving
these out of view, the noticeable point is that the vegetation of
California is most strikingly unlike that of the Atlantic United
States. They possess some plants, and some peculiarly Ame-
rican plants, in common—enough to show, as I imagine, that
60 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and tts History.
the difficulty was not in the getting from the one district to the
other, or into both from a common source, but in abiding there.
The primordially unbroken forest of Atlantic North America,
nourished by rainfall distributed throughout the year, is widely
separated from the western region of sparse and discontinuous
tree-belts of the same latitude on the western side of the con-
tinent, where summer rain is wanting or nearly so, by immense
treeless plains and plateaux of more or less aridity, traversed
by longitudinal mountain-ranges of a similar character. Their
nearest approach is at the north, in the latitude of Lake
Superior, where, on a more rainy line, trees of the Atlantic
forest and that of Oregon may be said to interchange. The
change of species and of the aspect of vegetation in crossing,
say on the forty-seventh parallel, is slight in comparison with
that on the thirty-seventh or near it. Confining our attention
to the lower latitude, and under the exceptions already specially
noted, we may say that almost every characteristic form in the
vegetation of the Atlantic States is wanting in California, and
the characteristic plants and trees of California are wanting
here.
California has no Magnolia, nor tulip-trees, nor star-anise
tree, no so-called papaw (As¢mina), no barberry of the common
single-leaved sort, no Podophyllum or other of the peculiar
associated genera, no Ne/wmbo nor white water-lily, no prickly
ash nor sumach, no loblolly-bay nor Stwartia, no basswood
or linden-trees, neither locust, honey-locust, coftee-trees
(Gymnocladus), nor yellow-wood (Cladrastis), nothing answer-
ing to Hydrangea or witch-hazel, to gum-trees (Nyssa and
Liquidambar), Viburnum or Diervilla; it has few asters and
golden-rods, no lobelias, no huckle-berries, and hardly any
blue-berries—no Epigea, charm of our earliest eastern spring,
tempering an icy April wind with a delicious wild fragrance—
no Kalmia, nor Clethra, nor holly, nor persimmon—no catalpa
tree, nor trumpet-creeper (Zecoma)—nothing answering to sas-
safras, or to benzoin tree, or to hickory—neither mulberry nor
elm—no beech, true chestnut, hornbeam, nor ironwood, nor a
proper birch tree; and the enumeration might be continued
very much further by naming herbaceous plants and others
familiar only to botanists.
In their place California is filled with plants of other types,
trees, shrubs, and herbs, of which I will only remark that they
are, with one or two exceptions, as different from the plants of
the eastern Asiatic region with which we are concerned (Japan,
China, and Mandchuria) as they are from those of Atlantic
North America. Their near relatives, when they have any in
other lands, are mostly southward, on the Mexican plateau, or
elas "5
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and tts History. 61
many as far south as Chili. The same may be said of the
plants of the intervening great plains, except that northward
and in the subsaline vegetation there are some close alliances
with the flora of the steppes of Siberia. And along the crests
of high mountain-ranges the arctic alpine flora has sent south-
ward more or less numerous representatives through the whole
length of the country.
If we now compare, as to their flora generally, the Atlantic
United States with Japan, Mandchuria, and Northern China,
z. e. eastern North America with eastern North Asia (half the
earth’s circumference apart), we find an astonishing similarity.
The larger part of the genera of our own region which I have
enumerated as wanting in California are present in Japan or
Mandchuria, along with many other peculiar plants, divided
between the two. There are plants enough of the one region
which have no representatives in the other. There are types
which appear to have reached the Atlantic States from the
south ; and there is a larger infusion of subtropical Asiatic types
into temperate China and Japan: among these there is no re-
lationship between the two countries to speak of. There are
also, as I have already said, no small number of genera and
some species which, being common all round or partially round
the northern temperate zone, have no special significance
because of their occurrence in these two antipodal floras, al-
though they have testimony to bear upon the general question
of geographical distribution. The point to be remarked is that
many or even most of the genera and species which are peculiar
to North America as compared with Europe, and largely pecu-
liar to Atlantic North America as compared with the Califor-
nian region, are also represented in Japan and Mandchuria,
either by identical or by closely similar forms! The same
rule holds on a more northward line, although not so strikingly.
If we compare the plants, say of New England and Pennsyl-
vania (lat. 45°-47°), with those of Oregon, and then with those
of North-eastern Asia, we shall find many of our own curiously
repeated in the latter, while only a small number of them can
be traced along the route even so far as the western slope of the
Rocky Mountains. And these repetitions of Kastern American
types in Japan and neighbouring districts are in all degrees of
likeness. Sometimes the one is undistinguishable from the
other; sometimes there is a difference of aspect, but hardly of a
tangible character ; sometimes the two would be termed marked
varieties if they grew naturally in the same forest or in the
same region; sometimes they are what the botanist calls re-
presentative species, the one answering closely to the other,
but with some differences regarded as specific ; sometimes the
62 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History.
two are merely of the same genus, or not quite that, but of a
single or very few species in each country,—when the point
which interests us is that this peculiar limited type should
occur in two antipodal places, and nowhere else.
It would be tedious and, except to botanists, abstruse to
_ enumerate instances ; yet the whole strength of the case depends
upon the number of such instances. I propose, therefore, if
the Association does me the honour to print this discourse, to
append in a note a list of the more remarkable ones. But I
would here mention two or three cases as specimens.
Our Rhus toxicodendron, or poison-ivy, 18 very exactly re-
peated in Japan, but is found in no other part of the world,
although a species much like it abounds in California. Our
other poisonous Lhus (2. venenata), commonly called poison dog-
wood, is in no way represented in Western America, but has
so close an analogue in Japan that the two were taken for
the same by Thunberg and Linneus, who called them &.
vernix.
Our northern fox-grape (Vitis labrusca) is wholly confined
to the Atlantic States, except that it reappears in Japan and
that region.
The original Wistaria is a woody leguminous climber with
showy blossoms, native to the Middle Atlantic States ; the
other species, which we so much prize in cultivation, W. s7-
nensis, 1s from China, as its name denotes, or perhaps only from
Japan, where it is certainly indigenous.
Our yellow wood (Cladrastis) inhabits a very limited dis-
trict on the western slope of the Alleghanies. Its only and
very near relative (Maackia) is in Mandchuria.
The Hydrangeas have some species in our Alleghany region.
All the rest belong to the Chino-Japanese region and its con-
tinuation westward. The same may be said of Philadelphus,
except that there are one or two mostly very similar in Cali-
fornia and Oregon.
Our blue cohosh (Caulophyllum) is confined to the woods of
the Atlantic States, but has lately been discovered in Japan.
A peculiar relative of it, Diphylleta, confined to the higher
Alleghanies, is also repeated in Japan, with a slight difference,
so that it may barely be distinguished as another species.
Another relative is our twin leaf, Jeffersonia, of the Alleghany
region alone. A second species has lately turned up in Mand-
churia. A relative of this is Podophyllum, our mandrake, a
common inhabitant of the Atlantic United States, but found
nowhere else. ‘There is one other species of it; and that is in
the Himalayas. Here are four most peculiar genera of one
family, each of a single species in the Atlantic United States,
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History. 63
which are duplicated on the other side of the world, either in
identical or almost identical species, or in an analogous species,
while nothing else of the kind is known in any other part of
the world.
I ought not to omit ginseng, the root so prized by the Chi-
nese, which they obtained from their northern provinces and
Mandchuria, and which is now known to inhabit Corea and
Northern Japan. The Jesuit Fathers identified the plant
in Canada and the Atlantic States, brought over the Chinese
name by which we know it, and established the trade in it,
which was for many years most profitable. The exporta-
tion of ginseng to China has probably not yet entirely ceased.
Whether the Asiatic and the Atlantic American ginsengs are
exactly of the same species or not is somewhat uncertain ; but
they are hardly if at all distinguishable.
There is a shrub, Hiliott’a, which is so rare and local that
it is known only at two stations on the Savannah river in
Georgia. It is of peculiar structure, and was without near
relative until one was lately discovered in Japan (in Tripeta-
leia) so like it as hardly to be distinguishable except by having
the parts of the blossom in threes instead of fours, a difference
which is not uncommon in the same genus or even in the
same species.
Suppose Li/iottia had happened to be collected only once, a
good while ago, and all knowledge of the limited and obscure
locality was lost; and meanwhile the Japanese form came to
be known. Such a case would be parallel with an actual one.
A specimen of a peculiar plant, Shortia galacifolia, was de-
tected in the herbarium of the elder Michaux, who collected it
(as his autograph ticket shows) somewhere in the high Alle-
ghany mountains more than eighty years ago. No one has
seen the living plant since, or knows where to find it, if haply
it still flourishes in some secluded spot. At’ length it is found
in Japan; and I had the satisfaction of making the identifica-
tion*. One other relative is also known in Japan; and an-
other, still unpublished, has just been detected in Thibet.
Whether the Japanese and the Alleghanian plants are ex-
actly the same or not, it needs complete specimens of the two
to settle. So far as we know they are just alike. And even
if some difference were discerned between them, it would not
appreciably alter the question as to how such a result came to
pass. Each and every one of the analogous cases I have
been detailing (and very many more could be mentioned)
raises the same question and would be satisfied with the same
answer.
* Amer, Journ. Science, 1867, p. 402; Proc. Amer. Acad. viii. p. 244.
64 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and tts History.
These singular relations attracted my curiosity early in the
course of my botanical studies, when comparatively few of
them were known, and my serious attention in later years,
when I had numerous and new Japanese plants to study in
the collections made by Messrs. Williams and Morrow dur-
ing Commodore Perry’s visit in 1853, and especially by Mr.
Charles Wright in Commodore Rodgers’s expedition in 1855,
I then discussed this subject somewhat fully, and tabulated
the facts within my reach*,
This was before Heer had developed the rich fossil botany
of the arctic zone, before the immense antiquity of existing
species of plants was recognized, and before the publication
of Darwin’s now famous volume on the Origin of Species
had introduced and familiarized the scientific world with those
now current ideas respecting the history and vicissitudes of
species, with which I attempted to deal in a tentative and
feeble way.
My speculation was based upon the former glaciation of the
northern temperate zone, and the inference of a warmer period
preceding (and perhaps following). I considered that our own
present vegetation, or its proximate ancestry, must have occu-
pied the arctic and subarctic regions in pliocene times, and
that it had been gradually pushed southward as the tempera-
ture lowered and the glaciation advanced even beyond its
present habitation—that plants of the same stock and kindred,
probably ranging round the arctic zone as the present arctic
species do, made their forced migration southward upon widely
different longitudes, and receded more or less as the climate
grew warmer—that the general difference of climate which
marks the eastern and the western sides of the continents
(the one extreme, the other mean) was doubtless even then
established, so that the same species and the same sorts of
species would be-likely to secure and retain foothold in the
similar climates of Japan and the Atlantic United States, but
not in intermediate regions of different distribution of heat and
moisture, so that different species of the same genus, as in
Torreya, or different genera of the same group, as Redwood,
Taxodium, and Glyptostrobus, or different associations of forest
trees, might establish themselves each in the region best suited
to its particular requirements, while they would fail to do
so in any other. These views implied that the sources of our
actual vegetation, and the explanation of these peculiarities,
were to be sought in and presupposed an ancestry in pliocene
or still earlier times occupying the high northern regions.
And it was thought that the occurrence of peculiarly North-
* Mem, Amer. Acad. vol. vi.
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History. 65
American genera in Europe in the tertiary period (such as
Taxodium, Carya, Liquidambar, Sassafras, Negundo, &c.)
might be best explained on the assumption of early inter-
change and diffusion through North Asia, rather than by that
of the fabled Atlantis.
The hypothesis supposed a gradual modification of species
in different directions under altering conditions, at least to the
extent of producing varieties, subspecies, and representative
species, as they may be variously regarded—likewise the sin-
gle and local origination of each type, which is now almost
universally taken for granted.
The remarkable facts in regard to the Hastern-American
and Asiatic floras, which these speculations were to explain,
have since increased in number—more especially through the
admirable collections of Dr. Maximowicz in Japan and adja-
cent countries, and the critical comparisons he has made and
is still engaged upon.
I am bound to state that in a recent general work* by a dis-
tinguished botanist, Professor Grisebach, of Géttingen, these
facts have been emptied of all special significance, and the
relations between the Japanese and the Atlantic United States
floras declared to be no more intimate than might be expected
from the situation, climate, and present opportunity of inter-
change. his extraordinary conclusion is reached by regard-
ing as distinct species all the plants common to both countries
between which any differences have been discerned, although
such differences would probably count for little if the two in-
habited the same country, thus transferring many of my list
of identical to that of representative species, and then by simply
, } eliminating from consideration the whole array of representa-
tive species, ¢.e. all cases in which the Japanese and the
American plant are not exactly alike,—as if, by pronouncing
the cabalistic word species, the question were settled, or rather
the greater part of it remanded out of the domain of science—
as if, while complete identity of forms implies community of
region, any thing short of it carries no presumption of the
kind—so leaving all these singular duplicates to be wondered
at, indeed, but wholly beyond the reach of inquiry.
_ Now the only known cause of such likeness is inheritance ;
, and as all transmission of likeness is with some difference in
individuals, and as changed conditions have resulted, as is well
known, in very considerable differences, it seems to me that if
the high antiquity of our actual vegetation could be rendered
| probable, not to say certain, and the former habitation of any
| of our species, or of very near relatives of them in high northern
| * Die Vegetation der Erde nach ihrer klimatischen Anordnung, 1871.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. x1. a
66 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and tts History.
regions could be ascertained, my whole case would be made
out. The needful facts, of which I was ignorant when my
essay was published, have now been for some years made
known, thanks mainly to the researches of Heer upon ample
collections of arctic fossil plants. These are confirmed and
extended through new investigations by Heer and Lesque-
reux, the results of which have been indicated to me by the
latter.
The Taxodium which everywhere abounds in the miocene
formations in Europe, has been specitically identified, first
by Goeppert, then by Heer, with our common cypress of the
Southern States. It has been found fossil in Spitzbergen,
Greenland, and Alaska, in the latter country along with the
remains of another form, distinguishable, but very like the
common species ; and this has been identified by Lesquereux
in the miocene of the Rocky Mountains. So there is one
species of tree which has come down essentially unchanged
from the tertiary period, which for a long while inhabited both
Europe and North America, and also at some part Sf the
period the region which geographically connects the two (once
doubtless much more closely than now), but has survived only
in the Atlantic United States and Mexico.
The same Sequoia which abounds in the same miocene for-
mations in Northern Europe has been abundantly found in
those of Iceland, Spitzbergen, Greenland, Mackenzie river, and
Alaska. It is named S. Langsdorgiz, but is pronounced to be
very much lke S. sempervirens, our living redwood of the
Californian coast, and to be the ancient representative of it.
Fossil specimens of a similar, if not the same, species have
been recently detected in the Rocky Mountains by Hayden,
and determined by our eminent paleontological botanist, Les-
quereux ; and he assures. me that he has the common redwood
itself from Oregon, in a deposit of tertiary age. Another
Sequoia (S. Sternbergii), discovered in miocene deposits im
Greenland, is pronounced to be the representative of S. gigan-
tea, the big tree of the Californian sierra. Ifthe Taxodium
of tertiary time in Europe and throughout the arctic regions
is the ancestor of our present bald cypress, which is assumed
in regarding them as specifically identical, then I thmk we
may, with our present light, fairly assume ‘that the two red-
woods of California are the direct or collateral descendents of
the two ancient species which so closely resemble them.
The forests of the arctic zone in tertiary times contained at
least three other species of Seguota, as determined by their re-
mains, one of which, from Spitzbergen, also much resembles the
common redwood of California. Another, “which appears to
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History. 67
have been the commonest coniferous tree on Disco,” was
common in England and some other parts of Europe. So the
Sequoias, now remarkable for their restricted station and num-
bers, as well as for their extraordinary size, are of an ancient
stock ; their ancestors and kindred formed a large part of the
forests which flourished throughout the polar regions, now
desolate and ice-clad, and which extended into low latitudes
in Europe. On this continent one species at least had reached
to the vicinity of its present habitat before the glaciation of
the region. Among the fossil specimens already found in
California, but which our trustworthy paleontological botanist
has not yet had time to examine, we may expect to find
evidence of the early arrival of these two redwoods upon the
ground which they now, after much vicissitude, scantily
oceupy.
Differences of climate, or circumstances of migration, or
both, must have determined the survival of Sequoia upon the
Pacific, and of Taxodium upon the Atlantic coast ; and still the
redwoods will not stand in the east, nor could our Taxodiwm
fmd a congenial station in California.
As to the remaining near relative of Sequoia, the Chinese
Glyptostrobus, a species of it, and its veritable representative,
Was contemporaneous with Sequoia and Taxodium, not only
in temperate Europe, but throughout the arctic regions from
Greenland to Alaska. Very similar would seem to have been
the fate of a more familiar gymnospermous tree, the gingko
or Salisburia. It is now indigenous to Japan only. Its an-
cestor, as we may fairly call it (since, according to Heer, “ it
corresponds so entirely with the living species that it can
scarcely be separated from it”), once inhabited Northern
Europe and the whole arctic region round to Alaska, and had
even a representative further south in our Rocky-Mountain
district. For some reason, this and Glyptostrobus survived
only on the shores of Eastern Asia. uh}
Libocedrus, on the other hand, appears to have cast 1n its
lot with the Sequoias. Two species, according to Heer, were
with them in Spitzbergen. Of the two now living, L. decur-
rens (the incense cedar) is one of the noblest associates of
the present redwoods ; the other is far south, in the Andes of
Chili.
The genealogy of the Torreyas is more obscure; yet it is
not unlikely that the yew-like trees named Yaaites, which
flourished with the Sequoias in the tertiary arctic forests, are
the remote ancestors of the three species of Torreya, now
-severally in Flomgda, in California, and in Japan.
As to the ning and firs, these were more numerously asso-
5e
68 Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History.
ciated with the ancient Sequoias of the polar forests than with
their present representatives, but in different species, apparently
more like those of Eastern than of Western North America.
They must have encircled the polar zone then, as they encircle
the present temperate zone now.
I must refrain from all enumeration of the angiospermous or
ordinary deciduous trees and shrubs which are now known by
their fossil remains to have flourished throughout the polar
regions when Greenland better deserved its name, and enjoyed
the present climate of New England and New Jersey. Then
Greenland and the rest of the north abounded with oaks, re-
presenting the several groups of species which now inhabit
both our eastern and western forest districts—several poplars,
one very like our balsam poplar or balm-of-Gilead tree—more
beeches than there are now, a hornbeam, and a hop hornbeam,
some birches, a persimmon, and a plane-tree, near represen-
tatives of those of the Old World, at least of Asia, as well as
of Atlantic North America, but all wanting in California—
one Juglans like the walnut of the Old World, and another
like our black walnut—two or three grape-vines, one near our
Southern fox grape or muscadine, the other near our Northern
frost grape—a Tilia very like our basswood of the Atlantic
States only, a Liguidambar, a Magnolia which recalls our
M. grandiflora, a Liriodendron, sole representative of our
tulip-tree, and a sassafras very like the living tree.
Most of these, it will be noticed, have their nearest or their
only living representatives in the Atlantic States—and when
elsewhere, mainly in Hastern Asia. Several of them, or of
species like them, have been detected in our tertiary deposits
west of the Mississippi, by Newberry and Lesquereux.
Herbaceous plants, as it happens, are rarely preserved in a
fossil state; else they would probably supply additional testi-
mony to the antiquity of our existing vegetation, its wide
diffusion over the northern and now frigid zone, and its enforced
migrations under changes of climate.
Concluding, then, as we must, that our existing vegetation,
as a whole, is a continuation of that of the tertiary period, may
we suppose that it absolutely originated then? Evidently not.
The preceding Cretaceous period has furnished to Carruthers
in Europe a fossil fruit like that of the Sequoia gigantea of the
famous groves, associated with pines of the same character as
those that accompany the present tree—has furnished to Heer,
from Greenland, two more Sequoias, one of them identical with
a tertiary species, and one nearly allied to Sequoia Langsdorfii,
which in turn is a probable ancestor of the common Californian
redwood—has furnished to Lesquereux in North America the
Prof. Asa Gray on Sequoia and its History. 69
remains of another ancient Sequota, a G'lyptostrobus, a Liquid-
ambar which well represents our sweet-gum tree, oaks analo-
gous to living ones, leaves of a plane-tree which are also in
the tertiary and are scarcely distinguishable from our own
Platanus occidentalis, of a magnolia and tulip-tree, and “ of
a sassafras undistinguishable from our living species.’ I need
not continue the enumeration. Suffice it to say that the facts
will justify the conclusion which Lesquereux (a very scrupu-
lous investigator) has already announced, ‘ That the essential
types of our actual flora are marked in the Cretaceous period,
and have come to us after passing, without notable changes,
through the tertiary formations of our continent.”
According to these views, as regards plants at least, the
adaptation to successive times and changed conditions has been
maintained, not by absolute renewals, but by gradual modifi-
cations. I, for one, cannot doubt that the present existing
species are the lineal successors of those that garnished the earth
in the old time before them, and that they were as well adapted
to their surroundings then as those which flourish and bloom
around us are to their conditions now. Order and exquisite
adaptation did not wait for man’s coming, nor were they ever
stereotyped. Organic Nature (by which I mean the system
and totality of living things, and their adaptation to each
other and to the world), with all its apparent and indeed real
stability, should be likened, not to the ocean, which varies
only by tidal oscillations from a fixed level to which it is
always returning, but rather to a river so vast that we can
neither discern its shores nor reach its sources, whose onward
flow is not less actual because too slow to be observed by the
Ephemeree which hover over its surface or are borne upon
its bosom,
Such ideas as these, though still repugnant to some, and
not long since to many, have so possessed the minds of the
naturalists of the present day that hardly a discourse can
be pronounced or an investigation prosecuted without refer-
ence to them. I suppose that the views here taken are little
if at all in advance of the average scientific mind of the day.
I cannot regard them as less noble than those which they are
succeeding,
An able philosophical writer, Miss Frances Power Cobbe,
has recently and truthfully said * :—
“Tt is a singular fact that when we can find out how an
thing is done, our first conclusion seems to be that God did
not do it. No matter how wonderful, how beautiful, how in-
timately complex and delicate has been the machinery which
* “ Darwinism in Morals,” in Theological Review, April 1871.
70 M. F. Plateau on the Aquatic Articulata.
has worked, perhaps for centuries, perhaps for millions of
ages, to bring about some beneficent result, if we can but catch
a glimpse of the wheels, its divine character disappears.”
I agree with the writer that this first conclusion is prema-
ture and unworthy; I will add, deplorable. Through what
faults or infirmities of dogmatism on the one hand and scepti-
cism on the other it came to be so thought, we need not here
consider. Let us hope, and I confidently expect, that it is not
to last—that the religious faith which survived without a
shock the notion of the fixity of the earth itself, may equally
outlast the notion of the absolute fixity of the species which
inhabit it—that, in the future even more than in the past,
faith in an order, which is the basis of science, will not (as it
cannot reasonably) be dissevered from faith in an Ordainer,
which is the basis of religion.
VILI.—Physico-chemical Investigations upon the Aquatic
Articulata. By M. Feirx Puatreav. Part I1.*
THE first part of my investigations, of which an abstract was
published in this Journal in 1871 (vol. vu. p. 862), contained
the results of my experiments on the causes of the death of
the freshwater Articulata in sea-water, and of the marine Ar-
ticulata in fresh water.
In the present memoir I take up three other interesting
questions connected with the life of the aquatic Articulata—
questions of detail indeed, the solution of which could not
open any new vista in comparative physiology, but which,
carefully treated, have led me by numerous experiments to
curious and sometimes unexpected results.
I. Experiments on the time during which the aquatic Articulata
can remain in the water without coming to the surface to breathe.
The swimming aquatic Articulata with aérial respiration
(Coleoptera in the perfect state and Hemiptera) come frequently
to the surface to renew their provision of air. If we pre-
vent them from performing this operation, what will be the
time during which they may with impunity be subjected to
submersion? Is their resistance to asphyxia greater than that
of terrestrial insects? or only equal or interior to it?
‘The experiments were effected as follows: at the bottom of
an open vase of the capacity of one litre, and full of ordinary
spring water aérated, a smaller vessel containing about 200
cubic centimetres is placed ; a piece of cotton net is stretched
* Bulletin de lAcad. Roy. de Belgique, 2° sér. tome xxxiy. nos.9&10, 7}
1872. From an Abstract by the Author.
aS
M. F. Plateau on the Aquatic Articulata. 71
over the orifice of the latter, in such a way that an insect placed
in this smaller vessel is actually in the general mass of water,
but cannot rise to its surface.
Terrestrial insects placed in these conditions ascend, carried
by their specific levity, till they rest against the lower surface
of the net; the movements of their feet soon cease, they do not
seem to suffer, and quickly become insensible. The aquatic
Coleoptera and Hemiptera on the contrary, instead of sub-
mitting passively to their fate, seek to escape from their prison,
swim about rapidly, endeavour to rise to the surface, and con-
tinue their agitation until their forces become weakened, and
they finally remain as if dead at the bottom.
‘To cause an insect which has been subjected to a prolonged
immersion torecover fromits state of insensibility, it is necessary,
after taking it out of the water, to dry it with bibulous paper.
If the duration of the submersion has not exceeded a certain
limit, the animal gradually recovers its original activity, the
trial it has undergone leaving no sensible traces upon it.
These experiments were of course repeated as much as
possible upon several individuals and with different durations,
so as to ascertain for each species the limit of time after which
the insect was actually dead. I have thus arrived at the fol-
lowing two curious conclusions, which are supported by a
great number of experiments.
1. Terrestrial Coleoptera resist complete submersion during
a very long time (from three to four days). For example,
Oryctes nasicornis resists a submersion of 96 hours.
Agelastica alni ip “3 tin) OF
Carabus auratus - 71h. 30m.
2. Natatory aquatic Coleoptera and Hemiptera, far from
presenting a greater resistance to asphyxia by submersion, are
no better endowed in this respect than terrestrial insects, and
even perish in most cases much more rapidly. I cite the fol-
lowing numbers from the tables in my memoir :-—
A Dytiscus marginalis g died at the end of 65 h. 80m.
An Acilius sulcatus 3 e * 24 hours.
A Nepa cinerea os =< BL yw sig
A. Notonecta glauca <3 59 we
The cause of this unexpected inferiority of the aquatic in-
sects seems to consist exclusively in their greater activity in
the water, and consequently in a more rapid expenditure of
oxygen.
II. Influence of cold: effects of congelation.
What is the lowest temperature that the aquatie Articulata
72 M. F. Plateau on the Aquatic Articulata.
that we meet with in winter in these regioas can endure? can
they remain with impunity fixed in the ice for a certain time ?
And, in the event of a negative answer, what is the cause of
the mischief observed ?
The aquatic Articulata of our latitudes exist indefinitely in
water kept by means of melting ice at a temperature of 32° F.
As soon as we have recourse to lower temperatures, the water
freezes, and the question then arises to ascertain how long the
animals can remain completely fixed in ice at 32° F.
All the experiments were made in winter upon the species
which are met with in Belgium in December and January.
They consisted in placing an aquatic insect or crustacean,
together with the bulb of a Centigrade thermometer, in a thin
glass tube containing a little water and surrounded by a freez-
ing-mixture intended to produce the complete congelation of
the liquid. Care was taken not to allow the temperature of
the ice formed ever to descend below 0° C. After the lapse
of a certain time the tube was taken out of the freezing-mix-
ture and immersed in water of the temperature of the room,
when, as soon as a commencement of fusion permitted, the
lump of ice was extracted from the tube and put directly into
water, in order to hasten the disengagement of the animal.
The analysis of the results which I have obtained shows
that the time during which the aquatic Articulata may be fixed
in ice without perishing is excessively short, the longest resis-
tance not having reached half an hour. The following num-
bers will give an idea of the rapidity with which death ensues
under these circumstances :—
Imprisonment in ice at 0° C. (52° F.).
Maximum period : 5
supported lan _ Period which
being followed by inevitably causes
immediate death. death.
minutes. sec. minutes.
Agabus bipustulatus ....| Between 15and20 0 25
Hydroporus lineatus .... “n 20) 5, 30) 0 30
Gyrinus natator ...... 10 Flora 15
Notonecta glauca ...... 10; 70 20
Coraatstriata 7 os ae oe 2 0 3
Asellus aquaticus ...... 10 yO 15
Cyclops quadricornis.... 1 30 2
I have endeavoured, by means of special experiments, to
explain the cause of the rapid death of animals imprisoned in
ice at 0° C.; but although these may, perhaps, be of a nature
Dr. J. E. Gray on Spatulemys Lasale. Ta
to interest the reader, I shall confine myself to referring for
their description to my memoir. The primary cause of rapid
death when Articulata are fixed in ice, seems to be the abso-
lute privation of movement and the consequent absorption of
the corporeal heat, without any possible restitution.
Ill. Action of heat: maximum temperature.
I have endeavoured to ascertain by experiment the highest
temperature which our freshwater insects, Arachnida, and
Crustacea can endure—in other words, what is the tempera-
ture of the hottest water in which they can live.
I have thus found that the highest temperatures endured
without serious accidents oscillate between 33°°5 and 46°2 C.
(=92° and 115° F.), and consequently between very narrow
limits.
These temperatures correspond with those of a certain num-
ber of known thermal springs, in the waters of which we may
meet with articulate animals wherever the salts or gases in
solution have no injurious action upon them.
If we compare the results with which the aquatic Articulata
have furnished me with those which have been obtained by
means of animals belonging to other groups, we find that the
highest temperature that aquatic animals, whether vertebrate,
articulate, or molluscous, are able to support probably does
not exceed 46° C. (115° F.).
1X.—Additional Notes on Spatulemys Lasale.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
[Plate II. ]
CoLoneL P. PEREZ DE LASALA has brought with him several
very interesting specimens from his museum, and has kindly
presented to the British Museum a fine adult broad-nosed
alligator, and a freshwater tortoise from Rio Paranda, Corrientes,
which is quite new to our collections, and the largest example
of the family that has yet been brought to Europe; I have
named it, from its very depressed form, Spatulemys, and
dedicated the species to the enterprising collector, by calling
it Spatulemys Lasale (Plate I1.).
This species was characterized in the ‘ Annals’ for 1872,
x. p. 463, to which I wish to add the following particulars
and comparisons with allied species, and also a figure of this
very interesting animal.
The genus has many similarities to Hydromedusa; and I
thought at one time that it might be the HZ tect/fera of Mr.
Cope, brought from the Parana or Uruguay river, and described
74 Dr. J. E. Gray on Spatulemys Lasale.
in the ‘ Proc. Amer. Phil. Soe.’ for 1869, p. 147; but it has a
nuchal plate in the margin, and only five vertebral plates, and
is quite distinct from the genus Hydromedusa.
The mouth is semicircular in front, with the gape wide.
The palate is broad, flat, with the internal nostrils oval, rather
near together, rather before the hinder end of the alveolar
surface. Alveolar surfaces flat, broad, well separated from
one another in front, broadest about one third their length from
the front, and rather more than half the width behind, with a
rounded outline. Lower jaw with a slightly concave alveolar
surface, which is of the same breadth the whole of its
length, and has a well developed raised sharp edge on the
outer circumference and a less developed one on the inner
margin. There is a well-marked conical tooth-like promi-
nence in the front of the middle of the outer edge.
The upper and lower jaws of The upper and lower jaws of
Spatulemys Lasale. Hydraspis raniceps.
The alveolar surface, as seen in the stuffed specimen, is very
like that of the skeleton of Hydraspis raniceps: but the alveo-
lar plates of the upper jaw of the latter species are well
separated in the middle, and the internal nostrils are much
further back in the palate; and the alveolar edge of the lower
jaw is even—and not with the rounded tubercle on each side,
rather behind the central tube.
In Hydraspis Gordonii (P. Z. 8. 1868, p. 563) the alveo-
lar plates of each side of the upper jaw are separated by a
narrow linear space ; they are moderately wide and nearly the
same width for the whole length, truncated at the front end,
and gradually rounded off at the hinder end. The internal
'
Wt
Dr. J. E. Gray on Macleayius australiensis. 75
nostrils are about opposite to the midddle of the length of the
alveolar plate. The alveolar surface of the lower jaw is slightly
concave, with a raised edge on the hinder side; it is rather
broader behind, and oradually slightly narrowed towards the
front, There is a large slightly elevated rounded tubercle
occupying the whole of the middle of the alveolar surfaces
between the two rami, and a slight elevation on the outer
margin on each side of the middle, giving the edge of the
jaws rather a sinuated appearance.
X.—On the Macleayius australiensis from New Zealand.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Dr. Haast has sent the skeleton of a New-Zealand whale
to the British Museum as that of Caperea antipodarum; but
the examination of the bones led me at first to believe that
it was Hubalena australis. However, on further examination,
the cervical vertebre and the blade-bone show that it cannot
belong to either of those genera; for it has a broad upper
process to the atlas, while they have a small narrow one; and
it has an acromial process to the scapula, which is only very
rudimentary in Caperea, and is of very different shape in
Hubalena; like most whales, it has no coracoid. The form
of the lobes of the atlas are so like those figured from a pho-
tograph by Mr. Krefft, which I described and figured as
Macleayius australiensis in the ‘ Proc. Zool. Soc.’ 1864, and
. in the ‘Catalogue of Seals and Whales in the British
Museum,’ 1866, p. 105, f. 10, 11, and p. 372, f. 74, 75, that
I am inclined to consider it an example of that genus,
which was previously known only from a mass of cervical
vertebre in the Australian Museum at Sydney.
Upper jaw very narrow; the nasal bones oblong elongate,
arched out at the front end. Cervical vertebrae united into
one mass. Atlas very large and thick, with a very long upper
process forming a large keeled crest, which is united to the
upper process of the five following vertebre; the upper
lateral process of the atlas high, square, truncated at the end ;
the lower process twice as high as broad, with an oblong,
rounded end. The other cervical vertebra short, thin: the
second with slender upper and lower lateral processes; the
remainder with only descending superior processes (and no
indication of inferior), which are slender in all but the seventh
vertebra, where they are thick and truncated; and this is
the only vertebra that has the upper part distinct from
the bony crest. ‘The ear-bone is very like that of Hubalena.
The sternum is oblong, with two or three irregular tubercles at
the side. ‘The first rib, like the others, is simple. The blade-
76 Miscellaneous.
bone is triangular, rather wider than long. The acromial process
is compressed, attenuated at the end, and bent outwards.
The chief difference between the mass of the cervical ver-
tebre and the specimen in the Sydney Museum, according to
Mr. Krefft’s photograph, is that the lower process of the axis in
that figure appears to be rather longer and narrower at the end.
The mass of the cervical vertebra in some respects resembles
that of Balena mysticetus of the Arctic seas, but differs in
being much more united. It differs from Caperea and
Eubalena in having the lower lateral process of the second
cervical vertebra well developed.
MISCELLANEOUS.
On the Reproduction and Development of the Telescope-fish of
China. By M. Carponnier.
Tue telescope-carp (Cyprinus macrophthalmus, Bloch; in Chinese
Long-tsing-ya) is a native of the fresh waters of China and Japan. Its
conformation is remarkably anomalous. Its body is globular ; its
caudal and anal fins are doubled ; its eyes project from two to five
centimetres from its head; in fact the entire animal is the exact
model of those fishes, hitherto regarded as chimerical, that we meet
with in a great many Chinese paintings. ‘This fish seems to me to
be a monstrous goldfish, a monster designedly produced by means of
processes of breeding (in which the Chinese are very clever), so
powerful that the original anomaly has now become hereditary.
I have already, in goldfish, met with analogous partial monstro-
sities, especially the gemination of the caudal fin. M. G. Pouchet,
in a note presented to the Academy on the 30th May 1870, notices
a similar anomaly presented by two living specimens received by him
from China; but hitherto, so far as I am aware, no one has had the
opportunity of studying the variety of carp which I call telescope-fish.
By the kindness of a relation, I received twenty-four specimens,
all presenting the same modifications of structure; only three of
these died, the remainder have recovered sufficiently to allow me to
try to reproduce them since the first year.
The globular form of the body of the animal renders its equilibrium
extremely unstable, and it can swim only with difficulty ; hence,
whilst its congener the goldfish effects its spawning by rubbing itself
against aquatic plants, flexible bodies of little resistance, the
telescope-fish seeks a firmer point of support, opposing a direct
resistance to the impulse of the fins. It is at the bottom of the
water, on the ground, that it rubs its abdomen.
While the female acts thus in oviposition, the males, which are
exceedingly ardent in fecundation, pursue her several together, push
her with their heads, turn her over and roll her over and over, in-
flicting upon her an actual punishment.
Having deposited, in a basin containing 20 cubic metres of
water, four fishes belonging to a first lot, about a month afterwards
(on the 14th of September last) I saw the three males pursuing the
Miscellaneous. 77
female, roll her like a ball upon the ground for a distance of several
metres, and continue this conduct, without rest or relaxation, for two
days, until the poor female, who had not been able to recover her
equilibrium for a moment, had at last evacuated all her ova.
Being then obliged to suspend my observations, I returned a
fortnight afterwards, and, carefully examining the surface and the
edges of the basin, I had the satisfaction of discovering several
little embryos, which swam with considerable difficulty, and which
a more careful examination enabled me to recognize as the young
fry of the telescope-fish.
They had the same double caudal fin, and the same sinuosity of the
upper part of the back ; but the eyes were not yet very prominent.
Having brought them to Paris and observed them carefully, they
furt rished me witli the following results. At its earliest age the
telescope-fish has the elongated form of most of our young fishes ;
the transparency of the body allows us to distinguish plainly the
air-bladder, lodged in the upper part of the body, and the intestine,
forming a right angle, of which the apex is opposite to the bladder.
So long as the embryo lives at the expense of the umbilical vesicle,
it swims easily and in a horizontal position; but subsequently the
absorption of exterior aliment has for its result an abnormal and
irregular development, which, in nearly half the specimens, causes
a deviation from the normal position, and the animal holds itself
vertically, sometimes with the head upwards, but most frequently
with it downwards. The faulty position of the air-bladder and the
too slight development of the fins neutralize the intluence of these
directive agents; the want of equilibrium persists, the young animal
can no longer seek its nourishment, and it dies in two or three days.
I have scarcely been able to make them live for ten or twelve days
by mixing triturated animal matter with the water of my aquaria.
I have, however, no doubt that the rearing of the young fry which
remain will furnish me with some new facts.—Comptes Rendus,
November 4, 1872, tome Ixxy. p. 1127.
Additional Observations on Codiophyllum.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
More than one botanist has asked me for a specimen of Codio-
phyllum (described in the ‘ Annals,’ for August 1872), which they
wanted to examine microscopically and to unravel the fibre. The
very expression shows that I have not sufficiently explained the
structure of this very curious plant; but I believed that Mr, Ford’s
excellent figure would exhibit it better than I could explain it in
words. The frond of this curious Alga is not formed of continuous
fibres interlaced together, but of a number of oblong rings of a cylin-
drical tube, each gradually formed and all connected and anastomosed
together, so as to form an expanded frond: each ring is separately
formed; and when complete it sends from a part of its surface a tube
of the same form, size, and structure, which gradually lengthens,
after a time curves back, and unites itself to the ring from which it
sprung, thus forming another ring, and in time emitting a new ring
from its surface in the same manner.
Mr. Ford has attempted to show this development in his figure.
78 Miscellaneous.
The Bell Collection of Reptiles.
To the Editors of the Annals and Magazine of Natural History.
Oxford, Dec. 16, 1872.
GrnTLEMEN,—With reference to the correspondence which has
appeared in the recent numbers of the ‘ Annals’ relative to the Bell
Collection of Reptiles, and with the view of enabling your readers to
form a proper opinion upon the subject, I think it incumbent upon
me to state :—that the negotiation for the purchase of the entire col-
lection, on behalf of the Rev. F. W. Hope, was effected by myself
with Prof. Bell in 1862; that an estimation of the extent of the
collection and of the value thereof was made by Mr. 8. Stevens, the
Natural-History Agent; that the purchase comprised 288 specimens
of tortoises (either entire or shells), about 40 dried snakes and
lizards, and 1065 reptiles of various kinds in spirits; and that the
collection was immediately removed by Mr. Rowell to Oxford, where
it was partially arranged during the last year by Dr. Giinther, of the
British Museum.
I am, Gentlemen,
Your obedient Servant,
J. O. Westwoop.
Answer to Herr Ritsema’s “ Note on Crinodes Sommeri ” &e.
By A. G. Burzer, F.L.S. &e.
A simultaneous attack upon a new genus, in two different maga-
zines, is calculated to impress one with the idea that the discoverer
of the supposed error must have been anxious that his acumen should
be widely recognized. As an answer to the entirely unwarranted
supposition contained in the said paragraph, I need merely inform
Herr Ritsema of one or two facts, which, had he studied my writings,
he might have discovered for himself: Hiibner’s ‘Sammlung’ has
been almost constantly on my table for the last seven years; and I
know his figures as well as | know my own.
I do not make a practice of hunting up every conceivable resem- .
blance in pattern between a new genus and those previously figured
in works known to me; I content myself, at most, with a compa-
rison of structure between closely allied forms*.
I did refer in my paper to the genus Dudusa (inadvertently written
Duduna), a group to which C. Sommeri probably belongst; I had
examined two species of this genus, and therefore could speak with
confidence of its relationship to Tarsol pis.
If Hiibner was not attached to the “type system” there is no
reason why C. clara of Cramer should not stand as the type of the
genus Crino quite as much as C. Sommeri.
* When describing Zarsolepis, I knew for certain that the structure
before me was entirely new. I admit that I did not remember at the time
that Hubner’s Crino Sommeri was so similar in pattern; had I done so,
I might have referred to it as a moth resembling mine in pattern, although
clearly belonging to a different genus.
+ The females of Dudusa have a zone of spatulate scales round the tail,
but of only half the length of those in the males; the antenne are mode-
rately pectinated, more so than in Crinodes ; but there are no tufts of long
hairs at the base of the abdomen in either sex.
Miscellaneous. 79
The remainder of Herr Ritsema’s remarks being to a great extent
based upon suppositions, I shall content myself with answering his
direct statements. He says that the anal tuft entirely covers the
sexual organs; this is not the case with any of the specimens which
I have examined, whether of Crinodes, Dudusa, or Tarsolepis.
As to the probability ofa long curved brush of carmine hairs being
concealed about the body of a Crinodes, it is to my mind more pre-
posterous than it would be were our discussion respecting the iden-
tity of the Philippine Lusemia bambusina and the South- American
Limnas zoega, to suggest that the difference consisted in the Husemia
having concealed the red spots towards the base of the wings*.
If the size of the body is dependent upon sex, it is evident that
OC. Sommeri must be a male; but as Herr Ritsema is avowedly work-
ing principally with Mr. Snellen’s male, which agrees in all the most
important characters with Hiibner’s figure, it does not signify to
what sex the type of C. Sommerz belongs. It now seems highly pro-
bable that Herr Ritsema actually has the Hiibnerian species, whilst
it is more evident than ever that I have not.
The inaccuracies stated to exist in Hiibner’s figures are easily ex-
plicable when we know that figs. 1 and 2 represent the opposite
surfaces of C. Sommeri, and that in fig. 2 hardly any of the inner
margin is visible, so that it 1s impossible to decide whether it is
waved or not. The mention of differences in the hind wings of fig. 1
is mere carping.
I have now no more to say on this subject until I have seen Hiib-
ner’s type. If the two genera come from Java, they will probably
add another to the numerous illustrations of mimetic analogy already
on record; I shall not, therefore (until I have proof of some such
interesting fact, by a comparison of the actual type with Javan
specimens), encroach further upon the patience of the readers of
this magazine.
On a Mite in the Ear of the Ox.
Prof. Leidy remarked that he had received a letter from Dr. Charles
8. Turnbull, in which he stated that while studying the anatomy of
the ear he had discovered in several heads of steers, at the bottom
of the external auditory meatus, a number of small living parasites.
They were found attached to the surface of the membrana tympani.
Specimens of the parasite preserved in glycerine, and a petrosal bone
with the membrana tympani to which several of the parasites were
clinging, were also sent for examination. These prove to be a mite
or Acarus, apparently of the genus Gamasus. The body is ovoid,
translucent white, about three fifths of a line long, and two fifths of
a line wide. The limbs, jaws, and their appendages are brown and
bristled ; the body is smooth or devoid of bristles. The limbs are
from two fifths to half a line long. The feet are terminated by a
five-lobed disk and a pair of claws; the palpi are six-jointed; the
* In other respects these two insects are as much alike as in most cases
of actual mimicry.
80 Miscellaneous.
mandibles end in pincers or chel, resembling lobster-claws ; the
movable joint of the chelz has two teeth at the end; the opposed
extremity of the fixed joint of the chele is narrow, and ends in a
hook.
Dr. Turnbull had seen the cattle killed, and was positive that the
mites occupied the position in the ear of the steers while these were
alive; such being the case, the Acartis may be viewed as a parasite
of the ox, and may be specifically named Gamasus wuris.—Proc. Acad.
Nat. Sct. Philad. 1872.
The Horns of Antilocapra. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
The British Museum has purchased of Mr. E. Gerrard, junior, the
skin of an adult male Antilocapra which was just developing the
new horny sheath; and this was rather different from what, by ob-
serving the horns in a more deyeloped state, I had been led to
expect.
The core of the horns was covered with a thick skin, which in the
dried state is black; but the apex is covered with a small conical
sheath about 1? in. long and 4 in. wide at the base, hard and per-
fectly horny, very like the horn of cattle. It is black, with a white
acute tip about 4 in. long.
The horny sheath of a more developed specimen brought at the
same time has a similar hard horny tip; but the lower part of the
horn is less solid and more evidently formed of felted, matted hair,
which is more distinct and less compactly matted at its base or last
developed part ; so that it would appear that the skin of the core
first develops the horny tip, and then the more spongy part formed
of felted hair.
Notice of a new and remarkable Fossil Bird. By O, C. Marsa.
One of the most interesting of recent discoveries in paleontology
is the skeleton of a fossil bird, found during the past summer, in the
upper Cretaceous shale of Kansas, by Prof. B. F. Mudge, who has
kindly sent the specimen to me for examination. The remains in-
dicate an aquatic bird about as large as a pigeon, and differing
widely from all known birds in haying biconcave vertebra. The cer-
vical, dorsal, and caudal vertebre preserved all show this character,
the ends of the centra resembling those of Plesiosawrus. The rest
of the skeleton presents no marked deviation from the ordinary avian
type. The wings were large in proportion to the posterior extremi-
ties. The humerus is 68-6 millims. in length, and has the radial
crest strongly developed. The femur is small, and has the proximal
end compressed transversely. The tibia is slender and 44-5 millims.
long ; its distal end is incurved as in swimming birds, but has no
supratendinal bridge. This species may be called Jchthyornis dispar.
A more complete description will appear in an early number of
Silliman’s Journal.
Yale College, Sept. 26th, 1872.
THE ANNALS
MAGAZINE OF NATURAL HISTORY.
[FOURTH SERIES. ]
No. 62. FEBRUARY 1873.
XI.—Summary of Zoological Observations made at Naples in
the winter of 1871-72. By E. Ray Lanxester, M.A.,
Fellow and Lecturer of Exeter College, Oxford.
My chief object during a recent stay of some months in Naples
was to commence a study of the general and histological de-
velopment of Mollusca, with the view of ascertaining what
significance is to be attributed to the various parts of their
organization in the light of the “germ-layer theory,” recently
extended with such convincing force by the admirable obser-
vations of Kowalewsky from the Vertebrata to various groups
of lower animals, such as the Vermes and the Insects.
I propose now to give a very short statement of some of
these observations, as well as of others made on some of the
innumerable interesting forms of marine invertebrates with
which the invaluable fishermen of Santa Lucia provided me.
Development of Loligo.
Since the time of K6lliker (1837) no contribution has been
made to our knowledge of the development of Cephalopoda. A
short note by Mecznikow on Sepzola contains very little and is
not illustrated. I obtained eggsof Loldgo first in January, and
subsequently with tolerable ee Mlniity until April: they are
better adapted for observation than those of Sepia.
The structure of the ovary is very similar to that of a bird.
The branched ovary contains eggs of all sizes enclosed in vas-
cular capsules. ‘The basketwork marking seen on the ovarian
egg is not a plication of the proper capsule, but of the surface
of the vitellus, where it is in contact with the inner cellular
lining of the capsule, which sends deeply penetrating ridges and
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser.4. Vol. xi. 6
82 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
villi into the growing egg. This cellular lining of the capsule
grows very rapidly ; and its cells are continually being absorbed
or fused into the vitellus, whence the increase of this in size.
Some of the cells retain their form and are to be found floating
in the complex vitellus thus built up.
On attaming full size, the egg, having lost entirely its
large germinal vesicle, loses all the plications or basketwork
of its vitelline surface, and escapes from its capsule, which
remains on the branched ovary and undergoes a yellow dege-
neration. Passing as a free ovoid homogeneous mass of com-
plex yelk (protoplasm and deutoplasm, Van Beneden, com-
bined) into the oviduct, the egg is fertilized ; and then at one
pole a segregation of plastic yelk, or a germinal patch, occurs
in the form of a thin disk or cap. This exhibits subsequently
a faint nucleus and commences to divide into two, four, eight,
&c. arez, marked out by intercrossing grooves. In some
minor respects my observations differ from Kélliker’s, who -
appears to have represented the segmentation as more regular
than it is, and the resulting cells as becoming detached, which
they do not.
When this superficial layer of blastodermic cells has spread
over an area relatively as large as would be inclosed by the cir-
cumference of a half-crown drawn round the pole of a large hen’s
egg, an exceedingly remarkable fact presents itself, which has
not been observed before, and which has great importance in re-
gard to the various theories as to the origin of the ‘ mesoderm,”
or a portion of that layer. Outside the primitive segmentation-
area (fig. 1P), and quite unconnected with it, appears a ring of
very large pellucid nuclei, seven or eight in number (fig. 1D) ;
they increase in number, and a second, third, and fourth ring of
such large nuclei arise, till at last they spread over the whole
Fig. 1.
egg. Meanwhile the cells of the segmentation-area spread by
i; ie 1 — ie — ie — i — ee ee ee — 2
Ee Fes SO Ss eee
=
— a —— oe od
a. =
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 83
continual division at the free edge of the cap which they form ;
and they grow over the large nuclec, which are thus seen to lie
in a lower stratum of yelk than that along which the cap of
cells from the primitive segmentation is spreading. Both the
segmentation-cells and the large nuclei finally cover-in the
whole surface of the egg as two distinct layers. This process
I observed over and over again, and repeatedly observed that
the large nuclei arise, each one separately, by segregation from
the yelk-mass. They are products of free-cell formation, and
as such of the very highest interest in relation to histogenetic
doctrine. The cells which pass into the ovarian egg in such
enormous numbers to swell its vitelline mass become so much
altered and broken down that it is not possible to regard these
large nuclei as descendants from them, though no doubt they,
as well as the original egg-cell’s protoplasm and the fertilizing
male element, have contributed to form an organic “mixture,”
if one may use the term, from which these free nuclei, as well
as the polar segmentation-disk and nucleus, take origin.
The large pellucid nuclei subsequently become branched and
stellate; whether they give rise to the whole of the elements
of the layer immediately below the outer segmentation-layer it
is not possible to say. If they do, contractile muscular cells
must be regarded as one of their products. In any case they
form the great bulk of the subepidermal tissue, that which cor-
responds with the mesoderm of vertebrates.
Organs now begin to appear as thickenings on the sur-
face of the blastoderm: two eyes (the details of the primitive
development of which are remarkable), two ears (which I
repeatedly saw in their primitive state as two pits, holes, or
in-pushings of the surface ; subsequently they present the con-
dition of capsules, each with a narrow canal opening on the
surface of the head, which canal becomes eventually the little
ciliated cecum seen by Kdlliker), and a median semicircular
primitive mouth; besides these the mantle and arms—the
position of the latter marking off the blastodermic sac into two
parts, a great yelk-bag, and a smaller embryonic sac, which
gradually becomes more and more distinctly pinched off and
shaped out. It is not possible to say much of the further de-
velopment without illustration ; but I must mention two very
important facts. The primitive semicircular mouth is not the
real mouth. Itis at this point that an inward cellular growth
commences, which eats its way into the mass of homogeneous
yelk lying in the embryonic portion of the blastodermic sac,
and meets (how or where exactly my observations do not show)
a shorter ingrowth from the anal aperture, in connexion with
which is also developed the ink-bag, thus agreeing with the
G*
84 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
renal organ of Gasteropods. The first portion of the alimentary
tube (which early appears in connexion with the primitive
semicircular mouth) becomes the yelk-duct. The primitive
mouth sinks into the yelk-bag, by the growth of its margins,
in a peculiar manner ; and there appears at some distance along
the primitive alimentary tube a new mouth. It seems desirable
to speak of these apertures as primitive and secondary mouth,
for the sake of description; but it is a possibility that the
primitive mouth must be considered identical with the aper-
ture of blastodermic invagination of many Vermes and of
Amphioxus, discovered by Kowalewsky, and observed also by
me in several mollusks (Nudibranchs, Limax, Pisidium,
Mytilus).
The second fact of especial interest in the later development
of Loligo is the occurrence of an in-pushing from the surface
in the form of a groove just below (that is, posterior to) the
margin of each eye. A somewhat botryoidal mass of tissue is
the result of this ingrowth, and gives rise, I believe (though I
have not definitely followed out its growth), to the optic gan-
glion on each side. Lateral masses of tissue are seen to dif-
ferentiate below the surface on either side of the cesophagus, and
extend to the eyes—which may become ultimately other parts
of the nervous system. ‘The heart and large vessels develop
below the surface, also without any remarkable features. The
development of the mantle, gills, and cartilaginous skeleton
was accurately described by Kolliker.
The “pen” or shell of Loligo develops in a follicle which
begins to form at a very early period, and remains open
to the surface of the mantle until the embryo is nearly ready
to leave the egg-case.
An interesting phenomenon is the contractility of the walls
of the yelk-sac, which is observed at a very early period, as
soon as the first rudiments of eyes, ears, and mouth have
appeared. A rhythmic wave of contraction passes continually
along the wall of the sac, at that part immediately in front of
the alimentary tube, and doubtless acts so as to cause a circu-
lation of nutrient material in the direction of the young embryo.
The tissue which exhibits this contractility is of the same
structure (stellate cells) as that of the remarkable contractile
vesicle observed in the Pulmonate Gasteropods, and which I
have studied in Limax. It is probable that the two parts are
homogenous.
I should mention that I made frequent examination of eggs
of Sepia, but found those of Loligo the best fitted for study.
I was unable to obtain Argonauta at Naples; it is to be had
im quantity at Messina.
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 85
Development of Aplysia.
The development of two species of Aplysia was studied in
considerable detail as far as the completion of the velum-
bearing embryo and its escape from the egg-jelly. Various
devices failed of enabling me to observe the later development
of this or of several Nudibranchs which were also kept for
study.
The Aplysie were :—a larger species, in which each capsule
in the egg-coil contained from thirty to forty embryos ; and a
smaller species, in which the number was not more than seven,
usually less. ‘The germinal vesicle escapes previously to yelk-
cleavage as the “ Richtungsbliischen ;” the egg then divides
into two larger yellow masses and two smaller pale balls. The
pale balls now divide rapidly, and grow over and enclose the
larger yellow masses. By a process of multiplication (which
I could not satisfy myself was accompanied in Aplysia by
invagination, though there were indications of such a mode of
growth) the pale cells give rise, not to a single layer of cells
enclosing the yellow, but, at the pole whence they started,
to a considerable mass or thickness of cells. The deeper
of these work themselves in between the two large yellow cells
and give rise to the alimentary tract; the outermost cells form
epidermis, nerve, and shell-gland, whilst an intermediate por-
tion gives rise to muscles.
In the two species, however, there is a very curious difference:
for in the larger species the two yellow cells almost as soon as
they are enclosed lose their nuclei and definite outline, becoming
mere granular masses, which the deep layer of pale cells rapidly
invest and attach to themselves in an intimate manner; whilst
in the small species the two yellow cleavage-masses, each with
its large bright nucleus, retain their form to the last (that is,
as long as I studied the embryos), the deep pale cells (hypo-
derm, Darmdriisenblatt) only passing between the two masses,
and growing by absorption of the matter which they yielded,
as was evident by their gradual thinning out and shrinking,
but without being invested or themselves undergoing any for-
mative changes. ‘The liver-mass, and perhaps the genital
glands, subsequently appear in the position occupied by these
two big cells, probably growing out ¢nto them, not from them.
An important fact is the occurrence of cilia on tracts of the
pale cells, lying deeply within the segmentation mass ; this I
have also seen in the eggs of Pistdium pusillum.
The shell-gland is the first organ to appear in Aplysia, as
it is also in the freshwater Lamellibranch Pistdiwm, and occurs
as a groove on the surface, the cells in which take on a special
86 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
development. It is in this way also that the “cuttle-bone”’ of
Loligo takes its origin; and from the observation of this common
mode of origin of the shells of Lamellibranchs, Gasteropods,
and cuttlefish, I do not doubt that they are fundamentally
identical or homogenous—that is to say, have a common an-
cestral representative. The pharynx and cesophagus early
develop in Ap/ysia as in-pushings at the opposite pole to that
at which the shell-gland appears, which latter is the pole of
active segmentation in the first embryonal changes.
The supracesophageal ganglion is clearly seen to develop as
a thickening of the outer layer of cells in the prostomial region.
It sends branches downwards and forwards, and gave rise to
the suspicion that the subcesophageal nervous mass was but a
lobe of it.
Below the mouth, in a blunt process (which is the foot) the
pair of otolithic sacs (or otocysts, as M. de Lacaze-Duthiers
terms them) appear; I took great pains to ascertain their
earliest beginning. They certainly never communicate with the
exterior ; they have been erroneously supposed to do so in
Gasteropoda; and I have established the fact that they really do
soin Cephalopoda. The first appearance of each otocyst is,
betore any organs except the shell-gland are indicated, as a
faint vesicle, with no proper walls of its own, just below the
most superficial layer of cells ; and I believe that it really be-
longs to that layer. As the foot develops, the otocyst shifts
greatly its position, and acquires thicker walls and larger size.
The otolith develops within the cyst at a late period; often it
may be seen in one cyst and not in the other.
Development of Nudibranchs.
The eggs of species of Doris, of Tethys, Pleurobranchus, and
others were frequently studied. I found those of Polycera
quadrilineata and of Holis exigua the most favourable for study.
I was able to determine in these that the first step in develop-
ment, after the formation by cleavage of the mass of embryo-
cells or “polyblast,” is the invagination or in-pushing of these
cells at one pole, just as Kowalewsky has drawn it in Amphi-
oxus and Phallusia, and as seen also in the Heteropod mollusk
Atalanta. ‘The orifice of invagination is at one time large and
obvious enough, but closes entirely at a very early period.
The same invagination and orifice I have made out in the
Lamellibranch Pisidiwm, the development of which I studied
in the spring of 1871 at Jena. I also observed it in Lima ;
and its occurrence in a similar stage in certain marine Lamel-
libranchs is clear from Lovén’s admirable figures, though he
has mistaken its significance.
‘ij
| -—$—«
—s
=
—— co fe a Se ee eS or. oa
— * =
“i eee
=
=>
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 87
Hence the two primitive layers of cells in the embryo mol-
lusk have the same origin as in Vermes and Vertebrata; and,
indeed, it would appear that the whole animal series above the
Protozoa agree in possessing these two primitive layers at one
time of their development. The addition to these of a third,
intermediate layer, or mesoderm, is the distinguishing feature
of another great branch or stem (Triploblastica), which has as
its base the Vermes, and from which diverge the Mollusks, the
Arthropods, the Vertebrates, the Echinoderms. That branch
which retains but two layers of cells through life, the endoderm
and ectoderm, includes the corals, polyps, and sponges (Diplo-
blastica). So far biologists seem to have arrived at very
promising results with the germ-layer theory. The great diffi-
culty at present lies in the question, Whence doesthis third layer,
or mesoderm, originate? There are a number of conflicting
replies to this question, which have yet to be reconciled.
Development of Terebella nebulosa.
An abundant supply of the eggs of this annelid enabled me
to follow its development as far as its opacity permits. A
delicate chorion forms round the egg after segmentation, on the
surface of the cleavage-cells, which are densely ciliated. I ob-
served that the chorion could be caused to separate from the
surface of the cells; and the cilia were then seen to be really
processes of the protoplasm of the cells, and to perforate this
cuticular exudation, since they did not break off with it, as often
happens, but were drawn through it, remaining fixed to the
cells. The development of the ciliated tracts, segments, ap-
pendages, and tubiparous glands was followed and drawn.
The young of this species has no otolithic sac.
Young Appendicularia furcata.
Numerous specimens of this most interesting form were ob-
tained in February. The recent memoir of Foll has given
very full and accurate information on the anatomy of the Ap-
pendicularie. I have still, however, something to add in this
case with regard to the cutaneous glands and the cellular out-
growths of the integument, and as to the heart. It is curious
that no one has yet drawn attention to the very remarkable
fact that the heart in A. furcata consists of but two cells—that
is to say, two nucleated histological units. ‘The small number
of histological units which build up the organs of an Appen-
dicularia is avery noticeable fact, and is parallelled in the case
of the Rotifera. The elaboration, however, of so important an
organ as the heart from but two units is quite unexampled.
88 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
The heart as known and described is an oval pellucid body,
with a dense mass at each pole. Durin
life it beats with marvellous rapidity, quite
unlike the action of a heart, and suggesting
(what I believe it is) a form of protoplasmic
movement allied to the ciliary. The mass
at each pole of the oval heart is seen in spe-
cimens about two thirds grown, when dilute
acid is added, to be a nucleated cell. From
each of these extends, not a contractile
membrane (as would appear from the figures
of Gegenbaur, Foll, and others), but from
twelve to twenty fine processes or filaments
joining one cell to the other, leaving open
spaces between them. The rapid contractions
of these processes of the cells, which are not
unlike (except in being fixed at both ends) those pro-
cesses known as cilia, agitate the blood in which the heart
is suspended ; but there is no trace of blood-vessels connected
with the heart. In specimens of Appendicularia furcata of
full size the heart was seen to be a little more complex in
structure; for at the base of each fibre or process of the
two original large conical cells (which still retain their form
and their large nuclei) is developed a small swelling with a nu-
cleus (fig. 2). Moreover each of the fibres is now seen (when
treated with picric acid) to possess a transverse striation, like
that of the muscular fibres of the great tail or flabellum. I
have specimens of Appendicularia furcata, treated with picric
acid and mounted in glycerine, which exhibit admirably at
the present moment this very remarkable structure of the
heart.
Histology of Sipunculus nudus.
Every naturalist who visits Naples studies this very in-
teresting and abundant worm more or less, and comes to a
conclusion respecting its generative organs differing from those
of his predecessors. [ can only briefly state on the present
occasion the results of my study of this worm, as to the his-
tology of which I have a mass of drawings and preparations.
First, as to the corpuscles of the perivisceral fluid. These
are the pink corpuscles, the amceboid, the mulberry corpuscles
of various sizes (usually regarded as testicular cell-masses), the
ova, and the detached portions of the peritoneal membrane, and
the “Tépfchen” or ciliated globes. hese last were especially
studied recently by Brandt; he did not ascertain their origin ;
he is mistaken in his statements as to “ciliz capitate.” The
ay
AN ERR
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 89
cilia of the “Tépfchen” are in no wise peculiar. What he
has supposed to be a head or knob on the end of the cilium is
really nothing but the bending over of the extremity of the
cilium under the influence of the dilute acetic acid which he
used. I convinced myself time after time that the cilia of the
Tépfchen are perfectly normal, by study, with Hartnack’s 10 a
immersion, of living specimens, and of others treated with
osmic acid. By the use of acetic acid I obtained the knob-like
appearance which deceived Alexander Brandt.
urther I have found out the source of the “ Tépfchen.”’
They are to be observed in great numbers attached within the
curious pair of tubes or vessels formed by duplicatures of the
peritoneal membrane, which lie on each side of the cesophagus,
and the connexion of which with the tentacle-crown was so
well shown by Brandt in his memoir. They develop as “ but-
tons ”’ on the cellular surface (fig. 3), which is throughout the
perivisceral cavity provided in parts with patches of cilia-bear-
ing protoplasm ; and then they become detached and swim off
into the fluid. The whole history of this beautiful peritoneal
Fig. 3.
tissue and its shedding of elements into the perivisceral fluid
is of extreme interest ; but I cannot go into it until my draw-
ings can be given. So much for the Tépfchen at present.
Next as to the ova. ‘These occur of all sizes in the perivisceral
liquid; and Brandt appears to have supposed that they take
origin in it. Various zoologists have tried to establish this or
that structure as the “ ovary.”” Some have assigned this nature
to the pair of large brown tubes opening to the exterior,
so paradoxical in character. MM. Keferstein and Ehlers
mistook the unicellular cutaneous glands and some vagrant ova
90 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
for the ovaries, which they actually located beneath the skin ;
this view I must most fully oppose, as a special study of the
integument of Sipunculus has shown me what structures these
authors have mistaken for ova. Others, again, have taken the
strange little diverticulum of the intestine placed near the rec-
tum for the ovary, but without offering proof. I have yet a
new view. I consider that the “bush-like processes”’ de-
scribed by Keferstein and Ehlers as occurring on each side of
the rectum are the ovarian villi. These arborescent tufts are
outgrowths of the cellular peritoneum and enclose the ova,
which become detached when very small (34 inch), either
in groups or singly, ensheathed in a portion of peritoneum,
and proceed to grow to full size in the perivisceral liquid. The
proot of this is in the structure of the villi, and in the structure
of floating masses of minute ova occasionally to be found in
the perivisceral liquid. The ova are detached from the villi
probably at certain seasons and as soon as developed; hence
I have never found the villi containing unmistakable ova,
when attached in place on the rectum.
The mulberry spheres are certainly not, as supposed by Brandt,
testicular. They have not the structure of such testicular mul-
berry masses in Annelids ; for in these of Sipunculus I have
made out what Brandt does not describe, viz. a membrane with
a distinct nucleus enveloping the aggregated spherules. They,
I believe, give rise to the abundant pink corpuscles of the peri-
visceral fluid, and are, like the ‘‘ Tépfchen,” detached from the
tentacular vessels originally. The true testis is still an open
question. I found that the curious little diverticulum of the in-
testine in several specimens examined in March had become
greatly dilated, attaining a full inch in length ; and it was filled
with a creamy fluid in which were a dense mass of motile fila-
ments. It is possible that these were bacterioid parasites, but
most unlikely when they recur in eight individuals examined
within two days. There were further appearances of the develop-
ment of these vibratile rods which tended to confirm the notion
that the wall of this diverticulum of the intestine becomes the
testis. On the other hand the structure of the great brown pair of
tubes was very carefully studied ; and I found that they develop
in their walls innumerable corpuscles which in spring (May)
take quite the form of the Mammalian spermatozoon, and abound
in immense number in the liquid fillmg the brown sacs. The
balance of evidence is on the whole in favour of the brown
tubes being testes. At the same time let me mention that
they become much dilated in May, and take into their cavity
large quantities of the perivisceral fluid, and with it the floating
ova, or the mulberry spheres, if they are present.
Sa, a eS Se ee
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 91
I should mention that one fact in favour of regarding the
mulberry spheres as testicular is that when they abound the
ova appear to be absent, and vice vers@. Thisis only apparently
the case ; for I have found numerous ova (though far less numer-
ous in proportion than elsewhere) in Stpunculi in which the
mulberry spheres were predominant, and I have noticed young
stages of the mulberry spheres present when ova abounded.
It should, however, be noticed that all the full-grown Sipun-
culi (some eighty-five in number) which I opened were di-
stinguishable as either “ ova-bearing ”’ or “ mulberry-sphere-
bearing.”
Brandt and, in earlier years, Krohn have been the supporters
of the view that the mulberry spheres are testicular; but
neither of them has seen the development of the component
spherules of the ane into tailed spermatozoa. Brandt states
that he found in May, in a Sipunculus of the mulberry-sphere
kind, tailed spermatozoa floating in the perivisceral fluid. But
he admits that such spermatozoon-like bodies are developed in
the brown tubes; and he has no evidence whatever to prove
that those he found in the perivisceral fluid had not come thence,
especially since he obtained the fluid by puncture and might
thus have wounded the brown tubes.
I must yet further mention with regard to the pink corpuscles,
that I sometimes found them of large size and containing crystals
—a fact not noticed by Brandt; also in May I noticed cases in
which they were all very small, and in which only a few loosely
aggregated mulberry spheres and no ovawere present. I believe
that the reason why mulberry spheres and ova are reciprocally
exclusive in the perivisceral fluid is this, that after the ex-
pulsion of the ova a renewal of the pink corpuscles is necessary,
and accordingly we get this development of mulberry spheres,
destined to break up into young pink corpuscles. It is not until
the spheres have fully developed and broken up into young
pink corpuscles that a new development of ova takes place, by
detachment from the rectal arborescent villi. The testis is either
the tissue on the intestinal diverticulum or the brown tubes ;
which of the two, my notes and drawings do not decide.
The termination of nerves in the skin, the cutaneous glands,
the minute structure of the nerve-chord, the structure and
varieties of connective tissue in various parts of the worm, and
the curious pink or red line on the intestinal wall, which is not
a vessel, were examined, and will be described and figured on
a future occasion.
Brandt’s description of the perforate structure of the egg-
envelope is perfectly correct.
92 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
Anatomy of Sternaspis.
Specimens of this interesting worm were from time to time
brought to me by the fishermen. Its structure presents no
special points of contact with the Gephyrea, but rather with
the capitibranchiate polychetous Annelids, such as Pherusia,
which certainly approach the Gephyrea in the condition of their
segment-organs. ‘The closed vascular system contains hemo-
globin i in solution, and presents an internal series of gills, the
structure of which is remarkable in many ways. It would be
difficult to make any account of the details of its organization
intelligible in this brief summary without illustration.
Notochordal rudiments in Glycera.
The observations of Claparéde on the “ drei riesige Réh-
renfaden ”’ lying above the nerve-cord in Lumbricus induced
me to search, by means of transparent transverse sections, for
evidences of a skeletal or supporting arrangement of the con-
nective tissue in immediate relation with the nerve-cord in
other Annelids. The disposition of the muscles in relation to the
sheath of the nerve-cord in Glycera has some interest in this
respect, since these parts are seen, in suitably prepared sec-
tions, to have generally the same relations as have the muscles
and neural sheath, including the notochord, of a vertebrate.
Terebratula vitrea.
These most beautiful Brachiopods were sometimes brought
in quantities by the deep-sea fishermen. I was not able to
obtain the ova in a developing condition.
There are still many points in doubt with regard to the
Brachiopoda, and especially as to the Terebratulide.
This species has not, I believe, been studied in the living
state. A young specimen, of the size of a pin’s head, exhibited
the ‘arms ”’ in a condition corresponding in general characters
with the lophophore of a Polyzoon, with which Mr. Morse’s
researches on Terebratulina also render it clear that the Bra-
chiopod arms are homologous (homogenous). Let me also
say here that a comparative study of the structure of the adult
arms of Terebratula and of the gill-lamelle of Lamellibranchs
leads to the conclusion that these are also homologous (homo-
genous) structures.
The observations of Mr. Barrett on Terebratulina, and of
M. de Lacaze-Duthiers on Thecidium, are the only ones at
present, I believe, as to the condition of the “arms” oy
Terebratulide in the living state.
The cirri are finely ciliated externally ; they are also in-
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 93
dividually movable, though rarely moved. ach cirrus
corresponds in essential structure as to its tubular character,
its horny and calcareous skeleton, and the circulation within
it of the blood, with a tube of certain Lamellibranchs’ gills. In
young Pisidium pusillum the gills originate as three (in-
creasing in number) pairs of tubular processes. In young
Anomia they equally retain their character as a series of
isolated tubules ciliated on the surface. In young Terebratula
vitrea I found nine pairs of tubular tentacles (wonderfully like
the tentacles of a Pedicellina) ; and in the adult we have an
immense series of them, which only require to become adhe-
rent in order to give the essential structure of the Lamelli-
branch’s gill-plate.
The blindness in relation to the intestine of Terebratula
vitrea is certainly in that Brachiopod’s rectum. There is no
anus, but a blunt cecal termination.
I entirely failed to convince myself that the organ regarded
by Mr. Hancock as a heart really has the function of one in
TL’. vitrea. I repeatedly opened fresh specimens with rapidity,
in order to witness its contractions, if any, but never saw such
contractions ; nor could I find vessels in connexion with it, nor
evidence that it had muscular walls. Dr. Krohn, of Bonn,
had equally been unable to obtain evidence that this curious
little dilatation has the function of a heart.
The “ segment-organs”’ or oviducts (hearts of Owen) pre-
sented a beautiful appearance in the living state, on account of
their ciliation. It was possible to preserve them mounted in
balsam and also in osmic acid.
The ovaries, lying as they do on the inner surface of the body-
wall (which is beautifully marked with calcareous spicula), may
be readily studied in various stages of development. The testes
are not known at present in any Brachiopod except the dicecious
Thecidium. 'The red matter suggested by Hancock as possibly
testicular in Lingula has its parallel in yellow matter which is
abundant amongst the ovarian ova of Terebratula. This yellow
matter is clearly due to degeneration of the envelopes of escaped
ova—is, in fact, a series of corpora lutea.
I think it has not yet been clearly pointed out that the ova
in Terebratula do not lie freely on the surface of the body-
wall ready to drop into the blood-sinus (perivisceral cavity),
into which the oviduct opens. Each ovum has really a very
delicate connective-tissue envelope; and it is only upon bursting
through that that it can escape. Sometimes the ovaries (in De-
cember) contain comparatively large eggs, which are readily
detached. In the spring, on the other hand, I found most with
moderate-sized ova, but some with no ova at all. The ovarian
94 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
tracts in the latter specimens were obvious enough, since
they form a reticulate arrangement of ridges, and the corpora
lutea marked these tracts also; but no cells which were dif-
ferentiated as ova were present. Some persons have been
inclined to regard these specimens as males; but I consider
this merely a temporary condition of the ovary. In some
ovaries, at intervals, large white spherical masses containing a ,
quantity of small cells were found; these were the most
likely indication of testicular organs which I succeeded in
finding. ‘The appearances of the ovary in various conditions,
and the structure of the mantle (in which I could not identify
the numerous layers distinguished in Waldheimia flavescens
by Mr. Hancock, in his great essay on Brachiopoda), require
illustrations for a fuller explanation.
Phyllirrhoé bucephala and Mnestra.
Perhaps the most charming of all the objects which the
Naples Bay affords to a zoologist of histological tendencies is
the curious little fish-shaped mollusk Phyllirrhoé. Its trans-
parency is perfect, at the same time that the tissue-elements
present definite outlines. Its anatomy and histology are well
enough known from Heinrich Miiller’s paper. The pulsating
heart—lying in the small pericardium which communicates by
a long partly ciliated tube (the representative of the organ of
Bojanus) with the exterior—is an object of intense interest.
It was easy to trace the connexion of the finest nerve-twigs
with muscular fibres and with various peculiar corpuscles.
Prof. Panceri discovered, whilst I was at Naples, that these
corpuscles, as well as the nerve-ganglia, are phosphorescent.
Krohn described, some thirty years ago, a medusoid which
presents the remarkable character of being parasitic on Phyllir-
rhoé. 1 obtained specimens of this, but have no indication of
the way in which it becomes attached. The tissue of the me-
dusoid’s disk appears to be fused at its middle aboral point with
the tissues of the Phyllirrhoé. It cannot be removed without
tearing, and always occurs just below the chin (if the term be
allowed) of the Phyllirrhoé. I made out (and have drawings
of) acircular and four radiating canals, four marginal tentacles,
abundance of thread-cells, and a central chamber.
Pyrosoma, Auginopsis, and Cercaria.
Prof. Panceri and his assistants were carrying on their valu-
able investigations on the embryology and phosphorescence
of Pyrosoma whilst I was staying at Naples. In December we
obtained a good supply of these most interesting Tunicates.
I directed my attention chiefly to the early changes in the
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 95
vvum, but, owing to the interest which the later development
also had for me and the impossibility of keeping specimens
alive, did not come to definite conclusions. The germinal
vesicle seems to disappear; and a cap of blastodermic cells
appears at one pole of the egg, somewhat as in Loligo, The
changes in the mass of the yelk whilst this goes on are re-
markable, and lead to the formation of corpuscles, which appear
to circulate subsequently in the embryonic blood-system. I
can confirm (if confirmation be wanting) Professor Panceri’s
and Pavyesi’s description of the heart and mouth of the cyatho-
zooid, and its mode of connexion with the four ascidiozooids.
Professor Panceri’s recently published figures (Academy of
Naples) are excellent. ‘The colonial muscular system described
by Panceri (see ‘Quart. Journ. Micr. Sci.’ Jan. 1873) was also
examined; and I repeated the experiments which he had just
carried out, leading to the determination of certain granular
masses on the sides of the pharynx as the phosphorescent
organs of Pyrosoma.
Aiginopsis was found on one occasion in some water taken
from the surface. The structure of the arms was not given by
Johannes Miiller so fully as examination with a no. 10 Hart-
nack now allows.
Cercaria echinocerca was obtained and drawn from examina-
tion with the 10 immersion on several occasions. It is re-
markable for the flattened seta-like processes of the integument
of the tail.
The Parasite of the Renal Organ of Cephalopoda.
Dicyema sepie and D. eledone were first described by
Kdlliker. Claparéde afterwards found a species in the Eledone
norvegica, and referred Dicyema to the ciliate Infusoria.
Subsequently Guido Wagner described D. sepie and D. ele-
done in more detail than his predecessors.
There is probably no stranger parasite than the Dicyema.
The renal organ of most Sepre may be said to be literally
made up of these organisms in all stages of growth. They
are clearly not Infusoria, but adegraded form of worm, being mul-
ticellular in structure. They are, when typically grown, thread-
like bodies one third of an inch in length. There is no mouth,
but an axial tissue of scattered stellate cells, which is clothed
with large epithelial scales: these are at one time all ciliated ;
but after full growth the cilia only remain about the head.
The head is indicated by a knob, on which the epithelial scales
are very regularly disposed in two series. It is rare to find a
large Dicyema with this head well developed—the reason being
that the animals are continually dividing transversely, and a
96 Mr. E. Ray Lankester’s Zoological Observations
complete head with its symmetrically arranged scales never
grows at the surface of fission, but only a partially formed ill-
shapen head with two or four scales. _
In addition to transverse division, Décyema reproduces by two
kinds of internally produced embryos, as pointed out by pre-
vious writers. One kind is like the long worm-shaped parent ;
the other is oval, and ciliated at one extremity. No one has
succeeded in following out what becomes of this latter “infu-
sorian-like embryo ;”’ but the embryos resembling their parents
clearly grow up to the reproductive state within their host’s
kidney, and are to be seen in all stages.
I have made out, and hope to figure hereafter, the mode of
formation of these two kinds of embryos, which differs con-
siderably in the two cases. ach originates from a single
nucleated cell, which multiplies. Those cells, however, which
grow into infusorian embryos are contained at first in an oval
capsule or space, twenty or so together, and escape from this
capsule to undergo development in the axial tissue. The
worm-like embryos, on the contrary, arise from single cells
scattered at intervals in the axial parenchyma, which do not
at first present any special characters.
Dicyeme which are developing infusorian embryos do not
at the same time develop worm-embryos. No trace of male
reproductive organs is to be seen in these organisms. Their
structure admits of the most complete investigation, on account
of their small size and transparency.
New type of Infusorva.
Among some eggs of Terebella, associated with other Infu-
soria, I found several specimens of an altogether novel type.
The general form was oval ; above the mouth projected a small
cephalic tubercle ; round this oral extremity was raised up a
large collar or ruffle, which continually opened and shut with
a slight spiral twist, and caused the locomotion of the animal,
whilst at the same time food was brought into the region of
the mouth. This membranous vibratile collar or ruffle may be
compared to a blended crown of cilia. It forms one of the rare
examples of undulating membranes, similar to that of Undulina
(parasitic in the frog’s blood, ‘Quart. Journ. Micr. Sci.’ October
1871), where, however, the membrane is in the form of a crest,
and not of a collar as here.
There is not a trace of a cilium on any part of this infuso-
rian, the whole work being done by the vibrating collar.
It is obvious that this form cannot be placed in any one of
Stein’s divisions of ciliate Infusoria, but must stand alone.
made at Naples in the winter of 1871-72. 97
Gregarina sipuncult.
I may refer here to a paper in the ‘Quart. Journ. Micr. Sci.’
October 1872, in which I have described some facts relating to
the development of this form, and figured the pseudo-Navicula
or spore-form, the Moneran, pseudo-Cercarian, and Gregarina-
forms of this parasite.
Spectroscopic Observations.
Numerous observations with the spectroscope on a variety
of animal colouring-matters gave the following results.
Hemoglobin is present in the nerve-cord of Aphrodite acu-
leata, also in its pharyngeal muscular tissue, in muscles of the
dorsal fin of Hippocampus, in muscles of the pharynx of various
mollusks, in corpuscles in the blood of Solen legumen, in cor-
puscles in the perivisceral fluid of Glycera, of Capitella, of
Phoronis hippocrepia, and diffused in the perivisceral fluid of
Polia sanguirubra.
No characterizable absorption-bands could be obtained from
the blue pigment of Velella, from the blue pigment of Salpa
democratica, or from the red pigment of other Sa/pe, from the
red pigment of the foot of Cardium and other Lamellibranchs,
or trom the ved pigment of chromatophores of Loligo and other
red pigments of fish, &c., or from the madder-pink pigment
of the corpuscles of the perivisceral fluid of Sipunculus.
I cannot conclude this summary without pointing out how
great an advantage will be gained by zoologists in the station,
now nearly ready for work, which my friend Anton Dohrn has
erected on so magnificent a scale, by the devotion of his
private fortune and much energy and patience. It stands in
the Villa Reale, on the sea’s edge ; and there the naturalist will
not have to dispute and bargain with the intelligent but
rascally fishermen; all will be managed for him by the
employés of the station. Further, he will have the use of a
splendid library*, he will be able to keep his specimens with
ease in the tanks of the station, supplied with streams of sea-
water, and will have constantly the means of contemplating,
even when he may not wish to study minutely, those exquisite
forms which came in hundreds through my hands, but of which
I have here said nothing, with which the waters of the bay
are teeming.
* I take this opportunity of asking for contributions of zoological and
botanical books or papers to the library of the Naples station. Several
publishers in Germany have given valuable works; the Messrs, Engelmann
of Leipzig have presented the whole of their biological publications.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. x1. 7
98 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Geographical
XII.—On the Geographical Distribution, Migration, and Oc-
castonal Habitats of Whales and Dolphins (Cete). By Dr.
J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Dampier long ago observed that seals did not occur within
the tropics ; and Capt. Maury, in his Whale-Charts, shows that
the Sperm-Whale inhabits a belt of sea in or on each side of ~
the tropics in the Atlantic and another in the Pacifie Ocean,
which was avoided by the Right Whales as if it were a belt
of fire. Both these observations are correct in the main—
though a seal has been found in the West Indies, and some
Humpbacked Whales inhabit near Bermuda, and they and the
Finner off the coast of Brazil. The Sperm-Whale wanders
away from its usual habitat, to its own destruction, on both
sides of the tropical belt, and is carried by currents like the
gulf-stream as far north as Shetland and Norway, and very
likely as far south in the Antarctic Ocean.
This observation about the tropics is important, as showing
that the whales of the northern seas must be of different species
from those that inhabit the southern oceans; and the examination
of the animals, and especially of their skeletons, has shown the
truth of this fact, which is universal as far as I have been able
to examine and compare the bones of the Whalebone- Whales,
Dolphins, and Ziphioid Whales of the northern and southern
hemispheres, and seems also to show that each species has
defined limits.
Most whalers, in their writings, state that the whales visit
their usual fishing-grounds at stated periods, and inhabit certain
bays during their breeding-season, showing that they make
migrations, each species within its own district.
Whales and dolphins always inhabit sheltered bays during
the breeding-season; and the Whalebone-Whales generally
live in shallow water, not very far from the shore or over
sunken banks.
Unfortunately our knowledge of these animals is very Incom-
plete, as, the observation of them being attended with so many
difficulties, we have very imperfect accounts of the his-
tory and habits of the species which inhabit the North and
South Pacific, the South Atlantic, and the Indian Ocean.
Indeed it is only within the last few years that the species of
these seas have begun to be studied and determined. Before
that period they were confounded with the whales of the North
Atlantic, and included under general names (as Right Whales,
Finners, Humpbacks, Scrag-Whales, and Sulphur-bottoms)
which are now found to represent so many families or genera,
The study of the whales and dolphins of the North Atlantic
SIU Ss eS
Se ee ee
And la ase
S a
— ay
> oo <4
Ss
=
Distribution of Whales and Dolphins. 99
exhibits their geographical distribution and migrations, natural
or accidental, which give us some idea of what may be the
case with the whales of the other parts of the world, where
they are perhaps better developed than inthe North Atlantic ;
for there can be no doubt that commerce and, more especially,
steamboats in the North Atlantic have driven the northern
species further back and confined them more to the Arctic
regions, have destroyed many individuals, and limited the
breeding of the Mediterranean species and of those which in-
habit the southern districts of the North Atlantic, and that
several species that are now only found in a subfossil state,
imbedded in the alluvial soils of Sweden, Holland, and the
coasts of England, were formerly inhabitants of these seas.
The species that are now found in the North Atlantic may
be divided into :—first, those that inhabit the Arctic seas and
migrate or are accidentally brought south; secondly, those
which chiefly live and are bred in the Mediterranean, or in the
bays of the southern parts of the North Atlantic, and which
migrate and follow the shoals of fish towards the north. There
are no doubt some species, as the common Porpoise, the Pike
Whale, the common Finner, and the Goose Whale (Hype-
roodon), that breed in the middle district (on the coasts of
Germany, Holland, and Great Britain), and are found in the
more northern and more southern seas. On the other hand,
the Ziphius Sowerbiensis has been found in the German Ocean
only in its southern part and off the north coast of Scotland,
but is most abundant on the west coast of Ireland, belonging
as it does to a Mediterranean group (though not yet observed
in the Mediterranean) and perhaps only carried north by the
Gulf-stream.
Some species are essentially Arctic, as the Beluga and the
Monodon ; but even they are sometimes driven south, perhaps
by storms. Others, as the Pilot Whale, always proceed south
in large ‘schools :’? some keep on the west side of the North
Atlantic and go to the east coast of America; others keep on
the east side and are found on the west coast of Europe, the
east and west coasts of great Britain, the coasts of France
and Spain, and some in the Mediterranean; but the Medi-
terranean species is generally smaller and may be distinct.
The voracious and destructive Orca, or Killer, lives in smaller
groups, and seems to follow the same course as the Pilot
Whale; that is to say, Orca are found, in the Arctic and other
seas, as far south as the Mediterranean ; and, like the Pilot
Whales, the southern specimens are much the smallest. I
determined that we had two species of Killer on the British
coast ; and by a photograph sent me by the Royal Academy of
fied
100 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Geographical
Sweden I see they have discovered and recognized my second
species in Swedish seas, showing that both the British species
probably migrate from the north. The skull of the Mediter-
ranean Orca, though so much smaller, is very like those of the
Arctic and British ones.
The Grey Finner ( Cuvierius) is doubtless a northern species
that sometimes comes south; but one is not so certain of the
Broad-headed Whale (udolphius) and the gigantic Flat-back
(Sibbaldius), which have only been found so seldom in the
south part of the North Sea or German Ocean that it is im-
possible to say if they are northern or southern species. At
any rate we may make sure that an animal upwards of one
hundred feet long does not breed in the much-frequented
German Ocean; and neither genus has been discovered in the
Arctie Ocean or in the Mediterranean sea. Perhaps they are
the last remains of their race.
Thus the Dolphin (Delphinus delphis), the Grampus
(Grampus Cuviert), and the Petrorhynchus mediterraneus,
which are essentially Mediterranean species, following the fish
out from Gibraltar, come north down the coasts of Spain and
France, and impinge on the coasts of Hampshire, Devon, and
Cornwall along with the pilchards and mackerel. Some pro-
ceed to the left, up the German Ocean—and others to the nght,
either up the Irish Sea or the Atlantic Ocean on the west side
of Ireland, and they have rarely been found as far north as
Shetland or the coast of Norway ; but I am very doubtful if
these animals, like the Sperm-Whales, ever find their way
back.
A kind of whale exists in the Bay of Biscay: and we are
told that there was formerly a whale-fishery there ; but both it
and the Basque fisheries have long passed away. A whale at
distant periods has occurred, especially at the south-east corner,
which is probably the most quiet part of this stormy bay. The
occurrence of a specimen is a proof of the existence of enough
animals to carry on the race residing permanently in or occa-
sionally visiting the bay ; for we may make sure that it is not,
as some people seem to suppose, a spontaneous reproduction or
renewal of the species.
In January 1854 a cow whale and its calf were observed in
the Gulf of Gascony near San Sebastian : the calf was taken ;
but the mother escaped. The skeleton was preserved in sepa-
rate bones at Pampeluna; Eschricht obtaimed it by ex-
change for the museum at Copenhagen; and Professor
Reinhardt intends some day to describe and figure it. Itis said
to be quite different from the Greenland Whale; indeed Mr.
Flower informed me that it is a Zuntertus, with coarse whale-
Distribution of Whales and Dolphins. 101
bone and a bifid first rib. It has been called, but not described
as, Balena biscayensis by Eschricht. M. van Beneden has
made a species under this name from the cervical vertebree of a
whale found at Sainte Marguérite in the Mediterranean, the
subfossil cervical vertebree dredged up at Lyme Regis, and the
ear-bones of the Balena cisarctica trom the coast of North
America (!), never having seen either the skeleton at Copen-
hagen or a figure of it; and itis easy to see by the comparison
of the two cervical masses, which he gives on the same plate,
that they do not belong to the same species. It was possible
that this might be the same whale that occurs at Sainte Mar-
guérite in the Mediterranean, or might be the same as that
found at Lyme Regis, as that is consistent with what we know
of the habits of whales; but we have proof of its not being so ;
and it is not the one found in America, if Mr. Flower’s note is
correct.
The Arctic whales and dolphins on the western coast of the
Atlantic are numerous; Dr. Brown mentions two or three
Right Whales. Some of these migrate southwards down the
east coast of North America; and it is to be observed that some
of the Arctic species inhabit that side of the Atlantic which are
not found at all, or only as stragglers, on the north coast of
Europe. Some species, as Beluga, go much further south on
the coast of Labrador and Nova Scotia than they do on the
coast of Europe.
There were formerly whale-fisheries on the southern parts
of the west side of the Atlantic ; but, like those in the Bay of
Biscay, they no longer exist, the whales having been destroyed
or driven away by commerce. The south-western part of the
North Atlantic has forms peculiar to it, as is the case on the
eastern side; for as yet the Ziphioid Whales, the Grampi,
Delphinus, &c. have not been observed on the American coast,
nor does the Scrag-Whale (Agaphelus) occur on the coast of
Europe. This is very inconsistent with the theory that the
whales of the same species inhabit a belt across the Atlantic
and other oceans, each species occurring in a peculiar locality.
In the first volume of the ‘Philosophical Transactions’ (for
1665, p. 11) there is an account ‘fof the New American W hale-
fishing about Bermuda;” and at p. 132 there is ‘a further
Relation of the Whale-fishing about the Bermudas and the
Coast of New England and New Netherland ;” and it appears
that there then existed a Bermuda Company. ‘The writer ob-
serves, “these whales are met with between the coast of New
England and New Netherland, where they might be caught eight
or nine months in the year, whereas those about the Bermudas
are to be found there only in the months of February, March,
102 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Geographical
and April.” He particularly refers to the “'Trumpo,” which
is evidently the Sperm-Whale, one of which he says was
stranded in New England.
The Hon. Paul Dudley, in the ‘ Philosophical Transactions’
for 1724 (p. 256), writes an “Essay on the Natural History
of Whales . . . . found on the Coast of New England.”
He says he is particularly indebted to Mr. J.Coffin, some time at
the island of Nantucket, and Mr. Greenhouse, of Yarmouth near
Cape Cod, both of them places famous for the whale-fisheries.
These fisheries have now disappeared, the fisheries being now
carried on in the South Seas. He mentions :—
1. The Right or Whalebone Whale, which is probably a
true Balena.
2. The Scrag-Whale. This is evidently the Agaphelus
gibbosus of Cope, in character intermediate between the true
Whales and the Fin-backs. It has no dorsal fins or throat-folds.
This animal probably goes south, and is the ‘‘ Norwega” of
Bahia mentioned by Dr. Hartt.
3. The Fin-back Whale is most probably a Physalus ; but
the North-American Fin-backs have not been described. It
may be the same species that goes south as far as Bahia; and
they are called “ Mystica.”” They first appear, according to
Dr. Hartt, in the Abrolhos waters at the end of May, and stay
until November; the females often brmg their young calves
with them and seek the shelter of the reets.
4, The Bunch or Humpback-Whale is probably the JMega-
ptera osphyia of Cope, described from a skeleton in the museum
at Niagara, which he thinks is one of the largest species of
Balenide, and may be the same as Megaptera americana of
Bermuda.
5. The Sperma Cete Whale.
The same migrations or circummigrations appear in the
southern part of the Atlantic and the southern seas. Dr.
Dieffenbachinformsus that the Sperm- Whale, the Black Whale,
the Finner, and the Humpback are found in Cook’s Straits in
New Zealand. The Sperm-Whale inhabits the open sea and
does not approach shallow coasts and inlets, as is the habit of
the other whales. The Finner and Humpback are seldom
captured, on account of their wildness and celerity ; and they
contain only a small quantity of oil. Almost all the Black
Whales caught are females and their calves; indeed it is the
affection of the mother for her young that causes her sacri-
fice, the young being taken to secure the parent. The male
is very rarely caught; he never approaches the land so near
as the female, and is more shy and wild. The cows ap-
proach the shallow coast and smooth waters for the purpose
Distribution of Whales and Dolphins. 103
of bringing forth their young, and are generally accompanied
by the calf of the preceding year, called a“scrag,” which does
not leave its mother till it attains its full size. The Black
Whale is truly a migratory animal; it arrives in Cook’s
Straits from the northward at the beginning of May, then
passes along the coast of the northern island to Entry Island,
then sweeping into Cloudy Bay ; and then at the end of October
they go to the eastward or return to the northward; and many
whales are to be found in the “whaling-ground” which
extends from Chatham Island to the eastward of the north-
ern island of New Zealand and thence to Norfolk Island;
and the whalers say this district is a shoal. Besides this
migration, which rather ought to be called a circumnavigation
of a limited district, there exists a daily one; the whales ap-
proach the shores and bays with the flood tide and quit them
with the ebb; they are often seen in places where the depth
of water does not exceed their own breadth (Dieffenbach’s
Travels in New Zealand, vol. i. pp. 44-47). The whalers
thought they were the same species that were found at the Cape
of Good Hope, which are known to have similar habits, as
also have the Black Whales at Van Diemen’s Land; but I
now know, from the examination of the skeletons, that there
are two Black Whales im New Zealand, both of which are
quite different from the two Black Whales that inhabit the Cape
of Good Hope.
Mr. E. Hartt, in his ‘ Physical Geography of Brazil,’ ob-
serves :—The first whales (Physalus brasiliensis, Gray) appear
in the Abrolho waters at about the end of May, and they stay
till October. The females often bring their young calves with
them, and appear to seek the shelter of the rocks. ‘The fishery
begins at Bahia, according to Castelnau, at about the 13th of
June, and lasts till the 21st of September; at Caravellas I was
assured the whales always appeared later than at Bahia.”
Further south, the Finners in passing the Rio de la Plata
ascend that river ; and Professor Burmeister has described from
the skeletons of the whales in the museum of Buenos Ayres,
obtained near that city, no less than three distinct species of
Physalus (see Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1872, x. p. 413).
Wherever there are whale-fisheries (as in Walvisch Bay
near the Cape, Cook’s Straits at New Zealand, and Caravellas,
and especially Bahia) the bones of the whales killed form large
banks, as many as 500 to 1000 whales or more on the same
spot (indeed in Walvisch Bay the bank is said to be several
miles in length), showing great destruction of these animals in
these seas as well as in the northern ones.
In the ‘Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist.’ 1870, vi. pp. 391-394, is
104 Dr. J. Hector on the Whales and
a list of the species of whales according to the countries in which
they have been observed.
XITI.— Notes on the Whales and Dolphins of the New-Zealand
Seas. By Dr. JAMes Hector, F.R.S. With Remarks by
Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
1. Neobalena marginata, Gray.
The tympanic bone of the type of this species in the Colonial
Museum agrees exactly with the ear-bone on which is founded
Caperea nove-zealandie, Gray (Cat. Seals & Whales, p. 101).
Practical whalers, after examining the baleen of this whale,
affirm that it is the Fin-fish or Sulphur-bottom, and that it
grows to an immense size. It is not the Finner, which has
the dorsal fin further back. They judge by the colour of the
baleen.
2. Eubalena australis, Gray. (The Black Whale.)
Balena antipodarum, Gray.
Whalers do not distinguish two species ; and if the tympanic
bone of the second species cited belongs to Neobalena mar-
ginata, there is no evidence that the Black Whale of New
Zealand is different from that of the Cape.
3. Megaptera nove-zealandie, Gray.
This species is also founded on a tympanic bone. A whale,
34 feet long, with a falcate dorsal fin, stranded in Wellington
Harbour, has a similar ear-bone, and may be this species.
The bones were unfortunately lost.
4, Physalus australis, Gray.
(The Southern Finner or Razor-back.)
Physalus antarcticus, Gray.
The only reason given for distinguishing the above is the
colour of the baleen. Whalers state the baleen of the Finner
to be very variable in colour, even from the same individual.
5. Catodon macrocephalus, Lacép. (The Sperm-W hale.)
Several varieties of teeth are in the museum, and must
belong to different species.
6. Delphinus novee-zealandie, Quoy & Gaim,
A skull of this species in the museum has the intermaxillary
Dolphins of the New-Zealand Seas. 105
plates united, so as to form the nasal groove into a tube through-
out two thirds of its length.
7. Delphinus Forstert, Gray.
A skull in the museum agrees in its dentition with this
species. It differs from the preceding species in the greater
proportional width of the beak and more perpendicular fore-
head, the width of the middle part of the beak being con-
tained four times in the length from the notch, while in D. nove-
zealandie it 1s six times.
8. Electra clancula, Gray.
The generic character requires to be amended by leaving out
the second dorsal lobe, which is not present in this species.
9. Pseudorca meridionalis, Flower. (Tasmanian Blackfish.)
An imperfect skull found in Lyall Bay appears to belong to
this species.
10. Grampus Richardsoni, Gray.
A lower jaw found on the Munawutu beach agrees with
this, except that it has only three instead of four teeth on each
side.
11. Beluga Kingii, Gray.
A very imperfect skull, in the collection of the late Mr.
Swainson, appears to resemble this species. A large white
Porpoise is frequently seen at certain seasons in Blind Bay,
and may be this species.
12. Globiocephalus macrorhynchus, Gray.
(New-Zealand Blackfish.)
Several skulls, more or less perfect, are in the museum, one
from the Chatham Islands.
The same trivial name (Blackfish) is also applied to a
small species of Sperm-Whale.
13. Epiodon chathamiensis, sp. nov.
Beak of skull tapering, callous, with a slight upward curve.
Vomer forming a posteriorly truncate callous ridge, depressed
between the intermaxillaries. Upper jaw toothless. Lower
jaw elongate, bent up, truncate, with two terminal, short, sub-
cylindrical teeth in shallow sockets, and in front of a long
dental groove.
106 Dr. J. Hector on the Whales and
Skull: Chatham Islands (coll. G. H. Travers).
Weight of teeth 817 and 836 grains.
inches
Total lengthy 156; 4 .oya 2. hades ete ot eee 36
Width-at orbits* “0. 3... coms 5.1c,- eee 20
: Hotel. 3. SARE eae eee 12
Length of beak.) 0)... sai. ld. ee eee 18
¥o|) “Deane cawaty 3 npt..teie- oe 6
47 ‘sperm=cayaby 9) .)fi21../c07 ey. see 12
si JOWOPAONG 15 ted) Pe ycioat ade gsm 30
Height: of ramis’t sti-s'c chet ee ee cf
The beak is trigonal, three times as long as the brain-cavity
measured internally. The vomer is not observed in the profile
as in Petrorhynchus capensis ; otherwise the general structure of
the skull agrees with that species. The teeth are ground down,
each with two lateral facets and a central ridge; as these
teeth, when the mouth is closed, are beyond the lower jaw,
there is probably a callosity on the upper lip against which
they are applied.
Two teeth of another individual are in the museum, with
triple facets.
This species may be the same as Epiodon australis, Burm.,
of which I have no description.
14. Mesoplodon Layardit.
Lower jaw with teeth: Chatham Islands (coll. G. H.
Travers).
Total length 33 inches ; symphysis one third of total length.
Hinder edge of the teeth is 18 inches from the condyle ; and
their length along the jaw is 5 inches, the anterior margin
being in advance of the commencement of the symphysis ; no
notch on the edge of the jaw posterior to the teeth. The teeth
are 6 inches long, 3 inches wide, and 3inch thick. ‘The acute
point in the upper and forward angle is very marked ; there is a
deep rough notch worn on the anterior margin ; and the com-
pressed root of the tooth shows seven distinct fangs. The teeth
are directed obliquely backwards and inwards, but do not
approach so as to close over the beak, as described in the type
of the species (Cat. Seals & Whales, p. 353).
15. Berardius Hector’, Gray. (Scamperdown Whale.)
Berardius Hectori, Gray, Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. viii. p. 116 (August
1871).
Mesoplodon, sp., Flower, Nature, Dee. 7, 1871, p. 105.
Teeth 5. Body fusiform ; head rounded, beaked ; upper lip
long and flexible; eye halfway between angle of mouth and
wa
——
et — ee — ee ee
Dolphins of the New-Zealand Seas. 107
pectorals, which are small; dorsal over the tail; tail-lobes
large, faleate—Know.
Skull globular, with a slender conical beak. The intermaxil-
laries form thin linear callous plates, incurved over a deep groove
that extends back from the snout to the blow-holes, as in Dol-
phins; they then expand to form a flat lunate area in front of
the blow-holes, and rise behind to form moderate knob-like
crests that are separated by a notch, owing to the feeble de-
velopment of the nasals. ‘The maxillaries commence as lateral
plates some distance from the top of the beak, but expand
behind into slightly concave areas. The blowers are straight,
vertical, and almost equally developed.
Before I had seen Berardius Arnouxit I took this for the
young of that species ; but it differs in the presence of crests
over the blow-holes, feeble nasals, narrower beak, and more
compressed teeth.
The tympanic bones of the two species have a close resem-
blance.
A second, fragmentary skull, of exactly the same form and
dimensions as that described above (see also Trans. N.-Z. Inst.
vol. ili.), has been lately obtained in a sandy deposit near
Wanganui.
16. Berardius Arnouxti, Duv.
Ziphioid whale with skull like a Porpoise.
The specimen in the museum has the first three cervicals
united, and the fourth united by the neural arch.
The preceding species has the first two thoroughly united
and the third by its spines; the rest are free, not united, as
might be inferred from the description (Trans. N.-Z. Inst. in.
p- 129), where the term combined cervical vertebre referred
only to the manner in which they are sketched.
Remarks on some of the Species in the foregoing paper.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
This paper was received from Dr. Hector yesterday morning
(December 26, 1872). As it is marked ‘“‘abstract,” probably it
refers to a paper that he has sent to the New-Zealand Institute.
He does not say, in his letter on other subjects which accom-
panies it, what 1 am to do with it; but I suppose it is sent for
publication in the ‘Annals,’ as others received in the same way.
It contains many most valuable observations, and adds con-
siderably to our knowledge of the Cetacea of the southern
regions; it is very interesting as confirming the existence of
the genera Grampus and Beluga in the southern or Antarctic
108 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Whales and
seas. It is accompanied by tracings of the skull of Hpzodon
chathamiensis, of the lower jaw of Mesoplodon Layardit, of the
ear-bones (represented half the natural size) of Neobalena
marginata, Megaptera?, Berardius Arnouxii, and Berardius
Hectort.
1. Neobalena marginata.
The discovery that the baleen named Balena marginata,
and that the ear-bones on which I first established the genus
Caperea, belong to this whale is entirely due to Dr. Hector; and
I gladly accept the correction, although it has always appeared
to me that the baleen is very narrow and long for a whale with
such a broad upper jaw compared with that of the northern
Right Whale ; but that may be a peculiarity of the group. The
combination of characters thus brought together mdicates an
entirely new group of whales, which I propose to call Neoba-
lenide.
The form of the skull and ear-bones is peculiar and very
different from that of any known group of Cetacea; and I have
always found that the characters derived from these parts are
connected with peculiar modifications of the external form.
The removal of the ear-bone of Neobalena from the family
Balenide makes the character from that bone in that family
as uniform as it is in the other families of Balenoidea. In
form and structure the whalebone is finer, but very similar
to that of the Greenland Right Whale, and shows an affinity
of this family to the Baleenide ; but the structure of the head
is more like that of the Physalidee, as far as we can judge from
the figure, never having had an opportunity of seeing the skull
itself. The dilated character of the lower jaw is very peculiar,
and no doubt characteristic. The face, or rather maxille and
intermaxille, is broad for a whale having such long and slender
baleen,
We await the discovery and the description of the complete
Neobalena with great anxiety. If it is the Sulphur-bottom or
Fin-fish it will be even more interesting, as removing that
often-mentioned and hitherto undetermined whale from our
books.
The synonyms will therefore run thus :—
Balena marginata, Gray, Zool. Erebus & Terror, p. 48, t. 1. f. 1 (baleen
only).
Caperea antipodarum, Gray, P. Z. S. 1864, p. 202, fig.; Cat. Seals &
Whales, p. 101, f. 9 (ear-bone only); part only of Suppl. Cat.
Neobalena marginata, Gray, Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1870, v. p. 221, vi.
p- 155, figs. 1 & 2; Suppl. Cat. p. 40, figs. 1 & 2 (skull only).
Tapplied the name of C. antipodarum tothis species, believing
it to be the Black Whale of New Zealand, of which Dr. Dief-
Dolphins of the New-Zealand Seas. 109
fenbach had brought such an accurate figure ; and I was con-
firmed in thinking that it was the same as the skeleton from
New Zealand which was in the Paris Museum, by the obser-
vations of Milne-Edwards, Professor Lilljeborg, and Van
Beneden, who, though the skeleton had lost its ear-bones,
seemed to feel no doubt that it was the skeleton of the whale
the ear-bones of which I figured. I have never seen the
skeleton myself; for when I was in Paris they considered the
skeleton a duplicate of the one they had set up, and not
worth my seeing.
I think it better to retain the name of Neobalena for this
genus. The genus Caperea, though first established on the
ear-bone of this genus, has had its character enlarged by the
study of the Paris skeleton ; and it would produce less change
of name to retain Caperea for the whale the skeleton of which
| is at Paris ; otherwise we should have to form a new name for
| that genus ; but doubtless there will be some one who, wishing
to append his name to a new-named old genus, will give it
another appellation.
As the specimen in the Paris Museum has lost its ear-bones,
M. van Beneden has added to the figure of that skeleton the
figure of some ear-bones, said to have come from New Zealand,
in the Belgian Museum. Now,as there are at least two Black or
Right Whales with very different shoulder-blades that inhabit
| the seas of New Zealand, it is not possible to say to which of
these species the specimens figured by M. van Beneden belong.
2. Hubalena australis.
There are at least two Black Whales in New Zealand ; and
| as yet I have no evidence that the Hubalena australis has been
| taken in New-Zealand seas. It is doubtful to which of the
two Right Whales the animal figured by Dr. Dieffenbach really
| belongs. I applied to this figure the names of Balena antip-
darum (Dieffenb. New Zeal. t.1) and Balena antarctica (Voy.
Erebus and Terror, t. 1); but as this has been applied to the
skeleton of the New-Zealand whale in the Paris Museum by
M. Milne-Edwards, Prof. Lilljeborg, myself, and M. van
Beneden in his ‘Ostéographie des Cétacés,’ I believe it will be
better to retain it for that species. The form of the bladebone,
which is different from that of all the other Right Whales
| known, is not likely to be connected with a change in the ex-
| ternal form of the animal.
The synonyms will run thus :—
Balena antipodarum, Gray, Dieffenb. New Zeal. tab. 1 (animal).
Balena antarctica, Gray, Zool. Erebus & Terror, Cet. p. 16, tab. 1 (ani-
mal, not Lesson nor Owen),
110 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Whales and
- Caperea antipodarum, Lilljeborg; Gray, Cat. Seals & Whales, p. 371,
Suppl. p. 45 (not ear-bones).
Balena antipodarum, Van Beneden, Ostéog. Cét. tab. 3 (skeleton; ear-
bones doubtful).
The second Black Whale is Macleayius australiensis, a
skeleton of which is in the British Museum (noticed in the
Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1873, vol. xi. p. 75), and which is de-
scribed and will be published in the ‘ Proceedings of the Zoolo-
gical Society’ for 1873. It was sent from the coast of Canter-
bury, New Zealand, as Balena antipodarum, by Dr. Haast.
T at first thought, from the similarity of the ear-bones, that it
was the Hubalena australis ; but it is extremely different from
this.
3. Megaptera novee-zealandie. °
The whale stranded at Wellington Harbour with “a falcate
dorsal” is most probably a Physalus ; for the peculiar character
of Megaptera is to have merely a hunch instead of a dorsal fin,
and elongate pectoral fins. ‘The ear-bones of Megaptera and
Physalus are nearly similar ; and therefore it is most probably
Physalus antarcticus. The colour of the baleen may vary, as
the whalers say the character and texture are very different—so
distinct that a dealer in these articles can distinguish the
baleen of the Finners of the different countries, and they fetch
different prices.
8. Electra clancula, Gray.
I do not know what Dr. Hector’s remark refers to; perhaps
it does not refer to my description. I published a description
and figure which Dr. Hector sent to me in the ‘Ann. & Mag.
Nat. Hist.’ 1872, ix. p. 436, fig.
10. Grampus Richardsoni.
The number of teeth varies in the different specimens of the
European species.
13. Epiodon chathamiensis, and
14. Mesoplodon Layardit.
I have not seen the skull of Zpiodon australis ; but as yet I
have never seen a species of whale or seal common to the coast
of South America and New Zealand. It may be different with
the Cape of Good Hope and Australia and New Zealand ; but
I have seen no decided instance of the same species occurring —
in two countries; therefore I can give no decided opinion re-
specting the jaw of Mesoplodon Layardii.
At the same time I may observe that the Mesoplodon
Layardti, or, as I should call it, Dolichodon Layardi, has a much
Dolphins of the New-Zealand Seas. 111
longer and more attenuated lower jaw, and much slenderer
teeth, than the Chatham-Island specimen, figured and described
by Dr. Hector under that name; and I have very little doubt
in my own mind that the Chatham-Island specimen will be
found, when more perfect specimens are obtained, to be the
representative of a very distinct species of Dolichodon, which
I would propose provisionally to designate as Dolichodon Tra-
versii—a curious comment on the comparative anatomists, who
think that Dolichodon Layardi of the Cape, Callidon Giintheri
of New South Wales, Petrorhynchus capensis of the Cape, &e.
‘all differ in so trifling a degree as not to exceed the range of
individual variations one often meets with in comparing a series
of skulls of the same species.” Surely the author means
of the same domestic animals, and entirely leaves out of the
question the experience gained by the study of wild ones and
the evidence afforded by the study of their geographical distri-
bution.
I must think that when these authors become more expe-
rienced they will wish their observations to have a “ tacit
burial and oblivion,” and perhaps themselves learn how to
define genera and species.
15. Berardius Hector.
I know nothing of this skull except from Dr. Hector’s
figures and description: and theskull hasnever been in England;
so that I do not think that any comparative anatomist has had
the opportunity of seeing it. Dr. Hector considered it the
young of B. Arnouxt. I at once saw that it was different ; but
as it has the teeth in the front of the jaw like Berardius, I
considered it best (and am still of the same opinion) to retain
it in that genus, with which it agrees in the position of its
teeth as developed in the adult animal, and in geographical
distribution ; and Dr. Hector’s tracings of the ear-bones of the
two species show that there is a great affinity between them in
the very peculiar manner in which those bones are dotted. I con-
sider the position of the teeth a more important zoological cha-
racter than a slight difference in the “conformation of the naso-
premaxillary region,” a part that, as every zoologist who has
examined several skulls of different ages in the same species
of Cetacea knows, is very apt to vary ; but when a comparative
anatomist draws his conclusions from figures, or the examination
of a single specimen of a group, he is often liable to be misled
as to the value of the characters to which he attaches much
importance. Nothing showed this better than the published
results of the labours of a comparative anatomist who has
named, but not defined, a multitude of species and genera from
112 Mr. A. G. Butler on the Genus Gonyleptes.
fragments of fossil bones, but who when he attempted to name
recent skulls, as of crocodiles (of which he has perfect specimens
under his eyes), named, described, and published what are now
regarded as three distinct species in one case, and two distinct
species in another, under the same name, and, on the other
hand, a series of skulls of the same species under three different
names (see Trans. Zool. Soc. vi. 1869, p. 127), and who mixes
up together under one name the skulls of two such large and
distinct animals as a one-horned and a two-horned rhinoceros
as a double-horned one (see Proc. Zool. Soc. 1867, p. 1015). I
need not (but could) refer to many more instances of the same
kind. Iam in the habit of estimating, from what is written
about what I know, the reliance I may place upon what is
written of what I do not know, and have thus lost my confidence
in this author’s writings on zoological questions.
It is an old complaint that persons will write about what they
have a limited knowledge of. Thus the comparative anatomists
are always giving their opinions on the limits and definitions
of genera and the names that ought to be used—subjects not
much in their way, and on which they have very crude ideas.
What would they say if a zoologist interfered with their ana-
tomical details, their confused nomenclature of bones, and their
much controverted homologies ? But it is the more remarkable,
when we consider how very few animals have been dissected,
and how imperfectly those that have been dissected have been
described, as is proved by their own papers (see for instance Mr.
Clark’s paper on the hippopotamus, ‘Proc. Zool. Soc.’ 1872,
p. 185), that an anatomist should leave his subject and diverge
to write upon the synonyma of species and the priority of names,
all of which is mere compilation on his part.
XIV.—A Monographie List of the Species of the Genus Gony-
leptes, with Descriptions of three remarkable new Species.
By ArTHUR GARDINER BUTLER, F.L.S., F.Z.8., &e.
[Plate III.]
Family Gonyleptide, Wood.
Genus GONYLEPTES *, Kirby.
1. Gonyleptes horridus.
Gonyleptes horridns, Kirby, Trans. Linn. Soe. xii. p. 452, pl. 22. fig. 16
(1818).
Gonyleptes curvipes ?, Koch (nec Guérin), Arachn, vii. pl. 224. fig. 555
(1839). ;
Hab. “Brazil” (Kirby); Surinam. One example. B.M.
* I take this genus in its restricted sense, as used by Gervais (‘Aptéres,’
iii. pp. 102-105). Wood, in his recent papers on Gonyleptide: and Pha-
langidee, applies it equally to Gontosoma and Cosmetus !
Mr. A. G. Butler on the Genus Gonyleptes. 113
2. Gonyleptes aculeatus.
Gonyleptes aculeatus, Kirby, Trans. Linn. See. xii. p. 452 (1818).
Var. ? Faucheur acanthure, Duméril, Dict. Sc. Nat., Ent. pl. 60. figs.
14-16 (1819).
Gonyleptes acanthurus, Gervais, Aptéres, iii. p. 105, pl. 46, fig. 2 (1844).
Hab. Monte Video (Darwin). 'Two examples. B.M.
3. Gonyleptes scaber.
Gonyleptes scaber, Kirby, Trans. Linn. Soe. xii. p. 453 (1818); Koch,
Arachn. vii, pl. 223. figs. 553, 554 (1889).
Hab. Monte Video?; Valdivia (Cuming). Three examples.
B.M.
4, Gonyleptes acanthopus.
Phalangium acanthopus, Quoy & Gaim. Voy. de l’Uranie, Zool. p. 546,
pl. 62. figs. 2, 5, 3, 9 (1824).
Eusarcus grandis, Perty, Del. Anim. p. 206, pl. 40. fig. 2, 2 (1830-34).
Gonyleptes horridus, Koch, Arachn. vii. pl. 222. figs. 551, 552 (1839).
Hab. Brazil. Five examples. B.M.
5. Gonyleptes asperatus.
Gonyleptes asperatus, Gervais, Gay’s Chili, Zool., ¢Arachn. pl. 1. fig. 9
(1849).
Hab. Chili.
6. Gonyleptes planiceps.
Gonyleptes planiceps, Gervais, Mag. de Zool., Arachn. pl. 2; Aptéres, iil.
p- 105 (1844); Gay’s Chili, Zool., Arachn. pl. 1. fig. 10 (1849).
Hab. Chili.
7. Gonyleptes pectinatus.
Gonyleptes pectinatus, Koch, Arachn. xii. pl. 402. fig. 971 (1845).
? Gonyleptes curvipes, Koch, Arachn. vii. pl. 224. fig. 555 (1839),
Hab. “Bahia” (Koch); near Rio Janeiro (A. Fry). One
example. B.M.
8. Gonyleptes curvipes.
Gonyleptes curvipes, Guérin, Icon. du Régne Anim., Arachn. pl. 4. fig. 5
1842-49); Gervais, Aptéres, iii. p. 104, pl. 46. fig. 1 (1844); Gay’s
hili, Zool., Arachn. pl. 1. fig. 6 (1849).
Gonyleptes chilensis, G. R Gray, Anim. Kingd., Arachn. pl. 20. fig. 2.
Hab. Chili. Four examples. B.M.
9. Gonyleptes armatus.
Gonyleptes armatus, Perty, Del. Anim. p. 205, pl. 39. fig. 18 (1830-34),
Hab. Rio Negro.
G. spinipes and asper of Perty are referred by Koch to his
enus Ampheres ; G. curvispina and elegans to his genus Ce-
us
‘Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 8
114 Mr. A. G. Butler on the Genus Gonyleptes.
10. Gonyleptes acanthops.
Gonyleptes acanthops, Gervais, Gay’s Chili, Zool., Arachn. pl. 1, fig. 4
(1849).
Hab. Chili.
There is a species nearly allied to this in the British Museum.
11. Gonyleptes bicuspidatus.
Gonyleptes bicusprdatus, Koch, Arachn, vii. pl. 224. fig, 556 (1839).
Hab, Brazil (Koch).
12. Gonyleptes muticus.
Gonyleptes muticus, Koch, Arachn. vii. pl. 225. fig. 557 (1839).
Hab. Brazil (Koch).
13. Gonyleptes polyacanthus.
Gonyleptes polyacanthus, Gervais, Gay's Chili, Zool., Arachn. pl. 1. fig. 7
(1849).
Hab. “Chili” (Gervais); ——? One example. B.M.
14. Gonyleptes modestus.
Gonyleptes modestus, Gervais, Gay’s Chili, Zool., Arachn, in vol. iv.
p- 23. n. 4 (1849).
Hab. Chili? ; Valdivia (Cuming). Two examples. B.M.
15. Gonyleptes bicornis.
Gonyleptes bicornis, Gervais, Gay’s Chili, Zool., Arachn. in vol. iv. p. 21.
n. 2 (1849).
Hab. Chili.
16. Gonyleptes subsimilis.
Gonyleptes subsimilis, Gervais, Gay’s Chili, Zool., Arachn. pl. 1. fig. 8
(1849).
Gonyleptes polyacanthoides, Gervais, Aptéres, iv. p. 577 (1847 ?)*.
Hab. Chil.
Seems to be a female closely allied to G@. aculeatus ?;
several of the species at present referred to the genus Gloniosoma
have much the same aspect, and may possibly have to be re-
ferred to this genus when we know both sexes of them. The
two genera have been somewhat artificially separated; but I
have thought it better to leave them for the present as Gervais
left them.
G. ornatum of Say, recently figured and redescribed by
Wood as a Gonyleptes, in which genus Gervais also retained
it (Apt.iv.p. 344), belongs to the genus Cosmetus (Phalangide),
, nr reference is given at p. 576 to the pagination and plates of Gay’s
ili.’
Mr. A. G. Butler on the Genus Gonyleptes. 115
the palpi being unarmed. We have four examples from
Georgia, where the type also was taken; they agree closely
with Say’s description, but not with Wood’s.
With regard to the species recently described from Ecuador
(Trans. Am. Phil. Soc. n. s. xiii. 1869, pp. 435-440, pl. xxiv.),
G. predo, G. injucundus, and G. spinipalpus appear to be
Goniosomata, and G. multimaculatus a mutilated and greasy
example of Cosmetus cordatus; the species (O. marginatus)
forming the new genus Octophthalmus is unknown to me at
present ; O. bilunata®* and O. ferox, forming the genus Or-
tonia, are also unknown to me, although the latter appears to
be congeneric with Gloniosoma raptator of Gervais, which I
have always considered the type of a distinct genus.
The following are new species :—
17. Gonyleptes armillatus, n. sp. Pl. TIT. figs. 1, 2.
Colours: above pitchy, the marginal tubercles of cephalo-
thorax tawny in the centre ; tarsi ochraceous ; palpi olivaceous ;
below brownish in parts, the joints of the legs testaceous ;
mandibles or chele olivaceous, their pincers ferruginous.
Male. Above with oculiferous tubercle prominent, arched
forwards, and obtusely bifurcate ; immediately behind it and
in front of the transverse suture two groups of five to six
minute tubercles ; central atea of cephalothorax transversely
ovate, margined on either side by six gradually imcreasing
prominent tubercles, and in front of these to just above the
suture by a series of minute shining granules; bearing on
either side a robust obtuse incurved spine above base of cox
of hind legs; distinctly convex and crossed by six to seven
transverse irregular series of moderate-sized tubercles, besides
six prominent central ones placed longitudinally in pairs ;
posterior area trisegmented, tuberculate, second segmentation
bearing a prominent terminal spine: legs short, coarsely rugose,
spinous, pilose; hind legs with coxe obtusely spinous ; femora
coarsely tuberculate, externally obtusely dentate-spinous ;
tibie coarsely tuberculate: sternal surface entirely tuberculate
and pilose, as also the segments of the abdomen ; palpi (“‘ man-
dibules palpiformes” of Gervais) of moderatelength, compressed,
with slender spines ; cheliceres short, pilose, the chele cylin-
drical, pincers minutely serrated internally.
* This species has quite the aspect of a Cosmetus, so far as one can
judge by the figure; but the description says, “Palpi ... . penulti-
mate joint broadly dilated, somewhat triangular, thin, and armed with
minute slender spines on its margins, and a pair of larger ones on its distal
end; the distal article more cylindrical, with one or more acute spines,,
against which the movable claw works.”
8*
116 Mr. A. G. Butler on the Genus Gonyleptes.
Length of cephalothorax 4 lines ; relative length of legs 1,
3, 4, 2, the second pair being the longest.
Female. Differs chiefly in its narrower cephalothorax, which
has smaller tubercles and less strongly developed lateral spines ;
the legs also are much less spinose.
Hab. Ecuador (Buckley). g¢ 9. B.M.
Must be placed next to G. curvipes, but is a very distinct
and beautiful form.
18. Gonyleptes ancyrophorus, n. sp. Pl. III. figs. 5, 6.
Colours: cephalothorax above pitchy, becoming testaceous
at the margins; legs black-brown, with coxe ochraceous and
base of femora ferruginous; femora of hind legs entirely fer-
ruginous ; palpi blackish olivaceous, terminal claw and points
of spines ochraceous ; cheliceres olivaceous, with pincers ochra-
ceous; body below dirty testaceous, clouded with olivaceous,
and becoming blackish posteriorly.
Cephalothorax above with oculiferous tubercle prominent,
bearing two well-developed and moderately acute divergent
spines; entire dorsum unusually convex; posterior area tra-
pezoidal, and bearing on its hinder margin two slightly diver-
gent and well-developed acute spines ; legs long, smooth ; hind
legs irregularly spined along inner margin of femora; palpi
rather longer than cephalothorax, their joints more or less
cylindrical, irregular, coarsely spined; cheliceres with second
joint above trispinose behind ; chele rather large, fixed finger
with two obtuse teeth on its inner margin: inferior surface
smooth, the metasternum bearing on either side (about halfway
between the third and fourth pair of legs) a strong acute per-
pendicular spine, and on its outer margin, below the retracted
abdominal segments, a long, thick, incurved, and nearly per-
pendicular horny process, bifurcate at its tip.
Length of cephalothorax 4 lines; relative length of legs,
apparently, 1, 3, 2, 4.
Hab. Quito (W. C. Hewitson). B.M.
Not nearly allied to any described species.
19. Gonyleptes telifer,n. sp. Pl. III. figs. 3, 4.
Colours almost as in G. armillatus, but (with the exception
of the cheliceres) rather darker ; under surface of body pitchy.
Cephalothorax similar in general form to that of G. armil-
latus ; irregularly tuberculate, marginal tubercles smaller, some
of them obtusely spinose ; oculiferous tubercle very prominent,
bispinose ; six central tubercles of cephalothorax elongated into
obtuse spines, the hindmost pair being the longest; margin.
On the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 117
above base of coxee of hind legs bearing two widely divergent
obtuse spines ; posterior area trisegmented, tuberculate, second
segmentation bearing a prominent central acute spine, third
segmentation terminating in a long, feebly curved, and very
robust spine, three lines in length; legs long, rugose, denticu-
late; hind legs, with the exception of the femora, internally
dentated; body below, including abdomen, coarsely tuberculate;
palpi moderately long, subcylindrical, with slender spines ;
cheliceres small ; the chelee cylindrical, pilose, pincers crossing
at the tips and strongly denticulate internally.
Length of cephalothorax (excluding terminal spine) 44 lines ;
relative length of legs 1, 3, 2, 4.
Hab, Kga (Bates). One specimen. B.M.
Most nearly allied to G. armillatus, but in general appear-
ance utterly unlike any thing previously described: it reminds
me of a similarly ornamented fossil torm described by Mr.
Henry Woodward (Geol. Mag. vol. viii. p. 355, pl. xi. 1871)
as Hophrynus Prestvicti (Curculioides of Samouelle) ; the latter,
however, excepting in ornamentation, appears to come nearer
to Ischyropsalis of Koch.
XV.—WNotes on the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America.
By H. W. Bates, F.L.S.
[Continued from p. 45. |
Genus ACYPHODERES.
Serville, Ann. Soc. Ent. Fr. 1838, p. 549; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p. 505.
The character given by Serville as distinguishing this genus
was the broadly ovate depressed uneven thorax. A more
constant feature is the rather abruptly subulate elytra. The
thorax is sometimes oblong-ovate and convex. The antenne
in all the species are robust and strongly serrated.
I. Apew of elytra entire.
A. Thorax without dorsal ridges.
1. Acyphoderes crinitus, Klug.
Stenopterus crintus, Klug, Entom. Bras, Specim. alter. p. 56, t. xliy.
fi.
Rio Janeiro,
2. Acyphoderes mestus, n. sp.
A, niger, velutinus, dense breviter hirsutus; thorace elongato, sub-
118 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
ovato, postice constricto; elytris disco fuscescenti-albis vitreis.
Long. 9 lin. ¢.
Prov. Parand, Brazil (coll. W.. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Allied to A. crinitus (Klug). More slender and elongate.
Hind tibie with the apical half dilated externally, and densely
clothed with rather short black hairs. Head slender; muzzle
greatly elongated and narrow; eyes (male) nearly approaching
in front the mesial line. Antenne rather slender ; jomts dilated
at the apex, and serrate from the fifth joint. Thorax similar in
form to thatof A.crinitus, but narrower, considerably constricted
near the base; disk depressed. LElytra subulate, reaching
scarcely the middle of the fourth segment; disk pale, vitreous ;
borders black, not clearly defined. Beneath, the breast clothed
in the middle with a dense woolly tawny-grey pubescence ;
metasternum very broad, keeled down the middle. Abdomen
(male) slender, cylindrical; terminal ventral segment with
two elevated ridges, with their anterior angles projecting and
pointed. Legs black; hind femora elongate, gradually clavate.
3. Acyphoderes femoratus, Klug.
Stenopterus femoratus, Klug, Entom. Bras. Specim. alter. p. 57, t. xliv.
f MONT Siz
Acyphoderes brachialis, Pascoe, Journ. of Entom. i. p. 3869, ¢.
Brazil.
Pascoe’s description agrees closely with that of Klug; and
the figure quoted represents clearly the singular form of the
anterior legs, which struck both Pascoe and Lacordaire, who
both appear to have overlooked Klug’s well-known figure.
AA. Thorax with dorsal ridges.
4, Acyphoderes hirtipes, Klug.
Stenopterus hirtipes, Klug, 1. c. p. 55, t. xliv. £9, 2.
S. Brazil.
The anterior legs of the male are very similar in form to
those of A. femoratus g.
In both these species the muzzle is intermediate, as to length
and narrowness, between A. crinitus and A. aurulentus. The
thorax is elongate and almost cylindrical in A. femoratus (al-
though showing faint dorsal ridges), a little more ovate in A.
hirtipes, differing much in shape according to sex in both spe-
cies. ‘T'his character, therefore, is of no avail as a generic
distinction.
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 119
5. Acyphoderes aurulentus, Kirby.
Necydalis aurulentus, Kirby, Trans. Linn. Soc. xii. 443 (1817); Dalm.
Anal. Entom. p. 71 (1823).
Acyphoderes sericinus, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 195.
Rio Janeiro, Bahia.
Kirby’s original description is made from the dark form of
this insect, in which the femora and tibie are black in the
middle, and the elytra have a furcate black streak on each
side. The type of White’s sericinus is a specimen of this
form.
6. Acyphoderes Olivieri, Bates.
Acyphoderes Oliviert, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 328.
Necydalis abdominalis, Oliv. no. 74, p. 8, pl. 1. f. 5 (?).
Amazons and Cayenne.
Olivier makes no mention of golden pubescence in his de-
scription; and the elytra in the figure have not the form of
those of the present species. Nevertheless it is probable his
species is the same as A. Oliviert.
7. Acyphoderes carinicollis, n. sp.
A. minor, fusco-niger, minus pubescens, femoribus lete rufis,
posticis basi flavo-testaceis ; thorace anguste oblongo-ovato, line-
atim aureo-tomentoso, carina levi mediana marginem anticum
attingente, altera utrinque latiore grosse punctata. Long. 6 lin. 2.
Prov. Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W. Bates).
Small and slender for this genus. Head punctate-scabrous,
partly golden tomentose ; muzzie moderate; eyes (female) not
widely distant in front. Antenne elongate, slightly thickened
towards apex; joints moderately dilated at apex, and serrate
from the fifth. Thorax oblong-ovate, as in Bromiades bra-
chyptera, sparsely hirsute, and appearing glabrous, except the
lines of golden tomentum, of which there are two dorsal (one
on each side the median line), one along the anterior and
posterior margin, and a short oblique one trending towards the
disk from the tomentose flanks. The three longitudinal ribs
of the disk are coarsely punctate, except the anterior part of
the middle one, which is smooth and extends to the fore mar-
gin. Scutellum golden tomentose. Elytra elongate, subulate;
margins deep black and clearly defined, and on each side emit-
ting a branch, which passes above the humeral angle to the
base; rest of surface yellow, vitreous. Body beneath pitchy
black; breast golden tomentose. Legs black; thighs red;
posterior pair at base pale, sometimes with a dusky ring at
commencement of the rather abrupt club.
120 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
8. Acyphoderes odyneroides, White.
Aepioderes odyneroides, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 196,
pl. o. I. oe
R. Tapajos, Amazons.
The apex of the elytra in this species is prolonged into a
very sharp point. The species is an exact mimic of the wasp
Polybia liliacea, ¥., found abundantly in the same localities
and frequenting the same flowers.
II. Apex of elytra emarginate-truncate. (Thorax with dorsal
ridges.)
9. Acyphoderes acutipennis, Thomson.
Acyphoderes acutipennis, Thomson, Classif. des Céramb. p. 179.
Mexico.
Genus BROMIADES.
Thomson, Syst. Ceramb. p. 165; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p. 506.
This differs from Acyphoderes only in the short cuneiform
elytra, which barely pass the base of the first abdominal seg-
ment, and are scarcely dehiscent at the suture. B. brachypte-
rus bears the closest resemblance to Acyphoderes aurulentus,
even to the tubercle on the anterior part of the prosternum.
Lacordaire was unacquainted with the male, which differs from
the female only in the less dilated antenne and the eyes
reaching nearly to the median line of the forehead.
Bromiades brachypterus, Chevy.
Bromiades brachypterus, Chevrolat, Rey. Zool. 1838, p. 285.
Cuba and Sta. Marta, New Granada.
A specimen from the latter locality in my collection differs
from the Cuban form in having the hind legs wholly tawny
red, with the exception of the two apical joints of the tarsi,
which are black.
Genus SPHECOMORPHA.
Newman, Entom. Mag. v. p. 896; White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus.
197
Prod
Syn. Sphecogaster, Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p. 471.
Lacordaire placed this genus in his group Necydalides, al-
though its characters interfered much with the compactness of
his definition of the group, as shown by his citing it often as
an exception. In fact it is merely an extreme form of Rhino-
tragine much modified probably by mimetic adaptation. The
anterior coxe are certainly much exserted, but not more so
than in Jsthmiade and in many Odontocere and Ommate, in
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 121
some of which latter the prosternum between the coxe is also
reduced, as in Sphecomorpha, to a narrow thread. Stenopte-
rus murinus of Klug, which I venture to associate with the
typical species, bridges over the difference between it and
Odontocera and Acyphoderes. In both the narrowed part of
the subulate elytra is of extreme length and tenuity, ending in
a sharp point. The thorax in Sph. murina is not so broad as
in Sph. chalybea, but it is of similar shape ; and the third anten-
nal joint is relatively not so long.
1. Sphecomorpha chalybea, Newm.
Sphecomorpha chalybea, Newman, 1. c. p. 396.
S. biplagiatus, Lacord. 1. c. p. 472, note.
Amazons; Surinam; ‘ Brazil” (Newm.).
The species is deceptively similar to Syneca cyanea, F.,
oa wasp in the countries where the Sphecomorpha is
ound,
2. Sphecomorpha murina, Klug.
Stenopterus murinus, Klug, Entom. Bras. Specim. alter. p. 55, t. xliv. f. 8.
Rio Janeiro.
The abdomen is much attenuated at the base, and remark-
ably vespiform in both sexes.
Genus ISTHMIADE.
Thomson, System. Ceramb. p. 166; Lacord. Gen. vol. viii. p. 504.
The elytra are subulate (narrower than in Acyphoderes).
The antenne have all joints elongate and slender, strongly
serrate from the sixth joint. ‘The thorax is narrow, strongly
eee and tuberculate. All the species are mimics of
chneumon flies of the group Braconide.
1. Isthmiade braconides, Perty.
Stenopterus braconides, Perty, Del. An, Art. Bras, p. 94, t. 19. f. 3.
Isthmiade hephestionoides, Thoms. 1. c. p. 166,
South Brazil.
2. Isthmiade rubra, n. sp.
I, castaneo-rufa, nitida, vertice nigra; elytris disco pallide fuscis
vitreis; alis pallide fuscis, ante apicem fascia fulva. Long. 7-8
lin. ¢ Q.
Proy. Rio Janeiro et Parand, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders,
Dr. Baden, and H. W. Bates).
Very similar to J. braconides (Perty), differing in its bright
glossy chestnut-red colour, and especially its pale brown
122 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
wings. The thorax is smooth and glossy, with five promi-
nent tubercles on the disk. The eyes in the male do not reach
the median line of the front ; in the female they are separated
by a space about twice the width of that of the male. The
elytra are strongly subuliform. The metasternum is very
voluminous, and the abdomen very slender, especially at the
base, in both sexes. In the male the apical ventral segment
is concave in the middle and elevated at the sides.
A single male in Dr. Baden’s collection has two strong
spines at the apex of the fourth ventral segment, like the male
ot Acyphoderes femoratus. In two other males there is no trace
of this armature. The terminal ventral segment in the speci-
men mentioned has not the concavity and lateral wings of the
type. As the form and colours of all the specimens are
exactly similar, I do not venture to consider these sexual
differences specific.
3. Isthmiade ichneumoniformis.
Isthmiade ichneumoniformis, Bates, Trans, Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 826.
R. Amazons.
4, Isthmiade macilenta, un. sp.
I. rubre similis, at minor et multo angustior, thorace vix tubercu-
lato, ete. Valde angustata, rufo-castanea; antennis, elytris, pe-
dibus quatuor anticis, basique femorum posticorum pallidioribus ;
capite angusto nigro; thorace elongato, angusto, medio paulo
dilatato, polito, supra sparsim punctato, tuberculo mediano dorsali
parvo; elytris haud subito angustatis, apice late rotundatis, spar-
sim punctatis, nitidis. Long. 53 lin. Q.
S. Brazil (coll. Dr. Baden}.
Differs from all other species by its narrow elongate thorax,
destitute of tubercles except the small discoidal one, the rest
of the surface being simply uneven, and sprinkled with small
circular punctures; a lateral sulcus is very strongly marked
near the base. The antenne also differ in being distinctly
thickened towards the apex, with the joints compact and
moderately serrated. The elytra are subuliform, but not
suddenly narrowed, the lateral incurvature being much weaker
than in the other species. The wings also differ in not having
the yellow fascia which gives to the other species their strong
resemblance to the Braconide; they are very light brown,
and have only a faint indication of a yellow stigmoidal spot.
Genus ISCHASIA.
Thomson, Syst. Ceramb. p. 163; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p, 508.
This genus is distinguished by its short and broad cunei-
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 125
form elytra, not reaching the apex of the first abdominal seg-
ment and punctured throughout, the punctures being only a
little wider apart on the disk, with the interstices shining.
The muzzle is elongated, but rather broad. ‘The legs long
and slender, with the thighs rather abruptly clavate and the
hind tibie not tufted. The antenne are elongate-clavate ;
Thomson describes the joints (from the sixth) as ‘ paulo ser-
ratis,” which is nearer the fact than Lacordaire’s statement,
‘non dentées en scie.”” In the male the eyes do not reach the
median line of the front.
Ischasia rufina, 'Thoms. /. c.
Prov. Rio Janeiro and Parand (coll. W. Saunders, Dr.
Baden, and H. W. Bates).
The antennez and legs are sometimes more or less black.
Genus CHARIS, Newman.
Newman, Entom. p. 21; Lacord. Genera, vol. viii. p. 507.
Syn. Epimelitta, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 380.
Having had an opportunity of examining a considerable
series of species of these insects, so curiously modified to attain
a close resemblance to different species of hairy bees, I think
Epimelitta may be very well incorporated with Charis, the only
differences being the broader thorax and more hirsute body.
I. Elytra very short, cuneiform. Thorax broad, tumid on each side
near the hind angle.
1. Charis euphrosyne, Newman.
Charis euphrosyne, Newman, Entom. p. 21.
S. Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders).
2. Charis barbicrus, Kirby.
Necydalis barbicrus, Kirby, Trans. Linn. Soe. t. xii. p. 443.
Charis Aede, Newm. Entom. p. 91.
Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W. Bates).
The elytra in this species are strongly emarginate along
their sutural margin, and the lateral edge 1s very little incurved.
3. Charis scoparius, Klug.
Molorchus scoparius, Klug, Entom. Bras. Specim. alter. p. 51, t. xliy.
f, 2,
Cametid (Amazons).
4. Charis mimica, n. sp.
C. nigra, tibiis posticis apice et tarsis rufis, illis dense fulvo-penicil-
124 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
latis ; femoribus magnis, crassis, nigro-hirsutis et supra penicil-
latis. . Long. 5lin. ¢.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden).
Head coarsely punctured, black; mouth pitchy. Eyes
(male) nearly touching in front the median line. Antenne
very slightly thickened towards the tip; joints from the fifth
distinctly enlarged at apex and serrate. Thorax strongly
transverse, rounded, transversely convex in the middle, the
convexity clothed with long, erect, black hairs, partially gla-
brous and punctured behind. Elytra cuneiform, short, reach-
ing only halfway down the first abdominal segment, black,
brownish and punctured on the disk, with a line of long, erect,
black hairs curving from the base to the middle of the suture.
Legs pitchy black, hairy, short, except the elongated hind
pair, of which the femora are much thickened, and have a di-
stinct tuft of black hairs on their upper edge and a fringe be-
neath. The tibie have their apical half reddish, with two
tufts of tawny hairs on their outer edge, and a continuous
long fringe of similar hairs on their inner edge; the tarsi of
the same legs are also reddish ; the anterior femora are bearded
underneath with long black hairs. Body beneath black ; me-
tasternum voluminous, clothed with yellowish hairs ; abdomen
in male moderately slender.
This curious insect bears a striking resemblance to certain
bees of the Melipona group.
5. Charis meliponica, Bates.
Epimelitta meliponica, Bates, Trans, Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 331.
R. Amazons.
6. Charis rufiventris, Bates.
Epimelitta rufiventris, Bates, 1. ¢. p. 831.
R. Amazons.
7. Charis bicolor, n. sp.
C. niger, griseo-pubescens ; partibus oris, antennis basi, abdomine,
elytrisque dimidio apicali, fulvo-testaceis. Long. 44 lin. ¢ Q.
Resembles Ch. barbicrus, Kir. (= Aede, Newm.), but dif-
fers in the elytra not incurved along the sutural edge &c.
Head rugose-punctate, clothed with silvery-grey pile; muzzle
short; eyes in male not reaching the median frontal line, in
female rather more widely separated. Antenne half the length —
of the body (a little longer in male), thickened and strongly
serrated from the sixth joint, tawny testaceous; tips of apical
joints blackish. Thorax short, rounded, constricted at the base,
and slightly gibbous on each side above the constriction ; sur-
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 125
face longitudinally confluent-strigose, partially clothed with
silvery pile. Elytra short, cuneiform ; apex obtuse, sparingly
punctured, scarcely shining; basal half violet-black, apical
half tawny; tip convex and somewhat darker; a patch of
gold-coloured hairs on each side of the scutellum. Abdomen
fulyous, not disproportionate to the metasternum, or differing
much in form according to sex. Legs pitchy black, hairy ;
hind legs slightly elongated; tibize with a dense brush of
blackish hairs on the outer side of their apical haif.
The following species, unknown to me, belong possibly to
this section :—
8. Charis Erato, Newm. Entom. p. 21.
Brazil.
9. Charis Mneme, Newm. I. c. p. 90.
Brazil.
10. Charis Melete, Newm. l.c. p. 91.
Brazil.
The description in some respects applies to Tomopterus lati-
8. (King); but it is not sufficiently complete to enable one
to decide.
Il. Elytra narrowed and strongly divergent towards the apex (reach-
ing nearly to the apex of the second abdominal segment). Thorax
subcylindrical.
11. Charis Aglaia, Newm. Entom. p. 22.
Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W. Bates).
This species forms a transition to the genus Phygopoda.
Genus PuyGopropa, Thomson.
Thomson, Syst. Ceramb. p. 164.
Differs from Charis by the great length of the hind legs and
the more abruptly clavate hind femora. In the smaller and
narrower thorax and the narrowed and divergent apices of the
elytra it agrees with section II. of that genus.
1. Phygopoda albitarsis, Klug.
Stenopterus albitarsis, Klug, Entom. Bras. Specim. alter. p.57, t.xliv. f.12.
Phygopoda fugax, Thoms. 1. c. p. 164 (?).
Thomson’s description of his Ph. fugax agrees with small
examples of Ph. albitarsis, except the omission of mention of
the smooth raised dorsal line of the thorax.
R. Amazons. Abundant occasionally on flowers.
126 . Mr. H. W. Bates on the
2. Phygopoda subvestita, White.
Odontocera subvestita, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 190.
R. Tapajos, Amazons.
This species would be almost equally well placed in the
genus Charis, sect. 11. The hind thighs are longer and rather
more abruptly clavate than in any species of Charis, but they
are less so than in Phygopoda albitarsis.
ACORETHRA, Novy. gen.
Corpus, precipue abdomen valde elongatum. Caput parvum, rostro
paululum producto. Oculi g magni antice fere contigui, 9?
modice distantes. Antenne modice breves, articulis a sexto dila-
tatis, serratis. Thorax parvus, antice angustatus. Elytra cunei-
formia, obtusa, abdominis segmenti primi medium attingentia,
disco nitida. Pedes postici elongati; femora gradatim clavata ;
tibie haud scopifere ; tarsi breves. Metasternum haud distentum;
abdomen ¢ lineare, gracile, 9 sessile.
This genus is closely allied both to Charis and Phygopoda,
but cannot be united to either without rendering their defini-
tion impossible. The simple hind tibize and obtuse cuneiform
elytra distinguish it from Phygopoda; and the elongated hind
legs and abdomen separate it from Charis. The abdomen is
of disproportionate extension, exceeding by one half the length
of the rest of the body.
Acorethra chrysaspis, n. sp.
A, gracilis, fusco-eastanea, capite thoraceque obscurioribus, reticu-
lato-punctatis ; elytris cuneiformibus, disco pallide fuscis politis,
macula utrinque scutellari scutelloque aureo-tomentosis ; pectore
aureo-tomentoso; segmento primo ventrali testaceo, ceteris ( 2)
utrinque macula laterali aureo-tomentosa; pedibus fulvo-casta-
neis, posticis valde elongatis, tibiis longe hirsutis haud scopiferis,
femoribus gradatim clavatis, basi pallidis. Long. 5-7lin. ¢ 9.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W.
Bates).
Head narrow; muzzle as in Ph. albitarsis, moderately elon-
gated. Eyes, in male contiguous in front, in female moderately
distant. ‘Thorax gradually narrowed in front and slightly
constricted at the base. Elytra not reaching the apex of first
segment, dehiscent at suture, obtusely pointed at apex; disk
with a few scattered punctures, shining. Antenne rather
more than half the length of the body, thickened at the tips ;
third to fifth joints linear. The abdomen in the male is very
slender and linear, in the female sessile and not disproportioned.
to the metasternum.
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 127
PHESPIA, nov. gen.
Antenne breves, gradatim incrassate; articulo tertio cylindrico,
quarto et quinto trigonis, sexto usque decimum quadrato-dilatatis,
perfoliatis, nullo modo serratis. Zhoraw lateribus regulariter ro-
tundatus, supra convexus. /ytra abbreviata, gradatim attenuata,
apice acuminata, sutura prope apicem hiantia, supra vitta exteriore
subhyalina. Abdomen brevissimum, vespiforme. Pedes subgra-
ciles ; femora pedunculata, versus apicem clavata; tbie postice
apice scopiferee. Cetera ut in gen. Odontocera.
A genus formed for the reception of a small number of species,
differing in the form of the antennz and elytra too much from
Odontocera and Acyphoderes to be united to either. The en-
larged antennal joints are not serriform, but almost equally
dilated on each side, so as to form a quadrate or thick cylin-
drical figure; and the elytra are subuliform, in quite a dif-
ferent way from the same members in Acyphoderes, Isthmiade,
Sphecomorpha, or in Odontocera in the few species which as-
sume this form. They are narrowed almost from the base,
most so on their outer side, by which, when closed, the sides
of the metasternum and abdominal segments are visible from
above; along the suture they are straight until near the apex,
whence they taper obliquely and each forms a point at its apex :
above, the vitreous stripe runs obliquely from the shoulder,
and is interrupted by a dark bar before the apex. The abdo-
men is relatively very short, not much longer than the meso-
and metathorax together. In general appearance the species
mimic the species of the Cerceris group of solitary wasps.
The genus is no doubt closely allied to Tomopterus.
1. Phespia cercerina, Bates.
Odontocera cercerina, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 325,
R. Amazons.
2. Phespia simulans, n. sp.
Ph. cercerine similis, at elytris longioribus ; fulvo-brunnea vel nigro-
fusca; capite thoraceque nigris, tibiis posticis fere a basi dense
fusco-nigro hirsutis. Long. 4-5} lin. 9.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro, and Prov. Parand (coll. Dr.
Baden and W. W. Saunders). ;
Larger than Ph. cercerina. Head blackish, with stripe of
golden pile down each side of the forehead and round the eyes.
Antenne black, reddish at the base; sixth to tenth joints
thick, cylindrical, compact. Thorax closely but indistinctly
punctured, black; anterior and posterior margins golden pu-
bescent. Scutellum golden pubescent. Elytra longer than in
128 Mr. H. W. Bates on the’
Ph. cercerina, reaching to base of penultimate segment, blackish
at base and tawny reddish at apex, roughly punctured near
the base and shoulders; a line of golden pubescence on each
side of the scutellum and a narrow vitreous yellowish vitta
beginning near the shoulder and ending long before the apex,
with a transverse dusky spot across it before its termination.
The breast and abdominal segments have similar transverse
lines of pubescence (rich golden) as in Ph. cercerina. 'The
legs are reddish tawny, with the exception of the dense brush-
like pubescence of the hind tibiz reaching nearly to the base,
which is blackish.
3. Phespia corinna, Pascoe.
Charis corinna, Pascoe, Trans. Ent. Soc, ser, 3. vol. v. p. 290.
New Granada.
Genus TomorrTervs, Serville.
Serv. Ann. Soc. Ent. Fr. 1833, p. 544.
I. Elytra short, quadrate, not reaching the base of the abdomen.
1. Tomopterus staphylinus, Serv.
Tomopterus staphylinus, Serv, 1. c. p. 545.
Tomopterus pretiosus, Newm. Entom. p. 31 Ke),
Brazil.
The only character mentioned by Newman as distinguishing
his 7. pretiosus from T. staphylinus is its much larger size and
greater beauty ; but I have no doubt he had not the true 7.
staphylinus before him when he made the comparison, and was
misled by the 7. quadratipennis (described further on) being
named as Serville’s species. Serville gives his species as 6-7
lines in length, and as having the basal segment of the ab-
domen testaceous.
2. Tomopterus bispeculifera, White.
Odontocera bispeculifera,. White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 190;
Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 530,
R. Tapajos, Amazons.
3. Tomopterus quadratipennis, n. sp.
T. niger, opacus, thoracis marginibus anticis et posticis fasciaque
utrinque abbreviata laterali aureo-tomentosis ; elytris apice recte
truncatis, apud suturam leviter obliquis, vitta obliqua testacea ;
antennis (scapo nigro excepto) rufo-piceis. Long.4-5lin. ¢ 9.
Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden and H. W. Bates).
Differs trom 7’, staphylinus by its much smaller size, and from
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 129
T. obliquus by its more transversely truncated elytra, oblique
only at thesutural angle. Head with much elongated muzzle ;
front and emargination of the eyes clothed with golden pile.
Thorax quadrate, with sides slightly rounded ; surface convex,
regularly punctate-reticulate; the short lateral golden fascia
joins the anterior marginal one near the anterior coxe. Scu-
tellum black, with a spot of golden pile at the apex. Elytra
black, closely reticulate-punctate, the lateral margin as well
as oblique discal vitta rufo-testaceous. Body beneath finely
griseous pubescent ; a lateral stripe on mesosternum and meta-
sternum and apical margins of ventral segments golden tomen-
tose. The abdomen is slightly vespiform in both sexes, more
slender in the male. The antenne are pitchy red, the fifth
joint being dilated at apex and joints 6 to 10 serrate and
thickened; in 7. latécornis (Klug) the fifth joint is linear.
4. Tomopterus obliquus, Bates.
Tomopterus obliquus, Bates, Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 329.
R. Tapajos, Amazons.
5. Tomopterus vespoides, White.
Tomopterus vespoides, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 176, pl. v.
f, 8.
Guatemala.
6. Tomopterus larroides, White.
Tomopterus larroides, White, Cat. Long. Col. Brit. Mus. p. 177; Bates,
Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 380.
R. Tapajos, Amazons.
This species is an exact mimic of a small bee of the genus
Megachile (or allied thereto), which frequents the same flowers.
Il. Elytra cuneiform, reaching a little beyond the base of the
abdomen.
7. Tomopterus laticornis, Klug.
Molorchus laticornis, Klug, Entom. Bras. Spec. alter. p. 51, t. xiv. f. 1.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro (coll. Dr. Baden).
The resemblance in facies and colours between this and the
_ typical species of the genus is very great; but it differs in the
| elytra being a little prolonged, narrowed and rounded at the
) apex, and in the antenne having the sixth to eleventh joints
| very greatly compressed and dilated, with the fifth joint slender
) and linear.
The genus Pandrosos, Bates (Entom. Monthly Mag. 1867;
| Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4, Vol. xi. 9
130 Mr. H. W. Bates on the
vol. iv. p. 23), having parallel mesosternal episterna, must be
removed from the Fhinotragine, from which it also differs
in its lateral eyes, &c. Its proper place seems to be near
Coremia.
Pasiphile mystica, Thoms. Syst. Ceramb. p. 164 (Lacord.
Genera, vol. viii. p. 508), is unknown to me, both genus and
species. The descriptions of the two authors are scarcely recon-
cilable, Thomson stating the elytra to be “ punctata,” and
Lacordaire “ vitrées ;” the descriptions in other respects seem
scarcely to apply to the same species.
The following genera are closely allied to the Rhinotragine,
but differ in one or more of the essential characters of the sub-
family ; at the same time they do not quite agree with any of
the allied groupes established by Lacordaire.
APOSTROPHA, nov. gen.
g et 2. Modice elongata, linearis. Caput retractile, latum, genis
paululum elongatis. Oculi magni, convexi, laterales, antice valde
distantes. Palpi brevissimi, apice subovati, truncati. Antenne
(¢) corpore multo, ( 2 ) vixlongiores, filiformes, articulis a sexto
leviter serratis, tertio usque septimum extus sparsim setosis.
Thorax cylindricus. Elytra apicem segmenti secundi vix attin-
gentia, versus apicem extus curvata, apice late rotundata, supra
passim punctata. Pedes graciles, elongati; femora abrupte cla-
vata, intermedia et postica elongata; tibia lineares ; tars? postici
graciles, articulo primo ceteris longiore. Prosternum inter coxas
latiusculum ; cox vix exsertee. Mesosternum et abdomen normalia.
dsegmentum ultimum ventrale breve, apice late rotundato-emar-
ginatum; 2 modice elongatum, rotundatum.
A genus allied to Ommata, but differing in the widely sepa-
rated eyes (even in the male) from all the typical forms of
Rhinotragine. ‘The eyes, although lateral, are turned a little
towards the front ; and this character, taken together with the
distinct and moderately broad prosternal process, may bring the
genus within the limits of this subfamily. The external
margin of the elytra is very strongly incurved towards the apex,
and the suture widely dehiscent.
Apostropha curvipennis, n. sp.
A. rufo-castanea, vix pubescens, opaca; antennis dimidio basali,
capite et thorace obscurioribus, hoe utrinque griseo-lineato. Long.
3-31 lin. ¢ 9.
Prov. Parand, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Head punctured, opaque, blackish; front plane, griseo-pubes-
-l
Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America. 131
cent. Thorax very closely punctured, blackish, on each side
a narrow line of greyish hairs. Elytra tawny castancous,
rather thickly punctured, more sparsely on the disk, opaque.
Legs and underside of the body chestnut-red, base of thighs
paler; underside of prothorax and sides of abdomen with
patches of short hoary pubescence.
STENOPSEUSTES, nov. gen.
Facies gen. Ommate. Elongato-linearis, pubescens. Caput (db)
retractile, genis modice elongatis, parallelis. Ocul magni, distan-
tes, modice convexi, laterales, sed paulo versus frontem inflecti.
Antenne corpore vix breviores, apice paululum incrassatz, longe
sparsim setose, articulis omnibus elongatis, linearibus, ‘quarto
quam quinto paulo breviore. Thorax elongatus, cylindricus.
Elytra corpore paulo breviora, a medio paululum angustata, sutura
recta, apice singulatim acute rotundata, subtiliter pubescentia.
Prosternum inter coxas tenuissimum et subobsoletum; meso-
sternum angustum. Cow antice conico-cylindroides; acetabula
postice aperta. Metasternum convexum. Abdomen gracile, lineare.
Pedes elongati, graciles, postici longiores, passim longe setosi ;
femora omnia abrupte clavata.
Stenopseustes ceger, Ni. sp.
S. linearis, elongatus, pubescens, flavo-testaceus, thorace vitta dor-
sali fusco-nigra. Long. 5lin. ¢.
Prov. Parané, Brazil (coll. W. W. Saunders and H. W.
Bates).
Of similar elongate form to Ommata atrata, &c., but more
exactly linear, the thorax being scarcely narrower than the
elytra, and not attenuated in front or broader than the head.
The whole insect with fine decumbent golden pile, besides long,
erect, fine hairs, which are especially long all round the hind
legs. The head, legs, and sides of the thorax are waxy yellow ;
the antennz are of the same colour, but sometimes varied with
black ; the eyes in the male are widely distant both above and
below, but the large lower lobes are a little frontal. The
thorax is long and cylindrical, closely rugose and opaque, with
an indefinite black dorsal stripe. The elytra reach to the
base of the terminal segment, and are very minutely rugose
i) and opaque, with a few larger punctures.
The terminal ventral segment (male) is short, with the
| apical margin broadly and deeply notched.
XENOCRASIS, nov. gen.
Linearis, robusta. Caput valde retractile ; rostro modice clongato,
|
O*
1382 On the Longicorn Coleoptera of Tropical America.
lato ; fronte lateraliter carinata. Oculi ( 2 ) laterales, haud magni.
Palpi breves, apice cylindrici, truncati. Mazille lobo exteriore
elongato, exserto. Antenne ( 2 ) corpore paulo breviores, apice in-
crassate, haud serrate; articulis tertio usque sextum extus
-setosis ; art. undecimo appendiculato. Thorax cylindricus, antice
paulo dilatatus, dorso valde convexo, margine antico medio pro-
ducto. Slytra fere ut in gen. Acyphoderes subulata, apice rotun-
data, disco toto levissime hyalino. Pedes elongati, postici valde
elongati; femora abrupte clavata ; tibie postice densissime longe
-hirsute; tarsi graciles, breves. Prosternum inter coxas angus-
tissimum ; cox@ subconice, exserte. Mesosternum angustum.
Metasterni episterna elongato-triangularia, antice lata; meta-
sternum pauloinflatum. Abdomen ( Q ) basi breviter constrictum ;
segmento ultimo ventrali elongato, angustato, semitubulari.
Xenocrasis presents a strange mixture of characters of true
Necydaline and Rhinotragine. Its distant and not enlarged
eyes, and laterally carinated forehead, remove it from the latter
group, to which it is nevertheless more nearly allied than any
genus of Necydaline with which I am acquainted.
Xenocrasis Badenii, n. sp.
X. elongata, robusta; capite thoraceque nigris ; pedibus fulvis, tarsis
posticis albis; antennis nigris, articulis octavo usque undecimum
albis. Long. 9 ln. 9.
Novo Friburg, Rio Janeiro, Brazil (coll. Dr. Ferd. Baden).
Robust. Head black, rather shining; occiput coarsely,
forehead sparsely punctured; sides of forehead and centre
line of occiput carinated. Antenne black, jomts 8 to 11
white and thickened. Thorax black, opaque, disk sprinkled
with small circular fovez, interstices very minutely punctulate ;
disk very convex and subcarinate ; sides each with an oblique
raised patch, smooth on its outer side; the whole surface has
an extremely fine silky hoary pile. Elytra with straight
suture; sides beyond the middle rather sharply and greatly n-
curved, leaving the apical third very narrow and nearly
parallel; apex obtuse; the whole disk is glassy and perfectly
transparent ; the extreme margins are black and punctured, and
the black colour extends for some distance over the apex and
base. Underside black; metasternum proper and abdomen
reddish tawny, with very little pubescence. Legs brighter
reddish tawny, including the pilosity of the hind tibie ; an-
terior and middle tarsi blackish ; hind tarsi white.
On some Fossils from the Quebec Group. 133
XVI.—On a new Species of Turkey Vulture from the Falkland
Islands and a new Genus of Old-World Vultures. By R.
Bownbier Suarpe, F.L.S., F.Z.S., &c., Senior Assistant,
Zoological Department, British Museum.
THE Catharista from the Falklands has always been referred
to C. aura, from which species it is obviously distinct, by
reason of the conspicuous grey shade on the secondaries. It
might be supposed to be the Catharista iota of Molina from
Chili; this species, however, is well represented by Mr. Cassin
(U. 8. Expl. Exp. pl. 1), and differs in its small size and black
coloration from both the North-American and the Falkland-
Islands bird. The latter is about the size of C. aura of North
America and by no means smaller.
Iam much indebted to the kindness of Mr. Reeve, of the
Norwich Museum, for examining the specimens therein con-
tained; and as he finds that the Turkey Vulture from the
Falklands presents the same differences as the birds in the
national collection, I have no hesitation in proposing the name
of Catharista falklandica for the aforesaid Vulture.
At the same time I may be permitted to inquire whether
there are two species of true Turkey Vulture of Jamaica. I
do not refer to C. atrata, which is now found there also. The
ordinary Turkey Vulture has always been set down as C. aura;
but the only specimen in the museum from Jamaica is C. Bur-
roviana (C. urubitinga, Pelz. ex Natt.). Do, therefore, C.
auraand C. Burroviana both inhabit the island ?
Passing to Old-World Vultures I would suggest that an end
should be put to the indefinite characters of the genus Gyps,
whose tail-feathers are ecther fourteen or twelve in number,
by relegating the two species which enjoy the latter quantity
to a separate genus, which may be called
PSEUDOGYPS, gen. nov.
Genus a genere ‘“‘Gyps” dicto, rectricibus 12 nec 14 distinguendum.
The two species to be included in it will be Pseudogyps ben-
galensis and Pseudogyps moschatus (africanus, Salvad.).
XVI.—On some Fossils from the Quebec Group of Point
Lévis, Quebec. By H. Atteyne Nicnorson, M.D., D.Sce.,
M.A., F.R.S.E., Professor of Natural History in University
College, Toronto.
Havine during the preceding summer had the opportunity of
paying a hurried visit to Quebec, I was enabled to collect a
.
134 Dr. H. A. Nicholson on some Fossils
considerable number of fossils from the Graptolitic Shales of
the Quebec group along the fine exposures of Point Lévis.
Most of these are, of course, familiar forms, which have been
previously described and figured by Hall in his beautiful
memoir on the Graptolites of the Quebec group (‘ Figures and
Descriptions of Canadian Organic Remains,’ Decade u1.). T'wo
or three, however, of the forms which I obtained are new to
science; and in characterizing these I shall at the same time
take the opportunity of making some remarks on some of the
already described species. The following list embraces the
species which I have determined from my collection :—
HyYDROZOA.
Callograpsus elegans, Hall.
Saltert, Hall.
Dictyonema grandis, Nich.
Clonograpsus flexilis, Hall.
rigidus, Hall.
Tetragrapsus (Graptolithus) bryonoides, Hall.
( ) fruticosus, Hall.
quadribrachiatus, Hall.
approximatus, Nich.
Didymograpsus (Graptolithus) nitidus, Hall.
) patulus, Hall.
) pennatulus, Hall.
Phyllograpsus typus, Hall.
Dawsonia acuminata, Nich.
rotunda, Nich.
tenuistriata, Nich.
Corynoides.
BRACHIOPODA.
Lingula irene, Billings.
CRUSTACEA.
Caryocaris.
Dictyonema grandis, Nich.
Frond conical or fan-shaped; branches very strong and
robust, diverging from the base, frequently and regularly bifur-
cating, and separated by interspaces which are about twice
their own width. Width of the branches from 5 to 6 hundredths
of aninch. Fenestrules oblong, from 8 to 10 hundredths of
an inch in width by from 5 to 6 hundredths of an inch in
length, rarely square or longer than broad. Connecting
filaments or dissepiments from 4 to 5 hundredths of an inch in
width ; sometimes narrower, generally widest in the middle,
from the Quebec Group of Point Lévis. 135
and often curved, with their convexities directed towards the
base of the frond. Cellules undetermined. Surface smooth.
Length of the largest frond observed (not a perfect one) a little
over two inches, breadth a little above the base about one fifth
of an inch, breadth at summit nearly two inches (fig. 1, a, 6).
Fig. 1.
Dictyonema grandis, Nich. : a, fragment of a frond, natural size, showing
the rapid divergence and bifurcation of the branches; 6, a fragment,
enlarged, to show the fenestrules and connecting filaments.
There can be no doubt as to the close alliance which subsists
between this species and the Dictyonema Murrayi described by
Hall from the shales of Point Lévis (Grapt. Quebec Group,
p- 138, pl. xx. figs. 6, 7). The following are the characters
ascribed to the latter :—‘‘ Frond very large, gradually spreading
from its origin. Branches strong, width from 5 to 8 hundredths
of an inch, infrequently bifurcating ; divisions little diverging,
the interspaces being little wider than the branches. The
fenestrules have a width of 8 by a length of 11 hundredths of
an inch. ‘The connecting filaments are wide at their origin or
union with the branch, and slender in the middle; from about
one third to one half as wide as the branches. Cellules un-
determined. Surface smooth.”
When we compare the above description with that of the
present species, the latter appears to be clearly separated by
the conical form of the frond, and the rapid divergence and
frequent bifurcation of the branches, whilst the fenestrules are
almost always markedly wider than they are long, the reverse
of this obtaining in D. Murrayt. These peculiarities along
with some other, minor differences, which will be sufficiently
136 Dr. H. A. Nicholson on some Fossils
evident on a comparison of the descriptions of the two forms,
seem to be quite constant, and appear to me to be quite sufficient
to establish the specific distinctness of D. grandis.
From D. quadrangularis, Hall (op. cit. supra, p. 138, pl. xx.
fig. 5), to which it also bears some resemblance, though not so
close a one, D. grandis is readily distinguished by the fact that
the branches of the former are nearly parallel and rarely bi-
furcate, whilst the fenestrules are very nearly square.
Loc. and Form. Common in a single stratum of greenish-
grey shale, Point Lévis, the fronds covering large surfaces of
the beds.
Tetragrapsus approximatus, Nich.
Frond consisting of four simple undivided stipes, arranged
bilaterally, two proceeding from each extremity of the funicle.
Regarding the funicle as horizontal, the stipes are as nearly
as possible at right angles to it; so that the two stipes on either
side of the funicle form nearly a straight line. Stipes curved
at their origin from the funicle, and then running nearly straight
and parallel to one another. The entire frond closely resembles
two examples of Didymograpsus (Graptolithus) patulus, Hall,
united back to back by their radicles (fig. 2, a).
Fig. 2.
Tetragrapsus approximatus, Nich.: a, a specimen nearly perfect, natural
nee paneer of one of the stipes, magnified, to show the form of
the cellules,
Dimensions of the frond in the largest specimen observed :
length of funicle one tenth of an inch; width of funicle one
from the Quebec Group of Point Lévis. 137
twentieth of an inch; width of stipe at commencement one
twenty-fifth of an inch, at widest portion about one line; total
length of frond unknown, but exceeding three inches and a
half; distance between the stipes on opposite sides of the frond
from one fifth to one fourth of an inch, except close to the
funicle.
Cellules about twenty-five in the space of an inch, inclined
to the axis at about 45°; the denticles prominent and sharply
pointed or submucronate; the cell-mouths curved at right
angles or nearly so to the cellules, and making an angle of
about 135° with the axis (fig. 2, 0).
Tetragrapsus approximatus is most nearly allied to 7. cru-
cialis, Salter (=Graptolithus quadribrachiatus, Hall), from
which, however, it is separated by several very important
peculiarities. Most striking amongst these is the very remark-
able shape of the frond. In 7. quadribrachiatus, Hall, when
undistorted, the stipes upon the same side of the funicle are nearly
at right angles to one another; so that (keeping the funicle
horizontal) the left-hand upper stipe forms nearly a straight
line with the right-hand lower stipe, and the other two stipes
similarly form a straight line. The whole frond, therefore,
has in this species very nearly the shape of the letter X ; and
it may be compared to what would result if two examples of
Didymograpsus serratulus, Hall, were united back to back by
their radicles. In Tetragrapsus approximatus, on the other
hand, the two stipes on the same side of the funicle (keeping
the funicle, as before, in a horizontal position) are nearly in the
same straight line, and the two stipes on the one side are, as
nearly as may be, parallel with those on the other side. Hence
the whole frond (and this is a fact worthy of notice) bears a
very close resemblance to two individuals of Didymograpsus
patulus, Hall, united back to back by their radicles, this re-
semblance being increased by the similarity in the shape of the
cellules in the two species.
Again, the cellules in Tetragrapsus approximatus are much
more highly inclined to the axis than they are in 7. quadri-
brachiatus, the denticles are much more prominent and pointed,
and the cell-mouths are markedly curved instead of being
straight. Asin 7. quadribrachiatus, the funicle does not appear
to have been embraced by a central corneous disk. The pecu-
liarities above mentioned as distinguishing 7. approximatus
are constant in a large number of individuals ; and therefore
no doubt can be entertained as to the distinctness of the
species.
Loc. and Form. Common in dark grey or greenish grey
shales of the Quebec group, Point Lévis.
138 Dr. H. A. Nicholson on some Fossils
CiLonocrapsus, Hall.
In the course of last winter, when preparing the first part of
my ‘Monograph of the British Graptolitide,’ I wrote to Prof.
Hall asking him to propose a generic name for forms like his
Graptolithus flexilis and G. rigidus, which are clearly entitled
to be placed in a separate genus. Prof. Hall’s reply unfortu-
nately reached me too late to be available in the above men-
tioned publication, and I therefore left these forms temporarily
in the genus Dichograpsus. I take the present opportunity,
however, of defining the species in question under the generic
name of Clonograpsus (khwv, a twig) proposed for them by
Prof. Hall.
The characters of the genus are as follows:—Frond composed
of numerous (more than eight) stipes proceeding from a common
funicle, on the two sides of which they are symmetrically
arranged ; the frond dividing dichotomously and the pro-
cess of division going on after the cellules are developed,
till ultimately there may be produced from sixty-four to one
hundred and forty-four simple celluliferous stipes. No central
disk.
The genus Dichograpsus, Salter, will now contain only those
Graptolites in which the frond consists of eight simple stipes
proceeding from a funicle, the divisions of which are some-
times enveloped in a corneous disk. The celluliferous stipes
in this genus do not subdivide or branch.
The genus Loganograpsus, Hall, again, will embrace those
compound Graptolites in which the frond consists of from eight
to twenty-five simple stipes which do not subdivide, and which
are sometimes united at their bases by a corneous disk.
From both of these genera Olonograpsus is distinguished by
the great number of stipes composing the frond (sixty-four to
one hundred and forty-four in the typical forms, but fewer in
others), by the fact that the celluliferous stipes themselves sub-
divide, and by the apparently uniform absence of a corneous
disk.
The only undoubted species of Clonograpsus from the Quebec
group are C. flewilis, Hall, and C. rigidus, Hall, both of which
occur in great plenty in the shales of Point Lévis. It is also
probable that the Graptolithus Richardsoni and G‘. ramulus of
the same author, from the same formation, likewise belong to
this genus. Of the Graptolites of the Skiddaw series of the
north of England, the Dichograpsus multiplex, Nich., un-
doubtedly belongs to Clonograpsus, and Dichograpsus reticu-
latus, Nich., may likewise, in all probability, be placed in this
genus.
from the Quebec Group of Point Lévis. 139
DawsontiA, Nich.
I propose this genus, named in honour of Principal Dawson
of Montreal, for the singular bodies which I have elsewhere
(Monograph Brit. Grapt. part i. p. 71, fig. 41) described as the
“ovarian vesicles”’ of Graptolites. I am led to this step by
the extreme inconvenience of applying a general name like
“ovarian capsules”’ to fossils which often present differences
of specific value, which cannot be properly described unless a
special name be adopted. Moreover good authorities are dis-
posed to doubt whether these bodies are truly to be compared
to the “ovarian capsules ”’ of the Graptolites ; and the name of
“ srapto-gonophores,” which I originally applied to them
(Geological Magazine, vol. i. p. 448), is open to other grave
objections as well. Upon the whole, therefore, it appears to
me best to found for these fossils the provisional genus Daw-
sonia, which implies no theory as to thew nature, and which
will enable us to specify and name such varieties as appear to
be distinct. In fact this course seems to me to be the best,
even whilst I retain my belief as to their truly being the
“ovarian capsules” of Graptolites; for it cannot be hoped
that we shall ever be able to refer each (or perhaps any) par-
ticular species of Dawsonia to the species of Graptolite by which
it was produced.
The characters of the genus are as follows :—Horny or chi-
tinous capsules of a rounded, oval, conical, or campanulate
shape, furnished in most cases with a little spine or mucro, and
having a marginal filament exactly resembling the solid axis
of a Graptolite. The marginal fibre sometimes complete,
sometimes ruptured opposite to the mucro. The mucro some-
times apparently wanting, sometimes marginal, submarginal,
subcentral, or central. The surface smooth or concentrically
striated.
I first discovered the bodies included under this head in the
Lower Silurian anthracitic shales of the south of Scotland,
where they occur in great numbers along with the Graptolites ;
and, as before remarked, I regarded them as bearing to the
Graptolites the same relation that the “ovarian capsules” do
to the colonies of the Sertularians. Subsequently I detected
similar bodies in the Graptolitic mudstones of the Coniston
series of the north of England, also associated with numerous
Graptolites. I consider it the very strongest confirmation of
my views as to the nature of these fossils that I have now dis-
covered them in vast numbers in the Quebee group, associated
with the Graptolites of that formation. Not only are they
very numerous, but there are at least three distinct forms of
140 Dr. H. A. Nicholson on some Fossils
them, as might be expected when we consider the number and
complexity of the Quebec Graptolites. It would seem, there-
fore, that the constant association of these fossils with Grapto-
lites (whenever these latter occur in any plenty), and their
constant absence from strata in which Graptolites are unknown,
constitute extremely strong proofs as to there being a natural
connexion between the two sets of organisms.
Without entering further into their nature at present, I shall
simply describe three well-marked forms of these bodies which
occur in the shales of the Quebee group, and which differ both
from one another and from the forms which are found in the
Graptolitiferous rocks of the south of Scotland and the north
of England.
Dawsonia acuminata, Nich.
Capsule of a long oval shape, having one extremity prolonged
gradually, and without any marked line of demarcation, into a
long acuminate mucro. The marginal fibre extremely delicate,
and not always to be detected. Often showing an impressed
line, which proceeds inwards from the mucro to a greater or
less distance within the sac. Dimensions variable; in the
Quebec specimens mostly about one fifth of an inch in length
by one tenth of an inch at the greatest width ; in English spe-
cimens the average dimensions as above, but large examples
showing a length of two fifths of an inch by a greatest width
of three twentieths of an inch. (Fig. 3, a, al.)
“4
a
Various forms of Dawsonia: 2, Dawsonia acuminata, natural size ; a', the
same, enlarged; 6, D. rotunda, natural size; b’, the same, enlarged ;
c, D. tenuistriata, natural size; c’, the same, enlarged; d, d’, another
variety of D. tenwstriata; e, f, forms of D. campanulata, enlarged.
Dawsonia acuminata is exceedingly abundant in some beds
of the Quebec group at Point Lévis, where it constitutes the
commonest form of the genus. The species also occurs not
uncommonly in the anthracitic shales of the south of Scotland
(Upper Llandeilo). The size of the Quebec specimens is ex-
ceedingly uniform, whereas English specimens vary extraordi-
from the Quebec Group of Point Lévis. 141
narily in their dimensions, examples apparently belonging
to this species ranging from about one line in length to more
than a quarter of an inch. It is probable therefore that,
in spite of the identity of shape, more than one form is included
under this head. The species to which D. acuminata is most
nearly allied is D. campanulata, from which it is distinguished
by the fact that the mucro is not sharply separated from the
body of the capsule, whilst its figure is quite different.
Dawsonia rotunda, Nich.
Capsule minute, oval or circular in outline, consisting of a
flattened marginal limb surrounding a central elevated seed-
like body (the cast of the interior of the capsule). The mar-
ginal limb is quite smooth and exhibits no structure ; but the
central rounded mass often exhibits strize or furrows, which are
disposed concentrically round a marginal point (fig. 3, 5, 0’).
Dimensions very constant, the circular specimens having a
diameter of a line or a little less, whilst the oval specimens
have a long diameter of about a line by a short diameter of
about one twentieth of an inch.
This exceedingly distinct form cannot be confounded with
any of the ordinary forms of Dawsonia. It is found very
abundantly in certain beds of the Point-Lévis shales. It is
curious to note how closely D. rotunda approximates in struc-
ture to the “statoblasts” of the Polyzoa, since the capsule,
according to all appearances, has been composed of two concavo-
convex disks united by their faces, the union being effected by
the adhesion of a broad marginal belt on each disk. I have
not as yet determined this species from any of the Graptoliti-
ferous strata of Britain.
Dawsonia tenuistriata, Nich.
Capsule oval, obtusely ovate, satchel-shaped, or nearly round,
covered with fine concentric strie, which surround a prominent
elevated point. ‘This point (the mucro) marginal, submarginal,
subcentral, or central. The striz differmg in closeness and
fineness, but always delicate and regular in their arrangement.
Dimensions, like the shape, very variable, but the length usually
Hikes from one tenth to one fifth of an inch. (Fig. 3, ¢, ¢,
d, d'.
The forms included under this head are extremely like small
Brachiopods of the genera Lingula, Obolella, and Discina ; and
it is difficult to convince one’s self that they do not truly belong
to this group. That they are not Brachiopods, however,
appears certain from the following considerations. They occur
in great plenty, along with the two previously described forms
142 On some Fossils from the Quebec Group.
of Dawsonia, in the shales of the Quebec group at Point Lévis.
They have exactly the same texture, and are in just the same
state of mineralization as the ordinary forms of Dawsonia.
Their shape is so variable that we should have to believe that
there were at least four or five distinct species of small Brachi-
opods in these beds, which is very unlikely. Lastly, the
position of the elevated point, which would constitute the beak
if they were Brachiopods, is exceedingly variable, being most
commonly placed a little within the margin, but being at other
times subcentral or marginal. On the other hand all the re-
quirements of the case are met by the supposition that we have
in these singular fossils the horny capsules of a species of
Dawsonia, in which the capsule was furnished with striz con-
centric to the mucro. On this view the elevated point round
which the striz are disposed is the mucro; and its variable
position, as well as the variable shape of the capsule, can be
readily explained by supposing that it is due to the variable
direction in which the capsule has been compressed. When
compressed laterally the mucro will be marginal ; when com-
pressed from above downwards the mucro will be more or less
nearly central; when compressed obliquely the mucro will be
submarginal.
Dawsonia campanulata, Nich.
Capsule bell-shaped, with a very distinct marginal fibre and
a strong and distinct mucro. ‘The mucro does not pass insen-
sibly into the body of the capsule, but is sharply separated from
it. The surface of the capsule smooth. The marginal fibre
sometimes continuous, sometimes ruptured opposite to the
mucro (fig. 3, e, f). Dimensions extremely variable ; average
specimens about one fifth of an inch in length by three twen-
tieths of an inch in breadth.
Ordinary specimens of this form present the appearance
shown in fig. 3, e, where the capsule has been compressed
laterally and the mucro is marginal. Many specimens, how-
ever, present the appearance shown in fig. 3,7, in which the
compression has been directed from above downwards, and the
mucro forms an elevated point within the margin, surrounded
by a few concentric ridges. This appearance might lead to its
being confounded with Dawsonia tenuistriata ; but it is really
very different. In the latter the concentric strie which surround
themucro are really proper to the capsule, and they are extremely
fine, delicate, and regular; in vertically compressed specimens
of D. campanulata, on the other hand, the concentric ridges
which surround the mucro are truly foreign to the capsule,
being merely the result of the direction of the pressure, and
Dr. J. E. Gray on Tortoises. 143
being very irregular in size and number. In fact they are
not striz, properly speaking, at all, but simply concentric
crumplings or corrugations of the capsule.
I need not discuss here further the affinities and structure of
D. campanulata, as I have not yet detected the species in the
shales of the Quebec group. It is, however, the commonest
species which occurs in the anthracitic shales (Upper Llan-
deilo) of the south of Scotland.
Corynoides calicularis, Nich. (?)
Numerous examples of a species of Corynoides, Nich., occur
in a bed of black shale at Point Lévis ; but their state of pre-
servation is such as to render their specific determination
impossible. They agree very well in their dimensions with
C. calicularis, Nich. (Geological Magazine, vol. iv. p. 107,
pl. vii.), which is an abundant fossil in the Upper Llandeilo
shales of Dumfriesshire, Scotland. It is quite possible, however,
that more perfect examples will show that the Quebec species
is distinct.
Caryocaris, sp.
It is very interesting to notice the occurrence in the Point-
Lévis shales of a species of the Crustacean genus Caryocaris,
Salter, this genus being exceedingly characteristic of the cor-
responding formation of the Skiddaw Slates of the north of
England. The state of preservation of the Quebec specimens
is such as to render their specific determination hazardous and
uncertain; and I prefer therefore to leave them undescribed at
present. Upon the whole they closely resemble small speci-
mens of Caryocaris Wrightii, Salter (Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc.
vol. xix. p. 139); but it is probable that they will turn out to
be distinct. None of my specimens shows more than the cara-
pace, and that considerably crushed.
XVIII.—Notes on Tortoises. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Testudinella Horsfieldit.
General Goldsmid has kindly presented to the British Mu-
seum a small and a larger specimen of the shell of a tortoise,
the large one wanting the front of the sternum, from Rud-I-
Mil, Chuh Suguti to Duruh, in Persia, which were collected
on March 23rd, 1871; they evidently belong to this species,
though we have not the animal to determine the number of its
claws.
The two specimens are exceedingly like Peltastes grecus in
general character, but are much more depressed, and the horny
144 Dr. J. E. Gray on Tortoises.
dorsal plates are pale, with a darker edge and a dark diffused
spot in the middle of the areola; the front sides of the upper
art of the marginal plates are brownish ; the sternum is varied
with diffused black marks ; the caudal marginal plate is marked
with a central groove.
RHINOCLEMMYS.
The species of this very natural genus may be thus divided:—
I. Shell black above and below ; sternum with a pale (when alive red ?)
lateral stripe. Costals not spotted. Head black, with a streak on
each side, sometimes united in front.
1. Rhinoclemmys melanosterna.
Head black, with a white streak on the side of the nose and
head. (Gray, P. Z.S. 1870, p. 722, fig. 1.)
Emys dorsalis, Spix (young) ?
2. Rhinoclemmys scabra.
Head black, with a small spot on each side of the nose
and of the crown, a diverging streak on each side of the
head, and a round spot on the occiput. (Gray, J. c. fig. 2.)
3. Rhinoclemmys lunata.
Head black, with a spot on each side of the nose and occiput,
and a streak on each side of the head, united across the fore-
head. (Gray, l. c. fig. 3.)
II. Shell blackish above and below ; sternum with pale lateral stripes,
with a spot on each side of the nose and numerous longitudinal
stripes on the side of the crown,
4, Rhinoclemmys callocephala.
Geoclemmys callocephala, Gray, P. Z.S. 1868, p. 254, fig. (head) ; Suppl.
Cat. Shield Rept. p. 23, fig. 10 (head). -
Hab. Tropical America.
III. Shell olive above, with a pale spot in the centre of the areola of
each costal, surrounded by pale rings in the young ; beneath black,
with a pale margin.
5. Rhinoclemmys frontalis, n. sp.
Head dark olive, nose with a narrow central streak above
and a narrow streak on the lateral margin extending to over
the orbits.
Hab. Tropical America.
An adult specimen was purchased from the Zoological Society
in the year 1864.
Dr. J. E. Gray on Tortoises. 145
Head olive, with a narrow longitudinal central streak on the
upper part of the nose, a narrow white streak from the upper
part of the nostrils to the front of the orbit, and a narrow white
streak from the upper part of the nose, continued along the
side of the crown over the orbit and the outer side of the tem-
poral muscles to over the tympanum.
The shell olive above, with a distinct oblong, broad, pale
streak over the middle of the areola of the costal plates. The
sternum and underside of margin blackish, with a broad yel-
lowish white band (perhaps bright red when alive) down each
side of the sternum. ‘There is a pale mark on the middle of
each marginal plate, more distinct on the hinder plates.
Under surface and side of face and neck whitish ; side of neck
punctulated with black. '
This species has the peculiar pale spot which was previously
regarded as characteristic of Rhinoclemmys mexicana; but it
has quite a different head.
6. Rhinoclemmys mexicana.
Rhinoclemmys mexicana, Gray, P.Z.S. 1870, p. 659, fig. (head), 1871,
p. 296, t. 28.
IV. Shell blackish, with more or less distinct pale rays ; underside black,
with a pale band round the margin, and pale triangular spots
on the underside of the front and hinder marginal plates ; nose with
a central longitudinal streak ; crown white-varied ; sides of head
with a dwerging black-edged streak.
7. Rhinoclemmys annulata, Gray, 1. c. fig. 5 (head).
Hab. Ecuador.
8. Rhinoclemmys pulcherrima.
I described and figured a young specimen of a freshwater
tortoise in the British Museum, said to have come from Mexico,
under the name of Hmys pulcherrima, Cat. Shield Rept. p. 25,
t. xxv. f.2. The large cavity in the centre of the sternal
bones, like what is found in the young Lhinoclemmys, and the
short scarcely webbed toes make me think that it is most likely
a Rhinoclemmys, or at least very nearly allied to it. The spe-
cimen is very young, the marginal bones being very rudi-
mentary and only slender, half-ovate. It must be the young
state of a very large species.
The alveolar surface of the jaws appears to be like that of
Rhinoclemmys ; but the colouring of the back is very different
from that of any known species, and may indicate a new genus.
9. Rhinoclemmys ventricosa.
Shell oblong, broad, ventricose. Back swollen on the sides.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 10
146 Dr. J. E. Gray on Tortoises.
Vertebral plates keeled, more especially the three hinder ones.
Above black; under margin and sternum white, with a large
black blotch occupying the greater part of the middle of each
sternal shield. Sternum flat, rather convex, greatly bent up
in front. Shell 74 imches long, 54 inches wide.
Hab. Tropical America (Mus. Utrecht, no. 39).
This shell was at one time taken for a specimen of Hardella
Thurgi; but it is very unlike, and is at once known from that
genus by the peculiar triangular form of the first pair of mar-
ginal plates, as in the other species of this genus. The dorsal
and side of marginal plates have a more or less dark spot in
the centre of the areola.
Emys Fraser, n. sp.
Shell olive, minutely darker-spotted; underneath darker,
black-varied. Front legs with a series of four or five large
plates on the outer edge, and with two larger plates on the upper
part of the outer side of the front legs. Jaws strong, with a
rather broad alveolar surface.
Hab. Lake 'Tetzara, Algiers. Shell 8 inches long.
This species has much the appearance of Hryma laticeps,
with which it has been confounded; but the head is much
longer, and the alveolar surface of the two jaws narrower. It
agrees with Hmys caspica in the shape and proportions of its
head; but the alveolar surface of the jaws is much wider.
I donot know if Hmys caspica is also found in Algiers ; but
we have in the British Museum four very young Terrapins
(one brought by E. Doubleday, one by Canon Tristram, and
two by Mr. Fraser) from that country, which have a red stripe on
each costal plate, and a black sternum, like the young Hmys
caspica. Perhaps this character is common to the young of
the two species. One of these I have called Hmys Fraseri in the
‘Suppl. Cat. Shield Rept.’ p. 36.
CHRYSEMYS.
We have in the museum three distinct forms of this genus,
which in a large series do not appear to pass into each other,
and which have special localities.
1. Chrysemys picta.
Sternum one-coloured, pale edge of the front discal plate
broad ; lateral angles of the second, third, and fourth vertebral
plates anterior; marginal plates with a central spot and con-
centric rings above, and a yellow spot beneath.
Hab. North America, Eastern States.
Dr. J. E. Gray on Tortoises. 147
2. Chrysemys pulchra, n. sp.
Sternum with a large central blotch sinuated on the sides ;
pale edge to all the discal plates narrow, uniform; the outer
angle of the vertebral plates in the middle of their margin ; the
marginal plates with a small central marginal spot and two or
three interrupted pale rings above, and a large spot and pale
ring, with a broad black edge, beneath.
Hab. North America, Mississippi (Brandt).
The specimens in the museum have been called Emys ore-
gontensis (Fitzinger) by Brandt ; but they are not L. oregoniensis
of Harlan, which certainly is what I previously called C. Bell’.
They may be one of the four species that Agassiz names but
does not characterize.
ceo: Chrysemys Belliv.
Sternum with a blotch in the centre, which is longest over
the suture of the plates; the yellow edge of the discal plates
narrow, uniform; the outer angles of the vertebral plates in
the middle of the lateral margin; marginal plates with a pale
edge, and divided into halves by a pale cross band; costal
plates with a simple or forked subcentral pale cross band.
Emys Bellii, Gray, Syn. Rept.
Emys oregoniensis, Harlan, t. 31; Holbrook, t. 16.
Young. Actinemys marmorata, Lord.
Hab. West coast of North America; British Columbia.
Trachemys lineata, n. sp.
This species is very like 7. Holbrookii ; but the pale mark-
ings of the vertebral shields are quite different, they being
elongate and separate from each other—the lines of the different
plates nearly meeting together, forming a series of continuous,
more or less bent, lines on each side of the very narrow central
line; the black spots on the sternum are large and solid.
Hab.. North America.
There is a young specimen in the British Museum with fine,
slender, obscure markings on the vertebral plates, and numerous
regular black spots with pale centre on the sternum. This
specimen is somewhat like the young specimen figured by
Agassiz (Contrib. t. 3. fig. 9) as 7. elegans; but it is also like
the young specimen he has figured as 7. rugosa (t. 16. fig. 4),
but perhaps more like the former.
Trachemys lineata is at once known from 7. Holbrookii by
the slender lines on the vertebral plates. In the other species
of the genus the pale and dark lines are in more or less oblong
rings on each side of the vertebral plate, peculiar and complete
FOS
148 Dr. J. E. Gray on Tortoises.
in each plate. There is no doubt that the lines in 7. Iéneata
are a modification of this form: but the ends of the loops do
not exist; for they would be out of the margin of the plate.
Callichelys concinna, 0. sp.
Head elongate, chin convex. Shell very ventricose, longi-
tudinally rugose on the costal plates ; brownish olive, with a
roundish, dark, solid spot on the hinder angle of the fourth
costal, and on the suture of each marginal plate both above and
below.
Hab. San Mateo, Tehuantepec: freshwater lagoons.
Length of shell 12 or 114 inches.
This species is very like Callichelys ornata ; but the head is
longer, and neither of the two specimens has any dark areolar
spot on the hinder edge of the dorsal plates, and the spots on
the margin are solid and not ringed. ‘The upper jaw is notched
in front. The shell is ventricose like Pseudemys ventricosa,
but quite differently marked.
Damonia Reevesii. (Hairy Tortoise.)
Dr. William Lockhart in 1865 presented to the museum a
young freshwater tortoise, which is closely covered with a long,
simple, filiform species of Conferva, from the Kiu-Kiang
Yangtse.
These tortoises have excited considerable interest from their
having been figured by the Chinese in their books and on their
paper-hangings, and have been regarded by some naturalists
as a very peculiar animal,—in fact a hairy reptile. They
are figuied on the titlepage of Temminck and Schlegel’s ‘Fauna
Japonica ;’ but they are only a freshwater tortoise or terrapin,
with a species of simple Conferva parasitic on their backs.
They are collected and much esteemed in China; and an
account of them has been reprinted from Cooper’s travels in a
former volume of this Journal (1871, vol. vii. p. 72).
I have abstained from describing this species, in the hope
that I might obtain a more fully developed specimen ; but it is
of little consequence, as the characters of the genera do not
alter during age, though the species modifies its form ; but the
rules of these modifications are well understood, and the young
animal shows the markings of the head more distinetly. I
have no doubt that itis a very young state of a tortoise which
the late Mr. John Reeves brought from China many years ago,
and which I figured in the ‘Illustrations of Indian Zoology’
under the name of Emys Reevesi?. It is now called Damonia
Reevesti. We at first only received specimens about 3 inches
long; but now they are brought over nearly as large again.
Bibthiographical Notices. 149
The specimen we received from Dr. Lockhart is 12 inch
long. ‘The head is olive, with a short dark-edged white streak
from the middle of the hinder edge of the eye, and trom the
upper hinder edge of the eye a longer dark-edged white streak,
which is forked behind; the upper branch extends along the
side of the neck, and the lower one over the tympanum; on
the other side of the head the upper line is interrupted and
broken into three parts.
Dumerilia madagascariensis.
The British Museum has just received the skeleton of an
adult freshwater tortoise from Anuavandra (on the west coast of
Madagascar), which has been named Dumerilia madagascarien-
sis by Grandidier. It has been arranged with Pelomedusa. It
belongs to the tribe Peltocephalina of the family Peltocephalide,
which is essentially a South-American family, this genus being
the only exception. It chiefly differs from the genus Pelto-
cephalus in having, according to M. Grandidier (for, of course,
they are not to be seen in the skeleton), two short beards on the
chin, which are entirely wanting in that genus, and two series of
oblique lunate shields on the outer surface of the tail. The
alveolar surface of the upper jaw is broad, with an angular
ridge near and parallel to the sharply acute outer margin. The
alveolar surface of the lower jaw is narrow in front, much
broader behind, with a rather convex ridge, becoming broader
behind, occupying a great part of its surface, and with a groove
parallel and quite close to the outer edge.
The head is like that of Peltocephalus, but is more depressed
and the crown flat and broad. The nose is shorter, and the
lower jaw not with such an acute point; and the upper jaw is
not so sinuated in front. The frontal plate is hexangular,
elongated behind ; and the temporal plates are largeand meeting
in the centre behind the frontal one, whereas in Peltocephalus
the central plate is very large and separates the temporals to the
occiput ; but in other respects the two genera are very similar.
It is a much smaller species, the shell of the adult animal being
only 12 inches long.
BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTICES.
Records of the Rocks ; or Notes on the Geology, Natural History, and
Antiquities of North and South Wales, Devon, and Cornwall. By
the Rev. W.S. Symonns, F.G.S. && 8vo. London, 1872.
Tue author says, “ This book . .. . is written for amateurs who,
like myself, enjoy passing their leisure hours among rocks, old castles,
old authors, and the wild flowers of strange wayside places. It does
150 Bibliographical Netices.
not assume to be a strictly scientific description of the geological
structure of the different tracts of country to which it alludes; but L
trust it is correct as far as it goes.” It begins with a general petro-
graphico-geological introduction, and proceeds with a dilettante
account of the districts mentioned in the titlepage, with the suc-
cessive geological formations as the basis for a systematic collocation
of every thing the author finds cause to put together, in a pleasant
talky style, from his note-books and his memory, from his geological
text-books and local guide-books, his county-histories and his library
in general, but more especially from the late Sir Roderick Murchison’s
standard work ‘ Srrvrza.’
In fact the ‘Records of the Rocks’ may be succinctly described as
consisting of ‘Siluria’ deeply diluted with antiquarian gossip, folk-
lore, local botany, and recent geological notings, the prominent per-
sonage in that book being replaced by the ego and his friends in this.
It is garnished with 82 woodcuts, of which 62 have been taken
bodily, descriptions and all, from ‘ Siluria’ without any special refer-
ences, but noticed generally in the preface only as an enrichment for
Mr. Symonds’s volume.
Although fully appreciating the advantage to the amateur geolo-
gist, whether indoor or out, of his having in his guide-book or
book of reference such good illustrations as those transferred from
‘Siluria’ to this general itinerary and field-book for Mr. Symonds’s
favourite districts, we must regret that their respective relationships
with the original are not carefully acknowledged by proper indica-
tions, and that their transference is not in every case unaccompanied
with avoidable mistakes.
Printed in good legible type, and with little pretence of indicating
technical words, this book is intended for easy-going amateurs
“round the Wrekin,” and will serve them for a pleasant book of
reference. The geologist, too, will find much readable information
here and there throughout its pages, if he cares to winnow it out
from among country-seats and personal history—such as the réswmé
of the Cambrian rocks and fossils at one end, and of the bone-cayes
at the other, also of the Drift observed in the Woolhope Valley
(p. 165), &c. There is, however, quite sufficient to bear out the
author’s statement that the book is not strictly scientific. Thus the
woodcut at p. 72 and its description are transferred from ‘ Siluria’
without the corrections from the list of errata of that work, and
the cut at p. 215, with the old references, instead of new ones to Mr.
Woodward's perfect monograph ; the descripi 01 of the cut at p. 261,
modified by an idea taken from the page opposite the cut in ‘ Siluria,’
carries more than the exact truth ; at p. 271 the asterisk left under
the cut finds its meaning only in ‘Siluria;’ at p. 281 the name of
fig. 1 has not been corrected, whilst the new name of fig. 2 is indi-
cated by an initial only, The supposition that Sequoia is a “fir”
(p. 289), and the making Mr. Lankester hold a fossil fish in two
genera at once (p. 184), are weak points ; and the misprints of names
of fossils are too frequent,—as “ Paloeopyge,” ‘“* Bowmannu,” “ as-
permus,” “ Illcenus,” ‘‘ hemispherica,” ‘ Platychisma,” “ Euglypha
Bibliographical Notices. 151
cardiola,” ‘‘ Paleaster,” “ Brodei,” “ Cronchii,” “crenistra.” We
imagine that ‘Heterostracon” and ‘‘ Osteostracon Cephaspide ”
(p. 219) should be either English, Heterostracous and Osteostracous
Cephalaspids, or properly converted into the Latin form.
The guidance of the Author, of Mr. Jones, gardener at Builth, and
other good people, is recommended passim to the reader ; and papers
in the ‘Geological Magazine’ and other useful periodicals are cited
for information old and new: but why the only perfect geological
work on North Wales (Geol. Surv. Mem. vol. ii.), the real basis of
Mr. Symonds’s country, should not have been kept well before the
reader, and why the guidance of the Geological Surveyors should
have been so little thought of, it is difficult to conjecture.
We have thus pointed out several matters for improvement in this
well-intentioned book, which we hope will be required in a new
edition. Written by one who has known his country-side, with cul-
tivated intelligence and an eye for nature, for many years, and who
has long enjoyed the companionship of good observers, thinkers, and
writers, the Rev. Mr. Symonds’s * Records of the Rocks,’ like his other
writings, is directed, with a good and useful aim, to the advance of
knowledge among the so-called “ educated,” but frequently little-
informed, class of society. Itis a learned and comprehensive guide-
book, thoroughly imbued with a love of nature in her many aspects,
and with a desire that all should benefit by an intelligent recognition
of the natural sciences and by scientific pursuits.
A Manual of Paleontology for the Use of Students, with a General
Introduction on the Principles of Paleontology. By H. A. Nicuo.-
son, M.D., D.Sc., &c. 8vo. Edinburgh, 1872.
ScHoors and colleges now find themselves better provided with
zoological and paleontological text-books than heretofore. Dr.
Nicholson’s ‘Manual of Palwontology’ has several good points.
Though very comprehensive it is not too diffuse (only to Graptolites,
a favourite subject, are a few extra pages given); it keeps the con-
ditions of fossilization and geological succession well before the reader
(especially in Parts I. and IV.)—and treats the Vertebrate remains
less in detail than the Invertebrate, in accordance with the larger
acquaintance the student has usually to make with the latter than
with the former..
Part III., on fossil Plants, treated of as the successive floras of
geological periods, is a useful addition to the palzozoology, and is
carefully worked as far as it goes; but unaccountably it makes no
mention of the Diatomacec and the Calciferous Algze (Lithothammium
&e.), which, like Chara, play such an important part in the consti-
tution of many strata.
The author judiciously handles fossils of obscure affinities, such as
Stromatopora, Receptaculites, Crossopodia, &c. But a study of Mr.
Albany Hancock’s memoir ‘on Vermiform Fossils,” in the ‘Annals
of Natural History’ for 1858, would have enlightened him on the
nature of the last-mentioned fossil and its innumerable allies, in-
152 Miscellaneous.
cluding even some of the Oldhamiae, Eophytons, and Fucoids. Nor
does he seem to be aware that two head-portions of Palewopyge
(p. 167) have been found and published, thus removing it from the
category of the doubtfuls.
Dr. Nicholson’s illustrations are numerous and apt. They have
been selected for the most part from such as the Geological Survey
of Canada, Principal Dawson (author of ‘Acadian Geology’), the
publishers of D’Orbigny’s ‘ Cours élémentaire,’ and, he might have
added, Page’s ‘ Text-book’ and his own ‘ Text-book of Zoology’ have
supplied him with. Why the wretched Ventriculite at p. 70 should
claim its paternity so boastfully from “ Lyell” is not clear. That the
authorship of some only, and not of all the cuts (often as they may
have been used before), should have been acknowledged is to be re-
gretted ; for if the real origin of all the figures were carefully indi-
cated, the student might have the opportunity of learning something
more of the history of genera and species by referring to the original
observers. Not but that many authors are mentioned in the text:
by following, however, a good example in this matter, such as
Dana’s excellent ‘Manual of Geology,’ Dr. Nicholson would have
improved his well-designed book ; and he would probably have been
reminded that the Russian Mammoth skeleton (p. 445) is always a
puzzle to tyros on account of its unexplained head-skin and shapeless
hoofs, that the Ichthyosaur at p. 369, with outlined body, ought to
have a fluked tail in the figure as well as in the text, and that Mr.
S. V. Wood’s fine Alligator-relic, at p. 367,is an upper and not a
lower jaw.
MISCELLANEOUS.
Anatomical Investigations on the Limuli. By A. Mrtye-Epwarps.
On June 26, 1869, I communicated to the Philomathic Society
the first part of an investigation which I had just made upon the
anatomy of the Limuli; and a short abstract of this communication
was inserted in the ‘ Bulletin’ of that learned Society and in the
‘Journal de l'Institut.’ This memoir, accompanied by numerous
figures, ought to have been printed soon afterwards ; but the unhappy
circumstances under which France laboured in 1870 and 1871
prevented its publication, and it is only now that I am able to bring
it out in its entirety.
The first notions that we possess as to the internal organization of
the Limuli date from 1828, and are due to Strauss-Diirckheim.
Ten years afterwards Van der Hoeven published on the whole group
a very carefully executed monograph ; but all the anatomical part of
his work, which was studied by means of individuals preserved in
spirit, leaves much to be desired, and we observe in it serious errors,
which, however, it was almost impossible to avoid under the
circumstances in which this author found himself.
About the same time Duvernoy added some details to what was
previously known as to the respiratory apparatus of the Zimuli. In
Miscellaneous. 153
1855, Professor Owen inserted in his ‘ Lectures on the Anatomy of
Invertebrata’ various facts with regard to the structure of these
singular Arthropoda; and quite recently an English journal an-
nounced that this illustrious naturalist had resumed the investigation
of the same subject; but his work is as yet known only by an
abstract published in 1871. Some points relating to the histology
of the Limuli have been treated by M. Gegenbaur; and works of
great interest on the habits of these animals, on their embryology,
and on their zoological affinities, have been published by MM.
Lockwood, Packard, Dohrn, and E. van Beneden. Finally, Mr.
Woodward, in several consecutive memoirs, has presented us with
very interesting observations upon the relations of the Limuli with
the Trilobites, the Pterygoti, and various articulate animals, the
remains of which occur in the fossil state in the Silurian, Devonian,
and Carboniferous formations.
I have no intention of discussing here the questions relating to
the zoological affinities which may exist between the Zimuli and the
extinct species of ancient geological periods. My observations relate
to the anatomy of these animals, and principally to the constitution
of their circulatory apparatus and to the structure of their nervous
system.
The circulatory apparatus of the Zimuli is more perfect and
complicated than that of any other articulate animal. The venous
blood, instead of being diffused through interorganic lacunze, as in
the Crustacea, is for a considerable portion of its course enclosed in
proper vessels with walls perfectly distinct from the adjacent organs,
originating frequently by ramifications of remarkable delicacy, and
opening into reservoirs which are for the most part well circum-
scribed. The nutritive liquid passes from these reservoirs into the
branchie, and, after having traversed these respiratory organs,
arrives, by a system of branchio-cardiac canals, in a pericardiac
chamber, then penetrates into the heart, of which the dimensions
are very considerable. It is then driven into tubular arteries with
resistant walls, the arrangement of which is exceedingly complex,
with frequent anastomoses, and of which the terminal ramifications
are of marvellous tenuity and abundance. By making use of the
microscope we can trace them, with their contours still well defined,
even into the substance of the finest and most transparent mem-
branes (for example, the intestinal coats and even the floor of the
pericardiac chamber); we see them also, by employing sufticient
magnifying-power, in the midst of the primitive muscular fibres,
which they do not even equal in diameter; and some of those which
I measured had a calibre of less than =, millim.
One of the most striking peculiaritics of this vascular apparatus
consists in its relations with the nervous system. Thus the ab-
dominal artery, formed by the union of the two aortic branches,
ensheathes the whole of the ganglionic chain: most of the nerves
are lodged in the branches which spring from this median vessel.
These relations of the apparatus of innervation with the arterial
system of the Limuli were perceived, although very imperfectly, by
154 Miscellaneous.
Prof. Owen, and are more intimate than that eminent anatomist
seems to think. In fact the nervous chain of these animals is not
simply enveloped by the ventral blood-reservoir, and fixed to it in
such a way as to be difficult to distinguish from it, but is enclosed
in it; and this reservoir does not consist of a simple interorganic
lacuna due to the disappearance of the arterial walls in this por-
tion of the animal economy. It is not a case of juxtaposition of
the nerves and arteries; it is a complete ensheathment of the
former by the latter. The nerves destined for the integuments
alone constitute an exception to this; they are free, and the vascu-
lar walls only accompany them to a small distance from their
origin.
The principal arterial trunks open freely into one another, in
such a manner that the blood can traverse a circulatory course
without passing through the veins. These ways of communication
are wide and easy; but there are others, formed by the terminal
capillaries of the arterial system, which are continuous with
the roots of the venous system. The latter is formed in part by
interorganic lacune, in part by tubular vessels with perfectly di-
stinct walls and presenting all the characters of true veins. This
last mode of organization exists throughout in the substance of the
liver. The hepatic veins open into a wide trunk situated on each
side at the ventral part of the body, and giving origin to the
afferent vessels of the branchie. The neighbourmg muscles are
arranged so as to act upon these venous trunks, and can cause alter-
nately their contraction or dilatation. The blood which, by means
of this mechanism, has traversed the respiratory apparatus, after-
wards passes into the pericardiac reservoir.
The origin of the nerves which go to the different appendages
enables us to determine the homologies of these parts, and to esta-
blish that in the Zimuli there are no antenne, as has been supposed
by some anatomists. Lastly, I shall add that the visceral ganglionic
system is not eomposed only of stomato-gastric and angeian ganglia
in connexion with the csophageal collar; there are also small
nervous centres attached to the ganglionic chain, and furnishing
branches to the terminal portion of the digestive tube.—Comptes
Rendus, Dec. 2, 1872, pp. 1486-1488.
On the Boomdas (Dendrohyrax arboreus).
By Dr. J. HE. Gray, F.R.S. &c.
The British Museum has lately received three skins, with their
skulls, of a species of Dendrohyrax from Elands-Post, South-east
Africa.
They appear to be the Boomdas, Dendrohyrax arboreus of my
monograph. ‘This species was first described by Dr. Andrew Smith
as Hyrax arboreus, and is known from the D. dorsalis of the west
coast of Africa by the fur being much longer and softer, and the
dorsal streak yellowish white ; but the great difference is to be ob-
served in the skull.
Miscellaneous. 155
The skull of Dendrohyrax dorsalis is elongate and depressed,
that of Dendrohyraw arboreus is short and high. The hinder part
of the lower jaw of D. dorsalis is moderately dilated, and the
back edge ascending from the condyle is gradually rounded off;
whereas in D. arboreus the hinder part is much more dilated, and
the ascending edge is straight nearly to the hinder end and then
rounded.
The following measurements show the most striking differences
between the skulls of the two species :—
D. dorsalis, D. arboreus.
inches. _ inches,
Length of adult skull .............. as 32
Heiehs of skulle... sae ois ie wis vi oes 22 211
Length of lower tooth-line .......... 14 es
Width of upper part of lower jaw . 1} 1,3;
The skull of D. arboreus is most like that of Hyrax Burtoni in its
height, but differs in the shape of the lower jaw and by the very
small diastemata, especially that of the lower jaw.
On Deep-sea Dredging in the Gulf of St. Lawrence.
By J. F. Wurreaves, F.G.S. &e.
To the Editors of the Annals and Magazine of Natural History.
Montreal, Dee. 20, 1872.
GrntLemEeN,—As I did not see any proofs of my article on Deep-
sea dredging in the Gulf of St. Lawrence (published in the ‘ Annals,’
ser. 4, vol. x.no. 59), I should be glad if you would correct the fol-
lowing typographical and other errors which occur in it.
Page 343, lines 14 and 15 from the bottom of the page, for “ only a
portion of these have ” read “ only a few of these have.”
Page 347, at the bottom, it appears as if two species of Retepora were
collected; the specimens all belong to that form which Smitt calls
Retepora cellulosa, var. elongata.
Page 349. Under the head Dacrydium vitreum the phrase occurs,
«This and the preceding are new to America.” The words with
quotation marks belong to the preceding species, Yoldia frigida ;
Dacrydium vitreum is not new to America, but Yoldia frigida and
lucida are.
Page 350. The asterisk placed before Utriculus pertenuis belongs to
U. hyalinus ; specimens of the latter shell had been identified by
me as Bulla debilis, Gould. My intention was to give Mr. Jeffreys
as the authority for the statement that Bulla hyalina, Turton, and
B. debilis, Gould, are synonymous.
Page 352, lines 10 and 11 from the bottom. Strike out the words
‘if any such there are.”
Additions and Alterations.
Foramrnirera. The long-spined Marginulina described on page 343
is, I believe, Marginulina spinosa, M. Sars.
156 Miscellaneous.
Acrtnozoa. Prof. Verrill thinks (and I quite agree with him) that
the St.-Lawrence Pennatula is a well-marked variety of Pennatula
aculeata, Danielssen. This latter species he considers to be distinct
from P. phosphorea. My St.-Lawrence specimens vary so much in
their characters that I am not yet satisfied on this latter point.
For the present the St.-Lawrence specimens may be provisionally
called Pennatula aculeata, Danielssen, var. canadensis. Those who
accept Kdélliker’s views as to specific differences in this group
would regard the Canadian sea-pen as one of the many protean
forms of P. phosphorea.
Urticina digitata (Miill.). Recognized by Prof. Verrill among speci-
mens dredged in 120 fathoms off Bear Head, Anticosti.
Zoanthus (sp. i is Epizoanthus americanus, teste Verrill.
Motiusca. Dentalium abyssorum, Sars. Adult but dead specimens
of a Dentalium dredged last year were referred to this species.
Having since taken the same shell alive in all stages of growth,
I now doubt the correctness of this identification. It is never
pentagonal when young; and I believe it is the shell originally
described by Dr. Gould, though erroneously, as Dentaliwm dentale,
his specimens being few and very imperfect. Its proper name is
Dentalium occidentale, Stimpson, a perfectly good and distinct
species, nearly related to D. abyssorum—widely different from Hn-
talis striolata, which has not yet been found north of the Bay of
Chaleurs.
Sipho Sarsii, Jeffreys. The proper name of this shell seems to be
Sipho curtus (Jeftreys).
Nitophyllum litteratum, a new British Alga.
By Prof. T. G. Acarpu.
This seaweed was received from Mrs. Griffith as Nitophyllum
Hillie: but it is very different in the form of the leaflets ; the sori are
not dot-like and scattered as in that species, but linear-oblong or
variously shaped, scattered between the veins, looking, on the lower
lobes, like letters or signs.
“ N. litteratum, stipite brevi cuneato, in frondem venis dichotomo-
anastomosantibus obscuriusculis inferne venosam, cuneato-reni-
formem subpalmato-pinnatifidam abeunte lobis cuneato-linearibus
margine minute undulato-crenulatis, basi contractis, soris inter
venas seriatis figuras irregulares inter se plus minus confluentes
formantibus.
“ Hab. Ad littora meridionalia Angliz.”—Lunds Univ. Arsskrift,
t. vill. p. 49.
On a new Freshwater Tortoise from Borneo (Orlitia borneensis).
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
ORLITIA.
Head covered with large plates, plain-coloured ; lower jaw strong,
Miscellaneous. = TSF
acute, curved up at the tip ; alveolar plate of upper jaw narrow, with
a raised inner margin, of lower jaw narrow, sharp-edged. Toes short,
well webbed to the end ; claws 5. 4, short, acute. Thorax ovate, very
convex, shelving on the sides, with a blunt and interrupted vertebral
keel. Vertebral plates in the young as broad as long, front one
narrowed behind ; second, third, and fourth hexagonal; fifth much
smaller, square. First, second, and third costal plates large, angular
above ; the fourth very small, square, only as high as the small fifth
vertebral. Marginal plates broad, hinder four much narrower, with
a serratededge. Nuchal plate broad, well developed. All the discal
and upper part of the marginal plates in the young with a very large
punctate areola. Sternum flat, strongly keeled on the sides. Anal
shields small. Tail short.
The general form is very peculiar, somewhat like Cuora; but the
sternum is perfectly solid, and there is no indication of any mobility
of the two lobes. The animal differs externally in the head being
one-coloured, without any band over the eye.
Orlitia borneensis.
Cistudo borneensis, Bleeker.
Hab. Borneo (Bleeker).
T mentioned this specimen under Cuora amboinensis in the ‘ Suppl.
Cat. Shield Rept.’ p. 21; but on reexamination I am satisfied that it
has no relation to that species. It is evidently the young of a very
large and solid species ; for even this young specimen is well solidified,
though there is an oblong groove (the remains of the opening of the
yelk-bag) in the central suture of the abdominal and preanal plates.
Descriptions of three new Species of Crustacea parasitic on the
Cetacea of the N.W. Coast of America. By W. H. Datt, U.S. Coast
Survey.
Genus Cyamus, Lam.
Cyamus, Lam. Syst. An. s. Vert. p. 166; Bate & Westwood, ii. p. 80.
Larunda and Panope, Leach.
Cyamus Scammoni, n. sp.—Male. Body moderately depressed, of
an egg-ovate form; segments slightly separated ; third and fourth
segments furnished with a branchia at each side; this, near its base,
divides into two cylindrical filaments spirally coiled from mght to
left ; at the base of each branchia are two slender accessory filaments
not coiled, quite short, and situated one before and the other behind
the base of the main branchia; second pair of hands kidney-shaped,
with the carpal articulation halfway between the distal and proxi-
mal ends, and having two pointed tubercles on the inferior edge,
before the carpal joint ; third and fourth segments somewhat punctate
above, all the others smooth. the sixth and seventh slightly serrate
on the upper anterior edge, and without ventral spines. Colour yel-
lowish white. Long. -70, lat. ‘39 in., of largest specimen.
Female similar to the male in all respects, excepting in being a
153 Miscellaneous.
little more slender, and in wanting the accessory appendages to the
branchiz ; the ovigerous sacs are four in number, overlapping each
other.
Hab, On the California grey whale (Rhachianectes glaucus of Cope)
on the coast of California, very numerous. ‘This species is named in
honour of Capt. C. M. Scammon, U.S. Rev. Marine, well known by
his studies on the cetaceans. The specimens here described were
collected and submitted by him for description, and will be figured
in his forthcoming monograph of the West Coast whales. I may
remark here that these species are all so distinct from those figured
by Milne-Edwards, Gosse, Bate, and Westwood, that a comparative
description has seemed unnecessary—also that the species obtained
on different species of cetaceans have so far been found invariably
distinct. The inference is, of course, that each cetacean has its.
peculiar parasites, a supposition which agrees with our knowledge of
the facts in many groups of terrestrial animals.
Cyamus suffusus, n. sp.—Body flattened, elongate; segments sub-
equal, outer edges widely separated; branchie single, cylindrical,
slender, with a very short papilliform appendage before and behind
each branchia ; superior antennze unusually long and stout ; first pair
of hands quadrant-shaped; second pair slightly pufctate, arcuate,
emarginate on the inferior edge, with a pointed tubercle on each side
of the emargination; third joint of the posterior legs keeled above,
with a prong below ; pleon extremely minute; segments all smooth ;
no ventral lines on the posterior segments. Colour yellowish white,
suffused with rose-purple, strongest on the antenne and branchie.
Length -41, breadth (of body) -25 in. All the specimens which
have passed under my observation, some eight or ten in number,
were males.
Hab, On the “humpback” whale (Megaptera versabilis, Cope),
Monterey, California.
Cyamus mysticeti, n. sp.—Body flattened, subovate, segments ad-
jacent ; branchiz single, short, stout, pedunculated, a single papilli-
form appendage behind each ; head short and wide ; first pair of legs
very small; hands all simple and smooth, fingers greatly recurved ;
carpal articulation in the second pair of hands halfway between the
proximal and distal ends of the hand; pleon very minute. Colour
dark brownish yellow. Length -33 in., breadth (of body) -16 in.
Two female specimens.
Hab, On the northern “ bowhead” whale (probably Balena mys-
ticetus, Linn.), near Behring Strait.
This is the most compact of the three species, as well as the smallest.
I find, in comparing large series of C. Scammoni, that a considerable
variation in form obtains, so far as regards comparative length and
breadth, even in adult specimens, and these differences are greater
than those observed, in the same characters, between the sexes.—
Proc.. Calif. Acad. Sci., Nov. 1872.
Miscellaneous. 159
Orca stenorhyncha (the Narrow-nosed Killer).
I described a new Orca or Killer from a skeleton received by the
British Museum from Weymouth. The skull is figured in the ‘Suppl.
Cat. Seals and Whales,’ pp. 86-88, figs. 7-9.
The authorities at the Zoologiska Riks-Museum at Stockholm have
sent to the British Museum three large photographs of an animal
which they have determined to be this species, and which was
taken at Bohusliin in November 1871, showing that it is coloured
like the other Killers, and that it (like Orca latirostris) is an in-
habitant of the north seas,—J. E. Gray.
Preliminary Descriptions of new Species of Mollusks from the North-
west coast of America. By W. H. Dart, U. 8. Coast Survey.
Voluta (Scaphella) Stearnsii, Dall.—Shell large, slender, spindle-
shaped, moderately thick ; colour livid purple, more or less obscured
by an ashy-white outer layer, more conspicuous near the sutures and
on the callosity of the inner lip; exterior smooth (but not polished),
except for the strong lines of increase ; sutures appressed ; siphonal
fasciole strong ; nucleus small, white, mammillated ; aperture more
than half as long as the shell, white and livid purple, with a dash of
brighter purple at the posterior notch and on the anterior portion of
the callus; edge white; callus reflected, thick and strong, with a
chink behind the anterior portion; canal twisted to the right,
moderately deep; whorls 6-8, Long. 4:13 in., lat. 1-62 in., long.
apert. 2°59 in. ; defl. 40°. Living, from stomach of cod, Shumagin
Islands ; dead on beach, Gull rocks, Akutan Pass, and west side of
Amaknak Island, Captain’s Bay, Unalashka.
Nacella (?) rosea, Dall—Shell small, egg-ovate, of a deep rose-
colour, externally smooth, except for very faint radiating ridges
divaricating from the apex, and for lines of growth ; margin entire ;
apex minute, produced before the anterior margin ; interior smooth,
white, except the margins, which are polished and of the same colour
as the exterior ; nacre, especially when weathered, silvery. Long.
35 in., lat. -27 in., alt. -12 in., of largest specimen.
Dead on beach, east side of Simeonoff Island, Shumagins ; living,
probably on Fuei, off shore.
This, from its appearance, is probably a true Nacella, congeneric
with the Cape-Horn species, and the first described from the northern
hemisphere. Its occurrence with that of several other mollusks in
the Aleutian fauna is remarkable; and the facts, on further inspec-
tion, have developed a considerable resemblance between these an-
tipodal faunee.
Tittorina aleutica, Dall.—Shell depressed ; whorls 4, the nucleus
including one and a half, last whorl much the largest ; spire depressed
or nearly flattened ; colour variable, from dark brown or purple to
waxen white, or banded with white on a darker ground; nucleus
polished, dark brown, translucent; sculpture consisting of rather
160 Miscellaneous.
coarse lines of growth, and about six or eight nodulous revolving
ridges, more or less strongly elevated in different specimens, the
three middle ones being the most prominent, and faint revolving lines
being also traceable occasionally between the ridges; aperture very
oblique, smooth, white or purplish within ; outer lip sharp ; columella
broad, straight, generally with a chink behind it; anterior margin
a little produced. Long. ‘41 in., lat. -53.in., of an average specimen.
Animal and operculum precisely as in L. sitkana, which was abun-
dant on the same rocks.
Hab. Living at Gull rocks, Akutan Pass, Aleutian Islands, abun-
dantly (W. H. Dall).
This is a very remarkable and distinct species, resembling no other
on the west American coast.
Nores.—Buccinum Kennacottir, Dall, proves, on obtaining specimens
containing the soft parts and the operculum, to be a Chrysodomus.
It was originally described as a Buceinum, in deference to the opinion
of the late Dr. William Stimpson, who had recently monographed
the northern species of that group. Its distribution is from the
Shumagins eastward, not, as was originally reported, from Una-
lashka.
Buceinum Baeri, Midd., proves to be a very marked race of B. cya-
neum. B. Fischertanum, Dall, which was suspected at the time it
was described to be similarly related to B. cyaneum, proves to be
distinct.
Haliotis, which has long been tabulated as an inhabitant of the
Aleutian chain, does not exist in that part of the archipelago east of
Unalashka, and probably not in these islands at all—Proceedings of
the California Academy of Sciences, Oct. 8, 1872.
Projectile Power of the Capsules of Hamamelis virginica.
By Mr. T. Mrrnay.
The Author said that while travelling through a wood recently
he was struck in the face by some seeds of Hamamelis virginica, -
the common Witch-Hazel, with as much force as if these were
spent shot from a gun. Not aware before that these capsules
possessed any projecting-power, he gathered a quantity in order to
ascertain the cause of the projecting force, and the measure of its
power. Laying the capsules on the floor, he found the seeds were
thrown generally four or six feet, and in one instance as much as
twelve feet away. The cause of this immense projecting-power he
found to be simply the contraction of the horny albumen which
surrounded the seed. The seeds were oval, and in a smooth bony
envelope ; and when the albumen had burst and expanded enough
to get just beyond the middle (where the seed narrowed again), the
contraction of the albumen caused the seed to slip out with force,
just as we should squeeze out a smooth tapering stone between the
finger and thumb.—Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phil. part ii. p. 2385
(1872).
|
ft
THE ANNALS
MAGAZINE OF NATURAL HISTORY.
[FOURTH SERIES.]
No. 63. MARCH 1873.
XIX.—On the Original Form, Development, and Cohesion of
the Bones of the Sternum of Chelonians ; with Notes on
the Skeleton of Sphargis. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
[Plates IV., V., & VI.]
Ir has long been known that the sternum of all Chelonians is
formed of four pairs of bones with an odd one, which is always
attached to the centre of the inner edge, opposite the suture
between the front pair. In some Chelonians these bones
always remain of nearly the same form, and are more or less
separate from each other during the whole life of the animal.
In the land Tortoises and the freshwater Tortoises or Terrapins
the bones of the young become expanded as the animal grows,
coalesce, and at length form in the adult animal a single bony
disk.
Cuvier, in his chapter on the “ Ostéologie des Tortues,” in
the Oss. Foss. v. p. 204, observes :—
“‘ Dans les tortues de terre et d’eau douce, et dans les ché-
lydes, ils ne laissent de vides entre eux que dans le premier
age seulement, ot ils se forment de rayons osseux dirigés en
divers sens dans le disque encore cartilagineux du plastron,
comme les os du crane dans les fétus des mammiféres ; mais
avec l’Age ces rayons se joignent de toute part et forment un
disque compact dans toutes ses parties et qui s’unit par une
étendue plus ou moins considérable de chaque cété au bouclier
dorsal. Voyez pl. xii. f. 44, le plastron d’un jeune Testudo
scabra.”
The sternum figured is very like that here figured as belong-
ing to Emys concentrica, and is quite different from that of
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4, Vol. xi. 11
162 Dr. J.E. Gray on the Development and Cohesion
T. scabra of Latreille, which is figured here under the name
of Rhinoclemmys scabra. Mr. Owen figures the skeleton of
a young Testudo indica ‘ Phil. Trans.’ cxxxix. 1849, t. 19.
f. 4-6. These are the only observations I have noticed on
the form of the bones in the sternum of the young Chelonians.
These authors did not seem to be aware of the great variation
in the forms of the bones in the young of the different genera,
the changes that they undergo during the growth of the animal,
and the important assistance that their study affords in the
arrangement of the animals.
Land- Tortoises (Testudo).
The bones of the sternum in young Land-Tortoises (Tes-
tudo) are the same in number as in the Terrapins, but of very
different form. The front two pairs and the hinder two pairs
each form a very distinct group, separated bya more or less broad
space across the middle of the sternum. The front pair of bones
are generally large and well developed, and the odd bone on
the inner side of them is triangular and usually small. The
two lateral pairs are somewhat similar, broad and expanded,
and more or less semilunar, each pair having a convex semi-
circular edge towards the middle of the inner central vacant
disk. The hinder pair are attached to the inner side of the
outer edge of the hind lateral pair, and are generally united
together.
This formation is well exhibited in a specimen of Testudo
tabulata (P\. IV. fig. 1) 24 inches long, and also in a specimen
of 7. elephantopus (Pl. IV. fig. 2), about 4 inches long, and
Testudo radiata, 24 inches. he lateral bones in Testudo
radiata and in T. indica ave much more convex and irregular
on the edge towards the centre of the sternum.
In 7. platynota (Pl. IV. fig. 3), about 2 inches long, the
lateral bones are of the same lunate shape as in 7. tabulata,
but the lateral pair are much further apart. Perhaps this
arises from the ossification being less developed. The lateral
bones in 7. semdserrata, about 2 inches long, are similar to
those of the young 7. tabulata, but rather more irregular
in their outline; but the opposite bones are rather further
apart, leaving a broader central space between them than in
T. tabulata.
These bones evidently enlarge in size, their edges approxi-
mate, and at length join and coalesce. Thus 7. stellata
(Pl. IV. fig. 4) appears to become solidified when of a very
small size; for in a specimen only 2 inches long the ribs are
dilated and ossified nearly to the margin, and the sternal bones
are very expanded, forming a nearly solid disk, leaving only
of the Bones of the Sternum of Chelonians. 163
a broad rhombic vacant space not quite half the width of the
sternum ; and in a specimen 24 inches long, this vacant space
is reduced in size so as not to be a third of the diameter of the
disk. But I think it is very probable that in the very young
of this species the separate bones of which the sternum is com-
posed are all more dilated than in the other species, although
I have no specimens by which I can indicate this fact.
Freshwater Tortoises or Terrapins.
The sternum of the young Freshwater Tortoises is composed
of the same number of bones (which are united together into a
bony disk in the adult animal) as that of the Land-Tortoises ;
but these bones are very different in shape and disposition from
those of the Land-Tortoises, and differ in the various groups,
offering a curious subject of study,
The sterna of the adult animals are naturally divided into
three groups :—
1st. The sternum solid, continuous, and firmly connected
with the marginal and other bones of the dorsal disk by an
ascending lateral process from each of the central lateral pair
of bones.
2nd. The sternum is only connected with the marginal
plates of the dorsal disk by a cartilaginous suture or an adhe~
sion between the bones of the sternum and the marginal
plates. These are called Box Tortoises.
The Box Tortoises present two forms :—
In the true Box Tortoises the sternum is divided transversely
into two portions, which close down on the cavity of the upper
shell before and behind. ‘The suture is about the middle,
between the two lateral bones—the front lobe consisting of
the anterior and anterior lateral bones, and covered externally
by the gular, pregular, and pectoral plates, the hinder por-
tion consisting of the hinder lateral and the hinder sternal
bones. It is covered externally by the abdominal, preanal,
and anal shields.
In the Trap Tortoises the sternum is divided into three
portions by two transverse sutures. ‘The middle one, which
consists of the anterior and posterior lateral bones (which form
a square central portion), is attached by a cartilaginous or
more or less bony suture to the margin of the dorsal shield, and
does not send any ribs up to the inner part of it. It is covered
by two large abdominal shields. The front flap consists of the
frontal pair of bones and the odd bone; the front pair are very
much larger than usual. Itis covered by the gular plates (which
are generally soldered into one) and the intergular and pectoral
plates (which are triangular). The hinder flap only consists
Ets
164 Dr.J.E.Gray on the Development and Cohesion
of the hinder pair of bones, which are much larger than usual,
and united by a straight median suture; it is covered by the
preanal and anal plates.
This form is described from the genera Swanka and Kino-
sternon, where this modification of the sternum is in its most
developed state. The sternum of the other genera is often
narrow, and a portion is only slightly mobile, and the plates
(which cover it) are diminished in number or coherent to-
gether.
The land-tortoise Pyais and the fluviatile Sternotherus have
the front lobe of the sternum free; but it is only the front
lobe of the sternum that is free, the abdominal portion being
firmly united to the marginal portion of the back, as in the
tortoises with an undivided sternum.
The true Box Tortoises consist of the family Cistudinide.
The Trap Tortoises consist of the Chelydrade.
3rd. All the other families of Freshwater Tortoises or Ter-
rapins have a simple undivided sternum.
One might premise that these three forms would each have
a distinct development of the bones of which the sternum is
formed, or that the bones of each of the three forms would be of
the same shape and developed in the same manner during the
growth of the animal. But the examination of the young
specimens which have come under my observation (which, un-
fortunately, are too few for the proper study of the subject) proves
this not to be the case; and I am inclined to think that the
study of the development of these bones may be subservient to
the natural arrangement of these animals, and also a great
assistance in the determination of the fossil species.
The development of bones of the sternum of Freshwater
Tortoises may be divided into three series, thus :—
I. The nine bones in the very young state are well developed,
the lateral bones being largely developed and covering the
greater part of the middle of the sternum. There is a mode-
rate-sized vacant space in the middle of the sternum, and a
smaller one at the hinder part of the sternum, between the
inner hinder angles of the lateral pair of bones and the inner
side of the hinder plates, and an oval space on each side of
the angular odd bone between it and the inner front edge of
the anterior lateral bone.
This form is well exhibited in the sternum of Malaclemmys
concentrica (Plate V. fig. 1) of the family Malaclemmyde, and of
Pelomedusa subrufa (fig. 2), family Hydraspide. The anterior
lateral bones are larger and more developed in Malaclemmys
than in Pelomedusa; and this appears to be the most usual form
of the sternum of the Freshwater Tortoises.
of the Bones of the Sternum of Chelonians. 165
In Chelydra serpentina, even when the shell reaches 7 inches
length, the sternum is not united along the central longi-
tudinal suture, and there is a triangular cavity on each side
of the narrow lanceolate odd bone and the front end of the
front lateral, and a moderate-sized square unossified portion
between the inner ends of the front and hinder lateral bones on
the suture between the pectoral and abdominal plates.
The sternum of the skeleton of the young Stauremys Salvinit
in the British Museum is like that of Chelydra; but the inner
edge of the front bones is further apart, and the odd sword-
shaped bone is thinner and longer.
If. In the second form the four pairs of bones form a ring
round the margin of the sternum, the two pairs of lateral bones
being the least developed and forming the narrowest part of
the ring, leaving a large open space in the centre between all
the bones which form the greater part of the sternum, with
the point of the odd bone projecting into it. This form is well
seen in the sternum of Cyclemys dhor (figs. 3), belonging to
the family Cistudmide.
Rhinoclemmys scabra (fig. 4). As this animal grows, the
front part of the sternum becomes more dilated and extended
externally on the front of the outer side. It is also to be ob-
served in the animal that I have described and figured as Emys
pulcherrima (Cat. Sh. Rept. pl. xxv. fig. 1), which may be a
Rhinoclemmys. These two latter terrapins belong to the
family Emydidee.
III. This form is somewhat intermediate between the two
former. The four pairs of bones in the young animal are even
less developed, and form only a narrow ring round the margin
of the sternum, leaving a very large part of the sternum only
formed of membrane, occupying more of its space than even
in the former kind; but the anterior lateral and posterior
lateral bones throw out each a more or less narrow bony pro-
cess across the space, dividing it into three portions. Into the
front edge of the front one the small triangular odd bone pro-~
jects. In Notochelys platynota (Pl. IV. fig. 5) the front pair
of bones is moderate. The inner process of the front pair of
lateral bones is small, but broad and divided into three or
four finger-like lobes at the end. This belongs to the family
Cistudinide.
In Kachuga (Pl. VI.) the front pair of bones is less deve-
loped. ‘The inner lobes of the front lateral pair of bones are,
as in the former, broader and divided into finger-like lobes at
the end. The internal bony lobes of the hinder lateral bones
are well developed, and like those of the front pair of bones,
but much narrower; but, unlike the sternum of Notochelys
166 Dr. J.E.Gray on the Development and Cohesion
(Pl. IV. fig. 5), the hinder pair of bones are not united together
behind, and each sends forth a lobe from the middle of the
inner side, which eventually unite in the centre line, leaving
a small posterior central space between the hinder ends of these
bones.
This form seems common and perhaps peculiar to the family
Bataguride. I have figured the inside of the sternum of a very
young specimen of Kachuga major (PI. VI. fig. 1), which has the
bones and lobes very slender. These parts are more developed in
Kachuga dentata even in the youngest state, the outside of
which is figured (fig. 2), and which has the posterior pair of
bones; and in an older specimen in the British Museum this
is also figured from the outside.
In Morenita and Pangshura the hinder part of the sternum is
ossified soonest if these vacant spaces exist in the very young
specimens.
In the young Morenia Berdmorez, about 4 inches long, there
is an oblong longitudinal unossified space on each side between
the branches of the sternum and the margin, and an elongate
four-sided space in the centre between the sutures of the pec-
toral and abdominal plates, and another rather smaller one
between the preanal plates. There is a series of large spaces
between the ends of the ribs and the marginal bone.
In a skeleton of a half-grown Pangshura tecta there are two
rhombic imperfections, the one placed between the sutures of
the pectoral and abdominal plates, and a rather smaller one
between the two preanal plates.
This form bears some relation to the bones found in a very
young Chelonia (Pl. VI. fig. 4), where the anterior bones are
very narrow. ‘The anterior and posterior lateral bones of each
side are separate from each other, having a simple rounded end ;
each of them has two digitate external lobes, extending towards
the margin of the dorsal disk: the anterior one has two
simple processes towards and uniting at the centre ; the hinder
one has a series of simple digitate processes extending towards
the centre and hinder part of the sternum.
Another form is very peculiar; and as yet I have only seen
one example, ina very young specimen of H/seya dentata (P1.V.
fiz. 5), belonging to the Hydraspidee, from Australia. The front
pair of bones, the odd bone, and the front lateral bones are all
united together and form a solid front half to the sternum. The
hinder lateral bones and the hinder pair of bones are narrow,
and form a margin to the hinder half of the sternum, leaving a
very large triangular central space. In an older specimen the
large naked space becomes filled up, except a very small oblong
hole in the middle of the suture of the preanal plates, and a
of the Bones of the Sternum of Chelonians. 167
larger roundish subhexagonal open space occupying the place
of the suture between the abdominal plates.
Perhaps a somewhat similar structure exists in the young
Hydromedusa flavilabris (P1.VI. fig. 3); but I have only been
able to examine and figure the outside of this specimen, and
have not described the separate bones of which it is composed.
But this form does not seem to be universal in the Hydraspide,
as in the young Chelymys Victorte in the British Museum
(about five ches long), examined from the outside, there is a
narrow rhombic unossified space in the suture between the pair
of abdominal plates, and a narrower lanceolate space between
the hinder part of the preanal plates, somewhat like what we
find in the young Bataguride.
Thus it will appear that the tortoises that have a solid con-
tinuous sternum in their adult state have the bones of which
it is composed of a very different form in their young state,
though they are all developed into a solid mass composed of
nine bones in the adult state, as, for example, Malaclemmys
(PL. V. fig. 1) of Malaclemmyde, Pelomedusa (tig. 2) of Pelo-
meduside, Chelydra and Stauremys of Chelydrade, Kachuga
(Pl. VI. figs. 1 & 2), Morenia, and Pangshura of Bataguride,
Lhinoclemmys (Pl. V. fig. 4) of Emydide.
Thus, among the Box Tortoises, the sternum of the young
Oyclemys dhor (P1.V. fig. 3) is very like that of Rhinoclemmys,
and the young of Notochelys platynota is like that of Batagur.
We have not had the opportunity of examining the young
state of the other genera of Box Tortoises.
I labour under the same disadvantage with regard to the
young state of the two-flapped Trap Tortoises. I have only
seen the young stuffed specimen of Ainosternon pennsylvanicum
(PI. V. fig. 6), which I can only examine from the outside. That
has an oblong slender unossified space occupying more than
half the length of the central suture of the sternum, somewhat
like, but narrower than, the unossified space of Cyclemys and
Lthinoclemmys.
Mud- Tortoises (‘Trionyx).
The bones of the sternum of the young and adult Mud-
Tortoises undergo little alteration of shape; only the adult
animals have on the outer surface of each an expanded bony
callosity, which, like those on the outer surface of the ribs,
is pitted externally and covered with a soft skin, so that the
expansions of the ribs and sternal bones are only seen in the
animal when it is dry. hey are peculiar for having the first
pair of sternal bones elongate and bent like an L, one branch
of each being directed straight forward, and the elongate
168 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Development and Cohesion
odd bone, on the inner margin of the other branch, slightly
arched.
In some genera there is only in the adult state a callosity
on the sides next the suture between the two middle pairs of
bones, as Aspilus; in others these callosities are expanded, as
in Rafetus; but generally the anal pair of bones are also
covered with expanded callosities, asin Trionyx. In some, as
Emyda, the front pair and the odd front bone are provided with
callosities. The Mud-Tortoises are generally without any
bones on the margin; but some few bones are developed in the
margin of the adult animal in Hmyda.
The development of the genus Hmyda has been imperfectly
observed. In EL. punctata the margin of the disk of the young
is flexible, without any marginal bones. At length an oblong
marginal bone is developed on the front part of the hinder side
over the hind legs ; and afterwards a series of smaller marginal
bones are developed on the margin behind it. When very
young the expanded bony dorsal disk is very narrow, only
occupying the centre of the back, the expanded part being
shorter than the ribs.
The odd front bone is rather broader than long, and separated
from the front pair of bones by the prominent square first ver-
tebral callosity ; but as the animal grows the odd first callosity
becomes much broader and closely united to the first pair of
callosities, which become wider so as quite to enclose the first
vertebral callosity. It is not until after this change has taken
place that the single anterior nuchal callosity and the two
hinder lateral callosities before referred to, over the hind feet,
are developed. At length the anterior transverse callosity is
united to the front of those of the first pair of ribs to form
the dorsal shield, and the single anterior marginal callosity fits
into a central notch in its front margin.
In the young specimen the odd anterior marginal callosity
is not developed. When the three marginal bones before
mentioned are developed, then it is oblong, transverse, and
very small; but it enlarges as the animal increases in size.
In the very young specimen the front pair of sternal callosities
are small, roundish, and very far apart. ‘They gradually increase
in size, being at first rounded quadrangular, rather longer
than broad; but they at length spread out on the sides, and
are much broader than long, being broader in front than on the
outer side. ‘The hinder pair of sternal callosities are always
separate behind. In the very young specimens the pair are
far apart, much longer than broad, arched on the inner and
straight on the outer side. As they increase in size they
become broader compared with their length, and closer together,
of the Bones of the Sternum of Chelonians. 169
and at length irregularly semicircular, rather longer than broad,
nearly close together, and oblique to each other.
The other species (. ceylonensis), when adult, has the hinder
pair of callosities subquadrangular, parallel, and nearly united
by a straight inner edge and a large rounded anterior callosity.
Sea- Turtles.
The number of the sternal bones of Turtles is the same, and
the first pair and the odd bone on the inside of them are of the
same form, as in the Terrapins ; but they always remain more
or less separate from one another, and do not enlarge; solidify,
and consolidate into a continuous bony disk.
As in the Terrapins, the bones of the sternum in the young
Turtles are found in twoforms. In the true Turtles (Chelonia)
(Pl. VI. fig. 4) the three hinder pairs of lateral bones are
always expanded and furnished with radiating lobes on the
inner and outer edges. These lobes are very uniform in
their direction and generally in their form, and afford very good
characters for the distinction of the species and their division
into groups. In the Luth (Sphargis) (Pl. VI. fig. 5) the
sternal bones in the young state are very narrow, cylindrical
and weak, merely forming a slight framework to the cireum-
ference of the sternum, and the two front pairs form a group
which is separated by a considerable space on the side of the
sternum from the part of the rmg formed of the two hinder
ateral pairs, being in this respect somewhat like the sternum
of the young Land-Tortoises, but consisting of slight cylin-
drical rudimentary bones instead of the broad expanded ones
of that group.
The study of the development of the sternum of the tor-
toises has brought out affinities between groups that have not
hitherto been observed ; and no doubt, as the state of the bones
in more young specimens is known, it will greatly add to our
knowledge of the relations which the genera bear to each other.
This may be exhibited by the following table, which will lead
the zoologist and comparative anatomist to consider this sub-
ject, and see many affinities between groups that have hitherto
been considered very different, and divergences in groups that
have hitherto been regarded as allied.
Chelonians may be divided thus :—
I. The bones of the sternum, and also of the dorsal disk and
margin, of the adult animal all united together and con-
solidated as if they were a single bone.
a. The bones of the sternum in the young animal expanded,
170 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Development and Cohesion
and forming a more or less bony disk protecting the
greater part of the sternum.
* The sternal bones in the very young expanded and forming
two groups :—the front, of the two anterior pairs of bones
and the odd bone; the hinder, of the two hinder pairs of
bones, leaving a space in the middle of the sides. Tylo-
poda or Land-Tortoises: Testudo &c.
** he sternal bones of the very young united into a disk or
marginal ring. Steganopoda or Terrapins, as Mala-
clemmys, Pelomedusa, Chelydra, and Staurotypus.
It is to be observed that it is among the latter genera of the
family Chelydrade that the sternum of these animals is smaller
and less developed compared with the size of the animal than
in any other Chelonians.
6. The bones of the sternum in the young animal slender, and
merely forming a ring round the circumference of the
sternum, leaving the centre part vacant, to be filled up
by the development of the bones.
In the most developed form of this group the bones form a
simple external ring, leaving the centre of the disk vacant, as
in the genus Lhinoclemmys among the Terrapins with a con-
tinuous sternum, and Cyclemys among the Box Tortoises (which
have the sternum divided into two parts by a central suture) ;
and the structure seems to be similar im the genus A7nosternon
(Pl. V. fig. 6), which have the sternum divided into three
parts by two cross sutures, and have been called Flap-Tortoises.
Some of the tortoises that have the sternum in the very
young state supported by aring of bones send forth bony lobes
from the inner side of the three pairs of lateral bones, which
divide the vacant central space into four parts; this has only
been observed in the genus Kachuga among the Asiatic
Batagurs. This group is intermediate between the two sections
aand 6; and the sternum of the young has considerable affinity
to the sternum of the adult turtles.
II. The bones of the sternum in the adult animal remaining
separate, and only forming a ring of bones round the
centre part of the disk.
In the marine Turtles the marginal bones are only slightly
developed ; and in the freshwater Mud-Tortoises the marginal
bones are not developed aé all, or only deposited on part of the
margin when the animal arrives at the adult age. ‘These may
be divided into :—
The Mud-Tortoises (Trionychide). The front pair of ster-
nal bones separate, slender, bent at a right angle in the middle,
of the Bones of the Sternum of Chelonians. 171
the front part produced forwards, the hinder to the side, and
attached on the inner side to the elongate arched odd bone.
The Turtles (Chelonia) have the front and hinder pairs of
bones narrow, and the front pair furnished with an elongate,
more or less lanceolate, odd bone at the posterior end of the
suture between the front pair.
* The two lateral pairs of sternal bones being expanded and
more or less united in the Turtles.
** The two lateral pairs of sternal bones linear and far apart
in the Luth.
The Mud-Tortoises and the Luth are peculiar among tor-
toises for being covered with a soft leathery skin instead of the
horny plates peculiar to this group of animals: but the Mud-
Tortoises have beneath their skin more or less dilated callosities,
forming their ribs and sternum into a solid mass ; while in the
Luth the ribs and sternal bones are very slightly developed,
separate from each other, being chiefly supported by the hard
callosities enclosed in the skin, so that 1t may be regarded as
a reptile on the border of the vertebrate kingdom.
On the Osteology of Sphargis &c.
In the adult Sphargis the bones are not more developed,
considering the size of the animal, than they are in the very
young (previously described), and very unlike the skeleton of
other Chelonians. ‘There is no regular dorsal or sternal shield,
nor marginal bones. ‘The vertebree are compressed ; the seven
ribs on each side are depressed, weak, of nearly the same width
the whole length, and quite separate from each other, and
without any bony expansion between them to form a dorsal
disk as in other Chelonians. In all the other very young tor-
toises I have seen, the ribs are lanceolate, more or less dilated
near the vertebral column ; andit is from the upper surface of
this dilatation that the callosities of the outer surface by which
the ribs are united commence and gradually proceed down the
ribs to the marginal bones.
The sternum of the adult specimen (5 feet long) examined
was more rudimentary and less apparent than in the very
young specimen about 4 inches long, which is figured in
PILVi. fie. 3.
The animal, unlike the generality of Chelonians, appears to
be chiefly supported by its hard, longitudinally costate skin.
The skin is very thick, and the whole outer surface is studded
with very close hard hexangular disks, more like the surface
of a trunkfish (Ostracton) than any thing that I can compare
it with. These disks are larger and more oblong on the
172 ~=Dr. J. E. Gray on the Osteology of Sphargis.
longitudinal ridges of the back, the sides of the sternum, and
on the sides of the tail, and are produced above into hard
conical elevations or tubercles, which are largest on the ridges
of the tail. These tubercles are somewhat like those to be
observed on some species of Ostracion and on Lophius and
other fishes.
The form of the two hinder central bones of the dorsal disk
(placed beyond the one that bears the pelvis, and forming the
central line of the hinder part of the shell that covers the tail
of the animal) is very different in the young and halfgrown
specimens of the different kinds of turtles, and affords a very
good character to determine the species ; but these bones expand
in the more adult state when the dorsal shell becomes solidified
by the dilatation and coherence of the ribs, when they lose the
distinctness of their form, or at least they become coalesced
with the other bones and are not to be observed.
Thus in the young Caowana the hinder bone is narrow and
compressed, with a prominence on its outer side; in the other
turtles this bone is flat and expanded. In the Green Turtle
(Mydas) the last bone is lanceolate, ovate, and broad at the
base, and slightly contracted at the front edge, and the hinder
partis gradually contracted into a point. The last bone of the
Hawk’s-beak (Caretta) is similar, but broader and more rapidly
attenuated behind, and. not contracted in front next to the
pelvis. -
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATES.
Puate LV.
Fig. 1. Testudo tabulata.
Fig. 2. Testudo elephantopus.
Fig. 3. Testudo platynota.
Fig. 4. Testudo stellata.
Fig. 5. Notochelys platynota.
PLATE Y.
Fig. 1. Malaclemmys concentrica.
Fig. 2. Pelomedusa subrufa.
Fig. 5. Cyclemys dhor.
Fig. 4. Rhinoclemmys scabra.
Fig. 5. Elseya dentata.
Fig. 6. Kinosternon pennsylyanicum.
PuaTeE VI.
Fig. 1. Kachuga major.
Fig. 2. Kachuga dentata (outside).
Fg. 3. Hydromedusa flavilabris (outside),
Fig. 4. Chelonia mydas.
Fig. 5. Sphargis mercurialis.
On the Homologies of the Shoulder-girdle of Fishes. 173
XX.— On the Homologies of the Shoulder-girdle of the Dipnoans
and other Fishes. By THEopore GILL, M.D., Ph.D., &c.*
Few problems involving the homologies of bones in the ver-
tebrate branch have been in so unsatisfactory a condition as
that respecting the shoulder-girdle and its constituents in fishes.
But the recent observations of Bruhl, Gegenbaur, and Parker
have thrown a flood of light upon the subject. Some minor
questions, however, appear still to be unsettled ; the writer, at
least, has not been able to convince himself of the correctness
of all the identifications, and of the names conferred as ex-
pressions thereof. Recent study has increased such doubts
respecting the applicability of former nomenclatures, and has
led to conclusions different from those announced by previous
investigators.
The following are assumed as premises that will be granted.
by all zootomists :—
1. Homologies of parts are best determinable, ceteris pari-
bust, in the most nearly related forms.
2. Identifications should proceed from a central or determi-
nate point outwards.
The applications of these principles are embodied in the
following conclusions :—
1. The forms that are best comparable and that are most
nearly related to each other are the Dipnoi, an order of fishes
at present represented by Lepidosiren, Protopterus, and Cera-
todus, and the Batrachians as represented by the Ganocephala,
Salamanders, and Salamander-like animals.
2. The articulation of the anterior member with the shoulder-
girdle forms the most obvious and determinable point for com-
parison in the representatives of the respective classes.
The Girdle in Dipnoans.
I. The proximal element of the anterior limb in the Dipnoi
has, almost by common consent, been regarded as homologous
with the humerus of the higher vertebrates.
If. The humerus in the Urodele Batrachians, as well as the
extinct Ganocephala and Labyrinthodontia, is articulated
chiefly with the coracoid.
Therefore the element of the shoulder-girdle with which
the humerus of the Dipnoi is articulated must also be regarded
* Abstract, communicated by the Author, from a forthcoming work
(‘ Arrangement of the Families of Fishes’) now being printed for the
Smithsonian Institution.
+ Parts affected by teleological modifications may be excepted.
174 Dr. T. Gill on the Homologies
as the coracoid (subject to the proviso hereinafter stated),
unless some specific evidence can be shown to the contrary.
No such evidence has been produced.
III. The scapula in the Urodele and other Batrachians is
entirely or almost wholly excluded from the glenoid foramen,
and above the coracoid.
Therefore the corresponding element in Dipnoi must be the
scapula.
IV. The other elements must be determined by their relation
to the preceding, or to those parts from or in connexion with
which they originate.
All those elements in émmediate connexion* with the pectoral
fin and the scapula must be homologous as a whole with the
coraco-scapular plate of the Batrachians ; that is, it is infinitely
more probable that they represent as a whole or as dismember-
ments therefrom the coraco-scapular element than that they
have independently originated.
But the homogeneity of that coraco-scapular element forbids
the identification of the several elements of the fish’s shoulder-
girdle with regions of the Batrachian’s coraco-scapular plate.
And it is equally impossible to identify the fish’s elements
with those of the higher reptiles or other vertebrates which
have developed from the Batrachians. The elements in the
shoulder-girdles of the distantly separated classes may be (to
use the terms introduced by Mr. Lankester) homoplastic; but
they are not homogenetie.
Therefore they must be named accordingly.
The element of the Dipnoan’s shoulder-girdle continuous
downwards from the scapula, and to which the coracoid is
closely applhed, may be named ectocoracoid.
V. Neither the scapula in Batrachians nor the cartilaginous
extension thereof, designated suprascapula, is dissevered from
the coracoid.
Therefore there is an & priort improbability against the
homology with the scapula of any part having a distant or
merely ligamentous connexion with the humerus-bearing ele-
ment.
Consequently, as an element better representing the scapula
exists, the element named scapula (by Owen, Giinther, &c.)
cannot be the homologue of the scapula of Batrachians.
On the other hand, its more intimate relations with the skull
and the mode of development indicate that it is rather an
element originating and developed in more intimate connexion
with the skull.
* The so-called scapula and suprascapula of most authors are excluded
from this connexion.
of the Shoulder-girdle of Fishes. 175
We may therefore regard it, with Parker, as a post-
temporal.
VI. The shoulder-girdle in the Dipnoi is connected by an
azygous differentiated cartilage, swollen backwards.
It is more probable that this is the homologue of the sternum
of Batrachians, and that in the latter that element has been
still more differentiated and specialized, than that it should have
originated de novo from an independently developed nucleus.
The homologies of the elements of the shoulder-girdle of the
Dipnoi appear then to be as follows :—
ae ee ee ee ee
Nomenclature adopted. Owen. Parker. Giinther.
HUvUMERUS. Humerus. |Humerus. Forearm.
CoRracorp
(or PARAGLENAL)*. Scapula. Humeral cartilage.
ScapuLa. \ Coracoid. Supraclayicle. eee
Ecrocoracoip Clavicle. aan a
(or Coracorp)f.
STeRNUMt. Kpicoracoid. | Median cartilage.
PoOSTTEMPORAL. Scapula. |Posttemporal.| Suprascapula.
The Girdle in other Fishes.
_ Proceeding from the basis now obtained, a comparative
examination of other types of fishes successively removed b
their affinities from the Lepidosirenids may be instituted.
I. With the humerus of the Dipnoans the element in the
Polypterids (single at the base but immediately divaricating,
and with its limbs bordering an intervening cartilage) which
supports the pectoral and its basilar ossicles must be homolo-
ous.
But it is evident that the external elements of the so-called
carpus of teleosteoid Ganoids are homologous with that element
in Polypterids.
* Gelenkstelle der Brustflosse am primaren Schulterknorpel (Gegen-
aur).
+ Clavicula (Gegenbaur).
{ Verbindungsstelle des beiderseitigen Schulterknorpels (Gegenbaur),
Prof. Gegenbaur regards the median cartilage as a dismemberment of a
common cartilage, the upper division of which receives the pectoral limb,
while the lower unites with the corresponding dismemberment of the
opposite side and forms the median cartilage.
§ The suture separating the “ coracoid” into two portions has been
observed by Dr. Gunther, but he could “not attach much importance to
this division.”
b
176 Dr. T. Gill on the Homologies
Therefore those elements cannot be carpal, but must repre-
sent the humerus.
II. The element with which the homologue of the humerus,
in Polypterids, is articulated must be homologous with the
analogous element in Dipnoans, and therefore with the
coracotd,
The coracoid of Polypterids is also evidently homologous
with the corresponding element in the other Ganoids; and.
consequently the latter must be also coracoid.
It is equally evident, after a detailed comparison, that the
single coracoid element of the Ganoids represents the three
elements developed in the generalized Teleosts (Cyprinids &c.)
in connexion with the basis of the pectoral fin; and such
being the case, the nomenclature should correspond. There-
fore the upper element may be named hypercoracoid, the
lower hypocoracoid, and the transverse or median mesoco-
racovd.
ILl., IV. (Proscapula, or united scapula and ectocoracoid.)
The two elements of the arch named by Parker, in Lepido-
siren, “ supraclavicle” (= scapula) and “ clavicle” (= ecto-
coracoid) seem to be comparable together and as a whole with
the single element carrying the humerus and pectoral fin in
the Crossopterygians (Polypterus and Calamoichthys) and
other fishes*, and therefore not identical respectively with
the “ supraclavicle” and ‘ clavicle” (except in part) recognized
by him in other fishes.
As this compound bone, composed of the scapula and ecto-
coracoid fused together, has received no name which is not
ambiguous or deceptive in its homological allusions, it may be
designated the proscapula.
V. The posttemporal of the Dipnoans is evidently repre-
sented by the analogous element in the Ganoids generally, as
well as in the typical fishes.
The succeeding elements (outside those already alluded to)
appear from their relations to be developed from or in connexion
with the posttemporal, and not from the true scapular appa-
ratus ; they may therefore be named posttemporal, posterotem-
poral, and teleotemporals.
The homologies of the elements of the girdle of Dipnoans
with those of other fishes, and the added elements in the latter,
will be as follows :—
* Dr.Giinther (Phil. Trans. vol. clxi. p. 531) has observed, respecting the
division in question in Lepidosiren and Ceratodus :—“ I cannot attach much
value to this division; the upper piece is certainly not homologous with
the scapula of Teleostean fishes, which is far removed from the region of
the pectoral condyle.”
=~]
~l
of the Shoulder-girdle of Fishes. i
Cuvier. | Owen. | Gegenbauer. | Parker.
top cert i GUE Ald a |
ACTINOSTS. Osdu carpe. | Carpal. | Basalstiicke der) Brachial.
| Brustflosse. |
{
RACOID or ? ede Sade8: i Shee.
Coracor er | Simple in Dipnoi and Ganoidei.
PARAGLENAL. {
Hyrerrcoracorp.,| Radial. Ulna. Oberes Stiick | Scapula.
(Scapulare),
Mesocoracorp. | Troisiéme os; Humerus. | Spangensttick. | Precoracoid.
de Vavant- |
bras qui |
porte la na-
geoire pec- |
torale.
Hypocoracorp. | Cubital. Radius. | Vorderes Stiick| ' Coracoid.
| (Procoracoid).|
> |
PROSCAPULA*. Humeral. Coracoid. | Clavicula. | Clavicle.
ScaPpuLa tis : aS at gts
‘ differentiate 7 ol.
Bee ochnacom. Differentiated only in Dipnoi
STERNUM. Differentiated in Dipnoi.
PosTTEMPORAL ELEMENTS.
POSTTEMPORAL. Suprascapu- | Suprasca- | Supraclavicu- | Posttem-
laire. pula. dare (a). | poral.
POSTEROTEMPORAL.| Scapulaire. |Scapula. Supraclavicu- Supracla-
lare (0). vicle.
TELEOTEMPORALS. |Oscoracoi- | Clavicle. | Accessorisches Postclavicles.
dien. | Stiick.
—_—_— _ ©
Tt will thus be seen that the determinations here adopted
depend mainly (1) on the interpretation of the homologies of
the elements with which the pectoral limbs are e articulated, and
(2) on the application of the term ‘‘coracoid.” The name
“‘coracoid,” originally applied to the process so called in the
human scapula, and subsequently extended to the independent
element homologous with it im birds and other vertebrates, has
been more especially retained (e.g. by Parker in mammals
&e.) for the region including the glenoid cavity. On the
assumption that this may be prefer red by most zootomists, the
preceding terms have been applied. But if the name should
be restricted to the proximal element nearest the glenoid
* The name scapula might have been retained for this element, as it is
(if the views here maintained are correct) homologous with the entire sca-
pula of man, less the coracoid and elenoid elements ; but the restricted
meaning has been so universally adopted, that it would be inexpedient
now to ‘extend the word.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser.4. Vol. xi. 13
178 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
cavity in which ossification commences, the name paraglenal
(given by Dugés to the cartilaginous glenoid region) can be
adopted; and the coracoid would then be represented (in
part) rather by the element so named by Owen. That eminent
anatomist, however, reached his conclusion (only in part the
same as that here adopted) by an entirely different course of
reasoning, and by a process, as it may be called, of elimma-
tion; that is, recognizing first the so-called “ radius” and
“ulna,” the “ humerus,” the “scapula,” and the “ coracoid ”
were successively identified from their relations to the elements
thus determined, and because they were numerically similar to
the homonymous parts in higher vertebrates.
The detailed arguments for these conclusions, and references
to the views of other authors, will be given in a future memo1.
I will only add here that these homologies seem to be fully
sustained by the relations of the parts in the generalized
Ganocephalous Batrachians (Apateon or Archegosaurus, &c.).
XXI.— Additions to the Australian Curculionide. Part IV.
By Francis P. Pascoz, F.L.S. &e.
BrRACHYDERINZ. Enide, n. g.
Evas lineatus. porphyrea.
zestuans,
Moxrytin. saniosa.
Psaldus ammodytes. Hedy opis, 128.
= selligera.
Elepenrra Gerynassa, n. g.
Hse : nodulosa.
ypera acaciz. ieee
Propheesia confusa. Dicomada, n. g.
—— litigiosa.
HyLopun#. ORnlia.
Orthorhinus tenellns. terrea.
—— infidus. Paryzeta, n. g.
—— carinatus. : musiva.
Xeda, n. g.
ERIRHININ». amplipennis.
Agestra, n. g. —— hilineata.
suturalis. Olanzea, n. g.
Eniopea, n. g. nigricollis.
amoena. Antyllis, n. g.
Diethusa, n. g. setosa.
fervida. —— griseola.
Emplesis filirostris. aurulenta.
storeoides. Cyttalia, n. g.
Lybeba, n. g. eriseipila. -
subfasciata. Phrenozemia lunata.
—— repanda.
Meriphus coronatus.
the Australian Curculionide. 179
AMALACTINZ. Poropterus inominatus.
Brexius lineatus. Ne slat
oniscus.
CRYPTORHYNCHIN&. tumulosus.
Psepholax Mastersii.
egerlus. CEUTORHYNCHIN2.
latirostris.
Poropterus satyrus.
Rhinoncus nigriventris.
Evas lineatus.
E. nigro-piceus, omnino dense squamosus, supra lineis cervinis ar-
genteisque alternatis, infra pedibusque totis argenteis; rostro
cerasso, capite haud angustiore, incisura triangulari apice angusta,
bene determinata; prothorace latitudine longitudini cequali, cer-
vino-trivatto, vitta intermedia latiore; elytris sulcato-punctatis,
interstitiis primo secundoque, quarto et sexto cervinis, totis squamis
erectis argenteis uniseriatim instructis, apicibus parum divaricatis.
Long. 3}-4 lin.
Hab. Queensland (Gayndah).
The male is considerably narrower than the female, and is
perhaps more definitely marked. In proposing the generic
name (Trans. Ent. Soc. 1870, p. 182) I overlooked the fact
that Hvas is masculine.
Psaldus ammodytes.
P. ovatus, brunneo-testaceus, vage setulosus ; oculis nigris ; capite
rostroque punctis sparsis leviter impressis ; prothorace latitudine
vix longiore (haud confertim) rugoso-punctato; elytris fortiter
sulcato-punctatis, interstitiis convexis ; abdomine sparse punctato.
Long. 1} lin.
Hab. Champion Bay.
Besides colour, this species differs from P. liosomotdes in its
differently punctured rostrum. From a renewed examination
of Aphela and Hmphyastes I am inclined to think that these
two genera and Psaldus should form a subfamily near Moly-
tine. Hmphyastes, placed by Mannerheim by the side of
Trachodes and Styphlus, is referred by Lacordaire to Amalac-
tine, notwithstanding its very short metasternum ; at the same
time he says that it is one of the most aberrant genera of the
Curculionidee, and that if put anywhere else it would be still
more out of place. In the three genera the scrobe runs to the
eye, widening more or less distinctly, so that its upper boun-
dary, if continued, would pass above the eye; the scape either
lies in front, when of normal length, or passes over or above
the eye when the scape impinges on it, as it does in Psaldus.
They are all found on the sea-shore under seaweed or burrowing
in the sand, some below high-water mark.
12*
180 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
Hlypera acacte.
H, lata, fusca, squamis umbrinis griseisque confuse vestita ; rostro
prothorace manifeste breviore, sat tenuato, basi angustiore ; oculis
ellipticis, antice paulo approximatis ; antennis ferrugineis, funi-
culi articulo primo duobus sequentibus longitudine eequali ; pro-
thorace sat confertim punctato, vitta laterali indistincte notato ;
elytris prothorace multo latioribus, paulo depressis, striato-
punctatis, interstitiis latis, uniseriatim setosis, subplagiatim griseo-
variis ; corpore infra castaneo, squamis subargenteis, rotundatis
elongatisque intermixtis, vestito; pedibus breviusculis. Long.
23 lin.
Hab. Queensland (Gayndah).
__A true Hypera, but with broader elytra than usual. Mr.
Masters tells me it is found on wattles (Acacia, sp.).
Propheesia confusa.
P. pallide ferruginea, supra squamis oblongis, infra magis elongatis
vel piliformibus, albis vestita ; rostro apicem versus gradatim paulo
latiore; prothorace sat confertim punctato, punctis singulis squama,
plerumque piliformi gerentibus ; elytris striato-punctatis, inter-
stitiis haud eonvexis, leviter punctulatis ; sutura prima abdominis
fortiter arcuata. Long, 23 lin.
Hab. Tasmania.
The scales vary in size and form, as they do in the other
two species ; but in this one they are not close together so as
almost to hide the sculpture, but irregularly scattered, although
approximating in parts so as to form indefinite patches, which
are more or lessconnected according, apparently, to the freshness
of the specimen.
Orthorhinus tenellus.
9. cylindricus, fuscus, squamis albidis ochraceisque dense vestitus ;
rostro brevi, basi squamoso; antennis subferrugineis ; funiculo
brevi; clava breyiter ovata; prothorace latitudine longitudini
equali, tertia parte anteriore paulo constricta, in medio valde con-
vexo, ad latera vage granulato, apice fasciculis duabus parvis
ochraceis munito; scutello conspicuo; elytris sulcato-punctatis,
interstitiis alternis remote granulatis, singulis tuberculis quatuor,
una basali, una mediana, duabus prope apicem ochraceo-fascicu-
latis, instructis ; corpore infra pedibusque dense albo-squamosis ;
femoribus anticis majusculis, sed tibiis brevibus, compressis.
Long. 23 lin.
Hab. Champion Bay.
Like a small starved specimen of O. s¢mulans, Boh., but
proportionally longer and more slender ; in my solitary example
the upper surface has a somewhat silvery hue.
the Australian Curculionide. 181
Orthorhinus infidus.
©. anguste ovatus, piceus, squamis silaceis elongatis vel setiformibus
sat vage vestitus ; rostro modice elongato, cr -ebre punctato ; oculis
subgrosse granulatis; antennis subferrugineis ; ; funiculo longius-
culo, ar ticulo primo elongato ; ; prothorace subtransverso, lateribus
pone apicem fortiter rotundato, confertim granulato-punctato,
squamis setiformibus vestito, in medio, apice excepto, carinato ;
elytris modice convexis, sulcato-punctatis, punctis leviter impressis,
interstitiis convexis, granulis transversis concoloribus rude in-
structis, squamis elongatis, postice magis condensatis, conspersis ;
tibiis posticis prope apicem fortiter compressis. Long. 6 lin.
Hab. Richmond River.
A dull-coloured species, which in the smaller facets of the
eyes resembles O. hilipoides, a species which in momentary
aberration I described as an Alcides; in the sculpture of the
elytra it is unlike any of its congeners. This and the fol-
lowing species have no fasciculi.
Orthorhinus carinatus.
0. oblongo-ovatus, fuscus, sordide griseo-squamosus; rostro brevi-
usculo, rude punctato, parce elongato-squamoso ; antennis sub-
testaceis, squamis piliformibus vestitis ; funiculo articulo primo
elongato ; prothorace subtransverso, quarta parte anteriore mani-
feste constricta ; elytris sat fortiter convexis, apicem versus parum
latioribus, substriato-punctatis, interstitiis alternis tuberculato-
carinatis, carina interiore ante apicem evanescente, secunda pos-
tice paulo prominula, basi plaga umbrina, margine postico arcuata
et bene limitata notatis, sed aliquando fere obsoleta; tibiis, pre-
sertim anticis intermediisque, brevibus, illis valde compressis.
Long. 33-4 lin.
Hab. Wide Bay.
The outline and well-marked carinz on the elytra are the
principal diagnostic characters of this species.
As Ihave to propose several new genera of Erirhinine, the
following table will be useful in showing their more prominent
diagnostic characters ; and it includes, [ believe, all the Aus-
tralian genera yet published. There will still remain, however,
several unnamed species in collections to be examined. The
subfamily is apparently a very numerous one in Australia, and,
from the exceeding variability of its characters, a very difficult
one to classify. The two New-Zealand genera (Foplocneme
and Stephanorhynchus) are widely removed from all known
Australian forms *. 1 think that in Mr. Wallace’s Malayan
* A third genus, Lugnomus (Schonh, Mant. Sec. p. 45), is said to be from
New Zealand ; but no species has been described.
182 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
collection of more than a thousand species of Cureulionide
only five or six species belong tothe Evirhinine. In the table
I have followed Lacordaire’s division into five “groupes;” but
it seems to me that two of these (“‘Cryptoplides ” and “ Sto-
réides”) cannot be maintained satisfactorily, and should be
united to “‘ Krirhinides vrais.’’ Some of the genera might be
placed in either of them. .
‘‘ WRIRHINIDES VRAIS.”
Pectus not canaliculate.
Club of the antenne with closely united joints.
mcropes nearly: terminal i. cis sx. sae vacs coe GeO Desiantha.
Scrobes more or less distant from the mouth.
Rostrum quadransular....<.:..22 ot wae et careniere Nemesira.
Rostrum rounded or cylindrical.
Antenne inserted near the base of the rostrum .. Orichora.
Antenne inserted near the middle.
Femora not toothed. }
Scrobes connivent beneath ................ Aoploenemis.
Scrobes not connivent.
Anterior tibize spurred.
Anterior tibize slightly flexuous........ ELrirhinus.
Anterior tibiz falcate .............-.. Qnochroma,
Anterior tibise not spurred .....- 2 ae. nceee Nedyleda.
Femora toothed beneath......... ies naa ha Agestra.
Club of the antennz loosely jointed .................. Eniopea.
Pectus canaliculate ......... Fea bey TO LA. Be Diethusa.
Pecius, .canalicnlate sy. sts bacacc in batts “tA al: ures 2a Bagous *,
Funicle 6-jointed.
ParsiA ointed sheen! is ues ollie Wak eee eerie Endalus.
MAES JOUMEOW a i452. crt bravia the 2 Sahm eee OTe Misophrice.
Funicle 7-jointed.
Milyive callous posherioely kets cat vee aca Rhachiodes,
Elytra without callosities.
Tarsi 4-jointed.
Claw-joint not passing beyond the lobes of the third Cryptoplus,
Claw-joint passing beyond the lobes of the third .. Emplesis,
Parsiie-jOmbed bsx,: acisa'tjed cata eee eee eee ee Thechiat. -
“ STOREIDEs.”’
Funicle 7-jointed.
Pectus canaliculate.
Rostromcylindiical oo aaer = eke Cae eee Lybeba.
Rostrum narrowing gradually to the apex .......... Enide.
Pectus not canaliculate.
Second abdominal segment scarcely longer than the
thitde oN oc gees PORE Ie oe a ee Storeus.
* I have three Australian species of this well-known northern genus.
y¥ This genus will be published in my “Contributions towards a
Knowledge of the Curculionidee,” Part iv.,in the Journal of the Linnean
Society. It is related to a new Malayan form. #
the Australian Curculionide. 183
Second abdominal segment as long as or longer than the
next two together.
Prothorax bisinuate at the base.
Anterior and intermdiate tibize bicalcarate ...... Hedyopis.
Anterior and intermediate tibize with a single spur Lrytenna.
Prothorax rounded at the base.
Myesicoansely: faceted) <<ispoute ti <2 allele oleye ah af Gerynassa.
Kyes finely faceted.
Intermediate coxee remote.
Rostrum cylindrical throughout .......... Cydmea.
Rostrum broader at the apex .............. Dicomada.
Intermediate coxze approximate.
Scrobes running to the eye.
Rostrum slender, broader at the apex .... Paryzeta.
Rostrum stouter, cylindrical throughout .. Xeda.
Scrobes running beneath the rostrum ...... Olanea.
Beta Clif OWALC de hf says) h ernie Wedge ote Gin open we sre oie = ate Antyllis.
“ HUGNOMIDES.”
Rostrum abruptly connected with the head.
RpEIOtA PEdUMCMIALE), co.) sah prore earl neuescyen «a eeaere Meriphus.
Femora not pedunculate.
ALSTON COX CONMOUGUS, sass 6 vie) mse)5jci tue fae ssa = « Myosita.
EATTGCTION COX NOt COMMOWOUS. ej neice onic ss cies ee Orpha.
Rostrum gradually continued to the head.
Senperattainime*theeye sk le eels Phrenozemia,
Scape passing to the posterior border of the eye ........ Cyttalia.
AGESTRA.
Rostrum tenue, arcuatum; scrobes submedianz, paulo oblique.
Scapus oculum attingens ; funiculus 7-articulatus, articulo prime
ampliato, ceteris brevioribus, obeonicis ; clava distincta. Oculé
ovati, fortiter granulati. Prothorav subtransversus, basi perparum
bisinuatus, lobis ocularibus nullis. * Hlytra oblongo-cordiformia,
prothorace paulo latiora. Cowc intermedie haud approximate.
Femora crassa, subtus emarginata, obsolete dentata ; tbe antice
et intermedise fere recte, apice mucronatie, postice subilexuose ;
tarst articulo tertio anguste bilobo, quarto elongate. Abdomen
segmentis duobus basalibus brevibus, secundo tertio quartoque
conjunctim manifeste breviore, sutura prima obsoleta. Corpus
esquamosum.
The insect forming the type of this genus is remarkable for
the shortness of the two basal abdominal segments—the second,
however, owing to its close union with the first, being very
indistinctly limited. The genus seems to have more aflinity
with Dorytomus than with any other. The facets of the eyes
are very minute ; but, as only about ten or so may be counted
* T have omitted to mention the scutellum in this and some other
genera, as in the Erirhinine (and oftentimes in other Curculionide) it is
very small, and, unless the scales are rubbed off, it is often dificult to
ascertain its form.
184 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
across the short diameter, the eye, in proportion to its size,
must be characterized as coarsely granulate.
Agestra suturalis.
A, ovata, supra silacea, in prothorace saturata, subtus capiteque um-
brina, setulis subaureis adspersa, rostro, antennis, pedibusque
subferrugineis vel silaceis ; rostro prothorace vix longiore ; funiculi
articulo primo secundo tertioque conjunctim manifeste longiore ;
clava late ovata ; prothorace pone apicem fere parallelo, supra sat
crebre punctato: elytris seriatim punctatis, punctis majusculis,
approximatis, interstitio suturali nigro; femoribus posticis magis
clavatis, dente minus obsoleto instructis. Long. 1 lin.
Hab. Fremantle.
E\NIOPEA.
Rostrum subcylindricum, arcuatum, apice parum latius ; scrobes pree-
medianze, rectee. Scapus longiusculus, oculum attingens ; funi-
culus 7-articulatus, articulo primo ampliato, ceteris gradatim bre-
vioribus ; clava magna, laxe articulata. _ Cculi subovati, fortiter
eranulati. Prothorav oblongus, basi subrotundata, quam apice
paulo latiore, lobis ocularibus nullis. Hlytra oblonga, prothorace
manifteste latiora. Cove intermediz approximate. Memora crassa,
mutica, basi subpeduneulata ; téhiw antice et intermedize flexuose,
apice mucronate; tars? articulo tertio bilobo, quarto elongato. -
Abdomen segmentis duobus basalibus breviusculis, ultimo magno ;
processus intercoxalis haud remotus.
The diagnostic characters of this genus are found in the
antemnal club and in the abdominal segments; the former,
which is nearly as long as the six preeeding joints of the funicle
together, has its joints (except the last) narrowed at the base,
as in many of the Anthribide. As to the last abdominal
segment, in some of my specimens, probably females, it extends
beyond the elytra, and is more or less scaly, a true pygidium
in fact. Asin many other variegated species, little can be said
in regard to the distribution of colours, as they vary in almost
every > individual ; but in most there is to the naked eye a well-
marked spot at the side of each elytron; under the lens it
is a large spot among a confused mass of faces I have placed
the genus provisionally near Lrirhinus.
Eniopea amena.
E. oblonga, picea, squamis argenteis fuscisque variegata; rostro ferru-
gineo, prothorace manifeste longiore, basi eapiteque parce griseo-
pilosis; funiculi articulo primo quam secundo duplo longiore ;
prothorace latitudine paulo longiore, utrinque rotundato, supra
plerumque vitta argentea lateraliter ornato; elytris oblongo-
cordiformibus, plagiatim variegatis; corpore infra pedibusque
the Australian Curculionide. 185
ferrugineis, squamis argenteis adspersis; femoribus in medio
nigrescentibus. Long. 1} lin.
Hab. Fremantle.
DIerHUSA.
Rostrum breviusculum, versus apicem cito angustius ; scrobes submedi-
ane, laterales, oblique. Scapus oculum attingens ; funiculus 7-
articulatus, articulis duobus basalibus longiusculis, primo incrassato,
reliquis obconicis, ultimis transversis ; clava distincta. Oculi ro-
tundati, subtenuiter granulati, antice parum approximati. Pro-
thorax subconicus, basi bisinuatus,lobis ocularibus nullis. Scutellwm
oblongum. lytra subcordiformia, prothorace multo latiora.
Pectus breve, canaliculatum. Cove antice basi fere contigue,
intermedize distantes; femora crassa, dentata: tibiw breves,
flexuosee, apice bicalcaratze (posticee fere obsoletee exceptie) ; tarsi
articulo tertio bilobo, quarto minusculo; wngwicule divaricati.
Mesosternum depressum, antice arcuatum. Abdomen segmentis
duobus basalibus amplatis, suturis tribus intermediis rectis.
The peculiar character of the rostrum, in conjunction with
the normal character of abdominal segments and pectoral canal,
is at once distinctive of this genus. The two spurs of the
anterior and intermediate tibie are, I consider, mucros, the
outer and larger one being in the usual position, ‘the inner one
replacing the tuft of hairs often present when the tibia is a
little dilated on the inner margin of the apex.
Diethusa fervida.
D. nigra, squamis leete rufo-ferrugineis, supra maculatim ochraceis,
dense vestita ; rostro antennisque fulvo-ferrugineis, vel ferrugineis,
illo prothorace manifeste breviore ; funiculi articulo primo modice
elongato, secundo breviore ; prothorace utrinque rotundato ; elytris
striato-punctatis, punctis elongatis, nitidis, interstitiis modice con-
vexis; corpore infra pedibusque fulvo-ferrugineis, sejunctim griseo-
squamosis ; femoribus posticis dente ampliato instructis. Long.
2 lin.
Hab. South Australia.
Emplesis jilirostris.
&
i oblongo- elliptica, picea, squamis griscis sejunctim tecta; capite
inter oculos squamis majoribus prominulis instructo ; rostro fili-
formi, ¢duplo, 2 prothorace triplo longiore, castaneo, nudo, fere
impunctato; antennis gracilibus, sparse setulosis ; prothorace
transverso, antice constricto, lobis ocularibus nullis; elytris pro-
thorace quadruplo longioribus, humeris rotundatis, striato-punctatis,
punctis approximatis, interstitiis haud convexis; corpore infra
squamis piliformibus adsperso; pedibus sejunctim squamosis,
Long. 24 lin.
Hab, Champion Bay.
186 Mr. F. P™ Pascoe on Adduiens to
In this and the following species there is a decided curve at
the sides of the three intermediate abdominal segments, a
character which places them in the “ Storéides” of Lacor-
daire ; however, they cannot, in my opinion, be separated from
Emplesis.
Emplesis storeoides.
#. sat late elliptica, nigra, supra sat dense umbrino-squamosa ; eapite,
antennis rostroque ferrugineis, hoc prothorace longiore, nudo,
nitido, fere impunctato ; oculis majusculis ; funiculi articulo primo
manifeste crassiore; prothorace valde transverso, apice fortiter
angustato, utrinque pone apicem modice rotundato ; scutello ovali ;
elytris elongato-cordatis, striatis, in medio dimidii basalis nigro-
squamosis, postice vage nigro-maculatis ; corpore infra pedibusque
ferrugineis, sparse albido-squamosis. Long. 2 lin.
Hab. Queensland (Gayndah).
LYBABA.
Rostrum tenuiter cylindricum, arcuatum, basi paulo compressum ;
scrobes submediane, recte, fere in medio oculorum currentes.
Scapus oculum vix attingens ; funiculus 7-articulatus, articulo
primo elongato, ceteris gradatim brevioribus, obconicis; clava
distincta. Oculi subtenuiter granulati, vix approximati. Prothorax
subconicus, basi bisinuatus, lobis ocularibus nullis, Seutellum
oblongum. Llytra subcordiformia, convexa. Pectus modice elon-
gatum, canaliculatum. Coawe antice basi contigue, intermedi
distantes ; femora crassa, dentata; tibia antice et intermedize
rectee, calcarate, apice (unco obliquo armatz) postice subflexuosi,
versus apicem latiores; tarsi articulo tertio valde bilobo, quarto
minusculo. Abdomen segmentis duobus basalibus ampliatis, tribus
intermediis lateraliter arcuatis.
Except in the second abdominal segment, the curve at the
sides is very slightly marked ; still the sutures are not so straight
as in Diethusa. ‘The genus is closely allied to Enide; L. sub-
fasciata, indeed, might be taken at first sight for the small
variety of /. wstwans; but the character ot the rostrum is
essentially different.
Lybeba subfasciata.
L. ferruginea,squamis lete ferrugineis, nigro-varils, sat dense vestita ;
rostro nudo, subtestaceo, prothorace paulo longiore ; funiculi ar-
ticulo primo duobus sequentibus conjunctim equali ; prothorace
apice paulo constricto, utrinque rotundato ; elytris striatis, fasciis
nigris indeterminatis tribus, ad suturam interruptis, notatis ;
corpore infra pedibusque sejunctim griseo-squamosis. Long. 13 lin.
Hab. Swan River (Albany).
This species has a longer prothorax than the following,
the Australian Cureulionide. 187
narrower proportionally at the base and strongly constricted
towards the apex ; the scales also are more closely set.
Lybeba repanda.
L. castanea, squamis subfulvis castaneisque vestita ; rostro prothorace
lougiore, ferrugineo, nudo, punctis linearibus sat confertim im-
presso ; funiculo articulis duobus basalibus longitudine sequalibus ;
oculis minus tenuiter granulatis ; prothorace magis transverso,
apice vix constricte utrinque subfulvo, disco, macula triangulari
basali excepta, castaneo-squamoso ; elytris striatis, fasciis duabus
latis indeterminatis castaneis, una ante, altera pone medium, ad
suturam interruptis, ornatis ; corpore infra pedibusque sat vage
griseo-squamosis ; COXIS intermediis valde remotis ; abdominis seg-
mento secundo breviore. Long. 1 lin.
Hab. Swan River (Albany).
JNIDE.
Rostrum paulo arcuatum, apicem versus tenuius ; scrobes premediane,
laterales, oblique. Scapus longiusculus, oculum attingens ; funi-
culus 7-articulatus, articulis duobus basalibus longiusculis, reliquis
obconicis, gradatim brevioribus ; clava distincta. Ocult rotundati,
tenuiter granulati, modice approximati. Prothorav subconicus,
basi bisinuatus, lobis ocularibus nulls. Scevtellum angustum.
Elytra subcordiformia, singula basi emarginata. Pectus breve,
canaliculatum. Cove antice basi contigue, intermediz distantes ;
jemora crassa, dentata ; tébiv apice mucrone calcariformi munite,
antice et intermediz arcuate vel subflexuose, postice fere rectz,
apicem versus crassiores ; ¢ars? articulo tertio late bilobo, quarto
longiusculo; wagwiculi divaricati. Abdomen segmentis duobus
basalibus ampliatis, intermediis lateraliter arcuatis.
The rostrum is bent and narrowed towards the apex; this
will at once differentiate the genus from Lybaba, which has
also a short pectoral canal. he three intermediate segments
of the abdomen in LZ. porphyrea are slightly curved at the sides ;
but in H#. westuans it is difficult to decide either way : when the
abdomen is at all convex there must be a corresponding curva-
ture ; but this is quite different from the little curved processes
at the sides, which are the peculiarity in question. In this
genus there 1s a broad excavation extending over the whole of
the meso-and metasterna and the middle of the first abdominal
segment; a similar excavation is found also in Lybeba, but
not involving the abdomen. ‘There is aconsiderable difference
in the coloration of individuals of the same species in this and
some of the allied genera.
Enide poryhyrea.
#. pallide ferruginea, sqramis flavescentibus, supra plagiatim rufis
188 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
vel rufo-ferrugineis, omnino dense vestita; rostro antennisque
pallidioribus, illo prothorace paulo breviore, apice solo nudo, in
medio leviter carinulato; funiculo articulis duobus basalibus lon-
gitudine fere «qualibus; prothorace subtransverso, basi fortiter
bisinuato; elytris basi prothorace multo latioribus, lateraliter
modice rotundatis, humeris callosis, striato-punctatis, punctis
linearibus, interstitiis secundo, tertio, quinto et septimo carinato-
elevatis. Long. 24-23 lin.
Hab. Western Australia.
My specimens from Champion Bay are much paler than
those from Albany. -
Enide estuans.
#. nigra, squamis ruto-ferrugineis, maculatim ochraceis dense ves-
tita; rostro prothorace longiore, magis subulato, basi lineis
elevatis tenuiter munito; funiculi articulo secundo quam primo
longiore ; prothorace transverso, utrinque modice rotundato, seepe
ochraceo-quadrimaculato; elytris parum brevioribus, postice magis
latioribus, maculis ochraceis numerosis sepe ornatis, striato-
punctatis, punctis linearibus, interstitiis convexis, secundo, tertio,
quinto et septimo elevatis, in medio linea levigata instructis,
basi singulatim late emarginatis ; corpore infra sparse flavescenti-
squamoso ; femoribus crassis, anticis margine superiore arcuatis ;
tibiis anticis longiusculis. Long. 14 lin.
Hab. Swan River (Albany).
Prothorax more transverse, the elytra broader posteriorly,
and the base of each less deeply emarginate, are among the
most prominent diagnostic characters of this species.
Enide saniosa.
E. nigra, squamis saturate ferrugineis, maculatim nigris ochraceisque
dense vestita; rostro ut in precedente; antennis pallide ferru-
gineis ; oculis minus tenuiter granulatis; prothorace transyerso,
utrinque modice rotundato, fere unicolori; elytris striato-punctatis,
punctis linearibus, interstitiis vix convexis, equalibus, maculis
nigris ochraceisque indeterminatis notatis ; corpore infra sat sparse
flavescenti-squamoso ; femoribus minus incrassatis, anticis margine
superiore vix arcuatis; tibiis anticis breviusculis. Long. 1} lin.
Hab. Fremantle.
This dark-coloured little species will be readily known from
the two preceding by the absence of raised lines on the elytra.
HEpDYOPIS.
Rostrum tenuiter cylindricum; scrobes preemediane, fere infra rostrum
currentes. Scapus oculum haud attingens; funiculus articulis
duobus basalibus elongatis, ceteris gradatim brevioribus, ultimis
the Australian Cureulionide. 189
obconicis ; clava distincta. Oculi ovati, tenuiter granulati. Pro-
thorax subconicus, basi bisinuatus, lobis ocularibus nullis. Elytra
breviuscula, prothorace multo latiora. Femora incrassata, mutica ;
tibie antice et intermedi arcuate, apice bicalcarate, postice
rect, aplcem versus crassiores, spinoso-mucronate ; tarsi articulo
tertio late bilobo. Abdomen segmentis duobus basalibus ampliatis,
tribus intermediis ad latera arcuatis.
Allied to Erytenna ; but without ocular lobes, and the an-
terior and intermediate tibiz having two spurs at the apex,
the inner one the ordinary mucro, the other being claw-shaped
and arising within the rim of the apex, as in many Crypto-
rhynchine. ‘The species here described is not unlike Sibinia
arenarie,
Hedyopis selligera.
H. ovata, nigra, sat dense albido-squamosa, in medio plaga magna
communi ochracea postice atro-marginata ornata; rostro nitido,
fere nudo, vage punctulato ; antennis ferrugineis ; clava breviter
ovata; prothorace latitudine longitudini equali, utrinque paulo
ampliato; scutello triangulari; elytris subcordatis, prothorace
multo latioribus, striatis, humeris subeallosis, apice rotundatis ;
corpore infra pedibusque argenteo-squamosis; tibiis anticis lon-
giusculis. Long. 13 lin.
Hab. Champion Bay.
GERYNASSA.
Rostrum cylindricum, arcuatum, apice latius; scrobes mediane,
laterales, oblique. Scapus oculum attingens: funiculus 7-articu--
latus, articulo primo ampliato, secundo vix breyiore, ceteris
brevibus, ultimis transversis ; clava distincta. Oculi subrotundati,
fortiter granulati. Prothorax transversus, antice constrictus,
basi subtruncatus. Scutellwm triangulare. Elytra ampla, pro-
thorace multo latiora. Pectus brevissimum, haud canaliculatum.
Coxe antice contigue, intermedie approximate. Femora crassa,
mutica; tibie subflexuosse, apice mucronate ; tarsi articulo tertio
bilobo, quarto elongato. Abdomen segmentis duobus basalibus
ampliatis, tribus intermediis ad latera leviter arcuatis. .
The coarsely faceted eyes and subtruncated base of the
prothorax are the diagnostic characters of this genus, by
which it may at once be differentiated from Hrytenna; both
genera, from the breadth of their elytra, havea similar contour.
Gerynassa nodulosa.
G. rufo-ferruginea, squamis griseis silaceisque variegata, plagis nigris
basi prothoracis et circa scutellum notata, aliquando maculis aliis
adspersa; rostro nitide ferrugineo, basin versus utrinque linea
elevata instructo; antennis dilute ferrugineis; prothorace pone
apicem sat abrupte convexo, utrinque ampliato; scutello nigro,
190 | Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
triangulari; elytris supra ineequaliter striato-punctatis, interstitils
tertio et quarto singulatim tribus vel quatuor nodulis nigro-
squamosis munitis, in medio fascia pallidiore ornatis, humeris paulo
callosis ; corpore infra pedibusque sejunctim griseo-squamosis.
Long. 2 lin.
Hab. West Australia; South Australia.
Gerynassa basalis.
G, nigra, squamis ferrugineis et nigrescentibus variegata; rostro
nitide ferrugineo, prothorace longiore, versus apicem obsolete
impunctato ; antennis ferrugineis, scapo apice valde clavato ; funi-
culi articulo primo quam secundo paulo breviore; clava nigra;
prothorace ut in precedente; elytris supra sequaliter convexis,
striato-punctatis, singulis basi plaga nigra ornatis, in medio et
parte apicali nigrescentibus; corpore infra pedibusque seyunctim
griseo-squamosis. Long. 21—23 lin.
Hab. South Australia (Gawler).
DICOMADA.
Rostrum tenuiter cylindricum, apice latius et crassius, arcuatum;
scrobes submedianz (in D, terrea premediane), rectze. Scapus
oculum haud attingens; funiculus 7-articulatus, articulis duobus
basalibus elongatis, vel primo solo elongato; clava distincta.
Oculi tenuiter granulati. Prothorax transversus, postice dilatatus,
basi rotundatus, vel parum bisinuatus, lobis ocularibus nullis.
Elytra subcordiformia, leviter convexa; prothorace paulo latiora.
Pectus breviusculum. Cove intermedi sat remote ; femora in-
crassata, mutica; tibiew flexuose, apice mucronate; tarsi lati,
articulo quarto breviusculo. Abdomen segmentis duobus basalibus
ampliatis, tribus intermedius ad latera arcuatis.
Of the three species here described, D. terrea has a shorter
and proportionally stouter rostrum, with the scrobes more
towards the apex; the rostrum, however, is in other respects
essentially the same. Cydmeaa has the rostrum attenuated
throughout, and the apex compressed when viewed sideways.
Dicomada litigiosa.
D. fusca, squamis concoloribus argenteisque varie vestita; rostro
prothorace sesquilongiore, vix squamoso, basi subtiliter lineatim
punctulato; antennis subtestaceis, funiculo gracili; prothorace
apice multo angustiore, utrinque rotundato; elytris oblongo-sub-
cordiformibus, striato-punctatis, interstitiis convexis ; corpore infra
argenteo-squamoso ; pedibus ferrugineis, parce squamosis.. Long.
12 lin.
Hab. Fremantle.
In the individual here described there are three lightly
the Australian Curculionide. 191
marked stripes on the prothorax, and an ill-defined band on
the middle of the elytra; but in others there is simply a faint
mottling of brown only to be seen under a good lens.
Dicomada ovalis.
D. ferruginea, subtus prothoraceque nigrescentibus, squamis sub-
aureis parce adspersa; rostro prothorace manifeste longiore, piceo,
apice pallidiore, scrobibus paulo pone medium incipientibus ; funi-
culi articulo primo quam secundo duplo longiore; prothorace
antice latiore, utrinqne pone apicem paulo dilatato, lateribus leviter
rotundato; elytris breviter subcordiformibus, striato-punctatis,
interstitiis haud convexis, in medio uniseriatim setulosis ; pedibus
rufo-ferrugineis, parce squamosis. Long. 1 lin.
Hab. Swan River (Albany).
The shorter elytra and somewhat subequilateral form of the
prothorax are at once distinctive of this species.
Dicomada terrea.
D. nigra, subsilaceo-squamosa, medio prothoracis fusco ; rostro minus
tenui, prothorace vix longiore, basi lineis quinque elevatis munito ;
scrobibus apicem versus incipientibus; antennis ferrugineis ;
funiculi articulo primo quam secundo paulo longiore ; prothorace
apice multo angustiore, utrinque rotundato, in medio longitudina-
liter fusco ; elytris oblongo-cordiformibus, striis obtectis ; corpore
is. infra nigro, squamis albidis adsperso; pedibus ferrugineis, parce
n. squamosis. Long. 13 lin.
i Hab. Champion Bay.
a, : . :
ti The scales, without being very closely set, completely hide
the narrow striz of the elytra.
et
ore PARYZETA.
0t8 Rostrum tenuiter cylindricum, arcuatum, versus apicem gradatim
tel latius ; scrobes submedianze, oblique. Scapus oculum attingens ;
funiculus 7-articulatus, articulo primo elongato, incrassato, ceteris
minusculis; clava ampla, distincta. Oculi ovales, tenuiter granulati.
Prothorax transversus, basi rotundatus, lobis ocularibus nullis.
Elytra prothorace multo latiora, oblongo-cordiformia. Femora
incrassata, mutica ; dibiw subarcuatee, apice obsolete mucronate ;
tarsi articulo tertio late bilobo, quarto elongato. Cowa intermedi
approximate. Abdomen segmentis duobus basalibus ampliatis,
tertio quartoque ad latera paulo arcuatis.
The characters of the rostrum and the narrower elytra are
those which principally distinguish this genus from Yeda.
Erirhinus infirmus will give a good idea of the following
species.
192 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
Paryzeta musiva.
P. ovata, ferruginea vel fusca, dense griseo-squamosa ; rostro an-
tennisque fulvo-testaceis, clava nigricante, illo prothorace sesqui-
longiore, basi sparse piloso, apice nudo, subtilissime vage punctu-
lato; prothorace antice multo angustiore, utrinque fortiter
rotundato ; elytris basi parum convexis, lateribus ad medium sub-
parallelis, deinde rotundatis, striatis, interstitiis planatis, fasciis
duabus indeterminatis, aliquando obsoletis, ad suturam interruptis,
una in medio, altera ante apicem sita; corpore infra pedibusque
ferrugineis, sat dense albido-squamosis. Long. 13 lin.
Hab, Champion Bay.
XEDA.
Rostrum breviusculum, cylindricum, arcuatum ; scrobes submedianee,
laterales, paulo oblique. ante oculos desinentes. Scapus 1 ocu-
lum impingens; funiculus 7-articulatus, articulo primo valido ;
clava distincta, acuminata. Oculi ovati, laterales, ampliati,
tenuissime granulati. Prothorav transversus, subconicus, basi
rotundatus; lobis ocularibus nullis. /ytra ampliata, paulo con-
vexa. Pectus breve. Cow antic contiguee, intermediz approx-
imatie ; femora incrassata, mutica ; tebee paulo arcuatee vel sub-
flexuosee, apice mucronate; tars? articulo tertio bilobo, quarto
elongato ; wnguiculi. divaricati. Abdomen segmentis duobus
basalibus ampliatis, tribus intermediis lateraliter paulo arcuatis.
This genus differs from Cydmea (ante, vol. ix. p. 137) in its
scape impinging on the eye, in the absence of ocular lobes,
and in the approximation of the intermediate coxe. The two
species here described are somewhat remarkable for the large
size of the elytra; of the first there is a small variety with more
mottled elytra.
Xeda amplipennis.
X. nigra, varie griseo-squamosa ; rostro. prothorace vix longiore,
nigro, punctulato, basi linea levigata munito ; antennis ferrugineis,
clava nigra ; funiculi articulo basali tribus sequentibus conjunctim
vix breviore; prothorace basi longitudine fere duplo latiore,
saturatim bivittato ; scutello rotundato ; elytris striato-punctatis,
interstitiis haud convexis, pone medium fascia maculata nigra
angusta ornatis; corpore infra femoribusque nigris, dense ar-
genteo-squamosis; tibiis tarsisque ferrugineis, squamis angustis
adspersis. Long. 13 lin.
Hab. Swan River (Albany).
Neda bilineata.
X. picea, fusco-squamosa, prothorace elytrisque dorso linea interrupta
albida utrinque ornatis; rostro prothorace paulo breviore, basi
excepta, leete fulvo; antennis fulvo-ferrugineis, clava nigricanti ;
funiculi articulo basali duobus sequentibus conjunctim vix lon-
the Australian Curculionide. 193
giore ; prothorace basi angustiore, utrinque rotundato, sejunctim
punctato; scutello minuto; elytris striato-punctatis, interstitiis
4°, 5°, 6° plus minusve albido-squamosis, postice setulis albis
raris munitis; corpore infra nigro, argenteo-squamoso ; apicibus
femorum, tibiis tarsisque fulvo-ferrugineis. Long. 12 lin.
Hab. Champion Bay.
One of my specimens, which I take to be a female, has a
longer unicolorous rostrum.
OLAN ZA.
Rostrum paulo arcuatum, apicem versus tenuius ; scrobes premediane,
oblique, infra rostrum cito currentes. Scapus longiusculus, oculo
impingens ; fuwniculus 7-articulatus, articulo primo majusculo,
ceteris breviter obconicis; clava distincta. Oculi minusculi,
tenuiter granulati. Prothorax angustior, postice rotundatus, basi
subtruncatus, lobis ocularibus nullis. Hlytra oblonga, prothorace
multo latiora. Femora clavata, mutica; tibie@ subflexuosz, apice
mucronate ; tars? articulo tertio bilobo, quarto elongato. Coae
intermedi approximate. Abdomen segmentis duobus basalibus
ampliatis, tribus intermediis ad latera arcuatis. Corpus setosum.
This genus is trenchantly differentiated by the direction of
its scrobes and the absence of scales, except on the under patts.
Its affinities are doubtful.
Olanea nigricollis.
O. ovalis, ferruginea, capite, rostro basi, prothorace, elytrisque mar-
ginibus suturaque nigris ; rostro prothorace paulo longiore, usque
ad medium parce albido-setosis ; antennis ferrugineis; funiculi
articulo primo quam secundo, fere duplo longiore ; prothorace lon-
gitudine parum latiore, utrinque rotundato, crebre punctulato,
setulis erectis adsperso ; elytris oblongo-subcordiformibus, striato-
punctatis, interstitiis uniseriatim setosis; corpore infra nigro,
albo-squamoso. Long. 13 lin.
Hab. Swan River (Albany).
ANTYLLIS.
Rostrum longiusculum, cylindricum, vel apicem versus paulo attenu-
atum ; scrobes submediane, laterales, infra oculos desinentes.
Scapus oculum attingens ; funiculus 6-articulatus, articulis duobus
basalibus breviusculis, ceteris transversis. Oculi minores. Cetera
ut in Xeda.
In general appearance like Xeda, but very trenchantly dif-
ferentiated by its six-jointed funicle.
Antyllis setosa.
A, fusca, pedibus rufo-ferrugineis, unguiculis nigris, supra sat dense
ps ;
griseo-, in medio cervino-squamosa ; rostro griseo-setoso, dimidio
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 13
194 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
apicali rufo-ferrugineo ; antennis ferrugineis, clava nigricante ;
prothorace manifeste transverso, utrinque valde rotundato ; elytris
subcordatis, striato-punctatis, interstitiis uniseriatim albido-
setosis ; corpore infra albido-squamoso. Long. 13 lin.
Hab. South Australia.
Antyllis griseola.
A, picea, pedibus ferrugineis, unguiculis nigris, supra minus dense
griseo-, in medio cervino-squamosa ; rostro magis subulato, dimidio
apicali ferrugineo; scapo articuloque basali funiculi ferrugineis,
reliquis clavaque nigris ; prothorace angustiore, longitudine lati-
tudini fere wquali; elytris striato-punctatis, interstitiis haud
setosis ; corpore infra dense argenteo-squamoso. Long. 13 lin.
Hab. Swan River (Albany).
Differs from the last principally in its longer prothorax and
absence of setee from the elytra.
Antyllis aurulenta.
A, pallide ferruginea, dense aureo-rufescenti-squamosa, setulis albis
numerosis adspersa ; rostro prothorace paulo breviore, sparse albo-
setoso, dimidio apicali nigro ; antennis pallidis ; clava nigricante ;
prothorace longitudine latitudini fere equali, utrinque leviter
rotundato ; elytris breviter subcordatis, striato-punctatis, inter-
stitiis uniseriatim sat confertim setosis; corpore infra pallide
flavescenti-squamoso. Long. 1} lin.
Hab, Champion Bay.
A shorter species proportionally than either of the two pre-
ceding ; under a Coddington the scales appear of a beautiful
golden brown (reddish), but in certain lights a little hoary.
CYTTALIA.
Caput deflectum, angustum ; rostrum cum capite gradatim confluens,
subtenue ; scrobes subapicales, infra rostrum cito currentes. Scapus
ad marginem posticum oculi attingente; funiculus 7-articulatus,
articulis duobus basalibus longiusculis, primo ecrassiore, ceteris
gradatim brevioribus; clava distincta. Oculi prominuli, fortiter
granulati. Prothorax transversus, antice paulo constrictus, basi
truncatus, lobis ocularibus nullis. Hlytra ovalia, prothorace
latiora. Femora incrassata, postica dentata; tibie flexuose,
apice inermes ; tarsi articulo tertio lato, fortiter bilobo ; wunguicula
divergentes. Coxe antice exserte, contigue. Abdomen segmentis
duobus basalibus ampliatis. Corpus pilosum.
A very distinct genus, which agrees with Phrenozemia in
its narrow head gradually passing mto the rostrum; but it is:
pubescent or pilose and not scaly, and its hind femora only are
toothed. The prothorax is unusually small compared with the
the Australian Curculionide. 195
elytra. The two species of the genus, the second of which is
from New Zealand, are not unlike Orchestes fagi, but con-
siderably larger.
Cyttalia griseipila.
C. oblongo-ovalis, fusca, subnitida, omnino subtiliter griseo-pilosa,
supra setulis erectis adspersa; rostro prothoraci longitudine
eequali, carinulain medio ante apicem desinente ; antennis sub-
testaceis, scapo apice clavaque nigricantibus ; prothorace latitudine
paulo breyiore, crebre punctato, utrinque modice rotundato ; scu-
tello minuto, triangulari; elytris quam prothorace ampliatis, et
plus quadruplo longioribus, substriato-punctatis, punctis paulo
approximatis ; pedibus posticis longioribus; tibiis longiusculis.
Long. 2 lin.
Hab. Sydney.
Phrenozemia lunata.
P. oblonga, fusca, squamositate sordide grisea tecta, squamulis pili-
formibus adspersa; rostro nigro, confertim punctato, basi squa-
moso; antennis ferrugineis, funiculi articulo primo valde incrassato,
secundo tertioque conjunctim manifeste brevioribus ; prothorace
cylindrico; elytris striato-punctatis, interstitiis alternis fortiter
elevatis, tertio quintoque singulatim versus apicem tuberculo parvo
instructis, pone medium litera V-reversa, nigro-marginata, signatis.
Long. 13 lin.
Hab. Western Australia (Fremantle).
Size and outline of P. lyproides (ante, vol. x. p. 95), but,
inter alia, at once differentiated by the raised alternate inter-
stices of the elytra; the coloration and, indeed, the general
appearance can scarcely fail to recall our Gronops lunatus.
In the generic formula, owing to some agglutination of the
hairs in the specimen I examined, the second and third joints
of the funicle were described as one; in reality, however, P.
lyproides has the second joint considerably shorter than the
first, as in this species.
Meriphus coronatus.
M. griseo-setulosus, vix nitidus; capite supra nigro ; rostro capite
fere duplo longiore, subferrugineo, apice nigro; antennis sub-
ferrugineis, funiculo clavaque infuscatis ; prothorace basi minus
dilatato, crebre rugoso-punctato, silaceo, margine antico nigro ;
elytris silaceis, scutello suturaque nigris, rude striato-punctatis,
singulis basi emarginatis, humeris callosis; corpore infra nigro,
squamis niveis rotundatis elongatis intermixtis adsperso ; pedibus
ferrugineis, femoribus in medio nigris. Long. 2 lin.
Hab. West Australia.
Besides the difference of colour, this species has the prothorax
13*
196 Mr. F. P. Pascoe on Additions to
narrower at the base, and the elytra on each side of the scu-
tellum are projected forward, the part between this and the
shoulder showing a deep emargination.
Brexius lineatus.
B. oblongus, niger, squamulis piliformibus griseis adspersus ; rostro
prothorace breviore, antice carinulis quinque manifeste munito ;
scrobibus terminalibus ; antennis subferrugineis, clava infuscata ;
prothorace paulo longiore quam latiore, confertissime granulato-
punctato ; elytris striato-punctatis, interstitiis in medio uniseriatim
setosis, alternis paulo elevatis, sexto sordide albido; corpore infra
nitide castaneo, parce setoso ; femoribus infuscatis ; tibiis tarsisque
subferrugineis, longe pilosis. Long. 3 lin.
Hab. Melbourne.
A dark, almost black, species, notwithstanding its greyish
scales; the scrobes are completely terminal. I placed Brexius
with the Amalactine on account of its cavernous corbels, the
only character apparently that separates it from the Erirhinine. .
Psepholax Mastersii.
P. ovyalis, fuscus, opacus, disperse squamosus ; capite inter oculos ex-
cavato; rostro brevi, antice et inter oculos dense ferrugineo-
hirsuto ; antennis ferrugineis ; prothorace transverso, antice multo
angustiore, utrinque fortiter rotundato, creberrime granulato-
punctato; elytris striato-punctatis, interstitiis convexis, sat con-
fertim granulatis; tibiis intermediis in medio dente magno in-
structis. Long. 4 lin.
Hab. Wide Bay (Queensland).
Differs from P. barbifrons, Wh. (Ereb. & Terr., Ins. p. 15),
in its more closely punctured prothorax, with the intervals
granuliform, the different form of the intermediate tibie, &c.
This and the two following species are interesting as belonging
toa genus hitherto supposed to be peculiar to New Zealand.
Psepholax egerius.
P. obovatus, fuscus, vix nitidus, rostro breviusculo, basi antice et
inter oculos pallide barbato; antennis ferrugineis, longioribus ;
prothorace transverso,apice subito constricto, creberrime granulato-
punctato ; elytris oblongo-cordatis, striato-punctatis, interstitiis
convexis, dense ferrugineo-squamosis, pygidio detecto; tibiis in-
termediis dente magno instructis. Long. 33 ln.
Hab. Queensland.
Tam indebted to Dr. Howitt for my specimens of this species.
It may be known at once from the preceding by its outline,
dependent on its short prothorax, suddenly narrowed anteriorly,
and its cordiform elytra.
the Australian Curculionide. 197
Psepholax latirostris.
P. cylindricus, fuseus, parum nitidus, squamis concoloribus griseo
irroratis vestitus ; rostro brevi, latissimo, crebre punctato ; oculis
ovalibus, inter se valde remotis ; antennis ferrugineis, scapo in
oculum impingente ; prothorace latitudine parum longiore, antice
angusto, utrinque modice rotundato, confertim punctato ; elytris
longiusculis, striato-punctatis, interstitiis parum convexis, sat
confertim granulatis ; tibiis intermediis margine exteriore edentatis.
Long. 4 lin.
Hab. UWlawarra.
It would be better perhaps to consider this species the
exponent of a new genus.
Poropterus satyrus.
oblongo-ovatus, convexus, niger, omnino pallide umbrino-
squamosus ; capite inter oculos foveato; rostro modice tenuato,
basi irregulariter sat vage punctato; antennis piceis; funiculi
articulo secundo quam primo fere duplo longiore ; claya ovata,
acuminata; prothorace modice conyexo, apice vix producto,
utrinque fortiter rotundato, basi versus scutellum paulo lobato,
supra squamis erectis claviformibus adsperso; elytris convexis,
pone medium latioribus, postice gradatim declivibus, apicibus ro-
tundatis, epipleuris distinctis, supra tuberculato-fasciculatis, gra-
nulis nitidis paucis prope scutellum obsitis; segmento ultimo
abdominis tribus preecedentibus conjunctim longitudine equal ;
tibiis subtenuatis, manifeste flexuosis; tarsis articulo tertio sat
fortiter bilobo. Long. 8-9 lin.
Hab. Tasmania.
A large coarse species, in outline like P. antiquus, Er.,
which has, ¢nter alia, the first two joints of the funicle equal
in length, and shorter, nearly straight, tibie.
Poropterus tnominatus.
P. ovatus, minus conyexus, niger, umbrino-squamosus ; capite inter
oculos foveato, fronte carinato; rostro basi confertim, apicem
versus gradatim minus punctato ; funiculi articulo secundo quam
primo fere duplo longiore ; clava ovata, obtusa; prothorace ut in
P. satyro, sed apice parum bituberculato; elytris brevioribus,
basi circa scutellum paulo depressis et squamulis concoloribus
arcte adpressis, apicem versus magis constrictis, singulis fasciculis
duobus nigricantibus (una subbasali, altera paulo pone medium)
notatis, apice rotundatis ; corpore infra pedibusque dense squa-
mosis, squamis claviformibus erectis interjectis. Long. 7 lin.
Hab. Queensland.
This species resembles the preceding ; but is shorter, less
convex, the parts behind the carina, marking the upper margin
198 On Additions to the Australian Curculionide.
of the epipleura, abruptly constricted, and the scales at the
base of the elytra-concolorous with and closely fixed to the
derm, the part, except under a strong lens, appearing denuded.
Poropterus varicosus.
P. ovatus, convexus, niger, capite rostroque umbrino-squamosis ;
funiculi articulo secundo quam primo duplo longiore, ceteris ro-
tundatis vel submoniliformibus ; prothorace apice paulo producto,
utrinque manifeste rotundato, tuberculis sex inconspicuis notato—
duobus apicalibus, quatuor in medio transyersim sitis; elytris
pone medium latioribus, singulis interrupte bicarinato-fasciculatis,
apice late rotundatis, epipleuris haud determinatis; tibiis brevibus,
validis, manifeste flexuosis. Long. 5 lin.
Hab. Mlawarra.
Much the same kind of outline as the two preceding, but
more convex, the flanks of the elytra not marked off by a
carina, shorter and stouter tibie, &e.
Poropterus oniscus.
P. ovatus, sat fortiter convexus, niger, capite rostroque squamis um-
brinis tectus ; rostro valido ; scapo breviusculo, ante medium rostri
inserto ; funiculi articulo secundo quam primo sesquilongiore ;
oculis fortiter granulatis ; prothorace antice modice constricto, apice
paulo angustiore, vix producto, utrinque rotundato, tuberculis fasci-
culatis sex notato—duobus apicalibus, quatuor transversis ; elytris
ovalibus, in medio quam prothorace multo latioribus, seriatim punc-
tatis, interspatiis subtuberculiformibus, squamis majoribus erectis
adspersis, basi paucifasciculatis, apice rotundatis ; segmentis duobus
basalibus abdominis valde ampliatis ; tibiis breviusculis, flexuosis.
Long. 4 lin,
Hab. Queensland.
The antennez in nearly all the species of Poropterus are in-
serted not far from the tip of the rostrum; in this one the
insertion is nearer the middle.
Poropterus tumulosus.
P. ovatus, modice convexus, fuscus, omnino squamis pallide um-
brinis dense tectus; rostro valido; funiculo articulis duobus
basalibus haud elongatis, primo quam secundo fere zequali, ceteris
transversis ; clava ovali; oculis tenuissime granulatis ; prothorace
antice multo angustiore, apice producto, crebre punctato, in medio
longitudinaliter excavato, tuberculis duodecim instructo—ducbus
apicalibus, decem in seriebus duabus transversis sitis; elytris
breviter oyatis, pone medium prothorace multo latioribus, postice
fortiter declivibus, singulis tuberculis validis circa viginti sub-
seriatim positis, apicibus rotundatis ; segmentis duobus basalibus
On the Silurus and Glanis of the Ancients. 199
abdominis valde ampliatis; tibiis brevibus, anticis flexuosis, re-
liquis rectis. Long. 3 lin.
Hab. South Australia; Tasmania.
This little species will be easily recognized by the numerous
tubercles on the elytra.
Rhinoncus nigriventris.
R. ovatus, subnitidus, supra pedibusque ferrugineus, parce subtiliter
pilosus, sternis abdomineque nitide nigris ; rostro breviusculo, sat
valido ; prothorace crebre punctato, basi nigro-marginato ; elytris
cordiformibus, striato-punctatis, interstitiis valde convexis, sutura
basi albido-squamosa ; corpore infra modice punctato. Long. 14 lin.
Hab. Queensland (Gayndah).
Rhinoncus was, with one exception, a purely European
genus; there are, however, a number *of European genera
with representatives, not yet described, in Australia; some of
them are also found in the Malasian region. This species
is very distinct, and, with all the others from Gayndah men-
tioned above, have been kindly sent to me by Mr. Masters,
whose successful explorations I have had so often to mention.
ERRATUM.
In vol. ix. p. 189, under Ochrophebe, “scrobes antemedianz ” should
have been “ scrobes postmediane.”
XXII.— On the Silurus and Glanis of the Ancient Greeks and
Romans. By the Rev. W. Houcuton, M.A., F.L.S.
THERE appears to be no doubt that the sheatfish (Silurus
glanis, Linn.), which has of late years attracted some attention
in this country, was known to the ancient Greeks and Romans
under the names of sz/wrus (aidovpos) and glanis (yAavis),
although some of the writers make a distinction between the
names, and the silurus of one author does not necessarily
represent the silurus of another. ‘The controversies and con-
cessions of perplexed critics,” as the late Dr. Badham remarks,
“caused by this confusion in the ancient nomenclature is
amusing. Poor Scaliger, having first asserted that the glanis
and silurus were different fish, and the silurus certainly the
sturgeon, nexts doubts, and lastly becomes convinced, that the
silurus was unknown to Aristotle ; and after breaking his head
to reconcile what was quite irreconcilable, he offers Cardan, at
last, to give up the controversy altogether, on one condition—
200 Rey. W. Houghton on the Stlurus
viz. that if he himself consents no longer to dispute the identity
of the glanis and silurus, Cardan on his side must forbear to
teach or listen to others who would make him believe that the
silurus was the sturgeon. ‘Itaque,’ says he (laying down the
conditions), ‘silurus sane esto qui et glanis, modo ne glanim
quis dicat sturionem.’”’ (Prose Halieutics, p. 305, note; see also
Scaliger, Exerc. ad Card. 218. n. 3.)
Let us note what classical writers have written as to the
silurus and glanis.
Aristotle, in his ‘ History of Animals,’ does not once mention
the silurus by name ; but speaks of a fish called glanis, which
he says has a tail like a cordylus (newt), that it produces its
ova in a mass (cuveyes adiaor TO KUnua) like perch and frogs,
that large individuals deposit them in deep water, but the
smaller ones in shallow water near the roots of willows amongst
weeds and aquatic plants, that the male glanis is very careful
of the young fry and continues to watch by the eggs and
young for forty or fifty days to protect them from other fish,
that the ova of the glanis are as large as the seed of the orobus,
that it has four branchie on each side, all divided except the
last, that the female glanis is better to eat than the male (an
exception, Aristotle thinks, to fish in general in this respect),
that this fish, from swimming near the surface, is sometimes
star-struck and stupified by thunder, that, if it has ever
once swallowed a hook, it will bite and destroy the hook with
its hard teeth. This is, I believe, all that the Stagirite has
written about the glanis; and with the exception perhaps of
the male of this fish guarding its eggs and young fry, there is
hardly any thing left by means of which the glanis can be
identified. Aristotle nowhere speaks of the great size to which
the sheatfish grows, though he mentions large and small in-
dividuals ; again, the glanis is represented as swimming near
the surface, whereas the sheatfish, like the Siluride generally,
inhabits the bottom of the water.
/Elian appears to consider the glanis and silurus distinct
species of the same family. He speaks of the glanis as being
found in the Meander (Mendere) and Lycus (Tchoruk-Su),
rivers of Asia (Minor), also in Europe in the Strymon (Struma
or Carasou), and says it resembles the silurus. He mentions
the fondness of the male for its eggs, but here, perhaps, is only
quoting Aristotle.
Of the silurus, however, Aulian gives us some interesting
and definite information. He tells us that “in the Egyptian
city of Bubastis there is a pond in which are preserved a great
number of siluri, which are quite tame and gentle; the people
throw them pieces of bread; and the fish jump about one before
and Glanis of the Ancients. 201
the other in their desire to seize the morsels. This fish is also
found in rivers, as in the Cydnus (Tersoos) in Cilicia; but
here it is small, the reason of which is that the clear pure water
of this river, which is moreover very cold, does not supply
the fish with abundant food, the siluri loving disturbed and
muddy water, in which they fatten. The Pyramus (Jihun)
and Sarus (Sihun), also Cilician rivers, produce much finer
specimens. ‘The siluri are also found in the Syrian Orontes
(Nahr el Asy), in the river of the Ptolemies (Belus, the modern
Nahr N’man, which enters the Mediterranean near Ptolemais
in Palestine), and in the lake of Apameia, where they grow
to a large size.” (Nat. Hist. xii. 29.)
Elian is probably correct in all that he has stated here.
The Siluride are still found in the Syrian rivers, as we learn
from Russell, in his ‘Natural History of Aleppo,’ and from
Hiickel, who enumerates three genera. The lake of Apameia,
in which the siluri are said by ddlian to grow to a large size,
appears to be identical with Ayn el Taka (‘‘a large spring
issuing from near the foot of a mountain, and forming a small
lake which communicates with the Orontes”’), visited and
described by Burckhardt in 1812. This traveller says that
the temperature of the spring is “like that of water which has
been heated by the sun in the midst of summer; it is probably
owing to this temperature that we observed such vast numbers
of fish in the lake, and that they resort here in the winter from
the Orontes ; it is principally the species called by the Arabs
the black fish, on account of its ash-coloured flesh; its length
varies from 5 to 8 feet.’ The fishery was in Burckhardt’s
time in the hands of the governor of Kalat el Medyk (¢.e.
castle of Medyk), the ancient Apameia, capital of the province
of Apamene, which Seleucus Nicator fortified and called after
the name of his wife. The fish were principally caught during
the night in small boats, with harpoons, in enormous quantities ;
they were salted on the spot and carried all over Syria and to
Cyprus, for the use of the Christians during their fasts. The
governor of Kalat el Medyk derived income from this fishery
amounting to about £3000. The lake is about 10 feet deep ;
“its breadth is quite irregular, being seldom more than half
an hour; its length is about one hour and a half.” There
seems to be no doubt that the species of Siluroid spoken of by
{Elian as inhabiting this lake is the St/urus anguillaris figured
by Russell (Aleppo, ii. pl. 8), who says the market is plentifully
supplied with this fish from winter till March ; it comes, he
says, from the Orontes and stagnant waters near that river.
“Though it has a rank taste, resembles coarse beef in colour,
and by the doctors is considered unwholesome, it is much
202 Rev. W. Houghton on the Stlurus
eaten by the Christians. It is vulgarly called the black fish
(Simmak al Aswad) ; but the natives affirm the proper name to
be Siloor.” (ii. p. 217.) It would be interesting to know
whether modern travellers have visited this lake and reported
on its fish. The Stlurus anguillaris, Linn., is perhaps the
Clarias Orontis mentioned by Dr. Giinther.
In chapter 25 of Aflian’s 14th book there is the following
account of a curious method of catching siluri, pursued by the
ancient Mysian inhabitants of Scythia and the Danubian
districts, which is interesting and amusing. The species of
fish here referred to is, | presume, the large European Silurus
glanis. “An Istrian fisherman drives a pair of oxen down
to the river-bank, not, however, for the purpose of ploughing ;
for as the proverb says there is nothing in common between
an ox and a dolphin, so we may say, what can a fisherman’s
hands have to do with the plough? If a pair of horses are at
hand, then the fisherman makes use of horses; and with the
yoke on his shoulders down he goes and takes his station at a
spot which he thinks will make a convenient seat for himself,
and be a good place for sport. He fastens one of the ends of
the fishing-rope, which is very strong and suitable, to the
middle of the yoke, and supplies either the horses or the oxen,
as the case may be, with sufficient fodder, and the beasts take
their fill. To the other end of the rope he fastens a very strong
and sharp hook baited with the lung of a wild bull; and this
he throws into the water as a lure to the Istrian silurus (a very
sweet lure for the fish), having previously attached a piece of
lead of sufficient size to the rope near the place where the hook
is bound on, for the purpose of regulating its position in the
water. When the fish perceives the bait of bull’s flesh, he
rushes immediately at the prey, and, meeting with what he so
dearly loves, opens wide his great jaws and greedily swallows
the dreadful bait; then the glutton, turning himself round with
pleasure, soon finds that he has been pierced unawares with
the hook, and being eager to escape from his calamity, shakes
the rope with the greatest violence. The fisherman observes
this, and is filled with delight; he jumps from his seat, and—
now in the character of a fisherman, now in that of a plough-
man (like an actor who changes his mask in a play)—he urges
on his oxen or his horses, and a mighty contest takes place
between the monster («jTos) and the yoked animals; for the
creature (the foster-child of the Ister) draws downwards with
all his might, while the yoked animals pull the rope in the
opposite direction. The fish is beaten -by the united efforts of
two, gives in, and is hauled on to the bank.”
The sheatfish, it is well known, still occurs in the Danube,
and Glanis of the Ancients. 203
and often grows to an enormous size; so that A‘lian’s account
of fishing for it may hardly be exaggerated. Some years ago
there was an amusing drawing in ‘ Punch’s Almanac’ of an
angler, whose fishing-apparatus consisted of a portable crane
on wheels with ropes and pulleys, fishing for these same siluri,
in case of their ever growing to a gigantic size in the rivers of
this country.
It is not quite certain whether Plmy meant to distinguish
between the silurus and the glanis. Of the latter he only says,
“cautius qui glanis vocatur, aversos mordet hamos, nec devorat
sed esca spoliat”’ (Nat. Hist. ix. 43). He may here be referring
to what Aristotle says in the passage I have quoted above.
Of the silurus he says that it inhabits a lake called Nilides,
formed by the Nile (v. 9), also that it occurs in the rivers of
the Fortunate Islands (Canaries) (vi. 32). He enumerates the
silurus of the Nile amongst the fish which grow to an enormous
size, speaks of the devastation it commits, and adds that it
sometimes drags horses under the water as they swim (ix. 15) ;
the male takes care of the eggs (ix. 51). Athenzeus quotes old
writers who appear to regard the glanis and silurus as distinct
fish; the glanis is always much esteemed as a dainty dish.
Matron, the parodist, mentions this fish, with numerous others,
as one of the choice items at an Attic banquet (Athenzus, iv.
136,c). Atheneeus compares a large fish found in the Nile to
the fish called glanis which is found in the Danube (vii. 311, f).
He mentions the silurus four times. In one passage he merely
names it as one he remembered when he was in Egypt (vil.
312, b); in another passage (vil. 287, b) he asks “why people do
not call the fish wedoupos instead of oidovpos, as he has his name
from constantly shaking his tail (aro Tob celew Tv ovpav).”
In other passages the word silurus is used with the epithet
“bad” or stinking, as Sopater the parodist writes (vi. 230, e):
Lampov aidovpoy apyupous rivas Exwv
(‘a stinking silurus on a silver dish”’)*; and Diodorus of Sinope,
speaking of flattering parasites, says that if a man were to eat
cabbages and stinking siluri they would immediately say that
his breath smelt delightfully of violets and roses :
> ,
ois éreto)) Tpocepvyot,
pagartoas 3) Campoy Cidoupoy Karapaywr,
ta kat pd0 pacar abrov hprarnkévat.
(vi. 239, e.)
And the bad quality attributed to the silurus by Athenaus
reminds one of what Juvenal has said to the same effect. He
reminds Crispmus of his low birth and former low occupation,
204 Rey. W. Houghton on the Stlurus
when he used to hawk about siluri for sale in the streets of
Alexandria :—
Jam princeps Equitum, magna qui voce solebat
Vendere municipes fricta de merce siluros.
(Sat. iv. 32, 33.)
And the miser puts by for to-morrow’s dinner the summer bean,
a bit of lizard-fish, with half a stinking silurus :—
nec non differre in tempora cen
Alterius conchem estivam cum parte lacerti
Signatam vel dimidio putrique siluro.
(Sat. xiv. 130.)
Several kinds of St/ur7 are now found in the Nile ; and it is
probable that Juvenal is referring to some small-sized fish of
that family which was much used by the poor people. Both
the lacertus and the silurus were salted and sent over to Rome,
just as we have seen the black fish from the lake of Apameia
were salted and sent to Aleppo, as recorded by Burckhardt and
Russell. The “fricta de merce” appears to allude to the mode
in which the fish were prepared. “Pisces fricti,” says Apicius,
“ut diu durent, eodem momento quo friguntur et levantur, aceto
calido perfunduntur.” Both Diodorus and Lucian tell us that
the Egyptians used to export large quantities of salt fish.
“The Nile,” says Diodorus (1. 36), ‘‘ produces all kinds of fish
in great abundance ; it not only supphes abundant food which
is eaten fresh by the natives, but an endless number (7760s
avéxNevT@Tov) Which are salted and sent abroad.” Lycinus
(in Lucian, Navigium, cap. xv.) implores his friend “ by Isis,
to remember to bring him from Egypt the little salted fish of
the Nile, or ointment from Canopus, or an ibis from Memphis,
or’’ (he jocularly adds) “if his ship was big enough, even one of
the pyramids.”
The “ stinking siluri”’ of Atheneeus and Juvenal therfore no
doubt allude to salted fish which, from being often hastily and
carelessly prepared and hawked about the streets of Rome or
other towns in the hot month of September, would merit the
epithet applied to them.
Pausanias (Greeciee Descrip. iv. cap. xxxiv.) says that “the
Grecian rivers do not produce creatures destructive to man, as
the Indus, the Egyptian Nile, the Rhine, the Ister, Euphrates,
and Phasis; for these rivers nourish creatures which devour
men, and in form they resemble the g/anides of Hermus and
the Meander, excepting that they are blacker and stronger.”
From the passages quoted it seems that various kinds of
Siluri were known to the ancient Greeks and Romans, some-
times under the name of silurus, sometimes under that of glanis.
and Glanis of the Ancients. 205
They do not mention them as fishes either of Greece or Italy ;
and I believe no species of this family is now found in the
rivers of those countries. With regard to the male (Silurus
glanis) protecting its fry, | am not aware whether any modern
observer has recorded this circumstance. It is well known that
some male members of the Siluride# make nests and watch over
their eggs and young ones, like the sticklebacks of this country.
Dr. Hancock has described two species of the genus Doras
(the round-headed and flat-headed hassars of Demerara) which
evince great care for their young ; and I believe Agassiz has
noticed the same thing in two other genera of the same family.
The males of Ardus fissus and A. Commersonii carry the eggs
in their mouth, the latter species even hatching them there.
The peasants of Wallachia say that the males of Silurus glanis
protect their young.
There is one more passage which requires a little considera-
tion. In this one it is certain that the name s¢/urus does not
stand for any of the Siluride, but must mean a sturgeon.
Even at the risk of disturbing the manes of J. C. Scaliger and
Cardan I maintain that the silurus of the Moselle as sung of
by Ausonius can be nothing else than a sturgeon.
Here are Ausonius’s lines :—
Nunc pecus equoreum celebrabere magne Silure:
Quem velut Actzo perductum tergora olivo
Amnicolam Delphina reor ; sic per freta magnum
Laberis, et longi vix corporis agmina solyvis
Aut brevibus defensa vadis, aut fluminis ulvis :
Aut cum tranquillos moliris in amne meatus,
Te virides ripe, te cerula turba natantum,
Te liquide mirantur aque: diffunditur alyeo
Kstus, et extremi procurrunt margine fluctus.
Talis Atlantiaco quondam Balena profundo,
Cum vento motuve suo telluris ad oras
Pellitur, exclusum fundit mare, magnaque surgunt
AEquora, vicinique timent decrescere montes.
Hic tamen, hic nostr mitis Baleena Moselle,
Exitio procul est, magnoque honor additus amni.
(Avson. Id. x. 135-149.)
Hardly a single sentence in this description can apply to the
Stlurus glanis : the arrow-like dartings of the unbending body
cannot possibly refer to the sluggish, slow-swimming, mud-loy-
ing sheatfish ; the voracious silurus can never be called “ mitis
Balena:” but the whole description is well suited either to the
common sturgeon or to the huso. The name river-dolphin is
applicable not only in some degree to the general form of the
sturgeon, but especially to the shape of its head; the “ pecus
206 Prof. A. E. Verrill on the Mollusca
eequoreum”’ may refer to the gregarious habits of that fish ;
“mitis Balena’’ is equally applicable to the mild and in-
offensive sturgeon, while the ‘ agmina defensa corporis’ seem
to allude to the bony plates on that fish’s body. There are,
it is true, other classical designations for the sturgeon more
generally used, such as acipenser and helops; but in this
passage of Ausonius, sd/urus certainly stands for that fish.
Whether sturgeons are now found in the Moselle I am unable
to say.
The flesh of the silurus formed part of the ancient pharma-
copeeia. Dioscorides (Mat. Med. 11. 29) says that in a fresh
state it is nourishing and good for the bowels ; but when salted
it has no nutriment, though it is good for clearing the bronchial
tubes and for the voice ; used as a poultice it draws out thorns,
while the brine from it is good in early stages of dysentery.
XXI.—Remarks on certain Errors in Mr. Jeffreys’s Article
on “The Mollusca of Europe compared with those of Eastern
North America.” By A. E. VERRILL, Professor of Zoology
in Yale College, New Haven, Conn., U.S. A.
In the October number of the ‘Annals and Magazine of Natural
History’ Mr. Jeffreys published an article upon this interesting
subject, in which many important errors occur, due, no doubt,
to the fact that the distinguished author is much less familiar
with American than with European shells. But as the
dredgings in connexion with the investigations of our fisheries
by the U.S. Fish Commission were under my superintendence
during the two past seasons, and Mr. Jeffreys alludes to the
fact (though rather indefinitely) that he, by invitation of Pro-
fessor Baird, accompanied us on several dredging-excursions
in 1871, it seems necessary that I should point out some of the
more important of these errors, lest it be supposed by some
that the same views are held by me.
It is not my intention to discuss at this time the numerical
results presented by Mr. Jeffreys; but | would remind the
readers of his article that the regions compared are in no respect
similar or parallel, and that it is scarcely fair to compare the
shells from the entire coast of Kurope with those from about
200 miles of the coast of New England, where the marine
climate is for the most part more arctic than that of the extreme
north of Scotland—and, moreover, that the last edition of
Gould’s ‘ Invertebrata of Massachusetts’ contains only a part
of the species added to our fauna since the first edition was
published in 1841, and very little of the great mass of facts
of Europe and North America. 207
in regard to distribution, &c., which have been accumulated
by American naturalists during the last thirty years. Con-
sequently that work is far from being a good “standard of
comparison.” ‘To make a just comparison, all the shells on
our coast, from Labrador to Florida, should be compared with
those of Europe.
And without gomg into a long discussion of his peculiar
views on the geographical distribution of our shells, [ would
remark that, to ane American, it seems rather singular that
most Huropean writers, whether zoologists or botanists, find it
necessary to trace back to a Kuropean origin all the existing
species of this country, and to suppose that they have
“migrated” from Europe to America and other countries in
spite of opposing currents and all other obstacles. Thus Mr.
Jeffreys can imagine that our land and freshwater shells could
have migrated from Kurope all the way across Asia, the Pacific
Ocean and North America in order to reach Canada and New
England; but he does not seem to think it possible that they may
have originated in America, and thence crossed to Europe
in the direction of the prevailing currents and winds. Never-
theless geology teaches us that America was a great continent,
in very early ages, when Europe was only a group of islands,
that no other country is richer in the remains of terrestrial ani-
mals and plants connecting the Tertiary and Cretaceous ages
with the present, that many of these supposed European forms
(whether terrestrial or marine) can be traced back into our Ter-
tiary formations quite as far (if not further) than they can in
Europe, and that many of the genera of animals, and especially
of plants, now found living in both countries can be traced back
to the Cretaceous in America and only to the Tertiary in
Europe. Moreover the great number and diversity of the
land and freshwater shells of America (e. g. of Unionide,
Melanie, &c.), and the peculiar facts in their geographical
distribution, cannot but convince any one familiar with the
subject that they have ortg/nated in America at a very remote
period; which is confirmed by the fact that many of these can
be traced far back into our Tertiary formations. Nor are there
sufficient reasons for supposing that those of our species living
also in Kurope have had a history different from those that are
still peculiar to America.
Of course no one will deny that certain species of land-shells
have been introduced from Europe in modern times by human
agency; but, so far as most of the identical species are con-
cerned, it seems to us far more probable that America gave them
to Europe, rather than the contrary, and this whether animals
or plants, terrestrial or marine.
208 Prof. A. E. Verrill on the Mollusca
But the special errors to which I wish to call attention occur
in the table of species, showing their geographical distribution.
These relate both to the names and specific identity of certain
shells, and to the geographical distribution. Although not
agreeing with the author in regard to many of his remarks con-
cerning the generic relations and names of species, I do not
propose to discuss them here; for there seems to be no danger
of their general adoption either in Europe or America.
The following marine species (named as in Gould) which
Mr. Jeffreys puts down as belonging to the region north of
Cape Cod, actually belong properly to the region south of
Cape Cod, extending in most cases to the Carolina coasts or
beyond, while north of Cape Cod they are rare or local, viz.:—
Cochlodesma Leanum, Mactra lateralis, Petricola pholadiformis,
P. dactylus, Gouldia mactracea, Cytherea convexa, Venus
mercenaria, V. notata, Gemma gemma, Liocardium Mortont,
Arca transversa, Modiola plicatula, Pecten irradians, Ostrea
virginiana, Anomia electrica (not of Linn.), Diaphana debilis,
Cylichna oryza, Placobranchus catulus, Crepidula fornicata,
C. plana, C. convera, C. glauca, Ianthina fragilis, Bittium
Greenii, Odostomia bisuturalis, O. seminuda, Turbonilla in-
terrupta, Pleurotoma bicarinata, P. plicata, Nassa obsoleta,
Buccinum cinereum, Diacria trispinosa, Loligo Pealiti.
The following, to which a northern distribution is likewise
given, are also found far south of Cape Cod, and many of them
belong quite as much to the southern as to the northern division;
and some of them are decidedly southern, extending even to the
Gulf of Mexico :—Teredo navalis, T. megotara, T. chlorotica,
Solen ensis, Machera costata, Pandora trilineata, Lyonsia
hyalina, Mactra solidissima, Kellia planulata, Macoma fusca,
Tellina tenera, Astarte castanea, A. quadrans, A. sulcata,
Nucula proxima, Yoldia limatula, Mytilus edulis, Elysia chlo-
rotica, Crucibulum striatum, Littorina rudis, L. tenebrosa,
L. palliata, Lunatia heros, L. triseriata, Nassa trivittata,
Melampus bidentatus, Alexia myosotis.
Many others, not named in the above lists, are not limited
by Cape Cod; but as they belong properly to the northern
division, they are here omitted.
As an offset to these numerous instances in which he has
unduly exaggerated our northern fauna, we find not one un-
doubted instance of an error on the other side, among the
marine shells.
The distribution indicated for our land and freshwater shells
ig even more erroneous. It is sufficiently evident that Cape
Cod is in no sense a proper boundary between the northern and
southern fluviatile and terrestrial species; but, disregarding
of Europe and North America. 209
this, there are no reasons whatever for most of the special in-
dications that he gives.
Thus he gives the northern distribution to all of the sixteen
species of Spherium and Pisidium ; but most of them are well
known to be widely distributed over the eastern, middle, and
western parts of the United States, some even extending to the
southern parts. Unio complanatus, U. nasutus, Margaritana
arcuata, and Anodon tmplicatus are indicated as distributed
north of Cape Cod; but all these are found over most of the
northern and middle states and some in the western, while the
last one is somewhat rare at the north. But Unio radiatus,
U. cariosus, U. ochraceus, Margaritana undulata, M. mar-
ginata, Anodon fluviatilis, and A. undulatus are put down as
southern. It would certainly be difticult to show that these,
as a group, are more southern than the previous lot; for most
of them have nearly the same wide distribution, and all of them,
except U. cariosus, occur even in Maine. Some of them (as
U. radiatus, M. undulata, and A. fluviatilis) are the most
abundant species in all the waters of northern New England
and New Brunswick. ‘The distribution given for the species
of Valvata, Melantho, and Amnicola is equally faulty.
All of the eighty-one species of Helix, Hyalina, Macrocyclis,
Limax, Pupa, Vertigo, Succinea, Arion, Zonites, Tebennophorus,
Limnea, Physa, Bulinus, Planorbis, and Ancylus are set down
as having the northern distribution, except Hyalina Binneyana,
Pupa fallax, Limnea catascopium, and Physa ancillaria.
But every American conchologist knows that nearly all of
those species are very widely distributed over North America,
east, west, north, and south, many of them being limited only
by the Gulf of Mexico on the south and California or the
Pacific on the west. Nor is there any reason for the distinction
made in the case of the four species named above ; for these,
though differmg among themselves, have the same distribution
as many of those put down as northern, while H. Binneyana
and P. ancillaria certainly have a very northern range, for
they are abundant in Maine, New Brunswick, and Canada.
It is evident that such numerous errors of this kind render
the paper, so far as geographical distribution is concerned,
quite worthless ; for it is sure to mislead.
Most of these errors might have been easily avoided had the
author depended less on Gould’s work and more on the recent
works of American conchologists ; for there is no lack of data
in regard to the distribution of most of our shells. Even Dr.
Stimpson’s ‘Shells of New England’ (1851), if consulted,
might have saved most of the errors in regard to the distribution
of the marine shells.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 14
210 Prof. A. E. Verrill on the Mollusca
The fact that there is in the southern and shallower parts of
the Gulf of St. Lawrence an isolated colony of southern shells
may have misled Mr. Jeffreys in many cases, especially as he
evidently consulted the Canadian collections much more than
those of the United States, many of the largest of which he
did not see at all. In respect of erroneous identifications and
the reduction of certain species to varieties, there is also much
to be said; but this article is already so long that it will be
necessary to refer only to some of the more obvious and im-
portant errors of this kind, leaving the rest to be discussed
more fully elsewhere.
Every naturalist should be willing to allow his fellow natu-
ralists full liberty of opinion with respect to the specific identity
or difference of closely allied forms ; and no one can claim to be
infallible in such matters. Some of the errors to be mentioned
do not, however, come under this head; for the species united
have only remote affinities. Nevertheless the naturalist who
has collected and carefully studied animals in their native
haunts, under various circumstances, in many localities, and in
great numbers, has, other things being equal, a very great ad-
vantage in these matters; and therefore I believe that Mr.
Jeffreys would in most cases agree with me had he collected
and studied as many American shells as I have durimg the
past fifteen years, or if he were as familiar with them as he is
with the British species. In most of the cases to which I refer,
my own conclusions are in harmony with those of Dr. Stimpson,
who devoted so many years to collecting and carefully studying
our shells, and who is well known for his accuracy im such
matters. And it would be strange indeed if all American
naturalists, as well as many eminent foreign ones, have always
been making such ridiculous blunders in regard to some of our
most familiar shells as Mr. Jeffreys would have us believe.
Thus he states (p. 240) that “Gemma gemma” (or Tottenia
gemma) is the young of Venus mercenaria! But it has long
been known to European as well as American conchologists
that the animal of gemma is very different from that of mer-
cenarta, and quite peculiar ; that the hinge is constructed on a
very different type is well known; and Prof. G. H. Perkins
has shown (Proc. Bost. Soc. N. H. 1869, p. 148) that gemma
is viviparous, producing about three dozen young with well-
formed shells at one time. Moreover the young shells of
mercenaria, smaller than the adult gemma, are sufficiently
abundant on our shores, and may be seen in many American
collections; they are certainly very unlike the gemma in form,
sculpture, and hinge, as has been well known for more than
thirty years.
of Europe and North America. 211
Again, he states that Arca transversa is a variety of Arca
pexata, the former being put down as northern, the latter as
southern. That these shells are widely different in form and
in the structure of the hinge is well known; for Dr. J. E. Gray
many years ago established a new genus (Argina) for the
latter on account of its very peculiar hinge. That the animals
are also quite different I can assert from personal observation.
Moreover the differences in the hinge, epidermis, and form
are remarkably constant; and, finally, the two species have
the same geographical range from Cape Cod to South Carolina,
and are often found together. Both are very common in Long-
Island Sound and New-Haven harbour; and I have examined
hundreds of specimens of both species without finding the
slightest evidence in favour of Mr. Jeffreys’s views. Indeed
they are only distantly related, and evidently belong to distinct
genera, Argina and Scapharca, where several writers have
placed them.
He also states that Mactra ovalis is a variety of M. solidis-
sima. He may not have seen a specimen of the true ovalis,
for it is not common in collections; but the genuine ovals is
certainly a very well-marked species, widely different from the
solidissima. They differ greatly in the hinge, epidermis, form
of shell, and position of the umbos ; moreover the animals are
also quite different. Both occur together of equal size in the
Bay of Fundy; but the former is not known south of Cape
Cod, while the solidissima is abundant everywhere along our
sandy shores to South Carolina.
Concerning Astarte castanea he says, “ Perhaps a variety
of A. borealis, Ch. ;” but castanea is one of the best-defined
species in this difficult genus, varies comparatively little, and
does not extend far north, its range being decidedly southern.
It is perfectly distinct from A. borealis. He reduces A. qua-
drans to a variety of A. castanea, and gives it a name that is
quite uncalled for, even if this view were correct. He then
makes A. portlandica a variety of A. compressa; but I have
already shown (Amer. Journ. of Science, April 1872) that it
is a variety of A. guadrans. His arrangement of the other
species of Astarte is equally objectionable, but it is not necessary
to discuss them here.
The Pecten fusus, Linsley, is given as the young of
P. trradians, from which it is very distinct; but the writer
has shown (Amer. Journ. of Science, vol. i. p. 361, and
vol. iii. p. 213, 1871-72) that it is really the young of P.
tenwicostatus.
Dekay is given as the authority for dolis salmonacea and
4G. gymnota ; but they were both described by Couthouy in
14*
212 On the Mollusca of Europe and North America.
1838, from whom Dekay borrowed both the descriptions and
fizures five years later.
He states that Dentaliwm dentale (non Linn.) is a variety
of Entalis striolata, and that the latter is a variety of D.
abyssorum, Sars; but both of these statements are incorrect.
The first is the Dentaliwm occidentale, Stimpson, and is a true
Dentalium, entirely different, generically and specifically, from
the striolata; and the latter is also quite distinct from abyssorum.
Possibly Mr. Jeftreys has not seen perfect specimens of all the
American species ; otherwise I cannot understand how he could
have made these statements.
He is correct in considering Crepidula glauca a variety
of OC. fornicata, as others have done before him; but he has
adopted a serious mistake, made by several other writers, in
regarding C. plana (or unguiformis) also as a variety of C.
fornicata, from which it is really very distinct. It is a very
common error to suppose that this species always inhabits the
inside of dead univalve shells; for it very often occurs on the
outside of such shells, on stones, the back of Limulus, &c.,
and is frequently associated intimately with fornicata in all
these situations ; but nevertheless it always retains its essential
characters under all circumstances. The typical fornicata is
also often found with it, plentifully, on the insdde of dead
shells.
Nor can Margarita acuminata be the young of M. varicosa ;
for in our collection there are full-grown specimens of both,
equal in size, from Labrador.
There is no sufficient reason for adopting the name Lacuna
divaricata in place of L. vincta ; for it is not the Trochus divart-
catus of Linné (1767), although it is the shell described under
the same name by Fabricius in 1780, as shown long ago by
Dr. Stimpson and others. Fabricius made a mistake which
we have no right to perpetuate; nor does “ usage,” to which
Mr. Jeffreys so often appeals, sanction the change.
The Lunatia triseriata is not, as Mr. Jeffreys thinks, the
young of L. heros, but only a colour-variety, as the writer had
previously shown (April 1872). Both varieties occur together,
from the smallest to the largest sizes; but the former some-
times becomes plain-coloured before reaching maturity. There
is no evidence that Natica clausa is the Nerita affinis of
Gmelin, but quite the contrary ; for the latter was placed in the
section of wmbilicated species, was described as stlvery within,
and came from New Zealand! It is probably one of the
Trochidee, and certainly could not have been this imperforate
Natica.
In this place I shall not enter into a discussion of te
On Cervus chilensis and Cervus antisiensis. 213
numerous cases in which the author has reduced the American
shells to “varieties” of the European species, because in many
of these cases there must long be great diversity of opinion,
and for most purposes it matters little whether these closely
related forms be called “varieties” or “species,” so long as
the actual differences are recognized. But since Mr. Jeffreys
has evidently made so many important mistakes in his article
in regard to the identity of species, and has united those that
have no near affinities, as already shown, it is logical to con-
clude that he may have made other mistakes in the case of
more critical species. He must therefore pardon us if we
regard his decisions in all these cases as at least doubtful, until
confirmed by other evidence.
XXIV.—Remarks on Cervus chilensis and Cervus antisiensis.
By P. L. Scuater, M.A., F.R.S., Secretary to the Zoological
Society of London.
I BEG leave to offer to the readers of the ‘Annals’ a few remarks
upon the paper “ On the Guémul (Huamela leucotis)” by Dr.
Gray, which appeared in the number for December last (Ann.
Nat. Hist. ser. 4, vol. x. p. 445). The acquisition of the male
sex of the deer proposed by Dr. Gray to be called Huamela
leucotis is of much interest. But Dr. Gray seems to have
overlooked the fact that this deer had been named Cervus chi-
lensis by Gay and Gervais in 1846 (Ann. des Sci. Nat. ser. 3,
vol. v. p. 91), three years before he published a description of it
as Cervus leucotis (P. Z. S. 1849, p. 64). Under these cireum-
stances Cervus chilensis is the oldest name for this animal,
under which name it has also been figured and described in
Gay’s ‘Historia de Chile.’ It may be objected that the name
chilensis is inappropriate, as the animal is more particularly
Patagonian than Chilian. But Dr. Philippi, as will be seen
by reference to his remarks (Wiegm. Arch. 1870, pt. 1. p. 46),
says that the Guémul, or Cervus chilensis, though now rare,
as found in Chili, and gives notices of several places called
after its name, from its having formerly occurred there.
As regards the allied species of deer of which Mr. Whitely
has sent specimens from Tinta in Peru, and which Dr. Gray
has called Anomalocera huamel, Xenelaphus huamel, and Xene-
laphus leucotis, and now proposes to call Xenelaphus anoma-
locera, I may state that I have examined the specimens now
in the British Museum, and have convinced myself that they
are referable to Cervus antistensts of D’Orbigny.. Tschudi
214 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Guémul.
(‘Fauna Peruana,’ Mamm. p. 241) has already recorded the
existence of this deer in the Andes of Peru. The horns of the
male specimen figured in P. Z. 8. 1869, p. 497, are, in my
opinion, monstrous or diseased; such distorted specimens are
not unfrequently met with in several species of deer.
I am therefore of opinion that, although Dr. Gray is correct
in distinguishing his so-called Huamela leucotis from his Xene-
laphus anomalocera, the former (from Patagonia and Chili)
should stand as Cervus chilensis, and the latter (from Peru and
Bolivia) as Cervus antisiensis. If a generic or subgeneric
name is required for these two closely allied species, Furcifer
of Wagner (Siugeth. Suppl. vol. iv. p. 384, 1844) is the first
given, and should be employed.
XXV.—Further Remarks on the Guémul of Patagonia
(Huamela leucotis). By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
In the ‘Annals’ for December 1872, p. 445, I gave an account
of the skins of a male and female Guémul from Patagonia,
presented by Don Enrique Simpson, and stated that it was
the same animal that I had described and figured under the name
of Capreolus leucotis (P. Z. 8. 1849, p. 64, t. xii.), which Lord
Derby had received from Patagonia.
Dr. Philippi, who lives at Santiago, says that the animal I
figured as C. leucotis does not live in Chili, I suppose thereby
meaning that it cannot be the Guémul of Molina; but Molina
refers to the animal which Captain Wallis saw at the Magellan
Straits,and Lord Derby’s specimen was received from Magellan
Straits.
The Earl of Derby in 1840 received an imperfect skin of a
female in thick winter fur from his brother-in-law Admiral
Hornby, who obtained it on the coast of Chili; but no other
particulars were to be obtained about it. I thought it probable
that it was another specimen of Capreolus leucotis (Cat. Mamm.,
Ungulata, p. 227); but it shows so much more white on the
abdomen and inner side of the legs, and appears to belong to
a smaller animal, that I now think that it is probably a spe-
cimen of the same species that we received from Mr. Whitely,
jun., from Tinta in the Peruvian Andes, or probably the
winter coat of another species.
In 1869 we received a male, female, and fawn in summer
fur of a deer, which were collected by Mr. Whitely, jun., at
Tinta, in South Peru. As the skin of the male showed some
thick dark fur like the female in Lord Derby’s collection,
Dr. J. E. Gray on the Guémul. 215
I thought that it was probably the summer state of the
same animal, and perhaps a smaller variety of it. I first gave
a notice of these skins in ‘ Scientific Opinion’ for October 6,
1869 ; and as the horns of the male showed that it was different
from any known deer, I proposed the name Anomalocera for it ;
but (recollecting that this name had several times been used)
in the longer account of the deer which I gave in the ‘ Proc. Zool.
Soc.’ 1869, pp. 496-499, with figures of the horns of the male
and skull of female, I altered the name to Xenelaphus leucotis.
But as it is now found that the original Capreolus leucotis from
the Straits of Magellan is a different species with very different
horns, and was a larger-sized animal, I have called this, in the
‘Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist.’ Dec. 1872, p. 445, Xenelaphus
anomalocera.
The animal to which the skins of the male and female now
received from Don Enrique Simpson through Mr. Bates belong,
and which appears to be called the Guémul in Patagonia, is
certainly different from the animal which we received from
Tinta, South Peru, being of a larger size, and uniform dark
colour as much below as above, and the males having very
different horns, which are simple, with a long subbasal frontal
snag, indeed very like the horns of a fawn of the common stag
(Cervus elaphus); but, like the other American deer, it has
no gland and pencil of hair on the outside of the metatarsus ;
and therefore I propose to describe it in the catalogues as
Huamela leucotis.
In Dr. Hawkesworth’s account of the voyages for making
discoveries in the Southern Hemisphere (3 vols. 4to, 1773),
Captain Wallis (vol. i. p. 388, Jan. 1767) says, when
in Cordes Bay, Royal Reach, Magellan Straits, ““we saw an
animal that resembled an ass; but it had a cloven hoof, as we
discovered afterwards by tracking it, and it was as swift as a
deer. This was the first animal we had seen in the streight,
except at the entrance, where we found the guanicoes, that we
would fain have trafficked for with the Indians. We shot at
this creature, but we could not hit it ; probably it is altogether
unknown to the naturalists of Europe.”
Molina, in his ‘Saggio sulla storia nat. del Chile’ (Bologna,
1782, 8vo), p. 320, speaks of the “Guémul or Huamel”’ as
“Hauus bisulcus,”’ but thinks it ought to be a separate genus ;
he quotes in a footnote a French translation of Captain Wallis’s
observation. In the second edition of the work, published in
quarto at Bologna in 1810, p. 262, the account of Captain
Wallis is embodied in the text, the whole of the account of
the animal is rather altered, and the name Lquus bisulcus is
left out.
216 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Guémul.
In the first edition (p. 322) he says it lives on the less steep
rocks of the Andes; in the second edition (p. 262), it is a rare
wild animal which inhabits Chili. Itis seldom seen except on
the precipices and rocks of the Cordilleras, and rarely descends
to the lower valleys; so the hunter considers himself fortunate
who manages to surprise one. In both editions he observes
this is the unnamed animal which Capt. Wallis says he saw
in passing the Straits of Magellan (p. 321).
This account has been a fertile source of errors, and perhaps
he confused two animals in it; but at any rate I have no
doubt that the animal I described as Capreolus leucotis from
Magellan Straits is the one mentioned by Captain Wallis.
Molina himself thought the Guémul was a horse, and called
it Equus bisulcus, but he has left this name out in the second
edition. It is referred to Auchenia by Col. Hamilton Smith,
to Camelus by Leuckart and Treviranus,and made intoa genus,
under the name of Hippocamelus, by Leuckart, and Cervequus
by Lesson, and is mentioned as a new genus without a name
by Gay; and MM. Gay and Gervais, in the ‘Ann. Sci. Nat.’
1846, p. 91, thought it was Cervus chilensis ; but Dr. Philippi
(in Wiegm. Archiv, 1870) says that Gay’s animal is the same
as Cervus antisiensis of D’Orbigny (Voy. d. Amér. mérid.
tom. xx.), the Furcifer antisiensis of my ‘Catalogue of Rumi-
nant Mammalia in B. M.’ (8vo, 1872, p. 88).
According to Gay, the Guémul is Furcifer antistensis from
Bolivia and Peru; this may be the Chilian animal which
Molina confounded with the Magellan-Straits one. I thought
it might be the Xenelaphus anomalocera, which is also a
Peruvian animal; and now we have identified Wallis’s
Magellan-Straits animal as Huamela leucotis.
It is impossible to use any of the generic names given to
Molina’s Guémul, because they all convey a false impression
as to the relationship of the animal; one is not sure whether
they belong to the Chilian or Patagonian genus, or, in fact, a
combination of both.
The Guémul or Huamel is mentioned in Viduare’s ‘Chil.
Reiseb.’ published in Hamburg in 1782; but I have not been
able to lay my hands on it. Is it the animal mentioned by
Molina?
“Guemul, q. du Chili, qui ne peut étre le Poco,” appears in
Ray’s ‘Zoologie Universelle et Portative’ (Paris, 1787); but
there is no such word as “ Poco”’ in his dictionary. Perhaps
he means ‘ Paco,” a name which occurs under ‘ Lama,”
. 300.
: Fischer in his ‘Synopsis,’ p. 433, puts in Equus bisulcus of
Molina, the cloven-footed horse of Shaw’s ‘Zoology’ (ii. p. 441),
Dr. J. E. Gray on the Guémul. 217
adding, “In inaccessis montium Andium. Num generis
Lama?” ‘The universal reference to the animal being an in-
habitant of Chili misled me until I consulted the original
work.
HUAMELA.
Head elongate; ears acute. Horns nearly erect, simple,
rather converging together at the tip, with a well-developed
subbasal anterior branch ; beam tapering to a point; the front
of the right horn is keeled ; and rather below the middle there
is a compressed tubercle, probably indicating a branch in the
adult state; but there is no appearance of this on the other
horn. Fur very close, thick, formed of quills like those of the
roebuck and the Peruvian deer.
Skull with the intermaxillary bones broad, and extending
up to and terminating with a truncated end on the sides of the
nasal bones, which are broad, with parallel sides for two thirds
their length, and truncated at the front end. Lachrymal pit
elongate, triangular, very deep, with a rounded bottom at the
hinder end, quite close to the front edge of the orbit. The
horns with a well-developed rugose burr, with many irregular
tubercles round the base. The subbasal front branches are
placed some distance above the base, the one on the right horn
being the smallest, and projecting straight forwards, with den-
ticles on its surface; the branch on the left horn is much
higher up from the base, longer, and ascending at a rather
acute angle, and smaller at the tip. Length of the skull, from
nose to condyles, 117 inches; width at back edge of orbits,
which is the widest part, 53 inches.
Lower jaw very slender, with a straight lower edge not
more than an inch broad in the widest part, narrower in front,
and becoming wider behind the middle, with a sinuous margin
and a thin rounded angle. The part in front of the grinders
much produced, about double the length of the symphysis.
Tail short and bushy, coloured like the back above, and
whitish beneath. The line from the anus to the groin is white,
and the upper part of the inside of the thighs is pale; the rest
of the riduatde is considerably darker than the back. The
inside of the legs is coloured like the rest of the back, perhaps
a little lighter; there is a well-developed pencil of rigid hair,
which is of a dark colour. No indication of any glands on the
outside of the legs.
The false hoofs are surrounded with rather longer darker
hair. The lips are blackish, with two small white spots on
the upper lip, and a narrow white edge on the under one.
To correct the synonyma, itis better to give the following
revision of them :—
218 Dro Ja: Gray on the Guémul.
Skull of male Huamela leucotis.
Dr. J. E. Gray on the Guémul. 219
FHuamela leucotis.
“ Hoofed Animal,” Hawkesworth’s Voyages, vol. i. ae
Equus bisulcus, Molina’s Chili, p. 320, 1782 (from Hawkesworth and
other copiers of Molina).
Capreolus leucotis, Gray, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1849, p. 64, t. xii. (female).
Capreolus (?) huwemula, Knowsley Menag.
Furcifer huamel, Gray, P. Z. 8. 1850, p. 236.
Xenelaphus leucotis (part.), Gray, Cat. Ruminant Mamm. p. 89.
Hab. Magellan Straits (Capt. Wallis, 1767; Molina, 1782;
Lord Derby, 1849); Patagonia (Don Enrique Simpson,
1872).
Male and female (Brit. Mus.).
This animal is most likely the one mentioned by Captain
Wallis, as (1) it inhabits the Magellan Straits; (2) it is the
only hoofed animal on the west coast of America nearly the
size of a donkey ; (3) it was sent to the British Museum from
Don Enrique Simpson with the name of “ Guémul” used by
Molina.
I have not been able to trace the origin of this name, and do
not know if it is Patagonian or Chilian. It has been applied
by zoologists to different animals which thay have discovered.
Gay applies it to Purcifer antisiensis. I, thinking that it was
the animal mentioned by Molina, applied it to Xenelaphus, and,
in the Knowsley Menagerie, thought it might be the animal I
described as Capreolus leucotis, which I now think is the most
correct determination.
The horns are very unlike those of any other American
deer, and are more like those of the young stag, or Cervus
elaphus, but very distinct from it, and probably more different
from it in the adult state, if those we have belong to a young
animal. It is the only South-American stag that has a
basal snag, the absence of which is a peculiarity of those
animals.
Probably the fur of this animal, like that of the roebuck
kind, is formed of shorter, more slender hair in summer.
It is not necessary to figure the animal, as the figure by
Wolf, given in the P. Z. 8. (1849, p. 64, t. xii.) is very cha-
racteristic and accurate. I observe im the description that it
is at least three times as large as the usual Huropean roebuck,
is much darker, and has not the white spots extending over
the upper part of the side of the haunches.
The height at the shoulders of Lord Derby’s specimen is
38 inches ; and the length of the body is 40 inches, of the head
12 inches, of the ears 7 inches, of the tarsus, from the false
hoof to the hock, 124 inches.
220 Mr. R. B. Sharpe on the Peregrine Falcon
XENELAPHUS.
Anomalocera, Gray, Scientific Opinion, 1869; Philippi, Wiegm. Archiv,
1870, p. 46.
Xenelaphus, Gray, P. Z. S. 1869, p. 498, fig. (horns & skull); Cat. Ru-
minant Mamm. p. 89.
Xenelaphus anomalocera.
Anomalocera huamel, Gray, Scientific Opinion, 1869, p. 385.
Xenelaphus huamel, Gray, P. Z. 8. 1869, p. 497, fig. (horns), p. 498,
fig. (skull, female).
Anomalocera leucotis, Philippi in Wiegm. Archiv, 1870, p. 46.
Xenelaphus leucotis, Gray, Cat. Rumin. Mamm. p. 89.
Hab. Peruvian Andes, Tinta (Mr. Whitely, jun.).
Male, female, and young (Brit. Mus.).
The adult male from Tinta is 28 inches high to the withers,
and the body from the chest to the tail is 34 inches long.
Length of head 10 inches, of the ears 5} inches, of the tarsus
from the false hoof to the hock 92 inches.
XXVI.—On the Peregrine Falcon of the Magellan Straits.
By R. Bowpter Suarpe, F.L.S., F.Z.8., &e., Senior As-
sistant, Zoological Department, British Museum. .
Mr. Gurney has already (Ibis, 1867, p. 465) drawn attention
to the differences existing in the Peregrine from the Straits of
Magellan and Chili, which he considers to be undescribed.
He writes as follows :—‘ South of Chili, in the southern part
of Patagonia and about the straits of Magellan, a really
distinct race does occur, closely allied to F. melanogenys of
Australia, from which, indeed, it only differs in its slightly
larger size. It is worthy of remark that the three southern
races of Peregrine Falcons, viz. this Magellan race, to which,
I believe, no specific name has yet been given, /. melanogenys
of Australia, and F. minor of South Africa, all agree between
themselves, and differ from the true I. communis in having
much narrower spaces than occur in that bird, between the
dark transverse abdominal bars which characterize the adult
plumage of all these Falcons.”
Mr. G. R. Gray considered the Magellan bird to be the
same as Valco nigriceps of Cassin from Western North Ame-
rica. Mr. Cassin, in describing the latter species, gives Chili
as an additional habitat, suggesting that its range may extend
throughout the whole of the western side of America. J am
unable to determine by internal evidence whether Mr. Cassin
had adults or young of the Chilian birds, on which to found
his opinion. He could hardly have united the Magellan
of the Magellan Straits. 221
species if he had had adults, while he might have been easily
misled by the rufous character of the young birds into sup-
posing that the two birds are identical. I agree, however,
with Mr. Gurney in supposing that the Magellan bird is a
distinct species, being, in fact, the American representative of
Falco melanogenys, trom which it differs not only in its
slightly larger size, but in the less rufous plumage of the
female; and neither male nor female has the very narrow
closely set bars of the Australian Falcon, though they are
more narrowly barred than the true Falco nigriceps. I
pers therefore, to separate the Falcon of Chili and the
agellan Straits as
Falco Cassini, sp. n.,
and append a description of the bird.
Adult. Above dark bluish ashy, everywhere transversely
spotted or barred with black; bars very broad and closely set
on the upper part of the back, further apart and more sagittate
in shape on the lower back, rump, and upper tail-coverts; a
frontal line tinged with whitish, very indistinct ; entire head
and hind neck, cheeks, ear-coverts, and moustachial streak
(that is to say, the whole of the face) deep black, extending on
to the interscapulary region; least wing-coverts blackish like
the latter, the others coloured and barred like the back ; quills
deep brownish black, the primaries with obsolete grey spots
near the base, the imner secondaries uniform with the back ;
tail bluish ashy, with black bars, which become merged
towards the tip of the tail, so that this is conspicuously black
for about a quarter of its length; throat itself creamy buff,
unspotted ; fore neck and chest pale buffy fawn-colour, with
very narrow black shaft-lines, the shade of fawn extending
shghtly on to the breast; rest of the under surface creamy
white, with a very strong grey shade on the lower parts,
crossed with closely set bars of black ; under wing-coverts
buffy white, thickly crossed with black bars; the inner web
of the quills with numerous buffy white bars, becoming
smaller and more obsolete towards the tips of the quills ; bill
orange at the base, inclining gradually to bluish horn-colour
towards the tip; feet yellow, claws horn-brown. Total length
15:5 inches, culmen 1*1, wing 12, tail 7, tarsus 2.
Female. Similar to the male, but larger, and without the
bluish shade on the lower parts (probably not so old a bird) ;
the head, neck, and sides of the face black. Total length
20 inches, culmen 1°35, wing 13°5, tail 7°8, tarsus 1:9.
Young male. Above deep blackish brown, the nape tinged
with chestnut, all the feathers more or less distinctly margined
222 Mr. R. B. Sharpe on the Peregrine Falcon
with the same colour, except the upper tail-coverts and inner
secondaries, which are tipped with buff; quills blackish, the
inner webs half barred with clear rufous ; tail blackish, tipped
with creamy buff, and crossed with several indistinct grey
bars, becoming rufous on the inner web; forehead whitish,
the feathers under the eye, fore part of the cheeks, and mous-
tachial stripe deep black; throat creamy buff; rest of the
under surface deep ferruginous, paler on the lower abdomen,
all the feathers mesially streaked with a longitudinal black
spot, much larger and more arrow-shaped, on the flank-
feathers. Total length 16 inches, wing 12.
Mr. Gurney, in writing to me on the subject, observes that
he has seen two distinct Falcons from Chili, one being my F.
Cassini, and the other coming from the north, and called by
Cassin /. nigriceps, but which he considers to be only £.
communis. I agree with Mr. Gumey in considering that F.
nigriceps does not go to Chili; and the migratory bird is
therefore probably the common Peregrine, which visits South
America, as it does India and Africa in the Old World, while
the resident southern form is /. Cassind.
The typical specimen of the latter is mounted im the
national collection.
I may add a few words as to the Peregrine Falcons and
their geographical distribution. No two ornithologists agree
as to whether the Peregrines of the world are to be considered
races or subspecies of one particular form, or whether there
are several species to be designated by different specific
names. I incline to the latter view, as rendering the subject
less intricate than by merging some of the very different forms
under one name. ‘Taking, then, 1 communis as the typical
form, I would characterize the various allied Falcons as
follows. Adult specimens of all the birds, excepting F. minor
(of which there is at present only a young one), are to be seen
in the British Museum.
1. Falco communis. (‘The Peregrine Falcon.)
The whole of the Palearctic region, migrating into India,
to the Malay archipelago, and South Africa (more rarely).
The entire Nearctic region, except the western coast of North
America, where replaced by F. nigriceps. I cannot find any
difference in the North-American Peregrine, and consider #,
anatum to be identical with the European bird.
2. Falco Brook. (The Sardinian Peregrine Falcon.)
Very much smaller than /. communis, with the bars on
of the Magellan Straits. 223
the under surface very numerous, and broader than in any
other species.
Hab. Sardinia.
3. Falco nigriceps. (The Western Peregrine Falcon.)
Rather smaller than /. communis and darker. The young
different; much more rufous and richly coloured. The adult
creamy white on the breast, without a single sign of a shaft-
stripe.
Hab. Western side of North America from California to
Vancouver’s Island, probably further north.
The two birds procured in Japan, and mentioned by Mr.
Whitely (Ibis, 1867, p. 194), are in the British Museum, and
are unfortunately both young birds. They are of a more
slender build than is usual with the young female Peregrine
of Europe, and, from the strong wash of tawny buff on the
under surface, might be supposed to belong to Falco nigriceps.
They are not, however, quite so rufescent underneath, and the
centres to the breast-feathers are not nearly so dark; thus I
at present prefer to keep them distinct from this bird, although
it is by no means improbable that they may ultimately turn
out to be the same. Latham’s Oriental Falcon coming from
Japan, it can do no harm to keep these Japanese specimens,
which agree well with his descriptions, under that title, until
the arrival of an adult bird shall enable us to define the
species accurately. The late Mr. G. R. Gray referred both
these examples and the young Vancouver-Island specimens to
Falco orientalis, with which he joined Falco anatum. 1 think,
however, that Falco anatum is nothing but the Kuropean
Peregrine, and the Vancouver birds are really the young of
Falco nigriceps, which Mr. Brown identifies as the species
found there (Ibis, 1868, p. 418).
4. Falco micrurus. (The Himalayan Peregrine Falcon.)
With this bird Dr. Jerdon identifies Mr. Hume’s lately
described Falco atriceps; and two specimens in the national
collection belong to this species. They are closely allied to
F. communis, but are remarkable for their very nearly obsolete
barring underneath, and very pale coloration.
Hab. Himalayas.
5. Falco peregrinator. (The Indian Peregrine Falcon.)
Blacker in all stages than any other allied species. When
fully adult, deep rufous underneath, against which the clear
blue of the rump and upper tail-coverts contrasts strongly.
Hab. The whole of India; nowhere common.
224 Bibliographical Notice.
We now come to the three southern forms with jet-black
hoods, viz. :—
6. Falco melanogenys. (The Australian Peregrine Falcon.)
A very distinct species, distinguished by its black face and
close-set narrow barring.
Hab. Australia northwards to Java (judging by Schlegel’s
figure in the ‘ Vogel van Nederlandsch Indié’).
7. Kalco minor. (The South-African Peregrine Falcon.)
The smallest of all Peregrines.
Hab. South Africa and Madagascar.
8. Falco Cassint. (The Chilian Peregrine Falcon.)
Allied to F. melanogenys of Australia, but differmg as
above mentioned. The young deeper rufous than in any of
the other Falcons.
Hab. Straits of Magellan and Chili.
BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTICE.
Dr. Ehrenberg’s Microgeological Studies. {‘* Mikrogeologische Studien,
&c.,” Monatsbericht kon. preuss. Akad. Wissensch. Berlin fiir April
1872, pp. 265-322: 1872.]
Tus is the abstract of a memoir which the veteran, and now nearly
octogenarian, naturalist of Berlin has laid before the Academy as the
results of his long-continued methodical researches on the microscopic
life of the sea-bottom of all zones, especially in its relationship
to past life and its influence on geological studies. From 1836 to
1871 Ehrenberg has given to the world numerous descriptions and
hundreds of good figures (all magnified 300 diameters) of microscopic
objects, recent and fossil, the latter mainly in his ‘ Mikrogeologie’
(1854). However numerous the shore-sands, dredgings, and deep-
sea soundings he has examined, yet, says he, the spots are so widely
scattered over the map as to show how much more we have to learn
of the sea-bed.
The distribution of warm and cold currents is now beginning to
be understood, he remarks; and the dispersion and relative abund-
ance of deep-sea life, and the formation of siliceous and calcareous
ooze and muds, are still to be more deeply studied. At all events, the
sounding-line has never gone so deep but the microscope shows that
nature is rich there also with life. We know not, he says, what
forms of being, minute or gigantic, exist throughout the abyssal
depths; and “the abundant occurrence of Peridinia in the flint of
the deep-sea chalk, as well as the living luminous animals on
the ocean’s surface, and even at the deep bottom off Florida, point
to a possibly periodic, and even permanent, strong light in those
Bibliographical Notice. 225
depths, enabling the creatures of the abyss to have the use of their
visual organs.”
Dr. Ehrenberg then enumerates the organisms which he has him-
self determined from the shallow and deep waters of oceans and
inland seas, namely :—I. (Independent organisms) 724 Polygastrica,
287 Polycystina, 585 Polythalamia, 22 Mollusca, 30 Pteropoda, 1
Annulatum, 2 Entomostraca, 6 Radiata, 9 Bryozoa, 1 Anthozoum ;
II. (Not independent, but named for convenience of recegnition)
226 Phytolitharia (including 142 Spongolitha), 50 Geolithia, 37 Zo-
olitharia, and 23 soft parts of plants. Of living marine shelled
animals {including Diatomacez] thus observed, he reckons 1645;
and of the derivative forms mentioned above under the second head-
ing he has 336; altogether 1981.
For the North Polar Zone he has 71 definite organisms out of the
list, for the North Temperate 918, for the Equatorial 487, for
the South Temperate 47, and for the South Polar Zone 24, the
greater numbers going with the larger researches.
In six stages of depth from 101 to 20,000 feet the calculation
is as follows :—
All observed
Feet. Definite Forms. Organisms,
101— 500 88 315
501— 1000 72 240
1001— 5000 141 437
5001-10000 146 408
10001-15000 130 344
15001-20000 115 236
The shallow-water forms are not here taken into consideration, as
freshwater organisms are mixed with them by geographical accidents.
Ehrenberg points out that the abundance of independent forms
inhabiting the deep-sea bed is against the old notion, born of Bory
de St. Vincent, and resuscitated of late years, that a living pulp
pervades the sea and sinks in decay to the bottom; nor, says he,
are the small the fry of the larger organisms.
Prof. Ehrenberg’s researches in microscopic fossils were begun in
1836 (with sliced flint and semiopal) and 1838 (with the Chalk), and
are chiefly exhibited in the ‘ Mikrogeologie,’ 1854. Enumerating
the subjects of these researches, he arrives at the following numbers :
—independent forms, 1485; derivative fragments and parts, 172;
altogether 1607. Adopting the following five great periods, he
arranges his microscopic results * thus :+—
Definite All observed
Forms. Organisms.
GUGALOITIARY i. sw te ‘s wiser 4 « 419 652
PURO oa os be 8 urs Sew! Gnd dhs 362 807
WME, tere rath ee uie ace ¥ & 292 445
UPA ERS ak ir ees eos 7 vy
Carboniferous and Grauwacke .. 52 60
* Tn relation to this table of the geological distrspution of Prof.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi.
226 Bibliographical Notice.
Ehrenberg finds that the notion of there being partially, or even
altogether, different life-conditions in the superficial and the deep
sea is weakened by his numerous observations.
Polycystina, Actinophrys, Coccoliths, and Bathybius, besides the
relationships of animals, and development, as treated by Darwin and
others, are subjects also dwelt upon, in a conservative manner, in
the memoir of which the abstract is before us; and the author re-
co nmends cautious limitation of subject, restriction of hypothesis,
and uniformity of method, as the only foundation for good work
among naturalists.
The diagnoses of a great number of living genera and species of
Polythalamia, Polygastrica, Polycystina, Spongolithides, Geolithia,
and Zoolitharia follow (pp. 276-322).
A review of Prof. Ehrenberg’s genera and species of Forami-
nifera having been lately offered in the ‘Annals of Nat. Hist.’
(Nos. 51, 52, 57, 58, and 60, vols. ix. & x. 1872), it is convenient
to add in this place some results from a study of the new notices
before us.
To the Polythalamia [Foraminifera] Prof. Ehrenberg adds, as
genera :—1. Aspidodewia (apparently some Rotaline). 2. Bolbodium
(possibly a Pullenia). 38and 4. Hemisterea and Hemisticta (probably
Rotaline, of which there are several genera which have the spiral
or upper surface porose, whilst the umbilical or lower face has an
extra-thick glassy coat). 5. Otostomwm (probably a dimorphous
Virgulina, such as is indicated under the name Bifarina in Ann.
Nat. Hist. Sept. 1872, p. 198). Lastly, No. 6. Pylodeaia [1859],
which is intended to comprise the Globigerinw which have the spire
on the left and the large aperture on the right side, the true Glo-
bigerine having these features reversed—characters which appear to
be of little or no value.
Of Foraminifera 90 are described as new species, chiefly from great
depths in the Arctic and Atlantic oceans, with several from the
Agulhas Bank (at about 400 feet depth) off the Cape of Good Hope,
and a few from the Pacific. Of “ Polygastrica,’ 39 are diagnosed ;
of Polycystina, 123 ; Spongolithides &e., 7.
Ehrenberg’s Microzoa &c., we must refer to the several lists of local spe-
cies of Foraminifera, determined according to the revised nomenclature,
in the review of his figured fossil specimens in the ‘ Annals of Nat. Hist.’
Nos. 51, 52, 57, 58, and 60, vols. ix. and x. 1872; and we must add that
in the classified list of fossil Foraminifera figured by Ehrenberg down to
1858, in the ‘Annals of Nat. Hist.’ Dec. 1872, pp. 454-457, there are
enumerated, besides 20 undetermined forms, only 138 species and notice-
able varieties, most of which are living at the present day, and of which
81 had been named by other observers.
Royal Society. 227
PROCEEDINGS OF LEARNED SOCIETIES.
ROYAL SOCIETY.
Dec. 19, 1872.—Sir George Biddell Airy, K.C.B., President, followed
by Mr. Busk, Vice-President, and Dr. Sibson, Vice-President,
in the Chair.
“On the Organization of the Fossil Plants of the Coal-mea-
sures. Part IV. Dictyorylon, Lyginodendron, and Heterangium.”
By W. C. WitrtaMson, F.R.S., Professor of Natural History in
Owens College, Manchester.
In 1866 Mr. Binney gave the name of Dadowylon Oldhamium to
a fossil stem of a plant from the Lower Coal-measures of Lancashire,
believing it to belong to the same class of 4ymnospermous Exogens
as the Pimtes of Witham and the Dadoaylon of Endlicher. In 1869
the author pointed out that the reticulated markings upon the
surface of its vessels were modifications of the spiral fibre of fibro-
vascular tissue, and not the disks of what is often designated glandu-
lar fibre. He consequently separated the plant from the Dadoxylons
under the name of Dictyoaylon Oldhamium. At the Edinburgh
Meeting of the British Association in 1871 he gave a brief account
of the structure of this plant, as also of what appeared to be a second
species from the Lower Coal-measures of Burntisland in Fifeshire,
which he called D. Grievit, after its discoverer, D. Grieve, Esq. A
detailed exposition of the organization of these two plants is given
in the memoir.
Dictyoaylon Oldhamium.—This was a stem composed of the three
divisions of pith, wood, and bark. The pith consisted of regular
parenchyma without divisions or cavities of any kind. In very
young plants it was surrounded by an irregular ring or medul-
lary cylinder of reticulated vessels, not arranged i in radiating lamine.
This cylinder broke up at an early period into several detached
vascular bundles, which, as the stem enlarged, became widely
separated from each other, the intervening space being occupied by
medullary parenchyma. But before this change was completed,
the true ligneous zone appeared as a thin ring of vessels arranged
in radiating vertical lamine, separated from each other by large and
conspicuous medullary rays, composed of mural cellular tissue.
Additions were made ‘to the exterior surface of this zone by the
agency of a delicate cellular layer of cells, which constituted the
innermost layer of the bark. These additions demonstrate their
exogenous nature in several specimens in which the vessels of the
outermost zone have not attained to half their normal size, resembling
in this respect some of the Lepidodendroid plants described in the
author’s last memoir (Part I1I.). Through these successive ex-
ogenous growths the vascular axis of the stem ultimately became
arborescent. One specimen is described in which such a vascular
axis, though imperfect and waterworn, is fully six inches in dia-
meter, independent of the bark; other specimens have been ob-
15*
228 Royal Society -—
tained intermediate in size between the above example and the
small stems more usually met with. The vascular lamine increased
in thickness as they proceeded from within outwards, and then
subdivided, in the ordinary exogenous manner, through the inter-
calation of new medullary rays. These rays are remarkable for the
great vertical range of each one, as well as for the large number of
cells which enter into their composition. In tangential sections
they appear as elongated lenticular masses of parenchyma.
The Bark.—This organ is separable into three, if not four layers.
The mnermost one is a delicate parenchyma closely vesting the
ligneous zone, its cells being continuous with those of the medullary
rays. Atits outer surface this tissue passes gradually into another
parenchymatous layer of greater thickness than the inner one.
Both of them have patches of dark-coloured cells scattered through
their tissues. But the most remarkable part of the bark is the
third or prosenchymatous layer, which presents very different
features according to the aspect in which it is regarded. In the
transverse section it consists of radiating bands of parenchyma
alternating with narrower and very dark-coloured ones of woody
prosenchyma, the latter looking very like the Roman numerals upon
the face of a clock. Tangential sections show that the black bands
are fibrous lamin, which pursue an undulatory course as they
ascend through the stem, and which, as they alternately approach
and recede from one another, divide this part of the bark mto a
series of lenticular or rhomboidal areas, occupied by various forms
of parenchyma. No vascular bundles enter these areole; hence
they are something altogether different from the leaf-scars of the
Lepidodendra, Externally to this prosenchymatous layer some
specimens exhibit detached traces of a very thin external layer of
parenchyma, apparently derived from the cells of the rhomboidal
areole, which have extended beyond the fibrous laminz and spread
themselves over the surface of the bark as a continuous layer ;
but this condition appears to be confined to very young stems.
Vascular bundles of large size ascend vertically through the two
inner parenchymatous layers of the bark. In some instances
each of these bundles exhibits, in the transverse section, an oval
outline, with faint traces of a vertical division into two parts. But
ordinarily the two halves of the bundle have separated, forming two
distinct bundles, which are some distance apart. They exhibit little
or no tendency to diverge from the ligneous cylinder as they ascend,
and in some instances actually become incorporated with it. It
is remarkable that the position of each of these double bundles,
at the exterior of the ligneous zone, corresponds with the spaces
intervening between the detached masses of the medullary cylinder
within it, as if the former were designed to act as buttresses
strengthening these weaker pomts in the vascular axis. It not
unfrequently happens that exogenous additions are made to such
of these bundles as are encompassed by the innermost layer of
the bark, in the shape of a few radiating lamine of vessels developed
on their outer or peripheral surfaces.
On the Fossil Plants of the Coal-measures. (229
One specimen of the vascular axis is, as already mentioned, so
large as to demonstrate that the plant became arborescent.
Though Dictyovylon was not a dichotomizing plant, like Lepido-
dendron, it gave otf lateral bundles of vessels. Some of these are
simple bundles, consisting of numerous vessels intermingled with
some cellular tissue. Others have this central bundle invested by
a thin ring of radiating lamine with intervening medullary rays;
this exogenous ring sometimes becomes developed into a relatively
large and distinct woody zone, like that of the parent axis. The
vessels of these lateral growths appear to be wholly derived from
the radiating woody zone.
A second form of lateral appendage appears to spring from the
medullary rays, and consists of a cylindrical mass of reticulated
cells, which are chiefly prosenchymatous, but of an elongated type.
It is suggested that this structure may have been prolonged into an
adventitious root.
The structure of the central or medullary vascular axis of the
former of these two kinds of lateral appendages seems to indicate
that the history of the development of the medullary vascular cylin-
der in these plants corresponds with what the author described
in his preceding memoir (Part II.) as taking place in the similar
parts of the Lepidodendra, viz. that some of the cells of the central
part of the axis underwent rapid fission, and thus developed a di-
stinct cellular medulla, which forced the medullary vessels outwards
where at first they constituted a ring, but which ring soon broke
up into the detached vascular masses already referred to as adhering
to the inner surface of the exogenous zones.
The enlargement of the exogenous woody cylinder by the peri-
pheral intercalation of new radiating vascular lamin, and the
repeated subdivision of these laminz by a corresponding intercala-
tion of new medullary rays, demonstrates the close resemblance
between the growth of the ligneous zone in these plants and that
of ordinary exogenous stems. A fine series of specimens collected
by the Rev. H. Higgins, of Rainhill, near Liverpool, and which
exhibit various modifications of the type figured by the late Mr.
Gourlie under the name of Lyginodendron Landsburghiz, are shown
to be merely casts of the exterior surface of the bark of some species
of Dictyoxylon. They may actually belong to D. Oldhamium; but
this is not yet proven.
Dictyoxylon Grievii—This plant has many points of affinity
with D. Oldhamium ; nevertheless it has very distinct features of
its own. Itscentral or medullary axis is very large in proportion
to the thickness of its exogenous ring; the former consists of
cellular parenchyma, throughout which are scattered numerous
bundles of exquisitely reticulated vessels unprovided with any
special sheaths. The largest vessels are nearest the centre of the
axis, the peripheral ones becoming smaller, more numerous, and
grouped in more continuous masses. Immediately surrounding
this vasculo-cellular axis is a thin ring of similar vessels, but
arranged in radiating lamine, separated by well-defined medullary
230 Royal Society.
rays. This zone is generally of unequal thickness on opposite sides
of the plant, and contains some barred vessels amongst its re-
ticulated ones; the medullary rays are composed of mural cells.
The bark consists of three very distinct layers. The innermost
one is very thin, consisting of delicate parenchyma, but which
nevertheless has formed a very clearly defined flexible layer ;
outside this is a thick stratum of coarser but regular parenchyma
subdivided in the transverse section into vaguely defined areas by
thick wavy lnes of condensed cells. The peripheral outline of
this zone is very irregular, frequently projecting outwards in large
angular masses. It is bounded by a prosenchymatous external
layer, which is a dwarfed representative of the corresponding one
ot D. Oldhamium. In the transverse section it exhibits dark radiating
bands of fibres, longitudinally disposed, alternating with similar
bands of parenchyma; but it differs from D. Oldhamium in the
narrowness of the latter, and consequently in the more linear form
of the cellular areole of the outer bark. In longitudinal sections
of the bark its innermost layer appears as in transverse ones.
The middle parenchyma, on the other hand, exhibits remarkable
differences from its aspect in the transverse section: its cells are
arranged in vertical columns ; but these are intersected at intervals
of nearly J, of an inch by horizontal and parallel bands of very
dark-coloured cells of a special nature.
Seven or eight large vasculo-cellular bundles exist in each trans-
verse section of the bark. Some of these are located within the
exogenous layer of the wood, being obviously detached portions of
the cells and vessels of the medullary axis; others occur, in various
specimens, at every point between the wood and the outer bark.
The author finds that these bundles remained for a time in the
immediate neighbourhood of the innermost bark, but that they sue-
cessively became detached and moved more rapidly outwards, until
each one emerged at the periphery of the bark in one of the
prominent angles of the latter, already referred to ; when one bundle
has thus reached the periphery, another begins to follow the same
centrifugal course. The inference is, that these are foliar bundles,
supplying large leaves or petioles, sparsely grouped round the stem.
A single example of a similar centrifugal bundle was found in
D. Oldhamium. The seemingly irregular “projections of the bark of
D. Grievii thus appear to represent angular petioles, and are not the
result of merely accidental pressures. A. second kind of cylindrical
bundle is noticed, consisting of reticulated prosenchymatous cells.
It is connected at its central extremity with the medullary
parenchyma, whilst its peripheral end passes outwards through the
bark. It appears to have had the same character as the similar
one of D. Oldhamium, having probably been an adventitious root-
bundle.
Somewhat triangular twigs or petioles of the above plant are
numerous. They consist of a single vascular bundle, located ex-
centrically near the cordate base of the triangular transverse section,
and surrounded by the three bark-layers seen in the older stems.
Se
Miscellaneous. 231
The structure of these layers, as seen in the longitudinal sections,
is identical with, though less complex than, that of the matured
stems ; but no cortical vascular bundles are seen in them.
Having identified his Dictyoaylon Oldhamium with the older genus
Lyginodendron, the author abandons his own generic name, and
proposes that the plant shall henceforth be designated Lyginodendron
Oldhamium. He establishes in the same way the generic identity
of Dictyoxylon Grievit with the Heterangium of Corda; hence that
plant must now take the name of Heterangium Grievii. Whilst
having no doubt that the above were two Cryptogamic plants, it
appears impossible for the present to determine to what class of
Cryptogams they belong. Many of their features indicate Lycopo-
diaceous affinities ; but this point can scarcely be determined until
the actual fronds are discovered. ‘This has not yet been done.
The Lyginodendron is from the horizon of the Ganister beds of
Lancashire and Yorkshire; the Burntisland deposit belongs to the
middle portion of the calciferous sandstones of the Burdiehouse
Carboniferous strata.
MISCELLANEOUS.
On Whales in the Indian Ocean. By H. J. Carrer, F.R.S. &e.
(In a letter to Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S.)
I Ave been much interested in the perusal of your paper in the
‘Annals’ for February ‘“‘On the Geographical Distribution &c. of
Whales and Dolphins;” and, with reference to Captain Maury’s
observation that the sperm-whales inhabit a belt of sea in or on
each side of the tropics, would communicate to you the following
facts, which, if not already known to you, will, I am sure, be
acceptable.
Within twelve years, while I was at Bombay, the mutilated car-
casses of two dead whales drifted on shore there. One I went to
see: it was an ernormous mass, and supposed to have belonged
to a whale 80 feet long. The bodies of the vertebrae were as large,
I think, as the bodies of any whale-vertebree that [ ever saw. Not
being interested in any further detail, and the stench of the putrid
blubber being so great that it was full a month before it left my
shoes, | went no further than to witness the sight.
It is very common for whaies to be seen off the coast of Khat-
tyawar, a little north of Bombay, but still in the tropics, by those
who are making the voyage between Bombay and Kurrachee, in
Sind. And if at Bombay, within the space of twelve years, two
dead whales drift in, it may be assumed that such must occur at
many other places on this coast, and therefore that the number of
dead whales which thus become stranded must be considerable.
While on the survey of the south-east coast of Arabia (that is,
the northern boundary to the Indian Ocean), for two years we never
232 Miscellaneous.
saw a whale; but in the Bay of Maskat one used to come in every
day in the afternoon, plough his way among the boats and vessels
there, and then go out again. He appeared to me to be about 20
or 30 feet long; and when I pointed him out to the officers of the
vessel, they said “that is ‘Muscat Tom;’ he pays a visit to the
bay every day, and has been known to do so from time immemorial.”
We saw schools of porpoises, sometimes perhaps two miles long, on
the south-east coast; and one of the perquisites of the Shaykh of
Raidah, a town on the coast about sixty miles north-east of Makalla,
is the unborn young of the porpoise when a female is caught in this
condition. Once, also, when we were sailing down the coast, in a
stiff breeze, towards Aden, two or more “ blackfish,” as the sailors
called them, accompanied us for twenty-four hours, keeping close
to the side of the vessel and sporting round her. They appeared
to me to be about 12 feet long.
But, if we did not happen to see any whales on this coast, we
heard that the fishermen (who go to the most unfrequented parts
yearly to catch small and large shark, the former to salt-in for pro-
vision, which is a staple commodity on this coast, and the latter for
their fins for the China market) often pick up portions of ambergris,
which, I think, at Maskat, sells for more than its weight in gold,
chiefly for its fancied aphrodisiacal power.
One day, one of these fishermen came alongside our vessel, and
handed me in, through my scuttle, a piece half as big as my head.
It was formed of concentric layers like cholesterine, in which were
imbedded an innumerable quantity of cuttlefish-beaks. Of course,
T only regarded it in a scientific point of view; and, fancing that
it was analogous to the “ hair-ball ” in the ox’s stomach (the horny
beaks of the cuttlefish forming the ingesta), I took a little bit as a
specimen, gave the man a dollar, and told him to take the rest to
the Maskat market.
On another occasion, while fishing in the jolly-boat with a mid-
shipman and one of our Beni-Bo-Ali pilots in the channel between
the mainland of Arabia and the island of Masira, we saw some large
fish biting at something on the surface of the water, when, to our
astonishment, the Beni-Bo-Ali pilot leapt over and, swimming up to
it, laid hold of it and brought it on board, when it turned out to be
a dead cuttlefish. Our pilot said, “ Ah! I thought it had been a
piece of ambergris which the sharks were eating; for they are very
fond of it, and it is often found under such circumstances.”
All this goes to prove that there are many whales in this part
of the Indian Ocean just within the tropics, and that they are the
sperm-whale. Of course they cannot get very far out of the tropics
to the north without getting into the land-locked waters of the Red
Sea and Persian Gulf respectively.
I know that Cephalopoda abound on this coast, and that American
whalers used to capture the sperm-whale there ; for our captain had
saved the crew of an American whaler there which had become in-
jured, and took them all up to Maskat.
Miscellaneous. 233
On a new Subclass of Fossil Birds (Odontornithes).
By O. C. Marsu.
The remarkable extinct birds with biconcave vertebre (Ichthyor-
nid), recently described by the writer from the upper Cretaceous shale
of Kansas *, prove on further investigation to possess some additional
characters, which separate them still more widely from all known
recent and fossil forms. The type species of this group, Ichthyornis
dispar, Marsh, had well-developed teeth in both jaws. These teeth
were quite numerous and implanted in distinct sockets; they were
small, compressed, and pointed, and all of those preserved are similar.
Those in the lower jaws number about twenty in each ramus, and are
all more or less inclined backward. The series extends over the entire
upper margin of the dentary bone, the front tooth being very near the
extremity. The maxillary teeth appear to have been equally nume-
rous, and essentially the same as those in the mandible.
The skull was of moderate size, and the eyes were placed well
forward. The lower jaws are long and slender, and the rami were
not closely united at the symphysis; they are abruptly truncated
just behind the articulation for the quadrate. This extremity, and
especially its articulation, is very similar to that in some recent
aquatic birds. The jaws were apparently not encased in a horny
sheath.
The scapular arch, and the bones of the wings and legs, all conform
closely to the true ornithic type. The sternum has a prominent
keel, and elongated grooves for the expanded coracoids. The wings
were large in proportion to the legs; and the humerus had an extended
radial crest. The metacarpals are united, as in ordinary birds. The
bones of the posterior extremities resemble those in swimming birds,
The vertebr were all biconcave, the concavities at each end of the
centra being distinct and nearly alike. Whether the tail was elon-
gated cannot at present be determined ; but the last vertebra of the
sacrum was unusually large.
This bird was fully adult, and about as large as a pigeon. With
the exception of the skull, the bones do not appear to have been
pneumatic, although most of them are hollow. The species was
carnivorous, and probably aquatic.
When the remains of this species were first described, the portions
of lower jaws found with them were regarded by the writer as repti-
lian+; the possibility of their forming part of the same skeleton,
although considered at the time, was not deemed sufficiently strong
to be placed on record. On subsequently removing the surrounding
shale, the skull and additional portions of both jaws were brought to
light, so that there cannot now be a reasonable doubt that all are
parts of the same bird. The possession of teeth and biconcave ver-
tebre, although the rest of the skeleton is entirely avian in type,
obviously implies that these remains cannot be placed in the present
* Amer. Journ. of Sci. and Arts, vol. iv. p. 344, Oct. 1872, and vol. v.
p. 74, Jan. 1875. ‘Annals,’ Jan. 1873, p. 80.
t+ Amer. Journ. of Sci. and Arts, vol. iv. p. 406, Noy, 1872.
234 Miscellaneous.
groups of birds ; and hence a new subclass, Odontornithes, is proposed
for them. The order may be called Ichthyornithes.
The species lately described by the writer as Jchthyornis celer
also had biconcave vertebra and probably teeth. It proves to be
generically distinct from the type species of this group, and hence
may be named Apatornis celer, Marsh. It was about the same size
as Ichthyornis dispar, but of more slender proportions. The geolo-
gical horizon of both species was essentially the same. The only re-
mains of them at present known are in the museum of Yale College.
The fortunate discovery of these interesting fossils is an important
gain to paleontology, and does much to break down the old distine-
tions between Birds and Reptiles, which the Archopteryx has so
materially diminished. Itis quite probable that that bird, likewise,
had teeth and biconcave vertebree, with its free metacarpals and
elongated tail Amer. Journ. of Science and Arts, vol. y., Feb. 1873,
On two new Free Sponges from Singapore.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Dr. A. B. Meyer has sent to the British Museum five specimens of
free sponges (four of them belonging to one species, and the
other to a separate one), which I believe were obtained in the neigh-
bourhood of Singapore.
The one is very like Tetilla polyura of O. Schmidt (‘ Spongien-
fauna des atlantischen Meeres,’ t. vi. f. 8), which is the type of my
genus Lophiurella, but differs from it in several particulars ; and the
other is a form which has not hitherto occurred to me.
It has been thought that these free sponges are only the young
and free state of sponges which become attached in their older state ;
but this theory wants further confirmation. Tetilla polyura of
Schmidt might be young, as it is only 3 inch long ; but the specimens
from Singapore are more than 2 inches in diameter and length.
The four specimens, which I have called Psetalia globulosa, exhibit
four different states of growth, the sponge being considerably
modified in its general form as it enlarges.
The youngest specimen, about + inch in diameter, is half-oblong,
with a few conical projections on the lower part, each ending in a
tuft of spicules, and with a flattened upper surface having a small
central opening leading to the inner surface.
In a larger specimen, about 13 inch in diameter, the conical pro-
minences on the under surface, each ending in a tuft of elongate
spicules, are more numerous, and the upper surface is produced,
conical, and endingin a much larger central opening.
In the largest specimen, about 23 inches in diameter, the sponge
is irregularly conical below, the surface being covered with distinct,
rather prominent, tubercles, each containing a tuft of elongate
filamentous spicules, ending below, as in the other specimens, in
three or more recurved anchoring spines. The upper surface is
deeply concave, with only a broad convex margin, incurved, edging
the concavity. This, like that of the interior of the other specimens,
Miscellaneous. 235
has a series of rounded oscules, that are small near the margin and
gradually increase in size as they approach the centre, where the
oscules become united into two very large oblong rather sinuous
holes. The outer surface of this sponge exhibits a quantity of small
circular holes interspersed among the tubercles which bear the bunches
of spicules.
The other sponge I have named Labaria hemispherica. It is
hemispherical, about 2 inches in diameter, and rather more than L-
inch high, with a rather smooth outer surface and a rather deep
regular concavity on the upper surface, which seems formed of
interlacing spicules, leaving considerable spaces between them.
The outer surface and its margin are scattered with distant, but
rather regularly placed, cylindrical perforations, from the centre of
which are emitted tufts of elongated filiform spicules, diverging in
all directions from the surface of the sponge. The middle of the
underside deeply concave, with a well-defined edge, from which is
emitted a very large tuft of very numerous crowded spicules, form-
ing a kind of brush, each filament when perfect ending in three
short recurved spines.
Mr. Carter will give a further account of these sponges, with
descriptions of the spicules of which they are formed, in his account
of the sponges in the British Museum.
On the “« Capreolus” of Zonites algirus. By E. Dusrevrt.
In our anatomical and historical investigation of the generative
apparatus of the Helices, we have noticed the presence of a sperma-
tophore in Zonites algirus, and described the capreolus of that species,
which had not been indicated by any malacologist.
This body, 26 millims. in length and 1 millim. in breadth at its
most inflated portion, is of a tubular form, diminishing in size on
both sides from its inferior third. It is a complete canal, furnished
with numerous spiral channels. A transverse section made about
its middle has the aspect of a cogged wheel furnished with from
twelve to fourteen little teeth. Its superior extremity terminates in
a tube with a capillary aperture, where the lamelle disappear ; whilst
the other, where they are more distinct, is shorter and presents a
wider orifice. It is covered with an albuminoid membrane.
When the introduction of the capreolus is completed, its inferior
extremity, curving into the are of a circle, inserts itself for three,
four, or five millimetres into the neck of the oviduct, which, in this
species, is destitute of a transverse muscle. This extremity is
enveloped by a whitish viscous matter, which escapes from the
interior of the spermatophore, and contains an infinity of sperma-
tozoids. The issue of these from the interior of this appendage is
due to the action of the muscular membrane of the copulatory canal.
A part of the inferior deferent duct is destined to the production
of the capreolus. This duct, which measures 50 millims. in extent,
has not the same volume throughout its length. From its point of
junction with the deferent channel for a distance of 31 millims. its
diameter is 3 or at most 3 millim., whilst in the second half of its
236 Miscellaneous.
course, which terminates at the penis, it is } or sometimes 3 millim.
The narrow portion of the duct is pellucid; the dilated portion, of
an opaque white, is composed of the same layers which are met with
in the flagellum of the Helices. Beneath an external cellular mem-
brane we find a muscular membrane, followed in its turn by a
glandular layer, which does not exist in the narrow part of the duct.
In the wide portion of the same organ we observe numerous lamelle | -
. arranged like the spiral fibre of the trachez of plants. ‘These lamellee
extend in an oblique spiral between the two margins of this portion of
the canal, their obliquity increasing towards the point of junction of
the two portions of the latter, in the neighbourhood of which they
finally become longitudinal. At the breeding-time they are covered
with solid white particles, which effervesce with hydrochloric acid.
In its movement of retroversion the penis is followed by the
inferior deferent canal, which contains the capreolus until the
moment when this body is expelled.—Comptes Rendus, November 4,
1872, tome lxxv. pp. 1126, 1127.
On the Developmental History of Petromyzon. By A. ScHNEIDER.
Since August Miiller published his fine discovery of the transforma-
tion of Ammocetes into Pteromyzon (Miiller’s Archiv, 1856; see also
Ann. & Mag. N. H. ser. 2, vol. xviii. p. 298), every zoologist must
certainly have been desirous of witnessing this wonderful metamor-
phosis. Here in Giessen the opportunity seemed to offer itself to me ;
for, in the Bieberbach, Ammocaites branchialis occurs in such abun-
dance that in the course of two years I obtained about two hundred
Ammoceetes and a dozen of Petromyzon Planert. But I never obtained
the transition-stages, nor could I succeed in getting full-grown speci-
mens of Ammocetes to undergo any further development in tanks. I
must therefore acknowledge with thanks that Prof. von Siebold had
the kindness to give me two specimens of the transition-stage which
were in his possession. As I was sufficiently familiar with the struc-
ture of Amimocetes and Petromyzon, these sufficed to give me an in-
sight into some of the most important processes.
On the ventral surface of the Ammocetes there is an elongate-oval
organ, already mentioned by Rathke, which was regarded by A.
Miller as the rudiment of the tongue, but the structure of which
has hitherto remained entirely unknown, It isa gland which opens
into the cesophagus in the ventral line between the third and fourth
branchial clefts. Its structure differs from that of all other known
glands. ‘The orifice leads into two tubes lying close to one another,
and which extend forward to the end of the branchio-cesophageal
cavity, and backward to the boundary between the fifth and sixth
branchial clefts. Just at the orifice another tube branches off on
each side, passes a short distance backward, and then, bending up-
ward and forward, reaches the vicinity of the orifice of the gland,
then again bends downward and backward, and again downward
and forward, so that it describes about 14 spiral convolution. In
the part situated in front of the orifice of the gland, there are on
each side four cords consisting of nucleated cells, The cells are cu-
Miscellaneous. 237
neiform, with a polyhedral transverse section; they stand with their
bases at the surface of the cord; and all converge towards a longitu-
dinal central surface. ‘The whole mass appears as if finely striated ;
but the striation does not seem to be due to fibrille, but only to the
edges of the rather thin cells.
These four cords are united by vascular connective tissue into a
thick compact cord, which, lying upon the tube, projects into its
lumen. The inner surface of the tube, including the compact cord,
is covered by a ciliated epithelium. The four distinct cords lie at the
surface of the compact cord something like four cylinders which are
enveloped by a larger cylinder touching them. At the line of con-
tact the ciliated cells are deficient, and the subjacent glandular gub-
stance appears freely towards the lumen of the tube. These places
are also those towards which the cells converge. Of the four cords, two
run into the portion of the tube which extends directly backward,
whilst two pass into the spirally convoluted part and follow its con-
volutions. In other respects the structure in the hinder part is
exactly as in the anterior part. No trace of a neutral fluid is to be
found in the gland.
From this gland the tongue certainly does not originate, as has
been concluded from its position, but during the metamorphosis the
striated cell-substance disappears. The connective tissue and the
epithelial lining of the tubes remain; the latter separates from the
wall, and in part remains tubular, but in part constricts itself into
balls. In short, there is produced from it an organ which, both in
position and structure, agrees with the thyroid glands of the deve-
loped vertebrate. The organ described as the thyroid gland in
Petromyzon by Wilhelm Miller (Jenaische Zeitschr. vi. p. 433), I
cannot regard as the same, either in structure or position. I have
found the true thyroid gland both in P. Planeri and P. fluviatilis ;
and it will certainly not be deficient in the other species. In Am-
mocates consequently we find for the first time, and hitherto alone
among all Vertebrata, the thyroid gland in function during a long
period of life and in a high state of development.
The branchial clefts in Ammocates, as is well known, open into
the cesophagus—but in Petromyzon into a free tube, closed posteriorly,
the bronchus, above which there is an cesophagus which unites the
intestinal canal with the buccal cavity. From the mere comparison of
Ammocetes and Petromyzon we cannot see how the new state is
produced from the old one. This takes place as follows :—The ceso-
phagus is formed in the dorsal median line of the branchial cavity
as a solid cord, consisting of round, closely approximated nuclei, only
separated by a little interstitial substance; and into this a cavity
penetrates from the front and gradually renders it permeable. At the
same time an increase of the blood-vessels commences in the connec-
tive tissue which surrounds the branchial cavity and the cesophagus,
The vessels finally coalesce, so that both the bronchus and the wso-
phagus lie free in a great blood-space, extending from the so-called
pericardium to the point of the head. In this are also situated the
branchial artery, the tongue, and the branchie themselves.
\
238 Miscellaneous.
The above-mentioned foundation of the cesophagus is not indicated
at allin Ammocetes. It must not be confounded with the fold which
hangs down from the dorsal median line into the branchial cavity
of Ammocetes.
One of the first processes of the metamorphosis must be the forma-
tion of the tongue; in both my specimens it was already formed,
whilst the cesophagus was only permeable for a few millimetres, and
the mouth still possessed the narrow opening figured by Von Siebold
(Stisswasserfische von Mitteleuropa, p. 381).—Oberhessischen Gre-
sellsch. fiir Natur- und Heilkunde, January 11, 1873.
On 4’ Parasites of the Cetaceans of the N.W. Coast of America, with
Descriptions of New Forms. By W. H. Dax, U.S. Coast Survey.
Among the parasites most widely known as infesting the Cetacea,
two classes may be recognized, viz. those which are true parasites,
deriving their subsistence from the animal upon which they are
found, such as the Pycnogonoids and Cyami; and those which are
merely sessile upon the animal, and derive no nourishment or other
benefit from it which might not equally well be furnished by an
inanimate object, such as the various Cirripedes.
No Pyenogonoids have yet been reported from the Cetacea of this
coast. Brief descriptions of the species of Cyamus found upon the
California grey, the humpback, and the Arctic bowhead whales
were submitted by me to the Academy at a recent meeting. I may
here add to those descriptions a few facts since obtained, and bearing
upon the species described. I have, through the courtesy of Capt.
Scammon, been able to examine a large number of Cyamz obtained at
Monterey, Cal., from the humpback (Megaptera versabilis, Cope).
They are all of the same species as that (C. swffusus) described by me
as parasitic upon that whale—a fact which tends to confirm the hypo-
thesis that each species of whale has its own peculiar parasites, and
that there is rarely more than one species of Cyamus found upon one
animal. The females, which were unknown at the date of my descrip-
tion, now prove to resemble the male in every respect, except in re-
gard to the sexual organs, and in being a trifle more slender in form.
Among the Cirripedes, Tubicinella has not been reported from
these waters, nor is the Chelonobia known to have been obtained
from any of the whales of this coast. The genera known from the
north Pacific waters are Coronula, an allied form which I believe to
be uncharacterized, and Otion or a closely allied form.
SESSILIA.
Coronuia, Lam.
Coronula, Lamk. An. s. Vert. v. p. 387.
Coronula balenaris, Linn. sp.; Lamk. Ann. du Mus. i. p. 468,
pl. 30. figs. 2-4.
This species, or one very closely allied to it, was obtained by the
late Mr. Bridges, probably from the coast of Central America; but
the identification of the exact locality and the species of cetacean
Miscellaneous. 239
from which it was obtained was prevented by the premature and
lamented decease of that energetic field naturalist.
Coronula diadema?, Lamk.
It is quite possible that the species here indicated under the above
name may be distinct from the true Atlantic diadema; but materials
for exact comparison are wanting, and the figures given by Reeve
and others very closely resemble the form before me. The radiating
ridges are six in each group, often slightly bifurcated at their bases,
and strongly sculptured with transverse, fluctuating, slightly elevated
beaded lines. ‘The interspaces are sharply transversely grooved.
The superior membranous surface is brown, the pallium or hood
surrounding the cirri is shghtly purplish. The scuta are subtrian-
gulate, with the posterior prolongafion longest, slightly keeled above,
with sharply pointed adjacent umbones at the anterior angle of the
occludent margin. No vestiges of the terga are present. Adult
specimens are over two inches in diameter at the base. In sucha spe-
cimen the dimensions of the scuta are as follows :—length of occludent
margin -215in., posterior margin (slightly arcuated) -28 in., anterior
margin‘175 in. Colour of scuta white; concave below, stout, solid.
This species has been obtained from the humpback whale (1. versa-
bits) from Behring Strait to the Gulf of California, and may also be
found on other species. It is especially abundant on the flippers and
on the under lip of these animals.
CRYPTOLEPAS, Nn. g.
Scuta and terga both present, minute ; valves six ; externally pro-
duced below the surface of the whale’s skin in thin radiating lamine,
with their planes perpendicular to the vertical axis of the animal,
and bifurcating and enlarged toward their distal edges. Parasitic on
Cetacea.
Type Cryptolepas rhachianectis, Dall, n. sp.
Valves subequal, rostrum radiate, not alate. Lateral valves ante-
riorly alate, posteriorly radiate ; carina alate, not radiate. Each valve
internally transversely deeply grooved, and furnished externally with
six radiating laminee vertically sharply grooved, the adjacent ter-
minal laminz of each two valves coalescing to form one lamina of
extra thickness; all the lamine bifurcated and thickened toward
their outer edges, with two or more short spurs on each side, irregu-
larly placed between the shell-wall and the bifurcation. Superior
terminations of the valves (bluntly pointed ?) usually abraded, trans-
versely striate. Scuta subquadrate, adjacent anteriorly, very slightly
beaked in the middle of the occludent margin; terga subquadrate,
small, separated from the scuta by intervening membrane ; both very
small in proportion to the orifice. Membranes very thin and deli-
cate, raised into small lamelle between the opercular valves. All
the calcareous matter pulverulent, and showing a strong tendency to
split up into lamin. Antero-posterior diameter of large specimen
1-62 in., ditto of orifice 63 in. ; transverse diameter of orifice 58 in. ;
length of scuta ‘17 in., breadth -08 in. ; length of terga:07 in., breadth
240 Miscellaneous.
‘O07 in. Colour of membranes, when living, sulphur-yellow ; hood
extremely protrusile.
This species is found sessile on the California grey whale (Rha-
chianectes glaucus, Cope). I have observed them on specimens of
that species hauled up on the beach at Monterey for cutting off the
blubber, in the bay-whaling of that locality. The superior surface
of the lateral laminz being covered by the black skin of the whale,
was not visible; and the animal, removed from its native element,
protruding its bright yellow hood in every direction to a surprising
distance, as if gasping for breath, presented a truly singular appear-
ance.
PEDUNCULATA.
Orton, Leach.
Otion, Leach, Encycl. Hrdannita mene vol. iii. p. 170.
Otion Stimpsoni, Dall, n. sp.
Scuta only present, beaked, with the umbones on the occludent
margins ; anterior prolongation the longer, pointed, rather slender ;
posterior prolongation rounded, wider; external margin concave.
Colour (in spirits) hght orange with a dark purple streak on the
rostral surface and on each side of the peduncle, while the lateral
surfaces of the body-case and lobes are mottled with dark purple.
The lower lip of the orifice is transversely striated and translucent,
the upper margins, slightly reflexed internally, white; in some spe-
cimens with two prolongations or small lobes above, which are wanting
in other specimens. ‘The tubular prolongations very irregular and
variable in size and form, usually unsymmetrical; one sometimes
nearly abortive. Length of peduncle 2°8 in., of body 2°16 in., of lobes
2-0 in., of orifice 1-18 in., of scuta *55 in.; width of seuta +16 in.
Hab. On the “ humpback” (MW. versabilis), sessile on the Coronule
which infest that species, but never, so far as I have observed, on the
surface of the whale itself.
Dr. Leach describes five calcareous pieces, namely the scuta, terga,
and rostrum, in the typical species (O. Cuvier, Leach); and they are
figured by Reeve; but this species has certainly only the scuta.
Whether this difference is of more than specific value I am not able
to decide, owing to the great paucity of works of reference here. I
should be unwilling to describe the species, were it not that it was
submitted to the late lamented Dr. Stimpson for examination, and
was pronounced by him to be new.
A variety, or perhaps another form, was observed by me in Behring
Strait in 1865, which was blotched all over with rose-pink, and had
the scuta narrower and more slender; it was also smaller than the
specimens before me; but as it is not at hand, I am unable to decide
with certainty.
I am indebted to Capt. C. M. Scammon and R. E. C. Stearns, Esq.,
for specimens and facilities furnished in the preparation of this paper.
Most of the specimens were collected by the former gentleman, and
will be figured in his forthcoming monograph of the Cetaceans of the
N.W. Coast.—Proceedings of the California Academy of Sciences,
Dec. 18, 1872.
THE ANNALS
MAGAZINE OF NATURAL HISTORY.
[FOURTH SERIES. ]
No. 65. MAY 1873.
XXXV.—On the Primitive Cell-layers. of the Embryo as the
Basis of Genealogical Classification of Animals, and on
the Origin of Vascular and Lymph Systems*. By E. Ray
a” M.A., Fellow and Lecturer of Exeter College,
xford.
A “wNATURAL” classification in modern zoology—in the
zoology which recognizes in the various forms of living things
the expression of one part of the general result proceeding from
the continuous operation of physical forces—is a genealogical
tree. In this tree, as in a family pedigree, no arbitrary
arrangement is admissible, no association or separation of
organic forms in harmony with theories of types, or with
reference to symmetry and the vested interests of subkingdoms,
classes, and orders. The simple questions are :—Have we
grounds for believing this lot of forms to have a common an-
cestry with that lot ? Which of these, again, give evidence of
closer kinship? and which represent diverging lines of descent ?
The evidence at our disposal for answering these questions
satisfactorily, with regard to the innumerable varieties of
plants and animals, is at the present time small indeed, but is
increasing with great rapidity.
The fact that we are able to classify organisms at all in ac-
cordance with the structural characteristics which they present
is due to the fact of their being related by descent; and the
* The substance of the following pages formed part of a course of
lectures on the classification of animals, commenced in the University
Museum, Oxford, during Michaelmas term, 1872.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4, Vol. xi. 21
322 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
classifications in vogue before the recognition of the origin of
organic forms by descent may be regarded as unconscious
attempts to answer the questions above put before they had
been rightly formulated.
The chief means which the naturalist at present possesses of
making out the genealogical tree of the animal kingdom lie
in the fact that the individual animals living at the present day,
in the process of reproduction, revert to the original simple
condition (or nearly so) from which they have in the course of
long ages been evolved as specific forms. The doctrine of
evolution teaches us that at a certain period in the history of
this planet such albuminoid substances as protoplasm came, by
gradual building-up, into existence. From such protoplasm,
by slow continuous development, due to its properties of heredity
and adaptation, all living forms have proceeded by direct
descent. Strangely enough, a simple spheroid of protoplasm
(nucleated or not) is the form under which the detached repro-
ductive particle of each living organism makes its appearance,
and from such a spheroid every individual living thing has
been more or less directly developed within the space of a few
days or weeks. In passing from this simple condition to its
adult form the individual goes through a series of changes, which
are now explained by what may be termed “the recapitulation
hypothesis,” which supposes that the individual organism
in thus developing repeats more or less completely the successive
series of forms which its ancestry has presented in the course
of past ages; in fact the development of the individual is an
epitome of the development of the species. This tendency to
recapitulate, which is the fullest expression of the phenomenon
termed heredity, is lable to be masked in its effects in two
chief ways, due to adaptation—namely, the tendency to develop
directly to the adult form without exhibiting any ancestral
phases, and the tendency to develop evanescent organs for the
temporary wants of the young organism. The discrimination
of the appearances due to these distinct factors is the task of
modern embryology. It is clear that in proportion as this can
be effected we have in our hands in the recapitulation hypo-
thesis the means of determining the pedigree of all organisms.
Comparative anatomy (the morphology of adult organisms),
so far as it establishes identity of structure in certain groups
of organisms, widens the significance of a developmental history
worked out in one member of such a group, and furnishes
suggestions of the highest value in the disentanglement of the
hereditary and adaptational factors of such a history.
The remains of extinct forms have a specially suggestive
value ; but paleeontology as a whole, taken in connexion with
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. 323
the study of geographical distribution, furnishes, with regard to
such groups of organisms as have been preserved in the con-
dition of fossils, a distinct and independent mass of evidence,
enabling the naturalist to sketch out parts of the genealogical
tree, thus supplementing and independently reiterating the
conclusions drawn from embryology.
It is only within the last ten, or, we may almost say, the
last five years that the development of animals, especially of
the Invertebrata, has begun to be studied with the requisite
minuteness. Stimulated by the Darwinian theory and the
recapitulation hypothesis, naturalists are beginning to apply
the highest powers and new methods* of examination to the
study of the development of all kinds of organisms, so as to
trace out cell by cell the complete history of the elaboration
of the complex adult from the simple ovum. It is only now
that the first changes in the egg (the first dispositions of the
embryonic cells) are becoming known in a sutliciently widely
varied series of forms to enable the naturalist to form genera-
lizations. It is only by slow degrees that those species are
being found out which conserve - precious records in their
pregnant infancies, often not even hinted by the uneventful life-
histories of their nearest congeners. A commencement only has
been made, but one of great promise, by the researches of
Fritz Miiller (‘Fiir Darwin’), WeissmanT, Kowalewsky t, Ed.
van Beneden§, Hiickell||, and others, from which we may, I
think, draw conclusions of the greatest importance for genea-
logical classification.
It would not be surprising if the facts of development were
to lead to another primary grouping of the animal kingdom
than that indicated in the four are types or the six or
seven types now generally adopted, or should assign to
those great divisions unequal significance. They are con-
fessedly groupings based upon the anatomy of the adult or-
* The method of hardening the developing egg, imbedding it in a
matrix, and then cutting thin sections, has only quite recently been ap-
plied to Invertebrata, chiefly by Russian naturalists.
+ Embryology of the Diptera (Zeitschr. fiir wiss. Zool. 1865-66).
{ A series of papers, in the Memoirs of the Imperial Academy of St.
Petersburg (1867-71), on the development of Ctenophora, Ascidia, Amphi-
oxus, Sagitta, Euaxes, Lumbricus, Apis, and Hydrophilus,
§ A series of papers on the development of the Gregarina of the lobster
and of various Crustacea (Nebalia, Mysis, Sacculina, &c.), in the Bulletins
of the Belgian Academy, 1869-72. Also prize memoir, in the same
Academy’s Transactions, on ‘‘ The Signification of the Parts of the Ege.”
|| Monograph of the Monera, Jenaische Zeitschr. 1868 ; Generelle Mor-
phologie, 1867 ; The Organization of the Sponges and their Relationship
to the Corals, Jenaische Zeitschr., and Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1870, y.
pp. 1 & 107.
21*
324 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
ganism ; and therefore necessarily there has been a tendency in
forming them to attach great importance to distinct plans of
structure due to a secondary adaptation, whilst the fundamental
community of organization has been ignored with something
like intention. Von Baer’s coincidence with Cuvier in his
establishing four modes of development, marking out groups
of the same value as the latter’s “‘embranchements,” is due to
the fact that fifty years ago the condition of biological science
did not allow even the great philosophic student of embryology
to go more deeply into the problem. He pointed out four
modes in which the later adaptation of animals may proceed ;
but he was unable at that time to bring into consideration the
details of the previous stages of the history. It was under his
immediate influence that the invaluable memoirsof Kowalewsky
have been produced.
It is, then, to be borne in mind that the four types of Baer
and Cuvier represent essentially four modes of mechanical
adaptation, and might be assumed, as, indeed, in some cases they
are, by organisms exhibiting divergent characters of an earlier
and more fundamental character. The doctrine of “ unity of
type,” which has from time to time been put forward by oppo-
nents of Cuvier, seems to be in closer agreement with the facts
made known by recent embryological study than the more
widely received dogma of a plurality of types. Already the
most eminent of German anatomists, Professor Gegenbaur, has,
in the second edition of his Comparative Anatomy (1870),
adopted an arrangement of the seven great divisions of the
animal kingdom which indicates this inequality in their relative
value as branches of a genealogical tree. Whilst the Protozoa
stand at the base of the main trunk, and the Ccelenterata
diverge from this as a primary branch, the Mollusca, Verte-
brata, Arthropoda, and Echinodermata are depicted as springing
as four distinct secondary branches from the primary branch,
represented by the heterogeneous and feebly marked group
Vermes. This filiation of the five highest groups of the
animal kingdom is supported on grounds which are chiefly
anatomical ; and in the pages of this inestimable book facts
are continually pointed out tending to demonstrate the homo-
geny of the various organs of all these large groups—in short,
exhibiting them as modifications of one type.
The early history of the developing embryo tends con-
clusively to establish this mode of representing the main
features of the family tree of the animal kingdom; whilst,
further, the hypothesis of unity of type (which is to be pre-
ferred as a preliminary hypothesis on account of its greater
simplicity as compared with that of a plurality of types) is, in
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. 325
its application to the five higher groups of animals, continually
receiving new support from observation, and seems likely to
lead into most productive lines of research.
The early changes in the developing spheroid of protoplasm
leading to the formation of organs may be summarily stated
as follows, so as briefly to put in view the fundamental cha-
racteristics which they present in different groups of the animal
series.
Fig. 1. Fig. 2.
Cytode. Cell. Polyplast without central
cavity. (Optical section.)
A. The reproductive spheroid is a non-nucleated particle of
protoplasm (Cytod, Hck.), which either acquires a nucleus and
becomes a true cell (Hck.), or remains in the non-nucleated
condition; this latter condition characterizes the Monera or
Protozoa homogenea, whilst the former is what is observed in
all the other groups commonly classed as Protozoa (from which,
however, the Spongida are excluded, since they appear in the
next section). By differentiation of the primitive substance of
the plastid (cell or cytode), without fission of the original mass,
a cuticle and cuticular appendages, muscular fibrous layers,
cilia, contractile cavities, and, by the segmentation of the
nucleus, a reproductive germ- or sperm-mass may be former.
Division of the primary spheroid, when it does take place,
gives rise to new and separate individual spheroids, or to a
loosely aggregated colony of such spheroids, to be termed a
polyplast. In this polyplast there 1s no arrangement of the
units into definite layers.
The organisms whose mode of growth is thus described may
be distinguished as HOMOBLASTICA.
Notes to \.—The stock of the Homoblastica thus coincides
with the Protozoa with the exclusion of the Sponges, and con-
tains the following chief groups, the genetic aflinities of
which must be hereafter discussed :—1. Llomogenea (embracing
326 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
Hiickel’s Monera as Nuda and the Foraminifera as Testacea) ;
2. Nuclerfera (embracing Ameboidea, Gregarinida, and Catal-
lacta); 3. Radiolaria or Cytophora (embracing the Heliozoa
or freshwater Radiolaria, and the Radiolaria proper or marine
forms); 4. Jnfusoria (embracing the Suctoria and Ciliata,
excluding the so-called Flagellate Infusoria, which, it seems,
should be referred to the Volvocinean Alge); 5. Noctilucida
(Noctiluca and Peridinium).
We are indebted to Hiickel’s monograph in the ‘ Jenaische
Zeitschrift’ (and translated in ‘Quart. Journ. Micr. Sci.’ for
1869) for the knowledge of the Monera and their reproduction.
Prof. Ed. van Beneden, of Litge, has given a valuable account
of the development and structure of a Gregarina from the
lobster (Quart. Journ. Mier. Sci. 1870 & 1871), from which it
appears that the reproductive spheroid appears first as a cytode,
and subsequently acquires a nucleolus and nucleus, whilst
considerable tissue-differentiation also goes on, though the uni-
cellular condition is maintained. The high differentiation of
the Ciliate Infusoriais thus no evidence against their unicellular
character.
The development of the Radiolaria is not properly known in
any case. Hiickel, in his great monograph, and more recently
Cienkowski (Schultze’s Archiv, 1871, and Quart. Journ. Mier.
Sci., Oct. 1871) have given some account of the formation of
spores, which demonstrate the central capsule to be reproductive
like the nucleus in other groups. If the yellow cells should
prove to be parasitic, as Cienkowski suggests, then, as in
colonies of Monera or Catallacta,all the units, with the exception
of the central reproductive body, would be of coordinate value.
B. The reproductive sphe-
roid is at first a nucleated
particle of protoplasm; in
some cases it develops from
a non-nucleated stage. In
many cases the nucleus dis-
appears before fertilization.
Division of the spheroid then
gives rise toa polyplast. By
the growth of this polyplast
either a hollow sphere boun-
ded by a single layer of cells
is produced, into which a
portionot its/own) walll:be- Planula formed by invagination of a
Ce invaginated or tucked, part of the wall of a polyplast with
as by the adjustment of a central cavity. (Optical section.)
Fig. 4.
|
|
|
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. 327
woven nightcap from its pulled-out to its cap-like condi-
tion, or the cells arrange themselves in two definitely marked
Fig. 6.
Planula, without orifice, Planula with orifice, which
formed by direct growth. has broken through.
(Optical section. ) (Surface view.)
layers, the inner of which bounds a cavity which subsequently,
by a breaking through at one pole, communicates with the
exterior. In either case the result is an organic form charac-
terized by being constructed of two layers of cells, the inner of
which lines a cavity opening to the exterior. This cavity is
the primitive gastric cavity; and the organic form thus
characterized may be known as the Planula*.
The production of such a Planula, recognizable under
extreme modifications of non-essential general shape (one of
the most common causes of which is the admixture of a large
mass of secondary yelk with the original egg-cell), is common
to the developmental history of all animals above the Protozoa.
But after this there is a divergence ; for whilst there is a further
development of primitive cells in the Vermes, Mollusks, Echi-
noderms, Arthropods, and Vertebrates, in the Coelenterata (in-
cluding herein the Sponges) these two layers of cells, the
endoderm and ectoderm, remain throughout life as the basis of
further histological differentiation, even though in the larger
forms the ectoderm may largely develop deep layers of a special
muscular or skeletal nature. ‘The series of forms thus branching
off from the genealogical tree may be termed DrpLOBLASTICA.
The endoderm and ectoderm of the polypes and corals was
recognized first by Professor Huxley, who at the same time
* It may be advantageous to use the term Gasérula for that condition
of the Planula when the orifice is present, as Hiickel has proposed since
the above scheme was drawn up.
328 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
pointed out the similarity of these layers to the two primitive
layers of the Vertebrate embryo.
Notes to B.—The difference in the two modes of origin of
the Planula may be due to the dropping of the mvagination-
process as a shortening of the developmental process—that is
to say, in obedience to the tendency to a direct as opposed
to arecapitulative development. It is, however, to be noticed
in connexion with this that in the later development of
special organs we have examples where development occurs
sometimes by invagination and sometimes by simple accretion,
and where the bulk of the developing structure appears to
determine the invagination. Such, for instance, is the case
with the otocysts or auditory capsules of mollusks. In the
Nudibranchiates I have satisfactorily determined that their
cavity does not arise by invagination. On the other hand, in
the Cephalopod Loligo [have found (what was previously sus-
pected but undemonstrated) that the otocyst zs formed by an
invagination, the ciliated canal connected with it being a
remnant of its external communication. The development of
the nerve-centres also furnishes examples. In Loligo I have
observed that the cephalic ganglia originate each by invagina-
tion and formation of a groove and cavity. In Gasteropods
the corresponding ganglia form by simple thickening of the
outer layer of cells. ‘The origin of the cerebro-spinal nerve-
centre of Vertebrates and certain Tunicates, as compared with
that of Arthropods and notably of certain Annelids (Lumbricus,
and Huaxes as described by Kowalewsky), offers the same
contrast.
It is remarkable that the origin of the primitive gastric
cavity by invagination has been more widely observed in the
higher groups, and that in most Coelenterata as yet studied the
cavity is formed directly. ‘There are exceptions to this among
Coelenterata; but in this subject it must be remembered that
we have as yet very few adequate observations. Among the
higher groups the observations of KKowalewsky have especially
established the occurrence of this primitive invagination in
Amphioxus, in Tunicates, and certain Vermes ; my own ob-
servations (as yet unpublished) have proved its wide-spread
occurrence in Mollusca, viz. in the Lamellibranch Cyclas
pusilla, in several Nudibranchs (Polycera, Holis, Doris, Pleuro-
branchus), inthe Pulmonates Arion and Limax. 'The presence
of accessory yelk is what, more than any thing else, appears
among the Mollusca to be associated with the suppression of
the invagination-process. The anus of Rusconi in the de-
veloping Batrachia among Vertebrata represents the orifice of
invagination in a somewhat modified condition.
—j oD «<
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. 329
The observations of Miklucho-Macleay*, which have been
followed up in a masterly way by his teacher Professor
Hiickel of Jena, first demonstrated the relationship of Sponges
and Ceelenterata. The Planula-embryo of a calcareous sponge
(Guancha blanca) is made known in Macleay’s paper;
Q. Schmidt has figured that of another (Dunstervillia). The
embryo of Spongilla, as described by Lieberktihn, is also a
Planula.
The retention of the Diploblastic constitution throughout life
by the Coelenterata serves as an important fact in determining
the homogenies of the perigastric and canal systems of the
corals and medusoids. It is clear enough that they are merely
diverticula, or portions of the primitive gastric cavity. As
such they can have no homogenetic, but merely a homoplastic,
agreement with the vascular and perivisceral systems of higher
animals, the origin of which will be pointed out below. ‘The
fluid which they contain will also be seen to be of a different
nature from chyle or blood, and, in fact, is merely a diluted chyme.
In the histological differentiation of Coelenterata the outer
layer of cells gives rise to muscular fibre, and also represents
a nervous system; in the case of [Hydra the fibres are con-
tinuous with the large ectodermal cells (Kleimenberg), whilst
in others (Meduse &c.) deep-lying cellular elements of the
nature of muscular and connective tissue develop from the
ectoderm. ‘The endodermal cells are confined to vegetative
functions. The origin of generative products will be discussed
below.
C. Development having proceeded, as in the Diploblastica,
to the production of an ecto- and endoderm, or an epi- and
hypoblast, with primitive gastric cavity bounded by the latter,
a third layer of cells makes its appearance between these two,
whence taking its precise origin is notyet determined. A portion
of this middle layer becomes more especially adherent to the
ectoderm, another portion more especially to the endoderm.
The separation between these two portions of the new mid layer
may be complete so as to leave a wide cavity, or it may never
be carried to any extent; but whatever extensive cavity or
partial channels make their appearance, or whatever mesh-
bearing or sponge-like character the mesoblast takes on, so as
to produce an imperfect continuity between 1ts more super-
ficial and deeper parts, connected and bound together, it may
be, by branched cells—such cavity, channels, or spongy tissue
are more or less complete representatives of the blood-lymph
system. ‘lhe organisms characterized by the presence of these
* Jenaische Zeitschrift, 1868, p. 221.
330 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
three primitive layers of cells, which furnish the original
material for further histological differentiation, may be termed
TRIPLOBLASTICA.
In all Triploblastica (Vermes, Echinodermata, Mollusca,
Vertebrata, Arthropoda) it appears that of the three layers the
outer (epiblast) gives rise to epidermic structures, sense-organs,
and the great nerve-centres ; the mid layer (mesoblast) to mus-
cular tissue, skeletal tissue (varieties of connective tissue and
cartilage), blood and lymph, and the walls of the cavities in
which they are held; the imnernost layer (hypodlast) to the
lining of the gastric or alimentary tract and its diverticula, in
the form of glands. The primitive orifice of invagination
(mouth of the Planu/a) does not persist, either as mouth or,
as has been erroneously supposed, as anus, but becomes entirely
closed up, and a new mouth and an anus eat their way into the
gastric cavity from the exterior, developing thus pharynx and
terminal intestine. ‘The origin of the generative products is,
as in the Diploblastica, not ascertained to be exclusively from
either epiblast or hypoblast. The communication of the meso-
blastic blood-lymph-cavity, or a part of it, with the exterior
occurs in all Triploblastica, and is accompanied by an ingrowth
of the epiblast, which, appearing in the simplest worms as the
pair of segmental organs or ‘ciliated excretory tubes,” persists
in all the subsequent modifications of the type (Echinoderms,
Arthropods, Mollusks, Vertebrates).
Notes to C.—The above generalization must be understood
as resting on a limited number of facts, which, however, are
being daily increased in number. Attention has been already
drawn in the notes to B to the frequent masking of the Planula
stage and invagination-process in this group as well as in the
preceding one. In the early stages of development of the few
Vertebrata as yet carefully studied (viz. a few fish, Batrachia,
and the common fow]) it is only in the Batrachia that evidence
of the invagination, and that in a modified condition (see
Stricker’s valuable paper in ‘Zeitschr. fiir wiss. Zoologie,’
vol. xi., 1861), is obtained. It is yet a question, on which
there is a considerable divergence of opinion, supported in each
case by careful observation, whether the mesoblast has uni-
formly the same essential origin in the various groups of the
Triploblastica. The hypothesis that it has is justifiable in the
present condition of knowledge as the simplest. We have to
look for a reconciliation of the opinions based upon interpre-
tation of observations carried out with different animals, which
variously point to the derivation of the mid layer fromcells of the
epiblast, from cells of the hypoblast, from original cells of the
primitive polyplast, or from a new cell-formation in the yelk
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. 331
distinct from the cleavage-process (free-cell formation). A
further comprehension of the accompanying conditions and
mode of carrying out of the suppression of steps in the historical
epitome of the individual’s development will, more than any
thing else, tend to this result. The non-identity of the mouth
in Diploblastica and Triploblastica is one of the most curious
divergences which a comparison of the two groups brings out.
There is on the whole a satisfactory concordance of testimony
with regard to the chief tissues and organs to which the three
layers respectively give rise, if we except the generative
products. The hypoblast of the Triploblastica retams the
characters and significance of the Diploblast’s endoderm. The
fundamental properties of the latter’s ectoderm .(musculo-sen-
sorial layer of Kleinenberg) become distributed between the
tissues differentiated from epiblast and mesoblast—a fact which,
whether rightly or wrongly, suggests the ectoderm as the true
source of origin of the mesoblast ; and, in the case of the earth-
worm, Kowalewsky’s researches demonstrate this origin con-
clusively.
That the generative products arise from cells of the ectoderm
in Hydra is certain, from Kleinenberg’s careful observations.
- Hiickel, on the other hand, has found them derived from the
endoderm in certain Meduse and in Caleareous Sponges, whilst
Allman makes the same statement as to some Hydroid polyps.
That the ovaries and testes in higher animals arise from the
outer layer is not inconsistent with the fact that they may first
definitely appear within the limits of the mesoblast. An in-
growth and intercalation of the cells of the epi- and mesoblast
at an early period, such as Waldeyer has pointed to, sufficiently
explains the position of the vertebrate ovary and testis, even
though they be developed from the epiblast. ‘The position of the
generative masses of Oligochetous Annelids in their earliest
phase, as buds of the tissue in immediate contact with the
nerve-cord, to which I have drawn attention in Chatogaster*
and Tubifext, is in complete agreement with the view of their
derivation from cells of the epiblast, when considered in the
light of Kowalewsky’s admirable demonstration of the ingrowth
of the epiblast to form the ganglion-chain of Lwmbricus and
Huaxes.
A true blood-system, or blood-lymph-system as it is better to
call it in view of the present signification of words, is only
possible where a mesoblast is developed—that is, in the Tn-
ploblastica. In all Triploblastica it is represented by lacunz
or channels, or by mere wide-setting of the cellular elements
* Quart. Journ. Microsc. Science, July 1870.
+ Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1871, vii. p. 90.
332 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
of the mesoblast, between and around which the movement of
a fluid, so-called lymph, is possible.
A blood- -lymph-system or series of channels appears in its
simplest form in the flat-worms, where the main portion of
those channellings in the mesoblast, sometimes spoken of as
““water-vascular system,” must be regarded as the commencing
differentiation of the blood-lymph vascular system. The true
nature of these channels is well seen in a transverse section,
such as that of Bothriocephalus given by Landois (Zeitschr.
f. Zool. 1872), or such as that of the Planarian Bipalium to be
described by my friend Mr. Moseley, who assigns to them the
same importance as is done here. ‘The channels of the water-
vascular system in these cases are seen in section to be inter-
sected by long branching cells; they are, in fact, only partial
excavations of the mesoblastic tissue. Such excavation, carried
to a greater extent and widened out, ultimately forms the
“nerivisceral space” seen in many Nemerteans, and in all the
Gephyrea, Cheetopoda, Echinodermata. When parts of this
excavation remain shut off from parallel parts, and either com-
municate or do not communicate with the larger sinus-like
spaces, the conditions are given for the further modification of
this primitive vascular channelling into distinct blood-vessels,
lacunee, and pericardial smus-system, as in Mollusks, or into
a closed vascular system lying within a perivisceral sinus, as
in Chetopoda, or (no perivisceral sinus being apparent) into
closed vessels containing hemoglobin surrounding organs, as
in some leeches, or, lastly, into great sinus-spaces opening
through a “lymph-sy stem’? into a closed system of blood-
vessels, as in Vertebrates.
The orifices of the water-vascular system of the Planarians,
Cestodes, and Trematodes are, no doubt with reason, looked upon
as representing exactly the orifices of the ‘‘segment-organs”’
of the Cheetopoda ; but we have no warrant for assuming that
more than the aperture and a first portion of the “canal” in
the flat-worms corresponds with the little trumpet-mouthed
tube which hangs freely in the large perivisceral space of a
Cheetopod, or such a leech as Branchiobdella. The observed
facts of development are not conclusive as they at present stand
as to the origin of the segmental organ of Chetopoda. Kowa-
lewsky derives them from the middle layer in the case of
Euaxes ; but in view of the difficulties of the observation, and
of adverse considerations furnished by the facts of development
of apparently homogenous parts in Mollusks and Insects, an
argument cannot be based upon their mode of development ;
nor do the facts of development at present established lend
themselves to the decision of the question whether the flat-
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. 333
worms possess in their vascular system the commencement of
a body-cavity. The most conclusive evidence which can be
adduced on the matter is the analogy of such a mollusk as Phy/-
lirhoé, where, as in other Mollusca, the perivisceral cavity is de-
veloped only as a series of sinuses, of which the pericardium is
one. or where, as we may say, the perivisceral space is reduced
to the pericardium. This pericardium is produced at one end
into a tube or canal ciliated at one part, which opens to the
exterior. The ciliated tube represents a segment-organ, as
must be admitted for the renal organ of Mollusca generally,
and especially for the so-called “hearts” or “oviducts” of
Brachiopoda. In Phyllirhoé we have, it seems to me, as in
the flat-worms, the imperfect channellings and spaces of a
“parenchymatous” body placed in relation with the exterior
by the segment-organ, the wall of which is not discontinuous
with that of the channels. It is when the perivisceral space
becomes large and expanded that the segment-organ floats in
it with a trumpet-like inner orifice ; on the other hand, when
the blood-lymph-space is canal-like, then the segment-organ is
merely its continuation to the exterior.
Ciliation and contractility, both exhibited by the “water-
vascular system”’ in T'rematodes, are both familiar characters
of the perivisceral space when developed on a more capacious
scale. Contractility is of course in the nature of the case, the
walls of the perivisceral space being muscular. Cilia occur in
the perivisceral cavity of some Chetopoda and in that of
Gephyrea, in the primitive mesoblastic cavity of the developing
Lamellibranch Pisidiwm and of Aplysia, also in the peritoneal
(perivisceral) space of the frog.
The condition of the vascular system in different genera of
leeches is instructive, tending, as it seems, to bridge over the
gulf between a simple perivisceral primitive blood-lymph-space
and the more complicated differentiations of lymphatic systems,
pleuro-peritoneal cavity, and blood-vascular system to which
it simultaneously gives rise in higher organisms. The blood-
lymph-space exists in the common leech as four chief longitu-
dinal canals, in one of which the nerve-cord lies. The apertures
of the segment-organs lead into closed pouches, whose cavity is
also to be reckoned to the blood-lymph-space, though not in
continuity with its longitudinal portions. In other leeches
(e. g. Branchiobdella), whilst two of the longitudinal canals are
retained, excavation iscarried on in the mesoblastic parenchyma
in such away as to leave the segment-organs floating trumpet-
like in a great perivisceral sinus, in which also the nerve-cord
lies. The longitudinal canals may, as in Hirudo, contain a
liquid impregnated with haemoglobin, and remain closed from
334 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
communication with the rest of the blood-lymph-system. This
is very generally the case in Annelids ; not so, however, in the
Gephyrean Sipunculus,where the tentacular vessel communicates
periodically with the perivisceral space. In Vertebrates the
hemoglobin-bearing or respiratory system and the lymph-
bearing sinus-system communicate at various points, so that the
fluid in the former is complex, being comparable to the respi-
ratory fluid of an Annelid plus its perivisceral fluid. It is hence
hemochyle or blood-lymph, if we limit the significance of
“blood” to that which it really connotes, namely the red part
of the vascular fluid. If such a nomenclature be admissible,
viz. the limitation of “blood” to the respiratory element, then
the fluid in the closed vascular system of Annelids would be
blood, the perivisceral fluid lymph; the perivisceral fluid of Gly-
cera with its red corpuscles would be blood-lymph or hemo-
chyle ; the circulatory fluid of Mollusca and Arthropods would
also be hemochyle, since there is no separation of a respiratory
element in separate vessels, and in exceptional cases (Solen,
Planorbis, Chironomus, Chirocephalus, Daphnia) hemoglobin
does appear in the common circulatory fluid; the fluid of the
pleuro-peritoneal cavity, lymphatic canals, and vessels in Ver-
tebrates would be “lymph,” and its corpuscles, derived, as
throughout the triploblastic series, from the proliferation of the
connective-tissue corpuscles lining the walls of the lymph-spaces,
would be lymph-corpuscles or leucocytes; the fluid in the
arteries and veins, on the other hand, would be blood-lymph or
heemochyle, being lymph added to other liquid and corpuscular
elements, the latter of which are respiratory and impregnated
with hemoglobin, whence they may be termed “‘pneumocytes.”’
As an illustration of the point which I wish to urge—viz.
that the various vascular and sinus systems of T'riploblastica
are not to be regarded as important differentiations, but are
rather parts of one and the same primary blood-lymph-cavity
slightly modified or isolated—let me point to two facts. — First,
among polychetous Annelida we have generally a closed vas-
cular system and a perivisceral space; in Glycera, however,
the shutting off of a part of the blood-lymph-space as a closed
system does not occur, but we have only the one great peri-
visceral chamber, with pneumocytes added to its corpuscular
contents, this change being unaccompanied by any other great
structural modification; and it is a fact that “anangian —
genera” occur in the same family with others possessing the |
closed set of vessels, e.g. Aphroditacea. Secondly, in a |
parasitic crustacean as yet undescribed, discovered by Prof.
Edouard van Beneden of Liége, there is developed a closed
vascular system lying within the regular blood-sinuses, and —
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. ea)
containing, as in the case of Annelids, hemoglobin. The
exceptional development of such a subdivision of the blood-
lymph-space, unparalleled throughout the whole group of Ar-
thropoda, is additional evidence in favour of the view that the
primitive blood-lymph-space readily lends itself to the develop-
ment of variously distributed and communicating vascular
systems, even systems as special as the ambulacral and respi-
ratory systems of Echinoderms.
The relation of the segment-organs to the primitive blood-
space has already been spoken of. There is considerable
ground for regarding it as constant throughout the Triploblas-
tica, as the blood-lymph-space itself is constant. It appears
under various modifications as a canal, ‘often ciliated and
funnel-like, forming a communication between part of the
blood-lymph-space and the exterior—as, for example, the brown
tubes and the cloacal tree of Gephyrea, the organ of Bojanus,
the Fallopian tubes and seminal ducts of sharks, and more
doubtfully in Echinodermata and Arthropods.
The Triploblastica not only exhibit this unity of type as
regards their chief viscera, but there are certain regions of the
body which must be considered identical in all; especially
must the prostomium or region in front of the mouth, the axis
of anterior growth, where it is persistent, be held to be homo-
genous throughout the series. It is in relation with this
“head-flap”’ that the primitive nerve-centres are developed
and always make their appearance as the great sensorial gan-
glion-masses. Already in the free-swimming larve of some
Diploblastica, such as Actinia, the prostomium is indicated,
having a necessary mechanical relation to bilateral symmetry
when the mouth is placed anteriorly and locomotion is
parallel with the alimentary axis, though here we must
not overlook the distinct character of the Diploblastic and
Triploblastic mouths. The large primitive tentacle of the
young Actinia is a prostomium, and only loses its superior
overhanging character as regards the mouth when the animal,
abandoning locomotive habits, fixes itself and develops other
processes around the mouth which soon equal the first in size.
The prostomium in Triploblastica is liable to be suppressed alto-
gether in the course of individual development, the mouth
becoming terminal or other modifications arising ; but where it
does appear it constantly carries the chief organ of sight,
whilst the auditory sac is prostomial in Turbellarians, but
metastomial in Tunicates, Vertebrates, and Mollusca.
The production of individuals of an increased complexity of
organization among 'T'riploblastica, by the linear aggregation
of zooids, produced by budding in the posterior or metastomial
336 Mr. E. Ray Lankester on the
axis of growth (tertiary aggregates
of Herbert Spencer) among Annu-
losa, and probably (though not
according to Spencer) among
Vertebrata, and even some Mol-
lusea—the process occurring at a
very early period and its results »
being obscured, or even entirely
resolved, by later “ integrating ”
development in the two latter
cases—does not affect the prosto-
mium, which always has an axis
of anterior growth. When a
zooid-segment of a linear tertiary ep
ageregate develops a prostomium
or axis of anterior growth, the
chain necessarily breaks at that
point (Microstomum, Tenia, Nai-
did, Syllide). The segmenta-
tion of the prostomial axis in 4rchiscoler (optical section) :
Arthropoda and some Annelids, pr, prostomium; pst, metasto-
which has an appearance of being ‘m™ium; 0, mouth; a, anus; s,
a zooid-segmentation comparable Souci wR aper-
: ue ure; ep, epiblast; », nerve-
to that of the metastomial axis,on Gentre; mes, mesoblast; hyp,
account of the identity in the —hypoblast.
character of the appendages with :
those of the metastomial axis, has yet to be explained. It
may be suggested that it is due to a distinct breaking up of
this axis like the posterior one into zooid-segments or zoon-
ites: there is much against this supposition (see Trans. Linn.
Soe. 1869, On Chetogaster and dvolosoma”’). Much more
likely, it seems, is the explanation that the oral aperture shifts
position, and that the ophthalmic segment alone in Arthro-
poda represents the prostomium, the antennary and antennular
segments being aboriginally metastomial and only prostomial
by later adaptational shifting of the oral aperture.
The assumption of such a shifting of the oral aperture is
fully warranted by what has been demonstrated in the case
of Vertebrata through Kowalewsky’s researches on <Am-
phioxus. It is certain from those observations that the mouth
of Amphioxus is the first gill-slit or pharyngeal perforation
of the left side, and has no relation to a mouth such as that
which appears at an earlier phase of development in the allied
Ascidian larva, which latter mouth is that of Vermes generally.
Amphioxus, then, and the Vertebrata have a new oral aperture,
the old one having been gradually suppressed. Comparative —
hs
hyp/
Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo. 337
osteology and the embryology of higher Vertebrata have long
made it clear that the vertebrate mouth belongs to the series
of visceral clefts; but the significance of this in the comparison
of Vertebrata and Invertebrata has yet to be fully appreciated.
The identification of the neural and hemal aspects of Verte-
brata and Vermes, in the light given by this demonstration of
Kowalewsky’s as to the distinct character of the mouth in the
two cases, must lead to most valuable results *.
The triple basis of histological differentiation, the nerve-
centres, the alimentary tract, the blood-lymph-spaces, the
segment-organs, the prostomial and metastomial regions being
recognizable as homogenous under varied adaptative modifi-
cations throughout the Triploblastica, is it not probable that
other parts may still further exhibit that unity of type of the
included groups which forms our hypothesis? Whilst it
is necessary always to be on guard against mistaking homo-
plastic agreements such as clearly must and do existt for
homogenetic agreements, yet, since the working hypothesis
must be that of uniformity, as the simpler, we ought to assume
homogeny or unity of type as explaining similarity in organs
until research proves it necessary to regard this orthat particular
case as due to coincidence of adaptative causes. Hence it may
fairly be suggested that the appendages of T'riploblastica,
appearing under two chief forms as locomotive and respiratory,
(external gills) are homogenous throughout the series.
Such an hypothesis opens a very large field for discussion;
but within certain limits it will not, perhaps, meet with strenuous
opposition. The gills of Mollusca generally, of Brachiopods, the
tentacles of Polyzoa, and the gill-tufts of Annelids—again, the
locomotive appendages of Annelids and Arthropods—or, again,
the external gills of Vertebrata (embryo Selachians, Batra-
chians, &c.) and those of Annelids, offer themselves as likely
enough to prove homogenous ; but since many further embryo-
logical inquiries have to be made, and no doubt will be made
in consequence of these possibilities presenting themselves to
the imagination of many students of embryology, it will not now
be useful to discuss them upon the limited evidence at hand.
Note.—Professor Hiickel, in the final part of his newly
published splendid monograph of the calcareous Sponges,
has entered into speculations on the significance of the poly-
plast and planular stages of development and the development
* 1 am indebted to my friend Anton Dohrn for first drawing my atten-
tion to some of the legitimate consequences of Kowalewsky’s observations
as to the mouth of Amphioxus.
+ Ann. Nat. Hist. 1870, vol. vi. (“On the use of the term Homology”).
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 22
338 On a new Australian Species of Thyrsites.
of a body-cavity, which are of the utmost value. He adopts
a more detailed nomenclature than I have used here, and does
not take the same view of the water-vascular system of flat-
worms as I have done; but to some extent there is naturally
coincidence, due to the fact that the material here used in the
form of facts has been mainly drawn from his other writings
and those of other German and Russian embryologists. [have
not attempted to discuss Professor Hiickel’s views nor referred
to his terms, chiefly because the substance of this paper was
drawn up before the ‘ Kalkschwiimme’ appeared.
XXXVI.—On a new Australian Species of Thyrsites.
By Prof. FREDERICK M‘Coy.
THE common Barracoota of the Cape seas is very abundant in
the Melbourne market from the adjacent coast, and has long
been known; but an equally large and important species for
food is brought in great quantities from Tasmania to the
Melbourne fish-shops, usually split open and dried; and, as far
as I can see, it has been overlooked by naturalists. Itis easily
distinguished at a glance from the Thyrsites atun or Barracoota
by the much greater depth of the body, fewer finlets, shorter
dorsal, larger teeth, and double lateral line; but the mode of
preparation usually obscures the still more striking character
of the ventrals being almost absent, or at least very minute
and rudimentary. I subjoin a description of the species.
Thyrsites micropus (M‘Coy).
D.17|44+12| VI. A.24+11. IV. V.1+1 (bifurcate).
Pp. 14. ©. 224.
Height of body five times in total length to centre of caudal
fin; head four times to end of lobes of caudal. Lower jaw
projecting in advance of the upper; diameter of orbit one fifth
the length of the head, and one half the length of the muzzle.
Ventrals each with one spine and one bifureate ray, slightly in
advance of base of pectorals; about one third the diameter of
the eye in length. Lateral line bifurcate: upper branch ex-
tending from a little above the operculum, a little below the
dorsal line, as far as the third finlet; lower branch coming off
from upper one under base of fifth dorsal spine, and descending
with an abrupt curve nearly to the middle of the side, con-
tinuing nearly straight to opposite middle of anal fin, from
which to middle of tail it describes three upward undulations.
wae, FS Re eee ne ees ee COU
o =
Rey. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C.E. Broome on British Fungi. 339
Colour brilliant lead-grey, whitish below; fins brownish.
Surface of body smooth, with very minute scales imbedded in
the skin.
ff, om.
Potaliionptlerge a Peee yon. ees 4 2. 64
Length of head from chin........ 0 83
Length of pectoral . .4.)3.....: ron. Q 33
Greatest height of body.......... 0 63
Greatest height of first dorsal fin .. 0 23
iemober Ol OFbib. tied: sotsiasaieto abe 0: »l4
There are about sixteen compressed teeth of moderate size
(about 2 lines) on each intermaxillary, and a group of three
on each side of the upper jaw in front, very large (about 6 or 7
lines) and curved backwards. As in Gempylus, the ventrals
are so reduced as to be scarcely visible; but there is a row of
seven or eight small conical teeth on each palate-bone, as in
Thyrsites. T. prometheus, T. Solandri, and T. prometheotdes,
all have the ventrals reduced to one small spine ; and the latter
Amboyna species has also, according to Bleeker, the double
lateral line; but the proportions of the head and body and
number of the fin-rays completely distinguish the present
fish from them.
The popular name is Tasmanian kingfish.
Melbourne National Museum, January 30, 1873.
XXXVII.—Notices of British Fungi. By the Rev. M. J.
BerKeELey, M.A., F.L.S., and C. E. Brooms, Esq.,
F.L.S.
{Continued from vol. vii. p. 436. |
[Plates VII., VIII., [X., & X.]
1335. Agaricus (Armillaria) awrantius, Scheff.; Fr. Ic.
tab. 27.
Forres, Rev. J. Keith. Pine-woods.
Varying a good deal in the nature and frequency of the
scales. One or two of the specimens exactly accorded with
the figure of Fries.
1336. A. (Tricholoma) pessundatus, Fr. Ic. tab. 28.
Street, J. A. Clark, Esq., Oct. 1871.
Smell like that of new meal.
*A. (Tricholoma) sordidus, Fr. Ic. tab. 45.
On the naked soil in gardens, as at Coed Coch.
22*
340 Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr. C.E. Broome on British Fungi.
Like Fries, we had formerly considered this a mere form of
A. nudus.
1337. A. (Tricholoma) resplendens, Fr. Ic. tab. 29.
Amongst grass on the borders of woods. Coed Coch,
Sept. 10, 1872. It has, however, occurred in other localities,
as at Reading.
* A. (Clitocybe) maximus, Fr.
Abundant. Coed Coch, Sept. 11, 1872.
Pileus 15 inches across, squamulose ; margin lobed and
crisped; stem 2-3 inches high, 14-2 thick, very blunt,
fibrilloso-striate or grooved.
1338. A. (Clitocybe) ericetorum, Fr.
Coed Coch, Sept. 10, 1872, Mrs. Lloyd Wynne.
Exactly Bullard, tab. 551. fig. 1.
1339. A. (Collybia) suecineus, Scheeff.
Amongst grass. Coed Coch, &c.
1340. A. (Collybia) aquosus, Bull.
Coed Coch.
1341. A. (Collybia) tylicolor, Fr.
Coed Coch.
1342. A. (Entoloma) Wynnei, B. & Br. Pileo primum
plano, fuligineo, velutino, dein convexo, squamuloso, hy-
grophano; margine striato, seepe undulato; stipite fuligineo-
ceruleo, compresso, basi gossypino ; lamellis latis, transversim
costatis, pallidis, margine crenulatis ; odore cimicino.
In fir-woods. Coed Coch, Sept. 16, 1872.
Allied to A. costatus, with which it agrees in size.
1343. A. (Nolanea) mammosus, L.
On lawns. Coed Coch, Sept. 10, 1872.
1344. A. (Hebeloma) relicinus, Fr.
Stannage Park, C. E. Broome, 1871.
1345. A. (Hebeloma) Clarkii, B. & Br. Pileo campanulato,
albo, sericeo ; stipite subeequali, flocculoso, farcto; lamellis
adnexis, albo marginatis.
Street, J. A. Clark, Oct. 20, 1871.
Allied to A. sindonius. Pileus 3 inch across, 1 inch high ;
stem 14 inch high, 2 lines thick, slightly incrassated at the
base.
1346. A. (Hebeloma) truncatus, Fr.
On the grassy base of a bank. Dangstein, Sept. 25, 1872.
Pileus 1}-2 inches across, plane, rigid, slightly viscid,
rufous, depressed in the centre, smooth ; margin crisped, in-
flexed, the extreme edge pruinose; stem 24 inches high, ? thick,
claviform at the base, stuffed, fibrilloso-striate, pale rufous,
less deeply coloured below; gills narrow, adnexed, with a
tooth. Smell rhaphanoid.
Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C. E. Broome on British Fungi. 341
1347. A. (Naucoria) pusiolus, Fr.
West of England, J. Renny.
1348. A. (Naucoria) sobrius, Fr., var. Pileo convexo,
ochraceo, subtiliter punctulato; margine furfuraceo ; stipite
sursum incrassato v. equali, furfuraceo, fistuloso; annulo ap-
pendiculato; lamellis pallidis, adnatis, planis.
On lawns amongst short grass. Sibbertoft, July 7, 1871.
Pileus 3-4 lines across; stem 3-1 inch high, 1 line thick.
Margin of gills white. A. dispersus, P.
1349. A. (Psalliota) cnwnctus, Fr., Saund. & Sm. tab. 29.
Ely, W. Marshall, Esq. It has also occurred at Epping.
1350. A. (Psalliota) merdartus, Fr. ; Saund. & Sm. tab. 25.
In a grass-field. Sibbertoft, Norths.
* Cortinarius (Phlegmacium) triumphans, Fy.
Exhibited at South Kensington, Oct. 2, 1872.
This is clearly the same as Mrs. Hussey’s C. sublanatus.
1351. C. (Phlegmacium) porphyropus, Fy.
Coed Coch, Oct. 1871.
1352. C. (Dermocybe) e¢nnabarinus, Fr.
Street, J. A. Clark, Oct. 1871.
1353. C. (Telamonia) torvus, Fr.
Coed Coch, Oct. 1872.
1354. C. (Telamonia) armillatus, Fr.
Near Reading, B. J. Austin.
The species figured by Mrs. Hussey is clearly the plant of
Bull. t. 527. fig. 1, and is therefore C. hematochelis. ‘This has
occurred at Coed Coch.
1355. C. (Telamonia) helvolus, Fr.
Coed Coch, Sept. 1872.
1356. C. (Hygrocybe) decipiens, Fr.
Leigh woods, Bristol, Oct. 25, 1871. Hoffm. Ic. An. t. 9.
eel.
* Hygrophorus chrysodon, Fr., var. pube candida.
Street, J. A. Clark.
* H. pratensis, Fr., var. - Pileo infundibuliformi, pallido ;
margine undulato, deflexo ; stipite sursum dilatato, fibrilloso-
striato; lamellis distantibus, decurrentibus, ramosis, pallidis.
Coed Coch, Oct. 1872. We have also received it from M.
Terry.
1357. H. livido-albus, Fr.
Street, J. A. Clark, Oct. 1871.
1358. H. Clarkii, B. & Br. Fragilis ; pileo convexo, sub-
umbonato, livido-cinereo, viscoso ; margine levi; stipite con-
colori, cavo ; lamellis latis, distantibus, crassis, adnatis, albis.
Street, Oct. 1872, J. A. Clark, no. 1788.
Gills in large specimens nearly 4 inch wide.
342 Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C. E. Broome on British Fungi.
1359. H. metapodius, Fr.
Street, J. A. Clark, Oct. 1871, J. Renny, Nov. 4, 1871.
1360. H. Houghtoni, B. & Br. Pileo convexo, leeticolor,
centro demum depresso, striato, cum stipite fulvo-flavo, trans-
versim undulato, viscosissimo; lamellis decurrentibus, tenuibus,
ilvis.
. Amongst grass. Preston, Salop, Oct. 21, 1872.
Pileus 14-2 inches across; stem 2 inches and more high,
1 thick, sometimes tinged above with blue. Odour foxy.
The gelatinous coat is extremely thick, and at length separates
and forms a cup in the centre.
* Lactarius glyciosmus, Fr.
Herefordshire.
This appears to be a rare species, at least in England.
1361. Marasmius terginus, FY.
Batheaston, Nov. 28, 1870. Amongst leaves in a wood.
Pileus ;4; inch across, faintly striate, of a pale reddish brown,
darker in the centre; stem about 3 inches high, } line thick,
smooth, pale brown, satiny; gills reddish ochre, adnate by a
tooth, but sinuated, moderately distant.
1361*. Dedalea mollis, Sommf.
C. B. Plowright, Sept. 1872. Exactly agreeing with spe-
cimens from Blytt.
1362. Boletus inunctus, Kromb. tab. 76. figs. 10,11.
Ascot, Lyndhurst, Coed Coch.
1363. B. rubinus, Smith.
Chippenham.
Spores at first rosy, then warm brown, 00025—-0003 inch
long, ‘0002 wide.
* B. cyanescens, Bull.; Saund. & Sm. tab. 47.
East Budleigh, C. H. Spencer Perceval.
We were very glad to receive the true plant of Bullard, as
that figured by Mr. Cooke is a very different species, with very
different spores. ‘The floccose coating which encloses the whole
plant when young is very curious. ‘The degree in which the
tlesh becomes blue is variable, and was very shght in Mr.
Perceval’s specimens.
1364. Polyporus frondosus, Fr.
Berkshire, 1871. Exhibited at South Kensington, Oct.
1871.
1365. P. (Anodermei) mollis, Fr.
Near Slough, M. Terry, Esq.
1366. P. (Placodermei) carneus, Fr.
Welshpool, on an old stump, Nov. 1871, Rev. J. E. Vize.
This species occurs in various parts of the world, and has
been found in British North America.
Rey. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C. E. Broome on British Fungi. 343
*Hydnum fragile, Vr.
Forres, Rev. J. Keith.
1367. H. compactum, Fr.
Forres, Rev. J. Keith.
1368. H. aurantiacum, A. & 8.
Forres, Rev. J. Keith.
1369. H. ferrugineum, Fr.
Reading, Mr. B. J. Austin.
1370. H. cirrhatum, P.
On a beech tree. Epping Forest, Mr. J. English.
On comparing the specific characters of H. cirrhatum and
H. corrugatum there could be no doubt about Mr. English’s
plant being the former species ; but this is not so clear on com-
paring the figures in Fries’s ‘ Icones.’
At first snow-white, but gradually acquiring a pale ochra-
ceous tint; imbricated, confluent behind ; aculei long ; pileus
rough, with.abortive prickles.
*Cortictum sulphureum, Fr. Var. ochroideum.
Batheaston, C. EK. Broome.
1371. C. lacunosum, B. & Br. Molle, late effusum ; hypo-
thallo lanoso, fulvo, lacunoso ; hymenio pulverulento.
Aboyne, Sept. 1870. Spreading for several inches, and
looking like a thin sponge from the numerous lacune.
1372. Cyphella pallida, B. & Br. Cupulis primum orbicu-
laribus, demum irregulariter lobatis, planis, tomentosis vel
hispidulis, sessilibus; hymenio demum rugoso, pallide ochraceo.
Rabenh. Fung. Eur. Exs. no. 1415.
On old stems of Clematis vitalba, spreading here and there
to neighbouring rotten sticks.
Cups 3-1 line across, sometimes proliferous.
Differs from C. Currey? in the colour of the hymenium,
which is rugose, like that of Cantharellus muscigenus, and its
more irregular form. It appears also not to be erumpent as
that species often is, but is seated on the bark or wood. Spores
00025-00035 inch long, elliptic.
1373. C. dochmiospora, B. & Br. Minuta, pezizetormis,
nivea; sporis obliquis, ovatis, acutiusculis.
Batheaston, Oct. 28, 1864.
Resembles externally Peziza villosa; but the hairs are not
granulated. Spores ‘0005-0006 inch long.
1374. Dacrymyces macrosporus, B. & Br. _Gelatinosus,
tuberculatus, roseus ; floccis septatis, apice sporiferis; sporis
primariis oblongis, 3—5-septatis, articulis constrictis ; sporis
secundariis ellipticis, utrinque apiculatis; conidiis concatenatis.
On dead branches, forming irregular gyrate and tubereu-
lated masses of a rosy colour, about 4 inch long, parasitic on
344 Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C. E. Broome on british Fungi.
old remains of Spheria stigma. 'The mass of gelatine consists
of delicate, branched, septate threads, mixed with shorter threads
bearing oblong 3-5-septate primary spores ‘0015-002 inch
long, ‘00034-0004 wide ; these at length fall off and produce
shortly stipitate secondary spores, one from each division.
Secondary spores elliptic, ‘0005 long, more prominent on one
side, pointed at either end. The cells of the primary spores
are empty after the production of the secondary spores. Other
threads break up into much branched chains of conidia, *0002
in diameter ; the parts of the gelatinous mass where these are
produced acquire a paler tint.
Batheaston, Dec. to March. It preserves its rosy tint when
dry.
Puate VII. fig. 1. a. threads with primary spores and conidia;
b. primary spores; c. ditto, producing secondary spores; d. secondary
spores, more highly magnified.
* Clavaria aurea, Scheeff.
This fine species occurred in 1871 in two or three places in
the west of England, as at Stannage Park; and the Rev. H.
Nicholls has lately sent from Hawkhurst a form closely ap-
proaching C. rufescens, which was found at the foot of a beech
tree.
* easter Michelianus, B. & Br., Herb. Crit. It. no. 343.
This fine species has occurred at Castle Ashby, in a bed of
rhododendrons, in two or three successive years.
The tough thick outer coat, large size, aud other points suf-
ficiently distinguish it from G. tunicatus, to which it bears
some resemblance. The laciniz of the outer peridium are
sometimes as much elongated as in G. saccatus. It was con-
sidered as G'. tunicatus under no. 1306.
1375. Lycoperdon echinatum, P.
Berkshire, Messrs. Hoyle and Austin.
Spores echinulate, °0002—-00025 inch in diameter.
Scleroderma geaster, Fr.
Hereford, Oct. 6, 1870.
Spores °0003—-0005 inch in diameter.
* Batarrea phalloides, P.
Noble specimens of this rare fungus were lately found at the
Earl of Egmont’s Nork, amongst the débris at the base of a
hollow ash, by Mr. C. H. Spencer Perceval. The Dropmore
specimens occurred in a similar situation.
* Didymium squamulosum, A. & 8.
On fern, J. Renny.
Columella white.
1376. Perichena quercina, Fr. Peridio externo crustaceo,
Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C. E. Broome on British Fungt. 345
dealbato ; interiore tenuissimo, luteo-brunneo, e sporis flavis,
areolato-impresso ; floccis parcis ; sporis globosis, asperulis.
On ash. Batheaston, March 1859; Shrewsbury, W.
Phillips, Esq., Jan. 18, 1872.
Spores -0005 inch in diameter.
1377. P. picea, B.& Br. Peridio atro-fusco, hemispherico,
demum circumscisso ; sporis coffeatis, subglobosis floccisque
fuscis levibus.
On dead wood, W. Phillips, Esq.
Looks at first like a Perisporium. The colour of the spores
approaches that of those in the section Hyporhodiw of
Agaricus.
1378. Spheronema cemulans, B. & Br. Peritheciis sub-
globosis, e mycelio parco oriundis; collo apice ciliato; sporis
minutissimis, motu Browniano preeditis.
Epping Forest, Feb. 18, 1871.
Perithecia *06 inch long; spores *0001—"0003 in diameter.
Possibly a pyenidiiferous state of some Melanospora.
PuaTeE VII. fig.2. a. plant, more or less magnified, with emitted
spores.
1379. Monosporium saccharinum, B. & Br. Hyphasmate
gelatinoso, coffeicolori, e floccis brevibus erectis subclavatis ;
sporis obovatis, basi truncata affixis, pallide coffeatis.
Growing on decayed substances under glass. Batheaston,
Heb. 1871.
Spores 0004-0005 inch long. Sometimes the tips of the
threads have an articulation, and possibly form a second spore.
Puate VIL. fig. 3. a. spores seated on their sporophores; b. a single
immature spore ; ¢. free spores.
1380. Helminthosporium exasperatum, B. & Br. Floccis
flexuosis, sursum nodosis, fructiferis ; sporis oblongis, utrimque
obtusis, triseptatis.
On sweet william. Sibbertoft.
Flocci knotted above, each knot bearing an oblong spore,
0012-0018 inch long, :0004—"0005 wide.
PuaTeE VII. fig. 4. a. flocci; 6. spores; c. spore germinating.
1381. Dactylium implecum, B. & Br. Floccis erectis, im-
plexis; sporis subcylindricis, basi apiculatis, apicalibus.
On the inside of a willow. Hereford.
Spores ‘001-0012 inch long.
Prater VI. fig. 5. a. threads with spore; 6. spores, more highly
magnified.
1382. D. melleum, B. & Br. Strato tenui, melleo ; floccis
? b ?
346 Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr. C. E. Broome on British Fungt.
apice ramosis ; ramis ramulis acutis sporas uniseptatas feren-
tibus terminatis.
On some decayed Polyporus or Stereum. Batheaston, Feb.
1871.
Spores *0005 inch long.
Approaching, like the last, Diplocladium minus, Bonorden.
Puate VIII. fig. 6. a. creeping threads ; b. fertile threads with spores ;
c. spores, more highly magnified.
1383. D. Renny’, B.& Br. Floccis subtus parce ramosis,
ramis apice ramulis clavatis coronatis; sporis ellipticis, uni-
septatis.
J. Renny.
Very near Diplocladium minus, Bonorden ; but the spore-
bearing ramuli are obtuse above and slightly clavate, not
attenuated.
1384. Verticillium aspergillus, B. & Br. Floccis deorsum
simplicibus vel rarius divisis, sursum attenuatis, apice repetitim
furcatis.
On decaying Polyporus vaporarius. Kelmarsh, Norths.,
Nov. 19, 1870.
Threads °0055 inch high ; spores ‘0001 long. The threads
are occasionally divided below, in which case each branchlet
is forked at the tip. The habit is that of Chlonostachys arau-
carta, Cda. It is worth inquiry whether this may not be a
state of Hypocrea farinosa.
Puate VIII. fig. 7. a. threads with spores; 0%. spores, more magnified.
1385. Polyactis galanthina, B. & Br. Floccis sursum bre-
viter ramosis, fuscis; ramulis sursum incrassatis ; sporis
obovatis, sessilibus, e spiculis elongatis oriundis.
On bulbs of the common snowdrop, affecting the outer coats,
and very destructive. G. F. Wilson, Esq.
Spores ‘0006-0007 inch long.
Prats VIII. fig. 8. a. threads with spores ; b. ditto, more highly mag-
nified; c. separate spores.
1386. Helicomyces roseus, Lk. Obs. 1. 19.
1387. Oidium microspermum, B. & Br. Pulvinulis regu-
laribus, ochraceo-citrinis, e floccis radiantibus furcatis ; sporis
subglobosis, concatenatis.
On bark of Scotch fir. Batheaston, Nov. 25, 1871.
Spores 0002 inch in diameter. Differs altogether from
O. aureum and O. fulvum in the shape and size of the spores.
Pulvinuli at length confluent.
1388. Synchytrium taraxact, de By. & Wor., Schroet. in
Cohn’s Beitriige, p. 39.
On leaves of the common dandelion. Batheaston.
Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C. E. Broome on British Fungi. 347
1389. S. mercurialis, Fuck. no. 1607; Schroet. 7. c. p. 40.
On leaves of Mercurialis perennis. Batheaston, April 24,
1871.
Spores echinulate, 0012—-0015 inch in diameter.
*S. anemones, Wor. ; Schroet. 1. ¢.
On leaves and petals of Anemone nemorosa. Not uncommon.
1390. Peziza (Humaria) Chater?, Sm. Cupulis concavis,
demum expansis, sessilibus, intus aurantio-rubris, extus pal-
lide brunneis, granulatis, esetosis; paraphysibus clavatis ;
sporidiis ellipticis, echinulatis. Gard. Chron. Jan. 1872, p. 9,
cum icone.
Cambridge, Mr. Chater.
Sporidia ‘0008 inch long, :0004 wide, echinulate when mature.
Differs from P. melaloma in its rough sporidia and the absence
of the dark hairs on the cups, which are granulated from the
projecting coarse clavate brownish cells, and from P. hirta in
the latter particular.
PxatE VIII. fig. 9. Sporidia, magnified.
1391. P. (Dasyscyphe) asia, B. & Br. Cupulis globosis,
erumpentibus, aurantiacis, demum ore laciniato-dentato apertis,
extus lasiis; ascis elongatis; sporidiis fusiformibus ; para-
physibus supra urneformibus, quandoque uniseptatis, mter-
‘mixtis floccis brevibus.
Onelm. Langridge, March 16, 1870.
Cups smaller when on bark. Sporidia -0005 inch long by
0001.
PuaTE VIII. fig. 10. a. plant, magnified; 6. paraphyses; ¢. asci; d.
sporidia.
1392. Rhyparobius dubius, Boud. Amn. d. Sc. Nat. 1869,
x. p. 240.
On rabbits’ dung. Bathford, C. E. Broome.
1393. R. Cooker, Boud. J. c. p. 238.
On dogs’ dung. Batheaston, C. EK. Broome.
1394. R. argenteus, B. & Br. Minutissimus, argenteus, pilis
mollibus ciliatus; ascis brevibus ; cysto sporidiifero elliptico,
apicem versussito ; sporidiis fusiformibus; paraphysibus fureatis.
On rabbits’ dung, for the most part attached to filaments of
Mucor. Mr. Renny, with figures.
Cups *004 inch across ; asci ‘004 long ; sporidia normally 64
in each cyst, 0007 inch long, -00025—-0003 wide. Scarcely
visible to the naked eye ; asci opening with a little lid, which
splits vertically. Comes near to 2. felinus, Boud., but has
soft hairs and is of a pure white ; tips of paraphyses slightly
enlarged.
Puate IX. fig. 11. a. young plant; 6. full-grown plant, magnified
100 diameters ; c. hairs; d. asci with cyst; ¢. paraphyses ; f. sporidia.
348 Rev. M.J. Berkeley & Mr.C. E. Broome on British Fungi.
1395. R. woolhopensis, Renn. Minutus, primum candidus,
dein albidus; cupulis basi substipitiformi incrassatis, tuber-
culatis, sursum pilis mollibus vestitis; paraphysibus simpli-
cibus; ascis clavatis; cysto sporidiifero apicem versus sito ;
sporidiis fusiformibus. :
On birds’ dung, mixed with filaments of Mucor and mostly
borne by them. Mr. Renny, with figures.
Cups 4 a line (-041) wide and high; sporidia normally 64,
‘0007 inch long. Minute, scattered, at first pure white, then
dingy, with a thick stem-like base, which is studded with
large semi-globular warts, covered above with close-set hairs,
which form a fringe to the margin; at length expanded, the
hairs disappearing with age; substance of base vesicular ;
the cells often ‘0015-0018 inch in diameter, much smaller
above.
Puate IX. fig. 12. a. plant, magnified 100 diameters; 6. cells of stem,
compressed under the microscope ; ¢. edge of cup; d. asci with cyst and
paraphysis; e. sporidia.
* Hypocrea lenta, Fr.
On dead wood. St. Catharine’s, Bath, Nov. 1866.
1396. Spheria (Pertuse) poedida, B. & Br. Peritheciis
ovatis, rugosis, opacis, liberis, brunneo-nigris ; ostiolo conico,
demum deciduo; ascis linearibus; sporidiis uniserialibus,
medio contractis.
On beech. Langridge, April 1859.
Quite superficial, confluent ; sporidia *0005—-0006 inch long,
"0002-0003 wide.
ee X. fig. 15. a. plant, more or less magnified; b. ascus; e. spo-
ridla,
1397. Chetomium rufulum, B. & Br. Peritheciis subglo-
bosis, eximie cellulosis, rufulis, e mycelio tenui oriundis ; ascis
brevibus, obtusis ; sporidiis octonis, globosis, granulatis, bi-
serlatis.
On a paper box under a bell-glass. Elmhurst, April 24,
1871.
Sporidia when young 0004-0005 inch in diameter, when
full-grown ‘0007. Perithecia globose, with a pointed apex, com-
posed of about three rows of coarse cells, of a pallid ochre at
first, attached to the paper by a few white threads about -032
in diameter; ostiolum, if any, very inconspicuous ; asci mostly
curved, obtuse at either end, the narrow base soon losing all
signs of attachment and floating freely in the perithecium ;
sporidia spherical when mature, strongly granulated, of a pale
brown tint, and containing a small nucleus.
Puate X. fig. 14. a. plant on paper; 5. perithecium ; c. asci; d. spo-
ridia.
Dr. A. Giinther on two new Australian Frogs. 349
*C, glabrum, B.
Asci linear; sporidia globose, uniseriate, smooth, ‘0005 in
diameter.
On the same matrix Lycogala parietinum occurs; and we
have little doubt that it is a mere state of the Chetomium.
The asci are mixed up with yellow threads ; and it is probable
that, as in other Chetomia, they are often absorbed, leaving
the sporidia free, and thus appearing to be the spores of a
Myxogaster.
Puate X. fig. 15. a. plant, more or less magnified ; 6. ditto, ruptured ;
c. threads ; d. asci; e. sporidia.
1398. Sphinctrina coremioides, B. & Br. Gard. Chron. 1872,
p- 40, cum icone. Peritheciis stipitatis, globosis, extus setu-
losis ; ascis linearibus, cito evanidis ; sporidiis globosis, con-
catenatis.
On pear-roots. Painswick, Mr. J. Atkins.
Sporidia -00025 in diameter, forming chains at the tips of
the elongated pedicels of the asci, which are soon absorbed.
1399. Peronospora ficariv, Tul. Comptes Rendus, Jan. 1854.
On Ranunculus ficaria. Rev. J. E. Vize, Forden, May 1872.
1400. P. lami, De By. Ann. d. Sc. Nat. 1863, xx. p. 120.
On Lamium rubrum. Forden, Rev. J. E. Vize, May 1872.
1401. P. hyoscyami, De By. 1. c. p. 1238.
Market Deeping, in Mr. Holland’s herb-garden, on the
common henbane.
[To be continued. }
XXX VIIL.—Description of two new Species of Frogs from
Australia. By Dr. ALBERT GUNTHER.
I am indebted to Mr. Gerard Krefft for the opportunity of
examining some frogs, of which the following appear to be
new.
NorTAvEN (g. n. Bufonid.).
Body thick, short, covered with large flat glandular warts.
Head very short and high, with a very obtuse snout; eye of
moderate size ; mouth very short, reaching to below the middle
of the eye. Limbs short. ‘T'eeth none; a pair of short and
soft prominences between the narrow choane. Ear-opening
covered by the skin, and visible only after the skin is removed;
it is very narrow, as are the Eustachian tubes. Tongue
without notch, broad. Not only the skin of the parotoid
350 Dr. A. Giinther on two new Australian Frogs.
region, but that of the entire back is thickened by numerous
glands. Fingers free; toes with a narrow web and fringe.
A large shovel-like metatarsal prominence ; no other tubercle.
Clavicle present. Transverse process of sacral vertebra much
dilated.
Notaden Bennettit.
Ground-colour greenish, with a very broad brownish band,
marbled with black, along the middle of the back ; it bifureates
anteriorly on the head, leaving the forehead greenish, and emits
a transverse bar on each side of the back behind the shoulder.
Limbs blackish, with a few small white specks. Throat with
scattered black spots; abdomen whitish.
lines
Leneth of the: body. <=: . 26 en 21
4 foreslimbs es yeak 12
ee ind Limestone 22
Castlereagh River; but it has been also observed near Fort
Bourke.” I have named this remarkable form after Dr. G.
Bennett, to whom we are indebted for many specimens of the
greatest interest.
Chiroleptes platycephalus.
Head large, broad, depressed, with its sides shelving ; eyes
small, shorter than the snout ; canthus rostralis none ; nostrils
directed upwards ; tympanum very indistinct, smaller than the
orbit; choanz and openings of the Hustachian tubes of equal
and moderate width. ‘Tongue rounded behind. Skin of the
upper parts nearly smooth, with a few very small tubercles on
the back. Inner finger distinctly opposite to the others, as
long as the fourth, which is considerably shorter than the third.
Second finger feeble and short. Toes depressed, broadly
webbed ; the third very little longer than the fifth ; subarticular
tubercles very little developed. Inner metatarsal tubercle
shovel-like, with blunt edge ; no outer tubercle on the meta-
tarsus. Uniform greenish olive above, whitish below, with
some small greenish spots on the throat.
lines.
Length; of the body- « dais otis. fe. See 25
Width between the angles of the mouth.... 12
‘Leneth of fore lambpii4e wc dot do cere 16
$3 hirnid dimmb:2s* here os ect eres 35
<i BOT SUS» 73 sais shag Sua take Pato Cae nade 5
55 hind Toots. ctacs erate oskaate 104
One specimen, from Fort Bourke.
Mr. H. J. Carter on the Spongiade and the Foraminifera. 351
XXXIX.—Deseription of a new Saurian (Hyalosaurus)
allied to Pseudopus. By Dr. ALBERT GUNTHER.
A FEW days ago, when looking with Professor Kélliker at
some animals in Mr. Jamrach’s establishment, two living
reptiles (a Zamenis hippocrepis and what appeared to be a
young Pseudopus) were oftered for sale by a man who stated
that he had just obtained them from a ship coming from North
Africa.
On a closer inspection I found the lizard to be distinct from,
though closely allied to, Psewdopus. The absence of an ear-
opening being generally considered a generic character, I
propose for this new type the name of
HYALOSAURUS.
Differs from Pseudopus in having the region of the ear
entirely covered with scales, without a trace of an external
ear-opening.
Hyalosaurus Koellikert.
The shields on the head differ little from those of Pseu-
dopus ; but the vertical shield forms a broad suture with the
posterior frontal, which occupies the entire width of the fore-
head, and a still broader one with the central occipital shield,
which is of an unusually large size and subtriangular in shape.
Dorsal scales in fourteen longitudinal series, of which the six
middle ones are obtusely keeled, the keels being more promi-
nent on the tail; ventral scales in ten series. Rudimentary
hind limbs undivided, movable, very distinct. Brownish,
with a row of black specks along the middle of the back of
the anterior part of the trunk; sides of a darker colour;
abdomen greenish white.
The length of the trunk of the single example is 5 inches ;
a considerable portion of the tail is lost, the remaining piece
being about as long as the body.
XL.— Points of Distinction between the Spongiade and the
Foraminifera. By H. J. Carrer, F.R.S. &e.
HAVING preliminarily described and sketched most of the
sponges in the British Museum, and having examined all
microscopically, in the general as well as in the private
collections of that institution, for the purpose (as desired by
Dr. Gray) of finally placing them in some kind of order, and
302 Mr. H. J. Carter on Points of Distinction
having previously examined many others (both living and
dead), together with many. Foraminifera under the like con-
ditions as well as in a fossilized state, I have, as a matter of
course, come to certain conclusions in my own mind respecting
the general points of distinction between these two classes of
organisms after they have become fully developed. The germ or
“beginning” bemg apparently alike in all, that which chiefly
concerns us is what the special vitality in each can make out
of the germ.
Taking, then, the sarcode first, which can only be successfully
studied in the living state, we find that the pseudopodial pro-
longations from Spongillain the mass, are short, coarse, more
or less conical, scantily branched, and seldom if ever reunited ;
while in the Foraminifera they are extremely long, delicate,
and more or less reunited into an oblique reticulation.
Of the former I know of no figure that illustrates this better
than that of Spongilla which was published in September 1849
(‘Annals,’ vol. iv. pl. 4. fig. 2), and none better of the latter
than that by Dujardin of Miliola vulgaris (‘ Hist. Nat. des
Zoophytes Infusoires,’ pl. i. fig. 14, 1841).
Tam not aware that in the sarcode itself of these pseudopodia
there is any distinguishing peculiarity which is worth noticing
here.
When, however, we come to the composition of the mass,
then there are many points of difference ; for while that of the
Foraminifera as yet has shown nothing recognizable beyond
granules, nuclei, ova, and probably contracting vesicles, that
of Spongilla, which is apparently much more complicated,
possesses two kinds of surface-openings, called respectively
‘pores ”’ and ‘‘oscula ’’—the former minute and multitudinous,
and the lattercomparatively scanty and large—both respectively
leading to more or less spherical groups of flagellated cells
(spongozoa) in the interior. The pores go in more or less
directly to the cavities where the groups of spongozoa are
situated; and the oscula are the terminations of branched canals,
whose ramifications lead from the same points. Currents of
water &c. pass i through the pores and out through the
oscula.
The spongozoon possesses a cilium, nucleus, and one or two
contracting vesicles, together with apparently nothing more
than a little granular mucus ; they take in crude food brought
to them through the pores, and eject the refuse through the
ramifications connected with the branched systems of excretory
canals that terminate respectively in the oscula. Ova are
present in the sarcode of both Sponges and Foraminifera ; but
the organs for their production have not yet been discovered.
between the Spongiade and the Foraminifera. 353
Although, however, the spongozoon is a flagellated infusorian
possessing, so far as has yet been shown, no further organs than
those mentioned, still, for all that we know, it may be as com-
plicated as an elephant, whose trunk, liver, and bladder could
alone be seen through the general transparency of the body.
In these matters minuteness goes for nothing. Size, light,
darkness, motion, tenuity, &c. are only relative in degree ;
and the degree to which we can appreciate them depends
upon the power of our brains respectively, which ds limited.
That mind (taken in its general sense) alone can com-
prehend any thing beyond the power of the brain, which
builds up the whole of the body and permits a portion of itself
to be used by the brain it has developed, bearing a relation to
the latter somewhat similar to that which steam bears to a
steam-engine.
Thus, in the philosophy of the Buddhists, the mind does not
perish with the brain ; while Christianity promises a resurrec-
tion of the flesh.
But to return to our immediate subject, as this digression
is merely to show that we should not deny or affirm that
which is beyond the power of our brains to comprehend.
We come, now, to the skeleton of the Spongiade and the
Foraminifera respectively ; and here the differences are most
manifest, inasmuch as the skeleton of the former is inside,
while that of the latter is outside.
The sarcode of the sponges hangs upon their skeleton as the
flesh of a human being hangs about his bones; while the
sarcode of the Foraminifera lives inside its skeleton after the
manner of a snail, only making its exit through holes all over
its shell or test, in which generally, if not always, there is one
principal opening, leading directly outwards from a single- or
many-chambered interior, in accordance with the simple or
complicated form of the species. Of course by the term “ ske-
leton”’ I mean the organ of support.
The materials, too, of which the skeleton is composed are
arranged differently. Thus, in the sponges the proper spicules
(that is, the spicules formed by the sponge itself) have, in all
instances with which I am acquainted, their points directed
outwards, one object of which is no doubt for the better holding
on of them by the sarcode, and another defence, as spines
upon a hedgehog’s back ; while in the test of the Foraminifera,
where spicules are present on the surface, both heads and points
are directed outwards indiscriminately.
This is particularly well shown in Squamulina scopula and
its branched variety (‘Annals,’ vol. v. p. 309, pls. iv. & v.,
May 1870, and vol. vi. p. 846, Oct. 1870), together with the
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 3
354 Mr. H. J. Carter on Points of Distinction
concamerated form of the interior, rising evidently from the
central or primary cell of a pseudoconcamerated discoidal base,
closely resembling a discoidal foraminifer. The terminal
opening is also shown, as well as the sarcodal contents of the
concamerated cavity, consisting of granular sarcode charged
with ova; and the peculiar form taken by the pseudopodia is
described in the branched variety (op. et loc. cit.) ; so that,
indeed, Squamulina scopula prominently puts forth all the
points which distinguish a foraminifer from a sponge.
My astonishment, therefore, may be easily conceived when
I saw the following footnote in Hiickel’s ‘Monographie der
Kalkschwiimme,’ vol. i. p. 456, translated in the ‘Annals,’
by W. S. Dallas, F.L.S.. as “ communicated by the author”
(vol. xi. p. 244, April 1875.\ Hiickel there states :—
“Whether the simplest sponge-forms, corresponding with
the picture of Archispongia, still exist is not known. Possibly
a very near ally is the singular sponge which Bowerbank has
described as Haliphysema Tumanowiczii (Brit. Spong. vol. i.
p. 76, fig. 359), and which Carter regards as a Polythalamian
(Squamulina). I suspect, on the contrary, that it is a very
simple Myxospongia, which, like Dysidea, forms for itself a
skeleton of foreign bodies (spicules of other sponges, spines of
Echinoderms, &c.), but im other respects has the simple
structure of Olynthus.”
But I am still more astonished at Hiickel’s likening Squa-
mulina scopula to Dysidea, since in Dysidea, as well as in all
the sponges which draw in foreign objects to strengthen their
skeletons, these foreign bodies form the axis, not the walls, of
horny fibre, or are cemented together by amorphous sareode
into a fibrous structure, according to the nature of the species,
about which the soft portions of the sponge hang, as before
stated, like flesh on the bones of a human being—that is, owt-
side the fibre. This is the case in Dystdea. On the other
hand, Squamulina scopula builds up a similar structure, but
lives ¢nside it—that is, inside the fibre as it were.
Perhaps Polytrema rubra, Dujardin (see Carpenter’s ‘ Intro-
duction to the Study of the Foraminifera,’ p. 235, Ray Soc.
Pub. 1862), most nearly approaches in structure to the sponges
which strengthen their skeletons with foreign material. Here
we have a cancellous structure whose cavities communicate
with each other, but finally terminate on the surface in little
circular aree, each of which is pierced, like a pepper-box, with
a number of distinct holes, while the intervals are filled up by
the exterior termination of the clathrate skeleton, which, albeit
for the most part it consists of a thin curvilinear lamina of cal-
careous matter, frequently presents in its structure foreign
objects, such as the spicules of sponges, &c.
between the Spongiade and the Foraminifera. 355
But even here the sarcode lives in the cavities, which may
be easily seen to be but an extreme degree of what is already
foreshadowed in the chambers of less complicated forms of
Foraminifera, while its communication with the exterior is
through the minute holes mentioned.
Thus, while the minute holes on the surface of the Forami-
nifera are fixed in form and size in a solid hard crust for the
egress of the pseudopodia, the minute holes on the surface of
the sponge (that is, the “pores ”’) are situated in an unfixed,
ever-changing, soft sarcode for the ¢ngress of water bearing
the particles of food on which the species may subsist. In
short, one goes out to search for food with its bare pseudopodia,
after the manner of an Actinia, while the other draws it into
the interior of its habitation by the aid of currents of water
produced by cilia, after the manner of an Ascidian. It is to
the latter, I think, that we shall by-and-by find the sponges
passing through Schmidt's Gumminee.
The structure (not the form) of Polytrema appears to have been
like that of Parkerta and Loftusia, Carpenter and Brady (Phil.
Trans. vol. clix. part 11. 1869, pls. 72-80) ; but I have nothing
to do with the joss? Foraminifera here.
It might be stated that the boring-sponges have a segmented
form, like the Foraminifera, and that they often, in oyster-
shells, leave a concamerated chain of cavities. This is true;
but still they also have their spicular ‘skeletons, and the pa-
rietes of their chambers consist of those parts of the oyster-shell
which immediately surround the chambers. Thus the sponge
does not form for itself a concamerated test. The polythala-
mous cavity is merely a “ burrow.”
Hence when Hiickel states, regarding Squamulina scopula,
that he suspects it to be a very simple Myxospongia, which,
like Dysidea, forms for itself a skeleton of foreign bodies, but
in other respects has the simple structure of his Olynthus,
while his Olynthus primordialis (Monographie, Atlas, ‘Taf. 1.
fig. 1) is at the foot of his whole system, I am naturally in-
clined to say, “Ha uno disce omnes” ?
Among the mounted specimens which Dr. Oscar Schmidt
generously sent to the British Museum are two bearing respec-
tively Squamulina scopula and the branched variety of this
species, under which is written in his own hand “ keine Spon-
gien,”’ as well here as in his estimable work on the Sponge-
fauna of the Atlantic Ocean, p. 72,1870. But Schmidt speaks
with the modesty of a bond jide naturalist, Hiickel with the
infallibility of a Pope*.
* In the arrangement which I have proposed for the sponges in the
British Museum, and which will of course apply to all Pa find that
23
356 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Dentition of Rhinoceroses.
XLI.—On the Dentition of Rhinoceroses (Rhinocerotes), and
on the Characters afforded by their Skulls. By Dr. J. E.
Gray, F.R.S. &e.
[Plate XI.]
In the ‘Proceedings of the Zoological Society ’ for 1867, and
in the ‘ Catalogue of Carnivorous and Pachydermatous Mam-
malia in the British Museum,’ p. 295, I gave an account of the
skulls of the Rhinoceroses in the British Museum, and described
their dentition in the young and in the adult animals. Since
that period the British Museum has received several additional
specimens, which have enabled me to observe further details
of the changes that take place in the skulls and teeth durmg
their growth ; and I have been induced to condense in this
paper the results of their examination.
The Asiatic Rhinoceroses have the front of the nasal bone
convex, produced, and more or less acute in front.
The intermaxillaries in the skull of the very young animal
are spongy and united together in front, with two rudimentary
teeth on the hinder part of each side. In the older animals
these teeth are more elongate, produced, and separate from each
other in front, and supported by a more or less long process
of the intermaxillary bone, which encases the upper and outer
side of their hinder part. ‘The young animals have two teeth
on each side, the hinder being the smallest ; but in the older
animals both these teeth drop out, and the front one is re-
placed by a large tooth, which eventually has a large flattened
crown.
In the Asiatic one-horned Rhinoceroses (Rhinoceros) there
is a small cylindrical cutting-tooth on the inner side of the
they can be divided into five principal groups, in which ad/ sponges, inclu-
ding the Hexactinellide and Calcispongiz, may be included, thus :—
1st. Sponges with horny fibre and granular axis without foreign objects.
Aplysinide.
2nd. Sponges with horny fibre, amorphous sarcode, and axis of foreign
objects. Herciniade.
3rd. Sponges with horny fibre and axis of proper spicules only, ¢. e.
spicules formed by the species. Chahnide.
4th. Sponges with horny fibre and axis of proper spicules, more or less
echinated also with proper spicules. Armate.
5th. Sponges in which the fibre is formed of proper spicules cemented
together by amorphous sarcode. Renzerine.
It should always be remembered that the materials of the axis cannot
get into the fibre after the latter is formed, and therefore that the sponge
must arrange all this beforehand.
In a short time I hope to go further into this subject, as I have com-
pleted the Ist and 2nd divisions so far as subgrouping goes.
Dr. J. E. Gray on the Dentition of Rhinoceroses. 357
two large lateral ones. These teeth are close to the inner side
of the lateral ones in the skull of the foetal animal; but they
become separated from them as the front of the jaw dilates for
the secretion of the permanent cutting-teeth, and when the
larger lateral cutting-teeth are developed they are more com
pressed together. ‘They are generally present ; but there is a
skull of Rhinoceros yavanicus in the Museum (723a) in which
they are deficient, the inner sides of the large lateral cutting-
teeth being very close together.
In the lower jaw of the skulls of very young animals there
is a large conical cutting-tooth on each side in front. This
tooth is very depressed, and has sharp edges on the sides, and
a half-ovate end. It becomes worn down, and is replaced by
a larger tooth, which becomes worn down on the upper sur-
face so as to produce an elongated flat disk with an acute
front.
In the skulls of the adult two-horned Asiatic Rhinoceroses
(Ceratorhinus), these two middle cutting-teeth are wanting.
I have never seen a very young skull of these animals.
Ceratorhinus sumatranus.
The figure of the skull, like the figure of the animal, attached
to Mr. Bell’s paper in the ‘Philosophical Transactions’ (vol.
Ixxxiii. 1793, p. 3, t. ii—iv.) well represents this species, and
has well-developed cutting-teeth in the lower jaw, and the
space between the condyles of the skull narrow, which is the
character of this species.
Home’s figure of the skeleton of the Sumatran Rhinoceros
(Phil. Trans. 1821, t. xxii.), from the skeleton now in the
Royal College of Surgeons, better represents the height of the
skull, but scarcely sufficiently shows the distinction between
the two species.
The figure of R. sumatrensis 9, Blainv. Ostéog. t. ii., is
not so high behind as the skulls of either of the species, and
in other respects is not characteristic.
Ceratorhinus niger. Plate XI. (skull).
The British Museum purchased from the Zoological Society
the body of the Rhinoceros which was obtained by Mr. William
Jamrach at Singapore, and which was captured at Malacca in
1871. It is peculiar for having a very rough skin, the body
being covered with thick black hair; the tail is comparatively
long and thin; and the ears are closer together than in C.
sumatranus.
Mr. Edward Gerrard, Jun., has preserved and stuffed the
skin, and prepared a very complete skeleton of the animal.
358 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Dentition of Rhinoceroses.
The skull is very different from those of the Sumatran Rhi-
noceros (L2. suwmatranus, Raffles), collected by Sir Stamford
Raffles and now in the British Museum and in that of the
Royal College of Surgeons, and from the skull which we pur-
chased of Mr. Theobald, and proves most distinctly that I
was right in stating the animal, when alive, to be ve
distinct from the Sumatran Rhinoceros described and figured
by Bell in the ‘ Philosophical Transactions’ for 1793, to which
Sir Stamford Raffles gave the name of 2. sumatranus, under
which name the Malaccan Rhinoceros was exhibited at the
Zoological Gardens and mentioned in the list of accessions in
the ‘ Proceedings of the Zoological Society ;’ and I see by the
report that a paper on the details of its visceral anatomy has
been read to the Society by Mr. Garrod.
There has for many years existed in the British Museum a
stuffed skin of a young specimen of this species, which was
purchased of Mr. Franks of Amsterdam as the young Sumatran
Rhinoceros ; but there is reason to believe that this specimen
was from Singapore, the port of Malacca.
The skull of the Malaccan Rhinoceros is very like that of
the Sumatran one; but it is shorter and broader than that of
fi. sumatranus. 'The hole in the cheek for the passage of the
large vessels is oblong, much larger, and nearer the margin
of the nasal aperture ; while in the two skulls of 2. sumatranus
it is smaller, circular, and some distance from the margin of
the aperture. The front edge of the intermaxillary bones is
broader, rounded, and not compressed or nearly so much pro-
duced as the front edge of the intermaxillary bone of the adult
skull of 2. sumatranus, nor so much as in the skull of the
young animal of the same species, which is shorter and broader
than in the adult. The grinders of the upper jaw are six in
number, and appear broader than those of the adult 2. swma-
tranus, but they occupy the same length.
The skull of the Malaccan Rhinoceros is not so high behind
as that of the adult Sumatran Rhinoceros ; and the space in the
crown between the temporal muscles is flat, and much wider
than that of the adult but not so aged Sumatran Rhinoceros
in the British Museum. The back end of the upper part of
the occiput is not nearly so broad as that of the Sumatran
Rhinoceros.
The most striking difference is in the lower jaw. The con-
dyles are further apart; indeed the whole jaw is wider; but
the outer edge of the hinder angle is much more expanded.
This latter peculiarity, as well as the form of the crown of the
grinders in the upper jaw, may arise from the greater age of
the specimen. The greatest peculiarity is that the front of the
Dr. J. E. Gray on the Dentition of Rhinoceroses. 359
lower jaw is comparatively thin, expanded, and has neither
teeth nor alveoli, nor, indeed, one may say, sufficient thickness
to hold the large cutting-teeth usually found in the front of the
lower jaw of this genus. The grinders are six on each side ;
that is to say, the front tooth on each side is retained, whereas
it is shed from the skull of the adult but much less aged ani-
mal of C. sumatranus in the British Museum ; and the grinders
appear to differ in the form of their folds from those of the
Sumatran species.
C. niger. C. sumatranus.
Length from tip of nose to occipital condyle in. in.
G1 GN Se BSE eons eae pee erie Ee 214 22
From front of intermaxillary to occipital
CONC hare! cesta this of alaga’s (a -nphal scat (atererave yey 202 21
From front edge to back edge of lower jaw. 163 17
Width at zygomatic arch 2. ..).0.00 0 00) 12 11
Width of hinder end of lower jaw ........ 102 93
Width of upper part of lower jaw at end
SERRE ITEC cc ain otra on a age cio aaa a 62
fereut of back of skulls. 0. jee ce we os 1S Neale 133
It is very probable that the want of front teeth in the
lower jaw may be an individual peculiarity produced by the
age of the specimen; at least I do not think it safe to regard
that peculiarity as specific without an examination of more
specimens.
Ceratorhinus Crossit.
In the ‘ Annals and Magazine of Natural History,’ 1872,
x. p. 209, I referred to this species and thought it might be
the same as f. sumatranus from T'avoy and Tenasserim,
mentioned by Blyth, Journ. Asiat. Soc. Bengal, 1862, p. 156,
who figures the skull and horns, and who identifies his animal
with my 2. Crossii (which was described from a pair of horns,
P. Z.S. 1854), and has just informed me that he is certain
that it is the head of the small black rhinoceros with two
horns.
It is most likely that he is correct in thinking that the horn
I figured as 2. Crossivis of the same species as the skulls which
he received from Tenasserim; but it is to be observed that I
have never seen a skull of the Tenasserim Rhinoceros, and do
not know whether it is the same as C. sumatranus from Su-
matra or C. niger from Malacca, or whether it may be a
distinct species. ‘Therefore I think it best, until we receive
skulls of the Tenasserim species, to give the Malaccan one a
distinct name and eall it C. niger (as the black colour at once
distinguishes it from the greyish Sumatran species), more es-
360 Dr. J. E. Gray on the Dentition of Rhinoceroses.
pecially as some zoologists who admit the difference of the
two species refer R. Crossti, of which we know nothing but
the horn, to each of the species.
Ceratorhinus Blythit.
Mr. Blyth, in the ‘ Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal,’
vol. xxxi. t. iil. f. 1, 2, 3, lithographs from photographs (which
he has since given to me) three skulls of what he calls RL. swma-
tranus from 'Tenasserim.
These skulls, according to the photographs, differ so much
from each other that they do not afford materials for the de-
termination of the question of the species to which the Tenas-
serim Rhinoceros should be referred.
The photographs represent the skulls.of animals of very
different ages; but I cannot believe the difference between
them depends solely on age, as the skull of the oldest (fig. 1)
and of the youngest (fig. 3) agree in the shape of the occiput
and in the upper surface not being produced behind, while the
skull of the half-grown one (fig. 2) has the upper surface of
the occiput very much produced backwards, and the occipital
condyles not so prominent.
The three photographs are nearly of the same breadth at the
lateral condyles; but the length of the upper surface of the
skull differs considerably as compared with its breadth. Thus
in the photograph of the aged specimen (t. ii. f. 1) the length
of the skull is once and_three-fourths its breadth; in the
youngest skull (t. 11. f. 3) it is very nearly of the same
proportion ; but in the nearly adult skull the photograph
represents the upper surface as a little more than twice as long
as the breadth at the condyles.
The most striking difference is in the height of the occipital
end and the form of the lower jaw in the photographs of the
adult and nearly adult skulls (f. 1 & 2).
In the adult skull the occipital end is high (that is, as high
as two thirds the length of the skull from the occipital condyle
to the end of the nose), and the hinder end of the lower jaw is
nearly erect, with a broad rounded lower part, which is promi-
nent, with diverging ridges on its outer margin. In the nearly
adult specimen the hinder end is not nearly so high compared
with the length, and the hinder end of the lower jaw shelves
off towards its lower edge and has not the expanded rounded
form of the lower jaw of the other specimen ; but it is curious
that the skull of the youngest one has the form of the occiput
of the very aged one and the form of the lower jaw of the
middle-aged one. All this shows the difficulty of distinguishing
the species of these animals and the necessity of waiting until
Dr. J. E. Gray on the Dentition of Rhinoceroses. 361
we get together more specimens and their skulls from different
parts of Asia. It may turn out that more than one species of
two-horned Rhinoceros inhabit Tenasserim. There is a one-
horned one, F. javanicus, also found there. The photograph
of the oldest skull (t. i. f. 1) and the youngest (t. iii. f. 8)
agree in many particulars with our skulls of C. swmatranus
from Sumatra—that is to say, in the width of the skull at the
lateral condyles and in the narrowness of the space that sepa-
rates the temporal muscles of the adult; but the surface of the
lower jaw of the adult specimen most resembles that of C. niger.
The latter fact may depend solely upon the age of the specimen.
Mr. Blyth informs me that he believes the adult skull (t. iii.
f. 1) is the skull of A. Crossii, which he thinks is 2. lasiotis,
and he believes that the two younger skulls (t. i. f. 2 & 3)
belong to the black Rhinoceros. The youngest skull (t. iii.
f. 3) has the skin of the head and horns attached to it in the
Museum at Calcutta. But the lower jaw in the two younger
specimens does not agree in form with the lower jaw of
C. niger ; and therefore I should provisionally name them C.
Blythit.
The African Rhinoceroses have the intermaxillary bones
small, laminar, situated on the front end of a bony plate sepa-
rated by a suture (which becomes obliterated in the older spe-
cimens) in the inner side of the front part of the maxille ; and
it has a tooth on the edge, which generally falls out in the adult
animal; hence they are usually described as having no inter-
maxillary cutting-teeth. The lower jawof the young Rf. bicornis
(1365 6) has a smallcylindrical cutting-tooth on each side of the
broad end of the jaw, which disappears in the older animals ;
and the breadth of the front of the jaw does not increase, and
therefore becomes smaller compared with the size of the skull.
In the skull of the foetal specimen of 2. bicornis, 8} in. long
(1365 h), with the three grinders but partially developed, the
intermaxillaries are cartilaginous, and show rudiments or,
rather, nuclei of two teeth.
The lamina on the inside of the maxille of these African
Rhinoceroses, bearing the intermaxillaries, is represented in the
Asiatic Rhinoceroses by a broad portion of the inside of the
maxille, which is marked by an external groove; but in these
animals the broad intermaxilla is attached to the end of the
maxilla, as well as to the end of this defined part.
EXPLANATION OF PLATE XI.
The skull of the two-horned Rhinoceros (Ceratorhinus niger) from
Malacca; and a view of its occipital extremity, showing the form
and breadth of the hinder part of the head.
362 M. E. Favre on some Works relating to
XLIL.—On some Works relating to a new Classification of
Ammonites. By Ernest FAvre*.
THE abundance with which Ammonites are distributed in the
deposits of the secondary epoch, the variety and beauty of these
fossils, and their importance in the classification of strata have
long attracted the attention of naturalists. When the known
species of this group increased in number, and a greater diver-
sity of forms was discovered, the necessity of introducing some
subdivisions among them came to be felt. Nevertheless, as
no representative of this genus has yet been found living, and
the organization of the animal was and still is in great part
unknown, the various classifications proposed were only based
on the most apparent characters of the shell—that is to say, on
its general form, the nature of its ornaments, and that of the
septa. Thus it was that the Ammonites were divided into
various families, the HHeterophylli, Globosi, Ornati, Cristatt,
&e.
The great works of M. Barrande on the Cephalopoda of the
Silurian strata, the development of paleeontological collections,
and a very complete study of the anatomy of the Nautilus (the
only tetrabranch now living) have thrown, within the last
few years, a new light on the organization of the Ammonites.
Important characters have been recognized, and have served
as a basis for a classification into various groups which have
been called genera. In this way a number of new names, such
as Arcestes, Phylloceras, Perisphinctes, &c., of which the use
has not yet spread beyond a certain number of paleontologists,
have been introduced into certain works published in Germany.
The new classificationt, however, is not complete; and it re-
lates especially to the Ammonites of the Jurassic formation, of
which the museums of Munich and Vienna possess admirable
collections. Moreover the naturalists who have created and
adopted it still retain the old designation for the Ammonites
from this formation which are not yet classed, as well as for
the greater part of the Cretaceous Ammonites, until new mate-
rials enable the work to be completed.
Professor Suess has the merit of first drawing attention to
the characters which may serve to establish a new classifica-
tion of Ammonites, and directed in a quite different course from
his predecessors’ the researches on this group. M. Laube, M.
* Translated by W. 8. Dallas, F.L.S., from the Bibliothéque Univer-
selle, Archives des Sciences, January 15th, 1878, pp. 1-28.
+ I shall not speak here of an attempt at classification which has been
made in America by Prof. Agassiz and Mr. Hyatt, and which rests upon
very different principles from those of the German classification.
a new Classification of Ammonites. 363
Zittel, and M. Waagen afterwards, especially occupied them-
selves with this question*. The classification proposed by M.
Suess rests in great part on the size of the last chamber and
on the nature of the appendages to the mouth of the shell,
which he believes to be in relation with the essential characters
of the animal. That of M. Waagen, whilst taking into ac-
count these characters, is based on the nature of the Aptychus,
which plays, as I shall show, an essential part in the organi-
zation of the Ammonite.
The ast chamber, the size of which is constant in each group
of Ammonites, differs much from one group to another. In
some of them it occupies as much as one turn and a half, in
others hardly half a turn. This difference is often connected,
according to M. Suess, with differences in the form of the
margin of the aperture, and in important anatomical characters.
According to this learned paleontologist, in the Ammonites
furnished with a large chamber the adductor muscles were
probably placed on the sides near the margin of the shell,
which generally presents the form of a crescent. In the much
more numerous Ammonites which have a shorter chamber the
latter encloses only a part of the animal; the margin of the
aperture is then furnished with appendages of various forms,
sometimes simple and discoidal (myothéque), sometimes more
elongated and presenting a myotheca united to the shell by
a longer or a shorter peduncle (myolabe). As these names in-
dicate, these appendages served, in the opinion of M. Suess,
as points of attachment for the muscles.
M. Waagen has opposed this opinion. The muscles have,
according to him, a part too important in the organization of
the Ammonite, and the life of the animal depends too much
upon their preservation, for them to be thus placed on the edge
* The following are the titles of the various works in which this sub-
ject is treated :—
1865 and 1870, Ed. Suess, ‘Ueber Ammoniten,” Sitzungsber. k. Akad.
Wiss. Wien, lii., lxi.
1868. Zittel, Paliontologische Mittheilungen. Die Cephalopoden der
Stramberger Schichten.
1869. Laube, “Ueber Ammonites Aon und seine Verwandten,” Sitz-
ungsber. k. Akad. Wiss. Wien, lix. 15.
1869. Waagen, “ Die Formenreihe des Ammonites subradiatus,” in Be-
neke’s Geogn.-pal. Beitr. 1869, ii. 183.
1870. Zittel, Paliontologische Mittheilungen. Die Fauna der altern
Cephalopoden-fiihrenden Tithonbildungen.
1870. Waagen, “ Ueber die Ansatzstellen der Haftmuskeln beim Nau-
tilus und den Ammonitiden,”’ Paleeontographica, herausg. y. Dunker und
Zittel, xvii. 185.
1871. Waagen, “ Abstract of results of examination of the Ammonite-
fauna of Kutch, &c.,” Records of the Geol. Surv. of India, 1871.
364 M. E. Favre on some Works relating to
of the shell, and often beyond this edge on a pedunculated
organ, exposed to all sorts of external dangers. The anatomy
of the Nautilus, in conjunction with observations made directly
on well-preserved Ammonites, lead him to a very different
result from that obtained by M. Suess. This I shall explain
hereafter.
It has long been a question how the animal of the Ammo-
nite advanced in its shell, and how it formed its septa. The
mode of progression was evidently the same as in the Nautilus.
The researches of M. Keferstein, and those of M. Waagen, on
the anatomy of the latter animal seem to have settled the
question. he animal grows periodically; at certain moments,
which are for it a time of repose, it remains fixed: the poste-
rior part of its body, which is free, secretes calcareous matter
and forms the septum; at other times this part secretes air,
and the animal advances slowly. All its periphery is bound
to the shell by a thin layer of conchioline*, of which the outer
margin has the form of a ring (annulus), marked in the inte-
rior of the shell by a band from 1 to 2 millimetres in breadth.
The adductor muscles are attached by a thicker coat of the
same substance; the marks which they leave on the shell in
the last chamber have a perfectly definite form. The whole
animal, the posterior part excepted, is therefore united to the
shell, and the chamber is hermetically closed.
This explains how the air can accumulate, how the animal
can resist variations in the pressure of the air according as it
is at a greater or less depth, and also how the soft parts thus
sustained could, in the Ammonites, secrete the delicate lobes
of the septa always in the same position and on the same spiral
line. The mantle extends in front of this attaching ring (/aft-
ring) ; it is composed of two parts—one, which is very short,
corresponding to the antisiphonal region of the animal; the
other, which is much longer, corresponds to the siphonal re-
gion, and secretes the shell with which it is connected by its
outer margin. Contrary to the opinion of M. Suess, the form
of the margins of the aperture has no direct relation with the
position of the adductor muscles; it depends entirely on the
form of the mantle.
Aptychus.—Vhe most various opinions have been put for-
ward as to the nature and functions of the AptychusT. L. von
* A substance resembling epidermose and containing about C 50, H 6,
and N 16:5 per cent.
+ M. Coquand published, in 1841, ‘ Considérations sur les Aptychus,’ in
which he sums up all the opinions brought forward up to that date as to
the nature of these singular organisms. He endeavours to demonstrate
that these shells belonged to an extinct family of naked Cephalpooda.
a new Classification of Ammonites. 365
Buch was the first to suppose that they belonged to the Am-
monites, and that each species has a determinate form of
aptychus. Oppel (Paliiont. Mittheil.) demonstrated this fact,
and ascertained that they have always a perfectly definite
position in the neighbourhood of the siphonal side of the
last chamber when the fossil is in a normal state of pre-
servation *,
Three kinds of Aptychus have been distinguished :—Apty-
chus properly so called; Anaptychus, which is characteristic
of the groups of the Ardetes and Amalthe’; and Sidetes, of
which the Ammonite is not yet known, and which belongs to
the Cretaceous formation.
The form of the Aptychus is generally known. The shell
consists of three layers of different textures, of which the two
external ones are often detached. The inner layer is thin,
homogeneous, and often impregnated with organic substance ;
it is marked with fine lines of growth, and sometimes also
with radiating lines. The middle layer, which is the thickest,
is distinguished by its structure of juxtaposed canals.
The outer layer disappears easily ; it has not always been
observed. In the thick Aptychi of the Perarmati (A. cellu-
lost) it is very thin and pierced with very small holes; in the
Aptychi of the Flexuost and Falcifert (A. imbricati) it forms
a thin homogeneous layer, destitute of pores, which often be-
comes detached ; in the Aptychi of the Planulat? it is covered
with small points. It is particularly developed in the Aptychi
of the Alpine strata; in many of them (A. punctat?, Zitt.) the
surface of the thick middle layer is, as in the Jmbricati, gar-
nished with imbricated folds. But while in these last the
outer layer is very thin, it is thickened in the others so as to
fill up the intervals of the projecting folds, so that well-pre-
served specimens seem nearly smooth; their surface is covered
with round pores, which are sometimes pretty large, arranged
in a radiating order, each row corresponding to a furrow of the
middle layer. A. profundus, Pict., alpinus, Giimb., striato-
punctatus, Voltz, cunerformis, Oost., radians, Coq., and Mal-
bost, Pict., present this structure. We do not yet know to
what group of Ammonites they correspond; for they are very
abundant in certain beds of the Alps, in which Ammonites are
scarcely ever found. This fact, which has repeatedly fur-
nished an argument against the opinion that the Aptychus is
an integral part of the Ammonite, may be explained in various
ways. We may suppose that after the death of the animal
* M. Schluter has ascertained that the aptychus of the Scaphites occu-
pied exactly the same position (Cephal. der ober. deutsch. Kreide, 1872,
pl. 25. figs. 5 & 6).
366 M. E. Favre on some Works relating to
the Aptychus detached itself from the shell and fell to the
bottom of the water, whilst the shell of the Ammonite was
thrown on the shore—or, as M. Zittel has supposed, that these
organisms belong to a group of naked Tetrabranchs.
What is the part played by the Aptychus in the Ammonite ?
The Nautclus presenting nothing like it, it was difficult to de-
termine its function. Voltz found its analogue in the opercu-
lum of the Gasteropoda. Von Buch and Quenstedt regard it
as an internal shell. Keferstein has put forward the opimion
that the Aptychus might be a protecting organ of the nida-
mentary glands of the female Ammonite. M. Zittel has cor-
roborated this opinion by several proofs; and M. Waagen has
made it a certainty.
The normal position of the Aptychus in the Ammonite is so
closely related to that of the nidamentary gland in the female
Nautilus, that it seems difficult to assign to it a different func-
tion. Moreover the soft tissue of this gland has a great re-
semblance in its various parts to the structure of the different
types of Aptychus, and the form of the Aptychus corresponds
very well with that of the outer part of this gland. These vari-
ous characters indicate therefore almost certainly the purpose |
which it serves, although in no living Cephalopod has there been
found a similar thickening of the teguments of these glands.
We may add, as an indirect proof, that no other organ exists
in the Nautilus with the analogue of which the Aptychus
could have been connected in the Ammonite.
It is evident that it could not have served to close the aper-
ture of the shell. This opinion, which has been repeatedly
maintained, and quite recently by M. Lehon*, has been refuted
by M. Waagen. The museum at Munich contains a hun-
dred specimens of Ammonites still provided with the Aptychus.
Only five of them present the Aptychus placed perpendicularly
to the aperture, as M. Lehon has shown it. In all the others
it is deeply immersed in the shell in the position here figured
(see opposite), a position which corresponds. with that of the
nidamentary glands of the Nauwtilust. M. Waagen shows
besides, by measurements of Amm. steraspis, that the dimen-
sions of the Aptychus by no means agree with those of the
aperture. Moreover its presence in Ammonites provided with
appendages to the aperture proves evidently that it never plays
the part of an operculum ; for these appendages often approach
each other towards the apex, and would have entirely paralyzed
its movements. Keferstem, who had recognized the true
* Bull. de la Soc. Géol. de France, 1870, vol. xxvii. p. 10.
+ See, for the position of these glands in the Nautilus, the excellent
figure given as the frontispiece to Woodward’s Manual.
a new Classification of Ammonites. 367
function of the Aptychus, believed that the Anaptychus served
as an operculum : it occurs, however, in the same position as
A. steraspis: figure taken from Waagen, Paleeont. xvii. pl. 40. f. 4.
the former of these organs *; and it is therefore evident that
it fulfilled the same purpose.
The function of the Aptychus being thus determined, fur-
nishes an important point for the determination of the relative
| arrangement of the organs in the Ammonite, which may be
| deduced from that which they occupy in the Nautilus. In
| this animal the nidamentary gland is situated on the siphonal
side above the adductor muscle, and outside of the rig of
adherence. It is only natural to suppose that the relations of
these various organs were the same in the Ammonite. Direct
observation serves here to confirm the theory.
Oppel has remarked in a great number of Ammonites from
the limestones of Solenhofen a mark of a peculiar form (Paliiont.
| Mittheil. pl. 69). M. Waagen has ascertained that this im-
pression has precisely the same shape as that of the ring of
| adherence in the Nawtzlus (see the foregoing sketch) ; it is the
| trace of the horny margin of this ring, which has been preserved
in consequence of the tranquillity of the deposition of the sedi-
ments. ‘This trace begins at the margin of the aperture, about
in the middle of the sides, follows the spiral of the shell back
towards the septum, and then bends forward towards the
siphonal side. The Aptychus is above and outside of this
* See 4. planorbis, Sow., in Waagen, Palontogr. 1869, xvii, pl. 40.
fig. 5.
368 M. E. Favre on some Works relating to
mark (that is to say, nearer the siphonal side), the same as the
nidamentary gland in the Nautilus. This important line once
ascertained, M. Waagen deduces from it by analogy the position
of the adductor muscle, of which the trace is ideally represented
in the figure by a dotted line.
Apertural appendages.—We owe to M. Suess a detailed
study of these appendages in various groups of Ammonites.
In the group of the #%mbriati the ventral side shows nothing
but a broad, short, and but slightly marked process, while the
dorsal margin presents a long appendage which spreads far
over the preceding turn. In the Amalthet, the Falciferi, and
the Cristati* the keel extends far beyond the anterior margin
of the chamber, in a long appendage which M. Suess regards
as destined to support and protect the naked part of the body
of the Ammonite, and in particular the excretory canal, in
those groups which are distinguished by the smallness of their
last chamber ; this appendage curves outwards in A. rostra-
tust, and inwards in A. Lambertif. In a great number
of Ammonites (Ornati, Coronati, Planulati, Flexuosi, Tri-
marginati) the margins of the shell are produced into lateral
appendages or auricles of various shapes, which M. Suess
regards, as I have already stated, as the points of attachment
for the muscles. In the typical Planulati the discoidal part
and the stalk of these appendages are both well developed ; in
the Coronati the stalk is always short and the disk very
large§; in A. Jason||, these two organs are more or less
confounded. The often hollow spiral line that we see in
many Ammonites (A. lunula, A. canaliculatus, A. bifrons, &c.)
is produced as far as this appendage; it is nothing but the
trace left by the stalk, which gradually incorporates itself
with the shell in proportion as the latter grows, while the
discoidal part is very probably subjected to resorption.
If these lateral processes did not serve as points of attachment
for the muscles, what could have been their use? The margin
of the aperture of the Nawtz/us is also falciform ; it is so in a
more marked manner in some Clymenie, and still more in Ortho-
ceras undulatum. ‘This process serves in the Nautilus for the
protection of the head, and in particular of the eye. We may
therefore suppose, with much probability, that it fulfilled the
* See A. Amaltheus and A. costatus, Quenstedt, Jura, p. 162 and pl. 21.
figs. 1-8; Cephalopoden, pl. 5. fig. 10a; A. serpentinus, Pictet, Traité de
Paléont. pl. 53. fig. 2; A. ertstatus and A. varvans, D’Orbigny, Céphal.
crét. pls. 88 & 92.
+ Buvignier, Statistique géolog. de la Meuse, pl. 31. fig. 8.
{ Quenstedt, Jura, pl. 70. fig. 16.
§ D’Orbigny, Céphal. Jurass. pl. 149. fig. 1, pls, 155 & 139,
|| D’Orbigny, Céphal. Jurass. pl. 159, fig. 1.
a new Classification of Ammonites. 369
same function in the Ammonite. It occurs constantly in
certain genera of Ammonites; but this is not the case with
the auricles ; and the irregularity in the form and presence of
these organs proves that they were not destined to the part
M. Suess has attributed to them.
On examining these appendages with care, we see that
their length is by no means in inverse proportion to that of
the chamber. In the Amalthe?, in which the chamber forms
from half to two thirds of a turn, the margin scarcely pre-
sents a slight lateral process; in the Planulati, on the con-
trary, in which it is much longer, the auricles are often well
developed. ‘Their presence itself is very irregular, even in
the same species; it presents great variations with age:
M. Waagen has ascertained that they often disappear at
a certain age. Moreover, sometimes, of two Ammonites
of the same species and the same size, one presents auricles
and the other a simple margin, As examples of this,
Waagen cites and figures* two A. opalinus obtained at
Zaskale, in Gallicia. It is probable that these appendages
had some other physiological function. The species furnished
with an Anaptychus do not present auricles at any period of
their existence ; those which have auricles, even if only during
their youth, have, on the contrary, a true Aptychus.
The differences which I have just indicated are not sexual
differences. In fact, there have been found, at Solenhofen,
amongst the Ammonites which contain Aptychi, as many in-
dividuals provided with auricles as destitute of them. Now
we have seen that the Aptychus is a distinctive sign of the
female Ammonite. Certain shells from this same deposit, in
which the line of the ring of attachment is still well marked
and which have consequently been submitted since their death
only to a slow decomposition in which the soft parts alone
have disappeared, are not furnished with Aptychi; therefore
they never had any, and they evidently belonged to males.
Now they do not present any difference from the female indi-
viduals, except perhaps a little more strongly marked orna-
mentation.
The figures of A. steraspis given by Oppel (Paliiont. Mitth.
1, 69) are very instructive on this point.
The Structure of the Shell—The shell of the Nautilus is
composed of two layers—an external layer formed of an
aggregate of cells of different sizes, and the largest of which
are those nearest the outside (it forms the most important
part of the shell properly so called, and M. Suess has named
* Palwontographica, 1869, xvii. pl. 40. figs. 6 & 7.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser.4. Vol. xi. 24
370 M. E. Favre on some Works relating to
it ostracum), and an internal nacreous layer formed of very
small cells, which constitutes the septa and lines the inner sur-
face of the ostracum. The former is secreted by the mantle ;
the latter by the body of the animal. This same structure has
been recognized in many Ammonites, notwithstanding the
difficulties which observation presents ; it is observed, in par-
ticular, in many Ammonites of the /imbriati group.
M. Barrande has established the fact that in many of the
paleeozoic Cephalopoda the organization was such that not
only the animal was entirely lodged in the shell, but it could
not put out more than a comparatively restricted number of its
organs. This character coexists generally with a great thick-
ness of the shell, due very probably to the nacreous layer,
and with certain swellings of this layer which M. Barrande
has named organic deposit. The structure of certain Ammo-
nites presents some analogy with this latter fact. In A. eym-
biformis, of the Trias of Hallstatt, the surface of the ostracum,
garnished with the strize of growth of the shell, is seen
continuing regularly without interruption to the anterior
margin; and it is only where the shell is broken that we
observe on the cast deep periodical furrows, corresponding to
so many folds or varices which were formed regularly on the
inner surface of the shell, and which occur in the youngest in-
dividuals. Generally these varices do not represent former
apertures; for they are not parallel to the lines of growth of
the ostracum, as is seen in A. Jarbas. ‘The periodical arrests
of growth which are indicated by these varices have nothing in
common with those which are necessary for the formation of
the septa. The constrictions which are observed in the Planu-
lati, for example in A. polygyratus, are of a totally different
nature ; they do not accord with a varix of the interior of the
shell, but they are produced by folds in the ostracum, without
any change in the thickness of the shell: M. Suess calls them
contractions. The varices and the contractions have this in
common, that in each group they are only observed in those
individuals which have the aperture but little elevated; in
Arcestes they exist in A. cymbiformis, but they are wanting
in those which have an elevated aperture, such as A. Layer?,
Metternichi (Pinacoceras, Mojs.). The varices are only seen
in Goniatites, Arcestes, Phylloceras, and Clymenia. ‘The con-
tractions are seen in Lytoceras, Perisphinctes, and many other
Ammonites. The distinction of the contractions and the
varices seems to agree with that of the great groups of
Ammonites.
The wrinkled layer (Runzelschicht) is formed by a deposit
of calcareous folds in the neighbourhood of the mouth, a
a new Classification of Ammonites. 371
little in front, on the convexity of the preceding turn, It has
been observed in the Goniatites by Keyserling, in many
Silurian Cephalopoda by M. Barrande, and in the Clymenie by
M. Giimbel; M.Quenstedt and M.von Hauer have recognized
it in the Ammonites of the group Arcestes; M. Laube in
A. (Phylloceras) Jarbas; M. Suess in Clydonites delphi-
nocephalus.
This layer extends to a larger or smaller part of the interior
of the shell ; it becomes gradually effaced and disappears with
growth. Itappears to be wanting in the genera which present
contractions. ‘The Ammonites in which it is found (Arcestes
and Phylloceras) are also those which have varices ; by these
characters they approach certain paleeozoic Cephalopoda; they
are also those which appeared first*.
The great differences in the structure of the Aptychi indicate
considerable differences in the structure of the nidamentary
glands, and consequently in the entire organization of the
Ammonites. The various characters which we have enume-
rated seem fully to justify a division into genera of the fossils
of this great group. ‘This new classification is based, then,
first of all on the structure of the nidamentary gland; next,
on the length of the chamber of habitation ; in the third place,
on the form of the latter and of the aperture, the septa, and the
- ornaments. The general form of the shell, to which the older
classification attached great importance, seems to be a very
variable character, and, in consequence, a secondary one. It
is upon these principles that M. Waagen has based the
following table :—
A. NIDAMENTARY GLAND WITHOUT SOLID INTEGUMENT.
Chamber short; appendage ventral .......... PHYLLOCERAS, Suess.
Chamber short; appendage dorsal .......... LyTocERas, Suess.
Chamber very long (13 to 2 turns) .......... ARCESTES, Suess.
? Chamber short; apertural margin falciform,
with the appendage ventral ; ornaments of
the same kind as those of the Argonaut .... TRacHycERAS, Laube.
B. NripaAMENTARY GLAND WITH A SOLID INTEGUMENT (Aptychus).
I. Gland simple, not divided, with :—
1. Integument horny (Anaptychus).
Chamber very long (1 to 1} turn); apertural
margin with a pointed ventral appendage .. ArreTiTES, Waag.
Chamber from 2 to 1 turn; apertural margin
with a rounded ventral appendage ........ /Ecocrras, Waag.
Chamber short (4 to 3 turn); apertural margin
with a long ventral appendage ............ AMALTHEUS, Montf.
* These Ammonites are abundant in the Trias. M. Waagen has lately
discovered some in the Carboniferous formation in India.
24*
372 M. E. Favre on some Works relating to
2. Integument calcareous.
Aptychus Numida, Coq. Shell unknown, (Si-
detes ?)
pinwheel = ice (Ree HER Ore Cee —?
Il. Gland double, with the Aptychus calcareous.
1, Aptychus possessing furrows on the external side.
Aptychus thin, presenting externally a layer of
conchioline, which is easily detached. Cham-
ber short; apertural margin falciform, with
an acute ventral appendage .............- Harpoceras, Waag.
Aptychus thick, having internally a solid layer
ot conchioline. Chamber short; apertural
margin falciform, with a rounded ventral
BP PENT ALS Ae sale siavckcle = sue sts cetetel atte ae OppE.ta, Waag.
Chamber short, having near the aperture a
groove or a swelling; apertural margin pro-
vided with lateral auricles and a rounded
VOUELAl APPCHAASS vices ss waline oe hie ce Sane Haptoceras, Zitt.
Chamber pretty long; last turn detached from
thie ‘ofhers jw 2st aia ie ele ete ome sian ee ? Scapuirss, Park.
2. Aptychus thin, granulated externally.
Chamber long; apertural margin simple or
furnished with auricles 7..¢.2......:.e50 STEPHANOCERAS, Waag.
Chamber long ; aperture narrowed by a furrow,
simple or furnished with auricles.......... PERISPHINCTES, Waag.
Chamber short; aperture simple or furnished
With auricles. cp 6 on etek ion Reem «htc CosmocrErRas, Waag.
3. Aptychus thick, smooth, and punctated externally.
? Chamber long. Umbilicus large. Shell with
furrows; apertural margin with a nasiform
ventral appendare pi... sige syle see) oeide Sraroceras, Zitt.
Chamber short; apertural margin generally
RiIMMplO Re Me beek oe ak oe Vaden ete eee ASPIDOCERAS, Zitt.
In this table I have employed the words ventral and dorsal
in place of s¢phonal and antisiphonal, because the appendages —
to which they apply, and which are placed at the extremity of
the last chamber, are not in any way related to the siphon.
Two newly established genera must be added, viz. Pinacoceras,
Mojsis., allied to Arcestes, and Peltoceras, Waag., intermediate
between Perisphinctes and Aspidoceras.
This table is far from embracing the whole of the family of
Ammonitide. There are wanting Ceratites and CGoniatites,
long since separated from the true Ammonites, all the unrolled
Ammonitide, already classified in accordance with other cha-_
racters, and to which the genus Scaphites forms the transition ;
and, lastly, many true Ammonites for which no genus has yet
been created, and to which, in the meanwhile, it is necessary
still to leave the old name, are necessarily omitted from it.
As the nature of this memoir does not permit me to give
a new Classification of Ammonites. 373
here the descriptions of the newly established genera, I confine
myself to citing the works in which they have been described,
and giving a few examples of them. In the works indicated,
there will be found especially the descriptions of the septa
characteristic of each genus. The names of the authors
followed by the dates of their publications refer to the biblio-
graphic note at the commencement of this article.
Puy tioceras, Suess, 1865, 6. Zittel, 1868, 56; 1870, 153. Neu-
mayr, Jahrb. geol. Reichsanst. 1871, xxi. 297. Heterophylli, von
Buch, Ueber Ammoniten, 1832. Triassic, Jurassic, and Cretaceous.
Examples: Ph. Jarbas, heterophyllum, tatricum, Zignodianum,
ptychowum, Thetys.
Lyrocrras, Suess, 1865, 8. Zittel, 1869, 70; 1870,162. Fimbriati,
lineati. Triassic, Jurassic, and Cretaceous. Examples: L. Simonyi,
spherophyllum, fimbriatum, Eudesianum, Adele, Liebigi, subfim-
briatum.
Arcestss, Suess, 1865, 6. Globosi. Triassic. Examples: A. galei-
formis, subumbilicatus, cymbiformis.
Prnacoceras, Mojsisovics, Verhandl. geol. Reichsanst. 1872, 315.
Triassic. Example: P. Metternichi.
Tracuyceras, Laube, 1869, 15. Triassic. Example: 7. Aon.
Artetires, Waagen, 1869, 69 ; 1870, 98. Arietes, Von Buch ; par-
tim capricorni. Triassic and Liassic. Examples: A. Bucklandi,
obtusus.
Acoceras, Waagen, 1869, 69; 1870, 199. Partim capricorni, coro-
narii, ornati; macrocephali, &e. Triassicand Liassic. Examples:
4. incultum, planorbis, angulatum, Henleyt.
Amattuevs, Montfort. Waagen, 1869, 69; 1870, 207. Amalthei,
Von Buch; partim ornati, falciferi, pulchelli, clypeiformi. Triassic,
Jurassic, and Cretaceous. Examples: A. ovynotus, margaritatus,
pustulatus, cordatus, Lamberti.
Harpoceras, Waagen, 1869, 245, 250; 1870, 202. Falciferi, Von
Buch; partim disci, insignes, clypeiformi. Jurassic. Examples:
H. radians, opalinum, hecticum, discus.
Opprria, Waagen, 1869, 72; 1870, 203. Q&kotraustes, Waagen,
1869, 25. Oppelia, Zittel, 1870, 175; partim denticulati, disci,
clypeiformi, ligati. Jurassic and Cretaceous. Zittel has united
under this name the two subgenera Oppelia, Waag., and @hko-
traustes, Waag.; he has separated from it the genus Haploceras.
Examples: O. subradiata, tenuilobata, flexuosa.
Harroceras, Zittel, 1870,166. Jurassic and Cretaceous. Examples:
H. Erato, ooliticum, Grasianum.
SrepHanoceras, Waagen, 1869, 248; 1870, 205. Coronarii, Von
Buch ; partim macrocephali, coronati, dentati, bullati, &e.
Jurassic and Cretaccous. M. Waagen at first made of Stephano-
374 Dr. A..Giinther on a new Snake from Madagascar.
ceras a genus which comprised three subgenera, Stephanoceras,
Perisphinctes, and Cosmoceras ; subsequently he raised each of
these subgenera to the rank of distinct genera. Examples:
S. Humphriesianum, macrocephalum, coronatum, Parkinson.
Perispuinctes, Waagen, 1869, 248. Zittel, 1870, 218. Waagen,
1870, 206. Planulati, Von Buch ; partim macrocephali, coronati,
coronarii, dentati. Jurassic and Cretaceous. Examples: P. Mar-
tinst, plicatilis, biplex, Calisto.
Prttoceras, Waagen, 1871, 91. Includes the species detached from
the genera Perisphinctes and Aspidoceras. Jurassic. Examples::
P. arduennense, transversarium, athleta.
Cosmoceras, Waagen, 1869, 248. Zittel, 1870, 215. Waagen,
1870, 208. Dentati, ornati. Jurassic and Cretaceous. Examples:
C. calloviense, ornatum, mamillare, verrucosum.
Smroceras, Zittel, 1870, 207. Tithonic. Examples: S. volanense,
biruncinatum, strictum, catrianun.
Asprpoceras, Zittel, 1868, 116. Waagen, 1869, 248. Zittel, 1870, |
192. Middle and Upper Jurassic and Lower Cretaceous. Ex-
amples: A. bispinosum, cyclotum, orthoceras, Lallierianum, tphi-
cerus, rogoznicense.
XLIUI.—Deseription of a new Snake from Madagascar.
By Dr. A. GUNTHER. |
Tue Trustees of the British Museum have purchased ison
specimens of reptiles from Madagascar, and among them a
snake which appears to be the type of a new genus of the
family Dendrophide.
ITHYCYPHUS.
Body compressed, with the abdominal scutes distinctly
keeled. Scales smooth, imbricate, without apical groove, in
twenty-one series. Ventral scutes less than 200; anal and
subcaudals divided. Upper shields of the head normal. One
undivided nasal ; loreal distinct; one pree-, three postoculars.
Pupil round. N one of the sutenion or middle maxillary teeth
enlarged ; posterior maxillary tooth grooved.
Ithycyphus caudolineatus.
Body slender, compressed; head narrow, flat, with the
snout depressed, obliquely truncated in front. Eye rather
small. Vertical bell- shaped. Nostril round, in the middle of
the narrow, elongate, single nasal shield. Loreal elongate, as
On the Mollusca of Europe and North America. 375
long as the nasal. The single preocular reaches to the upper
surface of the head, and is in contact with the vertical. Three
postoculars. Hight upper labials, the fourth and fifth entering
the orbit. Temporals 1+ 2+ 3, but rather irregularly arranged.
A groove (of black colour) between the temporals and labials.
Ventrals 187; subcaudals 135. Brownish, some of the dorsal
scales with a blackish edge; tail with a black line on each
side, along the outer margin of the subcaudals; sometimes
another pair of less distinct blackish lines along the back of
the tail. Brownish yellow below, with or without irregular
powdered spots.
Total length 33 inches, of which the tail takes 13 inches.
Southern parts of Madagascar.
XLIV.—Reply to Professor Verrill’s “ Remarks on certain
Errors in Mr. Jeffreys’s Article on the Mollusca of Europe
compared with those of Eastern North America.” By J.
Gwyn JErrreys, F.R.S.
I HAVE been hitherto prevented by various engagements from
noticing Prof. Verrill’s remarks on the above article, which
was published in the ‘ Annals’ of last October.
Although I would rather invite than deprecate a fair criti-
cism of this or any other publication of mine, I cannot help
regretting that the present critic has not adopted the same
style of courtesy which so agreeably characterizes his scientific
countrymen.
I do not admit the wholesale charge of “ errors” and “ mis-
takes” which is so freely made in his “ Remarks,” nor that it
was incumbent on him personally to disclaim my views. Let
them be examined by some competent authority.
The errors attributed to me are those which relate to geo-
graphical and local distribution, to the difference of certain
species, and to the nomenclature of two other species.
The question of geographical distribution, involving that of
migration, is a subject which cannot be hastily disposed of ;
but Prof. Verrill’s idea that the land and freshwater shells
which are common to the Old and New Continents may have
originated in America and thence crossed to Europe “ in the
direction of the prevailing currents and winds” is more
ingenious than probable. Currents and winds are not the kind
of agency we should expect for the migration of such animals.
However, I will not offend his national susceptibilities any
further.
With regard to local distribution I can only repeat that I
376 On the Mollusca of Europe and North America.
consulted the recent edition of Gould’s ‘Invertebrata of Massa-
chusetts,’ and found it a most useful guide. If Prof. Verrill is
dissatisfied with that work, he may directly criticise it to his
heart’s content; but he ought not to indirectly criticise it
through me.
As to the difference of certain species (9 only out of 401
species) I would observe as follows :—
1. Gemma gemma. Iam by no means sure that this is not
the fry of Venus mercenaria, although Prof. Verrill has far
greater opportunities than I have for deciding the matter.
2. Arca transversa. ‘This may be distinct from A. pexata,
and not merely a variety of it; but Prof. Verrill is evidently
fond of adopting genera founded on unimportant characters,
and his proneness to multiply species also may therefore be
assumed as probable. |
3. Mactra ovalis. I cede the point to Prof. Verrill as to this
being distinct from JZ. solidissima. I had not seen specimens
of M. ovalis and the preceding two controverted species, and
only formed my opinion from Gould’s work.
4, Astarte castanea. A. borealis and other species of the
same genus are so polymorphous that I was justified in saying
A. castanea is “ perhaps a variety of A. borealis.” I fully |
expect to see a connecting link between them. The same
observation will apply to A. quadrans.
5. Pecten fuscus. Prof. Verrill may be right in stating that
this is the young of P. tenuicostatus and not of P. trradians.
I judged otherwise from the description of the first-named |
species in Gould’s work.
6. Dentalium dentale, Gould. I admit that this may be
specifically, but not generically, distinct from D. striolatum.
7. Dentalium striolatum. Having examined and carefully
compared numerous specimens of this shell and D. abyssorum,
I have no hesitation in considering them the same species. —
All have a terminal pipe (as in D. dentalis), which is partly
slit (as in D. entalis), so as to connect Dentalium with the so- —
called genus Entalis. |
8. Crepidula plana. If Prof. Verrill has found this species
on the outs¢de of other univalve shells or other substances in |
company with typical specimens of C. fornicata, and there 1s no |
intermediate form, I agree that they may be different species. —
9. Margarita acuminata. Probably distinct from MW. varicosa.
As to the alleged errors of nomenclature, my answer is
this :— |
Miolis salmonacea and 44. gymnota. Couthouy certainly |
described both before Dekay ; and the names of the former
must therefore stand for these species.
Bibliographical Notices. 377
Lacuna divaricata. The mistake made by Fabricius in
supposing this was Linné’s species does not invalidate his claim
to the authorship of the specific name, inasmuch as it belongs
to a different genus. The specific name has been adopted by
Méller, Lovén, Sars, the Messrs. Adams, Petit, and nearly
every other writer on North-Kuropean shells.
Natica afinis of Gmelin is unquestionably the N. clausa of
Sowerby. It was originally figured and noticed by Olafsen
and Povelsen in their ‘ Reise igiennem Island’ (1772), vol. i.
t. x. and vol. 11. pp. 665 and 1016. It was afterwards (1776)
described by O. F. Miiller in his Prodromus to the ‘Zoologia
Danica,’ p. 245. no. 2956, citing Olafsen and Povelsen’s work,
but without a specific name. That name (afinis) was given
by Gmelin in his edition of the ‘Systema Nature’ (1788),
p: 3675, with a reference to Miiller as above and the following
habitat, “in Oceano septentrionali.” Prof. Verrill has mistaken
for this species the Nertta australis of Gmelin, which is
described as having a silverish mouth or aperture and inha-
biting New Zealand. He might have spared his note of
admiration.
In conclusion I acknowledge my obligation to Prof. Verrill
for pointing out the mistakes, although so very few, which I
made. I conscientiously did my best with the materials at
my command, and I am satisfied if I have done something
towards correlating the European with the North-American
Mollusca.
BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTICES.
Birds of the Humber District. By Joun CorpEavx.
London: Van Voorst, 1872.
Tur pursuit of Natural History has, we rejoice to say, become ex-
ceedingly popular of late years; and perhaps nothing has tended to
diffuse this taste more generally than the publication of local Faunas.
Not very long ago the immortal chronicler of Selborne, whom every
field-naturalist still regards as his patron saint, stood nearly alone
in this department ; and his faithful though simple records, limited
almost to a single parish, have possessed a charm for succeeding
generations, and roused a kindred feeling among out-of-door observers,
who naturally take a deeper interest in things they see around them
than in those they merely read of. If ‘ the schoolmaster has been
abroad,”’ so has the botanist, the geologist, the entomologist, and
last, though not least, the ornithologist. So preeminent, indeed, are
the attractions of this charming study, that its votaries are probably
378 Bibliographical Notices.
more numérous than those of any other branch of zoology. We do
not here allude to what may be termed the science of ornithology
or to the labours of the closet-naturalist, to the manufacture of
genera or the nomenclature of species, but to the knowledge ac-
quired and to the delight experienced by the true lover of nature,
who studies the habits of his feathered favourites in the woods, in
the fields, on the sea-shore, or in the swamps and fens of the county
to which, either from choice or chance, his attention has been espe-
cially directed.
Such a one is Mr. Cordeaux, the author of the volume before us,
which is evidently the result of assiduous observation at all seasons
and in all weathers, during a period of ten years, in the maritime
tract which he characterizes as “The Humber District,” including
within its limits not only the wide estuary itself, with its muddy flats
from the Spurn Head to its junction with the Trent and Ouse, but
“the lands adjoining, namely part of North and Mid Lincolnshire
and Holderness, a district enclosed to the north, west, and south by
the curved sweep of the wold hills. To the east its sea-board ex-
tends from Flamborough Head in the north to Skegness on the
Lincolnshire coast in the south. This is a well-defined and clearly
marked province, both geologically and zoologically. It may be
compared to a half circle or bent bow, the Lincolnshire and York-
shire wolds forming the bow, the coast-line the string; whilst the
great river itself is like an arrow placed in the string and across
the bow, dividing the district into two nearly equal divisions.’
(Introduction, page v.)
But in spite of the attractions it still possesses for the practical
observer, our author tells us that even in the beginning of the pre-
sent century, “ when Colonel Montagu made his celebrated ornitho-
logical tour through Lincolnshire,” it had been shorn of much of its
ancient wildness, “immense changes having taken place in the
physical features of the country by the drainage and partial culti-
vation of the fen lands. Some species of birds had disappeared, and
others were rapidly verging on extinction.” Truly it must have
been a perfect paradise for wild fowl before it became what it now
is, ‘‘ probably the best-farmed county in the kingdom.”
Mr. Cordeaux says that the migratory birds visiting this district
in the autumn and winter, almost without an exception, come from
the direction of the sea, arriving on the coast in lines of flight vary-
ing from full north to east.
«The only exception to this rule is that of the Grey or Winter
Wagtail (Motacilla boarula), which reaches us from the west or north-
west. In the spring also, I am strongly inclined to think, the
greater portion of our little summer visitors, including the delicate
Warblers and Willow-wrens, arrive from the sea, coming from the
south-east to east, appearing first in the warmer and low-lying
country between the coast and the foot of the wold range, and gra-
dually extending inland across the high wolds, a cold backward
district, to the interior of the county.” (Introduction, page vi.)
The latter portion of the above paragraph is exceedingly interest-
= SS ee
eS
Bibliographical Notices. 379
ing. We can testify, from our own observation, that most of our
insectivorous vernal visitors, in the southern and south-western
maritime counties, also “arrive directly from the sea,” apparently
from the opposite coast of France ; but to reach the Humber district
these delicate migrants from the south (and even from the south-
east) apparently make a detowr of many miles to avoid the pro-
jecting coast of Norfolk, showing that ‘the overland route” has
less attraction for them than the open sea-voyage at this season of
the year.
Our author fully appreciates the value of that indispensable com-
panion of the field-naturalist, a good spy-glass. We envy his expe-
rience as recorded in the following passage :—
“The Godwits which visit our foreshore in the spring and autumn
feed largely on an annelid, Arenicola piscatorum, or some allied
species, which they obtain by boring. With the aid of my telescope
I have frequently observed their manner of feeding. They advance
rather quickly over the flats, and at the same time keep rapidly
thrusting their long bills into the ooze, as if feeling for some con-
cealed creature. It is easy to see when any are successful, as
instantly every motion displays extreme energy, the bird’s head
itself being half buried in its eagerness to grasp and hold its wrig-
gling prey. Often when the bill is withdrawn I have seen a huge
lob-worm, held crossways, dangling from it. This requires some
little manipulation before it can be swallowed; the Godwit’s head
is thrown backwards, and the mandibles are rapidly worked till the
worm becomes properly adjusted, when down it goes, the neck per-
ceptibly swelling and thickening in the descent; then there is a
satisfied smack of the mandibles, and the search recommences.”
(Page 119.)
The Ruff (Machetes pugnax) and Reeve (female) are still associated
in the popular mind with the fens of Lincolnshire; and, judging
from the numbers occasionally exposed in the London markets, the
species is yet numerous; but most, if not all, of these birds are
supplied from Holland. Mr. Cordeaux says :—
“The Ruff and Reeve, formerly so abundant in Lincolnshire,
where its capture and feeding for the London market was a regular
trade, is now only known as a bird of passage, lingering for a few
weeks or days in small numbers in the neighbourhood of its old
haunts during the period of the spring and autumn migrations. It
is almost a regular autumn, but only an occasional spring, visitant
to this district.” (Page 120.)
That apparently fragile little creature, the Golden-crested Wren
(Regulus cristatus), unlike so many comparatively robust insectivorous
birds, remains with us the whole year; but, avoiding equally the
extremes of heat and cold, vast numbers arrive on the east coast of
Lincolnshire and Yorkshire at the period of the autumnal migration,
when they ‘cross the wild North Sea, arriving on our eastern shores
in October. The migration of the Golderests is now a fact as well
established as is that of the Woodcocks. They appear about the
second or third week in October, preceding the Woodcocks by a few
380 Bibliographical Nottces.
days ; and so well is this known to those living on the east coast of
Yorkshire and Lincolnshire that they have earned for themselves
the sobriquet of the ‘ Woodcock-pilots.’ Almost every year I find
some about the second week of October, either on the Humber
embankments or in the marsh hedgerows. On the 12th of that
month in 1863 an extraordinary flight appeared in the Great-Cotes
marshes. On that morning I observed large numbers of these fairy
birds on the hedgerows and bushes in the open marsh district near
the Humber, many also creeping up and down on the reeds in the
drains, and at my lonely marsh farmstead quantities of these active
little fellows, everywhere busily searching every nook and corner on
the fold-yard fences, the cattle-sheds, and stacks. The Goldcrest
appears in flocks every year, both at Spurn and Flamborough, about
the middle of October ; they have on several occasions been found
dead beneath these lighthouses, having dashed bewildered against
the glass lanterns in their night migration.” (Page 37.)
Equally valuable are our author’s notes on the arrival and de-
parture of our shore and sea birds; but some of his personal ex-
periences and observations are even more especially interesting ; and
we only regret that we have not space for copious extracts in veri-
fication of our opinion. Here is a delightful little episode, the hero
of which is one of our rarest feathered visitors from the far north,
and the only example of the species that Mr. Cordeaux had ever
met with in the county :—
“ December 12th, 1870. I came quite suddenly this morning on
a beautiful little Phalarope (Phalaropus hyperboreus) swimming in
a drain near the Humber. I saw at once, by its small size (about
as large as a Dunlin) and plumage, that it was not the grey species.
The little bird rode as buoyantly as a gull upon the water, with
head thrown backward like a duck. It was the first occasion that
I have seen a Phalarope in these marshes; I observed all its
movements intently. It was shy, but not wild, diving on my
approach for twenty yards up the drain, and then, leaving the water,
ran along the narrow strip of ‘warp’ like a Sandpiper. On my
moving forward it again entered the water, diving further up the
drain, issuing as before on to the ‘warp.’ but this time under the
opposite bank ; the dive was again repeated, when I lost sight of it |
round a sharp bend in the stream. For the next ten minutes I
stood at this corner, vainly looking both up and down the drain for
its reappearance, and had nearly given it up when I caught sight
of the little creature directly opposite, and within a few feet—so near,
that had I reached forward I might have touched it with the gun-
muzzle. No wonder that I had overlooked it ; for it had now exactly _
the appearance of a small lump of earth fallen from the bank; the |
whole of its body was sunk below the water, excepting the upper |
part of the back and head from just below the eyes, which were |
level with the surface—the bill and fore part of the forehead also
immersed, the water covering the hind part of the neck between the —
back and head. The deception was perfect; and had I not beer |
specially looking, I might have passed the place scores of times _
Bibliographical Notices. 381
without noting any thing unusual. As it was, I had stood within a
few feet for several minutes, and had passed my eyes over and over
again across the place without finding it. Once, and once only, it
raised its head, and immediately afterwards dived, going under very
quietly and leaving hardly a ripple; this time I saw it emerge on
the drain side about the same distance, namely twenty yards.
Just then a flight of Plover passed, at which I fired; and I think
the report must have caused it to rise, as, although I spent an hour
in looking up and down the drain, and returned again at a later
period in the day, I saw it no more.” (Page 140.)
Vast numbers of Guillemots (Uria troile) and Razor-bills (Alca
torda) breed on the precipitous cliff of Flamborough Head, as well
as in various similar localities on the coasts of the British Islands.
We ourselves have never had the good fortune to observe the mode
in which the mother birds safely convey their young to the water
from their aérial nurseries on the upper ledges, although we have
often watched patiently for hours, in the vain hope of witnessing
the performance. Indeed until now we never met with a satis-
factory solution of the mystery ; but here it is :—
“When the young are partly fledged, and even when they are
quite little things, the old birds carry them down to the sea on their
backs. This is done late in the evening, after sunset. The Flam-
borough boatmen say that when they are fishing under the Speeton
Cliffs, on summer evenings, they have often observed this process of
carrying the young down, the little fellow clinging to its parent’s
back, and not unfrequently tumbling from the somewhat precarious
perch into the sea sooner than was intended.” (Page 184.)
We must now take leave of this, the latest contribution to the
avifauna of the British Islands, which, as a careful and painstaking
record of the arrival of our migratory birds on the shores and flats
of the wild and interesting region to which the author’s remarks
have been limited, may be regarded as almost exhaustive ; and we
heartily recommend, as a model for future monographers with
similar tastes and equal opportunities, this charming little volume on
the “birds of the Humber District.”
Lecture on the Feree Nature of the British Islands.
By Joun Cotaunoun, Author of ‘The Moor and the Loch,’ &c.
Ir quality, not quantity, is the test of merit, then is the little
brochure before us (for its modest dimensions forbid a claim to a
more ambitious title) deserving of our warmest commendation.
Though purporting to be simply “a lecture delivered to the
St. Steven’s Young Men’s Literary Society,” yet it contains matter
that might easily be expanded into a goodly volume. Indeed the
pleasure we have experienced in perusing its few though charming
pages induces us to regard with envy the favoured audience who
enjoyed the still greater treat of listening to the instructive words
of such an observant naturalist and dexterous sportsman as the
author of ‘The Moor and the Loch.’
382 Bibliographical Notices.
Unlike many who undertake to deliver public lectures in the
present day to their less enlightened brethren, nothing has been
“ oot up” by Mr. Colquhoun for the occasion. There has been no
“cramming” or petty larceny from the labours of others; all is
fresh and original, the result of long personal experience. Few
indeed of the present, and still fewer of the rising generation, can
venture to hope for such opportunities as have fallen to the lot of
this veteran observer. Even in Scotland the nobler predatory
quadrupeds are rapidly diminishing in number, while in England
they have, with the exception of the fox, all but disappeared, the
exclusive preservation of Reynard as an object of sport having per-
petuated the species ; but even in the Scottish Highlands, where no
such immunity from persecution exists, Mr. Colquhoun considers
that he will be “ the last to disappear,” as “ from his swiftness and
strength he can gather subsistence scattered over an immense tract
of country, and when food fails on the higher grounds can make a
raid on the lowlands during the long wintry nights, returning again
to shelter with his booty ere the day dawns. Next, the great
increase of alpine hares on the mountains and gradual but steady
introduction of rabbits into many remote ranges, afford the hill-fox
a favourite meal with but little trouble in securing it. Lastly, of
all beasts of prey sly Reynard is the most difficult to trap.”
On the other hand the marten (Martes foina) and the wild cat
(Felis catus) are easily deceived with a bait. “ Indeed both are so
greedy and fearless as to rush into the snare for a piece of raw
meat. Neither have speed to hold out before a swift plucky terrier,
but are quickly ‘treed’ or run to ground. Should they take refuge
in a hole or cleft of the rock, they are not difficult to bolt by smoke ;
but if they prove stubborn a neatly set trap will most likely secure
them after nightfall. Nowonder,then, that these interesting carniwora
have vanished from the greater part of even the Scottish hill-districts,
and that a tourist may now explore two thirds of the Highlands,
and far from seeing either of them will find from the natives that
there are none to be seen!”
Our author shares the popular belief that the dark ferrets, so
common in every ratcatcher’s hutch, owe their dusky hue to polecat
parentage. He says, “dark ferrets exactly resemble foumarts,
only they are smaller and of lighter shade. Many of these brown
ferrets are half polecats ; in fact the polecat is just a wild ferret.”
Most of our high zoological authorities are of a different opinion.
Bell considers the ferret (Mustela furo) specifically distinct from
the polecat (Mustela putorius), and says that “ of the assertion that
the breeders of ferrets have recourse to the polecat to improve the
breed he could obtain no authentic verification” *. Surely this
questio vexata might easily be decided by experiment.
In reference to the food of the foumart, Mr. Colquhoun records
that he found on one occasion, under the last massive boulder of a
huge heap of stones, a female polecat with three young ones and
* * British Quadrupeds.’
Royal Society. 383
the remains of several large yellow frogs—and adds, “ Still more
difficult to credit, eels are often found among the food-store. How
he catches them I have some curiosity to know. Yarrell says eels
slide like serpents over the dewy grass from one drain to another.
If so, the difficulty ends ; for the foumart’s instinct would soon teach
it to watch for the land progress of its slimy prey.”
In dear old Bewick, the delight of our youth, the woodcut of the
foumart represents the animal with an eel in its mouth, the accuracy
of the illustration being founded on the fact that several fine eels
were discovered in its retreat, and that it had been tracked in the
snow to the banks of a rivulet. Now we have never met with any
one who could assert that they had ever seen a foumart in the water,
and the matter has always been a puzzle to us; but we have to thank
Mr. Colquhoun for dispelling the mystery.
We regret that the limited space at our disposal forbids us to
indulge in further quotations. Suffice it to say that the badger
(Meles taxus), the otter (Lutra vulgaris), and even the rat, all come
in for their share of notice, their habits being graphically described
and illustrated by characteristic anecdotes. We cordially recommend
this interesting essay to the general reader as well as to the natura-
list and sportsman.
PROCEEDINGS OF LEARNED SOCIETIES.
ROYAL SOCIETY.
Jan. 30, 1873.—George Busk, Esq., Vice-President, in the Chair.
“Note on the Origin of Bacteria, and on their Relation to the
Process of Putrefaction.” By H. Cuartron Bastian, M.D., F.R.S.
In his now celebrated memoir of 1862, M. Pasteur asserted and
claimed to have proved (1) that the putrefaction occurring in
certain previously boiled fluids after exposure to the air was due
to the contamination of the fluids by Bacteria, or their germs,
which had before existed in the atmosphere, and (2) that all the
organisms found in such fluids have been derived more or less
immediately from the reproduction of germs which formerly existed
in the atmosphere.
The results of a long series of experiments have convinced me
that both these views are untenable.
In the first place, it can be easily shown that living Bacteria, or
their germs, exist very sparingly in the atmosphere, and that solu-
tions capable of putrefying are not commonly infected from this
source.
It has now been very definitely ascertained that certain fluids
exist which, after they have been boiled, are incapable of giving
birth to Bacteria, although they continue to be quite suitable for
384 Royal Society :-—
the support and active multiplication of any such organisms as
may have been purposely added to them. Amongst such fluids I
may name that now commonly known as “ Pasteur’s solution,” and
also one which I have myself more commonly used, consisting of
a simple aqueous solution of neutral ammonic tartrate and neutral
sodic sulphate*. When portions of either of these fluids are
boiled and poured into superheated flasks, they will continue quite
clear for many days, or even for weeks ; that is to say, although
the short and rather narrow neck of the flask remains open the
fluids will not become turbid, and no Bacteria are to be discovered
when they are submitted to microscopical examination.
But in order to show that such fluids are still thoroughly
favourable media for the multiplication of Bacteria, all that is
necessary is to bring either of them into contact with a glass rod
previously dipped into a fluid containing such organisms. In about
thirty-six hours after this has been done (the temperature being
about 80° F.), the fluid, which had hitherto remained clear, becomes
quite turbid, and is found, on examination with the microscope, to
be swarming with Bacteriat.
Facts of the same kind have also been shown by Dr. Burdon
Sanderson + to hold good for portions of boiled ‘“ Pasteur’s solu-
tion.” Air was even drawn through such a fluid daily for a time,
and yet it continued free from Bacteria.
Evidence of this kind has already been widely accepted as justify-
ing the conclusion that living Bacterca or their germs are either
wholly absent from or, at most, only very sparingly distributed
through the atmosphere. The danger of infection from the
atmosphere having thus been got rid of and shown to be delusive,
I am now able to bring forward other evidence tending to show
that the first Bacteria which appear in many boiled infusions
(when they subsequently undergo putrefactive changes) are evolved
de novo in the fluids themselves. These experiments are more-
over so simple, and may be so easily repeated, that the evidence
which they are capable of supplying lies within the reach of all.
That boiling the experimental fluid destroys the life of any
Bacteria or Bacteria-germs preexisting therein is now almost uni-
versally admitted ; it may, moreover, be easily demonstrated. If
a portion of “ Pasteur’s solution ” be purposely infected with living
Bacteria and subsequently boiled for two or three minutes, it will
continue (if left in the same flask) clear for an indefinite period ;
whilst a similarly infected portion of the same fluid, not subse-
quently boiled, will rapidly become turbid. Precisely similar
phenomena occur when we operate with the neutral fluid which
I have previously mentioned ; and yet M. Pasteur has ventured to
assert that the germs of Bacteria are not destroyed in neutral or
* In the proportion of 10 grains of the former and 3 of the latter to 1 ounce
of distilled water.
+ The Modes of Origin of the Lowest Organisms, 1871, pp. 30, 51.
{ Thirteenth Report of the Medical Officer of the Privy Council (1871),
p. 59.
See Se RSS Ee SS EE t—i—
-- =—sa Pe
es Ff
!)
Dr. H. C. Bastian on the Origin of Bacteria. 385
slightly alkaline fluids which have been merely raised to the
boiling-point *.
Even M. Pasteur, however, admits that the germs of Bacteria
and other allied organisms are killed in slightly acid fluids which
have been boiled for a few minutes; so that there is a perfect
unanimity of opinion (amongst those best qualified to judge) as
to the destructive effects of a heat of 212° F. upon any Bacteria
or Bacteria-germs which such fluids may contain.
Taking such a fluid, therefore, in the form of a strong filtered
infusion of turnip, we may place it after ebullition in a superheated
flask with the assurance that it contains no living organisms.
Having ascertained also by our previous experiments with the
boiled saline fluids that there is no danger of infection by Bacteria
from the atmosphere, we may leave the rather narrow mouth of
the flask open, as we did in these experiments. But when this is
done, the previously clear turnip-infusion invariably becomes turbid
in one or two days (the temperature being about 70° F.), owing to
the presence of myriads of Bacteria.
Thus, if we take two similar flasks, one of which contains a
boiled “‘ Pasteur’s solution ” and the other a boiled turnip-infusion,
and if we place them beneath the same bell-jar, it will be found
that the first fluid remains clear and free from Bacteria for an
indefinite period, whilst the second invariably becomes turbid in
one or two days.
What is the explanation of these discordant results? We have
a right to infer that all preexisting life has been destroyed in each
of the fluidst; we have proved also that such fluids are not
usually infected by Bacteria derived from the air; in this very
case, in fact, the putrescible saline fluid remains pure, although
the organic infusion standing by its side rapidly putrefies. We
can only infer, therefore, that whilst the boiled saline solution is
quite incapable of engendering Bacteriat, such organisms are able
to arise de novo in the boiled organic infusion.
Although this inference may be legitimately drawn from such
experiments as I have here referred to, fortunately it is confirmed
and strengthened by the labours of many investigators who have
worked under the influence of much more stringent conditions,
and in which closed vessels of various kinds have been employed §.
Whilst we may therefore infer (1) that the putrefaction which
* How unwarrantable such a conclusion appears to be, I have elsewhere
endeavoured to show. See ‘ Beginnings of Life,’ 1872, vol. i. pp. 826-333, 372-
399
+ [Note. Jan. 31, 1873.]—In ‘The Beginnings of Life,’ vol. i. p. 332, note 1,
I have cited facts strongly tending to show that Bacteria are killed in infusions
of turnip or of hay when these have been heated to a temperaturejof 140° F.
| They also seem to die at the same temperature in solutions of ammonic tartrate
with sodie phosphate.
t See ‘ Beginnings of Life,’ vol. ii. p. 35, and vol. i. p. 463.
§ See a recent communication by Prof. Burdon Sanderson, in ‘ Nature,’
January 9th.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 25
386 Royal Society :-—
occurs in many. previously boiled fluids when exposed to the air
is not due to a contamination by germs derived from the atmo-
sphere, we have also the same right to conclude (2) that m many
cases the first organisms which appear in such fluids have arisen
de novo, rather than by any process of reproduction from pre-
existing forms of life.
Admitting, therefore, that Bacteria are ferments capable of
initiating putrefactive changes, I am a firm believer also in the
existence of not-living ferments under the influence of which
putrefactive changes may be initiated in certain fluids—changes
which are almost invariably accompanied by a new birth of living
particles capable of rapidly developing into Bucteria.
Feb. 27, 1873.—William Spottiswoode, M.A., Treasurer and Vice-
President, in the Chair.
“On Leaf-Arrangement.” By Hupert Arry, M.A., M.D.
Assuming as generally known the main facts of leaf-arrange-
ment, the division into the whorled and spiral types, and in
the latter more especially the establishment of the convergent
series of fractions 3, 4, 2, 3, 3, 3, 44, 24, 34 3, &e. as re-
presentatives of a corresponding series of spiral leaf-orders among
plants, we have to ask, what is the meaning that lies hidden in
this law ?
Mr. Darwin has taught us to regard the different species of
plants as descended from some common ancestor ; and therefore
we must suppose that the different leaf-orders now existing have
been derived by different degrees of modification from some com-
mon ancestral leaf-order.
One spiral order may be made to pass into another by a twist
of the axis that carries the leaves. This fact indicates the way in
which all the spiral orders may have been derived from one
original order, namely by means of different degrees of twist in
the axis.
We naturally look to the simplest of existing leaf-orders, the
two-ranked alternate order 4, as standing nearest to the original ;
for it is manifest that the orders at the other extreme of the
series (the condensed arrangement of scales on fir-cones, of florets
in heads of Composite, of leaves in close-lying plantains, &c.)
are special and highly developed instances, to meet special needs
of protection and congregation: they are, without doubt, the
latest feat of phyllotactic development; and we may be sure that
the course of change has been from the simple to the complex,
not the reverse. This point will be illustrated by experiment
below.
But first, what are the uses of these orders? and at what period
of the leaf’s life does the advantage of leaf-order operate? The
period must be that at which the leaf-order is most perfect—
not, therefore, when the twig is mature, with long internodes
between the leaves, but while the twig and its leaves are yet in
the bud; for it is in the bud (and similar crowded forms) that
Dr. H. Airy on Leaf- Arrangement. 387
the leaf-order is in perfection, undisturbed by contortions or
inequalities of growth; but as the bud develops into the twig
the leaves become separated, the stem often gets a twist, the leaf-
stalks are curved and wrung to present the blades favourably to
the light, and thus the leaf-order that was perfect in the bud is
disguised in the grown twig.
In lateral shoots of yew and bow and silver fir we see how leaves
will get their stalks twisted to obtain more favourable exposure to
light; and if general distribution round the stem were useful to
the adult leaves, we should expect the leaves of a vertical elm-shoot
(for example) to secure such distribution by various twists of stalk
and stem; but the leaf-blades of the elm keep their two ranks
with very great regularity. This goes to show that it is not in
the mature twig that the leaf-order is specially advantageous.
In the bud we see at once what must be the use of leaf-order.
It is for economy of space, whereby the bud is enabled to retire
into itself and present the least surface to outward danger and
vicissitudes of temperature. The fact that the order 3 does not
exhibit this advantage in any marked degree, supports the idea
that this order is the original from which all the more complex
spiral orders have been derived.
The long duration of the bud-life as compared with the open-
air life of the leaf gives importance to the conditions of the for-
mer. ‘The open-air life of the bud is twelve months, and adding
the embryo life of the bud, we have about a year and a half for
the whole life of the bud ; and for the twelve months of its open-
air life it is in a state of siege, against which a compact arrange-
ment of its embryo-leaves within must be of great value. But
the open-air life of the unfolded leaves is (except in evergreens)
not more than six months.
That the order 3 would under different degrees of contraction
(with twist) assume successively the various oe Grice that
exist in nature, in the order of their complexity, 3, 2, 3, y, &e.,
may be shown by the following experiment :—
Take a number of spheres (say oak-galls) to represent embryo
leaves, and attach them in two rows in alternate order (4) along
opposite sides of a stretched india-rubber band. Give the band a
slight twist, to determine the direction of twist in the subsequent
contraction, and then relax tension. The two rows of spheres will
roll up with a strong twist into a tight complex order, which, if
the spheres are attached in close contact with the axis, will be
nearly the order 4, with three steep spirals. If the spheres are set
a little away from the axis, the order becomes condensed into
(nearly) 2, with great precision and stability. And it appears
that further contraction, with increased distance of the spheres
from the axis, will necessarily produce the orders (nearly) #, +,
3, &c. in succession, and that these successive orders represent
successive maxima of stability in the process of change from the
simple to the complex.
25*
388 Royal Society :—
It also appears that the necessary sequence of these successive
steps of condensation, thus determined by the geometry of the
case, does necessarily exclude the non-existent orders, 7, 2, 3, 4,
, &C.
Ty umbering the spheres from 0 upwards, it appears that, under
contraction, the following numbers are brought successively into
contact with 0, alternately to right and left:—1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13,
21, 34, 55, 89, 144, &e. None of them stands vertically above 0
while in contact with it, but a little to the right or a little to the
left; and so far the results of this experiment fall short of the
perfect fractions 3, 2, 3, 54 &c.: but in this very failure the results
of the experiment are more closely in agreement with nature than
are those perfect fractions themselves ; for those fractions give the
angular divergence only in round numbers (so to speak), and lose
account of the little more, or the little less, which makes all the
difference between a vertical rank and a spiral. In the large
majority of spiral-leaved plants, one has to be content with “ 2
nearly ” or “ # nearly ;” and it is difficult to find a specimen in which
the fraction represents the order exactly.
The geometrical relations of the members of the above series
1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, &. are as simple as their numerical relations.
Analysis of the order seen in the head of the sunflower and
other examples, by consideration of their several sets of spirals,
presents a striking agreement with the above synthetical process.
In the sunflower, a marginal seed taken as 0 is found to be in
contact with the 34th, the 55th, and the 89th (counted in order
of growth), and even with the 144th, if there is not contact
with the 34th. The dandelion, with a lower degree of conden-
sation, has 0 in contact with the 13th, the 21st, and the 34th in
large specimens ; the house-leek in its leaf-order has 0 in con-
tact with the 5th, 8th, and 13th; the apple-bud has 0 in contact
with the 2nd, 3rd, and 5th; and thus we see that in nature the
very same series of numbers is found to have contact-relation
with 0 which we have already seen possessing that relation in
the experimental condensation of the order 3.
Difference of leaf-order in closely allied species (e.g. Plantago
major and P. coronopus) is found in close relation to their different
habits and needs.
The prevalence of the order 3 in marine Alga, and in Gramineae,
a low-developed gregarious group, and its singular freedom from
individual variation in that group and in elm, beech, &c., support
the view that this order is the original of the spiral orders.
In many plants we find actual transition from the order 3 to an
order more complex, as, for instance, in Spanish chestnut, laurels,
nut, wy; and these instances agree in presenting the complex
order in the buds that occupy the most exposed situations, while
they retain the simple 3 in the less-exposed lateral buds. Several
kinds of aloe have the order 3 in their basal leaves, and a higher
order in the remainder. A species of cactus often contains a
On a new Genus of Amphipod Crustaceans. 389
complete epitome of phyllotaxy in a single plant, or even in a
single shoot.
Shoots of acacia often present a zigzag disposition of then
leaves, on either side of the branch, which seems unintelligible
except as a distortion of an original two-ranked order.
The prevalent two-ranked arrangement of rootlets or roots seems
to be a survival underground of an order which originally pre-
vailed through the whole plant, root, stem, and branch.
In the whole Monocotyledonous class the first leaves in the seed
have the order 3.
In the Dicotyledonous class the first leaves in the seed have
the simplest order of the whorled type.
As the spiral orders have probably been derived from a two-
ranked alternate arrangement, so the whorled orders have pro-
bably been derived from a two-ranked collateral (two abreast)
arrangement. This is illustrated by an experiment similar to
the former; and it is seen that successive parallel horizontal pairs
of spheres are compelled under contraction to take position at right
angles to one another, exactly in the well-known crucial or
decussate order. These whorls of two contain potentially whorls
of three and four, as is seen in variations of the same plant ; but the
experiment does not show the change.
The reason of the non-survival of the (supposed) two-ranked
collateral order lies in its manifest instability; for under lateral
pressure it would assume the alternate, and under vertical the
crucial order.
The bud presents in its shape a state of equilibrium between
a force of contraction, a force of constriction, and a force of growth.
To sum up, we are led to suppose that the original of all existing
leaf-orders was a two-ranked arrangement, somewhat irregular,
admitting of two regular modifications, the alternate and the
collateral—and that the alternate has given rise to all the spiral
orders, and the collateral to all the whorled orders, by means of
advantageous condensation in the course of ages.
March 6, 1873.—Sir George Biddell Airy, K.C.B., President, in the
Chair.
“On anew Genus of Amphipod Crustaceans.” By Rupo.rx
von Wittemées-Sunm, Ph.D., Naturalist to the ‘Challenger’
Exploring-Expedition.
In lat. 35° 47’, long. 8° 23’, off Cape St. Vincent, the trawl
was sent down to a depth of 1090 fathoms on the 28th of
January, and brought up, among other very interesting things, a
large transparent Amphipod with enormous faceted eyes. The
animal, evidently hitherto unknown, will be the type of a new
genus, having the following characters :—
390 fioyal Society :—
THAUMOPS, nov. gen.
Caput oblongum, inflatum, oculis maximis superiorem capitis par-
tem tegentibus. Segmenta thoracica 6, abdominalia5. Anten-
narum in feminis par unum, maxillarum par unum, pedum
paria duo minima maxillarum locum tenentia. Mandibule
null. Pedes thoracici 5, abdominales 3 in utroque latere.
Appendices caudales 4. Gangliorum pectoralium paria 5,
abdominalium 3.
Thaumops pellucida, n. sp.
Corpus longitudine 14 mm., latitudine 21 mm., pellucidum.
An anatomical description of this interesting animal is given,
illustrated by two plates; and it is shown that, among the
Amphipods known to us, Phronima is its nearest relative. But
there are so many points in which this genus differs from Phronima,
that it cannot form a member of the family Phronimide; and
I therefore propose to establish for it a new family, Thaumopide,
belonging to the tribe of Hyperina.
The form of the head is totally different from that of Phronima ;
the antenne are not situated near the mouth, but at its front ;
and the enormous faceted eyes occupy its upper surface. The
first two pairs of thoracic appendages are not, as m Phronima,
ambulatory legs, but maxillipeds, so that only five pairs of legs
are ambulatory in Thaumops. The thorax is composed of six
segments—the first of which has, on its underside, the vulva
and one pair of maxillineds; and the second, representing two
segments, bears two pairs of appendages, the larger maxillipeds
and the first pair of ambulatory legs. The abdomen consists of
five segments, with three pairs of pedes spurii, the caudal appen-
dages being attached to the fourth and fifth segments.
The animal being beautifully transparent, the nervous system
could be carefully worked out without dissecting it; the position
of the nerves going out from the cephalic ganglion, as well as
that of the five pairs of thoracic and the three pairs of abdominal
ganglia, could be ascertained. The eyes, having at their borders
very peculiar appendages, were examined; and a description is
given of the structure of the large crystalline bodies which are
to be seen in them. Organs of hearing and touch have not been
discovered.
The mouth is covered by a pair of maxille and a small labinm.
There is a recurved cesophageal passage leading into a large
cecal stomach, and an intestinal tube departing from near the end
of the esophagus and running straight to the anus.
The heart is an elongated tube extending from the second to
the fifth segment, with probably three openings. Three pairs of
transparent sac-like gills are attached at the base of the second,
third, and fourth pairs of feet.
Genital organs.—The single specimen taken is a female. The
ovary, probably composed of two ovaries, has a rose-colour ; and
On the Distribution of the Invertebrata. 391
the genital papilla is situated at the under part of the first
segment ; it is covered by two small lamellew, which in this case
did not sustain the eggs, which were found to be attached to
the first pair of ambulatory legs. The animal seems to carry
them in a similar manner as the pyenogonid Nymphon.
Development.—The eggs contained embryos having already the
antenne, the five pairs of legs, and the abdominal feet ; they show
that Thawmops has to undergo no metamorphosis, and that the
young ones leave the eggs with all their appendages well de-
veloped.
Mode of life-—It could not be made out whether 7. pellucida
inhabits the deep sea, or whether it is, like Phronima, a pelagic
animal, having been caught by the trawl only as the latter came up
from the depths.
H.MLS. ‘Challenger,’ Teneriffe,
February 13, 1873.
March 20, 1873.—Mr. George Busk, Vice-President, in the Chair.
“On the Distribution of the Invertebrata in relation to the
Theory of Evolution.” By Joun D. Macponaxp, M.D., F.R.S.,
Staff Surgeon R.N., Assistant Professor of Naval Hygiene, Netley
Medical School.
All organized beings exhibit both structural and functional con-
ditions, forming the grounds of comparison by which natural
affinities in smaller groups, and points of difference in larger ones,
are detected and established in systematic classification.
General anatomical or physiological considerations in agree-
ment are usually of more importance than the harmony of single
or special conditions of either description; and though structural
characters, as a rule, are superior to those of a functional nature,
much may be learnt from an arrangement founded on physiological
principles alone. I have elsewhere pomted out the deceptiveness
of taking the habit of life as a guide in classification, though this
is adopted by many zoologists ; for essentially different types may
live under precisely similar circumstances, or the habit of life
may be very different in the members of the same type. Thus,
if we look upon a pectinate gill for aquatic respiration, fluviatile or
marine, and the amphibious coincidence of this with a pulmonary
chamber, or the presence of the latter cavity alone in purely
terrestrial Gasteropods, as grouping characters, nothing can be
more erroneous ; for all these conditions of the respiratory system
are to be met with in unequivocal examples of the same group,
anatomically defined, asin the Nerite alliance, or that of Rissoa for
example. Nevertheless animals so simple in their nature: as the
Protozoa may be distributed physiologically, with some show of
truthfulness in the resulting scheme.
Passing the leading types of the Protozoa in review, we notice
that the Gregarinide alone are essentially parasitic in their
habit of life, obtaining nutriment from materials elaborated by
392 ‘Royal Society :—On the Distribution of
other animals. All the rest are therefore non-parasitic, deriving
their sustenance from the outer world. If we now consider
the manner in which nutritious matters are taken up and assimi-
lated by these animals, we find that some of them must subsist
on organic substances in solution, which are absorbed by the
general surface of the body. Moreover we observe that this
takes place either indirectly through a more or less consistent
investing substance, or directly through the pores, foramina, or
fenestrations of the caleareous or siliceous capsules protecting
the contained sarcode bodies. In other instances, on the contrary,
solid food is actually consumed by mouthless beings, which simply
open their bodies to receive it; and this opening of the body
may take place at any part of the surface most convenient, or
it may be restricted to a definite locality, shadowing forth the
permanent mouth of the Stomatoda, or even that of the most
primitive form of Hydrozoa.
The annexed Table of arrangement is drawn up in accordance
with the foregoing remarks.
Physiological Classification of the Protozoa.
Habit of life and mode of nutrition :~-
1G JRERESTIR(G poscocriecdaqcog9eco9pnde Jund2oAbseeocsoKEdcodocednoer Gregarinide.
II. Non-parasitic.
A. Assuming food in a state of solution by absorption
of the general surface.
1. Indirectly through a medium
a. Forming a cell-like envelope ................2+0+. Thalassicollide.
6, Lining porous canals in the common mass ... Pordfera.
2. Directly through
a. The pores or foramina of a calcareous shell .... Foraminifera,
b. Fenestrations of a siliceous shell.................. Polycystina.
c. A more largely exposed surface .............00... Acanthometride.
B. Assuming solid food by an adventitious mouth.
1. At any part of the surface where the contact
ISHMAGE, |S uforae c seek clos dase es cesta eee ee eee Monera, Ameba, &c.
2. At a definite part, determined by the opening
ofithe'shell acces athreensecsessecanevesseescacees sescate Gromia, Difflugia, §e.
C. Assuming solid food by a permanent mouth,
1. The same orifice being also excretory............... Infusoria.
2. Discharging excreta by a rudimentary anus ...... Noctilucide.
This Table may be said to afford us good general grounds for
forming an estimate of the relative superiority of the several types
thus physiologically defined, and it is mainly in keeping with
their more commonly received distribution founded on structural
particulars.
A show of progressive improvement is seen in the respective
sections A, B, and C—though to all appearance the simplest
group of animals in existence, namely the Monera of Hiickel, is
included in the section B. These rudimentary creatures are
destitute of both nucleus and contractile vesicle, though exhibiting
activities in movement, taking food, and reproducing their kind,
not even second to those of Ameba and its allies. The smallest
ciliated molecule endowed with animal life could not present a
4
the Invertebrata in relation to Evolution. 393
more simple structure than that of the perfectly homogeneous
and jelly-like Monera. Indeed the evolution of any of the other
primitive forms from a plastic source like this is quite conceivable,
though of course we have no actual means of observing such a
transmutation.
Moreover the development of amceboids in some part of the
life-history of most Protozoa would appear to stamp that form
as the earliest genetic type of beings. With the exception of a
nucleus and a contractile vesicle, Ameba itself may have sprung
from Protameba; and the finally encysted jelly-globules of Proto-
myxa and My«astrum breaking up into naked ameeboids, or
pseudonavicelle liberating them, very strikingly suggest the source
from which the Gregarine may have been evolved.
The valuable researches of Mr. Archer, of Dublin, have brought
to light many very interesting freshwater Protozoa, thus much
augmenting our materials for comparison, and adding new zest to
inquiry as to their natural affinities or their probable origin and
derivatives.
If evolutionary forces are admitted to be in constant opera-
tion, it would be hard to say that any two existing forms should
stand to each other in the relation of source and product. It
would perhaps be safer to say that existing forms have taken
their origin from such forms as are still in existence; for as it
is but reasonable to suppose that in the lapse of time all the
members of the primary type must have undergone some change,
the -persistence of that type through all in its primitive state is
difficult to conceive, though, for any thing we yet know, this may
be the case.
Without indulging in this theme further, if we now seek for
the most probable derivatives of definite types of Protozoa, some
remarkable facts strike us, first, in relation to the Cestoid worms,
as bearing upon their possible derivation from the Gregarinide.
I have already noticed the affinity of the Gregarinidans them-
selves to Protomyxa and My«astrum amongst the Monera; but
when we find the hooklets of Tenia and the sucker-pits of Tenia
and Bothriocephalus shadowed forth in Hoplorhynchus and Actino-
cephalus respectively, we can scarcely help acknowledging the
alliance here indicated. Inthe Gregarinidx, moreover, there is not
only a distinct external integument, but Van Beneden has lately
demonstrated the existence of circular muscular fibres on its
inner surface; a similar habit of life in both cases is also very
significant. Nor would it be inconsistent to regard the Trematoda
and Nematoidea as further developments of the same series of
essentially internal parasites.
Now, although the Thalassicollide are not parasites, the genus
Thalassicolla and the Gregarine alone of all the simple Protozoa
take up their nutriment in solution, after the manner of the com-
pound forms, namely the Porifera, restricted Polycystina, and
Foraminifera. This fact, I think, is significant, as suggesting the
derivation of Gregarina from some such original as Thalassicolla,
394 Royal Society :—On the Distribution of
as it does not seem natural to suppose that the former, which is
so essentially an Entozoon, could have been descended from a stock
capable of assuming solid food in the outer world.
Dr. Carpenter unconsciously gives us the weight of his opinion
in the following quotations from his valuable work on the mi-
croscope. On page 449 he says, speaking of Spherozoum,
“Towards the inner surface of this (the outer) coat are scattered a
great number of oval bodies resembling cells, having a tolerably
distinct membraniform wall and a conspicuous round central
nucleus, thus corresponding closely with the Gregarina type.”
I might mention in passing that, having frequently taken in
the towing-net the unequivocal allies of Dictyocha with sarcode
bodies identical with those of Spherozowm, I have no hesitation
inassuming Dictyocha itself to belong rather to the Thalassicollide
than to the group with which it is more usually associated.
This family is commonly included under the head of Rhizopoda ;
and there can be no doubt that the generalization, irrespective
of that term, is a correct one; but it is a stretch of transcendental
anatomy to speak of the existence of pseudopodia in any member
of it. The radiating branched filaments within the dense external
investment of Thalassicolla nucleata are not extensions of the sar-
code body, like those of Gromia for example, but apparently act as
retinacula, and as conduits for dialytic currents, which may account
for the phenomenon of cyclosis observed in some instances.
Professor James-Clark, of Pennsylvania, appears to have satisfied
himself, at least, that there is a remarkable agreement of characters
exhibited between the Porifera and the Infusoria, which are
connected, as he endeavours to show, by a regular gradation of
animals. The derivation of the latter group of Protozoa from
the former, which I had myself assumed quite independently, is
therefore supported by that gentleman’s researches.
Even with our present advanced knowledge of the Infusoria
it is doubtful if we do not still include amongst them the larvee of
Turbellaria ; and, indeed, the passage from the one type to the
other would appear to be natural and easy. On the other hand,
tracing through such forms as Nemertes, Bonellia, and Priapulus,
Sipunculus will lead directly to the less-equivocal Echinodermata;
and here the series must wind up; for further evolution, though
perhaps possible, does not appear to have taken place.
The existence of such low or simple forms of Rotifera as the
genus Asplanchna, for example, would be favourable to the idea
that the Noctilucide might have been the progenitors of that order
of beings. It is of course quite gratuitous, but convenient, at
present to assume that the Noctilucide would thus hold the same
relationship to the Polycystina that the Infusoria appear to do to
the Porifera. However this may be, it is more certain that the
Rotifera are at the root of the annulose and articulate series.
From the Rotifera, through the Annelida, we may thus trace
the development of the crustaceous and chitinous types of Arti-
culata like a dichotomous branch.
the Invertebrata in relation to Evolution. 395
The Annelida may be linked with the Crustacea by means
of the Sagittide, whose exquisitely striped muscular fibres accord
to them a higher position than the other parts of their organization
would perhaps warrant them to take.
There is obviously a representative relationship between the
crustaceous Macrura, Anomura, and Brachyura and the chitinous
Myriopoda, Insecta, and Arachnida.
The earthworms and the leeches may help to fill up the gap
between the Chetopod Annelida and the Myriopoda (as, for
example, between the genera Geophilus and Nereis), though it must
be confessed that the existing links are inadequate, or they have
never been sufficiently made out.
The first rudiments of a tracheal system are probably to be sought
for in the Terricolous Annelida, though true articulated limbs and
a dorsal heart seem to make their first appearance in the Tulide.
Should the simplest hydroid polyps have sprung from such
Protozoa as Difflugia, Arcella, or Astrorhiza, with their pseudopodial
tentacula encircling a fixed oral point, the existence of a living
series from the lowest type of animals to that which is obviously
on the confines of the Vertebrata would be clearly demonstrable*.
Furthermore, as the interpolation of any other invertebrate types
would disturb the harmony here, the inference is natural that they
also might be distributed in a similar way into as many groups or
series as their affinities or antipathies would suggest or necessitate.
Having studied this subject very carefully, it appears to me
that the whole of the Invertebrata admit of distribution into four
distinct series, corresponding with the number of sections of the
Protozoa, from which all the other types may have taken their
origin. Thus, on dividing the Astomatous Protozoa into com-
pound types and their allied simple forms, we obtain the follow-
ing highly suggestive arrangement, in which the groups represent
each other soremarkably that they would seem to be quite natural.
* The annexed Table exhibits the progressive modification of the alimentary
system in ascending from the Hydrozoa to the Tunicata :—
Evolution of the Alimentary Canal in particular.
( With primary hamal
ih ie and final neural } Ascidiozoa.
Intestine insulated from
M th ti +t HOXUNO ie ctesteueses
aay © somatic cavity --- | With simple neural ) Brachiopoda
8 me hora) flaming: ii. tebacesset: and Polyzoa.
snophora) | Ttestine straight, and communicating with Ctenophora.
DHE LSOMALIC CHVIUY si. ccs caccenenncsnerceementetsy:
Intestine not yet developed ; stomach commu-
nicating with the somatic Cavity ........seeeee
True stomach not yet developed, its office being Hyd
: ydrozoa.
answered by the somatic cavity ......+0....e+ .
\ Actinozoa.
Ca@LENTERATA
Additional matter in the above connexion will be found in a paper by the
author “On the Morphological Relationships of the Molluscoida and Ceelen-
terata,” published in the Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, vol.
xxiii. part 3, 1864.
396 Royal Society.
I have appended the Stomatoda and the twelve remaining sections
of the Invertebrata in the order indicated by their affinities.
Scheme of Classification of Invertebrata,
Leading Types of Protozoa, aggregate or compound.
‘ 2. 3. 4.
Collosphera. Porifera. Polycystina. Foraminifera.
Corresponding simple forms.
Thalassicolla. Actinophrys. Acanthometra. | Ameeba.
Gregarina. Gromia. Podocyrtis. Difflugia.
Derivative types.
Cestoidea. Infusoria. Noctilucidz. Ceelenterata.
Trematoda. Turbellaria. Rotifera. Molluscoida.
Nematoidea. Sipunculide. Annelida. Mollusca.
Echinodermata. Articulata.
So as not to complicate the Table, | thought it better to sup-
plement it with the definition of the four leading types of compound
Protozoa.
1. In the Collosphera type, the sarcode bodies le at some
distance apart and are always distinct.
2. In the Porifera type the sarcode bodies are closely approxi-
mated or confluent.
3. In the Polyeystina type the sarcode bodies are concentric and
connected by radiating stolons.
4, In the Foraminifera type the sarcode bodies are connected
by stolons in linear series or some order of juxtaposition.
If it is incumbent upon the developmental hypothesis to derive
the Vertebrata from the preexisting Invertebrata, the only line
through which it would be possible to trace their descent is that
leading from the Protozoa to the Mollusca proper, or the fourth
series of the Table. It would also appear that the Entozoa,
Echinodermata, and Articulata appertam severally to separate
series of their own; and whatever may happen by-and-by, it
would be difficult to find, in the present fauna of the globe, a single
form clearly deducible from any of them.
The habit of life of the Entozoon, the pecularity of structure
of the Echinoderm, and the very perfection of organization of the
Articulata, as it were, preclude their evolution into any other
existing type. ‘To use a common phrase, they may be said to lead
nowhere, though they may be easily and, I think, consistently traced
back to their possible origin in the Protozoa.
It would be great presumption to say that even an approach to
perfection had been attained in this attempted classification of
a whole subkingdom of animals. Nevertheless, in the preceding
Table, the relationships existing amongst the members of that sub-
kingdom are presented to the eye at a single glance, and in a
manner that would be quite unattainable by systems maintaining
the original creation of every so-called species, and that in an
order perhaps more easily described than understood.
Miscellaneous. 397
MISCELLANEOUS.
Preliminary Notice of some Extinct Tortoises from the Islands of
Rodriquez and Mauritius. By Dr. Atburr Ginruer, F.R.S.
Some time ago M. L. Bouton, of Port Louis, sent me for examination
some Chelonian remains from Rodriguez and the Mauritius, and
more especially, among those from the latter island, a nearly com-
plete carapace. This collection has been supplemented by a series
of bones in the Geological Department of the British Museum, which
were discovered at the same time and at the same place with the
skeleton of Didus ineptus.
As some time must elapse before the plates illustrating my
description can be finished, I think it advisable to indicate the main
results of my examination.
All these tortoises belong to a group of gigantic land-tortoises,
characterized by a flat skull (type Testudo platyceps of Gray), and
by a dilated (not vertically compressed) symphysial bridge between
the foramina obturatoria.
The Rodriguez species is distinguished by very slender vertebra
and leg-bones, and by having the neural arch of the sixth cervical
vertebra perforated by a pair of large foramina. This species I have
named 7’. rodericensis.
Among the remains from the Mauritius two species can be readily
distinguished :—
One appears to have been the more common ; it has three serrated
dental ridges along the lower jaw, a peculiarity hitherto unknown
among recent land-tortoises: for this species I propose the name
Testudo triserrata.
The other is more sparingly represented, and distinguished by
various modifications in the form of the bones of all the limbs. I
distinguish it by the name Testudo inepta.
On the Dorsal Shield of Tolypeutes. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S, &e.
In the ‘Catalogue of Carnivorous and Edentate Mammalia (Bruta,
Linneus) in the British’ Museum,’ p. 385, I formed these animals
into a family (Z'olypeutide), from the manner in which they walk,
and on account of the dorsal disk being partially free from the back
of the body; but only being able to examine a living specimen,
which I was afraid of injuring, I believed that the disk was attached
to the middle of the back, which is found not to be the case when
one can examine more carefully a specimen preserved in spirits.
Mr. Edward Gerrard, Jun., has sold two specimens of the
Mataco (Tolypeutes conwrus) to the British Museum, which had been
preserved in spirits; and he has pointed out to me that these speci-
mens show that the dorsal disk of these animals is quite free from
the body of the animal, except in three places—(1st) at the front end
round the neck, (2nd) on the sides at the margin inside the three
median dorsal rings, and (3rd) over the pelvis and round the caudal
398 Miscellaneous.
end of the shield ; so that, in fact, it is even more free than in Chla-
mydophorus.
In these places it is united by an extension of the skin of the body,
which from these parts extends over the whole internal surface of
the disk. The whole outer surface of the bony disk is also covered
by a very thin skin, which is visible and easily rubs off the animal
that has been preserved in spirit.
The male and female are very like one another in external ap-
pearance ; but the penis of the male is very large, and fusiform.
Observations on the Structure of the Proboscis of an Hermaphrodite
Nemertian from the Marseilles Coast. By M. E. Zev.
M. Marion has described, under the name of Borlasia Kefersteinii,
a curious Nemertian, the examination of which proves with certainty
the occasional hermaphrodism of the Turbellaria of this group. The
importance of this anatomical fact leads me to present to the Academy
the results of some investigations made in the laboratory of the
«“ Ecole pratique des Hautes Etudes” of Marseilles, under the direction
of M. Marion, in consequence of which it has been ascertained that
the Borlasia parasitic upon Phallusia mamillata, so frequent in the
gulf, must be united with B. Kefersteinii, with which it presents the
same sexual organization. It will therefore in future be easy to
meet with this species, which always exists in great abundance on
the branchial tissue of the Ascidia. The anatomical examination of
more than sixty individuals has revealed to me some peculiarities,
often not very observable, in the structure and functions of .the
proboscis.
The greatly developed proboscis extends in the dorsal region of
the animal from the ganglia to the anus, where it is recurved so as
to attach itself to the walls of the general cavity. I have distinguished
five parts, namely :—1, a protractile region; 2, a bulb of the style;
3, a poison-sac; 4, a glandular region ; and 5, a muscular region.
The walls of the first four parts of this organ are formed by longi-
tudinal and transverse muscles; the muscular region seems to be
formed entirely by longitudinal muscles.
The protractile region is equal to about one third of the total
length of the proboscis; it passes between the commissures of the
cerebral ganglia, is reflexed, and fixed by its terminal portion to the
membrane which covers these ganglia. On its muscular envelope
we may distinguish a transparent homogeneous layer, roughened
with pretty thick papille, resembling more or less elongated mamille,
upon which I have not observed any vibratile cilia.
Behind this region is placed the bulb of the style, of a more or
less rounded form, in the centre of which is arranged the apparatus
of attack. The point, which is much drawn out, penetrates by a
small aperture into the inferior portion of the protractile part. It is
fixed at its base in a sort of ring or ridge which surmounts the haft.
The mass of the haft appears to be granular and brownish.
The style does not float freely in the centre of the bulb. It is
Miscellaneous. 399
placed in a sac having the form of two truncated cones one above
the other; that in which the haft plays rises nearly to the height
of the ring. The margins of this sac appear to be attached to the
haft by muscles destined to facilitate the movements of the style.
On the two sides of the upper region of the bulb are the styligenous
pouches, three in number. These are ovoid cavities, two of which
are placed horizontally on each side of the base of the haft, with
ducts which, starting from the extremity near the base of the style,
are directed towards its point. (I have not been able to determine
exactly where these ducts open.) The third was on the right, and
placed vertically. Most frequently they contain three darts; but in
many individuals I have found four and even five, surrounded by
their basal ring and arranged symmetrically in accordance with the
longer axis of the pouches.
I have several times observed in these pouches, as Claparéde had
done in 1869 in Tetrastemma varicolor, the presence of a transparent
vesicle ; sometimes also I have seen this vesicle containing a dart
in course of formation, as has been indicated in other species by
Claparéde, Schultze, and Keferstein.
In all these Nemertians I have detected above the styliferous
apparatus a more or less blackish layer, which is no doubt a secretory
apparatus. In those individuals in which the style was in process
of formation this layer appeared to me to be thicker; it entirely
enveloped the styligenous pouches. The mass which separates these
pouches from the enveloping muscles is formed by fine pigment-
granules.
The poison-sae follows the bulb of the style. It is rounded, and
the muscular layer which envelops it is much thicker than in the
other parts of the proboscis ; it keeps in reserve the liquid produced
by the glandular region. From this sac a duct starts, which traverses
the bulb and opens near the point of the style.
Last comes the glandular region, which terminates the muscular
region, and the interior of which is filled with numerous vesicles
containing little granular drops of an oily appearance, penetrating
into the poison-sac in proportion as the latter is projected out of the
animal. J have always seen this part of the proboscis occupied by
these vesicles, just as the poison-sac was filled with the liquid which
has to flow from it.
When the animal has to project its proboscis we see the muscular
region take on a vermicular movement, which is communicated to
the glandular region, and carries with it the liquid of the general
cavity, which collects in front of the cephalic lobes and compels the
anterior part of the proboscis to fold like the finger of a glove and
penetrate into the canal which separates it from the orifice of issue.
The canal, formed of very powerful muscles, plays an important part
in the projection of the proboscis. The protractile region penetrates
into it with difficulty ; but as soon as a part of it projects under the
influence of the liquids accumulated in the cul-de-sac, we see it issue
with very great rapidity, in consequence of the pressure of these
muscles upon the part which is still in the interior.
400 Miscellaneous.
The repeated movements of the inferior region of the proboscis
quickly produce such a pressure in the anterior part that it is soon
projected. Compressed at the same moment by the muscles of the
canal just mentioned, the bulb becomes terminal ; and we notice the
jerking-movements of the style at the same time that a granular
liquid flows through an aperture situated near its point.
The movements which act in the projection of the proboscis serve
equally to accumulate the liquid of the glandular region at the
entrance of the poison-sac. The muscles which surround this sac
contract in such a way that the anterior region seems to approach
the posterior region. The same mechanism is produced in the bulb.
It is this combination of movements that causes the issue of the
point of the style at the same time as the flow of poison. As soon
as the poison-sac has allowed a certain quantity of liquid to escape,
this is immediately replaced by that contained in the glandular
region.
The return of the proboscis is effected by the inverse contraction
of the muscles of the canal and protractile region. ‘These observa-
tions justify us in regarding the muscular region as the principal
motor of the proboscis.—Comptes Rendus, April 14, 1873, tome
Ixxvi. pp. 966-969.
French Measures. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
French measure is being used by several scientific writers, being
chiefly introduced by translators of French elementary books,
who are too idle to reducethe French to the relative English measures;
for there can be no doubt of the greater convenience of the English
foot, inch, and line, being adapted to the different sizes of the things
wished to be measured. Few people but can tell you what is a
foot and what is an inch, and give a close approximation to the size
in feet and inches of any thing you show to them ; but I have never
found a person using a French measure who could tell you the size
of 190 millimetres, though he could tell what was the length of 74
inches, which is within a very little of the same thing.
It may be of some advantage to give such persons an idea of a
size mentioned to be informed that a decimetre, or L00 millimetres,
is about the usual length of a man’s fore finger, from the tip of the
nail to the back of the knuckle when the finger is bent down, and
that the first joint of the finger when bent down is as nearly as
possible 25 millimetres, or a fourth part.
I challenged a well-known physiologist who has long used
French measure to give me his idea of the measure of certain things
lying before him; and he declined to guess, and was surprised at the
accuracy with which I could guess them by this simple means. The
decimetre is as nearly as possible 4 inches, which is the usual length
of the fore finger ; and the first joint, as nearly as possible a quarter
the length of the fore finger, an inch or 25 millimetres long.
THE ANNALS
MAGAZINE OF NATURAL HISTORY.
[FOURTH SERIES. ]
No. 66. JUNE 1873.
XLV.— On the Advantage of a Dominant Language for Science.
By ALPHONSE DE CANDOLLE, Corresponding Member of the
Académie des Sciences, Foreign Member of the Royal and
Linnean Societies, &c.*
Av the period of the Renaissance Latin was the language
employed by all the learned men of Europe. It had been
carefully preserved by the Romish Church; and not one of the
modern languages presented, at that time, a sufficiently rich
literature to become its rival. But. at a later period the Refor-
mation disturbed the unity of the Romish influence. Italian,
Spanish, French, and English gained successively regular
idioms, and became rich in literary productions of every kind ;
and at last, 80 or 100 years ago at most, the progress of science
caused the inconvenience of the use of Latin to be felt. It
was a dead language, and, in addition to that, was wanting in
clearness, owing to its inversions, to its abbreviated words, and
to the absence of articles. There existed at that time a general
desire to describe the numerous discoveries that were being
made, and to explain and discuss them without the necessity
of seeking for words. The almost universal pressure of these
causes was the reason for the adoption of modern languages in
most sciences, natural history being the only exception: for
this Latin is still employed, but only in descriptions—a special
and technical part, where the number of words is limited and
* The fifth chapter of the ‘Histoire des Sciences et des Savants depuis
deux siécles,’ 8vo, Genéve, 1873: London, Dulau. Translated by Miss
_ Miers, by permission of the author.
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4, Vol. xi. 26
402 M. A. de Candolle on the Advantage
the construction very regular. Speaking truly, what natura-
lists have preserved is the Latin of Linneus, a language in
which every word is precise in meaning, every sentence
arranged logically, clearly, and in a way employed by no
Roman author. Linnzeus was not a linguist: he knew but
little even of modern languages; and it is evident that he
struggled against many difficulties when he wrote im Latin.
With a very limited vocabulary and a turn of mind which
revolted equally from the periods of Cicero and the reticence
of Tacitus, he knew how to create a language precise in its
terms, appropriate to the description of forms, and intelligible
to students. He never made use of a term without first
defining it. To renounce this special language of the learned
Swede would be to render descriptions less clear and less
accessible to the savans of all nations. If we attempt to
translate into the Latin of Linneeus certain sentences in modern
Floras, written in English or German, we quickly perceive a
want of clearness. In English the word smooth applies equally
to glaber and levis*. In German the construction of sentences
indicating generic or other characters is sometimes so obscure
that I have found it impossible, in certain cases, to have them
put into Latin by a German, a good botanist, who was better
acquainted than myself with both languages. It would be still
worse if authors had not introduced many words, purely Latin,
into their language. But, exclusive of paragraphs relative to
characters, and wherever successive phenomena or theories are
in question, the superiority of modern languages is unquestion-
able; it is on this account that, even in natural history, Latin
is every day less employed.
The loss, however, of the link formerly established between
scientific men of all countries has made itself felt. From this
has arisen a very chimerical proposal to form some artificial
language, which should be to all nations what writing is to
the Chinese. It was to be based on ideas, not words. The
problem has remained quite devoid of solution ; and even were
it possible, it would be so complicated an affair, so impracti-
cable and inflexible, that it would quickly drop into disuse.
The wants and the circumstances of each epoch have brought
about a preference for one or other of the principal European
languages as a means of communication between enlightened
men of all countries. French rendered this service during
two centuries. At present various causes have modified the
[* The word glaber in botany means bald, or not hairy, which is applied
to other parts as well as the head; and /evis smooth, not rough; but I
know they have both been carelessly translated ‘smooth,’ as M. de
Candolle implies.—J. E. G.]
of a Dominant Language for Science. 403
use of this language in other countries, and the habit has been
almost everywhere introduced that each nation should employ
its own tongue. We have therefore entered upon a period of
confusion. What is thought to be new in one country is not
so to those who read books in other languages. It is vain to
study living languages more and more ; you are always behind-
hand in the complete knowledge of what is being published in
other countries. Few persons are acquainted with more than
two languages ; andif we try to pass beyond a certain limit in
this respect, we rob ourselves of time for other things; for
there is a point at which the study of the means of knowledge
hinders our learning. Polyglott discussions and conversations
do not answer the intentions of those who attempt them. I
am persuaded that the inconvenience of such a state of things
will be more and more felt. I also believe, judging by the
example of Greek as used by the Romans, and French in
modern times, that the need of a prevailing language is almost
always recognized ; it is returned to from necessity after each
period of anarchy. To understand this we must consider the
causes which make a language preferable, and those which
spread its employment in spite of any defects it may possess.
Thus in the 17th and 18th centuries motives existed for the
employment of French in preference to Latin throughout
Europe. It was a language spoken by the greater part of the
educated men of the period, a language tolerably simple and
very clear. It had an advantage in its resemblance-to Latin,
which was then widely known. An Englishman, a German,
was already half acquainted with French through his know-
ledge of Latin; a Spaniard, an Italian, was three parts
advanced in his study of the language. If a discussion were
sustained in French, if books were written or translations made
in the language, all the world understood.
In the present century civilization has much extended north
of France, and population has increased there more than to
the south. The use of the English tongue has been doubled
by its extension into America. ‘The sciences are more and more
cultivated in Germany, in England, in the Scandinavian
countries, and Russia. The scientific centre of gravity has
advanced from the south towards the north.
Under the influence of these new conditions a language can
only become predominant by presenting two characters: 1st, it
must possess sufficient German and Latin words or forms to
be within reach at once of the Germans and of the people who
make use of Latin tongues ; 2nd, it must be spoken by a con-
siderable majority of civilized people. In addition to these
two essential conditions it would be well for the definitive
26*
404 M. A. de Candolle on the Advantage
success of a language that it should also possess the qualities
of grammatical simplicity, of conciseness, and clearness.
English is the only language which may, in fifty or a hun-
dred years, offer all these conditions united.
The language is half German and half Latin. « It possesses
German words, German forms, and also French words and a
French method of constructing sentences. It is a transition
between the principal languages used at present in science, as
French was formerly between Latin and several of the modern
languages.
The future extension of the Anglo-American tongue is evi-
dent. It will be rendered inevitable by the movement of the
populations in the two hemispheres. Here is the proof, which
it is easy to give in a few words and a few figures.
At the present time the population stands thus (Almanach
de Gotha, 1871) * :-—
English-speaking peoples—in England 31 millions, in the
United States 40, in Canada &e. 4, in Australia and New
Zealand 2: total 77.
German-speaking peoples—in Germany and a portion of
Austria 60, in Switzerland (German cantons) 2: total 62.
French-speaking peoples—in France 363, im Belgium
(French portion) 24, in Switzerland (French cantons) 4, in
Algeria and the Colonies 1: total 404.
Now, judging by the increase that has taken place in the
present century, we may estimate the probable growth of
population as follows T :—
millions.
In England it doubles in 50 years; therefore in a century
(1970) tt willbe ee on
In the United States, in Canada, in Australia, it doubles
in 29; therefore if willbe |... » >.» -.,eeeenneeeel
124
Probable total of the English-speaking race in 1970 . 860
In Germany the northern population doubles in 56 to 60
years, that of the south in 167 years. Let us suppose
100 years for the average. It will probably be in
1970, for the countries of German speech, about . 124
In the French-speaking countries the population doubles
in about 140 years. In 1970, therefore, it will pro-
bably amount to . -) del ey Wyuna dee ghee
694
_* No notice is here taken of the English-speaking people in India and
the East.—J. E. G.
+ Almanach de Gotha, 1870, p. 1039.
of a Dominant Language for Science. 405
Thus the three principal languages spoken at the present
time will be spoken a century hence with the following
progression :—
millions.
The English tongue will have increased from 77 to 860
The German 5 a from 62 to 124
The French 5 5 from 403 to 693
The individuals speaking German will form a seventh
part, and those speaking French a twelfth or thirteenth part
of those of English tongue; and both together will not forra
a quarter of the individuals speaking English. The German
or French countries will then stand towards those of English.
speech as Holland or Sweden do at present with regard to
themselves. I am far from having exaggerated the growth
of the Anglo-Australian-American populations. Judging by
the surface of the countries they occupy, they will long continue
to multiply in large proportion. ‘he English language is,
besides, more diffused than any other throughout Africa and
Southern Asia. America and Australia are not, I confess,
countries in which the culture of letters and sciences is so
much advanced as in Europe; and it is probable that, for a
length of time, agriculture, commerce, and industry will absorb
all the most active energies. I acknowledge this. But it is
no less a fact that so considerable a mass of intelligent and
educated men will weigh decisively on the world in general.
These new peoples, English in origin, are mingled with a
German element, which, in regard to intellectual inclinations,
counterbalances the Irish. They have generally a great
eagerness for learning and for the application of discoveries.
They read much. Works written in English or translated into
that tongue would, in a vast population, have a very large
sale. ‘l'his would be an encouragement for authors and trans-
lators that is offered by neither the French nor the German
language. We know in Europe to what degree difficulties
exist in the publication of books on serious subjects ; but open
an immense mart to publishers, and works on the most special
subjects will have a sale. When translations are read by
ten times as many people as at present, it is evident that a
greater number of books will be translated ; and this will con-
tribute in no small degree towards the preponderance of the
English language. Many French people already buy English
translations of German books, just as Italians buy translations
in French. If English or American publishers would adopt
the idea of having translations made into their language of the
best works that appear in Russian, Swedish, Danish, Dutch,
406 M. A. de Candolle on the Advantage
&c., they would satisfy a public dispersed over the whole
world, and particularly the numerous Germans who understand
English. Yet we are but at the beginning of the numerical
preponderance of the English-speaking populations.
The nature of a language does not, at first sight, appear to
have very great influence on its diffusion. French was pre-
ferred for two centuries; and yet Italian was quite as clear,
more elegant, more harmonious, had more affinity with Latin,
and, for a length of time, had possessed a remarkable literature.
The number, the activity of the French, and the geographical
position of their country were the causes of their preponderance.
Yet the qualities of a language, especially those preferred by
the moderns, are not without their influence. At the present
time briefness, clearness, grammatical simplicity are admired.
Nations, at least those of our Indo-European race, began by
speaking in an obscure complicated manner; in advancing they
have simplified and made their language more precise. Sanscrit
and Basque, two very ancient languages, are exceedingly
complicated. Greek and Latin are so in less degree. The
languages derived from Latin are clothed in clearer and simpler
forms. Ido not know how philosophers explain the pheno-
menon of the complication of language at an ancient period ;
but it is unquestionable. It is more easy to understand the
subsequent simplifications. When a more easy and convenient
method of acting or speaking has been arrived at, it is natu-
rally preferred. Besides, civilization encourages individual
activity ; and this necessitates short words and short sentences.
The progress of the sciences, the frequent contact of persons
speaking different languages, and who find a difficulty in
understanding each other, lead to a more and more imperious
need for clearness. You must have received a classical edu-
cation to avoid the perception of absurdity in the construction
of an ode of Horace. ‘Translate it literally to an uneducated
workman, keeping each word in its place, and it will have to
him the effect of a building the entrance-door of which is on
the third story. It is no longer a possible language, even in
poetry.
Modern languages have not all, to the same degree, the
advantages now demanded, of clearness, simplicity, and
briefness.
The French language has shorter words and less complicated
verbs than the Italian: this, in all probability, has contributed
to its success. The German has not undergone the modern
evolution by which each sentence or portion of a sentence
begins with the principal word. Words are also cut in two
and the fragments dispersed. It has three genders, whereas
of a Dominant Language for Science. 407
French and Italian have but two. ‘The conjugations of many
verbs are rather complicated. Nevertheless modern tendencies
weigh with the Germans, and it is evident that their language
is becoming a little modified. Scientific authors especially
exert themselves to attempt the direct modes of expression and
the short phrases of other countries, in the same way that they
have abandoned the Gothic printed letters. Should they
correspond with strangers, they often have the politeness to
write in Latin characters. They willingly introduce in their
publications terms taken from foreign languages, modifications
sometimes merely of form, occasionally fundamental. These
attest the modern spirit and the enlightened judgment of the
learned men so numerous in Germany. Unhappily the modi-
fications of form have no great importance, and the fundamental
changes take place very slowly.
The more practical English language shortens sentences and
words. It willingly takes possession of foreign words, as
German does ; but of cabriolet it makes cab, of memorandum it
makes mem. It makes use only of indispensable and natural
tenses—the present, the past, the future, and the conditional.
There is no arbitrary distinction of genders : animated objects
are masculine or feminine ; the others are neuter. The ordi-
nary construction is so sure to begin with the principal idea
that in conversation you may often dispense with the necessity
of finishing your sentences. ‘The chief fault of the English
language, its inferiority in comparison with German or Italian,
consists in an orthography absolutely irregular, and so absurd
that children take a whole year in learning to read*. The
pronunciation is not well articulated, not well defined. I
shall not go as far as Madame Sand in her amusing impreca-
tions on this point ; but there is truth in what she says. The
vowels are not distinct enough. But, in spite of these faults,
English, according to the same clever writer, is a well-ex-
pressed language, quite as clear as any other, at least when
English people choose to revise their MSS., which they will
not always do; they are in such a hurry!
English terms are adapted to modern wants. Do you wish
to hail a vessel, to cry “‘stop”’ to a train, to explain a machine,
to demonstrate an experiment in physics, to speak in few words
to busy and practical people, it is the language par excellence.
In comparison with Italian, with French, and, above all, with
* Surprised, on one occasion, by the slowness with which intelligent
English children learnt reading, I inquired the reason. Lach letter has
several sounds, or you may say that each sound is written in several ways.
It is therefore necessary to learn reading word for word. It is an affair
of memory.
408 M. A. de Candolle on the Advantage
German, English has the effect, to those who speak several
languages, of offering the shortest cut from one point to an-
other. I have observed this in families where two languages
are equally well known, which often occurs in Switzerland.
When the two languages are German and French, the latter
almost always carries the day. ‘‘Why?” Lasked of a German
Swiss established in Geneva. “I can scarcely tell you,’ he
replied ; ‘‘at home we speak German to exercise my son in the
language ; but he always falls back into the French of his
comrades, French is shorter, more convenient.” Before the
events of 1870, a great Alsatian manufacturer sent his son to
study at Zurich. I was curious to know the reason why.
““ We cannot,” he said, ‘‘ induce our children to speak Ger-
man, with which they are quite as familiar as with French.
I have sent my son to a town where nothing but German is
spoken, in order that he may be forced to speak it.” In such
preferences you must not look for the causes in sentiment or
tancy. When a man has choice of two roads, one straight
and open, the other crooked and difficult to find, he is sure to
take, almost without reflection, the shorter and more convenient
one. I have also observed families where the two languages
known in the same degree were English and French. In this
case the English maintained supremacy, even in a French-
speaking land. It is handed down from one generation to
another ; it is employed by those who are in haste, or who want
to say something in as few words as possible. ‘The tenacity of
French or English families established in Germany in speaking
their own language, and the rapid disappearance of German in
the German families established in French or English countries,
may be explained by the nature of the languages rather than
by the influence of fashion or education.
The general rule is this :—In the conflict of two languages,
every thing else being equal, it is the most concise and the
most simple that conquers. [French beats Italian and Ger-
man; English beats the other languages. In short, it need
only be said that the more simple a language is, the more easy
it is to be learnt, and the more quickly can it be made avail-
able for profitable employment.
The English language has another advantage in family use :
its literature is the one most suitable to feminine tastes; and
every one knows how great is the influence of mothers on the
language of children. Not only do they teach what is called
‘the mother tongue,” but often, when well educated, they feel
pleasure in speaking a foreign language to their children.
They do so gaily, gracefully. The young lad who finds his
of a Dominant Language for Science. 409
language-master heavy, his grammar tiresome, thinks very
differently when his mother, his sister, or his sister’s friend
addresses herself to him in some foreign tongue. This will
often be English—and for the best of reasons: there is no
language so rich in works (written in a spirit of true morality)
upon subjects which are interesting to women—teligion, educa-
tion, fiction, biography, poetry, &e.
The future preponderance of the language spoken by Eng-
lish, Australians, and Americans thus appears to me assured.
The force of circumstances leads to this result; and the nature
of the language itself must accelerate the movement.
The nations who speak the English tongue are thus bur-
thened with a responsibility which it is well they should recog-
nize at once. It is a moral responsibility towards the civilized
world of the coming centuries.
Their duty, as it is also their interest, is to maintain the
present unity of the language, at the same time admitting the
necessary or convenient modifications which may arise under
the influence of eminent writers, or be arranged by common
consent. ‘The danger to be feared is that the English lan-
guage may, before another century has passed, be broken up
into three languages, which would be in the same relation to
each other as are Italian, Spanish, and Portuguese, or as
Swedish and Danish.
Some English authors have a mania for making new
words. Dickens has invented several. Yet the English lan-
guage already possesses many more words than French, and
the history of its literature shows that there is greater need to
suppress than to add to the vocabulary. No writer for three
centuries past has employed nearly so many different words as
Shakspeare ; therefore there must have been many unneces-
sary ones. Probably every idea and every object had formerly
a term of Saxon origin and one of Latin or French origin,
without counting Celtic or Danish words. The very logical
operation of time has been to suppress the double or triple
words. Why reestablish them? A people so economical in
its use of words does not require more than one term for each
thing *.
The Americans, on the other hand, make innovations of accent
or orthography (they almost always spell labour “ labor,” and
harbour, “harbor”’). he Australians will do the same if they
do not take care. Why should not all possess the noble am-
* A clever English writer has just published a volume on the institu-
tions of the people called Swiss in English, He names them Switzers.
For what reason? Will there soon be Deutschers ?
410 M. A. de Candolle on the Advantage
bition of giving to the world one uniform concise language,
supported by an immense literature and spoken in the next
century by 800 or 1000 millions of civilized men? ‘To other
languages it would be as a vast mirror in which each would
become reflected, thanks to newspapers and translations, and all
the friends of intellectual culture would have a convenient
medium for the interchange of ideas. It would be rendering
an immense service to future races; and at the same time the
authors and men of science of English-speaking race would
give a strong impulsion to their own ideas. The Americans,
above all, are interested in this stability, since their country is
to be the most important of those of English tongue. How
can they acquire a greater influence over Old England than
by speaking her language with exactness ?
The liberty of action permitted amongst people of English
race adds to the danger of a division in the language. Hap-
pily, however, certain causes which broke up the Latin lan-
guage do not exist for English nations. The Romans con-
quered nations the idioms of which were maintained or reap-
peared here and there in spite of administrative unity. The
Americans and Australians, on the contrary, have before them
only savages, who disappear without leaving any trace. The
Romans were conquered and dismembered in their turn by the
barbarians. Of their ancient civilization no evidence of unity
remained, unless it was in the Church, which has itself felt the
influence of the universal decline. The Americans and Austra-
lians possess many flourishing schools; they have the lite-
rature of England as well as their own. If they choose, they
can wield their influence by means of maintaining the unity
of the language. Certain circumstances make it possible for
them to do so; thus the teachers and professors mostly come
from the States of New England. If these influential men
truly comprehend the future destiny of their country, they will
use every effort to transmit the language in its purity; they
will follow classic authors and discard local innovations and
expressions. In this question of language, real patriotism (or,
if you will, the patriotism of Americans really ambitious for
their country) ought to be to speak the English of Old Eng-
Jand, to imitate the pronunciation of the English, and to fol-
low their whimsical orthography until changed by themselves.
Should they obtain this of their countrymen, they would
render to all nations and to their own an unquestionable benefit
for futurity.
The example of England proves the influence of education
upon the unity of a language. It is the habitual contact of
of a Dominant Language for Science. 411
educated people and the perusal of the same books which, little
by little, is causing the disappearance of Scotch words and
accent. A few years more, and the language will be uniform
throughout Great Britain. The principal newspapers, edited
by able men, also exercise a happy influence in preserving
unity. Whole columns of ‘The Times’ are written in the
language of Macaulay and Bulwer, and are read by millions
of people: the result is an impression which maintains the
public mind in a proper literary attitude.
In America the newspaper articles are not so well written ;
but the schools are accessible to all classes, and the universi-
ties count amongst their professors men especially accomplished
in their use of the English tongue. If ever there should arise
a doubt in the opinions of the two countries as to the advisa-
bility of modifying the orthography, or even making changes
in the language, it would be an excellent plan to organize a
meeting of delegates from the principal universities of the
Three Kingdoms, of America, and Australia, to propose and
discuss such changes. Doubtless they would have the good.
sense to make as few innovations as possible; and, thanks to
common consent, the advice would probably be followed. A
few modifications in the orthography alone would render the
English language more easy to strangers, and would contri-
bute towards the maintenance of unity in pronunciation
throughout Anglo-American countries.
Notes by Dr. J. E. Gray.
It may be observed, in addition, that the people who use
the English language in different parts of the world are a
reading and book-buying people, and especially given to the
study of scientific or quasi-scientific books, as is proved by
the tact of the extensive sale which they command.
In support of this assertion I may quote the Baron Férus-
sac’s review of Wood’s ‘ Index 'Testaceologicus,’ in the Bull.
Sci. Nat. Paris, 1829, p. 375. He remarks :—
“¢ We observe with interest the number of subscribers that
exist in England for an octavo volume on shells, cost-
ing 186 francs. It is a curious fact, which booksellers and
authors will appreciate, as it will afford them the means of
seeing how a return is obtained for their outlay on such works
in England, compared with other countries. The number of
subscribers is 280, of which 34 are females and 6 foreigners.
Certainly all the rest of Europe could not produce as many,
nor perhaps even the half of that number.”’
412 On a Dominant Language for Science.
How much more astonished would M. Férussac have been, if
informed that these were only the subscribers before publica-
tion, and that 1000 copies were sold! Since 1829 the sale of
scientific books has much increased, as is shown, for example,
by the many editions of the works of Lyell and other naturalists,
each edition being of 1000 copies.
Most scientific books in France and other continental coun-
tries can only be published when the Government furnishes the
cost ; and they are chiefly published in an expensive form as a
national display, and are almost confined to their public libra-
ries, except the sale of copies that are bought by English
collectors.
In England such works are generally published by indi-
vidual enterprise, and depend on the general public for their
support, and are published in a style to suit the different
classes. Thus there are works of luxury for the rich, often
published by individuals who confine themselves to the pro-
duction of that class of books, very cheap works for the stu-
dent and mechanic, and books of all intermediate grades, pro-
duced by the regular publishers. The females of all grades
are extensive readers of this class of books, which I believe is
chiefly the case with English-speaking races.
Some of the scientific Swedes and Russians have published
their papers in the English language, or appended an abstract
in English to them, as Thorell on European spiders, Prof.
Lilljeborg on Lysianassa, and Prof. Wackerbarth on the
planet Leda, &e. &e. The Danes and Dutch often publish
their scientific papers in French, as ‘Temminck, Reinhardt,
and the late Prof. Van der Hoeven, who themselves read and
write English ; but it appears they regard French as the polite
language of courts, and forget that courtiers generally have a
contempt for science and that they should look among the
people for their readers.
It is to be observed that Professor de Candolle himself uses
the French language with a very English construction ; but we
believe that his work would have commanded the greatest
number of readers if written in the English language, which
he reads and writes so fluently.
See also Mr. Galton’s interesting article on the Causes
which create Scientific Men, in the ‘Fortnightly Review’ for
March 1873, p. 346, which contains some interesting observa-
tions on M. de Candolle’s work.
On the Paleozoic Bivalved Entomostraca. 413
XLVI.—Notes on the Paleozoic Bivalved Entomostraca. No. X.
Entomis and Entomidella. By Prof. T. Rupert JONEs,
F-R.S., F.G.S.
THESE two genera of Paleozoic Bivalved Entomostraca are
little known, though comprising several wide-spread species,
found in Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous strata. ‘T’o
draw attention to these small but well-marked and abundant
fossils, by offering a synopsis of their species, will be useful, it
is hoped, to paleontologists.
I. Entomis, Jones, 1861.
Cypridina, De Koninck, 1841. Mém. Acad. R. Se. Belg. vol. xiv. p. 18;
1844, Descr. Anim. foss. Terr. Carb. Belg. p. 587.
Cypridina, G. Sandberger, 1842. Leonh. u. Bronn’s Jahrb. f. 1842,
p- 226; 1845. Jahrb. Ver. Nat. Nassau, Heft ii. p. 121; G. & F.
Sandberger, Verst. Rhein. Sch. Nassau, p. 4.
Cypridina, F. A. Romer, 1854. Paleeontographica, vol. iii.; Beitr.
Harzgeb. pp. 19, 28, 42.
Cypridina, Richter, 1856, Denksch. math.-nat, Cl. k. Akad, Wien,
vol. xi.; Beitr. Palaont. Thiir. Waldes, p. 35.
Entomis, Jones, 1861. Mem. Geol. Surv. Gt. Brit., Geol. Edinburgh
(Map 32), p. 137.
Entomis, Jones & Kirkby, 1863. Geologist, vi. p. 460; 1864. Rep.
Brit. Assoc. Newcastle, 1863, Trans. Sect. p. 80; Neues Jahrb. f.
1864, p. 54; Canad. Nat. Geol. n. s. vol. i. p. 237.
Entomis, Bigsby, 1868. Thesaurus Siluricus, p. 74.
Entomis, Jones, 1869, Paleeoz. Biv. Entom. (Geol. Assoc.), pp. 2 & 5;
1870. Month. Microsc. Journ. vol. iv. pp. 185, 187.
Entomis, Barrande, 1872. Crust. Poiss. Sil. Bohéme (Extrait &c.), p. 41 ;
Syst. Sil. Bohéme, vol. i., Suppl. p. 513.
Entomis is a bivalved Entomostracon of uncertain alliance.
It has an ovato-oblong, bean-like carapace. The valves are
strongly indented by a transverse furrow, which begins on the
dorsal margin, at about one third of its length from the anterior
extremity, and reaches halfway or more across the valve.
This is the usual place of the dorsal or nuchal sulcus in several
Paleozoic Ostracoda, as:—Aristozoe, Barrande; Orozoe, Barr.;
Cypridella, De Koninck ; Cyprella, De Kon. ; Primitia, Jones
& Holl; Lsochilina, Jones; Leperditia, Rouault ; Beyrichia,
M‘Coy ; and Hippa, Barr.
The surface of each valve sometimes presents in front of the
sulcus a rounded tubercle : but this is variable in position and
shape ; sometimes it is a spine, sometimes it is wanting.
The anterior margin is not indented by any sinus or notch,
and is therefore without beak or hood.
In Entomis tuberosa a radiate muscle-spot, in connexion
with the tubercle, is shown on casts in Silurian mudstone from
414 Prof. T. Rupert Jones on the
the Pentland Hills, Scotland (Messrs. Haswell and Brown’s
Collections).
The surface of the valves in some species is ornamented
with delicate riblets, transverse, longitudinal, or concentric.
As far as the shape of the carapace is concerned, Hntomis
stands in the same relation to Cypridella of De Koninck as
Polycope of Sars to Cypridina of Milne-Edwards, the anterior
notch having disappeared in both Po/ycope and Entomis. The
animals, however, may have respectively differed very much ;
for Polycope and Cypridina belong to different families, and
the deep nuchal furrow in Hxtomis, far more impressed than in
Cypridella, was probably in direct relation with the structure
of its internal organs, under modifications not present in other
genera.
The physiological meaning of the nuchal furrow in these
Entomostraca is not understood. It is faintly indicated in
Philomedes and Halocypris; it is stronger in Pleopsis and
Daphnella, belonging to quite another group of Entomostraca.
The known Entomides are :—
1. Entomis concentrica (De Koninck), 1841.
Cypridina concentrica, De Kon. 1841, Mém. Acad. Roy. Belg. vol. xiv.
p- 18, f. 10; 1844. Desc. Anim. foss. Terr. Carb. Belg. p. 587, pl. 52.
figs. 4, 5.
Cythere concentrica, Dupont, 1863. Bull. Acad. R. Se. Belg. ser. 2,
vol. xv. p. 110.
Entomis concentrica, Jones & Kirkby, 1864. Neues Jahrb. fiir 1864, p. 54;
Canad. Nat. Geol. n.s. vol. i. p. 237.
Lower Carboniferous: Belgium.
2. Entomis serratostriata (G. Sandberger), 1842.
Cypridina serratostriata, G. Sandberger, Leonh. u. Bronn’s Jahrb. 1842,
p. 226; Jahrb. Ver. Nat. Nassau, Heft ii. 1845, p. 121, pl. 1. fig. 6;
G. & F. Sandberger, Verstein. Rhein. Schicht. Nassau, 1850, p. 4,
pl. 1. fig. 2. From the Cypridinen-Schiefer of Nassau.
Cypridina serratostriata, F. A. Romer, 1854, Palontogr. iii. Beitr.
geol. Kennt. nordw. Harzgeb. p. 42, pl. 6. fig. 15, From the Cypri-
dinen-Schiefer of the Harz.
Cypridina? serratostriata, Jones, in Morris’s Catal. Brit. Foss. 1854,
p- 104. Devonshire ?
Cypridina serratostriata, Richter, 1856. Denkschr. Akad. Wien, vol. xi.,
Beitr. Pal. Thiir. Waldes, p. 35, pl. 2. figs. 20-29. Thuringia.
Cypridina serratostriata, Ferd. Romer, 1856. In Bronn’s Leth. Geogn.
3rd edit. vol. i. p. 532 (not including the synonyms). Germany.
“Entomis of the Cypridinen-Schiefer,” Jones & Kirkby, 1863. Geolo-
gist, vi. p. 460; 1864, Rep. Brit. Assoc. Newcastle, 1863, Trans.
Sect. p. 80.
Devonian: Europe; England (fide Ferd. Romer & Godwin-
Austen*).
* Quart. Journ. Geol, Soe. vol. xiii. p. Ixxxix.
Paleozoic Bivalved Entomostraca. 415
3. Entomis nitida (F. A. Romer), 1854.
Cypridina nitida, F. A. Rémer, 1854. Paleeontographica, vol. iii. ;
Beitvige Harzgebirge, p. 28, pl. 4. fig. 20.
Goniatite Limestone of the Harz.
4, Entomis fragilis (F. A. Rémer), 1854.
Cypridina fragilis, F. A. Romer, 1854. Paleeontogr. vol. iii.; Beitrage
Harzgebirge, p. 19, pl. 3. fig. 31.
Weissenbach Schists of the Harz.
5. Entomis globulus (Richter), 1856.
Cypridina globulus, Richter, 1856. Denkschr. Akad. Wien, vol. x1. ;
Beitr. Pal. Thiir. Waldes, p. 36, pl. 2. figs. 80-32.
Cypridinen-Schiefer, Thuringia.
6. Entomis gyrata* (Richter), 1856.
Cypridina gyrata, Richter, 1856. Ibid. figs. 33, 34.
Cypridinen-Schiefer, Thuringia.
7. Entomis teniata (Richter), 1856.
Cypridina teniata, Richter, 1856, Ibid. fig. 35.
Cypridinen-Schiefer, Thuringia.
8. Entomis tuberosa, Jones, 1861.
Entomis tuberosa, Jones, 1861. Mem. Geol. Sury. Gt. Brit., Neighb.
Edinburgh (Map 32), p. 157, pl. 2. fig. 5.
Upper Silurian: Aymestry, and Bow Bridge, near Ludlow,
Shropshire; Pentland Hills, Scotland; Yarra Lumla, New
South Wales.
9. Entomis impendens, Haswell, 1865.
Entomis impendens, Haswell, 1865, Silur. Form. Pentland Hills, p. 38,
pl. 3. fig. 11.
Upper Silurian: Pentland Hills, Scotland.
10. Entomis biconcentrica, Jones, 1870.
Entomis biconcentrica, Jones, 1870, Month. Microsc. Journ. vol. iy.
p- 185, pl. 61. fig. 13.
Lower Carboniferous : England ; Ireland.
* Illustrated by a so-called ‘back view” of the carapace. This and
other “ back views ” of carapaces among Dr. Richter’s figures are not clear
to me; and I wait for a fuller description of these species. Figs. 36-38
illustrate a very curious form, “Cypridina calcarata” (p. 87), which,
possibly a link between Cypred/a and Entomis, requires further examination.
416 On the Paleozoic Bivalved Entomostraca.
11. Entomis aciculata, Jones, MS. 1871.
Entomts aciculata, Jones, MS. 1871 (Mr. D. J. Brown’s Collection.
See Rep. Brit. Assoc. Edinburgh, 1871, Trans. Sect. p. 93).
Upper Silurian: Pentland Hills, Scotland.
12. Entomis dimidiata, Barrande, 1872.
Entomis dimidiata, Barrande, 1872. Crust. Poiss. Sil. Bohéme (Ex-
trait &e.), p. 41; Syst. Sil. Bohéme, vol. i., Suppl. p. 513, pl. 24.
figs. 7-9.
Upper Silurian; Stages III. Ee 2, Ff 2,Gg1: Bohemia.
13. Entomis migrans, Barr. 1872.
Entomis migrans, Barr. 1872. Ibid. p. 514, pl. 24. figs. 10-14, & pl. 27.
fig. 2
Upper Silurian ; Colony in Dd 5, and Ee 1, Ee 2: Bohemia.
14. Entomis pelagica, Barr. 1872.
Entomis pelagica, Barr. 1872. Ibid. p. 515, pl. 24. figs. 1-6.
Upper Silurian ; Stage Ff 2: Bohemia.
15. Entomis rara, Barr. 1872.
Entomis rara, Barr. 1872. Ibid. p. 516, pl. 25. figs. 23, 24.
Lower Silurian; Stage Dd 5: Bohemia.
In the Carboniferous Limestone of Belgium Entomis con-
centrica (De Koninck) is a characteristic fossil. In the same
great geological formation in the British Islands four species
have been met with by Mr. Joseph Wright, F.G.S., and Mr.
J. H. Burrow, M.A. Entomis biconcentrica from Little
Island, Cork, Ireland, has been already noticed; another,
E. obscura, Jones & Kirkby MS8., from the same locality and
from the North of England, and two from Settle in Yorkshire,
FE. Burrovii and E. Koninckiana, J. & K. MS., have yet to be
described.
II. ENTOMIDELLA, gen. nov.
In 1861 the genus Hntomis was intended to include £.
divisa, in which the nuchal furrow, altogether crossing the
valves, divides off the anterior moiety. But it is now pro-
posed to make a distinct generic group, ENTOMIDELLA, for
E. divisa and E. buprestis, in which the furrow is continued
across the valve, and no tubercle is present.
1. Entomidella divisa, Jones.
Entomis divisa, Jones, 1861. Mem. Geol. Sury. Gt. Brit., Edinburgh
_ Dr. Albert Giinther on Ceratophrys, de. AIT
(Map 32), p. 187; 1870. Month. Microse. Journ. vol. iv. p. 185,
pl. 61. fig. 12.
Upper Silurian: Builth and Ludford.
2. Entomidella buprestis (Salter).
Leperditia buprestis, Salter, 1866. Rep. Brit. Assoc. p. 285.
Leperditia ? punctatissima, Salter, Siluria, 1867, Appendix, p. 519.
Entomis buprestis, Jones, 1872. Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. xxviii.
p- 188, pl. 5. fig. 15.
Menevian: St. David’s, Wales.
On account of their extremely developed nuchal furrow, Hn-
tomis and Entomidella stand apart from the other known
Ostracoda, recent and fossil, and may be grouped in a family
as ENTOMIDIDA.
In an undescribed bivalved Entomostracon (Sulcuna, gen.
nov., with two species, from the Carboniferous Limestone of
Cork, Ireland) the nuchal sulcus, passing very obliquely
downwards and forwards, is so well defined as to cut off the
antero-dorsal region of each valve, and raises it into a hump
or a sharp process, pointing upwards and backwards. ‘This
genus, however, cannot be allied to Hntomis; for it presents
evidence of the Cypridinal notch on the anterior margin, and
is far more closely related to Cypridella.
XLVIL.— Contribution to our Knowledge of Ceratophrys and
Megalophrys. By Dr. ALBert GiNTHER, F.R.S.
Ceratophrys Fryt.
No bony dorsal shield. Skin densely covered with small
tubercles unequal in size; the two dorsal lines of tubercles,
which are so conspicuous in C. Boze?, are absent on the anterior
and middle portions of the back, but represented by two short
series commencing in the sacral region and converging into a
oint above the vent. Supraciliary horn long and_ pointed.
‘The upperside of the head deeply concave, bordered on each
side by a blunt-edged ridge terminating on the occiput, and in
_ front by a rough prominent crest running from the eye to the
nostril. Tympanum not visible. The vomerine teeth stand
on a rather long transverse ridge slightly interrupted in the
middle, between the choane. ‘longue much smaller than in
C. Boiet, not covering the bottom of the buccal cavity. Digits
rather long, with the tubercles on the lower side much developed;
carpus with three ovate flattish tubercles, the middle of which
is a little larger than the outer. Metatarsal tubercle long, as
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser.4. Vol. xi. 27
418 Dr. Albert Giinther on Ceratophrys, &c.
long as its distance from the end of the inner toe; third toe
rather longer than fifth. Web between the toes very short,
but conspicuous.
Upper parts brown, indistinctly marbled with darker. The
upperside of the snout milk-white, the boundary between the
brown and white being marked by a black line. Lower parts
white, with irregular brownish-black spots.
lines
_ Length of the body ..¢ 5:24. eee 35
Width between the angles of the mouth .. 16 |
Ibength of fore Jee ot)..c hoi. is cases 23
apy) ALES IM GOP 2 ches oi hia Giro 42
y5,, .. Second linger” .40..%... eee 32
55 third finger’. 2%. 2 eee 54
wy, Ind Om fyi ot\. < cieteeee coe eee 40
Distance between heel and end of fourth toe 18
Length of metatarsal tubercle............ 24
t
A female of this fine species, from the Serra de Mantiqueira, |
Minas Geraes, has been presented to the British Museum
by A. Fry, Esq. ., a gentleman who has contributed numerous
valuable specimens from Brazil to the National Collection.
Ceratophrys appendiculata.
Allied to C. Bote*; but the upper parts are covered with
skinny appendages instead of with tubercles, and the snout
terminates in atriangular flap. A pair of prominent glandular
ridges on the back, running from the long supraciliary horns,
to the vent; a similar transverse ridge between the two horns.
Snout more depressed than in the other species, and crown)
of the head but slightly concave. Tympanum not visible.
Vomerine teeth on two short prominences between the choane.
Tongue not covering the bottom of the buccal cavity. The
two ‘outer carpal tubercles very small, much smaller than the
inner; metatarsal tubercle long, nearly as long as its distance,
from the inner toe. ‘Third toe rather longer than fifth. Web
between the toes very short.
Upper parts greyish, with symmetrical brown markings;
throat brown ; lower parts densely speckled with brown.
=
lines
Length’ of theody . jc) 0: . .t ssc ee eee 25 u
Width between the angles of the mouth .. 13 a
Length’ of forelep 5 .. Pie oa ae 17 b
5 indi leg: 4. Gass Ae eR 33 R
Distance between heel and end of fourth toe 15
One male specimen; purchased. It is from Brazil, but it
could not be ascertained from what part.
Rey. A. M. Norman on Ligidium agile, Persoon. 419
Megalophrys montana and Megalophrys nasuta.
At the time of the publication of the ‘Reptiles of British
t| India’ (1864) I had seven examples for examination. Three
#| of them were provided with a rostral appendage, and con-
8} sequently belonged to “Ceratophrys nasuta of Schlegel ;” they
were males. ‘The four others had no such appendage, and
proved to be females. In this curious coincidence some excuse
may be found for my drawing the inference that these examples,
so extremely similar to one another in other respects, were of
the same species, and that the rostral appendage was a secon-
dary sexual character peculiar to the male (Rept. B. Ind.
. 413).
a in the course of last month the British Museum
received three additional examples, every one of which shows
that I have fallen into an error. ‘Two of them (larger than
any example I had previously seen, the body being 5 inches
‘| long), from Matang in Borneo, have a well-developed rostral
“| appendage, but they are females. The other (probably from
®) Java) is a male and lacks the appendage.
_ Therefore there can be no further doubt that there exist in
reality two species of Megalophrys with a somewhat singular
distribution ; for whilst J. nasuta appears to be rather common
‘h}in Borneo, the Malayan peninsula, and Sumatra, WZ. montana is
iit| limited to Java and Ceylon.
it) I regret to have fallen into this error, the more so as Mr.
m8! Darwin, whose attention I had directed to Megalophrys, has
is |referred to these frogs in his ‘ Descent of Man,’ 1871, ii. p. 26,
m|and figured the heads of the two species as those of the male
la) and female of the same animal.
‘ XLVIII.—Note on the Discovery of Ligidium agile, Persoon
ey (=Zia Saundersii, Stebbing),in Great Britain. By the
| Rev. A. M. Norman, M.A.
HE Crustacean which Mr. Stebbing has described in the
Annals’ for April, p. 286, under the name Zia Saundersii,
nd which was found by him near Copthorn Common, is a
ell-known European species, which it is astonishing that
r. Spence Bate, to whom it would appear that it was sub-
itted, should not have immediately recognized. It is an
nteresting addition to our Crustacean fauna. —
it, The Rey. T. R. R. Stebbing quotes the following words from
Spence Bate and Westwood’s ‘ British faa Crustacea’
7
ay
420 Rev. A. M. Norman on Ligidium agile, Persoon.
with reference to the genus Philoscia :—“It is a curious cir-
cumstance that the animals of this genus, common as they are,
and well described by Latreille and Zaddach, should have been
unknown to Brandt, Lereboullet, and Milne-Edwards, who
have affirmed that the genus ought to be re-united to Oniscus,
whereas it is in fact more nearly allied in several respects to
Ingia. The typical species appears to have been figured by
Koch under the name of Ligta melanocephala, which in his
generic table he subsequently altered into the generic name of
Zia, giving, however, fifteen joints to the antenne, the flagellum
being represented as composed of ten articulations.”
Now, while the authors to whom Spence Bate and Westwood
refer were undoubtedly wrong in mistaking a certain species of
Oniscus for the genus Philoscia, Bate and Westwood have
themselves fallen into as serious an error in merging Za, with
its fifteen-jointed antenne andother strongly marked characters,
with Philoscia. The genus Zia of Koch is synonymous with
the previously described genus Ligidium, Brandt; and our
recently discovered British Crustacean is the typical species,
the Ligidium Persoont, Brandt, the specific name of which
must, however, yield to the prior appellation of Persoon him-
self, and the Oniscoid must bear the name of Ligidium agile
(Persoon).
Mr. Stebbing’s woodcut is very characteristic, and agrees
very closely with the admirable figures of Lereboullet.
The following is the complete synonymy of the species as far
as it is known tome. As here in the country I have no means
of referring to such works as are not in my own library, I am
unable personally to verify four of the references, namely those
to Koch, Panzer, Brandt, and Cuvier, the first of which I quote
on the authority of Budde-Lund in his ‘Danmarks Isopode
Landkrebsdyr,’ and the last three on the authority of Lere-
boullet. Zaddach gives Zia melanocephala, Koch, as a syno-
nym, and adds “Zia paludicola et Zia agilis, quas Koch
describit, varietates tantum hujus speciei esse videntur.”’
Ligidium agile (Persoon).
Oniscus agilis, Persoon; Panzer, Faun. Germ. fase. ix. fig. 24.
Oniscus hypnorum, Cuvier, Journ. d’Hist. Nat. vol. ii. p. 19, pl. xxvi.
figs. 3-5; Fabricius, Syst. Entom. Suppl. p. 500. :
Ligia hypnorum, Latreille, Gen. Crust. et Insect. vol. i. p. 68, Hist. Nat...
des Crust. et Insect. vol. vii. p.51; Bosc (edit. Desmarest), Hist. Nat.§ ~
des Crust. vol. ii. p. 179; Desmarest, Consid. Gén. sur la Classe des§
Crust. p. 818; Lucas, Hist. Nat. des Crust. p. 263. by
Lygidium Persooni, Brandt, Conspectus Crust. Onisc. p. 174; Milne-§.
Edwards, Hist. Nat. des Crust. vol. iii. p. 158; Lereboullet, Mém.
sur les Cloportides, p. 14, pl. i. fig. 1, & pl. ii. figs. 20-51 ; Johnsson,
Prof. E. Hiickel on the Calcispongie. 421
Synop. Frams. af Sveriges Oniscider (1858), p. 10; Zaddach, Synop.
Crust. Prussic. Prod. p. 17; Fric, Die Krustenthiere Bohmens (1872),
p. 256.
Zia agilis, Koch, Deutschl. Crust. xxxiv. f. 22, 23.
Ligidium \hypnorum, Budde-Lund, Naturhistorisk Tidsskrift, 1871,
226
Zia Saundersii, Stebbing, Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1873, ser. 4. vol. xi.
p- 286.
Ligidium agile has a wide European distribution, and has
been found in Sweden, Denmark, Prussia, Bohemia, and
France. It might therefore have been expected to be found
in Great Britain, especially as Latreille’s specimens had been
received from the shores of the British Channel (‘ Habitat in
littoribus Oceani Britannici, ab entomologo Brébisson mihi
transmissus ’’).
The relationship of the species to Ligia rather than to
Oniscus was first pointed out by Fabricius, who, in his ‘Suppl.
Entom. Syst.,’ though he assigns it to Oniscus, asks “An
potius Ligia?”
As has been already mentioned, Koch described two other
species, which, however, are perhaps mere varieties of L. agile.
More recently Schébel has described a form, under the name
of Ligidium amethistinum, as distinct from L. agile. Perhaps
this species also is destined hereafter to reward the careful
search of some British carcinologist. Very little has as yet
| been done among our /and Crustacea, my lamented friend
Dr. Kinahan being the only British naturalist who has paid
any attention to the Isopoda Aérospirantia.
XLIX.—On the Calcispongie, their Position in the Animal
Kingdom, and their Relation to the Theory of Descendence.
By Professor Ernst HACKEL.
(Continued from p. 262.]
Il. Tue CALCISPONGLE AND THE THEORY OF DESCENDENCE.
1. Principles of Classification.
The task which we had set before us as the primary object in
this monograph of the Calcispongie, the analytical solution of
the problem of the origin of species, has been followed out in dif-
ferent ways in the first and second volumes. In the first
volume, and especially in its second section, the ‘‘ Morphology
of the Calcispongie,” I have endeavoured to describe all the
422 Prof. E. Hiickel on the Calcispongie
characters of form occurring in this group in their general con-
nexion, and to explain the perfect “unity of their plan of
structure’ by the common descent of all Calcispongice from the
Olynthus. In the second volume, on the other hand, I have
sought to demonstrate the stock-relationship of all the forms
of this group by subjecting the species of Calcispongiz to the
most exact anatomical analysis; in doing which I found my-
self compelled, in opposition to the existing rules of classifi-
cation, to set. side by side two perfectly different systems, a
natural and an artificial one.
The principles of classification which I have followed will
manifest themselves tothe thoughtful reader from a comparative
study of the two systems. The natural system is “carried out
in accordance with the phylogenetic principles of the theory of
descendence, with an average extension of the idea of species.”
It contains 21 genera with 111 species. The artificial system
is “carried out in accordance with the principles hitherto
followed in the classification of the sponges, with an average
extension of the idea of species.” It includes 39 genera with
289 species.
The logical principles upon which the artificial system is
founded are quite different from the genealogical principles
upon which the natural system rests. The former takes into
consideration especially the products of adaptation, the latter
the constancy of ¢nheritance. The artificial system furnishes
as definite a distinction as possible,and a summary arrangement
of the various forms founded on those characters which strike
one as specific characters on a logical comparison merely
directed to the external morphological connexion of the forms.
The natural system, on the contrary, strives after the more
profound recognition of their ¢nternal morphological connexion,
and seeks, in accordance with this, to approach the genealogical
tree of the species. As a matter of course, this object will never
be completely attained among the sponges, any more than with
other organisms, for the simple reason that the three great
documents of the natural history of Creation (Comparative
Anatomy, Ontogeny, and Paleontology) are accessible to us
only in imperfect fragments. Nevertheless, by continued
phylogenetic attempts, the natural system will gradually ap-
proach more and more to the true genealogical tree.
Howfar this approximation has been successful in the natural
system of the Calcispongiz, the thoughtful reader will best see
by the study of the second volume, and especially from the
estimation of the generic and specific, connective and transitory
varieties. The approximation to the true genealogical tree is
more possible than with other groups of organisms, because
=
oe
a rs == «a an
and the Theory of Descendence. 423
the conditions of ¢nheritance and adaptation may be unusually
clearly reviewed in the Calcispongie. The part taken by these
two formative functions in the production of the individual form
may be here determined more accurately and certainly than is
usually the case.
2. Idea and Descendence of Species.
The idea of the species is the central point of attack of the
theory of descendence, and the true nucleus of all discussions on
“development or creation.”’ To investigate this idea again here
would be completely superfluous. I have explained my views
upon it in such detail in my criticism of the morphological, phy-
siological, and genealogical idea of species in my ‘General Mor-
phology’ (Bd. ii. pp. 323-364) that I should merely have to
repeat what I have there said. All attempts up to this time to
give the idea of the species a decided limit and contents have
tailed, and by this negative result itself have led tothe conviction
that the positive idea sought for cannot be defined. The
genealogical definition of the idea attempted by me is just as
unsatisfactory and untenable as all the rest. ‘his lies in the
nature of the thing. The species is just as arbitrary an abs-
traction produced by the subjective contemplation of the author,
just as much a category of only relative significance, as the
ideas of the variety, genus, family, &c. All these categories
have their value only in their reciprocal relations to one another,
and owe their origin to the subjective law of specification (I. ¢.
p- 331).
Moreover we have only to glance at the practice in zoological
and botanical classification to be convinced that the practical
distinction of species has nothing at all to do with all these theo-
retical definitions of the idea of species. On the contrary there
prevails in that distinction the greatest subjective arbitrariness,
and hence an endless dispute between the various systematists.
No two systematists, who have thoroughly worked upon the
same group of forms, have ever yet agreed perfectly as to the
number and limitation of the species united in it.
In the Calcispongie the practical distinction of species is
subject to much greater difficulties than in most other groups
of animals. According as the systematist conceives the idea
of the species in a wider or narrower form, according as he
estimates most highly the principles of the artificial or the
natural system, he may considerably increase or diminish the
number of 21 genera and 111 species of the natural system
which are described in the first section of my second volume.
The natural system might, for example, be founded upon any
one of the following six conceptions :—A. 1 genus with 1
424 Prof. E. Hickel on the Calcispongiz
species; B. 1 genus with 3 species; C. 3 genera with 21
species ; D. 21 genera with 111 species; E. 43 genera with
181 species ; F. 43 genera with 289 species. On the other
hand the artificial system might experience the following six
arrangements :—G. 1 genus with 7 species; H. 2 genera with
19 species; I. 7 genera with 39 species; K. 19 genera with
181 species; L. 39 genera with 289 species; M. 113 genera
with 591 species. Every one of these twelve systems might
cite in its support arguments such as every systematist brings
forward in favour of his subjective conception. None of them,
however, could ever be demonstrated as the absolutely true
system. This circumstance shows most clearly that no absolute
species exists, and that species and variety cannot be sharply
separated *.
3. Generic and Specific, Connective and Transitory Varieties.
The different forms which I have cited in the system of the
Calcispongie as generic and specific, connective and transitory
* The twelve systems here cited as examples (in which, moreover, the
external form is not taken into consideration) would be as follows :—
A. I. Natural system with the widest conception of the idea of species
(in the first degree): a single genus with one species, Calcispongia
grantia.
B._U. Natural system with a very wide extension of the idea of species
(in the second degree): a single genus with three species: 1. Caleispongia
ascon, 2. C’. leueon, 3. C. sycon.
C. III. Natural system with a narrower conception of the idea of species
(in the third degree) : 3 genera (Ascon, Leucon, Sycon) with 21 species.
Here the 21 groups of forms which the next system accepts as genera
( Ascetta, Leucetta, Sycetta, &c.) are reckoned as species.
D. IV. Natural system with average extension of the idea of species
(in the fourth degree): three families (Ascones, Leucones, Sycones) with
21 genera and 111 species.
i. V. Natural system with a narrower extension of the idea of species
(in the fifth degree): 3 families with 43 genera and 181 species. This
system is attained when the subgenera cited in the natural system in the
second volume are accepted as “ good genera,” and the “ specific varieties”
or incipient species as “good species.” Their characters are sufficiently
sharply marked and relatively constant.
F, VI. Natural system with a very narrow extension of the idea of
species (in the sixth degree): 3 orders, with 21 families, 43 genera, and
289 species. This system is attained by a further analytical specification
of the fifth system, the “ generic varieties ” of the latter being raised to the
value of distinct species.
G. VII. Artificial system with the widest conception of the idea of
species (in the first degree) : all Calcispongiz form a single genus, Grantia
(Fleming, 1828), or Lewcalia (Grant, 1829), or Calcispongia (Bainville,
1834). We may then distinguish the following as seven species :—
1. Caleispongia dorograntia ; 2. C. cystograntia ; 3. C. cormograntia; 4. C.
c@enograntia; 5. C. tarrograntia ; 6. C. cophograntia; 7. C. metrograntia.
and the Theory of Descendence. 425
varieties, are of the greatest importance to the theory of de-
scendence and the object of this monograph, namely to ascertain
analytically the origin of species as exemplified by a single
group. ‘The thoughtful and unprejudiced systematist, who
has followed carefully the method of classification followed by
me in the second volume, will comprehend without further
explanation the extraordinary phylogenetic importance of these
four different varieties. I may, however briefly sum up the
most important points connected with them.
1. The generic varieties of the natural system are the genera
of the artificial system. Within one and the same natural
species many different forms may be developed by multifarious
stock-formation and mouth-formation ; and these the artificial
system (having no knowledge of their close genealogical con-
nexion) must regard unconditionally as representatives not
only of distinct species but even of distinct genera. Thus,
for example, Ascandra variabilis includes forms which the
artificial system would divide among eleven different genera ;
H. VII. Artificial system with a very wide extension of the idea of
species (in the second degree): 2 genera with 19 species, namely :—
I, MonoGRranv1, with 6 solitary species: 1. M, olynthus; 2. M. disycus;
3. M. sycurus; 4. M. clistolynthus; 5. M. lipostomella; 6. M. sycocystis :
II. PoLtyerantia, with 13 social species, namely: 1. P. soleniscus; 2. P.
amphoriscus ; 3. P. sycothamnus; 4. P. nardosus; 5. P. ceenostomus ; 6. P.
tarrus; 7. P. artynas; 8. P. auloplegma; 9. P. aphroceras; 10. P. syco-
phyllum ; 11. P. ascometra; 12. P. leucometra; 15. P. sycometra.
I. IX. Artificial system with a narrower extension of the idea of species
(in the third degree) : 7 genera with 39 species. The genera would be :—
1. Dorograntia; 2. Cystograntia; 3. Cormograntia; 4. Ccenograntia ;
5. Tarrograntia ; 6. Cophograntia ; 7. Metrograntia. The 39 species would
be represented by the 39 forms which are cited as genera in the artificial
system in the second volume. Thus, for example, the second genus
(Cystograntia) would contain three species:—1l. C. clistolynthus; 2. C.
hipostomella; and 3. C. sycocystis.
K. X. Artificial system with a still narrower extension of the idea of
species (in the fourth degree) : 7 families, with 19 genera and 181 species.
he 7 genera of the ninth system are here raised to the rank of families,
and the 19 species of the eighth system to that of genera; and the 181
species are the same that in the fifth system were divided into 43 essen-
tially distinct genera.
L. XI. Artificial system with an average extension of the idea of species
(in the fifth degree): 7 orders, with 19 families, 39 genera, and 289
species. This system is carried out in the second section of the second
volume on the principles hitherto followed in the classification of sponges.
M. XII. Artificial system with a very narrow extension of the idea of
species (in the sixth degree): 7 orders, with 19 families, 113 genera, and
591 species. Here those groups of forms are regarded as genera which
in the eleventh system had Daly the rank of subgenera ( Olynthettus, Dys-
sycettus, Sycurettus, &c.), and as species those forms which figure in the
eleventh system as subspecies.
426 Prof. E. Hickel on the Calcispongice
Leucetta primigenia represents seven different genera of the
artificial system; and Sycandra compressa furnishes the arti-
ficial system with no fewer than nine distinct genera.
2. The specific varieties of the natural system are incipient
species of the natural system in the sense of the theory of de-
scendence. By further development and increasing constancy
of the characters by which the specific varieties of a natural
species are distinguished they would raise themselves to the
rank of “bone species. ” An analytical system that takes a
very narrow conception of the idea of species might already
recognize them as species. Thus, for example: Ascandra
variabilis would divide into four natural species (A. cervi-
cornis, confervicola, arachnoides, and hispidissima); Leucetta
primigenia would form three good species (L. tsor aphis, micro-
raphis, and megaraphis); and Sycandra compressa would even
break up into six natural species (S. foliacea, pennigera,
clavigera, rhopalodes, lobata, and polymorpha). Many of these
specific varieties have, in fact, already been described as
species.
3. The connective varieties of the natural system are direct
transition forms between the genera of the natural system. The
foundations of a new natural genus are laid by very trifling
changes in the constitution of the skeleton. Thus, when certain
triradiate spicules of the skeleton of Ascetta, (Leucetta or
Sycetta), which is composed only of triradiate spicules, develop
a fourth ray, this genus passes into Ascaltis (Leucaltis or Sy-
caltis). a variabilis furnishes trans-
ition forms to four natural genera (Ascaltis, Ascortis, Ascu-
linus, Ascyssa) ; Leucetta primigenia produces connective forms
towards three genera of the natural system (Leucaltis, Leucortis,
Leucandra); and Sycandra compressa passes into Sycortis.
4. The transitory varieties of the natural system are direct
transition forms between the species of the natural system. 'They
are the “transitions from one good species to another’ which
horrify the opponents of the theory of descendence. Such in-
termediate forms, the existence of which is denied by dogmatic
species-makers, occur in abundance among the Calcispongie.
Thus we have transitions from Ascandra variabilis to A. pinus,
A. Lieberkiihnii, and A. complicata; transitory intermediate
forms between Leucetta primigenia and L. pandora and
sagittata ; and direct transitions from Sycandra compressa to
S. utriculus and lingua.
4. Polymorphosis and Polymorphism.
One of the most remarkable peculiarities of the Calcispongiz,
and the Theory of Descendence. 427
by which they are most strikingly distinguished from most
other organisms, is the extraordinary instability of the outer
form of the body. It is this that renders their study so in-
structive in connexion with the problem of species. Every
systematist knows how great and decisive is the significance
of the external form in the distinction of species in almost
every class of animals; indeed the great majority of species
are distinguished merely by more or less important differences
in the details of the external form. In complete opposition to
this, the external form in the Sponges, and especially m the
Calcispongiz, is so variable that it cannot be employed at all
for characterizing species, either in the natural or the artificial
system. What I have observed in this respect among the
Calcispongiz exceeds all previous conceptions, and goes much
further than the wonderful variability of the external form in
the Fibrospongiz, which have been indicated as quite extra-
ordinary by all recent spongologists, especially Oscar Schmidt.
A systematist who should adopt the external form alone as a
specific character in the case of Ascandra variabilis, Leucetta
primigenia, or Sycandra compressa might at his pleasure di-
stinguish among the individuals of any one of these extremely
variable species from a single locality ten, twenty, or more
than a hundred species.
It may perhaps seem still more remarkable that this ex-
cessive instability affects even the most important organs, such
as the stomachal cavity andthe mouth. In very many natural
species we find side by side individuals with and without a
mouth. Among the Fibrospongie also the loss of both mouth
and stomach appears to be very frequent. This singular phe-
nomenon is probably to be explained by the fact that in the
Sponges (as in the parasitic worms, Crustacea, &c.) the mouth-
opening does not possess the same physiological importance
as in the higher animals. It becomes rudimentary and is finally
lost (Cestodea, Rhizocephala, lipogastric Sponges). The
quadruply different nature of the mouth in the Calcispongie is
also very variable.
I have particularly described this remarkable multiformity
of the species of Calcispongiz in the second volume, and elu-
cidated it by many figures. Inthe explanation of the plates
it is called polymorphosis, in contradistinction to the well-
known polymorphism of the Siphonophora and of many of
the higher animals. The latter is well known to be a product
of physiological division of labour. Polymorphosis, on the con-
trary, is a polymorphism without division of labour ; its cause
is to be sought merely in adaptations to external conditions of
existence of quite subordinate importance.
428 Prof. E. Hiickel on the Calcispongie
The most remarkable form of polymorphosis among the
Calcispongiz is the union of polymorphotic persons upon one
stock, which I have called metrocormism. . In the artificial
system these metrocormotic Calcispongie form the order of the
Metrograntiz (Ascometra, Leucometra, Sycometra). Forms
which the artificial system regards as representatives of dif-
ferent genera and species here grow united upon a single stock.
This fact is quite irreconcilable with the species-dogma.
5. Causes of the Production of Form.
Besides the great interest which the biology of the Calci-
spongiee possesses in connexion with the theory of descendence
and the critical conception of the organic species, it is also of
extraordinary general significance, because in this small and
simply constructed group of animals the true causes of biological
phenomena, and especially the causes of the production of form,
may be reviewed with particular clearness and recognized with
particular certainty. These causes prove throughout to be
purely mechanical unintelligent causes (cause efficientes), while
we seek in vain for any designedly active intelligent causes
(cause finales).
If we briefly sum up the most essential points relating to
this matter, we arrive at the following results :—
1. The general external form of the Calcispongie, both that
of the social stocks and that of the individual persons, is a pro-
duct of growth which is principally governed by adaptation to
the external conditions of existence of the locality and surround-
ings; the mode of growth is only to the smallest extent in-
herited within the species. ‘The same applies to the quadruply
different formation of the mouth in the persons.
2. The triply different structure of the wall of the stomach by
which the three natural families are distinguished is in part a
product of inheritance and in part of adaptation. ‘The original
structure of the wall of the stomach, as it occurs in the Ascones,
is inherited from Olynthus, the stock-form of all Calcispongiee :
Olynthus, however, inherited it from the Archispongia, the
latter from the Protascus, and this from the Gastrea. The
structure of the wall of the stomach in the Leucones has been
produced from that of Olynthus by growth of the exoderm and
stabilization and ramification of the inconstant pores, and the
structure in the Sycones by strobiloid budding.
3. The multifarious other characters of the gastro-canal
system are mere products of special adaptations, in which the
flow of water is especially effective ; this, again, is dependent
on the movement of the flagella of the cells of the entoderm.
and the Theory of Descendence. 429
4, The extremely remarkable conditions of the ¢ntercanal
system are brought about merely by concrescence. By this
purely mechanical process of, growth very complicated and
characteristic stock-forms and personal forms are produced, in
which enclosed portions of the sea become constituent organs of
the organism.
5. The exceedingly characteristic primary form of the cal-
careous spicula is a purely mechanical product of two co-
operating factors, the capacity for crystallization of calc-spar
and the secretory activity of the sarcodine. In the production
of the secondary forms of spicules the formative current of
water and adaptation to other, more subordinate, external
conditions of existence are effective.
6. The orderly, often very regular, elegant, and apparently
artificial constitution of the skeletal system is for the most part
a direct product of the current of water; the characteristic
position of the spicules is produced by the constant direction of
the current of water; to a very small extent it is the con-
sequence of adaptations to subordinate external conditions of
existence.
7. All other characters of form which might come into con-
sideration here may be referred to the formative activity of the
cells of which the two constituent lamellz of the sponge-body,
the entoderm and the exoderm, are composed; but these are
inherited from the Protascus, and further from the Gastrea.
The motile phenomena of these cells are particularly efficacious
in this respect—on the one hand the ameboid movement, and
on the other the flagellar movement, which is to be referred to
the latter.
8. The special properties of these cells in the Calcispongiz
are due to the chemical composition of their body—of the pro-
toplasm on the one hand and of the nucleus on the other. Of
these two constituents of the cell, the protoplasm is especially
to be regarded as the biorgan of adaptation, and the nucleus as
the biorgan of inheritance.
9. The (chemical) properties of the two albuminoid com-
pounds which form the protoplasm and the nucleus are to be
referred to the peculiar affinities of carbon. Originally they
were active in the simplest manner in the constitution of the
plasson which formed the entire body of the simplest Moneron.
From this was produced, only by adaptation (differentiation of
the plasson into nucleus and protoplasm), the first cell, an
Ameba. This is recapitulated, in accordance with the bio-
genetic fundamental law, by the ovicell. The specific pro-
perties which the ovicell of the Calcispongie possesses were
acquired by it by inheritance from the most ancient Olynthus.
430 Prof. E. Hiickel on the Calcispongie.
6. The Calcispongie and Monism. .
The most general results furnished by the present monograph
of the Calcispongiz are of a purely philosophical nature, and
may be summed up in the statement that the biogeny of the
Calcispongie is a coherent proof of the truth of monism. In
my ‘General Morphology’ I sought todemonstrate synthetically
that all the phenomena of the organic world of forms can be
explained and understood only by the monistic philosophy ; and
now this demonstration is furnished analytically by the mor-
phology of the Calcispongiz. The great contradictions of the
philosophical conceptions of the world, or between monism or
the mechanical and dualism or the teleological conception of
nature, which are rendered evident by every consistent reflec-
tion, may be tested in detail in the biology of the Calcispongie ;
and every examination turns out favourable to the former and
disadvantageous to the latter.
All the phenomena met with in the morphology of the Cal-
cispongie may be completely explained by the reciprocal
action of two physiological functions, inheritance and adapta-
tion ; and we need no other causes to comprehend their produc-
tion. All the causes which are found to be effective in the mor-
phology and physiology of the Calcispongie are unintelligent
mechanical causes (cause effictentes) ; and nowhere do we meet
with intelligent designedly active causes (cause finales). Every-
where we can detect the prevalence of unalterable natural laws,
nowhere the interposition of a preconceived plan of creation.
It might appear that in the form-production of the Calci-
spongie every thing depended upon chance. But chance no
more exists in nature than design or freedom. All processes
are performed with absolute necessity, as the complex result
of the coincidence of numerous causes, each of which is of
purely mechanical nature, and itself again conditioned by more
distant cause efficientes. What we call chance is merely the
coincidence, unexpected by us, of circumstances each of which
is finally brought about with absolute necessity by a chain of
efficient causes.
As all the phenomena presented to us by the biology of the
Calcispongiz may be perfectly understood by the theory of
evolution, as a matter of course all assumption of a creation is
completely excluded in this department. But as the body of
the Calcispongiz in the developmental stage of the Gastrula
already consists of the same two germ-lamelle which compose
the body of man and of all the higher animals at an early
period of embryonic development, we must consistently assume
the same mechanical development for man also. This indica-
tion shows in the clearest manner the high importance of the
Calcispongie for the monistic philosophy.
co
a
Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls. 431
L.— Observations on Pigs (Sus, Linneus; Setifera, Iliger)
and their Skulls, with the Description of a new Species.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
THE Pigs (Setigera) are a well-marked group, which have
been recognized from the earliest times and are distinguished
by the least-informed persons. They may almost be considered
the best and most anciently known thick-skinned Mammalia,
or Bellue of Linneus, or Multungula of Lliger.
Some palxontologists, who have only a rudimentary know-
ledge of zoology and anatomy, and chiefly confine their
attention to the imperfect skeletons found in a fossil state,
have separated the Pigs from-the other Bellu or thick-hided
Mammalia, with which they agree in all their chief external
and internal characters, and placed them with the Ruminants,
because they have four toes on their feet, and call them Artio-
dactyla—thus destroying a group which has been acknowledged
by the Greek philosophers and by the Jewish historians, and
by Ray, Cuvier, and, indeed, naturalists of all times, to combine
them with a series of animals to which they have little or no
affinity.
There can be no doubt that a group that has been so uni-
versally adopted as the Ruminants or Pecora should not be
destroyed without very weighty reasons and on account of
most important characters; and I think that every one must
allow that the habit of ruminating their food, and their strictly
herbivorous diet, are much more important characters than the
mere fact of the animals having four toes, and constitute a
good reason for not placing with them in one group animals
that do not ruminate, have a quite different dentition, live on
a heterogeneous diet, and have entirely different habits, fighting
with tusks instead of horns. This union is only to be compared
to the separation of Marsupials from the other Mammalia on
account of a character that can only be observed’ during par-
turition, and which no doubt is of the greatest importance
to the physiologist, but is scatcely recognizable by the
zoologist. ,
The paleontologists, in choosing to use the group Artio-
dactyla for the Ruminants and some of the Bellue with four
toes, have not only destroyed a well-established group, but
they have separated the Pigs and Hippopotami from their real
affinities to unite them to the Pecora by a character of com-
paratively little importance, and one which varies in almost all
the groups that they refer to it, to define which they have
been obliged to separate as two distinct suborders the Hyraces
and the Elephant (Hyracoidea and Proboscidea) from the
Ungulata, which are as truly Bellue or thick-skinned animals
432 Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls.
as any of the rest, and are at once known as such by any
person who has an eye to the natural grouping of Mammalia.
The division of the hoofed animals (Ungulata) into the
Artiodactyla and the Perissodactyla has been regarded by
many as an important discovery, especially by certain pale-
ontologists; but if they had taken the trouble to read the
history of zoology they would find that these terms are only
Greek names for groups recognized and named in Latin by
Ray, Latreille, and others.
It is amusing but sad to see the various explanations and
the different theories which are put forth to make the tapirs,
that have four toes before and three behind, and the horse, that
has only one toe, odd-toed Ungulates or Perissodactyla, like
the rhinoceros, that has only three toes on each foot; and they
have been obliged to put Hyrax and the elephant into a
separate order, because it is rather difficult to explaim into
which it ought to go (see Flower’s ‘Osteol. Mam.’ pp. 264-267,
figs. 90-98).
At the same time I do not at all underrate the importance
of observing the structure and proportion of parts in the ar-_
rangement and definition of the minor groups. Thus it would
appear that the equality of the two middle toes, which repre-
sent the middle and ring fingers of the human hand, is an im-
portant character in the Pecora or ruminant animals, and in
the pigs (Setifera) and the Obesa (Hippopotami); while the
greater length and thickness of the middle toe, representing
the middle finger of the human hand, makes a modification in
the form of the feet of these animals—especially as this toe is
always present, while one or more of the side toes may be
rudimentary or entirely absent, as may be expressed in the
following table :—
Toes of fore feet. Toes of hind feet.
LE DIMAS toe: boone op 1;:2,'3,'4,°5.> “2k
VEOH GAM tpn otic , 2,0, 4, 5. ° 072593; 4505
Dapeng.) teehee ae 0,:2, 3,4, 55 (Of27s74aG
Rhinoceros .......+ 0,:.2, 3, 4,0...» 10;.2)3; 45 03
DS STL NCP te 0; 0, 3, 0,0: 0,055,050:
Sometimes, as in the elephant, the middle toe is very little
longer than the rest.
The name Perissodactyla has been given to the three latter
genera; but I cannot conceive aslight difference in the propor-
tion of these toes to be of ordinal importance. It is no doubt
an important character in the definition of minor groups, but
scarcely of higher importance, as having little influence on the
habits and manners of the animals, and as separating groups
2
Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls. 433
nearly allied to each other and having the same habits and
appearance.
Artiodactyla and Perissodactyla are very good technical
terms to define that form of the feet in which the middle finger
is longer and thicker, and that in which the middle and ring
fingers are equally thick—just as one might apply Chirodactyla
to those animals that have the thumb-like great toe larger
than the rest, and Ptychodactyla to those that have the outer
and inner toes longer and stronger than the intermediate
three, as in the hind feet of the seals.
The real fact is that each group of animals has a peculiar
kind of foot, that will not bend itself to human systems with-
out being distorted to suit their authors’ views or theories. [
think it is much better to take the facts as they are, and admit
that in the bones of the feet, as in all other parts of the body,
there is a network of affinities, not in a single line, but in
_ various directions.
SETIGERA.
Section A. Homopontirna. The premolars permanent, forming with
the molars a continuous series ; molars solid, with a tubercular
crown.
Subsection 1. Pseudoperissodactyla. Hinder feet with three toes ;
the short external lateral toe of the hind feet wanting. Western
Hemisphere or America.
The two middle front toes of the fore and hind feet are of
equal size, as in the pigs; and these animals are placed in the
Artiodactyla, although they have an odd number of toes on
the hind feet, which we are told are more to be depended upon
than the front feet as giving a character of the group. It has
been well observed that “the attempt to define these groups
will break down with the increase of our knowledge of fossil
forms,” overlooking the fact that they did break down when
the recent genera were properly studied. As regards number
of toes they agree with the tapirs, which are referred to the
Perissodactyla or odd-toed Ungulata.
True pigs are found in America, but only in a domestic or
semidomestic state, having been introduced from Europe or
Asia.
Family Dicotylide, Gray, Cat. B. M. p. 300.
The sides of the skulls are dilated and much expanded in
front of the orbit as far as the zygomatic arch. Both the
peceary or tajacu and the taguicati (or white-lipped peccary)
are at birth of a pale brown colour, not striped; and the
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 28
434 Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls.
peccary has the white collar well marked in this stage, but |
it much sooner assumes its dark livery than the white-lipped
peccary.
This family contains only two recent species, Notophorus
torquatus and Dicotyles labiatus. 'The skulls of the two genera
are very different, and are immediately known from one
another—the skull of Notophorus having a groove of a vessel
over the eye curved to the lateral margin, then bent back over
the canines and continued to the end of the nose. In Dicotyles
labiatus the groove of the vessel over the orbit is only continued
to the lateral margin of the front of the zygomatic arch. It
is to be observed that De Blainville, in his ‘Ostéographie,’
figures them both under the name of Sus torquatus, t. i. & v.
Subsection 2. Artiodactyla. ore and hind feet with four toes ; the
lateral toe of each side much shorter. The Eastern Hemisphere,
or Europe, Asia, and Africa.
Family Suide.
Head conical. Upper canines of the males elongate and
more or less recurved, and enclosed in a bony sheath at the
base. Teeth 40-44; cutting-teeth =}; premolars 33 or #4:
Teats ten, rarely eight. Skull with the sides of the nose in
front of the orbit more or less deeply concave. ‘Tail elongate.
The males have a large thick canine and a longitudinal ridge
over the sheath of its base; this ridge is wanting in the
females.
The swine of the western hemisphere have four toes on the
front and hind feet.
Tribe I. Poramocua@rra.
Ears elongate, attenuated and pencilled at the end. The
concavity in front of the orbit without any ridge on the
lower part from the front of the zygomatic arch. The sheath
of the upper canines expanded out, of the males largest and
with a ridge across its upper surface, of the females often
bent up at the outer margin.
1. Poramocuarus. Africa.
Tribe IT. Svzwa.
Ears rounded, in the domestic state elongate, drooping, not
pencilled at the end. The concavity in the skull in front of
the orbit with a ridge on the lower part from the front of the
zygomatic arch. Cutting-teeth ==. The front grinders close
to the back of the upper canine, which in the males is bent
h
d
Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls. 435
upwards and outwards. The sheath of the upper canine of
the males is spread out, with a ridge or crest across its
upper surface ; that of the females is often slightly bent up at
the end.
Wild Swine. Kars moderate, hairy.
1. Evunys.
Head elongate, twice as long as high at the occiput. Cheeks
and throat covered with long projecting hairs. Lower canines
of the males elongate, slender, convex on the sides and rounded
in front. The front false grinders near the base of the canines
separated from the other grinders by a rather broad diastema.
Sheath of the upper canines in the males with an elongated
ridge, which has a straight top.
Euhys barbatus.
Sus barbatus, Miiller.
2. AULACOCHERUS.
Head conical, about once and a half as long as high at the
occiput. Male, the upper canines keeled in front with a
very high keel across the base of the sheath; the lower
canines triangular, flat on the sides, and keeled in front.
Aulacocherus vittatus.
Head, body, and legs covered with black bristles ; bristles
of forehead and neck white-tipped; streak round angle of
mouth and lower part of cheek white.
Sus vittatus, Miller.
3. DASYCHGRUS.
Head elongate conical, more than once anda half the length
of its height at the occiput. Nose with a large flat-topped
wart on each side over the angle of the mouth, with a tuft of
elongate pale bristles on the lower part of each cheek. Males
with a compressed ridge across the sheath of the upper canines ;
lower canines triangular, flat on the outer side and keeled in
front. Black, with a tuft of yellow hair on each side of the
jowl.
Dasycharus verrucosus.
Head nearly twice as long as high at the occiput. Black,
underside and front of thighs pale.
Sus verrucosus, Miiller.
28*
436 Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls.
Dasycherus celebensis.
Head about once and a half as long as high at the occiput.
Animal black below.
4, Sus.
Head conical, about once and a half as long as high at the
condyles, without any or only a very small wart on the side
of the head. Ears ovate. The upper canines of the males
recurved, with a more or less keeled ridge across the sheath at
their base ; lower canines of the males triangular, flat on the
outer side, and keeled in front.
Sus scrofa.
Hab. Europe. And other species.
1
Sus mystaceus, n. sp.
Brown, with scattered black bristles on the muzzle, forehead,
sides of cheek, and sides of body; crest and hinder part of
body browner ; streak on each side of nose and over angle of
mouth elongate ; whiskers (on the black cheeks), gullet, throat,
chest, front of shoulders, thighs, and underside of body whitish.
Skull: concavity on the sides broad and deep, only separated
from the orbits by a very narrow ridge; the sheath of the
upper canines with a keeled ridge, and convex on the outside
of it.
From the Zoological Gardens. Said to have come from
Java; but I think that very doubtful. It is not like any
of the animals described by the Dutch zoologists.
Domestic Swine. Ears more or less dependent, often very large.
ScroFA.
Scrofa domestica.
CENTURIOSUS.
Centuriosus pliciceps.
Tribe III. Bazrevssza.
Kars rounded, not pencilled at the end. Cutting-teeth $3 ;
the front grinders separated from the upper canines by a long
diastema. Upper and lower canines of the male much elongated
and recurved ; the sheath of the upper canines elongate, arising
from the outer side of the margin of the upper jaw, and closely
—— Oo ee
Dr, J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls. 437
applied to, but separate from, the side of the nose, without
any or only a very slight indication of a cross ridge ; not de-
veloped in the females, and its usual situation indicated by
a sharp-edged ridge just above the lower margin of the upper
jaw in front of the grinders. The males have a deep concavity
on each side of the roof of the hinder upper part of the
inner nostrils; in the females this part is only slightly
concave. J cannot find any exit from these pits, which are
very deep.
Blainville figures the skeleton of a female and gives a cross
section of its skull, and also the skull of a male. He re-
presents the canine tooth of the female as just appearmg
out of a very short sheath on the side of the upper jaw, con-
siderably above the lower edge. It probably may be the
skeleton of a young male; at least the skull in the museum,
said to be a female, does not show any indication of the
canine,
The bulle of the ears are oblong and elongate. No such
concavity exists in the back of the nasal cavity in any of the
pigs that I have examined; but there is a deep pit on each
side of the centre of the hinder part of the nasal cavity in
Phacocherus, which is small in the young and larger in the
more adult skulls. In the adult skulls there is a very deep
concavity on each side of the roof of the inner nostrils in front
of these pits, which are separated from each other by a thin,
erect, longitudinal plate. These concavities are scarcely per-
ceptible in the skulls of the very young animals.
The bull of the ears of the skulls of the very young Pha-
cocherus are large, nearly hemispherical, and very prominent ;
but in the adult skulls they are small and scarcely separated
from the rest of the skull.
BABIRUSSA.
Canines of the males elongate, convex at the sides, the
lower ones rounded, scarcely keeled in front; of the females,
wanting in the upper jaw, and only short, conical, and slightly
recurved in the lower.
Babirussa alfurus.
The skulls of the adult males present two very distinct
varieties. In one the upper and lower canines are very long
and gradually arched; in the other the upper and lower
canines are short, not more than three inches long, the
upper ones being very much curved, sometimes nearly into a
circle.
438 Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls.
Section B. Evroponrina. Premolars deciduous, their places being
filled up by the development of the molars ; molars formed of
lamine, many-rooted.
Family Phacocheride.
PHACOCHERUS.
Zygomatic arch very broad, with only a very slight broad
concavity in front of the orbit. Lower canines triangular ; the
upper canines bent upwards and outwards, very large and
thick, with a ridge across their sheath as in the Suide, but in
both sexes. Lower canines flat on the outer sides and keeled
in front. The sheath of the upper canines with a very obscure
ridge across the middle in skulls said to belong to the two
sexes which were living in the Zoological Gardens. The
sheath and upper canines of the females are rather smaller and
more elongate than those of the males.
Phacocherus cethiopicus.
Phacocherus Aliant, Riippell.
Phacocherus Sclatert, Gray, Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist.
1870.
Phacocherus Atliani and P. africanus, Sclater.
Dr. Sclater described a young female African pig, with very
small canines and small ovate ears with short hair, in the
Zoological Gardens, as distinct from P. wthiopicus, under the
name of P. diliant (Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869, pp. 276, 277,
fig. head, & t. xx. animal). In the ‘List of Vertebrate
Animals in the Zoological Gardens,’ 1872, p. 83, the figure
of the head is repeated as that of the young of “P. africanus,
Gmelin,” with the English name of “Atlian’s Wart-hog.”
Gmelin established Sus africanus on the “Sanglier du Cap
Vert” of Buffon (xiv. p. 209, xv. p. 148), and on the ‘‘Cape-
Verd Hog” in Pennant’s ‘History of Quadrupeds,’ vol. 1.
p- 146, which was established from Buffon’s description and
from a head in the Leverian Museum; and he adds to
Buffon’s description that the ears are “narrow, upright,
pointed, and tufted with very long bristles.” Buffon only
describes the skull, tail, and hoofs of this animal, but says
it has two teeth in the upper jaw, and says nothing about its
ears.
The animal described and figured by Dr. Sclater is_ still
living in the gardens, and no longer has small short canines ;
they have become elongate, conical, and bent upwards, like the
Dr. J. E. Gray on Pigs and their Skulls. 439
' canines of the female Phacochwrus cthiopicus, which, as
Riippell and Sundevall say and the specimen in the museum
proves, are very like those of the male, only they are smaller
and more elongate.
There is askull of this pig in the British Museum from the
Cape-Verd Islands, which is exactly like the skulls of the
other Phacocherus ethiopicus.
If the animal is to be distinguished from the common Pha-
cocharus athiopicus by the small size and oval form of and
short hair on its ears, it is not the Cape-Verd hog of Buffon
and certainly not of Pennant, from which Gmelin described
Sus africanus. Indeed it is very probable that the head which
Pennant described from the Cape of Good Hope in the Leverian
Museum, which he says has the ears “narrow, upright, pointed,
and tufted with very long bristles,” was the head of the common
African pig (Potamochwrus africanus), peculiar for having
“‘narrow elongate ears, with tufts at the end,”—and that his
description is made up of two genera ; for Butfon’s description
of the skull of the “‘Sanglier du Cap Vert” is evidently that
of a Phacocherus, and, I believe, of P. wthiopicus with broad
hairy ears, because that animal always has two cutting-teeth
in its upper jaw in the very young state, and there is no doubt
that one or both drop out before the animal arrives at maturity,
and their presence or absence is a mere accident, and not a
specific character.
It cannot be Avlian’s Phacocheere (Phacocherus Ailiani of
Riippell), as that was first described and figured as having
(and the typical specimen that is in the British Museum has)
large, broad, hairy ears, like the figure of the male given by
Dr. Sclater as the type of Phacocherus ethiopicus.
If the animal in the Zoological Gardens does not as it grows
older have the ears become broader and more hairy, like the
ears in the adult male and female Phacochewrus ethiopicus, it
must be a distinct species, to which my name of Phacocharus
Sclatert will have to be given.
See Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1870, vi. pp. 189,264, 455, and
1871, viii. p. 138. See also Proc. Zool. Soc. 1850, p. 78, t.Xvil.,
where two young animals, then in the Zoological Gardens,
| from Natal, with small oval ears, are noticed and figured ;
_} they were said to be fifteen months old. But can these be the
animals that were afterwards called in the Gardens Phacocherus
| ethiopicus, and had large hairy ears ?
440 On the Appearance of Danais Archippus in Australia.
LI.—Note on the Appearance in Australia of the Danais
Archippus. By FRepEricK M‘Coy, Professor of Natural
Science in the Melbourne University, and Director of the
National Museum of Victoria, &e.
Tuts fine butterfly was sent to me about December 1870 from
Lord Howe’s Island, on the north-east coast of Australia, by
a collector for the museum who was wrecked there; but as I
had never seen it in any of the North-Australian, or Queens-
land, or New-South-Wales collections, and knew it to be an
inhabitant of the Southern States of America, I suspected that
the specimen might have been obtained from some collector
on board some American ship in those seas. A few months
after, a specimen was sent to me by a collector established on
the Clarence River, in New South Wales, as something he
had not seen before, and another friend fond of insects, travelling
in the far north of the continent, also sent me an example as
something strange. As there were no exact accounts of the
actual capture of these specimens, I fancied they all might
have come from some one American source, and paid little
attention to the matter. On the last Sunday in April last (or
about a year and five months after) I was walking in my
garden at Brighton, a place on the sea-shore about eight miles —
south of Melbourne, and was astonished to see that a larger —
butterfly, with a more bat-like flight than any inhabitant of
the colony, which attracted my attention amongst the flower-
buds, was the Danais Archippus ; and presently the two sexes
were seen. Being Sunday they escaped; but next morning,
going through the grounds of the University on the north
side of Melbourne to the Museum to make the teeth water
of my assistant (who had collected Lepidoptera for twenty
years in Victoria) by mentioning what I had seen, I ob-
served two more before me, and on going to my room found
the collector in a great state of excitement at having caught
one in my botanic garden in the University grounds, and
having the previous day seen one five miles south of Brighton.
So that the imsect had made its appearance for the first time
in the colony simultaneously at places fourteen miles apart, and
with no community of character or vegetation—Brighton and
to the south being a sandy bush in a state of nature, with
houses few and far between, each surrounded by several acres
of land, while about the University is a clay soil, densely
populated. On the three following Sundays I saw two or
three specimens in fine condition, which could not, therefore,
have been those seen at first ; and last week I saw some in the
street leading to the University ; and on the same day the col-
(oS —
= _——
a &
= oS =
Mr. F. Smith on new Species of Fossorial Hymenoptera. 441
_- lector came across them at the Treasury, situated at the oppo-
site side of the city. The specimens vary a little in the width
of the black border and the number of the white spots in it,
but to no greater extent than in the American specimens with
which I compared them.
This sudden American invasion of the whole continent
seems worth recording.
Melbourne, March 26, 1873.
LIL.—Descriptions of new Species of Kossorial Hymenoptera
in the Collection of the British Museum. By FREDERICK
Situ, Assistant in the Zoological Department, British
Museum.
THE species described in the present paper were collected by
Mr. H. W. Bates in the Amazons Valley, in Brazil, and
formed part of his private collection ; they were purchased by
the Trustees of the British Museum, and are nearly all unique
in the National Collection. The most valuable additions made
to the Fossorial tribe are the species now added to the following
genera :—to Ceropales four species, to Aporus three, to Ampulex
one, to Trigonopsis two, and to Trachypus two; many new
and beautiful additions are made to the Pompilide, Larride,
Crabronide, and the Philanthidee.
Tribe Fossores, Latr.
Family Pompilide.
Genus Pompi.us, Fabr.
Pompilus Servidus.
Female. Length 7 lines. Ferruginous, with the wings
fuscous. Head: the eyes, ocelli, tips of the mandibles, and
the seven apical joints of the antenne, as well as the eighth
joint above, black. Thorax: the posterior margin of the pro-
thorax, the tegule, postscutellum, and the posterior margin
of the metathorax yellow; the wings dark fuscous and iri-
descent, with their apical margins and hinder margin of the
posterior pair paler; the tibie and tarsi with ferruginous
spines. Eiidgrets with the apical margins of the segments
bordered with fusco-ferruginous bands, indistinctly defined.
Hab. Para.
442 Mr. F. Smith on new Species
Pompilus decedens.
Female. Length 9: lines. Head, thorax, legs, and base of
the abdomen yellow, the rest of the latter black. The antenne
reddish yellow, with the six apical joints fuscous ; the eyes
black at their outer margins; the tips of the mandibles black. _ |
Thorax of a reddish yellow above; the metathorax, tegule,
the scutellum at the sides, the postscutellum, and the posterior
margin of the metathorax paler, the latter being yellowish
white ; legs reddish, with a line on the posterior femora, within,
and the posterior tarsi black; wings flavo-hyaline, palest at
their apical margins, the nervures ferruginous; the costal
nervure fuscous. Abdomen: above black at the extreme base ;
the rest of the first segment reddish yellow, and with a pale
spot next to the black base; the second segment at its base,
as well as the third, has a yellow fascia, the latter narrowest
and attenuated in the middle; the second segment reddish
yellow, with two large black macule, which occupy nearly the
entire segment, except a central line and the apical and lateral
margins; beneath, the three basal segments are pale yellow,
except the apical margin of the third, which is black.
Hab. Para.
Pompilus diversa.
Female. Length 5-6 lines. Black, variegated with silvery
pile ; wings hyaline, with two transverse fuscous fascize. Head :
the face covered with silvery pile, in very fresh examples it has
a golden lustre; the anterior margin of the clypeus, which is
transverse, more or less obscurely ferruginous ; the mandibles
ferruginous at their apex and the palpi of the same colour, but
paler; the head is wider than the thorax; the antenne fulvous
towards their apex, sometimes obscurely so. Thorax: the
posterior margin of the prothorax angulated ; a silvery spot on
each side of the scutellum close to the lateral margins, and the
metathorax silvery at its apex, which is rounded ; an impressed
line extends from the base to the apex of the metathorax; in
small specimens the legs are obscurely ferruginous beneath.
Abdomen: the basal margins of the segments more or less
ornamented with silvery pile, glittermg brightly in certain
lights.
Male. Length 5 lines. Of a much more slender form than
the female, and more brightly decorated with silvery pile ; the
face, coxee, and abdomen at its base very bright ; the basal seg-
ment much attenuated; the legs elongate, slender, and spinose.
Hab. Kiga; Para.
A series of specimens of this species, on being carefully
of Fossorial Hymenoptera. 443
examined, show that in all probability, on the insect being
freshly disclosed, the disk of the mesothorax is covered with
pale golden pile; some examples have traces of it.
‘ Pompilus varietatis.
Female. Length 4-53 lines. Black; the thorax and abdomen
more or less maculated with minute yellow spots. Head rather
wider than the thorax; the anterior margin of the clypeus
widely truncate; the palpi pale testaceous ; the antennz fulvous
beneath. Thorax: the posterior margin of the prothorax
arcuate, and frequently bordered with yellow ; the mesothorax,
in some examples, with two very narrow longitudinal yellow
lines ; a minute spot on each side of the scutellum, the post-
scutellum, two longitudinal lines on the metathorax, and its
posterior margin yellow ; the extreme apex of the coxe, tro-
chanters, femora, and of the anterior tibize rufo-testaceous ;
the calcaria and spines on the tibie and tarsi pale rufo-testa-
ceous; the anterior half of the fore wings dark fuscous; the
anterior margin of the posterior pair with a slight fuscous tint.
Abdomen covered with a fine glossy cinereous pile; the basal
segment with two yellow circular spots ; in some examples the
spots are larger and of an irregular shape, and form a large
only slightly interrupted transverse macula; in other ex-
amples there is a minute spot at the extreme lateral basal
margins of the second and third segments.
Hab. St. Paulo; Ega; Para (Amazons).
All the varieties received are described ; but probably others
exist. The longitudinal lines on the metathorax are in different
examples more or less obsolete, sometimes entirely so. The
smaller specimens appear to be the most highly coloured.
Pompilus vi vidus.
Male. Length 5 lines. Black, and covered with silvery
ile, which is most dense on the face, cox, femora beneath,
and also on the three basal segments of the abdomen beneath,
the other segments being black. The posterior margin of the
prothorax with a white band, which is slightly interrupted in
the middle ; the wings hyaline, the anterior pair with a dark
fuscous cloud, which extends to the base of the marginal cell ;
a narrow fuscous fascia crosses the wing at the apex of the
externo-median cell; a space at the base of the metathorax
black, being without a covering of pile; a portion of the apical
margins of the three basal segments of the abdomen black and
without pile, the third margin narrowest ; the anterior tibiz
t44 Mr. F. Smith on new Species
and tarsi slightly, and the intermediate and posterior pairs very
spinose.
Hab. Santarem.
Pompilus detectus.
Male. Length 53 lines. Black, abdomen partly red, and
with dark fuscous wings. ‘The face with a covering of silvery
pile ; the clypeus widely truncate, the lateral angles rounded,
and having a brownish pile. The posterior margin of the
prothorax arcuate and with a yellow border, somewhat obscure ;
the metathorax smooth, covered with brownish pile, and of a
blue tinge in certain lights; the wings slightly iridescent in
some positions. Abdomen: the three basal segments ferru-
ginous, and the basal margin of the fourth narrowly so; the
four apical segments with a thin cinereous pile.
Hab. Santarem.
Pompilus vitabilis.
Female. Length 5 lines. Head and thorax black, the
abdomen blue-black ; the wings dark fuscous, with a splendid
violet iridescence, which varies to purple in certain lights.
The face covered with silvery pile; the anterior margin of the
clypeus sinuated; the apex of the mandibles ferruginous.
Thorax : above, in certain lights, with more or less of a blue
tinge, particularly the metathorax, which is smooth and opaque.
Abdomen subpetiolate; the apical portion of the fourth segment,
and the fifth and sixth and seventh entirely, covered with a
thin cinereous pubescence; the abdomen beneath, as well as
the coxee and femora, covered with a changeable silvery pile.
Hab. Para.
Pompilus exclusus.
Male. Length 53 lines. Blue, with green tints in certain
lights ; wings dark fuscous ; antenne, mandibles, and clypeus
black, the latter widely truncate. ‘The posterior margin of
the prothorax angulate ; the metathorax smooth and rounded
posteriorly ; the wings have a violet and purple iridescence ;
the first submarginal cell as long as the two following; the
second cell subquadrate, receiving the recurrent nervure near
its apex; the third submarginal cell much restricted towards
the marginal cell. Abdomen of a bright blue-green.
Hab. Para.
Pompilus tratus.
Male. Length 47 lines. Head and thorax black, with yellow
of Fossorial Hymenoptera. 445
markings; abdomen red. The head and thorax covered with
short cinereous pile ; the scape of the antennz yellow in front,
and covered with cinereous pile; the flagellum fulvous beneath
and fuscous above. Thorax: the tegule and posterior margin
of the prothorax broadly yellow ; wings hyaline, and with a
_ dark fuscous cloud beyond the third submarginal cell, the
nervures dark fuscous; the posterior tibia, their apical cal-
carla and their tarsi, as well as the intermediate pair and the
spurs of the tibie, pale yellowish white; the tips of the tarsal
joints and of the posterior tibiz black, as are also their spines.
Abdomen ferruginous, with cinereous bands at the base of the
segments.
Hab. Para.
Pompilus conterminus.
Female. Length 33 lines. Black, with a broad yellow fascia
on the abdomen, and hyaline wings. Head: a narrow line
behind the eyesand a broader one at their inner orbits yellowish
white ; the clypeus covered with silvery pile. The thorax,
coxee, and femora, as well as the base of the abdomen, with a
coating of silvery pile ; the posterior margin of the prothorax,
which is arcuate, with a narrow yellow fascia; wings hyaline,
their nervures fuscous, and the anterior pair with a fuscous
cloud beyond the third submarginal cell, covering the apex of
the wing; the intermediate femora at their apex, and the
posterior pair as well as the tibie, ferruginous. Abdomen :
the basal segment covered with silvery pile; a broad yellow
fascia at the base of the third segment, slightly narrowed in
the middle.
Hab. Para.
Genus AGENIA, Schiddte.
Agenia agitata.
Female. Length 3-4 lines. Black; wings hyaline, with
a fuscous macula; the abdomen petiolated. Covered with
a thin slate-coloured sericeous pile; on the face, coxe, and
ae portion of the metathorax it is silvery. The man-
ibles ferruginous at their apex; in small examples the
apical margin of the clypeus is testaceous ; the antenne fulvous
beneath, brightest in small examples. Thorax: the posterior
margin of the prothorax arcuate ; wings clear hyaline, with a
fuscous cloud occupying the second submarginal cell, and
usually extending more or less into the third discoidal cell ;
the third submarginal cell twice as long as the second and
slightly restricted towards the marginal one; the anterior
tibiz and tarsi, and all the calearia that arm the apex of the
446 Mr. F. Smith on new Species
tibize, rufo-testaceous; these are palest in small examples.
Abdomen with a short petiole at its base.
Hab. Para; Ega; Santarem.
Agenia multipicta.
Male. Length 63 lines. Black ; the head and thorax spotted
and striped with pale yellow. Head: the labrum, clypeus,
scape in front, a broad stripe on each side of the face, and a
narrow line behind the eyes pale yellow. Thorax: the
posterior margin. of the prothorax, the outer margin of the
tegule, a stripe over the tegulz, an ovate spot before the scu-.
tellum and a larger one on it, the postscutellum, three spots at
the base of the metathorax, and its apical portion pale yellow ;
wings flavo-hyaline; the nervures black, with a fuscous cloud
over the marginal and two submarginal cells, and from them
to the apex of the wings ; the anterior coxe in front, a stripe
on the inner margin of the intermediate pair, and on both
margins of the posterior ones pale yellow ; the posterior femora
yellow beneath. Abdomen subsericeous, and with a blue
tinge ; its apical segment pale.
Hab. Paya.
It is probable that the yellow markings will be found to be
more vivid insome examples. The unique one in the Museum
collection is mutilated, and the wings are ragged at their
apical margins ; it is probable that it had been long disclosed
at the time of its capture.
Agenia gloriosa.
Male. Length 7} lines. Black, and covered with a bright
golden pile, exceedingly brilhant in certain lights. Head:
the anterior margin of the clypeus sinuate ; the sixth, seventh,
and eighth joints of the antenne orange-yellow. ‘Thorax: the
wings flavo-hyaline, with a faint cloud in the marginal, second
submarginal, and over the apex of the third discoidal cell ;
the tips of all the wings faintly clouded; the legs without
golden pile, except the coxe, which are brightly adorned.
Abdomen petiolate.
Hab. Paya.
Agenia comparata.
Female. Length 5 lines. Black ; wings hyaline ; posterior
femora ferruginous. The insect covered with fine hoary pile ;
on the clypeus and sides of the thorax it has a silvery lustre ;
the cheeks, sides of the thorax, and the metathorax with a
long thin white pubescence ; the palpi testaceous. Thorax:
—_— oa
of Fossorial Hymenoptera. 447
the posterior margin of the prothorax arcuate; the tarsi
obscure ferruginous ; the nervures of the wings nearly black ;
the wings iridescent. Abdomen petiolated ; the apical margin
of the second and following segments narrowly testaceous.
Hab. Para.
Agenia ceruleocephala.
Female, Length 5 lines. Head and thorax blue, exhibiting
tints of purple, green, and violet in certain lights; abdomen
ferruginous. Head purple, covered with silvery pile below
the insertion of the antenne; the mandibles, palpi, and scape
of the antenne beneath pale testaceous; the flagellum fulvous
beneath. Thorax: the posterior margin of the prothorax
subangular, and bordered with silvery pile; the sides of the
thorax silvery ; the metathorax with a central longitudinal
impressed line, which widens towards the apex ; wings hyaline
and iridescent, the nervures ferruginous; legs ferruginous.
Abdomen petiolated ; the base of the petiole blue.
Hab. Para; St. Paulo.
Agenia deceptor.
Female. Length 4 lines. Pale ferruginous, abdomen darkest,
with the vertex and thorax above dark fuscous. Head:
above the insertion of the antenne nigro-zneous, and with a
pale stripe at the margin of the eyes; the apical half of the
antenne fuscous above. Thorax: the posterior margin of
the prothorax arcuate, and bordered with a pale ferruginous
band; the postscutellum, tegule, and apex of the metathorax
pale ferruginous ; wings hyaline, the superior pair with their
anterior margin slightly fuscous. Abdomen petiolated.
Hab. Para.
Agenia timida.
Male. Length 33 lines. Head and thorax blue; abdomen
black, with the petiole ferruginous. Head wider than the
thorax; the face and clypeus silvery; the margins of the
clypeus, apex of the mandibles, pai, inner orbits of the eyes
not as high as their vertex, and the scape of the antenne in
front very pale ferruginous. ‘The posterior margin of the
prothorax arcuate ; the metathorax with a central longitudinal
depression, and the sides with silvery pubescence; wings
hyaline and iridescent, the nervures and tegule testaceous ;
the legs ferruginous, the apical joints of the anterior and in-
termediate pairs, and the posterior pair entirely, as well as the
apex of the tibiz, fuscous. Abdomen: the petiole and basal
448 Mr. F. Smith on new Spectes
margin of the second segment ferruginous ; the apical segment
white.
Hab. Para.
Agenia reversa.
Female. Length 32 lines. Ferruginous, with the anterior
wings, beyond the second submarginal cell, dark brown.
Head rather wider than the thorax ; the three basal joints, and
a portion of the fourth, of the antenne ferruginous, the rest
black; the joints of the antenne widest at their base, most
obviously so when viewed on the underside; the scape of the
antenne beneath, the lower portion of the inner orbits of the
eyes, the clypeus, labrum, mandibles, and palpi white.
Thorax: the prothorax transverse, narrow, and very slightly
curved; the anterior coxe white beneath; the posterior tarsi
fuscous. Abdomen narrow, and acuminate both at the base
and the apex.
Hab, Para.
This species is very remarkable in having the base of the
antennal joints wider than their apex; in this particular it
agrees with the male of the British and European species,
Agenia variegata.
Agenia gracilenta.
Male. Length 3 lines. Black, covered with hoary pile;
wings hyaline ; the base of the second segment of the abdomen
yellow. Head: the mandibles and palpi pale testaceous ; a line
on the scape of the antenne and the third joint yellow beneath ;
three or four of the following joints obscurely ferruginous.
The posterior margin of the prothorax arcuate; the anterior
femora in front, the tibie and tarsi, the tips of the inter-
mediate femora, and the tibize rufo-testaceous ; the calcaria at
the apex of all the tibiae white ; wings hyaline and iridescent, -
their tegule testaceous, the nervures fuscous ; a faint cloud in
the second submarginal cell, and extending over the apical
portion of the third discoidal one ; there is also a slight fuscous
stain at the apex of the externo-median cell. The first segment
of the abdomen forming a petiole, which is pale beneath.
Hab. Para.
Agenia modesta.
Male. Length 34 lines. . Black, the legs variegated with
white; the abdomen fuscous at the base, and with a white
fascia, which covers the apical margin of the first segment
very narrowly, and a broader portion of the base of the second
segment; the apical segment also white. Head: the scape
of Fossorial Hymenoptera. 449
of the antenne in front, the clypeus, mandibles, and palpi
white ; the coxze, anterior legs, and the base of all the tibice
white; the wings hyaline and iridescent; the tegule testa-
ceous, a fuscous cloud occupying the marginal and second
and third submarginal cells ; the prothorax with a white fascia
on its posterior margin. Abdomen: the three basal segments
white beneath.
Hab. Para.
Agenia ordinaria.
Female. Length 53 lines. Black, with the abdomen red,
and anterior wings fuscous. Head: a pale abbreviated line
at the inner orbits of the eyes; the palpi also pale. Thorax:
the posterior margin of the prothorax arcuate ; the metathorax
narrowed to, and truncate at, the apex; the third submarginal
cell nearly twice as wide as the second, and much narrowed
towards the marginal cell; the posterior wings hyaline and
beautifully iridescent. The extreme base of the abdomen
black. ‘The entire insect covered with a thin hoary pile.
Hab. Santarem.
Agenia aureicornis.
Female. Length 82 lines. The head and thorax olive-green ;
the abdomen blue ; the wings with two fuscous fascia. Head:
the clypeus with a changeable silvery pile; the scape of the
antenne in front, and the five apical joints of the antenne,
bright orange-yellow ; the rest of the joints obscure fulvous
beneath. Thorax: the first fascia crosses the anterior wings
at the apex of the externo-median cell and the base of the
first submarginal, the second from the base of the marginal.
Abdomen smooth and shining, and thinly covered with hoary
pile ; a few long black hairs at its apex.
Hab, Santarem.
Agenia gratiosa.
Female. Length 4 lines. Green, with the anterior margin
of the fore wings narrowly fuscous. Head a little wider than
the thorax ; the lower part of the face and the clypeus covered
with silvery pile; the antenne fulvous beneath and fuscous
above; mandibles ferruginous towards their apex, and the
palpi pale testaceous. ‘Thorax: the posterior margin of the
prothorax, and the base, sides, and apex of the metathorax, with
short glittering silvery pubescence ; wings hyaline, the fuscous
stain covering the marginal, first and second submarginal cells,
and extending at each end a little way beyond; the nervures
pale testaceous, with those towards the margin of the anterior
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi. 29
450 On new Species of Fossorial Hymenoptera.
wings fuscous ; legs pale ferruginous, with the cox, and femora
above, green, the outside of the tibize more or less tinted with
green, and the apical joints of the tarsi fuscous. Abdomen
petiolated, smooth, and shining.
Hab. Ega.
Agenia tarsata.
Female. Length 4 lines. Green; legs ferruginous, with
the tarsi of the intermediate and posterior legs black. Head
a little wider than the thorax ; the clypeus and lower part of
the face silvery ; the apex of the mandibles, the palpi, and
scape in front pale ferruginous ; the flagellum fulvous beneath.
Thorax: the sides and the metathorax with a changeable
silvery pubescence; wings hyaline, nervures ferruginous.
Abdomen petiolate, shining, and covered with a thin hoary
le.
3 Hab. Figa.
Agenia letabilis.
Female. Length 7 lines. Black ; wings subhyaline, with a
brown spot at their apex; abdomen with ferruginous spots.
Head and thorax thinly covered with hoary pile; the legs
stout and destitute of spines; the metathorax rounded; wings
subhyaline, and with a fuscous spot at the apex of the anterior
pair, which extends from the base of the third submarginal cell
to the apex of the wing. Abdomen: a large ferruginous spot
on each side of the first and second segments, those on the
second nearly uniting ; the fourth (except its extreme base)
and the two following ferruginous.
Hab. Para.
Agenia fortipes. < athe
Male. Length 6 lines. Black, with dark brown wings.
The face covered with silvery pubescence, brilliant in certain
lights ; the clypeus widely truncate. The thorax has on the
sides and beneath a thin hoary pubescence ; the prothorax,
margins of the mesothorax and of the metathorax with a bright
silvery pile; the coxee are adorned in the same way, but it is
only observable in certain lights ; the wings have violet, purple,
and coppery iridescence. Abdomen petiolate, and with an
obscure blue tinge; the three apical segments have a thin,
hoary, short pubescence.
Hab. Para.
Agenia conspicua.
Female. Length 5 lines. Black; wings subhyaline and
a — | 2
ae - = =
On “a New Classification of Ammonites.” 451
clouded; abdomen variegated with white and yellow. Head
scarcely as wide as the thorax, and both covered with silky
white pile; the palpi pale testaceous. The posterior margin
of the prothorax arcuate; the metathorax longitudinally de-
pressed ; the wings fusco-hyaline, a darker cloud occupying
the marginal and second and third submarginal cells; the
anterior legs in front and their tarsi ferruginous. Abdomen
subsessile, having a fine silky pile; the apical margins of the
first and second segments, and the following segments entirely,
reddish yellow ; a large pale yellowish-white macula on each
side of the second segment.
Hab. Para.
Agenia cursor.
Male. Length 54 lines. Black, with a fine silky pile ; legs
elongate, the posterior pair longer than the insect; anterior
wings dark fuscous, and having a clear hyaline space that
occupies the three discoidal as well as the first apical cell.
Head transverse, as wide as the thorax; the face below the
insertion of the antenne and the clypeus covered with silky
pile. Thorax: the sides, beneath, and the apex of the meta-
thorax silvery ; the anterior tibize beneath and the tarsi obscure
| ferruginous. Abdomen: the first segment forming a petiole
which is longer than the metathorax ; the other segments have
a blue tinge.
Hab. Para.
[To be continued. |
LIUI.— Observations on M. Favre's Paper on a New Classi-
fication of Ammonites. By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
| As to M. Keferstein’s theory that the Aptychus is ‘a pro-
| tecting organ of the nidamentary glands of the female Ammo-
) nite,” which M. Favre considers certain—and he further goes
| on to say, “the soft tissue of this gland has a great. resem-
| blance in its various parts to the structure of the different
types of Aptychus, and the form of the Aptychus corresponds
very well with that of the outer part of this gland” (p. 366)—
| I do not offer any decided opinion on this extraordinary
| theory, as I have never studied the question; at the same
| time | may observe that it is not supported by any thing I
| have observed in the structure or habits of recent Mollusca,
| and is, indeed, entirely opposite to all my experience as a
| student in the structure and development of shells.
29*
452 Dr. J. E. Gray on “a New
A protecting organ of a gland, or a gland itself, becoming
shelly would be an entirely new fact in malacology ; and the
notion should not be entertained without very strong reasons,
of which M. Favre gives none.
All true shells are secreted by the mantle of the mollusk,
and not by any other part of the animal. The operculum of
Univalves, which is the analogue of the second valve in the
Bivalves, has a peculiar mantle on the foot of the animal for
its secretion; and when the operculum is formed of several
layers (that is to say, when its inner and outer surfaces are
covered with an additional calcareous coat) the outer coat is
secreted by a peculiar lobe of the mantle, as the outer coat of
the cowrie, Marginella, &c. is secreted; and I have no
doubt that the outer coat of Aptychus is secreted by a lobe of
the pedal mantle, like the outer coat of the operculum of
Gasteropods.
The only instance that has occurred to me of a body se-
creted by a mollusk having the slightest resemblance to a shell,
and yet not being secreted by the mantle of the animal, is
that of the three shelly plates that encase the gizzard of Bulla
lignaria and B. aperta. These plates are only the hardening of
the cartilaginous tubercles that are found in the stomach of
Aplysia and other allied genera, and have not the structure
or texture of true shells; they certainly bear no resemblance to
the shells of Aptychus, which, as M. Favre describes them,
have the regular texture of shells. ?
The structure of the Aptychi that I have examined, as well
as the account of it given by M. Favre (p. 365), is quite the
same as that observed in many opercula of Univalve shells.
It certainly is against all my experience of fossil shells
(which has been extensive) if the Aptychus is a fossil nida-
mentary gland, or that a soft glandular part should be fos-
silized so as to produce a body formed of three layers, each
with a peculiar structure, and that the structure which they
produce by becoming fossilized should be similar to the
structure observed in opercula, which are often formed of three
layers, as M. Favre describes them. The reasons which he
gives that they cannot be opercula show M. Favre’s slight
acquaintance with the structure and economy of living
Mollusca ; for otherwise he would have known that the majority .
of opercula, although found in the aperture and protecting the
animal, evidently ‘“ could not have served to close the aperture
of the shell.”’
M. Favre observes :—‘ The shell of Nautilus is composed
of two layers—an external layer formed of an aggregate of
cells of different sizes, and the largest of which are those
of
Vu
Classification of Ammonites.” 453
nearest the outside (it forms the most important part of the
shell properly so called, and M. Suess has named it ostracum),
} and an internal nacreous layer formed of very small cells,
) which constitutes the septa and lines the inner surface of the
ostracum. The former is secreted by the mantle ; the latter by
the body of the animal.”
Thirdly, he states, ‘The whole animal (of the Nawtzlus),
the posterior part excepted, is therefore united to the shell,
and the chamber is hermetically closed ;”” and goes on to say,
“the mantle extends in front of this attaching ring (/faft-
| ring); it is composed of two parts—one, which is very short,
| corresponding to the antisiphonal region of the animal; the
other, which is much longer, corresponds to the siphonal
region, and secretes the shell, with which it is connected by
| its outer margin.”
These observations come within my study; and I may
observe that they are directly at variance with all my expe-
rience in the structure and growth of the shells or opercula
_ of Mollusca, and appear to me only to be compared to the
Swiss author, living in the centre of Europe, who described
ships being built of brick.
The Nautilus-shell is composed of two layers, the outer
chalky and opaque, the inner pearly : the outer is first formed,
and forms the edge of the shell; the inner pearly layer is
deposited on the inside of the outer as it is enlarged, the two
going on part passu; and both are deposited by the mantle of
the animal, as all shells are deposited, and as may be seen both
in the univalve Turbo and the bivalve Uniones or Avicule,
| which exactly agree with Nautilus in structure ; and I should
like to know how the body of the bivalve got out of the
| large mantle to deposit the pearly layer of the inner surface
of the shell, which is quite out of its reach and influence. It
is quite a new fact to me that the whole animal of a mollusk
should be united to the shell, and so hermetically close it; if
true, it would require an entire change in the definition of
Mollusea, which are always entirely free from the shell, and
only attached to it by peculiar muscles; and I can vouch for
this being the case in the Nautilus from the examination of
several specimens preserved in spirit ; and, further, I can assure
M. Favre that the edge of the mantle in these animals is
quite free from the edge of the shell, and that the chambers
of these shells are formed in the same way as the septa in
other shells—as, for example, the septa across the vertex of
Bulimus decurtatus and other decurtated shells.
I am willing to allow that there are things to be explamed
in regard to the formation of the septa and the siphons and
454 Royal Society :-—
the use of the Aptychus to the Ammonite ; but this is not to be
settled by the wild theories of persons who are evidently de-
ficient in elementary knowledge of the structure and economy
of living Mollusea. This is one of the evils of the paleon-
tologists (as they call themselves) considering paleontology
a separate science, and confining their study to fossil bones, —
shells, &c., and not paying sufficient attention to the study
of recent animals, instead of studying them as parts of the
same subject, the former only to be explained by the latter—
as Cuvier demonstrated in his ‘ Ossemens Fossiles,’ by a
careful study of the existing animals and their parts before he
attempted to determine the fossils he then knew: instead of
this we find the paleontologists describing and forming
genera on mere fragments, and putting forth the wildest and
most erroneous theories. If the recent and fossil species were
studied together by the same person all this would be got rid
of ; and we cannot expect that any reliable information as to
the determination, structure, or distribution of fossils will be
obtained until this course is adopted. One can have no con-
fidence in paleontologists who describe numerous species and
genera from fragments, when they fail in describing or deter-
mining the osteology or conchology of recent species.
PROCEEDINGS OF LEARNED SOCIETIES.
ROYAL SOCIETY.
March 20, 1873.—Mr. George Busk, Vice-President, in the Chair.
“On the Temperature at which Bacteria, Vibriones, and their
Supposed Germs are killed when immersed in Fluids or exposed to
Heat ina moist state.” By H. Coartron Basrtan, M.A., M.D., F.RS.,
Professor of Pathological Anatomy in University College, London.
For more reasons than one we may, perhaps, now look back
with advantage upon the friendly controversy carried on rather
more than a century ago between the learned and generous Abbé
Spallanzani and our no less distinguished countryman Turberville
Needham. Writing concerning his own relation to Needham,
the Abbé said*, “I wish to deserve his esteem whilst combating
his opinion;” and, in accordance with this sentiment, we find
him treating his adversary’s views with great respect, and at the
same time repudiating much of the empty and idle criticism in
which so many of Needham’s contemporaries indulged with regard
* Nouvelles Recherches sur les Découvertes Microscopiques et Ia Généra-
tion des Corps Organisés, &c. London and Paris, 1769, vol. i. p. 69.
On the Heat necessary to kill Bacteria &c. 455
tohis work. This criticism, Spallanzani says*, “ Without looking
into details, contented itself by throwing doubt upon some of
the facts, and by explaining after its own fashion others whose
possibility it was willing to admit.” He moreover warmly re-
probated the ignorant and disrespectful statements made by an
anonymous writer who had shown himself little worthy of being
heard upon the subjects in dispute. Spallanzani on this occasion
very wisely said t:—‘ When it is a question concerning obser-
vations and experiments, it is necessary to have repeated them
with much circumspection before venturing to pronounce that
they are doubtful or untrustworthy. He who will allow him-
self to speak of them with contempt, and who can only attempt
to refute them with writings composed by the glimmer derived
from a treacherous lamp, will not find himself in a condition to
' retain the esteem of learned men.” The anonymous writer (in
his ‘Lettres & un Américain’) to whom Spallanzani referred
had gone so far as to doubt the statements of Needham as to
the constant appearance of organisms in infusions which had
been previously boiled, and also intimated that even if they were
to be found, it was only because they had been enabled to resist
the destructive influence of the boiling fluid. This latter asser-
tion was emphatically denied by Spallanzani, his denial being
based upon a most extensive series of experiments with eggs in
great variety and with seeds of all degrees of hardness; these
were all found to be killed by a very short contact with boiling
water. Spallanzani had thoroughly satisfied himself that even
very thick-coated seeds could not resist this destructive agent ;
whilst he thought that the idea, entertained by some, of the eggs
of the lowest infusoria being protected from the injurious influ-
ence of the boiling water by reason of their extreme minuteness,
was a supposition so improbable as scarcely to deserve serious con-
sideration. Such a notion was, he thought, wholly opposed to
what was known concerning the transmission of heat. Whilst,
therefore, the opinion of those who believe that eggs have the
power of resisting the destructive influence of boiling water could
be fully refuted, Spallanzani thought it by no means followed
that the infusoria which always, after a very short time, ap-
peared in boiling infusions had arisen independently of the ex-
istence of eggs. The infusions being freely exposed to the air,
it was very possible that this air had introduced eggs into the
fluids, which by their development had given birth to the infusoria t.
After the lapse of a century it haggat last been clearly shown
that this supposition of aérial contamin&tion advanced by Spallan-
zani (warrantable and natural as it was at the time) is one
* Lee. ct. p. 9. t Loc. cit. p. 114.
t A few pages further on this view is thus shortly expressed :—‘ TI est
évident qué toutes les tentatives faites avec le feu, peuvent bien servir 4 prouver
que les animaux microscopiques ne naissent point des ceufs que l’on supposait
exister dans les infusions avant qu’on leur fit sentir le feu; mais cela n’empéche
pas qu’ils n’aient pu étre formés de ceux qui auront été portés dans les vases
aprés l’ebullition.”
456 ) Royal Soctety :—
which, in the great majority of cases, is devoid of all foundation
in fact, so far as concerns the organisms essentially associated
with processes of putrefaction, viz. Bacteria and Vibriones. The
means of proving this statement, based upon independent obser-
vations made by Professor Burdon Sanderson and myself, were
recently submitted to the consideration of the Royal Society *.
Before the reading of this communication I was under the im-
pression that almost every one of those who had taken part in
the controversies which had been carried on both here and abroad
concerning the Origin of Life were prepared to admit, as Spallan-
zani had done, that the eggs or germs of such organisms as appear
in infusions were unable to survive when the infusions containing
them were raised to the temperature at which water boils. This
impression was produced in part by the explicit statements on this
subject that had been made by very many biologists, and also in
part by a comparatively recent and authoritative confirmation
which this view as to the destructive effects of boiling infusions
upon Bacteria had received. Little more than two years ago Pro-
fessor Huxley, as President of the British Association for the
Advancement of Science, recorded experiments in his Inaugural
Address which were obviously based upon this belief as a starting-
point ; and subsequently,in one of the Sectional Meetings, after
referring to some of my experiments, and to the fact that all un-
mistakably vital movements ceased after Bacteria had been boiled,
Professor Huxley addedt:—“I cannot be certain about other
persons, but I am of opinion that observers who have supposed
they have found Bacteria surviving after boiling have made the
mistake which I should have done at one time, and, in fact, have
confused the Brownian movements with true living movements.”
Some eminent biologists do not now (in reference to the experiments
cited in my last communication) suggest that the organisms found
in the infusions were dead and had been there before the fluids
were boiled: they express doubts concerning that which seems
formerly to have been regarded as established, and now wish for
evidence to show that the germs of Bacteria and Vibriones are killed
ina boiling infusion of hay or turnip, as they have been proved to
be in “ Pasteur’s Solution ” and in solutions containing ammonic
tartrate and sodic phosphate.
With the view of removing this last source of doubt more effec-
tually, and also of refuting the unwarrantablet conclusion of M.
Pasteur, to the effect that the germs of Bacteria and Vibriones are
not killed in neutral or #ightly alkaline fluids at a temperature
of 212° F., I almost immediately after the reading of my last
communication commenced a fresh series of experiments.
* See Proceedings of Royal Society, No. 141, 1873, p. 129. 4
t See Report in Quart. Journ. of Microscop. Science, Oct. 1870.
{ Reasons for this opinion have been fully set forth in ‘The Beginnings of
Life,’ vol. i. pp. 374 et seg. ; or the discriminating reader may at once find my
justification for this expression by reading pp. 58-66 of M. Pasteur’s memoir in
‘Ann. de Chim. et de Physique,’ 1862.
On the Heat necessary to kill Bacteria dc. 457
Nearly two years ago, in my ‘Modes of Origin of Lowest
Organisms, I brought forward evidence to show that Bacteria,
Vibriones, and their supposed germs are killed at a temperature of
140° F. (60° C.) in neutral or very faintly acid solutions containing
ammonic tartrate and sodic phosphate, and also evidence tending
to show that these living units were killed in neutral infusions
of hay and in acid infusions of turnip at the same temperature.
The crucial evidence adduced concerning the degree of heat
destructive to Bacteria, Vibriones, and their germs, in the saline
solution, was of this nature. The solution had been shown to be
incapable of engendering Bacteria and Vibriones (under all ordi-
nary conditions) after it had been boiled, although it still continued
capable of supporting the life and encouraging the rapid multi-
plication of any of these organisms which were purposely added to
it. Some of this boiled solution, therefore, was introduced into
flasks previously washed with boiling water; and when the fluids
had sufficiently cooled, that of each flask was inoculated with
living Bacteria and Vibriones—in the proportion of one drop of
a fluid quite turbid with these organisms to one fluid ounce of the
clear saline solution*. These mixtures containing an abundance
of living organisms were then heated to various temperatures,
ranging from 122° F. (50° C.) to 167° F. (75° C.); and it was in-
variably found that those which had been heated to 122° or 131° F.
became quite turbid in about two days, whilst those which had
been raised to 140° F. or upwards as invariably remained clear
and unaltered. The turbidity in the first series having been ascer-
tained to be due to the enormous multiplication of Bacteria and
Vibriones, and it being a well-established fact that such organisms
when undoubtedly living always rapidly multiply in these fluids,
the conclusion seemed almost inevitable that the organisms and
their germs must have been killed in the flasks which were briefly
subjected to the temperature of 140° F. How else are we to
account for the fact that these fluids remained quite unaltered
although’ living organisms were added to them in the same _pro-
portion as they had been to those less-heated fluids which had
so rapidly become turbid? Even if there does remain the mere
possibility that the organisms and their supposed germs had not
actually been killed, they were certainly so far damaged as to
be unable to manifest any vital characteristics. The heat had, at
all events, deprived them of their powers of growth and multipli-
cation ; and these gone, so little of what we are accustomed to call
“life” could remain, that practically they might well be con-
sidered dead. And, as I shall subsequently show, the production
of this potential death by the temperature of 140° F. enables us to
draw just the same conclusions from other experiments, as if
such a temperature had produced a demonstrably actual deatht.
* Fuller details concerning these experiments may be found -in the little
work already mentioned at pp. 51-56, and also in‘ The Beginnings of Life,’
vol. i. pp. 3820-332.
t See p. 462.
458 Royal Society :-—
Seeing also that these saline solutions were inoculated with a
fluid in which Bacteria and Vibriones were multiplying rapidly,
we had a right to infer that they were multiplying in their
accustomed manner, “as much by the known method of fission,
as by any unknown and assumed method of reproduction.” So
that, as I at the time said*, “ These experiments seem to show,
therefore, that even if Bacteria do multiply by means of invisible
gemmules, as well as by the known process of fission, such in-
visible particles possess no higher power of resisting the de-
structive influence of heat than the parent Bacteria themselves
possess.”
This is, in fact, by far the most satisfactory kind of evidence
that can be produced concerning the powers of resisting heat en-
joyed by Bacteria and Vibriones, because it also fully meets the
hypothesis as to their possible multiplication by invisible gemmules
possessed of a greater power of resisting heat, and because no
mere inspection by the microscope of dead Bacteria can entitle
us positively to affirm that they are dead, even though all cha-
racteristically vital or ‘‘ true ving” movements may be absent.
Facts of a very similar nature were mentioned in the same
work strongly tending to show that Bacteria and Vibriones are
also killed at the same temperature in other fluids, such as infu-
sions of hay or turnip. These facts were referred to in the following
statement? :— Thus, if on the same slip, though under different
covering-glasses, specimens of a hay-infusion turbid with Bacteria
are mounted, (a) without being heated, (5) after the fluid has been
raised to 122° F. for ten minutes, and (c) after the fluid has been
heated to 140° F. for ten minutes, it will be found that in the
course of a few days the Bacteria under a and 6 have notably
increased in quantity, whilst those under ¢ do not become more nu-
merous, however long the slide is kept. Facts of the same kind
are observable if a turnip-infusion containing living Bacteria is ex-
perimented with ; and the phenomena are in no way different if a
solution of ammonic tartrate and sodie phosphate (contaming
Bacteria) be employed instead of one of these vegetable infusions.
The multiplication of the Bacteria beneath the covering-glass,
when it occurs, is soon rendered obvious, even to the naked eye,
by the increasing cloudiness of the film.”
The facts just cited concerning the behaviour of thin films of
turbid infusions which had heen heated to different temperatures
gave me the clue as to the proper direction of future work. It
would seem that, when mounted in the manner described, such
thin films of infusion continue capable of supporting and favouring
the multiplication of any already existing Bacteria and Vibriones,
although under such conditions no new birth of living particles
appears to take place even in these fluids. The question then |
arose as to whether, by subjecting larger quantities of the same
infusions to any particular sets of conditions, we could ensure
* Modes of Origin of Lowest Organisms, 1871, p. 60. 1 Loc. cit. p. 60.
On the Heat necessary to kill Bacteria &e. 459
that they also should continue to manifest the same properties— —
because, if so, it would be almost as easy to determine the death-
point of Bacteria and Vibriones when exposed to heat in these
infusions as it had been to determine it for the saline solutions
already mentioned.
It was pointed out by Gruithuisen early in the present century,
that many infusions, otherwise very productive, ceased to be so
when they were poured intoa glass vessel whilst boiling, and when
this was filled so that the tightly fitting stopper touched the fluid.
Having myself proved the truth of this assertion for hay-infusion,
it seemed likely that, by having recourse to a method of this kind,
I should be able to lower the virtues of boiled hay- and turnip-
infusions to the level of those possessed by the boiled saline solu-
tion with which I had previously experimented—that is, to reduce
them to a state in which, whilst they appear (under these conditions)
quite unable of themselves to engender Bacteria or Vibriones,
they continue well capable of favouring the rapid multiplication of
such organisms. |
This was found to be the case; and I have accordingly per-
formed upwards of one hundred experiments with inoculated
portions of these two infusions raised to different temperatures.
The mode in which the experiments were conducted was as
follows :—
Infusions of hay and turnip of slightly different strengths
were employed. These infusions, haying been first loosely strained
through muslin, were boiled for about ten or fifteen minutes,
and then whilst boiling strained through ordinary Swedish filtering-
paper into a glass beaker which had previously been well rinsed
with boiling water. A number of glass bottles or tubes were
also prepared, which, together with their stoppers or corks, had
been boiled in ordinary tap water for a few minutes*. They were
taken out full of the boiling fluid ; and the stoppers or corks being
at once inserted, the vessels and their contents were set aside to
cool. When the filtered infusion of hay or turnip had been
rapidly cooled down to about 110° F. (by letting the beaker con-
taining it stand ina large basin of cold water), it was inoculated
with some of a turbid infusion of hay swarming with active
Bacteria and Vibriones—in the proportion of one drop of the turbid
fluid to each fluid ounce of the now clear filtered infusiont. The
beaker was then placed upon a sand-bath, and its contained fluid
(in which a thermometer was immersed) gradually raised to the
required temperature. The fluid was maintained at the same tem-
perature for five minutes by alternately raising the beaker from
* The vessels employed have varied in capacity from two drachms to four
ounces; some have been provided with glass stoppers and others with very
tightly fitting corks ; and the latter I find have answered quite as well as the
former. On the whole I have found tightly corked one-ounce phials to be about
‘the most convenient vessels to employ in these inoculation experiments.
+ It was found desirable to filter the infusions after they had been boiled,
because the boiling generally somewhat impaired their clearness.
460 . Royal Society :-—
and replacing it upon the sand-bath. The bottles to be used were
then one by one uncorked, emptied, and refilled to the brim with
the heated inoculated fluid*. The corks or stoppers were at once
very tightly pressed down, so as to leave no air between them and
the surface of the fluids. The beaker was then replaced upon the
sand-bath and the gas turned on more fully, in order that the ex-
erimental fluid might be rapidly raised to a temperature 9° F.
(5° C.) higher than it had been before. After five minutes’
exposure to this temperature other bottles were filled in the same
manner, and so on for the various temperatures the influence of
which it was desired to test.
Thus prepared, the bottles and tubes have been exposed during
the day toa temperature ranging from 65° to 75° F. And generally
one had not to wait long in order to ascertain what the results
were to be. In some cases, if the contents of the vessels were
to become turbid, this was more or less manifest after an in-
terval of forty-eight hours ; in other cases, however, the turbidity
manifested itself three or more days later: the reason of this
difference will be fully discussed in a subsequent communication.
For the sake of simplicity and brevity, the necessary particu-
lars concerning the 102 experiments have been embodied in the
opposite Table.
The experimental results here tabulated seem naturally divisible
into three groups. Thus, when heated only to 131° F., all the in-
fusions became turbid within two days, just as the inoculated saline
solutions had donet. Heated to 158° F. all the inoculated organic
infusions remained clear, as had been the case with the saline
solutions in my previous experiments when heated to 140° F.
There remains, therefore, an intermediate heat zone (ranging from
a little below 140° to a little below 158° F.) after an exposure to
which the inoculated organic infusions are apt to become more
slowly turbid, although inoculated saline solutions raised to the
same temperatures invariably remain unaltered. The full expla-
nation of these apparent anomalies I propose to make the subject
of a future communication to the Royal Society ; meanwhile we
may quite safely conclude that Bacteria, Vibriones, and their sup-
posed germs are either actually killed or else completely deprived
of their powers of multiplication after a brief exposure to the tem-
perature of 158° F. (70° C.).
This evidence now in our possession as to the limits of “ vital
resistance ” to heat displayed by Bacteria, Vibriones, and their sup-
posed germs in neutral saline solutions, and in neutral or acid or-
ganic infusions, is most pertinent and valuable when considered
in relation to that supplied by other sets of experiments bearing
upon the all-important problem of the Origin of Life. These
* At this stage, of course, very great care is needed in order to avoid all
chance of accidental contamination either with living organisms or with un-
heated fragments or particles of organic matter.
t In the experiments already referred to.
On the Heat necessary to kill Bacteria &c. 461
Inoculation Experiments made with the view of ascertaining
the Temperatures at which Bacteria, Vibriones, and their sup-
posed Germs are killed in Organic Infusions.
Nevutrat Hay-Lyrusion.
Pe Number ae Results
Ee of ex- 7. ot at Expiration
te periments y eh 2 of the
SS a made. pan 8th day.
en Hs ) } 1 24 hours. Turbid.
be B. i 48 hours. All turbid.
if in 48 hours.
140° F. 9 as ee Ath tecbid!
lin 8 days.
5 2in 5 days. Three turbid.
eee ; { lin 8 days. } { One clear.
158° F. 05) Aald itl Wh Ads os All clear.
fou eu. ANS. Uso, ibe. ee Ee All clear.
(eo)
fei F ) } abe. ly Dame sok anes . All clear.
Actp Turntp-IyFusion.
T t Number Date Results
et a of ex- =a: at Expiration
whieh . of Turbidity,
d periments #f an of the
eon made. as 8th day.
122° F. SPE A NTIS SGIS Ws alee ML & eae
5 in 24 hours. .
131° F. 7 { ee | All turbid.
6 in 40 hours.
140° F. 12 4in 3 days. All turbid.
2in 4 days.
lin 3 days.
3in 5 days. 1th en turbid.
149° F. a lin 7 days. | Thee clear.
2in 8 days.
WA)! |S ha Sa All clear.
Ab’ Sly Gge reread eae All clear.
cegeaeceaee fh) ie sieves ere «
462 Royal Society.
latter experiments alone may possibly leave doubt in many minds ;
but the more thoroughly they are considered in relation to the
evidence brought forward in this communication, the more fully, I
venture to think, will every lingering doubt as to the proper con-
clusion to be arrived at be dispelled.
Thus we now know that boiled turnip- or hay-infusions ex-
posed to ordinary air, exposed to filtered air, to calcined air, or
shut off altogether from contact with air are more or less prone to
swarm with Bacteria and Vibriones in the course of from two to six
days ; but, placed under slightly different conditions, such as were
employed in the inoculation experiments above quoted, although
infusions of the same nature do not undergo “ spontaneous” putre-
factive changes, yet when living Bacteria@and Vibriones are added,
and not subsequently heated, putrefaction invariably takes place and
the fluids thus situated rapidly become turbid. There is therefore
nothing in the conditions themselves tending to hinder the process
of putrefaction, so long as living units are there to initiate it. Our
experiments now show that as long as the added Bacteria, Vibriones,
and their supposed germs are subjected to a heat not exceeding 131°
F. (55° C.), putrefaction invariably occurs within two days; whilst,
on the contrary, whenever they are subjected to a temperature of
158° F. (70° C.) putrefaction does not occur. T’o what can this
difference be due, except to the fact that the previously living or-
ganisms, which, when living, always excite putrefaction, have been
killed by the temperature of 158° F.? It would be of no ayail to
suppose that the absence of putrefaction in these latter cases is
due to the fact that a heat of 158° F., instead of killing the or-
ganisms and their germs, merely annuls their powers of repro-
duction, because in the other series of experiments (with which
these have to be compared), where similar fluids are exposed to
ordinary or purified air, or are shut off from the influence of air
altogether, the most active putrefaction and multiplication of or-
ganisms takes place in two, three, or four days, in spite of the
much more potent heat of 212° F. to which any preexisting germs
or organisms must have been subjected. The supposition, there-
fore, that the Bacteria, Vibriones, and their germs were not killed
in our inoculation experiments at the temperature of 158° F., but
were merely deprived of their powers of reproduction, would be no
gain to those who desire to stave off the admission that Bacteria
and Vibriones can be proved to arise de novo in certain cases. Let
us assume this (which is indisputably proved by these inoculation
experiments), viz. that an exposure to a temperature of 158° F.
(70° C.) for five minutes deprives Bacteria, Vibriones, and their
germs of their usual powers of growth and reproduction—that
is, that it reduces them to a state of potential, if not necessarily
to one of actual death. What end would be served by such a
reservation? The impending conclusion could not be staved off
by means of it. The explanation of what occurs in the other set
of experiments, where the much more potent heat of 212° F. is
employed, still would not be possible without having recourse to
Miscellaneous. : 463
the supposition of a de novo origination of living units, so long as
those which may have preexisted in the flasks could be proved
to have been reduced to such a state of potential death. It would
be preposterous, and contrary to the whole order of Nature, to
assume that the vastly increased destructive influence of a heat of
212° F. had restored vital properties which a lesser amount (158°
F.) of the same influence had completely annulled.
The evidence supplied by these different series of experiments,
in whichever way it is regarded, as it seems to me, absolutely
compels the logical reasoner to conclude that the swarms of living
organisms which so often make their appearance in boiled infusions
treated in one or other of the various modes already proved to be
either destructive or exclusive of preexisting living things are the
products of a new brood of “ living ” particles, which, in the absence
of any coexisting living organisms, must have taken origin in the
fluid itself. For this mode of origin of living units, so long
spoken of and repudiated as “spontaneous generation,” I have
proposed the new term Archebiosis.
MISCELLANEOUS.
Habits of Xenurus unicinctus, or Cabassou.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S., F.Z.8., &e.
A sprctMEN of this animal has been living in the Zoological
Gardens for this last three or four months.
It feeds freely on chopped meat and vegetables.
The head is very blunt, with a broad, truncated, flesh-coloured
nose with large nostrils. The ears are very large and covered with
scales; they are usually open and spread out, but always have a
keel on the inner side; the fore and hinder flat surfaces are fre-
quently completely closed by compressing the two sides of the ear
very closely together, perhaps to protect the cavity of the ear from
the sand of the places they are said to inhabit. The body is broad,
depressed, and sunk in the middle of the back, and the dorsal disk is
very soft and flexible. The tail is elongate, subcylindrical, blackish,
naked, and smooth, with three longitudinal series of calcareous
tubercles on each side of the under part of the hinder half of the
tail, which are of a roundish shape and are sunken into its sub-
stance so as to be level with the surface. The front claws are very
large, and squarely truncated at the end, from the animal’s habit
of walking on the tips of them. The front fingers are very mobile ;
and the animal is constantly spreading them out, so that they
radiate from one another and can make a very broad foot, if re-
quired by the place it inhabits. The hind claws are similar, but not
quite so large or unequal. The penis is long, fusiform, and entirely
retractile. The front claws of the wild specimens in the Museum
are not.so much truncated as those of the specimen in the Zoological
Gardens ; and though the tubercles on the tail are present in the
464 Miscellaneous.
dried specimens, they are not so regular, well-marked, and distinct
as in the living animal.
The way of “walking is somewhat similar to that of Tolypeutes.
The generality of stuffed specimens give a very wrong idea of the
form of the nose, dorsal shield, and of the feet. Though Xenwrus
and Yolypeutes walk on the tips of the claws, they stand and walk
in a very different manner. In the Cabassou (Xenwrus) the toes
are short, and have very strong elongate claws, which spread out
horizontally, and are rather divergent; the animal walks on the
tips of its claws, the remainder of the claws and the soles of the
feet being parallel to, but raised from the soil. In Tolypeutes the
toes are very short; the claws are slender, elongate, and bent down
perpendicularly, so that the animal walks on the tips of its claws,
as on stilts.
Several persons to whom I have mentioned these facts doubt their
truth, especially in the latter genus; but I have repeatedly verified
them with my own eyes. The stuffed specimens and the figures of
the animals, and also the figures of the bones of the feet, though
very accurate in all their details, give a very erroneous idea of the
manner in which these animals stand and, more especially, walk.
The Cabassou walks about with the nostrils of his broad truncated
nose expanded, sniffing very much like a pig; and from the way it
turns over the hay of its cage with its nose, I think that very pre-
bably it searches for its food in the same manner as pigs do, thereby
Justifying the English name generally given to the armadilloes,
“hog in armour.’
On the Fauna of Nowaja-Semlja. By Prof. Euxers.
Prof. Ehlers has published a list of marine animals from Nowaja-
Semlja, belonging to the classes Insecta, Arachnoidea, Ascidia, to
the Vermes, Bryozoa, Echinodermata, Ccelenterata, and Sponges.
He concludes it with the following remarks.
Although this catalogue cannot claim to even approximate com-
pleteness in the enumeration of the animals belonging to the classes
treated in it which occur on the shores of Nowaja-Semlja, it is
nevertheless large enough to show that in general the fauna is that of
the European north sea; but it further shows that on these islands
animals occur together which we should otherwise regard as endemic
forms of two distinct zoogeographical provinces. Thus, if we indi-
cate the coasts of Spitzbergen, Greenland, and perhaps polar America
as parts of an arctic province, and those of Iceland and northern
Scandinavia as parts of a boreal province, and distinguish those
animals which have hitherto been found in one province or the other
as boreal and arctic animals, it appears that on the shores of Nowaja-
Semlja arctic and boreal animals occur side by side, besides those
animals which are distributed through all provinces of the northern
seas.
It seems probable that the behaviour of the Gulf-stream has some
influence upon this distribution, inasmuch as a part of its current at-
tains the southern shore of Nowaja-Semlja, and so on this coast a
Miscellaneous. 465
neutral territory is produced, in which the conditions of the arctic
province, scarcely, if at all, affected by the Gulf-stream, may meet
more or less with those of the boreal province ; whilst boreal animals
may the more easily be carried northwards to Nowaja-Semlja from
the neighbouring Scandinavian coasts, as the Gulf-stream passing by
the latter carries them to this island.
The following summary furnishes evidence of this. In it I have
referred only to those animals of whose distribution in the northern
sea we are accurately informed.
There have been found on the shores of Nowaja-Semlja :—
I. Animals which were known only as arctic:
Castalia arctica, Mlmg., Spitzbergen. Nereis zonata, Mlmg.,
Spitzbergen and North Greenland. Huchone analis, Kr., Spitz-
bergen and Greenland. Ohone Duneri, Mlmg., Spitzbergen.
Asteracanthion gronlandicus, Steenstr., Greenland. Myriotro-
chus Rinkii, Steenstr., Greenland.
IJ. Animals which were known only as boreal, or which had their
northern limit of distribution in the boreal province :
Evarne impar, Johnst., Iceland, Norwegian, English, and French
coasts. Pista cristata, Mull., Norwegian and English coasts.
Euchone papillosa, Sars, Norway.
II. Animals found everywhere in the northern sea:
Harmothoe imbricata, Linn. Pholoe minuta, Fab. Lumbriconereis.
Cirratulus cirratus, Mull. Amphitrite cirrata, Mull. Terebel-
hides Stromu, Sars. Priapulus caudatus, Lam. Aleyonidium
gelatinosum, Linn.
Here also must be placed Hrigone longipalpis, Sund., which, as
Dr. Koch kindly informs me, has been observed in England, occurs
in Sweden, and has been found in Spitzbergen. Bdella arctica,
Thor., appears to be widely distributed in high northern latitudes,
and to occur particularly abundantly in Greenland.
As regards the animals collected on the coast of Finmark, I have only
to remark that among them there are some which have hitherto been
known onlyfrom more northern coasts, such as:—Scezone lobata, MImg.,
Spitzbergen and Greenland; Phascolosoma boreale, Kef., Greenland ;
Ophiocten sericewm, Forb., Ljungm., Polar America, Greenland, and
Spitzbergen.—-Sttzungsber. phys.-med. Soc. zu Erlangen, January 12,
1873.
On “Le Rut de Madagascar.”
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Buffon, in the third volume of the ‘Supplement’ to the ‘ Histoire
Naturelle,’ p. 49, t. xx., describes and figures “le Rat de Madagascar ”
from a specimen that lived several years in the collection of Madame
la Comtesse de Massam. This figure has been referred to the Lemur
murinus of Gmelin and to several other nominal species.
Unfortunately the size of the animal is not mentioned ; but if the
figure is of the size of the living specimen there can be little doubt
Ann. & Mag. N. Hist. Ser. 4. Vol. xi, 30
466 Miscellaneous.
that it is the same as a small Lemuroid in spirits that we have
lately purchased, labelled ‘La plus petite Macque de Madagascar
entre Manham et Ténériffe.”
It agrees with Buffon’s figure in all particulars, especially in the
acuteness and prominence of the nose beyond the lips. As the animal
has only been described from a stuffed specimen, I may add:—The
muzzle naked, having a central longitudinal groove on the underside
to the border of the lip; the whiskers are long; the ears are rather
large, about half the length of the head from their front edge,
rather naked, with short close hairs on the outer surface. The hind
legs and feet are strong.
The head is 13 inch long, the body 32 inches. The tail is eylin-
drical, 33 inches long, covered with close hair, and with scattered,
longer, soft hair near the end. The hind leg is 13 inch long, and
the hind foot 13 inch long, when the animal is measured taken out
of spirit.
The examination of the skeleton has proved this animal to be the
AzemaSmithit ; and, like this, it has the nose and the intermaxillary
bones produced not so much as in the Galago Demidoffii. This
prominence of the intermaxillaries at once distinguishes it from
Murilemur murinus, which is otherwise very like it and comes from
Madagascar, the skull of which is also at once known by the existence
of a large round perforation on each side of the hinder edge of the
palate, well figured by Mr. Mivart, and not found in the skullof either
Azema Smithu or Galago Demidoffii.
Note on the Anatomy of Comatula rosacea. By E. Prerrrer.
Last summer, at the laboratory of experimental zoology of M.
Lacaze-Duthiers, at Roscoff (Finisterre), I endeavoured to clear up
the obscure points which still exist in the anatomy of the Comatule,
the last remains of the rich fauna of Crinoids presented to us by
geological strata. Our Comatule are provided with ten arms, ar-
ranged in pairs, and radiating round a disk, upon which is placed a
visceral sac containing the digestive apparatus. The arms are fur-
nished on each side with a row of alternate pinnules, each joint of
the arms bearing a pinnule upon one of its sides. The pinnules
seem to be a repetition on a small scale of the arms themselves, but
they do not bear secondary pinnules.
On the disk we see twe orifices—one central, which is the mouth;
the other lateral, corresponding to the interval between two pairs
of arms, and situated at the extremity of a sort of fleshy chimney
terminated by eight lobes; this is the anus. Round the mouth
there is a vascular ring, which, opposite to the base of each pair of
arms, emits a vascular branch; and this, bifurcating at the base of
each pair, furnishes each arm with a canal called the radial or ten-
tacular canal. The vascular ring in the intervals between the five
primary radial canals gives origin, on its inner margin, to eight or
ten contiguous digitiform tentacles, which are largest at the middle
of each interval, and become smaller in the neighbourhood of the
Miscellaneous. 467
canals which separate them. In traversing the disk the latter canals
also give origin to small, simple, and alternate digitiform tentacles.
The five radial canals of the disk cut off five sectors upon it. If we
examine the integument upon each of these sectors, we find it per-
forated with about twenty perfectly circular orifices, irregularly ar-
ranged, about 0-005 millim. in diameter, and bordered by an epithe-
lial ring of which the cells are 0-001 millim. in diameter. These ori-
fices lead into little ovoid cxca, lined with the same epithelium ; I do
not know what may be the function of these singular organs. The
very young Comatula only presents one of them in each sector; their
number consequently increases greatly with the age of the animal.
Some of the orifices touch each other, as if their multiplication took
place by a longitudinal division of preexistent cecal organs. The
tegumentary membrane of the disk is lined internally with a num-
ber of calcareous plates, of irregularly circular form, often marked
with annular strie, and presenting a sort of central star thicker than
the plate itself, and having its arms sometimes bifurcated. Some of
the plates are destitute of stars ; others are perforated; their study
may be of some importance in specific determinations. These plates
and the cecal organs just described have not previously been indi-
cated, so far as I am aware.
I have made the arms of the Comatula the subject of particular
study. Their calcareous skeleton is formed of pieces of an hourglass-
shape, having at the lower part of their anterior margin a certain
number of spines, which prevent the complete reversal of the joints
upon each other. Itis surrounded bya sheath of soft tissues, which
is developed laterally into a membranous lamella, festooned on each
side in such a manner that the festoons of one side alternate with
those of the other; between two consecutive festoons there is always
a group of three unequal tentacles, the largest of which is towards
the extremity of the arm. These tentacles, which are all extremely
mobile, present no external orifice ; they bear two or three rows of
papille terminated by a small dilated head, which bears three slender
rigid and divergent sete. The three tentacles of each group spring
by a common branch from the tentacular canal. The largest tentacle
exactly separates two festoons from each other ; the two smaller ones
repose upon the festoons, to which they partially adhere ; and this has
led Prof. Wyville Thomson to think that they formed part of it and
opened into the tentacular canal by a different orifice from that of
the large tentacle.
The tentacular canal adheres to the vibratile epithelium of the
upper surface of the arms; it is composed of two envelopes, separated
by brilliant stellate corpuscles ; and these two envelopes assist in the
formation of the walls of the tentacles. Seen in profile they simu-
late the appearance of two or even three superimposed vessels be-
neath the tentacular canal, which is the cause of the notions that
have hitherto prevailed as to the organization of the Comatule.
There is, however, absolutely no other canal in the arms of the Coma-
tule, although this canal does not rest directly upon the skeleton, but
is separated from it by a vacant space, which is more or less apparent
30*
468 Miscellaneous.
according to the state of flexure of the arms, and which is nothing
but the prolongation of the general cavity. It is to this cavity that
Dr. Carpenter has given the name of the celiac canal. The ealca-
reous joints are besides enveloped by a delicate membrane, beneath
which are seen stellate conjunctive corpuscles. The tentacular canal
terminates czecally in the arms and in the pinnules, a little beyond
the middle of the antepenultimate calcareous joint. Muscular fibres
unite the groups of tentacles to the point where they spread into
three branches ; a muscular ribbon also runs all along the median
line of the arms beneath the epithelium of the ambulacral furrow.
Kach tentacle, moreover, has its proper muscles, situated between
the external epithelium and the first envelope proceeding from the
tentacular canal. We cannot, therefore, accept the opinion of Pro-
fessor Wyville Thomson, who regards the tissues of the Comatule
as sarcodic.
I could find no trace of a nervous system.
I have cut off the arms of several of these animals, and witnessed
their regeneration, which takes place very rapidly.— Comptes Rendus,
March 17, 1873, p. 718.
On Mammalia from the Neighbourhood of Concordia, in New Granada.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Mr. Edward Gerrard, Jun., has just received a series of Mam-
malia from Concordia or Antioquia, which is very interesting as
showing that several species have a more northern distribution on
the western side of the subtropical part of South America north of
the equator.
1. Ateles ater. A fine large specimen.
2, Cebus hypoleucus. A large specimen, with the upper part of
the forearms white.
3. Nyctipithecus Commersonii. Like the other monkeys of a large
size.
4. Nasua dorsalis, Gray, P. Z. 8S. 1866, t. xvu. There are four
specimens of this species, of different ages, but very nearly alike.
The younger one is the darkest, and most resembles the single one
figured, on which was established the species, which the present
specimens confirm.
5. Galera barbata. The specimen is peculiar for having a white
lunar mark on the front of the back ; but this mark is not quite sym-
metrical, and most probably accidental.
6. Grisonia vittata. The specimen is of very large size, larger
than those we usually have from Demerara.
7. Didelphys canerivora.
8. Erethizon rufescens, Gray, P. Z. S. 1865, p. 321, t. xi. Only
one specimen of this species before known ; and this confirms the
habitat (Columbia) assigned to it, and also the distinctness of the
species, and enables us to examine its skull.
9. Dasyprocta nigra, Gray, Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1842; Zool.
Miscellaneous. 469
Ereb. & Terr.t. This is the first time that the habitat of this species
has been recorded. The specimen has a much greener tinge than
the two specimens in the British Museum ; but this may arise from
its freshness.
10. Sciurus griseogena, Gray, Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. The Con-
cordian specimen differs from the others in the Museum from Vene-
zuela in having a black streak on the whole length of the back, as
in Macroxus medellinensis, Gray (Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist.), which we
received from Concordia on a former occasion ; but that has a white
throat and belly, and is of a smaller size.
11. Tatusia granadina, Gray, Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1873.
12. Cholepus Hoffmanni.
13. Tamandua tetradactyla, var. leucopygia.
Additional Note on Tolypeutes conurus.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Since I examined this animal, taken out of spirit, and sent
a note on it to the ‘Annals,’ Mr. Edward Gerrard has made
a beautiful skeleton of that animal, on which I may further ob-
serve :—
1. The dorsal and the head shield of these animals are much
thicker and harder than the shields of other armadilloes, in this
respect showing much affinity to the fossil genera, especially
Glyptodon.
2. The whole internal surface of the dorsal disk is lined with
skin, the entire front margin of the front ring being attached to
the animal by the skin; and the central part of the hinder dorsal
disk is attached by cartilage to the central ridge of the pelvis. This
cartilage leaves a rough line on the central crest of the pelvis
and on the inside of the dorsal disk, showing the extent of its
adhesion.
According to Dr. Burmeister’s figure, the pelvis and internal part
of the dorsal shield of the Glyptodon are attached in the same man-
ner (see ‘Anales del Museo Publico de Buenos Aires,’ 1873, ii.
part 10, t.). Indeed there seems great analogy in the pelvis and
shields between the genera; but the skulls and teeth are very dif-
ferent. A figure of the skeleton and dorsal shield of this animal
will shortly appear in the ‘ Hand-list of Mammalia.’
On the Respiration of the Psammodromi.
By M. J. Jurtren.
The lung of the Psammodromi is traversed internally by very
voluminous muscular bundles composed of smooth fibres anastomosing
with each other and forming a sort of interior framework, which
seems to support the pulmonary tissue properly so called, as in all
reptiles.
470) Miscellaneous.
These muscular bundles have a most important part in the re-
spiration of these animals. They do not swallow the air lke the
Batrachians; but when they respire, the muscular bundles contract
(as the heart itself would do), the air is expelled, and after the con-
traction reenters the lungs by virtue of the elasticity of the thorax,
aided, no doubt, by the elevator muscles of the ribs. Contractions of
the thoracic muscles take no part in the expiration, which is due
solely to the muscles of the lungs themselves. It does not seem
probable that these pulmonary muscles are subjected to the will of
the animal ; it appears to me that they must act like the muscles of
the iris, which contract independently according to the intensity of
the light. When we observe one of these lizards breathing, the
longest respiratory period is that of expiration, followed immediately
by a sudden inspiration. When a mammal respires, the contrary is
the case; a long inspiration precedes a shorter expiration. The
respiration of the Psammodromi therefore differs profoundly, both
from an anatomical and a physiological point of view, from that of
Mammalia and Birds. It belongs to an intermediate type, which
must take its place below that of the two classes just mentioned and
above that of the Batrachia.—Comptes Rendus, March 3, 1873, tome
lxxvi, p. 585.
M. Gervais on the Skeleton of the Luth (Sphargis coriacea).
Two specimens of this Turtle were caught on the coast of France
in May 1872. One specimen was sent to Paris; but it arrived in
such a bad state that it could only be made into a skeleton, there
being none previously in the Anatomical Museum of Paris.
M. Gervais has published a paper on this specimen, which,
though called adult, is evidently a young one, though the size is not
stated ; and he has added some indications of the skeleton of a much
younger animal, in the eighth volume of the ‘Nouvelles Archives
du Muséum,’ illustrated with five beautiful plates, and describes the
skin of a new fossil species as Sphargis pseudostracion, found in the
blue calcareous strata of Valergues (Hérault).
This paper confirms the account of the skeleton of this animal
given by Dr. Gray in a previous number of the ‘Annals.’ It would
be curious to compare this skeleton with the perfect skeleton from
the coast of Demerara in the museum at Stuttgard.
On an adult Skeleton of Tyrse nilotica in the British Museum.
By Dr. J. E. Gray, F.R.S. &e.
Dr. Baikie sent home a very fine skeleton of an adult Tyrse
from West Africa, which has just been mounted; and it shows
peculiarities which haye not heretofore been observed in this
animal.
The sternal callosities are much broader and more deyeloped. The
Miscellaneous. 471
lateral pair on each side are very broad and dilated on the inner side,
forming an entire expanded disk; all the diverging lobes at the
front inner and at the hinder inner margins are obliterated and
covered with the callous outer surface. In the same manner the
anterior outer process is reduced to a short, broad, blunt, simple
process ; and the hinder outer one is also reduced to a short thick
process, bluntly divided into two lobes at the end.
The hinder pair of anal eallosities are very large and triangular,
nearly as broad as long. The pair are united to each other by a
straight central suture, so as to form a broad triangular callosity,
the anal and the hinder lateral bones being united by two sinuosities,
being the remains of the usual lobes on the marginal plates in the
young animal.
The most remarkable peculiarity, because there is nq indication of
it in the younger specimens, is that it possesses a moderate-sized
triangular callosity, with a curved hinder side on the middle of the
odd anterior sternal bone, showing an alliance in this respect to the
Emydina, or Mud-Tortoises with valves over their feet, which
generally have an odd anterior callosity ; but I had never before seen
it in a tortoise with exposed hind feet and legs.
Bryozoa of Florida.
| F. A. Smitt has published the first part of the descriptions and
} figures of the Floridan Bryozoa, collected by Count L. F. de Pourtales,
) in the ‘Kongl. Svenska Vetenskaps Akademiens Handlingar,’
| vol. x.
| This paper, like many others published by the Royal Swedish
| Academy of Sciences, is entirely written in the English language,
'}) and is illustrated with five very large plates, showing the various
| changes of form that the species undergo.—J. E. Gray.
The late Ropert M‘Anprew, Esq., F.R.S.
We much regret having to announce the death on the 22nd inst.
of Mr. Robert M‘Andrew, F.R.S., at his residence, Isleworth House,
in the 72nd year of his age. His researches by dredging in the
| North Atlantic from Hammerfest to the Canary Isles, as well as in
| the Mediterranean and Gulf of Suez, produced most important
| additions to our knowledge of the geographical distribution of the
marine invertebrate fauna. He was an excellent conchologist, having
derived his taste for that branch of natural history about thirty years
ago from the lamented Edward Forbes. Mr. M‘Andrew was at that
time engaged in commerce, but latterly devoted his ample means and
| time to the pursuit of science. We believe he has left his extensive
collection of shells to the University Museum at Cambridge. His
contributions to this Journal were extremely valuable.—J.G. J.
ABRETIA, new species of, 270.
Acorethra, description of the new
genus, 126.
Acyphoderes, new species of, 117.
Agardh, Prof. T. G., on a new British
Alga, 156.
Agaricus, new British species of, 340.
Agenia, new species of, 445.
Agestra, on the new genus, 183.
Airy, Dr. H., on leaf-arrangement,
386.
Alga, on a new British, 156.
Ammonites, of a new Classification
of, 362, 451.
Animals, on fabulous Australian,
315; on the classification of, 321.
Antilocapra, on the horns of, 80.
Antyllis, on the new genus, 193.
Aplysia, on the development of, 85.
Apostropha, description of the new
genus, 130.
Appendicularia furcata, on the young
of, 87.
Argyrosomus, new species of, 319.
Articulata, physico-chemical investi-
gations upon the aquatic, 70.
Azema Smithii, on, 465.
Bacteria, on the origin of, 383; on
the heat necessary to kill, 454.
Bastian, Dr. H.C.,on the origin of
Bacteria and their relation to the
process of putrefaction, 383; on the
temperature necessary to kill Bac-
teria, Vibriones, and their germs,
454.
Bates, H. W., on the Longicorn Co-
leoptera of Tropical America, 21,
Ives
Berardius, observations on, 17, 111.
Berkeley, Rev. M. J., on British
Fungi, 359.
Bipalium, on the anatomy and his-
tology of, 310.
Birds, new, 15, 21, 133, 221; fossil,
on new and remarkable, 80, 233.
Books, new :—Symonds’s Record of
the Rocks, 149 ; Nicholson’s Man-
ual of Paleontology, 151; Ehren-
berg’s Microgeological Studies,
224; Cordeaux’s Birds of the
Humber District, 377; Colquhoun’s
Fer Nature of the British Islands,
381.
472 |
INDEX to VOL. XI.
Borlasia Kefersteinii, on the struc- | Q
ture of the proboscis of, 398. Wer
Brexius, new species of, 196. I
Broome, C.E., on British Fungi, 339,
Butler, A. G., on Crinodes Sommeri,
78; on new species of Gonyleptes,
112.
Calcispongiz, on the position of the,
in the animal kingdom, 241, 421.
Callichelys, new species of, 148.
Carbonnier, M., on the reproduction
and development of the telescope-
fish of China, 76.
Carter, H. J., on the transformation
of an entire shell into chitinous—
structure by the polype Hydrac-
tinia, with descriptions of the poly-
pidoms of five other species, 1;
on whales in the Indian Ocean,
231; on Labaria hemispheerica and | ,
the Sarcohexactinellid Sponges, | ),,
275; on the points of distinction |
between the Spongiade and the
Foraminifera, 351.
Cephalopoda, on the parasite of the
renal organ of, 95.
Ceratella, new species of, 10.
Ceratophrys, new species of, 417. | y
Cervus chilensis and C. antisiensis, |,
remarks on, 213. 1 1
Cetacea of the N.W. coast of Ame- |p),
rica, on the parasites of the, 157, |)...
258 ; new species of, 316.
ee new British species of,
Charis, new species of, 123.
Chelonians, notes on, 143; new
genera and species of, 156, 289;
on the original form, development,
and cohesion of the bones of the
sternum of, 161; on some extinct, |
from the islands of Rodriguez and: Dn
Mauritius, 397,
Chiroleptes, new species of, 850, ie
Chitina, new species of, 13. bit
Chrysemys, new species of, 147. ba
Cistoclemmys, new species of, 294. m
Clonograpsus, on the genus, 138, J),
Codiophyllum, observations on, 77. _ x
Coleoptera, on the Longicorn, off),
Tropical America, 21, 117. he
Comatula rosacea, on the anatomy»,
of, 466,
Corticium, new species of, 343.
Crinodes Sommeri, on, 78.
Crustacea, new species of, parasitic
on Cetacea, 157, 238; on a new
| — genus of Amphipod, 389.
Cryptolepas, characters of the new
genus, 239.
Curculionide, new Australian, 178.
Cyamus, new species of, 157.
Cyphella, new species of, 343.
) Cyprinus macrophthalmus, on the
reproduction and development of,
76.
| Cyttalia, description of the new
genus, 194,
Dacrymyces, new species of, 343.
Dactylium, new species of, 345,
Dall, W. H., on three new species of
Crustacea parasitic on Cetacea,
157 ; onsome new species of Mol-
lusks, 159; on the parasites of the
Cetaceans of the N.W. coast
of America, 238; on three new
species of Cetacea, 316.
| Damonia, new species of, 299.
)) Danais Archippus, on the appearance
of, in Australia, 440.
| Dawsonia, description of the new
genus, 139,
| De Candolle, A., on the advantage of
a dominant language for science,
_ 401.
Deep-sea dredging in the Gulf of St.
Lawrence, 155,
i) Delphinus, new species of, 316.
i) Dendrohyrax arboreus, note on, 154.
Descendence, on the theory of, 241.
Dicomada, description of the new
genus, 190,
Dictyonema, new species of, 134.
Dictyoxylon, on the organization of,
227
Dicyema, observations on, 95.
Diethusa, description of the new
genus, 185.
Dipnoans, on the homologies of the
shoulder-girdle of the, 173.
Dolphins, on the geographical distri-
bution, migration, and occasional
habitats of the, 98; of the New-
Zealand seas, 104.
Draper, Dr. J. C., on growth or evo-
_ _ lution of structure in seedlings, 45.
) Dubreuil, E., on the capreolus of
| Zonites algirus, 235.
Ehlers, Prof., on the fauna of No-
waja-Semlja, 464.
INDEX.
| Ann. & Mag. N. H. Ser. 4, Vol, xi.
47:
Embryo, on the primitive cell-layers
of the, 321.
Emplesis, new species of, 185,
Emys, new species of, 146.
Enide, description of the new genus,
87.
Eniopea, description of the new
genus, 184.
Entomidella, description of the new
genus, 416,
Entomis, on the genus, 413.
Entomostraca, on the Paleozoic bi-
valved, 415.
Epiodon, new species of, 105,
Eryma, on the genus, 299.
Hyas, new species of, 179.
Falco, new species of, 20, 221.
Fauna of Lake Michigan, on the
deep-water, 319; of Nowaja-
Semlja, on the, 464.
Favre, E., on a new classification of
Ammonites, 362, 451.
Fishes, on the homologies of the
shoulder-girdle of some, 175; new,
319.
Foraminifera, on points of distinc-
tion between the Spongiade and
the, 351.
Fossils from the Quebec group of
Point Lévis, Quebec, on some, 1333.
French measures, 400.
Frogs,new speciesof Australian, 349.
Fungi, notices of British, 339.
Gamasus, new species of, 79.
Geomalacus, on the French species
of, 271.
Gervais, M., on the skeleton of
Sphargis coriacea, 470.
Gerynassa, description of the new
genus, 189
Gill, Dr. T., on the homologies of the
shoulder-girdle of the Dipnoans
and other fishes, 173.
Glycera, on notochordal rudiments
in, 92.
Gonyleptes, monograph of the genus,
1 €
Grampus, new species of, 317.
Graptemys, new species of, 300.
Graptolites, new genera and species
of, 134.
Gray, Dr. J. E., on Berardius and
other Ziphioid whales, 17; on
Spatulemys Lasale, 73; on the
acleayius australiensis, 75; on
Codiophyllum, 77; on the horns
of Antilocapra, 80; on the geo-
474
graphical distribution, migration,
and occasional habitats of Whales
and Dolphins, 104; on the Whales
and Dolphins of the New-Zealand
seas, 107; on Tortoises, 143; on
the Boomdas, 154 ; ona new fresh-
water Tortoise from Borneo, 156;
on Orca stenorhyncha, 159; on the
original form, development, and
cohesion of the bones of the ster-
num of Chelonians, 161; on the
Guémul of Patagonia, 214, 308 ;
on two new Sponges, 254; on new
genera and species of Chelonians,
289; on the dentition of Rhino-
ceroses, and on the characters
afforded by their skulls, 356; on
the dorsal shield of Tolypeutes,
597,469; on French measures, 400;
on Pigs and their skulls, with de-
scription of a new species, 431;
on M. Favre’s paper on a new
classification of Ammonites, 451;
on the habits of Xenurus uni-
cinctus, 463; on “le Rat de Ma-
dagascar,’’465; on Mammalia from
New Granada, 468; on an adult
skeleton of Tyrse nilotica, 470.
Gray, Prof. A., on Sequoia and its
history, 52.
Gunther, Dr. A., on two new species
of frogs, 349; on a new Saurian,
351; on a new snake from Mada-
gascar, 674; on some extinct tor-
toises from the islands of Rodriguez
and Mauritius, 397 ; on the genera
Ceratophrys and Megalophrys, 417.
Hackel, Prof. E., on the Calcispongie,
their position in the animal king-
dom, and their relation to the
theory of descendence, 241, 421.
Hamamelis virginica, on the projec-
tile power of the capsules of, 160.
Hector, Dr. J., on the whales and
dolphins of the New-Zealand seas,
104.
Hedyopis, description of the new
genus, 188
Helminthosporium,
species of, 345.
Heynemann, D. F., on the French
species of Geomalacus, 271.
Houghton, Rev. W., on the Silurus
and Glanis of the ancient Greeks
and Romans, 199.
Hoy, Dr. P. R., on the deep-water
fauna of Lake Michigan, 319.
new British
INDEX.
Huamela leucotis, observations on,
218, 214, 308.
Hyalosaurus, description of the new
genus, 351. ;
Hydractinia, on the transformation
of an entire shell into chitinous
structure by the polype, 1; new
species of, 9.
Hydraspis, new species of, 304.
Hydromedusa, new species of, 301.
Hygrophorus, new species of, 341.
Hymenoptera, new species of fos-
sorial, 441.
Hypera, new species of, 180.
Infusoria, on a new type of, 96.
Invertebrata, on the distribution of
the, in relation to the theory ot
evolution, 391.
Isthmiade, new species of, 121.
Ithycyphus, description of the new
genus, 374. ,
Jeffreys, J. Gwyn, on the Mollusca
of Europe compared with those of
North America, 375.
Joly, N., on hypermetamorphosis in
Palingenia virgo, 317.
Jones, T. R., on the genera Entomis
and Entomidella, 413.
Jullien, J., on the respiration of the —
Psammodromi, 469.
Krefft, Dr. G., on fabulous Australian Nid
animals, 315.
Labaria hemispheerica, description of,
235, 275.
Lankester, E. R., summary of zoo- ©
logical observations made by, at — Nin
Naples in the winter of 1871-72, | w
81; on the primitive cell-layers of
the embryo, and on the origin of
vascular and lymph systems, 321.
Leaf-arrangement, on, 386,
Ligidium agile, on the discovery of, —
in Great Britain, 419.
Limuli, anatomical investigations on —
the, 152.
Littorina, new species of, 159.
Loligo, on the development of, 81.
Lybba, description of the new | (
genus, 186.
Lyginodendron, on the organization
of, 227.
M‘Andrew, R., obituary notice of, 1 Oris,
471.
M‘Coy, Prof. F., on a new Australian —
species of Thyrsites, 338; on the Ont
appearance of Danais Archippus
in Australia, 440.
Macdonald, Dr. J. D., on the distri-
bution of the Invertebrata in rela-
tion to the theory of evolution,
391.
Macleayius australiensis, on the, of
New Zealand, 75.
Mammalia from New Granada, notes
on some, 468.
Marsh, O. C., on a new and remark-
able fossil bird, 80; on a new
subclass of fossil birds, 233.
Meehan, T., on the projectile power
of the capsules of Hamamelis vir-
ginica, 160.
Megalophrys, on the genus, 419.
Meriphus, new species of, 194.
Milne-Edwards, A., on the anatomy
of the Limuli, 152.
Mollusca, new species of, 159; of
Europe and North America, on
the, 206, 375.
Monosporium, new species of, 345.
Moseley, H. N., on the anatomy and
histology of the Land-Planarians
of Ceylon, 310.
Myurella, new species of, 266.
‘Nacella, new species of, 159.
Nemertian, on the structure of the
proboscis of an hermaphrodite, 398.
‘Nettapus, new species of, 15.
Nicholson, Prof. H. A., on some
fossils from the Quebec group of
Point Lévis, Quebec, 133.
Nitophyllum,on a new British species
of, 156.
Norman, Rey. A. M., on the dis-
covery of Ligidium agile in Great
_ Britain, 419.
Notaden, description of the new
genus, 349,
Nudibranchs, on the development of
the, 86.
Ocadia, new species of, 300.
Odontocera, new species of, 37.
-Odontornithes, on the new subclass,
233.
Oidium, new British species of, 346.
Pare description of the new genus,
193.
Ommata, new species of, 26,
Orca stenorhyncha, note on, 159.
Orlitia, new species of, 156.
Orthorhinus, new species of, 180.
Otion, new species of, 240.
Oxylymma, new species of, 25,
Palingenia virgo, on hypermetamor-
phosis in, 317,
INDEX:
475
Paryzeta, description of the new
genus, 191.
Pascoe, F. P., on Australian Curcu-
lionidee, 178.
Perichzena, new species of, 345.
Perrier, E., on the anatomy of
Comatula rosacea, 466,
Petromyzon, on the development of,
236.
Peziza, new British species of, 347.
Phespia, description of the new genus,
127.
Phrenozemia, new species of, 195.
Phyllirrhoé bucephala and its para-
site, note on, 94,
Pigs, observations on the group, 431.
Planarians, Land, on the anatomy
and histology of the, of Ceylon,
310.
Plants of the Coal-measures, on the
organization of the, 227,
Plateau, F., on the aquatic Arti-
culata, 70.
Polyactis, new species of, 346,
Pompilus, new species of, 441.
Poropterus, new species of, 197.
Propheesia, new species of, 180.
Psaldus, new species of, 179.
Psammodromi, on the respiration of
the, 469.
Psepholax, new species of, 196.
-Psetalia globulosa, description of,
234.
Pseudogyps, characters of the new
genus, 155.
Putrefaction, on the origin of Bac-
teria, and on their relation to the
process of, 583.
Pyrosoma, on the embryology of, 94.
Rhinoceroses, on the dentition of,
356.
Rhinoclemmys, new species of, 144.
- Rhinonchus, new species of, 199.
Rhynchodemus, on the anatomy and
histology of, 310.
Rhyparobius, new species of, 347.
Royal Society, proceedings of the,
227, 310, 388, 454.
Schneider, A., on the developmental
history of Petromyzon, 236.
Science, on the advantage of a do-
minant language for, 401.
Sclater, P. L., on Cervus chilensis
and C. antisiensis, 213.
Seedlings, on growth or evolution of
structure in, 45.
Sequoia and its history, on, 52,
476
Setifera, observations on the, and
their skulls, 431.
Sharpe, R. B., on the Peregrine
Falcon from Sardinia, 20; on a
new species of Turkey Vulture
from the Falklands, and a new
genus of Old-World Vultures, 153;
on the Peregrine Vulture of the
Magellan Straits, 220.
Shell, on the transformation of, into
chitinous structure by the polype
Hydractinia, 1.
Silurus and Glanis of the ancient
Greeks and Romans, on the, 199.
Sipunculus nudus, on the histology
of, 88.
Smith, E., on some new species of
Terebride, 262; on a new species
of Vitrina, 288.
Smith, F., on new species of fossorial
Hymenoptera, 441.
Spatulemys Lasalz, notes on, 73.
Spheria, new British species of, 348.
Sphezronema, new species of, 546.
Sphargis, on the osteology of, 171,
470.
Sponges, on new species of, 234, 275;
on the position of the, in the ani-
mal kingdom, 241; on points of
distinction between the Foramini-
fera and, 351.
Stebbing, Rey. T. R. R., on a crus-
tacean of the genus Zia, 286.
Stenopseustes, description of the
new genus, 131.
Sternaspis, on the anatomy of, 92.
Sus, new species of, 436.
Swinhoe, R., on a new species of
Nettapus, 15.
Terebella nebulosa, on the develop-
ment of, 87.
Terebra, new species of, 264.
Terebratula vitrea, on the develop-
ment of, 92.
Terebride, on new forms of, 262.
Tetragrapsus, new species of, 136.
Thaumops, description of the new
genus, 390,
Thyrsites, new species of, 338,
Tolypeutes, on the dorsal shield of,
597, 469.
Tomopterus, new species of, 128.
Tortoises, notes on, 143; new genera
INDEX.
and species of, 156, 289; on the
original form, development, and
cohesion of the bones of the ster-
num of, 161; on some extinct,
from the islands of Rodriguez and
Mauritius, 397. mt seit
Trachemys, new species of, 147.
Triglopsis, new species of, 320.
Turnbull, Dr. C. S., on a mite in the
ear of the Ox, 79.
Tursiops, new species of, 516.
Tyrse nilotica, on an adult skeleton
of, 470.
Verrill, Prof. A. E., on the Mollusca
of Europe compared with those of
Eastern North America, 206.
Verticillium, new species of, 346,
Vibriones, on the heat necessary to
kall, 454.
Vitrina, new species of, 288.
Voluta, new species of, 159.
Westwood, Prof. J. O., on the Bell
Collection of Reptiles, 78.
Whales, on Berardius and other
Ziphioid, 17 ; on the geographical
distribution, migration, and occa-
sional habitats of, 98 ; of the New- —
Zealand seas, on the, 104; new
species of Crustacea parasitic on,
157, 238; of the Indian Ocean,
notes on the, 231; new species of,
from California, 316.
Whiteaves, J. F., on deep-sea dredg-
ing in the Gulf of St. Lawrence,
155.
Willemées-Suhm, Dr. R. von, on a
new genus of Amphipod Crusta-
ceans, 389.
Williamson, Prof. W. C., on the
organization of the fossil plants of
the coal-measures, 227.
Xeda, description of the genus, 192.
Xenocrasis, description of the new
genus, 131.
Xenurus unicinctus, on the habits of,
463.
Zeller, E., on the structure of the
ppboes of an hermaphrodite
emertian, 398.
Zia, on a crustacean of the genus,
286, 419.
Zonites algirus, on the capreolus of,
END OF THE ELEVENTH VOLUME.
PRINTED BY TAYLOR AND FRANCIS,
RED LION COURT, FLEET STREET.
4 Vol Pd
Ann f- Ma Q Nat Tliat
WIVSV1 SANZTALVdS
PHLHO
dur soag tas yuny
rt Pia
Fiche)
Ae
Ann & Mag Not Hist § 4.Vol ATPLIL
G.Butler del.et. hth. Jan. 1873 Mintern Bros jm.
NEW GONYLEPTIDA.
Mirrtern Bros. imp.
S
a
SS
:
3
<
S
S
:
:
3
Ann & Mag. Wat. Hist 5.4. Vol I. PLV.
G.H. Ford. Mintern Bros. amp.
“a
Ani & May. Nat. Hist. $4. Vol. PU. VI
\
GH .Ford. Mintern Bros. imp.
l
!
U
(
Anné Mag Nat Hist. S4 Vol FLV
3 1
*
y- ,
a‘ 4 f
ee ’ ¥
a 4 ‘
f. ‘
oe eae fi |
é ‘
\
s .
y .
‘ te
‘ 7 ‘
ny \
a)
.
.
}
Tr,
Ann.é Mag Nat tist 34, VoL LVI.
=
ae a — <a © = i. prem Me ie ie 8! a 2 el el ad
Ann.& Mag Nat Hist. 34 Voll] PLLe
ze.
Nr ee mig pd Ba! ti eat es ge
LUV SQUE Ut PUTA JIE GSI)
IX Id HINES BY YON CONS Uupy
BINDING SECT. JUN 12 1972
QH The Annals & magazine of
rE natural history
M6
ser.4
Vou
Biological
& Medical
Serials
PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE
CARDS OR SLIPS FROM THIS POCKET
UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO LIBRARY
STORAGE
ESS; -%
rene
> A aeons
Ne > eras oy ee
Rigs coh
SINC ed
ee
a
a4